Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Haycock, Laurel A., et al. “Procrastination in College Students: The Role of Self-Efficacy and
Anxiety.” Journal of Counseling & Development, vol. 76, no. 3, Jan. 1998, pp. 317–24.
EBSCOhost,search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eric&AN=EJ573153&authtype=s
hib&site=ehost-live&scope=site.
2. Credibility/ethos of author/organization
Authors are Laurel A. Haycock, Patricia McCarthy, Carol L. Skay. Patricia McCarthy is a
independent statistical consultant in Minnesota. Laurel Haycock is a psychologist. They all have
publications with the topic of counseling, psychology. The publication is Journal of Counseling
& Development, v76 n3 p317-24 Sum 1998. Journal of Counseling & Development is a peer
reviewed journal published on behalf of the American Counseling Association. Targeted for
people interested in counseling psychology and applied psychology. I found this source from the
3. Summary:
The source is based on a study of university students and how procrastination is related to
self-efficacy, anxiety, gender, age, race. Procrastination is more than poor study habits and bad
time management. The authors refer to other research, uses stats, research studies. They used
were rated based on confidence (0-100). The counselor could look at the weak self-efficacy
statistics, numbers, figures, regression analysis. It uses tables to show the summary of the study
variables and how they relate to procrastination. The study results claimed that procrastination
scores were related to self-efficacy and anxiety. The purpose of looking at self-efficacy was to
see if efficacy strength was related to procrastination when other variables were included. They
observed the different efficacy strengths to determine which could predict the strongest level of
procrastination.
4. Does this voice agree/disagree with others you have found? In what ways?
The voices and results from this research study agree with other sources. Procrastination can lead
to anxiety, irritation. Self-efficacy has a role in completing behaviors and behavior avoidance.
“Internal consequences may include irritation, regret, despair, and self blame (Burka & Yen,
1983). External consequences may be costly and can include impaired academic and work
progress, lost opportunities, and strained relationships.” (page number 317, 2nd paragraph)
“As expected, the three measures of efficacy level and strength were significantly and positively
related, as were the state and trait anxiety variables. To examine the relationship between
procrastination and all of the predictor variables of interest, a simultaneous multiple linear
6. Your Analysis/thoughts - can be more casual. How might you use the source in your thesis?
I am interested in using the results from this research method in my thesis. Also, include what
Lieberman, Charlotte. “Why You Procrastinate (It Has Nothing to Do With Self-Control).” The
New York Times, The New York Times, 25 Mar. 2019, www.nytimes.com/2019/03/25/smarter-
living/why-you-procrastinate-it-has-nothing-to-do-with-self-control.html.
2. Credibility/ethos of author/organization
Charlotte Lieberman the author of the article. Her background includes writing about
psychology, mental health. Her articles have been in different publications like The New York
Times, The Harvard Business Review, Cosmopolitan. Lieberman received a bachelor’s degree
from Harvard, majoring in English. The New York Times has a more liberal bias. The New York
Times features all types of news, some being sports, movies, education, travel.
3. Summary
procrastinate depending on the task or situation. Negative things associated with procrastination
include stress, anxiety, low self-esteem. The article mentions entire body of research only
You can manage procrastination by looking at emotions instead of time management and
Procrastination solutions need to be internal, forgive yourself for putting things off. Self-
compassion is another emotional way to help limit procrastination. More healthy ways to manage
triggers of procrastination are to cultivate curiosity, consider the next action, make temptations
more inconvenient. Pathos is used because it talks about specific emotions experienced when you
procrastinate and when you don’t procrastinate. The author uses views from doctors, other
4. Does this voice agree/disagree with others you have found? In what ways?
This voice agreed with others because it spoke about the relation of procrastination and anxiety,
low self-esteem, stress. This article was a little different than others I have seen because the
“When we procrastinate, we’re not only aware that we’re avoiding the task in question, but that
“When faced with a task that makes us feel anxious or insecure, the amygdala — the “threat
detector” part of the brain — perceives that task as a genuine threat, in this case to our self-
esteem or well-being. Even if we intellectually recognize that putting off the task will create
more stress for ourselves in the future, our brains are still wired to be more concerned with
removing the threat in the present. Researchers call this “amygdala hijack.”
6. Your Analysis/thoughts
I really like how this article talked about why people procrastinate. I can add information about
procrastination becoming a cycle that can then lead to a chronic habit. Looking at the
perspectives from psychologist doctors added another view and was very interesting.
Source #3
“At Last, Procrastination.” Wait: the Art and Science of Delay, by Frank Partnoy, PublicAffairs,
2. Credibility/ethos of author/organization
Frank Partnoy is a Professor of Law at UC Berkeley, before that he taught 21 years at the
University of San Diego. B.A./B.S from University of Kansas in 1989 and Juris Doctor degree
from Yale University in 1992. His writing background includes books, articles in various
journals.
3. Summary
This chapter in the book shows positive and negatives to procrastination. Frank Partnoy
used different views from historians, psychologists, economists, neuroscientists. Wrote about
George Akerlof and Joseph Stiglitz, two friends and economists that spent time in India. When
leaving Stiglitz was leaving India he had too many bags and was unable to take them all so
Akerlof sent a box with the stuff later. Akerlof didn’t send the box until 8 months later. The
procrastination wasn’t irrational because Stiglitz didn’t need the clothes instantly, Akerlof got
many more things done while he postponed sending the box. This event formed one of the most
When does putting something off become procrastination. Some say procrastination has
been going on forever, others say it is recent. Pathos is used when talking about procrastination
relating to stress, impatience. Learn how to procrastinate well, manage tasks, form priorities.
Procrastination cannot be done away with altogether. The chapter in the book also talks about a
study done on pigeons and relating procrastination to time inconsistency. FMRI helped scholars
map procrastination and related reactions to different regions of the brain. In this chapter many
different people and their views are mentioned, some include: Earl of Chesterfield; sermons from
Jonathan Edwards; Leonardo da Vinci and Agatha Christie were inveterate procrastinators.
Author Frank Partnoy brings in quotes from articles from the Wall Street Journal. Psychologist
4. Does this voice agree/disagree with others you have found? In what ways?
This source agrees and disagrees with others I found. It has some of the same positives and
negatives to procrastination. One person mentioned in this source was someone that wrote
“Our society is obsessed with productivity and efficiency and we despise procrastination. The
early Americans imported the Earl of Chesterfield’s admonition: “No idleness, no laziness, no
procrastination: never put off till tomorrow what you can do today.” 2
“Studies find that although procrastination is problematic for some people, others can
procrastinate but still get plenty done without stress, coping problems, or low self esteem.”12
“Procrastination has become a hot subfield in economics, but if we asked three economists about
throughout a semester, and the ability to cram for an exam or quickly finish a term paper at the
6. Your Analysis/thoughts
I found great quotes. I am interested to find a way to use those in my thesis. This source was a
great source to summarize both sides of procrastination. One negative thing that people might
not find interesting was the economists side of procrastination because they talked about
procrastination in terms of paying off debt, interest rates. Procrastination being a coping strategy
Source #4
Nic Voge. “Self Worth Theory: The Key to Understanding & Overcoming
2. Credibility/ethos of author/organization
Nic Voge is a senior associate director at Princeton University. He directs McGraw Center
authored Life Beyond Grades: Designing College Courses to Promote Intrinsic Motivation.
Intended audience in this specific video is people attending the TEDx Talk which looks to be
students and faculty from Princenton, and also people watching the video online. The x in TEDx
3. Summary
Nic Voge’s talk is based on a personal experience with procrastination. Didn’t work on
an assignment, earlier. Things get in the way conversations, other classes, lunch. Deep and
motivation roots of procrastination. Nic says procrastination isn’t a flaw, not lazy. College is a
competitive environment, in those circumstances, people will protect themselves for self-worth.
You feel bad about yourself for being behind and not working on something. Not getting
something done is worse than not writing the best paper is what some people think.
motivation, we need to be capable, able, competent. Because that is a primary need we will
sacrifice some needs to meet the overall need. People who are fearful of failure think P-A-W,
this stands for performance equals ability which equals worth. The P-A-W equation is flawed.
Procrastination isn’t just a habit. Pathos is used because he uses a personal experience so you can
truly relate to him and understand what he is saying. Logos is used because he shows models,
graphs. One model shows high&low fear of failure, high&low success orientation. Stuck point
image shows driven by success but motivated to avoid failure. Tip balance from avoidance
4. Does this voice agree/disagree with others you have found? In what ways?
with procrastination.
5. Two or three interesting quotes
“Every person “should strive to learn before they die what they are running from, and to, and
-If we procrastinate something we care about and we fail we have excuses. I only had two hours
“If I don’t start now I won’t get this done. The fear of not getting it done exceeds the fear of
doing less than perfectly or to an exceptional standard or to as good as I did it last time because
those of us who are perfectionists and procrastinate we have often excelled at high levels in the
past we could begin to internalize those standards and feel we must meet them each time.” Nic
Voge
“Motivation can only operate on us if we’re thinking of it or feeling it because that’s the nature
of motivation.”
“Think of all the reasons why I want to do this task” Predominate over reasons you avoid.
“May your choices reflect your hopes, not your fears.” - Nelson Mandela
Approach avoidance motivation theory. Can we be motivated by things we aspire despite the
fears?
6. Your Analysis/thoughts
I like how Nic talked about the relationship between self-worth and procrastination. This source
provided personal experiences that were easy to connect with. I can also use his views on how to
stop procrastination. He expressed that the 3 broad categories for overcoming competing
motivations are to develop awareness, tip the balance, challenge P-A-W beliefs. Make something
small to make it feel manageable. Use his tips to make progress in avoiding procrastination. It is
important to understand procrastination before you can take steps to avoid it.
Source #5
Perry, John. “How to Procrastinate and Still Get Things Done .” The Chronicle, 23 Feb.
1996, www.chronicle.com/article/How-to-ProcrastinateStill/93959.
2. Credibility/ethos of author/organization
John Perry wrote a book titled “The Art of Procrastination: A Guide to Effective Dawdling,
Philosophy at Stanford. His education includes a B.A. from Doane College in 1964 and a Ph.D.
from Cornell University in 1968. The founding date of the Chronicle of Higher Education was
1966. The Chronicle of Higher Education includes news, information geared toward university
faculty members, administrators, and even students. You do have to make an account to see
some news but it is free. So the intended audience would be those who have an account or
3. Summary
beings.” Procrastinators sometimes accomplish other tasks and think of them as a way of not
doing something more important. Structure your tasks as a hierarchy having the most urgent
thing you need to do first, worthwhile things towards the bottom. Procrastinators can be
Perry talks about a personal experience for structured procrastination. Perry would go
play Ping-Pong with the residents at Stanford instead of grading papers, preparing lectures.
While spending time with the students Perry got to know them and build a reputation. Make sure
the things at the top of your list are those that have deadlines and are important. Perry
incorporates one of the things at the top of his list which is finishing an essay that was supposed
to be done 11 months ago. He also wrote about how many things he accomplishes while not
4. Does this voice agree/disagree with others you have found? In what ways?
This source adds another way to look at procrastination. I read about John Perry’s structured
procrastination while looking at a different source. I have never really thought about how much I
accomplish that isn’t the most important or “at the top of my list.”
gardening or sharpening pencils or making a diagram of how they will reorganize their files
when they find the time. Why does the procrastinator do these things? Because accomplishing
“I am working on this essay as a way of not doing all of those things. This is the essence of what
procrastinators into effective human beings, respected and admired for all that they can
I can really relate to what Perry is saying about doing “difficult, timely, and important tasks, as
long as these tasks are a way of not doing something more important.” I have finished all my
math homework up until next week and will probably get my chemistry homework done soon
too. Yet I sit working on my inquiry assignments the night they are due.
Source #6
pp. 3–17.
2. Credibility/ethos of author/organization
Schouwenburg is the main author of this chapter. The book was edited by Schouwenburg, Clarry
H. Lay, Timothy A. Pychyl, and Joseph R. Ferrari. Schouwenburg has written, co-authored
multiple books. Multiple involve procrastination, one is titled “Do It Now: Do Not Leave It for
Tomorrow.” The book “Counseling the Procrastinator in Academic Settings” was published by
the American Psychological Association so it may be geared toward people interested in science
3. Summary
Procrastination is defined as “to put off intentionally”, “the act of continuing to delay
something that must be done, because it is unpleasant and boring”, “leaving it until later.” Those
definitions are part of how procrastination is defined in the Cambridge dictionary, Collins
Cobuild dictionary, Merriam-Webster’s dictionary. Procrastination can be interpreted as a
behavior or a habit, trait. Behavioral procrastination has to do with lack of time and task
management. Traits are tendencies that result in patterns of behavior in different situations.
Traits can be grouped in the “Big Five model” “(1urgency, or Extraversion-Introversion; (2)
Agreeableness; (3) Conscientiousness’ (4) Emotional Stability; and (5) Intellect or Openness to
Experience.” The trait procrastination is associated with low emotional stability and neuroticism.
Logos is used throughout this chapter by showing graphs. A graph relating subjective
value and number of days left is shown on page 9, as the number of days decreases the subjective
value increases. This shows the sense of urgency something has as a due date approaches. There
are 3 components of intervention; increase in reward value of long term goal, blocking access to
procrastinators have concerns with doing homework, writing papers, preparing for exams.
4. Does this voice agree/disagree with others you have found? In what ways?
A part from this source that disagrees with others is the relation of procrastination and anxiety.
“It is a rational assumption that the activity or project that will win out will depend on the project
“These related processes include the student’s ability to concentrate, to protect their study
intentions from other temptations, and to persist at the task, as well as their overall satisfaction
6. Your Analysis/thoughts
This source has great graphs, tables to use. Some other chapters in the book might also be useful
to use when writing my thesis. One particularly interesting figure to me in the book was showing
the relation between fear of failure and the lack of work discipline.
Source #7
1. MLA Works Cited entry (article title in quotation marks, books/websites/videos in italics-
and Research.” Procrastination and Task Avoidance: Theory, Research, and Treatment, by
2. Credibility/ethos
competing activities. Fear of failure isn’t the main problem for people that procrastinate. Low in
conscientiousness means your more likely to procrastinate and give up when frustrated. Big Five
includes conscientiousness, neuroticism. Logos is used when tables, sets of variables, analysis
are used in the book. Another interesting use of logos is a graph showing how procrastination,
motivation, hours studied, hours planned relates to weeks until exam.Competitive nature impacts
self worth. Ethos is used to Covington, Lay’s General Procrastination Scale is in the book.
Student groups are labeled as overstriving, success oriented, failure avoiding, failure
accepting. Overstriving people have high hopes for success, high failure, don’t procrastinate.
Success oriented people have high hopes for success, low fear of failure, don’t procrastinate.
Failure avoiding people have low hopes for success, high fear of failure, do procrastinate. Failure
accepting people have low hopes for success, low fear failure, “pure” academic procrastinators.
Some people are more likely to procrastinate than others. Treatment of procrastination is also
Procrastination checklist study tasks are comparable for all students. Single actions of study
4. Does this voice agree/disagree with others you have found? In what ways?
This source agrees with the other sources. It shows a graph how students study more as the exam
approaches, I found a graph like that in another source. The fear of failure, and
5. Two or three interesting quotes (make a note of page or paragraph for future reference) you
procrastination when writing a term paper, 30% when reading weekly assignments, 28% when
studying for exams, 23% on attendance tasks, and 11% on administrative tasks.” (71)
Procrastinators Code “I must be perfect. Everything I do should go easy and without effort. It’s
6. Your Analysis/thoughts - can be more casual. How might you use the source in your thesis?
I really like the “Procrastinators Code” and the other quote I chose. The quote with the
Source #8
1. MLA Works Cited entry (article title in quotation marks, books/websites/videos in italics-
Hu, Yue et al. “The Neural Substrates of Procrastination: A Voxel-Based Morphometry Study.”
reasonableness of their work. Rhetorical situation including intended audience (ie. tell us about
Southwest University in China. “The study was supported by the National Natural Science
Foundation of China and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities.”
3. Summary
Sample 1 of study was done on 151 participants some male and some female, ages ranged
from 17-25 from Southwest University in China. The second sample only included 108
participants. Self-control and emotion regulation have important roles in procrastination. Some
studies linked procrastination is associated to negative life events, health problems. Meta-
analysis connects self-control to procrastination. Self-control and limiting distractions are some
ways to take immediate action toward procrastination. Mood and emotion associated with a task
has an effect on whether or not someone will procrastinate. Neuroimaging studies were used to
show strong association between trait procrastination and parts of the brain that deal with
cognitive control. Voxel-based morphometry (VMO) method used in the study to look at
The measurement of procrastination was done by using the General Procrastination Scale
designed by C.H. Lay. The scale contained 20 items and the participants ranked themselves as
procrastinating. Previous studies have used this scale so that shows credibility. MRI data and
different processing technologies were used. Logos is used by showing figures and data. Figure 1
shows different parts of the brain and if they had a positive or negative correlation with
procrastination. Self-control and emotion plays a role in procrastination. The author included a
long list of references so they gathered a lot of information while looking to compare and
contrast their findings. “It was found that the procrastinators had reduced GM volume in the
MFG which was known to support the ability of self-control. Whereas, the procrastinators tended
to have increased GM volume in the OFC that was involved in negative emotional regulation.”
Middle frontal gyrus (MFG) and orbital frontal cortex (OFC) are regions of the brain that could
4. Does this voice agree/disagree with others you have found? In what ways?
This source focuses on the neurological aspects of procrastination. Mentions short term, long
term goals, self-control like some other sources. Ferrari’s thoughts were used in this source and I
“It was found that the procrastinators had reduced GM volume in the MFG which was known to
support the ability of self-control. Whereas, the procrastinators tended to have increased GM
6. Your Analysis/thoughts - can be more casual. How might you use the source in your thesis?
The figure of the different regions of the brain could be really interesting to include in the thesis.
Source #9
https://www.bbc.com/news/health-45295392
2. Credibility/ethos of author/organization
Nazima Pathan writes for BBC mainly about health and science. Couldn’t find much information
about Pathan. BBC stands for British Broadcasting Corporation, and write about news not only
about the UK but also about the U.S. and Canada. The article was written based on a study.
3. Summary:
The amygdala is in the temporal side lobe of the brain. The amygdala controls motivation
and was larger in procrastinators. Those who procrastinate had worse connections between
amygdala and DACC. The DACC is the part of the brain and stands for dorsal anterior cingulate
cortex. DACC keeps people focused and on track by blocking out things that may be distracting.
Procrastination is more about emotions rather than time. Procrastinators struggle to filter out
Ethos is used when the author brought in views from Moyra Scott (a productivity expert)
. Tips from Moyra Scott for procrastination are to use a timer, break tasks down, minimize phone
interruptions, be busy. You need to make sure you have time to do tasks because even though
you think you are too busy you can make time. Views from Professor Tim Pychyl, Carleton
University in Ottawa are used in the article. Pychyl studies procrastination. Dr Caroline Schluter
who was a lead author of a study done on procrastination and the brain said: “The brain is very
responsive and can change throughout the lifespan.” The study was about 264 people’s brains to
4. Does this voice agree/disagree with others you have found? In what ways?
This source agrees with others I found. The ways it agrees is by mentioning self-regulation, tips
for deadlines, breaking tasks down. It was focused on a view of procrastination from looking at
the brain which was very interesting and related to the previous source. This source focused
more on the emotional issues with procrastination rather than the aspects of managing time.
5. Two or three interesting quotes (make a note of page or paragraph for future reference) you
"Individuals with a larger amygdala may be more anxious about the negative consequences of an
action - they tend to hesitate and put off things," says Erhan Genç, one of the study authors,
that mindfulness meditation is related to amygdala shrinkage, expansion of the prefrontal cortex
6. Your Analysis/thoughts - can be more casual. How might you use the source in your thesis?
In my thesis I can explain what the brain is like for people that procrastinate. The tips I
mentioned in the summary also seem helpful and are mentioned in some other sources so they
Source #10
Gustavson, Daniel E, and Akira Miyake. “Academic Procrastination and Goal Accomplishment:
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5608091/.
reasonableness of their work. Rhetorical situation including intended audience (ie. tell us about
Gustavson, Miyake have written many other articles about procrastination. Gustavson is a
professor in the Department of Psychiatry at the University of California in San Diego. Akira
Colorado in Boulder. Source is from U.S. The National Library of Medicine, more specifically
the National Institutes of Health. The NIH is the medical research agency for the nation.
3. Summary:
A study was done to examine the relationship between academic procrastination and goal
accomplishment. Two session laboratory study done. The first session students took a test of
academic procrastination, did goal exercises of assignments they wanted to complete in a certain
amount of time. When creating those goals they also looked at possible things that would be
distracting. The students went back to the lab 3 weeks later to provide information like how
much they procrastinated and if they accomplished the goals they had set. Many students who
procrastinate want to find ways to reduce it. Setting goals and reducing procrastination doesn’t
have a clear connection. This article references many other studies done about procrastination
and what other people have found. One study led to acceptance based intervention being
SMART goals stands for specific, measurable, achievable, realistic, time-defined. This
specific study examined SMART goals and reducing academic procrastination. The result of the
procrastination is highly limited.” Motivational factors are internal academic motivation and
external academic motivation. An intervention procedure they did was modeled after the
“Personal Project Analysis approach.” The writer used logos by including summaries and graphs
of what they found in their studies. Personality domains used in the study were impulsivity,
4. Does this voice agree/disagree with others you have found? In what ways?
I really like how this source brought in information about SMART goals, this wasn’t a main
thing mentioned in other sources. This source relates to others when it talks about there not being
to be worse off for that delay—is so pervasive that, according to some estimates, 50–80% of
college students procrastinate moderately or severely (Day, Mensink, & O'Sullivan, 2000;
“Although we obtained further correlational evidence for the relationship between academic
procrastination and goal accomplishment, we were not able to obtain any evidence for the causal
influence of the two goal-related interventions (SMART goals and implementation intentions) on
6. Your Analysis/thoughts
The quotes I found were interesting and can be used in my thesis. Especially the quote about the