THE SHIVELY

NIEWSLETTER
lssueNo. 86 February
2011

MTCHAEL SHTVELY,SON OF MTCHAEL Sr{rVEtY,

FROM MONONGALIA COUNTY, WVA

NancyShively,wife of DennisShivety,recentlyhad the goodfortunemany

genealogyresearcherscan only dreamof. She acquirednot only one Shively
family photoalbumbut two. Even betterwas that the photo'swere identified.
Nancyrecentlywas chosento write a blog on the FamilyTree Universitysite. lt
is here that you can read her stories on the Internet at http://
www.familytreeuniversity.comPrior to ChristmasNancy was contactedby a
gentlemanwho had purchaseda photoalbumon eBay.He told her the photos
were identifiedand therewere picturesof Shivelys.The man
found Nancy'sgenealogytree on ancestry.comand may
have recognizednames. He sent her scansof someof the
picturesand one of the pictureswas the same pictureshe
had hangingon the wall in her home.This picturewas a
pictureof Peter $hively,great-greatgrandfatherof Dennis
Shively.The photo album also had picturesof Michael
Shively,son of MichaelShively.MichaelShivelywas born
17-May-1807in MonongaliaCounty,UruA and died 22-
April-1900in Henry County,lN. Michaelwas the son of
MichaelShivelyand CatherineToothman. MichaelShively
?n.tcLozt"'t i)*4,
i,q-&2nwLrVoZt t*
(born 1807) was the grandson of Phillip Shively and
Appolona'Abigail"Back. The great-grandfather of Michael
(born 1807)was MichaelShivelywho is this Shivelylines
immigrant. Nancyand Dennisdiscoveredthe fly leafof the albumwas inscribed
to NaomiShivelywho was the sisterof PeterShivelywith a dateof 1866.
A short time after news about the first photo album Nancy receiveda
messagefrom a womanwho had boughta familyphoto albumon ebay. This
album had picturesfor family membersof the surnameMillikan. A Shively
daughterhad marrieda Mr. Millikan. This albumhad a pictureof PeterShively
and his wife Susannah.Therewere also otherphotosof relativesof the Shively
family.
Nancywrappedthe albumsand gave to Dennisas part of his Christmas
presents.After ChristmasNancywas able to sharethe storyon her blog. She
was ableto contact Debby Shively who also descendsfromthe Monongalia
CountyShivelylines. She also kindlysharedher
photosfor the restof the Shively'swho are related.
lf interestedin viewing the pictures of the first
album the site on the Internet is: http:ll
p ica sa w eb. goog l e. c om / N S h iv e ly /
lS66ShivelyAlbum# The site of the picturesfor
the photos from the second album is: http://
p ica sa w eb. goog l e. c om / N S h iv e ly /
ShivelyM illikanAlbum#
From the work that MargaretE. Shively
Smithfrom Osawatomie,Kansashas preservedfor
future generationsentitled "Johann Michael
Scheiffle(JohnMichaelShively),lmmigrant1738"
whichwas datedOctober,1993and January,1997
w e h a ve the hi s tory of thi s S h iv e ly lin e .
Acknowledgement by Margaretis given that her
publication was "the combinedfamilyresearchof I
Mary Ann Fokken,Ruth Wandeland Sue Rulfs,
AliceFreed.and herself'. MichaelShively(1896)
BecauseMargaret'swork is writtenso well
and expressedbetter than I could do I quote the followingfrom her work:
"MichaelScheiffle,who arrivedat Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, on the Palatine
Ship,the St. Andrew,October27. 1738,is consideredour immigrantancestor.
The St. Andrewwas one of sixteenshipsthat arrivedthat year with 119 men
passengers.Althoughthe commanders hadbeenorderedto listalsothe women
and children,and to givethe placeof domicileplusthe adults'occupations, very
few did. Commander JohnStedmanof the St.Andrewwas onewho didn'tfollow
the order,unfortunately.Therefore,we do not knowwhetheror not Michaelhad
a wifeand/orchildren."
"Accordingto Strassburgerand Hinke in PENNSYLVANIA GERMAN
PfONEERS, VOL l, pp 238,239, Michaelsigned,October27. 1738,at the
Courthouse in Philadelphia,
the Oathof Allegiance to the BritishCrown,and the
Oathof Abjurationand Fidelityto the Proprieterand the Lawsof the Province.In
VOL. lll of GERMANPIONEERS, pp 244,246, Michael'ssignature writtenin
GermanScript is MICHAEL SCHEIFFLE. No other were
Scheiffles listedon the
St.Andrew."
"The immigrantssoon movedout into other areas, particularlythe York
Countyarea of then LancasterCounty,Pennsylvania.York Countywas settled
chiefly by those Germans of the Lutheranand Lutheran Reformedfaiths.
Michaelprobablytraveledto LancasterCo.,thenabout75 mileswestto Wrights
Ferry taking the MonocacyTrail throughYork County,Adams County,and
southwardto Monocacyin FrederickCounty,Maryland. From my readings,
Monocacywas locatedseveralmileswest of the MonocacyRiverand aboutten
mifesnorthof the townof Frederick.ln 1740,MichaelSchauffle was listedas a
memberof the MonocacyLutheranChurchCongregation.(PENNSYLVANIA
GERMANSlN MARYLAND, p 93 by Nead). Here, Michael'sdaughter,EVA
DOROTHEA,was born March 9. 1740 and was baptizedAugust 10. 1740.
Sponsorswere Georgeand MargarettaSpengel,and SebastianWinterbauer.
(EARLYLUTHERANBAPTISMSAND MARRIAGESIN SE PENN,Recordsof
Rev.JohnCasperStoever,1730-1779, p 14). BothSpengeland Winterbauer
hadarrivedat Philadelphia in Oct 1737."
From MargaretSmith'swork it is known that MichaelScheifflehad,
besidesthe daughterEva Dorthealistedabove,the followingchildren: John
ChristianSchauffle, bornOctober25, 1746;JohnSchaufele, bornApril 14, 1749;
John Jacob Scheiffle,born July 9, 1751;and Joh. HeinrichScheifele,born
January27, 1759. Fromothersourcesis listeda son,JohnPhillipShively,born
1753.
It is knownthat three of the sons of MichaelScheiffle(Shively)movedto
Kentucky. The three sons were ChristianShively,Jacob Shivelyand Henry
Shively.
Fromthe ShivelyfamilyDNAprojectit is knownthatthe descendants of
PhillipShively, whosewillcan be foundin the Monongalia County,\ ruAWill Book
1, Page138,matchthe DNAof the descendants of the aboveChristianShively
and HenryShively.ThisPhillipShivelyis the gr-gr-gr-gr-gr-grandfather of Dennis
Shivelywho is the husbandof NancyShively.The picturesincludedin thisarticle
areof MichaelShively(1807-1900), whowasthe grandson of PhillipShively.
Picturedbeloware additional picturesof DennisShively'sancestors that
wereobtainedfromthe photoalbums:

f";.*

PeterShively(gr-gr-grandfather) AlonzoRobertShively(gr-grandfather)
CLARENCEH. SHIVELY: GANSTERS,1920'5 PROHIBITION, SEATTLE,
WASHINGTON In the November2010 issue of the Shively Newsletter
informationwas presentedon ClarenceH. Shivelywho lived in the Seattle,
Washingtonarea in the 1920's. Clarencewas indictedon the charge of
conspiracyto violatethe nationalprohibitionact and sentto the U.S.Penitentiary
on McNeillsland,Washington.lt was also believedthat Clarencewas involved
in the robberyand theft of bondsfrom two Bank of Californiamessengersin
November of '1923.
A third incidentinvolvingClarenceH. Shivelyis recordedin The Seattle
Daily Times. Informationfrom the SeattleDaily Times reportedthat he was
involvedin the robberyof the Citizens'NationalBankof Everett:
TheSeattleDailyTimes,SeattleWashington, Monday,September 29, 1930,Page1, Columns2-5:
"*""Pictureof ClarenceH. Shively*""*"
*"""Pictureof roadhousewhereShivelywas captured.,...Caption reads"ClarenceH. (Dick)Shively,his
captorand the roadhousewhere he was taken. Shively,upper left, is shownafter his anival at the
SnohomishCountyjail wherehe was lodgedSundayevening,accusedof participation in the Citizens'
NationalBankof Evereftrobbery.Upperrightis SheriffGeorgel. Steverof Snohomish County,who ledthe
possesthat raidedthe Blue Ox Inn, Shively'sroadhouseon Hood Canalshownbelow,where he was
capturedin bed.
ShivelyldentifiedAt BankScene
Ex-OfficerDeclaredln BanditAuto
EvereftPatrolmanPositiveHe SawPrisonerOutsideRobbedlnstitution:OthersSeeResemblance.
Seatedat the wheel of an automobilein front of the Cilizens'SecurityNationalBank of Everett
today,ClarenceH. (Dick)Shively,formerSeattlepoliceman, ex-convictandsuspected leaderof the gangof
six sub-machine gun menwho robbedthe bankof $44,300on September 15 posedsmilingas a numberof
the hold-upwitnessesscrutinizedhis featuresin an effortto identiffhim.
One man did so positivelyand a numberof otherssaid he closelyresembledthe driverof the
automobilein whichthe gangstersfled afterthe robbery.
Fred Lawrence,Everettpatrolman,declaredhe was certainShivelywas the man. Lawrencewas
the onlypoliceman whoapproached the bankwhilethe hold-upwasgoingon.
RanTo Scene
He was not on duty at the time,but seeingsomething was amiss,ran to the bankwith revolver
drawn.A gangster witha submachine gunmethimat the doorandcommanded:
'Dropthatgunand upwithyourhands."
Lawrencedid so and, handsin the air, starteddownthe street,takingnote,he said,of the manat
thewheelof the carparkedat the bankentran@in whichthe banditslaterescaped.
He said at that time the driverof the car was Shivelyand to furtherclinchhis identificationwentto
Shively'sroadhouse, the BlueOx lnn,at Hoodsport on HoodCanal,wherehe madecertain,he said,that
the proprietorwas the gangstersuspect.
It was at the inn yesterdaythat Shivelywas arrestedafter Lawrencehad spentmost of the night
there. The placingof Shivelyin the car in frontof the robbedbankthis morningwas for the purposeof
makingthe identification stillmoreconclusiveinvestigate
claims
Seattleofficialsmeanwhilewere conductingan investigation into an alibi Shivelyclaimswill wholly
exoneratehim and provehe couldnot havebeenin Everettat the time of the robbery.
It is knownhe was in attendanceat the Lyletrial in Seattleon that day as a subpoenaedwitness.
Coollyhe showedthe officerswho arrestedhimat the BlueOx Innthe subpoenaitselfthatsummoned him
to court.
"l wasthere,"he said,"andwastalkingwithUnitedStalesSecretServicemenmostof the day."
CaptorsDubious
But his captorsbelievehe cannotaccountfor an hourand a halfat leastthat includesthe verytime
the bankwas robbedandsomehalfhouror morepreceding anda likeperiodimmediately followingit.
A conversation that Shivelytold them he had had with a womanKingCountyjail prisoner,Kitty
Marlin,shortlybeforenoonlhat day,theyclaimwas not on thatdayat all,thoughthe womansaidshewas
of it andShivelydid notleavethejail untilten minutesbeforenoon.
c,ertain
Eventhoughshe may not be mistaken, the officerscontend,Shively,knownas an expertdriver,
mighthavereachedthe bankin twentyminutes.Therobberyoccunedat exactly12.10p.m. Theusualfast
drivingtimeftom Seattleto Everettis abouthalfan hour.
 Aftera carefulinquiryinto the supposedjail visit,Capt.SilasH. Bunker,the jail superintendent,
madethefollowing statement;
'The two menwho wereon thejail gateon Monday,September15,are WalterSmithand James
Barnes.BothknowShively. Smithknewhimwhentheywereon the policeforce,andBarneshasseenhim
hereat the jail oncebeforewhenhe cameto visita prisonerabouta monthago. BothSmithand Barnes
saypositively theydid notletShivelythroughthegateon September 15 "
Matron'sStory
"Thematronof the women'squarters,Mrs.GeorgiaBarconier, sayssheremembers Shivelycalled
to talk to a womanprisoneron one day duringthe lastweek of the Lyle-Whitney trial. She is tryingto
remember someotherincidentthatwouldfix in her mindjustwhatday it was,butso far hasbeenunableto
do so. We knowShivelywas at the jail on two occasions, onceearlyin the month,whenhe camewith a
womanand somebundlesand I sawhim myself,and onceagainon Thursdayof the finalweekof the Lyle-
Whitneytrial.'
Scorein Officer'sPafi
Armed with submachineguns, sawed-offrepeatingshotguns,rlfles and pistols,and carrying
sufficient ammunition to haveconducted a shortJived siegeagainsta considerable forceof gangsters such
as they expectedthey mightmeet,SheriffRobertStewartleft EverettearlySundaymorningwith a scoreof
pickedmen,and with searchwarrantsand a warrantfor Shively'sarrestdescended intoMasonCountyto
raidShively's BlueOx lnnandhisranchnearShelton.
Joinedby SheriffClaudeHavensof ThurstonCounty,SheriffGeorgeTucker,of Masonand
numerousotherdeputiesand police,all similarlyarmed,the big partysplitat Shelton,somegoingto the
ranch,othersto the inn.
Theyhada theorythatthe bankrobbers,afier leavingEverettwiththe loot,had drivento the beach
and escapedto Shively'sroadhouse in a fast speedboat,and eighteen-footer with powerfulengines,that
was lyingoff shoresouthof Everettthat day. Theyexpectedto findthe boatin its floatat the BlueOx Inn.
Boat,LootNotFound
But it was not there,norweretheyableto findanyof the Everettbanklootor any of the weapons
usedin the Everettrobbery.All theyfoundof conseguence in the searchof bothplaceswasShively.
He was in bed whenSheriffSteverand four auto loadsof deputiesand otherpossemenleaped
fromtheircarsandrushedintothe inn. lt was nearly11 o'clock.
Shivelytookhis anestcalmly,and almostas a joke,it seemed.He laughedand conversed good
naturedly with his captors,showedthemhis FederalCourtsubpoenaandate a heavymealwiththemlater
at Sheltonon the way backto Everett.
Fearingthe par$ mightbe waylaidand attackeden route in an attemptto liberatethe prisoner,
SheriffStevertook a circuitousway. He avoidedmain highwaysand led the caravanover less frequently
usedcountryroads.Shivelyconversing cheerfullyall the way.
But at the Snohomish Countyjail, afterhe had beensearchedand bookedas "C. H. Shively,40
yearsof age,six feetin height,200 poundsin weightandbornin Califomia," andwas ledawayto Cell2 he
lookedsomewhat worried.
'No,"he said,"l don'tthinkl'll putup bail. I don'tthinkit willbe necessary."
A momentbefore,as he emptiedhis pocketsand handedover to the jailer his watch,papers,
fountainpenandothereffects,including $15.10in money,he said: 'Thatis all my worldlygoods."
GrinsAt Question
Askedif he had any furtherstatements to maketo reporters, he grinned:"Putin the papersthat I
runa finepavilionon HoodCanalwherewe havedanceseverynight,andthaton the dayof the bankhold-
up I wasin FederalCourtin Seattleas a witness,thoughI wasn'tcalledto the stand."
Shivelywasbookedto Justiceof the PeaceAndrewJohnson, who hadissuedthewarrantcharging
himwithrobbery.SheriffSteversaidit wasunlikelya hearingwouldbe heldfor a considerable time.
Hisbail,firstfixedat $5,000,was raisedto $10,000today.
TireMarksCheck
Witnesseshavebeenfound,it was learnedtoday,who tracethe flightof the banditcar fromlhe
bankto SilverLake,thencewestto a beachoff whicha speedboatlay. At this pointon the beachis a
shacknearwhichthe day afterthe robbery,tire markswerefoundof the pattemthatwereon the banditcar.
A rowboathad beenpickedup adriftneartherethe eveningfollowingthe robbery.lt is believedthe
skiffwas usedto transferthe robbersand theirlootfromthe shoreto speedboat.
Shively's dismissalfromthe SeattlbPoliceDepartment in 1919 followeddiscovery of hisconnection
with a mysterious transactionin seizedliquor. ln 1923he was sent to McNeillslandprisonfor liquor
conspiracy.While he was at libertyon bond he was arrestedin connectionwith an attemptto disposeof
securities stolenin the Bankof California robberyhere,but laterwas exonerated.He was one of the men
acquitted of the robberyof a Nanaimo, B. C.,bankin 1924.
BankHold-Up Map
"**Diagram (Map)ShowingSuspected RouteUsedto FleeScene****
This map shows the supposed route of flight of the robbers of the Everett Citizens' Security National Bank and the territory
covered by Snohomish County officers yesterday in the capture of Clarenee H. Shively, suspected leader of the
gangsters. According to the authorities theory, the bandits automobile, in which they escaped was driven by Shively
south to Silver Lake, thence west to a shack on Puget Sound, where it was abandoned,to be picked up later by a woman,
the robbers embarking in Shively's speedboat and hurrying to the Blue Ox Inn on Hood Canal, where he was anested
yesterday.

The SeattleDailyTimes,Tuesday,September30, 1930,Page 2, Column2,3:

Outlaw, Price On Head, Sought As Everett Bandit
HarryStone,NotoriousThug, HuntedAs MemberOf SubmachineGun Band;ShivelyAccusersIncrease
(Picture of Harry Stone)
Harry Stone, notorious Pacific Northwest outlaw with a price on his head for murder, was being sought to day
as one of the six submachine gun bandits wanted for the $44,300 robbery of the Citizens' Securily National Bank at
Everett.
Swiftly following the arrest of Clarence H. (Dick) Shively, former Seattle policeman, and his idenlificationas the
driver of the bank robbers' automobile,word was broadcastto authoritiesthroughoutthe country today to look for Stone in
company with another ex-convict also wanted for the Everett hold-up.
Notification came simultaneouslyfrom Vancouver, 8.C., that it had been learned two white men, a few days
before the Everett holdup, had aftempted to buy submachine guns from a Seattle Chinese underworld character. The
same Chinese is believed to have had a hand in the "passing" of $14,500 of the Everett curensy at the Royal Bank of
Canada last week.
A short, stocky ltalian with a peculiar "spider-like"way of moving about like a prize fighter in the ring, was one of
the robbers particularlynoticed by those in the bank. This man, officers suspect, was Stone, whose true name is said to
be George Rossi, and who formerly was a pugilist.
12 ldenti! Shively
No less than twelve witnesses, il was reported by Sheriff George l. Stever of Snohomish County, have now
identifiedShively as the man who sat at the wheel of the bandits' machine outsidethe bank while the robberywas in
progress.
At the same time operatives of the \A/illiamJ, Burns lnternationalDetectiveAgency here said Shively's alibi that
he was in Seattle at the time of the Evereft bank hold-up had been shattered.
Bail Set At $10.000
Shively's lawyer was in Everett last night conferringwith the prisoner. But the attorney did not get Shively out of
jail, if that was his intention,bail havingbeen increasedto $10,000,and amountShivetywas said to be unableto raise.
Search continued for an 18-foot speedboat which authorities suspec{ was used by the bank bandits to escape
from a beach near Everett afier the robbery. Such a boat, Sheriff Stever was informed, had been seen near the Blue Ox
Inn, where Shively was arrested, both before and after the hold-up.
The boat, it is believed, may furnish important clues to the whereabouts of the six gangsters who were inside
the bank while the man identifiedas Shively waited outside in the automobile.
Its disappearance is believed suggestive that lhe robbers have a secret rendezvous somewhere on Puget
Sound where they are hiding, probably well fortified and provisioned and can keep the speedboat comptetely concealed
for use again at anothertime.
Four men of a type resemblingsome of the bank bandits were reported to Sheriff Stever to have been seen on
the Shivelyranch near Sheltonin Mason County as late as last Friday. This was the reason,it was said, that the ranch
was searchedby a posse under his directionat the same time on Sundaythat the Blue Ox Inn was searchedand Shively
taken.
But, in view of lhe disclosurethat Shively had been 'tipped off that he was under surveillance,the officers said
today it is not strange that they found the ranch deserted and could find non evidence of any kind.

The SeattleDailyTimes, Friday,October24, 1930,Page 10, Column3:

Shively Freed At Hearing On Bank Hold-Up
Fofmer Seattle PolicemanCleared \/VhenEvidence ls lnsufiicientto Link Him in Everett Robbery
Special to The Times of C. H. Shively*"t"
Everett,Friday,Oc{.24.- ClarenceH. (Dick)Shivelyagainis a free man.Evidenceproducedby the stateat a preliminary
hearingwas insufficient,Justiceof the PeaceAndrewJohnsonheldlasteveningto bringthe formerSeattlepolicemanto
trial. \Mrenall witnesseshadbeenheardthe scorefor and againsthimwas as follows:
Onewomantestifiedshe saw Shivelyin the Citizens'SecurityNationalBankapparently"sizingthingsup"five
daysbeforesubmachine gunbanditsrobbedthe bankof $44,300September15.
Threeotherwitnessesidenlifiedhimas the driverof the car in whichthe banditsescaped-
Severalotherssaidhe resembled the driver,butfour of thesedeclaredthe manin the car seemedsmallerthan
theprisoner.
Ninesaidintheiropinionthedriverwas personthanShively.
".3::f,,rrg::rent
Nearlya dozentestifiedthatthey hadseenand someof themhadtalkedwith Shivelyin Seattlebetween11:30
a.m.andnoonon thedayof the robbery. Thehold-up wasat 12:10p.m.
ProsecutorCharlesR. Denneydid not opposevigorouslya motionof Shively'scounselto dismissthe prisoner,
thoughhe said in his opinionthe positiveidentificationby the threewitnesseswouldwarranthis beingbroughtto trial.
JusticeJohnsonsaidhe thoughta trialwouldbe a wasteof taxpayer' money.
CIVIL WAR PENSIONOF SUSANASHIVELY,WIDOWOF SAMUELSHIVELY,
STARKECOUNTY,INDIANA- Followingis someof the information extractedfromthe
CivilWar pensionof SusanaKoontzShively,widowof SamuelShively. A listof Indiana
marriageslists SamuelShibleymarryingSuannaKoontzon 1- March-1860at the
GermanMethodistEpiscopalChurch,LaPorte,LaPorteCounty,lN. lt appearsthat
Susanamarrieda secondtime,afterthe deathof SamuelShively,to HenryPeterSulton
12-June-1864.(Starke County,lN marriageBook A, Page 123). From the pension
papersSamuel Shivelyis listed as having died in June-1863in Vicksburg,MS.
Genealogy recordslistSusannaas beingborn25-Feb-1840anddied25-Oct-1898.On
the 1860OregonTownship,StarkCounty,IND census,family187,is SamuelShively
age24bornin OH,Susannah age20 bornin OH,and Mariaage2 bornin lN.

Stateof Indiana
MarshallCounty
On this 6mday of August,1863,beforeme a Clerkof the CircuitCourtin and for
the Countyand Stateabovenamed,personally cameSusanaShively,whoseresidence
and Postofficeaddressis Grovertown, StarkeCounty,lndiana,and who afterbeingduly
swornsay she is aged24 years,and thatshe makesthe followingdeclaration in orderto
obtainthe benefitof the pensionmadeby the Act of Congress, approved July 14, 1862:
Thatsheis thewidowof SamuelShivelywhowasa privatein Company"D"commanded
by CaptainWilsonin the 48thRegimentof lndianaVolunteers, in the war of 1861,who
diedat Mcksburgh, Mississippi,on or aboutthe 28thdayof June,1863,andthe causeof
his deathwas typhosfever.
She furtherdeclaresthat she was marriedto the said SamuelShivelvat Knox.
StarkeCounty,lndiana,on or aboutthe 1ttdayof March,1860,by one Johnd. Schafer,
a ministerof the Gospel;that her husbandthe aforesaidSamuelShivelydiedon the day
abovementioned,and that she has remaineda widow ever since that periodas will
moredulyappearby referenceuntilthe proofhereuntoannexed.She alsodeclaresthat
she has not in any mannerbeenengagedin or aidedor abetted,the rebellionin the
UnitedStates.And shefurtherdeclaresthatshe hasthe followingchildrenliving,by said
husband,underthe age of sixteenyears:
DanielShively,aged2 yearsthe 27thof January,1864
And she hereby constitutesand appoints John D. Devor her attorneyto
prosecutethis claimand processfor her a Pensioncertificate. her
Susana x Shively
Mark
Also personallyappeared Philip Weller and Caroline Smith residents of
Grovertown,StarkeCounty,Indiana, personswhom I certifyto be respectableand
entitledto credit,and who beingby me duly sworn,say that they were presentand saw
SusanaShivelysign her markto the foregoingdeclaration, and they haveeveryreason
to believe,from the appearanceof the applicant,and their acquaintance with her, that
she is the identicalpersonshe representsherselfto be, and thatthey haveno interestin
the prosecution of thisclaim.
PhilipWeller
CarolineSmith
Swornto and subscribedbeforeme and I herebycertifuthat I haveno interestin
the prosecution of this claim,directlyor indirectly. In witnesswhereofI havehereunto
set my handandofficialsealthis6thdayof August,1863.
H. R. Pershing
C.C.C.MarshallCounty
SamuelShively Be it remembered, that on this
To 29thday of Feby,1860,the following
SusanaKoontz marriagelicensewas issuedtowit:
Indiana,towit: StarkeCounty.ss.
To all who shall see these presents,Greeting: Know that my person
legallyauthorizedto solemnizematrimonyis herebyrequiredto join in marriage
as husbandand wife SamuelShivelyand SusanaKoontz,and for so doingthis
shallbe his sufficientauthority.
S.S. In testimony whereofl, JohnS. Benton,Clerk
By J. E. Short (De )
Be it remembered that on this Sthday of MarchA.D. 1860the following
certificatewas recordedin this office,to wit:
Indiana,to wit:StarkeCoun$
Thiscertifiesthat ljoinedin marriageas husbandandwifeSamuelShively
andSusanaKoontz,on the 1 day of MarchA.D. 1860 JohnG. Schafer
( ) John S. BentonClerk

Stateof Indiana,Countyof Starke,ss.

l, OliverH. P. Howard,Clerkof the CircuitCourtwithinandfor saidCounty
and State, do herebycertifythat the foregoingare true copies of the license
authorizingthe marriageof SamuelShivelyand SusanaKoontz,and is the
certificateof their marriageas appearsin the propermarriagerecordnow in my
saidoffice. In testimonywhereofI hereuntoset my handand affixthe seal
of saidCourtthis7thdayof September 1863at Knox,tnd.
OliverH. P. Howard Clerk

Datedat NearSavannahGA Dec 1711864.

I certifyon honorthat SamuelShivelywas a privatein Company"D" of the 48th
Regimentof IndianaVolunteersand that whilestrictlyin his line of duty at the
siegeof Vicksburg,Misson the 6thday of June 1863he contractedby exposure
and overexertion,a diseasecommonlyknownas typhosfever,whichresultedin
his deathon the 20thday of June,1863,at Vicksburg,Mississippi, all of which
I
fact have personalknowledge.
AdolphusH Green
Capt48 IndVol Infty
ComdgCo. D
SHIVELY'SlN NEW ORLEANS,ORLEANSPARISH,LOUISIANA- In the November
2010issueof the ShivelyNewsletter information was requestedon who mightbe buried
in NewOrleans,Louisiana in Lafayette CemeteryNo. 1. Thiscemeteryis locatedin the
historicGardenDistrict.lt is amongthe city'searliestand mostsignificant aboveground
burialsites. Oncepart of the LivaudaisPlantation, LafayetteNo. 1 was designated a
cityburialsitein 1833.
At the head of this gravewas probablya marker
listingthe namesof the personsburiedhere. At
the time of visit this marker was missing.
Researchon the surnameShivelyin NewOrleans
has givensomecluesas to who mightbe in this
cemetery. From the census records and
informationextracted from the New Orleans
newspapersit is knownthat there were Shively's
who did live in the GardenDistrictin the area of
this cemetery.
Locatedin the marriagerecordsfor Louisianawas foundthe marriageof WilliamShirley
to MaryHaleyon 3-Dec-1867 in OrleansParish.On the 1870OrleansParish,11Ward
of New Orleanswas foundthe familyof WilliamShivelyage 27 born in lndiana,wife
Mary H. age 28 born in Liverpooland daughterIndianaage 1yr 2 monthsborn in
Louisiana.
On the next censusrecordin 1880the familyof \Mlliamand MaryShivelyhas
grownand listedin OrleansParish,200 Annunciation Street,New Orleansis William
Shivelyage 38 bornIndiana, wife Maryborn in England,daughterIndianaage 11,son
Williamage 8 anddaughterMaryage6.
The childrenof Vt/illiamand Mary Shivelymarriedas follows: Mary Louisa
ShivelymarriedRoderickS. Huddlestonon 1-Aug-1894, WilliamC Shivelymarried
BlandR. Huddleston on 28-Jan-1897 in New Orleans, IndianaMyrtillaShivelymarried
WilliamFrederick Weishaupt on 25-Mar-1908.
On the 1900OrleansParish,1427HarmonyStreet,NewOrleansis listedthe son
of \Mlliamand Mary Shively. The son \MlliamC. Shivelyage 28 born Oct 1871 in
Louisianais listedwith wife Bland R age 28 born Dec 1871 in Mississippi and son
WllliamC., Jr age2 born 1897in Louisiana. By 1900the daughterof Williamand
Mary Shively,Mary Louisa,has movedand is livingin Chicago,lL with her husband
RoderickHuddleston and childrenRoderickage4 and Mae age2.

Other record sourceswere searchedto give additionalinformationon these

Shivelyfamilies.A deathcertificate
was foundfor WilliamHenryShively.He died in
New Orleanson 27-Oct-1930at the age of 87 years 3 months. The certificatestates
the deceasedwas the widowerof Mary Holey,and the son of UlricShivelyand Polly
Johnson,bothnativesof Indiana.
we then knowthe parentsof WilliamHenryShivelywere
Fromthis information
UleryShivelyborn1819Montgomery Co.OH died1858MadisonCo, lN and MaryJane
"Polly"Johnsonwho were married9-April-1838 in RushCo., lN. Williamwouldhave
beenthe grandsonof JacobC Shivelyand Mary Siler. Wlliam'sgrandparents were
lsaacDavidShively(1759-1823) Bossler(1764-1800).Finally,
and Elizabeth William
would have been the great-grandson
of UlrichSchaublin(1721-1776')
and Elizabeth
Thommen (1722-1777).

A newspaper obituarywas locatedfor WlliamCushingShivey,son of \Mlliamand

MaryShively:The DailyPicayune, NewOrleans,Monday,December3'1,1900,Page6,
Column5: W. C. Shively
SuddenDeathOf A Promising YoungBusinessMan
Mr. WilliamCushingShively,a rising young businessman, diedsuddenly
at 1:30o'clockSundaymorningat his homeon Harmonystreet,nearPrytania.
He was in his 29thyear,and had for a longtime held a responsiblepositionwith
the firm of A. Baldwin& Co. Mr. Shivelysuccumbedto an apoplecticattack
inducedby a too closeapplication to business. He was ill only a few minutes.
Althoughhe had recentlycomplainedof feelingunwell,he himselfattachedno
importanceto the fact, and was not evenconfinedto the house. He was a man
of exeeptionalability and attractivepersonality,and his suddendeath will be
regrettedby a wide circleof friends. His wife and one chiH survivehim, besides
his parentsand two sisters,one of whom, Mrs. R. S. Huddleston, residesin
Chicago.

The next newspaperobituarylistsone Shivelymemberas beingburiedin

the LafayetteNo. 1 cemetery.Notethat in the obituaryis mentionof Mrs. Bland
Huddleston,mother of WilliamC. Shively. This \Mlliam C. Shivelyis the
grandsonof Williamand MaryShivelyand son of \MlliamCushingShivelyand
BlandHuddleston:
TheTimes-Picayune, Friday,September 30, 1932,Page2, Column8:
SHIVELY-AI Chicago,lll., on TuesdaySeptember27, 1932, Mrs. Bland
Huddleston Shively,motherof WilliamC. Shively.
Remainswill arrivein New Orleanson Fridayevening.September30,
1932at 7:50 o'clockvia l. C. Railroad. Funeralserviceswill be heldfrom the
funeralhomeof Pat J. McMahon-Coburn Co., 2305 Canal,cornerN. Mire,on
Saturday morning, October1,1932,at 11o'clock.
Intermentin LafayettecemeteryNo. '1.

A newspaperobituarywas locatedfor the grandsonof Williamand Mary

Shively and who was the son of William Cushing Shively and Bland R
Huddleston:
TheTimes-Picayune,Monday, April14, 1980,Sec.1-Page20, Column8:
SHIVELY---WilliamC. Shively,82 years,of Jaffrey,NH, formerlyof New lberia
and New Orleans,died on April 12, 1980 quietlyat home; survivedby his
daughterJanetS. Magoun(Mrs.T. R.) at Jaffrey,NH; 4 grandchildren,PeterR.
Magounof NorthHaven,CT,MattS. Magounof PaltoAlto,CA, JenniferL. and
JessicaA. Frenchof Tulsa,OK; and 1 great-grandson, StevenR. Magoun,of
NorthHaven,CT. Servicesprivatewith burialin Jaffrey,NH.
JACOBWHEELERSHIVELEY (SHIVELY) AND JULIAHOOD- In the November 2A1O
issueof the ShivelyNewsletterinformationwas sharedregardingthe familyof Jacob
WheelerShiveley(Shively). Ray Shively,Des Peres,MO e-mailedwith additional
on thisfamilyand photo's.
information
JacobWheelerShiveleywas the son of GeorgeShively(born25-Dec-1842, died
8-Sep-1902) and his first wife, PaulineJane Nelson(born 7-June-1843, died 18-
Aug-1874AdamsCounty,OH). Jacobwas marriedto JuliaA. Hood,daughterof John
Hoodand NancyStovall. Jacoband Juliahad threechildren: John Murle(Merle)
Shiveleywho marriedHelen Hundall,GeorgeHenry Shiveleywho marriedMargart
AlmetaMorton,and MildredMarieShiveleywho marriedEdwardE. Porterfield, Jr.
Jacob\NheelerShiveleyis a relativein Ray Shively'slineage. For additional
on Jacobyou cango to RayShively's
information website:
http://www.shivs.com/shively/genealogyiindividual.php?pid=15592&ged=Shively%20Family.ged

Julia !Ifdmd_, George flenry and_J_acob Wheeler SHMLEY

QUERIES- Freeto anyoneinterestedin the Shivelyfamilyresearch. Pleasegive as

as possible,particularly
muchinformation datesand localities.lf you do notget a reply,
submityourqueryagainat a laterdate.

The successof the SHIVELYNEWSLETTER is directlydue to the participation

of the
subscribers.Withoutyour interestand input,nothingwouldhavebeenaccomplished.
The NEWSLETTER is publishedquarterly. To subscribe,send $8.00for one year.
Pleasemakecheckspayableto LarryShively.
 SHIVELYBLOGS- On the lnternetyou canfinda blogfor aboutanysubjectimagined.
A blogis a websiteor a partof a websitewith information pertainingto usuallyone area
of interest.Blogsare usuallyupdatedfrequentlywith new information addedas oftenas
daily. This type of technologycan be a good sourceof sharinginformationfor the
genealogist. The Shivelyresearchers workingon the familiesthat descendfrom Michael
Scheifflehave a very interestingblogwrittenby NancyShively. For more information
aboutNancyandherhusbandDennispleaseseethe leadarticlethismonth.
The authorof your Shivelynewsletterhas beentakinggenealogyclassesat the
FamilyTree University and it was duringJanuary2011that I had the goodfortuneof
findingNancyand Dennis. Shewas selectedto createa blogon the FamilyTreesite.
Withouther blogI mighthaveneverconnected withherhusband,Dennis,whodescends
fromthe samelineas thoseof us who havethe Michaeland PhillipShivelylinesin West
Virginia.
I saw Nancy'sgenealogyblogwhile I was finishinga classentitledFindYour
GermanRoots. I hadjust starteda newclassentitledBuildA FamilyWebsite.For quite
some time I have wanted a site where the Shively Newslettercould be shared
electronically.The ShivelyNewsletter hasgoodparticipation fromthe researchers and it
is hopedthat withthe information postedquarterlyon the Internetthatwe can all benefit
andlearnmoreaboutour Shivelyfamilies.
lf interestedyou can find my new Shively Family Genealogy blog at
http:i/shivelyfamilygenealogy.blogspot.com/ lt is my intentto use the siteto further
our Shivelyresearch,sharethe Newsletter quarterlyand add linksto websitesthat are of
particularinterestto the Shivelyfamilygenealogyresearch.

Shively Newsletter
Lurry W Shively
PO. Box 1462
Hlnes.IL 60141-1462