Shubham Bansal (19PGDM194) Shubham Khandelwal (19PGDM196) Shubham Todi (19PGDM197) Walid Ansar (19PGDM280) •Samir Singh as Lifebuoy’s global sales increased by 17%p.a. and gross profit by 22%p.a. from the period 2009- 2012. 1. How would you evaluate Samir Singh’s •The key features of his role as VP in first three years as the first 3 years were: Global Brand VP for • To improve the health and hygiene Lifebuoy soap? How of a billion people by 2015 difficult was the • Unilever had an uneven situation he inherited? performance in the recent decades How effective has he been in dealing with • He managed to reverse the decline those challenges? Where in market share that Lifebuoy was has he fallen short? experiencing • Lifebuoy had to be the standard bearer of the goals that the top management wanted to achieve Singh dealing with the concerns:
Integrating the social mission
The challenges faced by Singh were:
Unilever had an uneven performance in recent
decades Defining a global strategy to Competitors like Dettol were into price and reclaim Lifebuoy’s status promotional competition
The new CEO wanted to make strategic and
organizational changes How to go about implementation of plans in India among the Lifebuoy was into continued reinvention, repositioning and launch following KKD Rural Outreach Campaign MP Partnership Model Urban Schools Liquid Initiative 2. What do you think Paul Polman’s strategy was to: of Paul Polman’s USLP Halve the environmental strategy? How realistic footprint of it’s products is it to overlay USLP’s Help 1 billion people improve bold sustainability their health and well being goals over financial objectives? What Source 100% of it’s agricultural raw materials sustainably implications does it have for middle He believed that growth at any managers like Singh price is not viable and frontline It was launched as a part of managers like Unilever’s Sustainable Living Sitapati? Plan Rationale behind overlaying Implications on managers: USLP:
Tackling sustainability challenges They set unrealistic targets
provides new opportunities for sustainable growth Constantly under pressure to perform It creates preference for brands
Builds business with retail Even Unilever did not have all the customers answers and was aiming to form partnerships Drives innovation
Grows potential markets They had too many parameters to
lay focus on, varying from finances to Generates cost savings sustainability to sales to profit margin
They had a limited time period to
show whether what they were doing was translating into results The KKD Rural Outreach Initiative : Risks – 3. As Sitapati, what • The reach to remote villages decision would you becoming decreasingly cost effective. make regarding the • The Lifebuoy demonstrations to three handwashing housewives is not resulting in behavior change sustainable behavior change. programs that have Benefits – been proposed? What risks and benefits are • Ability to reach remote rural media associated with dark areas. each? • Prominent Product Placements in the village shops. The MP Partnership The Urban School Liquids Initiative Initiative: Risks - Risks – Time Consuming with a long The total size of the liquid payback period hand wash market -> 5% of the total soap market. The training and materials Distraction from the could not be branded with organization attention Lifebuoy’s name towards the behavior change. Reach of only 1.5 million Benefits - people. Training children could influence the family Benefits – behavior. High growth segment – The scope of expansion to Growing at 40% annually. And other Indian States. is also having high profit margins. Less payback period – 3.5 4. As Singh, what The option of the Urban schools Liquid Initiative could be chosen action, if any, It focusses solely on Lifebuoy, not on multiple would you take to products influence It targets children not housewives Sitapati’s It is aimed at increasing the use of liquid hand wash rather than the decision? What Lifebuoy soap would you do if he chooses not to So, to influence Sitapati’s decision one factor that implement either could be brought to notice is that liquid handwash market was only $65 million which is just 5% of of your preferred total soap market, and expected to reach only 1.5 Jakarta models? million people, which won’t be helpful if the company wants to achieve the USLP target of changing lives of 1 billion people in the country