Scribd
Upload
307 views1 page

Comment Resolution Sheet for Project

The document is a comment resolution sheet between an engineering contractor and client discussing design requirements for a separation facility project. It addresses 4 items: 1) maintaining 20% installed spares after the project, 2) using separate instruments for control and safeguarding, 3) using heat detectors with normally closed contacts, and 4) using individual and overall screened cables between instruments and junction boxes and multipair cables from junction boxes to the control system. The comments were noted and incorporated into the project design.

Uploaded by

Geetha_jagadish30
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
307 views1 page

Comment Resolution Sheet for Project

The document is a comment resolution sheet between an engineering contractor and client discussing design requirements for a separation facility project. It addresses 4 items: 1) maintaining 20% installed spares after the project, 2) using separate instruments for control and safeguarding, 3) using heat detectors with normally closed contacts, and 4) using individual and overall screened cables between instruments and junction boxes and multipair cables from junction boxes to the control system. The comments were noted and incorporated into the project design.

Uploaded by

Geetha_jagadish30
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Client /Contractor: Engineering Contractor:

COMMENT RESOLUTION SHEET (CRS)

PROJECT NAME: FEED & DD for Additional


CONTRACT / PROJECT NO.: Date:
Separation facility
DOCUMENT TITLE: Project Design Basis DOCUMENT NO: Revision No: Page 1 of 1

Item Reference
Comments Valdel Response Resolution
No Page / Section

Section 8.1, 8.2 & 8..3 : 20% installed spares shall be maintained after
1 Noted and incorporated
DCS, IPS and FGS implementation of this project

Noted. Different instruments will be used

Separate instruments shall be used for control and for control and safeguarding functions. As
Section 8.4 : Field
2 safeguarding. Instrument used for safeguarding shall SIL study is not part of scope, SIL 1
Instruments
be certified according to relevant SIL. certified instruments will be selected for
safeguarding functions.
Section 8.4.8 :
Heat detectors contacts shall be of normally closed
3 Miscellaneous Noted and incorporated
type
Instruments
Noted. Pair cables (instruments to JB) will
be with overall screens and Multipair
4 Field Cables Individual and overall screen
cables (from JB to Control System) shall be
individual and overall screen.

You might also like