Professional Documents
Culture Documents
51 97 1 SM PDF
51 97 1 SM PDF
$EUDFW ,QIHFWLRQ 5HVSLUDWRU\ DFXWH ,5$ NQRZQ DV RQH RI FDXVH WKH PDLQ GHFHDVH DW EDE\ DQG
WRGGOHULQGHYHORSLQJFRXQWULHV5HVXOWVRIWKHVXUYH\KHDOWKLQGLFDWHH[SHULHQFH,5$DQG
H[SHULHQFH,5$V\PSWRP:KLOHWRWDOWRGGOHUGHFHDVHFDXVH,5$LQ&HQWUDO-DYDDVPDQ\DV
WRGGOHUDQGXQGHUIRXU\HDUWRGGOHU7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVXG\WRGHWHUPLQHWKHQXUVLQJFDUHLQFKLOGUHQ
ZLWKLQIHFWLRQUHVSLUDWRU\DFXWH7KLVXG\ZDVDTXDOLWDWLYHFDVHXG\GHVLJQXVLQJWKHQXUVLQJSURFHVV
DSSURDFK7KHSRSXODWLRQLQWKLVXG\ZHUHFKLOGUHQZKRKDGLQIHFWLRQUHVSLUDWRU\DFXWH7KHVDPSOH
ZDV$Q$7KHVDPSOLQJWHFKQLTXHXVHGSXUSRVLYHVDPSOLQJ7KHXG\ZDVGRQHDWWKHRUFLGZDUG
UHJLRQDOSXEOLFKRVSLWDORI6XNRKDUMRRQ)HEUXDU\5HWULHYDOWHFKQLTXHVGDWDXVHGDUHLQWHUYLHZRU
DQDPQHVDSK\VLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQREVHUYDWLRQXG\GRFXPHQWDWLRQ7KHLQUXPHQWXVHGLVJXLGHOLQHVIRU
DVVHVVPHQWIRUPV\HPDWLFSURFHVVFRQVLVRIGDWDDFFXPXODWLRQYHUL¿FDWLRQDQGGDWDFRPPXQLFDWLRQ
DERXWSDWLHQW:KHQGRQHDVVHVVPHQWREWDLQHGGDWDPRWKHUVD\KHUFKLOGEORZQPRWKHUVD\KHUFKLOG
DFRXJKDNUDOSDOSDEOHZDUP55[PLQXWHGHFUHDVHGDSSHWLWH%HIRXQGQXUVLQJSUREOHPWKH\
DUH LQH௺HFWLYHQHVV RI FOHDYDJH ZD\ EUHDWK K\SHUWKHUPLD DQG QXWULWLRQDO LPEDODQFH OHVV WKDQ ERG\
UHTXLUHPHQWV$IWHU [ KXRU QXUVLQJ FDUH REWDLQHG LPSURYHG GHYHORSPHQW LVVXHV &RQFOXVLRQ WKH
PDLQQXUVLQJSUREOHPRI$Q$ZLWKLQIHFWLRQUHVSLUDWRU\DFXWHLVLQH௺HFWLYHQHVVRIFOHDYDJHZD\EUHDWK
.H\ZRUGVQXUVLQJFDUHFKLOGUHQLQIHFWLRQUHVSLUDWRU\DFXWH
I. PENDAHULUAN %HUGDVDUNDQGDWD\DQJGLSHUROHKGDUL$Q$
3HQHOLWLDQ$U\X &DQGUD 0HL (O\DQD REVHUYDVL ႋXVL GRNXPHQWDVL ,QႋUXPHQ \DQJ
\DQJEHUMXGXO+XEXQJDQ)UHNXHQVL,63$GHQJDQ GLJXQDNDQ\DLWXSHGRPDQSHQJNDMLDQPHUXSDNDQ
6WDWXV*L]L%DOLWD'DULKDVLODQDOLVLVGDWDGLSHUROHK SURVHVVLႋHPDWLNDWHUGLULGDULSHQJXPSXODQGDWD
,63$SDGD%DOLWDGL'HVD.D\XDSDN.HFDPDWDQ LEXPHQJDWDNDQDQDNSDQDVLEXPHQJDWDNDQ
3RORNDUWR .DEXSDWHQ 6XNRKDUMR +DVLO KDVLO DQDN PDNDQ VHGLNLW LEX PHQJDWDNDQ DQDN
VXDUDQDIDVVXEMHNWLILEXPHQJDWDNDQDQDN VXKXVXEMHNWLILEXPHQJDWDNDQVXKXWXEXK
EDWXN REMHNWLI VXDUD QDIDV URQFKL '[ DQDN VXGDK WXUXQ REMHNWLI 6 Û& DNUDO
MDP :,% PHODNVDQDNDQ DGYLV GRNWHU WHUDEDKDQJDW'[MDPPHPEHULNDQ
SHPEHULDQ WHUDSL QHEXOL]HU VXEMHNWLI LEX QXWULVL WLQJJL NDORUL WLQJJL SURWHLQ VXEMHNWLI
PHQJDWDNDQ GDKDN WLGDN NHOXDU REMHNWLI DQDNPHQJDWDNDQLQJLQPDNDQREMHNWLIDQDN
DQDN PHQDJLV GDKDN WLGDN NHOXDU 55 PDNDQVHQGLULPDNDQKDELVóSRUVLPDNDQ
[PHQLW '[ MDP :,% PHODNXNDQ ELVNXLWKDELVNHSLQJPXNRVDELELUOHPEDE
¿VLRWHUDSL GDGD VXEMHNWLI LEX PHQJDWDNDQ %%NJ
DQDN VHVDN QDIDV REMHNWLI VXDUD QDIDV
,PSOHPHQWDVLWDQJJDO)HEUXDUL'[
URQFKL55[PHQLW'[MDP:,%
GDQMDP:,%PHQJREVHUYDVLWDQGD
PHQJREVHUYDVL WDQGDWDQGD YLWDO SDVLHQ
WDQGDYLWDOVXEMHNWLILEXPHQJDWDNDQEDWXN
VXEMHNWLI LEX PHQJDWDNDQ DQDNQ\D SDQDV
VXGDKEHUNXUDQJSDQDVVXGDKWXUXQREMHNWLI
REMHNWLI 55 [PHQLW 1 [PHQLW 6
1[PHQLW55[PHQLW6Û&'[
Û& '[ MDP :,% PHODNXNDQ
MDP:,%PHODNVDQDNDQDGYLVGRNWHU
NRPSUHV KDQJDW VXEMHNWLI LEX PHQJDWDNDQ
QHEXOL]HU VXEMHNWLI LEX PHQJDWDNDQ DQDN
DQDNSDQDVREMHNWLI6Û&'[MDP
VXGDKWLGDNVHVDNQDIDVREMHNWLI55[
:,%PHQJNDMLDGDQ\DDOHUJLPDNDQDQUHVSRQ
PHQLW'[MDPPHODNXNDQ¿VLRWHUDSL
VXEMHNWLILEXPHQJDWDNDQDQDNDOHUJLGHQJDQ
GDGDVXEMHNWLILEXPHQJDWDNDQDQDNPDVLK
HV UHVSRQ REMHNWLI DQDN EDWXN '[ MDP
EDWXN EDWXN WLGDN NHOXDU GDKDN REMHNWLI
:,%PHQJDQMXUNDQPDNDQVHGLNLWWDSL
DQDN PDVLK EDWXN WLGDN NHOXDU GDKDN '[
VHULQJVXEMHNWLILEXPHQJDWDNDQ³\D´QDIVX
MDP PHQJDXVNXOWDVL VXDUD SDUX
PDNDQ PHQXUXQ REMHNWLI WXUJRU NXOLW EDLN
VXEMHNWLI WLGDN DGD UHVSRQ REMHNWLI VXDUD
PXNRVDELELUOHPEDE%%NJ
SDUXURQFKLVHNUHWEHUNXUDQJ'[MDP
,PSOHPHQWDVLWDQJJDO)HEUXDUL'[ :,%PHQJDQMXUNDQXQWXNPHPDNDLEDMXWLSLV
MDP:,%PHQJREVHUYDVLWDQGDWDQGD VXEMHNWLIWLGDNDGDUHVSRQREMHNWLI6Û&
YLWDOVXEMHNWLILEXPHQJDWDNDQSDQDVVXGDK '[GDQMDPPHQJDQMXUNDQEDQ\DN
WXUXQREMHNWLI1[PHQLW55[PHQLW PLQXP'[:,%PHQJREVHUYDVLVXKX
6Û&'[MDP:,%PHODNVDQDNDQ VXEMHNWLILEXPHQJDWDNDQDQDNVXGDKWLGDN
DGYLVGRNWHUQHEXOL]HUYHQWROLQòSXOPLFROGò SDQDVREMHNWLI6Û&'[SXNXO
1D&OFFVXEMHNWLILEXPHQJDWDNDQVHVDN :,% PHPEHULNDQ QXWULVL WLQJJL NDORUL WLQJJL
QDIDVEHUNXUDQJWDSLPDVLKEDWXNREMHNWLI SURWHLQ UHVSRQ VXEMHNWLI LEX PHQJDWDNDQ
VXDUDURQFKLEHUNXUDQJ55[PHQLW'[ DQDN VXGDK PDX PDNDQ UHVSRQ REMHNWLI
MDP:,%PHODNXNDQ¿VLRWHUDSLGDGD PDNDQKDELVSRUVLPXNRVDELELUOHPEDE
VXEMHNWLILEXPHQJDWDNDQDQDNEDWXNGDKDN WXUJRUNXOLWEDLN%%NJ
WLGDNELVDNHOXDUREMHNWLISDVLHQEDWXNDQDN 5. Evaluasi
WLGDN ELVD PHQJHOXDUNDQ GDKDNQ\D '[
(YDOXDVL KDUL SHUWDPD '[ VXEMHNWLI
PHQJREVHUYDVL WDQGDWDQGD YLWDO '[ GDQ
LEX PHQJDWDNDQ DQDN VHVDN QDIDV LEX
SXNXO :,% PHQJDQMXUNDQ PLQXP
PHQJDWDNDQDQDNQ\DEDWXN2EMHNWLIVXDUD
EDQ\DN '[ :,% PHQJREVHUYDVL
QDIDV URQFKL GDKDN WLGDN ELVD NHOXDU
55 [ PHQLW $QDOLVD PDVDODK EHOXP 3HUHQFDQDDQ ODQMXW LQWHUYHQVL KLGDQJNDQ
WHUDWDVL 3HUHQFDQDDQ ODQMXW LQWHUYHQVL PDNDQDQ GDODP NHDGDDQ KDQJDW DQMXUNDQ
DXVNXOWDVL VXDUD QDIDV ODNVDQDNDQ DGYLV PDNDQVHGLNLWWDSLVHULQJNRODERUDVLGHQJDQ
GRNWHUSHPEHULDQWHUDSLQHEXOL]HUREVHUYDVL DKOLJL]LSHPEHULDQWLQJJLNDORULWLQJJLSURWHLQ
UHVSLUDVL UDWH ODNXNDQ ¿VLRWHUDSL GDGD (YDOXDVL KDUL NHWLJD '[ VXEMHNWLI LEX
'[ VXEMHNWLI LEX PHQJDWDNDQ DQDNQ\D PHQJDWDNDQEDWXNDQDNVXGDKEHUNXUDQJLEX
SDQDV REMHNWLI DNUDO WHUDED KDQJDW 6 PHQJDWDNDQDQDNVXGDKWLGDNVHVDNQDIDV
Û& $QDOLVD PDVDODK EHOXP WHUDWDVL 2EMHNWLIVXDUDSDUXURQFKLEDWXNWLGDNNHOXDU
3HUHQFDQDDQ ODQMXW LQWHUYHQVL REVHUYDVL GDKDNVHNUHWSDGDSDUXEHUNXUDQJ55
VXKX ODNXNDQ NRPSUHV DQMXUNDQ EDQ\DN [PHQLW$QDOLVDPDVDODKWHUDWDVLVHEDJLDQ
PLQXPDQMXUNDQPHPDNDLSDNDLDQWLSLV'[ 3HUHQFDQDDQ ODQMXW LQWHUYHQVL PRQLWRU
VXEMHNWLI LEX PHQJDWDNDQ QDIVX PDNDQ UHVSLUDVL UDWH ODNXNDQ ¿VLRWHUDSL GDGD
PHQXUXQ LEX PHQJDWDNDQ DQDN DOHUJL DXVNXOWDVLVXDUDQDIDVODNXNDQDGYLVGRNWHU
WHUKDGDSHVREMHNWLIPXNRVDELELUOHPEDE QHEXOL]HU '[ VXEMHNWLI LEX PHQJDWDNDQ
WXUJRUNXOLWEDLN%%NJ$QDOLVDPDVDODK SDQDV DQDN VXGDK WXUXQ REMHNWLI DNUDO
WHUDWDVL VHEDJLDQ 3HUHQFDQDDQ ODQMXW KDQJDW6Û&$QDOLVDPDVDODKWHUDWDVL
LQWHUYHQVLKLGDQJNDQPDNDQGDODPNHDGDDQ 3HUHQFDQDDQ LQWHUYHQVL GLSHUWDKDQNDQ
KDQJDW DQMXUNDQ PDNDQ VHGLNLW WDSL VHULQJ REVHUYDVLWDQGDWDQGDYLWDODQMXUNDQEDQ\DN
'DUL KDVLO ZDZDQFDUD GDQ REVHUYDVL SHPHULNVDDQ ¿VLN ,33$ \DLWX LQVSHNVL
GLGDSDWNDQNHOXKDQXWDPDLEXPHQJDWDNDQ SDOSDVL SHUNXVL GDQ DXVNXOWDVL 3DGD
DQDNVHVDNQDIDV6HVDNQDIDVEXNDQVDODK SHPHULNVDDQ ¿VLN SDUX GLGDSDWNDQ KDVLO
VDWXWDQGDGDQJHMDODWHUNDLWGHQJDQLQIHNVL GDGDVLPHWULVWLGDNDGDOHVLZDUQDNXOLWVDZR
VDOXUDQSHUQDIDVDQSDGDED\LGDQDQDNDQDN PDWDQJSHUQDIDVDQFHSDWLUDPDQDIDVWLGDN
VHVDN QDIDV PHUXSDNDQ VDODK VDWX WDQGD WHUDWXUGHQJDQIUHNXHQVL55[PHQLWWLGDN
JHMDOD LQIHNVL VDOXUDQ QDIDV EDZDK \DLWX DGD Q\HUL WHNDQ KDVLO SHUNXVL K\SHUVRQRU
EURQNLROLWLV:RQJ'DULGDWDVXEMHNWLI GDQ VXDUD SDUX URQFKL +DVLO SHPHULNVDDQ
ODLQ \DQJ GLGDSDWNDQ ROHK SHQXOLV NHWLND SDUX\DQJGLGDSDWVHVXDLGHQJDQNRPSRQHQ
ZDZDQFDUDDGDEHEHUDSDWDQGDWDQGD,63$ SHQJNDMLDQSHUQDIDVDQPHQXUXW:RQJ
SDGD$Q$\DLWXLEXPHQJDWDNDQDQDNEDWXN IUHNXHQVLFHSDWNHPXGDKDQGHQJDQXSD\D
LEXPHQJDWDNDQDQDNSDQDVLEXPHQJDWDNDQ GLVSQHDEDWXNLUDPDQDIDVURQFKL
DQDN PDNDQ VHGLNLW LEX PHQJDWDNDQ DQDN
-HQLVWHUDSL\DQJGLEHULNDQSDGDSDVLHQGDUL
PDNDQ[VHKDULKDELVòSRUVL6HGDQJNDQ
WDQJJDO )HEUXDUL )HEUXDUL \DLWX
GDULKDVLOREVHUYDVLGLGDSDWNDQGDWDREMHNWLI
5LQJHU/DNWDWWSPFHIRWD[LPHPJ
\DLWXSHUQDIDVDQFHSDWVXDUDQDIDVURQFKL
MDPFHIRWD[LPHPHUXSDNDQJHQHUDVLNHWLJD
55 [PHQLW 1 [PHQLW 6 Û&
GDUL FHSKDOVSRULQ &HIRWD[LPH GLJXQDNDQ
%% LGHDO NJ %% VHNDUDQJ NJ
XQWXN WHUDSL LQIHNVL PLNURED \DQJ SHND
SHQXUXQDQ %% GDUL %% LGHDO \DLWX
WHUPDVXN LQIHNVL VHULXV GDQ EHUEDKD\D
NJ PXNRVD ELELU OHPEDE FDSLOODU\ UH¿O
6LUDLW7HUDSLREDWRUDOFHWLUL]LQH
GHWLNNRQMXQJWLYDDQHPLVQDIVXPDNDQ
PJ MDP &HWLUL]LQH DGDODK REDW GHQJDQ
PHQXUXQ7DQGDGDQJHMDOD\DQJGLWHPXNDQ
LQGLNDVLULQLWLVDOHUJLNPHQDKXQULQLWLVDOHUJLN
SDGD $Q $ VDDW GLODNXNDQ SHQJNDMLDQ
PXVLPDQGDQXUWLNDULDLGLRSDWLNNURQLV6LUDLW
VXGDKVHVXDLGHQJDQPDQLIHႋDVLNOLQLVDWDX
3X\HUEDWXN[EXQJNXV.DQGXQJDQ
EDWDVDQ NDUDNWHULႋLN ,63$ 0HQXUXW :RQJ
GDULSX\HUEDWXNDGDODK DPR[LFLOLQJO\FHU\O
WDQGD JHMDOD ,63$ \DLWX GHPDP
JXDLDFRODWH GDQ FKORUSKHQLUDPLQH PDOHDWH
PHQLQJLVPXVDQRUHNVLDPXQWDKGLDUHQ\HUL
&70 $PR[LFLOLQ UHVLႋHQ GDUL SURVHV
DEGRPHQ KLGXQJ WHUVXPEDW UDEDV KLGXQJ
EDWXNEXQ\LQDIDVGDQVDNLWWHQJJRURNDQ LQDNWLYDVL ROHK DVDP ODPEXQJ ,QGLNDVL GDUL
JO\FHU\O JXDLDFRODWH XQWXN EDWXN SURGXNWLI
3HQXOLVPHQJNDMLSRODQXWULVLGDQPHWDEROLVPH
,QGLNDVL &70 \DLWX JHMDOD DOHUJL VHSHUWL
SDVLHQ VHEHOXP GDQ VHODPD VDNLW DVXSDQ
XUWLNDULD EHUVLQEHUVLQ GHUPDWLWLV HNVLP
PDNDQDQVHODPDVDNLWDQDNPDNDQVHGLNLW
HGHPDDQJLRQHXURWLN6LUDLW0HQGDSDW
PDNDQ[VHKDULKDELVòSRUVLGHQJDQMHQLV
WHUDSLLQKDODVLXDSQHEXOL]HUGHQJDQYHQWROLQ
PDNDQDQ QDVL WLP VD\XU ODXN GDQ QDIVX
òSXOPLFRUWò1DWULXP.ORULGDFFVHWLDS
PDNDQPHQXUXQ3DGDSHQJNDMLDQSRODQXWULVL
MDP9HQWROLQPHUXSDNDQVDODKVDWXMHQLV
WHUGDSDWSHQXUXQDQDVXSDQPDNDQDQ
GDUL VDOEXWDPRO 6DOEXWDPRO GLJXQDNDQ
3HQXOLV MXJD PHODNXNDQ SHPHULNVDDQ ¿VLN VHEDJDLEURQNRGLODWRUSDGDWHUDSLDVPDGDQ
\DQJGLPXODLGDULNHSDODVDPSDLGHQJDQNDNL SHQ\DNLWSDUXREႋUXNVLNURQLV6LUDLW
KHDG WR WRH GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ WHNQLN
PDNDQ EDLNPHQLQJNDW .ULWHULD KDVLO \DQJ DGYLV GRNWHU SHPEHULDQ WHUDSL FHIRWD[LPH
GLFDQWXPNDQ ROHK SHQXOLV VHVXDL GHQJDQ PJMDP
WHRUL PHPSHUWDKDQNDQ EHUDW EDGDQ 5. Evaluasi
NJDWDXEHUWDPEDKPHQMDGLNJPHPLOLNL
3HUNHPEDQJDQGLDJQRVDSDGDKDULSHUWDPD
QLODL ODERUDWRULXP GDODP EDWDV QRUPDO
GDQ NHGXD PDVDODK EHOXP WHUDWDVL 3DGD
+E JGO +&7 PHODSRUNDQ
KDUL NHGXD DGD VHGLNLW SHUNHPEDQJDQ
WLQJNDW HQHUJL \DQJ DGHNXDW 'DQ UHQFDQD
3HUNHPEDQJDQKDULNHWLJDOHELKEDLNGDULSDGD
WLQGDNDQ\DQJGLVXVXQSHQXOLVDNDMLDGDQ\D
KDULSHUWDPDGDQNHGXD\DQJGLWDQGDLGHQJDQ
DOHUJLPDNDQDQEPRQLWRUWXUJRUNXOLWF
EDWXN DQDN EHUNXUDQJ DQDN VXGDK WLGDN
KLGDQJNDQ PDNDQDQ GDODP SRUVL KDQJDW
VHVDNQDIDVVXDUDSDUXURQFKLEDWXNWLGDN
GDQMXUNDQPDNDQVHGLNLWWDSLVHULQJH
NHOXDUGDKDN55[PHQLW3HUNHPEDQJDQ
NRODERUDVLGHQJDQDKOLJL]LSHPEHULDQ7.73
GLDJQRVDSDGDKDULSHUWDPDPDVDODKEHOXP
5HQFDQD\DQJGLVXVXQSHQXOLVVXGDKVHVXDL
WHUDWDVLWLGDNDGDQ\DSHUXEDKDQSDGDSDVLHQ
GHQJDQ 1,& 6HODLQ WLQGDNDQ \DQJ WHODK
PDND LQWHUYHQVL GLODQMXWNDQ 3DGD HYDOXDVL
GLVXVXQ SHQXOLV GDSDW MXJD GLODNXNDQ D
KDULNHGXDGDQNHWLJDSDVLHQDGDNHPDMXDQ
PRQLWRUOLQJNXQJDQVHODPDPDNDQEDMDUNDQ
GLEDQGLQJKDULSHUWDPD
RUDQJWXDGDQDQDNWHQWDQJPHPLOLKPDNDQDQ
\DQJVHKDWFVXDSLDQDNELODSHUOXGWHPDQL 3HUNHPEDQJDQGLDJQRVDSDGDKDULSHUWDPD
SDVLHQVHWHODKPDNDQXQWXNPHQJREVHUYDVL GDQNHGXD\DLWXPDVDODKWHUDWDVLVHEDJLDQ
\DQJWHODKGLVXVXQ1DPXQSDGDKDULNHGXD
DGDWLQGDNDQ\DQJEHOXPGLGRNXPHQWDVLNDQ DAFTAR PUSTAKA
ROHK SHQXOLV \DLWX PHQJDQMXUNDQ NRPSUHV
0XEDUDN:DKLW,JEDOGDQ1XUXO&KD\DWLQ
7LQGDNDQ \DQJ GLODNXNDQ SHQXOLV XQWXN
%XNX $MDU .HEXWXKDQ 'DVDU 0DQXVLD
GLDJQRVD MXJD VXGDK VHVXDL GHQJDQ
7HRUL $SOLNDVLGDODP3UDNWLN-DNDUWD(*&
UHQFDQDWLQGDNDQ\DQJWHODKGLVXVXQQDPXQ
SHQXOLV NXUDQJ GDODP PHQGRNXPHQWDVLNDQ 1$1'$ 'LDJQRVLV .HSHUDZDWDQ 'H¿QLVL
SDGDSHODNVDQDDQ\DLWXPHQJNDMLWXUJRUNXOLW GDQ.ODVL¿NDVL-DNDUWD(*&
'DULWLQGDNDQ\DQJWHODKGLODNXNDQROHKSHQXOLV
1XUVDODP 3URVHV 'DQ 'RNXPHQWDVL
DGD SXOD WLQGDNDQ \DQJ WLGDN GLFDQWXPNDQ
.HSHUDZDWDQ .RQVHS GDQ 3UDNWLN (G
SDGD UHQFDQD WLQGDNDQ ROHK SHQXOLV WHWDSL
-DNDUWD6DOHPED0HGLND
GLODNXNDQ SDGD SDVLHQ \DLWX PHODNVDQDNDQ
:LONLQVRQ -XGLWK 0 GDQ 1DQF\ 5$KHUQ 3HUWDPD ,63$ SDGD %DOLWD GL 'HVD
:RQJ'RQQD/%XNX$MDU.HSHUDZDWDQ
3HGLDWULN(G-DNDUWD(*&