Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Transmission Challenges and Solutions For All Digital AM IBOC NAB 2014
Transmission Challenges and Solutions For All Digital AM IBOC NAB 2014
ALL-DIGITAL AM IBOC
BRIAN W. WALKER
Nautel Limited
Hackett’s Cove, Nova Scotia, Canada
−10
−20
Relative magnitude (dBc)
−30
−40
−50
−60
−70
−80
−90
−100
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Frequency (kHz)
7 AM-AM CORRECTION
Figure 5: The MA3 signal passing through an NX50 transmitter. The amplifiers in the transmitter will tend to have some
Note that the power level displayed in the top banner is RMS, while degree of amplitude distortion. The distortion is typi-
the sidebar shows the actual carrier power.
cally low enough that it does not cause issue with analog
transmission, but it benefits from being corrected for bet-
ter audio specifications as well as digital transmission.
6 TRANSMITTER NONLINEARITY CORRECTION The actual mechanism for applying this type of correc-
tion in the NX transmitter is by digitally applying a look-
The transmitter would not have any difficulty with meet- up table (LUT) to the magnitude signal before generat-
ing the spectral mask if it were not for some inherent ing the pulse duration modulation (PDM) signals for the
nonlinearities in the amplification. There are four princi- amplifiers. It is adapted by comparing the desired sig-
pal sources of spectral regrowth: nal against the measured output voltage of the transmit-
1. Amplitude nonlinearity, otherwise known as AM- ter, after appropriate delay-matching and filtering. The
AM distortion correction that would usually be applied on a transmit-
ter is accomplished with a 1 kHz tone, and assumes that
2. Incidental phase modulation caused by envelope the amplitude distortion is relatively constant with fre-
variation, also know as AM-PM distortion quency. This simplification holds true at low frequency,
but as the frequency increases the response of the modu- of the RF output is dependent on the magnitude of the
lator filter comes into play. envelope voltage. This effect is certainly present when
The transmitter AM-AM correction was adapted us- broadcasting in analog, and a suitable correction can be
ing several different frequencies as shown in Figure 7. applied to remove it. A relatively simple method involves
At 1 kHz, the modulator filter has very little response using a lookup table to find the opposite phase shift at a
and so its impedance can be modelled as a short. As given amplitude and applying it to cancel the distortion.
the frequency increases, the source impedance added by An example of such a lookup table is shown in Figure 8.
the modulator filter increases, and an interesting effect It can be seen from the characteristic in the graph that the
happens. The PA tends to behave as a lower resistance correction required is quite significant at low amplitudes,
value at very low amplitudes, which then has a tendency and drops off to almost nothing above the nominal carrier
to counteract the modulator distortion once the source level.
impedance increases. As a result, less AM-AM correc-
AM−PM correction on NX50 at 1 MHz
tion is required at higher modulating frequencies. This 45
implies that while the curve determined at 1 kHz, which 40
higher. 20
15
1 5
0
0.9
−5
0.8 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
signal level (% full scale)
gain correction
0.7
0.6
Figure 8: Example AM-PM correction curves from NX50 operating
0.5
at 1 MHz, using 1 kHz training frequency.
0.4 1khz
3khz
0.3 5khz
7khz
When operating with an all-digital signal, this type of
0.2
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 AM-PM distortion can result in poor spectral compliance
signal level (% full scale)
if left uncorrected. This is considerably worse than if
the same transmitter were transmitting analog. It may
Figure 7: AM-AM correction curves at 1, 3, 5, and 7 kHz. be counter intuitive, since there would obviously also be
troughs on an analog signal that would result in phase
The principal problem with running the AM-AM cor- modulation, but the high frequency envelope content in
rection at higher frequencies, or on an actual signal, is the troughs of a digital signal in turn causes high fre-
that there tends to be a frequency response on the resul- quency phase modulation. This has far more of a ten-
tant signal due to the modulator filter. The requirement dency to make the transmitter exceed the spectral mask,
for delay matching on the desired signal vs. the mea- especially at frequencies farther away from the carrier.
sured output also becomes much stricter, since otherwise In contrast, the incidental phase modulation of an analog
a correction update may be applied to the wrong index transmitter tends to fall closer to the carrier and be within
in the look-up table. This can cause instability in the the spectral emissions mask.
precorrection algorithm, and will result in the transmit-
ter emitting unwanted spectral content because of noise 9 ENVELOPE EQUALIZATION
and poor convergence in the LUT. In order to help alle-
viate this issue, each update to the lookup table can be In an AM transmitter using an EER architecture, with a
applied as a weighted average to a region of the look-up modulator followed by a RF amplifier, there is often a
table. This has the effect of filtering the update, and helps bandwidth limitation on the envelope path. This is im-
tremendously with the stability of the algorithm. Using posed by the combination of the PDM process and the
this technique to run the adaptation on the actual signal reconstruction filter. The PDM frequency should be kept
allows for the most appropriate correction to be used, and low to minimize AM-AM distortion and to boost the ef-
does not interrupt the on-air signal. ficiency. At the same time, the modulator filter must
attenuate any harmonics of the PDM that might pass
8 AM-PM CORRECTION through the amplifier and cause unwanted spectral emis-
sions. These goals are at odds with the desire to keep
Another common distortion found on AM transmitters the envelope bandwidth as wide as possible to maximize
is AM-PM distortion. When this occurs, the phase shift transmitter linearity.
Using a compensation filter on the magnitude signal tion should be considered after all precorrection options
can help extend the bandwidth by boosting those fre- are exhausted, since it will degrade the modulation er-
quencies that are attenuated by the modulator reconstruc- ror ratio (MER) slightly. It has been incorporated in the
tion filter. This compensation filter also equalizes group NX series for wide bandwidth Digital Radio Mondiale
delay, which is often just as if not more important than (DRM), but is equally applicable to the MA3 signal with
correcting for amplitude variation. The challenge often the appropriate configuration[3]. The principle used is
lies in finding the ideal filter for the system. On the similar to some peak to average power ratio (PAPR) re-
NX series, a modified version of the least mean squares duction schemes, where the problematic portion of the
(LMS) algorithm is used to adapt the filter from the mea- signal is modified slightly to reduce its impact. With a
sured voltage sample. PAPR reduction the problem areas are peaks; with the
One method that has been used with success to adapt typical AM transmitter, the most challenging portions of
the filter is simply to run the transmitter in AM mode the signal are in the troughs, for a few reasons.
with wide band (>70 kHz) noise as the modulation
source. This has the advantage of being very simple to • The envelope signal has the highest frequency con-
implement, it tends not to be affected by any other non- tent in the troughs when operating with a digital sig-
linear effects, and it gives a good characterization of the nal.
modulator response since there is known frequency con-
• The AM-AM distortion is most pronounced at low
tent. The disadvantages are that it can be affected by
amplitudes, and the variation with frequency means
the RF filter response and a broadcaster could not real-
that it cannot be perfectly cancelled.
istically run a signal like this into the antenna, since it
would cause interference with several other stations. • The AM-PM distortion on the signal is largest at
To optimize the transmitter for the all-digital signal, low amplitude where the current from the PA is low.
the equalization needs to be adapted with the transmit- This can typically be corrected extremely well, but
ted signal, ideally into the antenna. This allows for the errors in the other corrections will cause phase er-
unique characteristics of the load to be taken into ac- rors since the predicted amplitude would not match
count, has the advantage of not driving the RF load at fre- the voltage across the RF bridge.
quencies that are not of interest, and allows on-air adap-
tation. The challenge with using the transmitted signal is • Bandwidth limitations on the antenna can translate
that the frequency content will not be flat for the adap- to either increasing or decreasing impedance being
tation. Using this filtering algorithm, this type of signal presented by the RF PA with frequency. This may
adapts the filter fairly well where there is significant fre- result in a requirement for the modulator to apply a
quency content, but not where there is less energy. This negative voltage to the RF PA in order to achieve the
is insufficient to help with the spectral regrowth, and in desired output, which is not possible without the ad-
many cases can make it worse than having no equalizer dition of considerable complexity to the amplifier.
at all.
The envelope signal can be altered to allow adaptation There are a few essential stages to the algorithm, with
by using a shaping filter to flatten the envelope frequency several methods being possible for each step.
content. This is only used in the adaptation algorithm, • Identify the problematic sections of the signal
not on the transmitted signal. The implementation on the
NX series measures the signal going through the trans- • Flag and extend the identified sections
mitter to dynamically design the shaping filter to use.
The overall effect of this process is that the equalization • Replace each section with a lower frequency transi-
filter will adapt more closely to the high-frequency re- tion (as measured with the magnitude and phase)
gions in the trough. The same portions of the signal tend
to be responsible for most spectral regrowth, so this gives • Low pass filter the resulting signal to ensure it stays
the best results. within the original RF bandwidth