Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CME EDUCATIONAL OBJECTIVE: Readers will recognize and appropriately manage warfarin resistance in patients
CREDIT who need higher-than-expected doses of this drug
Olusegun Osinbowale, MD, MBA, RPVI Monzr Al Malki, MD Andrew Schade, MD, PhD John R. Bartholomew, MD
Department of Cardiology, Section of Noninvasive Biotherapeutics Department Labora- Division of Pathology and Laboratory Department of Cardiovascular
Cardiology, Ochsner Clinic Foundation, New Orleans, LA tory, Division of Surgical Research, Medicine, Department of Clinical Medicine, Head, Section of Vascular
Boston University School of Medicine, Pathology, Cleveland Clinic Medicine, Cleveland Clinic
Roger Williams Medical Center,
Providence, RI
does not itself establish the diagnosis of war- ■■ WHAT CAUSES WARFARIN RESISTANCE?
farin resistance. The prevalence of warfarin
resistance varies by patient population and Warfarin resistance can be classified in prac-
is difficult to determine. The difficulty lies tical terms as acquired vs hereditary, or in
largely in accounting for dietary factors and in mechanistic terms as pharmacokinetic vs
defining normal metabolic variations among pharmacodynamic. Patients
individuals. needing
The range of normally recommended daily Acquired vs hereditary resistance
or weekly warfarin doses to maintain a thera- Hulse4 categorizes warfarin resistance as either > 15 mg/day
peutic prothrombin time or INR depends on acquired or hereditary. should be
the study population. Nevertheless, patients Acquired resistance to warfarin may result
who need more than 105 mg per week (15 mg/ from:
considered
day) should be considered warfarin-resistant. • Poor patient compliance (the most com- warfarin-
These patients are likely to be in the top 5% mon cause) resistant
for warfarin doses within an anticoagulated • High consumption of vitamin K
cohort. • Decreased absorption of warfarin
Warfarin resistance is different than war- • Increased clearance (see warfarin is metabo-
farin failure, which is defined as a new throm- lized by P450 enzymes on this page )
5–11
botic event despite a therapeutic prothrombin • Drug interactions (TABLE 1). 12,13
time and INR. This situation is commonly Hereditary resistance has been postulated
seen in patients with malignant diseases. to be caused by genetic factors that result ei-
An important characteristic of warfarin ther in faster metabolism of the drug (a form of
resistance is that patients need much smaller pharmacokinetic resistance) or in lower activ-
doses of vitamin K to reverse the effect of war- ity of the drug (pharmacodynamic resistance).
farin.2 Thijssen3 showed that, in warfarin-resis- Polymorphisms may play a role, as some VKO-
tant rats, warfarin did not irreversibly inhibit RC1 and CYP2C9 variant alleles are known
vitamin K1 2,3-epoxide reductase (VKORC1) to be associated with increased sensitivity to
activity. This is consistent with the vitamin K warfarin.14
hypersensitivity observed in warfarin-resistant However, the genetic mechanisms of war-
people.2,3 farin resistance are not clearly understood,
CL EVEL AND CL I NI C J O URNAL O F M E DI CI NE V O L UM E 76 • NUM BE R 12 DE CE M BE R 2009 725
Warfarin resistance
Vitamin K
Dietary sources
VKOR*
(blocked Active factors II, VII, IX, X
Vitamin K
by warfarin) epoxide Active proteins C, S
Agents not available in the United States Vitamin K antagonists other than war-
include the following. farin that are not available in the United
Dabigatran, an oral direct thrombin inhib- States include bishydroxycoumarin (which
itor, is undergoing phase 3 studies of its use for has limitations including slow absorption
long-term anticoagulation. and high frequency of gastrointestinal side
Rivaroxaban (a direct factor Xa inhibi- effects), phenprocoumon, and acenocou-
tor) and dabigatran have been approved in marol. Another is phenindione, which has
Canada and the European Union to prevent been associated with serious hypersensitivity
venous thromboembolism after knee and hip reactions, some of which proved fatal and
arthroplasty, based on prospective compari- occurred within a few weeks of initiating
sons with enoxaparin (Lovenox).34–37 therapy. ■
■■ References 22. MacLaren R, Wachsman BA, Swift DK, Kuhl DA. Warfarin resistance as-
1. Lefrere JJ, Horellou MH, Conard J, Samama M. Proposed classification sociated with intravenous lipid administration: discussion of propofol
of resistance to oral anticoagulant therapy. J Clin Pathol 1987; 40:242. and review of the literature. Pharmacotherapy 1997; 17:1331–1337.
2. Linder MW. Genetic mechanisms for hypersensitivity and resistance to 23. DeCurtis A, D’Adamo MC, Amore C, et al. Experimental arterial throm-
the anticoagulant warfarin. Clin Chim Acta 2001; 308:9–15. bosis in genetically or diet induced hyperlipidemia in rats—role of
3. Thijssen HH. Warfarin resistance. Vitamin K epoxide reductase of Scot- vitamin K-dependent clotting factors and prevention by low-intensity
tish resistance gene is not irreversibly blocked by warfarin. Biochem oral anticoagulation. Thromb Haemost 2001; 86:1440–1448.
Pharmacol 1987; 36:2753–2757. 24. O’Reilly RA. Drug interaction involving oral anticoagulation. In:
4. Hulse ML. Warfarin resistance: diagnosis and therapeutic alternative. Melmon KL, editor. Cardiovascular Drug Therapy, Philadelphia; FA
Davis, 1975:23–41.
Pharmacotherapy 1996; 16:1009–1017.
25. O’ Reilly RA, Pool JG, Aggeler PM. Hereditary resistance to cou-
5. Hirsh J, Dalen JE, Deykin D, Poller L, Bussey H. Oral anticoagulants.
marin anticoagulation drugs in man and rat. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1968;
Mechanism of action, clinical effectiveness, and optimal therapeutic
151:913–931.
range. Chest 1995; 108(suppl 4):231S–234S.
26. Cain D, Hutson SM, Wallin R. Warfarin resistance is associated with a
6. Daly AK, King BP. Pharmacogenetics of oral anticoagulants. Pharmaco-
protein component of the vitamin K 2,3-epoxide reductase enzyme
genetics 2003; 13:247–252.
complex in rat liver. Thromb Haemost 1998; 80:128–133.
7. Daly AK, Aithal GP. Genetic regulation of warfarin metabolism and
27. Rodvold KA, Quandt CM, Friedenberg WR. Thromboembolic disorders.
response. Semin Vasc Med 2003; 3:231–238.
In: DiPiro JT, Talbert RL, editors. Pharmacotherapy. A Pathophysiologic
8. Takahashi H, Echizen H. Pharmacogenetics of warfarin elimination and
Approach, 2nd ed. New York: Elsevier, 1992:312–335.
its clinical implications. Clin Pharmacokinet 2001; 40:587–603.
28. Park BK. Warfarin: metabolism and mode of action. Biochem Pharma-
9. Retti AE, Wienkers LC, Gonzalez FJ, Trager WF, Korezekwa KR. Im-
col 1988; 37:19–27.
paired (S)-warfarin metabolism catalysed by the R144C allele variant of
29. Cain D, Hutson SM, Wallin R. Assembly of the warfarin-sensitive
CYP2C9. Pharmacogenetics 1994; 4:39–42.
vitamin K 2,3-epoxide reductase enzyme complex in the endoplasmic
10. Porter RS, Sawyer WR. Warfarin. In: Evans WE, Shentag JJ, Jusko WJ, edi-
reticulum membrane. J Biol Chem 1997; 272:29068–29075.
tors. Applied Pharmacokinetics. Principles of Therapeutics Drug Monitor-
30. Gallop PM, Lian JB, Hauschka PV. Carboxylated calcium binding pro-
ing, 3rd ed. Washington, DC: Applied Therapeutics, 1992:31.1–31.46.
teins and vitamin K. N Engl J Med 1980; 302:1460–1466.
11. Warrell DA, Cox TM, Firth JD. Oxford Textbook of Medicine, 4th ed.
31. Rost S, Fregin A, Ivaskevicius V, et al. Mutations in VKORC1 cause
Oxford University Press, 2003:734.
warfarin resistance and multiple coagulation factor deficiency type 2.
12. Holbrook AM, Pereira JA, Labiris R, et al. Systematic overview of
Nature 2004; 427:537–541.
warfarin and its drug and food interactions. Arch Intern Med 2005;
32. Loebstein R, Dovskin I, Halkin H, et al. A coding VKORC1 Asp36-
165:1095–1106.
Tyr polymorphism predisposes to warfarin resistance. Blood 2007;
13. Medical Economics Staff. Physicians’ Desk Reference, 55th Ed. Medical
109:2477–2480.
Economics, 2001:1139–1140.
33. Bentley DP, Backhouse G, Hutchings A, Haddon RL, Spragg B, Rout-
14. Schwarz UI, Ritchie MD, Bradford Y, et al. Genetic determinants of
ledge PA. Investigation of patients with abnormal response to warfa-
response to warfarin during initial anticoagulation. N Engl J Med 2008;
rin. Br J Clin Pharmacol 1986; 22:37–41.
358:999–1008.
34. Eriksson BI, Borris LC, Friedman RJ, et al; RECORD1 Study Group.
15. Diab F, Feffer S. Hereditary warfarin resistance. South Med J 1994;
Rivaroxaban versus enoxaparin for thromboprophylaxis after hip
87:407–409.
arthroplasty. N Engl J Med 2008; 358:2765–2775.
16. O’Reilly RA. The second reported kindred with hereditary resistance to
35. Kakkar AK, Brenner B, Dahl OE, et al; RECORD2 Investigators.
oral anticoagulant drugs. N Engl J Med 1970; 282:1448–1451.
Extended duration rivaroxaban versus short-term enoxaparin for the
17. O’Reilly RA, Aggeler PM, Hoag MS, Leong LS, Kropatkin ML. Heredi-
prevention of venous thromboembolism after total hip arthroplasty: a
tary transmission of exceptional resistance to coumarin anticoagulant
double-blind, randomised controlled trial. Lancet 2008; 372:31–39.
drugs. The first reported kindred. N Engl J Med 1964; 271:809–815.
36. Lassen MR, Ageno W, Borris LC, et al; RECORD3 Investigators.
18. Alving BM, Strickler MP, Knight RD, Barr CF, Berenberg JL, Peek CC.
Rivaroxaban versus enoxaparin for thromboprophylaxis after total
Hereditary warfarin resistance. Investigation of rare phenomenon.
knee arthroplasty. N Engl J Med 2008; 358:2776–2786.
Arch Intern Med 1985; 145:499–501.
37. Wolowacz SE, Roskell NS, Plumb JM, Caprini JA, Eriksson BI. Efficacy
19. Warrier L, Brennan CA, Lusher JM. Familial warfarin resistance in a
and safety of dabigatran etexilate for the prevention of venous throm-
black child. Am J Pediatr Hematol Oncol 1986; 8:346–347.
boembolism following total hip or knee arthroplasty. A meta-analysis.
20. Nikkila EA, Pelkonen R. Serum lipid-reducing agents and anticoagulant Thromb Haemost 2009; 101:77–85.
requirement. Lancet 1963; 1:332.
21. Robinson A, Liau FO, Routledge PA, Backhouse G, Spragg BP, Bent- ADDRESS: John R. Bartholomew, MD, Department of Cardiovascular
ley DP. Lipids and warfarin requirements. Thromb Haemost 1990; Medicine, Section of Vascular Medicine, J3-5, Cleveland Clinic, 9500 Euclid
63:148–149. Avenue, Cleveland, OH 44195; e-mail barthoj@ccf.org.
730 CLEV ELA N D C LI N I C JOURNAL OF MEDICINE VOL UME 76 • N UM BE R 12 DE CE M BE R 2009