Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ScienceDirect
QUASI-EXPERIMENTAL STUDY
Received 7 August 2013; received in revised form 22 October 2013; accepted 31 October 2013
KEYWORDS Summary Falls are a common problem in older adults. Impaired balance, mobility and
Pilates; postural stability are risk factors for falling. Limited research has been performed on Pilates
Fall prevention; exercise and the ability to decrease fall risk.
Balance; In this quasi-experimental study, 35 adults (61e87 years old) participated in an 8-week Pi-
Physical therapy lates based exercise program. Blind examiners conducted the Timed Up and Go (TUG), Forward
Reach Test, and Turn 180 Test before and after the intervention. Number of falls, perception of
Pilates, and fear of falling was also recorded.
Thirty-two (91.4%) participants completed post-test measures. Significant improvements
were seen in the TUG (p <0.001) and Turn 180 Test (p Z 0.002). Improvements were also
demonstrated in the Forward Reach Test (p Z 0.049). A positive perception of the Pilates pro-
gram and decreased fear of falling was shown.
Results suggest a Pilates based exercise program may be effective in improving balance,
mobility and postural stability to decrease fall risk.
ª 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Introduction et al., 2003). The total cost of these falls was £981 million.
In the United States one out of three adults over the age of
Falls have been a long-standing problem facing older 65 falls each year; yet less than half of these individuals
adults. In 1999 there were over 647,721 fall related acci- discuss their falls with their healthcare provider (Hausdorff
dents and emergencies in the UK for persons 60 (Scuffham et al., 2001). Falls account for approximately 10% of visits
to the emergency department and 6% of urgent hospitali-
zations of the elderly each year (Sattin, 1992). In 2010, the
* Corresponding author. Tel.: þ1 203 582 8321; fax: þ1 203 582
overall rate of non-fatal fall injury episodes for which a
6714. health-care professional was contacted was 43 per 1000
E-mail address: Rachel.pata@quinnipiac.edu (R.W. Pata). population. Rate of falls was 26 per 1000 in persons aged
1360-8592/$ - see front matter ª 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jbmt.2013.11.002
362 R.W. Pata et al.
18e44 and increased incrementally up to 115 per 1000 in the use of the reformer system, which is not feasible for all
persons aged 75 years (Centers for Disease Control and to use.
Prevention, 2013). Falls often results in long term compli- This study investigated the efficacy of a group based
cations and participation restrictions in this population. exercise program combining traditional and Pilates-derived
The National Health Interview Survey indicates that falls movements. The purpose was to determine if a Pilates-
are the leading cause of restricted activities among older based program is effective in improving dynamic balance,
adults, accounting for 18% of total restricted days mobility, and postural stability in order to decrease the
(Rubenstein, 2006). By the year 2020, the annual direct and number of falls in older adults. Based on previous research,
indirect cost of fall injuries is expected to reach $54.9 it is hypothesized that the Pilates program will be effective
billion dollars in the United States (Englander et al., 1996). in improving these risk factors for falls in the older adult
Falls are a multifactorial problem with many intrinsic population.
and extrinsic risk factors that have been identified
(Rubenstein, 2006). Extrinsic risk factors may include un- Methods
safe foot wear or environmental tripping hazards (Tinetti
et al., 1988; Tinetti and Speechley, 1989). Some intrinsic
For this study, a quasi-experimental pre-test, post-test
risk factors for falling include impaired mobility, decreased
study design was used. Participants completed pre-testing
postural stability, and impaired balance (Tinetti et al.,
one week prior to the beginning of the exercise interven-
1988; Campbell et al., 1989; Nevitt et al., 1989; Lord
tion. Post-testing was completed one week after the
et al., 1991). Additionally, many people, who fall, even if
completion of the Pilates based intervention program.
they are not injured, develop a fear of falling. Due to this
Thirty-five participants were enrolled in the class which ran
fear, they limit their activities leading to reduced mobility
through September and October 2012. Prior to
and loss of physical fitness, which in turn increases their
commencement of the study approval was received from
actual risk of falling (Clark et al., 1993; Brown, 1999).
the Quinnipiac University Institutional Review Board (IRB).
Vellas et al., reported about one-third of elderly people
developed a fear of falling after an incident fall. Fallers
who were afraid of falling again had significantly more Participants
balance and gait disorders (Vellas et al., 1997).
Many exercise programs have been studied to determine Subjects for the study were recruited in the town of Wall-
their effectiveness on improving these risk factors. Aerobic ingford, CT through flyers at the Wallingford Senior Center.
and resistance activities have been used by many re- Individuals that were interested in participating were
searchers to improve physical functioning and reduce fall instructed to contact the Wallingford Senior Center Pro-
risk (Liu-Ambrose et al., 2004; Providence et al., 1995; gram Coordinator. The Program Coordinator then took
Tromp et al., 1998). Multicomponent exercises programs down names and telephone numbers of those interested.
have targeted strength and balance for the prevention of Eligibility was then determined by a telephone interview.
falls and shown improvements in fall rates of up to 34% Inclusion criteria for participation were: 1) over 60 years
(Gillespie et al., 2009). Tai Chi programs with an emphasis old 2) no history of hospitalization in the past 3 months 3)
on balance have demonstrated improvements in postural residents of Wallingford, CT 4) able to attend at least 80%
stability (Wolf et al., 2003; Li et al., 2003). Additionally of the fitness classes. Exclusion criteria included: 1) the use
when comparing group based exercise to no intervention, of assistance device 2) inability to comprehend instructions
group based exercise has been found to be more effective in the English language 3) medical and pharmacologic
in decreasing fall frequency, increasing balance, and contraindications to exercise 4) peripheral neuropathy 5)
improving quality of life (Martin et al., 2013). vertigo 6) inability to raise the arms to 90 degrees of
Pilates based exercise is increasing in popularity and has shoulder elevation. After being deemed eligible to partici-
begun to have an impact in rehabilitation (Di Lorenzo, pate, each individual signed an informed consent.
2011). The goal of Pilates is to fuse the mind and body so Thirty-seven participants were screened and thirty-five
that the body uses the greatest mechanical advantage to were eligible to participate. Two participants were not
achieve optimal balance, strength and health (Pilates and eligible due to an exacerbation of vertigo. See Fig. 1.
Miller, 1945). The core principles of the Pilate’s method
of exercise include centering, concentration, control, Procedures
breath, precision and fluidity (Di Lorenzo, 2011). From a
clinical perspective, Pilates is composed of synergistic The pre-testing session was scheduled the week before the
movement patterns that include isometric, eccentric, and start of class. Each participant completed three standard-
concentric muscle contractions. These movement patterns ized testing measures that have been associated with fall
are easily translated into functional activities. Pilates em- risk. Participants also completed a survey requesting in-
phasizes lumbo-pelvic stability, precision of movement, formation about previous falls, perception of Pilates, and
segmental mobility of the spine, coordination, and balance fear of falling. Participants were additionally provided with
(Smith and Smith, 2005). Recent Pilates research has sug- a monthly calendar with instructions to indicate any falls
gested that a Pilates based exercise program may also during the month. Post-testing was completed one week
reduce risk factors, such as impaired balance and postural after the completion of the class with identical procedures
stability associated with falls (Kaesler et al., 2007; Guedes to the pre-testing. Three examiners, who were blinded to
et al., 2010; Johnson et al., 2007; Newell et al., 2012). This participant allocation, conducted the pre-test and post-
research is limited however, due to small sample size and test measures. The same examiner performed all pre-test
The effect of Pilates based exercise on reducing risk of falls in older adults 363
feet hips width apart, flex their shoulder to 90 and reach
forward as far as possible without stepping. The distance is
then measured in inches. A forward reach less than 10
inches is indicative of impaired balance (Weiner et al.,
1992). In a study of 128 volunteers, ranging from age
21e87, the forward reach test was determined to be pre-
cise (coefficient of variation Z 2.5%) and stable (intraclass
correlation coefficient across days Z 0.81) (Duncan et al.,
1990).
Intervention protocol
Discussion
although not statistically significant, did show improvement Determining effective strategies to reduce falls is an inte-
with a p-value of 0.049. See Table 2. gral part of reducing growing healthcare costs. National,
Many participants presented at increased risk for falls at state, and local partners are coming together across the
the pre-testing by presenting with decreased mobility, United States to address the growing public health issue
postural stability, balance, or some combination of the through evidence-based interventions that promote
only reduce the strain on the healthcare system, but also measurement with ultrasound scanning. Arch. Phys. Med.
improve the quality of life of elderly individuals. Pilates- Rehabil. 89, 2205e2212.
based exercise may improve mobility, postural stability, Englander, F., Hodson, T.J., Terregrossa, R.A., 1996. Economic
and balance in order to reduce falls in the elderly. dimensions of slip and fall injuries. J. Forensic Sci. 41 (5),
733e746.
Improved core strength, alignment and fluidity of move-
Fitzpatrick, C., Simpson, J.M., Valentine, J.D., et al., 2005. The
ment are all factors that may contribute to these im- measurement properties and performance characteristics
provements. This study also demonstrated the impact of a among older people of TURN180, a test of dynamic postural
community Pilates based program on confidence and fear of stability. Clin. Rehabil. 19, 412e418.
falling. Pilates based exercises can be effectively inte- Gillespie, L.D., Robertson, M.C., Gillespie, W.J., Lamb, S.E.,
grated into; fitness classes for the older adult as well as Gates, S., Cummings, R.G., Rowe, B.H., 2009. Interventions for
rehabilitation programs. Physical therapists should preventing falls in older people living in the community.
encourage patients to partake in exercise classes to Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 15 (2), CD007146.
improve functional status and decrease fall risk. Addition- Guedes, B., Cader, S., Valim, N., Torres, O., Monteiro de
ally these exercises and the principals of Pilates may be Oliveira, E., Dantas, E., 2010. Pilates method in personal au-
tonomy, static balance and quality of life of elderly females. J.
incorporated into a rehabilitation treatment plan with the
Bodywork Movement Therapies 14 (2), 195e202.
goal of improving balance and stability and reducing fall Hausdorff, J.M., Rios, D.A., Edelber, H.K., 2001. Gait variability
risk. In summary, the results of this study suggest that a and fall risk in communityeliving older adults: a 1eyear pro-
short-term Pilates based program focused on strengthening spective study. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 82 (8), 1050e1056.
and core stability may improve balance, mobility, and Hides, J., Wilson, S., Stanton, W., Strudwick, M.W., Wilson, S.J.,
postural stability in order to reduce falls in the older adult 2006. An MRI investigation into the function of the transversus
population. abdominis muscle during “drawing in” of the abdominal wall.
Spine 31, 175e178.
Horak, F.B., Shupert, C.L., Mirka, A., 1989. Components of postural
Acknowledgments dyscontrol in the elderly: a review. Neurobiol. Aging 10, 727e738.
Johnson, E., Larsen, A., Ozawa, H., Wilson, C.A., Kennedy, K.L.,
2007. The effects of Pilates-based exercise on dynamic balance
Thank you to Denise Cameron for her assistance with data in healthy adults. J. Bodywork Movement Therapies 11 (3),
analysis. Thank you to Megan Hastie, Sarah Kaye, Ashley 238e242.
Kenyon, Corey Lewis for their assistance with the collection Kaesler, D.S., Mellifont, R.B., Swete Kelly, P., Taaffe, D.R., 2007. A
of outcome measures. novel balance exercise program for postural stability in older
adults: a pilot study. J. Bodywork Movement Therapies 11 (1),
37e43.
References Li, F., Harmer, P., Fisher, K.J., McAuley, E., Chaumeton, N.,
Eckstrom, E., Wilson, N.L., 2003. Tai Chi and fall reductions in
Barnett, F., Gilleard, W., 2005. The use of lumbar stabilization older adults: a randomized controlled trial. J. Gerontol. 60 (2),
techniques during the performance of abdominal strengthening 187e194.
exercise variations. J. Sports Med. Phys. Fitness 45, 38e43. Liu-Ambrose, T., Khan, K.M., Eng, J.J., Janssen, P.A., Lord, S.R.,
Beattie, B.L., 2013. Effective fall-prevention demands a community McKay, H.A., 2004. Resistance and agility training reduce fall
approach [Epub ahead of print March 8 2013] J. Geriatr. Phys. Ther. risk in women aged 75 to 85 with low bone mass: a 6-month
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov.libraryproxy.quinnipiac.edu/ randomized, controlled trial. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 52 (5),
pubmed/23478394 (accessed 15.03.13.). 657e665.
Brown, A.P., 1999. Reducing falls in elderly people: a review of Lord, S.R., Cark, R.D., Webster, I.W., 1991. Physiological factors
exercise interventions. Physiother. Theor. Pract. 15, 59e68. associated with falls in an elderly population. J. Am. Geriatr.
Campbell, A.J., Borrie, M.J., Spears, G.F., 1989. Risk factors for Soc. 39 (12), 1194e2000.
falls in a community based prospective study of people 70 years Martin, J.T., Wolf, A., Moore, J.L., Rolenz, E., Dininno, A.,
and older. J. Gerontol. 44, M112eM117. Reneker, J.C., 2013. The effectiveness of physical therapist
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2013. Falls-older administered group-based exercise on fall prevention: a sys-
Adults. http://www.cdc.gov/HomeandRecreationalSafety/ tematic review of randomized controlled trials [Abstract pub-
Falls/index.html (accessed 16.03.13.). lished online ahead of print Feb 27 2013] J. Geriatr. Phys. Ther.
Clark, R.D., Lord, S.R., Webster, I.W., 1993. Clinical parameters http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov.libraryproxy.quinnipiac.edu/
associated with falls in an elderly population. Gerontology 39, pubmed/23449007 (accessed 15.03.13.).
117e123. Nevitt, M.C., Cummings, S.R., Kidd, S., Black, D., 1989. Risk factors
Crus-Ferreira, A., Fernandes, J., Kuo, Y.L., Bernardo, L.M., for recurrent nonsyncopal falls: a prospective study. J. Am.
Fernandes, O., Laranjo, L., Silva, A., 2013. Does pilates-based Med. Assoc. 261, 2663e2668.
exercise improve postural alignment in adult women? Women Newell, D., Shead, V., Sloane, L., 2012. Changes in gait and balance
Health 53 (6), 597e611. parameters in elderly subjects attending and 8-week supervised
Di Lorenzo, C.E., 2011. Pilates: what is it? Should it be used in Pilates programme. J. Bodywork Movement Therapies 16,
rehabilitation. Sports Health 3 (4), 352e361. 549e554.
Duncan, P.W., Weiner, D.K., Chandler, J., Studenski, S., 1990. Overstall, P.W., Exton-Smith, A.N., Imms, F.J., Johnson, A.L.,
Functional reach: a new clinical measure of balance. J. Ger- 1977. Falls in the elderly related to postural imbalance. Br. J.
ontol. 45, 192e197. Med. 1, 261e264.
Emery, K., De Serres, S.J., McMillan, A., Côté, J.N., 2010. The Pilates, J.H., Miller, W.J., 1945. Pilates’ Return to Life Through
effects of a Pilates training program on arm-trunk posture and Contrology. JJAugustin, NY, New York.
movement. Clin. Biomech. 25, 124e130. Podsiadlo, D., Richardson, S., 1991. The timed up and go: a test of
Endleman, I., Critchley, D.J., 2008. Transversus abdominis and basic functional mobility for frail elderly persons. J. Am. Ger-
obliquus internus activity during Pilates exercises: iatr. Soc. 39, 142e148.
The effect of Pilates based exercise on reducing risk of falls in older adults 367
Providence, M.A., Hadley, E.C., Hornbrook, M.C., Lipsitz, L., Smith, K., Smith, E., 2005. Integrating pilates-based core
Miller, J.P., Mulrow, C., Ory, M.G., Sattin, R.W., Timetti, M.E., strengthening into older adult fitness programs. Top. Geriatr.
Wolf, S.L., 1995. The effect of exercise in falls in elderly pa- Rehabil. 21 (1), 57e67.
tients. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 273 (17), 1341e1347. Sparrow, W.A., Bradshaw, E.J., Lamoureux, E., Tirosh, O., 2002.
Ringsberg, K., Gerdhem, P., Johansson, J., Obrant, K., 1999. Is Ageing effects on the attention demands of walking. Hum. Mov.
there a relationship between balance, gait performance and Sci. 21, 961e972.
muscular strength in 75-year-old women? Age and Ageing 28, Tinetti, M.E., Speechley, M., Ginter, S.F., 1988. Risk factors for
289e293. falls among elderly persons living in the community. New Engl.
Rubenstein, L.Z., 2006. Falls in older people: epidemiology, risk J. Med. 319, 1701e1707.
factors and strategies for prevention. Age and Ageing 35, Tinetti, M.E., Speechley, M., 1989. Prevention of falls among
37e41. elderly. New Engl. J. Med. 320, 1055e1059.
Sattin, R.W., 1992. Falls among older persons: a public health Tinetti, M.E., Williams, C.S., 1997. Falls, injuries due to falls, and
perspective. Annu. Rev. Public Health 13, 489e508. the risk of admission to a nursing home. New Engl. J. Med. 337,
Schlicht, J., Camaione, D.N., Owen, S.V., 2001. Effect of intense 1279e1284.
strength training on standing balance, walking speed, and sit- Tromp, A.M., Smith, J.H., Dereg, D.J.H., Bouter, L.M., Lips, P.,
to-stand performance in older adults. J. Gerontol. Ser. A-Bio- 1998. Predictors for falls and fractures in the longitudinal aging
logical Sci. Med. Sci. 56, M281eM286. study Amsterdam. J. Bone Miner. Res. 13, 1932e1939.
Scuffham, P., Chaplin, S., Legood, R., 2003. Incidence and cost of Vellas, B.J., Wayne, S.J., Romero, L., Baumgartner, R., Garry, P.,
unintentional falls in older people in the United Kingdom. J. 1997. Fear of falling and restriction of mobility in elderly
Epidemiol. Community Health 57, 740e744. fallers. Age and Ageing 26, 189e193.
Shubert, T.E., McCullock, K., Hartman, M., Giuliani, C.A., 2010. Weiner, D.K., Duncan, P.W., Chandler, J., Studenski, S.A., 1992.
The effect of an exercise-based balance intervention on phys- Functional reach: a marker of physical frailty. J. Am. Geriatr.
ical and cognitive performance for older adults: a pilot study. J. Soc. 40, 203e207.
Geriatr. Phys. Ther. 33, 157e164. Whitney, J.C., Lord, S.R., Close, J.T., 2005. Streamlining assess-
Shumway-Cook, A., Brauer, S., Woollacott, M., 2000. Predicting the ment and intervention in a falls clinic using the timed up and go
probability for falls in community dwelling older adults using test and physiologic profile assessments. Age and Ageing 34,
the timed up and go test. Phys. Ther. 80, 896e903. 567e571.
Simpson, J.M., Worsfold, C., Reilly, E., Nye, N., 2002. A standard Wolf, S.L., Sattin, R.W., Kutner, M., O’Grady, M., Greenspan, A.I.,
procedure for using turn 180. Physiotherapy 88, 342e354. Gregor, R.J., 2003. Intense Tai Chi exercise training and fall
Sinaki, M., Brey, R.H., Hughes, C.A., Larson, D.R., Kaufman, K.R., occurrence in older, transitionally frail adults: a randomized,
2005. Balance disorder and increased risk of falls in osteoporosis controlled trial. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 51, 1693e1701.
and kyphosis: significance of kyphotic posture and muscle
strength. Osteoporos. Int. 16 (8), 1004e1010.