Peer Review Project 2 Early Drafts

Read your peers draft, taking notes on the following questions as you read. Then discuss with your findings with your partner. 1. What is the main issue this paper addresses? 2. Opponent: a. What are the main points? b. Context? 3. Writers side: a. What are the main points? b. Context? 4. What is the common ground? 5. What compromise does the writer suggest? Is the compromise realistic? Why or why not? Is the compromise fair to both sides? Why or why not? Is the compromise something that hasnt already been tried and failed? 6. Is the problem that the writer tackles specific enough? 7. Is the paper focused around one central idea that lies within one field of study? What is that field? 8. Are the sources credible? Why or why not? 9. Is the formatting helpful, distracting, or something else? Why or why not? What changes, if any would you suggest for the formatting?