RFQ: Transportation

Planning and Funding

On Call Consultants
All Scorers
3-Feb-16

Acumen

RFQ Standard/Scorers

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

Presentation,
completeness, clarity,
organization, and
conformance of proposal

Demonstrated ability and

experience of the project
manager and proposed
team

Demonstrated expertise or
resources

Prior experience and ability

to work with City staff and
stakeholders

Staff and resources to

deliver quality products on
schedule

24
72

13

26

Project management and

quality control
Indiv Total
Group Total
Highest = 1, Lowest = 5

WW
WW

WW

Qualifying
Kittelson
CD+A
Fehr and Peers
Alta
Nelson Nygaard
Placeworks

Score
30
31
41
47
48
50

Not Qualifying

Score

Questa - 250k
CDM Smith
Diablo - 250k
Kimley Horn

53
54
55
55

New
New
New
below
the line

WW
WW
WW

BKF Engineers
DKS Associates
TJKM Transportation
Wood Rogers
Acumen

56
59
61
64
72

Highest = 1, Lowest = 5

BKF
Engineer
s

Alta
MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

11
47

17

11

16
56

10

17

13

CDM
Smith

CD+A

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

16
54

11

18

10
31

DKS
Associat
es

Fehr and
Peers

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

21
59

12

19

8
41

16

Kimley
Horn

Kittelson

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

18
55

11

17

5
30

10

TJKM
Transpor
tation

Placewor
ks
MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

10
50

11

19

10

19
61

11

22

Wood
Rodgers

Diablo250

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

18
64

12

22

12

14
55

24

Nelson
Nygaard

Questa 250

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

MTC

OPW

Planning

AC
Transit

6
48

19

15

24
53

10

19