Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword or section
Like this
1Activity
P. 1
Neg Nukes1

Neg Nukes1

Ratings: (0)|Views: 47|Likes:
Published by AffNeg.Com

More info:

Published by: AffNeg.Com on Dec 21, 2008
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

10/16/2011

pdf

text

original

 
UMKC SDI 2008Mapes/PetiteNuclear Power Neg
Nuclear Power Negative
 Nuclear Power Negative ..............................................................................................................................1**Global Warming Advantage** .................................................................................................................2Can’t Solve- General ...................................................................................................................................3Can’t Solve- Time Delays ............................................................................................................................4Can’t Solve- Time Delays ............................................................................................................................5Increases Pollutants .....................................................................................................................................6Increases Warming .......................................................................................................................................7Increases Warming .......................................................................................................................................8**Prolif Advantage** ..................................................................................................................................9Prolif Inevitable .........................................................................................................................................10 Nuke Power = Prolif ..................................................................................................................................11 NPT Crashing Now ....................................................................................................................................12 NPT Crashing Now ....................................................................................................................................13 NPT Bad ....................................................................................................................................................14**Hegemony Advantage* ..........................................................................................................................15Hegemony Dead ........................................................................................................................................16Hegemony Dead .......................................................................................................................................17**Solvency* ..............................................................................................................................................19Time Delays ...............................................................................................................................................20Accidents ...................................................................................................................................................21Accidents ...................................................................................................................................................22Meltdowns .................................................................................................................................................23Loan Guarantees Not Enough ....................................................................................................................24Don’t Increase Electricity ..........................................................................................................................25Labor Shortage ..........................................................................................................................................26Locations ...................................................................................................................................................27 NRC Won’t Approve ..................................................................................................................................28Plants = terrorism .......................................................................................................................................29**Disad Links** ........................................................................................................................................30Spending Links ..........................................................................................................................................31Spending Links ..........................................................................................................................................32Spending Links ..........................................................................................................................................33Oil Links ....................................................................................................................................................34Politics Links- Unpopular (Public) ...........................................................................................................36**Australia DA**......................................................................................................................................37Australia Coal 1nc.....................................................................................................................................38Australia Coal 1nc.....................................................................................................................................39Australia Coal Dependent..........................................................................................................................40Coal Key Australia Economy.....................................................................................................................41Australia Key Asian Economy...................................................................................................................42Asian Economy Key Global Economy......................................................................................................43Trade Key US/Australian Relations...........................................................................................................44US/Australia Trade Key Global Economy.................................................................................................45**Trade Off DA**.....................................................................................................................................46Trade off 1nc..............................................................................................................................................47Uniqueness- Investments...........................................................................................................................48Link- Nuclear Power..................................................................................................................................49Link- Nuclear Power.................................................................................................................................501
 
UMKC SDI 2008Mapes/PetiteNuclear Power Neg
Link- Nuclear Power..................................................................................................................................51Investment key...........................................................................................................................................52impact economy .....................................................................................................................................53
**Global Warming Advantage**
2
 
UMKC SDI 2008Mapes/PetiteNuclear Power Neg
Can’t Solve- General
Nuclear Power doesn’t solve global warming
.Michael
Totty
news editor for The Journal Report in San Francisco, June 30, 20
08
; “The Case For andAgainst Nuclear Power”. The Journal Report.http://www.wsj.com/public/article_print/SB121432182593500119.html. 7/27/08$
 Nuclear power isn't a solution to global warming. Rather, global warming is just a convenient rationale for anobsolete energy source that makes no sense when compared to the alternatives. Sure, nuclear power generates lotsof electricity while producing virtually no carbon dioxide. But it still faces the same problems that have stymiedthe development of new nuclear plants for the past 20 years -- exorbitant costs, the risks of an accident or terroristattack, the threat of proliferation and the challenge of disposing of nuclear waste.
Nuclear Power cant solve global warming because we still use fossil fuels and the supply of uranium is finite
Kathy
Graham
, researcher on nuclear energy, September 1, 20
05
, “The Power and Passion”. The Lab.http://www.abc.net.au/science/features/powerpassion/default.htm. 7/27/08$
Sometimes that means glossing over the fact that annual global electricity generation is responsible for only about39% of atmospheric pollutants (the bulk of which are actually produced by trucks and cars). Even if the entireworld switched to nuclear power, it wouldn't solve the problem of global warming. The uranium we have,including that from recycled decommissioned warheads, won't last forever. In fact it's been estimated thateconomically viable (high-grade, low cost) uranium will run out in 50 years - much sooner than that if morereactors are built.
Nuclear Power can’t solve global warmingPublic Citizen’s Energy Program
,
September 
20
06
, Climate Change: The Urgency, Impacts, andSolutions” Public Citizen’s Energy Program.http://www.citizen.org/documents/ClimateChange.pdf. 7/27/08$
The effects of global warming depend largely upon the energy path we take. Solutions will include changes both inelectricity production and transportation. For electricity, the current plan to build new coal and nuclear power  plants in the U.S. will not be effective at halting global warming and will only make other problems worse. Of the153 newly proposed coal plants, most are in addition to existing coal plants – not replacing older plants – andalmost all will continue to emit large amount amounts of CO2, as well as sulfur, nitrogen oxides and mercury.Even if plants are built with carbon sequestration technology, there are likely to be problems with CO2 leakageand contamination, and coal mining will continue to pollute soil and ground water. Likewise, the proposal for more than twenty new nuclear reactors in the U.S. – while releasing fewer greenhouse gas emissions than coal – would come with its own set of problems. Building new reactors requires polluting uranium mining, the generationof radioactive waste, and increased proliferation, accident, and terrorist risks. No country in the world has found asolution for these problems. Proposals for new reactors, licensing, and construction together also require long leadtimes, at best 10 years, and would be expensive. Already wind power at good sites in the U.S. is significantlycheaper than power would be from new nuclear power plants.
3

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->