Grading Rubric:

Craftsmanship (artistic quality of the pen work, complex ways of shading, cleanliness, 50/50 black & white) 1 (Incomplete, no effort) 2 (Poor, below average, mostly white) 3 (Completed, but problematic, Average quality, relies on simple black/white shading, or messy attempt at hatching, repeats solutions to artistic problems instead of experimenting with new ways to problem solve, close to 50/50) Concepts (readable through the visual language without use of stereotypical symbols, complexity of beliefs) 1 (Incomplete, no effort) 1 (Incomplete, no effort) 2 (belief is not clearly readable through the image or very simple stereotypical concepts) Composition (Elements/Principles/ Golden Mean) 2 (simple, simple, simple, no complexity) 3 (uses the golden mean some of time, focal point is simplistic without much connection made to the rest of the composition) Creativity (Use of found images, at least 3, successful & appropriate alteration of images, original visual language) 1 (Incomplete, no effort) 2 (images appear to be an unincorporated collage of images "stuck together") 3 (uses 4 images, begins to make them interact together, but simplistic) 4 (uses the golden intentional focal point that has some relationship to surroundings) 4 (uses 4 images, evidence of altering the images from the original source) 5 (uses the golden mean visual movement, very intentional focal point & creates a complex composition) 5 (uses 4 images, the cohesive whole, complex & intricate photo manipulations) mean all of the time, all of the time with good 3 (may use some/few stereotypical symbols, simple/common concepts) 4 (developing more complex original concepts, unusual, no stereotypical images used to represent idea) 5 (superior use of complex original beliefs, finds a complex and original way of visually telling the belief) 4 (Good, explores complex shading with hatching, artistic quality of pen work is developing, 50/50) 5 (Superior, inventive use of shading, outstanding neatness, artistic quality of pen work is top notch, 50/50 or better)

interacting and good whole composition is a