Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/284209499
CITATIONS READS
3 19,976
2 authors, including:
Samson Chukwuedo
University of Benin
18 PUBLICATIONS 32 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Samson Chukwuedo on 21 November 2015.
Samson O. Chukwuedo
Department of Vocational and Technical Education, University of Benin, Benin City
E-mail:dissam1@yahoo.com +2348029026002/+2348163389989
and
Chris E. Nwachukwu
Department of Vocational Teacher Education, University of Nigeria, Nsukka
Abstract
This study determined the maintenance practices in mobile phones for training electronic technology
students and in turn required of electronic technology graduates from technical colleges in Nigeria
for self-employment. The study determined the mobile phone faults for diagnosis and the practical
skills in the repairs of mobile phones. These formed the two research questions, out of which one
hypothesis was formulated and tested. Descriptive survey research designed was employed, using 17
electronic technology teachers and 50 mobile phone technicians in Edo State. Questionnaire
validated by experts, with reliability coefficient of 0.905 was the instrument used for data collection.
The mean and standard deviation were used to answer the research questions while t-test statistic was
used to test the hypothesis. It was found that it is necessary and required to train electronic
technology graduates from technical colleges on mobile phone fault diagnosis and practical skills in
the repair of faults in mobile phones. It was recommended that the teaching of maintenance practices
in mobile phones should be properly integrated into the curriculum of technical colleges and at the
same time be effectively implemented through electronic technology teachers’ capacity building in
maintenance repairs of mobile phone.
215
JORIND 12 (1) June, 2014. ISSN 1596-8308. www.transcampus.org/journals; www.ajol.info/journals/jorind
addition, mobile phones are made up of categories of faults can definitely be remedied by
mechanical, electrical and electronic devices employing the right repair principles.
with expiration capacity; hence they are not
expected to last indefinitely when used in various Repairs in the document of Bridgestone
places and conditions. Since these appliances Michellin Pirelli (2013) are services that are
must attain a level of down-time (the period required or necessary when something on a
devices, components or appliances are not system is not working properly or may have
working because of breakdown of faults), it is worn to the point where a replacement is
therefore necessary to carry out maintenance on required to maintain the performance of the
mobile phones. system. According to Australian Taxation Office
(2012) repairs mean work to make good or
Maintenance is the total attention and care given remedy defects in, damage to or deterioration of
to an appliance or a system in order to continue the property. It involves fixing faults in an
functioning well, both at its up-time and down appliance or a system. Repairs in the context of
time. It is simply the action taken to restore or this study involves the activities taken for the
keep an item in good functional order. According restoration of a broken, damaged or failed
to Ogbuaya, (2009) it involves all the activities component, device, equipment, part, or appliance
taken in order to prolong the service life of the to an acceptable operating or stable state. The
item. There are basically three types of skills involved in maintenance of digital
maintenance usually carried out in any system. electronic appliances are commonly acquired in
These are predictive, preventive and corrective Nigeria through the non-formal and/or the formal
maintenance. The practices engage in identifying educational system. The non-formal education
faults and remedying the faults in an appliance to involves the apprenticeship system or practice of
prolong the service life of the appliance is learning, which according to Omofonmwan
contextually termed maintenance practices. One (2011) is a contractual agreement undertaken by
of the important maintenance practices in mobile a master craftsman and an apprentice whereby
phone necessary for self-employment is the the apprentice is trained in a prescribed work
corrective maintenance, which can also be process through practical experiences under the
termed equipment repair maintenance or supervision of the master-craftsman. Perhaps, the
breakdown maintenance or simply repairs. more acceptable and preferable educational
system is the formal education approach, which
Generally, repairs are carried out when there is characterized as a system with fixed
exist faults in an appliance. Mobile phones are curriculum and a cadre of certified teachers with
prone to developing faults when used like other standard pedagogical methods for skill
appliances. Faults in mobile phones are generally acquisition. One of the levels through which
grouped into two. According to Gsmindia maintenance skills in mobile phone can be
(2013), Blogger (2011) and Archninja (2010) acquired is the secondary education, of which
mobile phone faults are classified into hardware technical colleges in Nigeria are grouped under
and software faults, but because some of the this level.
software faults are common with the phone
settings, a third classification of mobile phone According to Nwachukwu, Bakare and Jika
faults known as setting fault is considered. The (2011) technical college provides students
hardware faults are associated to printed circuit through training with the relevant and adequate
board (PCB), batteries and any other electronics knowledge, skills and attitude for employment
or hardware parts. These faults include no signal, under the guidelines of a teacher in related
battery empty, mic, vibration, keypads and occupations. In order to achieve these objectives,
earpiece faults, just to mention but a few. various trades or occupations are learnt at the
Software faults are associated to faults emanating technical colleges. Ede, Miller and Bakare
from the operating system (OS) of the mobile (2010) identified that students in technical
phone. Some of the faults are dead set, auto colleges are trained in auto mechanics,
restart, camera failure and booting problems. woodwork, plumbing, electrical installation and
Setting faults are faults related to the setting of maintenance work, radio and television (RTV)
the mobile phone, and these include call diverts, and electronics, computer craft and mechanical
SIM lock, no network and phone slow. These trades. These trades are meant to prepare
216
JORIND 12 (1) June, 2014. ISSN 1596-8308. www.transcampus.org/journals; www.ajol.info/journals/jorind
graduates in different areas, of which electronic phones in order to enhance their preparation as
technology graduates are also prepared. competent craftsmen, advance craftsmen and
technicians who will perform the required
Electronic technology prospective graduates repairs, otherwise there will be continuous waste
from technical colleges are the required of electronic products when there is breakdown.
craftsmen and technicians in the field of In addition, the problem of employment has
electronic technology. These set of graduates continued to mount. If better skills are acquired
have been or should have been exposed to the by graduates of technical colleges in the repairs
rudiments and practical skills in electronic of devices such as mobile phones, it will
technology including theoretical knowledge, but contribute to increasing a shift from youth
with more emphasis on psychomotor skills. unemployment to self-reliance.
Electronic technology graduates are expected to
go into the world of work as demand driven semi The common breakdown of these appliances, the
and middle manpower for employment or relative continual production of incompetent
become self-employed in electronics works in manpower to perform effective maintenance
order to earn a living and contribute significantly repair tasks in mobile phones and the problem of
to technological advancement. youth unemployment can raise many questions in
mind. One question the researchers ask is: is it
The technical college curriculum is planned and not time to introduce practical skills in repairs of
implemented such that electronics works are mobile phone in the curriculum for teaching and
taken into consideration. The NABTEB Syllabus learning in practical classes in technical colleges
(2007) and the document of NBTE (2011) in Nigeria? The study therefore identified the
identified two trades where maintenance skills maintenance practices required of electronic
are taught in technical colleges. These are technology graduates from technical colleges
Electronic Works and Appliance Maintenance which will help them earn a living after
and Repairs trades. One of the missing graduation.
appliances in these trades is the mobile phones. It
is therefore necessary that this study identify This study determined the maintenance practices
some of the necessities in the maintenance of in the repairs of mobile phones required for
mobile phones needed to be integrated into the training electronic technology students
trades in order to produce demand driven (prospective graduates) in technical colleges in
technicians for maintenance of mobile phones. Nigeria for self-employment after graduation,
with emphasis on common faults for diagnosis
Statement of the problem and on-the-job practical skills in maintenance of
In recent times, the use of digital electronic mobile phone. The following research questions
products such as mobile phones has increased, were raised and answered in the study.
but there seems to be relatively inadequate 1. What are the common faults in mobile
qualified and competent technicians to repair phones diagnosis necessary for training
these products when they are in bad conditions. electronic technology graduates from
The relative inadequacy of technicians in technical colleges?
maintenance repairs of mobile phones may be
traced to inadequate inclusion of such skills in 2. What are the on-the-job practical skills
the curriculum of the school system as early as in the repairs of mobile phones required
necessary. This may be the reason why majority of electronic technology graduates from
of the available technicians perform maintenance technical colleges?
repair tasks on trial and error basis as they were
never or rarely exposed to such skills while in Methodology
school and hence may not possess the adequate The study employed the descriptive survey
knowledge and skills needed to carry out such research design in which the opinions of a
repairs. representative sample of mobile phone
technicians from the world of work and the
The foregoing implies that there is need to electronic technology teachers in technical
identify the maintenance skills required by colleges in Edo State are sought in order to make
electronics technology students of technical generalization of the findings to other electronic
college to carry out basic repairs of mobile technology graduates from technical colleges in
217
JORIND 12 (1) June, 2014. ISSN 1596-8308. www.transcampus.org/journals; www.ajol.info/journals/jorind
Nigeria. The population of the study comprised coefficient of 0.905 was determined using
all the mobile phone technicians and the 17 Cronbach alpha formula.
electronic technology teachers in the four
functional technical colleges in Edo State. The The data were collected personally by the
sample size of the study was 67, which researchers. The data collected were analyzed
comprised all the 17 electronic technology using mean and standard deviations to answer the
teachers and 50 mobile phone technicians who research questions while the t-test statistic was
were selected using convenience sampling used to test the hypothesis at 0.05 level of
technique. significant. The decision rule for the research
question was based on real limit of values. Items
The instrument for data collection was a five with mean responses within the range of the real
point scaled questionnaire made up of two limit of values: 1.00 to 1.49, 1.50 to 2.49, 2.50 to
sections which were in line with the research 3.49, 3.50 to 4.49 and 4.50 to 5.00 were
questions. The first section was scaled as very remarked as VHN/VHR, HN/HR, AN/MR,
highly necessary (VHN), highly necessary (HN), SN/SR and NN/NR respectively. The items with
averagely necessary (AV), slightly necessary probability (p) values less than or equal to 0.05
(SN) and not necessary (NN), while the second were remarked significant (S) while items with
section was scaled as very highly required p-values greater than 0.05 were remarked not
(VHR), highly required (HR), moderately significant (NS).
required (MR), slightly required (SR) and not
required (NR). In both scales, the response Data presentation and analysis
categories were assigned numerical values of 5, The data analyses are presented in tables with
4, 3, 2 and 1 respectively. The questionnaire was respect to the research questions and the
validated by three experts, and its reliability hypothesis.
Research question 1: What are the common faults in mobile phones diagnosis necessary for training
electronic technology graduates from technical colleges?
Table 1: Mean and standard deviations of common faults in mobile phones diagnosis necessary for
training electronic technology graduates from technical colleges
S/N Necessary Diagnosable Faults in Mobile Phones Mean SD Remarks
Some of the Hardware Faults
1 Dead set (not powering on) 3.91 .668 HN
2 No charging 4.26 .528 HN
3 Battery empty 4.36 .510 HN
4 Auto charging 4.04 .484 HN
5 No signal/Low signal 4.08 .662 HN
6 Voice problem 4.04 .588 HN
7 Vibration problem 4.23 .541 HN
8 Ringer problem 4.32 .468 HN
9 Backlight problem 4.32 .468 HN
10 No network access 4.22 .559 HN
11 Hanging problem 4.23 .541 HN
12 Insert SIM card 3.86 .585 HN
13 Keypad problem 3.90 .605 HN
14 Display problem 4.30 .545 HN
15 mic fault 3.95 .468 HN
16 Earpiece fault 3.64 .653 HN
17 Keypad fault 4.29 .456 HN
18 Phone off when make calls 3.89 .614 HN
19 Call drop 3.86 .673 HN
20 Auto restart/Auto turn off 3.95 .575 HN
Some of the Software Faults
21 No signal/Low signal 4.08 .662 HN
22 Dead set (not powering on) 3.91 .668 HN
218
JORIND 12 (1) June, 2014. ISSN 1596-8308. www.transcampus.org/journals; www.ajol.info/journals/jorind
Table 1 shows that the mean values and standard homogenous and clustered around the mean
deviations of the responses ranged from 3.59 to responses. The table also reveals that a particular
4.36 and .456 to .746 respectively. This means fault can be classified under more than a fault, as
that the mean values for all the 50 fault diagnosis in the case of dead set, not charging and no
related item in mobile phones are highly network faults.
necessary for training electronic technology
graduates from technical colleges in the Research question 2: What are the on-the-job
maintenance of mobile phones. The values of the practical skills in the repairs of mobile phones
standard deviations reveal that the responses of required of electronic technology graduates from
the respondents are relatively in consensus, technical colleges?
Table 2: Mean and Standard Deviations of the Practical Skills in the Repairs of Mobile Phones
Required of Electronic Technology Graduates from Technical Colleges
S/N Practical Skills in Mobile Phone Repairs Mean SD Decision
1 Identify the tools/equipment to carry out repairs of mobile phone 4.82 .386 VHR
2 Ability to use the tools/equipment to carry out such repairs 4.84 .373 VHR
3 Ability to identify the components/parts of mobile phones 4.69 .467 VHR
4 Disassembling of phones 4.51 .612 VHR
5 Assembling of phones 4.52 .612 VHR
6 Fixing LCD screen viewing related problems 3.99 .564 HR
7 Removal and replacement of keypads 4.31 .556 HR
8 Fixing overheating problems 3.79 .808 HR
9 Flashing/reprogramming of phones 3.93 .841 HR
10 Removal and installation of main board/mother board 4.18 .796 HR
219
JORIND 12 (1) June, 2014. ISSN 1596-8308. www.transcampus.org/journals; www.ajol.info/journals/jorind
The data presented in Table 2 shows that the consensus, homogenous and clustered around the
mean values and standard deviations of the mean responses.
responses ranged from 3.61 to 4.84 and .373 to
.841 respectively. The data shows that the mean Hypothesis: There is no significant difference in
values ranging from 4.51 to 4.84 for items 1 to 5 the mean responses of electronic technology
corresponds to very highly required (VHR), teachers and mobile phone technicians as regards
while the mean values ranging from 3.61 to 4.31 on-the-job practical skills in the repairs of mobile
corresponds to highly required (HR) of the phones required of electronic technology
practical skills in the repairs of mobile phones. graduates from technical colleges in Nigeria for
The values of the standard deviations show that self-employment.
the responses of the respondents are relatively in
Table 3: The t-test comparison of the Mean Response between Electronic Technology Teachers and
Mobile Phone Technicians on the Practical Skills in the Repairs of Mobile Phones Required of
Electronic Technology Graduates from Technical Colleges
Teachers Technicians
(n=17) (n=50)
s/n Practical Skills in Mobile Phone Repairs X1 SD1 X2 SD2 t-cal P Decision
1 Identify the tools/equipment to carry out 4.82 .393 4.82 .388 .032 .975 NS
repairs
2 Ability to use the tools/equipment to carry 4.82 .393 4.84 .370 -.156 .877 NS
out repairs
3 Ability to identify the components/parts of 4.65 .493 4.70 .463 -.401 .690 NS
mobile phones
4 Disassembling of phones 4.47 .624 4.52 .614 -.283 .779 NS
5 Assembling of phones 4.53 .624 4.52 .614 .054 .957 NS
6 Fixing LCD screen viewing related 3.76 .664 4.06 .512 -1.672 .108 NS
problems
7 Removal and replacement of keypads 4.18 .636 4.36 .525 -1.179 .243 NS
8 Fixing overheating problems 3.71 .772 3.82 .825 .500 .619 NS
9 Flashing/reprogramming of phones 3.53 1.125 4.06 .628 -1.834 .081 NS
10 Removal and installation of main 4.24 .664 4.16 .842 .335 .739 NS
board/mother board
220
JORIND 12 (1) June, 2014. ISSN 1596-8308. www.transcampus.org/journals; www.ajol.info/journals/jorind
221
JORIND 12 (1) June, 2014. ISSN 1596-8308. www.transcampus.org/journals; www.ajol.info/journals/jorind
222