You are on page 1of 6

2016 IEEE International Autumn Meeting on Power, Electronics and Computing (ROPEC 2016).

Ixtapa, Mexico

Program for the Detection and Diagnosis of Broken Rotor


Bars in Squirrel-Cage Motors
Alejandro Villegas-Ortega, Tomás I. Asiaín-Olivares, Daniel Ruiz-Vega
Graduate Program in Electrical Engineering, SEPI-ESIME-Zacatenco
Instituto Politécnico Nacional.
Ciudad de México, México
avillegasortega7@gmail.com, yeriak1@yahoo.com.mx, drv_liege@yahoo.com

Abstract— This paper presents the implementation and


application of different methodologies for assessing the state of
the squirrel-cage rotor of induction motors, using a digital
embedded system programmed for this purpose. Also, an index is
proposed in order to detect the early degradation of the rotor
through the Wavelet Transform. The detection and evaluation of
the rotor’s health is carried out by a program developed for this
end by the authors. By means of the user interface, the method
for processing the start-up armature current is selected by the
operator. The program is tested considering a series of operation
conditions, including: steady and transient conditions. On the
former, the classical approach with the aid of the Fast Fourier
Transform (FFT) is applied, while in the latter the program Fig. 1 Curve representing different stages of the lifetime of an induction
utilizes both, the Short-Time Fourier Transform and the Wavelet machine.
Transform. Acceptable results are obtained using the techniques
mentioned above for both, steady and transient conditions. The new techniques based on the signal processing of the armature
program outputs not just graphical results, also quantifies the current, by means of recording different operation conditions.
level of fault by means of proposed rotor condition indexes; the
results were obtained through laboratory tests using motors with The latest advances on this end, points toward developing
different deterioration levels on the rotor. an automatic condition monitoring, where the intervention of
an operator is not required. Recently, artificial intelligence
Keywords— Motor Signature Current Armature Analysis, tools have been applied in the condition monitoring field such
induction motors, digital signal processing, rotor’s failure as expert systems, neural networks and fuzzy logic; they are
diagnosis, sidebands, Wavelet Transform, Short-Time Fourier applied for performing diagnosis tasks within a digital system
Transform. dedicated to the condition monitoring purpose [2]. Condition
monitoring systems are aimed at increasing both, uptime and
I. INTRODUCTION performance of machines while reducing consequential
damages.
The motor current signature analysis has taken an important
relevance since the utilization of induction machines had been
expanded over the last decades, on several industrial appliances II. SIGNAL PROCESSING TOOLS FOR
[1]. The curve representing the lifetime of an induction THE EVALUATION OF BROKEN BARS
machine is shown on Fig. 1; in this figure the zone of In this section, a brief introduction about the transforms
acceptable operation is grayed out. After this stage, the used to determine the deterioration of the rotor bars on
machine must be subjected to some kind of predictive induction squirrel-cage motors will be presented. As it is
maintenance, as indicated in Fig. 1, with the first point marked known, the Fourier Transform (FT) has numerous applications
on white. If the maintenance process is not carried out, the in the fields of pure and applied mathematics, physics and
deterioration process evolves, leading to a critical failure on the engineering; however, the FT has limitations related to the
machine. At this point, the lifetime curve will reach the stage temporal location or the time evolution of the signal of
with the point marked on red on Fig. 1, leading to a major interest [3].
maintenance process with several economic losses.
Regarding the wavelet transform, wavelet word is used to
The developed program focuses on the predictive describe a small wave. Wavelets have been created to represent
maintenance stage marked with the first point in white on Fig. functions in a more accurately and detailed way in the time-
1, its objective is to detect failures of rotor bars on early frequency plane. Wavelets are generated with a single function
deterioration stages. This is reached through the application of called mother wavelet, by means of displacement and
dilation [3].

978-1-5090-3794-0/16/$31.00 ©2016 IEEE


2016 IEEE International Autumn Meeting on Power, Electronics and Computing (ROPEC 2016). Ixtapa, Mexico

Before the development of the wavelet transform, an The DWT carries out a multiresolution analysis of the input
analysis window of a certain length was used as a relatively signal; this means that, through the discrete changes of the a
straightforward solution to the problem of location in time. and b parameters on (3), the input signal is decomposed into
This window slides through the signal under study, in the dual frequency bands. This is the principal reason why the
direction of the time axis, with the aim of performing a FT analysis of the sidebands of an armature current signal through
localized in time. This method is called Short-Time Fourier the DWT is convenient, besides requiring less computing time
Transform (STFT). The STFT, performs a Fast Fourier than the STFT.
Transform (FFT) every τ time, in a predefined window on the
function x(t); as a result of this procedure, a surface showing To carry out the implementation of the DWT into the
the spectrum (flat frequency-magnitude) versus time is program of evaluation of broken bars, it is necessary to
obtained. The STFT is defined as shown in (1). represent the a and b coefficients in matrix form. These
matrices represent a low- and a high-pass filter (matrices G and


H, respectively) of the input signal f. Fig. 2 shows the
STFT ( ,f)  x, g , f  x(t ) g*, f (t ) dt
application of the aforementioned filters G and H on each


(1)
decomposition level; a sub-sampling by a factor of 2 is
 x(t   )e j 2 ft dt
performed, since this reduces the array size by half on every
The equation (1) can be seen as a measure of similarity level of decomposition; A detailed explanation of this
between the signal x(t) and frequency modulated function f(t) algorithm can be found in [7].
at window function g(t), shifted every τ time. In the case of this In addition, Fig. 2 represents the proposed methodology by
study, to identify the evolution of the sidebands during engine I. Daubechies, this process constructs an orthogonal filter bank.
start, it is necessary to have a high resolution FFT in terms of Such filters and the coefficients vector of the dilation equation
time and frequency. A high resolution is desirable because the defines the orthonormal base Wavelet, with acceptable
signal components have a better separation between them, but approximation properties [8]. Additionally, there exists dbn
in the STFT, resolutions cannot be chosen arbitrarily at the Wavelets that satisfies the mentioned characteristics in [7] and
same time, according to the uncertainty principle [4]. The that are computed using a recursive pyramidal-type algorithm
product of frequency and time resolution is bounded by a as detailed in [9]. The present work uses up to a 14th order
minimum value as shown in (2). Wavelet (db14), however, the same implemented code can be
1 used with any n order Wavelet.
  f  (2)
4
In addition to the above limitation, the resolutions of time
and frequency should be adjusted depending on the signal to be
analyzed, prior to being processed, thus, the particularities of
each signal must be known before the analysis. In particular, if
a high frequency resolution is chosen, details of the evolution
of the signal would be lost, because the time resolution would
be low; in the same way, if a high resolution in time is chosen,
losses in frequency bands of the signal will be present [5]. This
paper, proposes to apply an appropriate balance between
frequency and time resolutions for the analyzed signals. This
setting will be explained in detail in the section IV presenting
the results obtained by means of the STFT. Furthermore, with
the above analysis, the implementation of a software tool Fig. 2 J-Step decomposition using the DWT for a signal f.
which deploys a method that overcomes the limitations of the
FT and the STFT is proposed; this is achieved by employing A different approach for the detected level of deterioration,
the Wavelet Transform. based on the Wavelet Transform, is proposed and
implemented. This classification takes on account the
In order to implement the Discrete Wavelet Transform into Euclidian norm (L2) used with the purpose of obtaining the
the program, the parameters a and b are discretized from the energy present on each of the decomposition signals [6].
Continuous Wavelet Transform equation [6]. The DWT
implementation is shown on (3). The decomposition signal values are normalized using

 aJ ,k  J ,k ( x)   bJ ,k  J ,k ( x)
J some reference value (in this case the peak current during the
f ( x)  (3) start-up of the motor is used). Also, the norm is multiplied by a
kZ j 1 kZ
factor k, such that k<1. The equation (4) shows the modified
Euclidian norm used to quantify the level of deterioration on
where:
the rotor bars.
a J ,k represents the approximation coefficients.
bJ ,k represents the detail coefficients.  X 2
X1
2
X n 1 
2

 J , k ( x) represents the dilation function. X k  0    (4)


 I rms I rms I rms 
 
 J ,k ( x) represents the Wavelet function.
2016 IEEE International Autumn Meeting on Power, Electronics and Computing (ROPEC 2016). Ixtapa, Mexico

Irms is the rms value of the input signal during the tests. It related to the Wavelet Transform; the first one consists of the
should be noted that the dc value of the signal could be used selected approximation signal, which can be controlled from
instead the rms value, as is shown in [10]. the user interface (UI), and the nine subsequent signals are the
ones computed from the first one by the wavelet transform.
III. DESCRIPTION OF THE DEVELOPED SOFTWARE TOOL The signal under analysis is displayed on the top, along with
the configuration parameters. The frequency range of these
The main objective of the developed software tool is to signals is determined by (5); the software shows, by means of
implement and apply the diagnosis of rotor's broken bars with this equation, the corresponding frequency range for each one
different processing signal methods, in order to obtain a of the decomposition signals. Both, the detailed and the
reliable diagnosis regarding to the health of the rotor from decomposition signals are properly labeled. The tests reported
squirrel-cage induction machines. As for the software tool on this paper takes into account the number of decomposition
both, the graphical interface and the code, were implemented levels recommended in [13]. In general, one must be able to
using the graphical-programming language LabVIEW®. In decompose the original signal in at least two levels, under the
order to use the software, the user should select a binary file main frequency of the input signal; in this work 10 levels of
from the test on the first screen; this file is created during the decomposition were selected, and thus the main signal
tests by the real-time monitoring software developed for frequency is found on the decomposition signal 8, leaving two
monitoring electric machinery, specially synchronous decomposition signals and one approximation signal for the
generators in [11]. This system has the capability to acquire the appreciation of the left sideband evolution, during the motor's
terminal current and voltage of the induction machine, thus start-up. The developed program computes the frequency band
obtaining a wider and detailed analysis of the machine’s ranges of the decomposition signals trough (5); this expression
dynamics as reported on [12]. The system encompasses a set of is function of fs which represents the sampling frequency [14],
sensors to acquire voltage signals proportional to the three- and j and n represent the decomposition and approximation
phase voltages and currents, and the rotor position of the levels respectively.
induction machine. Using the data acquired, the system
f j   2   f s , 2 j f s  , an  0, 2   f s 
computes: rms values, active, reactive and apparent power,  j 1  n 1
   
(5)
energy consumption, harmonic decomposition, slip, angular
velocity, frequency, as stated in [11]. In this respect, the signal Three frequency bands below the fundamental frequency
from an encoder is also registered by the monitoring system. are displayed on the user interface as shown in Fig. 3. The
This signal is used to determine, with a high degree of decomposition signals d10 and d9 with the approximation
precision, the speed of the shaft in order to compute the signal a10 are shown. The characteristic behavior of the left
sidebands location by the classical FFT analysis [12]. sideband in a damaged rotor is marked with a red line. This
The graphical user interface is composed, as seen in Fig. 3, behavior is well documented and, in general, consists as
by three main tabs: the first two are the Wavelet and STFT follows: on the motor's start-up, the frequency of the left
analysis options, while the last one corresponds to the classical sideband is the fundamental frequency; during the transient
FFT approach. Regarding the first tab, 10 signals are shown period, this frequency decreases to a near-zero frequency value,
and finally, on steady state, the frequency goes back to the

Fig. 3 User interface of the software tool during a test of a 6 broken-bars rotor.
2016 IEEE International Autumn Meeting on Power, Electronics and Computing (ROPEC 2016). Ixtapa, Mexico

fundamental frequency. The described process analyzes the


start-up of an unloaded induction motor; however, using the
methodology described above, acceptable results can be
obtained when analyzing the motor start-up with different
mechanical loads.
As for the user interface layout on the Wavelet Transform
tab, for the motor’s start-up, it is shown in the bottom right part
of the window, the location of the selected data file, in addition
to an alarm called Read Error which is activated if the data file
does not meet the requirements to be used by the main
program. It is important to note that, in a predefined way, the
processing tool palette in LabVIEW® allows to use up to a 14-
order Daubechies Wavelet (db14); however, this parameter
(Mother Wavelet) can be processed by another program on any
programming language and uploaded to this program in order
to obtain higher-order Wavelet results.
The obtained results when (4) is applied, are shown through Fig. 6 Approximation signals (a10) for the different tests performed.
a cluster containing up to 10 data (which corresponds to the
same amount of graphs to display the decomposition levels) on
the UI. The data arrangement is the same as the graphs shown IV. TESTS AND RESULTS
on Fig. 3 (an, dn,..., dn-1). In order to test the developed program, two motors were
It is important for the user to identify the band where the used; the first one with no broken bars and the second one with
fundamental frequency is located, to allow the decomposition a deterioration of the rotor, consisting of 6 and 7 drilled broken
signals of the characteristic pattern, present when a bar on the bars. The tests performed, consisted on recording the steady
rotor is broken, can be displayed below the one containing the state and transient operation of each one of the cases described
fundamental frequency. In order to accomplish this, the FFT is above. The main characteristics of the motors tested are:
computed over the entire test, thus obtaining the fundamental power, 5 HP; voltage, 220/440 V; current, 15.6 / 7.8 A; rated
frequency; this value is then used, along with a comparison speed: 1723 rpm; 48 bars in the rotor. In the tests performed,
function, to determine which detail signal falls into the range of the sampling frequency is fixed to 20.4 kHz per signal
the fundamental frequency. The implemented function called acquired. The tests procedure consists of recording the
Level Detect, needs as an input, the frequency ranges armature current during the motor startup with a 60% of the
computed for every detailed and approximation signal along rated terminal voltage, in order to prevent that the startup
with the fundamental frequency from the FFT computation; transient transposes the sidebands evolution. The fundamental
this function highlights the detailed signal where the frequency of 60 Hz is observed in the detailed signal d8 using
fundamental frequency is present, as shown in Fig. 4, allowing the selected sampling frequency to acquire the signals,
the user recognize the aforementioned characteristic v-shape however the function implemented may obtain satisfactory
pattern. results using any sampling frequency, or processing a signal of
different frequency. The total time (start-up time) was 7
The first method by which the user can detect a failure is, seconds for the tests performed in this section.
as mentioned before, the recognition of the v-shape pattern of
at least three decomposition signals, below the one containing Firstly, the results of the Wavelet Transform option of the
the fundamental frequency. The second method consists of start-up transient condition, for the three cases studied, i.e.
reviewing the proposed indexes to quantify the level of
deterioration of the rotor’s bars.

Fig. 4 Detail and approximation signals for the start-up current of the healthy
rotor condition test. Fig. 5 Computed indexes for the tests performed.
2016 IEEE International Autumn Meeting on Power, Electronics and Computing (ROPEC 2016). Ixtapa, Mexico

healthy rotor, 6 broken bars rotor, 7 broken bars rotor are


presented. On Fig. 6, the level-10 approximation signals are
displayed. Note that the behavior on this graph, showing the
frequency band corresponding to [0, 9.965] Hz interval, is the
expected one for the healthy rotor test. This can be stated
because there are no significant oscillations on the central part
of the graph. On the other hand, the six broken bars rotor test
presents significant oscillations, as well as the one with the
seven broken bars. In addition to the characteristics described,
on Fig. 6, the approximation signals display oscillations on the
final part of the test; this is a non-desirable response because of
its contribution on the computed indexes; on [15] this problem
is addressed.
The indexes values obtained through the developed program
for the healthy rotor are considered as the reference values for Fig. 8 Spectrogram corresponding to the test of 6 broken bars rotor condition.
the following tests. On Fig. 5, the computed indexes are
displayed for the purpose of visualizing these data. The indexes not to cut the original current signal, to avoid processing
for the healthy rotor tests tend to increase on magnitude along unnecessary portions of the signal. Once the configuration
with the number of broken bars; moreover, the gap between the parameters are ready, the program outputs results, that include:
indexes from the 6 broken bars and the 7 seven broken bars the spectrogram corresponding to the STFT, the magnitude of
tests tends to be proportional to the number of broken bars the transformation is represented on the z-axis, the frequency
present on the rotor as seen on Fig. 5. This behavior confirms on the y-axis and the time on the x-axis. In addition to the
the usefulness of the proposed indexes for monitoring spectrogram, the software tool displays additional data on the
purposes; the proposed method intends to use the computed UI: type of window used to perform the FFT, frequency
indexes as it follows: first, a reference value is computed on the resolution, slide steps, adjustment of the z-axis and the colors
current motor condition, whether healthy or not. Secondly, a map configuration of the spectrogram.
periodic or on-line monitoring of the start-up current has to be It is important to note that the same data used for the
scheduled and keep a record of the program results. When a Wavelet analysis can be used for the STFT analysis as well.
predefined threshold is reached, predictive maintenance should When a healthy rotor is analyzed, the v-shape pattern is not
be performed. The next value (threshold) of the index that is visible, as shown in the spectrogram of Fig. 7. This type of
expected to occur when a new rotor bar is broken, is indicated analysis searches for a particular pattern on the magnitude of
by a yellow-dashed line in Fig. 5, and is computed considering the frequency bands on the spectrogram. This pattern is known
the gap between two failures. as a v-shape pattern; in case of broken bars present on the rotor,
Besides Wavelet Transform, the program allows to the aforementioned pattern should appear right under the band
compute the STFT using the same start-up data, with the corresponding to the fundamental frequency, as seen on Fig. 8.
purpose of obtaining an analysis and diagnose of the state of The characteristic pattern depends, as indicated in [16], [17],
the machine's rotor. As previously exposed, the general [13], among others, on the particular evolution of the left side
description of this transformation consists on applying the FT band. As stated before, the frequency of the left side band at
on a sliding window of the input signal. In the configuration the beginning of the start-up equals the frequency of the power
options of this part of the program, the user needs to input the supply (slip=0), when the slip reaches a value of 0.5, the left
following parameters: the length window in terms of time, the side band frequency falls to a near-zero value; finally, on
sliding time, and the resolution of the FFT in terms of samples. steady state, the left side frequency reaches again the value of
Once the user inputs this data, the program requests whether or the power supply. The evolution of the left side band was
identified on the spectrograms for both, the tests of 6 and 7
broken bars; only the results for the healthy and 6 broken bars
conditions are presented on the following paragraphs.
On Fig. 7 the spectrogram obtained for the healthy rotor
test is shown. Note that the red-colored lines represent, on the
z-axis, the magnitude of the current, along the time axis on a
frequency band, on rms values. At least three red lines are
present: the first one corresponding to the fundamental
frequency of the 60 Hz power supply represents the greater
energy concentration. Also the fifth and seventh harmonics
(300 and 420 Hz respectively) are present on the spectrogram.
The configuration data requested by the program were set to:
FT length: 8192 samples, sliding-window time: 17 ms,
frequency bands: 48611. These data remain fixed for the
following tests, and offer an adequate resolution in time and
Fig. 7 Spectrogram corresponding to the test of the healthy rotor condition. frequency, as seen on the reported spectrograms (see Fig. 7,
2016 IEEE International Autumn Meeting on Power, Electronics and Computing (ROPEC 2016). Ixtapa, Mexico

Fig. 8). However, the program allows changing the described in this work. Funding from CONACyT in project
configuration parameters at any time, for further tests on 83701 is also gratefully acknowledged.
different motors. The spectrogram obtained for the start-up
corresponding to the rotor with 6 broken bars is presented on VII. REFERENCES
Fig. 8. The frequency axis adjustment was set to a maximum [1] M. R. Mehrjou, N. Mariun, M. Hamiruce Marhaban, and N. Misron,
value of 540 Hz in order to appreciate the v-shaped pattern "Rotor fault condition monitoring techniques for squirrel-cage
induction machine—A review," Mechanical Systems and Signal
which is present below the fundamental frequency. The Processing, vol. 25, pp. 2827-2848, 2011.
characteristic evolution of the left sideband was found on the
[2] G. K. Singh and S. a. Ahmed Saleh Al Kazzaz, "Induction machine
tests for the 6 and 7 broken bars; as it is seen on Fig. 8, the drive condition monitoring and diagnostic research—a survey,"
pattern is highlighted on the spectrogram with a black-dashed Electric Power Systems Research, vol. 64, pp. 145-158, 2003.
line with the corresponding label. At this point, the user should [3] R. S. Pathak and SpringerLink, The Wavelet Transform vol. 4.
notice that a failure on the rotor is present. The left sideband Dordrecht: Springer-Verlag, 2009.
begins at a value of frequency close to the fundamental [4] L. Cohen, "Time-frequency distributions-a review," Proceedings of the
frequency, at approximately 3.4 seconds, the value of the left IEEE, vol. 77, pp. 941-981, 1989.
sideband frequency reaches a value near to zero and, finally at [5] R. X. Gao, R. Yan, and SpringerLink, "Wavelets: Theory and
6 seconds, the value of the left sideband frequency reaches Applications for Manufacturing," vol. 1., ed. Boston, MA: Springer
US, 2011.
again the frequency of the power supply. Note that the start-up
of the motor is carried on unloaded; this indicates through the [6] D. P. Radunovic, Wavelets: From Math to Practice vol. 1. Aufl. DE:
Springer-Verlag, 2009.
classic approach of sidebands, that the sidebands are
[7] H.-G. Stark, Wavelets and Signal Processing: An Application-Based
superimposed to the fundamental frequency band, because the Introduction. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2005.
slip has a near-zero value. [8] A. la Cour-Harbo and A. Jensen, Ripples in Mathematics: The Discrete
In the spectrogram presented in Fig. 8, the bands Wavelet Transform. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg,
2001.
corresponding to the fifth and seventh harmonic components
[9] S. Mallat, A wavelet tour of signal processing vol. 2nd. Orlando, Fl:
are shown on the 300 Hz and 420 Hz bands respectively. On Academic, 1999.
the other hand, the presence of the right side band begins its [10] A. Nasiri, J. Poshtan, M. H. Kahaei, and F. Taringoo, "Wavelet Packet
evolution on the 3fs (180 Hz) band, it reaches a value that is Decomposition as a proper method for fault detection in three phase
superimposed to the main frequency band. This behavior is induction motor," ed, 2004, pp. 13-18.
proposed in [13] as a complementary diagnosis in monitoring [11] A. Villegas-Ortega, "Design and Implementation of a Supervisory and
sidebands in the rotor. Is important to note that both, the left Data Acquisition System for Generators of a Experimental Laboratory
and right sideband can be detected by the developed software. Simulator," Thesis to obtain Master's Degree on Electrical Engineering,
Escuela Superior de Ingeniería Mecánica y Eléctrica, Programas de
In this type of analysis, an index to quantify the level of failure Posgrado en Ingeniería Eléctrica, Instituto Politécnico Nacional,
has not been programmed yet; this implementation is proposed México, D.F., 2015.
to be included in future upgrades on the software tool. [12] P. V. De Mata-Castrejón, A. Villegas-Ortega, T. I. Asiaín-Olivares, and
D. Ruiz-Vega, "Evaluation of progressive deterioration of a squirrel-
V. CONCLUSIONS cage rotor, with a condition monitoring system that implements the
sideband methodology," in 2015 IEEE International Autumn Meeting
A revision of some of the latest methods for the Transient on Power, Electronics and Computing (ROPEC), 2015, pp. 1-6.
Motor Current Signature Analysis (TMCSA) has been [13] J. Antonino-Daviu, P. Jover, M. Riera-Guasp, A. Arkkio, and M.
presented. The implementation of this method was also Pineda-Sánchez, "Complementary diagnosis of rotor asymmetries
performed, using a specialized software tool. Monitoring through the tracing of the Right Sideband Component in the stator
startup current," Proceedings of the 2008 International Conference on
techniques for the quantification of rotor broken bars have been Electrical Machines, pp. 1-6, 2008.
proposed as well; this is achieved through the implementation [14] J. A. Antonino-Daviu, M. Riera-Guasp, J. R. Folch, and M. P. Molina
of indexes along with the Wavelet Transform. A method is also Palomares, "Validation of a new method for the diagnosis of rotor bar
proposed to use the mentioned indexes. The main feature of the failures via wavelet transform in industrial induction machines," IEEE
proposed indexes is based on the determination of the Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. 42, pp. 990-996, 2006.
magnitude of the gap between the decomposition and [15] B. M. Ebrahimi, J. Faiz, S. Lotfi-Fard, and P. Pillay, "Novel indices for
approximation signals; when a considerable gap exists, one broken rotor bars fault diagnosis in induction motors using wavelet
transform," Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, vol. 30, pp.
may determine that there exists a failure on the bars of the 131-145, 2012.
rotor. However, it is important for future works, determine the [16] V. Climente-Alarcon, J. A. Antonino-Daviu, F. Vedreno-Santos, and R.
magnitude’s gap under different tests, i.e. to carry on tests with Puche-Panadero, "Vibration Transient Detection of Broken Rotor Bars
motors of different ratings. In this case it is necessary to by PSH Sidebands," IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol.
implement statistical functions (standard deviation, variance, 49, pp. 2576-2582, 2013.
covariance) to verify the usefulness of the proposed indexes. [17] F. Briz, M. W. Degner, P. Garcia, and D. Bragado, "Broken Rotor Bar
Detection in Line-Fed Induction Machines Using Complex Wavelet
Analysis of Startup Transients," IEEE Transactions on Industry
VI. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Applications, vol. 44, pp. 760-768, 2008.
The first author thanks the Instituto Politécnico Nacional
(IPN) for the doctorate’s scholarship, plus the resources of the
research project 1734, which were necessary to acquire the
components that were used to implement the equipment

You might also like