Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. Warehousing
2. Picking Strategy
i. Order Picking
ii. Automation Picking
3. Inventory Management
i. Holding Stock
ii. Cycle Count
4. Resources Planning
i. Productivity Data
ii. Work Hours Calculation
iii. Manpower Calcualtion
Break-Bulk Warehousing
This type of warehousing, at the receiving end of a transportation route,
separates large, consolidated freight loads into smaller loads according to
destination or customer.
Cross-dock warehouses
Transferring goods from incoming trucks at receiving docks to outgoing trucks
at shipping docks, or goods are staged for a short time (< 24h) before loading.
Avoids placing goods into storage
Hub-and-spoke system
Combines the benefits of consolidation, cross-docking, and break-bulk
warehouses. Similarly to cross-dock facilities they did not hold stock but just
function as trans-shipment points for sorting of goods. The locations are road,
sea or airfreight concentration points.
Receiving
• Speed and information accuracy critical for all subsequent activities like
picking
• Most WMS’s will not release orders if product is not in the system, even if
the product is sitting on the dock!
• Common KPI is ‘dock to stock’ time
Dispatch
• Throughput speed key, since most operations are subject to cut off times
for same - or next-day dispatch
Reasonable design rule of thumb:
• Receiving and dispatch (staging and work areas) usually account for
15%-20% of the warehouse floor area (can be up to 30%, depending on
systems and operations circumstances).
• Should not be used as a blanket assumption. It is supposed to 12 m from
the rack.
The required height for receiving and dispatch activities is generally low, so
mezzanine or other ‘high’ solutions not required
• Floor stacking or drive-through racking for pallet staging
• Can use headroom above marshalling for slow-moving storage/picking,
mezzanine office (ensure adequate clear height for MHE in marshalling
areas)
Receiving and dispatch typically do not account for the majority of labor in a
warehouse
• Picking optimization is key
• In loose-case receiving operations, receiving represents a higher
percentage of labor
Data relating to all the above activities needs to be sourced and analyzed
before a warehouse design can be prepared accurately, and should include
the following:
• Physical characteristics of the product stored, for example fragility, size and
perishability.
• Stock holding volumes (cartons, pallets).
• Throughput (number of orders, lines per order, items per line, receipts, etc).
• Equipment available for storage and handling.
• Cost data (buildings, equipment, labor).
• Existing equipment and buildings constraints.
• Statutory requirements.
• Market trends – what is likely to happen in the future.
• Synthetics – the analysis, modeling and simulation required to establish optimum
equipment.
• Labor availability and quality.
• Service level requirements – what customers expect.
• Safety and security.
• Capital and time available.
• The relationship with other parts of the system – both internal with other departments
within the same organization and external with customers and suppliers.
Shelving
Packing
area
Advantages (cont)
Advantages
• Shared use of space/equipment • Optimises both pick / putaway
• Better security with single-sided entry and exit • Good when few SKUs make up much of volume
• Minimise travel distance for cross-dock operations • Good layout for interleaving
Flow-Through Layout
Advantages
• Single direction of flow; therefore, limited cross traffic and design is able to accommodate more doors
Disadvantages
The simplest method you can use for storing it is to place one
pallet on top of another in rows without any racking.
Advantages
• Low cost
• Flexible / Quick access to stock - high
productivity
• Good use of the square floor area (though
not the height)
• Excellent space utilization with high
number of pallets/SKU
Deeper bays mean
Disadvantages lower utilization!
• Honeycombing
• FIFO rotation
Suitability
If there are a lot of items stored, with relatively low quantities of each,
then it is good practice that every pallet in a warehouse will need to
be
accessible without moving other pallets first. This means that racking
is required, along with either a manual or computerized system for
recording what quantity of which product is stored in which location.
Racking Types
Advantages
Disadvantages
• Poor building utilisation (due to the
aisles)
• Lower productivity compared to floor
storage
• Difficult to accommodate pallets of
varying heights
• Higher capital investment in racking
and MHE
Suitability
• Suitable for fast-moving and slow-
moving product
• Product lines with low level of pallet
holdings per SKU
a = height of leg
H = pallet + load + a + clearance
Location | July 1, 2021 Page 27
Storage and Equipment
Advantages
Very Narrow Aisle (VNA) Racking - Flexible, versatile system
Disadvantages
- More expensive MHE requirement (VNA or even
wire-guided trucks)
- Low productivity if MHE not dedicated to each
aisle
- Lengthy training
Suitability
- Space is extremely expensive or limited
Disadvantages
• Loss of pallet selectivity (FIFO)
• Honeycombing
Suitability
• SKUs that cannot block stack but have
between 4-8 pallets/SKU
• Drive-in/Drive-through Racking
This racking system has been designed to allow a fork lift truck
to drive into the bay creating very high density storage for non-
stackable loads. It is useful for operations with limited stock
keeping units (SKUs) and high quantities of pallets per SKU.
FIFO is difficult to maintain in drive-in racking systems however.
Disadvantages
• Operationally more difficult to manage
• Honeycombing
• Push-Back Racking
This is a racking system that incorporates a carriage or other
sliding device that makes it possible to feed multiple pallets into
the same location, “pushing back” the previous pallet. This can
be used in wide aisle and narrow aisle applications.
OUT
• Cantilever Racking
This is a racking system where the shelving supports are
connected to vertical supports at the rear of the rack. There are
no vertical supports on the face of the rack allowing for storage
of very long pieces of material such as piping, timber or carpets.
Cantilever rack
for rods / pipes
• Wire Decking
Wire decking can be used with
adjustable pallet racking and
cantilever racking, and is usually
used when a product is placed into
racking without pallets. Wire
decking increases safety,
productivity, and reduces product
damage. There are other types of
decking available including solid
decking, but fire inspectors
generally do not like solid decking
since it reduces the effectiveness
of sprinkler systems.
Individual items can be stored in
carousels or in drawer systems as
well as in shelving. Carton live
storage can also be used.
• Wire Decking
For some types of product, it is likely
that cases could fall from their rack
locations and cause safety risks
• Small product
• Loosely palletized
• Non-palletized product
• Sanitation reasons
• In-rack sprinklers
Power Mobile
racking
Stacking racks
(temporary) suitable
for seasonal or odd-
shaped loads
Pallet Flow
racking
Half gap = 50 mm
Pallet = 1000 mm
Half RT aisle = 1350 mm
Total = 2,400 mm
Please design :
•What kind of rack where have you seen it in use?
•Considering the honeycomb and the accelerate picking and the warehouse utilization.
•Consider the office station will reduce the space
•Consider the staging area
One group will present their results in front of the class. Others compare and ask questions.
Pallet SKU
Types of pallet
From a design perspective, the two most important considerations are likely:
• Overall height (plan for this in height of rack levels, typical dimension is ~15
cm)
• Four-way entry (if pallets can only be accessed only from two sides, will drive
pallet orientation)
• Don’t forget about pallet overhang!
A post pallet is a stackable pallet with permanent or removable support posts on all
four corners of the pallet, used for temporary storage or to stack ‘non-stackable’ goods
These are
‘stack
racks’.
Pallets sit
inside of
these.
Walk-behind or ride-on
models are available. Many
feature small steps for
reaching high areas, as well
as small work area
convenient for writing and
clipboard storage. Ground-
level use only.
Extended models
available for carrying
two pallets at a time
Source: Crown Equipment Corporation
Stacker
Similar to power pallet
truck, except the forks
can raise and lower
Reach Truck
Stand-up vs. sit-down
reach trucks may require
varying aisle widths.
Always validate aisle
width requirements with
your vendor.
8.0
6.0
4.5
Lifting Heights
15 m
11,5 m
5,4 m
3,7 m
1,8 m
WP ST WE WE RR TSP
Source: Crown Equipment Corporation
WP
One Pallet up to 6 Km/h max speed
PR
PE
Two Pallets up to 12 Km/h max speed
PE
Three Pallets up to 16/20 Km/h max speed
Troughput Pallets/h
Source: Crown Equipment Corporation
Transporting / Pulling
Small-Item Picking
Cases are frequently picked to pallets
Picking Productivity
Productivity in order picking is measured by the pick rate – the
number of items, lines or pallets picked over a given period of time,
usually an hour.
Cycle Time
Cycle time is the amount of time it takes to get an order from order entry
to the point of dispatch – the shipping dock. Customers’ increasing
expectations in terms of how quickly they want to receive orders has
increased the emphasis on reducing cycle times from days to hours or
minutes. Immediate release of orders to the warehouse for picking
include methods that provide concurrent picking of items within large
orders thus reducing cycle times
An example being splitting an order into different parts and giving one
part each to a number of picking staff
Accuracy
Regardless of the type of operation, accuracy is a key objective.
Virtually every decision made in setting up a warehouse will have some
impact on accuracy, from the product numbering scheme, to the design
of product labels, product packaging, the design of picking documents,
location numbering scheme, storage equipment, lighting conditions, and
picking method used.
Technologies that assist in picking accuracy include pick-to light
systems, counting scales, and barcode scanners. Beyond the design
aspects of an order picking operation, employee training, accuracy
tracking, and accountability are essential to achieving high levels of
Accuracy.
Item Picking
Where individual items are picked.
1. Basic Order Picking
In the most basic order picking method, product is stored in fixed locations on
static shelving or pallet racking. An order picker picks one order at a time
following a route up and down each aisle until the entire order is picked. The
order picker will usually use some type of picking cage or trolley, or pick product
directly onto a pallet.
This basic order picking method can work well in operations with a small total
number of orders and a high number of picks per order. Operations with low
picks per order will find the travel time excessive in this type of picking and
operations with large numbers of orders will find that the congestion from many
pickers working in the same areas slows down the processing.
2. Batch Picking
In batch picking, a number of orders are grouped together in batches. An order
picker will pick all orders within the batch in one run using a consolidated pick list.
In operations with low picks per order, batch picking can greatly reduce travel
time by allowing the picker to make additional picks while in the same area. As
multiple orders are being picked at the same time, systems and procedures are
required to prevent orders being mixed.
In very busy operations, best practice is batch picking is often used in conjunction
with zone picking and automated material handling equipment
3. Zone Picking
In zone picking, the picking area is broken up into individual pick zones.
Order pickers are assigned a specific zone, and only pick items within that
zone. Orders are moved from one zone to the next as the picking from the
previous zone is completed in assembly line style (also known as "pick and-
pass"). Usually, conveyor systems are used to move orders from zone to zone. In
zone picking it is important to balance the number of picks from zone to zone to
maintain a consistent flow to maintain productivity.
Zones are usually sized to accommodate enough picks for one or two order
pickers. Creating fast pick areas close to the conveyor is essential in
achieving high productivity in zone picking. Zone picking is most effective
in large operations with high total numbers of SKUs, high total numbers of
orders and low to moderate picks per order, such as mail-order
operations. Separate zones also provide for specialization of picking
techniques such as having automated material handling systems in one
zone and manual handling in the next..
4. Wave Picking
A variation on zone picking and batch picking where rather than orders
moving from one zone to the next for picking, all zones are picked at the
same time and the items are later sorted and consolidated into individual
orders/shipments. This is the quickest method for picking, but sorting and
order consolidation can prove to be difficult.
50%
15%
15%
Order picking Shipping Receiving Storage
Order picking typically accounts for 50% of the direct operating costs
• Careful not to over-engineer 001 003 005 007 009 011 013 015 017 019 021 023
Good IT system for effective picking 020 019 018 017 016 015 014 013 012 011
• Walking order
• Effective reporting for slotting purposes
001 003 005 007 009 011 013 015 017 019
Heaviest
Stock availability at the pick face must be Product
maintained 002 004 006 008 010 012 014 016 018 020
020 018 016 014 012 010 008 006 004 002
Picking stock should be concentrated in the smallest feasible area, with care
taken to avoid congestion
• Try to avoid ‘foot’ traffic and MHE traffic in the same areas for safety
This often involves keeping the reserve stock and order-picking stock separate
• Vertical separation: Picking stock at lower level and reserve stock at higher
levels (good for operations with high replenishment but rarely works
‘perfectly’ in practice)
• Horizontal separation: Reserve stock on one side of the warehouse and
picking stock on the other side
Some interesting articles on picking and other concepts
http://www.theprogressgroup.com/publications/wp5_pick.html
http://www.strategosinc.com/Downloads/NAVSUP529/ns10.PDF
http://usco.kuehne-nagel.com/pdf/KN_wp_Design_for_Payback_070104.pdf
Fully automated picking machines (such as A-frames) are still pretty rare and
are used only where very high volumes of similar products are picked such as
music CDs, or, where high volume in combination with high accuracy
requirements exist such as pharmaceutical fulfillment.
Pick-to-light
Pick-to-light systems consist of lights and LED displays for each pick
location. Pick-to-light systems have the advantage of not only increasing
accuracy, but also increasing productivity
Carousels
Horizontal carousels work on the same principle as those
used at baggage reclaim at airports, although on a smaller
scale. Horizontal carousels are most common in picking
operations with very high number of orders, low to moderate
picks per order, and low to moderate picks per SKU.
Horizontal carousels provide very high pick rates as well as
high storage density. Pick-to-light systems are often
integrated into carousels.
Vertical Carousels (similar to a small scale Ferris wheel) are
frequently used in laboratories and specialty manufacturing
operations and are rarely used in regular order picking
operations.
Location | July 1, 2021 Page 87
Automation Options for Picking
Voice-directed Picking
Voice technology has come of age in recent years and is now a
very viable solution, although it is not widespread. Directions are
given to staff via head sets.
There are many methods to calculate the ABC classification of a given SKU
An ABC classification based on pure case movement indicates the relative
volume of each case
Slotting is the process of determining the specific warehouse location for each
SKU and is based on:
• Frequency
• Product weights and dimensions Slotting research paper
provided for your
• Segregation requirements information
• Separation of similar SKU numbers
• Separation of products with similar appearances
• Fragrance transfer
• Family mix distribution (which product groups ship together)
The most important concept in slotting is frequency, which is based on the
number of trips to a location, and NOT the total outbound volume
• In keeping with the goal to minimise travel distance, the largest time-
consumer in the picking process
You may want to create more than one pick face per SKU, depending on
desired replenishment frequency
Be sure to specify the slotting objective prior to doing this analysis, i.e., reduced
travel, reduced crushing/damage, etc.
• Etc.
One group will present their results in front of the class. Others compare and ask questions.
Stockholding Costs
The cost of holding stock varies from industry to industry, and from
business to business. Martin Christopher states that “It is estimated
that in total it (inventory) costs a minimum of 25 percent per annum
of the book value of inventory just to hold it” 2 The cost of holding
stock is made up of two main elements – the investment in the
inventory and the storage costs
• Line Accuracy ?
Total number of Line / SKU that were cycle counted AND had
the incorrect Qty per Line / SKU within Total number of
line/SKU that were cylcle counted according to Data Base
(WMS)
• Location Accuracy ?
Total number of locations that were cycle counted AND had the
incorrect SKU, quantity, lot ID, date and status within Total
number of locations that were cylcle counted according to Data
Base (WMS)
Behavior
Maintaining inventory accuracy must be an integral part of your behavior
and of your organization. Like quality, customer service, and plant
safety, accuracy must be promoted throughout the organization as
everyone's responsibility. Processes are often shortcut if they impact on
short term productivity and profitability. In the long term, this will reduce
an organization’s ability to service its customers to expected levels, and
could result in losing customers.
Defining the Process
Define clearly the processes in an organization that affect inventory.
Each of these processes can then be evaluated to find out where and
why errors occur, and steps taken to correct them. Formal checks can
be put in place at critical points to reduce problems. Input is required
from all areas within the organization to gain a complete understanding.
Procedure Documentation
The processes and procedures within them should be written down,
once identified, and staff advised that they must follow them. It
should include everything the employee needs to know to complete the
task. Good practice requires that procedures should also include the
correct method for filling out and processing paperwork, the sequence
and timing of entering data, and any checks that are required to be
performed.
Employee Training
Go through the processes with staff to ensure they have a thorough
understanding of what needs to be done for each documented task.
Revisions to procedures should take place periodically, but not too often
as this can cause confusion.
Employee Testing
Employees should be tested to ensure they understand what is required
of them. Those you have identified as not having understood properly
must be retrained.
Monitoring
Any actions observed which do not comply with the written procedures
must be addressed immediately with the employees involved
Pareto method
Derived from the Pareto principle, is to cycle count inventory by
percentage of inventory value. This leads to the expensive items
being counted most frequently.
This traditional approach may appeal to accountants by minimizing
the variance in inventory value. However, it can be inefficient from a
supply chain
. management perspective. Inventory shortages of even
a small, inexpensive component can bring the entire assembly line
to a halt while the component is re-ordered.
Hybrid
.
Most cycle counting frequencies are determined first by a computer
running some kind of Pareto-like or frequency analysis, and then
changing the count frequency, or ABC code, as needed per item..
Automation
To conduct efficient and accurate cycle counts, many organizations
use some form of software to implement an inventory control
system, which is part of a warehouse management system. These
systems may include mobile computers with integrated barcode
scanners that allow the operator to automatically identify items, and
enter inventory counts via keypad. The software then transmits data
to a database on a host system which can generate inventory
reports
.
Dangers
Cycle counts can introduce inventory errors if the cycle count
process is poorly executed or performed infrequently
Differences in the physical count and the stock file can be down to
any number of reasons, and include:
•Inaccurate counting.
•Inaccurate keying of stock counts.
•Stock incorrectly receipted.
•Stock incorrectly shipped.
•Shrinkage.
Frazelle, Edward H. Various sources of information from The Logistics Institute, Georgia Institute of
Technology.
Frazelle, Edward H. World-Class Warehousing. Atlanta, GA: Logistics Resources International, Inc.,
1996.
Rushton, Alan, John Oxley and Phil Croucher (Editor). “The Handbook of Logistics and Distribution
Management (Creating Success).” 2000.
Cranfield University. Various notes from courses in the Logistics and Supply Chain Management MSc
program.
Pilot, Vincent, Facility Design: A Discussion on Warehousing Concepts , A Practical Approach to Design,
6 November 2006
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cycle_count