Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/orggeochem
Abstract
A set of 18 Cretaceous rock samples from wells drilled in the Raudhatain and Minagish Oil Fields and 10 oil samples
from Cretaceous reservoirs (Raudhatain, Bahra, Burgan and Minagish Oil Fields) were characterized using geochem-
ical methods including compound-specic carbon isotope analyses of n-alkanes and isoprenoids. In addition, one oil
(Miqua) from the Jurassic (Marat Formation) of the Great Burgan Oil Field was included in the study. Despite having
high organic carbon content in some samples, the Burgan and Zubair formations and the Ratawi Shale Member, of
Albian to Valanginian age, are not source rocks for the oils for several reasons, but primarily due to lack of correlation
of molecular and isotope chemistry as well as a humic organic matter type. These results are consistent with the cor-
responding depositional conditions for these rocks, which are deltaic/estuarine in the Burgan Formation and littoral/
deltaic in the Zubair Formation. The Minagish and Sulaiy Formations of Late Jurassic to Cretaceous age appear to be
potential source rock candidates based on their molecular and bulk isotope geochemistry. Detailed isotopic analysis
using individual normal and isoprenoid C15+ alkanes did not provide a good correlation between these possible source
rocks and the oils. However, one sample from the Sulaiy Formation was found to be comparable to the oils. The oils
belong to the same genetic family and were expelled from a source rock with a dominant carbonate lithology (e.g. the
Sulaiy-Minagish Formations). These formations contain sulphur-rich, amorphous kerogen as observed in recent,
shallow marine shelf deposits. The Miqua oil, which accumulated in the Jurassic Marat Formation reservoir, does not
dier from the other oils in terms of genetic characteristics. This oil is the deepest and most mature of the set. Maturity
assessment has not been possible using well-known parameters based on steranes, terpanes or methylphenanthrenes.
However, sulphur-bearing aromatics, comprised of alkylated BT and DBT, show important variations. Parameters
based on alkylated BT and DBT have been applied successfully as tools to evaluate maturity changes. Oil maturity was
determined to be middle oil window, but has been found not to be related directly to the present depth of the reservoir.
However, it has been established that within the same oil eld, oil maturity increases with reservoir depth. Evaluation
of these maturity characteristics may be related to major chronological events, especially major tectonic movements
that have enabled oil to ll dierent reservoirs successively. The reconstruction of the most important phases, i.e.
genesis and migration through active faults, will provide guidelines to understand the present-day maturity pattern of
these oils. # 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: connan.jacques@wanadoo.fr (J. Connan), tamam@kuc01.kuniv.edu.kw (F.H. Abdullah).
0146-6380/02/$ - see front matter # 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S0146-6380(01)00143-7
126 F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148
Fig. 1. Map showing the Kuwaiti oil elds, which are producing mainly from Cretaceous reservoirs.
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148 127
The thickest Jurassic sequence accumulated in the unconformably overlain by the Gotnia and Hith For-
northwest corner of the basin, near Kuwait (Kamen- mations, deposited in a giant sabkha that covered most
Kaye, 1970). Average thickness of the lower Jurassic is parts of the basin (Murris, 1980; Beydoun, 1984). The
1456 m (4780 ft). Late Jurassic rocks in Kuwait are average thickness for these two formations in Kuwait is
represented by the Marrat Formation, which is com- 520 m (1695 ft). According to Fox (1959) this thick
posed of dense micritic limestones and wackestones, evaporite section resulted from more than one cycle of
packstones and oolithic grainstones with rare anhydrite. evaporite deposition.
This formation was deposited in an intertidal and barrier The Cretaceous was characterised by increased tectonic
environment (Yousif and Nouman, 1997). activity, which resulted in the presence of two regional
During the Middle Jurassic, the area was dominated by unconformities in the Gulf area shown in the stratigraphic
a carbonate environment (Murris, 1980). The Dhruma column of Kuwait (Fig. 2). During the Early Cretaceous
Formation ranges between 4065 m and is composed of until the end of the Valanginian, most parts of the basin
calcareous shales with rare limestones, deposited in a sub- were covered by carbonate rocks, which are represented
tidal zone of the inner-shelf (Yousif and Nouman, 1997). in Kuwait by the Sulaiy (Makhul) and Minagish For-
From the Middle Jurassic to Early Cretaceous, the mations and the lower part of the Ratawi Formation
northern part of the basin was occupied by an intra- (Limestone Member). These formations were deposited
shelf depression known as the Luristan Basin, while in intra-shelf and shallow carbonate environments. This
other parts of the Iranian side were undergoing diapiritic period was followed by regression and regional uplift,
salt movement. This silled basin remained restricted with which resulted in the deposition of clastic sediments
portions including part of Kuwait, reaching the halite including the Ratawi Shale Member, Zubair, Burgan,
evaporite deposition stage (Koop and Stoneley, 1982). Wara and Ahmadi Formations. Transgression and
Beydoun (1993) hypothesized that the ecient water deposition of the Shuaiba and Mauddud Formations
ushing from the distant ocean to this basin caused stra- interrupted the regressional periods. The Rumaila and
tication and anoxia leading to the development of Mishrif Formations, except in high areas such as the
extensive areas of sapropelic source rocks. Burgan structure, cover the Ahmadi Formation. By the
The Bathonian interval in Kuwait is known as the end of the Cretaceous, the Tethys Ocean on the eastern
Sargelu Formation. It is 65 m (210 ft) of interbedded side of the basin was closing. This resulted in a regional
wackstone and packstone. This lithologic composition unconformity and the reactivation of Mesozoic or older
indicates an upward energy increase and evolution of a structures. These are now described as the Burgan,
new regressive cycle (Youssif and Nouman, 1997). Sabria and Raudhatain Anticlines (Murris, 1980).
During the Late Callovian to Early Kimmeridgian,
euxinic conditions prevailed in the Luristan intrashelf
basin. These conditions were conducive to the deposi- 3. Petroleum geology of Kuwait
tion of laminated bituminous lime muds, which are
thought to be source rocks for the Middle-Upper Jur- The Arabian plate region will dominate world
assic reservoirs on the Arabian sides of the basin. The hydrocarbon reserves well after other currently produ-
oils from these reservoirs have been correlated to the cing major hydrocarbon regions have declined to insig-
Jurassic Tuwaiq Mountain and Hanifa Formation in nicance (Beydoun, 1991). This statement signies the
Saudi Arabia (Carrigan et al., 1994). The Najmah For- importance of that basin. Current oil and gas reserves in
mation is composed of cemented peloidal packstone, the basin have shown a slight increase (OAPEC, 1997).
and argillaceous and bituminous limestone. Yousif and Table 1 summarises by country the highest oil and gas
Nouman (1997) believed that this formation was reserves in the Arabian plate region. The reserves per
deposited during a ooding event, which encompassed square kilometers for both oil and gas indicate that
the entire Middle East. The Najmah Formation is Kuwait has the highest potential.
Table 1
Gas and oil reserves in main producing countries of the Arabian-Iranian Basin (after OAPEC, 1996)
Fig. 2. Stratigraphic column and regional tectonics, onshore Kuwait (after Carman, 1996). The Jurassic stratigraphy is after Yousif
and Nouman (1997) and the ages after Harland et al. (1989). In Kuwait the Minagish and Sulaiy Formations are considered as good
potential source rocks.
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148 129
In Kuwait, oil is produced mainly from reservoirs of the Jurassic Marrat Formation in the Miqua Oil Field.
Cretaceous age (Fig. 2), but smaller volumes are also API gravity and sulphur concentration were measured
produced from Tertiary reservoirs. Recently (1997), oil on whole crude oils. Carbon isotope analysis was per-
has been produced from Jurassic reservoirs such as the formed on asphaltene fractions of both crude oils and
Marrat Formation. These reservoirs are either clastic, rock extracts. All crude oils were analysed using com-
such as Burgan, or carbonate, such as Minagish. The bined HPLCGC. This automatic instrument provides a
quality of oil ranges between 848 API with sulphur good record of the molecular spectrum of both satu-
concentrations between 2.34.5%. rated and aromatic hydrocarbons from C6 to C40 (Des-
Most oil elds are located in a series of north-south sort et al., 1995). GCMS analysis of C15+ alkanes was
trending anticlines, associated with some minor faults carried out to elucidate the distributions of steranes and
(Carman, 1996). Stratigraphic studies of these structural terpanes in these oils. GCMS was performed using a
features indicate growth as a result of tectonic uplift Hewlett-Packard 6890/5973 GC/MSD. The mass spec-
since the Middle Cretaceous or even earlier, (Abdullah trometer was operated at 70 eV with a mass range of m/
et al., 1997). These anticlines are part of the Kuwait z 50600. The gas chromatograph was equipped with a
Arch. The Great Burgan Field, the largest eld in Kuwait, DB5 column (J&W, 60 m0.25 mm, lm thick-
covers an area of about 770 km2 and has oil reserves of ness=0.1m) with a deactivated pre-column of 5 m0.32
approximately 60 billion barrels (Adsani, 1965). mm between the injector and the chromatographic col-
Source rock studies indicate that oil in Cretaceous umn to improve the chromatographic resolution. The
reservoirs may have been generated from the Minagish oven temperature was programmed from 40 to 300 C
and Sulaiy Formations (Abdullah and Kinghorn, 1996). at 2 C/min and held at 300 C for 66 min. The C15+
Murris (1980) suggested that Kuwaiti oil was generated aromatic fractions were analysed by GC to determine
from source rocks in the Luristan Basin in Iran and that the molecular distribution of benzothiophenes and
oil migrated laterally to the Kuwait area. Ala (1979) and dibenzothiophenes.
Beydoun (1993) hypothesized that the Middle Kazh- Source rock extracts were analysed to establish their
dumi Formation in Iran is one of these source rocks. possible genetic relationships to the oils. Isotopic values
Hussein (1983) suggested Jurassic source rocks from the of carbon in saturates, aromatics, and asphaltenes were
Sargelu and Najmah formations based on assessment of determined for rock extracts and oils. Further geo-
wireline logs. An additional Jurassic source rock, the chemical analyses were applied to determine eective
Marrat Formation, was also suggested as a possible source rocks. C15+ alkanes and aromatics were analysed
source rock that may have generated the oil found in the using gas chromatography with FID (carbon) and FPD
Marrat Formation reservoirs (Kuwait Country Report, (sulphur) detectors. Further analysis of the C15+
1989, 1994; Beydoun, 1993). Also, within the Triassic alkanes by GCMS allowed determination of sterane
sequence in Kuwait, dark shales show high gamma ray and terpane patterns and calculation of maturity and
response (Khan, 1989), and these intervals might be also source parameters.
potential source rocks in the area.
5. Results
4. Method of study
5.1. Basic geochemical data on rock samples: Rock-Eval
Eighteen core samples were selected as possible source and organic petrography
rocks based on a preliminary study carried out by
Abdullah (1993). These samples are of Lower and Mid- The Rock-Eval data (Table 2 and Fig. 3) reveal three
dle Cretaceous age, from the Minagish and Raudhatain main groups of rock samples:
oil elds (Fig. 1). The samples were analysed by various
geochemical techniques (TOC, Rock-Eval, chloroform 1. Group A (sample 9, Mauddud Formation;
extraction, MPLC fractionation, asphaltene precipita- sample 7 and 8, Minagish Formation) contains
tion, isotopes, GC and GCMS analyses, X-ray dirac- the most hydrogen-rich samples. However this
tion, and petrographical tools) in order to identify and richness cannot be ascribed to source quality as
characterize possible source rocks. Organic petro- chloroform extract/TOC ratios are higher than
graphical analysis of kerogens was carried out to identify 95%, which indicates that these samples are oil-
type as well as environment of deposition. stained;
To investigate possible oil-to-source rock correlation, 2. Group B (sample 4, Burgan Formation; sample
eleven oil samples were collected from well heads. The 5, Zubair Formation; sample 17, Sulaiy Forma-
samples are from the Burgan, Raudhatain, Bahra, tion) corresponds to samples with TOC values
Miqua, and Minagish Oil Fields. The study focused on from 0.88 to 2.47% and HI values between 200
the Cretaceous interval, but includes one sample from and 300 mg HC/g TOC. Taking into account
130
Table 2
Basic geochemical data for rock samples: Rock-Eval and chloroform extract data. Abbreviations: TOC (%/w)=total organic carbon (%/weight): S1=mg HC/g rock; S2=mg HC/g
rock; S3=mg CO2/g rock; HI=Hydrogen Index=mg HC/g TOC; OI=oxygen index=mg CO2/g TOC; %Chlor.Extr./rock=% chloroform extract/rock; %sat.=%saturates;
%aro.=% aromatics; %pol.=%polars (=% resins+asphaltenes), %asp.=% asphaltenes
Sample Sample Labratory Depth in Formation TOC S1 S2 S3 HI OI Tmax %Chlor. %Chlor. %sat. %aro. %pol. %asp.
number reference number feet (%/w) ( C) extra./rock extra./TOC
Minagish
1 MN/6 B80820 6006 Ahmadi 0.41 0.24 0.18 1.74 43 424 437
Fig. 3. Rock-Eval data for rock samples: diagram of hydrogen index (HI in mg HC/g TOC) against Tmax (in C).
both values, these samples have fair to high source 3. Group C refers to all samples with HI values
rock potential. Variation of Tmax values from below 150 mg HC/g TOC. Within this group OI
420 to 450 C suggests dierent levels of maturity and Tmax cover a wide range of values, due to a
among the samples, which were conrmed by mixture of low-maturity oxygen-rich samples
organic petrographic analysis (Table 3); that are largely unconverted (e.g. sample 2;
132
Table 3
Results of organic petrographic analyses and environmental interpretation for rock samples. Abbreviations: Vitr.%=% vitrinite; Inert.%=% inertinite; Exin.%=% Exinite;
TAI=thermal alteration index; Ro=vitrinite reectance
Sample Sample Depth in Formation Mean Ro% TAI Mean Ro% Vitr. Inert. Exin. Type of Environment
number reference feet (Abdullah, 1993; (this study) % % % organic matter (after Abdullah,
Abdullah and 1993)
Kinghorn, 1996)
Minagish
1 MN/6 6006 Ahmadi 0.33
2 MN/4 6184 Mauddud Shallow marine environment
as a transgressive phase
Mauddud Formation and sample 3, Burgan Ratawi Formation are not likely source rocks for the
Formation, Table 3) and high maturity hydro- oils. On the other hand, the carbonate Minagish and
gen-rich samples with only residual potential Sulaiy formations appear to be possible candidates
(e.g. sample 16, Minagish Formation and sample based on similarity of asphaltene isotopes but also of
18, Sulaiy Formation, Table 3). pristane to phytane ratios, as seen in Fig. 4.
Organic petrographic analyses were conducted on 5.3. C6+ alkanes and C6+ aromatics of rock extracts
non-oil stained samples by J.-L. Faggionato at Elf EP obtained by LCGC
and compared to previous data (Abdullah, 1993). The
results are listed in Table 3. Gas chromatograms of C6+ alkanes (Fig. 5) illustrate
Two main types of organic matter were recognised: characteristic features of the rock extracts:
1. The rst type is humic with abundant vitrinite, 1. Sample 5 (Chlor.Extr./TOC=7%) is an imma-
uorescent sporinites, cutinites, and resinites, is ture rock (Ro=0.4%) of the Zubair Formation,
found in the Burgan and Zubair Formations. deposited under partly oxic conditions (prist/
This land-plant derived organic matter is con- phyt >2, Table 5, Fig. 4) in which the land-
sistent with the depositional environment of the derived input is clearly detectable by an odd-
sediments that were deposited in a deltaic/ carbon predominance in the n-alkane spectrum
estuarine complex for the Burgan Formation (n-C25, n-C27, n-C29, etc.). The contamination
and in a littoral/partly deltaic environment for and impregnation by oil (or possibly diesel from
the Zubair Formation. The maturity of this the mud) of some of these low maturity, humic
organic matter increases from 0.4% Ro at 7581 kerogens is exemplied by sample 4 of the Burgan
ft. in the Minagish oil eld (MN/13 well) to Formation (Chlor.Extr./TOC=12%), where the
0.7% Ro in the Raudhatain oil eld (RA/4); pristane to phytane ratio is less than one (as in
2. The second type, found in the Minagish and oils, Fig. 4) and high molecular weight alkanes
Sulaiy Formations, has the appearance of aniso- are reduced, reecting migrated oil or con-
tropic bitumen, suggesting that the correspond- tamination. Sample 7, severely depleted in C19-
ing immature kerogen was amorphous (Type II
or II-S) as seen in contemporary sediments
deposited in shallow marine shelf environments,
dominated by limestone lithology.
Crude oil references Data on whole oils Composition of the toped oil Isotopic data on specic fractions
Sample Depth in Formation Laboratory API Volatile Sulfur @13C % % % % @13C @13C @13C @D
Burgan BG
1 4689 Wara B80458 29.3 26.0 3.73 26.9 33.9 47.4 8.7 10.0 26.9 26.7 27.3 79
2 4683 Burgan B80459 31.0 30.5 2.53 27.0 44.3 46.2 4.7 4.8 27.1 26.6 27.4 91
3 7100 Minagish B80460 28.0 47.2 2.54 27.2 34.8 44.5 10.8 10.0 27.3 26.6 27.5 102
Rauhdatain RA
4 7580 Mauddud B80461 34.4 31.3 1.96 26.9 48.5 44.1 5.2 2.2 27 26.4 26.8
5 8316 Burgan B80462 33.0 27.8 3.10 27.2 40.8 46.6 11.6 1.1 27.2 26.8 27.4
6 10200 Zubair B80463 30.6 30.6 2.50 27.3 44.7 45.8 7.1 2.4 27.4 27 27.5 106
Bahra BA
7 12000 Mauddud B80464 28.7 21.9 4.02 27.2 31.6 50.4 10.9 7.1 27.3 26.8 27.6 109
8 11100 Burgan B80465 29.8 28.4 3.27 27.3 38.2 50.4 7.6 3.9 27.1 26.9 27.4
Miqua
9 11458 Marrat B80466 37.3 36.3 1.09 27.3 55.4 40.7 2.5 1.3 27.2 26.6 27.5
Minagish MN
10 6554 Burgan B80467 37.4 15.6 4.72 27.2 24.9 79.2 10.5 15.4 27.1 26.7 27.1 91
11 10455 Minagish B80468 33.4 29.2 2.67 26.9 41.9 48.7 5 4.5 26.8 26.5 27.4 80
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148 135
Table 5
Isoprenoid to n-alkane ratios, d13C and dD of asphaltenes in rock extracts
Sample number Sample reference Formation prist/nC17 phyt/nC18 prist/phyt @13Casp. @Dasp.
GCMS of saturates
alkanes, is typical of an oil-stained reservoir. graphic signals. The plot of this ratio for all
Lastly, sample 18, at a high level of maturity, samples including oils (Fig. 8) shows a sulphur
still shows a low pristane/phytane ratio, which richness of the same order of magnitude in
conrms the anoxic depositional environment Sulaiy-Minagish carbonate rocks, oil-stained
of that carbonate facies; Burgan-Minagish rocks, and in oils including
2. C6+ aromatics (Fig. 6) complete and corrobo- the light oil from the Jurassic Marrat reservoir.
rate the previous ndings. C6+ aromatics of the Clastic shales show a dierent pattern reecting
Zubair Formation (sample 5) are dominated by much less sulphur-bearing aromatics. Conse-
aromatic hydrocarbons (namely mono-, di-, tri- quently, crude oils from Kuwait do not origi-
methylnaphthalenes and phenanthrenes) con- nate from the Burgan, the Zubair Formation or
sistent with partly oxidising conditions. This the Ratawi Shale Member. Limestones from the
situation contrasts with that found in sample 4 Minagish and the Sulaiy Formations are hypo-
from the Burgan Formation, where signicant thesized as possible source rocks.
enrichment in sulphur-bearing aromatic com-
pounds is linked to allochthonous oil impregna-
tion (Fig. 7). The Sulaiy extract (sample 18), 5.4. Sulphur content in crude oils
which looks like the Burgan extract (sample 4),
is rich in sulphur-bearing aromatics but the Basic data on crude oil samples (Table 4) show sul-
DBT pattern is much more mature. These com- phur concentrations from 1.1% in the Miqua light oil
pounds are currently observed in restricted car- up to 4.7% in the Minagish (sample 10) oil; the average
bonate environments (Connan et al., 1986; value is 2.9%. The oils analysed are sulphur-rich and
Hughes et al., 1995, Fig. 7). The sulphur rich- must have been formed in a source rock with a type II-S
ness in the C6+ aromatics was estimated using kerogen that accumulated in carbonate lithologies (pos-
the ratio between the FID and FPD chromato- sibly in the Sulaiy Formation). However, other potential
136
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148
Fig. 5. Gas chromatograms obtained by LCGC of C6+ alkanes from representative rock extracts.
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148
Fig. 6. Gas chromatograms (FID) obtained by LCGC of C6+ aromatics from representative rock extracts.
137
138 F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148
139
140
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148
Fig. 9. Gas chromatograms obtained by LCGC of C6+ alkanes of representative oils.
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148
Fig. 10. Sterane distribution patterns (m/z 217) of representative oils.
141
142
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148
Fig. 11. Terpane distribution patterns (m/z 191) of representative oils.
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148 143
Fig. 12. Seismic section showing Kuwaiti Arch asymmetry, Burgan Dome, Burgan Graben Fault, cutting to near surface and Ahmadi
Ridge structure with shallow reverse fault interpretation and subcrop to the base Cretaceous unconformity (after Carman, 1996).
methylphenanthrene indexes (MPI1 and MPI3), as often present depth of the reservoir. However, within
observed when dealing with sulphur-rich crude oils each oil eld, the maturity of oil increases with
within the liquid oil window (Lichtfouse et al., 1994). depth of the reservoir. Maturity levels found in
Several maturity related parameters, based on sulphur- Cretaceous reservoired oils are lower than
bearing aromatics (MDR4,1, MDBTI1, MDBTI3, BT/ observed in rock samples from the Minagish
DBT, C3-BT/DBT, MDBT/DBT, Table 7) and and Sulaiy Formations. Oils that migrated
terpanes (Ts/Tm, C29neohopane/C30abhopane, C27Dia/ upward to Cretaceous reservoirs were expelled
C29aaRsterane, Table 6), were compared to classied oil at a time when the level of maturity of the
samples in terms of maturity. Ultimately, variations in source rocks (possible the Sulaiy Formation or
sulphur-bearing compounds were relied upon to establish other potential source rocks occurring within
a maturity classication. The most signicant results are: the Jurassic) was within the liquid oil window
(Ro equi. of 0.81.0%). Today, the maturity of
1. The Miqua oil, which is also the deepest (Jur- the studied Sulaiy Formation is much higher
assic Marrat Formation at 144580 ), is the most (estimated at 1.3% Ro equi.).
mature. Its maturity is of the same order of
magnitude as extracts from the Minagish and Finally, the variations in oil maturity are not well
the Sulaiy rock samples of the Raudhatain eld, understood but are probably related to major tectonic
which are at comparable depth (around 12,000 events which have favoured vertical migration of oils.
ft); There is no clear relationship between maturity of oils
2. The oil (sample 10) from the Minagish Field, and present-day reservoir depth. This feature may be
reservoired at 6554 ft in the Burgan Formation, due to the timing of reservoir lling. Some reservoirs
is the least mature; could have been lled earlier with a low maturity oil,
3. All crude oils except the Miqua sample show a whereas others have been fed later when the source
level of maturity that does not correlate with the rocks were much more mature. Most of the oil in place
144
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148
Fig. 13. Distribution proles of d13C values of n-alkanes and isoprenoids from some crude oils and three source rock candidates. Rocks: sample 16=B80831; sample 17=B80832;
sample 18=B80833; oils: sample 2=B80459; sample 3=B80460; sample 6=B80463; sample 8=B80465; sample 9=B80466; sample 10=B80467.
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148 145
Table 6
Isoprenoid to n-alkanes ratios and maturity parameters measured on C15+ alkanes. Abbreviations: prist=pristane; phyt=phytane;
nC17=n-heptadecane; nC18=n-octadecane; Ts/Tm=18a(H),22,29,30-trisnorneohopane/17a(H),22,29,30-trisnorhopane; 29neoH/
29abH=29neoH/29abH=18a(H)-norneohopane/17a(H),21b(H)-norhopane, 27Dia/29aaR=20 R+S- C27diasteranes/5a(H),14a(H),
17a(H), 20 R-C29 sterane
Rocks number Oils number Well prist/phyt prist/nC17 phyt/nC18 Ts/Tm 29neoH/29aH 27Dia/29aaR
Table 7
DBT/P and maturity parameters measured on C15+ aromatics. Abbreviations: P=phenanthrene; MP=methylphenanthrene;
BT=benzothiophene; DBT=dibenzothiophene; MDBT=methyldibenzothiophene; MPI1=1.5 (2MP+3MP)/P+1MP+9MP;
MPI3=2MP+3MP/1MP+9MP; MDR4,1=4MDBT/1MDBT; MDBTI1=1.5 (4MDBT+2,3MDBT)/DBT+2,3MDBT+1MDBT;
P P
MDBTI3=4MDBT+2,3MDBT/2,3MDBT+1MDBT; BT/ DBT=sum of benzothiophenes/sum of dibenzothiophenes (integra-
P P
tion of LCGC signal for C6+ aromatics); C3BT/ BT+ DBT=C3-benzothiophenes/sum of benzo- and dibenzothiophenes (inte-
P
gration of LCGC signal for C6+ aromatics); MDBT/DBT=sum of MDBT/DBT
in Cretaceous reservoirs was expelled at a maturity lower chemical techniques including molecular and isotope
than 1.3% vitrinite reectance equivalent. In a previous chemistry (d13C) on individual alkanes. The Burgan and
study considering the Sulaiy as the eective source rock, Zubair Formations and the Ratawi Shale Member, of
Abdullah et al. (1997) established by modelling that most Albian to Valanginian age, are not the source rocks of
oil generation took place during the Late Cretaceous and the crude oils for several reasons: dierent molecular
Early Tertiary and that oil expulsion occurred during the and isotope chemistry, humic kerogen that is poor in
Tertiary. Peak oil expulsion was at 62 Ma, which is the sulphur-bearing aromatics, and immaturity.
time of the Zagros orogeny. The tectonic movement The Minagish and the Sulaiy Formations, Upper
caused fracturing and faulting in many traps (Fig. 12), Jurassic to Lower Cretaceous age, appear as potential
which entailed a release in pressure and enhanced the source candidates based on the molecular and bulk iso-
migration of oil from the Sulaiy Formation. Thus, release tope chemistry. However, maturation level of these
in pressure as a result of tectonic movement and the micro- source rocks is higher than the maturity of the eective
fracturing of source rocks by intensive oil generation source rocks that have generated oils accumulated in the
appear to have occurred at about the same time, and Cretaceous reservoirs. In addition, d13C proles of C15+
enhanced the expulsion of oil out of the source rock and its alkanes do not provide a good match between the rock
distribution into dierent reservoir levels. Later, additional extracts and the oils. Nevertheless, the extract of one
tectonic events may have resulted in remigration of oil. Sulaiy sample is rather similar to the oils. Consequently,
the Minagish and Sulaiy Formations have not been
5.8. Attempt to establish oil-to-source correlation using denitely proved as the only source rocks for Cretac-
GCCIRMS analysis on C15+ alkanes and whole oil eous oils. First of all, the rock samples analysed, and
also those quoted in previous studies, are not prolic
A more detailed investigation was undertaken to source rocks according to their carbon content, which is
explore the possible genetic relationship between the lower than 2% in most cases. In addition, much better
chloroform extracts of the Minagish and Sulaiy source source rocks with TOC values higher than 10% are
rocks and the oil samples. Measurement of isotope known in the Najmah Formation. Finally, the mole-
values of individual compounds was carried out on cular and isotope characteristics encountered in Jurassic
whole oils, C15+ total alkanes and C15+ n-alkanes iso- oils (e.g. the Miqua 9 oil) is very much like those of the
lated by molecular sieving with silicalite. Comparison of Sulaiy-Minagish carbonates. Therefore, we consider
these analyses showed that heavier values, in the order that the question of the origin of oils from Cretaceous
of magnitude of 0.51.0% PDB, were found in the pure reservoirs is still open and that a complementary study
n-alkanes isolated by silicalite. Nevertheless, the line of the Jurassic interval is needed. Even if the Sulaiy
chart patterns and the classication of samples are pre- Formation remains a potential source rock in the area,
served when using the n-alkane data on whole C15+ the contribution of other prolic source rocks from the
alkanes. Jurassic interval is more likely to explain the huge
A line chart comparison of d13C values of crude oils amount of oil found in Kuwait.
to d13C values of the three potential source rocks The oils belong to the same genetic family. Similar
(Fig. 13), namely samples 16 (Minagish Formation), 17 results were shown in a study by Kaufman et al. (1998)
and 18 (Sulaiy Formation), shows that all oils lie on oils from the Great Burgan Field. These oils were
between samples 16/18 and sample 17. The Miqua oil expelled from a source rock with a dominant limestone
reservoired in the Marrat Formation, matches the gen- lithology, like the Minagish and Sulaiy Formation, but
eral pattern of the other oils, despite higher maturity. probably also the Najmah Formation. The Miqua oil,
Incorporation of additional data on isoprenoids did not reservoired in the Jurassic Marrat Formation, does not
modify the classication (Fig. 13). dier signicantly from the other oils in terms of
The GCCIRMS analyses of alkanes did not per- genetic characteristics. As expected, this deep, light oil
mit denite conclusions regarding the origin of the oils is the most mature of the set. On the contrary, the
to be made. Obviously, there is a need to upgrade the Minagish oil (sample 10) is the least mature of the set.
present study with a complete geochemical study of the None of the oils, except sample 10 of the Minagish
Jurassic interval because extremely organic-rich source Field, has been aected very much by biodegradation.
rocks have been reported in the Najmah Formation Their maturity has not been found to be related directly
(Zumberge, J., personal communication, 1990). to the present depth of the reservoirs. Nevertheless, it
has been shown that in the same oil eld the oil maturity
increases with reservoir depth. Upward migration has
6. Conclusions been very ecient in Kuwait through time, as biode-
graded oil has been collected near Burgan Hill. This
Eighteen rock and ten oil samples from Cretaceous crude correlates with the Cretaceous oils of the Burgan
formations, and 1 Jurassic oil were analysed using geo- oil eld.
F.H. Abdullah, J. Connan / Organic Geochemistry 33 (2002) 125148 147
Kuwait using wireline logs. Society of Petroleum Engineers, Kuwait Country Report, 1994. Proceedings of the seminar on
SPE paper 15747, 3rd Middle East Oil Show, Bahrain, 477- hydrocarbon potential of deep formations in the Arab coun-
488. tries Cairo, 3769.
Kamen-Kaye, M., 1970. Geology and productivity of persian Lichtfouse, E., Albrecht, P., Behar, F., Hayes, J.M., 1994. A
Gulf synclinorium. American Association Petroleum Geolo- molecular and isotopic study of the organic matter from the
gists Bulletin 54, 23712394. Paris Basin, France. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 58,
Kaufman, R.L., Kabir, C.S., Abdul-Rahman, B., Quttainah, 209221.
R., Dashti, H., Pederson, M.S., 1998. Characterizing the Murris, R.L., 1980. Middle East: stratigraphic evaluation and
Greater Burgan Field using geochemical and other eld data. oil habitat. American Association Petroleum Geologists
SPE 49216 Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition. Bulletin 64, 597618.
New Orleans, Louisiana. OAPEC, 1996. Organization of Arab Petroleum Exporting
Khan, A., 1989. Stratigraphy and hydrocarbon potential of Countries. Secretary Generals twenty-third annual report,
Permo-Triassic sequence of rocks in the State of Kuwait. Kuwait.
OAPEC seminar on hydrocarbon potential of deep forma- OAPEC, 1997. Organization of Arab Petroleum Exporting
tions in Arab countries, Abu Dhabi, 811 October 1989, 3 Countries. Secretary Generals twenty-fourth annual report,
29. Kuwait.
Koop, W.J., Stonely, R., 1982. Subsidence history of the Mid- Rubinstein, I., Sieskind, O., Albrecht, P., 1975. Rearranged
dle East Zagros Basin, Permian to Recent. In: The Evolution sterenes in a shale: occurrence and simulated formation. J.
of Sedimentary Basin. Proceedings of a Royal Society dis- Am. Chem. Soc. Transaction I, 18331836.
cussion meeting, 149168. Rullkotter, J., Spiro, B., Nissenbaum, A., 1985. Biological
Kuwait Country Report, 1984. Proceedings of the seminar on marker characteristics of oils and asphalts from carbonate
source and habitat of petroleum in the Arab countries. source rocks in a rapidly subsiding graben, Dead Sea, Israel.
Kuwait, 193214. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 49, 13571370.
Kuwait Country Report, 1989. Proceedings of the seminar on Yousif, S., Nouman, G., 1997. Jurassic geology of Kuwait.
deep formations in the Arab countries: hydrocarbon poten- GeoArabia: Middle East Petroleum Geosciences 2 (1), 91
tial and exploration techniques. Abu Dhabi, 135149. 110.