Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mechanical Engineering
Abstract
The design of R olling Contact Bearing is initiated with introduction, application and
necessitate of bearing in a different arena and ensuing those, we differentiate the
type of bearing. Then, we will be seeking anent the flaw and the cause of failure of
bearing under different contingency. Eventually, we do is the pristine selection of
the types, their design, and specification of the load for a satisfactory life. Here, we
also limn some of the research on bearing and their profound result.
Introduction
Rolling contact bearing is termed as a ntifriction bearing and rolling bearing. The
prevalently used name is a nti-friction i s due to modicum friction comparatively with
the same ilk of the mechanical instrument like sleeve bearing. The area of
application is that it must fit into a space of specified dimension, sustain a certain
load and have a satisfactory life under the specified condition. The factors affecting
the frictional characteristics are load, speed, lubrication and material properties. So
designing the bearing intrigue the specialist in the field of f atigue loading, friction,
heat, corrosion resistance, kinematic problems, material properties, lubrication, machining
tolerances, assembly, use, and cost.
The design of bearing, since, affected by multiple
factors we are unable to precedent the bearing life in a deterministic way so we
accompany the statistical approach which is typically Weibullian statistics.
It is a continuous goal for bearing engineers to always
develop advanced bearings that provide higher efficiency, lower friction, and are less
sensitive and more reliable even in applications under adverse operating conditions
[1].so the continuous research is adopted to meet that requirement.
Fig. Nomenclature of the tapered roller bearing
2
Fig Nomenclature of the roller bearing Fig. Component of the rolling bearing
Bearing Types and their Aptness
Bearing are manufactured to bear
1.Pure radial load
2.Pure thrust load
3.Combination of Radial and Thrust load
Here the roller bearing with different characteristics is delineated
1.Axial load carrying capacity:
Bearing designed mainly for axial loads (thrust ball bearings) have a contact angle
α>45 degrees.
Axial ball bearings and angular contact thrust ball bearings may,
depending on the design, transfer axial loads in one or both directions( see fig.1). In
cases of extremely high axial loads, a thrust cylindrical roller or spherical thrust
roller bearing is typically used.
3
Fig.1 (courtesy: ZKL group)
2.Radial load carrying bearing
Bearings designed primarily for transferring radial loads are called radial bearings(
fig.2). They have a nominal contact angle of α ≤ 45 °. Line contact bearing the higher
axial load carrying capacity than the single-point contact bearing, likely, straight
roller bearing.
Fig.2 (courtesy: ZKL Group)
4
3. Combined load carrying bearing
Single and double row angular contact ball bearings or tapered roller bearings are
best for capturing combined loads. Some of the s elf-aligning ball bearings are also
favorable with combined load but with a relatively small axial load.
Fig. 3 (courtesy: ZKL
Group)
4. Torque load carrying bearing
If the load application point lies outside of the bearing axis, then an overturning
torque is created. So double row radial load bearing and double row angular contact
bearing suffice for torque prompting load. Some time pairs of the angular contact
ball bearing and tapered roller bearing is also used with the same purpose.
5
Fig. 4 (courtesy: ZKL Group)
5. Alignment
With regard to manufacturing inaccuracies and shaft deflections, wobbling of the
bearing rings occurs in the housing which is compensated by using the self-aligning
ball bearings, double row spherical roller bearings, and thrust spherical roller bearings.
Fig. 5(courtesy: ZKL Group
Bearing Assembly
The assembly of the different bearing vary more or less but the most common
assembly is as shown in the figure below
The below diagram is lucidly showing us the most typical assembly procedure for
bearing (ball bearings). Here as shown first finding the mating inner and outer ring
then place the inner ring eccentrically touching one side of the outer ring( f ig: 2).
Prelastly center the inner ring with the outer ring and equally space the rolling
element and assemble the cage (separator). Add lubricant to the bearing, fit the shield
and scrutinize the pristine assembly and sealing process.
6
7
Typically, shoulder height is 22- 30 % of the ball diameter for the inner ring and
18-30 % of the ball diameter for the outer ring.
Characteristics of the Shoulder:
1. Strength must be high enough to support the load (axial).
2. Perfect enough to assemble an adequate size of the separator into the bearing.
3. The thickness of the bottom part of the pathway must be adequate enough to
bear compressive stress imposed by a ball and hoop stresses from press fit
assembly on the outside.
Fig. showing the Hoop stress
Bearing life affecting factors
Material Stressing under Contact Pressure
When the ball or roller bearing of the rolling contact bearing roll, the contact stress
occurs between the rollers, inner, and outer race. This generated stress at point
contact is given by the Hertzian Stresses( condition: when the radius in the plane of
rolling is different from the radius in a perpendicular plane).
At merely elastic deformation, a
semi-elliptical load distribution takes place in the contact zone of the two elements
in rolling contact. The resulting stress distribution is shown in figure 7.
8
Fig. 7(courtesy: FAG Aerospace Gmbh)
Material stressing here is evaluated by using the Von Mises Hypothesis. The
equivalent stress distribution in three dimensional and contour plot is shown by the
FAG Aerospace Gmbh researcher unveiling the maximum point of equivalent stress
relative to contact pressure P0.
Fig. 8 Equivalent stress distribution under
contact area
9
The maximum equivalent stress occurs at a depth of z/b=0.7; it amounts to 0.56p0.
At the surface, in the very center of the contact area, the equivalent stress is only 0.4
times po. This is illustrated by the figure given.
Fig. 10 Damage propagation from inclusion from surface
A comparison between this theoretical statement and findings from actual rolling
bearing failures shows that in many cases the damage starts near or at the surface.
An example of the origin of damage near the surface of a rolling bearing ring is
shown in Fig.10. It can be clearly seen that the damage started at a weak
microstructural point (inclusion) and progressed from there into the depth of the
10
material until it reached the area of greatest equivalent stress(wide crack paths in
Fig.10).
If a bearing is clean and properly lubricated, mounted and sealed against the
entrance of the dirt and dust, is maintained in this condition, and is operated at a
reasonable temperature, then metal fatigue will be the only cause of failure.
Here we proceed towards the quantitative measure of bearing life in which we decern
the number of revolution and hours of use unless the first substantial fatigue
prompted. According to the AFBMA( Anti-Friction Bearing Manufacturer's
Association), the failure criterion is the first evidence of fatigue.
The rating life is given by AFBMA is minimum life(L10), medium
life(L50). The most typically use rating life is L10. So does L10 means, it says that 90
percent of the bearing of the same family will accomplish or overwhelm the failure
criterion (oppositely 10 percent of them will flunk).
Three different way of determining the bearing life are delineated which is the
statistical approach
1. Bearing Load-Life Trade-Off at Constant Reliability
2. Bearing Survival: The Reliability-Life Trade-Off
3. Load-Life-Reliability Trade-Off
First one the bearing life at constant reliability whereas second is the bearing life at
constant load. The third one is the concession between the load, life, and reliability
where the designer has to be more active.
Fig.1 log-log graph of load-life(Courtesy: Mechanical Engineering design, Shigley)
Using the regression equation we get
11
F L1/a = constant or F 1 × L 1/a = F 2 × L1/a
2 [ a is constant and
depends
on bearing
a= 3, for ball bearing,a= 10/3 for roller berings]
As we described earlier that bearing life is too much detrimental to the lubrication
layer, shard, particles, improper mounting, the eccentricity of load, corrosion,
Smearing, electric current, heat, and also due to the deuterium penetration in a
vacuum all these are the reason of antedate failure. Some of them are reported here
with a plausible solution.
Lubrication
Preamble, we will first proof that how lubrication is more substantial to the bearing
life. In order to show that we probe the graph of bearing life with respect to contact
pressure as depicted in figure. it is shown that with minor load changes, the major
changes in the bearing life may result in well-lubricated elements in rolling contact
and under a high degree of cleanliness.
Fig. Bearing life Vs Contact pressure
12
In the same time, we have now another graph supporting the maximum attainable
bearing life antecedent of good lubrication and pristine cleanliness. FAG found the
actual correlation between the life and the stipulated bearing stressing as rendered
in the figure().
Fig.3 Limn maximum attainable life by bearing(courtesy:
FAG aeronautics)
Here we accomplished the culminated life of bearing but the prerequisite to attaining
that is
1. Clean Lubrication
2. Surface separation by an elastohydrodynamic boundary layer
The strong dependence of the bearing life capability on the amount of stress and on
the conditions of lubrication and cleanliness is obvious. This is a useful resource for
the designer to attempt the attainable life.
During lubrication, we have different sort of lubrication
1. Full fluid lubrication
2. Mixed friction
13
According to the known principles, the formation of a separating lubricating film
between surfaces in rolling contact bearing with oil or grease lubrication, rolling
bearings reach the longest possible life with full-fluid-film lubrication. Due to
lubrication, the asperity contact between the races and ball bearing is almost zero.
This full fluid lubrication is limited to low speed, light load. And the coefficient of
friction is also meager.
In contrast to this, there is mixed lubrication which usually lies
between the full fluid film lubrication and boundary layer lubrication. In the realm of
Mixed friction, the load is supported partly by the fluid film and partly by the surface
asperities. If the machine is working under the mixed friction contingency will bring
wear so we use extreme pressure additive which only causes smoothening of the
surface or might bring averse damage depending on additive properties.
14
Fig.5 illustrating Mixed Friction at micro level
Fig.6 Wear pattern vs the running time (bearing
81212 under short-term test conditions with EP oils I and II at varying temperatures)
This can happen with the stationary bearing, for example, due to an improper
lubricant, and also during the starting and stopping phases of execution otherwise
bearing will be running under EHD conditions (steady-state operation).
Due to contact, from Hertzian pressure, bearing
infer normal force and in addition mixed friction prompt the tangential force which
will impose over the surface and change the surface topography. The change of
surface is captured by the SEM(Scanning Electron Microscope).
15
16
The damage done by the particles or grit varies with their strength and
hardness. The life of the bearing drastically vulnerable to particles size which is
given by the following graph.
Fig. 8 illustrating the flabbergast deceasing of life
Under certain conditions, particles can get embedded in the surface of one of the
parts in rolling contact bearing, then act like a cutting tool and wear down the
mating part abrasively.
Corrosion
Lubrication will be act as a protective element from the corrosion and prevent from
coming in contact with water or vapor. If water is unable to abide the water to make
contact with the bearing, it will cause deep-seated corrosion and fretting corrosion.
Deep-seated corrosion
When a clean steel surface is exposed to the air, it will form a thin oxide layer which
will act as a protective layer. This oxide protective layer is not strong to impede water
to make contact. This will lead to deep-seated corrosion which brings premature
failure.
17
Acidic corrosion is more dangerous than alkaline corrosion. The galvanic corrosion
which flourishes when water containing salt make a contact by the means of
electrolytic process. This corrosion is more detrimental to bearing life. The flaking
and fretting process will hasten at this moment.
Left Right
Fig. Left: Corrision on the outer ring, Right: Corrision on the outer ring(water
etching)
Fretting Corrision
The oxide layer formed over the surface of streel is if penetrated by the water,
corrosion anent to appear. some contingency prevails that corrosion will occur due
to the relative motion of the bearing and shaft. This relative motion exfoliate the
particles from the bearing and then turned into the oxide form when making a
contact with the atmospheric air. This process of forming corrosion is called
Fretting
Corrosion.
18
Fig. Fretting corrosion on the outer spherical ball bearing
Electric current
If the electric current passes through the bearing it will damage every part of
bearing. Electric current will act like electric arc welding at the contact surface. It will
make a fluting etch on the raceways of the bearing.
Both the alternating and direct current will
cause bearing damage. Even low amperage current is vulnerable to bearing damage.
Typically bearing at the rotating stage is more prone to damage where the stationary
bearing is more resistant. The only solution for this is to prevent the bearing from
current leakage.
19
Fig. Damage caused by the passage of electric current
Coating of the surface in the vacuum
The study investigates the outgassing of bare stainless steel and MoS2 coated ball
bearings, both of which are widely used in modern high vacuum technological
equipment. Most measure outgassing species are methane, carbon dioxide, and
hydrogen.
Two main processes govern the outgassing from a ball bearing:
1. local heating of the contact surfaces and
2. plastic deformation and fracture of counterfaces
Outgassing from a ball bearing is very sensitive to damage of the contacting
surfaces.
Mean outgassing rate from the plated ball bearings was 2.5–3 times higher and the
peak outgassing was 10–20 times higher, than from the bare ball bearings. Thus, the
plated ball bearings have a durability that is 5–6 times longer than the bare ball
bearings. The graph depicted below will show you the relation of the speed with
mean outgassing, torque, and vibrations.
20
Three stages, corresponding to the main stages of the lifetime of a ball bearing can
be well distinguished with time:
(A) run-in
(B) gradual wear and
(C) catastrophic wear
Inclusion
Inclusions in the steel cannot be entirely avoided in the steel producing process. Fig.1
illustrates how the constant impulses from the R&D work of the rolling bearing
manufacturers on the steel sector have improved the steel quality in recent years.
And this research has helped in increasing the load rating of rolling element bearing
by improving the quality of steel.
21
Fig.1 Degree of enhancement in the purity of steel
According to the appearances of different types of inclusion in the micrograph,
they are classified into
1)streaky sulfides (SS), 2)accumulations of small oxides (OA), 3)streaky oxide (OS),
4)globular oxides (OG), 5)titanium carbonitrides with TiC and TiN.
The major problem pervaded from the inclusion is the flow of stress. If the inclusion
has a lower modulus of elasticity than the matrix (hosting element) then the flow of
stress will be more through the matrix and pole will be out of stress. Similarly, if the
young modulus of elasticity of inclusion is large than the matrix then force flow
greatly through the inclusion and more force will be convened by the matrix towards
inclusion. This will immensely increase the stress concentration at that point as
illustrated in the figure.
22
Fig.2 Effect of soft and stiff inclusion over stress flow
Path patterns and their interpretation
When the roller bearing rotates for a long time it will form some kind of dull surface
between the inner and outer surface. This is not an indication of wear or any sort of
indentation but a mark set by rotating the ball inside the race, called patterns. This
path pattern determines the operating condition of the bearing and one can predict
the behavior of operating load.
This one has no significance in the life of bearing. But in
the majority of the cases, the failure of the bearing occurs within the confined area of
path pattern so once the path pattern is vetted in a good way one can detect the
imminent damage in the race.
Deep groove ball bearing and cylindrical roller bearing is depicted here for path
patterns
23
Fig.1 Unidirectional radial load. The inner ring, rotating. The outer ring, fixed.
Path pattern is uniform all over the cross-section in inner ring whereabout in outer
ring path pattern is tapered off.
Fig. 2 Uni-directional radial load. The inner ring, stall. The outer ring, rotating.
Path pattern is extended over all cross-section in outer ring whereas in the inner
ring it is limited over less than half circumferential surface.
24
Fig. 3 Uni-directional axial load. Either of rings can be rotating. The path pattern
form is uniform all over the circumference for both with offset.
Fig.3 Uni-directional axial and radial load. Either of rings can be rotating. The path
pattern formed is all over the circumference. The inner ring has a constant eccentric
pattern where the outer ring has a tapered ring.
25
Fig.4 Uni-directional axial load. Rotating washer. Fixed housing washer.
Path pattern is uniform in both.
A width of path pattern is uniform all over the cross-section.
Fig.5 Oval compression of the outer ring. The outer ring, fixed. The inner ring,
rotating.
Path pattern formed in the outer ring is tapered at the point of pinching but the inner
ring has a constant width ring.
26
Fig. 6 Fit too tight. The inner ring, rotating. The outer ring, fixed. Due to over tight
ring is pre-stressed. The path pattern in the inner ring is constant all over
circumference wherein the outer ring it is wider at a point of radial load and offset.
Fig.7 Inner ring misaligned. Fixed inner ring and rotating inner ring.
Path patterns in two diametrically opposed section in the inner ring and constant
width pattern in the outer ring.
27
Fig. 8 Misaligned housing washer ring. Rotating shaft washer and fixed housing
washer.
Path pattern is uniform all over the circumference in shaft washer.
Path pattern is off-center extended all over the circumference.
Conclusion
The design of the ball bearing was perfectly done by our bearing expertise in past
time. The most immense abstruse problem we are facing is to extend the life of roller
bearing which is prevalently used. Considering the life span of bearing most of the
researcher found lubrication, cleanliness, quality of steel, modes of operation,
corrosion, and types of foreign particles are the major cause of decreasing the
bearing life.
Rolling element bearings can achieve endurance life if bearing stressing, lubrication
and system cleanliness are adequately taken into consideration.
28
Reference
[1]. http://www.zkl.cz/en/for-designers
[3]. Fundamentals of Design and Technology of Rolling Element Bearings Franz-Josef Ebert* FAG Aerospace GmbH & Co. KG,
D-97421 Schweinfurt, Germany
29