Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Conference Board
Boronnikova, Natalya (Perm State Research University) Georgievska-Jakovleva, Loreta (University "Ss Cyrill and Methodius") Koleva, Daniela (University of Sofia) Miodyski, Lech (University of Pozna) Panovski, Naum (Poiesis Theatre Project) Pavlovski, Mishel (University "Ss Cyrill and Methodius") Podmakov, Dagmar (Slovak Academy of Sciences) Soini, Katriina (University of Jyvskyl) , ( ) -, ( . . ) , ( ) , ( ) , ( . . ) , (Poiesis Theatre Project) , ( ) , ( ) , ( ) -, ( . ) , ( ) , ( ) , ( . ) , (Poiesis Theatre Project) , ( ) , ( )
Book of Abstracts
1st Annual CCCS Conference "Cultural Memory"
Individual Papers
7 Abadia Lilia; Cabecinhas Rosa & Macedo Isabel, Communication and Society Research Centre, University of Minho
(De)constructing the Past: cross-cultural analysis of migrants accounts in Brazil, Mozambique and Portugal
In this paper we will examine, through autobiographical accounts, the different interpretations of historical facts and the conflicts they entailed in the individual identity narratives of migrant people within the Portuguese-speaking countries. Aiming at understanding how historical references were used to support and reject national, ethnic and gender auto and heterorepresentations, we conducted, under the scope of an ongoing research project, 50 autobiographical interviews and 12 focus groups in three different countries, namely: Brazil, Mozambique and Portugal. Aware of the great variety of life stories, with specific narrative structures, collected under different conditions (8 cities, 6 interviewers), we established our analysis focus on firstly, accounts of their migration experiences; secondly, acculturation and cultural consumption; thirdly, auto and hetero-social representations; and finally, intercultural encounters. In each of these thematic categories, we examined the presence of historical facts and characters, as well as their correlation with the individual experiences narrated. In order to articulate the ensemble of the multilayered memories collected by our research team, we leaned toward some current oral history perspectives that emphasise the role of narratives in the remembering process by combining various cultural symbol systems and integrating them within one symbolic space. Moreover, the content and discourse analyses that were conducted, based on contributions mainly brought from cultural and communication studies, allowed us to understand how the participants used language to (re)construct meanings, roles and identities. One of the main implications of this study is to challenge predefined migrants hetero-representation and hegemonic interpretations of ethnic relations within our geographical scope. Furthermore, considering that social memory has been investigated in very fragmented paths, we believe that our research has the potential to contribute to the development of an integrative theoretical understanding of cross-cultural identitarian construction, taking the Portuguese-speaking space as our geographical frame. Keywords: autobiographical narratives, identities, social representations, migration, collective remembering Aceska Ana, Humboldt University of Berlin
Remembering the Joint Past of a Divided City: Reflections from Mostar, Bosnia-Herzegovina
In this paper I will give an insight to the interplay between memories and space in a post-war divided city. How are the collective and individual memories and forgetting related to mass violence taken into account when planning the post-war divided city? How do scholars, urban planners and policy makers describe and interpret these memories in their various professional responses to the post-war divided city? In most of the cases, the urban planning strategies in these cities are focused on the creation of common or neutral spaces which are planned as sites of forgetting rather than remembering. In scholarly works, moreover, these cities are being conceptualized as sites where the memories of mass violence are more present than elsewhere. On the bases of an ethnographic research conducted in Mostar, Bosnia-Herzegovina, in my paper I will challenge these takenfor-granted ways of conceptualizing and planning the divided city. I will argue that these approaches fail to recognize the extent to which spaces can be neutral in a city that is a locus of collective and individual memories and forgetting related to mass violence. I will moreover explore the way they fail to acknowledge that post-war ethnic identities and collective and individual memories and forgetting related to war-time mass violence are not what people have, but what people negotiate in their everyday lives. In the context of Mostar, they also fail to recognize that the various identity formations and we/they divides in the post-war times are not felt and mapped onto places on one side of the city only. Keywords: Airinei Vasile, Irina, National School for Political Studies and Public Administration, Bucharest, Romania
The Balkan Melos and the cultural (international) magazine Carmina Balcanica
The concept of Balkanity allows the perception of those elements that impregnate the psychology, mentality and, interrelated, the artistic creation in the specific forms of Southeastern mans sensitivity of yesterday and of today. In this respect, the cultural magazine Carmina Balkanica is an attempt to give substance to that concept. Within a dispute of the elements, which are obviously different, there is still an essence that includes also us, the inhabitants of the Levant, with our mutual identity in the same old and harmonious original lands. The great Romanian historian Nicolae Iorga explained the numerous similarities that emphasize the unity of the Balkanic peoples by the old ethnic element of Thracian origin, previous to the Latin, Slavic, Turanian and even Hellenic expansion. Here, in the Balkans, the tragedy was born, as well as the endless tragedies of some unhappy histories. This is how, probably, beyond all differences, beyond our original Thracic, Hellenic, Latin or Slavic oldness, Poetry as understood in our magazine is our possible (re)-unifying element, above history and languages. This is another element for what Balkanism could mean. Or Balkanity! It was stated before, in different ways: Poetry can be considered also a reason for the History development in the past and, possibly, in the future. Therefore, we do not think it is a simple cultural phenomenon. The fundamental similarities through which it can reveal us to the world represents the profound truth of a spirit that visits us all, and, at the same time, the unique impress of an old civilization that still exists in us. An existing unity in the forms of expression can be found in Carmina Balcanica, an international cultural publication offers, by the help of essays, poetry, book-reviews, an identification of rhythms and trajectories of thinking and expressing that are essential for Southeastern spirituality as forma mentis. Keywords: alcanism, Southeastern spirituality , unity and diversity, cultural expressions Albu Mihaela; Zabava Camelia, University of Craiova
Re-shaping memory of communism: The Museum of the victims of communism in the project Skopje 2014
After the fall of communism in Europe, reckoning with the authoritarian past and re-shaping memory was one of the challenges of post-communist nation-building. This paper considers the politics of re-constructing memory of communist past, as displayed
9 in the Macedonian Government's project Skopje 2014 and more particularly in the Museum of the victims of communism. It examines the politic of memory embodied in Skopje 2014 as reflecting the broader struggle of the Macedonian post-communist political elites for control over the collective memory and creation of a new nation-building narrative and national identity. Taking into account the theoretical assumptions of memory politics and of the new museology, the paper considers in details the representation of the communist past in the Museum of the victims of communism. The museum, alongside monuments and memorials, has played a significant role in post-communist memory culture. As argued by Pierre Nora, museums, rather than simply evoking memory, construct history selectively. The selective and political dimension of museum, as pointed out by new museology, has enabled critical re-thinking of th narratives of museum displays. The museum, in that sense, recreates and sanctions history and decides which parts of the past are to be commemorated or obliterated. Through the example of the Museums of the victims of communism, this paper considers how museum and memoralization practices can be also used to force a specific ideology upon society and to consecrate a particular version of history, becoming an instrument for glorification and legitimization of power-holders. Focusing moreover on the museum visitors experiences, the article also concentrates on the political and affective meanings it communicates to visitors. Keywords: (post)communism, victims of communism, national identity. nation-building, memory, memory politics, memoralization, museum, museum visitors experience . Baykova Ekaterina, Saratov State Technical University
10 may well be in the Foucaultian sense an exercise of power but it also has an affect, which is to create a counter narrative. This paper explores how the signs of gender fluidity in these photographs serve to disrupt the story of nation by laying bare its overinvestment in heterosexual masculinity. Keywords: gender performance, nationalism, counter-narrative, visual collective memory, masculinities, collective forgetting, Irish history. Bede, Ana, Josip Juraj Strossmayer University of Osijek, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences
Methodical Approaches to Roberto Benigni's La vita bella in a Literature Classroom: Discussing Identity and Ethical Issues
A motion picture has been used in a literature classroom for decades. However, more attention has to be paid to the discussion of the issues that the movie provides itself. This paper proposes various methods and techniques for teaching Roberto Benigni's motion picture La vita bella, in different methodical approaches: problem-oriented, integrated, and comparative. Therefore, cinema class, motion picture class, movie-literature class and a class about a movie and a director are systematically developed. Problem-oriented approach explores identity and ethical issues, as well as the interpretation of movie characters, with the aim of nourishing students' positive human values. Integration is mostly about correlation with history and other arts, like music and visual art. While in contemporary literature teaching more systematic affiliation between literature and motion pictures, on the basis of themes, motifs, symbols, characters, and plot is needed, emphasis is put on a comparative approach the movie and the chosen literature work in correlation. Keywords: methodical approaches, La vita e bella by Roberto Benigni, identity and ethical issues, motion picture, literature classroom Begicevic Alma, The University of Melbourne
Rethinking Transitional Justice and Social Repair: the Case of Bosnia and Herzegovina
The study considers what the construction of BH as a state with fixed, parallel identities means for its rebuilding in the wake of genocide and war. It suggests that this establishment of a framework to enable political reconciliation, where limited constitutional identities have been fixed as a form of power sharing arrangement, accountability becomes secondary. What is promoted rather is a form of political and social order that enables a limited living together, both nationally within BH and regionally, between BH and Serbia. This separation of identities has become fixed both in BH and across the region. The consequence of this process is that the accountability process is also restricted to individual and communal, rather than state accountability. The study explores these relationships to contemplate how cultural memory, and politics of how cultural memory is used in the process of selective collective remembering and forgetting, impacts the course of transitional justice and social repair processes. Keywords: Identity, Accountability, Transitional-justice, Recognition, Social-repair Bell Simon, Anglia Ruskin University, Cambridge
Laibach and the NSK: Aestheticising the East/West Nexus in Post-Totalitarian Europe
This paper reflects a study in how the Slovenian art-political movement the NSK (Neue Slowenische Kunst) and more specifically its sub-group Laibach interrogate the representation of Central and Eastern European cultural memory in the context of postcommunism, and operate as a nexus between Eastern Europe and the West. Emerging in the wake of Tito's death and shaped by the break-up of Yugoslavia, the NSK were founded in 1984 in Ljubljana, northern Slovenia. The NSK is a multi-disciplinary collective primarily comprised of three groups: IRWIN (visual arts), Noordung (theatre), and its most influential delivery system, Laibach (music). Championed by Slavoj iek for their subversive strategy of over-identification with the totalitarian spectacle, Laibach are Slovenias most famous cultural export, with a global following and an international and domestic history of controversy. With the strategy of Retrogardism, Laibach and the NSK re-mythologise totalitarian iconography associated with Nazi Kunst and Socialist Realism, which late-capitalism can only relate to as offensive kitsch. Through this process of remythologisation Laibach explore the unfinished narrative of Communism and the legacy of the European traumatic historical in the context of a post-ideological age. Retrogardism is unique to Eastern European aesthetic praxis and as such has been recontextualised by artist and cultural theorist Marina Grini as the new ism from the East. For the East, according to Grini, Only one subject is topical: history the re-appropriation of history. Other diverse fields such as ideological discourse, Suprematism, Balkanisation and the wider notion of European identity are all fertile ground for Laibach and the NSKs controversial provocation. The East collapsed because it blindly believed in the Western utopian definition of freedom of the individual. The West only survives because it slyly established a system, which insists on peoples freedom. - Laibach (2003) Keywords: Laibach, NSK, Eastern Europe, Slovenia, Retrogardism Bell, Claudia, University of Auckland
Cultural memory inscribed in the skin: symbols of nation as tattoo art in New Zealand.
In New Zealand there is a strand of cultural memory popularly known as kiwiana. The term embraces everyday popular cultural practices - beach activities in summer, food rituals - as well as an array of vintage artefacts. The latter are locally manufactured
11 items originating mainly in the 1940s-50s, when import restrictions limited the availability of household goods. Local makers created products for the domestic market, for instance grocery items (and their logo-bearing containers), household crockery and toys. Those items, intrinsically representations of white (pakeha) culture, have become popular collectibles. In 2009-11 I visited 20 kiwiana collectors throughout New Zealand. I viewed their artefacts and heard their stories, in which they often expressed their nostalgic commitment to earnest guardianship of otherwise potentially lost material remnants of national history. These symbols convey a period before the major social changes brought about by feminism, revised race laws, and increasing cultural diversity as new immigrant groups settled in this country. In short, kiwiana might be seen as signifying a re-actionist stance. Recently a further celebratory strand of kiwiana has appeared: the inscription of its symbols and objects as extensive permanent skin tattoos. While Maori have always practiced meaningful skin tattoo, and whilst body tattoos in general have joined the realm of fashion, this is something new. Here we see a recasting of the kiwiana images of popular cultural memory, now drawn onto the body. One wearer of such a tattoo, a 26 year old plumber, said I love New Zealand. I am very proud of who we are and I wouldnt change being a kiwi for the world. His design choice shows his personal subscription to the populist imagery that is utilised as apolitical definition of kiwi-ness. Kiwiana tattoo as a growing everyday practice is the focus of this presentation. Keywords: collective memory, material culture, nation, tattoo, kiwiana Belyakova, Natalia, St.Petersburg National Research University of IT, Mechanics and Optics
Sites of State Violence and the construction of democracy: Spain and Chile in comparative perspective
Space is a social frame of memory: it (re)presents the past, making it present through the direct contact with its remnants. Sites where episodes of collective violence have taken place can be read as marks: concrete realities that are at the same time territorial representations of what has happened. The story of these places and their material evolution show the ways societies handle their violent past, after it comes to an end as an historical event. This presentation focuses on specific sites located in the cities of Madrid and Santiago de Chile; sites that are considered symbols of the State violence perpetrated by two dictatorial regimes of the contemporary era: Chile, 1973-1990 and Spain, 1939-1975. The evolutions of these places show the construction of public discourse on dictatorial violence, in the context of two transitions to democracy that have followed similar patterns, and have interacted with each other in many ways, but have handled very differently their violent dictatorial past and its representations. The places that we compare are two detention centers, two institutional buildings and two commemorative monuments from the dictatorial era. In the Chilean case, after a difficult process of negotiation and conflict, today the symbols of past violence are incorporated in a sort of human rights liturgy that any political authority must assume as a necessary element of its present legitimization. In the case of Spain, the symbols of francoist past have been mainly destroyed, abandoned or recycled, showing the existence of a culture of impunity. Observing these sites we question the relations between democracies and memories of State violence, as they express in those public spaces. Keywords:
12 Bijukovi Mari Mirta; uki Marina: Sveuilite Josipa Jurja Strossmayera u Osijeku
13 Buckley, Alexis: Department of Geography, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ, USA
Negotiating Cultural Memory through Representations of Cultural Trauma: Murals as Memoryworks in Northern Ireland
This paper attempts to articulate more fully the complexity and nuance of the formations and expressions of cultural memory related to centuries of conflict and cultural trauma in Northern Ireland by engaging critically and respectfully with visual representations of oppression, resistance, and territoriality as depicted in murals. The murals are politically charged, preceptive portrayals of cultural trauma that function as part of an intricate visual discourse on the Anglo/Irish conflict particularly as it informs and is shaped by the often competing cultural memories of those living in predominantly working-class communities in Belfast and Derry. Recognizing the murals as memoryworks creates spaces through which to explore the power/knowledge dynamics between the muralists, those who may commission them, the community, and the state. Through participatory action research designed to access a plurality of narratives visual and textual and using storytelling as methodology this paper tries to move beyond often rehearsed narratives about the traumatic past. An important premise is that within each community exists a diversity of cultural and political affiliations that is often lost in broader discourses surrounding Northern Irish politics, identity, and the peace process. Engaging with murals as memory-works that represent regimes of truth and shape ways of seeing that influence the production of cultural memories is a means to access andarticulate the heterogeneity of space and plurality of trajectories. With that in mind, there is a focus on visuality or scopic regimes the ways in which one comes to recognize, understand, and explain what is seen through socio-cultural constructions that explore, in this case, the function and effect of the didactic and commemorative practice of mural painting on the ways in which people understand, engage, and disengage with spaces, each other, and the other. Keywords: Cultural Trauma, Memory-works, Scopic Regimes, Participatory Action Research Bulatovi, Dragan: Centre for Museology and Heritology, Faculty of Philosophy, Belgrade
Heritage vs fetish
This paper discusses the strategic importance of understanding, acceptance and preservation of heritage as material and spiritual values as well as its value of experience. We explain the potential of heritage as life-long practice of advancement based on difference that exists between the inheritance (that which is an excess) and the heritage (which is appropriated as a value for individual practice). Although analysis of our social practice of managing the heritage and the delight in its fruits as heritage reveals a complete inactivity, we maintain that the experience of inheriting as such is the only real general resource with which we will enter the era of knowledge. Key words: inheritance, heritage, strategy, fetish Bulc, Gregor: Independent researcher, London, UK
Gej Sloveni [Gay Slavs]: Queering the Yugoslav Popular Music History
Yugoslav popular music artefacts produced from 1940s to 1991 have arguably not been subject to any in-depth research in terms of their LGBT-related meanings. Using Foucauldian archaeological method, this paper aims to identify Yugoslav popular music songs that express affirmative sentiment towards LGBT persons, as well as interrogate public reactions to them through a discursive analysis. It seems that most of these artefacts have been generally integrated within the cultural milieu of (post)Yugoslav societies, while their queer meanings/messages have at the same time been thoroughly suppressed in dominant discourses. This paper attempts to reveal quite a different history of what men have said about these artefacts. While aiming at identifying a number of pro-queer popular music songs from the socialist Yugoslavia, the paper strives, through analysis of semiotic registers, visual codes, metaphors, tropology and explicit statements, to offer a fresh alternative reading of particular important chapters of Yugoslav popular music history. In short, it suggests the ways in which the Yugoslav popular music history could be queered. The paper does not nevertheless try to provide the true meaning of the queer-themed Yugoslav popular music discourses but rather to point to alternative meanings/histories such discourses embody. This effort might result in an acknowledgment of emancipative potential of the songs in question for contemporary struggles for LGBT rights in the region of former Yugoslavia, as well as provide reasons why queering of Yugoslav popular music history has not happened yet. Amongst others, the paper will be dealing with artists like VIS Idoli, Zabranjeno Puenje, Bijelo Dugme and Prljavo Kazalite. Keywords: Popular music, Yugoslavia, socialism, queer, cultural history Carnelli, Fabio, Il lavoro culturale www.lavoroculturale.org, Siena, Italia
14 special view on the creation of some tactics of subjects in facing the reconstruction of an imagined community after the disaster. The relation between time of trauma and displacement, and the need for a future and emplacement reveal how affect to places has to be made explicit through the activation of a dialectic between past and present. It is possible so, through these current practices of memory and emplacement, that call into question some specific symbols of the community boundary, to analyze the self-representation of the subjects of their community through the performance of the affection for their physical and emotional structures of routines holding people in places1, in the construction of a new collective history after the disaster. Keywords: disaster, displacement, memory, performance, affection, place, community Chikovani Nino; Kakitelashvili Ketevan, Institute of Cultural Studies, Ivane Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University
Artistic intervention projects and cultural memory: experiences from Portugals centre region
This presentation discusses the project Mondego Map of Ruins, organized and implemented by O Teatro, a theatre company in Coimbra. This initiative will develop and present three theatre performances in three abandoned spaces (ruins), one in each of three cities in the Centre region of Portugal Coimbra, Montemor-o-Velho and Figueira da Foz. These artistic presentations will be based on the collection of local memories, including local testimonies and other types of local materials from local, social and economic history. This initiative represents the prologue for the project Artria 7: O centro em Movimento. This is a regional and international project that is developing both artistic and academic initiatives to work with a group of local agents (municipalities, universities, artistic agents and artistic schools) in order to develop an artistic, social and academic network among the cities of the Centre region of Portugal (Coimbra, Montemor-o-Velho, Aveiro, Leiria, Guarda, Castelo Branco and Belmonte). In each city, the network will help catalyze local projects of artistic intervention. The main goal of this project is to create a regional dynamic with concrete local social impacts, proposing a new paradigm of cultural relations in the region based on the cultural memories of local communities, their material and immaterial ruins and possibilities for future reinvention. Ultimately, the project aims to contribute to reflections on how to articulate and express individual and collective identities, which find themselves under the undeniable pressure of globalization, transition and consumer processes, and to propose new understandings of how communities may reinvent their own future identities. Keywords:
15 Cox John K., Department of History, Philosophy, and Religious Studies at North Dakota State University, Fargo, USA
Hungarian Women and Their Literary Prose: Masculinity and History in Translated Fiction
This paper is a report on the first phase of a research project I have undertaken at the intersection of the disciplines of history and literature. The subject matter of this project is Hungarian women's literature (prose) in English translation. I am exploring this material for several reasons: to discuss representations of masculinity in the prose in order to answer the question "Do the works endorse an orthodox script or regime or ideal of masculinity?"; to try to shed light on the reasons for the numerically weak presence of translated women's writing in the male-dominated publishing industry; and, most especially, to explore, using a combination of historical and bibliographic analysis, the translated prose as a source of information and perspective for writing and teaching women's history. I do read Hungarian, but to keep the project of manageable size I wish, for now, to work primarily with English-language sources. Later, fuller comparative work could be carried out with Hungarian literary historians. The methodology for this first phase of the project involves these six steps, while steps number 4-6 will form the basis of my talk, if accepted for the conference in Skopje. Compiling a bibliography of relevant works published over the last 100-150 years: novels and short stories, but no poetry; in English (with French and German supplements). This list is likely, unfortunately, to be short. I have already begun consulting large reference works such as those by Livezeanu and Ferris, Hawkesworth, Wilson, and Kabdebo, as well as a number of specialized studies that might contain references to women writers in translation. Searches of the online catalogues of select library collections around the globe will follow. Categorizing the works by date of writing, time and place of setting, and themes Locating texts that could be recommended for use in undergraduate- and graduate-level teaching or in anthologies Assessing the historical insights of these works of Hungarian women's literature as a means of establishing themes, chronologies, and patterns for the creation of a framework or narrative for a general study of Hungarian women's history. Unearthing, to the extent possible, the factors that governed the publication of these translations (representations of masculinity, literary trends, current events, personal connections, marketing opportunities) Unearthing, to the extent possible, the factors that informed the reception of these translations (including but not limited to representations of masculinity, political considerations, etc. Keywords: Women's history, Hungary, Historiography, Novels in translation, Bibliographies uki Sanja, Union University, Faculty of Business and Industrial Management
Memory as means of identity formation in The Woman WarriorMemory as means of identity formation in The Woman Warrior
Abstract: Memory play very important part in The Woman Warrior and its connection with narration and language is one of the main topics in the novel. Memory is the means by which Kingston bridges the gap between the past and the present. At the same time, it gives the narrator an opportunity to find out about her ancestors history and reconstruct it. Kingston uses old myths, legends and stories from China told by her mother which she revises, creating new stories in English, showing that she sees culture as heterogeneous. At the same time, narration gives her the power to change the course of events and undermine history in order to translate the culture of her parents to herself. The act of remembering and reconstructing the events from the past helps the narrator not only to understand the lives of her parents and relatives in China, but also to find out who she really is and accept herself both as an American and Chinese American woman. The purpose of the paper is to show the significance of memories in The Woman Warrior and explore the ways Kingston uses Chinese myths told by her mother to revitalize her ancestors past in order to shape her own personality and find the answers to her identity. At the same time, the focus of the paper is going to be put on the power of memory to connect two different cultures, Chinese and American, and strengthen the bond between Kingston and her mother. Keywords: Maxine Hong Kingston, The Woman Warrior, memory, identity, immigration, narration Cukovic, Ana: American University of Paris
16 an understanding of the Yugoslavian transnational community and their collective practice of Yugonostalgia. Multiethnic dynamic of the Yugoslav Detroit Diaspora enables an effective study of Yugonostalgia implying certain characteristics which best aid in prediction of its future, collective, discourse. The field research reveals the answers concerning the survival of Yugonostalgia as a phenomenon and the survival of a memory of an inexistent nation for years to come. Keywords: performance studies; 1980s; imagined geographies; postmodern futures; affective archives Cvetkovska Ocokoljic Violeta; Cvetkovski Tatjana, Megatrend University, Belgrade, Serbia
Theatre as a place to deal with a family memory (on the example of two contemporary Czech performances)
The communist era is one of the most explored topics in Czech art and it is showed from different perspectives. Not a very common way is to present the past by studies on a family memory. However, two of the contemporary performances, share this perspective and show how social and political conditions created the identity of the family. I would like to analyze and compare them, because they use completely different means to talk about the history and the memory and, moreover, they are examples of memory and postmemory. The first, more traditional one which premiered in 2007, is based on a classical Czech drama (written by Milan Uhde) about the dilapidated house in which lives authoritarian father, Jewish mother, son dissident, second son collaborator and catatonic daughter. The performance shows them talking about harms they have caused each other in the past, but about which they cannot forget. Through grotesque and black humor theatre presents their attempt to find a solution and restore the family bonds torn by the ambiguities accumulated in the memory. Unlike the first, the second performance (premiered in 2012) is created by the artist (Veronika vbov) who was born at the end of communist era and it is based on her personal history. Through an alternative project she is trying to create a picture of her family using different means of preserving the memory: old photographs, letters, music listened with her grandmother, her own body, recipes handed down from generation to generation She is using new technologies to shorten the distance to her ancestors, to try to understand the family choices and to build her own identity. Keywords: family memory, postmemory, identity, Czech theatre, communism Davidovska Lidija, University of East Anglia, UK / University American College Skopje
Museums as Spaces of Representation of National Collective Memory. Case Study: How does one deal with the inheritance of the Communist Party Museum In Bucharest
Most of the countries in Eastern Europe that engaged in the reflective process of coming to terms with the communist past it became very popular that new forms of representation and building narratives on the recent communist past, such as: museums, monuments, memorials, start to emerge afresh. The focus of my presentation will be on how does one currently deal with the legacies of the communist regimes in eastern European countries with the purpose to emphasize on the use of museums as spaces where various interdependencies are performed, whereby I will focus on highlighting their role in the process of generating our sense of historical sense, shaping of the national identity and transmitting the memory of the past. Museums are not only a source of knowledge by preserving and displaying historical and artistic representations but also a space where identities and memories are being negotiated and transmitted. One needs to bear in mind also that the state often assumed the role of warrant, and profoundly influenced museums policies. Consequently, in my approach I will look at museums as subject to a constant process of politicisation, which engage in shaping and exposing historical memory and identity of nations, by intentional and often subjective acts of inclusion and omission of knowledge, of what deserves to be preserved, remembered and treasured. Bearing in mind Simina Badicas affirmation that museums which exhibited communism have existed all over in eastern Europe before 1989, the choice of the case study of the Romanian Communist Party Museum in Bucharest, is legitimised as being an important point of reference for the later developments (after 1989) of the museums which focus again on exhibiting communism. Therefore I will demonstrate that museums both during communism as in post---communist regimes claimed their role as important public institutions in education, while actually having served the same purpose, namely instrumentalising communism. Keywords:
Behind the Squares, Streets and Corners: A research into the places of memory of Porteos
In 1976 a military coup led by army general Jorge Videla took control of the Argentinean state apparatus. His aim was to crush the guerilla movements and to restore social order, and much of the Argentinean press and public gave their support. In the following years thousands of people from the (supposed) opposition disappeared. After this period of horror came a decade that was dominated by polticas de olvido (politics of forgetting). During the 90s the search for the past revived. Among other things it also materialized in the cityscape of Buenos Aires, re-signifying the stage for an eruption of memory; today Argentineans are constantly confronted with the past through papers, television, trials, stories, discourses and the public space. Streets, squares, corners and building carry a multitude of reminders. This paper addresses the meaning of these places of memory in the public space of Buenos Aires. What happens with memory and commemoration when the public space is filled with memorials, monuments, commemoration sites and buildings, streets and squares that remind people of the Dirty War? In other words, what are the effects of these aide memoires or tokens in the public space and how do people act, feel or think about these spaces of memory? By means of fieldwork, theoretical analysis and the collection of first hand stories, I aim to establish an image of this collective and individual memory shaped in the public space of Buenos Aires. In a society where the resent history is filled with violence and terror, commemoration is both a sensitive and a powerful subject that polarizes as well as unites. These different histories, memories and experiences of the public space conceptualize the Argentinian view on the past and shape the collective memory. Keywords: commemoration, collective memory, public space, Argentina, Buenos Aires, forgetting, aide memoires. Djordjevic Crnobrnja, Jadranka: The Ethnographic Institute of SASA
How theatres remember: culture of memory in institutionalized cultural system. Challenge or an obstacle to new leaderships?
The aim of research is to identify ways and modalities of preserving institutional memory in Belgrade theater system (within larger research investigating Organizational cultures and institutional memory: cultural system of the city of Belgrade). Having in mind complex historical context in which cultural institutions have been created and have developed over the years, transformations from royalist-capitalist to socialist system and then back to capitalist but republican system, the objective of the research is to identify types of strategies used for preserving the institutional memory in spite of public policies (sometimes explicitly policies of oblivion) and to investigate ways of transferring individual memories from privately kept memory to collective one, influencing organizational cultures and shaping theater identity. The research questions are: What are the organizational and programming strategies implemented in order to safeguard institutional identity and memory; what have been subversive or hidden strategies when official politics of memory was politics of oblivion? How institutions remember the dark sides of their history (accepted censorship and selfcensorship, rejection of creative dissident personalities, etc.)? How dissonant heritage is memorized (i.e. selfgoverning institutional past)? what is the role of leaders or managers in creating specific strategies and safeguarding memory; how the leadership style is influencing the process? How leaders deal with challenge which represents a need of audience of keeping the institutional identity and their need for creating a new artistic and esthetic identity according to their own artistic credo and poetics? The research sample will be comprised of key Belgrade city theater institutions created in different historical moments: National theater (1871), Yugoslav drama theater (1947), Belgrade drama theater (1950), Atelje 212 (1960), Zvezdara theater (1981), Bitef theater (1989) and 5 independent theater organizations, from New sensitivity (1984), to Dah Theater (1990), Rex and Center for Cultural Decontamination (1995) and Kult (2001). Keywords: Dragun, Dragica: Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Josip Juraj Strossmayer University in Osijek
20 Hungarian you greet Jo napot and you say Guten Tag to a German and its up to them, how they greet you back. You do your duty. This study aims to offer an insight into the culture of different ethnic groups based on Ioan Slavicis works. Keywords: culture, Germans, Hungarians, Serbs, cohabit Dudkov Jana, Institute of Theatre and Film Research, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava / Charels University, Prague
Cultural Memory in the Context of Representations of Central Europe: The Case of Slovak Cinema after 1989
The proposed paper is looking forward to analyse the representations of cultural memory of/and Central Europe in contemporary Slovak cinema. The context of the heart of Europe indicates a geopolitical region that lingers between multiple identities of the middle, the border, the crossroad, Europe, the not enough European, the postsocialist and the globalised world, and similar. The contribution will pay a special attention to the case study of Slovak cinema before and after the entrance of Slovakia to EU. It will also deal with possibilities of using terms designed in the context of postcolonial thinking about hybridity in order to reflect this truly (culturaly and historicaly) ambivalent, hybrid area that includes cinemas with a specific relation to transnational, transregional and transcultural aspects of identity. Keywords: Central Europe, cinematic representation, Slovak cinema, EU intergration processes, hybridity uri-Milovanovi Aleksandra; Kolakovi Aleksandra, Institute for Balkan Studies SASA
Competing Victimizations or Multidirectional Memories? Some notes on the Politics of Collective Memory in post-Nazi and post-colonial Left-wing Spaces
The proposed paper explores contentious entanglements of collective memory, memory politics and politics of location regarding the Holocaust and colonialism in Austrian inner-left debates. Due to the specific history and the resulting discursive opportunity structures in the Austrian post-Nazi and post-colonial national context, the conflicting political standpoints reflect the multi-directionality of memory as well as its reverse and competitive elements condensed in competitions of victimization. Such competitions are illustrated drawing on a special conflict within the Austrian radical Left. Concluding, multidirectional politics of location are discussed as tool to overcome competitive perspectives on collective memory and recognition. Since the 1990ies, struggles about anti-Semitic frames within Austrian left-wing criticism are part of radical movement politics - most prominently in controversies about the Middle East conflict. In the wake of 9/11 and the upswing of anti-Muslim resentment, controversies escalate and split parts of the Left in an antifascist, pro-Israeli camp and an anti-racist pro-Palestinian one. On the one hand, these camps argue about the dimensions of antiMuslim and anti-Semitic resentment and the debates could thus be seen as the subcultural answer to hegemonic migration discourses that construct aMuslim threatto Christian Western civilization. Quarrels also include debates about the grade of victimization caused by the Holocaust and Colonial genocides and culminate in debates about the horribleness and uniquenessof colonialism or the Shoah. In this context, debates also include the Israeli state that is supported as outcome of the annihilation of the European Jewry by the ones and contested as racist colonial state by the others. I analyse such clashing memories as logical competitions of victimizationin a post-Nazi and post-colonial society and propose a multidirectional perspective that discusses the legacies between colonial racism and anti-Semitism and allows for a synthesized approach to post-Holocaust and post-colonial memories. Such a perspective would analyze racism and anti-Semitism as interdependent but different power relations. In this respect, a theoretical starting point could be the critique voiced by women of colour and Black as well as Jewish feminists, directed against the exclusionary theory and practice of white German and Austrian women's movements and calling for a comprehensive reflection of political practice in the light of national (colonial and anti-Semitic) pasts as well as current power relations. Keywords: Multidirectional Memory, anti-Semitism, anti-Muslim Racism, Competitions of Victimization, Politics of Location Eglja-Kristsone, Eva: Institute of Literature, Folklore and Art, University of Latvia
21 culturally constructed minority. Beyond that, there is such a great heterogeneity among widows that there is no way of predicting the lifestyle, support systems, and identity of any one woman. As Helena Znaniecka Lopata (1925-2003), who had been the primary voice of widows and the leading researcher on the topic of widowhood throughout the world emphasized, widowhood becomes a pervasive identity rather than a specific social role and the problem is that there are oversimplified stereotypes that can influence personal perceptions. As shows my anthropological fieldwork among young (meaning young in an age) widows in Latvia there should be discussed such topics as everyday practices, trauma and personal narrative as well as widowhood as a part of collective and cultural memory being constructed through ancient social stereotypes and fiction, theatre, cinema, media. E.g., before a year a young Latvian choreographer produced a jazz dance performance Widows. The main idea was to create a harsh story about young women in 21th century being strong, independent, educated, exacting, self-rigorous, not willing to share their lives with weak and faithless male. Her idea was to speak about modern women as a black widow, the spider whose female eats male after coition. So if we ask a question: does this performance tells about real life of modern young widows or is it more symbolic use of the image of widow the answer is not so clear as a widow might transform in a black widow as well. If we look back at 19th and 20th century we may assume that the representation of the widow is indicative of the changing society and perception of women from the gender perspective. Keywords: young widow, cultural and social representation, individual and collective memory, constructed stereotype, Latvian society and culture Ermolin Denis S., Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera) Russian Academy of Sciences
Kosovo Urban Cemeteries in Maps: Forgetting, Remembering and Constructing New Reality
In the focus of my paper I put the analysis of cemeteries and their representation in city maps of Pristina and Prizren published mostly in the 1990-2010s. A map as a means of getting information may be regarded as an almost perfect source for studying of the so-called constructed reality (P. Berger & Th. Luckmann). First, I use the concept of social memory in its connection with spatial dominants, i.e. sites of memory, which are by all means the necessary elements of any area. Moreover, cemeteries are one of the most evident and manifest categories of traces that show and witness more or less prolonged human presence in a particular place. Second, Ill turn my attention to the comparative analysis of the representation of cemeteries in city maps, i.e. in the sources that are aimed at creating the image or replica of the area. Hereby I regard a map as the object that both depicts (represents, reflects) the reality and at the same time makes it (J.B. Harley, J. Pickles, D. Wood). Third, according to olovi, a memory site is an example and a part of the so-called sacred space of the nation (compare to Smiths ethnoscape). Thus, the way of representation and even names of cemeteries may change drastically in different maps, as the attitudes towards these sites depend on current national agendas and ideas. My paper discusses the representation of these sites of memory in city maps as the means of constructing new reality when cemeteries disappear from them or change their habitual names, we are forced to forget their previous names or even the fact of their existence; on the contrary the appearance of new cemeteries in the maps makes us remember not only their presence, but also people (or even communities, e.g. religious, ethnic) buried there. Keywords: Kosovo, urban cemeteries, city maps, memory, landscape Fldvri, Sndor, Debrecen Univ. Baltic Studies
Interactions between the Serbian Elite in the 18th Century Hungarian Kingdom and the West Ukrainian Cultural Centres
It is a false commonplace the ideas of enlightenment and national awakening in the 18th century came to the Slavic peoples of the Habsburg Empire only as result of the impacts on the cultural life made by the thinkers, artists and scientists in Vienna, whose activities were inspired and provided by the royal court, too. This statement is only partly true but not wholly. Though the West European cultural influences also political ideas came through Vienna (e.g. Dositej Obradovi, Jernej Kopitar), this was one of the ways of transmission but not the only one. The role and importance of the contacts between the various Slavic peoples in the Habsburg Empire are not able to be studied in the shadows of the overvaluation was given to the impacts of Vienna. Especially are of great importance the researches made by the Institute of Ukrainian Studies named Krypiakevich in Lviv in the last two decades, mainly the findings of later chair Isaievich, Iaroslav Dmitrovich, member of the Academy of Sciences. His investigations lead to new results in the history of the typographies and book-trade as the belles-lettres as well, therefore it became necessary to rethink the contacts between the Western territories of the recent Ukraine (i.e. then parts of Polish Kingdom) and the Slavic peoples of the Hungarian Kingdom, even their brothers on the Balkans. Moreover, investigations made by the author of this paper on the old printed liturgical books of the Byzantine rite, being held in various Church libraries in Hungary, gave enough matter to came to the conclusion that the book-trade was an important factor in the transmission of those impacts of early enlightenment which came from Poland across Ukraine to the Serbs living in Hungary and on the Balkans, too. Mita Kosti has already paid attention to the book trade but this very significant work of him remained forgotten in spite of the very respect was given to the findings of this great Serbian historian. The Russian Orthodox impacts on The Serb and interfering into the affairs on the Balkans became stronger later, after the turn of the 18/19 cc, and in results of more political than religious causes. Although it was being highlighted that Russia provided the Orthodox Serbs, it was of more political rhetoric than real activity. Russia provided those Serbs were oppressed by the Greek Phanariots i.e. Orthodox ones. It was not taken into consideration the the Serbian Church suffered and was almost destroyed by the Greek Orthodox Clergy. The latter replaced the Serbian language with the Greek in the service, the education and the administration, since the Church leaders represented The Christian toward the Ottoman Porta. Consequently, the aim of this
22 paper is to demonstrate the contacts between the Serbs and Ukrainian territories, as it has been evidenced by the book-trade between these peoples and areas, and to give some new insides into the church and national relations on the Balkans. Keywords: Serbs, Ukrainians, Habsburg_Empire, Hungarian_Kingdom, book_trade, Balkans Franc Renata; Mijic Ivana; Medugorac Vanja, Ivo Pilar Institute of Social Sciences
Perceived importance of recent historical events for national history among Croatian youth
Previous studies using open ended methodology resulted with formulation of three general characteristics of social representations of world history: (a) salience of politics and war; (b) existence of recency effect (c) salience of Eurocentrism, followed by nationlevel ethnocentrism (Liu et al., 2009; Liu et al. 2005). The aim of this paper is to examine the robustness of these general characteristics by using closed-ended survey methodology. The paper will present preliminary findings at a national level (collected in the frame of large European project MY PLACE, funded by the EC FP7, (http://www.fp7-myplace.eu/index.php) about perceived importance of recent historical events for national history among Croatian youth. Survey data were collected from a random sample of young people aged between 16 and 25 (on two areas of the city of Zagreb, N=1200). Participants assessed the perceived importance of the 11 recent historical events: WWI, WWII, Cold War, Fall of the Berlin Wall and the end of socialist regimes, Fascism; Communism, The NY terrorist attacks on September 11th 2001; and three national events: Signature of the Accession Treaty of Croatia (Brussels, 09.11. 2011), Croatian Homeland war (1991-1995) and Independent State of Croatia (1941-43 during the WWII). This close-ended data will be complemented by data from semi-structured interviews with subsample of surveys participants (N=60) about most interesting and/or important parts of Croatian past. Results showed that surveyed Croatian youth, as relatively most important events for country history perceive national and most recent events; Homeland War (1991-1995) followed by Signature of The Treaty of Accession 2011 and Independent State of Croatia (19941-43 during the WWII). Results are interpreted within a framework of general characteristics of the representation of world history, taking into account differences between this and previous studies, as well as, Croatian context (former Communist country, recent establishment of independence and sovereignty). Keywords: social representations of history, national history, youth, survey, MyPlace project Franzinetti Guido, Department of Law, Political, Economic and Social Sciences, University of Eastern Piedmont, Alessandria, Italy
23 Friganovi Sain, Zrinka, American College of Management and Technology, Dubrovnik, Croatia
Mediated Cultural Memories: Film Narratives of Mass Violence in Indonesia and Kosovo
Acts of mass violence, including murder on civilians, genocide, and wars, can be seen as seeds for memories of the involved persons and following generations. Acts of mass violence also construct a sort of looking glass of culturally dominant memories that are mediated through stories: retold as oral stories through generations, as myths or sagas, or remediated in contemporary documentary or fiction films. In these processes of retelling acts of violence, there are transformations of meanings across time, media, cultural, social and political contexts which influence audience reception. This paper explores two examples of narratives representing memories of acts of mass violence: Gzim Rewind (Sweden, 2011, director Knutte Wester) about 1990s Kosovo, and The Act of Killing (Denmark, 2012, director Joshua Oppenheimer) about 1960s Indonesia. The two films, in very different ways, focus on persons who tell about their involvement in acts of mass violence. Both films are told as "a film within a film" and experiment with documentary as genre. The films also convey personal relationships between the persons who recall violence and the filmmaker-storytellers, based in Scandinavia. In this paper, the two film projects and audiences are analyzed from perspectives of semiosis (meaning-making) in relation to the films as redefining genres and what sorts of meanings different audiences create about the films. Keywords: biographical memory; historical narratives; the politics of cultural memory; propaganda, popular media culture, social constructionism, dialogic theory; film Gajin Igor: The Academy of Art in Osijek
The (ir)racional in the locomotion of filmography, theater, music scene and pop culture as the creation of the ''new Croatian cultural memory''
The event of Croatia gaining autonomy at the beginning of the 90s had started a partially systematic, and partially spontaneous replacement of the contemptible socialist myths with the Croatian national myths. How has that phenomenon been reflected in the theater stages and on cinema screens? The hero of ''contemporary history of Croatian theater'' was - history itself. However, such plays starring history as the hero resulted in pap. The filmography, on the other hand, had decided on the propaganda as the means for sharing the ''national truths'', which had resulted in the audience's repulsion towards it. The repulsion was due to the fact that it was evidently a propaganda. It provoked the audience's ridicule because of its idealized imagery of the ''imaginary Croatia'' and the ''imaginary Croats'', that did not correspond with reality. On the music scene reconcilliation ''front'' there had been even more interesting and uncontrollable phenomena. This work focuses on the hitmaker Toni Hulji who managed to ''repack'' the ''Eastern tunes'' that the Croats were missing, thus proving that the lifestyle and culture born from the suddenly unwanted myths are not so easily eradicated. Another focal point of this work lies on the controversial Thompson, an icon of the Croatian nationalism soundtrack and the landmark of the (in)excusable within the public discourse. He gained his status due to having used his public appearances and hits in order to outlet and kindle (il)legitimate feelings towards the ''dark side'' of the Croatian state-constituing history, i. e. towards the Independent State of Croatia, a notorious partner of the Nazi Germany. The (quasi)- outbursts of a pop- star have, intriguingly enough, at the same time served the purpose of mediation and the liberating manifestation of a supressed, unwanted and forbidden ''cultural memory'', as well as the ''regime'' detection and ''new upbringing'' of the masses in relation to the sought political, historical and civilization standards formed according to the criteria of the European Union. Keywords: ideological strategies, propaganda, nationalism, (in)excusable, cultural fronts
Staged memories: Spanish drama, Andalusian identity and flamenco music in Argentina (1930s1950s)
Culture, particularly drama and music, exerted a key role in order to keep and reinforce the identity of Spanish migrants in Argentina during the first part of the 20th century. From decades ago, that country had received thousands of migrants from Spain, and by the period following the Spanish Civil War (1936-1939) a notable colony of them was settled in Buenos Aires. At the same time, several artists arrived to this city escaping the war, political repression or, simply, looking for new work opportunities. For instance, famous singers and actors as Miguel de Molina, Angelillo, or Nio de Utrera, achieved overwhelming successes in Buenos Aires theatres. Even more, they created a parallel Spanish stardom abroad. Hence, this proposal summarizes the contribution of some of these artists and the fusion between theatre and typical Andalusian music as flamenco to preserve and evoke the collective memory of such a faraway motherland. Since Andalusia (the Southern region of Spain) and its culture acted as a metonymic resource to represent Spain during that period, migrants from different regions could recognize a common notion of the Spanish identity in them. In this sense, home could be staged, remembered, fictionalized and, obviously, idealized. Keywords: Spanish migrations, theatre and memory, flamenco music, Buenos Aires, Andalusia. Genkal, Berkant: Anadolu University
The present actualities and future priorities of Pomak Culture Dernek in Turkey
The recent debates on the Pomak issue that are concerned with the authoritarian propaganda and diaspora place the past into deep murky waters, and as Said says, that it is not only about the disagreement about what happened in the past and what the past was, but uncertainty about whether the past is really past, over and concluded, or whether it continues, albeit in different forms. Established in 2009 in Alpu, Eskiehir Province, Pomak Culture Dernek (Association) became one of the most important institutional establishments that began to function as cultural dernek in Turkey trying to gather Izmir, Istanbul, Trace and Biga derneks under one federation entitled as PODEF. On the way of gathering into a federation Pomaks created a solid ground to preserve and to expose their culture. The founders of this Non-Governmental Organization, Mehmet Demir and Nazan Nazire ztrk clearly state on the notion of the dernek, that is, to come together, to remember the songs of grandmothers and grandfathers and to be recognized by the legislative authorities. But the constitution of Turkey, which was adopted in 1982 after military coup, and amended in 1995 does not deal with the term Pomak. In the future priorities of the dernek, language seems to have vital importance creating identity which will be born out from many narrative products. These narrative products such as songs, ballads, poems, epics, and tails were gathered during the fieldwork research done in villages of an, Biga provinces and Alpu between 2011 and 2012. In fine, interpreting the present, dernek appears to be an organization that encompasses the vast majority of the Pomak population in Turkey. As a scholar, scientific research on narratives will lighten up the way on which dernek members are believed to take into account. Keywords: Pomak, dernek, identity, collective memory, language Georgescu Elena Anca, Valahia University of Targoviste
25 means the opposite of creativity but the actual vehicle of creative activity and its understanding as a stable cultural system engraved in collective memory needs to be challenged. The tradition of egg decoration in Romania is a living and evolving social practice that engages the self and community in a creative exercise of building a cultural identity and (re)constructing the connection to a shared past. Illustrations are offered here of the ways in which cultural memory has a productive function in relation to the life of individuals and collectives and, at the same time, creativity is part and parcel of this phenomenon. This invites us to discover new theoretical and practical devices that are sensitive to both stability and change within cultural systems. Keywords: Gligorova, Bela, CCCS
When Theory Fails: Between Language and Memorialization, or (How) do contemporary Macedonians talk about the Jewish genocide?
The language of the Holocaust has been based on absences rather than a presence. More than half a century after the reality of the Nazi genocide, Holocaust historian Berel Lang informs us that no adequate decision has yet been reached regarding the issue of linguistic inscription for the people who were incarcerated through the Nazi concentration camp system, and almost terminated as a result of its devastating tactics. Thus, the inaptitude of our post-Holocaust language, to address the (plain) facts of Holocaust life, suggests that the events surrounding the Jewish genocide are somehow out-of-the-ordinary, never before witnessed by the diligent eyes of human history, thus proving to be out of languages reach. Accordingly, when talking about, writing of, re-membering this incongruous event, people, artists, survivors are compelled to seek the help of recollected patches of self-memory; these liminal clusters of present-day past re-memberances, where absence and presence take turns, where the historical self undergoes a painfully unavoidable self-invention, offer a way to begin to understand the post-Holocaust life while beginning to comprehend the fragmented semblance of the survivors narratives. In my attempt to read the current discourse which contemporary Macedonian society seems to have accepted if/when addressing The Shoah, I propose that we examine the following set of challenging questions in regards to the (re)presentation of the Nazi genocide; namely, How do we talk about testimonial narratives, like Tadeusz Borowskis photo-texts or Primo Levis non-fictional prose, if we, ourselves, have not lived through the experiences they recollect? Furthermore, how does a contemporary Macedonian artist (re)present the painful reality of Holocaust pre- and post-mortem survived life if he or she has heard it second-hand? And, how do we then comment on these historically and spatially detached (re)presentations of survivors testimonies? Do we read the artfully recollected accounts verbatim, assuming that they stand in for the missing links of Nazi era history, or do we treat them as we would treat other works of novelistic fiction loosely based on auto/biographical material? But again, what do we mean when we call someone or something truthful, how are our memories shaped, what do we leave out and what do we put in as a result of our exposure to the medias coverage of historical events? Keywords: Gnjatovi Milena, Centre for Museology and Heritology, Faculty of Philosophy, University of Belgrade, Serbia
Cultural Memory and Identity: Pictorial Memory Manners of the Individual Identity Construction
The title of this study directly refers to the importance of the images, meaning material objects, personal memories or literal images photographs one elects from the past in order to build up the individual identity and present it to others. Long ago, during the antique age, techniques of the remembrance by using pictorial memory had been created, and those just developed during centuries. The goal of this paper is to stress that, basic concepts of the self representation did not change, but just used different media through time. In the first part of the paper, the difference between terms memory and remembrance, their relation to the culture and reasons why one remembers something will be discussed. As it is tended to be shown, the remembrance is always pictorial, one always puts elected images of the past in the exact order and creates its own identity. Therefore, in the second part of this study, the idea of individual identity, creation of it and the representation of the self identity to the others will be examined and explained in the context of the pictorial memory and heritage on the one hand, and social determination on the other. Inspired by the wholes one leaves in its personal life story when presenting it to others, the need of forgetting as constituent part of memory will also be stressed. Finally, the last part of this study points out that we still use the same concepts of remembering, electing and presenting images from the past in the creation of the image of ourselves, using the most popular media today - virtual space. Keywords: individual identity, remembrance, memory, pictorial memory, image, heritage Golaska, Dorota: University of Lodz, Faculty of International and Political Studies
26 possible to grasp and express the traumatic experience in language, yet it is possible to activate it in an affective manner, also by making use of interactive formats. Interestingly, the idea of turning the sites of Holocaust remembrance into more interactive spaces has long been considered controversial. Criticisms of these processes mostly referred to the fact that it aims at turning the Holocaust memorials into tourist attractions, which are mostly commercially oriented. Therefore, these sites are often considered dark tourism attractions. Although the analysis and subsequent categorization of dark tourists experiences (including both traumatic and pleasurable ones) is still undeveloped, the such classification of the Holocaust sites bears explicitly pejorative connotation. It is thus crucial to disengage the Holocaust remembrance sites from negative associations, yet, at the same time, it is also of primary significance to understand contemporary tourist patterns and different kinds of pleasures associated therewith. The knowledge within the fieldI believecan be substantially broadened if we pay more attention to the concept of perception, understood in both bodily and mental terms. The concepts of aesthetic experience and pure perception adopted within my research project no longer rely on the dualistic opposition between sensation and thought. This theoretical perspective I am going to explore in my presentation. Keywords: affect, memorials, dark tourism, aesthetic experience, perception Handberg, Kristian: University of Copenhagen, Departments of Arts and Cultural Studies, Denmark
Coherent with what? A critical analysis of the relation between sense of coherence, integration and identity in a health context
The Sami are the indigenous of Northern Scandinavia and one out of five acknowledged national minorities in Sweden. The process of acculturation and the associated concepts of integration, assimilation, marginalization and separation have often been referred to when describing the health of indigenous people, of which integration has been considered to provide the better conditions for good health. A fairly reliable indicator of health is also the concept of sense of coherence (SOC), introduced as a tool for measuring coping abilities, suggesting that sense of coherence is positively associated with the degree of integration. Acculturation and thus integration also suggest different degrees of modifications of cultural memory which then give rise to the question of how health and SOC relates to cultural memory. The aim of this study is to seek a better understanding of the unresolved relation between the experience of integration, self-perceived identity, cultural memory and SOC. By triangulation analysis the study is expected to elucidate a possible mediating role of SOC between the identification with the Sami society and aspects of self-perceived integration which in turn will hint the positioning of cultural memory towards these concepts. The study will be based on a quantitative questionnaire on self-perceived integration and identity, SOC and value systems distributed among Sami eligible to vote in the Sami parliament. An open, text based question on the experience of integration is also included in the questionnaire and will constitute the point of departure for the qualitative part of the analysis. The study is expected to generate a foundation of conclusive arguments from which a discussion of the role and power of self-perceived identity in relation to the perception of integration and cultural memory could be based. This discussion will be presented at the conference on Cultural Memory in September Keywords: Sami, integration, identity, 'sense of coherence' (SOC), ackulturation Hebda, Anna: University of Social Sciences and Humanities, Warsaw, Poland
27 meet each other and merge continuously this meetings, learned and experienced from different sources, describe and represent the culture (city and its history, citizens, values and social relationships). In Poland the practice of eating out does not have long tradition and was strongly reduced during communism times. What is more, Warsaw is a city almost totally reconstructed after the 2nd world war and you can experience the history every step you take. In the same time it is the European capital fast, modern and multicultural. Eating places like restaurants and bars appear to reflect this two ways of thinking about this city on the one hand, it can be observed a significant growth of places offering traditional polish cuisine (with typical Warsaw specialties), and on the other hand, it may be pointed at popularity of places specialized in foreign cuisine (mostly Italian, Japanese, Arabian, Chinese/Vietnamese). In my paper I would like to present, how people living in Warsaw create the past, tradition and cultural memories through eating out practices. And how the tradition is created by restaurants owners too. Last year I conducted a qualitative and quantitative research to explore cultural and social roles of eating out and to analyze behaviour of people living in Warsaw in terms of gastronomy. During the conference I would like to share the research results and analysis. Keywords: culinary culture, social practices, everyday life, re-building memories, creating past Hebert, Emmanuelle: College of Europe, European General Studies; Brugge, Belgium
Cultural Memory as a Basis for Political Tensions: the Polish Case regarding Germany and Russia
Historically, culture has played a big role in Polish politics. Indeed, when Poland was partitioned and dominated by its neighbouring empires, the Polish nation benefited from a rather strong political and cultural unity. It is true that in the late 19th century Polish nationalism was divided. Nowadays, since 1989 and particularly the 2000s, Poland is characterized by a deep political conflict on memory and how to deal with it in the present. This can be seen in the politics towards Russia, Germany or foreign policy in general. An interesting question would be to ask how and why are Polish politicians and citizens divided today on the issue of dealing with their past and memory regarding Germany and more particularly Russia. A first answer to this question would be that Poles are politically and culturally deeply divided on the way to deal with their past, as the perception of these two countries is part of their identity. In order to lead this research, a construtivist framework would be used, so that the environment, cognitive dimension and the context could be taken into account. Some elements of sociology of public policy could be added to the analysis as well. The methodology would consist in analysing Polish newspapers and reviews such as Gazeta Wyborcza, Polityka or Wprost, which are the most circulated sources of informatio in the country. The study would also be done through an analysis of speeches, from the Prime Minister, the President, the Minister of Foreign Affairs or other politicians (e.g. Jaroslaw Kaczynski, head of the main opposition party in Poland and twin brother of the late President Lech Kaczynski). Keywords: Memory, Politics, Culture, Identity, Poland Hlavov Anna A., Slovak Academy of Sciences, Institute of Theatre and Film Studies
28 interrogative dialogues with the past, earlier cultures, earlier modes of thinking? My paper will touch upon the pre-enlightenment conception of nature, in order to examine inherent ideas in traditional, pre-industrial societies, that can be turned into cultural memory in support of sustainable development, by means of Bakhtinian dialogue and chronotope as well as ecosemiotic principles of deep-ecology (Kalevi Kull). This will be done by four brief and experimental analyses of: The medieval Saga of Grettir the Strong. The works of self-educated, Icelandic writer, poet, historian and sorcerer Jn the Learned. The rotten back-side of the heroic narrative of the herring-town Siglufjrur's prosperity and entry into modernity. The poetry of the Estonian poet Kristiina Ehin. Keywords: Hromadzic, Hajrudin: Department of Cultural Studies, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Rijeka
Media Coverage of Higher Education Reform in Croatia: The Case Study of Morning Paper (Jutarnji list)
The paper explores relationships between political and economic policies and the role of the media in promoting neoliberal ideology in a post-socialist transition context, and its social implications. We follow the argument that the media represent a field of constant struggle for hegemonic domination. It is a complex meeting point of economic, political and social class determinants in which particular (mainstream) media are used in order to serve the financial, commercial, ideological, and other interests of social elites. In doing so, the media are powerful actors in the promotion of certain ideological lines, and useful tools in the politics of denunciation and exclusion of those social actors and trends that represent some form of opposition - that practically disturb the promotion of the earlier mentioned hegemonic politics, and actively oppose them. The research focuses on the analysis of the daily newspaper Morning Paper (Jutarnji list) published by the media corporation Europe Press Holding (EPH) in Croatia, and its role in the above mentioned processes. This media corporation and its newspapers were established to serve as effective tools in the promotion of the supposedly unquestionable historical inevitability of neoliberal reforms in the transition period. At the same time, EPH media constantly defame social actors who actively oppose the mentioned economical, political, and social trends, regardless of their social position: they can be class-socially de-favored workers, farmers, health care workers, students, members of the academic community or civil-society activists - all those social actors who are fighting to defend the public good or values in various ways. More specifically, the research will explore the coverage of Morning Paper regarding the higher education reform in Croatia known as the Bologna process, characterized by a process of commercialization (among other aspects) which is a part of more general trends in which public wealth is privatized. I am interested in research of Morning Paper contribution to the construction of a historical narrative of Croatia's transition from socialism, and thus emphasize the inevitability of the neoliberal system which includes the reform of the educational system. The focus of the analysis will be placed on the period from 2009-2010, during the students blockade of Croatian universities. The paper will present the preliminary results of research that is a part of a larger project. Keywords: media, neoliberalism, political economy, Daily Morning (Jutarnji list), higher education Iikli, Hasan: University of Ghent
29 which provides the baseline of local culture and apparently, the localization and orientation of indigenous ones in their environment. A remark on awareness and consciousness about citizenship can be revealed as an additional element. Keywords: Ivanova, Dimana
Memory Construction and Practice. The Creating and the Use of Cultural Memory in ClujNapoca (Romania)
This paper focuses on the social usage of memory and seeks to explore the multiple roles and functions that the figures and representations of (cultural) memory have played and continue to play in representing, mediating and manipulating collective
30 memory, culture and politics within the multiethnic (Romanian majority Hungarian minority) context. Transylvania, annexed to Romania in 1920, is a place of continuous RomanianHungarian conflicts. There is always a domain of conflict between the Hungarian minority and the Romanian majority represented by the construction, the invention and commemorative use of the past. In my ethnographic and socioanthropologic analysis I focus on the place-making, memorial monuments and objects, the institutionalized uses of cultural memory and the interethnic relations and symbolic behaviors that stay behind it in contemporary Cluj-Napoca. The system change of 1989 brought along not only a political fracture, but also one in the imagined past. On the social level resulted in the drama of diminuation of belief in the institutions and authorities. The past constructed up to that point naturally lost its political legitimacy. The period of time after 1989 proved to be one of the most productive regarding local construction of memory; show how great social and political changes reshape attitudes to the past, and reveal differences between the old system and the new. Reinterpretation of the public sphere and the space, its resettlement with past events is a permanent endeavor for dominant groups, and of those in formation. I would like to analyze more deeply the tendencies of past construction, the contested memories and contributes to identitary settings. What previously exposed component of the past was made invisible by the new system? What conflicts were revealed, what kind of identity strategies, legitimating processes and national discourses were put into motion by the construction of (new) memory? Keywords: creating cultural memory ("spatialization"), contested memories, social usage of memory, symbolic behaviors, political legitimacy Jess Gmez de Tejada, Universidad de Sevilla (Spain)
Lives of Juan Abreu, Lorenzo Garca Vega and Octavio Armand: Cuban Transnational Autobiographies
This paper will offer a comprehensive analysis of contemporary Cuban autobiographical writing by examining three autobiographies written by Cuban intellectuals belonging to different generations. This global perspective is based on the idea of Cuba as a transnational space characterized by the regular ideological, cultural and economic exchange between the island and the different Diasporic groups (Damin Fernndez 2005). In this context, the nets that emerge from the different politics of memory, transcending the traditional opposition between Revolution and Counter-Revolution, acquire special relevance. The active role that, according to Aleida Assmann (2012), memory plays in the processes of transition from dictatorship to democracy contributes to the presentation of these autobiographies as loci for the reconstruction of the Cuban Revolution and its consequences. Juan Abreus A la sombra del mar: jornadas cubanas con Reynaldo Arenas (1998), Lorenzo Garca Vegas El oficio de perder (200) and Octavio Armands El ocho cubano (2012) have been written from a variety of locations, personal circumstances, ideological positions and conceptions of the genre. These accounts, published between 1998 and 2012, are an essential part of the literary corpus of autobiographical writing produced since the beginning of the Cuban Revolution, a corpus which has been substantially increased since the late 1990s. This paper will analyze the different ways these authors articulate the threads of Cuban memory by focusing on the ideological stance revealed in their works and how these are expressed through recognizable styles, themes, symbols, images of the self and of the other, and the attitudes adopted towards the reader. Keywords: Cuban literature, Cuban autobiographies, Transnationalism, Lorenzo Garca Vega, Juan Abreu, Octavio Armand Jekov Tereza, Charles University in Prague
When did the Revolution End? Memories of Transition in the Aftermath of the Portuguese Carnation Revolution
On the 25th of April 1974 it took place in Portugal what was to be known as the Carnation Revolution, led by the military the Portuguese Armed Forces - that put a stop to one of the longest dictatorship in Europe. Then, for 19 months, Portugal would live a period called PREC or Revolutionary Process Under Way. People took the power in the streets, the factories were taken by
31 the workers, landowners were expropriated, the lands occupied by people who reclaimed the right to work, the newspapers were taken by the typographers, there were strikes almost every day, manifestos were issued almost daily, politics was everywhere in every conversation, where before there had been but silence. This revolution down the road as many non-Portuguese put it attracted all sorts of people: journalists, photographers, political activists, film makers, workers, who came running to experience live a true revolution happening in front of their eyes. D. L. Raby writes to the effect: For 19 months this small and impoverished nation on the western fringe of the continent was to experience a genuine revolutionary process such has not been seen in Western Europe for generations. (D. L. Raby, Democracy and Revolution Latin America and Socialism Today, London: Pluto Press, p.213) On the 25th of November 1975 a coup staged by a moderate faction within the Armed Forces put a stop to this Revolutionary Process and Portugal got back into the track again. The 25th of November is still today an obscure episode of Portuguese history, some saying it saved the nation from a communist dictatorship, others saying that it betrayed the ideals of the revolution and ended it. Where some say true democracy started with the 25th of November, others say this date was actually the death of all possible political freedom. So, when did the revolution end? What revolution is this we are talking about? Is it one revolution or more? These discrepancies are today gaining momentum as ways of remembering these events are constantly being transformed with each new government and according to its ideology. This paper and performance lecture aims at looking at these narratives of transition, using testimonies from several people engaged in both revolutions to highlight the conflicting memories pertaining one of the most important and crucial moments of Portuguese history. I will also be using and analysing important films and documentaries made during this process, namely Scenes from the Class Struggles in Portugal, by Robert Kramer and Phillip Spinelli (1976), and Torrebela, by Thomas Harlan (1975/76), as well as the documentary Another Country by Sergio Treffaut (1999), that documents the foreign film production during this period. Keywords: Memories of Transition, Political Memory, Testimonies, Revolution, Counter-Revolution, Post-Memory, Revisionism, Struggles for Memory Jesalu, Kirsti: University of Tartu, Department of Ethnology, Center of Excellence in Cultural Theory, Estonia
"Madach, the comments" - from individual to collective memory, in a function of the construction of dynamic multi-cultural identity of Subotica
In 1985. Subotica National Theatre Nepsznhz - KPGT inaugurated the project "City Theatre", with the play "Madach, the comments", which is based on the epic drama "The human tragedy" (Az ember Tragedy, 1861.), written by Hungarian writer Imre Madach, and directed by Ljubisa Ristic, which had a stronghold in the concept of a "Unique Yugoslav cultural space". This project has had a great support of local authorities, in the beginning. Since Ljubisa Ristic incorporated personal "international" concept in directing "The human tragedy", his idea grew into a collective socially, ie. public memory. Believing that the theater is a relevant element in a process of identification, the subject of this research is a dynamic multi-cultural identity of Subotica, which is based on a relationship among "Madach, the comments" and the urban experience of the city, as a paradigmatic model of cultural pluralism. The play is seen as a socio-cultural phenomenon that reflects the supranational idea of its author. The aim of the research is descriptive reconstruction of play "Madach, the comments, " as the paradigmatic case of transformation from an individual to collective memory, in a function of the construction of dynamic multi-cultural identity of Subotica, as an inherent component of poli-identity (Yugoslav and European). This study analyzes multi-ethnicity, multi-confessionality and multi-linguality of the play, as the base of identification, which are the main principles of the concept of a "Unicue Yugoslav culture space", established by KPGT. We also examine the role of the stage space, in a function of memory space, as a symbol of urban identity. The participants in the process of identification are the artists, the audience, the media and representatives of the local authorities. The research aims to highlight how theatrical performance can display a value system that is crucial to the existence of multi-cultural communities (Subotica, Yugoslavia, Europe). Keywords: identity, memory, multi-ethnic, multi-confessional, multi-lingual, National Theatre, Nepsznhz KPGT, multiculturalism, cultural diversity, Subotica, place of memory
32 Kaaristo Maarja, Department of Ethnology, Institute of Cultural Research and Fine Arts
Mass popularization of the mediterranean topos and places of memory through the media genres video advertisement and reportage
The article analyzes the ways according to which the popular Mediterranean narrative is created within the media genres - video advertisement and TV reportage paying special attention on the selling and promotional aims. The interest moves toward giving possible answers of the question how much these practices of mass representation contribute for simulating the topos (in simulacra and simulation sense) and what is their impact when it is imagined. For this goal, we intent to interpret the popular
33 representative forms which are mostly articulated through the concepts of consumerism. At this point, the places (figures) of memory are taken into consideration as their function is being objects of market interest. The text interprets the stereotypical image of the Mediterranean through which it is performed as a place of adventure, elitism, hedonism, escapism trying to give enough arguments which will show the different (deconstructed) image of this topos. Keywords: Karapejovski Boban, CCCS
Karl Marx in the Cultural Memory of the Macedonians and the Nations of the so called Eastern Block - Reception and Perception
The severe economic crisis raised the question: Was Marx right? Or, as Terry Eagleton writes: WHY Marx was right. A reactualization of his ideas, his philosophy or his diagnosis and cures, as well as his economic and social studies, has recently become attractive once again. The acceptance and reactualization of Marx these days, especially in the Western countries, could bring us/open alternative ways of practicing politics, policy making and activism (take, for example, the Occupy Wall Street movement); or non-acceptance of Marx and a further global crisis could lead to a rebirth of the extreme right. Are Marx's ideas a philosophy, a view of the world or a practical "know-how"? "Marx was right about self-destruction of capitalism", says Nouriel Roubini. Does he inspire and will be inspiring new tendencies and ways of (more or less) global activism and are his ideas a phenomenon that will redefine global politics and society? Are Marx's ideas truly part of cultural memory in the so called Eastern block or were they perverted by the past system(s), which was/were using this philosophy for re-creation of its own bourgeoisie. What is todays /nowadays reception and perception of Marx in these countries and how do people react to the possibility of their memory becoming their present tomorrow!? Keywords: Kartal, Aylin, Istanbul based researcher
Working with the Memory of Place: The Curatorial Case of Gnl Nuholu Exhibition at the Castle of Trezzo
In this paper, I will focus on the contemporary artist Gnl Nuholu`s upcoming solo exhibition curated by myself at the Castle of Trezzo in Trezzo sulAdda Italy, in October 2013 and try to make meaningful quotations to unfold a larger framework of the social and political contexts of her work. Nuholu, has always been attracted to the special features of the exhibition space. Following her interest she produced space-related works throughout her career. This time the exhibition at the castle of Trezzo borrows its theme from the memory of the castle. The castle dates back to 1158 AC and has been used for different purposes over the years including, drawing the borderline of the natural border of Milanese area towards east, defensing, hosting the illustrious parties of the Barnabo reign, prisoning the enemy soldiers, hiding and sheltering for partisan detachment in the Second World War, etc. Nowadays it has been using for art exhibitions and festivals. At the outset I centered my thoughts for this exhibition on Nuholus interests and the idea of the remembering the past memories of the exhibition space. It was my desire to understand how the people had engaged with the specifities of this building in the past. A number of key ideas emerged from this idea regarding the conceptions of place and boundaries. Finally the artist and I found ourselves inspired by the memories of this place and decided to take them as our point of beginning for this exhibition. In this context a number of works and installations which revolve around memory, identity, borders and mapping are currently being created by the artist. Key Words: contemporary art in Turkey, curatorial studies, memory, identity, border/boundary Katarina Aladrovi Slovaek, The Faculty of Teacher Education of the University of Zagreb
34 Katharina von Kellenbach, Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies, Saint Mary's College of Maryland
An Irishman in Yugoslavia: Hubert Butler and Cultural Memory in Ireland and the Balkans
Hubert Butler (1900-1991) was an Irish historian and essayist whose work is notable for its European and specifically Balkan themes. Born into an aristocratic family in Kilkenny, southern Ireland, Butler was educated at Oxford before travelling widely in Russia and eastern Europe in the 1920s and 1930s. Describing himself as an Ascendency Nationalist, Butlers essays draw far-reaching parallels between the break-up of empire in the Balkans with post-independence Ireland where ethnic and religious divisions continue to haunt the Irish Republic. Always privileging the local against the global, Butler championed a civic nationalism against the violent racialism which he saw overtaking Europe in the 1930s. However, his exposure of Catholic complicity in the wartime genocide in Croatia in such essays as The Artukovitch File and Report on Yugoslavia, based on his archival work in Zagreb in 1947, would earn Butler notoriety in his own country where Butler was ostracized by the Catholic Irish establishment for publically condemning Archbishop Stepinacs collusion with the Ustashe regime. By identifying wartime atrocities in Croatia and Catholic Irelands collusion in assisting the war-criminal Artukovitch to escape to the USA, the Protestant Butler paid a high social price in the narrowly sectarian atmosphere of Ireland in the 1950s. This paper will re-examine Butlers Balkan essays and introduce them to a Macedonian audience. The alignment between the local Irish Butler rooted in his home country and his engagement with ex-Yugoslavia will be re-examined. The paper will explore the extent to which a cathartic and reconstructive sense of cultural memory depends on the ethical integrity of writers like Butler. Finally, the paper will briefly review the impact of Butlers writing in the Balkans and whether, in Chris Agees words, he has now established a niche in the national life that once hosted him Keywords: Krbizi Marisa, Aleksandr Moisiu University, Durrs, Albania
Shortening the distance between the narrator and the author in contemporary literature, as a medium for the transmission of ontological change
Contemporary literature (modern and postmodern) tends to bring to the surface movements in collective unconsciousness, shocks in the deep layers of national memory, ontological changes, phenomena felt but not visible and the ones that are visible but cannot be understood. These cultural changes (social and historical, too) are conveyed in different literary ways. The purpose of this paper is the analysis of the shortening of the distance between the narrator and the author, as a literary way to convey the dual shock of the historical memory associated with a certain time, the communist dictatorship one. The shortening of the distance between the narrator and the author makes the data transmitted through art to be filtered through two units: a) Narrative instance: the narrator generalizes the experience that comes through events/plot. b) Human instance: the involvement of the details concerning the authors life (in the plot) enriches the text with a human dimension. In this way, the combination between the two types of narrations: artificial narration and natural one provide literary texts (in modern and postmodern works), with an emphasized sensitivity. Such works function not merely as historical meta-fiction that follows a specific time. Their main goal is to present the Man who finds himself trapped within specific time with all his sensitivity, fear and desire to liven up. Keywords: ontological change, historical memory, contemporary literature, shortening the distance between the narrator and the author, etc. Klavora Marko, Research Centre of the Slovenian Academy of Sciences and Arts
Those who go
The paper is based on a field research (2012, 2013) among the Slovenians evacuated from Sarajevo by the Slovenian government with a collective Slovenian passport on November 18 and November 20, 1992, on the presumption of their Slovenian origins.
35 The author will present the beginning of the war in Sarajevo in 1992 and the context of the evacuation through the perception of some protagonists of the evacuation, Slovenians from Sarajevo who were interviewed by the author with the method of oral history interview. The starting point is the individual participant in the evacuation convoy in November 1992 and his/her historical experience of the pre-war Bosnia and Herzegovina and Sarajevo. I intent to demonstrate how the departure / rescue of the evacuees from Sarajevo was not an outcome of a logical and simple choice, but a process on which, in addition to war circumstances and events, personal and multi-generational family "histories" had an impact. These should be vied in the context of the Yugoslav socio-cultural model which generated them and which, at the moment of the beginning of the war, suddenly evaporated. Once arrived in Slovenia, they had to face their identity and a hostile environment: for the Slovenian public opinion, they were the Others. Through the life experience of Sarajevo Slovenians, their collective memory and the remembrance of the past life in Sarajevo the author tries to understand their experience of the war and the impossible dilemma they faced in November 1992, which a Bosnian-Croatian writer and poet Miljenko Jergovi characterized as a reduction to choosing a belonging team, which was not a political, but a cultural evil. Keywords: Sarajevo, war, Slovenians, memory, identity Knudsen, Britta Timm: Department of Aesthetics and Communication, Aarhus University, Denmark
The besieged city in the heart of Europe. Sniper Alley in Sarajevo as memorial site on YouTube
This study will look at witnessing at difficult heritage sites to investigate the particular forms of witnessing that online memorials to remember victims of conflicts articulate. The empirical material will be 45 recent YouTube videos and their subsequent commentaries. The tributes are vernacular responses to the siege of Sarajevo from 5 April 1992 to 29 February 1996, the longest siege of a capital city in the history of modern warfare. The web culture of commemoration characterized by easy access, openness and interactivity is part of contemporary participatory and DIY cultures performing the transition from a media user paradigm to a media produser paradigm. (Jenkins 2006, Lull 2007, Knobel and Lankshear 2010) and web memorials offer an opportunity for ordinary people to perform media witnessing in, by and through the media (Frosh & Pinchevski 2009, 2011). Witnessing is an inevitable form of subjectivity that globalization and transnational dependency and responsibility entail across borders and it has a double meaning: on the one hand it encompasses eyewitness testimonies based on first hand knowledge, on the other hand it signifies bearing witness to something and becoming a secondary or a nonwitness often to prosthetic memory (Oliver2001, Weissman 2004, Landsberg 2004). This piece will consider the web memorials as part of the social making of Sarajevo (Landsberg 2004, Sather-Wagstaff 2011) and will have a double analytical focus. On the one hand I will investigate the relation between BIH and in particular Sarajevo as a thanatouristic site and the prolific production of YouTube videos by travelers to Sarajevo. On the other hand I will analyze the videos using textual, filmic and documentary analytical tools in order to detect the communicative form of the videos and their subsequent impact on YouTube users. Keywords: Thanatourism, witnessing, digital media, events, affects Kobielska, Maria: Jagiellonian University in Cracow, Faculty of Polish Studies
36 contexts. There can be no talk of French exclusiveness of les lieux de mmoire, if only because from the mid-1990s onwards historians from many (Western) European countries have been conceptualising interesting research projects inspired by Noras idea. Most of them, however, deal with the national history. The first large-scale attempt to go beyond the national framework is the research project Polish-German Lieux de Mmoire carried out between 2006 and 2013 at the Center for Historical Research of the Polish Academy of Sciences in Berlin in cooperation with Carl von Ossietzky University in Oldenburg. The aim of this international undertaking is to rethink the Polish-German history through the lens of two approaches tied together: the history of Polish-German relations (Beziehungsgeschichte) and the history of collective memory (Erinnerungsgeschichte). Of the nine volumes in total (five in German and four in Polish), three contain essays on common, shared and parallel Polish-German lieux de mmoire. The last type of lieux de mmoire addressed in the Polish-German project is a new category referring to two (or more) completely dissimilar historical phenomena. Although the real objects of remembering are completely different there are many parallels in their identity-building functioning in the Polish and German society for instance as symbols of betrayal or success, as memorial embodiment of paradise lost or imperial ambitions or other figures constituting the sense of belonging to the community. This is not to say that Polish-German Lieux de Mmoire is the first publication ever that aims at transcending national borders in the examination of lieux de mmoire. Yet, in contrast to manifold rather disparate conference volumes or purely editorial undertakings, it is the first large-scale research project proposing a practical application of a new research design inspired by Noras concept. Keywords: cultural memory, lieux de mmoire (realms of memory), entangled history, neighbourhood, Polish-German history Korzheneva Olga, St.Petersburg State University, faculty of journalism
Religious values in a political discourse: analysis of Russian and Turkish mass media
Changes in historical events estimation always were faultless criterion of valuable orientations shift in political process. Media gives the chance to trace similar transformations, to receive information about current state of society, to predict further development. Today we see religion and policy rapprochement, and it is naturally reflected in the various historical periods assessment. For the purpose of confirmation or a denial of this hypothesis research on the example of Russia and Turkey is conducted. The countries are pulled together by existence of two historical periods. One of them we will call imperial and will pay attention that for it religious legitimization of the political power is characteristic, and the second secular. Today both countries are involved in globalization processes, and in everyone there are the political forces focused on ideals of the various periods. In Russia communists and the conservatives gravitating to socialist and monarchic values. In Turkey there still are supporters of Kemal Ataturk ideas, but considerably gains strength a neoottomanizm. Empirical base - media resources of different orientated political forces and official channels of two states. Research method the valuable and political analysis based on axiological approach to journalism and mass media studying. The purpose is determination of the political values connected with the various historical periods. Estimation of popular events of the past, modern questions of globalization, and also the persons personifying every era are interesting. Probably, in official discourse of both countries attempt of rehabilitation and reconciliation of the different historical periods, and also the appeal to religious values is observed. Research shows, what ideas are included into an official discourse and what remain part of extreme positions. The scientific analysis results show how new identity formation corresponds to perception of globalization process in Russia and Turkey. Keywords: valuable and political analysis, media, personification, values, globalization. Kos-Lajtman Andrijana; Buljubai Ivana, Faculty of Teacher Education of the University of Zagreb; Faculty of Humanities of the University of Osijek
37 (velikim dijelom medijski nadzirane i konstruirane) i kulture zaborava - krajnje su toke izmeu kojih postojanje nastoji definirati svoj identitet (Ivan Pavao II., Sjeanje i identitet). Na fonu postmodernizma, koji funkcionira kao skup strategija sjeanja, ali uglavnom na razini poetikih dodira (tehnike intertekstualnosti i citatnosti, preispitivanje jezinog potencijala), bez valorizacijskijh (ideologinih) intencija, nastaju novi narativni oblici - roman-rjenik (Nikola Pavi, Hazarski renik, Jasna Horvat, Vilikon), te posebice nam interesantan roman-album (eljka orak, Krhotine, Mladen Kirin, Album, Dubravka Ugrei, Muzej bezuvjetne predaje). Njegova je nakana sabiranjem dokaza o egzistentnosti individualne i kolektivne prolosti utemeljiti krhko tkivo identiteta na idejnosti koja se kontinuirano nadograuje definirajui (nacionalnu) posebnost. Takvom obliku poticaj je dao ratni kontekst, u kojem je pitanje naina i sadraja memoriranja izuzetno vano. Fotografija postaje vrijednost sama po sebi, time i album, koji se namee kao strukturni obrazac za organizaciju naracije. Na ruevinama ideje o kraju povijesti te zbog izuzetnog iskustva (rat), sjeanje, kulturna memorija i kultura memoriranja dobivaju izuzetno mjesto kao reakcija na kulturu (?) zaborava (Irena Vrkljan, Pred crvenim zidom) problematizirajui fenomen prolosti i njene relevantnosti u poimanju ivotnih tijekova i njihovoj interpretaciji Kljune rijei: roman-album, identitet, etika/estetika sjeanja, kraj povijesti Koziura, Karolina: Institute of Cultural Studies, Maria Curie-Sklodowska University in Lublin, Poland / Nationalism Studies Program, Central European University in Budapest, Hungary
Exploring the cityscape through the method of walking memory path. Czernowitz Jewish Diaspora and their search for Home.
The 1990s brought changes not only in the geopolitical map of Europe but also began the long path of transition into democracy and the market economy of the populace living in the former Soviet bloc. Moreover, it was a time of rediscovering lost memory and black holes (Gruber 2002) in the history of Central and East European societies in reference to pre-Soviet period. I believe that Chernivtsi, the city which is the subject of my presentation, is still undergoing a complex cultural memory transition. A part of this is the ethnic and religious revival observed in its space experienced by many national groups who live there. Moreover, Chernivtsi is a special place on the map of not only Ukrainian but the post-Soviet area. Its long and multiethnic history, changing rules of empires, borderland location and contemporary mixture of many ethnic groups make it an contested space for many actors struggling between each others for recognition and right to the city. One of the narratives connected with the cityscape of Chernivtsi produce the members of Czernowitz Jewish Diaspora, who live mostly outside of Ukraine and even Europe. As for them Czernowitz the name of the city from the Austro-Hungarian period - is not only a part of their history but first of all a myth of their Golden Age. In my presentation by using the method of walking memory path conducted with the members of Diaspora I show what is the Czernowitz from their memory and what are their particular identification. As I show by exploring the memory places in the city they build their own sense of identity and place belonging. Keywords: place memory, place identity, walking memory path, Jewish Diaspora, Chernivtsi Krajina Zlatan, Faculty of Political Science at the University of Zagreb
Snapshot memories of EU's Others: the floating location of Croatia (from a 'Balkan' to a 'European' country) in the symbolic cartographies of 'Western' tourist guide books surrounding the EU candidacy 2003-2013
In this paper I present findings of my discourse and textual analysis of the significance that cultural mapping, produced by tourist guide books on Croatia (published for 'Western' audiences in a ten-year period encompassing Croatia's 2003 EU candidacy and its 2013 EU entry), can have for our understanding of the volatility of remembering the Balkans outside the Balkans. My research suggests that Croatia's location in the European imaginary, within the specific symbolic infrastructures (such as guide books) of the rising post-industrial leisure mobility, is, to paraphrase Stuart Hall, one of a 'floating signifier': an expression of Balkanist representational power relations between the mapper and the mapped, articulated in specific historical contexts. At the beginning of the encompassed period Croatia was located (along a systematic emphasis on its involvement in recent Yugoslav wars and its mainly Slavic origin) on a marginal and underdeveloped European East, while, following a series of the country's adaptations to EU's norms as a coming member, Croatia was curiously re-located, onto a virtual Central European map (accentuating the country's historical connections to Austria, Hungary and Italy). 'Witness' guide books, serving an increasing number of Western European visitors as key resources in their cultural orientations on the Other's ground, hence produce what I call 'snapshot memories': mediated remembrances of the Other claiming first-hand travel writer's validity, but without lasting historical commitment. This incessant shifting of Croatia's place in Western Europe's memories requires us to question political relevance that contemporary discursive formations of Balkan Other's pasts can have for their European futures. Keywords: guide books, tourism, Croatia, EU, memory, Othering, Balkanism Kregar Tone, Museum of Recent History Celje
38 more conscientious at differentiating these terms, as their research focuses on studying the past and, consequently, on the role of memory or on the very process of remembering. However, within this corpus certain differences in the terminology and different views on the types and forms of memory do exist. In this paper, rather than psychological and sociological theories (by Maurice Halbwachs and others) we focus on how we, historians, look on the various forms of memory, especially those historians who study (still "alive") 20th century. And who in their work, let it be research, teaching, or, like in my case - work in a museum, rely on both, individual memories and collective memory to shape the historical memory of a community or society. Although greater terminological clarity in this regard would be more than welcome, it is most important that we correctly identify the different forms and types of memory and its components and that we use them appropriately in our work - that is in research, understanding and interpreting our past or our history. Even more so because they often intertwine with each other, overlap, complement, and transform from one to another, or, sometimes even exclude each other. Therefore it is often difficult to clearly distinguish one from another and to deal with them separately. Historians working in the Museum of Recent History Celje are faced with these issues and problems on a daily basis; many specific examples of our work further demonstrate the moulding complexity of memory and its forms and go beyond the theoretical classifications and division. Keywords: Kristberga Laine, Department of Film and Theatre Theory and History, Faculty of Humanities, University of Latvia
Ivan Grohar and Oskar Dev an interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary fragment comparison of their artistic works in kofja Loka/Slovenia (19051911)
The new Grohars room in the kofja Loka Museum that is located in a more than a thousand years old town, some kilometres northwest of Ljubljana, Slovenia, represents one of the new possibilities to popularize old local history. Ivan Grohar (18671911) is one of the four well-known Slovenian painters from the beginning of the 20th century, together with Richard Jakopi, Matija Jama and Matej Sternen. These Slovenian painters are the founders of impressionism within the modern style. kofja Loka became the so called Slovenian Barbizon (i.e. French village near Fontainebleau, once the settlement of painters) and this art and old tradition inspired another Slovenian (music) artist Oskar Dev (18681932), who composed some of his musical works (songs and choirs) in kofja Loka, too. His and Grohars period in kofja Loka (1905-1911) resulted in some extraordinary art works i.e. paintings and (musical) works. They both were inspired by the countryside that reflected on their works. This is now one of the new Slovenians challenges of museology and musicology in an interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary approach so the art of painting and music could be a benefit for the visitors of this and other museums. Keywords: old local history, painter, composer, impressionism, modern style, Barbizon, musical works: songs and choirs, museology, musicology Krstikj, Aleksandra; Koura Hisako, Osaka University
Design concept for the conservation of the Old Bazaar in Skopje, based on the historic significance of place
Historic urban areas are the main containers of cultural achievements of communities. Although modernization is logical continuation in the evolution of any living city, in this paper our aim is to examine a design concept of moderate modern developments in the historic area of Skopje to sustain and even promote the historic context. First, we examined modern developments and changes of the urban patterns that impaired the historic context of Skopjes old center. The discussion points
39 are: Typical modernization, such as regional road network, railway network and other infrastructure, that restructured the urban form and resulted in damage or destruction of the historic urban form; Urban policy to construct a new center and to modernize the public facilities without concern of the historic context that brought about loss of many historic buildings. Secondly, we examined the formation and layout of Skopjes historic center developed by the main principles of the Ottoman urban concept based on the Islamic religious lawSharia. We concentrated on two key elements of the Ottoman urban strategy: the allocation of public facilities and primary roads. The analysis, based on historical documents, evaluated the significance of places from three aspects: I) Main Center that represents the origin of the Ottoman city, II) components of the Bazaars urban structure and III) periphery points of urbanization that indicate the edge of the city and give significance to the location of the center. We concluded that today, the authentic significance of road and place in Skopjes historic area formed by the Ottoman urban strategy can still be recognized, even if the original buildings are lost, by careful examination of the Ottoman urban concept. The authentic significance of place can serve as base for design concept that can rescue the historic context and manage future favorable development in Skopjes Bazaar. Keywords: Skopje's Bazaar, conservation, Ottoman concept, place significance, urban strategy Krzysztof Malicki, University of Rzeszow, Institute of Sociology
Between cultural memory and communicative memory dilemmas of reconstruction of annihilated past of Polish Jews.
One of the most important features of Polish collective memory changes after the fall of communism in 1989 was including elements of the past life and the destruction of Polish Jews and often difficult, mutual relations between Poles and Jews. Despite two decades, this process is still far from being complete. It is shaping continually, each day, between the official state ritual practices and living message (cultural memory) and experience of Polish witnesses of the Holocaust (communicative memory). This phenomenon is accompanied by constant controversy and conflicts. The actors of this debate face recurring questions: which elements of Polish communicative memory should become part of the cultural memory? What should we pass to future generations and what should we forget? What consequences for the Polish memory is opening up to the memory of another nation? Keywords: cutural memory, communicative memory, Jews, Holocaust Kulasic, Elmina: Project Development Coordinator at the Cinema for Peace - Genocide Film Library
Non-Commemoration and the Nation The Politics of Identity, Memory and Forgetting in the Former Yugoslavia
Monumentality and collective memory have not been neglected by discourses concerning national identity. However, insights favouring forgetting and counter-memory are considerably new approaches reconstructing identities and redressing tragedy
40 after pronounced violence. Erecting monuments is often a strategy towards building and inciting public memory and defining the nation, but they can also be used as a means of masking histories and manipulating national narratives this is seemingly the case in a number of post-war monuments throughout the former Yugoslavia. The interplay between cultural heritage, memory, and space is a huge component of national identity; the installation of monuments memorializing non-Yugoslav celebrities throughout the newly defined states serve as a means to reconstitute identity, redefine heritage and avoid the celebration of a painful past. By consolidating existing theories on nationalism, identity and memory, this paper will examine the potential consequences of this manipulation of public space. Through a discussion of the way in which identities can strive to strategically avoid the state in the non-commemoration of the nation and its inflicted traumas, I hope to demonstrate that the state is always present: That even through neglecting it it is always referenced, that the framework of political sociology can operate, not just by identifying and treating the state as an actor, but also by simply acknowledging the state as spectre. Keywords: Kustritz Anne, University of Amsterdam
Dr. Frankenstein, Dr. Mengele ... Dr. Beckett?: The Repressed Eugenic Memories of Stargate: Atlantis
In the present era, rapid advancements in genetic technology mirror the enlightenment-age scientific transitions which inspired Mary Shelleys anxious probing of the human-Other divide and the moral meaning of human beings manipulation of life itself in Frankenstein. Similarly, contemporary speculative fiction on science and fantasy provide a vital window into the evolving cultural consensus about the morality and meaning of genetic manipulation and research. Set in a space and time removed from the regular workings of dominant culture, fantasyscapes allow metaphorical versions of historical disasters and modern choices to unfold in ways which might otherwise be suppressed. In the far-off universe of Stargate:Atlantis characters deal with a series of events which mirror on-going political problems in the real world, including terrorism, torture, nuclear proliferation, and cultural pluralism. However, perhaps the most profoundly disturbing plot centers around medical experimentation on political prisoners and the use of genetic research to eliminate Otherness, effectively committing genocide. The key role in achieving this racial purification by means of genetic manipulation is performed by Dr. Carson Beckett, a much beloved character primarily known in the series for affability, kindness, and a deep affection for his mother.That such a character becomes the face of a genetic final solution for racial and cultural conflict represents one part of a recurring ideology I have elsewhere termed Postmodern Eugenics. Increasingly, as cultural memory of eugenics fades and mutates, strains of the will to build a better race recur in contemporary fiction and politics, masked by new technologies, threatening to once again wreak terrible destruction from behind the facade of deliberate cultural and political forgetfulness, represented on Stargate: Atlantis by a face as placid and friendly as Dr. Becketts. Keywords: science fiction, eugenics, representational politics, race Kuznetsova Lyudmila, Perm State National Research University. Researcher, Centre of Comparative History and Political Studies
Memory About The Bright Future: Official Commemoration of vs Remembering the Soviet Resort
The Soviet resort has a controversial place in the cultural memory of post Soviet society. Resorts, as a model of the bright future and as the realization of Soviet utopia, were constructed as significant and monumental objects. They still occupy an important place in the physical and cultural space. However, even though their importance could be promising for cultural tourism, they are often disregarded by local authorities and managers. When someone says Soviet resort, the same shared image is evoked in almost any persons mind from the former Soviet Union. How this image was created is an important question in this paper, especially in terms of the fight between two discourses: the discourse of freedom vs the discourse of control and education. Moreover, the works of Soviet mass culture will also be examined as they are supposed to have a strong influence on the Soviet resorts image. A few images of the Soviet resort that were constructed during the Soviet past are still present in peoples memory. This paper will inspect what and how people remember about the Soviet resort today. Comparing these memories with the set of past images of the Soviet resort will reveal which features were forgotten. Looking at the national commemoration strategy, it would be essential to understand why and how local authorities deliberately avoid using the cultural memory about the utopian projects of Soviet imperia, even though it could be used in historical and cultural tourism to develop a region. To analyze the commemoration strategy, museum and touristic policies in resort regions will be reviewed. Peoples memories will then be compared to official commemorations ordered by managers and authorities to reveal their emotional attitudes. Keywords: Soviet resort, utopia, commemoration, cultural tourism, emotional attitudes Lehel Peti, The Romanian Institute for Research on National Minorities
Politics, religion and the use of cultural memory in a Catholic region from Romania
The presentation analyzes the connection between religious traditions based on cultural memory and the official rites controlled by the church in a Catholic region of the eastern part of Romania. The ethnographic material constitutes the local religious events appeared in the Catholic villages from this region after the death of an illegally ordained Franciscan priest and doctor, who, in the opinion of the locals, was suspected to be executed by the Romanian secret service during socialism. The tragic
41 story of this political martyr became the base of a religious movement that activated the Catholic villages on masse, edging along religiosity. His memory became the site of pilgrimage and collective healings. In the period of transition the Catholic church from the region started the beatification process of the martyr. The expropriation of the memory of the martyr priest is based on a well controlled process of collection, selection, and interpretation of narratives containing the cultural memory of the priest, also building officially controlled memorial places for him. The author argues that the beatification constitutes one of the most important project in the efforts for institutional consolidation of the Catholic church in Moldova after the Romanian system change, a possible success of this project would mean a second blessed for the Romanian Catholic church. Keywords: cultural memory, politics, religion, memorial place Leigh, James: University of Groningen
Difficult Past, Difficult Present?: How Collective Memory and Personal Experience Shape Beliefs on Politico-Cultural Identity in Post-Conflict Societies Today
In essence, we are all products of our experience; thus the positions we adopt today are influenced by what we remember (and forget) about our past. This is true at both individual and collective levels. In societies traumatised by conflict, the act of recalling and dealing with the past is particularly controversial: What should be remembered, and whose memories may be recalled? Can one deviate from the mainstream of accepted remembrance? In most societies it is possible to identify what has been referred to as a master narrative of identity, which determines both the accepted history of that society as well as values concerning what it means to be a (good) member of that community today. It is indeed useful to perceive identity through such a narrative framework, as a story which we construct about who we are and what we have done. This paper firstly takes the position that individual narratives are often shaped by the master narrative, which sets the tone for what is acceptable within the collective, not only in historical terms, but also in terms of beliefs on politics, nationality and/or ethnicity. Yet there exists in most societies a proportion of people whose positions diverge from the master narrative. This paper, which is intended to establish the theoretical position of my larger research project, will consider how such deviations amongst individuals in society could be explained by the various processes through which memory (both individual and collective) is formed and later recalled, processes which in turn impact on the way the individual perceives and relates to the master narrative and constructs the predominant features of their own identity. Particular attention will be given to how such processes function in post-traumatic settings, and the implications of difficult memories for narratives of present and future in such societies. Keywords: remembering and forgetting, narratives, post-conflict, post-trauma, nationalism, ethnicity Lewicka Maria, Faculty of Psychology, University of Warsaw
Place attachment and place memory: How to reduce ethnic bias in collective memory of places
Due to the territorial changes in the post-war Eastern and Central Europe numerous cities located on these territories changed their state belonging and consequently their populations. Most of the previously multicultural cities are now ethnically homogeneous. As a result of the post-war migrations and of the political censorship imposed by the communist regimes on memory of pre-war times, we observe at present a collective amnesia unawareness of the cities pre-war history and a strong Historical Ethnic Bias overestimation of the role of own nation in the history of residence places and neglect of the role of their previous inhabitants. In this presentation I am going to focus on the phenomenon of ethnic bias in the memory of once multi-ethnic and now ethnically homogeneous places located in two countries, Poland and Ukraine, which, as a consequence of international agreements after WWII, changed their state belonging and population. In contrast to these collective memory studies that usually focus on large place scales such as countries, my presentation will deal with more personal scales such as cities or towns, and perception of their pre-war national composition, local heroes and local events. The studies carried out in several cities and on representative country samples revealed a powerful Ethnic Bias and a number of factors contributing to its reduction, including: (i) presence of urban reminders (history traces), (ii) socio-demographic factors (cultural capital), and (iii) type of people-place bonds: place attachment and place identity. Living in the environment rich in historical traces, being endowed with cultural capital, representing an active form of place attachment and strong place identity contributed to more accurate place memories. Interest taken in the history of the place had a particularly positive impact on the open-minded and unbiased attitude towards the multicultural character of residence places. Keywords: place memory, Historical Ethnic Bias, place attachment, place identity Licata Laurent; De Guissm Laura; Mercy Aurlie, Universit libre de Bruxelles
Remembering WWII collaboration in Belgium: effects on political position taking in the linguistic conflict
Collaboration with the Nazi occupier during WWII has always been a topic of dissent between Walloons (French-speakers) and Flemings (Dutch-speakers) in Belgium. According to a popular myth coined after the war and often narrated in the media and literature, collaboration was widespread in Flanders, whereas Walloons bravely resisted, although historical reality is much more nuanced. These representations regularly resurface in political debates surrounding the Belgian linguistic conflict. Demands for amnesty addressed by nationalist Flemish parties are a case in point. A questionnaire survey (N = 521; 315 W and 206 F) showed that collaboration was generally represented negatively and was morally condemned in both groups. However, Walloon participants expressed more negative moral emotions towards collaborators (equally for W and F collaborators) than Flemish
42 participants. And Flemings, especially high Flemish identifiers and supporters of right-wing parties, were les reluctant to support the granting of amnesty to WWII collaborators than Walloons. Among Flemings, identification with Flanders was associated with a more positive collective memory of collaboration (serving Flanders interests), whereas identification with Belgium was associated with a more critical representation of it (more immoral and severe). In contrast, both levels of identification were associated with more negative memories among Walloons. Interestingly, support for amnesty was predicted by judgments of morality of Flemish, but not of Walloon, collaborators, in both groups, as if francophone collaboration was deemed irrelevant. Results suggest that differences between F and W in political position taking regarding the granting of amnesty are partly due to differences in collective memories of collaboration, and to different perspectives towards the same historical representation. The myth is both shared and disputed. Keywords: Linin Lea, University of Arts in Belgrade / Universit Lumire Lyon 2
The Urban Symbolic Ecology of Skopje: What Kinds of Identity Narrative Lines Do Skopjes Symbol Bearers Produce?
Inspired by the recent rapid transformation of Skopje through the urban project Skopje 2014 and the consequent influx of new symbol bearers in the urban landscape of the city, this paper entitled The Urban Symbolic Ecology of Skopje: What Kinds of Identity Narrative Lines Do Skopjes Symbol Bearers Produce? will focus on identifying, synthetizing, and critically examining the entirety of symbol bearers from the city, belonging to the pre-Skopje-2014 as well as the Skopje-2014 period. The term urban symbolic ecology is one of the fundamental concepts in the field of urban anthropology, which I will use as a main theoretical reference point in this paper. In his book entitled Cities Full of Symbols: A Theory of Urban Space and Culture, Peter J.M. Nas defines the urban symbolic ecology as a concept that studies the cultural dimension of the city, namely how symbols and rituals are distributed within the cultural milieu and what sort of meanings they bear in it. The symbol bearers as containers of a citys collective memory will be explored through the perspective of four categories as proposed by Nas urban symbolic ecology concept: material, discursive, iconic and behavioural. Material symbol bearers relate to the material objects of symbolic value within a city (architecture, statues, monuments, nature, etc.). Discursive symbol bearers are concerned with urban images and narratives. Iconic symbolic bearers are associated with people representing cities. And, finally, behavioural symbol bearers are considered to be activities such as rituals, festivals and demonstrations. The exclusivity or the combination of specific symbol bearers constitutes the symbolic structure of a city, thus developing its identity/identities. Unravelling a set of city identities, this paper will also expose the reasons behind the precedence of specific symbol bearers and identities over others. Keywords: urban symbolic ecology, symbol bearer, identity, city identity, Skopje Lisiak, Agata A., Dolgoy Rebecca Clare: Humboldt University Berlin / ECLA of Bard
The Master Plan and Cultural Memory: The Case of Berlin's Museum Island
Bolstered by its 1999 entry into the list of UNESCO World Heritage Sites, Museum Island has been for centuries one of the hearts of Berlin's memory culture. The UNESCO recognition came a decade after the fall of the Wall, as the city was trying to rethink, remake, and, eventually, remarket itself as a global city. In our paper, we look at the role of Museum Island in (re)creating Berlin's post-1989 image and its urban constellations of space and time. After examining the contemporary and historical contexts of Museum Island's master plan, we will discuss some of the controversies surrounding Museum Island's architecture and collections including their cultural and political dimensions. Our paper offers a reading that seeks to understand the current (re)turn towards the master plan, which we situate in a larger cultural memory context. We will give a brief historical account of the development of Museum Island with an eye towards narratives and then move on to present cultural and political repercussions of Museum Island's new master plan. Here, we will focus on the controversy caused by the recent decision by the director of Berlin State Museums to move the Old Masters collection currently housed at Gemldegalerie near Potsdamer Platz to Museum Island's Bodemuseum thereby dividing Berlin's art collection according to simplified, in our view, notions of space and time. We argue that this strategy to create a linear and geographically essentialist narrative of Berlin's collections may be seen, in light of the city's post-1989 urban marketing practices, is yet another attempt to (re)create and (re)shape Berlin's cultural memory and image. Keywords: cultural memory, museums, master plan, space and time, Berlin Lori Amy, Georgia Southern University
Collective Memory, National Identity, and the Battle for Control of the Public Sphere in Albania
This paper uses two recent and highly controversial construction projects in Albanias capital city, Tirana, to map the essential features of the field of memory and identity in which contemporary political processes are playing out. In 2010, the opposition Socialist Party (SP) leader and then-mayor of Tirana, Edi Rama, began a major reconstruction of the most important square in the historic city center, Skanderbeg Square. Shortly thereafter, Democratic Party (DP) Prime Minister Sali Berisha and Chair of the Parliament, Josefina Topalli, unleashed a city-wide controversy over plans to demolish the Pyramid originally, a memorial and museum for the Communist Dictator, Enver Hoxha. As highly charged symbols of contested national identity, both sites embody a fraught struggle to monumentalize a national story a monumentality never fully achieved, in the first instance, short-lived, in any case, and testifying as much as anything else to the fragmentary and embattled nature of national memory
43 and identity. In both cases, the proposed construction projects were attempts by political parties to impose a version of the past that legitimates party identity and silences/obliterates counter-memories that destabilize post-communist political party identity narratives. For the DP, this means that any signification of pre-transition communist party allegiance must be erased, and, for the SP, links to communist-era crimes and human rights violations must be repressed. While the country remains locked in these communist anticommunist polarizations, both positions require a selective remembering and a corollary strategic forgetting that obscure the much more complex experiences and memories of the regime and the ongoing conflicts within and amongst groups with different experiences and memories of that past. Following recent work on collective memory (Rothberg 2009, Irwin-Zarecka 1994, Connerton 2011, Olick 2011), this paper analyzes political battles for control of the public sphere in terms of these memory contests. Keywords: Albania, collective memory, national identity, post-communist, anti-communist Luki Mina, Faculty of Phylosophy, University in Belgrade, Serbia The Interplay of Museum Discourse and Popular Culture: How, When and Where History Comes Alive? Museum as an institution has been, throughout history, inevitably connected with ideology, involved in establishing and shaping of cultural memory and creation and affirmation of collective identities, based on scientific knowledge and interpretation of the past. Nowadays, other, more effective media are involved in those processes, e.g. film, which will be examined in the paper as such a medium. Also, museums have been used for spreading different prejudices and stereotypes some of our identities are often based on such prejudices, either about our own or somebody elses past or present. Nevertheless, museum as an institution has an aura of highest authority, based on scientific knowledge and legitimized by museum collections. It is a place to visit if you want to find the truth. Museum is seen as trustworthy, unbiased, objective. Such privileged status of a museum will be argued and contested, and problems of museum discourse will be analized through the case study of American Museum of Natural History in New York. Critical analysis of this museums discourse will be based on three sources: the text of Mieke Bal Telling, Showing, Showing off where she discussed museums permanent exhibition in 1991, the movie Night at the Museum (2006) and museums current internet presentation. We are going to follow and question narratives and stereotypes that are recognizable in this museums discourse and in other discourses with which museum discourse interacts (politics, popular culture). Considering the fact that museum officials have credited the film for increasing the number of visitors by almost 20% and that a sequel followed (Night at the Museum: Battle of the Smithsonian, 2009), the movie Night at the Museum seems to be an adequate example for the analysis of the interplay of museum discourse and popular culture and its role in the shaping of cultural memory. Keywords: museum discourse, popular culture, collective identities, American Museum of Natural History, Night at the Museum Lupis Vinicije B.; poljar Vrina Sanja; Hazdovac Baji Nikolina: Institut drutvenih znanosti Ivo Pilar
44 Rousseau and Lord Byron were revered as geniuses. With Woody Allens film Midnight in Paris (2011), the Hemingway Myth, in which various attributes and details about the author were exaggerated to fuel Hemingways image, has endured well into the twenty-first century. This paper will examine the progress and transformation of the Hemingway Myth, and how it countered with the man himself. Cultural memory is especially fostered through literature and film, and Allens film, along with the 2012 film Hemingway and Gellhorn, aid this image of Hemingway as a passionate, romantic gentleman, where the reality was quite different. Hemingways own works, moreover, facilitated the romanticised manner in which he was received by his public, only later to be confirmed in his appearances in TIME magazine. This paper will argue that in the field of literature, celebrity authors are particularly benefiting from the flattering outcome of cultural memory, in which figures such as writers and artists are particularly enamoured by their public. By existing in an overwhelmingly artistic industry, it is no surprise that the memory many of these writers leave behind, to this very day, is equally artistic. Keywords: Hemingway, Myth, Memory, Paris, Romanticism, Celebrity Maja Muhi, Faculty of Languages, Cultures, and Communications at the South East European University, Tetovo, Republic of Macedonia
Mediatized Memory in the Comics Cultures. The Case of the Mtys, a kirly
The comic media exists in different versions. The currently evolving institutional system, characteristic genres, social use and practices of the Hungarian comics are vastly influenced by the main types of global culture of this media: the oriental style comics, the French-Belgian bande dessine and the North American comics. These great versions are overlap and interpenetrate one another. We can see how transcultural flows create and form comic cultures as media cultures. In Hungary, the Ministry of Education and Culture organized a cultural season called Year of Renaissance 2008. It has celebrated the anniversary of King Matthias Corvinus who came to the throne of Hungary 550 years ago. A comics competition was organized and the winners published the comic book Mtys, a kirly (Matthias the King). This anthology composed by Hungarian mangas, North American and European style iconotexts various types of mediatization in the global culture of comics. The mediativity of these versions of the comic media participate at the construction (or reinterpretation) of the figure of Matthias who plays traditionally an emblematic role in the Hungarian popular culture and collective memory: Matthias the Just. This paper aims to examine and understand some of the processes of King Matthiass meditization in contemporary Hungarian comics. Keywords: media, mediatization, comics, manga, Hungary, King Matthias Maleska, Kalina: Blaze Koneski Faculty of Philology, Ss. Cyril and Methodius University Skopje
45 authority, influence, control. The research of literary works, however, has led me to the realization that the notion of power is understood on somewhat different terms in literature and literary theory and criticism in comparison to how it is explained in philosophy and the social sciences. In order to contribute to the broader understanding of power from literary point of view, this essay examines many questions concerning this phenomenon, some of which are: how does the past understanding of power determine how it is accepted and interpreted in the present? How is the success of the present efforts and strives affected by the memory of power? The essay attempts to shows that the memory of the notion of power is not and cannot be fixed and given once and for all. Therefore, the literary examples provided (by Vlada Urosevic, John Fowles, etc.) display how the definitions of power given in the past are transformed and transfigured by present literary works, which show how we may forget what we know about this phenomenon, and define it from a new perspective. Keywords: power, influence, past, resistance, literature Magorzata Gowacka-Grajper, Institute of Sociology, University of Warsaw
Multidimensional memory of the lost land in the postsocialist reality. The example of former Polish Eastern Borderlands (Kresy)
Social memory as a place of creation of visions of the group past, individual experiences of its members and the ties connecting them to each other and to the territory become the cultural construct, which should particularly draw anthropologists attention. I will try to define character of this cultural construct on the example of memory of the former Polish Eastern Borderlands (Kresy). Poles in these areas over the years formed a community, which identity was based on relationship with the territory. The social and political relations had been reversed Poles seen as colonialists had become colonized. After World War II, many of them have been resettled to new Polish state and nowadays about 5 millions of their descendant live in Poland. Over a period of communism, the memory of the Polish Kresy was successfully pushed to the margins of social and political life, and after the beginning of democratic changes in Poland, we had to deal with the "explosion" of memory connected with Kresy. However, it was a short period and this memory soon has became marginalized in public life. In his paper I will focus on the question: how these changes in socio-cultural environment and in the attitude of the Polish state affected the way of defining traditions of Kresy and the place of memory of it in political and public life in Poland. In the example of Kresy one can find many aspects of specific postcommunist situation: memory of hegemony together with the memory of being under domination, old ethnic and religious tradition together with new established political domain. And above all fear of being accused of hostile nationalism together with the desire for preserve the glorious past which is hard to define precisely important aspect, in my opinion, for understanding the postcommunist and postcolonial world. Keywords: marginalisation, postcommunism, social memory, territory, tradition Marko Stamenkovic, University of Gent (Belgium) -Department of Philosophy and Moral Sciences
The Light and Heat of Images: Mediated Memories, Cultural Patterns and Politics of Self-Sacrifice
According to sociologist Michael Biggs, the historical impact of self-immolation can be traced back to a single yet relatively recent case: the fiery self-sacrifice of Thich Quang Duc on 11 June 1963 in Saigon, South Vietnam. It was famously memorized and made public in a series of photographs by the Associated Press photojournalist Malcolm Browne. Thanks to the imagerecord, unlike any previous case of the same kind, this unique protest-event inspired people elsewhere to sacrifice themselves for a collective rather than exclusively individual cause. Due to the advent of photography and technologies for the rapid transmission and cheap reproduction of images it [became] possible for a single sacrifice to have a dramatic impact on a huge audience (Biggs 2005). This paper takes as its point of departure Brownes photograph as the progenitor of the great majority of these acts, including almost every case in which fire was used in the four decades since 1963 (in Biggs own terms and understood in a constitutive, foundational manner for any discursive analysis of the subject at hand). Thus, the visual rhetoric of a single image becomes a way to critically reconsider the ideas of self-sacrifice as cultural pattern, by virtue of which contemporary civic protests around the world (including Tibet, Tunisia, Morocco, Greece, Italy, and Spain) attempt to assess specific social events and situations in a culturally specific way: through a transnational political and media paradigm symptomatic of our times, namely, giving oneself for a collective cause by re-enacting the forms of communicative suffering through cultural memory rooted in visual rhetoric of suicidal protests. Keywords: mediated cultural pattern, visual rhetoric, self-immolation, Michael Biggs Markoska Marta, University Ss. Cyril and Methodius, Institute for Macedonian Literature
46 microscopic insights. Nevertheless, when some aspect of human life is marked as cultural memory, it contains a complexity of ethnic, national, religious, social, and personal, i.e. individual characteristics that are intertwined and their separate consideration will not produce reliable results. If we oppose these findings by wanting to know what affects the construction of cultural memory, then the answer could either be infinite or may be summarized in one word everything! All our day to day perceptions, all our moods, reflexes, habits, mental and spiritual conditions affect our construction of memory because memory is neither immune nor resistant to the process of understanding. When something is perceived, it is shaped and defined by all the cognitive, educational, emotional, and intellectual capacities of each individual. To avoid misunderstanding, we will split the term cultural memory into individual and collective cultural memory. Hence, in order to explain the collective, we must first explain the individual. To do this, it would be most helpful to add the time factor to all kinds of understanding, i.e. to the understanding across different processes. However, time as all other categories is relative, especially since it depends on the perspective of interpretation we want to move towards. When talking about memory, it is important to take into account physical time, as well as how we personally and individually experience it, because nothing, not even the cultural memory exists outside of it. The philosophical approach to this issue in the text will trigger many questions, such as: Do we remember only what we want to remember and, consequently, do we forget what we want to forget?; Is memory, bearing in mind its characteristics, qualities and attributes, selective and exclusive or cohesive?, and finally, Is/Why (is) memory necessary? Keywords: Markova, Ina: University of Vienna
Politics of Memory/Identity/Coming to Terms with the Past/History Text Books/Austria Negotiated Memory:History Text Books as (Re-)Sources of National Identity and Useful Visions of the Past
Cultural memory is shaped under the influence of socio-political and very often antagonistic processes. Thus, memory can be conceived as the result of negotiations of the past which need to be transmitted and passed on from generation to generation. In this respect, analyzing history text books offers the possibility to get a glimpse at those versions of the past deemed to be worthy of savouring and remembering. What does the adult generation want younger ones to remember when it comes to the past, what meaning do they want do allocate to history? In this respect, and, following a very political vision upon collective memory, this paper wants to describe history text books as the result of political and societal negotiations undertaken to reconstruct the past and to create historical identity in the present. Following Stuart Hall and his concept of representation, several questions arise: Which versions of the past come in handy when societies need to be reshaped in general but also especially in times of transition? Useful insight might be given focussing on the Austrian post-war case study: How did Austrian text books try to come to terms with such a dreadful history as the involvement in the criminal perpetrator society of the Third Reich after the liberation of the country? Which aspects of said past is meant to be an identificatory resource for the pupils and future citizens, what are the blind spots in this reconstruction of history? What are the intentions and political strategies of the agents of memoria when negotiating and putting onto paper the final outline of national history? Keywords: Politics of Memory/Identity/Coming to Terms with the Past/History Text Books/Austria Martin Baake-Hansen, Department of Arts and Cultural Studies, University of Copenhagen
Cultural memory about the sorrow in the advertising after the terrorists attacks.
The general objective of this research study is to do a comparative research to investigate the perception of sorrow in the advertising in the press after the terrorist attacks: 9/11/2001 (U.S.) and 04/11/2004 (Spain). A specific objective would be to investigate whether the presence of messages and symbols in this commercial advertisements specific of each culture and common
47 to both. The results of this research can also be used in the investigation help in the research to identify elements common and universal to the sorrow and suffering in the advertising. The general hypothesis considers that there are similar perceptions of the sorrow towards the ads although there are cultural differences. On a computer program the subject was shown these images about announcement advertisement published in the press after the 09/11 and 11/04 in a random order and was asked different questions that explored their perception and attitudes with regard to these advertisements. Their answers, through the computer keyboard, were registered on a data-base for subsequent anlisis: 1. Identify and obtain literature about this goal in the U.S., 2. Identify a sample of young American university students (male and female, aged 19 to 22), to take part in this research and participate in the interviews; 3.Elaboration of the categories and data analysis and 4.Comparison with data obtained in Spain. Keywords: Matanovi Damir; Ivanica Markovi, University J.J. Strossmayer Osijek, Croatia
Forgotten origins. Migrations from Bosnia and Herzegovina to Eastern Croatia during late 17th and 18th Century and position of Bosnians Immigrants in Eastern Croatia today
The authors write about two situations in history of Bosnia and Herzegovina and Eastern Croatia, called Slavonia. Using comparative method they write about moment when 1697th Prinz Eugen de Savoya, during Great Vienna War, rushed with their Army into Bosnia, burned Sarajevo and pull back into Slavonia. With Army in Slavonia migrate around 80 % Bosnian Catholics or Croats and settled into Slavonia and Southern Hungary. They were first Inhabitants in this, by war, depopulated Country. Country were filled completely during 18th Century migrations who were mostly from Bosnia and Herzegovina. Second moment is more contemporary and concerns economic or war related migrations from Bosnia and Herzegovina to Slavonia. The authors analize relations between domestic and newcomers or between those who migrate in 17th and 18th Century and those who migrate in 20th an 21st Century. The Authors also compare cultural heritage of both groups. Keywords: Mt Zombory, Institute of Sociology at the Academy of Sciences
The duty of social reconstruction. Reflections on the past in early post-war Hungary
One important development of social memory recently is the emergence of a global space of memory which serves as context for local, national and regional memory practices, be it in the political or in the academic field. This new field of action can be characterized, among others, by its dominating normative prescriptions for social action, preserving everything and duty to remember. The first is described by the concepts of archiving, patrimonializing, or musealizing denote: because of the uncertainties about the future, we no longer have the normative principals according to which we could select from the past that is worth remembering. Instead, we have the only principal of preserving everything. According to the second imperative, called duty to remember, individuals and societies have to commemorate past events so that they can never reappear again. The slogan of Never again! has its ground in avoiding history to repeat itself. The development of these features of today's dominant regime of historicity are closely tied to the social history of the memory of the Holocaust. In my paper I will first reconstruct the global space of memory politics according to these normative prescriptions. Second I will elaborate its critique through the analysis of the Hungarian early post-war (1945-449) intellectual and journalistic reflections on the recent past. Can we speak of a duty to remember in this case? What were the main discourses on Hungary's role during the war before the formulation of the concepts of Holocaust and genocide? What normative prescriptions, in relation to the past, oriented social action? Keywords: Hungary (1945-49), public discourses, reflections on the past, "duty to remember", intellectuals Matei Alexandru, Spiru Haret University, Bucharest
The right to laugh in postcommunism. Romanian Tv open and hidden memories history of European television, Ceausescu's regime, postcommunism, ideology and memory
After the end of communism, Romanian National Television (TVR) resumed, by the end of the 90ies, some old programs, especially black and white entertainment and movies. On the 50th anniversary, in 2006, TVR also resumed some old documentaries, newsreel, social and economic investigations, but this happened very late at night. It seems to us that the historical value of visual documents is higher within what we call social broadcasts, where we can find today the shape of the socialist Romanian society, as TVR felt free to scatter. This hidden history is maybe more important than what written documents reveal to us, and shows us the unsuspected continuities between two epochs Keywords: history of European television, Ceausescu's regime, postcommunism, ideology and memory Maura Maginn, Diversity Challenges Northern Ireland
Cultural Memory and Identity: Story Telling According to Ethical Principles in Northern Ireland
Story Telling According to Ethical Principles has been developed in Northern Ireland as a way to express cultural memory in a safe space. It is designed to promote healing, reconciliation and peace-building. The method is governed by a set of ethical principles guided by the core aim of beneficence doing good based on respect and safeguards. It places the story teller as the prime beneficiary and as the person in control of the process, rather than the facilitator. This form of story telling with individuals and with diverse groups has led to a
48 reconciliation with the past, including the impact of the conflict on their lives. Many have found a voice to speak of their experiences, their memories, their culture - often for a first time. They have also found the confidence to share their stories with others, including their children and grand children. They have also shared stories of their culture and identity with those from differing sides of the conflict. This form of storytelling represents a method of learning about the past and sharing cultural memory with the aim of building a better future. Keywords: Mesi, Milan, Department of Sociology, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Zagreb
Historical memory as a divisive force? National identity, exclusionism and xenophobia in an ethnically diverse society
One of the top priorities in Latvia recently defined by the government is preserving the national identity culture, language, and Latvian history. Among other things, it has resulted in calls for teaching children patriotism and increasing the number of Latvian history classes in schools. Nevertheless, recent scientific evidence suggests that some forms of nationalism can have very negative consequences, especially in an ethnically diverse society with a history of several wars, mass deportations, and Soviet occupation, such as Latvia. Using data on youth in Latvia collected as part of the MYPLACE research project, we explore whether a strong and vivid memory of recent national history particularly the WW II, Stalins purges and mass deportations, communist occupation and regaining independence in 1991 can facilitate the development of ethnic nationalism. Ethnic nationalism, on the other hand, can become a divisive force, as it fuels internal and external exclusionism, xenophobia, national and welfare chauvinism. We conclude that even though remembering history and preserving national language and identity is important, in some contexts placing an increased emphasis on certain historical events and fuelling ethnic nationalism can be counter-productive. Instead, focusing on the present and the future, and building an over-arching civic national identity based on respect for countrys institutions and laws might help to overcome grievances, reduce support for populist right-wing parties, and lessen social rifts and ethnic tensions within the country, leading to a more inclusive and less discrimi Keywords: history, national identity, national and welfare, chauvinism, exclusionism, youth Mikula Maja, University of Technology Sydney / Nottingham-Trent University
Others in Heritology: Private Collectors' Nostalgia and Creation of Local and Personal Memories
In this paper we would like to address issues pertaining to un-institutional contemporary practices of collecting and display. We would like to present several private collectors active in Serbia artists and private entrepreneurs whose practices of collecting and display reflect both their interests in heritage and their need to present objects in their possession to wider public. They usually acquire the objects they collect at flea markets. Some of them, such as Vladimir Peric Talent and Sasa Rakezic Zograf, use these objects in their art works, or present them as found objects, turning these into artworks. Some of them, the private entrepreneurs, use these objects to recreate a past, usually with nostalgia for an "ideal", as in cases of Manual Museum of Forgotten Arts in Novi Sad, or coffee shop "Wonder" in Belgrade, or coffee shop "Des Arts" in Sombor, all in Serbia. In these cases, these recreations of a past are used in business settings in order to attract customers, usually those with similar sensibilities. Whichever the case, all of these collectors share the same qualities of character: they are eager collectors, and they tend to document and classify the objects of their possession, their huge knowledge of the past is based in their collecting practices and interests, regardless of their tendencies to create narratives about private and local histories in terms of nostalgia. Keywords: private collectors, artists collectors, entrepreneurs as collectors, local history, personal narratives Mlakar, Anja: Department of Ethnology and Cultural Anthropology (Faculty of Arts, University of Ljubljana, Slovenia)
50 different- less reactive, and maybe more pacific- prospects for the future. A similar undertaking was proposed by Henri de SaintSimon when he diverted the term avant-garde away from its military implementation towards more a progressive usage. The avant-garde became an experimental association of artists working together for the benefit of society as an evolving whole. In On Social Organisation Saint-Simon described the avant-garde as follows: They [the artists, the men of imagination] will lead the way in that great undertaking; they will proclaim the future of mankind; they will bring back the golden age from the past to enrich future generations; they will inspire society with enthusiasm for the increase of its well-being by laying before it a tempting picture of a new prosperity. Economic prosperity might well be an appealing prospect for us, especially in these times of crisis when we are made to feel that our day-to-day existence is precarious. However, when Saint-Simon employs the term new prosperity, he is envisaging social values that are largely incompatible with capitalist consumer culture and competitive market forces. His suggestion that new technologies should serve to nationalize luxury and internationalise peace would require a radically different approach to social organisation from that prevalent today. Likewise, the demilitarized bunkers I wish to analyse also figure as alternative visions for living together. They therefore also offer forms of critical resistance to the current promotion of isolating individualism, bolstered national identity and protectionist border-controls. Keywords: cultural transformation/ historical reinscription, bunkers Murphy, Helen: Royal Central School of Speech and Drama, University of London
Living with the Dead Memory and State Authority in Post-socialist Vietnam
Since its birth in 1945, the Socialist State of Vietnam has had to deal with the projects of nation-building and modernization in which the state sought to reconstruct an official discourse of the past and marginalizing the others. State authority and its attempts to legitimize certain memories have been represented in the policies on religious and ritual practices being carried out for several recent decades. During the period of wars the State created a restrictive but controversial atmosphere regarding religious and ritual activities. In the one hand, Vietnamese Socialist State rejected the belief in the existence of a divine or supernatural entity (-ies) and superstitions (e.g., fate, geomancy, astrology, divination, and spirit mediumship), and officially the government opposed religion since they considered
51 it as primordial identities. In the other hand, the state remained ambivalent about one key concept of Vietnamese ritual life - the existence of the souls of ancestors and the veneration of the dead. As a rarely legitimate religion, the worship of the dead became an essential tool for the State to reconstruct and popularize an official discourse on nationalism. The State attempted to shift the focus of worshipers from the dead members of their families or communities to officially approved heroes, dead soldiers, martyrs, etc. Moreover, based on such traditional belief, the State invents their own rites related to commemoration of the war dead, through which they reconfigure the past, national heroes, and revolutionary martyrs in order to demonstrate characteristics of official national image such as solidarity, patriotism as well as the states prestige. More than ten years after the unification of the country taking place in 1975, in December 1986 the Sixth Party Congress of the Communist Party of Vietnam was held in which the government adopted a general policy of renewal or renovation (doi moi). Socially, this meant a loosening of state controls on religious and ritual practices. As a result, many ritual practices and traditional belief have been witnessed in contemporary social and cultural landscape of Vietnam. However, while the state has relaxed some restrictions on religious and ritual practices, the government has continued to maintain control over the institutional life of organized religions. Based on the certain issue of ritual practices, particularly the worship of the dead, this paper seeks to examine the relationship between state authority and the construction of collective memory as well as the contestations happening in this process. How and why certain memories would be selected while the other would be marginalized? How social memory relates to the establishment of nationalism and modernization under the government of a socialist state? How different political factors negotiate and contest the authority of the state in selecting and legitimating social memory? Keywords: Memory, socialism, state, nationalism, modernization, ritual, religion, ancestors, heroes, martyrs Nikodinoska Jelena, Sorbonne Nouvelle University Paris 3 / University of Texas at Austin
Sandra Cisneross The House on Mango Street: (collective) memory resonating from the barrio
The people I wrote about were real, for the most part, from here and there, now and then, but sometimes three real people would be braided together into one made-up person I cut apart and stitched together events to tailor the story, gave it shape so it had a beginning, middle, and end, because real life stories rarely come to us complete. Emotions, though, cant be invented, cant be borrowed. All the emotions my characters feel, good or bad are mine. (xxiii) Although Sandra Cisneros draws on autobiographical elements in The House on Mango Street (1984), her novella does not stand for an autobiography, but it rather represents a collage of events, characters, and places that independently from one another constitute vignettes. These vignettes are not necessarily chronologically related, yet they make up a whole of voices, stories, colors, and movements that once reverberated along Mango Street. Through her (Cisneross) stories, Esperanza Corderos stories, and Esperanzas neighbors stories, Cisneros conveys the Southwestern Latino experience of the big city and the streets, of the barrios that is. Taking my cue from Cisneross The House on Mango Street, I will try to examine how personal experiences become memories and those memories transcend into stories. Is what comes from experience and memory that make writing strong, powerful, persuasive, and to a certain extend relatable? Has Cisneross memories, reflected in Esperanzas living experience and language contributed to the Latinos collective memory of the life in the barrios coupled with racism, poverty and shame? On that note, I shall see how Maurice Halbwachss concept of collective memory applies to Cisneros story and the Latino experience, where Latinos memory is dependent upon the life in the barrio within which the majority were/are situated. Keywords: Sandra Cisneros, Latinos, barrio, story, (collective) memory, Maurice Halbwachs Nikolova, Diana; Aleksandrova, Sonya, Plovdiv University Paissii Hilendarski, Faculty of Languages and Literature, Bulgaria
52 Noam Tirosh, Department of Comunication Studies, Ben Gurion University of the Negev. Israel
Do We Remember Them All? The Representation of the German Resistance to Nazism in Holocaust Museums in France, Israel and the United States
Politically designed and influenced by social and political processes, collective memory is a major component in the construction of a shared national identity. . Among other political institutions, the museum plays a central role in establishing a societys collective memory. Extensive scholarly writing about collective memory this issue, which started emerging in the 1980s, was concerned with World War II and the Holocaust, yet even historical aspects pertaining to these historic events have taken on different characteristics in different countries, in which memory and forgetness were simultaneously combined. One such aspect of WWII is the history of the German resistance to the Nazi regime. This paper suggests that academic focus on "marginalized" historical issues such as the German resistance enables a better understanding of collective memory and helps its development from an amorphous theoretical term without explanatory capabilities to one that highlights the political and social power relations guiding it in different contexts. Analyzing three prominent Holocaust Museum exhibitions: "Yad Vashem" in Jerusalem, The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, DC, and the "Memorial de la Shoa" in Paris, and using qualitative content analysis methods treating the Museums exhibitions as texts, this work reveals the significant effects of memory work. For example, in Jerusalem's Yad Vashem, German Resistance is almost completely ignored. In Paris, the resisters are significantly present, however in many cases their treatment is merely factual and their actions are harshly criticized. By contrast, in the United States some of the German resisters are described as moral role models who symbolize the universal struggle against the human tendency to remain a bystander in the face of atrocities. The paper demonstrates the significance of purportedly marginal stories in developing collective memory and in effecting historical understanding while shaping moral and political lessons emanating from shared histories. Keywords: Memory, Collective memory, Collective Forgetness, Holocaust, Resistance, German Resistance, World War 2 Norbert Reck, universities of Berlin, Saarbrcken and Munich
53 oppressed ones, Maja Haderlap has succeeded to present the peripheral Slovene culture as central to contemporary intercultural dialogue. Engel des Vergessens is not only a felicitous continuation of the distinguished literature by Carinthian Florijan Lipu, but is also in line with similar aspirations to present general historical themes through the family narratives in which an individual figures as a stranger and outlaw: Marko Sosi from Italy (Tito, amor mijo, 2005) and Ale ar from Slovenia (O znosnosti/On Tolerability, 2011). Keywords: cultural memory, Slovene minority in Carinthia, autobiographic novel, family narrative, crippled identity Novik, Alexander A.: Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera) of the Russian Academy of Sciences., Saint-Petersburg
Ethnic affiliation, common memory and traditional culture of macedonian Muslims in Albania: adaptating and preserving the identity (Fieldworks of 20082010)
The paper is devoted to the question of ethnic affiliation of Macedonian Muslims in conditions of combined ethnical neighborhood. There are around ten settlements with Macedonian population in the Eastern part of the Republic of Albania (Mac. Golo Brdo, Alb. Golloborda). Five scientific researchers from St. Petersburg: Andrej Sobolev, Alexander Novik, Denis Ermolin, Maria Morozova and Alexandra Dugushina (Institute of Linguistic Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography and St. Petersburg State University) had organized fieldwork in the villages Trebisht, Klenje, Ostren etc. in 2008-2010. The author puts into academic context a new description of almost unexplored Macedonian community. The data have been obtained during the fieldworks in Eastern Albania. In conditions of long-term neighborhood with other languages and religious denominations, the adapting mechanisms have worked out specific approaches to preserving ethnical identity and traditional culture, perceiving their value and necessity of translating to descendants. Materials of fieldwork include data about identity, language, culture of Macedonian community in different periods of the state of Albania (Osmanli time, Royal Albania, Enver Hoxha monism period, post-communist transition, modern republic). These expedition materials are archived in the Kunstkamera (Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography of the Russian Academy of Sciences). The founds of the Museum have traditional clothes of Macedonian Muslims from Golo Brdo which are collected during the fieldworks 20082010. Keywords: Macedonian Muslims, Albania, common memory, narratives, identity combined ethnical neighborhood, traditional culture. Nugent Maria, Australian National University
54 hand groups that have emerged with various names have become both rivals and have also complemented themselves. Orchestras and other groups can perform together especially at the weddings of Macedonia immigrants. Orchestras using traditional instruments and other groups are indispensable parts of transition periods such as weddings, circumcision ceremonies, military service farewells. In addition to this, the immigrant institutions also organize special nights that host these musical groups and create a common perception binding the participants to their common past. In this aspect, the selection of songs that reminisce of the old days play a binding role in the patterning of cultural identity. This article will try to understand the identity debates of the Balkan immigrants in the Izmir city amdibi example using observations and interviews with musicians. Keywords: Balkan immigrant, identity debate, wedding musicianship Orli, Ivona, Ethnographic Museum of Istria
Feeling the past: Television archive material and cultural memory in the series Uutishuone
Contemporary European television is increasingly invested in recycling its own past. The televisual past becomes a part of the contemporary media landscape in the form of reruns and DVD releases, as clips of archive material in documentaries and commemorative programmes, and on Internet archives such as YouTube. As a result, there is an increasing need to understand how the circulation of television archive material contributes to the construction of cultural memory. This paper studies how the use of television archive material in fiction provides material for cultural memory through a close reading of the Finnish drama series Uutishuone (Newsroom, YLE, 2009). The series chronicles the experiences of a young female journalist working at YLE television news from the late 1960s to the early 1980s, making prominent use of television archive material in its narration. Im particularly interested in the affective uses of television archive material, asking what kinds of felt relations to Cold War era Finland Uutishuone constructs. Uutishuone uses archive material as an affective element in three ways: in scenes that describe the experience of watching memorable moments of television; to express the characters feelings, often by editing archive
55 material into a montage sequence accompanied by popular music; and by using footage from old news reports to create a sense of pathos by emphasizing the gap in knowledge between the series characters and the viewers who already know how history developed. Television archive material acts as documentary evidence of the past, but equally importantly it works as a affective element that at times creates connections between the viewer and the characters, at other times creates a sense of distance between the moment of viewing and the historical events depicted. Understanding this affective dynamic is crucial to understanding how the series constructs cultural memory of Cold War era Finland. Keywords: Cultural memory, television, archive material, affect Palch Martin, Institute of Theatre and Film Research of Slovak Academy of Sciences
Subjective (alternative) history in Czech and Slovak documentary cinema after 1989
In Czechoslovak cinema, shared by both Czech and Slovak film makers alike, it is rather unlikely to find particular examples of Czech and Slovak documentary films that deal with the issue of subjective history. The amount of films with the subjective interpretation of history didnt appear in both national cinemas until immediately after the division in 1993. This turn is connected with the new theme of coping with the national past and also with the uncovering of the collective identity and re- evaluation of the past, based on the impact of the historical events on the subject of individual. Keywords: Czech cinema, Slovak cinema, documentary film, subjective history, collective identity Panova-Ignjatovik Tatjana, Ss. Cyril and Methodius University Skopje, Blazhe Koneski Faculty of Philology
The Macedonian Womn Through the Prism OF THE British Travel Writers (From the beginning of the 20th c. until the end of the First World War)
This paper offers a comparative cultural analysis on the travel writings of the British authors such as G.F. Abbot, H.N. Brailsford, W. Miller, A.Upward, E.P. Stebbing and I.E. Hutton, focusing on the position of the Macedonian woman. They were direct witnesses of the events that took place in Macedonia in the period before and after the Ilinden uprising and in the course of the First World War, an exceptionally critical period for the future of the Macedonian people. Their observations regarding the Macedonian women reflect the specifics and the values of the Macedonian cultural identity and tradition. Moreover, their travel writings provide positive and negative stereotypes about the Macedonian women. However, they were deeply moved by their subordinate position and primitive lifestyles, and the stance that prevails in their works on Macedonia was, in fact, an outcry against the subjugation of the Macedonian people. Keywords: travel writing, Macedonia, Macedonian woman, cultural identity and tradition Panovski Naum, Poiesis Theatre Project, New York (USA)
CitySpace = CyberSpace = Poiesis-Space: a cultural and performing arts model as a new form of cross cultural engagement
Summing up the 20th century cultural and theatre experiences, - including the tradition of engaged theatre from Brecht to Boal and Heiner Mller and utilizing the work of POIESIS THEATRE PROJECT, this lecture/presentation will address one possible creative model which envisions a fusion of the performing arts, new online media, and culture. It will also introduce a vision for a new creative model open to us as a Poiesis Space. That is, the this lecture/presentation will discuss the idea of a specific cityspace, as an urban cultural and arts environment, which is working at the crossroads of different aesthetics and disciplines and one which is breaking down the barriers between artistic disciplines and cultures. The presentation will also introduce a vision for a new performing arts environment built for and by the people. It is a place as a cultural center at the heart of the city/polis and as a creative platform searching for new up-and-coming interactive forms in the electronic age and developing new models in our real and cyber space community. The presentation will also introduce an idea, an already attainable dream of a cityspace, which provides room for braiding and blending of different forms - performing and visual arts, film and computer design, new electronic media, architecture, the sciences and interactive online education, and provides a model of multi-cultural exchange in a new meaningful artistic entity. In so doing, on the one hand it becomes an open space for sharing our local, global, real and cyber neighborhoods while on the other it becomes a meeting platform for interactive interchange and communication that only arts and culture can provide in our global village. Keywords: Cityspace/Platform, Crossroads, Poiesis, Interchange, CyberSpace / Multiculturalism Pavlii Jelena, Centre for Museology and Heritology, Faculty of Philosophy Belgrade / Faculty of Arts, University of Pristina Kosovska Mitrovica
Narrative of cultural heritage: theory and practice - Church of St. Nikola in Pristina
Depending on the context in which the subject of past achieves a particular communications, is interpreted and used, the value of this subject is changed. The object polysemy is causing this so we are always challenged to rethink the phenomenon of heritage. In this paper we are doing it through examination of the concept of time, from linear to narrative one. Shaping the meaning of the past is followed on the route of a sense of self to the sense of everything - from individual images of past to those of collective one. These images of the past are product of selective forgetting and active process of remembering, and are part of narrative time concept through which we read and examine heritage object. The case study of this theory and focus
56 of this paper is 19th century church of St. Nikola in Pristina. We are following the life and meaning of this object in the old city center through the period of existence and ideas that enriched it. The aim is to recognize and discuss place of the church in the cultural memory of town, and opposite. Keywords: time concept, remembering, images of the past, narrative, structure of cultural heritage, church of St. Nikola in Pristina, cultural memory of town Pekka Pennanen Risto, School of Social Sciences and Humanities, University of Tampere
Traditional, Age-old and Rewritten Inventing Bosniak History through Sevdalinka Songs
The paper analyses the canonisation of invented traditions in Bosniak politics of memory in music. Nowadays, many Bosniaks interpret Bosnian traditional urban songs sevdalinke through the nostalgia for the glorified Ottoman past and the post-Yugoslavian Bosniak culture and identity. In popular discourse, such purportedly old and traditional songs form a part of the Bosniak history book, which portrays Bosniak culture, traditions and habits. These trends are connected with invented traditions, which comprise traditions that are blatantly invented, constructed and formally initiated. In Titoist Yugoslavia, the ethnic background of professional sevdalinka singers and musicians varied considerably, whereas the rise of nationalism after the mid-1980s and the Bosnian War shifted the emphasis towards the Bosniak character of the genre in scholarly and popular representations. Opened in 2008, Art kua sevdaha, the Sarajevo museum of sevdalinka, in one of the best indicators of the development in Bosniak musical history culture; the historical dimension of the exhibition does not go back further than the the age of folkloristic festivals and mass media of the post-Second World War era. The expansion of the sevdalinka repertoire requires attention since a number of Serbo-Croatian-language Orientalist songs even parodies from the pre-Second World War era have become canonised, serious representations of the Bosniak identity. In addition, Bosniak authors have created new sevdalinke out of pre-existing Bosnian and non-Bosnian songs by amending the lyrics. The volumnious output of Omer Pobris (1945-2010) privately-run Institute of Sevdah (Institut sevdaha) is crucial for the analysis of the rewriting and canonisation of the repertoire. The sources of the paper consist of commercial recordings from 1928 till today, scholarly and popular writings on music, CD sleeve notes, television programmes and audiovisual recordings from concerts. Keywords: Bosnia, sevdalinka, memory politics, invention, canonisation Perasovi Benjamin; Mustapi Marko, Institut drutvenih znanosti Ivo Pilar
Football, Politics and Cultural Memory: The Case of HNK Hajduk Split
Memory is not something given or fixed, it is specific process which includes various definitions and re-definitions, interpretations and re-interpretations (Hobsbawm, 1991; Olick 2006). Cultural memory could change through time and space; production of cultural memory depends also on various social actors. Starting from such position we wish to present main discourses and types of changes in interpretations of 102 years long history of Croatian football club Hajduk from the city of Split. Rogi (2000) divided contemporary Croatian history in three most important phases 'primitive capitalist modernization' (from 1868. to 1945.), 'totalitarian socialist modernization' (from 1945. to 1990.) and 'transition' (from 1990. till today). In similar manner, we should divide history of Hajduk in three key phases: from 1911. when the club was founded to the end of the WW2. Second phase is marked by the Yugoslav period, from 1945. to 1990. The third phase starts with the independent Croatian state and the foundation of Croatian football league (1992). The presidents of the club and whole management, in all three periods, belonged to the local and national political/economical elite. Political elites were most influential social actors, shaping and changing interpretations of the past, in this case it means shaping relation to symbols and history of the club itself. The direction of those changes is linked to dominant discourses of particular social periods. While emphasis on Croatian identity of the club was silenced in the Yugoslav period, in the recent period of Croatian state, the anti-fascist component of the identity of the club is mostly forgotten or denied. Our thesis is based on the qualitative analyses of official books and monographs on the history of the club, with our focus on permitted and forbidden stories. Keywords: football, Hajduk, Croatia, cultural memory, political elite, political power. Pitrolo, Flora: Roehampton University, London
'This Message was Recorded before your Departure': remembering imagined future and past geographies in Magazzini Criminali's Crollo Nervoso (1980)
In 1980 the Italian theatre company Magazzini Criminali staged Crollo Nervoso, a largely forgotten piece which, at the time, was critically considered as an apex of Italian postmodernity on stage. The performance, articulated into four scenes, takes place in four dimensions other than Italy in 1980, namely: 'Mogadishu 1985', 'Los Angeles International Airport three years later', 'Saigon 21st July 1969' and 'Africa August 2001'. The mise en scne of the piece makes present imaginations of three spatio-temporal dimensions in the future and one in the past: as they stand now, these imagined displaced futures and pasts seem to mostly illuminate a certain self-imagination of Italy in 1980, and act as a sort of affective fantasy from which to measure how imaginations of the future and the past have changed. Furthermore, the fact that Crollo Nervoso was a live performance means that, although it has been recorded in various ways, its ontological status in the archive is slippery: it has acquired sideways modes of circulation, which multiply and complicate its possible readings. This paper, moving from the specific case study of Crollo Nervoso, seeks to look at how imagined geographies and futuresas-history circulated in the context of early 1980s Italian postmodernism; at the same time, it seeks to advance hypotheses on how these imagined times and spaces may still be at work in the present imagination, considering Hans Belting's notion that 'it is within the human being, and only within the human being, that images are received and interpreted in a living sense' (Belting 2001, 37 Keywords:
57 Pjeivac eljka
Between museum, monument and memorial: Daniel Libeskinds Jewish Museum in Berlin (1999)
The main thesis of this paper is that the Jewish Museum in Berlin is moving between museum, monument and memorial. In other words, this museum is place of memory (lieu de mmoire) in the Pierre Noras sense of meaning. This thesis aims to explore this architectural object in the frames of cultural studies. The central foci of this paper are not just artistic (productional, technical, stylist, etc.) problems as specifics of autonomous world of arts, but problems of locating architecture within culture and representing procedures of culture within architecture. Through aesthetics of architecture this paper explores problems of representation and construction of cultural mechanism, relations between culture and power, history and memory, representation and construction of Jewish ethnical identity. What are the relations between memory and monuments, archives and museums? How the term place of memory operates in the context of architectural design of the Jewish museum? How is narrative of Jewish past represented through contemporary architecture of the Jewish museum, and how it can be read in the present? How does the architecture of this museum play the role in the construction and representation of Jewish collective memory? These are just ones of several key questions in this paper. As cultural studies is a heterogeneous field, this paper connects the following: theory of reception, narratology, cultural antropology, theory of film, curator practices, ethnology, and finally theory of performativity. Keywords: place of memory, museum, monument, memorial Poljanec-Bori Saa; Hornstein Tomi Caroline, Institute of Social Sciences Ivo Pilar
The Macedonia timeless - campaign for recognition: empirical insights into the limits of nostalgia as marketing concept in tourism.
The paper draws its key arguments from content analysis of 38 seminar papers produced by students over a three year period (2009 2012) as course requirement in Tourism Politics / Sociology of Tourism final year course within an Applied Academic Tourism Master program at a private University in Croatia. It reflects on a series of lectures on strategic tourism marketing in post-Yugoslav countries, in which different campaigns were comparatively discussed - the 1984 Slovenian National Tourist Office campaign Slovenia my country /Slovenija, moja deela, as well as subsequent campaigns such as the Slovenian Sunny side of Alps/Sunana strana Alpa, the Croatian Mediterranean as it once was/Meditaran kakav je nekad bio, the Montenegrinian Wild Beauty/Divlja ljepota, and the Macedonian National Tourist Office campaign Macedonia timeless/Vjena Makedonija. While in 2009 students were asked to write evaluations of the last mentioned campaign, in 2011 and 2012 a comparative evaluation of the Slovenian and Macedonian National Tourist Offices campaigns was the course assignment, bearing in mind the difference of international political positions the two countries held in 2011 and 2012 with regards to the European Integration process. The paper will look into the underpinning interaction between strategic tourism marketing and situational institutional policies through comparison of the different campaigns. It will furthermore present the seminar conclusions and analyze the students resonance in particular on the Macedonian campaign as contemporary narrative by: looking into the perception of the campaign as a tool within the Macedonian striving for political recognition; discussing the reach and effects of nostalgia as a concept employed by tourism campaigns; suggesting that home as correlating concept and metaphor is profoundly ambiguous in its meaning. Keywords: Polona Sitar, Research Centre of the Slovenian Academy of Science and Art (ZRC SAZU)- Centre for interdisciplinary Research
Italians looked down on us, but they had stuff: Cultural memory of cross-border shopping in socialist Yugoslavia after the mid-1960s
The contribution deals with a cultural memory and a tourism in the case of cross-border shopping in Slovenia, a former socialist republic of Yugoslavia. The analysis is based on in-depth interviews that provide oral narratives about cross-border shopping to Western capitalistic countries. The contribution examines ritual of shopping abroad in the period between mid-1960s and late 1980s, since in the mid-1960s Yugoslavia opened up towards the West. It points out the special position that Slovenia had with its geographical location while sharing borders with Austria and Italia. The contribution is divided into two parts. In the first part a detailed description of shopping practices, especially its tactics and strategies with an emphasis on gender division and a detailed description of purchased items abroad is given. It also highlights feelings of shame and discomfort that were accompanying these consumption practices and stresses out the role of cross-border consumption in creating a new middle class which emerged in Yugoslavia during its economic progress in the 1960s. The second part places reasons for shopping abroad into a wider context of socialist economy. On the one hand political regulation allowed smuggling and tolerated the black market economy because this mitigated the consequences of unsatisfactory socialistic economy but on the other hand the dissemination of fashionable Western items helped to undermine it, since people recognized its products as obsolete, expensive and non-diverse. The contribution also makes an important distinction between shopping tourism and leisure tourism, since Yugoslav citizens travelled abroad in large numbers for both recreation and shopping and tries to provide a better understanding in which way cultural tourism is associated with memory. Keywords: cultural memory, socialism, shopping practices, smuggling, tourism
58 Plya, Tibor; Kvg, Pl, : Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience and Psychology, Research Centre for Natural Sciences, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary; University of Pcs, Institute of Psychology, Pcs, Hungary
Balkan cinema as cultural Other: film, history and cultural memory in post- Yugoslav context
Problematic and often contested reality of the Yugoslav breakup was addressed in numerous films made during the post- conflict years. Films such as Underground, Ulysses Gaze or Pretty Villages Burn Nicely, to mention a few, reflect on war years through specific authors approaches that surpass a clear narrative distinction between the issues of guilt and redemption or good and bad, but investigate often escaping nuances of regions complexity. Termed as Balkan cinema in film theory, these films seem to construct a specific, regionally circumscribed group that is often recalled when regional particularity and specificity needs to be established or asserted. Through the creation of Balkan cinema or in recent years, Balkan genre, film theory reasserts the problematic view of the Balkans as the European Other. This paper reflects on current tendencies in film theory regarding the films from the Balkans and analyses the ways in which knowledge production interacts and influence collective cultural memory and the processes of remembering. More broadly, it engages with the ways in which memory and history are used both in film and film theory. Keywords: the Balkans, film theory, Balkan cinema, cultural memory Radu Voica: Aurel Vlaicu University, Arad, Romania
59 Ramujkic Vahida; Cosentino Daniel, Independent artist and American University in Kosovo (AUK), Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT)
The Role of Memory in the Perception of the Identity of Serb Returnees to Croatia
This paper observes the role of memory of the events of the 1990s war in Croatia in identity creation. The entire paper derived from a field research I conducted in 2011 among Serb returnees to Croatia for the purpose of my Master thesis. The conclusion deriving from the analysis of the interviews was that nowadays, Serbs returnees vacillate between ethnic, communal and civic identities. The key issue standing in the way of their full integration into the Croatian civic society is the way in which the memory of the events of 1990s is preserved among Serbs and Croats respectively. By observing the memory and silence of both Croats and Serbs in Croatia through the lens of the study of memory and silence, it is possible to discern two different perceptions of the 1990s in Croatia. The way in which certain events are recorded in the memory of members of those two groups reveal that their memories are diametrically opposing. In this process the memory of one group is combating the denial and breaking the silence of the other group and vice versa. The inability to acknowledge their respective pasts stands in the way of the possibility of creating a single supra-ethnical social identity and fosters the creation of two mutually exclusive group identities. Keywords: memory, silence, identity, ethnic, civic, communal, Serb returnees to Croatia, Croats. Roga Mijatovi, Ljiljana: Faculty of Dramatic Arts in Belgrade, Serbia
Inquiring ones past through archives: the memory of the Spanish Civil War between literature and public policies
A number of literary works produced in contemporary Spain feature the memory of the Spanish Civil War (1936-1939) as a major component of their plots. Written by authors who cannot count on a biographical connection with the late Thirties, this kind of narrative displays a recollection of painful events which still appears to be fragmented, traumatized and conflictive. Among a vast variety of writing styles and genres, in my paper I intend to focus on a subject which I was able to record in several texts, namely the pursuit of personal and familiar identity through the intricate search of data referring to an old or deceased
60 relative whose life is mostly unknown by the enquirer. Be it due to the physical disappearance of that member of the family, or to the self-censorship performed by his/her fellow war-survivors, in these fictional works the lack of information generates a sensation of personal void and incompleteness. In the absence of communicative memory, a way for tracing ones familiar past is provided by documents scattered in archives and depositories located all over the national territory, and even out of its boundaries. Such literature as that described above mirrors one aspect of democratic Spain which is common to many postdictatorial countries, i.e. the public demand and need for free access to documentary archives. Since the narratives I could analyze mainly portray recherches characterized by countless obstacles, I find it useful to delve into the current Spanish legislation and politics of memory in order to provide an evaluation of the effective availability and accessibility of documentary material for a generic user. The ultimate aim is to verify whether the difficulty of the inquiry for information is a mere fictional element or is, in fact, a plausible description of the conditions of the Spanish archival system. Keywords: Spanish Civil War, archive, memory, contemporary literature. Rou Petra-Melitta, Aurel Vlaicu University of Arad, Romania
Cultural Memory in Contemporary Tourism Media Products: Culture-specific and Cross-cultural Perspectives
Communication practices which are part of the contemporary media-culture are intrinsically tied to the processes of (re)creating collective identities. One of the possible strategies in the frame of the mediated communication practice is to connect traditional elements of cultural memory with new ones, which are declared as preferable and acceptable. In that way the collective identity remains on one hand homogeneous, offering stability to the members of communication community, on the other hand it is the subject to change and dynamics, always ready to be reshaped in order to achieve wider acceptance. The tourism media products, especially tourism promotion videos, are the best examples for this mediated communication practice. The visual images, combined with text messages, i.e. slogans, are not only some of the most important narrative mechanisms in the presentation of a certain tourist destination, they are also key elements of the mediated collective cultural memory and identity of the respective country presented in the tourism promotion videos. The main goal of this conference contribution will be to examine the representation and composition forms of some of the tourism promotion videos both from the Balkan countries as well as from other regions worldwide related especially to the elements of the cultural memory in order to define culture-
61 specific and cross-cultural strategies relevant to the creation of the collective identity. The analysis will be based on the Critical Discourse Analysis, respectively the analytical framework of the Grammar of Visual Design by Kress/van Leeuwen. Keywords: communication practices, cultural memory, tourism media videos, visual and textual structures. Salom Sola-Morales, Autonomous University of Barcelona
TattooYU: Tattooed souvenirs from the Yugoslav Peoples Army and the regimes of memory of the body inscribed with socialism
The paper will focus on the first mass imprints on the body in the entire region of ex-Yugoslavia, which eternally marked members of its armed forces. Through bodies permanently imprinted with socialist history and narrations of tattooed solders from the Yugoslav People's Army (YPA), I install tattoos from YPA in-between the subversion of power and the incorporation of the dominant ideology, in the antithesis between uniformity and subjectivity (collective and individual identity). Above all, the tattoos from YPA function as a mnemotechnical practice of recollection of the cultural memory, which awakens the narrations and the regimes of memory as well as the regimes of memorization of the YPA, socialism and the period of (post)transition. This vibrant phenomenon will bring me to the problematization of the reading, deciphering, and categorization of tattoos. Whereas the collected ethnographical material will sustain the claims above, the situations in which the ethnography is made impossible will be discussed further. Rejection, reflex silence or refusal of collaboration are all ways and modes in which I stress the importance of the ethnography of absent (Telban). In this vein, they represent a fertile springboard to discuss notions of counter-memory (Foucault), productive oblivion (Kulji), forgetting (Ricoeur) and the eloquent reticence. The recollection of
62 negative sentiments (as a way of activating the past) did not only materialize in tattooees' non-responses. The tattoos from YPA also triggered practices of permanent tattoo hiding (cover-up, cicatrisation, surgery) that do not fit into the classical ethnographical milieu as practices of embellishment, rites of passage, strengthening the pain-tolerance threshold, etc. Instead, I see those practices as a preliminary phase of oblivion and as ways of de-ideologization. Furthermore, I supplement Connerton's habitual memory preserved in the body, which conserves the past in the memory, with its material constitutional side on the body the tattoo. Keywords: Yugoslav Peoples Army, tattoo, memory, nostalgia, ideology Schulze Rainer, University of Essex, United Kingdom
Too Painful to Remember Too Painful to Forget: Roma Memories of the 1998-9 Kosovo War
In the armed conflict between ethnic Albanians and ethnic Serbs in Kosovo, the fate of the Roma, Ashkali and Egyptian communities has been largely overlooked. Both within Kosovo and outside, their experiences and memories remain widely unconnected to the wider narrative and collective memory of the conflict, even though they constituted a significant proportion of the overall population and one upon whom the war had an enormous impact. When Kosovos autonomy was revoked in 1989 by the Miloevi regime in Belgrade, the traditional position of Roma/Ashkali/Egyptian communities to refrain from involvement in Kosovo politics was no longer an option. During the armed conflict, they became involved on one side or the other some voluntarily, most coerced and under pressure. In the immediate aftermath of the war, Roma, Ashkali and Egyptians became the target of a campaign of violent retaliation, as many Albanians regarded them as willing collaborators in the repression of the Albanian community during the years of Serbian rule. Roma were subjected to physical abuse, rape, destruction of their property, eviction from their homes, and outright murder. The international peacekeeping force proved ineffective in protecting them. Up to 100, 000 Roma, Ashkali and Egyptians became uprooted, some fleeing to Western Europe, others to neighbouring countries, and many ended up as IDPs in makeshift camps. The German NGO Society for Threatened Peoples called the events in Kosovo the worst Roma pogrom since 1945. My paper is a first attempt to unlock the specific Roma/Ashkali/Egyptian memory of the Kosovo War by making their voices heard, using interviews that I am currently undertaking. I will also discuss the impact that a continued lack of acknowledgement of their experiences and memories is likely to have on the regions future, and propose ways of introducing Roma testimony into the general discourse of the recent past. Keywords: Ethnic conflict, Kosovo War, Memory, Individual, Collective, Inclusive, Oral History Roma (Ashkali, Egyptians) Selvelli Giustina, University Ca' Foscari of Venice
Cultural memory and national identity in Croatia: the case of the glagolitic monuments
My paper aims at presenting a particular pattern of cultural narrative expressed in the creation of monumental works and memorial paths in Croatia and connected with the use of the Glagolitic script, the first Slavic alphabet. In my presentation I will follow the passages that made this alphabet an element in the construction of a discourse of 'Croatness', starting from the first attempts to revitalize it and promote it made by regional agents in the '70s, up to contemporary times, when this alphabet has officially reached the status of symbol of national identity. One of the first examples I intend to present is the Glagolitic Alley, a 7 km memorial lane created in Istria thanks to the cooperation of artists and intellectuals and composed by eleven sculptures and commemorative headstones representing the history of the development of the script. Erected in 1976, it was meant to mark the 500th anniversary of the first mention of a Croatian printed book and 11 centuries since the creation of the Glagolitic. After the institution of an independent Croatia, the same alphabet became an useful element to propaganda purposes of a part of Croatian society that linked it to rhetorics exalting distinctiveness from the other republics and that sought to appropriate it as an exclusive element of identity. The promotion of this alphabet has continued with the erection of more monumental works and with another significant project such as the Baka Glagolitic path, consisting in 34 sculptures reproducing the letters of the alphabet in the Island of Krk. The significance of this project for purposes of cultural memory is accentuated by the fact that here is where the Baka Tablet was found, one of the oldest monuments to feature an inscription in the Glagolitic alphabet, and the first mentioning the ethnonim Croat. Keywords: Croatness, National Identity, Glagolitic Alphabet, Glagolitic Monuments, Ethno-Symbolism emberov, Kristina: Charles University, Prague, Faculty of Social Science, Institution for Communication Studies and Journalism
63 give a lot of tips how to survive in the years of financial crisis, what is now in Europe a big issue. Only if we know our past we can head towards the future. Keywords: Gastronomy, Czechoslovakia, 1918 1938, family food, woman magazines imi, Kreimir: Filozofski fakultet, Osijek
The (De)construction of Yugoslav Identity: Gendered Imagery and Ethnic Stereotypes in Croatian and Serbian Film Production During the Nineties
Media representations of ethnic imagery, mainly through the institutionalized praxis of socio-cultural reproduction of inequality, were strongly manipulated both in socialist Yugoslavia and, to a higher extent in the super nationalisms of the Nineties. Additionally, nationalistic rhetoric fueled Foucaults so-called praxis of bio-politics where political actors were officially enforcing (pro-natal) hetero-sexual policies, using them as mobilizing factor for war. Therefore reproductive processes became as well part of reproductive ideologies, which, especially in times of turmoil, heavily shaped nationalistic discourses and state propaganda. Women started to embody symbols of national purity and honor while one of their main responsibilities was to serve the courageous men and reproduce the nation biologically. As the national need for diversification grew, women simultaneously started to acquire territorial characteristics representing the symbolical boundaries of the nation, in which men were seen as the main protectors. Finally, when the mega force of nationalism escalated in warfare, women became equated to nations representing their material borders while men had to fight and safeguard the nation from the enemy. The annihilation of the other nation by invading/penetrating enemies nation/women eventually turned gender into territorialized ethnicity. The passage from a supra national idea, embodied in Yugoslavias brotherhood and unity to a super nationalistic one, depicted in the aggressive purity of the ethnos and nationhood in the 1990s, influenced the reemergence of traditional, patriarchal definitions of male and female imagery and their subsequent ethnic stereotypes. In this sense, the paper investigates, how and to what extent Croatian and Serbian film production during the Nineties influenced the (de)construction of Yugoslav identities. Keywords: Yugoslavia, film, nationalism, ethnicity, stereotypes, gender, symbolism Sobolev Andrey, St. Petersburg State University, Russian Academy of Sciences, Philipps-Universitaet Marburg, Germany
- ,
" " -. - (. . , . . , . . , . . , . . ) 2008-2010 . " - ", " - ", " - ", " - ", " " .., ( ), "" .
64 : , , - , " - ", " - ", " - ", " - ", " - ", , "" Soellner Louisa, LMU Munich, Department of American Literature
Reforming Revolutionary Myths: Photography in Castros Cuba and Tania Brugueras Tatlins Whisper#6
My paper introduces responses to photographs that emerged in the early years of the Cuban Revolution. Photography was a key medium for creating, spreading, and cementing myths about the Revolution and its leaders. The scope of the paper is twofold. On the one hand it aims at introducing the role of propagandistically engineered cultural memory in the context of Cubas Revolution, particularly with respect to some of the iconic pictures taken by photographers such as Alberto Korda or Jos Pepe Agraz. On the other hand I offer suggestions about the intricate manner in which photographs switch significance through re-contextualization and thus can become a powerful tool of subversion in contemporary Cuban art. Tania Brugueras piece Tatlins Whisper#6 (staged at the10th Havana Biennial in 2009) revisits well-known photographs of Castro with a white dove perched on his shoulder that were taken on 8th of January 1959. The work reiterates the scenario with the crucial difference that the leading parts (that of speaker and photographer) are played by Cuban visitors of the Biennial. Brugueras piece illustrates the degree to which iconic photographs of Castro make up part of collective memories and mythologies in Cuba, but it juxtaposes the evocation of these pictures with voices that usually remain unheard. Discussing Tatlins Whisper#6 will allow me to pose questions about tensions between personal and collective memory; the relevance of acts of picture taking for the fabrication of cultural myths; as well as the possibility of re-framing pictures and thus unsettling dominant approaches to a shared history. Keywords: Photography, Propaganda & Resistance, Performance Art, Globalization Sofo Giuseppe, Universit d'Avignon et des Pays de Vaucluse
Laboratoire de recherche identit culturelle. Textes. Thtralit. Carnival, Memory and Identity
The carnival of Trinidad and Tobago is a performative ritual of cultural resistance and awakening, claiming a space and celebrating freedom from any kind of oppression. The history of this ritual is strictly connected to the process of cultural decolonization and political independence of the Caribbean country from the mother(is)land; it is in carnival and for carnival that Trinbagonians have successfully fought against the British to gain their freedom. Imported in the Caribbean by French planters, as a ritual of amusement and temporary freedom, carnival in Trinidad and Tobago became, for the first time in the world, the instrument to earn an actual and non-temporary freedom, and the space for the celebration of a new interethnic national identity, obtained through the ritual itself. The present of carnival is divided between the memory of its glorious past, traditional mas, and a reality of bikini-and-beads costumes, ironically very close to the pretty mas that was imported from colonizers, and to the better-selling Brazilian carnival. The ritual that more than anything else shaped the national memory and identity of this country, is now pulled by two ends: the memory of a cultural-constructing ritual on one side, and the consumerism of a touristic product on the other side, attracting especially the many Trinbagonians abroad, and north-Americans. Will Trinidad carnival be able to defeat consumerism and neocolonialism, or will it just become another ritual of temporary freedom, as every other carnival in the world, and a way to attract tourists in one of the less touristic islands of the Caribbean? Past, present and future have to be discussed together for a real Keywords: carnival, memory, identity, cultural resistance, Caribbean pelec Sara, University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Arts, Department of Ethnology and Cultural Anthropology
Memorializing as resistance: Inscriptions of the nations body and soul in Timothy Mos The redundancy of courage
The present paper examines Timothy Mos quasi-fictionalised memorial to the genocide inflicted by Indonesia on the emerging nation state of East Timor, following its occupation in 1975. The Redundancy of Courage (1991) chronicles East Timors colonial and postcolonial history and its arduous process of national identity formation, interrupted by the aggression of neo-colonial powers serving the vested interests of global capital. The paper focuses on the narratives avowed function as a testimonial before the world about the young nations epic resistance and, more importantly, as its foundational heroic epic the discursive battle of memory against oblivion. It also dwells on the use of the traditional imagery of the body in representing nationhood as a unique organism. In analysing the rhetoric of nationalistic discourses, it highlights the key tropes and images deployed in figuring the nation as a new, discursively constructed body, narrated into being and kept alive through the ongoing narration of its birth, its growth, its battles and its dead. Ultimately, national identity resides in the inscription and preservation of its collective memories. Keywords: colonial, nation state, neo-colonial, national identity, genocide Stankovi, Isidora: Center for Museology and Heritology, Faculty of Philosophy, University in Belgrade
Spaces of Memory The presence of absence The cultural memory and oblivion mechanisms
The aim of this paper is to emphasize the role of tangibility, especially material places relevant for different social or interest groups in preserving and communicating with the past. According to different scholars cultural memory is frequently bounded to concrete manifestations spaces, gestures, images and objects. The first part of this paper would refer to a difference between biological and neurological foundation of memorizing and, on the other hand, the social aims that create relevant toponyms so that the group could more easily be identified with its past. Furthermore, the significance of oblivion in creating a groups memory will be recognized, but also its importance in creating mechanisms for remembering different aspects of the past. The second part of the paper will be dedicated to Pierre Noras definition of spaces of the past, as a way to revive the past eras and to place events, people and phenomena in our memory. However, Norras definition does not include only material spaces and places, but could also encompass the more abstract ones any idea of making connection with a past in literature, music, etc. with the purpose to avoid oblivion. In the third part of the text, Noras ideas of spaces of memory would be linked with Foucaults idea of heterotopias a way of intersecting things that could or could not be seen in realm of time and space. This thesis could, on the other hand, send us back to mechanisms of cultural and individual memory. At the end, spaces of memory will be regarded as the places of cultural encounters, therefore, of heritage itself as a phenomenon that combines different cultures with use of the past in present and guarding it for the future. Keywords: Memory, spaces of memory, oblivion, heritage. tatki Milena: Filozofski fakultet u Ljubljani; Heritologija i Muzeologija
Frames of Social Memory in Postwar Romania. The Sighet Memorial vs. the Museum of Communism
A museum of the totalitarianism in the sense given to the term by Hannah Arendt represents a contrasting architecture where the individual is embedded in the structures of the collective past, displaced, coerced to develop an attitude. With a view to healing, more or less, the trauma. Somehow, a spatial form of erotized social psychiatry. The exorcism and, at the same time,
66 the sublimation of our cultural and identitary memory and of our affects happen in such virtual or concrete environments which fall upon our consciousness and our emotions. In the postmodern, post-historical, post-human era we live in, alike the museums of Holocaust, the museums of communism satisfy besides their complex historical functions our need for socially, politically, ideologically and culturally driven voyeurism and consumerism. The museums of communism reflect our contemporary history much closer. Moreover, setting up a museum of communism nowadays constitutes a debatable question of political and ideological legitimacy. In most states of the former Eastern Bloc there are a series of museums dedicated to the communist regime. In Romania, the communist past still seems to play the curator role to our cultural memory and to our relatedness to the present. The Romanian post - Revolutionary realities expose more the recycling of the past under its persistent hypostasis than the systematic comprehension of its discursive significations. Given the present social context, creating a museum of the communism is perceived as nonsense. However, in Romania exists a Victims of Communism and of Resistance Memorial, founded in 1993 in Sighet, a town in the north of the country, by two writers, Ana Blandiana and Romulus Rusan. Unfortunately, as a way of reviving the collective memory, this place is not made popular enough. The study aims at exploring the process of collective identity restoring in this particular Institution of Memory. Keywords: museum of totalitarianism, communism, collective memory, The Sighet Memorial, contemporary history Stoimenova Canevska Emilija; Zivanovic Radmila; Stojkoska Vasilevska Marija, International Balkan University Skopje, Gestalt Institut Skopje
What historical narrative will the future generations have with the project Skopje 2014
The aim of our paper is to try and present what the Project Skopje 2014 would leave for the future generations as a national historical narrative that would represent the official history of our country and nation. With constructing official buildings and edifices, building over 30 sculptures dedicated to the Macedonian past, and erecting bridges full of statues of famous authors and cultural activists, is Macedonia presenting a truthful history of its past? Since modern theory provides analyses and contemplations of current cultural projects and events, adopting its own identity in the process of analysis and systematization of certain tropic discourse on which it is focused on, thus the importance of rethinking this cultural project, as a new process of identification for the Macedonian people. The problem starts when the specific elements of the projects are analyzed since the interpretation can come to a dead end because of the elementary inconsistencies. By trying to give some explanation of the entire project Skopje 2014 and by analyzing the personalities, i.e. the identities of the most important figures presented (most important since the magnitude of the sculptures is the highest in these cases, therefore concluding that these figures deserve the most attention) the statues of the Warrior on a Horse and Phillip II of Macedonia and his wife Olympia. Our stand is to try and demonstrate that in an atmosphere where the entire elements of the project are perceived as trops, as semantic knots begging to be interpreted, where the religious discourse has more power over the scientific one, there is the possibility that the Triad of a family (Alexander, Phillip and his Mother), by being emptied of their real historical background and significance is apt to adopt the spiritual meaning of the Holly Trinity, taking the place of Jesus, Marry and Joseph. Our analyses will provide sufficient theoretical support for this stand. Keywords: meta narration; public space; creation of national identity; history and memory transmitted through public monuments and architecture; Holly Trinity - new narrative in the figures of Alexander, Phillip and Olympia Stojkoski, Zdravko: Center for Culture and Cultural Studies
Attempts to re-read the Macedonian history, the issue of continuity and the role of cultural memory
The central topic of this research is the way Macedonian history is written and interpreted after the fall of the communist regime and the creation of the independent Macedonian state. The paper will attempt to interpret the new social circumstances from
67 the aspect of internal and external challenges and the negations of the Macedonian identity, which influence the way of viewing and interpreting the Macedonian history, and the relation to the history of neighboring nations and the wider region. In this context, the study and understanding of history will be related to the issue of individual, collective and national memory. The issue of memory will be taken into consideration i.e. how the process of memorizing and forgetting influences the interpreting and understanding of one's own history, and also how the interpretation of history in certain periods and social circumstances influences what remains remembered as a part of the collective memory, and what does not. In that context, the issue of continuity will be pointed out, as well as the right of owning a historic heritage. By creating a relation among the history, the memory and the continuity, the research will try to answer the reasons for the current tensions on the Balkans. Keywords: Macedonia, history, identity, culture, memory, continuity Stoi Mirjana, Faculty of Media and Communications, Singidunum University (Belgrade, Republic of Serbia)
Who Are We Now Then? The Welfare State Fantasy in Swedish Political Memory and Identity
In the late 1980s and early 1990s the Swedish welfare state underwent a crisis which led to a dramatic transformation of society that has continued up until today. The main node of this has been an adjustment to the global politico-ideological trend of privatization and individualism with a down-sized public sector ruled by market logic. Parallel with this Sweden has also changed from being relatively monocultural to becoming a more multicultural nation. Throughout these processes one constant has been how the memory and fantasy of the traditional Swedish welfare state has been used and fought over by different political parties. This paper deals with the struggle to appropriate this memory and to represent the fantasy. The Social Democrats, in power for most of the twentieth century, are seen as the architects of the Folkhem (Peoples home), a strong metaphor in Swedish history. But it was also the Social Democrats who under pressure from global economy initiated the neoliberal transformation through a series of decisions in the 1980s. Rhetorically they have treated this in two ways: one is through arguing that nothing really changed and one is through pointing out how much has changed but without acknowledging their own part in it. The ruling right-wing party (Moderaterna) has done so through changing their rhetoric from criticizing the Social Democrat welfare-state to now being the only ones representing its core-values and the only ones capable of adapting them to a new situation. Furthermore, the Folkhem-metaphor has also been central for the xenophobic far-right (Sweden Democrats), claiming that the demise of the welfare state is the result of excessive immigration. Discussing this spectrum, the paper deals with the Swedish welfare state as a political memory and fantasy and how versions of history always play a part in current politics. Keywords: welfare state, political memory, political fantasy, national identity, rhetorical struggle Susar Filiz A.; Kirlar Barokas Safiye, Istanbul Arel University
68 and New Zealand on the official holiday of Anzac Day. Veterans and their families stand and observe a minutes silence, hymn and say prayers in dawn services. The two nations, who think that the legend of ANZACs and the ANZAC spirit began in Gallipoli, feel that they were connected on this land. What the event means to the participants of the Anzac Day and what they recall about this day personally will be discussed in this study. In addition, the driving forces behind their participation and the significance of this event in the formation of individual and national identity will be examined in the light of analyses made on media texts and documentary films. Keywords: Anzac Day, identity, cultural memory, sense of belonging Battle of anakkale Szedlacsek Petru
Forgotten Topics of Slovenian History: Literature and its Contribution to the Creation of Cultural Memory
This paper tries to show the literature as an important part of building and conservation of the cultural memory of the society. Cultural memory belongs also to individuals and groups and they have a common reference point, which are often photos or objects that evoke the memory, event or commemoration which is an important part of identity. In this case is also important that literature through biographical or fictional stories represents space and time. Often fictional literature creates a genuine feeling of a memory to some particular times or events, because it had a wider range of stories, characters and situations and in this way is literature creating collective memory in a more concentrated form. On the case of some recent novels, especially written by Drago Jancar (To no sem jo videl - That night I saw her, Drevo brez imena - A tree with no name) and Duan arotar (Bilijard v Dobrayu - Billiards in Dobray) I will introduce the placement of some forgotten populations Slovenian space during the Second World War in to cultural memory. arotar in his work exposes the fate of the Jewish community in Prekmurje, reminds the Holocaust and Hungarian domination. Next to approaching the boundary areas of the country and the memory to the centre and cultural memory of a centre, is also dealing with feelings of provinces and cities. Drago Jancar addresses in his recent works also the World War II., but the centre of his narrative focuses is on two groups, which after the war no longer existed: a wealthy family, which has lost their possession and have emigrated or was even executed and Home Guards, who were opposing to the partisans/communist takeover of country and were killed after the war. Their memory and also the memory of them is erased. Keywords: Slovenian novel, ideology, cultural memory, communism, anticommunism Todorovska Marija, Institute for Philosophy, Faculty of Philosophy, University Sts. Cyril and Methodius
Rituals and Memory an Exploration of Primordial Religious Phenomena and the Persistence of the Sacred in the Modern World
In the paper the sentiment of the sacred and religious ritualisation will be explored, through phenomenology of space (sacred places/profane places; places of worship); the meaning of sacred practices; and the nature of sacred understood by homo religiousus. Questions about the different aspects of the purpose of the sacred practices, as well as the extent to which they differ shall be tackled in the context of totemic rites, mythopoesis and lore, and collective representations. The ideas of sacred space and sacred places as grounds for performative ritual acts shall be analysed in totemism, later religious phenomena, and recent lore. Questions about the persistence of piacular rituals shall be posed in the light of the presumed decline of the sacred in the modern world, along with several other categories of sacrificial action. The concept of social memory shall be pondered
69 in relation to the piacular rituals as the essence of the communities identity. The mechanisms of social memory and the identification through culture tend to sometimes complicate the creation of identity dependent on the memory, which, on its part, depends on the organisation and the ritualisation in the functioning of the communities. Sacred sacrificial rituals and specific piacula are possible only with common interpretation of the history, hence, the question arising is whether the different views endanger the ritualisation and obliterate the possibility for consistent social memory, or only make it more versatile and laden with rich complexity. This is also applicable to lore and the representation of phenomena and beings that are not necessarily sacred, like latent ritual initiations, and mythical creatures that have been transformed into fable beings and fable characters, and are scattered through cultures as a reminder of a sacred past. Keywords: Sacred, Rituals, Piacula, Lore, Memory Tsereteli, Ivane: Institute of Cultural Studies, Iv. Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University
The Dynamics of Public Discourse and the Transformation of Collective Memory in the Post-Soviet Georgia
Collective memory is the subject of constant transformation and change. A discourse of remembering and forgetting is an uninterruptable process, although it becomes a subject of radical revision during a process of transition. In the 1990s Georgia was found in a new political-economic and social-cultural environment. although, the freedom of speech has led to the formation of a public discourse. Since 1980s the debates on overcoming the Soviet reality has become active in Georgia. Various visions and plans of transformation of society have been offered by leaders of national movement. Besides, intellectuals, who were more or less different from the Soviet Intelligentsia has started to talk on the future direction(s) of Georgias possible development and transformation. A new group of intellectuals appeared in the country after the dissolution of the Soviet Union; this was the generation which used to be students during the Soviet times. By the end of 1990s next generation went to the stage, which lived in the Soviet times in their early childhood. They have introduced some new accents into the policy debates. This was the period when the first signs of civil society appeared. Interestingly, this generation managed to come to the power of the state. The paper aims to analyze the dynamics of public discourse, with the aim to monitor a shift in accents, priorities and approaches; while on the other hand, it will try to determine the influence of these processes on a collective memory. Thus, the paper will try to find answers to the following questions: were there influences on a collective memory from the side of the above-mentioned processes? In what forms were they revealed? What is the influence of public discourse of the Georgian reality on the transformation of collective memory? Keywords: Collective memory, remembering and forgetting, Public Discourse, Post-Soviet Georgia, society, transformation Tucan Dumitru, West University of Timisoara
The cultivated memories and the sense of identity as competitive tools for the modern decisionmaking processes
The set of values, ideas and beliefs brings people together in their community. In order to become relevant, they necessarily have to be bridged, mediated and cultivated in collective and individual memories. The power of memories strongly impacts the creation of identity. The power of identity strongly impacts the power of state and its nation. The identification of the state and its nation in the new globalize world is one of the strong pattern of the modern decision-making processes and the main political acts. The use of this power and the chosen strategy for dealing with the collective cultural memories and identity heritage makes the differences among the emerging nation states in the competitive international scene. Therefore the cultivation and its use of the cultural memories and the sense of identity is joint responsibility of the state, the governments, the intellectuals, teachers, poets, painters etc. The nostalgia is one very strong memory of the citizens of the Republic of Macedonia, since its a form of expressing the need of identity and identification with the state they belong, where they feel safe, protected and encouraged to contribute as citizens. People collective memory can and should be used for creative and efficient decisions for shaping the modern collective identity, transcendent trough individual experience, with strong focus on the state reputation in the postmodern world. In this framework, this text will offer short overview of the contemporary practices
70 in cultivating the collective memories of the practical multiethnic cohabitant, suggesting that Republic of Macedonia, have reach cultural memory heritage which can and should be use as strong competitive decision-making tool in shaping our state influence and reputation among the emerging multicultural and multiethnic modern societies in Europe. This aspect emphasizes the need of relevant interpretation of the present in terms of the past cultivated cultural memories and the sense of identity in modern context, in order to decide on possible actions for the future. The summary offers an overview of the country-specific cope with the inherited values, specifics, cultural memories and identity in modern context and circumstances, as indicator of the citizens inclusion in the democratic decision-making processes. Keywords: Cultivated memories, identity, cultural memory, public memory, decision-making processes, citizens, nostalgia Tupchiienko-Kadyrova Liutsia, Kirovograd faculty KNUCaA of Kyiv National university of culture and arts
( )
. , , , , , , . , , , . , . , , () . . (1976). , , . . , , , , , , , . , , .. , , , . , , , , , , . , , : , , . . , (1974), , , (1995), , . - , , , - , - . : , , , , Vnnen, Aino-Reetta: Helsinki University, Finland
JNA and the Yugoslav identity. The case of Mujo and ole.
The purpose of this this paper is to examine the role of the Yugoslav Peoples Army (JNA) in the forming of a Yugoslav citizen. Can we find an agenda of forging a particular Yugoslav identity through the JNA? Was the agenda official? How effective was it
71 in reality? What characteristics did it have (common language, the partisan myth etc.)? The military service in the JNA is investigated as building material in creating and strengthening of collective Yugoslav identity. For the purpose of this study, I view JNA as represented by the shared memories, nostalgia and emotions of the men who served in the JNA. My analysis is textual and contextual: I analyse the material in the light of the theories of identity and collective identity according to Hall (1996). The theoretical framework bases on social constructivism, the idea of reality as a social construction, as presented by Berger and Luckmann (1966). My research material consists of interviews with former JNA servicemen, who served together in Pej, Kosovo, SFR Yugoslavia. These interviews are reflected through recent research that include Bojan Dimitrijevis article Armija i jugoslovenski identitet 19451992. godine (2006) and Tanja Petrovis article Nostalgia for the JNA? Remembering the Army in the Former Yugoslavia (2010). My analysis indicates that, within the JNA, there was a set agenda for creating a strong collective Yugoslav identity, a Yugoslav citizen. Further, the results point out that the shared experience in a multiethnic, Yugoslav society, with the imposed lingua franca, Serbo-Croatian, had a significant impact and the shared memory of the military service in the JNA stays strong. Keywords: Yugoslav Peoples Army, identity, construction, memory, agenda Vasiljevi Marija, Centre for museology and heritology, Belgrade
Relation and attitude of the young people toward "problematic/difficult past" of the Second World War (1941 1945) and the Homeland War (1991 1997) in Croatia
Institute of social science Ivo Pilar is one of the sixteen research institutions from 14 European countries participating in the research project MYPLACE (Memory, Youth, Political Legacy And Civic Engagement) on the theme Democracy and the shadows of totalitarianism and populism: the European experience. One of the goals of this project is to explore how young people's social participation is shaped by the shadows (past, present and future) of totalitarianism and populism in Europe. This project is diveded into ten sections ("work packages), and within the second one, Interpreting the past (The construction and transmission of historical memory), is analyzed young peoples interpretations of the difficult/problematic period in the national/regional history. In Croatian context it is analyzed difficult period of the Second World War (1941 1945) and the Homeland War (1991 1997). Research is methodological based on expert interviews and focus groups with young people in the sites of memories (Jasenovac Memorial Site and Croatian History Museum) and analyze of the relevant sources and literature. The intention of this presentation is to analyze the results of this study with special focus on how are the problematic/difficult periods in the national history of Croatia represented and interpreted in the mainstream historical discourse and to find out how are theses historical memories experienced (interpreted, internalised and enacted) by young people. In other words, one of the goals of this presentation is to point out some of important aspects of traumatic moments in recent Croatian national history and to find out how it is, this kind of cultural memory transmitted across young generations. Keywords: Youth, History, Croatia, memory, Second World War, Homeland War. Vojak, Danijel; Tomi, Filip, Institute of social science Ivo Pilar
Cultural memory on the "great" people in the "small" town: Perception of the King Aleksandar Karadordevic and Marshal Josip Broz Tito in the cultural memory of Samobor
Nowdays we can defend thesis that ''history is written by the winners'' and therefore ''mainstream'' history can be understood as revised and politically instrumentalized mean of certain nation's ''cultural'' memory, which some consider as ''history of selective memorization and selective forgetivness''. In contemporary Croatian historiography most approaches which are focused on historical periods of monarhist and socialist Yugoslavia starts from the ''greater national'' themes. Similar preoccupation has not balked neither those historiographic approches which, as the main focus of their interest, put problems of analyzing and understanding how collective memories are being constructed. However, our aim here is to move from the ''greater'' themes to a ''smaller'' (local) setting. The example of a small Croatian urban centre, like Samobor, is going to serve us as theme for
72 analyzing in which way in that local setting rulers of two Yugoslavias King Aleksandar Karaorevi and Marshal Josip Broz Tito were being perceived? By analyzing relevant archival sources as well as contemporary periodics we would like to understand ways in which local authorities and elite, from the position of their social power and status, had received mentioned rulers in visit, in which ways they had been honoured and how were they are commemorated. We would like to understand proccess of creation of local social memory, constitution of memorial and cultural patterns, their key cultural elements and meanings, wnich are in moments of changes of social and state systems thorn apart, only to be constituted again by recombinating cultural and social elements as well as comprising other actors. In other words, center of analysis will be focused on tracing the collective memory of population of Samobor towards the ''great leaders''. Keywords: Samobor, Croatia, cultural memory, Aleksandar Karaorevi , Josip Broz Tito. Vos, Claske: University of Amsterdam/European Studies
Debating the Reconciliatory use of Heritage. European post-monumentalism versus Serbian national-monumentalism
In the 1990s numerous religious monuments were destroyed on the territory of Former Yugoslavia. Responding to this destructive use of heritage, the European Commission and the CoE developed the Regional Programme on Cultural and Natural Heritage in Southeast Europe. Since 2003 they have actively tried to change local perceptions on heritage in this part of Europe in order to facilitate the regions integration process into the EU. However, in Serbia, thus far not much openness has been shown towards this initiative. While the programme aims to bring about public debates about Serbias uses of the past, these discussions are systematically avoided. How this attitude affects the implementation of this programme is what this paper aims to discuss. It will become clear that introducing new narratives about the past in order to bring about reconciliation works out differently on the national and on the international level. While the European institutions urge for a European post-monumentalism, Serbia insists on its national monumentalism. Even though internationally there is a growing concern that heritage should heal, regional practices show that the potential for conflict on the basis of interpretations of heritage has not diminished. This poses new questions regarding the role heritage can play as an instrument to produce more inclusive memories. Is it possible and even desirable to come into terms with post-war realities and search for more accurate or inclusive histories by means of these kinds of programmes? If heritage is essentially dissonant is there not unavoidably also a risk that it will have the same effect regarding post-conflict heritage management? The paper will try to find some answers to these questions and provide new insights in the diverse responses to transnational trends in the field of heritage management which increasingly stress the importance of heritage as a factor in post-conflict action. Keywords: Heritage, reconciliation, resistance, Serbia, European integration Wagoner Brady, Aalborg University
Whose cultural memory is it, anyway?: jazz and nostalgia in contemporary Macedonia
Jazz has long played a role in the musical landscape of Macedonia, from the enduring public presence of the Skopje Jazz Festival to the recently opened jazz program at Goce Delcev University in tip. Over the last twenty years, a number of young musicians have studied jazz abroad, initially at the Berklee College of Music in Boston (i.e. Toni Kitanovski and Georgi areski) and more recently at the University of Music and Perforaming Arts in Graz, Austria. These musicians have returned to Macedonia wellversed in the techniques, repertoires, improvisational skills, and performance practices of jazz. Along with other Macedonian musicians who have acquired jazz musical skills and sensibilities through the transmitting the global flow of recorded music, these jazz musicians have been participating in a burgeoning scene in Skopje springing out of their embodied musical knowledge and its powerful social potential. As an oral tradition, jazz habitually references the past, presenting particular representations of cultural memory. As the Tavitjan Brothers draw on folkloric repertoires for their ethno-jazz aesthetic and as Leteki Pekinezeri perform original compositions in the styles of 1930s and 40s jazz, for example, they invoke cultural memories of two pasts, each one imagined and referencing musical symbols that signify different types of nostalgia. Following Svetlana Boym, I suggest that the Tavitjan Brothers evoke a restorative nostalgia of home and homeland, while Leteki Pekinezeri reveal a reflective nostalgia, mediating history and the passage of time and exploring ways of inhabiting many places at once (Boym 2002).
73 Through the examination of the aesthetic strategies of these groups, this paper discusses the ways and extent to which Macedonians use music to align themselves with (or distance themselves from) prominent discourses of the past in Macedonia. As they incorporate cultural memory from abroad, they not only demonstrate taste, but suggest ideological alternatives. Keywords: Yildiray Cevik, International Balkan University, Faculty of Languages, Skopje
Reflections of Cultural Memory in the Island of Disputes: Reading Durrells Bitter Lemons of Cyprus
The clean reading of Durrells Aegean travelogues favors the elaboration of memories of travels, a proper circumstance of getting involved in the cultural milieu of the island of Cyprus. Lawrence Durrells travel book Bitter Lemons of Cyprus (1957), which is based on his three-year stay on the island, a sojourn which coincided with the enosis crisis along with value, personal and cultural conflicts shows how representations of cultural and political conflicts are inextricably linked to representation of modern oriental thought. He sees the clashes of tension in living styles of bi-polar society, characters and British politics even though he claims to keep away from British politics. Islands cultural ideology of melting pot has been replaced by bi-culturalism in the recent decades. The novel is an embodiment of cultural identities in cleavages surviving for recognition which also demonstrates a need for the construction of an egalitarian bi-communal society. The novel is told of in various perspectives of ethnicities that are used as tools for cultural integration, preservation of identity and culture by the images of prominent figures from respective ethnicities. These perspectives formed mainly under Durrells orientalist viewpoint fill the novel through the cultural memory construed writers sovereign Western consciousness out of whose unchallenged centrality on Oriental perspective emerged. Durrell filters his experiences through cultural memory after the return to England. Thus, in this paper cultural memory as Durrell reflects on a tri-partite basis will be analyzed in terms of conflicts, stereotypes, identity crisis, clashes and hopes for negotiations. Keywords: Cypriots, memories, ethnic conflicts, cultural differences, values, identities, imperialism Yndigegn Carsten, Department of Border Region Studies, University of Southern Denmark
The Role of Historical Memories and Disciurses in Danish Young Peoples World Views
Nationalism and national identity have been perceived as belonging to the fringe of the political spectre in Denmark. Therefore, the lack of reflexivity concerning the importance of nationalism in Danish discourse makes it appropriate to characterise it as banal in Billigs sense of the word. Danish nationalism is anchored in one all-dominating historical event: the defeat to the Prussian-Austrian army in the battle at Dybbl in 1864. This single event has determined the strong, pacifist, national identity that has characterised public and political discourse until the recent decades. In the contemporary multicultural and cosmopolitan times, official policy has broken the long tradition of a defeat-determined political behaviour. Denmark has engaged in international wars, and it has broken the tradition of being a consensus seeking, open and tolerant society. This has been obvious in the public discourse about immigration and European integration. And this leaves a heritage of contradicting historical discourses to the current youth. The paper investigates how young people deal with the memories of the past, and how they reflect on the use of history in their daily life. This study is based on focus group interviews with young people who have visited the site of memory for the battle at Dybbl in 1864. The research shows that young people do not deal with history in an active, reflexive way. The role of history is implicit. Historical discourses work through cultural heritage. It is embedded in the reflexivity patterns. Therefore, it is unjust to say that young people lack historical consciousness: although, they do not display it reflexively, they practice it. The paper is based on research that has been carried out as part of MYPLACE, an international European Union 7th framework programme project (http://www.fp7-myplace.eu/). Keywords: young people, memory, banal nationalism, historical discourse alec Bojan, Faculty of Theology, University of Ljubljana
Ethics of Memory
Memory is a double edged sword. On one hand it can fuel the circle of hatred; on the other hand it is important for personal integrity and for bearing witness about injustice. Besides memories are created and fluid, not fixed and given. In short, memory of hostile violence and a reaction to this violence are in a dynamic interaction. Obviously, memories (of suffering, violence, injustice, atrocities ) can be misused for evil (political) purposes. Thus for instance Herbert Hirsch has argued that the primal passions unleashed in the cause of genocide are tied to the manipulation of memory for political purposes. Already the matters which we mentioned above suggest that an ethics of memory is needed to help us to deal with the ethical problems concerning memory, remembering and forgetting. The central question of the ethics of memory is the following: What we should remember and what we should not? The parallel of this question is: What should we forget and what not? Shouldnt we forget some persons, actions, events etc., for instance, for the sake of forgiveness? Further questions of the ethics of memory closely tied to the two mentioned above are: Are remembering and forgetting the proper subject of moral judgment (positive or negative) at all? Arent we just moralizing when we morally judge about remembering and forgetting? Who is we that should remember or forget? The aim of the paper is to contribute to the answer to the questions mentioned above. The approach in paper is philosophical. The central constituents of the frame of reference of the paper represent the works of Avishai Margalit and Jeffrey Blustein. Keywords: nature and kinds of memory, memory as a subject of evaluative inquiry, ethics of memory, responsibility to remember/forget, communities and ethical memory.
Imd al-Dn al-Ifahns al-Barq al-Shm: A Paradigm for Cultural Memory in Autobiography of the Arabic Literary Tradition
This paper aims at presenting Imd al-Dn al-Ifahns (A.D. 1125-1201) memoirs of his association with al al-Dn, i.e. Saladin (A.D. 1138-1193) and his purpose to enhance the identity of his people. Imd al-Dn rose to high rank in the service of the Sultans and the Caliphate in Baghdad and later was in the service of Nr al-Dn at Damascus and became secretary (ktib) to Saladin in A.D. 1175. In this post, he wrote an account of his experience in the service of Saladin, entitled al-Barq al-Shm (The Syrian Thunderbolt) (A.D. 1166-1193). Imd al-Dns work is a historical account referring to the brief but glorious reigns of Nr al-Dn and Saladin, that saw the unification of Syria, Palestine, and Egypt into a single kingdom and the recapture of Jerusalem from the hands of the Crusaders who had held it for eighty-eight years (A.D. 10991187). Although Imd al-Dns work is framed as a life of Saladin, the narrative focus slips away to highlight the role of Imad al-Dn himself (tarjama nafsah). Imd al-Dns historical account is in no sense an ordinary narrative chronicle. It is much more in the nature of a professional diary or record of the authors secretarial activities, copiously illustrated with copies of or extracts from his own dispatches. Moreover, Imd al-Dn gives a detailed account of his day-to-day activities as a high-ranking administrative secretary. Emphasis is given to the role that Imd al-Dn played during the reign of Saladin and his own social commentaries regarding the men of the pen and the men of the sword. Furthermore, Imd al-Dns autobiographical account focuses on the true moments of his personal glory. Certainly, Imd al-Dn shows a deep admiration for Saladin, but his greatness appears wholly as a corollary from the facts themselves, and only occasionally does he express some criticism of his master. These memoirs are seen as a chronicle of events, with the remarkable feature that they are usually related in the first person plural, a practice that gives an impression of vanity and self-importance on the writers part. By constructing the past and thus its cultural memory, makes one suppose that Imd al-Dn relies upon the veracity and the historical conscience and tries through his autobiographical memoirs to present important personal and national events. All these materials, though at times appear to be straightforward eulogies, aim at serving his patron as well as to instill confidence to his people. On the whole, it may be said that the various discourses of the past that are quoted by Imd al-Dn aim at determining and enhancing the social Arabic identity. Keywords: Imd al-Dn al-Ifahn, al-Barq al-Shm (The Syrian Thunderbolt), Saladin, autobiographical memoirs, cultural memory, Arabic identity. Zdravkova Djeparoska Sonja, University "Ss. Cyril and Methodius", Skopje
From industrial hall to shopping mall reconstruction and relativization of industrial halls as a lieux de mmoire (case study of Zagreb)
In this paper author analyses two issues related to Zagreb`s industrial heritage. The first issue pertains to societies and individuals toward material remains of citys industrialization, concretely, towards demolition of industrial halls and transformation in to the business towers and shopping malls, such as i.e. the Branimir Centre (former location of Chocolate Factory Union) and business and museum complex (former location of Zagreb Tobacco Industry). Is it at work a process of eradication of ones cultural memory and imposition/creation of another one? The author argues that in this case, one cannot speak of reutilization of the space that was once the place of production (which is quite prominent in the developed countries highly conscious and aware of their industrial heritage). Instead, one can notice a complete architectural and building reconstruction eradicated on the primary location. This newly shaped and constructed building has its purpose based on the contemporary consumer and
75 market oriented society, which is obviously more in demand than an empty and deserted former factory. The second issue, therefore, is related to the question whether factories are or can be lieux de mmoire? According to Zygmunt Baumans concept of the liquid modernity, the society of producers is transformed into society of consumers. Is this society able to accept a factory as lieux de mmoire? Can it become a place where one can recall and remember its industrial past; can it become a space where one can remember what was once here produced or with what it was produced? Among noticeable exceptions such as the initiative by the museologists and historians community, the case of Zagrebs factory halls proves otherwise. So far, the only positive example and exception to the rule is the Zagreb leather factory which now hosts The Glyptotheque of Croatian Academy of Sciences and Arts. Keywords: Zombory Mt, Institute of Sociology at the Academy of Sciences
The duty of social reconstruction. Reflections on the past in early post-war Hungary
One important development of social memory recently is the emergence of a global space of memory which serves as context for local, national and regional memory practices, be it in the political or in the academic field. This new field of action can be characterized, among others, by its dominating normative prescriptions for social action, preserving everything and duty to remember. The first is described by the concepts of archiving, patrimonializing, or musealizing denote: because of the uncertainties about the future, we no longer have the normative principals according to which we could select from the past that is worth remembering. Instead, we have the only principal of preserving everything. According to the second imperative, called duty to remember, individuals and societies have to commemorate past events so that they can never reappear again. The slogan of Never again! has its ground in avoiding history to repeat itself. The development of these features of today's dominant regime of historicity are closely tied to the social history of the memory of the Holocaust. In my paper I will first reconstruct the global space of memory politics according to these normative prescriptions. Second I will elaborate its critique through the analysis of the Hungarian early post-war (1945-449) intellectual and journalistic reflections on the recent past. Can we speak of a duty to remember in this case? What were the main discourses on Hungary's role during the war before the formulation of the concepts of Holocaust and genocide? What normative prescriptions, in relation to the past, oriented social action? Keywords: Hungary (1945-49), public discourses, reflections on the past, "duty to remember", intellectuals ,
. , . , . - , , . , . , , , . , , . , . , . , , : , , . . . , . , , , . , , , search of identity ( ). : (), (), (), , . : 1. . 2. ( , , ). : , , . 3. , . : , , , , . , -
. , , . - .
76 , , , . () () , . , , , , (, .). , . , , , , , , . , . , , ( ), , , . , , , , . : , , , , , , ,
: (1790-2012)
, -, 1831. , , . , , , , , , , 19. . , , , , 20. , , , , , 1928, . , 2012., , (1790-2012), , . , . : , , , . , . , . , . , , .
( )
- , , ( ), . , - . , - , . - , . , , modus operandi . , , . : , , , , , , , . ., . .,
( )
, , (, ), , . , , /
77 ( ) , / , , . , , , [; ], , , , . , . , - , . , / ; ; . . : , - , , , : ,
(1870-1938) . , , . , XIX XX . , . , , , , , , , (, , ). , , , , , , , ..., , , , , , - . , , , , . , , , , . , , . : , , , , : a (. , )
, , , . . - , . , , , , . . , . , , . , , , , , . , . . . , , , , , . , , . 15- 25 . - , , , , . , . : , , , ,
78 : a - , .
1991 , . , , , ? . , , , , . , . . , , . , . , . , , . , . , . , , . , . : , , , , . : -
- . , - . - . , " " . , , . , - , - , , . (, ), , . , , , . , . : , , , , : -
, , . ( ) , , . , , , , . , , , , . , ( : , , ), ( , , ). , , ( , , ). , ( , , ). : , , . , (, , , ) , , , . , -
79 , . , (, , ) (- , ). , . , . , ( , ) . , , , . : , , , , . ,
.. , . , . , , . . , . , .. o . , , . .. , , . . , . K : , , , , :
1989
. . - , , ..., , , . (, , , ...) . . : , , , ,
XVI-XVII .
, . , , , , .. . . . , , . - - . - , . , . , ,
80 , . , , , - . XVI XVII . , , . . , , . , , . : , , , , . , ..
, - , . , . , . . , , . . . (18-22 ) , . , , . , . . (68 %) , , . . , . , , . , , . . : , . , , , , , . , . : , , , , - : -
, . , , , , ; , . , , . : , , , , ,
XIX .
. , , , . , . , XIX . , , , , , , .
( )
, , . , , . . , , , . . . . . , , . , , . , , , . : , , , ,
- ,
, ( ) , , , , , . , - , , , () - , . , ( / , -
82 , , , .), , - , () , , . : , , , , vs. , : . ()
:
, , - , . , , , . , . XIX . ( ). , , . , , (, , , , , ) , , . , , , . , . . : , , , , : -
- - , () . , , ( ) , ( ), . , , , () , . , : () , /, . : , (, , ) ; , , , . : , , , . , ,
. . , (2002), . , . . .
83 () , . / , , , , ., . , . , . , , . : , , , , ; ,
: , -
, . , , , . ( ) : , - . - ( , ), ; , . , - ( 10 . ) . , , . . : , , , , ,
.
. - , , , . . 1960- . public art , : , , . , , . , - , - , , , - . , , , , . , . , ( ), , , , , . , . , , , (, , . . , ..). , : , , , , , . : , , , , .
84 .
- . ,
. . , , . , , , , , . , . , , . , , -. -, , , . , , , / ? . : , ( )
, , , , , . , (), , , , . , , , , on-line . , . , . : , , , , - :
- , vs ber Makedonische
( ). , , , ( 2008 ) . ber Makedonische, , , ( ) , . , , , , , , , , . , ,
85 , . : , , 2014, , , -
-
. (, , .), , , . , , . , 1918 . , , , . , ( , , .). XX . - , , , . . , (, , - ) . . , . (, , , ..) , . XX XXI . : , -, , , : a .
: (- )
, , . , , , , , , , . : , , -, , . , -
, - .
, ( ), , . , , , . , , ( ) , , , , , , , - . , , ( !, ), () 365 ( , . ) , - ( ), -. , , ( ) , :
86 ( /); , : 1) , vs , , ; 2) vs , ; 3) vs , , . , , , . : -, , -, , , ,
-:
, (, ), , , , . , , , . - , (, , , ) , . - , , , , . . , - , . , , , , -. : , , . . - , , , - , . : -, , , , : ,
.
, : , . .. , 19. 20.. ( ) . : , , , , , . , . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , . . , , . , , . , . . : . , , ( , . 149). , , , , , ( , . 163). : (. , , . 373). , , , . . , .
87 , . : , . , , . - . , . , . : , , , , . ,
., , . . . / . . , . , ? ? . . - : (1940-1950 ); , , - -, (1960-1990) ( ? (. ); , - (, ), - . , . , . : . , , . : , , , , . ; , - ; a
, trauma studies
. , . , . . , . , . . , , / . , ( . ). ( 9/11) , . . , . , . memory studies trauma studies. , . . ( durcharbeitung) - , . , . trauma/memory studies . , , (. ), , . , , , , . . , ( ), , , . : , , trauma studies
88 , , ,
O
6. 1934. , , , , , , 29. 2004. . , . , . . , : , , (1969), , , (1972) , , , I-II (1967), , , . , 2010. , . , , , 60- 70- XX , , . : , , , , ,
, . - , , , , , , . . , , . . , . , , . - , .. , , , . , , . [2]. , , . 20 . . : . , , , . , , , , , , . , - . , , . : , , , , . , :
89 , 1921 ., ( ) . , , , . ( , ), , . . , , , , () . , . : , , :
, . . , , . : . : , , , , . . , , : , , . , , . - , . . : , , , , . ; ; , -
, , .. . , . . , . , . , . , , , . . ( ), , , , , . . , . , , .. . , . , , . , , , . : , , , ,
90 - , - -
. / /, , , , ... . . . , , . , , . , . ( ), , . ., , , . : , ; ; . : , , , , , . .
( ..)
. , . (1920- 1930- .). , . 900- (1875-1951), , , () . 1945 . , , . , , . () (Forschungsstelle Osteuropa an der Universitt Bremen. Historisches Archiv). 1930- , . , , . , . , , . , , . , , , . . , . , . , , , , , - , , ; . , , , . : : -
: vs.
. , . , 2001 . . , . ( 2001 .) ( ) : , , ,
91 , , , ... : , , ... () , () . : ( ), ; . . , , , . , . : , , , , , a - , .
, , . , , , , . , . , , , .. , . , . . , , . , , . 403 .. . . , , . , , . . , , , . , , - , , , , . : , , , , . - : .
()
.. . , , , , - (La Capra, 2001:21). , , , , , , - / (2011:369, ). , .. . / ? . . (: , 1999), , , ( ) (: , 2009) , , , , , . :
92 -, :
/ , . "" . , ( . 1948-1975; ), , , . . , , " " . , , . Toa . / , . . : ; ; ; ; :
( )
. , -, , . . , , . , , , (), . , , , . , . , ( - ) ( ., ) - . , - , (-) . () ( , , , ) , . : , , , , -,
. ( ). , , / . (: , /), ( ). , - /, , / ,
93 . , - , , , . , / . , . : , , ( ) () - . : , , , , : -
. , , . ., . . , , , , , "", "" , . , , . : , , , , , , -
. (, , , .) , . , . . XX , . , , , . , , . - , . , , , . . , , . , , , . : , , , , - : -
, , () . 100 , , . : , , (), , , , , , ,
94 - , -
, . , . , , . , . . . . , , . , , . , , . : , , , , , : , ,
()
. . , , . . . o . : , , -, 1989 , - , :
. , , . , , , , , , . , , , . , , , - . : , , , , . , -
, . - . . , . , , , . , , . , , , , . ,
95 , ... : , , , , ,
- :
, , , / . / , .. . , , / : / homo sapiens- .. . , , ( , , / . : , , , , , / , / , , . :
/ :
/ : - , . , , / , , , , . , , , - ( , homo sapiens-), , ( , ), ... ( ) , , ( ). : , , , , , ... ,
-
, , , . , , , . ()
96 . , , , , , . : -, : . -
. ,
, , 50- , . , , , . , , . , - , , , . , . , . , , , , . , , : , , . : , . : , ( )
- : ( XX XXI .).
XX . - . , , , , . , ( ) . , . , , , . , . ( ), . . , , - [, 2004]. , , . , , - . . , ( ), , - . : , , , . : - , , , , .
97 ,
. 15
, . , . , , , . . . 15 , . , . , , . , , . , . , , , 10 , , , . , , , , . 15 . : . 15, , , , ,
The World in 2 Minutes, , -. YouTube , , , , , , , . , . , , . , . , , , , , , .. , . ( , , ), -, , , . , ( , ), ( ) ( , ). : -, , , , : -
:
. , , . , , . , . , , , , . . , . , . . . , , ,
98 . . , , . , , , . , . . , -, , -, , -, , . : , , , , , . : ,
:
, , - , , , . , , , , , - . , , . , , . , , , , , , , , , , . : , , , , . :
, . , ( ), , , , , . : , ; ; , , ; , , , , (. , . ), . , , (. ). , . , , , , , , , . , , , , , . , , (. , ). (. melting pot), , . , , , , , . : , , ,
99 : -
:
, , ( ) ( , , , .) , . , , . , , , . , , , , , - . , , , . : , , , , , , . , : , . , , , , . : ,
, , o : ( ), . : ( 1968), ( 1969), (1971), (1975), (1978), ( 1981), (1982), ( 1982), (1993), ( 1996) (2000) ; , , . , . , ( , 2001: 4). . , . , , , , , (Cahn, 1998: 90). . : , , , , , .
. . , , , . . . . . : , , , , ,
( ) -
( ) . , , , , , / . , , ,
: ,
. . , , . - , , . , , , . , . , , . , . , . , . : , , , , , -
. , / , . , .. , . . , , , . , , , . , / . . , ; , ; . . , , . : , , , , / . / /. : . -
, , , , . .
, , . - , . . 29 , 12 16 . : ,
() - ( )
, , : - , - . , , , . 10 - . , , 16- , ( , 1975) . , . ? , ? ? : , /, , , : -
XVII
XVIII . .. , , XVIII . . , .. .. . 1772 .. , , . .. . , , , , 1758 , . , 1770- , 1790- . .. , , . XVIII . XVIII . , 1777 . 1790- -
102 . , . : , , , , . : -
XVIII
1748 . . XIV. . . XIX , . .. - 1883 . , , , , .. . . . 1891 , .. , .. . . - 1903 , , . , . 1914 .. , , - . .. 1907 . . , . : , , , , . :
:
. ( ) . , , .. , ( .. . ., 2007. . 236). . , , , . , , ( ) ( ), , . , ., , , ( . . ., 2004. . 6). , , : -, , ; -, , . : , , , , -
. , . , ( ) ( ). , . .
103 , , , . : , , . , . ( ), , . . , , : , ; ; ; ; , , . .:
, . . : 1) , 2) , , ? 100 . 17-22 . 2012 . . : . , , , , , .. . , : (1), (3), I (3), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1). : (17), , (1), (6), (1), (2), / (2), / (2), (2), (1), (1), (3), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1), - (1), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1), (1). I, -, , . , - , . : , , , ,
. . , , , . , , . , . , . , . -, .. , .. . , , . , . , . .. , , , . , , , . - , , . . . , , . : , , , - , .
104 ,
, , , , . , , - : , , , , , . / / / : /, , , / / , , /// . . , , / . (1975, : . ), , (2006, : . . , : . ), - , , , , . , , . . : , , , , . -, : , ,
, . ( , , ), e , , . , , , . , - , , , , . , , ? ? , , , , , , , ? 15 . . , . : , , . ,
. , , , 1926 . 1938 . , - , , . : , , , -
105 : a
. .
. , , (, , ). , . , ( , ). . , , , , , . , , . . , , , , . . . , . , . , , , . , , . ( ), , . . : , , ,
Panels
109
City as a Battlefield of Urban Dissonant Memories: Narratives, Monuments, Public Art Projects
CHAIR: Dragievi ei Milena, University of Arts, Belgrade Milena Dragievi ei, University of Arts, Belgrade
URBAN DISSONANT MEMORIES (NARRATIVES, MONUMENTS, PUBLIC ART PROJECTS) METHODOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK
The aim of this introductory paper is to provide a methodological framework for the panel debate, using multiperspectivistic approach (Kellner) and theoretical categories developed within humanities and social sciences, culture of memory (A. & J. Assmann, Connerton, Buruma, Halbwachs), sociology of memory, history, heritage (Tunbridge and Ashworth) and cultural studies (Conrad, Hodgkin, Radstone, ), urban sociology and urban studies ( H. Lefevbre, Landry, Nas), etc. Thus panelist will use different interdisciplinary approaches from social sciences (Elena Battaigni), sociology of memory (Svetlana Hristova), culture of memory (Lj. Roga), urban studies and history of art (Lea Linin) The aim of the panel is to investigate contemporary memory policies and practices relating to recent conflictual past within different urban settings. The panel debate is expected to raise the following questions: How cities remember contemporary conflictual history? Clashing / contesting / mediating identities through new urban policies; Us and Them in urban settings: re-constructed memories and places; What is the meaning of ceremonies and historical dates for the identity of a city? Cities as spaces of memory battles (Day of the Albanian flag, Balkan war Memorials etc.) or a dialogue? In which ways are dissonant memories activated through heritage? Controversial symbols - heritage that divides; Monuments and Graveyards representing conflictual individual & collective memories; How do urban dissonant memories function through Art narratives in contemporary public arts projects? New creations as ideas battleground (Igor Grubi, Monument Group, Pravo na grad etc.) Roga Ljiljana, University of Arts, Belgrade
A MEMORIAL SITE IN THE WILD SETTLEMENT THE OLD BELGRADE FAIRGROUND BETWEEN THE CONTESTED PAST AND THE NEGLECTED PRESENT
The Old Belgrade Fairground is a memorial site, officially declared cultural heritage, during the Second World War it was a concentration camp (first a Judenlager Semlin and then Anhaltslager Semlin), a Holocaust site, one of the first Nazi camps in Europe for the mass interment of Jews, where thousands of people were tortured and killed. This chapter focuses upon the interrelations of memory, space and identity, regarding to the politics of memory. Taking the Old Fairground as a multilayered symbol bearer and a space of accentuated memory, a complex valorization of this cultural heritage place is conducted. The Old Belgrade Fairground is analyzed as a symbol of suffering and trauma, as a symbol of urban architectural modernity and a symbol of artistic avant-garde, and on the other hand, as an abandoned place in the urban city matrix. Bearing in mind the dissonance heritage, such as the case of the Old Fairground, the very different interpretations over the meaning of this site, as well as the politics of oblivion, remain the main ideological and political context in which the future of this site is shaped. Linin Lea, Multimedia research group, Skopje
HOW TO BOOST CULTURAL TOURISM AMONG UNSETTLED CONTESTING SENTIMENTS? CASE STUDIES: MUSEUM OF THE VICTIMS OF COMMUNISM AND FORTRESS CHURCH-MUSEUM
The paper will analyze the cases of two new museums, Museum of the victims of Communism and Fortress Church-Museum, which were built under governmental initiative in Skopje historical core with two aims: to re-balance historical injustice, revoicing the once won, oppressed narratives and to boost cultural tourism as part of the city regeneration strategy. Leaning on the theoretical texts from the cultural economy and urban theory (Franco Bianchini, Charles Landry, Pierre Luigi Sacco) will analyze the way these projects has been carried out, and will examine their possibilities to become landmarks of cultural tourism and factors of urban regeneration. Another layer of research will focus on the strong opposition and civil protests these projects faced during their installment. Following some notions from conflict resolution theory (Samy Smooha, Ljubomir Frckoski) as well as the postcolonial studies (Said, Spivak, Bhabha) the presentation would try to give some answers why this cultural offer
110 re-staged the clash over the symbolic possession of the city territory (Church-Museum) and why instead of the reconciliation and sympathy over the human suffering it arouse another set of historical debates. The presentation would be further, concrete elaboration on the questions rose in the introductory paper. Elena Battaigni, IRES (Economic and Social Res
DISCUTANT Cultural memory in narratives of film and visual arts: Serbia after 2000
CHAIR: Nikolic Mirjana, Faculty of Dramatic Arts, University of Arts Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia Mihaljinac Nina, Faculty of Dramatic Arts, University of Arts Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia
CONSTRUCTING NARRATIVES OF THE NATO BOMBING OF SERBIA THROUG VIDEO TESTIMONY: RED HOT SPOT/AFER THE FACT (MIRJANA OREVI), LOSS OF INOCENCE AND SHAVING (ANDREJ TIMA)
In order to investigate the ways of constituting the collective memory within the contemporary visual art scene in Serbia, as well as the impact of the current identity policy on the artistic production, with the use of some of the most important theories of collective, this paper analyses videos of two Serbian artists, Mirjana orevi and Andrej Tima, dealing with the theme of NATO bombing of Serbia. The paper also analyses the video-testimony as an artistic genre and the possible role of artistic testimony (or secondary witnessing) in the process of constructing the past. As the framing of a traumatic event, video testimony belongs to the larger genre of testimony and, as a genre, it has only evolved over the last two decades. Video testimony has a structure that reflects the structure of traumatic event it represents and ensures transmission of witnesses narrative. Analysis of video works of these two artists has three objectives. The first and most general is to describe the transformation of the genre from Shoh (C. Lanzmann, 1985, France) to videos presented in this paper. The second is to identify common formal and aesthetic values of video works of two artists, whose ideological positions, and thus the narratives about the bombing, are quite different. The third goal is to use the examples of these works to describe the mechanism of constructing narratives of the NATO bombing of Serbia and based on this, ask questions about the culture of memory in Serbia. Dakovic Nevena, Faculty of Dramatic Arts, University of Arts Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia
NONEXISTENT MEMORIES FROM NONEXISTENT COUNTRY (FILM AND POP MUSIC AS PARADIGMATICAL CULTURAL MEMORY
In the absence of relevant historical resources, film and pop music can sometimes represent the only document and commentary on the certain epoch, the identity, recollections, strivings, hopes and beliefs of the people. A specific phenomenon of nostalgia for the old days emerged during the first decade of the XXI century in the region generations who had not even seen the old glory days of Yugoslav New Wave or post New Wave time. Specific geopolitical view of Yugoslav pop culture of the 80's mystified by the youth born in early 90's represents a distorted system of values precisely because of the ten-year hiatus and vortex of cultural values in the times of great political and social turmoil (nineties ethnical wars). Film Oktobar by a group of authors (2011) or Klip by Maja Milo (2012) brings forth a generational consensus on numbness and disinterest, whereas The Box by Andrijana Stojkovic (2011), Jelena, Katarina, Marija by Nikita Milivojevi (2012) and Practical Guide to Belgrade with Singing and Crying by Bojan Vuleti (2012) brings stylized, almost utopian image of forgotten memories of the early 90's and an authentic insiders' story about survival with enduring dignity in Belgrade and abroad.
111
112 challenges of using visual methods include making the purpose for using methods clear, dealing with participants discomfort that may be expressed as not being able to draw or not being creative. Therefore, the facilitation with visual methods is important, involving constructing a framework for group work, balancing exercises that encourage participants to be playful and open to the concrete and abstract meanings yet feel safe. Also, facilitation involves dealing with ethical issues, such as the risk of exposing difficult, personal problems. My experience is that the use of visual and narrative methods is a dance with participants, which I conceptualize as a mutual meaning-making process that emerges in a specific context. In the discussion, I consider how I try to develop a dialogic dance inspired by a dialogic understanding of empowerment and phenomenological approach to emergence. I reconsider my use of visual and narrative methods in teaching and supervision practice in relation the whole context, especially how the purpose of an activity is conceptualized with or co-created with the participants in a given setting. Novak Martin, Department of Psychology, Masaryk University, Czech Republic
113 Until recently the definition of music folklore included oral/aural as a central category for distribution and reception of folk music artifacts. The recording era facilitated the distribution of the song and dance music to a much wider audience while eliminating the need for physical presence of the performers. The digitisation of music folklore has had further consequences both in musical and nonmusical aspects. In this paper, we try to explore the influence of the distribution channels on the extension of folk music in the collective cultural memory by comparing digital versus traditional means.
BLOWING UP BROTHERHOOD AND UNITY: COMPARING THE CULTURAL MEMORY OF WORLD WAR TWO IN ISTRIA AND LIKA
The cultural memory of World War Two, in particular the victory of the Partisan movement, was one of the pillars of the socialist regimes political legitimacy in Titos Yugoslavia. This included incorporating the slogan of Brotherhood and Unity, which represented the Yugoslav Communist Partys efforts to overcome the bloody legacy of internecine warfare, into the countrys commemorative culture and memorial heritage. The dissolution of Yugoslavia and the war in Croatia (the Homeland War, 1991-1995) resulted in the widespread revision of historical narratives and the destruction of thousands of antifascist monuments and memorial objects. As warfare between Croats and rebel Serbs supported by the Yugoslav Peoples Army and Miloevis Serbia spread throughout Croatia, the assault on the memorial heritage of WW2 became a systematic effort to erase the cultural memory of Serb-Croat cooperation and replace it with nationalist victimization narratives. This paper compares the fate of the WW2 heritage in two Croatian regions: Lika, which experienced considerable interethnic violence in the 1990s, and Istria (along with the city of Rijeka), which remained outside of the war zone. While Serb-Croat relations in Lika and Italian-Croat relations in Istria had both been strained by contested historical narratives since WW2, the recent conflict resulted in not only the construction of new state-building narratives based on the Homeland War but also the almost complete disappearance of physical markers of WW2. Puljar DAlessio Sanja, Department of Cultural Studies, University of Rijeka
THE MEMORY OF THE MISSING PEOPLE. THE ITALIAN EXODUS FROM ISTRIA AND RIJEKA AFTER WW2 IN THE WRITTEN WORDS OF THE ITALIAN MINORITY WRITERS IN YUGOSLAVIA AND ITS
This paper will deal with the question of Italian mass emigration from Yugoslav areas of Istria and Rijeka and with the demographic huge changes that it caused at a local level, in terms of ethnic balance in Istria and Rijeka, but also for its economic and social consequences for the whole area. The old residents found themselves scattered across the Italo-Yugoslav border, with families and old communities divided by different political, social and cultural systems, while ethnic and linguistic borders acquired new significances. For the people still intending to use Italian language or dialects or to identify themselves with the new local Italian minority, the emigration came first as a possibility and choice and then as a traumatic experience to re-elaborate in the new political and social situation. How the Italian minority community in socialist Yugoslavia and then independent Croatia and Slovenia articulated the discourse and memory of the loss? This paper will discuss the function of intellectuals and their abilities, will and possibilities to deal - and to not deal- with this trauma along the years, not only in the press and historical reconstructions but also in works of fiction as novels, tales and poetry. This paper will analyse historiographical and fictitious compositions on the mass emigration (and on the taboo topic of the mass killings) to see how they followed and fit in the political evolution in Yugoslavia, Croatia and Slovenia, along years of more or less freedom of speech and of good and bad relations with Italy.
THIS SEA OF OURS. THE NATIONALIZATION OF MARITIME HERITAGES AND THE CONTEMPORARY USES OF CULTURAL
MEMORIES OF THE SEA
The paper discusses the nation building process in the Adriatic Sea and explores how different social actors exploited cultural memories of the maritime world to build up national imaginaries. I address the topic of the rediscovery of the sea by sketching out the ways the Adriatic Sea has been imagined from the era of empires until the present. In this context, I shall point out how social representations of ethnic relations have been interwoven with the social construction of the sea and the sea dwellers, throughout a historical process of terrestrial conversion of the maritime-based social relations. With the collapse of the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, this context of ambivalence became even more problematic, because the end of a somehow shared Yugoslav frame set the stage for a virtual battle among the post-socialist nation states, which have been searching for national legitimacy and historical roots in the rich Adriatic imaginary. However, to perform an institutional appropriation of the littoral zones and the maritime areas is not an easy task because the cultural assimilation of the same areas within an exclusively ethno-national narration can be quite challenging. Actually, the public rediscovery of the sea and of the maritime identities brings about a rehabilitation of cultural heritages, symbolic systems and geographies of civilization that open up new cleavages and distinctions, which eventually work against the supposed homogeneity of the national cultures.
AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL FILMS AND CULTURAL MEMORY: REPRESENTATIONS OF NATIONAL HISTORY IN RECENT PORTUGUESE AUDIOVISUAL PRODUCTION
Media technologies and the circulation of media products have an active role in the (re)constrution of cultural memory. Media artefacts such as monuments, museums and films can link members of a community to their history, having the ability to shape the collective imagination of the past. In this paper we argue that autobiographical documentaries create sites for remembering, by rewriting history. We aim at understanding which representations of the past do the films recently produced in Portugal disseminate and how these representations of national history are related with attitudes towards immigrants. Crossing the potential of the autobiographical narratives as a powerful local discourse form with the need to give voice to lesser-known struggles of migrant people, documentary films has provided the necessary elements for our analysis of social representations of history, namely, of the colonial past. Therefore, we selected five recent documentaries (produced between 2007-2012), featuring autobiographical memories and presenting representations of the nation and its colonial history from different viewpoints. These films action takes place in Angola, Brazil, Mozambique and Portugal, with memories involving the colonial war, the Portuguese dictatorship, and migration experiences. They discuss how memory is (re)created in postcolonial contexts, by disclosing the narratives of individuals who have lived conflict and displacement experiences. Through content and narrative analysis of the selected documentaries, we aim to explore how these narratives of the past shape social and personal identities of those who have lived displacement experiences, and how are their emotions potrayed in audiovisual contents. Furthermore, we intend to discuss how these films, by transmitting historical accounts and generating a relationship with the public, can shape the social representations of history and consequently, affect the (re)construction of ethnic, national and post-national identities. Cabecinhas Rosa; Abadia, Lilia; Macedo Isabel CECS/ University of Minho, Braga, Portugal
115 to a face-to-face survey with open questions about the events and historical figures they considered to be the most important in their nation history, using an adaptation of the methodology pioneered by Liu et al., 2005, for the study of the representations of world history. After listing the events and the figures, participants evaluated their impact on national history (from very negative to very positive) and their emotions towards them. At the end of the survey, they indicated their sources of information about the national history and their degree of identification with several groups (national, ethnic, linguistic, religious, etc.). Results show that in all countries the most frequent nominations refer to the events and historical figures that symbolize the foundation of the state and/or its transition to the political present-day regime. Overall, historical figures are evaluated significantly more positively than events and cover a broader diversity of domains, such as arts and sports. Regarding the sources of information about these events, Portuguese participants mentioned mainly TV news, TV documentaries and schoolbooks whereas African youngsters mentioned mainly radio and word-of-mouth. The interplay between the social identification processes, objective conditions and the patterns of searching information in the (re)construction of the nationviews will be discussed. Flp, va, Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience and Psychology, Research Centre for Natural Sciences, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budapest, Hungary; Ilg, Barbara; Lszl, Jnos University of Pcs, Institute of Psychology, Pcs, Hungary;
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN NATIONAL IDENTIFICATION, LEGITIMIZATION TENDENCIES, GROUP-BASED EMOTIONS AND RESPONSIBILITY TAKING IN CASE OF IN-GROUP PERPETRATORS
The conceptual framework of social identity theory (Tajfel, 1978; Tajfel & Turner, 1981) and self-categorization theory (Turner s mtsai, 1987; Turner, 1999) proves that identification with the national in-group is an important factor in the judgment of inter-group situations. Our research team developed a Hungarian national identification questionnaire (N=586) (Szab & Lszl, in press), which can differentiate between two modes of identification, namely attachment to the in-group and glorification of the in-group (see also Roccas, Klar, &Liviatan, 2006). We have carried out several studies (3 studies, N=713) to demonstrate that attachment and glorification has a different relationship to group-based phenomena such as legitimization tendencies, groupbased emotions, and responsibility taking. In case of in-group aggression subjects with high glorification scores use alternative interpretations of the events (most importantly various types of moral justifications), deny the experience of self-critical groupbased emotions (such as guilt, shame, regret, in-group directed anger) and as a consequence they refuse to compensate the victims. However, in case of out-group aggression, glorification has a positive relationship with the demand of compensation and reparation.
How can the Faro Convention on the Value of Cultural heritage for Society (which several Balkan countries have ratified) be used to help establish heritage and memory as key elements of social cohesion, democratic participation and pluralistic identities (A panel discussion by members of the IS1007 Culture in Sustainability COST Action.)
CHAIR: Soini Katriina, COST IS1007 "Investigating Cultural Sustainability"/ University of Jyvskyl Graham Fairclough, COST IS1007 "Investigating Cultural Sustainability" / Newcastle University (UK)
PAPER TITLE: THE FARO CONVENTION ON THE VALUE OF CULTURAL HERITAGE FOR SOCIETY AN INTRODUCTION TO A NEW HERITAGE
Faro is a new type of heritage convention. It does not ask How heritage is to be preserved, but Why? It recognises the plurality and cultural diversity of heritage, and sees Heritage in all its forms (material and intangible forms, and with issues of social and cultural memory to the fore) as something to which every citizen has a right, part of the citizens right to participate in cultural
116 life as defined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. But it also sees that everyone has responsibilities - an individual and collective responsibility towards respecting and protecting the cultural heritage, and thus the cultural memory, of other groups everyone, alone or collectively, has the responsibility to respect the cultural heritage of others as much as their own heritage. Such aspirations have a new importance in a 21st world where the some established forms of belonging are melting away; where new supra-national, transnational and sub-national identities assert themselves, where migration forges new relationships between landscape and identity, and where virtual connections as well as mobility foster multiple identities. In this context cultural memory based on heritage, from costume and beliefs to landscape and history, becomes even more important. It is possible to imagine a reinforcement of ssocial cohesion through sharing responsibility towards the places in which people live, and to find ways to live equitably with situations where contradictory values are placed on the same cultural heritage by different communities Elizabeth Auclair, COST IS1007 "Investigating Cultural Sustainability" / Cergy-Pontoise University (F)
PAPER TITLE: CULTURAL MEMORY, PARTICIPATION AND SOCIAL COHESION IN SUBURBAN TOWNS
Cities all over the world are facing important changes due to globalization and neoliberal economic processes. The suburbs are specifically affected by rapid and uncontrolled urban growth, important regeneration operations, loss of public spaces, increase of spatial fragmentation and social segregation. Many suburban towns, characterized by a negative and despised image, realize that enhancing collective and individual memory can be an interesting tool for community cohesion, well being and quality of urban life. The projects led by the Val de Bievre eco-museum in the city of Fresnes (located in the suburbs of Paris, in the Val de Marne Department) seem a good illustration of this type of approach. The aim of this institution is to collect and valorize elements concerning the local populations and the way they live - and have lived - on the territory, that is to say the elements which contribute in defining the urban landscape: histories, traditions, values, needs and aspirations of the population. The diverse topics are related to urbanization, employment, immigration, feminine condition The Val de Bievre eco-museum intends to be a tool for the local population, and consequently it invites the inhabitants to participate in temporary exhibitions and various activities. The aim of the paper is to show under what conditions cultural memory can enable appropriation of the territory by the inhabitants, develop social cohesion, increase links between the towns districts (citer center, social housing neighborhoods, individual housing areas), between the generations, and between the different communities living in the town. Jasmina Beba Kuka, COST IS1007 "Investigating Cultural Sustainability", Belgrade Open School (SRB)
PAPER TITLE: CULTURAL HERITAGE AND MEMORY FROM CONFLICTED VALUES TO DIVERSITY OF INTERPRETATIONS.
Nowadays when the concept of cultural heritage is being significantly expanded and deepened, not only for its own intrinsic value, but especially in terms of its potentials for conflict resolution, economic recovery, it has become crucial for societies to work on these issues in the quest for sustainable community development. Presentation of the cultural heritage and its interpretations by different communities have for long been sources of conflict. In this context, it is important to raise questions: What is the role of cultural heritage in the construction of peaceful relations among societies in the region? How to raise and reinforce collective responsibility and competences among all the public towards cultural heritage? How to develop trust and mutual understanding as well as respect for diversity of interpretations of the meanings put upon cultural heritage? The contribution to the panel will be to explore that interrelation between cultural heritage, memory and identity through several examples, such as: conflicts over Monastery Prohor Pinjski, The Stone Bridge (Duan Bridge), etc.
117 CHAIR: Maricic Nikola, Faculty of Drama Arts/University of Arts Belgrade, Serbia Martinoli Ana, Faculty of Drama Arts/University of Arts Belgrade, Serbia
INDIVIDUAL AND COLLECTIVE MEMORY OF 9/11 ATTACKS THE ROLE OF TACTICAL MEDIA IN VIRTUAL REMEMBRANCE
PROCESS
This paper is aimed at analyzing the ways cultural memory and remembrance of 9/11 were built through mainstream media channels and through decentralized, free and activist tactical media, virtual and on site. Both practices of 9/11 mediatization, through mainstream and tactical media, had cohesive effect on the audience, but the core feelings were different - mainstream media built their practices mainly on fear, confrontation, obedience, unquestioned patriotism, national awareness, dominant political ideology, while tactical media opened new spaces for empathy, personal view, solidarity, reconciliation, connectivity on global scale, giving space for the narratives that were marginalized in mainstream media discourse. This paper will focus on mediatization of national and cultural trauma, relationship between personal and collective memory and mediatization of memory through virtual communities. What was role of the mainstream mass media in construction of 9/11 remembrance, what tactical media projects (as Virtual Casebook 9/11 or HereIsNewYork.org) brought into the process of creation of cultural memory and how they positioned individual identity expressed through individual memory and individual construction of the meaning of 9/11 events into broader context. Finally, paper will try to elaborate on the question what is the position of media consumer in contemporary media landscape are we witnessing the establishment of the new space for display of individual memory and how does individual/personal memory re-shape and affect collective memory and, further, change collective identity? Nikolic Mirjana, Faculty of Dramatic Arts/University of Arts, Belgrade, Serbia
MEDIA AS THE AGENCY IN BUILDING UP THE MEMORY OF THE CITY RTV STUDIO B
The concern of this paper is to analyse the actual programme-production specificities and characteristics of the RTV Studio B in order of mapping out its contribution to the creation and constitution of the memory narratives of the city of Belgrade. At the same time, the paper investigates the relation of the memory narrative toward recent and far past (hi)stories and the way it works in the contextualisation of the personal remembrances and memories. I seek to model the ways RTV Studio B becomes the active guard and keeper of the memory narratives of the city. Since its very foundation April 1st 1970 when it was founded as Radio Studio B of the daily news company Borba- Studio B is paradigm of the contemporary radio expression, concept and work. Due to the work of its journalists, producers and authentic radio stars- such as oko Vjetica, Duko Radovi, Marko Jankovi, Slobodan Konjovi, Zoran Modli, the team of the youth contact show Ritam srca - it became the model of the program concept dedicated to the the life of the metropolis; creating its image, narratives, history. In the year 1990 as sort of its spin off emerged first Independent TV Station Studio B. The memory narratives began to involve both image and sound.
"AGAINST OBLIVION"
Architectural structures are cultural signs and old, sometimes historical abandoned buildings have aura. They represent in a relative way zeitgeist. They keep mnemonic details, objects and remains. They become metaphors to discuss current political situations. They concretize the beginning of the end phenomenon. They belong to the collective memory and they are symbols of nostalgia. Sometimes, while documenting this kind of buildings in Izmir, in those void spaces, I feel that I record nothingness and each work session, I ask to myself: What is the nothing? Why I record it continuously? What am I looking for? Maybe I should remember the logic of Heidegger: Being is what it is that makes beings be / Nothing is what it is that makes beings be /Hence, being is nothing. (Priest, Graham, Heidegger and the grammar of being, in Grammar in Early Century Philosophy,
118 Routledge, London, 2001, p.243). In addition, maybe this act of record is a struggle for memories. Nezaket Tekin, Dokuz Eylul University Fine Arts Faculty Department of Photography, Izmir, Turkey
SIGNIFICANT ABSENCE
Who remembers? Who is this Subject? If he/she is a photographer, that means he/she is the most usual suspect of the History. Hence, he/she tries to catch the Moment. Which means he/she pasts from mnm to anamnsis. Then the old factories, warehouses, ruins, graffitis etc. became a mean to describe the own fury of the photographer. While photographing the urban areas, actually he/she express his/her individual stories. In this panel, I would like to show some visual testimony examples and personal experiences and photographic works.
FANTASY AS THE DISCOURSE OF CULTURAL AND HISTORICAL MEMORY IN CONTEMPORARY SERBIAN FILM
The aim of this paper is to analyze the elements of fantasy, as well as its meaning and function in the presentation of historical and cultural memory in contemporary Serbian film. The case study examines the films Sheitan Warrior (ejtanov ratnik, 2006) and Tears for Sale (arlston za Ognjenku, 2008). The main questions addressed in the analysis are: what is the place and function of historical and cultural memory in the films that are the subject of this study; what is the role of fantasy in the presentation of historical events and cultural circumstances and how is fantasy woven into the relationship/memory of national history and culture. The analysis is concerned with the relationship of individual and collective cultural memory, as well as the memory of historical events, predominantly wars that played a crucial role in Serbian history: Turkish conquest and life under Ottoman rule, the Balkan wars and WWI. The scope of examination covers the social and cultural circumstances arising from this struggle and internal national turmoil that echo in the memories and (through the prism of fantasy) are woven into contemporary film narratives and shape the (film) present. This analysis will examine the hypothesis that fiction and fantasy are ways of expressing not only memories but also the manner of their existence in collective memory and in art. Aleksandra Milovanovic, Faculty of Dramatic Arts in Belgrade, Serbia; Mila Turjalic, CERI, SciencesPo, Paris. France
FROM THE GENERATION MEMORY TO THE GROUP IDENTITY: THROAT FULL OF STRAWBERRIES
119 In the work with the topic From the generation memory to the group identity: A Throatful of Strawberries, the influence of personal and collective memory on generation identity is analyzed. The work is based on Jan Assmann and Aleida Assmanns theory of memory, with a special review to the books Cultural memory (Jan Assmann), and Work on the national memory and The long shadow of the past (Aleida Assmann). Firstly, the analysis includes the mapping, then explanation of the memory figures which were comprised in the movie. Also, the thesis which I covered in the work refers to the difference between Halbwachss term the images of memory, and the figure of memory introduced by Assmann: the figures of memory are complementary to the first term because they include not only pictorial, but narrative forms as well. (Assmann). In this paper, the relation between personal and collective memory is questioned, also how individual memory influences the establishment of ones group memory, and how memory and remembrance affect what we call generation identity. Film A Throatful of Strawberries (by Srdjan Karanovic, 1985) was chosen as my study of case. This movie is the continuation of the series The Unpicked Strawberries (Srdjan Karanovic, 1976). It tells about the reunion of the particular generation that evokes the memories about the events during the 60th (the time of their youth), so the topic this film is focused on represents the starting point for the study of the generation memory and its function.
Spaces of Memory in Comparative Perspective: Performing Life in Former Sites of Suffering and Death
CHAIR: Violi Patrizia, Department of Philosophy and Communication, University of Bologna Silke Arnold-de Simine, the Department of European Cultures and Languages, Birkbeck (University of London)
REMEMBERING WHAT HAPPENED AT THIS SITE: IN FLANDERS FIELDS (YPRES) AND THE MILITRHISTORISCHE MUSEUM DRESDEN
Ypres and Dresden have become almost mythical places of suffering and devastation during WWI and WWII. Both cities lay in ruins but whereas the people of Ypres rejected Churchills wish to preserve the destroyed city as a memorial to British and Commonwealth war dead and opted instead for rebuilding and for the monumental Menin Gate, in Dresden the pile of rubble that was left of the Frauenkirche, hit by Allied bombing in the last days of WWII, was kept as a memorial until 1993 when reconstruction began. These memorials in Ypres and Dresden were complemented in recent years by new war museums that have to balance the tasks of memorials and museums. Memorials are usually seen as sacred places for reverent commemoration, their commemorative functions and associated ceremonies evoke burial rites. As such they are supposed to honour the dead and establish a community united in mourning and in the resolve to prevent the cause for grief and suffering in the future. In contrast, museums are educational institutions tasked with critical interpretation and historical contextualization. Increasingly the distinction between the two institutions becomes more and more blurred: new museums often double as memorials and quite a few memorials feature so-called information centres, such as The World Trade Centre Memorial (New York), the Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe and Bernauer Strasse Wall Memorial (Berlin). My contribution will ask what the consequences are of the coalescing of memorial and museum functions for the commemoration and remembering of these events. Patrizia Violi, Department of Philosophy and Communication, University of Bologna
LEARNING FROM THE LARI MASSACRES: HERITAGE AND CONFLICT RESOLUTION IN CONTEMPORARY KENYA
In London during the summer of 2009 there was a battle raging in the British High Courts. Four Mau Mau veterans argued for the right to lay a claim against the British Government for the torture and degradation they experienced while in detention under suspicion of Mau Mau activities during the state of Emergency in Kenya during the 1950s. Later it emerged that Foreign and Commonwealth Office files filled with incriminating evidence of how this abuse of human rights was condoned and even encouraged by the British and their forces in Kenya, had been deliberately secreted away after Kenyan Independence in order to avoid embarrassment to the British Government. Details of abuse (sexual, physical and mental) which form part of this newly discovered archive and recounted in the British press made gruelling reading. Meanwhile national newspapers in Kenyan carried features listing similar abuses, this time between Mau Mau and Loyalist forces in what is now Lari District (north of Nairobi) on the anniversary of a double massacre committed there in March 1953. The pairing of these ghosts from the past in both
120 British and Kenyan national press highlights the complex allegiances and betrayals which characterise colonial conflicts whose legacies resurface in seemingly endless permutations and reinventions. This paper is an analysis of one communitys extraordinary attempt to come to terms with this violent history through the establishment of the Lari Memorial Peace Museum. Andermann Jens, Latin American and Luso-Brazilian Studies, University of Zurich
DISCUTANT The active silence of cultural memories in post-war Kosovo master narrative.
CHAIR: Anna Di Lellio, The New School, NYU, New York City Mevlyde Salihu, Independent Researcher, Prishtina; Anna Di Lellio, The New School, NYU, New York City
121 national histories, as well as helping to shed light on the cultural construction of gendered identities in a post-war era Farnsworth Nicole; Rogova Igballe, Kosovas Women Network
,
, . , , . . . , , , . , , , , , , , , . ? ? ? , , , . . , . : , .
, , .
122 # , "" , , - . "" . ( ) (, , , ...) . "" , , , ( 1960 ) , , "" ( , , , ...). , "" ; , . , , . Mihajlovski Robert, Australian Catholic University, Melbourne
:
, , . ,
,
, , , , . , , . - , . , , - . . . . , - . , - . . / . Lozanovska Mirjana, Deakin University, Australia
Which country pops up in your mind when I say banana? (Exploring past and present symbols attached to country images today)
123 CHAIR: Apostolova Ivanka, Cultural Studies, University Euro Balkan, Skopje, Macedonia, The goal of the workshop is to investigate how a coherent recognizable image of different countries is formed and perceived by the others, as well as how this image relates or not to the present-day realities of the countries. The extent to which past and present moments are used to this purpose will also be explored. Together with the workshop participants, we will address the following questions: Which are the components of the country image? (We are going to look at aspects related to politics, culture, education, economy, tourism, language, in order to see how they are connected to some countries and not to others, for ex. Communism connected to Eastern Europe vs. Monarchy to the UK and the Scandinavian countries; French language associates primarily with France, and not with Belgium or Switzerland; the car industry relates to Germany and not to France, etc.) Which can be the bearers of the symbolic meaning? (We are going to analyze several country branding campaigns to see to what extent they use the image of representative people, objects, places, events, etc. in order to symbolize their countries of origin. Are these symbols of the past or of the present?) Who are the image makers? (We will attempt to identify the bodies contributing to the creation of the countries image, such as the country and its official polices, tourist agencies, the media, international events such as the Eurovision song contest or the Olympic Games, fares, etc.) Are there different images projected? (We will explore whether or not there are one or multiple images of a country, depending on the image creator and the target audience, in particular if others perceive us the way we perceive ourselves.) The workshop will use interactive methods such as image and words associations, games and role-play within small-groups or with all workshop participants. A paper incorporating the workshop results will be developed and submitted to the conference proceedings as a co-authorship of the facilitators. Andreea Bratu, University of Craiova, Faculty of Letters, Department of Anglo-American and German Studies Milica Petrushevska, University St. Cyril and Methodius/University of Bucharest, Department of Slavic Languages