Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CTBUH - Frontiers in High-Rise Outrigger Design PDF
CTBUH - Frontiers in High-Rise Outrigger Design PDF
org/papers
Subjects: Seismic
Structural Engineering
Wind Engineering
Keywords: Outriggers
Seismic
Structural Engineering
Wind
© Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat / Hi Sun Choi; Leonard Joseph; SawTeen See; Rupa Garai
Structural Engineering
CTBUH
In 2012, CTBUH published the first Outrigger Design for
Technica
The Coun
has addr cil on Tall Build CTBUH
with this
essed the ing and
Urban Habi Technical
l Guides
guide, nowpressing need Guides
overview in its for desig tat’s Outrigge
n r
recomme of the use of outrisecond edition, guidelines for Working Grou
providing outrigger p
systems ndations for analy ggers in skysc a com systems
of rapers.
behavior tall buildings, sis of outrigger This guid prehensive
Outrigge
and for e
to the outri for practical recognizing s within the later offers detailed
and
and cons gger structural design solutions. addressing al load
resisting
the use
truction
sequ
system It also high effects on
of ence impa such as diffe light building
r Design
trusses, “hybrid” outri cts. In this rential colu s concerns
use lever gger mn shor specific
devices, age of the systems that edition, a new tening
and use can “tun chap
“yielding outrigger arms e” the stiffn ter explores
” materials to drive ess of outri
for High
Outrigger Working Group felt it would be beneficial to
Several that abso non-
outrigger
project
examples rb seism linear damping gger
are expl ic energy.
projects. systems in tall ored in
The guid building depth,
designs, e designs illustratin
-Rise Buil
and dem details the impa and g the
advancin
g
onstrates ct of outri providing idea role of
world. The to improve the ways in whic gger s for futur
efficiency h the tech systems on tall e
reflect currenew second and stab nology build
editi is continuo ing
dings
updated nt prac on featu ility of tall
recomme tices, Expanded res updated usly
2nd Edit
Hi Sun for futur examples, to
Choi e resea and
experienc is a Senior rch.
Principal
of build e in structural at
ing type analysis, Thornton Tom
ion
s, including inves asett
Dr. Gom commerc tigation, desig i with over 20
ial and n, years of
an Ho is residentia and review of
ise Buil r
dings
information on recently developed outrigger systems
An output
Outrigg
er2ndE
dition_
of the CTB
Cover_
UH Out
2nd Ed
mocku
p.indd
1 rigger Wo
Hi Sun
Choi, Gom
rking Gro
up ition
an Ho, Leon
ard Jose
ph & Nevi
Leonard M. Joseph, Principal “Stiffness Effects from Overall Systems” is a The effect of building taper is also discussed.
Thornton Tomasetti
707 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 4450 newly added section of the Technical Guide, For a building that tapers narrower with
Los Angeles, CA 90017 which discusses outrigger interactions with height, compared to a straight building of the
United States
t: +1 949 271 3320 complex architectural forms such as twisted, same total floor area, there are smaller wind
f: +1 949 271 3301 tilted, and tapered shapes, now common and seismic loads imposing on the building
www.thorntontomasetti.com
trends in contemporary tall building design. structure below thanks to reduced upper-floor
SawTeen See, Managing Partner For practicality, such designs utilize a vertical footprints and wind tributary “sail” areas, a
Leslie E. Robertson Associates core located within the building envelope relatively wider base, and reduced outrigger
40 Wall Street, 23rd Fl.
New York, NY 10005 for most of the height, with outriggers used arm lengths at the building top. The benefits
United States where the core alone provides insufficient are more pronounced for taller towers.
t: +1 212 750 9000
f: +1 212 750 9002 lateral strength or stiffness. A key point here
e: sawteen.see@lera.com is that the stiffness contribution of the
www.lera.com
outrigger system will be affected by overall Hybrid Outrigger Systems
Rupa Garai, Associate Director building geometry. Unlike a straight tower
Skidmore, Owings & Merrill LLP with a central core and symmetrical Another new chapter discusses innovative
1 Front Street
San Francisco, CA 94111 outriggers to perimeter columns at each hybrid outrigger systems. While traditional
United States side, in a tilted structure, outriggers can be outrigger systems sustain maximum forces
t: +1 415 352 6847
f: +1 415 398 3214 asymmetrical and have varying lengths. A when the building is experiencing maximum
e: rupa.garai@som.com second point is that tilted structures have lateral displacements, hybrid outrigger
www.som.com
inherent lateral displacements due to the systems can exhibit different relationships.
destabilization effect of gravity loads alone, Several examples of hybrid outrigger systems
which should be expected. Surprisingly, a are presented.
study shows that lateral displacements of
tilted structures under wind loads can be less Damped outriggers
than those of an equivalent straight tower, if The most significant of these, damped
a beneficial stiffening effect of triangulation outrigger systems use the leverage of stiff
outrigger arms projecting from a building columns in tall structures can be leveraged to A damped outrigger system disengages the
core to efficiently drive nonlinear damping yield supplemental damping by introducing outrigger elements (reinforced concrete walls
devices. The resulting supplementary vertically mounted dampers between the or steel trusses cantilevered from the core)
damping can significantly reduce tall building outrigger ends and the perimeter column from the floor framing at their top and bottom
accelerations, deformations, and forces from (Smith and Willford 2007). These movements edges and from the perimeter columns. This
vortex-induced oscillations (VIO) in wind, or are proportional to the lateral drift of the makes it possible to generate relative vertical
reduce building deformations and structural structure and can typically be of relatively movements between the outrigger ends and
demands in earthquakes. Supplementary small magnitude, particularly in wind events. the adjacent perimeter columns when a
damping can take the form of viscous Mechanisms can be utilized to amplify these structure is subjected to seismic and wind
dampers, viscoelastic dampers, tuned mass relatively small vertical movements to loads; the drift displacements/velocities can
dampers (TMDs), tuned liquid column potentially increase supplementary damping. be captured to generate supplementary
dampers (TLCDs), or sloshing dampers. But A concept for one such mechanism – where damping. To increase the efficacy of a
mechanically damped outriggers can provide the damper movement and velocity are damped outrigger system and create large
supplementary damping contributions amplified, thus increasing the supplemental velocities that would generate increased
comparable to a TMD or TLCD without the damping in the structure – was described by damping, the use of a mechanism has been
attendant space, weight, or tuning Mathias et al. (2016). proposed (see Figure 3). The geometric
requirements.
Another example is a concrete outrigger System Organization and Examples Grand Center was completed in 2017 (see
system with a structural fuse link. A steel Figure 8). Since the floor plan and reinforced
plate “shear link” element makes the final Mixed steel-concrete core and outrigger concrete core plan are elongated, three sets
connection from concrete outrigger tip to systems are now separated into two systems: of outriggers connect the core to 10 of the
the perimeter column. By sizing it to remain elastic and yielding outrigger systems. The perimeter concrete-filled steel box columns
elastic under wind loads, the outrigger 335-meter tall Wilshire Grand Center in Los to supplement core transverse stiffness for
provides desired building lateral stiffness and Angeles and Chongqing Raffles City in China, occupant comfort, help resist transverse
overturning resistance contributions, but can consisting of eight towers, the two tallest of overturning under strength-level winds, and
yield during a large seismic event (see which are 354 meters, are added as examples absorb energy in seismic events. Multistory
Figures 6 and 7). Damaged shear-link of mixed steel-concrete core and yielding steel belt trusses occur at two of the three
elements could be replaced after major outrigger system. The Lotte World Tower in outrigger levels to distribute transverse
seismic events, and shear-link connections Seoul is an example of an elastic system. The overturning forces across all columns,
could be delayed during construction to project features are summarized below. enforce similar shortening at all the
reduce gravity force transfers from perimeter columns, and provide “virtual
differential core and column shortening. Yielding outrigger system outrigger” assistance for longitudinal
Wilshire Grand Center, Los Angeles overturning forces. BRBs at all outrigger
The 335-meter, 62-story tower of the Wilshire diagonals set reliable upper limits on
Figure 8. Wilshire Grand Center, Los Figure 9. Wilshire Grand Center – isometric Figure 10. Chongqing Raffles City, Chongqing. © Capitaland
Angeles. © Wilshire Grand Center showing outriggers at three levels, belt trusses
not drawn here. © AC Martin
TYP. CJP
WELDMENT
CJP
CASTING
demands at connections, at columns, and in world (see Figure 12). The US$2.5 billion tower
transverse walls where high shear occurs at and adjacent development features a variety
“panel zones” from outrigger action during of uses, including office, retail,
DELAY FINAL CONNECTION
extreme events. The BRBs work elastically hotel, officetel (a combination
Figure 14. Lotte World Tower – outrigger-to-core-wall
under service loads. Demonstration of office/apartment common in
connection. © LERA
satisfactory seismic performance is shown by South Korea), parking,
figures based on nonlinear response history museum, and observation CASTING
analyses at the maximum considered space. CORE WALL
Recurrence Interval level. For maximum are concrete flat slabs with
TYP. CJP
considered events (MCEs), the “fuse” will yield drop panels. The diagrid
in shear, providing energy dissipation while structure at the top of the
limiting the forces applied to concrete building contains premium
outriggers, megacolumns, and their office, museum, and
connections. observation floors, which
are also steel-framed with a
Elastic outrigger system: slab-on-truss deck, and
Lotte World Tower, Seoul forms the exterior portion
BENT PLATE
At 555 meters, the 123-story Lotte World of the “lantern”
Tower stands as the fifth-tallest building in the structure above the Figure 12. Lotte World Figure 16. Lotte World Tower – weldment for outrigger-
Tower, Seoul. © LERA to-core-wall connection. © LERA
differential settlements between the umn, thus reducing the complexities and SMITH, R. J. & WILLFORD, M. R. 2007. “The Damped
perimeter columns and the services core, also eliminating the three-dimensional structural Outrigger Concept for Tall Buildings.” The Structural Design
had to be taken into account. The potential steel connections that would otherwise be of Tall and Special Buildings 16: 501–7.
imbalance of the floor was partly addressed required (see Figure 16).
by vertically cambering the megacolumns
during construction, allowing forces to be
transferred through the outrigger members as Conclusion Editor’s Note:
This research paper
CTBUH
The Council
has address on Tall Building CTBUH
Technical
al Guides
includes outtakes
of of outrigg pers. This guide hensive
behavio tall buildings,
Outrigger
concrete core. The structural engineering The complexity of tall building design
ing
the use ction sequenral system such s. It also highligeffects on buildin g
of ce as differen hts concern g
trusses, “hybrid” outrigg impacts. In this tial
Design
s
devices
use leverag er systems edition column shorten specific
, and use e of the outrigg that can “tune”, a new chapter ing
“yieldin explore
g” materia er arms to drive the stiffness s
for High-R
endatio ed systems
ns and organiz conside the
sugges
tions for ation and rations to
Hi Sun future researcexamples,
Choi is h. and
experie a Senior
Edition
nce Principa
of buildin in structural l at
g types, analysis Thornton Tomase
includin , investig
Outrigger Design
Neville s, and parking s, hangar designe
Mathia s, hotels, d,
Skidmo s, Associa garages
re, te around historic
has workedOwings & Merrill, Director and the world.
extensi speciali Senior Structu
force transfer in the short term, while also requirements intersect with more ambitious
vely on zing ral Enginee
major buildin in perform r at
gs around ance-based seismic
the world
for over design,
Outrigg
30 years.
er Desig
High-R
ise Build n for
designing for the potential force transfer due design and floor-plate-efficiency objectives. for High-Rise
Outrigger2n
dEdition_C
over_mock ings
up.indd
1
Hi Sun
An outpu
Choi, Goman
t of the
CTBUH
Ho, Leonard
Outrigger
Joseph
Working
Group
2nd Edi
tion
Buildings. Get it
& Neville
Mathias