Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Attractions;
Set out to attract visitors including day visitors
Provides fun and leisure experience and an
enjoyable way for people to spend leisure time.
Provide an appropriate level of facilities to meet an
cater for the demands of the tourists
May or may not charge an admission for entry
They are shared with host communities and this can
be source of conflict, where tourism can be
perceived to cause problems.
Accessibility
Infrastructure
Roads
Waste disposal
Sewerage system
Electricity
Water
Harbour – water quality
Cont…
Superstructure
Buildings and structures covering area that
cannot exist successfully without a good
infrastructure, e.g. Airport, Sea port
Societal structure
Culture
Rules
Rituals
Community
Destination Life Cycle
1. Exploration stage
The basic idea of Butler’s 1980 Tourism Area Life Cycle
(TALC) model is that a destination begins as relatively
unknown and visitors initially come in small numbers
restricted by lack of access, facilities and local knowledge.
Only small numbers of adventure tourists (explorers,
allocentrics, poets and painters) discover the destination,
making individual, non-institutionalized travel arrangements
and having limited impacts on the area.
Cont…
The number of tourists’ increases and at peak periods far outweighs the size of
the local population and this is helped by the improvement of accessibility.
The development stage reflects a well-defined tourist market area, shaped in
part by heavy advertising and as the stage progresses, local involvement and
control of development will decline rapidly.
Some locally provided facilities will have disappeared, being superseded by
larger, more elaborate, and more up-to-date facilities provided by external
organizations, particularly for visitor accommodation.
The number of incoming workers increases
Natural and cultural attractions will be developed and marketed specifically, and
these original attractions will be supplemented by man-made imported
facilities.
Changes in the physical appearance of the area will be noticeable, and it can be
expected that not all of them will be welcomed or approved by all of the local
population.
Cont…
Regional and national involvement in the planning and provision of
facilities will almost certainly be necessary and, again, may not be
completely in keeping with local preferences.
The number of tourists at peak periods will probably equal or exceed the
permanent local population.
As this stage unfolds, imported labour will be utilized .The type of tourist
will also have changed, as a wider market is drawn upon, representing the
mid-centric of Plog’s classification or Cohen’s institutionalized tourist.
Local agricultural and cattle production cannot provide the quantity and
perhaps the quality of food demanded by enterprises and many foods are
imported. Likewise the local handicraft production is not enough and
imported souvenirs are sold in the shops of the resort.
Large-scale investments are undertaken and local involvement and
control of development declines rapidly and the tourist trade is taken over
by outsiders.
Consolidation stage
Cont…
The resort image becomes divorced from its geographic
environment.
Although the resort now has a well-established image, it is no
longer in fashion and property turnover is high.
Few new establishments open, facilities depreciate in value and
local ownership of tourist facilities increases.
The type of visitor can also be expected to change towards the
organized mass tourist identified by Cohen and the
psychocentric described by Plog.
The end of the cycle is marked by the post-stagnation phase,
which may result in decline, if the tourist market continues to
wane and the resort is not able to compete with newer resorts,
or rejuvenation.
Decline
In the decline stage the area will not be able to compete with newer
attractions and so will face a declining market, both spatially and numerically.
It will no longer appeal to vacationers but will be used increasingly for
weekend or day trips, if it is accessible to large numbers of people.
Tourist facilities will be replaced by non-tourist related structures, as the area
moves out of tourism.
Local involvement in tourism is likely to increase at this stage, as employees
and other residents are able to purchase facilities at significantly lower prices
as the market declines.
Hotels may become condominiums, convalescent or retirement homes, or
conventional apartments, since the attractions of many tourist areas make
them equally attractive for permanent settlement, particularly for the elderly.
Ultimately, the area may become a veritable tourist slum or lose its tourist
function completely.
Rejuvenation
This stage requires a complete change in the tourist attractions. There are basically
two ways of achieving rejuvenation.
One is the addition of a man-made attraction, as in the case of Atlantic City’s
gambling casinos. However, if neighboring and competing areas follow suit, the
effectiveness of the measure will be reduced
An alternative approach to rejuvenation is to take advantage of previously
untapped natural resources. Spa towns in Europe and the summer holiday village
of Aviemore in Scotland have experienced rejuvenation by a reorientation to the
winter sports market, thus allowing the areas to experience a year-round tourist
industry.
The development of new facilities becomes economically feasible, and
simultaneously serves to revitalize the older summer holiday trade.
As new forms of recreation appear, it is not impossible that other tourist areas will
find previously unappreciated natural resources to develop.
Eventually, however, it can be expected that even the attractions of the
rejuvenated tourist area will lose their competitiveness .
Points to note
It must be noted that not all areas experience the stages of the cycle as clearly as
others. The establishment of what has become known as the ‘instant resort’ is a case
in point. Under these circumstances the development phase becomes the real
commencement of the cycle.
An increase in either visitors or time in the model implies a general reduction in
overall quality and attractiveness after capacity levels are reached.
The shape of the curve must be expected to vary for different areas, reflecting
variations in such factors as rate of development, numbers of visitors, accessibility,
government policies and numbers of similar competing areas.
Each improvement in accessibility to a recreation area results in significantly
increased visitation and an expansion of the market area. If development of facilities
and accessibility is delayed, the exploration period may be much longer than
anticipated
The classic, well-established tourist areas of the world (i.e. those which have been
popular over several decades), frequently reveal evidence of having passed through
all of the postulated stages. such as the Grand Isle resort of Louisiana (Meyer-
Arendt, 1985), Malta (Oglethorpe, 1984), Vancouver Island (Nelson and Wall, 1986)
etc.
Strengths of the model
Agarwal (1994) notes that the model should have alternative and
additional stages after the stagnation stage of the original model.
Baum notes that the original TALC Model does not acknowledge the
probability of having further stages which could take place as
associated alternatives to either decline or rejuvenation.
Other researchers found Butler’s model incapable of explaining the
tourism evolution of some resorts and proposed modifications or
alternative models that better fitted the development process of
particular resorts.
Choy (1992) suggested that it is better to treat each destination
individually, as a unique entity, and taking the case of Pacific island
destinations, proposed that different approaches may be required
from those which have been applied to other regions of the world.
Cont…
Exceptions to the process may also occur in case authorities decide
to control development and limit the construction of tourist
facilities before the destination reaches the stagnation stage.
In this case the resort remains in the involvement, development or
consolidation stage and is slow to reach the remaining stages of
evolution.
In addition, there is a possibility to jump stages (Prideaux, 2000).
As Goncalves and Aguas (1997:13) state about more recently
developed destinations; the first stage is being gradually reduced
and sometimes even disappears, giving as example the Cancun of
Mexico, where the resort has been transformed rapidly to a mass
tourist destination without passing the first stages of resort cycle.
Doxey’s Irridex Model – Doxey 1975