Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CDI 2 CHAPTER 6 Asphyxia and CHAPTER 7
CDI 2 CHAPTER 6 Asphyxia and CHAPTER 7
Asphyxia
At the end of this chapter, the student will be able to:
Define asphyxia
4. Penetrating injuries of the chest causing the collapse of lungs or chest muscles;
Suffocation refers to the exclusion of air from the lungs by means other than
compression of neck, such as through entrapment in an airtight enclosure with
inadequate oxygen in the environment. It is the most common term used for deaths
associated with reduced availability of oxygen as well as in cases where other
nontoxic irrespirable gases are encountered. This could happen to a homicide victim
who is left to die while tied up in a confined space, or a child who enters a self-
locking fridge or box while playing hide-and-seek then finds no mechanism of
escape. In a submarine, an increase in carbon dioxide can result in central nervous
system depression and respiratory collapse. Carbon dioxide poisoning can also occur
when infants are placed in a sleeping position that puts them at risk of rebreathing
carbon dioxide. There are also toxic gases, such as carbon monoxide, cyanide and
hydrogen sulfide, which can cause rapid collapse and sudden death when high
concentration is present in an enclosed space (Walker, Milroy, & Payne-James,
2005). Another form of suffocation involves the creation of a local hypoxic
environment within a plastic bag securely fastened around the head. This could
occur as a deliberate suicidal act, or accidentally by children. The decedent's face is
usually pale when the bag is removed. The term suffocation can also broadly refer
to cases of entrapment, suffocating gases, smothering, choking, mechanical
asphyxia, and traumatic asphyxia.
Smothering is the mechanical obstruction of the external airway or plastic bag. This
requires at least the partial obstruction of both the (mouth and/or nostrils) by an
object such as a hand, pillow, duct tape or plastic bag. This requires at least the partial
obstruction of both the nasal cavities and the mouth or the upper airway.
Choking
Choking involves the obstruction of the larynx by food, vomit, blood, or other foreign
bodies. This sometimes happens when a large bolus of food material becomes lodged
in the opening of the pharynx or larynx, making the victim gag and unable to inhale or
exhale (Adelman, 2007), thus leading to asphyxiation.
One form is the phenomenon of crush or traumatic asphyxia wherein the chest is
compressed, either by other individuals (such as in a stampede situation where there
is crushing by body upon body) or from solid objects (e.g., pinioning against strong
security fences during a stampede). Although the structures of the chest wall are
intact, compression of the chest wall prevents the normal movements respiration, thus
leading to asphyxia.
Strangulation
2. The base of the tongue is pressed to the back and upwards inside the neck
occluding the nasopharynx;
Drowning refers to a form of death that occurs when atmospheric in water or other
fluids. It is a specialized form of asphyxia in which air is prevented from entering the
lungs due to submersion of the body oxygen (air) is displaced by a liquid (usually
water).
Drowning is the frequent cause of death in bodies that are recovered from water,
such as swimming pools, ponds, lakes, oceans, rivers, fountains, and wells. However,
complete submersion is not essential for death to occur: drowning can occur even if
only the face is submerged. It can also occur indoors, such as in bathtubs, water or
even in buckets containing water. Drowning is common among infants, toddlers, and
young children who fall into water and cannot extricate themselves. It is also
common among intoxicated or risk-taking adolescents and young adults (Prahlow &
Byard, 2012).
When a body is discovered in water, one must question whether death is indeed
due to drowning. Merely finding a human body submerged or floating in the water
does not necessarily indicate drowning. Why was the dead person in the water and
why was he or she unable to get out of it? It could be that the person may have died
of natural causes before falling into or while in the water, or he/she may have died
of injury before being thrown in the water or while in the water. Inability to swim,
hazardous environment, trauma, seizure disorder, heart disease, exhaustion, alcohol
and drug use, hypothermia, and other causes should be sought to answer the
question of why this person drowned.
There are several phases involved in drowning (Adelman, 2007, pp. 55-56).
2. This is quickly followed by the voluntary act of holding one's breath because the
victim is fully conscious and aware of the dangers of inhaling water. Panic usually sets
in and a desperate effort to swim or to float to the surface knowing fully well that if
this is not possible, the result will be death. A person in good physical condition can
probably hold his/ her breath for about one minute, possibly even longer, but there is
a limit (usually under 2 minutes).
3. After this, another involuntary reflex occurs and the victim gasps for air. At this
moment, enormous quantities of water are inhaled and swallowed. A choking cough
reflex may be set up, which leads to further discomfort, terror, and the inhalation and
swallowing of more water.
4. As the victim loses consciousness, the water filling the (the spaces in the chest that
house the lungs). As the body fills with water, additional water may begin to leach into
the lungs oozes out of these organs into the pleural cavities abdominal (peritoneal)
cavity and into the pericardial sac.
1. Suicidal
• Heavy articles or weight may be found in the pocket of clothing
• Presence of suicidal note
• Strong reason to commit suicide
• Mentality of the person
• Previous attempts of suicide
2. Homicidal
• Evidence of struggle
• Articles belonging to the assailant
• Presence of motive for the killing
• Presence of ligature on the hands or legs
• Presence of physical injuries which could not be self- inflicted T
• Testimony of witnesses
3. Accidental
• Absence of any mark of violence
• Condition and the situation of the victim before death
• Exclusion of homicidal or suicidal nature of drowning
• Testimony of witnesses
4. Natural death while in water
• Presence of pre-existing cardiovascular disease
• Exacerbation of current condition due to physical exertion of swimming or
struggling
2. Submersion of mouth and nostrils in water for a time preventing free entrance of air
into the lungs;
4. Gross skin shedding, muscle loss with skeletal exposure, and partial liquefaction
There are no specific autopsy findings for a pathologist to
definitely determine that drowning has occurred. The findings
are different in cases of wet drowning in fresh water and sea
water. In dry drowning, water enters the air passages and
induces laryngeal spasm, which in turn, leads to complete
closure of air entry into lungs; water does not reach the lungs
and the characteristic features of drowning are absent. Internal
examination may indicate the presence of froth (usually white,
sometimes pink) in the nostrils and mouth, as well as in the
upper and lower airways. Lung weights are usually higher (600-
800 g) in drowning cases (non-drowned bodies have 350-550 g),
although normal weight is also possible, as in dry drowning. The
most valuable Positive sign could be an overinflated filling of the
thoracic cavity.
Differentiation of homicidal or suicidal strangulation
HOMICIDE
• “Dump body”
• Unlocked residence
• Evidence of burglary or belongings rummaged through
• Jewelry / belongings missing
• Inconsistent statements from acquaintance / witness / other
• Convincing motive(s) identified
• Recent life insurance policy started / significant shifts of money
• History of previous physical / sexual assult
• Ligature of extremities
CHAPTER 7
Poisoning
Learning Objectives
• Was a substance taken for therapeutic purposes, was it abused recreationally, was
it used for suicidal purposes, or was it administered homicidally?
Cyanides are chemical compounds, many of which are toxic. Cyanide products are
used in several industrial processes, mainly for the mining of gold and silver. It is also
employed in case hardening several chemical processes, such as fumigation, of iron
and steel, electroplating and photographic processing.
Cyanide is a rapid-acting and deadly poison that can kill in a matter of minutes. Its
use has been relatively common in suicides and accidents, and has also been used in
homicides. The most hazardous compound is hydrogen cyanide (also known as
prussic acid or hydrocyanic acid or HCN), very pale, blue, transparent liquid or
colorless gas that can kill a human within minutes. It has been used for capital
punishment in gas chambers and by terrorists as a chemical weapon.
Other common poisonous cyanide compounds include potassium cyanide (KCN) and
sodium cyanide (NaCN), which come in the form of white crystalline salts with a faint
almond-like odor. Cyanide in salt form is often administered orally, but can also be an
inhalation hazard when dissolved in acidic liquids. The toxicity of cyanide is due to its
ability to stop cellular respiration and ATP synthesis in cells, thereby causing anoxia.
Symptoms of poisoning include headache, dizziness, nausea, vomiting, shortness of
breath, and mental deterioration. Ultimately, seizures, apnea, coma, and cardiac
arrest cause death.
Strychnine
Strychnine
Strychnine is a highly toxic crystalline alkaloid usually obtained from the seeds of
the Strychnosnux-vomica tree, which is commonly found in India and Southeast
Asia. It is odorless and appears as a white or translucent crystal or crystalline
powder, with an extremely bitter taste that can easily be detected in foods and
beverages. It is primarily used as a pesticide against rodents. Fatal poisoning can
occur following exposure by inhalation, swallowing or absorption through eyes or
mouth. It produces excruciatingly painful and violent spastic reactions, resulting in
a horrific death. A lethal dose results in painful muscle cramps, followed by
extremely intense muscle contractions that are worsened by the slightest external
stimulus such as a simple touch. The convulsions appear to resemble seizures, but
the victim is completely conscious and aware of the painful event.
Carbon Monoxide
Carbon Monoxide
Carbon monoxide (CO) is a highly toxic gas produced by the incomplete
combustion of organic materials. It forms when there is insufficient oxygen to
produce carbon dioxide. It is colorless, odorless, tasteless and initially non-
irritating; hence, it is very difficult for people detect.
Saukko and Knight (2004) identify the following common causes, among
others, of carbon monoxide poisoning:
• Structural fires in houses and buildings where victims are overcome by the
gradually spreading monoxide while trapped or asleep;
• When a drunken person collapses with a lit cigarette then the bed cover
catches fire; the smoldering bed cover results in a high level of
carboxyhemoglobin; and
Thallium (Tl) is a soft gray metal mostly found geologically in produced as a byproduct
from the refining of heavy metal sulfide semiconductor industry, manufacture of
special glass, and for certain ores, and used in the manufacture of electronic devices,
switches, the medical procedures. Thallium sulfate is an odorless, tasteless and highly
toxic dense white powder salt that has been commonly employed as a rat poison. This
sulfate salt is soluble in water and can enter the body by ingestion, inhalation, or
through contact with the skin. It has been banned in several countries due to safety
concerns.
Thallium disrupts many cellular functions and is also a suspected cause of carcinogen.
Following absorption, it is distributed to the red blood cells and also appears in the
brain, lungs, guts, muscle tissue, salivary glands, pancreas, testes, spleen, kidney, liver,
and bone. Characteristic symptoms of thallium poisoning include loss of hair,
paresthesia (damage to peripheral nerves causing pain in the hands and feet described
as a sensation of walking on hot coals), endocrine disorders, gastrointestinal and
pulmonary distress, psychosis, delirium, and convulsions. Death may result from
cardio-respiratory collapse (Stripp, 2007 and Saukko & Knight, 2004).
Aconite
Aconite
Aconite (or aconitine) is a toxin produced by the Aconitum napellus plant, which is
also known as monk's hood, wolf's bane, women's bane, devil's helmet and blue
rocket; it is found chiefly in mountainous parts of the northern hemisphere. Once
believed as the most toxic substance known to man, it has been historically used to
poison arrow and lance tips, to kill condemned criminals, and to poison the water
supply of enemies. Women were thought to be especially vulnerable to the poison.
Aconite is a white powder that is barely soluble in water but very soluble in alcohol.
The rapidly acting poison takes effect within minutes of exposure and targets the
electrically excitable cells of the nervous, cardiovascular and skeletal muscular
tissues, causing abnormal and potentially fatal heart rhythms. Early symptoms
include a tingling and numbness at the point of contact (usually the mouth and
throat), sweating and nausea.
Ricin
Ricin
Ricin is a highly toxic, naturally occurring protein derived from the seed of the
castor oil plant Ricinus communis. Ricin is twice as deadly cobra venom and it is
poisonous if inhaled, injected, or ingested. It has a high lethality, causing
weakness, fever, and pulmonary edema after inhalation that can lead to death
from hypoxemia in 2 to 3 days.
Following ingestion, the first symptoms of ricin poisoning usually occurs in less
than six hours. Death takes place within 36 to 72 hours of exposure, depending
on the route of exposure (Stripp, 2007, pp. 34- 251. Ricin poisoning can occur
through three channels:
Ingestion - vomiting, diarrhea that may become bloody, severe dehydration, low
blood pressure, hallucinations, seizures, blood in the urine; Within several days,
the liver, spleen, and kidneys might stop working, and the person could die
Skin and eye exposure - ricin in the powder or mist form can cause redness and
pain of the skin and the eyes.
Ricin poisoning has been connected with several terrorist incidents involving the Al
Qaeda (the Islamic militant group Ansar al- Slam tested ricin, along with other
chemical and biological agents, n northern Irag), KGB (used for assassination during
the Cold War), and the Bulgarian Secret Service (killed a dissident named Georgi
arkov by injecting his leg with a small ricin-containing metallic pellet narged from the
tip of a weapon built into an umbrella).
Lead
Lead
Lead, is a soft and malleable metal used in building metal construction, lead-acid
batteries, bullets and shots, weights, as part of solders, pewters, fusible alloys, and as
a radiation shield.
Lead acetate is the most common salt that causes acute poisoning. Immediately upon
ingestion, the person will feel a sweet, metallic astringent taste in the mouth along
with a burning sensation in the include vomiting, constipation, cold clammy skin,
feeble rapid pulse throat and stomach, salivation and intense thirst. Other symptoms
and shock, drowsiness, headache, muscular cramps and convulsions. Paralysis of lower
limbs may be seen, and death may occur.
Drugs of Abuse
An autopsy can reveal the following clues that a person may have died of a drug
overdose (Dolinak, 2005, p. 500):
Cocaine is a strongly addictive controlled substance derived from the leaf of the
Erythroxylon coca bush. It has become an extremely popular drug with some
medicinal value, although it also has a high potential for abuse.
Cocaine in the form of white crystalline powder can be snorted intranasally or
injected intravenously, while crack cocaine is the less expensive form that can be
smoked. Injecting cocaine produces the most rapid, almost immediate effects.
Snorting results in a peak effect within 30-120 minutes; while smoking effects peak
within 5 minutes. The euphoric effects wear off very quickly and therefore have to be
quickly repeated. Larger doses or a "binge" may result in anxiety and panic leading to
paranoia (Stark & Norfolk, 2009). Cocaine makes the user feel euphoric, stimulated,
and alert. It also results in difficulty sleeping, loss of appetite, increased heart rate
and blood pressure, and causes the body temperature to rise. Adverse effects
include cardiovascular complications, psychosocial problems, and addiction resulting
in powerful cravings to produce the desired effect. Chronic abusers develop
dangerous psychological and behavioral patterns, and even severe psychosis.
Another unfavorable outcome of cocaine intoxication involves an episode of bizarre
behavior called "cocaine psychosis" or "excited delirium," which manifests in
hyperthermia (elevated body temperature), delirium, paranoia, abnormally great
strength, highly agitated state, cardiorespiratory arrest, and sudden death (Stripp,
2007).
Ecstasy
Ecstasy
In suspected drug and poisoning deaths, the pathologist collects and preserves the
specimens for toxicological analysis subsequent to the autopsy. These cases usually
involve toxicological scenarios, such as drug overdosè, homicide by poison, alcohol
impairment in an accident or crime, or use of drugs to commit suicide. Toxicological
analysis is also required in determining if assertions plausible, of self-defense against
drug-induced psychotic behavior are if drugs were used to incapacitate a victim of a
crime, or if a patient was in compliance with their prescribed medicines. Sometimes,
the cause of death is unknown, and the toxicologist has to review the case history
and investigation to narrow the search for a specific poison.
Specimen Collection
Specimen selection, collection, and preservation play an enormously important role in
toxicology. It is important to know which specimens are most useful for yielding drug
concentrations that are practical for interpretation. Furthermore, the proper specimen
must be used to assemble all the pieces of the puzzle when trying to determine a cause
and manner of death. The challenge with post-mortem samples is that the quality and
availability of the samples themselves can vary greatly. Unlike testing clinical samples
from living individuals, post-mortem toxicology has the unique problem of testing
samples collected at autopsy that may have undergone varying levels of decomposition.
For example, decomposed bodies may no longer have blood, yet may have vitreous,
urine, and tissue samples. The use of proper preservatives is important to prevent
further post-mortem changes in the samples. Even the selection of the container itself
can be important (Stripp, 2007; Molina, 2010).
• Blood is the most common and preferable sample to use, when possible. It is a
relatively easy sample to obtain and store. For post-mortem studies, peripheral
blood is more desirable than central blood as it is less affected by post- mortem
redistribution.
• Bile is usually not a first-line specimen but can be useful in qualitative screening.
Bile is not always present, and when it is available, it is usually in limited quantities.
It is most often used for detecting opiates and morphine.
• Tissue specimens are commonly collected at autopsy and are readily available in
large quantities. However, interpretation of drug concentration can be difficult
since data is not often available for comparison. Tissue concentrations may also
be elevated in oral overdoses and chronically administered drugs. Muscle is a
preferred tissue sample. Liver can be used as a secondary sample when blood is
not available; there is extensive data available for comparison of post-mortem
drug concentrations. Kidney specimen is used mainly in heavy-metal testing; lung
specimen for inhaled toxins, such as volatile substances; spleen for cases of
carbon monoxide poisoning; and adipose tissue for pesticide poisonings and
volatile analysis.
• Stomach contents are often collected in cases where an oral drug overdose is
suspected. Odors may be present that give a clue of agents present.
• Hair is an excellent screening source for arsenic poisoning and is becoming more
commonly used in screening for the chronic use of illicit drugs, including
morphine, cocaine, and amphetamines. Drugs can be deposited in hair as it
grows, allowing hair samples to yield information about drug intake over a period
of several months to years, depending on the length of hair sampled.
• Other samples include fly larvae (maggots), blood stains, soil samples and
cremation ash, which may contain drugs or poisons. Tablets, capsules, vials, and
various household products may also be collected at the death scene.
Laboratory Analysis
Once the samples have been collected and properly preserved the next step is called
the extraction procedure, which involves the, separation of the analytes (the
substances you want to measure) a certain degree from the biological matter. Most
specimens require of pretreatment to isolate the drug or poison by using separation
techniques such as distillation, protein precipitation, liquid-liquid extraction and
solid-phase extraction. This is followed by forensic toxicological analysis using two
types of tests: screening tests and confirmatory tests. Samples are usually first
screened for the presence of medications and/or intoxicating substances, then a
more specific, confirmatory test is performed to determine the exact substance and,
often, concentration. A confirmatory test should be a different methodology from
the screening test and should be run on a different sample/specimen, if possible
(Stripp, 2007; Molina, 2010).
Preliminary Screening Tests
Screening tests allow the toxicologist to rapidly test for a variety of drugs and toxins.
Screening tests give preliminary results, and then a positive result must be verified
with a confirmatory test.
• Immunoassays are popular techniques that can be used to screen a large number
of drugs. The methods are relatively fast and straightforward to use. Immunoassays
use antibodies that bind with a target class of compounds (in this case, drugs). The
antibody binds to the drug in question, thereby yielding a positive screen if the
drug is present.
• Chromatography can be used as a screening test for a large number of drugs when
combined with a detector. Gas chromatography (GC) and liquid chromatography
(LC) are very popular in forensic toxicology, because they are easy to perform,
sensitive, and can provide good initial separations. Drugs are dissolved into a
mobile phase (gas or liquid), which is then passed through a stationary phase
allowing for separation and isolation of the constituents of the sample. The time
taken to traverse the stationary phase is recorded by a paired detector and compared
to an internal standard, thus facilitating the detection of each component within the
sample.
Confirmatory Tests
The process of confirmation involves the use of various methods that give structurally
specific information about a compound in order to eliminate the potential for false
positive results. When a drug has been identified by one of the screening tests,
confirmatory tests should be performed using a different methodology than the
screening test and on a different sample, if possible (or at least a different extract of
the same sample). The confirmatory test should also be more specific than the
screening test. The popular method is GC or LC paired with mass spectrometry. Mass
spectrometry is accomplished by fragmenting a molecule using a barrage of electrons
and then analyzing the relative abundance of the fragments or by ionizing molecules
and analyzing the charge transference (Molina, 2010).