Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CARE Bangladesh: Strategic Impact Assessment Research Proposal
CARE Bangladesh: Strategic Impact Assessment Research Proposal
CARE Bangladesh: Strategic Impact Assessment Research Proposal
CARE Bangladesh began working with and for womens development as early as the
1980s, starting with the Womens Development Program (WDP). This program sought
to address womens basic health needs as well as income generation; whilst recruiting,
training and deploying women staff managers and field workers. When the program
ended in 1997, the organizational landscape had changed considerably with women
comprising nearly 65 percent of field workers and support staff (administrative assistants
and officer helpers).
The 1997 Long Range Strategic Plan (LRSP) institutionalized the emphasis on gender
programmatically and organizationally. Projects, regardless of their programmatic
emphasis, incorporated a Gender and Development approach, while progressive gender
policies to promote a more gender equitable and women-supportive work environment
were designed and implemented. A Gender Committee consisting of 13 members was
formed and Gender Focal Point (GFPs) persons were elected or selected and trained to
ensure implementation of the new policies. In 1998, the Gender Committee formulated
a Sexual Harassment Policy and circulated it throughout the organization.
By 2000, CARE had recruited two senior level staff (Gender Adviser Organization and
Gender Adviser Programming) to assist in the mainstreaming of gender equity in the
organization and promote gender sensitive approaches in its development initiatives. In
the same year, the organization developed a Project and Program Design Process
Guide that emphasized gender analysis and the integration of gender equity and
womens empowerment in all aspects of program / project development.
1
See Martinez, E. 2005. Proposed Global Research Protocol For CAREs Strategic Impact
Inquiry on Womens Empowerment. Atlanta: CARE USA.
2
This section heavily draws and liberally cites Moffat, L. 2002. Gender Assessment Report.
Dhaka: CARE Bangladesh.
In 1997, women were elected to Union Parishads for the first time. Yet, elected womens
discrimination, harassment and exclusion from important discussions and decisions persists
widely, restricting their ability to effectively represent womens interests. See Nazneen, S. 2004
for a more detailed discussion.
4
See Bourdieu, P. and L.J.D. Wacquant. 1992. An Invitation to Reflexive Sociology. Chicago: The
University of Chicago Press.
5
The gender discussion on Bangladesh draws on the literature review by Sohela Nazneen and
Scholarly work from different parts of the world over the past two decades has
emphasized the importance of how ideology and the material intersect and how class
and gender are interconnected.6 In Bangladesh, Chen (1983), Hartmann and Boyce
(1983), and White (1992) found that resource poor households are more likely to form
separate household units, providing women greater freedom from the control of mothersin-law, who tend to act as strict guardians of gender norms. Women from poorer
households tend to have greater decision-making power over resources, because of
their income contribution as well as greater mobility (Kabeer, 1998, White, 1992). At the
same time, the increased mobility reduces womens status in the larger society in light of
purdah norms, whilst the overall ideology of male control most crudely manifested in
violence against women tends to persist. (Kabeer, 1998, While 1992).
Some scholars have also commented on the contrasting nature of middle class and
resource poor womens adherence to gender norms. Ongs work in Malaysia (1990) and
Rozarios work in Bangladesh (2004) found that urban middle class women in both
societies have been far more directly caught up in the spirit of Islamic resurgence than
working class women. This resonates with gender patterns in the rural context of
Bangladesh, where middle and upper class women maintain stricter forms of purdah,
although it is not clear to which extent this is related to the status oriented nature of
Bangladeshi society and / or the increasing trend towards Islamism that spans nearly
three decades. 7 Rural women belonging to well-off (rich and middle income)
households tend to be subjected to greater control and have limited agency. This has
important implications in terms of building solidarity amongst women of different socioeconomic backgrounds. Chen (1983) found that poor women felt exploited by rich
women, and White (1992) argues that womens networks that include wealthier women
help to reinforce gender and class norms in the village, since those who participate in
these networks are careful to follow the rules. 8
This discussion highlights that womens powerlessness is mediated by their gender, as
well as their class, age, and religion. Power expressed in the social relationship
between groups that determine access to and control over the basic material and
ideological resources lies at the heart of transforming gender dynamics. Enabling
womens empowerment a process that changes the nature and distribution of power in
a particular cultural context must take these multiple dimensions into account.
liberally quotes her work. See Nazneen, S. 2004. Gender Relations in Bangladesh: The
Household and Beyond: Dowry, Womens Property Rights and Salish: A Literature Review.
Dhaka: CARE Bangladesh.
6
The literature is indeed vast; authors that have wedded the conceptual and empirical in a helpful
manner include Beneria, L. 1982. Class and Gender Inequalities and Womens Role in Economic
Development. Feminist Studies 8/1:156-176; Fraad, H. et.al. 1994. For Every Knight in Shining
Armor, There is a Castle Waiting to be Cleaned in Bringing it All Back Home: Class, Gender and
Power in the Modern Household. Boulder: Pluto Press, 1994). For South Asia see Agarwal, B.
1991. A Land of Ones Own. Cambridge: Univeristy Press.
7
For a brilliant discussion on the growing role of Islamicist parties since the early 1970s and their
influence on Bangladeshi national political culture see Riaz, A. 2004. God Willing: The Politics of
Islamism in Bangladesh. Oxford: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
8
This section is based on a number of writings: Bode, B. 2002. In Pursuit of Power. Dhaka: CARE
Bangladesh; Bode, B., A. Haq and B.C. Dev. 2002. Forms of Land Tenure in the Northwest of
Bangladesh in Field Review: The Newsletter of the Rural Livelihood Program. Dhaka: CARE
Bangladesh. Haq, A. and B. Dev. 2002. New Farmer Field School Cycle Selection Strategy.
Dinajpur: CARE Bangladesh.
10
CARE Bangladesh Social Development Unit has developed a typology of para and guidelines
to identify different types of para.
11
Institutions, here, are viewed in processual and dynamic terms. They are sites where
production, authority and obligations are contested and negotiated and form a part of the interplay
of knowledge and power. Berry, S. 1993. No Condition is Permanent: The Social Dynamics of
Agrarian Change in Sub-Saharan Agriculture. Wisconsin: University Press. Informal institutions in
Bangladesh include: the family, salish (local dispute arbitration), jamat (the Muslim
congregation), samaj (local brotherhoods), while formal institutions include: key committees that
channel resources (bazaar committee, local government committees, locally elected bodies).
Scholars of collective action have long argued that homogeneity of a group is an important
aspect to successful mobilization. See Olson, M. 1965. The Logic of Collective Action: Public
Goods and the Theory of Groups. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press; Ostrom,
E. 1990. Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press; McCay, B.K. and J.M. Acheson. (eds). 1990. The Questions of the
Commons: The Culture and Ecology of Communal Resources. Tuscon: University of Arizona
Press.
13
In elite dominated paras staff have to spend considerable time with elites to ensure their buyin to work on issues beyond income generating activities around the homestead. For more
discussion on staff tactics to negotiate elite support see: Howes, M. and B. Bode. 2004. Securing
Access to Water Bodies. Dhaka: CARE Bangladesh and CARE Bangladesh, Social Development
Unit with Kamal Kar. 2005. Building Solidarity Through Collective Action: A Process
Reconstruction. Rangpur: CARE Bangladesh.
14
See Nazneen, S. 2004. Gender Relations in Bangladesh: The Household and Beyond: Dowry,
Womens Property Rights and Salish. Dhaka: CARE Bangladesh. This literature review cites few
examples of work that touches upon womens strategies.
15
This is in striking contrast to work that has been done in other parts of South Asia (e.g. see
Agarwals work that draws on dozens of studies, some of which comment on the tactics that
women employ to resist male domination. Agarwal, B. 1991. A Land of Ones Own. Cambridge:
University Press) and around the world: Ong, A. 1987. Spirits of Resistance and Capitalist
Discipline: Factory Women in Malaysia. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. Hart, G.
1990. Household Production Reconsidered: Gender, Labor Conflict and Technological Change in
These critiques raise the issue to which extent our work further legitimizes existing
identities that rationalize the sources of structural domination. 20 This points to the need to
consider our own understanding of womens power and powerlessness and how
processes of empowerment would look like if built on existing forms of survival that are
different from, or opposed to, those permeating the institutions of society. The notion of
agency in particular womens strategies to negotiate day to day forms of subordination
is an important element of this Strategic Impact Inquiry. Viewing women as strategic
actors also reflects CARE Internationals 1 st Programming Principle: promoting
empowerment. (We support the efforts of poor and marginalized people to take control of
their lives and fulfil their rights).
Bringing It All Together
This discussion has highlighted that we need to be more critical of how our world views
influence the ways in which we interface with rural communities and particularly how
Malaysias Muda Region. World Development. Carney, J. And M. Watts. 1990. Manufacturing
Dissent: Work, Gender and The Politics of Meaning in a Peasant Society. Africa 60 (2).
16
See Chipeta, S. et.al. 2005. Rural Livelihoods Programme: Capturing Lessons Learned. CARE
Bangladesh.
17
18
Informal discussion with staff from other CARE projects who visited this pilot have also
confirmed this view, whilst recognizing that women had benefited from collective activities.
19
20
Rozario, S. 2004. Building Solidarity Against Patriarchy. Dhaka: CARE Bangladesh. P. 52.
This issue has been raised in a recent review of CARE Bangladesh Gender-Based Violence
Initiatives. See Robinson, V. 2004.
The Bangladesh SII team has selected 1) Violence Against Women initiative of Partnership for
Healthy Life (PHL); 2) Nijeder Janyia Nijera (We, For Ourselves) pilot situated in RLP; and 3)
Womens Access to Markets and Labor Contracting - an initiative situated in ISFP.
2) How are CAREs programming approaches (three SII projects) and interventions
shaped by the bodies of thought and knowledge that we have commissioned and
our organizational culture?
3) How do our programming approaches and interventions intersect with and reflect
womens own view of power and powerlessness, equity and equality, social
inclusion and mobility and build upon existing strategies through which women
negotiate forms of subordination in their day-to-day lives?
This work will provide the basis for Impact Assessment in fiscal year 2006.
The Strategic Impact Projects
The CARE Bangladesh SII Team has selected three project initiatives to be researched
over the next two years. A brief summary of each intervention is provided below. (Initially,
the SII team was also considering to include the HIV project, but consensus now
appears to have been reached that research findings would not apply to other projects /
programs as the sex worker population is a subculture whose condition are not
comparable to mainstream society.)
Initiatives to Address Violence Against Women:
A. Violence Prevention and Rights Reinforcement Cell (VPRRC) June 2003 to June
2004 This initiative has been implemented in the northern part of Bangladesh for the
past two years. It is situated within the Rural Maintenance Program, which employs
destitute women to maintain earthen roads. RMP also works with these women to raise
awareness of human rights and health issues and provides basic literacy and small
business development training. This small pilot project was designed to address
violence against women.
The pilot works with 2 men and 3 women elected
representatives, who receive training on gender issues, in particular violence against
women. These individuals collectively form a cell, a body that responds to confidants,
trained by RMP, who operate on a village level and intervenes in salish (informal dispute
arbitration, usually dominated by village elites and elders) on behalf of women who raise
issue around violence.
B. Violence Against Women Initiative of Partnership for Healthy Life (PHL) 2002-2004
This project operates in the northwest of Bangladesh and evolved from pilot project
(Safe Mother Initiative) that addressed maternal mortality and morbidity. PHL was
designed to explore, test and demonstrate different community based approaches to
addressing priority health and social issues that affect poverty. A key dimension to the
project is its work that seeks to mitigate violence against women.
Nijeder Janya Nijera (We, For Ourselves) October 2004 to September 2005
This is a pilot that emerged from the Rural Livelihood Program. It attempts an approach
to rural development that a) works in politically and economically marginalized
communities, b) employs Community Led Total Sanitation (CLTS) as an entry point to
build solidarity, c) facilitates a process of self-realization through analysis and action to
enable various interest groups within communities to set their own developmental
agendas and pursue these, d) encourages community to community sharing and
community consultants (natural leaders) to inspire neighboring hamlets to take
responsibility for key aspects of development that do not require state subsidy or
support, and ultimately e) seeks to build a larger forum within unions through which
marginalized groups and communities can effect change in local governance.
Womens Access to Markets and Labor Contracting: 2003-2004
The initiatives falls under the BUILD Capacity Project situated in the former Integrated
Food Security Program that ended in the fall of 2004. BUILD had been working for
several years with elected local government on the supply and demand side of service
provisioning to the larger constituency. Womens Access to Markets is an initiative to
increase womens facilities to engage as vendors in market places. The project chose
selected sites, where local authorities and market committees endorsed this initiative,
and brokered between prospective women traders, local government officials and
market committee members to facilitate the provision of funds for building physical
market infrastructures (stall, toilets, etc). The construction contracts were issued
through transparent open bidding processes in which Local Contractors Groups (LCGs)
-- headed by women participated as bidders.
Practical Considerations
The core SII team: Anna Minj, Frank Noij, Shameem Siddiqi and Brigitta Bode (this is
largely by default as other members where not present) agreed that the first initiative to
be researched (approach and context) would be the PHL project, located in Dinajpur
district. This is largely because PHL has operated for longer than the other two
initiatives. It was also agreed that we would limit this investigation to the Northwest of
Bangladesh, where all three initiatives have field locations. The advantage to limiting
ourselves to the Northwest is that the majority of context analyses were undertaken in
this region. In addition, CARE Bangladesh Social Development Unit operates from
Rangpur and over the past three years its staff have acquired considerable research
skills, with the potential to be a helpful resource to future consultants.
The model constructed by members of the CARE B SII Team (Anna, Frank, Shameem and Brigitta)
External Influences
(Media, NGOs, etc)
Project Intervention
Choice of Location
Entry Point / Activities
Agency
Group Formation
Solidarity building (with whom)
Socio-economic differentiation
class, age, religion, ethnicity
Social Position
and institutions
Social Inclusion/Exclusion
Mobility
Identity
Forms of Consciousness
IMPACT
10
11
Methods:
Mobility Mapping
12
FGD
Individual Interviews
Methods
13
Sequence of activities
Time spent
Actors involved
Issues raised
Kin group
Existing networks
14
dynamics. This work will take around 25 days (including report writing, attending and
presenting at the London Workshop in June).
Social Development Unit staff will not only assist the consultants, but will also provide
the ground work for Consultant 2, prior to her arrival.
Budget
Line item
Initial Consultant (10 days @ US$ 350/- per day) (Linda Moffit)
3,500.00
Local accommodation, local travel and other expenses for the lead
consultant (Linda Egypt)
1,500.00
12,075.00
22,975.00
4,000.00
3,500.00
3,000.00
Materials
500.00
Contingencies
1,500.00
Total:
52,550.00
15