Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ie2c04393 Si 001
Ie2c04393 Si 001
a UNESCO Chair on Water Reuse, School of Chemical Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Tehran,
Tehran, 11155-4563, Iran
b Department of Architecture and Civil Engineering, Division of Water Environment Technology, Chalmers University
16846, Iran
e Biosystems Engineering, Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849, USA
f Department of Civil, Geological and Mining Engineering, Polytechnique Montréal, Montréal, QC H3T1J4, Canada
2 H2O → 4H+ + O2 + e-
Equation S7
Initial
Coagulant/flocculant Type Dosage (mg/l) Wastewater type TSS pH COD color Lignin Reference
(mg/l)
Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal
(ppm) (%) (Pt-Co) (%) (ppm) (%)
effluent of the
primary
Fe2(SO4)3 Chemical 5 3446 7.5 295 36 16
sedimentation
tank
CaCO3 Chemical 5 3446 7.5 295 25 16
PAC +
chemical 100:50:15 1572 11 10773 9.8 17.6 18
MgCl2+polymer
Polyethylene 19
chemical 1200 Black liquor 2 35733 75 95 16060
oxide(PEO)
Poly - dimethyl diallyl 19
ammonium chloride chemical 308 Black liquor 2 35733 56 93 16060
(Poly-DADMAC)
19
PAC chemical 2913 Black liquor 7 35733 47 95 16060
(Turbidity:
Poly-DADMAC P&P mill
chemical 1.2 6000 2900 96 4585 – 87 - - 20
(MW: 88 kg/mol) wastewater
NTU)
prehydrolysis
PEO chemical 400 - 2 131000 24 - - 8800 44 21
liquor (PHL)
prehydrolysis
PEO + PAC chemical 200:200 - 2 131000 28.5 - - 8800 37.5 21
liquor (PHL)
thermomechanical (Turbidity:
Poly-DADMAC TOC:
chemical 120 pulping spent - 2330 32 262 – 96.7 1007 31.7 22
(MW: 185.7 kg/mol) 740
liquor NTU)
pulp and board 23
MgSO4 chemical 3400 784 11 2820 84 6660 89
mill wastewater
pulp and board 23
(Ca(OH)2 (Lime) chemical 1400 784 11 2820 86 6660 92
mill wastewater
pulp and board 23
Alum chemical 1200 784 6 2820 93 6660 97
mill wastewater
C. obtusifolia gum natural 750 P&P mill effluent 841 5 1453 35.3 - - - - 24
PDMC
Poly-DADMAC/
Model solution of
Calcium lactate Chemical/chemical 5.27/2.78 - 6.5 - - - - 2000 68 28
lignin
Poly-DADMAC/ Model solution of
Chemical/chemical 8/2 6.5 2000 65 28
magnesium hydroxide lignin
Poly-DADMAC/
Anionic Model solution of
Chemical/chemical 8/6 6.5 2000 65 28
polyacrylamide lignin
(APAM)
iron (III) trimesic (Fe- Synthetic lignin
chemical 2000 7.84 - - 368 93.48 300 62.5 29
BTC) wastewater
Pulp mill Deep Light
Ferric chloride chemical 30 36 6.7 1857 32 100 89 30
wastewater brown brown
Clay + Aluminum
sulphate chemical 100:300 P&P wastewater 10 6-8 260 - 1150 88 31
pre-hydrolysis
PEO chemical 350 liquor - 2 84800 20 - - 10300 22 32
Table S3 Performance of membrane technologies on the treatment of various P&P mill effluent
Membrane Wastewater MWCO Configuration TMP Permeate Cross Area COD Color Lignin Refer
characteristic type (kDa) (bar) flux flow (cm2) ence
(l/m2.h) velocity
(m/s)
Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal
effluent mol/l
(Al2O3-TiO2) Effluent 20
from Sulfite
Pulp mill
+ NF (TiO2) Effluent
from Sulfite
Pulp mill
PES membrane
MF / Paper mill 0.4 µm Flat sheet 0.75 20 1-1.3 948 84.3 7.49 84 95 82.5 39
UF / PES Paper mill 50 Flat sheet 0.75 12 1-1.3 948 80 7.49 75 95 76.5 39
wastewater abs
(TiO2-ZrO2) process
water from
TMP mill
NF/ Carbon Black liquor 1-1.2 Flat sheet 16 1.4 - 14.6 - - - - 66130 82-84 41
nanotubes and
polysulfone mixed
matrix membranes
membrane liquor
membranes liquor
5 1.8 - 2 5.77 8 110 - - - - 65
Adsorbent/Process Wastewater type Adsorbent pH Treatment time Agitation COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
dose (g) (h)/ HRT (h) speed (rpm) Removal
( %)
Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal
(ppm) ( %) (Pt-Co) ( %) (ppm) ( %)
Plastic mix waste Kraft mill wastewater 1.25 8 7 184 885.33 - 657 96.48 113 94.25 - 46
activated carbon
Nano fly ash Agro-based paper mill wastewater 60 7.3 1 80 596 72.31 878 92.45 - - 71.61 46
NCIM 2891
Bacillus aryabhattai P&P mill wastewater - 7.6 144 120 774 72.22 1065 67 539 54 - 46
wood-activated
carbon
sand
Fly ash thermomechanical pulping spent 20 5.73 24 100 5627 94.67 3500 92.9 1980 90.9 - 46
liquor
Fly ash Kraft bleaching effluent 25 5.2 0.5 100 1313 67.9 - - 1290 81.6 - 46
Delayed petroleum P&P mill wastewater 15 2.1 4 - 2126 >90 230 >90 - - >90 46
cake-activated carbon
Recycled paper wastewater
Granular activared 5.4 - 2 - 1152 80-94 - - - - 98 46
carbon (GAC)
sequence batch
reactor (AC-SBR)
Table S5 Performance of ozonation and photocatalyst treatments on various P&P mill effluent
Treatment type Wastewater type [O3] catalys UV Treatment pH COD Color Lignin AOX Referen
(mg/ t (g/l) (W) time removal ce
min)
( %)
Initial Removal Initial removal Initial removal
Ozonation + nano- Pulp and paper effluent 9.2 [ZnO] 125 30 5 4751 4910 60 >99 - 12
photocatalytic =0.1
(ZnO) + UV light
Ozonation + nano- Pulp and paper effluent 9.2 [ZnO] - 30 5 4751 4910 60 >80 12
photocatalytic = 0.1
(ZnO)
Ozonation + UV Pulp and paper effluent 9.2 - 125 30 5 4751 4910 60 >90 12
light
Ozonation Eucalypt kraft pulp ECF 10- - - 7-8 1300 Slightly 40 5 50 Slightly 50
bleaching effluents 11
ozonation + effluent
biological treatment
mg/l
under UV-LED
radiation
@SO3H wastewater ] = 40
photocatalytic mg/l
process + H2O2
Treatment type Wastewater type EC Treatment pH COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
(µS/cm) time removal
( %)
H2O2 (0.277 M) + CuFe2O4 Pulp and paper 1868 120 m 3 2000 78.3 - - 1632 - - 58
wastewater
Treatment type Wastewater type EC Treatment pH COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
(µS/cm) time removal
( %)
([Fe2+]/[H2O2]:0.32) semi-chemical
effluent
( %)
Fenton process ([Fe2+]: 2.5 Pulp mill effluent - 30 m 5 400 - 0.78 85 - - 18.5 66
process ([FeSO4]:
70mM+[H2O2]: 3M)
mM + [H2O2]:1500 mM)
( %)
clarification
wastewater,
followed by
biological treatment
UV/visible Synthetic - - - - - - - - 90 - 75
Biological treatment technique Mill type Reactor Treatment COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
type time
Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal Removal
(ppm) ( %) (Pt-Co) ( %) (ppm) ( %) ( %)
Various activated sludge plants - - - 60-82 - - - - 45-65 77
continuous
flow
bioreactors
Aerated stabilization basin VF Aerated 15 d 660 65 - - - - 53 78
continuous
Biological treatment technique Mill type Reactor Treatment COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
type time
Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal Removal
(ppm) ( %) (Pt-Co) ( %) (ppm) ( %) ( %)
flow
bioreactors
Facultative stabilization basin VF Aerated 15 d 660 66 - - - - 51 78
continuous
flow
bioreactors
Anaerobic process VF Bioreactor 15 d - 42 - 70 - 25 15 79
surface
aeration
Activated sludge VF Subsurface SRT=5 d ~1200 ~67 ~1400 ~86 - - - 81
diffusion
aeration
Activated sludge - - 20 h 1900 50 - - - - 63 82
strain grey
Activated sludge process using - Activated 24 h - 97 - 97 - - 84
AS reactor
Aerobic process using a bacterial - SBR 14 h 550-1000 72.3 600- 55 - - 45 86
sludge
Activated sludge VF - - 910 89 - - - - - 88
bed reactor
Anaerobic process VF,b UASB/FBR - 880-2100 30-70 - - - - 25-67 92
effluent
Two-stage - - - - - - - 71 93
effluent
Two-stage - - - - - - - 40 93
glucose addition
Anaerobic process with glucose VF,b - 66 73 94
addition
VF Activated - - - - - - - 46 95
stabilization
basins
Anaerobic process VF,b fluidized - 30 - - - - - 65 96
bed and
Aerobic process VF,b Aerobic 65 <65 96
trickling
filter
Aerobic process VF Batch 12 h 1160 - - - - - 75 97
process
Anaerobic + anaerobic process - UASB + 5 + 6.54 h - 91 - 90 - - 58 99
CSTR
Anaerobic process VF,b Fixed-film 10 h 1450 20 - - - - 102 100
reactors
Activated sludge process using VF - 24 h - 96.8 - 97 - - - 84
reactor
Biological treatment technique Mill type Reactor Treatment COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
type time
Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal Removal
(ppm) ( %) (Pt-Co) ( %) (ppm) ( %) ( %)
Activated sludge - - - - 70 - - - - 40-60 105
continuous
Anaerobic process - - - - 59 - - - - - 107
24 h 2500 93
12 h 1500 94
Aerobic granulation process - Aerated 24 h 780 90 - - - - - 110
SBR
Activated sludge Aerated - 780 92 - - - - - 110
SBR
Anaerobic process Synthesis Up-flow 24 h 2500 80 - - - - -
anaerobic 111
packed bed
reactor
(UAPB)
Microorganism Mill Reactor type Treatment COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
Removal
type time Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal ( %)
(ppm) ( %) (Pt-Co) ( %) (ppm) ( %)
Bacillus sp. (AY952465) and S. VF Batch shake 168 h 12800 99 1250 84 413 100 - 112
(AY856831)
Bacillus sp. (AY952465) VF Shaking flask 6d - - - 65 - 37 - 116
Microorganism Mill Reactor type Treatment COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
Removal
type time Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal ( %)
(ppm) ( %) (Pt-Co) ( %) (ppm) ( %)
Mixed culture of Paenibacillus sp., VF Shaking flask 6d - - - 69 - 40 - 116
Aneurinibacillus aneurinilyticus
(AY856831), and Bacillus sp.
(AY952465)
Bacillus cereus (ITRC-S6) VF Shaking flask 168 h 18766 60 3616 45 413 30 - 117
bioreactor
Brevibacillus agri strain RJH-1 Synt Batch mode 5d 500 69 1000 47 - 37 39 121
hesis
Synt Semi-continuous 32 h 500 62 1000 37 - 30 40 121
hesis
Bacterial consortium Serratia marcescens - Batch flask 192 h 18,700 83 6100 85 1000 - - 122
Mixture of Serratia marcescens, Serratia VF Shaking flask 7d 16400 63 8117 65 614 95 - 124
pneumoniae NITW715076_1
K. pneumoniae strain NITW715076_2 and - Batch - 15700 78 - - 10000 69 - 126
NITW715076.
Microorganism Mill Reactor type Treatment COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
Removal
type time Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal ( %)
(ppm) ( %) (Pt-Co) ( %) (ppm) ( %)
K. pneumoniae NITW715076_2 - Batch - 15700 51 - 74 1000 74 - 126
Serratia liquefaciens (LD-5) (the strain was VF Conical flasks 144 h - 85 1495 72 218 58 - 127
2443
Pseudomonas aeruginosa (DSMZ 03504), VF/R Batch 24 h - 76 - 76 - - - 129
Mixed culture Citrobacter freundii and VF Shaking Flask 6d 8068 80 6700 87 2000 - - 132
Serratia marcescens
VF Shaking Flask 6d 16700 67 6700 70 2000 - - 132
Axenic culture (Citrobacter freundii) VF Shaking Flask 6d 8068 45 6700 65 2000 - - 132
Axenic culture (Serratia marcescens) VF Shaking Flask 6d 8068 33 6700 60 2000 - - 132
Consortium (Nigrospora sp. LDF00204 VF/RF Repeated 21 h 6735 80 7253 82.3 1863 76.1 - 145
bioreactor
3d 4892 88 4032.2 86 4846 86 -
Bierkandera adusta - - 10 d - - - - 100 100 - 147
1005
Phanerochaete chrysosporium RF Batch flask 9d 5860 98.5 560 80 995 99.1 - 149
Rhizopus aarhizus - - 4d - - - - - 90 - 9
1654
Aspergillus flavus Strain F10 VF Shaking flask 10 d 253.2 - - 33.68 - 39-61 - 156
157
Microorganism Mill Reactor type Treatment COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
Removal
type time Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal ( %)
(ppm) ( %) (Pt-Co) ( %) (ppm) ( %)
Consortium (Pleurotus sajor caju, VF Batch flask 10 d 392 74-81 - - - - - 158
flask
Batch non- 10 d - - - 79 - - 60 162
shaking flask
Phanerochaete chrysosporium - Three-phased 3d 838.02 78.8 250 86.4 - - - 163
fluidized bed
bioreactor
(batch)
Fluidized bed - - 38.5 - 26.5 - - - 163
bioreactor
(continuous)
Penicillium camemberti VF Up-flow - - - - 59.28 - - 61.93 164
column reactor
P. chrysosporium (sample A) RF Shaking flask 4d 4347 70 - 52 - - - 165
Unknown white-rot fungi - - - 39012 40.74 34940 34.39 2870 16.38 - 166
Microorganism Mill Reactor type Treatment COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
type Time Removal
Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal ( %)
(ppm) ( %) (Pt-Co) ( %) (ppm) ( %)
Scenedesmus acuminatus VF Thermophilic and - 910-2000 29-39 - 74-80 - - - 168
mesophilic
anaerobic digesters
Mixed culture of some green VF Batch reactors 20 d 230 58 1200 79 - - 50 169
Scenedesmus sp.
Mixed culture of Chlorella, VF - 30 d - - 420 80 - - 70 171
Chlorococcum,
Chlamydomonas,
Microcystis, Anabaena,
Euglena, Phacus, Nitzschia,
Cyclotella, Pandorina,
Eudorina, Gonium, and
Prymnesium
Integrated treatments Mill Reactor type Treatment COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
Removal
type time Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal ( %)
(ppm) ( %) (Pt-Co) ( %) (ppm) ( %)
Hydrogenation (NaBH4) + activated VF CSBR 5d ~1200 92 - 97 - - - 81
sludge
Chemical coagulation + Synt Batch 25 m 1857 0.87 - very clear 100 100 - 30
electrocoagulation hesis
Ozonation + GAC VF Semi-batch 30 m 1130 46 1260 87 - - 80 172
bubble reactor
Pre-ozonation + algal treatment Semi-batch - 735 90 543 99 - - 87 172
bubble reactor
+ SBR
Pre-ozonation + GAC + algal Semi-batch 713 87 532 96 89 172
vulgaris)
Trametes versicolor - - 4d 59000 82 5800 80 - - - 174
Integrated treatments Mill Reactor type Treatment COD Color Lignin AOX Reference
Removal
type time Initial Removal Initial Removal Initial Removal ( %)
(ppm) ( %) (Pt-Co) ( %) (ppm) ( %)
Trametes versicolor and 4 d + 20 m 59000 97 5800 92 174
UV/TiO2/RuxSey
Anaerobic + membrane - (SAnMBR) - 5600- 93-99 - - - - - 175
10000
Chemical coagulation + EDR - 156 83.33 309 92.23 60 85 176
AS 24 h 577 58 - 8 177
+ NF
MBR + ozonation - MBR - 2900 40 - - - - - 178
sludge
Chemical coagulation-anaerobic + - Package 15 h - 88.1 - - - - 98.4 182
acidification–aeration reactor
Ozonation - Biofilm - 60 - - - - - - 183
reactor
Ozonation + Biological 85 183
chin
g
Ultrafiltration + anaerobic 60 70 184
membrane
reactor
Electrochemical + membrane - Continuous 8h 86 91 185
mode
Adsorption (bentonite) and - - 30 m 230 60.87 - 41.38 - - - 186
-
PhysicoChemical (poly-electrolyte VF Fluidized - - 11600 27 187
physicochemical (poly-electrolyte
(potash alum)
Constructed wetlands - - - - 62-88 - 97 - - - 188
filtration
Enzymatic + membrane - - - - - - - 1300 - - 190
4250
Aerobic MBR + electrochemical - - - - ~97.2 - 100 - - - 191
oxidation (Ti/SnO2-Sb2O5-IrO2)
Electrocoagulation (aluminum syn Batch 75 m 2500 95 - - 1852 - - 192
electrode)
Ultrafiltration - 88 193