Slurry

concentr
IMPACT
ation
VELOCIT
Erodent
Erosion
3
Y (m/sec) Angle-deg size-m (kg/m ) rate (g)
mg
8
30
91
10
0.0013
1.32
8
30
215
40
0.0168
16.8 AVG
8
30
305
60
0.0202
20.2 Max
8
45
91
40
0.0202
20.2 Min
8
45
215
60
0.0198
19.8 Plus
8
45
305
10
0.0345 34.53273 Minus
8
90
91
60
0.0069
6.9 Mean
8
90
215
10
0.0078
7.85 0.5*(SD/Mean)*100
8
90
305
40
0.0114
11.35
12
30
91
10
0.0325
32.5
12
30
215
40
0.0623
62.3
12
30
305
60
0.0829
82.9
12
45
91
40
0.0350
35
12
45
215
60
0.0413
41.3
12
45
305
10
0.0695 69.54326
12
90
91
60
0.0252
25.16
12
90
215
10
0.0263
26.3
12
90
305
40
0.0341
34.09
20
30
91
10
0.0692
69.2
20
30
215
40
0.0902
90.2
20
30
305
60
0.1450
145
20
45
91
40
0.0836
83.6
20
45
215
60
0.0954
95.4
20
45
305
10
0.0987
98.722
20
90
91
60
0.0512
51.198
20
90
215
10
0.0657
65.7
20
90
305
40
0.0810
81.005

Velocity
8
15.43919
34.53273
1.32
19.09354
14.11919
15.43919
31.92335

12
45.45481
82.9
25.16
37.44519
20.29481
45.45481
22.90423

Angle
20
86.66944
145
51.198
58.33056
35.47144
86.66944
15.3735

30
57.8244
145
1.32
87.17556
56.50444
57.8244
39.10095

45
55.34422
98.722
19.8
43.37778
35.54422
55.34422
28.62065

90
34.39478
81.005
6.9
46.61022
27.49478
34.39478
38.3839

91
36.11978
83.6
1.32
47.48022
34.79978
36.11978
37.99342

y = 0.3655x1.8564
R = 0.9563

120

90

Mean mass removal (mg)

Mean mass removal (mg)

120

Size

60

30

0
0

12
16
Impact velocity (m/s)

20

24

90

60

30

0
0

Size

Concentration

215
47.29444
95.4
7.85
48.10556
39.44444
47.29444
34.34562

120

305
64.14922
145
11.35
80.85078
52.79922
64.14922
33.62988

10
45.07422
98.722
1.32
53.64778
43.75422
45.07422
35.97081

40
48.28278
90.2
11.35
41.91722
36.93278
48.28278
32.30861

60
54.20644
145
6.9
90.79356
47.30644
54.20644
41.70737

120

Mean mass removal (mg)

y = -0.005x2 + 0.2099x + 56.031

R = 1

90

60

30

90

60

30

0
0

15

30
45
60
75
Impingement angle (degree)

90

120

Mean mass removal (mg)

y = 27.878e0.0027x
R = 0.984

90

60

30

0
100

200
Erodent size (m)

300

400

10

20
Slurry concentration (kg/m

y = 0.1767x + 42.71
R = 0.921

20
30
40
50
Slurry concentration (kg/m3)

60

70

IMPACT
VELOCITY
(m/sec)

Angle-deg

8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20

30
30
30
45
45
45
90
90
90
30
30
30
45
45
45
90
90
90
30
30
30
45
45
45
90
90
90

Slurry
Erodent size- concentration
m
(kg/m3)

91
215
305
91
215
305
91
215
305
91
215
305
91
215
305
91
215
305
91
215
305
91
215
305
91
215
305

10
40
60
40
60
10
60
10
40
10
40
60
40
60
10
60
10
40
10
40
60
40
60
10
60
10
40

31.92335 39.10095 37.99342 35.97081

22.90423 28.62065 34.34562 32.30861
15.3735 38.38393 33.62988 41.70737

(g)

mg

0.0013
1.32
0.0168
16.8
0.0202
20.2
0.0202
20.2
0.0198
19.8
0.0345 34.53273
0.0069
6.9
0.0078
7.85
0.0114
11.35
0.0325
32.5
0.0623
62.3
0.0829
82.9
0.0350
35
0.0413
41.3
0.0695 69.54326
0.0252
25.16
0.0263
26.3
0.0341
34.09
0.0692
69.2
0.0902
90.2
0.1450
145
0.0836
83.6
0.0954
95.4
0.0987
98.722
0.0512
51.198
0.0657
65.7
0.0810
81.005

IMPACT
VELOCITY
(m/sec)

8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20

mg

1.32
16.8
20.2
20.2
19.8
34.53273
6.9
7.85
11.35
32.5
62.3
82.9
35
41.3
69.54326
25.16
26.3
34.09
69.2
90.2
145
83.6
95.4
98.722
51.198
65.7
81.005

Mean

(X-M)^2

SD

(SD/Mean)*
100

15.43919 199.3515 9.857414 63.8467 31.92335

1.851804
22.66531
22.66531
19.01666
364.5633
72.91777
57.5958
16.72147
45.45481 167.8271 20.82214 45.80846 22.90423
283.7604
1402.142
109.3031
17.26245
580.2535
411.8793
366.9067
129.1589
86.66944 305.1813 26.64825
30.747 15.3735
12.46485
3402.454
9.421462
76.22268
145.2642
1258.223
439.7174
32.08588

ANGLE

30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
45
45
45
45
45
45
45
45
45
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90

mg

Mean

1.32 57.82444
16.8
20.2
32.5
62.3
82.9
69.2
90.2
145
20.2 55.34422
19.8
34.53273
35
41.3
69.54326
83.6
95.4
98.722
6.9 34.39478
7.85
11.35
25.16
26.3
34.09
51.198
65.7
81.005

(X-M)^2

SD

(SD/Mean)*
100

3192.752 45.21982 78.20191 39.10095

1683.005
1415.598
641.3273
20.03064
628.7837
129.4034
1048.177
7599.578
1235.116 31.67975 57.2413 28.62065
1263.392
433.1181
413.8873
197.2401
201.6128
798.3891
1604.466
1881.632
755.9629 26.40414 76.76786 38.38393
704.6253
531.0619
85.28116
65.52546
0.092891
282.3482
980.0168
2172.513

Size

91
91
91
91
91
91
91
91
91
215
215
215
215
215
215
215
215
215
305
305
305
305
305
305
305
305
305

mg

Mean

(X-M)^2

1.32 36.12444 1211.346

20.2
253.5865
6.9
854.0656
32.5
13.13628
35
1.264275
25.2
119.3425
69.2
1093.995
83.6
2253.933
51.2
227.2737
16.8 47.28889 929.573
19.8
755.6396
7.8
1559.373
62.3
225.3331
41.3
35.86692
26.3
440.5339
90.2
1841.363
95.4
2314.678
65.7
338.9686
20.2 64.14444 1931.11
34.5
878.7905
11.4
2781.972
82.9
351.7725
69.5
28.68245
34.1
902.666
145
6537.628
98.7
1194.089
81
284.1113

SD

(SD/Mean)*
100

27.44982 75.98684 37.99342

32.48332 68.69123 34.34562

43.1434 67.25976 33.62988

Concentration

10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
60

mg

Mean

(X-M)^2

SD

1.32 45.05778 1912.995 32.4153

34.5
111.4671
7.8
1388.144
32.5
157.6983
69.5
597.4211
26.3
351.8551
69.2
582.8458
98.7
2877.486
65.7
426.1004
16.8 48.28889 991.5508 31.20294
20.2
788.9863
11.4
1360.791
62.3
196.3109
35
176.5949
34.1
201.3249
90.2
1756.54
83.6
1246.874
81
1070.016
20.2 54.21111 1156.755 45.22006
19.8
1184.124
6.9
2238.34
82.9
823.053
41.3
166.6965
25.2
841.6439
145
8242.624
95.4
1696.525
51.2
9.066723

(SD/Mean)*
100

71.94163 35.97081

64.61723 32.30861

83.41474 41.70737

Erosion
1.3
32.5
69.2

30, 305 m, 60kg/m

V elocity
8
12
20

Erosion
16.8
62.3
90.2

Erosion
20.2
35
83.6

Erosion
19.8
41.3
95.4

90
60
30
0
0

150

Impingement angle: 45

120
90
60
30
0
4

Impact velocity (m/s)

Erosion
34.5
69.5
98.7
150

Impingement angle: 90

90, 215 m, 10kg/m3

V elocity
8

Erosion
6.9
25.2
51.2

Erosion rate (mg)

90, 91 m, 60kg/m
V elocity
8
12
20

Impact velocity (m/s

45, 305 m, 10kg/m

V elocity
8
12
20

Impingement angle: 3

120

Erosion
20.2
82.9
145

45, 91 m, 40kg/m3
V elocity
8
12
20
45, 215 m, 60kg/m
V elocity
8
12
20

Erosion rate (mg)

30, 215 m, 40kg/m

V elocity
8
12
20

150

Erosion rate (mg)

30, 91 m, 10 kg/m
V elocity
8
12
20

120
90
60
30
0

Erosion
7.8

Impact velocity (m/s)

12
20
90, 305 m, 40kg/m3
V elocity
8
12
20

26.3
65.7

Erosion
11.4
34.1
81

Impact velocity (m/s)

Impingement angle: 30
Erodent size: 91 m, Slurry concentration: 10 kg/m3

Erodent size: 215 m, Slurry concentration: 40 kg/m3

Erodent size: 305 m, Slurry concentration: 60 kg/m3

8

12

16

20

Impact velocity (m/s)

Impingement angle: 45

Erodent size: 91 m, Slurry concentration: 40 kg/m3

Erodent size: 215 m, Slurry concentration: 60 kg/m3

Erodent size: 305 m, Slurry concentration: 10 kg/m3

8

12

16

20

Impact velocity (m/s)

Impingement angle: 90

Erodent size: 91 m, Slurry concentration: 60 kg/m3

Erodent size: 215 m, Slurry concentration: 10 kg/m3

Erodent size: 305 m, Slurry concentration: 40 kg/m3

8

12
Impact velocity (m/s)

16

20

12
Impact velocity (m/s)

16

20

tion: 10 kg/m3

ation: 40 kg/m3

ation: 60 kg/m3

ration: 40 kg/m3

tration: 60 kg/m3

tration: 10 kg/m3

ation: 60 kg/m3

ration: 10 kg/m3

ration: 40 kg/m3