Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Peer Evaluator:
Directions:
Nancy ONeill
1. After selecting your content area and describing the English learners in your
hypothetical classroom, answer the questions below for each of the SIOP
components.
2. Ask a classmate to complete the peer review form and return it to you.
3. Make additions and changes to your lesson based on peer feedback.
Highlight all of the changes you make to your lesson.
4. Bring a hard copy of the peer evaluation (written feedback only) and your
final SIOP lesson (with highlights indicating the changes you have made to your
lesson) to the final class meeting).
Preparation
ACADEMIC CONTENT STANDARD(S):
New Curriculum standard: 4-LS1-1. Construct an argument that
plants and animals have internal and external structures that
function to support survival, growth, behavior, and reproduction.
[Clarification Statement: Examples of structures could include
thorns, stems, roots, colored petals, heart, stomach, lung, brain, and
skin. Each structure has specific functions within its associated
system.] [Assessment Boundary: Assessment is limited to
macroscopic structures within plant and animal systems.]
Old Standards: Students will know the sequential steps of
digestion and the roles of teeth and the mouth, esophagus,
stomach, small intestine, large intestine/colon in the function of the
digestive system.
Define what the function is for each specific part of the digestive
system and be able to label each part of the digestive system on a
diagram.
3. ELD STANDARD(S):
Expanding EL Students:
Exchanging information/ideas; Contribute to class, group,
and partner discussions, including sustained dialogue, by
following turntaking rules, asking relevant questions, affirming
others, and adding relevant information
Building Background
1. How will you link the concepts of the lesson to students background
knowledge (consider the students personal experiences as well as prior learning
in the classroom)?
Link the lesson with the previous lesson on nutrition and the food
plate
Use cracker experience to link the subject with an experience.
Identify other systems in their background that work together
Use Think/Pair/Share to have students discuss good or bad
digestive experiences
Emphasis key vocabulary words by using the content chart,
repeating words and definitions to relate to their everyday life by
having students make up nick names for the digestion parts
Link vocabulary words to visual body part on human chart
Use vocabulary self-selection to have students pick out vocabulary
words in the reading and underline them
Comprehensible Input
1. What will you do to help make content comprehensible? LIST the
chronological steps of your lesson in explicit detail (See example below). Be sure
to include time frames for each step of the lesson. Underline the steps of the
lesson where instruction will be differentiated for English Learners.
Lesson Steps:
1) Give me a thumbs up or down if you remember our lesson on nutrition
and the food plate. Put the food plate graph (attachment #1) on the
board. The food plate is a guide for to remember the components of a
healthy meal. Think Aloud questions: What are the sections of the food
plate? What is the relationship of food to our body? Either rephrase or
give answer: Food gives our body nutrition. Give thumbs up/ thumb
down: Are there good and bad foods for our body? Report out: Give me
some examples of good foods? What about bad foods? What is the
difference between good foods and bad foods? (2 minutes)
2) Think/Pair/ Share: How does your body process your food? Can you
think of a good or bad experience you have had after you ate a food what
happened in your body? (2 minutes)
3) Lets think about what happens to these good and bad foods in our
body while we do an experiment. Give students an observation organizer
log (attachment #2) and a cracker (dont eat the cracker), put the
observation guide on the overhead. Explain the sheet step by step:
Experiment/ noticed / explain what happened and what might happen
next/ Does it remind you of anything youve learned or have seen / what
are you curious about. Then have the students put the cracker in their
mouth. Tell them to just hold the cracker in their mouth and do not chew
or swallow it. While the cracker is in their mouth think. Ask them to think
about what is happening to the cracker? Are you noticing anything? Why
did start to get softer? What do you taste? Did the taste change? Have
them swallow cracker. Did it remind you of anything? What will happen
next to the cracker? (4 minutes)
4) In your table groups share your observations and fill out the log. Walk
and check with the groups. Check in with EL student to ensure they know
the process and are filling out the sheet. Call on each table group to share
an observation with the class. After each response ask group if they had
the same observations giving a thumbs up or down. Write responses on
the observation sheet on the overhead. Rephrase and expand on the
students answers, as needed. On the observation question what will
happen next? Expand on the fact that the process is just starting, the
cracker will go through a series of processes to get the food to the rest of
the body. (4 minutes)
5) Discuss that the cracker getting soft is the start of the digestive
process. Think/Pair/Share: based upon experiment, what is digestion? As
students discuss walk around and help students with their idea by
restating their comments. Should include breaking down, dividing, etc.
Students shared their thoughts with the whole class. Discuss the
meaning: to Divide Breaking down food into smaller and smaller parts
(1 minute)
Check in with EL student to ensure they know the process and are
answering the questions.
6) On the board write Digestion to start the vocabulary content wall
(attachment #3). Give EL students vocabulary content sheet that list
cognates to scaffold vocabulary, i.e.: digestion/digestion (attachment 3).
This will be the start of our vocabulary wall. State the lesson objective
which is written on the board: Students will know the steps of digestion
and the roles of each organ in the digestive system. (1 minute)
7) Discuss the Big Idea: The food breaks down into smaller and smaller
parts by working through the digestive system that has many working
parts /organs, each part does a job and it is important that all the parts
are working and doing their job for the whole system to work well. Work
as a table team: Can you think of systems, mechanisms or household
items that have many working parts that work together to accomplish
something? It can be from another lesson or from your own experience?
Elicit responses if having trouble, say what about a bicycle? What happens
when the chain falls off of your bike? The bike breaks? Your bike is a
system of parts that make it run smoothly. Everything must do its job to
run properly. (2 minutes)
8) Pass out a diagram of the digestive system with lines to list the organ
parts and functions (attachment 4). Put the diagram on the over head for
the class to see. Explain that in digestion system is divided into 3 phases
or categories: break the food down, move the nutrients to other places in
the body and move the waste products out of the body. Enlarge the
diagram for the board. Explain that like the digestive system that we also
5
Strategies
1. List the cognitive strategies your students will use during the lesson (e.g.,
problem solving, predicting, organizing, summarizing, categorizing, evaluating,
self-monitoring
Interaction
1. Explain the types of interaction (i.e., cooperative groupings) in the lesson
that will develop students listening and speaking skills in English.
Practice/Application
1. Identify the steps of the lesson when students will practice or apply what
they have learned in this lesson.
They will observe, write and think critically for the observation log
The students will practice by writing the names of the digestion
parts onto their human chart
They will also writing the part names on the food pathway on the
flow chart
They will practice the names of the parts by repeating names,
nicknames and gestures
They will read text, practice verbal skills and collaborate in their
project groups, each person having a role: reader, demonstrator or
commentator/reporter.
They will practice writing skills and apply their knowledge when
they write their stories
Review/Assessment
1. Identify the points in the lesson when you will check for understanding
10
1. Hold up a ball and point to a picture of an animal. Think-Pair-Share: How are the
two things are different? (Living vs. non-living). What are other examples of living
things? What are other examples of non-living things? (5 minutes)
2. Explain that living and non-living things live together in an ecosystem. Write the
word ecosystem on the science word wall in the classroom. (1 minutes)
3. Think. Pair. Share. Ask students to name various parts of their ecosystem in the
classroom. Be sure to elicit responses including living and non-living things. (2
minutes)
4. State the content objective to students (that is written on the board): Today we are
going to learn how living and non-living components of ecosystems interact. (1
minute)
5. Number off students in each table group to complete a numbered heads together
activity. Show students a picture of a rainforest and state that this is a picture of a
Rainforest Ecosystem. Ask students to define the living and nonliving components
of the rainforest ecosystem in their table groups. Call on a number and then ask an
individual student to respond for his or her group. Repeat the activity for the kelp
forest, tidal pool and desert ecosystems. Be sure to emphasize the word ecosystem.
(3 minutes per picture, 12 minutes total)
6. Ask students to take out a piece of paper, divide it into four sections, and write the
word ecosystem in the middle of the paper. (1 minute)
7. Think.Pair.Share: What is the definition of ecosystem? As students share, help
students articulate their ideas by restating and/or rephrasing their comments. Solicit
responses that incorporate the words living and non-living in the answer. (3
minutes)
8. After the students have shared their responses write the definition for ecosystem on
the word wall: An ecosystem is a community of living and non-living things that
work together. (2 minutes)
9. On the overhead projector divide the screen into four sections and write the word
ecosystem in the middle of the screen. The students will write the definition for the
word ecosystem in the first quadrant on their papers (model this step on the
overhead). In the second quadrant, the students should provide examples of
ecosystems. Ask the students to recall the ecosystems used in the numbered heads
11
together activity (write the word examples on the overhead in the second quadrant
to remind the students). In the third quadrant the students should write a sentence
using the word ecosystem (write the word sentence on the overhead in the third
quadrant to remind the students. Jorge can work with a partner to compose a
sentence). In the fourth quadrant the students should draw and label a picture of an
ecosystem (write the word picture in the fourth quadrant to remind the students).
(12 minutes)
10. Ask students to place their completed vocabulary development pages into their
vocabulary binders for future reference. (1 minute)
11. Pass out a picture of an ecosystem to each table group and a note-taking page. Jorges
group will be assigned the rainforest. Note: Jorge has been provided with a book on
rainforests in Spanish to read for homework the day before the lesson. He has been
asked to identify living and non-living things in the book.
12. Students should work together in their table groups to complete the note-taking page.
Circulate around the groups while students are working, ensuring that all students are
participating, and answering any questions. Check to ensure that Jorge has
contributed to his group by verbally identifying one living and one non-living
component of the rainforest ecosystem and can orally explain how the non-living
thing helps the living thing survive. If a student is not participating gently encourage
the student to participate by asking questions, or having the student speak directly to a
partner. (10 minutes).
13. Explain to the students that they are now going to use their note-taking guide to write
a paragraph about ecosystems. Ask the students what the first sentence in a paragraph
is called (topic sentence). Tell the students that they can use the definition of
ecosystem to write a good topic sentence. (1 minute)
14. Think. Pair. Share. What is a good topic sentence for a paragraph about ecosystems?
Guide the students responses and write the following topic sentence on the board for
the students to copy: An ecosystem is a community of living and non-living things
that all work together. As students write provide Jorge with a differentiated writing
guide that will provide him with additional scaffolding for writing his paragraph. (3
minutes)
15. Explain that the next sentence in the paragraph should focus the paragraph by stating
what ecosystem will be discussed in the paragraph. Solicit example sentences from
the students about how they will construct this sentence. Examples should follow the
pattern: A _____ is one example of an ecosystem. (3 minutes)
12
16. Explain to the students that they can now continue their paragraph by writing one
sentence using each section of their note-taking guide. Circulate around the groups
while students are working, ensuring that all students are participating, and answering
any questions. (Allow the students 10 minutes of writing time.)
17. Explain that the students must finish their paragraph with a concluding sentence.
Tell the students they can write a concluding sentence by using several adjectives to
describe their particular ecosystem. Brainstorm a list of adjectives that students can
use in their concluding sentence and write them on the board (diverse, amazing,
abundant, and interesting). (5 minutes)
18. Have students write their concluding sentence and turn in their note-taking guide and
paragraph for feedback. (3 minutes).
13