You are on page 1of 59

British Standard

A single copy of this


British Standard is licensed to
Giorgio Cavalieri
on August 29, 2000

This is an uncontrolled copy.


Ensure use of the most current
version of this standard by
searching British Standards Online
at bsonline.techindex.co.uk
BRITISH STANDARD BS 6079-1:2000
Incorporating
Amendment Nos. 1
and 2 to BS 6079:1996
(amendment no. 2
renumbers the BS as
BS 6079-1:2000)

Project management —
Part 1: Guide to project management
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

ICS 03.100.50
BS 6079-1:2000

Committees responsible for this


British Standard

The preparation of this British Standard was entrusted to Technical


Committee MS/2, Project management, upon which the following bodies were
represented:

Association of Project Managers


British Standards Society
British Telecommunications plc
Chartered Institute of Management Accountants

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


Federation of Civil Engineering Contractors
Federation of the Electronics Industry
Fellowship for Operational Research
Highways Agency
Institute of Quality Assurance
Institution of Incorporated Executive Engineers
Institution of Mechanical Engineers
Ministry of Defence
Operational Research Society
Power Generation Contractors’ Association (PGCA (BEAMA Ltd.))
Society of British Aerospace Companies Ltd.
South Bank University
User Standards Forum for Information Technology (Institute of Data
Processing Management)

Summary of pages
This document comprises a front cover, an inside front cover, pages i and ii,
pages 1 to 52, an inside back cover and a back cover.
This British Standard, having The BSI copyright notice displayed in this document indicates when the
been prepared under the
direction of the Management
document was last issued.
Systems Sector Board, was
published under the authority
of the Standards Board and
comes into effect on
15 April 1996

© BSI 01-2000
Amendments issued since publication
The following BSI references
relate to the work on this Amd. No. Date Comments
standard:
Committee reference MS/2 10146 February Indicated by a sideline
Draft for comment
94/408410 DC, 94/408411 DC
1999
and 94/408412 DC
10794 January Renumbers as BS 6079-1
2000
ISBN 0 580 25594 8
BS 6079-1:2000

Contents

Page
Committees responsible Inside front cover
Section 1. General
Introduction 1
1.1 Scope 1
1.2 References 2
1.3 Definitions 2
Section 2. The corporate aspects of project management
2.1 General 4
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

2.2 Nature of projects 4


2.3 The work to be done 5
2.4 The project life cycle 7
2.5 The benefits of project management 8
Section 3. Project and company organizational structures
3.1 General 9
3.2 The hierarchical functional organization 9
3.3 The matrix organization 10
3.4 The project organization 11
3.5 Criteria for reorganization 11
Section 4. The project management process
4.1 General 13
4.2 The project management process: introduction 13
4.3 The project management process: planning 13
4.4 The project management process: control 24
4.5 The project plan 27
4.6 Processes supporting the project management process 29
4.7 Project personnel development 40
Section 5. Project lifecycle
5.1 General 42
5.2 Types of project 42
5.3 Project phasing 42
5.4 Project phase sequence 42
5.5 Description of phase content 43
Annex A (informative) Project management methodology:
cost/schedule control system criteria (C/SCSC) 50
Figure 1 — Arrangement of project phases, stages and milestones 6
Figure 2 — Authority relationships in organization structures 10
Figure 3 — Project management process flow 15
Figure 4 — Model work breakdown structure 16
Figure 5 — Model bar chart 21
Figure 6 — Typical cumulative cost pattern 35
Figure 7 — Format of cash flow forecast 36
Figure 8 — Earned value chart 39
Figure 9 — Project management life cycle 43
Figure 10 — Periodic estimate of project cost and finishing date 47
Table 1 — Model project plan 29
Table 2 — Example of discounted cash flow 37
Table 3 — List of typical project phases 49
List of references Inside back cover

© BSI 01-2000 i
BS 6079-1:2000

Foreword

This part of this Britsh Standard has been prepared by Technical Committee
MS/2, Project management.
It is published in three parts:
Part 1: Guide to project management.
Part 2: Vocabulary.
Part 3: Guide to the management of business related project risks.
Change of identifier
Wherever BS 6079:1996 appears in the text it should be read as BS 6079-1:2000.

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


A British Standard does not purport to include all the necessary provisions of a
contract. Users of British Standards are responsible for their correct application.
Compliance with a British Standard does not of itself confer immunity
from legal obligations.

Summary of pages
This document comprises a front cover, an inside front cover, pages i and ii, pages
1 to 52, an inside back cover and a back cover.
The BSI copyright notice displayed in this document indicates when the
document was last issued.

ii © BSI 01-2000
BS 6079-1:2000

Section 1. General

Introduction — Project support staff: co-ordinators, planners,


designers, cost analysts, quality auditors,
Project management could be said to be as old as
technicians etc; to help them to understand the
humankind since, by definition, any management
problems that may occur in their project
activity that introduces a new objective or causes
environment, and to provide possible solutions to
change and has a definite start and finish time is a those problems.
project. Formal project management as we know it
today started from the development of network — educators and trainers: those engaged in the
techniques in the late 1950s. teaching of network-based and other techniques
for project management who need to understand
The application of sophisticated project
the industrial context in which these techniques
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

management techniques to projects in government


are used.
and industry has become necessary to ensure the
achievement of business, economic, environmental, This standard aims to draw attention to the
strategic and political goals. The benefits of project management problems encountered in different
management techniques are not restricted to large project environments and to present possible
projects. Such techniques, like all good management solutions to these problems. Since there are no
practices, can usefully be applied to a project panaceas in project management, the solutions
regardless of its size. It is often the case that major presented should be treated as guidance only; they
projects are broken down into smaller projects with may need to be adapted to suit the particular
a subcontractor, who thus becomes part of the circumstances for which they are being considered.
project plan of the parent organization and needs to The only certainty in projects is that, without the
demonstrate competence in this area when full support of management for the project team and
tendering for the business. the appropriate choice and use of planning and
control techniques for the project, it will usually fail
In any organization, whether private or public to achieve its objectives. The guidance given and the
sector, service or manufacturing, software or principles of project management described are
hardware, it is necessary to plan, control and
applicable to all sizes of project.
implement tasks to achieve a given objective.
Although the concepts and basic principles of project 1.1 Scope
management are universal, they have to be tailored
and adapted to suit the particular circumstances of This standard gives guidance on the planning and
any project. This guide describes a full range of execution of projects and the application of project
project management procedures, techniques and management techniques. It has a broad relevance to
tools and the user is advised to select those elements projects in many industries and the public sector,
that are appropriate to the project being considered. both at home and abroad. This standard aims
To ensure success, the management of a project primarily to provide guidance for relative
needs to be entrusted to an individual with a newcomers to project management and to act as an
knowledge of the particular requirements of a given aide mémoire for more experienced practitioners
project and with certain essential personal and those who interact with project management
attributes. This guide defines the basic skills to look teams.
for when selecting a project manager and the project The principles and procedures outlined are relevant
team. to all sizes of organization, although they may not
This standard provides guidance to the following cover all aspects of every conceivable type and size
people: of project.
— General managers: in organizations that When consulting this standard it should be noted
operate projects: to raise awareness of the that, by definition, projects will have differing
problems that are likely to exist within their own emphases and priorities.
environment in the management of projects and
to enable them to provide appropriate support for
the project manager and team.
— Project managers: responsible for achieving
the defined project objectives: to improve their
ability to cope with the many problems that occur
(only some of which may be foreseen) and
encourage better integration between the
different disciplines taking part.

© BSI 01-2000 1
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 1

1.2 References 1.3.5


matrix organization
1.2.1 Normative references
a structure in which individuals, groups and
This standard incorporates, by dated or undated
managers continue to work within their specialist
reference, provisions from other publications. These
functional departments, but are assigned to work
normative references are made at the appropriate
full-time or part-time under the direction of a
places in the text and the cited publications are
project manager who is not their line manager
listed on the inside back cover. For dated references,
only the edition cited applies; any subsequent such assignees are responsible to the project
amendments to, or revisions of the cited publication manager for their project work and to other

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


apply to this standard only when incorporated in the functional managers for activities that are not
reference by amendment or revision. For undated related to the project
references, the latest edition of the cited publication 1.3.6
applies, together with any amendments. project
1.2.2 Informative references a unique set of co-ordinated activities, with definite
This standard refers to other publications that starting and finishing points, undertaken by an
provide information or guidance. Editions of these individual or organization to meet specific objectives
publications current at the time of issue of this within defined schedule, cost and performance
standard are listed on the inside back cover, but parameters
reference should be made to the latest editions. 1.3.7
project life cycle
1.3 Definitions the sequential phases through which a project
For the purposes of this standard the definitions passes to reach its objectives
given in BS 3811, BS 4335, BS EN ISO 8402 and 1.3.8
BS 7000-10, apply, together with the following. project management
1.3.1 the planning, monitoring and control of all aspects
configuration management of a project and the motivation of all those involved
the technical and administrative activities in it to achieve the project objectives on time and to
concerned with the creation, maintenance and the specified cost, quality and performance
controlled change of configuration data throughout 1.3.9
the life of a product project management activity (PMA)
NOTE A fuller definition of configuration management and
related terms is given in BS 7000-10. an operation, within a work package of a work
breakdown structure, that is a specific action to be
1.3.2
deliverables completed to aid the fulfilment of the project as a
whole
the intermediate or end outputs of a project
1.3.10
1.3.3 project manager
earned value
the individual or body with responsibility for
the value of the useful work done at any given point managing a project to achieve specific objectives
in a project
1.3.11
1.3.4 programme manager
functional organization
the individual or body with responsibility for
a line management structure where specific managing a group of projects
functions of a business are grouped into specialist
1.3.12
departments that provide a dedicated service to the
project organization
whole organization
for example accounts department, production the organizational structure that is created or
department, drawing office evolves to serve the project and its participants
1.3.13
project programme
a time and resource related schedule or diagram of
project tasks that describes the project process

2 © BSI 01-2000
Section 1 BS 6079-1:2000

1.3.14 1.3.20
project phase statement of work (SOW)
that part of a project during which consistent a document stating the requirements for a given
activities are performed to attain a designated project task
objective 1.3.21
one of a series of distinct steps in carrying out a task
project that together constitute the project life cycle the smallest indivisible part of an activity when it is
1.3.15 broken down to a level best understood and
project plan performed by a specific person
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

a plan for carrying out a project, to meet specific 1.3.22


objectives, that is prepared by or for the project variations management
manager the monitoring, recording and assessing of
1.3.16 variations to the scope or timing of a project,
risk irrespective of who generated the change
a combination of the probability, or frequency, of the objective is to make all parties fully aware of the
occurrence of a defined threat or opportunity and cost, time and quality implications of implementing
the magnitude of the consequences of the occurrence such changes
1.3.17 NOTE Variations management is a term used in the
risk management construction industry. It is closely related to the more widely
used terms change management and configuration management.
the process whereby decisions are made to accept a 1.3.23
known or assessed risk and/or the implementation work breakdown structure (WBS)
of actions to reduce the consequences or probability
of occurrence the level at which a piece of work within a project is
broken down for programming, cost planning,
1.3.18 monitoring and control purposes, to be performed by
sponsor a specific person, group or organization
1) the individual or body for whom the project is 1.3.24
undertaken, the primary risk taker work package
2) the individual representing the sponsoring a group of related tasks that are defined at the same
body and to whom the project manager reports level within a work breakdown structure
1.3.19
stakeholder
a person or group of people who have a vested
interest in the success of an organization and the
environment in which the organization operates

© BSI 01-2000 3
BS 6079-1:2000

Section 2. The corporate aspects of project


management
2.1 General 2.2 Nature of projects
It is difficult to think of any corporate activity, Projects are the engines of change. They may be
private or public, for profit or not for profit, quoted revenue generating projects with all the
or non-quoted, which is not facing change. consequences chargeable to the profit and loss
The motive for change may stem from a perceived account or, as more commonly understood, capital
shortage of funds, changing patterns of demand, projects with the initial impact mainly on the
social pressures, technological advances, balance sheet. The book-keeping conventions have
competitive and alternative suppliers of goods or little bearing on the management process.
services. There is little reason to suppose that the A project is a means to an end. An enterprise may

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


pressures will diminish, indeed some people would need, for example, to enhance income, and/or reduce
argue that the rate of change is likely to increase. costs, and/or improve productivity with reasonably
Managements have to respond to those changes to clear ideas of the extent to which change has to be
survive, those who do it successfully will probably brought about. An understanding of the objective by
prosper, those who are slow or whose response is the appropriate personnel should bring alternative
inadequate will decline and in due course fail. ways of achieving or maybe even exceeding the
objective.
As managements take the series of decisions to
move from where they are to where they want to be, Following a review of the alternatives and their
or need to be, they will commit resources to the respective consequences senior management will
achievement of results they have not previously decide on their preferred course of action and issue
enjoyed. Each task will be unique in some aspect; instructions to a responsible person for work to
opening a bank branch may not be novel to a major proceed. In due course, perhaps on time, or early, or
clearing bank but some single aspect, or late, the project will be declared complete and will
combination of events involved in opening a usually become the responsibility of someone else.
particular branch will make it a one-off occurrence. The ensuing results may or may not justify the
expenditure that has taken place, which may or may
Thus the pace of change is causing corporate
not have been within agreed limits.
managements to undertake more tasks with
unfamiliar characteristics. The decisions, perhaps In some cases the time delay in completion leads to
to run with a series of projects of differing such excessive costs that the project in its
significance and durations, will test management operational mode will never deliver an adequate
skills. As the projects become more numerous, they return.
are likely to run across departmental boundaries Understanding the nature of projects may enhance
and will tend to become more expensive. Such a the ability of managements to handle them.
bundle of activities creates significant managerial There are several attributes of projects, as follows:
problems and the purpose of this standard is to
a) they are non-repetitive and tend to have
provide a guide to project management, based on
significant unique features likely to be novel to
best practices.
the management;
Research suggests that the overall track record of
b) they carry risk and uncertainty;
British organizations in managing projects,
including take-overs, leaves much to be desired. The c) they should be approved in return for
delivery of results on time, within predetermined undertakings to deliver specified (minimum)
cost and of the requisite standard within set safety quantified results within pre-determined quality
and quality criteria is less frequent than it should and safety/health parameters;
be. d) the authorization should leave no doubt that
This standard aims to help managements deal with the results will need to be delivered with firm
these situations more efficiently and effectively. The start and finishing dates, within clearly specified
principles expounded in the standard are as cost and resource constraints;
relevant to small companies and small projects as e) they are usually in the hands of a temporary
they are to major enterprises with multi-million team and may be subject to change as the work
pound projects spanning several years. progresses;
Sections 3, 4 and 5 are aimed at operating f) in a long duration project, events inside and
management and this section is directed at senior outside the enterprise may affect the outcome.
managers.

4 © BSI 01-2000
Section 2 BS 6079-1:2000

2.3 The work to be done Management needs to consider the motivation of


staff when they are taken out of their departmental
Effective project management may be broken down
roles. Tangible rewards related to the achievement
into five stages:
of the project within the set constraints may involve
— planning; money, but in an appropriate culture other rewards
— organising; might include the kudos of being selected to work on
— motivating; a project, of promotion to wider responsibilities
following success in a project team, etc. Where staff
— implementing; are deployed on a full time basis there should
— control by review and accountability. always be an understanding that as a minimum a
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

Senior management is responsible for establishing return to previous duties is safe.


the objectives and constraints within which the Having agreed to run with a project and after an
project has to be delivered. They should set appropriate structure and pattern of motivation has
acceptable criteria and ensure that adequate been set up, management should issue instructions
planning has been done. This should establish the to proceed and the work of implementation can
proposed expenditure and test the realism and begin. People will be deployed, materials bought and
acceptability of the expected benefits being put services secured.
forward as justification. Senior staff should, without becoming directly
One of the major causes of sub-standard project involved in the detail, ensure that proper
management arises from failures at the planning operational procedures and controls are in place and
stage causing a series of subsequent being used. They should normally insist on reports
alterations/clarifications that pushes up at predetermined intervals, usually set as a
expenditure and creates delays. condition of authorization, showing the current
Increasingly, projects cut across departmental state of affairs and the latest expectation of
boundaries and management has to ensure that the completion in terms of at least cost and time. These
appropriate organisation is in place to run a project. reports will typically form the basis of reviews and
This will often be a temporary arrangement, but it the exercise of accountability with the project
will generally call for a project manager supported manager. These reviews will close one cycle and lead
by a team of staff with the appropriate skills for the into the next cycle of replanning, to take account of
needs of the project. changed circumstances, deal with problems and
The authority delegated to the project manager exploit opportunities. Figure 1 shows a typical
needs to be quite clear and because it will cover the arrangement of project phases, stages and
team assembled from departments, that authority milestones and Figure 3 illustrates the cycle of
has to be notified throughout the enterprise. management activities that recurs throughout a
Without this authority the project manager may be project.
thwarted by departmental intransigence.
Working in a project team has been found to be an
excellent capacity enhancing experience for
departmental staff and may be seen as a valuable
development method in career planning. On major
projects it is not always possible for departmental
staff to make the required contribution and
maintain departmental responsibilities, as a result
they may be seconded to a project on a full time
basis.

© BSI 01-2000 5
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 2

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

Figure 1 — Arrangement of project phases, stages and milestones

6 © BSI 01-2000
Section 2 BS 6079-1:2000

2.4 The project life cycle 2.4.3 Evaluating the project’s feasibility
2.4.1 General In the first instance the feasibility study will be
approximate as the prime purpose is to identify
All projects tend to go through a similar life cycle. In
those ideas that look promising and separate them
large schemes the elements may be very clearly
for closer attention than those which fail the tests.
separated, in smaller works they may be linked
The schemes that offer promise should then be
and/or blurred. Different industries have their own
subjected to more demanding evaluation which will
terms but in general it is useful and possible to take up rather more of the time of the staff
identify the following work that has to be carried concerned. In many organizations those projects
out:
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

which survive a more rigorous examination will be


1) concept, basic ideas; brought to the notice of a senior manager who can,
2) feasibility; tests for technical, commercial and if so persuaded, champion the project and secure
financial viability; agreement for further progress.
3) evaluation and application for funds, stating This will usually take the form of extended planning
risks; and a full evaluation. Organizations often find this
4) authorization and any conditions; is an appropriate time to select someone to run the
initial project work, frequently someone who will
5) implementation including design, become the project manager if the scheme proceeds.
procurement, fabrication, installation etc.; It would be that person’s responsibility to assemble
6) control/accountability, periodic reviews and a shadow team to provide the required inputs from
updates; marketing, sales, production, personnel, finance
7) completion and hand-over to client; etc., that would be assembled and collated in
8) operation, and inclusion in normal revenue financial terms and critically examined. The
planning/control procedures; champion would seek authority to proceed only
when satisfied with the plans that had been drawn
9) close down and cease operations; up. These plans might be expected to incorporate
10) termination including disposal of residual Critical Path Analysis, an evaluation of Net Present
assets (liabilities). Value using appropriate discount factors and a
Some organizations are very successful in review of the sensitivity of the project to attendant
generating ideas for improvements, some are adept risks.
at converting those ideas into reality. The most Larger organizations tend to have tiered
successful do both, often by tapping into the authorities, each capable of authorizing projects up
knowledge and experience of their own workforce. to a set value and recommending higher amounts to
Basic concepts will arise from solving current senior management. In agreeing authorization,
problems and also from identifying opportunities. management will usually set conditions and
Management needs to give encouragement both by constraints not the least of which will be the
tangible and psychological rewards. timetable for reporting progress against key events
2.4.2 Project concept or milestones. Funds will be earmarked and in large
projects they may be released on a cumulative basis
Each concept should undergo a screening process to and triggered by the receipt of satisfactory progress
test the feasibility in at least three different ways. reports from the project manager.
This should involve establishing first if the project is
technically feasible, secondly if it would be 2.4.4 Project implementation and handover
commercially acceptable and finally if the costs and As implementation proceeds management will be
benefits show a balance that makes the risks of aware that the only certainty in projects is the
proceeding worthwhile. consequence of the costs and liabilities being
incurred; while the promised deliverables will come
later in the implementation phase. Hence there is a
need for competent project progress reports at
sensible intervals with review meetings for the
exercise of accountability.

© BSI 01-2000 7
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 2

When the implementation is complete, management 2.5 The benefits of project


will usually require some degree of formality in management
handing over the project from the team that handled
its completion to those responsible for its future Good project management has proved to be an
operation. It is not uncommon for this next stage to effective and efficient way of managing change in
last for a sustained number of years. Concurrent many types of organisation.
with the handover, a succinct and honest report on It allows senior management to accomplish the
the history of the project to that stage can be helpful following:
in identifying strengths and weaknesses to aid a) direct scarce resources to what are judged to be

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


future project planning and control procedures. the most desirable objectives;
At handover the project team may be disbanded or b) focus appropriate management skills on to
switched to other projects. The subject of their specific tasks;
efforts will be absorbed into the normal budgeting,
c) secure commitments to deliver results from
revenue planning and control systems until the
those wishing to proceed with the project;
operation ceases, for example due to technical
obsolescence, market changes, simple plant life d) direct major elements of the business without
expiry, etc. being submerged in detail;
2.4.5 Terminating the project e) keep control of a wide variety of projects
running concurrently;
In most cases, closing down the project may be
f) ensure that issues such as quality and safety
simple and straightforward, but in a minority of
are engineered into projects at the design stage;
instances final termination may be a major event,
and probably become a project in its own right. g) extend the experience of staff working on
Items such as North Sea oil platforms, nuclear projects and help equip them for wider
installations in submarines and power stations have responsibilities.
major termination consequences, which is why the Later sections of this standard pick up and expand
financial appraisals need to be whole life the points made here, in a detailed manner that is
assessments to allow for what may be massive more attuned to assisting the operators of project
termination costs. management activities.

8 © BSI 01-2000
BS 6079-1:2000

Section 3. Project and company organizational


structures
3.1 General 3.2 The hierarchical functional
Any group that provides a service or produces a organization
product should form itself into an organization with In this type of organization, which is the traditional
a structure. This structure, and the size of the form for most manufacturing and process
organization, will inevitably affect the way the companies, there is usually no separate project
organization can respond to change and the function or organization. This form of
introduction of projects. organizational structure has existed for a long time
The structural form of the organization will and has significant advantages, with its simple
normally be hierarchical, apart from organizations reporting and centralized control, so long as the rate
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

set up specifically to provide project services, with of change is slow and any projects are small enough
an emphasis on the functional operations. With this to be contained within and serviced by one
form, a small organization will always be able to functional group. If the project enlarges and crosses
respond more quickly to the need for change than a functional boundaries, or the sheer number of
large one, since the owner or chief executive will projects overstretches the functional resources, then
have delegated less authority for specialist decision the disadvantages of this structural form become
making to the functions. apparent. An ever-increasing burden may be
As the organization grows, this traditional form is imposed on the chief executive, in particular due to
characterized by comparatively routine and the lack of co-operation and co-ordination that
predictable working procedures, a relatively low occurs between the functional groups.
rate of change, specialized functional staff and, In these circumstances the project manager may
because of this, a significant reduction in the need report directly to the chief executive and require the
for cross-functional communication and support of some specialist staff in undertaking the
co-operation. This has caused major problems in the project. This of itself can cause problems for the
current industrial environment as quick response to executive as the functional heads will be reluctant
market demand for new or updated products or to release suitable staff and the project manager will
services or changes in the level of existing supply or be reluctant to make do with inexperienced people.
product mix are required. The increasing rate of If or when the number or size of projects increases a
change, coupled with competitive demand to permanent project function should be set up and
shorten development cycles, has led to the even then there will still be the need to draw
introduction and growth of project management as specialist assistance from the functional groups for
an organizational form within the traditional various aspects of the project. For instance, in a
structure and the development of the matrix hardware project, engineering design work will still
structure. be carried out in the appropriate functional groups
Although project management structures are often and the co-ordination and timing of that work will
incorporated within the traditional structure of be the responsibility of the project team in
hierarchical functional organizations, they have conjunction with the functional heads to whom the
many of the same basic characteristics and share design staff report for their professional
the same resources as the other functions. Such competence.
structures require a much higher degree of
flexibility in working procedures because of the
unique nature of projects. This flexibility is affected
by the size and complexity of the project, its
timescale, its geographical location and the contract
terms and finance. Figure 2 illustrates the primary
forms of organization and how the authority
relationships change between them. BS 3375-1
gives further guidance on organization study.

© BSI 01-2000 9
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 3

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


Figure 2 — Authority relationships in organization structures

3.3 The matrix organization In multi-project situations this structure is


essential and, while it may solve many problems,
The problem of co-ordinating project activities does
some will remain; also some new problems are
not become serious until functional boundaries are
created, in particular that of dual reporting.
crossed or functional resources are overstretched. However firmly a functional specilist is disengaged
Until this happens it is not worth making changes to from a previous supervisor, some loyalty will remain
the organizational structure just to accommodate
and the supervisor can influence the functional
single projects with what is known to be a limited
specialist’s career. This can often lead to a dual
life. Once it becomes clear that projects will continue
reporting situation: one official and one unofficial.
to be carried out within the organization and that
If, for example, a functional specialist has an
there may be several running simultaneously, then unresolved technical disagreement with the project
a different situation arises and a change of manager, any appeal will need to be made through
organizational structure becomes essential. It also
to the senior manager who has authority over both
becomes necessary to set up a project management
the project and the functional specialist’s
function with its own functional group of project
supervisor. There should only be one reporting
specialists.
system for the project, that operated by the project
Furthermore, if required by many of the projects, team through the project manager.
dedicated functional specialists will be appointed as The changes in managerial behaviour required by
part of the group either by withdrawing them from
the move to a matrix structure are far-reaching,
the existing functional groups or by external
stretching to the board itself. To ensure that
recruitment. If they are obtained internally, which
different project teams and functional groups react
if at all possible they should be, then it is essential
in the same way to similar circumstances and that
that they be organizationally disengaged from their all have the same view or priorities, a strong
previous positions. Ideally the project group, like corporate culture should be developed. This is
any other functional group, should be physically
neither an easy nor rapid goal to achieve, but
located in its own area, the functional specialists
without it there may be inconsistent behaviour
will then still be able to refer to the functional
between project and functional groups with possible
supervisors, but only for functional technical
serious consequences. The project manager’s
problems. challenge is to motivate the staff, both those
seconded from the functions and others within the
matrix, to achieve the required performance in the
primary areas of quality, cost and timing of outputs.

10 © BSI 01-2000
Section 3 BS 6079-1:2000

Equally, it is essential that these factors are also The effective management of change involves
monitored by the functional manager. The developing an understanding of the current state,
management structure should allow differing views developing an image of the desired future state and
on objectives to be identified and resolved and moving the organization through the transition
should encourage peer group discussion on key period. As much care needs to be devoted to the
issues. In a matrix structure several managers may transition state as to the future state, both are
have authority over project work; the functional critical. The two basic issues to be addressed in
manager for “how” and “by whom”, and the project reorganization are what the change should be and
manager for “what” and at “what cost”. The how the change should be implemented.
responsibility remains with the project manager
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

3.5.2 Politics of organizational change


and much tact and patience may be needed from
senior management and project sponsors to make Political behaviour is a natural and expected feature
the matrix structure work properly. In particular, of organizations. In the transition state these forces
clear policies need to be established for the career become even more intense as the old regime is
paths of those seconded to the project teams, both on dismantled and the new regime takes its place. Any
long and short term appointments. significant change can upset or modify the balance
of power among various formal and informal
3.4 The project organization interest groups. The uncertainty caused by changes
can lead to ambiguity and increased political
The pure project form of organization is not activity as individuals try to protect their own
common, however it can be employed with interests.
advantage where projects are the normal business
of the organization. In this type of organization the 3.5.3 Psychology of organizational change
project team usually remains as a multidisciplinary Change in organizations involves the movement
unit and is moved from one project to the next as from something known towards something that is
each is completed. This has the disadvantage that unknown and this is usually unsettling for the
there may be a failure to develop functional individuals concerned. There is a need to recognize
specialists and general managers within the a psychological attachment to the former
organization which may result in some projects organization and time should be provided to
being starved of adequate specialists. This also disengage from the current state. Change can
means that the project manager and the project sometimes create a sense of loss and individuals
team may need to have a high degree of autonomy need to work through their detachment from the
from the host organization and that the project current state.
manager has to be given almost total authority for Those involved will be concerned that they will be
the project within the constraints of the host needed in the new organization, that their skills are
organization’s general policies and strategies. valued and that they will be able to cope with the
This form of organization has the distinct advantage new situation. This stress and anxiety can create
of being able to precisely define and control the performance problems and may lead individuals to
project budget, with different policies for different resist changes that they might otherwise support.
projects. It also reveals the cost of management Wherever possible, staff should be given
which is normally contained within the reassurance regarding their roles in the planned
organization’s overheads. reorganization.
A significant change in organization may disrupt
3.5 Criteria for reorganization the normal course of events within the organization.
3.5.1 General Such changes may also undermine existing systems
of management control and make procedures seem
Organizational changes involve transition from the irrelevant. Control is easy to lose during the
current state towards a future state. Experience has transition from one state to another. As goals,
shown that the time scale for transition from, for
structures and people shift, it becomes difficult to
example, a totally functional organization to a
monitor performance and make correct assumptions
matrix organization can take from three to five
that would otherwise be made during a stable
years in a large organization.
period.

© BSI 01-2000 11
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 3

3.5.4 Planning the transition 3.5.5 Managing the transition


The transition phase is characterized by great Most formal organizational arrangements are
uncertainty and control problems as the current designed either to manage the current or future
state is disassembled prior to full operation of the states and not the transition state. Problems
future state. Managers should co-ordinate the encountered in the transition state can relate to
transition with the same degree of care, the same questions of power, anxiety and control.
resources and the same skills as they manage any Transition implies changes in power with the
other project. The following summarizes the actions inherent need to shape and manage political
to be taken during the transition state: dynamics. To ensure success it is critical to:

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


a) develop and communicate a clear image of the a) motivate individuals through communications;
future state;
b) obtain the support of key groups;
b) construct a statement that identifies the
c) demonstrate leadership support of the change;
impact of the change on different parts of the
organization; d) communicate using symbols, language and
graphics and build in stability, reduce anxiety;
c) maintain a stable vision and avoid unnecessary
changes and conflicting views; e) allow time to prepare for change, send
consistent messages, build support and
d) communicate, including information on future
encourage participation.
decision making and operating procedures.
Managers and team leaders should serve as models,
These actions can be helped by the appointment of a
as through their behaviour they provide a vision of
transition (project) manager, allocation of specific
the future state and a source of identification for
resources for the transition, the use of a transition
various groups within the organization. They should
structured management system and a transition
articulate the vision of the future state and provide
plan. The progress of the transition should be
support through political influence and needed
monitored and evaluated, with feedback of results
resources. This can be achieved by creating
via an established communication channel to the
dissatisfaction with the current state, so that it is
stakeholders.
recognized that the current state is not perfect and
requires change to avoid unwanted economic and
business consequences. It should also be achieved by
motivating staff and recognizing that their
participation, although time-consuming, yields
benefits that can lead to improved decision making.
There is a need to communicate constantly in this
phase and to encourage feedback.

12 © BSI 01-2000
BS 6079-1:2000

Section 4. The project management process

4.1 General The project management process can be divided into


two parts, project planning and project control.
The project management process described in this
Project planning is the development of a workable
standard is different from the traditional line
project plan that describes project tasks in terms of
management process. Project management is a
“who does what”, “when”, “at what cost” and “to
universal process that is as applicable to the design what specification”. This integrated plan of the
and construction of a hydro-electric power station as project should be at a level of detail that the project
it is to the introduction of an information system for
manager considers necessary and sufficient to
a bank or the design of a public transport system.
enable effective and efficient project control. The
Characteristically, the project management process
second part of the process is to use the plan to
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

is designed to minimize the risk of failure in terms


control and co-ordinate the progress of the project.
of time, cost and product fitness for purpose.
There are further subordinate processes contained
This standard describes a generic project within both planning and control and, depending on
management process that makes no assumptions
the circumstances of the project in question, each
about the content, size, phase or organization of the
process will make a greater or lesser contribution.
project. The guidance given can therefore be applied
The project management process and its
to most projects, regardless of industry sector,
subordinate processes are shown in Figure 3.
phase, size, complexity or content. Project plans are
one of the critical outputs from the project The process of creating and using project plans is
management process and they are described in usually the responsibility of the project manager,
detail in 4.5. assisted and advised as necessary by the sponsor
and project team. Although the need to plan is
4.2 The project management process: usually most pressing at the beginning of a project,
introduction the plan should be regularly reviewed and updated
as necessary during the project life cycle. It should
Projects do not succeed just by assiduous adherence be noted that the more planning done before
to a mechanical process. The successful project contractual obligations are established, the less risk
should be managed with enthusiasm, vision, there is of failing to meet those obligations.
single-mindedness and integrity. The project
manager should be able to generate these qualities 4.3 The project management process:
in the whole project team. It should be noted, planning
however, that no amount of misdirected enthusiasm
will avoid failure. The project management process 4.3.1 Obtain authorization to proceed from the
described here mitigates this risk. project sponsor
Project tasks exist at all levels within the project. A It is essential to apply for and obtain authorization
work breakdown structure helps to describe project from the sponsor or a board of management to
tasks in terms that are easily understood by all implement the project. Authorization may be given
those involved. At the top of the work breakdown by the project sponsor for the whole project, project
structure a single task can represent the complete phase or in stages for work up to specified
project while tasks at the base of the work milestones, at which point further authorization
breakdown structure may represent detailed work will usually be dependent upon satisfactory
undertaken by an individual (This concept is progress. Authorization starts the project
described later in this section). The project management process.
management process and project plan described
here can be applied at all levels of the work
breakdown structure. Thus, although the focus of
this section is the process and plan used by the
project team the guidelines for both process and
plan can be used at any level within the project.

© BSI 01-2000 13
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

4.3.2 Establish the project organization 4.3.2.2 Incentive mechanisms


Projects may evolve within organizations that Payment for goods and services is a critical part of
already have the structure necessary to support project management. Payment terms may often be
project work. Such organizations may be oriented defined by the contract and the project manager
exclusively towards projects or, more commonly, needs to be aware of the leverage that can be exerted
may adopt a matrix structure with the enterprise by terms that focus suppliers on delivery to time,
giving an equal and balanced emphasis to both the cost and performance parameters. Because projects
project team and the specialist functional are usually bound by strict timescales, the project
departments that undertake work for different team should be allowed adequate time to assess the

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


projects. A well designed and managed matrix quality of purchases before payment is authorized.
structure should have the advantage of generating It is essential, however, that suppliers are paid
creative tensions between the project and functional promptly and strictly within the timescales stated
disciplines. Functions usually demand clear and in the purchase order.
unambiguous statements of requirement from the Incentive, or premium payments, designed to
project team and project teams usually demand a accelerate critical activities that have a direct effect
positive commitment from the functions to on overall project timescales, can offer both supplier
timescales, costs and performance. Sub-contractors and project manager mutual benefits. Penalties for
may be treated in the same way as an in-house late delivery, cost overrun or failure to meet
function except that relationships between the specification should also be used where appropriate
sub-contractor and the project manager will usually to focus supplier efforts on project goals. The project
be subject to formal contract. manager may also seek the right to retain payment
Alternatively, the project may have emerged as a until a period has elapsed during which time the
separate entity without the support of an existing goods and services being purchased can be assessed
organizational structure. This is the case, for for fitness for purpose. The purchaser and supplier
example, when a consultancy undertakes a project need to have a clear understanding of incentive
for a customer and where the work is done by third mechanisms, which should be reflected in the
party agencies. contract. More guidance on procurement functions
The project manager needs to establish mutual is given in 4.6.4.
accountability between the sponsor, suppliers, task 4.3.2.3 Communication framework
owners and the project team and, if necessary, Success or failure of a project tends to depend on
written terms of reference. The following how well various members of the project team
organizational factors should be defined.
communicate with each other. It is essential for the
4.3.2.1 Limits of authority project manager to implement an effective
The project manager needs to clearly understand communication network designed to enable all
the limits of authority for any action that is relevant parties to report progress, express concerns
initiated, for example, financial limits may be and discuss how to achieve the project objectives.
imposed by the sponsor. Some organizations may The project manager needs to identify a structure
prescribe lists of approved suppliers that limit the and schedule of meetings, each with their own terms
freedom of choice of subcontractor. The project of reference, list of attendees and agendas.
manager may also be constrained in the action that All project management team members should
may be taken against defaulting suppliers. In order recognize that effective communication is a two-way
to operate effectively, the project manager needs to process and that suppliers need to be encouraged to
understand clearly how the freedom to act is raise concerns at the earliest opportunity, rather
constrained. Such limits should be stated in writing than waiting until a problem has matured into an
and form part of the project plan. intractable hazard. The project manager should
promote an open forum for the discussion of issues.
Suppliers and task owners should not feel so
intimidated that they are prevented from discussing
bad news or raising doubts about their ability to
achieve specific objectives. More guidance on project
organization is given in section 3.

14 © BSI 01-2000
15 Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI
© BSI 01-2000

Figure 3 — Project management process flow

BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

4.3.3 Development of a Project Work The techniques described in 4.3.3.1 to 4.3.3.6 should
Breakdown Structure (WBS) be used when developing a work breakdown
Once a project organization has been established, structure.
the project planning process should continue with 4.3.3.1 Task decomposition
the project manager providing suppliers with a The project deliverables need to be split into
summary statement of requirements so that each manageable units of work to generate an
supplier can identify the tasks that need to be done. hierarchical structure of tasks where any one task is
Figure 4 shows how a project can be broken down a child of a parent task that is higher in the
into individual tasks; although the example given is structure and also the parent of one or more child

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


a specific product-based WBS (a contract to supply tasks lower in the structure. An existing WBS can
gas turbines), the principle is applicable equally to be helpful in identifying tasks for new projects,
any type of project. where similar work has been done in the past.
The product-based WBS is the commonest and most
useful form; however, there are several other ways
in which a project can be broken down, such as by
activities or by cost elements.

Figure 4 — Model work breakdown structure

16 © BSI 01-2000
Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

4.3.3.2 Task identification The structured decomposition of tasks in the WBS


Task identification should begin by broadly defining should offer the project manager many
tasks outlined in the statement of requirements and opportunities to assess parent-children task
then expanding to a level of detail necessary and relationships using principles of conservation. For
sufficient for inclusion in the project plan. At each example, is some element of the product defined in
iteration the estimated workload and costs need to the parent task lost in the definition of child tasks?
be refined as necessary. It is essential that If so, then a child task corresponding to the missing
estimates, if not originated by the task owner, are element needs to be added to the WBS. New task
sanctioned by the task owner. The project manager material appearing in a child task also needs to be
explained in terms of its parent task.
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

should not accept an estimate for a task from a third


party who is not responsible for the task. The project 4.3.3.6 Relating tasks to the project
manager should gauge the acceptability of each organization
estimate by comparison with past performance and
this may only be possible if previous work has been There is considerable benefit in relating individual
structured in a similar way. lowest level child tasks to specific organization
elements, such that the child task is at the
4.3.3.3 Task levels intersection of a product-based project WBS and an
The single, top level task of the project WBS will be organizational breakdown structure. This
the project as a whole. Lower levels within the relationship enables a responsibility assignment
project WBS should describe tasks that, when added matrix to be developed that has lowest level child
together, comprise tasks appearing at higher levels. tasks along one axis and organizational breakdown
This hierarchy of tasks should enable task-related structure elements along the other. The name of a
information to be summarized and audited to task owner in a cell within the responsibility
various levels of detail and should also permit assignment matrix should show task accountability.
exception thresholds and summary reporting The work breakdown structure can be
requirements to be applied at whatever level the product-based, cost-centre-based, task-based and/or
project manager decides is appropriate. function-based, but product-based is preferred.
An additional benefit of using a project WBS is that 4.3.4 Analyse the project tasks
it provides a structured definition of tasks that can
be reused for future projects. It can also be used to 4.3.4.1 Level of task decomposition
record trends in supplier and task owner estimates A workable compromise between the extremes of
and actual performance for similar tasks in insufficient or excessive levels to work breakdown
different projects. structure needs to be achieved. The project manager
4.3.3.4 Level of detail should determine whether or not a task has been
defined at an adequate level and ultimately this
The project manager and project team need to be decision will be governed by experience, intuition
skilled in assessing the “depth” of the project WBS and circumstances.
required. For example, if a project WBS is too
shallow there will be a risk that tasks are not 4.3.4.2 Single accountability
defined to an adequate level of detail. Conversely, if Each of the lowest level tasks should have a single
the project WBS delves too deeply into the task owner who is accountable to the project manager for
structure there is a risk that the project will be the successful achievement of the task. If a task is
over-managed and the plan will become shared by two owners then it should be split until
over-sensitive to change. unique accountability for the major part of the task
4.3.3.5 Validation of the task structure can be clearly identified. One person may be the
owner of several tasks.
A useful rule that the project manager needs to
apply to any task that is put forward for inclusion in 4.3.4.3 Performance measurement capability
the project WBS is to test whether it contributes to Each task should contain within its definition the
the deliverables of the parent task. If it does then means to measure the performance of the task
the task is valid and should be included; if not, then owner. Performance of tasks with extended
the project manager should find out why the task is durations and few discrete deliverables can be
needed. difficult to assess. Ideally tasks should be defined at
a level where objective measures of performance can
be applied. Thus short tasks, or long tasks with
regular deliverables, should provide an adequate
basis for measuring performance.

© BSI 01-2000 17
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

4.3.4.4 Cost element 4.3.5 Assign a single accountable task owner to


The total costs of each task should be expressed in project tasks
terms of their separate elements, for example in The identification of a task owner for each child task
labour or purchases. It is often useful to decompose is an important step in developing a project plan. If
a task according to its cost elements. a single task owner cannot be identified then the
4.3.4.5 Criticality project manager may not be able to manage the
task. The task owner may be a member of the
It should be possible to describe the task as either project team, an individual appointed by a supplier
critical or non-critical. This means that task or subcontractor for liaising with the prime

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


interdependence needs to be understood accurately. contractor or a manager who has resources that
If a critical activity exists within a task then that could be used to achieve the task objectives. The
activity may need to be broken out as a separate project manager should be aware that blind
task. application of the “single accountable task owner”
4.3.4.6 Earned value type rule could lead to an unmanageable number of
The method of calculating earned value or tasks, each allocated to the individual doing the
performance should be the same for all work task. Sensible application of this guideline
contained in the task. The earned value method is recognises that reliable accountability normally
described in 4.6.6. If performance for part of the exists some way above the individual task doer. The
task is calculated on the basis of the discrete process of identifying the task owner is subtle but
deliverables achieved and another part is calculated vital and depends on how the word “accountable” is
on the basis of percentage of planned costs then the interpreted. In this case the accountable task owner
task should be split to separate the two types of should have a duty to the project manager for the
work. This should clarify the means of performance successful achievement of the task. This also
measurement. implies that the project manager has a veto over the
appointment of task owners and may, in certain
4.3.4.7 Supplier performance reliability circumstances, exercise the right to disqualify a
The level of detail to which the plan is defined will task owner whose performance is unacceptable.
be influenced by the reliability of the supplier. In a matrix organization where project groups
Tasks assigned to proven suppliers may be defined procure goods and services from various functions, a
in less detail than tasks assigned to unproven new distinction between task owner and functional
suppliers. The project manager should ensure that manager needs to be made. Often a relatively junior
the plan is set at a level that gives confidence and worker may be a task owner and have an
reassurance that the supplier will deliver in accountability to the project manager for achieving
accordance with time, cost and performance the objectives of the project work, while at the same
parameters. Reliable suppliers and task owners time reporting to a functional manager for the
should require less supervision, thus allowing the professional standards of the work. It is vital for the
project manager to concentrate effort on eliminating project manager to identify the task owner at the
risks elsewhere. level within the functional organization where the
4.3.4.8 Task risk task owner is best able to be accountable for project
work. Seniority does not always make for an
The ultimate criterion that the project manager
effective project task owner.
needs to use to assess whether or not the project
WBS is defined at an acceptable level of detail is the Although ideally the task owner should be in direct
degree of risk associated with any task. If there is control of all the resources needed to execute the
significant risk identified with the task the project task, this is rarely possible. A task owner who needs
manager may wish to decompose the task still to subcontract to fulfil the task requirement may be
further in order to isolate the risk and prepare acceptable to the project manager provided the
mitigation plans. subcontracted element of the task is a minor part of
the whole task. In this case the project manager
needs the ability to audit the trail of accountability
through the task doer to the subcontractor.

18 © BSI 01-2000
Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

4.3.6 Develop a statement of work (SOW) for The code for any task should correspond to the code
project tasks assigned to that task in the project WBS defined in
4.3.6.1 General the WBS section of the project plan. A parent-child
relationship between tasks is implied in the WBS
Each task should be defined by its SOW, which for code, for example task 1.1.1 is a subtask of task 1.1.
parent tasks need not be more than a summary of
the work defined in the child tasks. The SOW may 4.3.6.3 Summary description of task
contain a qualitative assessment of risk associated The SOW should contain a high level description of
with the task and should also define how and when the work content for the task. The definitive
to issue progress and exception reports and how detailed specification of the task requirements, for
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

performance is to be measured. The SOW may not example, a colour scheme for the internal decoration
emerge as a result of the task owner’s initial of a building, should normally be given in reference
response to the project manager’s statement of documents that may be quoted in the contract. Such
requirement. Useful SOWs, that remain relatively specifications need not be detailed in the project
stable throughout the project life cycle, usually plan. A summary description should be sufficient to
result from several iterations between task owner orient the reader and inform the project manager
and project manager. This iterative process should and task owner of the substance of the task and
improve the quality of both the project manager’s point to any supporting reference documents that
understanding of the task owner’s needs and the give the full information.
task owner’s understanding of the project manager’s 4.3.6.4 Named accountable task owner
requirements.
The SOW should identify the task owner, who is
Bypassing this step in the planning process poses a ultimately accountable to the project manager for
high risk of cost overruns, late deliveries and
the successful achievement of the task, by name.
contract changes. The primary elements of a SOW
Successful achievement needs to be measured in
are as follows and are further described in 4.3.6.2
terms of cost, performance and timely delivery of all
to 4.3.6.12:
deliverables and the satisfactory performance of all
a) a task reference code; reporting requirements. The task owner should
b) a summary description of the requirement; estimate the time and cost of the task and register
c) the name of the person accountable for agreement by signing the “commitment acceptance”
completion of the task; section of the project plan.
d) a list of key deliverables; 4.3.6.5 Key deliveries and milestones
e) timescales for the deliverables; The SOW should contain a list of the key
deliverables and the dates by which the task owner
f) a schedule of task dependencies and subsidiary
has committed to deliver them to the project
tasks;
manager through the life of the task. These
g) a schedule of costs by cost element; deliverables and the task cost schedule should be
h) an assessment of risks associated with the used for performance measurement. Deliverables
task; need to be defined in order to provide the sponsor
i) performance measurement and task completion and project manager with a means of measuring
criteria; performance, and should, for example, include the
start and finish of each subtask within the task and
j) a description of the work content of the task;
any relevant milestones. The SOW should also
k) reporting requirements. record the acceptance criteria to be applied to each
4.3.6.2 Task reference code deliverable.
Each task should be assigned a unique reference 4.3.6.6 Timescales for deliverables
code; this is an essential and efficient way of The start and finish dates and duration of the task
summarising project information and can also be should be recorded in the project plan. It may be
used within monitoring, reporting, accounting and beneficial to record earliest and latest start and
configuration management systems. For large finish dates for the task and to note whether or not
projects, WBS dictionaries of task definitions may the task is on or near to the critical path (see 4.5.6).
be compiled where the task code provides a unique This information needs to be consistent with dates
reference key. Task reference codes can provide a in the schedule section of the project plan. Where
logical shorthand description of tasks that should the risk assessment indicates that there is a
instantly convey the relative position of the task in significant risk then a three point duration
the overall project WBS. More information on (best-worst-most likely assessment) should be
configuration management is given in 4.6.2. included.

© BSI 01-2000 19
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

4.3.6.7 Task dependencies c) impact on costs


Tasks rarely exist in isolation. The project plan (catastrophic/critical/marginal/negligible);
should record those tasks and people on which the d) impact on delivery
current task depends (predecessors) and those tasks (catastrophic/critical/marginal/negligible).
and people (successors) that depend, in turn, on the More guidance on risk management is given
current task. The type of dependency should be in 4.6.3.
recorded, for example, “finish-to-start”, where the
4.3.6.10 Performance measurement and task
successor task cannot begin until the predecessor
completion criteria
task has finished. This should enable a network of

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


inter-related tasks to be constructed that can be The most important factor when selecting how to
used to support analysis of the complete project measure performance is to use the best objective
plan. (Most project planning tools use task start measure possible. A list of a combination of cost,
dates, durations and dependencies to calculate how schedule and deliverables should provide a robust
much additional time is available, also known as basis for measuring performance. Earned value or
float, before the task becomes critical, i.e., zero budgeted cost of work performed can be calculated
additional time available. using this combination (see 4.6.6).
4.3.6.8 Schedule of costs by cost elements If the task deliverables list provides for an even
distribution of deliverables throughout the project
The planning activity should establish a schedule of
and the task expenditure profile has been compiled
costs for the task that differentiates between
in line with the deliverables schedule, then these
different cost elements. The effect of changing cost
two data should form the basis for sound earned
rates needs to be isolated and understood by the
value calculation. Where no deliverables are
project manager. The SOW may contain a phased scheduled during a relatively long period of task
profile of expected costs for each task, with activity, then the project manager may impose a
contributions from different cost elements identified
subjective method for estimating earned value. For
separately. The integrity of this information is
example, earned value may be credited on the basis
fundamental to the success of the project and time
of 50 % of the planned cost at the start of the task
spent at the planning stage in identifying the key
and 50 % of the planned cost at completion. More
factors that influence costs is essential. guidance regarding performance measurement is
An expenditure profile, showing the phased budget given in 4.6.6.
for the task over the relevant timescale, should be
4.3.6.11 Detailed description of task work
stated. In order to support earned value
content
calculations, this profile should include increments
of planned expenditure corresponding to each The SOW should contain unambiguous information
deliverable defined in the SOW. The expenditure that describes in adequate detail the work content of
profile should also show the current limits of the task. Where possible, reference should be made
authorized expenditure in terms of value and time, to supporting documents and contracts in order to
together with a risk assessment where necessary. avoid duplication and possible corruption of
information. Where work definitions are contained
4.3.6.9 Assessment of risks
in reference documents, then these documents need
The SOW should record the results of qualitative to be subject to the same management disciplines as
and quantitative risk assessment for the task where the project plan.
appropriate. Qualitative risk assessment should be
based on identifying certain events with which risk
is associated and then describing the risk.
Quantification of each risk should be shown where
appropriate and may be stated simply as the best,
worst and most likely distribution in terms of cost,
timescale and specification. The impact on delivery
to specification is a technical statement of risk and
needs to be translated into a cost and timescale
effect before the project manager can process the
information for project management purposes.
The impact of a risk may be graded as follows:
a) likelihood of occurrence (high/medium/low);
b) impact on timescales
(catastrophic/critical/marginal/negligible);

20 © BSI 01-2000
21 Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI
© BSI 01-2000

Figure 5 — Model bar chart

BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

4.3.6.12 Reporting requirements 4.3.7 Balance time, cost, integrity of


The SOW should define what reports are needed specification and risk
and at what frequency to meet the requirements of The project manager needs to continuously balance
the sponsor, contractual obligations and the level of timescales against cost and risk, without
information that the project manager decides is undermining the performance of the project. The
necessary to control the work. In general terms the SOW will be further developed and refined during
task owner should be made responsible for the project planning process, usually revealing more
informing the project manager of any changes to the information concerning task costs, timescales and
information contained in the SOW, for example, risks. The project manager should analyze this

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


changes to risk assessments. The following specific information and understand the overall project cost
aspects of reporting should be addressed. profile, schedule and where the risks lie. This
a) Performance status: The task owner should information can be integrated into a cumulative
report the actual or forecast date of achievement probability distribution for cost and time for the
for the deliverables defined for the task. The whole project, where the uncertainty has been
method by which the task owner calculates and calculated by random sampling from the individual
reports the earned value for the work completed probability distributions for those tasks where risk
to date may be defined by the project manager. has been identified. This task may be mechanized
and is usually based on the best current version of
b) Schedule status: The task owner may be
the project task network.
required to report the estimated time of
completion for each task. This information should The project manager should compare data
be consistent with the status of deliverables contained in the SOW with previous data for similar
progress. Forecast start or finish dates which are work and, where differences are found, investigate
later than the most recent planned start or finish the causes with the task owner. This should reduce
dates should be shown separately, as any the risk of inaccurate forecasting. New information
slippage in these dates may affect the project is likely to perturb whatever fragile balance
completion date. between time, cost, performance and risk the project
manager has managed to construct. The critical
c) Cost status: The task owner should report the
path, at least during the preliminary project
actual expenditure and committed expenditure to
planning, may wander from task to task with
date for each task. The task owner should also
disconcerting ease and unpredictability.
report the estimated cost at completion for each
task. The project manager can often buy time with money
or save money by tightening timescales, but needs to
d) Status of quality progress: The task owner
be mindful of the objective to reduce the risk of
should report any change that might affect the
failure and maximize the chance of success. The
form, fit or function of the task deliverables.
project manager should gauge where a task needs
e) Risk exposure system: The task owner should more time and seek to lengthen the time available
report any changes in the status of identified by shortening other tasks. Alternatively some tasks
threats to the achievement of tasks, together with may be allowed to take longer and any resulting
any newly identified threats or opportunities. cash savings then used to shorten tasks that lie on
f) Exception thresholds and variance reporting: the critical path. This process is sometimes referred
The rules for triggering exception reports should to as “crashing” which involves the project manager
be based on margins applied to the forecast time in experimenting with the available options.
or cost at completion, or actual time and cost Significant results from such experiments need to
status and derived earned value statistics. An be recorded systematically, not only to form part of
exception report may contain a statement of the the project manager’s historical records for use in
actual or forecast exception, a description of the future projects, but also to justify actions and enable
planned recovery action and an estimate of the informed decision-making during the project life
threat to the project plan in terms of the time, cycle.
cost and performance.

22 © BSI 01-2000
Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

At this stage in the process the project manager may 4.3.8.2 Identify resources required
benefit from using a bar chart representation of The task owner needs to understand what resources
project tasks (see Figure 5). The chart should are required to perform the task and at what levels
present tasks as horizontal bars against a of efficiency, before making a commitment.
horizontal time axis. Its main use is as a graphical Resources may be in-house labour or goods and
method of showing both the current state of the plan services procured from an external source.
and, once the project has started, progress across all (Procurement is covered in 4.6.4.) Resource
tasks simultaneously. The bar chart has great management is a related, but separate, discipline to
visual power. A large format project bar chart may project management and the project manager need
be used to focus project review meetings on certain
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

not understand the nature of the resource required


issues and, more generally, as the medium for to undertake a task, only how the application of this
recording issues and comments that occur during resource translates into time, money, performance
the day-to-day running of the project. and risk. This separation of duties might appear
4.3.8 Obtain commitments to do project tasks unnecessary, but the task owner should be allowed
4.3.8.1 General the freedom to apply whatever resource is
appropriate to the task, providing the timing, cost
Each task owner needs to formally agree to the and performance of the project deliverables are not
appropriate tasks by signing the commitment jeopardised.
section of the project plan. The task owner’s
commitment should signal that the assigned work 4.3.8.3 Identify available resources
can be completed as defined in the plan. If the task It is the responsibility of the task owner to
owner has objections to the plan, changes should be understand the availability of resource needed to
negotiated with the project manager. If a complete the task as described in the SOW.
compromise cannot be reached, it may be necessary Resource is often not dedicated to specific projects
to obtain the task owner’s commitment, subject to and, in these circumstances, the task owner has to
caveats in written form, agreed with the project know what competing demands there are for the
manager. The process up to this point is likely to resource, when they will be made and with what
require several iterations between project manager priority.
and task owner. Commitment may be qualified by 4.3.8.4 Balance load with capacity
an expiry date beyond which the task owner
reserves the right to withdraw a commitment that Understanding the resource demand profile based
has not been formally accepted. On reaching the on all sources of demand is the responsibility of the
expiry date, the task owner may provide a revised task owner. Time and cost estimates should be given
offer of commitment with a new expiry date. Any to the project manager when the task owner is
work delegated by the task owner needs to be satisfied that there are sufficient resources to
supported by commitment obtained from the satisfy the demands of the project.
organization, individual or subcontractor 4.3.8.5 Reserve and allocate resource
undertaking the work. The trail of commitment In the latter stages of this iterative process the SOW
acceptance to the project from the ultimate task becomes progressively firmer until the point is
owner needs to be visible to, and auditable by the reached when the project manager accepts the offer
project manager. from the task owner and asks for resources to be
Final agreement between project manager and task reserved pending a formal instruction to start work.
owner should be based on the particular issue of the When the instruction to start is given, the task
project plan that defines the contract work. This is owner has a duty to allocate the resource.
necessary for obtaining a firm commitment to any
changes to the plan that are identified during
negotiation. The form of these negotiations will
depend on the legal relationship between project
manager and task owner and the agreement is often
in the form of a legally binding contract. The project
manager may need to select one or more bids from
several competing suppliers at this point in the
process and in the event of a contest should disclose
the selection criteria. The project manager should
be aware of the legal obligations relating to supplier
selection and the need for the selection process to be
non-discriminatory.

© BSI 01-2000 23
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

4.3.9 Finalize agreements 4.4 The project management process:


The iterative process of project planning is itself a control
task that is constrained by time and money. The 4.4.1 Control the project plan
project manager should be given enough time to
plan the project to the necessary level of detail, All projects are subject to change and their success
bearing in mind that project plans that are too depends on how well they are planned in the first
detailed will be too sensitive to change and may instance and how well changes are managed. The
require continuous formal change procedures project manager should ensure that changes to
during the project life cycle. When the project project objectives and consequent changes to task

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


manager is satisfied that the plan represents the SOWs are communicated unambiguously and are
best chance of satisfying the sponsor’s requirement reflected in the current version of the plan. All
the agreements between project manager and task changes need to be agreed by the project manager
owners can be formalized. The degree of formality and the task owners concerned and this agreement
may vary depending on the nature of the agreement should be registered in the project plan. Essential
and the organization in which the work is being changes should be implemented at the earliest
managed. opportunity to minimize the impact on time, cost
and specification.
Agreement signals that the project manager accepts
offers from the task owners to do work as defined in The project manager is responsible for the integrity
the plan. Agreement should also signify a bilateral of the project plan and should ensure that all
agreement between the project manager and each changes to the project plan are controlled. Such
task owner. This may take the form of several, changes may be requested by the customer, sponsor
separate contracts. Thus the task owner commits or task owner. The planning process outlined in 4.3
the resources as planned and the project manager should be followed as rigorously for a change to an
commits to release project funding, conditional upon existing plan as for a new plan. It is essential that
successful completion of deliverables if necessary in the project manager ensures that the current
agreed stages. A schedule of funding release dates, version of the project plan reflects the current
corresponding to phased increases in limits of contractual requirements in terms of time, cost,
liability, should be described in one of the performance and specification. The following
statements of work under the “manage project” guidelines should be used to manage changes to the
branch of the WBS. Work can then be released. plan effectively and efficiently.
The project manager should be authorized by the a) The project manager should be responsible for
sponsor to agree to plans within the constraints the control of the project plan and needs to
specified. If the plan falls outside these constraints authorize any changes.
then the project manager needs either to change the b) Issue of a revised, agreed project plan should
plan in order to conform to the constraints or refer automatically cancel all previous issues.
the issue to the sponsor. If the project manager is c) Each issue of the project plan should be
unable to accept any stated hazard or risk allocated a unique sequential revision code so
associated with any tasks in the plan, the that previous plans can be easily identified and
appropriate task owner should re-plan such tasks so replaced with the latest version.
as to eliminate the hazard and to recommit to the
d) The reasons for changes to the project plan
revised work prior to agreement. If the risks remain
should be fully documented and a cross-reference
unavoidable and unacceptable to the project
made to the revision codes. A complete history of
manager then the project manager may seek an
such changes should be retained by the project
alternative task owner or refer the issue to the
manager.
project sponsor. Ultimately, the sponsor may decide
to abandon the initiative. e) Work should not be released from a draft
project plan.
f) No one item of work should be put in more than
one project plan.

24 © BSI 01-2000
Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

g) Where a change to a project plan is minor and The task owner is responsible for ensuring that the
can be contained within the existing costs incurred in performing work for the project are
commitments of task owners, then the project attributable to the correct task in the project WBS
plan can be amended without re-issue. Details of and should ensure that all costs attributed to the
the amendment may then be given to all project project can be audited. Task owners should be able
plan holders by the project manager. Guidelines to give the project manager a clear statement of
for deciding whether a change constitutes an those irrevocable costs for which the project would
amendment or a re-issue should be documented. be liable if it was to be terminated. This needs to
h) The project manager, in consultation with a include, but not be limited to, the sum of all
legal advisor if necessary, should be responsible committed costs, If a legal relationship exists
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

for ensuring that the revised project plan does not between the project manager and the task owner,
jeopardize any contractual obligations. for example, where there is a formal contract in
place governing the sale of goods and services by the
4.4.2 Manage the project budget task owner to the project, it will be necessary to
4.4.2.1 Set annual budgets state contractually how the project and the task
Organizations usually budget annually and, owner should allocate the costs if work is terminated
because projects may span several years, the project prematurely. This requirement is usually only
manager should ensure that budgets reflect the necessary when the services of third party suppliers
funding and cash flow requirements of project work are employed. Guidance on procurement functions
in ensuing years. If this step is not followed, project is given in 4.6.4.
funding may evaporate or adversely affect the 4.4.3 Instruct work to begin, continue or stop
budgets of other parts of the organization. More The structured nature of the tasks contained in the
guidance on financial control techniques is given plan should permit the project manager to control
in 4.6.5. the project by releasing or stopping work in terms of
4.4.2.2 Release project funds and retain any permutation of task or part of a task. Critical
management reserve project reviews may be required at specified
Funds need to be released to the task owners so that milestones throughout long lead time projects, in
project work may start and the project manager order to give the sponsor and project manager the
should also make allowance for unexpected opportunity to review progress and decide whether
problems or small changes in plan by retaining some to continue or curtail work. The means used by the
of the project budget as a management reserve project manager to start, continue or stop work need
(MR). Determining the correct level of this reserve to be clear and unambiguous in terms of the amount
can be a key to the success of the project and the of money released, the nature of the goods and
reputation of the project manager. An inadequate services requested and the individual for whom the
management reserve may put the whole project at money is intended. This process is helped by having
risk when problems arise. Conversely, if the a realistic plan and clear SOW.
management reserve is too large the task owners Usually the project manager is responsible for
whose budgets have been used to provide MR may formal termination of the project. This action should
use lack of adequate funding as an excuse for late follow formal acceptance of the final project
delivery and poor quality of deliverables. deliverables by the sponsor, achievement of all the
Project funds may be applied according to the risks project completion criteria and settlement of
associated with the work. Where significant risks outstanding debts.
have been identified, maximum levels of 4.4.4 Monitor progress
expenditure for the task may be specified. Limits to The monitoring and analysis of project data should
the levels of both committed and actual expenditure enable the project manager to address problems at
should be identified for tasks that are to be released an early stage and take advantage of opportunities
in stages. that might benefit the project. Time is a vital and
Budget logs, with cross references made to the tasks non-recoverable asset, the aim should always be to
in the project plan, should be used to record all pre-empt situations rather than to respond to
transfers of project funds. The project manager may problems after they have assumed unmanageable
keep logs for planned profit, total expenditure, proportions.
management reserve and all task budgets.

© BSI 01-2000 25
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

Good communications between project manager and c) Earned value: The task owner should report
task owner are essential. If communication links are performance to plan regularly. Earned value
weak then problems can escalate, no matter how measurement is one of the available methods of
much information is available. Effective monitoring reporting performance and it can be used to
and analysis should help the project manager and calculate cost and schedule variances that may in
task owners to understand the status of the whole turn be used to calculate performance indices and
project, the effect of their performance on the project objective projections of cost, time or some other
objectives and any risks that lie ahead. measurable value such as labour hours or
The task owner should fulfil the regular reporting materials usage, at completion. More information

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


requirements contained in the project plan and on the earned value method is given in 4.6.6.
submit written exception reports to the project 4.4.5 Manage the project
manager if the progress of work deviates
The project manager is responsible for co-ordinating
significantly from plan. Exception reports should
reports submitted by task owners and for analyzing
not only explain the reasons for exceeding or failing
the information provided. The project manager
to achieve performance thresholds, but also describe
should ensure that, when appropriate, visual aids
how the situation can be recovered. such as a consolidated bar chart for the plan, are
The task owner is accountable to the project kept up to date. The relevant task owners should be
manager for the completion of committed tasks to kept informed of changes to the critical path for the
time, cost and specification and should warn the contract and the estimated cost and time at
project manager of any operational issues that affect completion for all permutations of tasks in the plan.
the work of other task owners. The task owner Task owners may not always be aware of, or
should ensure that SOW data are kept up to date, disclose, potential risks and in such circumstances
inform the project manager of tasks in danger of the project manager may be forced to make a
becoming critical and provide a revised risk personal assessment of risks. The overall pattern of
assessment for the task. Similarly, the project risk for the project needs to be analyzed continually
manager is responsible for keeping task owners to decide where to concentrate management effort to
briefed on the current state of the whole project. best effect.
Specific project monitoring reports may be required The project manager is responsible for reporting to
and the vital basic elements of information that all task owners any hazards that are identified through
projects require are as follows.
analysis of the plan and for ensuring that the task
a) Actual costs reported against planned cost and owner has appropriate recovery plans in place. The
variances: These should be identified and project manager should also co-ordinate all project
compared to variance thresholds imposed by the reports for the sponsor in accordance with the
project manager. If a threshold is breached then requirements of the plan.
the task owner should provide reasons for the The project manager may record statistical data on
variance and submit a recovery plan stating the task owner performance and overall project
impact on cost, time and specification. The
performance in terms of costs, timing and the
impact of current actual cost on project cash flow
quality of deliverables. This information may be
should be of specific concern to the project
used to validate future estimates from task owners
manager. This will either ease or increase the
for new project work.
financial burden of the project.
The project manager should be responsible for the
b) Time and cost at completion: The task owner security of the project plan. This will require control
should provide a regular estimate of the time and
of the distribution of the plan. Each holder of the
cost at completion for each task. Although it is
project plan should understand and comply with the
possible for the project manager to extrapolate
rules of disclosure governing the plan. The rules
existing data to provide such an estimate, the
may be dictated by either commercial sensitivity,
task owner should also be given an opportunity to national security or professional confidentiality
record a subjective view. Reconciling differences requirements. Where appropriate the plan should
between the project manager’s estimate based on
be clearly marked to indicate its security level, for
actual data and the task owner’s opinion should
example “personal and confidential”, “restricted”,
provide a useful insight into real and perceived
“private data” etc.
progress.

26 © BSI 01-2000
Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

4.4.6 Assess risks 4.4.9 Negotiate


The risk of success or failure should be assessed A project manager succeeds or fails depending on an
continuously by means of cost and time estimates of ability to negotiate effectively. It is essential to
the interdependent network of tasks that make up recognize two phases to negotiation: pre-contract
the project. The overall project risk factor can be and post-contract. The project manager needs to be
analyzed by simulating project progress, in a series aware that concessions or changes made during the
of tests, using random sampling from the pre-contract stage will be cheaper and easier to seek
best-worst-most likely time and cost distributions than when the project is in full operation. Once the
for each task and calculating where the critical path project has started, the pressure on the project
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

most often lies. This will produce cumulative cost manager to complete to time and cost is continuous
and time distributions around the planned project and task owners may be tempted to exploit their
cost and finish date. It can also produce a list of all position by seeking additional money in order to
project tasks ranked in order of the likelihood that keep the project on schedule. It is imperative that
each task will be on the critical path. Thus a task the project manager ensures that the scope of work
with a 95 % chance of being critical should warrant in each task is properly defined at the outset, that
more attention than a task with only a 5 % chance of risks are spread rather than concentrated and that
being critical. More guidance is given in 4.6.3. there is little opportunity for task owners to hold the
4.4.7 Manage risks project manager to ransom. The task owner will
naturally be seeking to exploit the position and
As a result of monitoring and analyzing risks, the profit from the project work. A project manager
project manager should be able to identify those should be capable of convincing task owners that
tasks where an alternative course of action is they too are stakeholders in the success of the
needed to mitigate the risk. Using the project plan project and that meeting the objectives of the project
the project manager can experiment with various subsumes their personal objectives.
alternative risk avoidance tactics and select those
actions that best contain or avoid the risk. The 4.5 The project plan
project manager may need to obtain the support of
the project sponsor to follow two parallel courses of 4.5.1 General
action in order to manage an otherwise unavoidable There may be variation in content, style and volume
risk. between one project plan and another, due to variety
The project manager needs to gain the support of in the work and in the circumstances in which the
task owners when deciding a new course of action. project is to be executed. The key contents of a
The negotiation is likely to follow the steps in the project plan are described in 4.5.2 to 4.5.7.
planning process until agreement is reached, when 4.5.2 Project plan sections
a revised project plan may be issued.
A basic project plan should contain the following
4.4.8 Motivate task owners sections:
Projects should, by their nature, be directed towards a) introduction and summary;
achieving a definite end result. As a consequence, b) commitment acceptance;
project managers should have very little trouble
focusing task owners on project objectives. Prudent c) project Work Breakdown Structure (WBS);
application of the management reserve should d) schedule;
enable the project manager to retain some project e) Statement of Work (SOW).
funding for bonus payments and, providing these A sophisticated project plan, for example, for a
are part of the agreement between the project major engineering development project may contain
manager and the task owner, there is scope for good the elements shown in Table 1.
performance to be rewarded. This is a powerful
motivating force. Good communication between the 4.5.3 Introduction and summary
project manager and task owners is an equally This section of the project plan summarizes the
powerful motivating force. A well-informed project essential elements of the project and makes
team will usually perform better than one where reference to any information that may affect how
information is rationed. tasks should be performed and managed. This
preliminary part of the project plan should include
the following information, not necessarily in the
order given:
a) project name, reference code, issue number and
date of issue;

© BSI 01-2000 27
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

b) project plan contents; 4.5.5 Project work breakdown structure and


c) name of sponsor; WBS dictionary
d) summary of the project objectives and the This is an hierarchical description of the tasks in the
means planned to achieve them; project plan. A project WBS should enable members
e) summary of the project completion criteria and of the project team to define their tasks at a
how the sponsor decides whether or not the meaningful level of detail. The use of a graphical
project WBS should reduce the possibility of
project has succeeded in achieving its objectives;
overlooking essential elements of project work and,
f) a list of amendments to the project plan with a if past project information is available and
project WBS reference to the amendment, a short structured in a similar way, it allows direct

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


summary of the amendment including the comparison of past performance with current
reasons why the amendment was necessary and estimates.
the date of its incorporation;
The most detailed level of project work defined in
g) reference to mandates and injunctions the WBS should be that which is considered by the
governing the project, for example, policies, project manager to be necessary and sufficient for
standards, specifications, health, safety and the effective and efficient monitoring of deliverables
environmental issues; and control of costs such that the requirements of
h) reference to guidelines governing how various the sponsor are met. A project WBS dictionary, with
elements of project work should be performed, for a short summary description of each task recorded
example, project management, procurement against the task project WBS code, may also be
strategy, contract management, configuration included. A dictionary should provide a useful
and variation management, financial glossary of task definitions, as well as helping users
management, quality assurance, reliability to locate specific tasks swiftly.
management and the project organization, 4.5.6 Schedule of work
including the project team and task owners;
The schedule of work required to satisfy the contract
i) a document circulation and contacts list;
may be recorded as a consolidated bar chart that
j) a list of associated contracts; may be based on a critical path analyzed task
k) reference to the business evaluation on which network. A consolidated list of all deliverables
the original decision to authorize the project was ordered by time and by responsible owner should
based. also provide a useful focus for the project team as a
The project manager needs to ensure that the whole.
project team are aware of any relevant assumptions 4.5.7 Statement of work (SOW)
in the business evaluation and that they each have A statement of work should be included in the
a duty to report to the project manager when these project plan as follows. Guidance on the contents of
assumptions are at risk. This section of the plan is a typical SOW is given in 4.3.6.
likely to be confidential and its circulation limited to
those who need to know. The project plan statement of work is not always the
vehicle for the definitive technical specification of
4.5.4 Commitment acceptance, agreements, the project work content. These detailed data may
budget releases and budget logs exist in separate reference documents and contracts
The project plan should contain a commitment and that may be referred to by the project plan where
agreement section that records task owner appropriate. Reference documents need to be
commitments and the project manager’s acceptance subject to the same control disciplines as the project
of such commitments. The task owners need to plan.
formalize their commitments by signing against the For reasons of confidentiality, suppliers and task
appropriate project WBS reference. The project owners may only be given information that impacts
plans should contain details of any caveats that their contribution to the project.
were added by task owners to qualify such
commitments. Accountability for work in the project
plan needs to be included in the statement of work.
As the project progresses documents such as
instructions for work to proceed and budget releases
need to be recorded systematically in the
appropriate budget log. Agreement by the project
manager or the sponsor gives the project plan
contractual status and responsibilities as described
in the plan become binding.

28 © BSI 01-2000
Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

Table 1 — Model project plan Table 1 — Model project plan


Typical Typical
clause clause
numbers numbers

1 Foreword 25.2 Organizational chart


2 Contents, distribution and amendment 25.3 Terms of reference (TOR)
record a) for staff
3 Introduction b) for the project manager
3.1 General description c) for the committees and working
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

3.2 Scope groups


3.3 Project requirement 26 Management reporting system
3.4 Project security and privacy 27 Project diary
4 Project aims and objectives 28 Project history
5 Project policy NOTE The clause numbers given in Table 1 are for illustration
only, they do not cross-refer to any clauses of this standard.
6 Project approvals required and
authorization limits 4.6 Processes supporting the project
7 Project organization management process
8 Project harmonization
4.6.1 Quality assurance
9 Project implementation strategy
4.6.1.1 General
9.1 Project management philosophy
The project management objective is to deliver on
9.2 Implementation plans
time, to cost and to specification; this can be made
9.3 System integration easier and more efficient if the organization
9.4 Completed project work implements a sound quality policy.
10 Acceptance procedure 4.6.1.2 Quality system
11 Programme management It is essential that the host organization has a
12 Procurement strategy quality management system that is directed
13 Contract management towards the control of those elements of the project
14 Communications management that affect the quality of the project deliverables.
The project manager can usually gain confidence in
15 Configuration management
the ability of the host organization when the quality
15.1 Configuration control requirements management system is certified to a national or
15.2 Configuration management system international standard.
16 Financial management 4.6.1.3 Quality objectives
17 Risk management There are many definitions of quality and one of the
18 Project resource management best known descriptive phrases is “fitness for
19 Technical management purpose”. This should be interpreted for the
20 Test and evaluation purposes of project management as meeting the
requirements of the customer with respect to time,
21 Reliability management (see also
cost and product specification (including health and
BS 5760-1)
safety, see 4.6.1.5).
21.1 Availability, reliability and
maintainability (ARM) 4.6.1.4 Quality plans
21.2 Quality management Quality plans, when required by the customer or the
project manager, need to form an integral part of the
22 Health and safety management
overall project plan. The quality plan should provide
23 Environmental issues a quantified means of demonstrating that specific
24 Integrated logistics support (ILS) quality requirements are being addressed. The
management quality plan should, for example, detail the steps
25 Project team organization needed to produce the project deliverables, with the
25.1 Project staff directory appropriate quantitative acceptance criteria.

© BSI 01-2000 29
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

Quality plans should be considered in the feasibility 4.6.2.3 Configuration management plan
phase (see section 5 for a discussion of project The task owner or contracting organisation should
phases) and confirmed at the beginning of the prepare a configuration management plan that
implementation phase. Before it is included in a formally describes the scope, organization and
contract as a technical requirement, the quality procedures for CM and the points of contact
plan needs to be agreed by both the quality manager responsible for CM. Where CM is a requirement at
and project manager. subcontract level the degree of control and the
4.6.1.5 Health and safety procedures to be employed should be detailed in the
Project work often causes risks in terms of health, configuration management plan, agreed by the

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


safety and the environment. In order to ensure such project manager and included in the overall project
risks are understood and reduced to an acceptable plan.
level, every project should include an audit of these 4.6.3 Risk management
specific risks before work starts. This audit should 4.6.3.1 General
be updated throughout the life of the project. Audit
updates should be scheduled as part of the overall All projects, in common with all future work, are
project plan. risky. A sponsor cannot be absolutely certain that
the anticipated benefits from the project will be fully
4.6.2 Configuration management realized however successfully the project has been
4.6.2.1 General carried out. The sponsor is the primary risk taker
A configuration management system should be used but a project manager also faces risk in the form of
to control the physical and functional the inevitable uncertainty surrounding the project
characteristics of a product or service through process and unpredictable project environments.
documentation, records and data. Good CM practice For the project manager, project risk is primarily
should ensure that changes (variations) are the likelihood of negative occurrences adversely
implemented only after being authorized by the affecting the project so that its objectives become
supporting documentation and not, as sometimes more difficult or even impossible to achieve. The
happens, with the documents being altered to reflect project manager should therefore take positive steps
a configuration change that has already been to identify, assess and ultimately manage all risk
implemented. inherent in the project, as an integral part of the
The configuration management discipline needs to project management process.
be applied throughout the life cycle of a project. By using a structured risk management process the
During the early project phases this may require an project manager should ensure that as many risks
increase in management costs. However, cost as possible are identified, thus enabling the
savings during the production and in-service phases following action to be initiated:
should follow if CM is practised in concert with a) categorisation according to the nature of the
established project requirements. risk;
4.6.2.2 Configuration management systems b) assessment of the probability of occurrence and
The task owner or contracting organization should potential impact on the project;
establish and maintain a configuration c) the application of suitable risk response
management system, to the satisfaction of the measures including contingency planning;
project manager, to ensure that technical and d) the sharing, transfer or full acceptance of risks
administrative direction and surveillance is applied to the project;
to the following activities:
e) taking account of risks in management
a) configuration item selection, identification and planning.
documentation;
b) configuration control;
c) configuration status accounting; and
d) configuration audit.

30 © BSI 01-2000
Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

Risk management, whether separately identified or a) What could go wrong?


not, should continue throughout the project life b) How likely is this to happen?
cycle. It should always be given special emphasis as
c) What would be the consequences?
a key element in project planning. Project planning
cannot be realistic unless serious account is taken of Encouraging a project team to recognize the
what could go wrong and what can be done to potential for failure can be helped by brainstorming,
increase the chances of success and lessen the using generic and specific checklists of typical
prospects of partial or complete failure. Risk problems, analyzing both team members’
management techniques should be used to identify experience and lessons from similar previous
in advance the risk from problems and threats to the projects, and modelling the project’s events through
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

project. They then need to be continuously applied the use of the networks that support the project
as a means of effectively reducing risk to a tolerable programme. The use of the project network to
level. structure the analysis allows a team to concentrate
not only on risks associated with particular
4.6.3.2 The nature of project risk
activities, but also on risks arising from the
Unless risks are recognized they cannot be dealt interfaces between those activities where
with. If the risk identification process is to be particularly high levels of risk may exist.
effective, risk should be seen as arising from any
4.6.3.4 Risk quantification and reduction
significant threat or area of uncertainty that the
sponsor and project manager may face during the Once the important risks have been listed each
life of a project. should be assessed by estimating the nature and
size of damage to the project that might occur should
Potential risk within projects is not limited to
the worst happen. This primary risk is then
accidents or the failure of technology or unsound
quantified by assessing the likely frequency of the
commercial arrangements; differing perceptions of
underlying problem occurring. Simply ranking the
the project among the project team may pose a
probability as high, medium or low will do much to
potential risk for the project manager. Failure to
indicate the size of risk and sophisticated methods
identify objectives and perceptions of all key
are available when a more accurate forecast is
stakeholders (those who participate in decision
required. Secondary risks arise because efforts to
making or are affected by the project in some way)
deal with the main problem or undesired event, if it
can result in a lack of shared understanding, or even
occurs, often create further difficulties. Secondary
conflict in a project, for which the project manager is
risk, that sometimes can be of a greater magnitude
unprepared.
than the primary risk, should not be overlooked in
Those who participate in projects bring to the risk management planning.
project their own perceptions of what they consider
Once quantified, some risks may turn out to be
as possible risks. These perceptions determine their
completely intolerable to the project sponsor,
approach to the project and also their behaviour
thereby raising doubts over the entire project, or at
towards areas of uncertainty. Areas of uncertainty
the very least, the desirability of pursuing certain of
that they have not considered, or that lie outside
the project objectives. The risk assessment may also
their experience, will often be disregarded or not
cast doubt over the wisdom of employing particular
seen as risky and this can create a major area of risk
methods to execute the project. In complex project
itself that often goes unrecognized.
situations analytical methods can be used to
4.6.3.3 Risk identification examine the likelihood of one problem impacting on
The essential first step in effective risk another to produce an even greater risk.
management is the identification of as many as
possible of the risks of significant problems arising
during a project’s life and the highlighting of areas
of uncertainty that themselves will constitute a risk.
Only when this has been done can a project manager
plan to reduce the threats and set up contingency
plans to be used if problems actually materialize.
Risk and the problems, threats or events that give
rise to them should generally fall into one of the
following categories: technological, political,
managerial, sociological and financial. Risk analysis
should answer the following three fundamental
questions.

© BSI 01-2000 31
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

4.6.3.5 Response to risk 4.6.4 Procurement processes


Plans for dealing with areas of risk and uncertainty 4.6.4.1 General
in the project should be an integral part of the Procurement is a vital element in the success or
project plan. Risk analysis and risk management failure of many projects, particularly those
need to be central to the project manager’s concerned with a hardware product. The
understanding of the project and the difficulties to commitments for materials, goods or services with a
be faced in attaining the agreed objectives. One long lead time may have to be made before either
extreme response to risk may be to compromise on the project team or the project manager are in place.
the project objectives; another may be to fund an These commitments can for good or ill set the course

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


alternative method of executing the project. of the project.
Examples of less drastic means of dealing with risk
are increasing management strengths in the The procurement processes aim to acquire
project, reducing the dependency on one technology hardware, software, processed materials, services or
or one task on another or increasing the project combinations thereof that are necessary for the
plan’s flexibility and scope for management completion of the project. Thus procurement in
intervention so that potential obstacles to progress projects is much wider than just purchasing or
are avoided rather than left to be dealt with if they buying, particularly since in many projects the
occur. items to be procured are outside the normal
experience of the parent organization and may
Risk management strategies should feed in to every involve special contract conditions. In addition, in
area of the project plan but are especially relevant to many projects, procurement may require the
procurement and contract management policies. A procurement officer to organize activities such as:
project’s sponsor or project manager may wish to
see some risks transferred to other parties who — the transport of material to a location distant
should be willing to take on and manage them and from the parent organization, possibly overseas;
for transfer to be worthwhile there should be a — the organization of transport and
balance between risk carried and the potential documentation;
reward for so doing. — the arrangement of accommodation for staff
4.6.3.6 The risk management plan away from home;
The entire risk management analysis and — the hiring of specialists or consultants or other
management plan should be documented and services;
integrated with the project plan. Recognizing — the renting of equipment and plant not
uncertainty in projects and the risks that can arise available in the parent organization.
is an essential part of project planning. The 4.6.4.2 Buying
problems that might occur and the measures for
dealing with them should be documented in risk There are three main types of buying organization:
management plans. These should record who is to a) Routine buying: where a central purchasing
take responsibility for each risk reducing action and department buys all goods and services, based on
for any other actions such as contingency planning. the requirements of the project organization.
Some risks may prove to be impossible to reduce and b) Commodity buying: where a buyer or group of
will require contingency plans. Expenditure on buyers specializes in a particular commodity. The
contingency plans is often provided for by insurance buyer becomes very familiar with the product and
or through the creation of management reserves its sources and should be able to obtain the best
under the control of the project manager. prices, discounts and deliveries. Care needs to be
Where more than one project is involved, a central taken that excessively close relationships with
contingency pool can be created and by this means a suppliers do not develop.
sponsoring organization can wholly or partly insure c) Project buying: where a buyer or group of
itself against the unexpected. buyers specializes in the purchasing needs of a
particular project, dealing with the complete
range of bought-in items. This should have the
advantage that the buyer is fully committed to
the project and is an integrated member of the
project team. An experienced project buyer is
often able to give valuable advice to the project
manager regarding, for example, outstanding
purchasing requirements and lead times.

32 © BSI 01-2000
Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

4.6.4.3 Purchase orders 4.6.4.6 Inspection


The key document issued by a buyer is the purchase Failure to inspect may result in faulty or unfinished
order. This needs to contain the following items being delivered. The subsequent repair or
information: return to the supplier will usually result in costly
a) a unique purchase order reference number; delays that far outweigh the cost of inspection and
rectification in the supplier’s works. Inspection of
b) terms and conditions of purchase;
items within the supplier’s organization should be
c) specification and reference or part numbers of carried out in addition to any other in-house
the items to be purchased; inspection stages specified in the quality plan. Any
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

d) acceptance criteria; problem with meeting quality and acceptance


e) value of order; criteria needs to be reported to the project manager,
who should approve all concession requests or
f) delivery date;
changes to specification, if necessary having first
g) terms of payment; sought the sponsor’s agreement. Details of
h) delivery address and instructions. concessions and changes may also be subject to the
configuration management system and details
4.6.4.4 Vendor qualification
should be approved and recorded as necessary.
Some advantages, in terms of delivery, cost and
4.6.4.7 Shipping
performance may be achieved by developing a
preferred single source for each major purchased The shipping of items (especially to overseas
item, particularly for projects in the volume destinations) requires careful planning and control.
production area. In the first instance, vendors It may also be necessary to carry out route surveys
should be ranked and selected for further when heavy or large loads have to be transported.
consideration according to their past quality and The shipping function should include custom
performance records. A good working relationship clearance, obtaining transport permits, chartering
should then be established between the preferred vessels or aircraft, co-ordinating the economical
vendor and the project team at all levels, so that the filling of containers and obtaining the necessary
vendor is effectively absorbed into the culture of the documents to comply with export and import
project organization and fully understands its regulations. Even when the responsibility for
requirements. For the vendor this should be an shipping rests with the supplier, the project
opportunity for long-term business without manager needs to be satisfied that all the shipping
significant competition. The advantage for the arrangements have been correctly implemented.
project team is quality and reliability of supply. 4.6.4.8 Subcontract administration in
4.6.4.5 Expediting construction projects
Unless orders are regularly expedited, delivery The conditions laid down in subcontracts for
dates and promises should not be relied upon. construction projects can be either general or special
Suppliers need to be visited or reminded at set as follows:
intervals to ensure compliance with delivery dates. a) general conditions, as laid down by
The project manager should set up an efficient professional institutions, trade associations,
contractual expediting programme and needs to be government departments or local authorities,
advised of every actual or potential slippage, so that
b) specialist conditions, as issued by the buying
remedial action can be taken immediately. This authority in accordance with an internal
could take the form of high level contacts, premium standard or specific project requirement
payments, reprogramming where possible or even
embodied in the contract.
cancellation of the order. The imposition of
liquidated damages for failure or partial delivery or
lateness of requested documentation can be of great
help to the expediter, who needs to be fully aware of
the downstream implications of a late delivery.

© BSI 01-2000 33
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

The difference between a subcontract and a It is important that as soon as sufficient work has
purchase order in the construction industry is that been completed, the disparate threads of a project
the former has a site erection content. Consequently are brought together in the common measure of
all construction enquiry and contract documents money. This is to determine the full cost of
need to contain details of the various site development and implementation and the difference
agreements with other contractors and trade anticipated between the operating costs and income
unions, regulations, restrictions and methods of over a reasonable period of time. The evaluation
progress control. Since stage payments are usually should concentrate on cash flow, rather than
based on site measurement, a subcontract demands bookkeeping conventions used for financial

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


considerably more administrative effort than a accounting. The project manager needs to produce a
purchase order. Whether this work is done in the realistic assessment of the cash needed; capital and
office or on site, the project manager should be associated revenue. These data should be given in
responsible for ensuring that it is done efficiently time periods, for example three or six monthly
and regularly by an experienced and trusted person. intervals, that are appropriate to the duration of the
4.6.5 Financial control processes project. The assessment may also show the expected
cash receipts throughout the project, from initial
4.6.5.1 Financial evaluation grants to any close down income at the termination
Authorization for projects to proceed should be of the project.
based on formal evaluation of a proposal. A project The project manager will need to ensure that the
that has not been subjected to such scrutiny is at financial forecasts are realistic and achievable and
much greater risk of failure. The only financial that a management reserve is included to cope with
certainty is that the rate of expenditure will escalate unexpected issues. For some projects a substantial
as the project progresses to implementation; the part of the full life cash flow may be needed for
project manager should therefore keep a firm decommissioning and safely disposing of assets at
control on project finances at all times. The cost of close-down. The accuracy of data will tend to
delivering the project will only be justified if the diminish as the forecasting horizon is extended into
claimed benefits, either in profit or services to the distant future and will become grouped,
society, are subsequently realized. rounded-off and generally less detailed. Data for the
Costs are largely set by specifications and relatively near term should, however, be reasonably
procedures built-in during the design phase. After accurate and detailed, see Figure 7.
the decision to proceed is taken, these tend to
progressively become legal commitments as binding
orders. Contracts are placed and actual expenses, as
they are fulfilled, are invoiced and paid for. Figure 6
shows how costs tend to build-up before any benefits
are delivered. Any review to consider possible
abandonment of a project needs to be concerned
with the total committed cost rather than merely
the amount actually expended.

34 © BSI 01-2000
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

Figure 6 — Typical cumulative cost pattern


The project manager needs to make the most Projects are concerned with the future and always
sensible use of the available data, while recognizing bear a degree of uncertainty and risk. The
that financial evaluation is only one of the elements evaluation needs to include a full assessment of the
that will be considered when deciding to approve or principal risks, showing the assumptions made and
reject a project. referring to the consequences of various scenarios.
In certain situations the quantifiable benefits will Where possible the sensitivity of the project to these
be augmented by real but less tangible benefits and risks should be analyzed. In appropriate
wholly subjective benefits. It is essential that these circumstances risk management will require a full
benefits are identified and wherever possible separate statement and contingency plan. It should
measured and further quantified as the work always be remembered that investment money is
progresses. In larger projects the initial evaluation usually the scarce resource and the results shown in
will be followed by periodic updated evaluations at the financial evaluation may be crucial in obtaining
predetermined milestones, as part of the monitoring the necessary funding. The consequent application
procedures and authorization requirements. of funds should also be seen as a commitment to the
project by the signatories.

© BSI 01-2000 35
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


Figure 7 — Format of cash flow forecast
4.6.5.2 Time related value of money A similar use of the concept of time adjusted cash
The purpose of most projects is to enhance profit by flow values seeks to find the Internal Rate of Return
some combination of improved income and reduced (IRR) that will discount the cash flow back to the
costs; this can be achieved, for example, by original investment. If that rate is higher than the
increasing the capacity or utilization of an asset. cost of borrowing, the proposal should pass the
The real value of money is constantly changing; one hurdle and may then have to be compared to other
pound of income today is likely to have significantly draft projects. Under most circumstances, managers
different buying power from a pound received in ten need to select the project offering the best fit to the
years’ time. To compare the worth of alternative criteria being used. Examples of these criteria are
projects competing for scarce funds, the net cash speed of pay back, first year return, overall
flow figures should be adjusted to a common time percentage return on investment and annual
base. Using compound interest to reflect the cost of average rate of return on the original investment. It
money, it is usual to discount a stream of future is being increasingly recognized that financial
cash flows to a Net Present Value (NPV). An NPV techniques need to deal with whole life projections.
calculation puts most weight on near term income DCF techniques should be applied consistently to
and increasingly less weight on receipts stretching ensure familiarity with the techniques being used
out into the more uncertain future. The resultant and to ensure comparability between projects
Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) needs then to be competing for scarce resources, with minimum
compared to the original investment to establish a hurdles of returns set for all investments in one-off
NPV that is directly comparable from one proposal projects. Table 2 gives the discounted cash flow and
to another. net present value of two small commercial projects
competing in an environment where the cost of
investment monies is judged to be 10 % and both
projects need an initial investment of £50,000.

36 © BSI 01-2000
Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

Table 2 — Example of discounted cash flow


Project A Project B Discount rate in 10 %
regime
Residual value at project end nil nil
Years of life 4 5
Cash profits after interest but
before depreciation
Year 1 32,500 20,000 .9091
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

Year 2 27,500 25,000 .8264


Year 3 22,500 25,000 .7513
Year 4 19,500 30,000 .6830
Year 5 15,000 .6209
Total 102,000 115,000
Average p.a. 25,500 23,000
Discounted cash profits
Year 1 29,545 18,182
Year 2 22,726 20,660
Year 3 16,904 18,782
Year 4 13,318 20,490
Year 5 9,313
Total 82,493 87,427
Less original investment 50,000 50,000
Net Present Value (NPV) 32,493 37,427
% NPV on investment 64.8 74.8
NOTE The authorizing body would consider these financial projections with other criteria in determining which project, if any, to
proceed with.

When this step has been completed, the manager 4.6.6.2 Earned value principles
evaluating the project needs to decide on the source Earned value is based on assigning a value to the
of the funds which are to finance the project and achievement of project work. Ideally, achievement is
should ensure that interest costs are built into the in terms of milestones and deliverables. The value is
evaluation and the balance sheet assessments. Full usually monetary but can be expressed in any
account should also be taken of the consequences of appropriate units such as man hours. The value to
changes in debtors, creditors, stock and working be earned when a specific milestone is achieved is
overdraft facilities etc. based on the planned cost of achieving the
4.6.6 Earned value performance measurement milestone. Thus, for example, if the plan showed
4.6.6.1 General that £50,000 was required to achieve
milestone X, £50,000 worth of earned value would
A key principle of good project management practice be credited to the task owner when achievement of
is the use of performance measurement techniques milestone X was demonstrated. Earned value is also
such as earned value analysis at the task level. known as the Budgeted Cost of Work Performed or
Earned value measurement should enable a clearer BCWP.
measure of the project work accomplished and
Earned value based performance measurement
better forecasts of the likely task and project
replaces the traditional practice which only
completion dates and associated costs, compared
compares planned and actual costs. This practice
with the traditional method of simply comparing the
tended to confuse actual costs with actual progress,
actual and planned cost to date.
a confusion which is eliminated by using earned
value (see Figure 8).

© BSI 01-2000 37
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

4.6.6.3 Project milestones and deliveries These ratios, known as performance indices, may be
The project plan should specify when milestones determined as follows:
and deliverables are to be achieved. Project
milestones and deliverables should have the Cost performance index (CPI) = BCWP
following characteristics: ------------------
ACWP
a) represent a well defined event, for example
delivery of a specific product or completion of a However, a Schedule Performance Index (SPI) may
project phase; be calculated in two alternative ways to give a cost
b) a clear relationship to a task within the project or time based forecast. The cost based SPI is part of

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


plan; earned value analysis and the time based SPI is for
use when forecasting the possible achievement of
c) quantifiable criteria for assessing achievement; intermediate time points, the remaining time to
d) be defined at a specific point in time. complete the project or the total project time.
4.6.6.4 Performance analysis Further guidance on time based forecasting is given
in 4.6.6.5.
Performance analysis should begin at the task
owner level, where the actual cost of work The alternative methods of calculating SPI are as
performed (ACWP) on a given task needs to be follows:
compared with the earned value credited so far to
the task owner. The difference between earned Cost based SPI = BCWP
value and actual cost is called the cost variance: ------------------
BCWS
Cost variance = BCWP – ACWP
where Time based SPI = OD
------------
ATE
ACWP is the acutal cost of work performed; and
BCWP is the earned value When calculating any of these ratios or indices, only
Similarly the cost impact of schedule slippage, the data from the current phase of the project should be
schedule variance, may be determined. At the end of used. This is because the preceding phases may
a task the earned value should always be equal to have been performed under different conditions. For
the planned cost (because earned value is based on example, activities in the conception or feasibility
planned cost). Thus use of the cost based schedule phases are likely to be significantly different in
variance is not recommended for work that is nature to those in the implementation phase.
nearing completion. Equally, these data should be directly related to the
Schedule variance (cost) = BCWP – BCWS work breakdown structure, so that by consolidation,
where the performance of the whole project, or any part of
BCWS is the budgeted cost of work scheduled (or the project, may be determined at any point in time.
planned cost). Provided an analysis of every task is available at a
Alternatively, as shown in Figure 8, a time based given milestone, a complete picture of the project
schedule variance may be determined by calculating performance, together with reasons for variations,
the difference between the planned and actual time should be identifiable. This should focus
taken to complete the work to date. management attention on the opportunities and
problem areas and their effect on the project as a
Schedule variance (time) = OD – ATE whole.
where A singularly useful way of using earned value data
OD is the Original Duration planned for the work is to plot CPI as a function of SPI (cost based)
to date; and through time. The line drawn through the points
ATE is the Actual Time Expended for the work to should reveal very accurately the direction of the
date. task and, if drawn at the level of the whole project,
the complete project.
Negative cost or schedule variances are
unfavourable and positive variances favourable. This method of presenting data, often referred to as
a “bull’s eye diagram”, may also be used to
The same data may be expressed as ratios that give
demonstrate the effect of recovery action. An
an indication of value for money. If work is
example of the chart is given in Figure 10.
proceeding to, or better than, plan, these ratios will
be equal to or greater than unity. Conversely
unfavourable variances will be less than unity.

38 © BSI 01-2000
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

Figure 8 — Earned value chart


4.6.6.5 Forecasting based on earned value where
statistics EAC is the estimated cost at completion
Forecast project completion cost and time can be
BAC is the budget at completion (total planned
based on simple formulae using earned value
cost of work).
statistics as follows:
( BAC – BCWP )
EAC = ACWP + ------------------------------------------
CPI

© BSI 01-2000 39
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 4

In time forecasts 4.7.4 Evaluation and decision making


Individuals should be able to evaluate alternatives
Planned Total Project Time = PTPT and make authoritative decisions by means of the
following attributes:
Schedule Variance (time) = OD – ATE
a) being able to sift through and understand
Planned Time to Complete (PTC) = PTPT – OD volumes of project data, identify important
Estimated Actual Time to complete = PTC/SPI material and seek out any missing information,
(time) to make an informed decision on the facts
presented;

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


Estimated Total Project Time = ATE +
PTC/SPI b) getting to the root of project issues, identifying
(time) key relationships, political implications and
applying a pragmatic cause and effect approach
Depending on the type and quality of the progress to the decision process;
data, alternative methods may be used for
c) understanding the project objectives,
producing forecasts. Wherever possible, it is
establishing the correct priorities and choosing
perferable to use cost or labour hours data, but in
the most appropriate course of action.
the absence of such data, other methods based on
network techniques may be used (to establish OD 4.7.5 Management of people
and ATE) if only activity durations are available. Individuals should be able to motivate and enthuse
colleagues by means of the following attributes:
4.7 Project personnel development
a) being able to work co-operatively and
4.7.1 General communicate effectively with people at all levels
The variety of demands placed upon a project in the organization;
manager and the members of the project team is b) being concerned for and having an
substantial. The list of attributes and skills understanding of people’s needs;
described in 4.7.2 to 4.7.14 should be developed to c) showing enthusiasm for the project and a
ensure the effectiveness of individuals and the constant personal drive toward achieving its
project team as a whole. goals;
NOTE Many of these attributes are not exclusive to project
management. d) developing the skills of and encouraging the
individual project team members.
4.7.2 Leadership
4.7.6 Systems design and maintenance skills
Individuals should be able to stimulate action,
progress and change and to get things moving by Systems design and maintenance skills include:
means of the following attributes: a) being computer literate and demonstrating
a) demonstrating initiative and achieving results; competence in the use of the relevant computer
b) displaying strong persuasive skills when systems and applications;
dealing with team members; b) having a working knowledge of the internal
c) delegating effectively; monitoring the administration and systems of organizations
effectiveness of the team as a whole and the within the project environment.
contribution of its individual members; c) having a working knowledge of the systems
d) being competent at running effective meetings and environment that the project deliverables
and having the ability to manage and control will encounter in the operational phase.
change. 4.7.7 Planning and control skills
4.7.3 Technological understanding Planning and control skills include:
Individuals need to have an adequate, but not a a) the ability to identify problems and
specialist, understanding of the technical opportunities;
requirements of the project so that business needs b) making the best use of available resources to
are addressed and satisfied. achieve the project objectives;
c) encouraging the project team members to set
personal objectives with respect to planning,
organizing and time management methods;
d) being familiar with modern planning and
monitoring techniques;

40 © BSI 01-2000
Section 4 BS 6079-1:2000

4.7.8 Financial awareness 4.7.13 Legal awareness


Financial awareness involves: The individual should have an understanding of
a) being familiar with financial and risk contract law and any statutory requirements that
management techniques; could affect the project.
b) having a broad based financial knowledge 4.7.14 Character
including the ability to understand company Besides these skills, that can all be learnt, there is
accounts; still one factor that is overriding: the personality of
c) being familiar with cash flow and variance the project manager. Without the personal qualities
analyses, understanding profit and loss that are a part of character the other aspects will
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

statements and able to develop financial models; generate only an average project manager, not a
d) being cost conscious and able to control costs to good one. Incorporated in the character should be a
plan. mixture of enthusiasm, dedication, drive,
determination, vision and humour.
4.7.9 Buying and general procurement
4.7.15 Project team blend
Individuals should have the capability to participate
in the development of the procurement strategy. As a project progresses, the project team should gain
a variety of functional skills and experience in such
4.7.10 Communications skills fields as marketing, engineering, social services,
Communications skills should consist of the finance and personnel. These skills may be brought
following: to the project by the people seconded to the team
a) being able to express themselves in a clear, perhaps for the life of the project or for particular
understandable and unambiguous manner; phases where the need for a particular talent is
dominant.
b) demonstrating skills in verbal and written
presentation; Besides the functional skills that are important for
carrying out the tasks of the project, it has been
c) using the most appropriate presentation media
found desirable to try to ensure a mix of personal
and methods and tailoring the level of detail to a
characteristics. It may be considered that the
given audience;
project manager needs the ability to link and lead
d) thinking on one’s feet and giving meaningful people who between them can:
responses to questions; a) create innovative approaches to the issues;
e) dealing effectively with sub-contractors,
b) sell the work of the team to the influential
customers and people outside the project
third parties;
environment;
c) pragmatically test ideas within the team before
f) giving clear, unambiguous instructions.
adoption;
4.7.11 Negotiating skills d) secure co-operation from within the
To be effective in negotiation individuals should be: organization and know where to go for specific
a) skilful in pre-determining a customer’s stated, backing and back-up;
implied and latent needs; e) get things done;
b) skilful in countering hidden agendas and f) insist on progress at acceptable standards;
political objections to the project; proficient in g) take a semi-detached view of events and
preparing appropriate responses to issues and see things as they are.
planning a negotiation strategy in advance;
h) maintain composure under pressure and keep
c) able to convince people, appeal to their calm when things go wrong.
interests and counter their technical objections;
d) persuasive in obtaining additional project
resources when required.
4.7.12 Contractual skills
Contractual skills include:
a) capability in developing a contractual strategy;
b) effective communication of contract terms and
conditions to appropriate sub-contractors;
c) ability to manage sub-contractors;

© BSI 01-2000 41
BS 6079:2000

Section 5. Project lifecycle

5.1 General 9) major overhauls and planned maintenance;


Projects differ from other enterprises in several 10) production planning;
ways, in particular by their transient and unique 11) emergency planning;
nature. The principal features that characterize 12) plant commissioning and/or operation;
projects include the following:
13) information technology software;
a) their duration is usually predetermined (finite)
14) office or factory relocation.
with definite start and termination dates
specified;
5.3 Project phasing

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


b) what happens during the execution of a project
invariably affects the subsequent deliverables; 5.3.1 General
c) the project organization is often temporary and Any project, irrespective of size and complexity, will
may change from one phase to the next during the naturally move through a series of distinct phases
execution of the project; between its conception and termination. In large
projects the phases should be formally identified
d) all projects will contain some risk and
and separated to enable effective management of
uncertainty;
the project. Where commitment of substantial
e) most projects are non-repetitive; they might resources is required, authorization may be limited
also include some essentially unique feature or and need to be reconfirmed at specific milestones.
the use of technologies beyond the current state of For small projects the phases are usually less
the art; formal, but may still need to be identified, for
f) and finally, although projects are a contained example, at management reviews. Figure 9 shows a
set of tasks they are seldom carried out in project phase structure that covers the project whole
isolation, but interact with other projects and life cycle.
organizations; their structures and systems are
interactive organizationally, technically, 5.4 Project phase sequence
economically and socially. Projects of any significant size, duration or cost
should benefit from phasing into sequential blocks
5.2 Types of project of related activities. There are a minimum of five
Projects may be categorized in various ways to fundamental project phases, namely conception,
identify appropriate methods of efficient project feasibility, implementation, operation and
management. termination, that can be identified in all projects.
Some examples of these project categories are as The points between phases are often referred to as
follows: milestones and they provide a natural opportunity
a) by duration, for example three months or ten to review, record and report project progress before
years; going forward to the next phase. Checks should be
made at each milestone to ensure that the previous
b) by total cost, for example £20,000 or £6 billion; phase has been satisfactorily completed and that
c) by complexity, for example straight sequence of the project objectives are being fully achieved.
simple activities or highly interrelated, Depending on the results, a decision on whether to
multi-organizational, multi-disciplined; proceed, modify or stop the project should be taken;
d) by method of operating, for example in-house in this respect it may be necessary to obtain
projects, contracted-out or a combination of both; authorization from the sponsor.
e) by technical, organizational and All projects should normally have some preparatory
administrative features as follows: work before they are formally started and it is
1) strategic long term; advisable to appoint a manager possibly in a
part-time capacity, at the earliest opportunity, to
2) research and development (R & D); co-ordinate such work. This manager may then
3) administrative and procedural; naturally progress into the role of project manager
4) capital plant manufacture; when the project is formally authorized.
5) major engineering works on local and/or
dispersed sites;
6) planning and controlling changeovers;
7) one-off or repetitive building construction;
8) new product introduction;

42 © BSI 01-2000
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI Section 5 BS 6079-1:2000

Figure 9 — Project management life cycle


Organizations and sectors of industry tend to 5.5 Description of phase content
develop project life cycles that are phased to enable
5.5.1 General
the use of an agreed methodology between
interested parties. In most cases these phases share The five basic phases described in 5.4 may be
many features of, and are therefore comparable to, further subdivided into stages depending on the
the generic life cycle described in Figure 9. Table 3 size, complexity and nature of planned activities,
gives some examples of project phases that are used the size and nature of the project. This is
in a wide range of industries and the public sector. particularly true of the implementation phase that
could, for example, include product definition,
design, development, production and installation
stages. Significant milestones, such as project
authorization and handover may also be indicated.
The content of a typical industrial project is
described in 5.5.2 to 5.5.9.

© BSI 01-2000 43
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 5

5.5.2 Conception phase A functional department or small team of specialists


Managers in enterprises should be constantly and researchers may manage the tasks until it is
looking for opportunities to improve the deemed that commissioning a full scale project is
performance of their organizations. Initial ideas are justified. Although it is not essential to formally
by their nature generally vague and uncertain, but appoint the project manager until the project
may have sufficient interest to merit further reaches a more advanced stage, a firm candidate for
investigation. Concepts that are considered worthy the post needs to be identified at the earliest
of serious consideration are then taken to the next opportunity. This person should be consulted during
phase that will test the feasibility of the ideas before the planning and decision process, pending formal

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


a full scale project implementation programme is appointment, perhaps on a part-time basis.
launched. 5.5.3 Concept-feasibility phase transfer
Concept formulation is usually the first phase of a milestone
project life cycle and should cover the period from At this milestone the project sponsor should apply to
the emergence of an idea for a project to an initial the appropriate level of management for
formal statement of a user’s or sponsor’s needs. authorization to enter the feasibility phase.
Ideas for new projects might be expanded by Development of the concept into a feasible project
exchanges of views between the customer, sponsor will almost certainly require the commitment and
and if necessary specialist advisors; they are derived use of funds and resources.
from factors such as: 5.5.4 Feasibility phase
a) a change in policy requiring a new capability;
The objective of this phase is to establish technical
b) the identification of a new actual or latent and financial feasibility and, where appropriate,
requirement; commercial feasibility. The studies, experiments
c) outputs from research programme offering new and results of test programmes, the initial estimates
means of meeting a requirement or providing a and appraisals of cost, timescales and risk, the
new capability; demand on resources and the impact upon
d) replacement of an obsolescent system or an incremental revenues, should then be used to
advance in technology; forecast the commercial or social benefits to be
expected from the project. Failure to identify
e) correction of a deficiency in an existing product
inherent deficiencies in a project at this stage can
or service identified in operation, training or
have extensive adverse effects in later phases. It is,
research;
therefore, important to invest adequate effort in
f) response to a new opportunity opened up by a clearly defining the work to be carried out in the
competitor; feasibility study.
g) an agreed perception of a need emerging from Work done in the feasibility phase may be confined
discussions with customers or other areas of the to paper assessments and evaluation, but technical
organization; and experimental work, including modelling, should
h) work being done on an existing project that be carried out where validation of a basic concept or
stimulates the idea for its successor, or some new identification of a technical problem is required.
utilization. The following work should be completed before a
During the conception phase the first basic ideas on positive recommendation to proceed with the project
how to create or satisfy a need or solve a particular can be contemplated:
problem should be generated and investigated. The a) a technical study to see if the concepts are
conception phase should be a period when free practical and can be developed into a useful
thinking and the involvement of potential working product or service;
stakeholders is encouraged to generate and then
b) a commercial and/or cost-benefit analysis;
build upon many new ideas and solutions.
c) market research to determine probable
demand and pricing sensitivity of the proposed
product or service;
d) preliminary estimates of the financial
implications of the project, including an
assessment of the probable income generated and
the operational costs such as production,
distribution and marketing.

44 © BSI 01-2000
Section 5 BS 6079-1:2000

These data have to be accurate enough to gauge Authorization may be conditional upon time and
the acceptability of the project to either expenditure limits, satisfactory progress reports
commerce or society. If this hurdle is passed, and further applications for authorization at
further work should be undertaken to complete a specified stages of implementation.
full technical and financial evaluation. The 5.5.5.2 Evaluation
output of the feasibility phase should be a
written report typically containing the following The evaluation should include a forecast of the
information: financial impact of the project in terms of its
probable costs and benefits. Because, with few
e) a technical appraisal of alternative solutions exceptions, the organization will incur significant
investigated including the results of any research costs long before the benefits of the project are
or experiments;
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

realized, tight cost controls should be exercised


f) an evaluation of the preferred solution(s) throughout. Where a project has a life of several
showing in broad terms how the project objectives years or more, the estimated cash flow should be
could be met and an outline description of the discounted, to offset interest cost factors and derive
characteristics, benefits and features of the an estimate of net cash surplus at net present value
preferred proposal; (NPV) that may be directly compared with the
g) a statement of any identified areas of scientific, original investment.
technical or social difficulty and any special steps The evaluation should assess whole life cycle costs
needed to overcome these, with an assessment of taking account of, for example, major cost
the risks involved; implications, such as those in a manufacturing
h) detailed plans, including specifications, for the environment where the build-up and financing of
implementation phase and plans for subsequent tooling, raw materials, manufacturing stock and
phases; marketing efforts will consume cash well before any
i) estimates, as thorough and realistic as income is received. With certain types of project,
necessary, of the likely time and costs for such as those in the power industry, the appraisal
development and delivery of a product or should allow for decommissioning, and/or disposal
establishment of a service together with costs that will arise after operations cease. In other
estimates of support costs. Costs of options words the financial case should encompass all
should be included as necessary; aspects of the project life cycle. It is not enough just
to know the respective totals of income and
j) an assessment of other resources required; expenditure.
k) operational considerations and potential for The financial and cash flow information should
future enhancements; generally reflect the timing of the various
l) end-of-life disposal methods and costs. operations and may be presented as a plan or
The sponsor should decide from an evaluation network; information regarding the timing of the
whether to seek further information or to expected cash outflows and inflows is essential. The
recommend management to authorize the project intervals used in the financial plans and assessment
moving into the implementation phase. will reflect the size and complexity of the project,
ranging from perhaps monthly on small schemes, to
5.5.5 Project authorization milestone
yearly for the very long term projects.
5.5.5.1 General In undertaking an evaluation it is essential that the
Formal authorization is needed to ensure that funds sensitivity of the project to the various risks is
and resources can be made available and committed properly considered so that the authorizing body
to the project. The authorization process usually has has a clear idea of the range of results that could be
three stages: evaluation and application followed by expected. For complex projects a risk management
formal authorization. The authorizing body should plan is essential and should be maintained
be informed of any potential risks and throughout the duration of the project. There is, for
disadvantages so that a balanced decision can be example, a particular requirement for risk analysis
made about the project’s future. in those projects where there is a high research
No substantial work, commitment of resources or element and a significant chance of failure, such as
expenditure should be permitted without prior the development of pharmaceuticals.
authorization. Small projects may be approved by a
senior manager, but major projects need to be
submitted to the top management level for
authorization. Applications should be presented in
writing, in a standard form, for signature by the
authorizing body.

© BSI 01-2000 45
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 5

It is necessary to make the most sensible use of all It is usually the sponsor or project manager who
the data available while recognizing that the should present the case for the project to the
financial evaluation, although a major element, is authorising authority. In most organizations there
only one aspect that should be considered when will be several levels of authorization, each
deciding to approve or reject a project application. In management level having authority to approve
certain situations the readily quantifiable cost capital expenditure to a preset financial limit.
benefits will be augmented by real but intangible Authorization for larger expenditures generally
benefits and as the impact of projects spreads across moves higher up the management hierarchy with
more functions the more elusive benefits will need to ultimately all major projects requiring

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


be identified even if measurement is difficult. authorization by the main board of directors, or in
5.5.5.3 Application the case of the public sector, such authorization
would be by an approving committee, HM Treasury
The project sponsor should make a formal and the Minister of State. The splitting of a large
application for approval of a project before project into smaller projects, so that authorization
commencement of any substantial work, can be given by a lower level of management, should
commitment of resources or expenditure. not be condoned; this practice is ultimately
Applications for major projects need to be counter-productive.
comprehensive and realistic, they should be
After due consideration, the authorizing body needs
presented in writing, in a standard form, for
to decide whether the project should proceed or not,
signature by the authorizing body. The quality and
given the funding facilities and competing demands
content of the application can have a significant
for finance, human and physical resources. The
bearing on whether or not the project is authorized.
An application should contain the following types of authorization may be conditional upon time and
information: expenditure limits and receipt of satisfactory
progress reports. Further applications for
a) a brief written description of the project and its authorization may be required at specified stages of
benefits, using illustrations and models where implementation, e.g. during the definition stage
appropriate; when a more comprehensive evaluation should be
b) financial data concerning the cost of delivering completed.
the project, if necessary broken down by phase; 5.5.6 Implementation phase
c) the expected revenues, operating costs,
Having secured a formal authorization to proceed
projected return on capital employed and
with the venture, the project manager should
cost-benefit analysis where applicable;
initiate the practical work needed to bring the
d) the human and physical resources needed; project to fruition. The implementation phase may
e) a realistic assessment of the technical and need to be fragmented into several stages,
financial risks involved; depending upon the nature, size and complexity of
f) a forecast of the effect of the project upon the the implementation tasks. These stages may
operation and strategic plans of the sponsoring encompass, for example, the following major tasks:
organization; a) further definition;
g) a recommended plan of action; b) design;
h) the signatures of the principal stakeholders as c) development;
a commitment to deliver the project in accordance d) procurement;
with the projected time, cost and performance
e) manufacture, construction or assembly;
criteria.
f) physical completion, commissioning and
5.5.5.4 Formal authorization acceptance testing.
Given an evaluation that is satisfactory and within During the implementation phase, a comparison of
the existing policy constraints of the organization, the physical and financial progress against plan
an authorization to start the project should be made at predetermined intervals.
implementation phase should follow. It may be the Assessments of the probability of completing the
project sponsor or senior managers who will need to project to time, cost and performance parameters
be satisfied that all the financial, technical and should be made at predetermined intervals and
other relevant evaluation data have been taken into corrective action initiated or progressed as
consideration to provide an audit trail and a clear necessary (see Figure 10).
and unambiguous way ahead. This information
should have been properly defined and adequately
documented in the application.

46 © BSI 01-2000
Section 5 BS 6079-1:2000

Planning for implementation is a key part of the It is seldom possible to achieve a clear cut transition
project definition and development stages. This is from the development stage into production.
essential not only to ensure a smooth transition Usually, for example, it is necessary to order some
from the feasibility study to implementation, but materials and tooling for production or recruit and
also to ensure that the final product conforms to the train staff in parallel with the last stages of
end user’s requirements. For example products development to ensure the smooth transition and
should be designed for ease of production, use and the emergence of a product or service. This involves
maintenance and be dependable in service. Before technical, financial and other risks that need to be
commencement of implementation, development quantified and the implications assessed. The
should have reached the point where there is project management team should identify those
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

sufficient confidence that a standard acceptable to risks and advise on alternative courses. Early
the user can be achieved. implementation commitments should normally be
entered only on a stage by stage release basis so that
the risk is minimized; the use of configuration
management becomes important here.

Figure 10 — Periodic estimate of the project cost and finishing date

© BSI 01-2000 47
BS 6079-1:2000 Section 5

5.5.7 Handover milestone c) further development, as necessary, where there


At the conclusion of the project implementation are initial performance limitations;
phase the product or service should be handed over d) the setting up and implementation of
to the customer; this may involve a commissioning post-design services;
activity plus formal acceptance procedures. e) in-use support consisting of the provision of
Handover may be a phase in its own right for a large training aids, spares, repair, maintenance,
project, or otherwise a key milestone. The handover modification/enhancement programmes and
may be instantaneous or a gradual process taking a upkeep facilities.
considerable period to complete depending on the
For certain projects the cost of plant shutdown and

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


nature of the deliverables.
decommissioning will be a major expense that
The project manager should be required to should be assessed at the beginning and throughout
demonstrate that the deliverables meet the the project life cycle. Provision for plant shutdown
specification and previously agreed quality. The and decommissioning should be made when
handover needs to be carefully monitored to ensure deciding pricing strategies for products made by
that rapid corrective action is taken with respect to plant during its operational phase.
potential and actual problems. As the transfer of
5.5.9 Termination phase
authority from the project team to the user takes
place, unexpected changes in the project may be Termination usually refers to the end of a project;
introduced that cause it to fail to meet the this point, for a project team, could occur when the
specification in some way, thus exposing the project responsibility is handed over to an operational
sponsor to financial penalties or legal action. organization, a customer or when the project is
As a consequence of handover the project manager discontinued at the end of its useful life. It may
and team may be redeployed to functional occur at an earlier stage in the life of the project if
departments or alternative projects. The handover there is a failure to meet the necessary cost, time,
needs to be documented by the project manager and performance or quality criteria. The final phase of
the recipient of the deliverables as follows. the project cycle may involve the disposal of
equipment, the withdrawal of a service or the
a) Before relinquishing responsibilities, the achievement of the project objective.
project manager should prepare a report
detailing the history of the project and its It is the responsibility of the sponsor or owner of the
accomplishments, compared with what was project deliverables to decide the timing of the
promised at the time of authorization. This disposal of obsolescent or surplus hardware,
handover report should also give reasons for any software and resources, and inform users that a
significant deviations from the project plan and product, service or process has been withdrawn.
specifications. As well as providing a justification Adequate effort should be expended to ensure that
for handover, the report should also be of benefit optimum solutions for disposal are found. The final
to future projects, in helping avoid common task should be the preparation of an analysis of the
problems and the tendency to re-invent the whole project and the documentation of its complete
wheel. life cycle history. The history of the project should
give valuable guidance to others who are embarking
b) Before accepting the project, the customer on new projects; provide lessons and examples for
should prepare a report that explains the newcomers and reference documentation for the
circumstances and conditions under which the owners of any remains of the project. The
project is being accepted. This acceptance report importance of this exercise cannot be
should also give details of performance shortfalls, over-emphasized for reducing risks in the planning
areas of dispute, payment retentions and action and execution of future project work and handling
needed to rectify specific problems, if appropriate. any issues that might arise, for example, following
5.5.8 Operation phase the disposal of scrap.
Operation is normally a set of recurrent activities NOTE The project life cycle may extend over many years and
the final report may be written by staff who were not members of
characterized by a relatively low rate of change and the original project team. In this case relevant information from
is usually the responsibility of a functional the project handover and acceptance reports should be referred to
manager. The main activities in the operational as necessary.
phase, besides the actual use of the project
deliverables, are as follows:
a) the marketing and sale of products and
services;
b) performance monitoring

48 © BSI 01-2000
Section 5 BS 6079-1:2000

Table 3 — List of typical project phases


Phase/Stage Description

Conception Usually the start of project work, by translation of ideas and/or identifying needs.
Pilot study
Research
Initiation
Feasibility Establishing the commercial, technical, social and environmental feasibility of
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

project.
Estimating project cost and timescale, also identifying risks and health and safety
issues; determining the support and capability of prospective contractors.
Evaluation Evaluation of the whole or part of the project between phases; prospective
contractor preparing tender.
Application Making a formal proposal for authorization of a project.
Authorization Getting agreement to proceed with project in whole or in part; by obtaining
acceptance of a tender by the customer or board.
Definition Verifying the approach; developing the specification.
Development Designing a product that conforms to the specification.
Implementation This phase can include several individual stages: design, procurement,
construction, commissioning etc.
Realization
Production
Manufacture
Fabrication
Construction
Works
Installation Installing the plant/product and making it work.
Commissioning
Launch Open up sales to a pilot area, then whole market.
Introduction
Branch-Out
Shipping
Handover Transferring responsibility for the project to a customer or functional department.
Acceptance
In-use Maintaining the product.
In-service
Operational
Termination Decommissioning the product; disposal of the project.
Disposal
Final report The last act of project manager, to document the history of the project.

© BSI 01-2000 49
BS 6079-1:2000

Annex A (informative) A.3 Planning and budgeting


Project management methodology: a) Schedule the authorised work in a manner
cost/schedule control systems criteria which describes the sequence of work and
(C/SCSC)1) identifies the significant task interdependencies
required to meet the development, production
A.1 General and delivery requirements of the contract.
In the 1960s the United States Department of b) Identify physical products, milestones,
Defense introduced 35 principles of good project technical performance goals, or other indicators
management practice to be adopted by government that will be used to measure output.

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


project managers for large scale government
contracts. These cost/schedule control systems c) Establish and maintain a time-phased budget
criteria, known as C/SCSC or C-Spec embody a baseline at the cost account level against which
contract performance can be measured. Initial
methodology aimed at integrating cost, schedule
budgets established for this purpose will be based
and performance measurement data with delivery
on the negotiated target cost. Any other amount
of a product. The criteria describe the attributes of a
used for performance measurement purposes
project management system but do not prescribe the
system itself. should be formally recognized by both the
contractor and the Government.
A number of national governments have adopted
d) Establish budgets for all authorised work with
these criteria as are an increasing number of
separate identification of cost elements (labour,
contractors, particularly within the military
material, etc.).
industrial sector. C/SCSC are also being adopted by
companies outside the military sector. The criteria e) As far as possible identify the authorized work
are quoted as “The contractor’s management control in discrete, short span work packages. Establish
systems shall include policies, procedures and budgets for this work in terms of money, hours, or
methods that are designed to ensure that they will other measurable units. Where the entire cost
accomplish the considerations reflected herein.” account can not be subdivided into detailed work
packages, identify long term effort in larger
A.2 Organisation
planning packages for budget and scheduling
a) Define all authorized work and related purposes.
resources to meet the requirements of the
contract, using the contract work breakdown f) Ensure that the sum of all work package
budgets, plus planning package budgets within a
structure (WBS).
cost account, equals the cost account budget.
b) Identify the internal organizational elements
g) Identify relationships of budgets or standards
and the major subcontractors responsible for
in work authorization systems to budgets for
accomplishing the authorized work.
work packages.
c) Provide for the integration of the contractor’s
planning, scheduling, budgeting, work h) Identify and control level-of-effort activity by
authorization and cost accumulation systems time phased budgets established for this purpose.
Only that effort which cannot be identified as
with each other, the contract work breakdown
discrete, short span work packages or as
structure, and the organizational structure.
apportioned effort may be classed as
d) Identify managerial positions responsible for level-of-effort.
controlling overhead (indirect costs).
i) Establish overhead budgets for the total costs of
e) Provide for the integration of the contract work each significant organizational component, these
breakdown structure with the contractor’s expenses will become indirect costs. Reflect in the
functional organizational structure in a manner contract budgets at the appropriate level the
that permits cost and schedule performance amounts in overhead pools that are planned to be
measurement for contract work breakdown allocated to the contract as indirect costs.
structure and organizational elements.
j) Identify management reserves and
undistributed budget.
k) Provide that the contract target cost plus the
estimated cost of authorized but unpriced work is
reconciled with the sum of all internal contract
budgets and management reserves.

1)
The text of this annex is based upon Part 11, Section B, Attachment 1 of the Department of Defense Instruction
Number 5000.2, dated February 1993 and titled “Defense Acquisition Management Policies and Procedures”.

50 © BSI 01-2000
Annex A BS 6079-1:2000

A.4 Accounting A.5 Analysis


a) Record direct costs, on an applied or other a) At the cost account level on a monthly basis
acceptable basis, in a manner consistent with the using data from, or reconcilable with, the
budgets in a formal system that is controlled by accounting system:
the general books of account. 1) compare budgeted cost for work scheduled
b) Summarize direct costs from cost accounts into and budgeted cost of work performed;
the work breakdown structure without allocation 2) compare budgeted cost for work performed
of a single cost account to two or more work and actual (applied where appropriate) direct
breakdown structure elements. costs for the same work; and
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

c) Summarize direct costs from the cost accounts 3) identify variances resulting from the
into the contractor’s functional organizational comparisons between the budgeted cost for
elements without allocation of a single cost work scheduled and the budgeted cost for work
account to two or more organisational elements. performed and between the budgeted cost for
d) Record all indirect costs which will be allocated work performed and actual or applied direct
to the contract. costs, classified in terms of labour, material, or
e) Identify the basis for allocating the cost of other appropriate elements together with the
apportioned effort. reasons for significant variances.
f) Identify unit costs, equivalent unit costs, or lot b) Identify on a monthly basis, in the detail
costs as applicable. needed by management for effective control,
budgeted indirect costs, actual indirect costs, and
g) The contractor’s material accounting system
cost variances with the reasons for significant
will provide for:
variances.
1) accurate cost accumulation and assignment
c) Summarize the data elements and associated
of costs to cost accounts in a manner consistent
variances listed in A.4 g)1) and 2), through the
with the budgets using recognized, acceptable
contractor organization and work breakdown
costing techniques;
structure to the reporting level specified in the
2) determination of price variances by contract.
comparing planned versus actual
d) Identify significant differences on a monthly
commitments;
basis between planned and actual schedule
3) cost performance measurement at the point accomplishment and the reasons.
in time most suitable for the category of
e) Identify managerial actions taken as a result of
material involved, but no earlier than the time
criteria items in A.4 a) to A.4 d).
of actual receipt of material;
f) Based on performance to date, on commitment
4) determination of cost variances attributable
values for material, and on estimates of future
to the excess usage of material;
conditions, develop revised estimates of cost at
5) determination of unit or lot costs when completion for work breakdown structure
applicable. elements identified in the contract. Compare
6) full accountability for all material these with the contract budget base and the latest
purchased for the contract including the estimate of funds requirement reported to the
residual inventory. Government.

© BSI 01-2000 51
BS 6079-1:2000 Annex A

A.6 Revisions and access to data d) Prevent revisions to the contract budget base
a) Incorporate contract changes expeditiously, except for Government directed changes to
recording the effects of such changes on budgets contractual effort.
and schedules. In the directed effort prior to e) Document internally the changes to the
negotiation of a change, base such revisions on performance measurement baseline and notify
the amount estimated and budgeted to the expeditiously the procuring activity through
functional organizations. prescribed procedures.
b) Reconcile original budgets for those elements f) Provide the contracting officer and the
of the work breakdown structure identified as contracting officer’s authorized representatives

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


priced line items in the contract, and for those with access to the information and supporting
elements at the lowest level in the programme documentation necessary to demonstrate
work breakdown structure, with current compliance with the cost/schedule control
performance measurement budgets in terms of systems criteria.
changes to the authorized work and internal
re-planning in the detail needed by management
for effective control.
c) Prohibit retroactive changes to records
pertaining to work performed that would change
previously reported amounts for direct costs,
indirect costs, or budgets, except for correction of
errors and routine accounting adjustments.

52 © BSI 01-2000
BS 6079-1:2000

List of references

Normative references

BSI publications
BRITISH STANDARDS INSTITUTION, London

BS 3811:1993, Glossary of terms used in terotechnology.


BS 4335:1987, Glossary of terms used in project network techniques.
BS 7000, Design management systems.
Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI

BS 7000-10:1995, Glossary of terms used in design management.


BS EN ISO 8402:1995, Quality management and quality assurance – Vocabulary.

Informative references

BS 5760, Reliability of systems, equipment and components.


BS 5760-1:1985, Guide to reliability and maintainability programme management.

© BSI 01-2000
BS 6079-1:2000

BSI — British Standards Institution

BSI is the independent national body responsible for preparing British


Standards. It presents the UK view on standards in Europe and at the
international level. It is incorporated by Royal Charter.
Revisions
British Standards are updated by amendment or revision. Users of British
Standards should make sure that they possess the latest amendments or editions.
It is the constant aim of BSI to improve the quality of our products and services.
We would be grateful if anyone finding an inaccuracy or ambiguity while using
this British Standard would inform the Secretary of the technical committee
responsible, the identity of which can be found on the inside front cover.

Licensed Copy: Giorgio Cavalieri, ALSTOM, 29-Aug-00, Uncontrolled Copy. © BSI


Tel: 0181 996 9000. Fax: 0181 996 7400.
BSI offers members an individual updating service called PLUS which ensures
that subscribers automatically receive the latest editions of standards.
Buying standards
Orders for all BSI, international and foreign standards publications should be
addressed to Customer Services. Tel: 0181 996 7000. Fax: 0181 996 7001.
In response to orders for international standards, it is BSI policy to supply the
BSI implementation of those that have been published as British Standards,
unless otherwise requested.
Information on standards
BSI provides a wide range of information on national, European and
international standards through its Library and its Technical Help to Exporters
Service. Various BSI electronic information services are also available which give
details on all its products and services. Contact the Information Centre.
Tel: 0181 996 7111. Fax: 0181 996 7048.
Subscribing members of BSI are kept up to date with standards developments
and receive substantial discounts on the purchase price of standards. For details
of these and other benefits contact Membership Administration.
Tel: 0181 996 7002. Fax: 0181 996 7001.
Copyright
Copyright subsists in all BSI publications. BSI also holds the copyright, in the
UK, of the publications of the international standardization bodies. Except as
permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 no extract may be
reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any
means – electronic, photocopying, recording or otherwise – without prior written
permission from BSI.
This does not preclude the free use, in the course of implementing the standard,
of necessary details such as symbols, and size, type or grade designations. If these
details are to be used for any other purpose than implementation then the prior
written permission of BSI must be obtained.
If permission is granted, the terms may include royalty payments or a licensing
agreement. Details and advice can be obtained from the Copyright Manager.
Tel: 0181 996 7070.

BSI
389 Chiswick High Road
London
W4 4AL

You might also like