Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(1)
Now, divide both sides by gz2 . The equation can then be written as
(2)
(3)
• To present the results of an experimental study, the drag force could be plotted
as a function of V for various values of the radius R holding all other variables
fixed.
• Then a second plot could show the drag force for various values of L holding all
other variables fixed, and so forth.
Example for Dimensional Analysis
• The plots may resemble those of Fig. 2 above. To vary the viscosity holding the
density fixed and then the density holding the viscosity fixed, would require a
variety of fluids leading to a very complicated study, and perhaps an impossible
study.
Example for Dimensional Analysis
• The actual relationship that would relate the drag force to the other variables
could be expressed as a set of dimensionless parameters, much like those of Eq.
(2), as
(3)
(4)
All three similarity conditions must exist for complete similarity to be ensured.
(5)
• We choose to select the M-L-T system (F-L-T system can also be used) and use Eq.
(5) to relate F to M, L, and T.
• If temperature is needed, as with the flow of a compressible gas, an equation of
state, such as
where the brackets mean “the dimensions of.” Note that the product RT does
not introduce additional dimensions.
Dimensions of fluid variables
1. First of all, write the functional relationship with the given data.
2. Now write the equation in terms of a constant with exponents i.e. powers a,
b, c,...
3. With the help of the principle of dimensional homogeneity, find out the
values of a, b, c, ... By obtaining simultaneous equation and simplify it.
4. Now substitute the values of these exponents in the main equation, and
simplify it.
5. If the number of exponents involved is more than 3, then the exponents of
the properties D, V, and are evaluated in terms of other exponents. That
helps to group the variables into recognized dimensionless parameters.
Problem using Rayleigh method
Show that the resistance force F to the motion of a sphere of diameter D moving
with a uniform velocity V through a real fluid of density and viscosity is given by
𝐹 𝜇
= f
𝜌𝐷2 𝑉 2 𝜌𝑉𝐷
Buckingham theorem
• Rayleigh method becomes laborious and cumbersome when large number of
physical variables are involved.
• The Buckingham theorem is used to create the dimensionless parameters, given
a functional relationship such as that of Eq. (3). Write the primary variable of
interest as a general function, such as
• The term 1 is selected to contain the dependent variable [it would be FD of Eq. (3)]
and the remaining terms contain the independent variables.
• It should be noted that a functional relationship cannot contain a particular
dimension in only one variable; for example, in the relationship v=f(d, t, ρ) the
density cannot occur since it is the only variable that contains the dimension M,
and M would not have the possibility of canceling out to form a dimensionless
term.
Buckingham theorem
Steps:
The steps that are followed when applying the Buckingham theorem are:
1. Write the dependent variable as a function of the (n–1) independent
variables. This step requires knowledge of the phenomenon being studied. All
variables that influence the dependent variable must be included and all
variables that do not influence the dependent variable should not be
included. In most problems, this relationship will be given.
2. Identify the m repeating variables that are combined with the remaining
variables to form the terms. The m variables must include all the basic
dimensions present in the n variables of the functional relationship, but they
must not form a dimensionless term by themselves. Note that an angle is
dimensionless, so it is not a candidate to be a repeating variable.
3. Combine each of the (n– m) variables with the repeating variables to form the
terms. Step 3 is carried out by either inspection or by an algebraic
procedure.
4. Write the term containing the dependent variable as a function of the
remaining terms.
5. Suitable non-dimensional group results when repeating variables are choses
as geometric property (such as length), a fluid property (such as density) and
flow characteristics (such as velocity).
Buckingham theorem
Example
The method of inspection will be used in an example. To demonstrate the algebraic
procedure, let’s form a term of the variables V, R, , and . This is written as
Suppose that only one term results from an analysis. That term would then
be equal to a constant which could be determined by a single experiment.
Buckingham theorem
• Finally, consider a very general functional relationship between a pressure change Δp,
a length l, a velocity V, gravity g, viscosity , a density , the speed of sound c, the
surface tension , and an angular velocity Ω.
• All of these variables may not influence a particular problem, but it is interesting to
observe the final relationship of dimensionless terms.
• Dimensional analysis, using V, l, and as repeating variables provides the relationship
• For example, if a model river is built to study flooding, the model is often several hundred times
smaller than the prototype due to limited lab space. If the vertical dimensions of the model were
scaled proportionately, the depth of the model river would be so small that surface tension
effects (and the Weber number) would become important, and would perhaps even
dominate the model flow, even though surface tension effects are negligible in the
prototype flow.
• In addition, although the flow in the actual river may be turbulent, the flow in the model river
may be laminar, especially if the slope of the riverbed is geometrically similar to that of the
prototype. To avoid these problems, researchers often use a distorted model in which the
vertical scale of the model (e.g., river depth) is exaggerated in comparison to the horizontal
scale of the model (e.g., river width). In addition, the model river bed slope is often made
proportionally steeper than that of the prototype. These modifications result in incomplete
similarity due to lack of geometric similarity.
• Model tests are still useful under these circumstances, but other tricks (like deliberately
roughening the model surfaces) and empirical corrections and correlations are required to
properly scale up the model data.
Flows with Free Surfaces: Froude number
In many practical problems involving free surfaces, both
the Reynolds number and Froude number appear as relevant
independent groups in the dimensional analysis (Fig.). It is
difficult (often impossible) to match both of these
dimensionless parameters simultaneously. For a free-
surface flow with length scale L, velocity scale V, and
kinematic viscosity , the Reynolds number is matched
between model and prototype when
The Froude number is matched between model and In many flows involving a liquid with
prototype when a free surface, both the Reynolds
number and Froude number are
relevant nondimensional
parameters. Since it is not always
To match both Re and Fr, we solve above possible to match both Re and Fr
simultaneously for the required length scale factor between model and prototype, we
Lm/Lp are sometimes forced to settle for
incomplete similarity.
Flows with Free Surfaces: Froude number
Eliminating the ratio Vm/Vp from above Eq., we see that the required ratio of
kinematic viscosities to match both Re and Fr:
• Even if liquid mercury would work, it would be too expensive and too
hazardous to use in such a test. What do we do? The bottom line is that
we cannot match both the Froude number and the Reynolds number in
this model test.
Ans:
Problem
The speed V of a weight when it hits the floor is assumed to depend on gravity g, the
height h from which it was dropped, and the density of the weight. Use dimensional
analysis and write a relationship between the variables.
Ans: