Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NEW WORDS
Reinforced Study and Design of
Earth
A composite
Reinforced Earth Retaining
material having Wall with steel Reinforcement
facing panels, soil
reinforcement for Highway Embankment
strips and select
fill as basic TABLE OF CONTENTS
components.
2 | Page
Figure f External stability checks (after Transportation Research Board, 1995)...11
Figure g Steel reinforced earth retaining wall...................................................12
Figure h Analysis of a Reinforced Earth retaining Wall.......................................14
Figure i Understanding the equation of Lateral pressure due to Surcharge.........15
Figure j Calculation for Overturning..................................................................20
PART 1 Introduction
• Over-burden
• Earth Pressure
• Hydrostatic Pressure
• Seismic Loads
Geosynthetical structures
Rock facing / rock riprap slope surface consists of rock or cobble fills,
no special slope surface treatment is necessary. Downstream slopes with
outer sand and gravel should be protected against erosion especially
during flood.
4 | Page
PART 2
Reinforced Earth
The frictional forces created when combining the select fill with the flexible
metallic or non-metallic reinforcing strips result in a robust structural
material, commonly known as Reinforced Earth. The strips are attached to a
front facing panel, which may be manufactured from concrete or steel. The
facing material selected is generally dependent on it having sufficient
durability to accommodate the design life of the structure, and also meet the
aesthetic needs of the project. The Reinforced Earth monolithic mass acts
cohesively and supports it’s own weight and any applied loads which may
include all the forces as described in part 1 of this report. The forces induced
in the steel strips can be precisely calculated and depend on ;-
• Strip geometry
Importantly, the durability of the structure relies heavily on the ability of the
soil reinforcement strip to maintain a level of tensile strength in the
operational environment for the duration of the structure’s design life. The
strip made up of steel, if used, is therefore designed to include a sacrificial
5 | Page
steel thickness, which predicts the amount of strip corrosion throughout the
design life of the structure. This is achieved by controlling the environment in
which the strip will be operating. The select fill, whilst having certain physical
requirements that ensure it is activated in forming part of the structural
mass, is also required to have electrochemical characteristics that also
ensures that corrosion of the strip is not excessive or beyond the allowance
made in the strip design. Furthermore, the strip is coated with zinc
galvanizing for further protection.
The final length and frequency of the soil reinforcement strips is a function of
the combinations of geometric and physical properties of the structure and
the applied design loads. Whilst the facing to the Reinforced Earth wall
technically does not take on a structural role in support of the loads, it
obviously forms an important part in the wall in preventing the erosion of
backfill, supporting the soil reinforcement and weathering the local
environment. Typically, for roads projects, concrete is the only economical
material that can achieve the necessary 100 year design life without the
need for any continuous maintenance or repair. The facing also forms the
most visual aspect of the structure and is often required to have some
aesthetic appeal, particularly in urban areas. Concrete can lend itself readily
to the provision of architectural and aesthetic requirements. The facing
panels can however, often be a complex component to manufacture as each
facing panel may have very individual
characteristics with respect to its
geometry, finish or cast-in inclusions.
6 | Page
reinforcing elements) eliminate the
need for a structural wall or a support
(figure B)
7 | Page
Mechanism Of Reinforced Soil
The mechanism of reinforced soil can be explained in simple terms
considering an element of cohesionless soil shown in figure C(a) . If a
vertical stress is applied on the soil it deforms both laterally and vertically
and reaches a new equilibrium. If reinforcement in the form of plane sheet is
introduced in the sample before the application of vertical stress on the
sample,
deformations are restrained due to the interaction b/w the soil and the
reinforcement to some extent as in figure C (b). introduction of reinforcement
generates inward lateral stress, which resists the shear stresses that are
generated when a vertical stress (sigma 1) is applied. If there is no
significant deformation, the lateral stress is equal to Ko times the vertical
stress and this condition prevails at higher vertical stresses also.
8 | Page
The shear stress at the interface of soil and reinforcement generates strains
in the reinforcement and tensile force is mobilized in the reinforcement. If the
reinforcement force exceeds the tensile capacity of sheet reinforcement,
rupture failure occurs. Secondly, it is likely that a slip occurs b/w soil &
reinforcement if deformation are high or interface is smooth. These two
conditions viz tesile failure & pullout failure need to be examined to ensure
stability of reinforced soil structures.
9 | Page
What can be used as a Reinforcement?
1. Geosynthetics
Figure 2 shear box test on unreinforced and reinforced soilASTMhas defined a
geosynthetic as a
planar product manufactured from a polymeric material used with soil, rock,
earth, or other geotechnical-related material as an integral part of a civil
engineering project, structure, or system.
Geogrids: Geogrids are primarily used for reinforcement; they are formed
by a regular network of tensile elements with apertures of sufficient size to
interlock with surrounding fill material. These are made up of High Density
Polyethylene (HDPE) and interconnected longitudinal and transverse
Member. These are made from sheets of polymer by punching holes and
stretching the sheets in one or two direction.
Geocomposits: Geotextiles and related products such as nets and grids can
be combined with geomembranes and other synthetics to take advantage of
the best attributes of each component. These products are called
geocomposites.
10 | P a g e
2. Reinforcing strips
Reinforced members are composed of thin wide steel or aluminum strips
called ties. The flexibility of reinforcing strips and their tensile strengths are
essential elements. The reinforcing strips are made of mild galvanized steel,
stainless steel or aluminum alloy. Bolts and nuts for fixing the ties are made
of the same material as that of the reinforcing strips. The durability of the
strips depends on the chemical and electro-chemical behavior of these
metals when in contact with soil particles
Works Cited
Introduction to Soil Reinforcement and Geosynthetics [Book] / auth.
Babu Visakumar. - to be added : to be added, to be added. - Vol. to be added.
A retaining wall may fail in any of the following ways (see figures):
• It may fail due to the loss of bearing capacity of the soil supporting the
base.
11 | P a g e
Figure f External stability checks (after Transportation Research Board, 1995)
When a weak soil layer is located at a shallow depth—that is, within a depth
of 1.5 times the width of the base slab of the retaining wall—the possibility of
excessive settlement should be considered. In some cases, the use of
lightweight backfill material behind the retaining wall may solve the problem.
As discussed before, the reinforced earth retaining wall can deploy steel and
geotextiles as reinforcements. In this part we will be looking at the design of
reinforced earth wall using steel as reinforcement. A basic model of steel
reinforced earth retaining wall is shown in figure (f).
12 | P a g e
Figure 0 Steel reinforced earth retaining wall
Ka = tan 2
(45 – ф1’/2). Thus,
13 | P a g e
When surcharge is added at the top, as shown then
= (1) + (2)
Due to Due to
soil Surchar
only ge
(For z≤2b’)
And
(For z›2b’)
Also when a surcharge is added at the top the lateral pressure at any depth
is
= + (2) Due to
Due to Surchar
soil ge
only
14 | P a g e
Figure h Analysis of a Reinforced Earth retaining Wall
= M[2q/π(β-
↑
(In radians)
Where
15 | P a g e
Figure i Understanding the equation of Lateral pressure due to Surcharge
T=)
Factor of Safety against Tie Failure
The reinforcement ties at each level, and thus the walls, could fail by either,
/)
Where = width of each tie
= thickness of each tie
= yield or breaking strength of the tie material
A factor of safety of about 2.5 – 3 is generally recommended for ties at all
levels.
16 | P a g e
which frictional resistance is developed may be conservatively taken as the
length that extends beyond the limits of the Rankine active failure zone,
which is the zone ABC in figure(). Line BC makes an angle 45 + ф1’/2 with the
horizontal. Now the maximum friction force that can be realized for a
tie at depth z is
FS(P) = FR / T
)
Total length of Tie
The total length of ties at any depth is
L = lr + le
l
Where r = length within the rankine failure zone
le = effective length
} + )}
The Design Procedure with summary of steps
Following is a step-by-step procedure for the design of reinforced-earth
retaining wall
General
17 | P a g e
Determine the height of the wall, H, and the properties of the granular
.)backfill material, such as the unit weight () and the angle of friction (ф1
Obtain the soil-tie friction angle, (фu) and the required value of FS (B) and
FS(P) |
Exhibit 1
18 | P a g e
Length within the rankine
metres
failure zone lr 0
Effective length of Ties le 4.625899 metres
Length of Ties L 4.625899 metres
Ka 0.333
Internal Stability (see the attached Exhibit 2 and the result of internal
stability analysis in succeeding pages)
Assume values for horizontal and vertical tie spacing. Also, assume the width
of reinforcing strip, w, to be used.
For the known values of FS(B), calculate the thickness of ties, t, required to
resist the tie breakout:
)/
The convention is to keep the magnitude of t the same at all levels, so in Eq.
should equal (max).
For the known values of Φu and FS(P), determine the length L of the ties at
various levels.
External Stability
Mo = Pa z’
19 | P a g e
soil only
8
⌠
5.478h
⋅ dh → 175.296= 175.296
⌡
0
⌠
1.4 − .96 ⋅ 1.66dH → 2.324H
⋅ + −11.382857142857142857
⋅ ln ) H)
.14H
⌡
2
⌠
1.4 − .04 ⋅ 20 ⋅ ) 1.159085553− sin ) 1.159085553 ) ) dH → 1.9955799158760896291
3 π ) ⋅ cos ) 2⋅ 0.099668652
⌡
⌠ .14H
1 1.4 − .04 ⋅ 20 ⋅ ) 0.947871788− sin ) 0.947871788 ) ) dH → 1.1424541308466395876
) ⋅ cos) 2⋅ 0.049958396 = 1.142
.14H π
⌡
2
7
⌠
1.4 − .04 ⋅ 20 ⋅ ) 0.460226744− sin ) 0.460226744 ) ) dH → 0.1408975856346407028
⌠ 4
π ) ⋅ cos) 2⋅ 0.016665124 = 0.141
⌡ 1.4 −
.14H
⋅ ⋅ ) 0.768469142− sin ) 0.768469142
) ) dH → 0.62900883954153347651
.04 20
6 ) ⋅ cos ) 2⋅ 0.033320996 = 0.629
.14H π
⌡
3
8 5
⌠⌠
1.4
1.4
−− ⋅ 20
.04.04
⋅ ⋅ ) 0.402613328
20
⋅ ) 0.634315275
− sin ) 0.634315275 ) ⋅ cos 2⋅ 0.024994794
) 2⋅)0.014284743
H → 0.36093894903972636611
) ) )d)Hd→ == 0.361
π
− sin ) 0.402613328) ⋅ cos
0.0949271368413852133360.095
⌡⌡
.14H
.14H π
7 4
6
⌠
1.4 − .04 ⋅ 20 ⋅ ) 0.534998393− sin ) 0.534998393) ⋅ cos) 2⋅ 0.019997334) ) dH → 0.21938693099589765693
= 0.219
⌡ .14H π
5
………… /{[
20 | P a g e
Exhibit 2
Overturning
Active
force 175.3 4.5 179.8
surchar
soil ge total
Resisting Moment
W1 1726.4 kn
x1 6.5 m
11221.
W1x1 6 kn-m
11269.
MR 6 kn-m
Overturning
Moment
z' 2.67 m
480.06
Mo 6
Figure j Calculation for Overturning
23.475
FOS 11 > 3
………… /{
Sliding
Numerat 639.27
or 69
3.56 >
FOS 3
Where k ≈ 2/3
21 | P a g e
3) Check for ultimate bearing Capacity can be done by
Ultimate Bearing
Capacity
qu = 3805.2
Vertical stress at
8 m = 142.5
FOS = 26.7 > 5
APPENDIX A
22 | P a g e
Exhibit 3: Three dimensional soil element (left), 2D soil element (middle), Induced
horizontal stress in an unconfined soil element (right)
Horizontal stresses are either direct (e.g. braking forces from wheels of large
truck) or induced (see figure (right)). Unlike the figure, real soils in the field
are not unconfined and the adjacent elements of soil or rock also wish to
expand but in opposite direction. These opposing forces may cancel each
other (i.e. there may be no horizontal strain) or the horizontal strain may be
much less than would occur in an unconfined sample. Either way, the result
will be the formation of horizontal stresses in the ground. If ground surface is
horizontal, the geostatic shear stresses on horizontal and vertical planes are
all equal to zero.
Induced stresses
These are the stresses due to external loads. Equation (1) will not be true for
induced stresses.
Effective stress
The compressive stress, σ, is carried partially by the solid particles & partially
by the pore water. It is called the total stress because it is sum of the
stresses carried by these two phases in the soil.
u = γ w zw
Where
The particle contact forces in an element of soil that is initially above the
groundwater table will decrease if the groundwater rises above that element.
This is because of the buoyancy force of water.
σy’ = σy – u
Mohr’s circle
It is used for computation of stresses acting on planes other than horizontal
and vertical planes. It describes the 2D stresses at a point in a material. Each
point on the circle represents the normal & shear stresses acting on one side
of an element oriented at a certain angle.
For example, in this mohr’s circle, points A & B represent (σz, τzx) and (σx, τ
xz),
which are the stresses acting on an element aligned with the x and z
axes, while points C & D represent the stresses on an element oriented as
shown.
Principal stresses
If the soil element is rotated to a certain angle, shear stresses will be zero on
all four sides. The planes on each side of this element are represented by
points E & F and are known as principal planes. Stresses acting along these
planes are known as principle stresses.
24 | P a g e
σ 1 = major principal stress (greatest normal stress acting on any plane)
these two stresses act on right angle to each other. As told earlier, when the
ground surface is level, the geostatic shear stresses on vertical & shear
planes ar all zero. Therefore, these are the principal planes and the geostatic
principal stresses act vertically and horizontally.
Frictional strength
The force that resists sliding is equal to the normal force multiplied by the
coefficient of friction, µ. For soils, ф’ is used i.e.
ф’ = tan-1 µ
Cohesive strength
Cohesion may be true or apparent. True cohesion is cementation and
electrostatic forces. Apparent cohesion is negative pore water pressures, etc.
25 | P a g e
APPENDIX B
Before the wall moves the stress condition is given by circle “a”
State of Plastic equilibrium represented by circle “b”. This is the
“Rankine’s active state”
Rankine’s active earth pressure is given by
26 | P a g e
∆L
A' A
σo' z
σ '
a
B' B
27 | P a g e
With geometrical manipulations we get:
1 −sin φ′ cosφ′
σ 'a = σ 'o −2c'
1 +sin φ′ 1 +sin φ′
( )
σ 'a = γz tan 2 45 − φ2′ −2c' tan 45 − φ2′ ( )
For cohesionless soil, c’=0
φ'
σ =σ tan ) 45 −
'
a
'
0
2
)
2
Rankine’s Active Pressure Coefficient, Ka
The Rankine’s active pressure coefficient is given
by:
σ a'
K a = ' = tan 2 45 − φ2′
σo
( )
The angle between the failure planes /slip planes
and major principal plane (horizontal) is:
(
± 45 + φ2′ )
28 | P a g e
With depth:
Horizontal backfill
Cohesionless soil
Cohesive soil
29 | P a g e
Sloping backfill
Cohesionless soil
Cohesive soil
Active Case
σ a = K aγz
1
Pa = K aγH 2
2
Horizontal
backfill with Cohesionless, partially submerged soil
30 | P a g e
σ a' = K a [q + γH 1+γ ' ) z − H1 )]
The
depth at which the active pressure becomes equal to zero (depth of tension
crack) is
2c '
z0 =
γ Ka
2cu
z0 =
γ
Tensile crack is taken into account when finding the total active force. i.e.,
consider only the pressure distribution below the crack
31 | P a g e
1 2c ' 2
Pa = K aγH − 2 K a c H +
2 '
2 γ
σ a' = K aγz
1
Pa = K aγH 2
2
Friction walls
Rough retaining walls with granular backfill. Angle of friction between the
wall and the backfill is δ'
32 | P a g e
Case 1: Positive wall friction in the active case (+δ´)
Pa will be inclined δ’ to the normal drawn to the back face of the retaining
wall
33 | P a g e
34 | P a g e