PAPER REVIEW FORM

Buletinul tiinific al Universitii Politehnica din Timioara Construcii - Arhitectur

Paper No.: Paper Title Authors :
1. Overall Rating

Secretariat: Adrian Ciutina, Ph.D. Dept. of Steel Structures and Structural Mechanics, Faculty of Civil Engineering The Politehnica University of Timisoara, Str. Ioan Curea No. 1, 300224 Timioara, Romnia. Tel/Fax: ++40 256 403932 Email: adrian.ciutina@ct.upt.ro

. .
Unacceptable Below Average Average Good Excellent

2. 2. Recommendations

Accept

Acceptable in present form Acceptable in present form with minor revisions suggested by reviewers. Acceptable if suggested revisions are made and re-review is not required. Acceptable only if suggested revisions are made and re-review is required. Author(s) should consider the suggestions of the reviewer and resubmit paper. Author(s) should re-submit as a short technical note (below 3000 word-equivalents) Unacceptable. Reasons for objections are attached. (a) Subject matter Within the scope of the journal Not appropriate for the journal (b) Originality Original work Minor extension of old technique or existing knowledge Little or no originality Review paper Other : (c) Readability of English Easy to understand Difficult to understand and improvements are needed Unreadable and should be rewritten Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No No No No

Reject

3. Comments

(d) Details Is the title clear & adequate? Is the abstract adequate? Are the conclusions adequate? Are the references adequate? Are the illustrations of good quality?

Confidential Report to Author(s)

Confidential Record to Chief Editor only

Information on this page will not be conveyed to the author(s). Reviewers Name : Address :

Telephone No: Fax No : Email :

Optional Confidential Report to Chief Editor

(required only if you intend to convey further confidential comments to editors)

Signature: Date: