Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sense of place.
What places have we come across in our
previous studies?
What places have we come across in our previous studies?
Brainstorm:
• Take five minutes to individually
brainstorm a place of importance
to you.
• You do not have to write full
sentences; just jot down words or
ideas you associate with this
place.
Introductory
writing task:
• Based on the place you have just
brainstormed; you will take fifteen
minutes to write about what this
place means to you.
• Include information on why this
place is special or important to you,
use descriptive writing to describe
this place to your readers.
Time to share:
‘But you Didn’t’
By Merrill Glass.
‘But you Didn’t’
By Merrill Glass
• Remember the time you lent me your car and I dented it?
I thought you’d kill me…
But you didn’t.
• The title:
• What possible meanings
might there be in the word
‘early’?
• For whom is this particular
purge ‘early’? The kittens?
The boy? Both? What is the
poet purged of in this poem?
Group work
discussions:
Opening Line:
• Why do you think we are
told what age the poet
was when he first saw
kittens drowned?
• Why does he tell us that
this was the first time?
Group work discussions:
• First Stanza:
• Why do you think that the farmhand is named? What do you think of
Dan Taggart’s language?
• Do you think Heaney agrees with him? Do you think it is significant
that Heaney separates Dan Taggart’s words from the rest of the poem
by placing them in inverted commas?
• What word suggests that the kittens are small and weak? What does
Heaney’s choice of words to describe the kittens tell us about his
attitude to the drowning?
Group work discussions:
• Second Stanza:
• What words evoke our
sympathy for the kittens?
• Can you find an example
of alliteration in this
stanza? What is the effect
of this?
Group work discussions:
• Third Stanza:
• What do you think of Dan Taggart’s claim? Why does he feel this
way?
• Does this give you the impression that life on the farm is harsh?
• Can you find a simile in this stanza? What does it bring to mind?
Group work discussions:
• Fourth Stanza:
• Do you think it is significant that the dead
kittens were thrown on the dunghill?
• What does it say about the attitude
towards animals?
• Why was the young boy frightened by the
death of the kittens? Do you think it made
him realise anything about life?
Group work discussions:
• Fifth Stanza:
• Why does the boy’s ‘fear come back’ when rats, rabbits
and old hens are killed?
• Look at the verbs used to describe Dan’s actions. Does
he seem decisive? Cruel? Matter-of-fact?
• Is there any word in this stanza, apart from ‘fear’, that
shows how upsetting and distasteful the young boy
found these killings?
Group work discussions:
• Sixth Stanza:
• In what way does the poet’s language now echo Dan Taggart’s in the
first stanza?
• How has growing up on a farm affected the poet?
• Do you think that the poet really believes his sentiments, or feelings,
were ‘false’? Why/Why not?
Group work discussions:
• Final Stanza:
• Why do you think the poet has put the words
‘Prevention of cruelty’ in inverted commas?
• Are the deaths that take place on the farms natural?
• Do you believe Heaney agrees with the argument that
‘on well-run farms pests have to be kept down’?
Final Thought:
• If you were going to write a poem
arguing in favour of the need to control
animal populations on farms, which
stanzas would you have changed and
why?
‘The Early Purges’
• Take some time to learn quotes from the poem.
Exam Papers: