Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Strange Properties Quasicrystals: Jean Bellissard
Strange Properties Quasicrystals: Jean Bellissard
The
STRANGE PROPERTIES
of
QUASICRYSTALS
Jean BELLISSARD 1 2
Universite Paul Sabatier, Toulouse
&
Institut Universitaire de France
Collaborations:
J.X. ZHONG (Oak Ridge)
R. MOSSERI (Groupe Physique Solides, Paris VII)
H. SCHULZ-BALDES (University of California, Irvine)
D. SPEHNER (Universitat Essen, Germany)
J. VIDAL (Groupe de Physique des Solides, Paris VII)
1
2
I.R.S.A.M.C., Universite Paul Sabatier, 118, route de Narbonne, Toulouse Cedex 04, France
e-mail: jeanbel@irsamc2.ups-tlse.fr
SUMMARY
1. Quasicrystalline Compound
2. Quasiperiodic Structures
3. Electronic Properties
4. Spectral Properties
5. Transport Properties
6. Anomalous Transport
7. Why are AlP dM n and AlP dRe
so different ?
8. Conclusion
References :
1. Lectures on Quasicrystals, F. Hippert & D. Gratias Eds.,
Editions de Physique, Les Ulis, (1994),
2. Quasicrystals, S. Takeuchi & T. Fujiwara Eds.,
World Scientific, (1998),
3. Electronic transport properties of quasicrystals,
S. Roche, D. Mayou and G. Trambly de Laissardi`ere,
J. Math. Phys., 38, 1794-1822 (1997),
Quasicrystalline alloys :
Metastable QCs:
AlMn
(Shechtman D., Blech I., Gratias D. & Cahn J., PRL 53, 1951 (1984))
AlMnSi
AlMgT (T = Ag, Cu, Zn)
Defective stable QCs: AlLiCu
(Sainfort-Dubost, (1986))
GaMgZn
(Holzen et al., (1989))
High quality QCs:
Perfect QCs:
AlPdMn
AlPdRe
Resistivity
(cm)
10
10
Semiconductors
Doped semiconductors
Mott
10
(AlPdRe)
Metastable quasicrystals
10
10
4K
Metallic crystals
300K
(Al,...)
T (K)
(AlCuLi, GaMgZn)
(AlMn, AlMgZn,...)
QUASIPERIODIC STRUCTURES :
65
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC 43
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC 21
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC 0/
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC .-
DC
DC
DC BA
DC BA
DC ,+ BA
DC BA
DC BA
DC BA
DC BA
DC BA
DC BA
DC BA
DC BA
DC BA
DC <; BA
DC BA
DC BA
DC
DC
DC >=
DC
DC
DC
DC
DCFE
DC
DC
DC
DC
DCKJ
DC
DC
DC
DC
@?DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
DC
:9 87 IH 65 DC DC DC DC DC 43 DC DC DC DC DC 21 DC DC DC DC DC 0/ DC DC DC DC DC .- DC DC DC BA DC BA DC ,+ BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC <; BA DC BA DC BA DC DC DC >= DC DC DC DC DCFE DC DC DC DC DCKJ DC DC DC DC @?DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
:9 87 IH 65 DC DC DC DC DC 43 DC DC DC DC DC 21 DC DC DC DC DC 0/ DC DC DC DC DC .- DC DC DC BA DC BA DC ,+ BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC BA DC <; BA DC BA DC BA DC DC DC >= DC DC DC DC DCFE DC DC DC DC DCKJ DC DC DC DC @?DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
:9 87 IH
65 DC DC DC DC DC 43 DC DC DC DC DC 21 DC DC DC DC DC 0/ DC DC DC DC DC .- DC DC DC DC DC ,+ DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC <; DC DC DC DC DC >= DC DC DC DC DCFE DC DC DC DC DCKJ DC DC DC DC @?DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
:9 87 IH 65 DC DC DC DC DC 43 DC DC DC DC DC 21 DC DC DC DC DC 0/ DC DC DC DC DC .- DC DC DC DC DC ,+ DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC <; DC DC DC DC DC >= DC DC DC DC DCFE DC DC DC DC DCKJ DC DC DC DC @?DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
"! "! "! :9 "! "! "! "! "! 87 "! "! "! "! "! IH "!
"!
"!
"!
"! 65
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD 43
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD 21
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD 0/
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD .-
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD ,+
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD <;
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD >=
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CDFE
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CDKJ
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD @?
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD
"!CD "!CD
"!CD
"!CD "!CD "!CD
:9 87 IH 65 DC DC DC DC DC 43 DC DC DC DC DC 21 DC DC DC DC DC 0/ DC DC DC DC DC .- DC DC DC DC DC ,+ DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC <; DC DC DC DC DC >= DC DC DC DC DCFE DC DC DC DC DCKJ DC DC DC DC @?DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
9: 78 HI 56 DC DC DC DC DC 34 DC DC DC DC DC 12 DC DC DC DC DC /0 DC DC DC DC DC -. DC DC DC DC DC +, DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC ;< DC DC DC DC DC => DC DC DC DC DCEF DC DC DC DC DCJK DC DC DC DC ?@DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
$# $# $# :9 $# $# $# $# $# 87 $# $# $# $# $# IH $#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$#
$# $#
$#
$# $# $#
65 DC DC DC DC DC 43 DC DC DC DC DC 21 DC DC DC DC DC 0/ DC DC DC DC DC .- DC DC DC DC DC ,+ DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC <; DC DC DC DC DC >= DC DC DC DC DCFE DC DC DC DC DCKJ DC DC DC DC @?DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
:9 87 IH 65 DC DC DC DC DC 43 DC DC DC DC DC 21 DC DC DC DC DC 0/ DC DC DC DC DC .- DC DC DC DC DC ,+ DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC <; DC DC DC DC DC >= DC DC DC DC DCFE DC DC DC DC DCKJ DC DC DC DC @?DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
&% &% &% :9 &% &% &% &% &% 87 &% &% &% &% &% IH &%
&%
&%
&%
&% 65
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC 43
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC 21
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC 0/
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC .-
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC ,+
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC <;
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC >=
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DCFE
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DCKJ
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%@?DC
&%DC
&%DC
&%DC &%DC
&%DC
&%DC &%DC &%DC
:9 87 IH 65 DC DC DC DC DC 43 DC DC DC DC DC 21 DC DC DC DC DC 0/ DC DC DC DC DC .- DC DC DC DC DC ,+ DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC <; DC DC DC DC DC >= DC DC DC DC DCFE DC DC DC DC DCKJ DC DC DC DC @?DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
:9 87 IH 65 DC DC DC DC DC 43 DC DC DC DC DC 21 DC DC DC DC DC 0/ DC DC DC DC DC .- DC DC DC DC DC ,+ DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC <; DC DC DC DC DC >= DC DC DC DC DCFE DC DC DC DC DCKJ DC DC DC DC @?DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
(' (' (' :9 (' (' (' (' (' 87 (' (' (' (' (' IH ('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
('
(' ('
('
(' (' ('
65 CD CD CD CD CD 43 CD CD CD CD CD 21 CD CD CD CD CD 0/ CD CD CD CD CD .- CD CD CD CD CD ,+ CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD <; CD CD CD CD CD >= CD CD CD CD CDFE CD CD CD CD CDKJ CD CD CD CD @?CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD
DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
:
8
I
6
4
2
0
.
,
<
>
F
K
@
9
7
H
5
3
1
/
+
;
=
E
J
?
G G9: G G G G G 78 G G G G G HI
G
G
G
G
G 56 DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G 34 DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G 12 DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G /0 DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G-. DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G+, DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G DC
G DC ;<
G DC G DC G DC G DC G DC => G DC G DC G DC G DC G DCEF G DC G DC G DC G DC G DCJK G DC G DC G DC G DC G ?@DC G DC GDC G DC GDC
G DC
G DC GDC G DC G
:9 87 IH 65 DC DC DC DC DC 43 DC DC DC DC DC 21 DC DC DC DC DC 0/ DC DC DC DC DC .- DC DC DC DC DC ,+ DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC <; DC DC DC DC DC >= DC DC DC DC DCFE DC DC DC DC DCKJ DC DC DC DC @?DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
:9 87 IH 65 DC DC DC DC DC 43 DC DC DC DC DC 21 DC DC DC DC DC 0/ DC DC DC DC DC .- DC DC DC DC DC ,+ DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC <; DC DC DC DC DC >= DC DC DC DC DCFE DC DC DC DC DCKJ DC DC DC DC @?DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC DC
*)DC
*)DC *)DC *)DC
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C 43
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C 21
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C 0/
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C .-
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C ,+
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C <;
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C >=
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)CFE
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)CKJ
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C @?
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C
D*)C *)DC
*) *) *) :9 *) *) *) *) *) 87 *) *) *) *) *) IH *)
*)
*)
*)
*) 65
:9 87 IH 65 43 21 0/ .- ,+ <; >= FE KJ @?
E//
e2
e4
e3
e1
ELECTRONIC PROPERTIES :
Measure or Computation of the Density of States
(DOS) near the Fermi level.
Experimental Methods
1. Soft X-ray Emission Spectroscopy (SXES)
2. Soft X-ray Photoabsorption Spectroscopy (SXAS)
3. Electron Photoemission Spectroscopy (XPS)
4. Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy (EELS)
5. Tunneling Effect Junction.
Numerical Methods
LMTO-ASA computations
(Linear Muffin-Tin Orbital Method in the Atomic
Sphere Approximation)
10
11
Energy (eV)
12
(B)
80
60
EF
40
20
0
Energy (eV)
(A)
400
EF
300
200
100
0
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
Energy (eV)
(Roche et al.
(1997))
13
n(k )
n(k )
VK =0
n(k )
n (k )
VK 0
2 VK
14
DOS
n(E)
2 VK
free electrons
E 0(K/2)
Energy E
Representation of a Pseudo-gap
(S. Roche et al. (1997))
15
20/32
38/61
26/41
14/21
8/12
6/9
7/11
18/29
Examples of pseudo-Brillouin-zones
of the icosahedral phase.
A: 42 (30+12) facets (main pseudo-zone for AlCuF e, ALP dM n;
B: 60 facets (main pseudo-zone for AlCuLi).
The arrows are issued from the peaks which together with all equivalent peaks
(by the icosahedral symmetry) define the facets of the pseudo-zone.
(1997))
16
SPECTRAL PROPERTIES :
Density of States (DoS) :
If H = 1-particle Hamiltonian
Then
1
# {eigenvalues of H| E}
N (E) = lim
Rd ||
is called the Integrated Density of States or
IDoS.
N is non negative, non decreasing and constant on
spectral gaps. N (E) = 0 for E < inf (SpH).
For E then N (E) N0(E)
where N0 is the free particle IDoS.
dN /dE = ndos defines a measure
(according to Stieljes) called
the Density of States or DOS.
17
18
0)
n
(E
ldos
dE 0
E0 E
19
Some Results :
Rigorous
For quasiperiodic chains (QC 1D):
both the LDoS and DoS are singular continuous,
the spectrum is a Cantor set of zero Lebesgue measure.
The exponent is model dependent.
Exacts
For D 2, the Labyrinth model (Sire et al.):
there is a transition between a Cantor spectrum
of zero Lebesgue measure and
a gapless continuous spectrum,
as the hopping parameters increases.
Numerical
Tight-binding models behave like the labyrinth one
But there is level repulsion (Quantum Chaos).
20
Interactions Effects :
Coulombs interaction between electrons in a disordered system is responsible for a pseudo-gap at Fermi
level :
In the strong localized regime (Anderson insulator) :
ndos(E) |E EF |D1
21
TRANSPORT PROPERTIES :
1. Al, F e, Cu, P d are good metals :
why is the conductivity of QCs so low ?
Why is it decreasing with temperature ?
2. At high enough temperature
T
22
( cm)-1
Al70,5 Pd22Mn7,5
100
10
4/300 = 2
Al70,5 Pd21Re8,5
4/300 = 70
10
100
T(K)
23
ANOMALOUS TRANSPORT :
J. Bellissard & H. Schulz-Baldes, Rev. Math. Phys., 10, 1-46 (1998).
Transport Exponents
The diffusion exponents diff(E) are defined by
~ X)
~ 2 > |E >
< E |(X(t)
disorder
t2(E) ,
Interpretation
The inelastic relaxation time diverges at low
temperature.
(E) = 1 ballistic motion
ex. : free particles in a perfect crystal.
(Drudes law).
(E) = 0 absence of diffusion
ex. : localisation.
1/ (anti-Drude).
(E) = 1/2 quantum diffusion
ex. : weak localisation.
1 (residual conductivity).
0 < (E) < 1/2 subdiffusion
ex. : most quasicrystals 3D at Fermi level.
1/ (12) 0 (insulating behaviour).
1/2 < (E) < 0 overdiffusion
ex. : quasiperiodic 2D lattices.
(21) (metallic behaviour).
24
25
Conductivity in QCs
T1.25
26
1/D+1
(T
/T)
0
e
Motts law
27
28
CONCLUSIONS
1. Forbiden symetries imply quasiperiodic lattices of
atomic positions.
2. The Fermi sea stabilizes the structure thanks to the
Hume-Rothery mechanism.
Thus appearance of a pseudo-gap at Fermi level.
3. Coulombs interaction createpa vanishing of the DOS
at Fermi level with ndos |E EF |.
4. This pseudo-gap is partially filled probably due to
impurities or defects.