Tajbaro v.

Muhammad Ashraf Jadoon (Muhammad Alain Khan, Member)

2925

2000 Y!"292# \^ $%.&.'.(. )ar *oun+il Tribunal,
Before Justice Mian Shakirullah Jan,
Chairman, Muhammad Alain Khan and
Saeed Akhtar Khan, Members
Ms-. TAJ)A"./(e-i-ioner
M01AMMA2 A31"A' JA2..%/"es4onden-
*om4lain- %o. T5# of 2000, de+ided on 2#-h June, 2000. 6
J027M8%T
M01AMMA2 A!AM K1A%f (M8M)8")./.n 9:99999 Ms-. Tajbarol ;5 o 'a<al 2i n residen- of To4i
r
and 2is-ri+- 3;abi filed a +om4lain- in -hej %.&.'.(. )ar *oun+il a=ains- Muhammad j Ashraf Jadoon, Advo+a-e, 3;abi
res4onden-,.> alle=in= -herein, -ha- res4onden- ;ho is 4ra+-isin= la;?er in 2is-ri+- *our-s, 3;abil -ha- -he son of -he
+om4lainan- Abdul Mas-an@ ;as +har=ed in a murder +ase and in -his +a ne=o-ia-ions for +om4romise ;as =oin= on ;i-h -he
+om4lainan- 4ar-?. The +om4lainan-> and !e=al "e4resen-a-ives of -he de+eased> ;as +laimin= -he 2e?a- mone? and for -his
A -he +om4lainan-. Ms-. Tajbaro sold her onl?.B house in favour of one Jah MaliC for a +onsidera-ion of "s. D2,500.
2. Tha-E -he res4onden- Advo+a-e in
3;abi *our- 4remises 4revailed u4on -he
+om4lainan- and asCed her -ha- -he sale
+onsidera-ion of "s, D2,500 is a hu=e amoun-
an+1he +om4lainan- bein= an a=ed lad? and is
air alone, is eF4osed -o ha<<ards and
eF4ressed his a44rehensions -ha- -he mone?
;ill be sna-+hed a;a? from -he +om4lainan-
,b? some one and asCed -he +om4lainan- -o Cee4 -his mone? as -rus- ;i-h -he res4onden-. The Advo+a-e ;as en-rus-ed -he
mone? in G4resen+e of ;i-nesses ;hi+h is s-ill l?in= ;i-h
r -he res4onden- Advo+a-e.
H. Tha- fur-her alle=a-ions in -he
+om4lain- are -ha- -he res4onden- ;as
f
I
re4ea-edl? reJues-ed -o re-urn -he mone? bu- Ki on one 4re-eF- or -he o-her -he res4onden- is GEGavoidin= -oGre4a? -he same and
is =oin= -o jG be-ra? -he -rus- so re4osed in -he res4onden-. ,i 3o, i- ;as 4ra?ed -ha-, dis+i4linar? a+-ion be ini-ia-ed a=ains- -he
res4onden- as he has +ommi--ed a 4rofessional mis+ondu+- under -he !e=al (ra+-i-ioners A+-, 99LH.
#. The 2is+i4linar? *ommi--ee of
%.&.'.(. )ar *oun+il ini-ia-ed 4ro+eedin=s
M a=ains- -he res4onden- and -he res4onden- submi--ed a ;ri--en s-a-emen- on 9H999999 in ;hi+h -he alle=a-ions +on-ained in
-he +om4lain- ;ere ho-l? +on-es-ed. M- ;as alle=ed -ha- -he +om4lain- is -he ou-+ome of
G. 4ersonal mali+e and =rud=es, ho;ever, i- ;as admi--ed in ;ri--en s-a-emen- -ha- -he res4onden- Advo+a-e remained as a
+ounsel for -he +om4lainan- and ;as defendin= her
I son in -he murder +ase. Mn shor- i- ;as averred -ha- -he mone? ;hi+h -he res4onden- had re+eived ;as his fee for
4rofessional du-ies and ;as no- re-urnable -o -he +om4lainan-.
5. Tha- -he 2is+i4linar? *ommi--ee of
.f.&.'.(. )ar *oun+il af-er re+ei4- of -he
;ri--en s-a-emen- of -he res4onden- fiFed -he
+ase for -he eviden+e of -he +om4lainan- for 9222000, on ;hi+h da-e -he res4onden- absen-ed himself. The 2is+i4linar?
*ommi--ee re+orded -he Geviden+e of -he +om4lainan- and +onsiderin= -he ma-erial on -he re+ord, referred -he ma--er -o -his
Tribunal vide order, da-ed 9222000, for final adjudi+a-ion.
D, %o-i+es ;ere issued -o -he 4ar-ies and -he 4ar-ies a44eared before -his Tribunal on #H2000. The
res4onden- a44eared and volun-aril? re+orded -he A follo;in= s-a-emen-I/
3-a-emen- of Mr. Muhammad Ashraf Jadoon, Advo+a-e5res4onden- on oa-hI
EM ;as 4aid "s.5D,000 in -o-o b? Ms-. Tajbaro +om4lainan-, ou- of ;hi+h M adjus-ed "s. 9D,000 for +ondu+-in= 3essions
Trial of Abdul Mas-an son of -he +om4lainan-, ;ho ;as -ried under se+-ion H02, (.(.*. in -he *our- of Addi-ional 3essions
Jud=e, 3;abi, ;hile M also adjus-ed A "s . H0, 000 ou- of . - h e abovemen-ioned amoun- for filin= an a44eal
a=ains- -he +onvi+-ion of Abdul Mas-an in (esha;ar 1i=h *our - , (es ha;ar. M r e- ur ned "s. 90,000 -o Ms-.
Muslim Taj, dau=h-er of -he +om4lainan-, %o-hin= is ou-s-andin= a=ains- me. Af-er +ommission of -he, offen+e
Abdul Mas-an ;as, abs+onder for some .-ime and M used -o mee- him durin= his abs+onden+e 4eriod in villa=e (a;oCa
and af-er -he failure of -he effor-s made for +om4romise, Abdul Mas-an ;as handed over -o 4oli+e of (oli+e 3-a-ion To4i
and he ;as dien arres-ed a++ordin=l?. M have in+urred eF4enses of Abdul Mas-an durin= -he 4eriod of his abs+onden+e

and also durin= -he 4eriod ;hen he ;as in -he lo+Cu4. The a44eal filed b? me on behalf of Abdul Mas-an in - he 1i =h
*our - a=ai ns- hi s +onvi+-ion is s-ill 4endin=. Mn order -o mee- all -hese eF4enses -he +om4lainan- has sold her
house for an amoun- of "s.D2,500 -o one Khan MaliC.E
L. The s-a-emen-s of Jan MaliC and
0mar Nada ;ere re+orded b? -he 2is+i4linar?
*ommi--ee ;hile -he +om4lainan- a44eared
and has re+orded her s-a-emen- on oa-h.
:. 6 The +om4lainan- mainl? relied on -he
s-a-emen-s of -he ;i-nesses re+orded b? -he
2is+i4linar? *ommi--ee of -he %.&.'.(.
)ar *oun+il and -he s-a-emen- of -he
res4onden-, da-ed #IH2000 and +on-ended
-ha- -he res4onden- under -he "obes of an
Advo+a-e, had -aCen a hu=e amoun- from -he
+om4lainan-, ;hi+h ;as -he saleG
+onsidera-ion of her house sold -o Jan MaliC,
(.&. 9 and -his amoun- of "s.D2,500 ;as
4aid -o -he res4onden- in 4resen+e of (.&.2
0mar Nada.
9. "es4onden- on -he o-her hand
+on-ended -ha- he a+-uall? re+eived "s.5D,500
from -he E+om4lainan- ;hi+h ;as -he
4rofessional fee as -he res4onden- ;as a
+ounsel for -he +om4lainan-Gs son in a murder
+ase ;as +ondu+-in= -he 3essions -rial in -he
*our- of 3essions Jud=e, 3;abi and on
+onvi+-ion of -he +om4lainan-Gs son -o life
im4risonmen- had filed a A+riminal a44eal in
. -he 1i=h *our- and -hus, "s. 9.D,000 and "s. Thir-? -housand, had been +har=ed for -he +ases as his 4rofessional fee and
- he remainin= "s. Ten -housand ;as 4aid -o -he dau=h-er of -he +om4lainan- Ms-. Taj )ibi. M- ;as fur-her submi--ed -ha- ;hen
-he +om4lainan-Gs son ;as a 4ro+laimed offender in murder +ase and ;hile livin= as abs+onder
in villa=e (o;aCa (esha;ar and durin= his de-en-ion in jail -he res4onden- used -o 4rovide and mee- his eF4enses and for all
-his -he +om4lainan- had sold her d;ellin= house for a sGale +onsidera-ion of "s. D2,500.
90. The narra-ion of -he above fa+-s and
submissions of -he 4ar-ies ;ould sho; -ha-
-he res4onden- admi-s -he sale of -he house b?
-he +om4lainan- and re+ei4- of -he mone? bu-
;i-h a differen- version as =iven in his
s-a-emen- da-ed #H2000. The eviden+e on
-he re+ord has +learl? es-ablished -ha- -he
+om4lainan- sold -he house and sale
+onsidera-ion ;as Ce4- ;i-h -he res4onden- as
sa+red -rus- ;hi+h la-er on -he res4onden-
refused -o 4a? and -he version of -he
+om4lainan- and her ;i-nesses is full?
+orrobora-ed b? E -he s-a-emen- of -he
res4onden- re+orded before -his Tribunal on
oa-h. G .
99. There is eviden+e on re+ord -ha- -he
res4onden- did re+eive a hu=e amoun- from
-he +om4lainan- ;hi+h -he sale 4ro+eeds of
her onl? house and -he mone? ;as Ce4- ;i-h
-he res4onden- as sa+red -rus- and on demand
-he res4onden- refused -o re4a? -he same and
-ried -o jus-if? -he same as his fee arid
eF4enses of -he +om4lainan-Gs son ;hen he
;as in abs+onsion.
92. AnGAdvo+a-e enjo?s a ver? hi=h
4osi-ion in -he so+ie-? and he ;ould +ondu+- O
himself in su+h a ;a? so as -o =i ve leas-
sus4i+ion -o his +lien- re=ardin= -he dis-rus-
and no- -o be-ra? -he -rus- re4osed in him b?
his +lien-. An Advo+a-e is al;a?s eF4e+-ed -o
u4hold -he di=ni-? of his 4rofession and i-s
hi=h s-andard bo-h ;i-hin and ou-side -he
*our- as 4rovided b? "ules 9H# and 9L2 of
-he !e=al (ra+-i-ioners and )ar *oun+il
"ules, 99LD and an? viola-ion of -hese rules
;ill amoun- -o a 4rofessional mis+ondu+- as
4rovided b? rule 9L5A of -he "ules (ibid.)
a
Mn vie; of -he fa+-s and +ir+ums-an+es of -he +ase narra-ed above, ;e find -he a++used =uil-? of
4rofessional mis+ondu+- and order his sus4ension from -he O= 4ra+-i+e for 4eriod of -hree ?ears +ommen+in= from 2#D2000 and
-he res4onden- is fur-her dire+-ed -o refund -he amoun- of "s. 5D,000 M Pfif-? siF -housand) -o -he +om4lainan-.
JM) T.59DH5( .rder a++ordin=l?.
JUDGM
ENT
Q > > 999D M!2 59D
[N.-W.F.P. Bar Council Tribunal]
Before Justice Mian Muhammad Ajmal, Chairman, Muhammad Younas Tinoli and Muhammad Alam Khan,
Members
Ms-. 3A"&AT and ano-her/(e-i-ioners versus
A0"A%7N8) K1A% A0"AKNAM, A2Q.*AT8 (831A&A"/"es4onden-
*om4lain-s %os.T59 of 9992 and T55 of 9995, de+ided on 92-h .+-ober, 9995.
M01AMMA2 A!AM K1A% (M8M)8"G)./ This sin=le jud=men- ;ill dis4ose of -he +om4lain- bearin= %umbers
T5l of 9992 and T55 of 9995 as bo-h 4er-ains -o (rofessional Mis+ondu+- and have been filed a=ains- Auran=<eb .raC<ai,
Advo+a-e, (esha;ar and +ommon le=al and fa+-ual Jues-ions a=ains- -he same res4onden-5Advo+a-e are involved in bo-h of -he
+om4lain-s.
2. *om4lain- %o. T5l of 9992 ;as filed b? Ms-. 3ar;a- +om4lainan- Jn 29:9999 in -he %.&.'.(. )ar *oun+il (esha;ar,
alle=in= -herein, -ha- her husband Muhammad "asheed %asir and her son Ali 1?der, had been arres-ed b? -he *.l.2. (oli+e on
-he +har=es of smu==lin= %ar+o-i+. .n +omin= -o Cno; abou- -he arres- of her husband, -he +om4lainan- +ame -o (esha;ar -o
enJuire abou- -he fa+-s of -he +ase and -o arran=e for -he bail of her husband and release of -he vehi+le. 3he fur-her alle=ed
-ha- durin= her firs- visi- on #59999 she
.&!.
59:
Mon-hl? !a; 2i=es-
MQol.R1
------------- ----------fc..w.ui.^u <JI
bo-h -he +ases is.-ha-, -he res4onden- never +ondu+-ed iiii+n +ases and nei-her he re-urned -he fee
re+eived nor rendered an? 4rofessional du-ies -o -he +om4lainan-s and as -he res4onden- has +ommi--ed a =ross
4rofessional mis+ondu+- as envisa=ed under -he 4rovisions of !e=al (ra+-i-ioners and )ar *oun+ils A+-, 99LH and -he rules
framed -hereunder has 4ra?ed for -aCin= sui-able le=al a+-ion a=ains- -he res4onden-.
#. The 2is+i4linar? *ommi--ee of -he %.&.'.(. )ar *oun+il ini-ia-ed 4ro+eedin=s a=ains- -he res4onden- and issued
no-i+es -o -he res4onden- -o a44ear before -he learned Members of -he *ommi--ee. Mn *om4lain- %o.T55 of 9995 -he
res4onden- on+e a44eared before -he 2is+i4linar?, *ommi--ee of -he %.&.'.(. )ar *oun+il on 29L9995 and -hereaf-er
absen-ed himself. ff *om4lain- %o.T59 of 9992 -he res4onden- submi--ed his ;ri--en s-a-emen-. The 2is+i4linar? *ommi--eeG
re+orded -he s-a-emen- of -he +om4lainan- and -ha- of -he res4onden-5Advo+a-e and -he *ommi--ee af-er +onsiderin= -he da-a
available on -he re+ord vide i-s findin=s da-ed 9909992 and 299995 res4e+-ivel?,G referred -he ma--er -o -his Tribunal
for final adjudi+a-ion.
5. Mn -he ;ri--en s-a-emen- of -he res4onden- -he alle=a-ions +on-ained in -he +om4lain- ;ere ho-l? +on-es-ed. M-
;as ho;ever admi--ed in -he ;ri--enI
t'
3ar;a- (Ms-.) v. Auran=<eb Khan AuraC<ai 599
+ame in +on-a+- ;i-h -he one 7ohar Ali shah r5o !aCar Mandi, (esha;ar and u narra-ion of -he fa+-s re=ardin= -he arres-
of -he husband and son of -h
=fff=G (Muhammad Alam
Khan, Member)
/ !",! o;.i m m+O1s-a-e>en-, -hai -he +ase of -he +om4lainan-Gs husband and son ;as
ini-iall? bein=
, o
Ah 3hah advised her -o en=a=e Auran=<eb .raC<ai, Advo+a-e5res4onden-
f
S
7
S
har

A@i

3hah

;as

a
(
rom
inen- +ounsel
+om4lainan- -he said 7ohar Ali 3hah re+eived a sum of "s.2L,000 for en=a=in=ii+oi&ied b? Mr. MJbal Ahmad 2urrani,
Advo+a-e and la-er on, -he res4onden- a +ounsel, 4a?men- -o 4oli+e offi+ers and o-her allied eF4enses. The +om4lainanfG
;as
B
>i=ed and -he -o-al fee re+eived b? -he res4onden- ;as "s.#0,000 and no- fur-her alle=ed -ha->on her se+ond visi- -o
(esha;ar on #59999, -he said 7oharf "s@sfOOT0GGas alle=ed b? -he +om4lainan- in her +om4lain-. The res4onden-
I,furlhelissen+d -ha- -he bail a44li+a-ion ;as ar=ued before -he learned 3essions
GU@GAV#$%&#'^(^)*+ A 9 l . . . W . . @AWA WWWWWWWWWWWWWW WWWWA .WWWWWW9 X6MWWWWWWWWW. V@WX WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW9 U@
Ju3=e>esha;ar, bin as a 4rima fa+ie +ase eFis-ed a=ains- -he a++used, -hus
, - " '
WWWW .._______ ^^in.!^.n ".#$U"J%&-" il'#J""(
+on-a+-s ;i-h Ma=is-ra-es and 4oli+e 4ersonnel. And in -his ;a? -he +om4lainan-
en=a=ed -he res4onden- as +ounsel and -he -o-al fee ;as se--led as "s.:L.000,
(8i=h-?seven -housand) ou- of ;hi+h "s. 90,000 ;as -he fee for 4rofessional,
du-ies of -he res4onden- and a++ordin= -o -he res4onden-, -he res- had -o be 4aidj
-o -he +on+erned offi+ial5offi+ers of -he 4oli+e for -he release of -he husband and
son of -he +om4lainan-. This amoun- of "s.:L,000 ;as 4aid b? -he +om4lainan
-o -he res4onden-. . G
ft
ji
H. *om4lain- %o.T55 of 9995 ;as filed b? one 3ajjad 1ussain r5o *haherO
Tehsil and 2is-ri+- *haC;al in -he %.&.'.(. )ar *oun+il, (esha;ar on 9H5999H a=ains- -he same res4onden- Mr.
Auran=<eb .raC<ai. The alle=a-ions in -he la--er +om4lain- a=ains- -he res4onden- summari<ed in brief are -ha- -heE
res4onden- me- -he +om4lainan- in a Tabli=hiMj-ima (*on=re=a-ion of 4rea+hin=Q Mslam) and -here -he res4onden-
in-rodu+ed himself as an Advo+a-e -o -he'U +om4lainan-. The +om4lainan- sou=h- -he advi+e of -he res4onden- in a
murder +ase in ;hi+h -he un+le of -he +om4lainan- had been murdered and -he@ res4onden- under-ooC -o +ondu+-
-his +ase on 4a?men- of "s.#0,000 (for-?G -housand) as a++ordin= -o -he res4onden- "s.20,000 ;as -he fee and
-heB remainin= amoun- ;ill defra? o-her eF4enses of -he +ase. The =rievan+e of -he,
)*$-unr+"oiniT-if r i, -./U /0-._ - 1
t JUUJiC^rCaiJflW'l2 Ulll r3.4 ll \n iiu' i'iac5 6-aa3 C7J.86CU a(cuiiai &&&^ a^9-uo^u2 6UUJ
!I-heirOOMOj,@a44li+a-ion ;as reje+-ed and
fur-hermore, he en=a=ed for -he said G
a++usOdUMr. Tasleem 1ussain, Advo+a-e in
-he 1i=h *our- and 4aid him his fee j
from
@
-ill4o+Ce- of -he .res4onden-. )u-
-he bail a44li+a-ion ;as, ho;ever, G
reje+-edbGb? -he au=us- (esha;ar 1i=h
*our-, (esha;ar. The res4onden- -ermed
E-he +om4lain-G-o be false, un+alled for and
beref- of le=al san+-i-?. 1en+e 4ra?ed ,Ef4r
-hejjilismissal of -he same .and
a;ardin= of severe 4unishmen- -o -he
+om4lafiam.
BQBD.YOinG
v
his s-a-emen- re+orded before
-he 2is+i4linar? *ommi--ee on ,2:99
9999,. -he res4onden- a=reed -o 4a?
"s.5#,000 -o -he +om4lainan- in
GGins-almen-sB.B, his s-a-emen- re+orded
on oa-h, in verba-im is re4rodu+ed as
IIunden/99>B. G .
.........................Z
G> ,K-jie +on-en-s of -he +om4lain-
;ere heard. M a=ree -o 4a? -he sum
of UB"KG5#,000 ('if-?four
-housand) in -;o ins-almen-s
;i-hin a 4eriod of
I
.j-v>DBBmon-hs.G'irs- ins-almen-
of "s.2L,000 (T;en-?seven
-housand)
@
;lQbe 4aid on 2D92
9999 and -he remainin=
"s.2L,000 on 2:99992 II5.before
-he +ounsel of -he +om4lainan-.E.
i- f.-f-f
:
:-^r L ; "V^jfj"! / ' ' ' - - ' , - ' <
4>OIl>K->H4,i.i- seems JI -ha- -he res4onden- 4aid "s.20,000 (T;en-? -housand)
B \ -o -he +om4lainan- as is eviden- from
her s-a-emen- da-ed 2D929999 and
for. -he G+iminin= "s.L,000 -he
res4onden- reJues-ed for -ime nil 95-h
Januar?
#I9992. The3re+ord sho;s -ha- nei-her -he
balan+e ins-almen- of "s.L,000 nor -he
rernamm= "s.2L,000 has been refunded
-o -he +om4lainan-K 1o;ever, -he
res4onden- submi--ed, an a44li+a-ion in
-he sha4e of an under-aCin= da-ed 9H
2#992 and in ;hi+h he under-ooC -o
de4osi-, -he balan+e Gamoun- of
. Ks,H#,000 ;i-h -he 2e+i4linar?
*ommi--ee ;i-hin 965 da?s from 9H2
9992I> )u- m s4ue of -he under-aCin=
-he res4onden- did no- abide b? -he
same, ou-, -he re+ord sho;s his -o-al
failure -o 4a? -he a=reed sum -o
-he
..+om4lainan-. E
. L MaliC 1amid 3aeed, learned
Addi-ional Advo+a-e7eneral mainl?G
relied on -ile admission in -he s-a-emen-
of -he res4onden- ;herein, -he fa+-um of
-he .++ei4- and 4ar- re4a?men- of a
sum of "s.5#,000 ;as admi--ed b? -he
res4onden- on oa-h in his s-a-emen-
before -he *ommi--ee and his 4an
4a?men- rZnn .
0l
SrS
- 0

- he

+om
(Gainan-
and +on-ended, -ha- -he +ondu+- of
-he
es4onden- in re+eivin= -he mone? from
-he +om4lainan- and refusin= -o do his
un1,@@
&H3

=r
S
3sl?

im
(rS(er and
amoun- -o 4rofessional mis+ondu+-
under Me 4rovisions of !e=al (ra+-i-ioners
and )ar *oun+ils A+-, 99LH and
-he -nereunder. The learned
Addi-ional Advo+a-e7eneral
s4e+ifi+all? -o rules 95H, 95#
and 955 of -he rules
abovememioned and relied on a
M,n
i iG 0r - i
9

520
$Qol. RMQ
Mon-hl? !a; 2i=es-G
jud=men- of Kara+hi 1i=h *our- Abdul A<i< *haudhr? v. Abdul &ahBilT Khan MaliC, Advo+a-e re4or-ed in (!2 99D# Kar5
4a=e DH0 and +on-ended -ha- -he +ondu+- of -he res4onden-, +omes ;i-h in -he four +orners of 4rofessional
9
mis+ondu+-
and his enrolmen- +er-ifi+a-e5li+en+e -o 4ra+-i+e is bailable -o. +an+ella-ion and 4ra?ed for -he removal (of -he
res4onden-Gs name from 4ra+-isin= -he le=al 4rofession.
;
:. *on-en-ions of -he learned Addi-ional Advo+a-e7eneral dul?
+onsidered. The res4onden- ;as dire+-ed b? -his Tribunal on 9L9995 -o de4osi-f
-he balan+e ins-almen- of "s.L,000 ;i-h -he 3e+re-ar? of -he %.&.'.(. )arU
*oun+il (esha;ar, ;hi+h he failed -o de4osi-. A=ain on 9099995 -he +ounsel
for -he res4onden- Mr. Tasleem 1ussain, Advo+a-e s-a-ed a- -he bar, -ha- he ;illf
4rodu+e -he res4onden- before -he Tribunal on :909995 and he ;ill de4osi- -helB
amoun- of "s.L,000 as ordered b? -hisGTribunal. &hen -he +ase +ame for hearin=U
on 92909995 none ;as 4resen- on behalf of -he res4onden- and -hus he ;asGG
4la+ed eF 4ar-e.
9. (erusal of -he re+ord sho;s, -ha- -he +ondu+- of -he res4onden- before
-he 2is+i4linar? *ommi--ee.as is eviden- from -he various order shee-s an,, asE -
;ell as before -his Tribunal ;as hi=hl? obje+-ionable. 1e bein= an Advo+a-e,B
-aCin= undue advan-a=e froni his 4osi-ion as an Advo+a-e -ried his level bes- -o
frus-ra-e -he 4ro+ess of -his Tribunal. 1is under-aCin= -o re4a? -he mone? and
-hen his nonabidin= b? -heG same has reall? 4er4e-ua-ed -he a>on? of -he
+om4lainan-, ;ho hails from a farflun= area of 2is-ri+- Kasur, (unjab and
similar is -he 4osi-ion of -he +om4lainan- in *om4lain- %o.T55 of 9995 ;ho@
.-ravels from *haC;al -o 4ersue his =rievan+es. B
90. (erusal of -he re+ord reveals, and -he same has been admi--ed b? -he@
res4onden- -ha- he has re+eived -he amoun- from -he +om4lainan- as men-ioned
in -heir +om4lain-s and has failed -o .render his 4rofessional du-ies as an
Advo+a-e. %o-hin= has been brou=h- on re+ord b? -he res4onden-, even -o
su==es- -ha- he ever a44eared in *our-s for -he +om4lainan-. This +ondu+- of -he
res4onden- is unbe+omin= of an Advo+a-e, ;ho enjo?s a ver? hi=h 4osi-ion in
-he so+ie-?, and -he +ondu+- is s-inCin=l? abominable in bo-h -he +ases, on -;o
o++asions, he re+eived -he mone? from his +lien-s arid a- -he same -ime abs-ained
-o 4erform his 4rofessional du-ies as an Advo+a-e. The mone? of -he +lien- is
al;,GV?s a sa+red -rus- ;i-h -heir +ounsel and an? be-ra?al of -his -rus- ;ill
defini-el? amoun- -o a 4rofessional mis+ondu+- as held b? -heir !ordshi4s in
(!2 99D# Kar. 4a=e DH0 +i-ed b? -he learned Addi-ional Advo+a-e7eneral,G
%.&B.'.(. G A
99. Kee4in= in vie; -he fa+-s and +ir+ums-an+es of -he above +ases, ;e find
-he res4onden- =uil-? of 4rofessional mis+ondu+- and order -he +an+ella-ion of
his li+en+e -o 4ra+-ise -he le=al 4rofession and his immedia-e removal
from . -he le=al 4rofession >nder se+-ion #9, subse+-ion ( 9 ) of -he !e=al
(ra+-i-ioners and )ar *oun+ils A+-, 99LH, &e are also of -he linn vie; -ha- -he
+om4lainan-s in -hese +om4lain-s have suffered a lo- b? -raversin= -he *our-s
M i. n + M

999D,
%ajeebud2in v. %i<amud2in 529
(TasadduJ 1ussain Jilani, J)
Z for suffi+ien-l? lon= -ime. Thus ;e im4ose a +os-s of "s.H#,000
,Ynur -housand) and "s.#0,000 ('or-? -housand) on -he res4onden- under
[m eFe+u-able under subse+-ion (Ha) of -he A+- ibid, b? 3enior *ivil
, A (esha;ar ;hi+h on re+over? ;ill be de4osi-ed ;i-h -he 3e+re-ar?
% I&.'.(. )a- *oun+il, (esha;ar, 4a?able -o Ms-. 3ar;a- and 3ajjad 1ussain.
+om4lainan-s res4e+-ivel?.
AA5 9995(5 T G ..rder a++ordin=l?.
999DM!2529
A $!ahore,
Before Tasaddu/ 0ussain Jilani, J %AJ88)022M% alias %AJMM022M%./A44ellan-
versus
%MNAM022M%/"es4onden- .
."e=ular 3e+ond A44eal %o.H:: of 99LH, de+ided on 9H-h %ovember, 9995. (a) \anune3hahada- (90 of 99:#)/
WWWAr-s 2f- ) ( + ) ] 9H2/(resum4-ion/&i-ness no- +rosseFamined on a
ma-erial 4ar- of his eviden+e/8ffe+-/&hen a ;i-ness ;as no- +rosseFamined on a vi-al 4oin- in issue, a valid
4resum4-ion +ould be dra;n abou- -he -ru-h of -he ma--er no- Jues-ioned, $4. 52#, A
A Ms-. %oor, Jehan )e=um -hrou=h !e=al "e4resen-a-ives v. 3?ed
Muj-aba Ali %aJvi 9999 3*M" 2H00 ref.
-b) (ui?ab (reem4-ion A+- (M of 999H)/
WWW3s. # ] L/3ui-, for 4reem4-ion*us-om of 4reem4-ion/(roof of
eFis-en+e/.n filin= sui- for 4reem4-ion b? 4lain-iff, vendee resis-ed same +on-endin= -ha- +us-om of 4reem4-ion did no-
eFis- in lo+ali-? in ;hi+h sui- 4ro4er-? ;as si-ua-ed/(lain-iff no- onl? 4rodu+ed ;i-nesses -o 4rove -ha- +us-om of 4re
em4-ion eFis-ed in -he lo+ali-?, bu- also filed +o4? of sui- for 4reem4-ion and order of *our-, ;hereb? 4reem4-ion sui-
filed in res4e+- of 4ro4er-? si-ua-ed in -he same lo+ali-? ;as finall? de+reed in favour of 4reem4-or/
2efendan-5vendee had failed -o 4rove -ha- 4ro4er-? in dis4u-e ;as si-ua-ed in lo+ali-? ;herein +us-om of 4reem4-ion
did no- eFis-/(lain-iff havin= 4roved -ha- +us-om of 4reem4-ion eFis-ed in lo+ali-? in ;hi+h sui- 4ro4er-? ;as si-ua-ed,
his sui- for 4reem4-ion +ould no- be dismissed on =round -ha- +us-om of 4reem4-ion did no- eFis- in -he lo+ali-?, $4. 525,
) .
2r. MJbal Ahmad *haudhr? v. Muhammad Mna?a- -hrou=h !e=al 1eirs
Mon-hl? !a; 2i=es-
$Qol. QMMM
9##0
(e-i-ion a++e4-ea
M.).A.5#0L51.*.A
"a<ia )e=um v. Muhammad MshaJ, Advo+a-e 9##9
(3hafiur "ahman, *hairman)
sea-s for =ivin= admission -o -he 4e-i-ioner. Mn su44or- of -his +on-en-ion rein
;as 4la+ed on *hairman 3ele+-ion *ommi--ee, )olan Medi+al *olle=e, \ue--G
+ase, 99L9 3 * M " 529. M- ;as also a +ase of admission in )olan,Medi+
r
*olle=e. Mn -ha- +ase, -he learned Jud=e of )alo+his-an 1i=h *our-, an a++e4-@
-he +ons-i-u-ional 4e-i-ion, issued a dire+-ion -o -he au-hori-ies -o in+rease -h
number of sea-s for admission of -he 4e-i-ioner. Mr. Jus-i+e Muhammad ACram
-he learned Jud=e of -he 3u4rerfie *our- ;ho re+orded -he verdi+- of -he *our-GG
disa=reed ;i-h -he manner of dire+-ion bu- a- -he same -ime, refused -o in-erfere
in -he order of -he 1i=h *our-. M- ;as also a +ase of admission in Ga Medi+alUG
*olle=e ;here -he 4e-i-ioner ;as denied admission on a++oun- Eof domi+uQ>G
+er-ifiea-erThe number of sea-s havin= been fiFed, s-uden-s havin= lesser marCsUE
;ere =iven admission ins-ead of -he 4e-i-ioner. Mn su+h +ir+ums-an+es, -he *our4G
+ame -o -he, +on+lusion -ha- -he res4onden-s ;ho se+ured admission ins-ead
II
E:(f
-he 4e-i-ioner, ;ere no- a- faul-, as a+-uall? -he admission ;as denied -o5 -lefi
4e-i-ioner on a++oun- of ;ron= de+ision of -he 3ele+-ion *ommi--ee. Mn 4resen->
+ase, su+h a si-ua-ionjj4es no- arise, as in fa+- -he number of sea-s is no- fiseff--
The res4onden-s have, in -heir defen+e, +on+eded -ha- -he number of s+a-s fiFe33
ori=inall?, ;as la-er on in+reased -o a++ommoda-e s-uden-s in+ludin= -hose ;lilf@
;ere admi--ed on -he re+ommenda-ion of -he *han+ellor. The res4onden-s hav3@
onl? -o 4rovide admission -o -he 4e-i-ioner irres4e+-ive of -he fa+- -ha- one sea--
shall have -o be added in rou-ine. Mn )anshidharGs +ase, AM" 99DH "ajas-han 9L2B@
a s-uden- ;asdenied admission in !!.). +lass. 1e invoCed -he jurisdi+-ion of iOel
1i=h *our-. The 4e-i-ioner +laimed -ha- he ;as a =radua-e from -he 7ujff(
0niversi-? as a 4riva-e +andida-e. 1e ;as denied admission on a++oun- of-a?4l
=radua-ed as>a 4riva-e +andida-e. The learned Jud=e arrived a- -he +on+lus(
-ha- su+h a +ondi-ion ;as viola-ive of la;, as su+h -he au-hori-ies ;ere dire+lef
=ran- admission -o -he 4e-i-ioner. An obje+-ion ;as raised on behalf
0niversi-? au-hori-ies -ha- admission in !!.). +lasses bein= dis+r+-i4r-ar?44il
1i=h *our- +ould no- in-ervene in -he same. The learned Jud=e overruieHjO
obje+-ion and heldI/ > iKZl
E-ha- -he ma--er of admission ;as no- dis+re-ionar?. )ein= -he heaAjT,OjO 4ubli+ ins-i-u-ion i- ;as -he du-? of -he
(rin+i4al -o a+- a++ordin= -;ill
" - '' "
;
'^'1s,vji8s
in -he ma--er of admission and he +ould no- i=nore -he rules andfef--sli admission a- his s;ee- ;ill. The 4e-i-ion
;as main-ainable.GG QM,I3M3^)
99. The aforesaid reasons lead -o -he +on+lusion -ha- -he a+-ionB res4onden-s in den?in= admission -o
-he 4e-i-iener is 4urel?a r b l > dis+rimina-or? and viola-ive of ri=h- of eJuali-? before la; and eJual 4ro-e+Oi\>=@
la;. The 4e-i-ion is, -herefore, a++e4-ed. The res4onden-s are dire+-ed ->nGre3-a- admission -o -he 4e-i-ioner in M.3+.
(h?si+s ;i-hin -hree da?s
f
romW-lnsWf.
9990 M ! 2 9##9 $Tribunal of (aCis-an )ar *oun+il,
Before Shafiur 1ahman, Chairman and 1aja 0a/ 2a3a4 KJian, Member
Ms-. "ANMA )870M/*om4lainan-
_
versus
3ardar M01AMMA2 M31A\, Advo+a-e/"es4onden-
2is+i4linar? *om4lain- %o. 2L of 99::, de+ided on 9#-h Mar+h, 9990.
U 5 ' + +
!e=al (ra+-i-ioners and )ar *oun+ils A+- (RRRQ of 99LH) /
3. #9(#)/(aCis-an !e=al (ra+-i-ioners and )ar,*oun+ils "ules, 99LD, ". 9#5/ $ofessional mis+ondu+-/2is+i4linar?
+ommi--ee/"es4onden-, (Advo+a-e) -in= su4ervised -he %iCah in -he sense -ha- he 4ermi--ed i- -o be held a- his
iden+e and ;as asso+ia-ed ;i-h i-, should no- have a44eared as a +ounsel on mlf of male 4ar-? -o %iCah in -he +ase under
.ffen+e of Nina (8nfor+emen- ofjdood) .rdinan+e, 99L9 re=is-ered a=ains- -he male4ar-? -o -he said ria=e/
"es4onden- asso+ia-ed himself ;i-h -he +ase a- a s-a=e ;hen -he i-emen- of a++used ;as re+orded b? -he Ma=is-ra-e/
"es4onden-Gs ;i-hdra;al im -1e 4ro+eedin=s had been re+orded b? -he 3essions Jud=e (1udood *our-) ,his o;n ;ords
-ha- EM ;i-hdra; m? QaCala-name as -he 4rose+u-ion had +i-ed as 4rose+u-ion ;i-ness, as -he same ;as no- in m?
Cno;led=e and moreover M -he advo+a-e for -he a++used from -he ver? be=innin= and had +rosseFamined 4rose+u-ion
before -he submission of final +hallan and -he same ;as full? ;n and in -he Cno;led=e of -he Mnves-i=a-in= .ffi+er
of -he +aseE/1eld, ifli+- of in-eres- as a ;i-ness in -he +ase should have been +lear -o res4onden- in -he ver? be=innin=
and he should no- have +har=ed -he fee or a44eared on \, fialf of a++used as a +ounsel/"es4onden- -o -his eF-en- had
been no- +areful E Ei=h and had +ommi--ed 4rofessional mis+ondu+- in -erms of ". 9#5, (aCis-an il (ra+-i-ioners and )ar
*oun+ils "ules, 99LD ;i-h re=ard -o +ondu+- ;i-h -he ai-s2is+i4linar? *ommi--ee found -ha- a re4rimand for -he
mis+ondu+- Glid be suffi+ien- and 4a?men- of +os-s of "s. 92,000 -o -he +om4lainan-, 90,000 of ;hi+h ;ill be
reimbursed of -he fee, ;hi+h should no- have been i-=ed/"e4rimand, ho;ever, ;as ordered -o be en-ered in -he
rolls of i+a-e a=ains- -he name of -he res4onden-, $4. 9###, A ] ) C,
."28"
31A'M0" "A1MA% (*1AM"MA%)./The 2is+i4linar? *ommi--ee @be (aCis-an )ar *oun+il has b? an order
da-ed 2#D99:9 referred under fen #9(#) of -he !e=al (ra+-i-ioners and )ar *oun+ils A+-, 99LH, a +om4lain- Jb? Ms-.
"a<ia )e=um a=ains- 3ardar Muhammad MshaJ, Advo+a-e, maCin= le=a-ions of 4rofessional mis+ondu+- a=ains- hirn.
9990,
$Qol. QMMM
9##2
ft
Mon-hl? !a;. 2i=es-
2. Mn her +om4lain- da-ed #-h of 3e4-ember, 99::, addressed lo -he 3e+re-ar?, (aCis-an )ar *oun+il, she
made -he follo;in= =rievan+esI
--6 U
(i) The res4onden- +har=ed a sum of "s.90,000 for arran=in= -he marria=f of her son Mobeen Ahmad in his o;n 'la-
A20, 3uleman Terra+e, 3ir 3uleman 3hah "oad, Kara+hi, ;i-h one Ms-. Mahin 3iddiJui, ;hose 4aren-s ;ere no-
;illin= -o =ive her hand in marria=eB and in res4e+- of -his even- a +riminal +ase ;as =o- re=is-ered b? Asad 0llah
3iddiJui, bro-her of Ms-. Mahin 3iddiJui under -he .ffen+e of Nina (8nfor+em+nl of 1udood) .rdinan+e, 99L9
vide '.M.". %o. ## of 99:5, ;hi+h +ame u4 for -rial as a *ase %o. H005:5 before -he Addi-ional 3essions Jud=e 8as-,
Kara+hi in ;hi+h -he res4onden- a44eared as +ounsel of Mobin Ahmed
(ii) The res4onden- advised -he son of -he +om4lainan- -o ins-i-u-e a +ase for res-i-u-ion of +onju=al ri=h-s foi ;hi+h he
demanded se4ara-el? a sum of "s.5,000 ;hi+h ;as 4aid -o him and *ase %o. 50D599:5 ;as filed b? him.
(iii) The res4onden- ;as no- +ondu+-in= -he +ase of Mobin Ahmed 4ro4erl? and he a++ordin= -o -he Cno;led=e and
belief of -he +om4lainan- had -aCen Ea -all s-un of mone? from -he bro-her of Mahin 3iddiJui, lo seeC a divor+e of
Mahin 3iddiJui on KhulaE.
(iv) The *our- in ;hi+h -he +riminal +ase ;as 4endin= on +omin= -o Cno;
-ha- -he marria=e had -aCen 4la+e a- -he residen+e of -he res4onden- and
;as arran=ed b? him, disallo;ed him -o +ondu+- -he +ase as his +ondu+-
of -he +ase -ill -hen ;as ille=al. . .
(v) .n -he im4ro4er advi+e of -he res4onden-, Mobin Ahmed had -o divor+e Mahin 3iddiJui.
3he +on+luded her +om4lain- in -he follo;in= ;ordsI G W A
E3ardar Muhammad MshaJ, no- onl? bla+Cmailed m? son, bu- also eF-ra+-ed -all sums of mone?, vi<. "s. 90,000
for -he marria=e, "s.5,000 for filin= -he +ase for -he "es-i-u-ion of *onju=al "i=h-s and "s. 95,000 for -he main
+ase. 1e -herefore eFra+-ed "s.H0,000. M +anno- 4rodu+e a re+ei4- of "s. 95,000 from 3ardar Muhammad MshaJ, as
i- is +us-omar? -ha- la;?ers -aCe all fees in advan+e and do no- issue re+ei4-s. )u- lu+Cil? for me a re+ei4- of "s.
95,000 issued -o m? fa-her is a--a+hed, ;hi+h ;ill am4l? 4rove -ha- 3ardar Muhammad MshaJ +ould no- have
arran=ed -he marria=e of m? son and filed -he +ase for "es-i-u-ion ol *onju=al "i=h-s, =ra-is.
Mr. Ahmad 2in, m? old fa-her and M have suffered a 4eriod of over -hVe ?ears of a=on?, an=uish and nervesha--erin=
;orr?, besides finan+ial los a- -he hands of 3ardar Muhammad MshaJ. M? son and M ;ere n +onversan- ;i-h
-he le=al 4ro+edure of -he *our-. M? son, full? rel?in= o 3ardar Muhammad MshaJ, a+-ed eFa+-l? as dire+-ed b? him.
*ravin= for jus-i+e a- ?our +a4able hands, M mos- res4e+-full? reJues- ?

1443
"a5.ia )e=um v. Muhammad MshaJ, Advo+a-e (3hafiur "ahman, *hairman)
-o Cindl? order -he re+over? of -he amoun- of "s.H0,000 from 3ardar Muhammad MshaJ and 4a?men- -o me. 3ardar
Muhammad MshaJ, in -he +ourse of -his +ase -rea-ed m? old and re-ired fa-her mos- shamelessl?, abnoFiousl?5;ilh
u--er disres4e+-, as M a ;oman +ould never run af-er him in -he +ourse of -his +ase. 1is role, bo-h le=al and moral
in Cee4in= ba+C -he fa+-s of -his +ase and bein= handin=love ;i-h -he 4rose+u-ion, is a subje+- -o be deal- ;i-h
b? Your 1onour, -o save, unfor-una-e ;omen liCe me, ;ho fall vi+-im lo su+h +ir+ums-an+es be?ond -heir
+on-rol.E
H. The res4onden- in his re4l? lo ih+ +om4lain- denied -he alle=a-ions and alle=ed -ha- one Mr. "ehma- Ansari A.(.(.
;ho is inimi+al lo him has been 2s-rum+n-al in 4rom4-in= M lie +om4lainan- -o inssi-ul+ -he +om4lain-. A++ordin= Bo him he
had been a44earin= in +ases ins-i-u-ed a=ains- -he +om4lainan- and her ion 1er sbn, a++ordin= -o him, had 4ar-i+ularl? a
+riminal re+ord and al-er haCin= men-ion of -he earlier en=a=emen-s in +riminal +ases, he denied as a fa+- laun= +har=ed
an? fee for arran=in= -he marria=e a- his residen+e -hou=h he idmilled -ha- a- -he reJues- of -he fa-her of -he
+om4lainan-, (=randfa-her of Mobin Ahm.f.d), he allo;ed -he marria=e -o be solemni<ed a- his fla-. 1e denied &vin=
es-ablished an? +on-a+-s ;ilh -he famil? of Mahin 3iddiJui or -o have been -on over b?,-hem. .n -he +on-rar? he s-a-ed -ha-
Mobin Ahmad himself ;as a Jarl? -o all -rie +ivil li-i=a-ion =oin= on and i- ;as on his s-a-emen- -ha- -he *our- lad been
4assin= -he order dissolvin= -he marria=e and maCin= -he res-i-u-ion -ase infru+-uous. 1e admi--ed havin= re+eived
"s. 90,000 as 4ar- fee for +ondu+-in= -he+ase under -he 1udood .rdinan+e bu- no-hin= more. 1e had ;ndu+-ed -he
+ases 4ro4erl? and -ha- ;hen -he *our- had asCed him -o disso+ia-e from -he +ase, Mobin Ahmed, -he son of -he
+om4lainan-, had eFe+u-ed -he 4o;er of a--orne? in favour of Aslam "ana Advo+a-e, ;ho made A44earan+e on @
#.
B
The +om4lainan- Ms-. "a<ia )e=um and her fa-her Ahmad 2in i44eared as ;i-nesses in -he +ase. 3ardar
Muhammad MshaJ, res4onden-, A44eared as his o;n ;i-ness. The? 4rodu+ed +er-ain do+umen-s in su44or- of Ofar
+laim.
K
5. The fa+- -ha- -he res4onden- advised, arran=ed and 4ermi--ed -he use of is residen-ial 4remises for 4erforman+e, of
Mhe %iCah b? Mobin Ahmad ;i-h Ms-. ahin 3iddiJui is es-ablished from -he s-a-emen- of res4onden- himself. 1e had
advised s4ouses, bo-h of ;hom ;ere adul-s, -ha- -he? should re4or- -he fa+- marria=e a- -he (oli+e 3-a-ion ;hi+h
had been done, and also no- reside some -ime, as husband and ;ife, ;hi+h advi+e -oo ;as heeded for a -ime G no-
lon=.
D. As re=ards -he +har=in= of -he fee for -he 4erforman+e of -he %iCah, *re are no re+ei4-s held for i- b? -he
+om4lainan-. Mn vie; of -he ill;ill lha- he 3lo4ed 4revious -o -he lod=in= of -he +om4lain- i- ;ill no- be safe -o rel? on
s-a-emen- of -he +om4lainan- and her fa-her ;i-h re=ard lo i-s 4a?men-.
9###
Mon-hl? !a; 2i=es-
$Qol. QMMM
9990,
Muhammad MJbal v. "ia< Ahmed (ir<ada (3bafiur 0ahmVn, *hairman)
9##5

0nfor-una-el?, Mohin Ahmed, -he son of -he +om4lainan-, ;ho +ould sav some-hin= in -he mailer 4osi-ivel? be+ause he
;as -he +on+erned 4erson ;ho had been si=nin= -he do+umen-s and ;as dire+-l? involved in -he 4ro+eedui=> ;as no-
available a- -he hearin=. &e ;ill, -herefore, =ive, in res4e+- of +har=in= of f+e f0r =e--in= marria=e solemni5ed a- his
residen+e, -he benefi- of doul5l, -o -he res4onden-.
L. .ne fa+-, ho;ever, emer=es ;i-h =rea- +lari-? from -he re+ord and i- is -ha- af-er havin= arran=ed and su4ervised
-he %iCah in -he sense havin= 4ermi--ed i- -o be held a- his residen+e and -o be asso+ia-ed ;i-h i-, -he res4onden- should
no- have a44eared as a +ounsel on behalf of Mobin Ahmad in -he +ase under nhe 1udood .rdinan+e re=is-ered a=ains- him.
1e asso+ia-ed himself ;i-h ihe +ase a- a s-a=e ;hen -he s-a-emen- of Mahin 3iddiJui ;as re+orded b? -he Ma=is-ra-e
9s- *lass on 5H99:5. 1is ;i-hdra;al from -he 4ro+eedin=s has been re+orded b? -he Addi-ional 3essiosn Jud=e (1udood
*our-) Kara+hi 8as-, in -he follo;n= ;ords on 25:99::I
EM ;i-hdra; m? QaCala-nama as -he. (rose+u-ion had +i-ed me as 4rose+u-ion ;i-ness, as -he same ;as no- in
m? Cno;led=e and moreover M ;as -he advo+a-e for -he a++used from -he ver? be=innin= and had +rosseFamined
-he 4rose+u-ion on DH99:5 before -he submission of final +hallan and -he same ;as full? Cno;n and in -he
Cno;led=e of -he M... of -he +ase.E
:. The +onfli+- of in-eres- as a ;i-ness in -he +ase should have been +lear to him from -he ver? be=innin= and he
should no- have +har=ed -he fee or a44eared on behalf of Mobin Ahmed a++used as a +ounsel. To -his eF-en- -he
res4onden- has been no- +areful enou=h@ and has +ommi--ed 4rofessional mis+ondu+- in -erms of "ule 9#5 of -he !e=al
(ra+-i-ioners and )ar *oun+ils "ules, 99LD ;i-h re=ard -o +ondu+- ;i-h -he +lien-s.
9. As re=ards -he alle=a-ion -ha- Asad 0llah 3iddiJui, ;on over A -he
res4onden- or -ha- he 4aid him a subs-an-ial amoun- in order -o a==rava-e -he
a=on? of involvemen- of -he +om4lainan-Gs famil?, -here is onl? an asser-ion -o.
-ha- effe+-, and even -he fa-her of -he +om4lainan- ;ho had been handlin= -he
ma--er has admi--ed -ha- he had no 4roof of i-.
90. As re=ards -he +om4e-en+e in handlin= -he +ases and advi+es -enderedG
on various o++asions, -here +ould be bona fide error of jud=men-. The alle=a-ion
of his havin= been ;on over, remainin= unsubs-an-ia-ed, in -he ;a? -he +ases
+ro44ed u4 and -he ma--ers 4ro+eeded, i- +anno- be said -ha- -he res4onden-
delibera-el? mishandled -he +ase or ;ron=l? advised -he +om4lainan-Gs son. ,
v
.
?U
99. .n -he fa+-s 4roved, -he onl? mis+ondu+- found es-ablished a=ains- -he
res4onden- is of his havin= +har=ed -he fee of "s. 67,777 ou- of a -o-al of
"s.95,000 a=reed u4on and -o have allo;ed himself -o be en=a=ed as a +ounsel ifll
1udood .rdinan+e and -o have re4resen-ed -he a++usedJor
iln-e Mn -hai +ase ;hen he ;as himself a ;i-ness a=ains- -he a++used in -ha-
+ase as sho;n b? -he +hallan submi--ed in *our-. W
92. Mn -he +ir+ums-an+es of -he +ase, ;e ;ould +onsider -ha- a re4rimand for -he mis+ondu+- ;ould be suffi+ien- and a
4a?men- of +os-s of "s.92,000 -o -he +om4lainan-, "s. 90,000 of ;hi+h ;ill be reimbursemen- of -he fee, ;hi+h should no-
have been +har=ed a- all. The re4rimand shall be en-ered in -he rolls of Advo+a-es, a=ains- -he name of -he res4onden-.
The )ar *oun+ils, -he63u4reme *our- and -he 4ar-ies be informed a++ordin=l?.
M.)A.5#5TI(.).*
.rder a++ordin=l?.
9990 M ! 2 9##5 $Tribunal of (aCis-an )ar *oun+il,
8resent9 Shafiur 1ahman, Chairman, Abdul Karim Malik and 1aja 0a/ 2a3a4 Klian, Members '^
M01AiMMA2 M\)A!*om4lainan-
versus
3?ed "MAN A1M82 (M"NA2A and ano-her"es4onden-s 2is+i4linar? *om4lain- %o. 6 of 99:L,
de+ided on 9#-h Mar Ih, 9990. i(a) !e=al (ra+-i-ioners and )ar *oun+ils A+- (RRRQ of 99LH)/
G./3.#9(#)/Mis+ondu+-/(ro+eedin=s/&hen eviden+e bad been +on+luded and ar=umen-s heard and before -he order
+ould be finalised b? 2is+i4linar? *ommi--ee res4onden- eF4ired/(ro+eedin=s a=ains- res4onden- ;ere aba-ed.
$Aba-emen-,. $4. 9##D, A
O(b) !e=al (ra+-i-ioners and )ar *oun+ils A+- (RRRQ of 99LH)/
/3.#9(#)/Mis+ondu+-/(ro+eedin=s b? 2is+i4linar? *ommi--ee/"e+ord sho;ed -ha- res4onden- ;as en=a=ed as
Advo+a-eon"e+ord in -he +aseB -ha- he had filed +ivil 4e-i-ion for leave -o a44eal in -he 3u4reme *our- re=is-r? on H
H99:D ;i-h an a44li+a-ion for s-a? in -he ma--er/"es4onden- admi--ed -ha- G4e-i-ion ;as re-urned -o him soon af-er i-s
4resen-a-ion on HH99:D bu- +laimed -ha- he Erefiled i- -he ver? same da? af-er removin= -he obje+-ions/%o indi+a-ion
eFis-ed -o sho; -ha- 4e-i-ion ;as refiled, as had he refiled i-, he ;ould have 4ursued -he fiFa-ion of -he ur=en-
a44li+a-ion/"es4onden- admi--ed -ha- he did no- 4a? an? a--en-ion -o -he fiFa-ion 4ar- -ill :L99:L and +om4lainan-
+on-a+-ed
J
im maCin= a =rievan+e of -he ina--en-ion of his ur=en- a44li+a-ion/"es4onden- - -his s-a=e filed ano-her a44li+a-ion for
s-a?, +laimin= iGor ur=en- relief, ;hen he Gas -old -ha- -he main 4e-i-ion had no- been refiled ana ;as no- 4endin=/
es4onden- did no- a+-ivel? -aCe an? s-e4s -o maCe fur-hei =rievan+e a=ains- -he i4onsibili-? so +as- on him -ha- he had
no- refiled -he 4e-i-ion -ill 99999:L