Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RINGWORM (Tineacapitis).
Abstract
Antifungal avtivities of some selected medicated soaps against ringworm (Tineacapitis) was
investigated. Samples were collected from infected children in LGEA primary school and St.
Mary’s primary school of North Bank area of Makurdi using swab sticks. Sterile swab sticks
Crusader, Actimed, Safeguard, Tetmosol and Dettol that contain Triclosan, Mercury (I) iodide,
and monosulfiram were used to test for their antifungal activities against ringworm in this study.
Sabouraud’s Dextrose Agar medium. The zone of inhibition was conducted using agar diffusion
method. Double serial dilutions of the soaps were made at 50mg/ml, 25mg/ml and 12.5mg/ml to
check for the minimum inhibitory concentration on both T.mentagrophytes and T.rubrum.
Crusader and Tetmosol have higher zone of (30.0mm) inhibition than Safeguard and Actimed
(26.0mm) with Dettol having the least (19.0mm) inhibition capacity on T. mentagrophytes.
While on T.rubrum, Actimed has 24.0mm, Safeguard has 16.0mm, Dettol 21.0mm, Tetmosol
22.0mm and Crusader has 23.0mm zone of inhibition. Crusader and Tetmosol equally have
T.rubrum. The control, Griseofulvin on the other hand had an average inhibition of 18.0mm and
1
10.0mm on T.rubrum and T. mentagrophytes respectively. Therefore, some of these soaps can be
consider as
Introduction
Ringworm infection continues to be a problem all over the world, particularly in the developing
countries, where poor living conditions and massive un-enlightenment prevail. This infection, as
it has no obvious fatal consequences, ringworm can be unsightly and can have far-reaching
social, economic and psychological impacts on the afflicted individual (WHO, 2006). Ringworm
is a skin infection that is caused by fungi. Some of the common places ringworm grows are the
feet (athlete’s foot), groin, scalp, face and nails. The infection gets its name from the
characteristic ring-like rash on the skin. The disease is spread through direct skin to skin contact
with person infected with ringworm or by touching an infected animal (Oyewale etal., 2015).
Barbing tools have also been reported to be an important source of ringworm infection (Enemour
etal.,2012). For instance, “barbing shop” was reported as the most frequently incriminated
probable source of ringworm disease in Anambra state of Nigeria (Emele etal.,2009). Ringworm
may also be spread through contaminated floor in locker rooms or showers or from sharing
combs, brushes, towels or clothing with an infected person. Animals, especially cats may be
primarily caused by dermatophytes in Trichophyton and Microsporumgenera that invade the hair
2
shaft. At least eight species of dermatophytes are associated with Tineacapitis(Peters etal.,2006).
Cases of Trichophytoninfection predominate from Central America to the United States and in
parts of Western Europe. Infections from Microsporum species are mainly in South America,
Southern and Central Europe, Africa and the Middle East (Wikipedia, 2015).
The clinical presentation is typically single or multiple patches of hair loss, sometimes
with a ‘black dot’ pattern (often with broken-off hairs), that may be accompanied by
inflammation, scaling, pustules, and itching (Oyewale etal., 2015). The rash may be reddened
and circular with disgusting and irritating appearance on infected individuals. Uncommon in
adults, Tineacapitis is predominantly seen in pre-pubertal children, more often boys than girls.
Treatment of Tineacapit is requires an oral antifungal agent; griseofulvin is the most commonly
used drug, but other newer antimycotic drugs, such asterbinafine, itraconazole, and fluconazole
The fungi are a large and successful group of organisms of about 90, 000 named species. They
range in size from the unicellular yeast to the large toadstools, puffballs, and stinkhorns, and
occupy a very wide range of habitats both aquatic and terrestrial (Taylor and Green, 2005). They
are also of major importance for the essential role that they play in the biosphere, and for the way
in which they have been exploited by humans for economic and medical purposes. Fungi include
the numerous moulds which grow on damp organic matter (such as bread, leather, decaying
vegetation and dead fish), the unicellular yeasts which are abundant on the sugary surfaces of
ripe fruits and many parasites of plants. They have a global distribution from polar to tropical
regions (Willey etal., 2011). Fungi are saprophytes, securing nutrient from dead organic material
by releasing degradative enzymes into the environment. They degrade complex organic materials
in the environment to simple organic and inorganic molecules. In this way, carbon, nitrogen,
3
phosphorus and other critical constituents of dead organisms are released and made available for
living organisms. Many fungi are pathogenic and infect plants and animals. Over 5 000 species
attack economically valuable crops, garden plants, and many wild plants, and about 20 new
Although hundreds of thousands of fungal species are found in the environment, only
about 50 produce disease in humans (Willey etal.,2011). Medical mycology is the discipline that
deals with the fungi that cause human disease. These fungal diseases called mycoses are typically
divided into five groups according to the route of infection: superficial, cutaneous, subcutaneous,
al., 2007). Superficial, cutaneous, and subcutaneous mycoses are direct contact infections of the
skin, hair, and nails. Systemic mycoses are infections that have disseminated to visceral tissues.
Most systemic mycoses are acquired by the inhalation of spores from soil in which the mould-
phase of the fungus resides. If a person inhales enough spores, an infection begins as a lung
lesion, becomes chronic, and spreads through the bloodstream to other organs (the target organ
varies with the species) (Malcolm et al., 2000). Some of the infections include blastomycosis,
called dermatophytosis, ringworms, or Tineas occur worldwide and represent the most common
DERMATOPHYTES
Dermatophytes are one of the most common sources of human fungal infections. The name
dermatophye consists of two parts, namely “derm” which means skin and “phytes” which means
plants. In fact the fungi known as dermatophytes are not plants and are not confined only to the
4
skin, but they can affect also hairs and nails. Consequently, the name is not correct, but it is used
because it is tradionally applied to this group of fungi and no other name was proposed
(Sheklakov etal., 1974). Annually they affect millions of individuals and are estimated to burden
the United States healthcare system to the toll of $400 million each year for treatment alone.
Examples of Dermatophytes include the fungi responsible for Tineapedis(athlete’s foot) which
has led to the immobilization of significant numbers of United States troops in recent history
(CDC, 1996). Other species are the cause of Tineacapitisa scalp infection that is a significant
pediatric health problem in urban settings. These fungi grow best on those areas of the skin that
are dark, warm and moist. The Dermatophytes are communicable and can cause chronic
infections in healthy, immune-competent individuals, and hence have adapted to evade and
maintain control of the host immune response for extended periods of time (Elson etal., 2001).
These adaptations must result from the co-evolution between Dermatophytes and their human
and other mammal hosts - evolutionary trajectories that resulted in species that span a continuum
of host specificities and mating competence (Mohamed etal., 2013). Dermatophytes are a unique
group of moulds which have the capacity to invade keratinized tissue, in man and animals,
causing cutaneous infections commonly referred to as Tineaor ‘ringworm’. They are dependent
on keratin as nutrient source as they can cause its hydrolysis. Dermatophytes affects the
keratinized tissues, for example skin, hair and nails and remain confined to the dead tissues and
do not invade the living part of the tissues (Malcolm and Michael, 2000).
These organisms colonize the keratin tissues and in response to their metabolic by products, host
experiences inflammatory reactions. They are usually restricted to the nonliving cornified layer
of the epidermis because of their inability to penetrate viable tissue of an immunocompetent host.
5
Acid proteinases, elastase, keratinases and other proteinases reportedly act as virulence factors
Microsporum. Dermatophytes may be grouped into 3 categories based on host preference and
natural habitat. Anthropophilic species predominantly infect humans, geophilic species are soil
based and may infect both humans and animals, and zoophilic species generally infect non-
Superficial mycoses are fungal infections limited to the stratum corneum and its adnexal
structures. Stratum corneum is the outermost layer of skin. Its external aspect is in contact with
the outside environment and its internal aspect is in contact with the sub-stratum corneum
environment (Malcolm and Michael, 2000). Skin is sterile at birth but soon becomes colonised
by a number of microorganisms which make up its flora. Dermatophytes are not considered part
of this flora. Dermatophyte fungi have been shown to have keratinolytic, other proteolytic and
lipolytic activity (Richardson etal., 2000). Serine proteinases (urokinase and tissue type
plasminogen activator) which are involved in extracellular protein catabolism have been found in
dermatophytes and their release by dermatophytes was suggested to play a major role in the
invasion of skin. Sulphitolysis, a process that denatures keratin non-enzymatically, has been
to keratinolysis (Richardson etal., 2000). Keratinase has been partially purified and detected from
technique. Using a fluorescent antibody technique keratinase was also detected in biopsy from
the skin of guinea pigs infected experimentally with Trichophyton mentagrophytes (Richardson
6
et al., 1992).Disintegration of hair thought to be caused by dermatophyte enzyme digestion has
been shown in human scalp infection, experimental infection in guinea pigs and in
vitro. Thus it seems that dermatophytes have a battery of enzymes able to digest different
substrates in their habitat (Malcolm and Michael, 2000). In a research work conducted by Dr.
Richardson Malcolm and Michael Edward of the Mycology Unit, Department of Bacteriology
and Immunology, University of Helsinki, Finland in the year 2000 suggested some conditions in
the skin that favour the growth of dermatophytes while others do not. Conditions favorable for
1. The stratum corneum is an avascular tissue composed of highly specialized but deadcells.
2. The stratum corneum is well hydrated – water reaches it through eccrine sweatingand
trans-epidermal water loss. Skin temperature is cooler than body temperature; pH ranges from
iscomposed of proteins, amino acids, lipids, carbohydrates and various trace elements, including
iron.
4. Over some areas of the stratum corneum there are certain anatomical considerationswhich
may enhance establishment of growth of dermatophytes. Firstly, hair on scalp may act as a
trapping device for an airborne dermatophyte infection. Secondly, the hyponychial horny layer is
covered by the distal portion of the nail plate and a groove is thus constructed which may also act
as a trapping device for dermatophyte infective particles. Thirdly, the interdigital spaces of the
toes, particularly the fourth, and the crural areas in males are naturally occluded and this may
contribute to the fact that Tineapedis in most instances starts in the toes webs and Tineacruris is
7
almost exclusively a male disease. Experimentally-induced occlusion will cause the hydrated
stratum corneum to swell and develop multiple folds and allow accumulation of desquameted
corneocytes on the surface of the stratum corneum. Therefore, it is likely that occlusion increases
the surface area and nutrients available for growth of dermatophytes on stratum corneum.
a dramtic increase in the thickness of the stratum corneum, there is frequent occurrence of
dermatophytosis.
Pathogenesis
Healthy skin acts as an effective physical barrier against fungal invasion. The increased rate of
regeneration of epidermal cells in response to contact with the dermatophyte with the consequent
removal of fungus from the skin surface is another protective mechanism (Chermette and
Ferreiro, 2008). As dermatophytes cannot penetrate healthy skin, many cats are merely passive
carriers of the arthrospores or remain subclinically infected. Whether such an infection will lead
to clinical signs depends on endogenous and exogenous factors. Predisposing factors include
nutritional deficits (especially proteins and vitamin A), high temperature and high humidity
(DeBoer and Moriello, 2006). Any skin trauma resulting from increased moisture, injury by
overcrowded feline groups, social stress may play a role. Thus in catteries or shelters infected
The prevalence of fungal flora was investigated with regard to the potential Immunosuppressive
effect of feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) and feline leukaemia virus (FeLV). However, the
8
higher prevalence of M.canis in FIV-infected animals compared with normal cats reported in one
survey (Mancianti etal., 1992) was not observed in another study [Sierra etal., 2000]. The
association may be related to differences in the environment rather than to the retroviral status of
the cats (Mignon and Losson, 1997). Affected hair tissues from cases of Tineacapitishave been
studied using light microscopy, scanning andtransmission electron microscopy. However, ultra
structural findings of the parasitic form of T.mentagrophytesin hair tissue have been inconclusive
and the studies have not used intact hair follicles (Malcolm etal., 2000). The pathological
changes of the affected hair structures are poorly understood. The stages by which detached hairs
are attacked by keratinophilic fungi are: (1) cuticle lifting, (2) cortical erosion, (3) production of
penetrating organs, and (4) colonisation of the medulla (Malcolm and Michael, 2000). The ability
to invade hair in vitro is a property of the keratinophilic fungi in general but various species
differ in the way this is accomplished. It has been found that the direction of invasion and the
pathological role of the fungal elements within the hair appratus are significantly different
between fungi. Experimental studies of hair penetration by dermatophytes are few and have been
restricted to cut or plucked hair and arthroconidia have not been previously used in experimental
Transmission
Dermatophytes produce spores (conidia) that are able to infect humans and animals when they
are being contacted. Those growing in a vertebrate host normally form only (arthroconidia),
asexual spores that develop within the hyphae. In the environment (e.g., in laboratory culture),
they can also produce microconidia and macroconidia, asexual spores that develop outside the
hyphae (Ameen, 2010). Initially, the dermatophyte infects a growing hair or the stratum corneum
of the skin. These organisms do not usually invade resting hair, since the essential nutrients they
9
need for growth are absent or limited. Hyphae spread in the hairs and keratinized skin, eventually
arthrospores in hairs or skin scales. Other asexual or sexual spores formed by the environmental
stages may also be infectious (Lee etal., 2011). Fomites such as brushes and clippers are
important in transmission (Emele etal., 2009). Spores may remain viable in suitable
environments for up to 12-20 months, and some spores were also reported to persist for at least a
year in salt water. Certain types of spores (e.g., microconidia) might be dispersed by airborne
Clinical Signs
Dermatophytes generally grow only in keratinized tissues such as hair, nails and the outer layer
of skin; the fungus usually stops spreading where it contacts living cells or areas of inflammation
(Chah etal., 2012). Many dermatophytes can invade hairs as well as the skin; however, some
anthropophilic species such as E.floccosumand T.rubrum are limited to the skin. Mucus
membranes are not affected. The symptoms of dermatophytosis vary, depending on the infecting
organism, affected tissues (e.g., skin, hair or nails) and area of the body (Noble, 1998).
In unhaired (glabrous) skin, the lesions are usually characterized by inflammation that is most
severe at the edges, with erythema, scaling and occasionally blister formation. The central area
may clear, resulting in the formation of a classic “ringworm” lesion. In haired areas, the hair
become brittle and areas of alopecia may appear (Degreef, 2008). Dermatophytes acquired from
animals or the soil generally produce more inflammatory lesions than anthropophilic
dermatophytes (but not all individual cases are highly inflammatory). These infections are also
less likely to become chronic than those caused by anthropophilic organisms (Degreef, 2008).
10
In humans, dermatophytoses are referred to as “Tinea” infections, and are named
according to the area of the body involved. Infections can, however, spread from one area to
another. For example, Tineafaciei (facial dermatophytosis) in children may result from a
Tineacapitis(scalp) infection that has spread to the face (Lee etal.,2011). Mohamed etal., revealed
that ringworm of the scalp may be classified as scaly ringworm, black-dot ringworm, kerion and
favus. Infection with M.audouinii and M. canis is characterized by small-spored ectothrix hair
invasion, where the spores are surrounding the hair shaft, and the hair fluoresce green under the
U.V. light. Largespored ectothrix hair invasion is seen in case of infection with M.gypseum,T.
by endothrix hair invasion. The inside of the hair may be fully filled with spores and the hair may
break and the remaining part appears as a black dot. In case of favus broad hyphae and air spaces
Direct microscopy, although false negative in 5 to 15% of cases in ordinary practice (Rippon
etal., 1988), is a highly efficient screening technique. Scrapings and hairs may be mounted for
direct examination in 25% KOH or NaOH mixed with 5% glycerol, heated (e.g., for 1 h at 51 to
548C) to emulsify lipids, and examined under 3400 magnification for fungal structures. Another
formulation is 20% KOH–36% dimethyl sulfoxide (Rippon etal., 1988), and two techniques for
fluorescence microscopy, the calcofluor white technique (Robinson etal.,1988) and the Congo
11
The classification of all structures seen in direct microscopy is beyond the scope of this article.
The reader is referred to several excellent texts for descriptions and photographs (Fragner etal.,
Culture is a valuable adjunct to direct microscopy and is essential at least in all nail infections
and in any infection to be treated by systemic medication. In all cases, a medium selective against
Cycloheximide is incorporated into this medium as a semiselective agent to reduce the growth
commercially available under various names such as Mycobiotic (Difco Laboratories, Detroit,
Mich.) and Mycosel (BBL, Becton-Dickinson, Cockeysville, Md.) agars. Dermatophyte Test
dermatophyte growth as a colour change to red in its constituent phenol red indicator. Some
nonpathogenic fungi (e.g., Trichophytonterrestre), however, induce the red colour change while
some Microsporum isolates (Moriello et al., 1991) and bacterially contaminated isolates (Kane
etal., 1980) may give a false-negative reaction. Therefore, this medium is good but is not an
absolute indicator of the growth of a dermatophyte. It has the disadvantage of not allowing
laboratories use
glucose or potato flake agar for primary isolation, a practice speeding the identification of
T.rubrumby rapidly inducing red pigmentation in uncontaminated, typical isolates and typical
12
isolates with relatively antibiotic-susceptible contaminants. When non dermatophytic fungi or
Treatment of Tineacapitis
systemic, although topical agents such as miconazole, clotrimazole, Whitfield’s ointment, and
selenium sulfide (Allen etat., 1982) may be used as adjuncts to eliminate the shedding of viable
inoculum from infected lesions. Griseofulvin is the long-standing drug of choice and has a
success rate of over 90% (Laude etal., 1982). It is often given as a dosage of 500 mg/day in
adults or 250 mg/day in children, administered as a fourpartdivided dose (Rippon etal., 1988).
Chronic infections may require 2 or more months of treatment. Porphyria is a counter indication.
Azoles may also be effective. Ketoconazole, however, in at least some studies has achieved
remission in only approximately 60% of patients (Conti-Diaz etal., 1984). The allylamine agent
terbinafine has proven highly effective (Villars etal., 1992), as has the triazole itraconazole
(Legendre etal., 1990). In addition to drug treatment, general sanitation measures are usually
employed to prevent recurrence and spread. Infected headgear is often boiled; infected hair is
clipped to reduce the chance of contagion, and the lesions are scrubbed daily, ideally with an
antifungal agent such as selenium sulfide (Allen etat., 1982). Kerion lesions may required
ebridement or other local care, and the use of antibacterial agents may be indicated to treat
13
This study focused on testing for the anti-fungal activities of five (5) different types of medicated
Mercuric iodide (HgI2) presents as 3% potassium mercuric iodide solution as the active
ingredient.
Mercury (I) iodide is a chemical compound of mercury and iodine. It is photosensitive and
decomposes easily to mercury and mercury iodide. Mercury(I) iodide, called Protiodide, was a
very commonly used drug in the 19th century, prescribed for everything from acne to kidney
disease. It was also a treatment of choice for syphilis. It is available over the counter at any
drugstore in the world, the most common form being a concoction of protiodide, licorice,
Dettol and Safeguard: these medicated soaps are one of the most patronized soaps in the market.
Structure of Triclocarban
Triclocarban is an antibacterial agent common in personal care products like soaps and lotions as
well as in the medical field, for which it was originally developed (Chang and McDonnell, 2005).
Studies on its antibacterial qualities and mechanisms are growing. Research suggests that it is
14
similar in its mechanism to triclosan and is effective in fighting infections by targeting the
potential for causing antibacterial resistance and its effects on organismal and environmental
compound since the 1960s (Orsi etal., 2010). It is commonly found in personal care products as
al.,2011). About 80% of all antimicrobial bar soap sold in the United States contains triclocarban
(Orsi etal., 2010). In addition, the United States spends nearly 1 billion dollars annually on
Triclocarban is predominantly active against Gram- positive bacteria (bacteria with a thick
peptidoglycan wall). The precise mechanism of action of triclocarban is unknown, but it is shown
triclocarban does not interfere with the membrane. As a result, it is hypothesized that
triclocarban’s molecular mechanism resembles that of triclosan, which inhibits bacterial fatty
acid synthesis (Heath etal., 1999). By mimicking the natural substrate of the enoyl-acyl-carrier
protein reductase (ENR) enzyme, triclosan acts as a site-directed inhibitor and disrupts lipid,
Tetmosol: this soap is formulated with 5% w/w of monosulfiram as the active ingredient.
15
Monosulfiram structure
Source: (Sweetman,2009).
Monosulfiram, trade name Tetmosol, is an ectoparasiticide used in the treatment and prevention
ACTIMED: this medicated soap contains triclocarban and triclosan as co-active ingredients,
though the percentages of these ingredients were not given by the producer. The mechanisms of
action and the uses of triclocarban have been discussed succinctly under Dettol and Safeguard.
Structure of Triclosan
Triclosan, similar in its uses and mechanism of action to triclocarban is an antibacterial and
antifungal agent found in consumer products, including soaps, detergents, toys, and surgical
cleaning treatments. Its efficacy as an antimicrobial agent and the risk of bacterial resistance
16
remain controversial. Additional research seeks to understand its potential effects on organisms
and environmental health. Triclosan was used as a hospital scrub in the 1970s. Since then, it has
expanded commercially and is now prevalent in soaps, shampoos, deodorants, toothpastes, mouth
washes and cleaning supplies (Thompson etal., 2005). It is part of consumer products, including
al., 2005). In healthcare, triclosan is used in surgical scrubs and hand washes. Use in surgical
units is effective with a minimum contact time of approximately two minutes (Brady etal., 1990;
Zafar etal., 1995). More recently, showering with 2% triclosan has become a recommended
regimen in surgical units for the decolonization of patients whose skin carries methicillin-
At high concentrations, triclosan acts as a biocide with multiple cytoplasmic and membrane
targets (Russell, 2004). However, at the lower concentrations seen in commercial products,
triclosan appears bacteriostatic, and it targets bacteria primarily by inhibiting fatty acid synthesis.
Triclosan binds to bacterialenoyl-acyl carrier protein reductase (ENR) enzyme, which is encoded
by the gene FabI. This binding increases the enzyme’s affinity for nicotinamide adenine
dinucleotide (NAD+). This results in the formation of a stable, ternary complex of ENR-NAD +-
triclosan, which is unable to participate in fatty acid synthesis (WHO, 2006). Fatty acids are
necessary for building and reproducing cell membranes. Humans do not have an ENR enzyme
Sample Collection
17
Samples used for this study were collected from 25 infected school children at different schools
in North Bank area of Makurdi with the consent of the school authorities. The site of infection
where the sample was collected was disinfected using methylated spirit. Different sterile swab
sticks was used for each child. Each sample was labeled and according to each place of
collection, the samples were labelled and packaged. The collected samples were immediately
wrapped tightly to avoid air contamination, and were brought to the Biological Research
Sabouraud’s Dextrose Agar (SDA) medium was used for the isolation of the organisms. 65g of
the medium powder is to be dissolved in 1litre of distilled water. Therefore, 32.5g per 500ml of
distilled water was prepared for 25 petri-dishes. The conical flask was covered with wad of
cotton wool, wrapped with aluminum foil. The conical flask was shaken gently to allow proper
dissolution of the medium. The medium was then autoclaved at 121 oC for 15minutes and allowed
to cool to 50oC.
Chloramphenicol was added as antibacterial agents. Aseptically, 2ml of sterile distilled water
was added to the chloramphenicol powder. It was allowed to dissolve by mixing it gently. Then,
10ml of distilled water was added and mix together. This was distributed in 2ml amounts into
appropriate sterile containers. Each 2ml volume was sufficient for 500ml of Sabouraud’s agar
medium. The final concentration is 0.4mg/ml. The chloramphenicol solution was added to the
18
Normal saline was dispensed into test tubes and were autoclaved at 121 oC for 15min. the swab
sticks were dipped each into a test tube. This was to transfer the organism into sterile medium.
Pour plate technique was used for the isolation of the organisms. Using micropipette, 20µl of
each of the sterile normal saline containing the organisms was dispensed into each corresponding
labeled petri dish. The Sabouraud’s Dextrose Agar medium was autoclaved and was allowed to
cool to 50oC. The medium was poured into the petri dishes. The poured plates were shaken at
intervals to allow even distribution of the organisms in the medium. The plates were then
incubated at room temperature (25 oC) for 5 days. After incubation, the agar plates were observed
The identification of the fungal isolates was done by its staining procedure. To study the
morphology of the isolates, thin layer of the fungal mycelia was spread on clean glass slides and
teased with needles followed by addition of a drop of lactophenol cotton blue stain on each slide.
The slides were covered with cover-slips and visualized under microscope at X40 magnification.
The culture of Tinea species were subjected to urease biochemical test for identity confirmation.
T.rubrumthe two species that were isolated from the samples by employing urease test medium.
4.8g of Urea base was dissolved in 190ml of distilled water. It was dissolved by heating gently.
10ml of distilled water was sterilized at 121 oC for 15 minutes. It was allowed to cool to 50 oC.
0.4g of urea concentrate was dissolved in the sterilized 10ml of distilled water. It was mixed to
19
dissolve and was added to the sterilized urea base. Phenol red was used as indicator during the
preparation of the medium (Cheesbrough,2010). The medium was allowed to cool to 50 oC before
it was poured. The medium was then dispensed in 5ml amounts into test tubes and arranged in
slant position. The medium was inoculated with the test fungi.A sterilized wire loop was used to
pick a loopful of the fungal mycelia growth. With the loopful mycelia, the medium was
urease activity within 7 days and the colour of medium changed to pink. The T.rubrumisolates on
the other hand are urease negative and as a result do not produce urease enzyme (Sinki etal.,
1981).
Crusader, Dettol, Safeguard, Tetmosol and Actimed soaps were diluted in distilled water. 10g
each of the soap was cut into smaller pieces using knife and was dissolved in 50ml of distilled
water. Two-fold serial dilution of the stock dilutions was made beginning at 50mg/ml, 25mg/ml
and 12.5mg/ml concentrations as working dilutions. On the other hand, 200mg of griseofulvin
drug, served as the control, was dissolved in 10ml of distilled water to make the stock dilution.
Working dilution was made by dissolving 2ml of the solution in 8ml of distilled water to
Determination of Inhibition Capacity: The ability of the soap samples to inhibit the growth of
Trichophyton mentagrophytes and Trichophyton rubrum in vitro was determined using agar
diffusion method. 200mg/ml concentration for each of the soap was prepared as stock culture.
This was used to test for the inhibiting capacity of the soaps. Inoculum suspensions of
20
T.mentagrophytesand T.rubrumwere prepared from the five days cultures grown on Sabouraud’s
dextrose agar at 35oC. Suspensions of the fungal colonies were made by scraping the surface of
the colonies with sterile loop into 10ml of distilled water. The resulting mixture of conidia and
hyphal fragments were withdrawn and transferred to sterile tubes for 15 to 20 minutes at room
temperature to sediment the heavy particles. At the start of each experiment, pour plate technique
was done using the inoculum suspensions of the species. Cock borer was used to create wells on
the Petri dishes under aseptic condition. The plates were incubated at room temperature for five
days to check for the zone of inhibitions (Esteban etal., 2005). The diameter of the inhibition of
each of the soap was determined using mathematical rule (cm) and was recorded in millimeter.
Minimum Inhibitory and Fungicidal Concentration: the concentrations: 50mg/ml, 25mg/ml and
12.5mg/ml were used to determine the minimum concentration at which these organisms can be
inhibited. The three concentrations were mixed with prepared Sabouraud’s Dextrose Agar
medium respectively. The medium containing each concentration was dispensed in 20ml to
sterile bottles and were autoclaved at 121 oC for 15min. After autoclaving, the media were poured
into labeled Petri dishes according to each of the soaps for the different concentrations. Under
aseptic condition, a sterilized wire loop was used to pick the fungal suspension to make spot
inoculation. The Petri dishes were then incubated at room temperature for five days. Two plates
without any soap diffusion were inoculated with test organisms as control to check for the
minimum inhibitory concentration of the soaps. The concentration at which there was no fungal
colony growth at all was the minimum fungicidal concentration of that soap.
RESULTS
21
The samples collected from the infected children were inoculated of SDA medium and two
plate showed no growth (Table 1). The biochemical test was done to differentiate the two species
using urease agar. The T. mentagrophyteschanged the colour of the medium to pink while
T.rubrum,the urease
Bottle A is the urease positive result of T.mentagrophytesthat changes the colour to pink while
The zones of inhibition of the soaps were done and were compared with that of the antifungal
26.0mm, Dettol 26.0mm, Tetmosol 30.0mm and Crusader 30.0mm with the control, Griseofulvin
haven an average inhibition of 18.0mm (Table 2). While on T.rubrum, Actimed has 24.0mm,
22
Safeguard 16.0mm, Dettol 21.0mm, Tetmosol 22.0mm and Crusader 23.0mm. Griseofulvin has
an average (10.0mm) zone of inhibition (Table 3). Crusader and Actimed have their minimum
and Dettol and Safeguard were at 50mg/ml. On T.rubrum, Crusader and Tetmosol inhibited at
12.5mg/ml and 25mg/ml respectively. Actimed, Safeguard and Dettol all have their minimum
inbition at 50mg/ml (Table 4). The treatment means of the soaps and Griseofulvin on T.
mentagrophytes were the same using ANOVA data analysis (Appendix 1) while the treatment
means on T.rubrumwere not the same (Appendix 2). The ANOVA result also shows that the
treatment means of the soaps both on T. mentagrophytesand T.rubrumare the same. The soaps
produced better inhibition on T. rubumthan Griseofulvin (Table 3). The difference in inhibitions
might be due to other components of the soaps that have effect on the organisms.
23
Reverse colony Microscopic Species
- - -
thin walls
6 and
Brown to tan Cigar-shaped with T.mentagrophytes
Buff powdery
thin walls
7 and
Buff powdery
Brown to tan Cigar-shaped with T.mentagrophytes
8 White to withbuff
thin walls
age.
Yellow Cigar-shaped T.rubrum
9 and
with thick
Buff powdery
rough walls
10 and
Buff powdery Brown to tan Cigar-shaped with T.mentagrophytes
thin walls
24
Brown to tan Cigar-shaped with T.mentagrophytes
thin walls
Isolated from Infected Pupils Attending LGEA and ST. Mary’s Primary Schools of North Bank
Area, Makurdi.
25
12 Buff and Brown to tan Cigar-shaped with T.mentagrophytes
thin walls
rough walls
thin walls
rough walls
26
22 White and downy Yellow Cigar-shaped with T.mentagrophytes
thin walls
thin walls
Table 2: Zones of inhibition by the soaps at 200mg/ml and the control (Griseofulvin) at 0.1µg/ml
on T.mentagrophyte.
Table 3: Zones of inhibition by the soaps at 200mg/ml and the control (Griseofulvin) at 0.1µg/ml
on T.rubrum.
27
Safeguard 16.0 11.0
Actimed + + + + - -
Safeguard + - - + - -
Dettol + - - + - -
Tetmosol + + - + + Crusader + + + +
+ +
The (+) indicates inhibition of the organism while (-) indicates resistance of the organism.
T.rubrum
28
50mg/ml 25mg/ml 12.5mg/ml 50mg/ml 25mg/ml 12.5mg/ml
Actimed + - - - - -
Safeguard - - - - - -
Dettol - - - - - -
Tetmosol + - - + - -
Crusader + + + + + +
The (+) indicates total fungicidal of the organism at that concentration while (-) indicates the
organism’s resistance.
DISCUSSION
Trichophyton rubrum respectively. ACTIMED, Safeguard and Dettol all have Triclosan as the
active ingredient. Therefore their ability to inhibit Trichophytonin vitro agrees with the work
done by Jones etal., 2000 that showed that Triclosan has in vitro effectiveness against a wide
range of dermatophyte species. The result agrees with the study conducted in Zürich by Jones
etal., 2000 that among the implicating agent for dermatophyte that could be identified through
cultures, Triclosan was proven to be effective against T. mentagrophytes and T. tonsurans with
minimum inhibitory concentrations ranging from 1 to 10ppm. A research was conducted among
primary school children in Kilombero District, Tanzania by Peters etal.,2006 which had similar
sample source with this study. This suggests that the morphology and the biochemistry of the
pathogens might be similar. In the study it was reported that Triclosan was able to decrease the
29
growth circumference of Tineacapitisfrom 2.9cm to 2.4cm among the school the children.
Tetmosol and Crusader have Monosulfiram and Mercury (I) iodide as active ingredient
respectively. These two soaps showed better inhibition and fungicidal activities than those
Minimum inhibitory concentration of the soap samples was done using 50mg/ml, 25mg/ml and
12.5mg/ml for the soap samples. After 5 days incubation, Actimed and Crusader showed
minimum inhibitory concentration was at 50mg/ml for Actimed, Safeguard and Dettol. Tetmosol
has its minimum inhibition at 25mg/ml while Crusader shows minimum inhibition at 12.5mg/ml.
This result shows that though T.rubrum is a slow growing organism but seems to be more
The fungicidal activities of the soap samples were determined using the above concentration.
Actimed and Tetmosol showed fungicidal activities at 50mg/ml and Crusader at 12.5mg/ml while
Safeguard and Dettol do not show fungicidal activity at any of the concentration on
T.mentagrophytes. No fungicidal was seen on T.rubrum for Actimed, Safeguard and Dettol but
Tetmosol and Crusader have fungicidal activities at 50mg/ml and 12.5mg/ml concentrations
respectively. Because of these in vitro findings, one might expect a more pronounced
30
mycological effectiveness of Crusader and Tetmosol against these pathogens. Though topical
treatment of Tineacapitishave been debated and doubt not to have been capable of eliminating
hyphae in the deeper part of the follicle or penetrate hair shafts according to Chan et al., 2004.
However, these findings will agree with Weitzman etal.,1996 recommendation that topical agents
may be used as adjuncts to eliminate viable material from the lesions and thus prevent further
spreading and particularly, he suggested that an effective antifungal soap available for masses
might fulfil this purpose better than any other sort of topical treatment, which will only be used
by patients who are aware of their disease. With these soaps, there is hope that asymptomatic
carrier could be “treated” effectively and this will prevent the spread of ringworm infection to
susceptible individuals.
CONCLUSION
Antifungal susceptibility testing has indeed come of age. The use of effective medicated soaps as
adjunct for topical treatment of Tineacapitiscould be encouraged. The results and findings from
this study showed that Crusader and Tetmosol may be better options as topical treatment agents
for Tineacapitisas they produce fungicidal activities at different concentrations. Though the use
of Crusader may be restricted to adult only, as it is consider being too strong for children use.
However adult carriers may still find it helpful in managing the infection spread.
REFERENCE
Abdel-Aal, H., Mustafa, E., El-Tayeb, S., Sorour, F., Refai, M. and Abdel-Hady, M. (1989);
Ajello L. and Georg L.K.(1957); In vitro hair cultures for diferentiating between atypical
31
isolates of Trichophyton mentagrophytes and Trichophyton rubrum. Mycopathological
MycologyAppl.;8:3–17.
Ajello L. (1977); Milestones in the history of medical mycology: the dermatophytes,In:K. Iwata
(ed.), Recent advances in medical and veterinary mycology. Universityof Tokyo Press,Tokyo. Pg.
3-11.
MycopathologicalMycologyAppl.33:28–32.
Allen H. B., Honig P.J., Leyden J.J. and McGinley K.J. (1982); Seleniumsulfide: adjunctive
28(2):197-201.
Andrews M.D. and Burns M. (2008); Common tinea infections in children. AmericanFam
Physician; 77(10):1415-20.
Bisoen R., Juan A. F., Luc Van Nuffel, F.W., Lieven B., Desire L. M. and Frank C. O.(2001);
Susceptibility testing of Pathogenic Fungi with Itraconazole: a process analysis of test variables.
Brausch J., and Gary R. (2011); "A review of personal care products in the aquatic environment:
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (1996); Epidemiology of Ringworm
Infection. 22:336-347.
32
Chah K.F., Majiagbe K.A., Kazeem H.M., Ezeanyika O., Agbo I.C. (2012); Dermatophytes from
Dermatology.;23(6):522-532
Chander J. (2002); Text Book of Medical Mycology, 2nd Edition, Mehtapublishers, New Delhi.
Pp 89-92.
Chang C.Y. and McDonnell D.P. (2005); "Androgen receptor-cofactor interactions as targets for
390.
Conti-Diaz I.A., Civila E. and Asconegui F. (1984); Treatment of superficial and deepseated
DeBoer D.J. and Moriello K.A. (2006). Cutaneous fungal infections. In Greene C.E (ed):
Mycopathologia;166:257–65.
Elson, L. C. D. (2001). Lackland Air Force Base, TX. personal communication. Emele F.E.,
Oyeka C.A., and Adinma E.D. (2009); Epidemiologic Study of Ringworm in Anambra State
33
Emmons C.W. (1934); Dermatophytes. Natural grouping based on the form of the spores and
Enemour S.C., Atabo A.R. and Oguntibeju O.O. (2012); Evaluation of microbiological harzards
Esteban A., Abarca M.L. and Cabanes F.J. (2005); Comparison of disk diffusion method and
MedicalMycology;43,61-66.
Garg J, Tilak R, Garg A, Prakash P, Gulati A.K. and Nath G. (2009); Rapid detection of
Georg L.K, Camp L.B. (1957); Routine nutritional tests for the identification of
dermatophytes.JournalofBacteriology; 74:113-121.
maladie contagieuse du cuir chevelu de´crite sous le nom de Teigne tondante (Mahon),
Gupta S., Agrawal P., Rajawat R., and Gupta S. (2014); “Prevalence of
34
Dermatophytic Infection and Determining Sensitivity of Diagnostic Procedure”
Halden U. R. (2014). “On the Need and Speed of Regulating Triclosan and Tricarban in the
Heath R.J., Rubin J.R., Holland D.R., Zhang E., Snow M.E. and Rock C.O. (1999). "Mechanism
Chemotherapy274(16): 11110–4.
Indira G., Raghuramulu G., Ramreddy S., and Kondal R. (2011); Identification of two species
Jones R.D., Jampani H.B., Newman J.L., and Lee A.S. (2000); Triclosan: A review of
35
Kwon-Chung K.J., Bennett J.E. (1992); Medical mycology:Lea& Febiger.Philadelphia USA. Pp
125.
Laude T.A., Shah B.R. and Lynfield Y. (1982); Tineacapitisin Brooklyn. AmericanJournal for
DiseasesofChildren.136: 1047-1050.
Lee D.W, Yang J.H, Choi S.J, Won C.H, Chang S.E, Lee M.W, Choi J.H, Moon K.C, Kim
AmericanAcademiaandDermatology.23: 559-560.
Madhavi S. Rama M.V. and Jyothsna K. (2011); Mycological Study of Dermatophytosis in Rural
Malcolm R. and Michael E. (2000); Model Systems for the Study of Dermatophyte Invasion of
Mancianti F., Giannelli C., Bendinelli M., and Poli A. (1992); Mycological findings in feline
Maraki S. (2012); Epidemiology of dermatophytoses in Crete, Greece between 2004 and 2010.
JournalofItalianDermatologyandVenereology;147(3):315-9.
`Mignon B.R. and Losson B. (1997); Prevalence and characterization of Microsporum canis
36
Mohamed R., Heidy A. E., and Mohmoud E. (2013). A guide for isolation and identification of
Moriello K. A. and DeBoer D.J.(1991); Fungal flora of the haircoat of cats with and without
dermatophytosis. JournalofMedicalVeterinaryMycology29:285–292.
Moriello K.A. (2004); Treatment of dermatophytosis in dogs and cats: review of published
FamPhysician;58:163-74, 177-8.
29:355–359.
Orsi M., Massimo N., and Jonathan E. (2015); "Dual-resolution molecular dynamics simulation of
Oyewale M. M., Godson R. A., and Mynepalli K. S. (2015); Use of Azadirachtaindica derived
Peters C., Hatz C. and Bruckner-Tuderman L. (2006); Efficacy of Triclosan Soaps Against
37
School Children in Kilombero District, Morogoro Region, Tanzania.
SchweizerischenTropeninstitutBasel; 5:1-130.
Prescott M.L., Harley J.P., and Donald A. K. (2003); Microbiology, 5th ed.McGrawHill
234.
Pg.123.
Schweizer H. (2001). “Triclosan: a widely used biocide and its link to antibiotics”.Microb
iologyLetters. 22:437-445.
28:161–182.
Sheklakov N.D. and Milich M.V. (1974); Mycoses in man. MirPublisher, Moscow. Pp 254.
Sierra P., Guillot J., Jacob H., Bussiéras S., Chermette R. (2000). Fungal flora on cutaneous and
38
mucosal surfaces of cats infected with feline immunodeficiency virus or feline leukemia virus.
Kushwaha RKS, Guarro J (Eds.). Biology of Dermatophytes and other Keratinophilic Fungi.
RevistaIberoamericanadeMicología,Bilbao:pg.1-11.
Sweetman S.C. (2009). "Pesticides and repellents". Martindale: the complete drug reference
Taylor D.J., Green N.P.O. and Stout G.W. (2005); Biological Science (3 rd Ed.). Cambridge
Thompson A., Griffin P., Stuete R. and Cartmell E (2005); “The Fate and Treatment”.
Villars V. and Jones T.C. (1992); Special features of the clinical use of oral terbinafine in the
8(2):240-259.
Willey J.M., Sherwood L.M. and Woolverton C.J. (2011); Prescott’s Microbiology (8 th Ed):
39
World Health Organization (WHO) (2006); Guidelines for diagnosis, prevention and control of
40