Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.fuelfirst.com
a
Department of Mechanical Engineering, The Middle East Technical University, 06531 Ankara, Turkey
b
Department of Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering, The Pennsylvania State University, PA, USA
Received 26 January 2006; received in revised form 22 March 2006; accepted 23 March 2006
Available online 24 April 2006
Abstract
An experimental investigation on the determination of ballistic properties and burning behavior of a composite solid propellant for
airbag application was conducted. The experimental results were obtained using a high-pressure optical strand burner. Steady-state burn-
ing rates were determined for a pressure range of 20.8–41.5 MPa and initial propellant temperatures of 30 to +80 C. For the pressure
and temperature ranges tested, the temperature sensitivity was on the order of 1 · 103 K1. The pressure exponent was found to be a
function of the initial propellant temperature and was 0.75 at 25 C. The activation energy and the pre-exponential factor of the Arrhe-
nius equation are 2.735 kcal/mol and 15.06 cm/s, respectively. The pressure deflagration limit for this propellant was found to be in the
range of 8.37–8.72 MPa. During combustion, small condensed-phase spherical particles were ejected from the burning surface. The size
of the particles decreased with either increasing the pressure or the initial propellant temperature. For pressures below 41.4 MPa, average
particle size was on the order of 900 lm, and at 84.4 MPa, the bead size was much smaller, on the order of 300 lm. A chemical analysis
on these particles using both the ESEM and the X-ray diffraction method indicated that the material of the beads was mostly sodium
chloride with a small amount of silicon-containing compounds.
2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0016-2361/$ - see front matter 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.fuel.2006.03.026
1980 A. Ulas et al. / Fuel 85 (2006) 1979–1986
solid-propellant formulation to produce combustion prod- Super VHS Panasonic VCR were used for the real-time
uct gases to inflate an automobile airbag. The chemical recording of the propellant burning process. A Setra pres-
ingredients (by weight) of the propellant include 23.5% sure transducer was used to record the instantaneous bur-
Ammonium Perchlorate (NH4ClO4), 58.5% Guanidine ner pressure. To have a constant pressure during test runs,
Nitrate (CH6N4O3), 17.8% Sodium Nitrate (NaNO3), and a computer-controlled solenoid valve was installed in the
0.2% silicon dioxide (SiO2). In this study, burning behavior exhaust line. The solenoid valve maintained constant pres-
of this propellant was investigated at different operating sure in the burner with less than ±1% variation. A Nicolet
conditions. In addition, ballistic properties such as the pres- data acquisition system was used to record the thermocou-
sure deflagration limit (PDL), the burning rate as a function ple signals and the pressure transducer output.
of pressure and initial propellant temperature, the tempera- The propellant was received in the form of powder and
ture sensitivity, and the activation energy of this propellant it was pressed into cylindrical pellets using a computer-con-
were determined experimentally. trolled presser. The propellant strands were pressed using
an extremely detailed pressing procedure to meet stringent
2. Experimental density specifications. Before the pressing, the propellant
powder was dried at 90 C for removing any moisture.
Experiments were conducted in a high-pressure optical For PDL determination tests, short pellets (about 6 mm
strand burner. The operating pressure and the initial pro- in length) were pressed according to the following proce-
pellant temperature were varied from 20.8 to 41.5 MPa dure. First, the pressure was increased to 138 MPa and
and from 30 to +80 C, respectively. A schematic dia- kept constant at this level for one minute. This duration
gram of the setup is shown in Fig. 1. In this investigation, was sufficient for the powder to relax at this pressure.
nitrogen was used as the purge gas. The initial temperature The pressure was then increased to 241 MPa and again
of the propellant strand was controlled by preconditioning kept constant at this level for another minute. Finally,
the purge gas initial temperature using either a cryogenic the pressure was increased to 345 MPa and kept constant
heat exchanger or an electric heating unit for low- and for ten more minutes. During this period, the pressed pow-
high-temperature experiments, respectively. The initial pro- der was fully relaxed, and the density became uniform
pellant strand temperature was determined by either an throughout the pellet. For the burning rate measurements,
S- or R-type thermocouple whose junction was embedded longer pellets (20–23 mm long) were required to suppress
in the propellant strand. A Pulnix CCD camera and a the effect of the transients at the beginning and end of
the tests. The same pressing procedure was used to press 2.1. Burning surface observation
these long pellets, except that after reaching 138 and
241 MPa pressures, it was kept at these levels for 5 min. The close-up observation of the burning surface of a
Also, after reaching 345 MPa, a 30-min interval was propellant is very useful in understanding the combustion
required for the relaxation of the pellets based upon the behavior of the propellant. In order to observe the burning
force gauge reading. surface of propellant with a high resolution, a copper-
The density of each pellet was determined by measuring vapor laser was incorporated. A schematic diagram of
the geometry (i.e., diameter and length) and mass of the the propellant sample configuration is shown in Fig. 3.
pellet. A micrometer with a resolution of 0.025 mm and a Optical lenses were used to convert the cylindrical laser
micro-scale (XE-50 Denver Instrument) with a resolution beam into a thin laser sheet, which has a width around 8–
of ten thousandth of a gram was used to measure the geom- 10 mm at the location of the burning sample. A Panasonic
etry and mass of the pellet, respectively. Only pellets with a SVHS VCR with a filming rate of 60 fields per second was
density of 1.62 g/cc or greater, as specified by the propel- used in conjunction with a Pulnix CCD camera having a
lant manufacturer, were used for the strand burner tests. 90-mm macro lens to record the burning surface phenom-
For measuring the sub-surface temperature profile and ena. The top surface of the pellets was slanted at 45 prior
the surface temperature of the propellant strand, the pro- to the tests for a better view of the surface (Fig. 3). For
pellant powder was pressed into a cone and cup configura- burning surface visualization tests, the propellant sample
tion to embed the micro-thermocouple inside the was ignited with the CO2 laser without any NOSOL-363
propellant. Following a procedure given in [4], thermocou- propellant initiator.
ple wires 25-lm in diameter were welded and then rolled
into a flat foil with a thickness of approximately 8 lm. 3. Results and discussion
The thermocouple bead was placed at the top of the cone,
and the cup portion was then slowly positioned on the cup 3.1. Pressure deflagration limit
to squeeze the thermocouple bead between the two propel-
lant surfaces. Force was exerted on the top of the propel- The results of PDL tests show that the PDL limit is sen-
lant strand in the vertical direction to slightly deform the sitive to the density of the pressed pellets. The PDL limit
thermocouple bead to match the contour of the propellant for pellets with densities larger than 1.62 g/cc ranged from
interface. A schematic of the sample configuration is shown 7.34 to 8.03 MPa, whereas the PDL limit for pellets with
in Fig. 2a. densities in the range of 1.56–1.61 g/cc ranged from 8.37
For the PDL experiments, a small piece of NOSOL 363 to 8.72 MPa. The PDL data was used as a lower pressure
(a double-base gun propellant) was attached to the top of boundary for steady-state strand burner experiments.
the propellant strand and a CO2 laser was used as the igni-
ter (Fig. 2b). NOSOL 363 ignition initiator provided 3.2. Steady-state burning rate
uniform ignition of the test sample, also it prevented in-
depth radiation absorption by the sample, and flame The burning rate was deduced using a linear curve fit to
extinction that could occur when the radiative ignition data obtained from recorded images. The time vs. distance
source was abruptly removed. For the steady-state burning data were deduced by measuring the distance burned and
rate experiments, the propellant strand was ignited by a the corresponding time. Fig. 4 shows typical time vs. dis-
conventional nichrome wire (Fig. 2a). tance trajectories of the propellant for the various pressures
Fig. 2. Sample configurations for the: (a) steady-state strand burner experiments, (b) PDL experiments.
1982 A. Ulas et al. / Fuel 85 (2006) 1979–1986
7.5
0.3
Pressure [psig]
0.2
5 3000 4000 5000 6000
20.8 MPa
27.7 MPa o
T = 25 C
0.1
2.5 34.6 MPa i
41.5 MPa 3 o
T = 80 C
i rb = 0.2133 P 0.665
0 T = -30 C
o
R 2 = 0.9941
n = 0.665
Burning rate [cm/s]
0 i
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8
Time [s] 2
1.6
0.6
0.652 0.497
1.4
r [cm/s] = 0.0121 P[MPa] T[K]
b o
1 PSU Data, T o=
Ti = 80 C 80 C i
0.5
1.2 o
TalleyTData, T o=
= 100 100 C
1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 i i C
2
Pressure [psig] R = 0.9997
4 o
2000 4000 6000 8000 10
PSUTData,
i = -30
TC
o
= -30 C
i
o o
Talley
Ti Data,
= -10 TC= -10 C i
0.1
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
0.802
rb [cm/s] = 0.1335 P[MPa]
Pressure [MPa]
Burning rate [cm/s]
2
R = 0.9907
Fig. 10. Combined low- and high-pressure burn rate data at cold
temperatures.
Temperature Sensitivity, σp , [K ]
-1
0.002
of the solid propellant is not significantly affected by the
temperature of the environment. Solid-propellant tempera-
ture sensitivity, rP, is defined by Eq. (2), which represents 0.0015
the change of the burning rate per degree change in initial -20%
temperature at constant pressure.
0.001
o ln rb
rP ð2Þ -1 -4 -5
σ [K ] = 7.701x10 + 2.071x10 P[MPa] - 1.032x10 P[MPa]
-7 2
oT i P p
0.0005
The temperature sensitivity at various pressures was
determined by constructing a semi-natural log plot of burn-
ing rate versus initial temperature. In this plot, the slope of 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
the linear curve fit represents the temperature sensitivity of Pressure [MPa]
the propellant at the specified pressure. A plot illustrating Fig. 12. Pressure dependency of temperature sensitivity.
this method is shown in Fig. 11. After rP was determined
at each pressure, a plot showing the pressure dependency
of temperature sensitivity was constructed (Fig. 12). The sensitivity is a highly desirable characteristic of a propel-
rP is 0.0011 K1 at P = 20.8 MPa and gradually increases lant. When the burning rate is not significantly influenced
up to 0.00208 K1 at P = 114 MPa. Fig. 12 also shows a with the propellant initial temperature, the airbag inflation
2nd order polynomial fitted to the experimental data. The time (which is related to the propellant burning rate) is also
propellant temperature sensitivity values are quite low, not significantly effected with the initial temperature. The
which means that the propellant performance would not temperature sensitivity information and its pressure depen-
be significantly influenced by the temperature of its envi- dency are useful for design predictions of the performance
ronment. The low temperature sensitivity characteristic of of airbag inflators using this propellant.
the propellant is also apparent from Fig. 11, which shows
almost a 20% change in the propellant burning rate when 3.4. Burning surface temperature
the propellant initial temperature changes from 30 to
+100 C. In the ballistic field, 20% increase in the propel- The subsurface temperature profile of a solid propellant
lant burning rate for an initial temperature range as wide is governed by an exponential profile until it reaches the
as the one considered in this study (30 to +100 C) is surface [6]. Therefore, to determine the surface tempera-
not considered a significant increase. Low temperature ture, the temperature profile was plotted on a semi-log plot
versus distance from the propellant surface. The departure
point on the semi-log plot represents the surface tempera-
ture (Ts). A typical temperature profile is shown in
1.6 P = 86.8 MPa P = 46.3 MPa P = 34.6 MPa Fig. 13. The sub-surface thermal wave penetration depth
P = 59.8 MPa P = 127.8 MPa P = 27.7 MPa is on the order of 20 lm. The dashed vertical line at
P = 114.2 MPa P = 41.5 MPa P = 20.8 MPa
1.2 x = 0 in Fig. 13 represents the burning surface location.
The positive x domain corresponds to the gas-phase region
0.8 and the negative x domain corresponds to the unburned
solid-phase region. The surface temperature for the pres-
ln (rb )
1
A = 15.06 cm/s
E a = 2.735 kcal/mol
0.1
0.0012 0.0013 0.0014 0.0015 0.0016 0.0017
-1
Inverse surface temperature, 1/Ts [K ]
Fig. 14. Arrhenius plot. Fig. 16. Image of the burning surface (P = 7.68 MPa).
Fig. 15. Photograph showing the burning surface (Laser-assisted burning at P = 2.86 MPa).
1986 A. Ulas et al. / Fuel 85 (2006) 1979–1986
Fig. 17. Magnified view of beads under: (a) 29 times, (b) 1500 times magnification.
larger for the low temperature tests. The bead-like residue diameter decreases with increasing chamber pressure and/
was analyzed using an environmental scanning electron or initial propellant temperature. Both the ESEM and the
microscope (ESEM) to construct the elemental map of X-ray diffraction method indicate that the composition of
the bead and an X-ray diffraction to determine its com- the bead residue was mostly sodium chloride.
pound composition. The X-ray diffraction results agreed
well with the ESEM results and indicated that the material
Acknowledgements
of the beads was mostly sodium chloride, NaCl, with a
small amount of silicon-containing compounds. Fig. 17 is
The authors would like to thank Talley Defense Systems
a photograph of the beads at a magnification of 28.8 and
for the sponsorship of this research program. The interest
1500 times of their original size. The diameters of particles
and support of Mr. Christopher P. Ludwig and Dr. Robert
in this photograph are approximately 900 lm.
Glick are greatly appreciated. Also, the authors would like
to acknowledge the micro-thermocouple and pellet press-
4. Summary and conclusions
ing effort of Professor Baoqi Zhang at PSU. Special thanks
go to Mr. Bruce Anderson of Talley Defense Systems for
An experimental study was conducted to determine the
Talley’s high-pressure burning rate data.
steady-state burning characteristics and some important
ballistic properties of an Ammonium Perchlorate/Guani-
dine Nitrate/Sodium Nitrate solid-propellant formulation References
for airbag applications. The pressure deflagration limit of
[1] Struble DE. Airbag Technology: what it is and how it came to be. In:
the propellant was found to be in the range of 8.37–
proceedings of the 1998 international congress and exposition, Feb 23–
8.72 MPa. The pressure exponent was 0.802 at room tem- 26, 1998, SAE special publications Airbag Technology, vol. 1333, p.
perature. The burning rate at room temperature can be 73–92, Paper 980648 SAESA2.
represented by an Arrhenius burning rate law with activa- [2] Deppert TM, Barnes MW, Mendenhall IV, Taylor RD. Development
tion energy of 2.739 kcal/mol and pre-exponential factor of of gas generants for passive automobile restraint systems, proceedings
of the 2nd international symposium on sophisticated car occupant
15.06 cm/s. The temperature sensitivity of the propellant is
safety systems: AirBag 2000 Conference, Karlsruhe, Germany,
relatively low (0.001–0.002 K1). The low rP characteristic November 1994. p. 10-1–17.
represents a desirable feature of an airbag propellant. The [3] Sherman D. The rough road to airbags, Invention and Technology,
temperature sensitivity dependency on pressure was deter- Summer 1995.
mined for pressures ranging from 20.8 to 128 MPa. At [4] Zenin A. Thermal wave profiling measurements using fine-wire
thermocouples. An Invited Presentation at Penn State University
low-pressures (P < 17.3 MPa), the propellant burns in a
1994;10(August).
highly non-one-dimensional manner, due to the dynamic [5] Risha GA, Ulas A. Kuo KK, Koch DE, Ludwig CP, Glick R.
melt zone and particle formation and ejection phenomena Combustion behavior of TAL-1308 composite solid propellant for
near the burning surface region. However, for pressures airbag applications, AIAA Paper No. 99-2632, 35th AIAA/ASME/
beyond 20.8 MPa, it burns in a nearly ‘‘layer-by-layer’’ SAE/ASEE joint propulsion conference and exhibit, Los Angeles, CA,
June 20–23, 1999.
form. The propellant generates some residual spherical
[6] Kubota N. Survey of rocket propellants and their combustion
beads on the order of 900 lm for pressures below characteristics. Fundamentals of Solid Propellant Combustion. In:
41.5 MPa. For pressures around 86.3 MPa, the spherical Kuo KK, Summerfield M, editors. Progress in Astronautics and
beads are on the order of 300 lm in diameter. The bead Aeronautics, vol. 90. AIAA; 1994. p. 1–52 [chapter 1].