Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Page 1 of 34
RULE I
These Rules are promulgated to prescribe the procedures and guidelines for the
implementation of SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014 as amended by SP Ordinance No. 5598-
2018 also known as the “Smoke Free Ordinance of Butuan City” which shall apply to all
persons, whether natural or juridical, whether resident or not, in all places found within
the territorial jurisdiction of Butuan City.
RULE II
INTERPRETATION
These Rules shall be construed in a manner that consistent with the spirit and purpose of
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014 as amended by SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018 or the
“Smoke Free Ordinance of Butuan City” in order to attain its objectives which are primarily
to safeguard public health and ensure the well-being of all its constituents by protecting
them from the deleterious effects of smoking and tobacco consumption.
RULE III
DEFINITION OF TERMS
b.) Civil Society Organization (CSO) – refers to a legally constituted voluntary civic
and social organization or institution created with no participation of government,
including but not limited to, charities, development non-governmental
organizations (NGOs), community groups, women’s organizations, faith-based
organizations, professional associations, coalitions and advocacy groups duly
recognized by the Office of the Mayor. It does not include organizations or
associations related to or connected with the tobacco industry in any way. 2
1
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.1
2
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec 4.2
3
R.A. 6713 (Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees)
Page 2 of 34
amended by SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018 or these Rules that meets the
standard specifications prescribed herein.
g.) Indicia – refers to any name, logo or trademark and other words, symbols,
designs, colors or other depictions of tobacco products which are registered, or
although unregistered, are either considered “well known”, as defined under the
Intellectual Property Code of the Philippines and its implementing rules and
regulations, or have become distinctive in relation to the tobacco product arising
from substantially exclusive and continuous use in commerce in the Philippines for
at least five (5) years. 6
h.) Manufacturer - refers to any person or entity, including a repacker, who makes,
fabricates, assembles, processes, or labels a finished product. 7
i.) Minor - refers to any person below eighteen (18) years old.8
j.) Non-smoking Buffer Zone – refers to a ventilated area between the door of a
DSA not located in an open space and the smoke-free area. There shall be no
opening that will allow air to escape from such Non-Smoking Buffer Zone to the
smoke-free area, except for a single door equipped with an automatic door closer.
Such door is distinct from the door of the DSA, which shall be at least two (2)
meters away from the other. 9
k.) Open spaces – refers to those areas forming part of a building or conveyance,
which are not covered by a roof or similar structure.10
l.) Outdoor advertisement - refers to any sign, model, placard, board, billboard,
banner, bunting, poster, streamer, paint-on, light display, device, structure or
representation, employed outdoors or visible from outside, wholly or partially
to advertise or promote a tobacco product or ENDS to the public. 11
m.) Package - refers to packs, boxes, cartons or containers of any kind in which
any tobacco product is offered for sale to consumers. 12
4
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.4
5
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec 4.4
6
Inter-agency Committee-Tobacco MC No. 1 (Rules and Regulations Implementing R.A. 9211)
7
R.A. 9211
8
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec 4.5
9
Executive Order No. 26 (e) “Providing for the Establishment of Smoke-Free Environments in Public and Enclosed
Places”
10
Executive Order No. 26 (f)
11
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.7
12
R.A. 9211
Page 3 of 34
n.) Perimeter – shall refer to any point in the boundaries as indicated in the
Original Certificate of Title or Transfer Certificate of Title of the track of land
that is actually used or occupied by a school, public playground or other
facility frequented particularly by persons below eighteen (18) years of age,
whether or not said tract of land is separated from adjacent tracts by a wall or
fence.13 14
o.) Premises – refers to a tract of land and the building or buildings thereon,
including the open spaces between the buildings located on the same tract of
land and within the perimeter of said tract of land. 15 16
s.) Public places - means all places, fixed or mobile, that are accessible or open to
the public or places for collective use, regardless of ownership or right to access,
including but not limited to:
1) schools,
2) workplaces,
3) government facilities,
4) establishments that provide food and drinks,
5) accommodation, merchandise,
6) professional services,
13
Inter-agency Committee-Tobacco MC No. 1
14
This definition of “perimeter” may be changed as recommended by the appropriate authority.
15
Inter-agency Committee-Tobacco MC No. 1
16
This definition of “premises” may also be changed as recommended by the appropriate authority.
17
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.8
18
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.9
19
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.10
Page 4 of 34
7) entertainment
8) other services.20
It also includes outdoor spaces where facilities are available for the public or where
a crowd of people would gather, such as, but not limited to:
1) playgrounds,
2) sports grounds or centers,
3) church grounds,
4) health/hospital compounds,
5) transportation terminals,
6) markets,
7) parks,
8) resorts,
9) walkways/sidewalks,
10) entrance ways,
11) waiting areas.21
t.) Second-hand smoke – means the smoke emitted from the burning end of a
cigarette or from other tobacco products usually in combination with the smoke
exhaled by the smoker.22
u.) Smoke free air – is air that is 100% free from tobacco smoke which includes, but
is not limited to, air in which tobacco smoke cannot be seen, smelled, sensed or
measured.23
w.) Sponsorship – refers to any public or private contribution to a third party in relation
to an event, team or activity made with the aim of promoting a brand of tobacco
product, which event, team or activity would still exist or occur without such
contribution. Sponsorship shall be understood as tobacco sponsorship. 25
x.) Tobacco Products – products entirely or partly made of the leaf tobacco as raw
material which are manufactured to be used for smoking, sucking, chewing or
snuffing, such as but not limited to cigarette, cigar, pipe, shiha/hookah and chew
tobacco.26
20
The term “other services” may be interpreted following the statutory construction rule of Ejusdem Generis
wherein the Supreme Court states that where a general word or phrase follows an enumeration of particular and
specific words of the same class or where the latter follow the former, the general word or phrase is to be
construed to include, or to be restricted to, persons, things or cases akin to, resembling, or of the same kind or
class as those specifically mentioned. (Vera v Cuevas, G.R. No. 33693, May 31, 1979)
21
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.11
22
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec 4.11
23
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec 4.12
24
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec 4.13
25
R.A. 9211 (Tobacco Regulation Act of 2003)
26
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec 4.14
27
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec 4.15
Page 5 of 34
z.) Tobacco Industry Interference – refers to a broad array of tactics and strategies
used by the tobacco industry to interfere with the setting and implementation of
tobacco control measures. 28
aa.) Vaping - refers to the act of inhaling and exhaling aerosols or vapor
produced by any Electronic Nicotine Delivery System (ENDS)/Electronic Non-
Nicotine Delivery System (ENNDS) or other electronic device whether or not it is
used to deliver nicotine to the user, and mimics the act of smoking. 29
bb.) Workplace – means any place used by people during their employment or
work, whether done for compensation or voluntarily, including all attached or
associated places commonly used by the workers in the course of their work
including but not limited to:
1) Private offices
2) Corridors or hallways
3) Stairwells
4) Elevators
5) Toilets
6) Lobbies
7) Lounges
8) Other common areas
9) Taxis
10) Ambulances
11) Delivery vehicles
12) Company-owned vehicles used for transporting employees and guests
13) Other conveyances used or frequented during the course of employment
or work.30
RULE IV
PROHIBITED ACTS
28
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec 4.16
29
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.18
30
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec 4.17
31
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.1
32
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.2
33
The term “other facility frequented by minors” may be interpreted following the statutory construction rule of
Noscitur a sociis wherein the Supreme Court states that where a particular word or phrase is ambiguous in itself or
Page 6 of 34
of Health (DOH) and attached agencies, hospitals and health facilities, or
within 100 meters from any point in the perimeter of these places. 34
d.) Sell and distribute tobacco products and/or ENDS within premises of a
government facility, and establishments that serve food and drinks or provide
accommodation and entertainment; 35 36
e.) Sell tobacco products and/or ENDS without a city/municipal permit to sell
tobacco products or ENDS. 37
f.) Sell tobacco products and/or ENDS as individual pieces or per stick, or in
tobacco product packs containing less than 20 sticks/pieces.38
g.) Sell tobacco products and/or ENDS removed from its original product
packaging or without the proper government-regulated and approved health
warning.39
i.) Sell or distribute sweets, snacks, toys or any other objects in the form of
tobacco products and/or ENDS which may appeal to minors or bearing
resemblance to their logo/indicia/packaging.42
l.) Ordering, instructing or compelling a minor to use, light up, buy, sell, distribute,
deliver, advertise or promote tobacco products and/or ENDS.45
n.) Place, post, display, distribute, publish, broadcast locally or conduct any
form of direct or indirect tobacco or ENDS advertisement and/or
promotion/promotional activity within the territorial jurisdiction of Butuan City,
is equally susceptible of various meanings, its correct construction may be made clear and specific by considering
the company of words in which it is found or with which it is associated. In other words, where a particular word is
obscure or of doubtful meaning, taken by itself, the obscurity or doubt may be removed by reference to the
meaning of associated or companion words. (Soriano v Sandiganbayan, G.R. No. 65952, July 31, 1984)
34
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.3
35
The phrase “and establishments that serve food and drinks or provide accommodation and entertainment” may
be interpreted to mean only such establishments found within the premises of a government facility. Following the
above-mentioned rule of Noscitur a sociis.
36
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.4
37
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.18
38
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.19
39
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.20
40
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.21
41
The terms “other mobile or temporary stalls, kiosks, stations or units” may also be interpreted to mean only such
stalls, kiosks, stations or units which are considered ambulant or street vendors, following the above-mentioned
rule of Noscitur a sociis.
42
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.22
43
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.5
44
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.6
45
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.17
46
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.7
Page 7 of 34
including those situated in outdoor and indoor premises of tobacco and/or
ENDS point-of-sale establishments.47
o.) Display and place tobacco products and/or ENDS in open store
shelves/racks, except in enclosed, opaque and single-colored
storages/containments.48 49 50
b.) Solicit or accept, directly or indirectly, any gift, gratuity, favor, entertainment, loan
or anything of monetary value in the course of official duties or in connection with
any operation being regulated by, or any transaction which may be affected by the
functions of their office from any person or business related to the tobacco
industry.53
c.) Directly or indirectly have any financial or material interest in any transaction
involving the tobacco industry requiring the approval of office and failure to declare
any interest in the tobacco industry in the annual declaration of assets and
liabilities.54
d.) Accept or have any member of the family accept employment or recommending
any one to any position in any private enterprise connected with the tobacco
industry which has a regular or pending official transaction with their agency. 55
e.) Have conflict of interest regardless of status with the tobacco industry and fail to
resign from office/service and/or divest from any shareholding or interest within
sixty (60) days from assuming office/service or from acquiring any shareholding or
interest.56
f.) Fail to inform any intention to engage in an occupational activity within the tobacco
industry, whether gainful or not, within a specified period of time after leaving the
service and to require applicants for government positions to declare any current
or previous occupational activity with any tobacco industry whether gainful or not. 57
47
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.8
48
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.9
49
As an observation, it appears to be the intent of the legislators that the containments must have all of the
following requisites:
a.) The containment/storages must be enclosed;
b.) It must be opaque;
c.) It must be single-colored.
50
Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines “opaque” as “blocking the passage of radiant light, exhibiting the quality or
state of a body that makes it impervious to the rays of light, exhibiting opacity. The term “opacity” has been
defined as “the quality or state of a body that makes it impervious to the rays of light; the relative capacity of
matter to obstruct the transmission of radiant energy.”
51
Violation of these provisions are also punishable under R.A. 3019 (Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act)
52
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 5.11
53
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 5.12
54
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 5.13
55
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 5.14
56
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec.5.15
57
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 5.16
Page 8 of 34
4.3 For any government official or personnel of Butuan City regardless of
employment status, whether permanent, casual, contractual, job order, consultant
or special appointment to:
RULE V
5.1 A Designated Smoking Area shall possess the following specifications and features:
5.2 There shall be no Designated Smoking Areas in places where absolute smoking bans
are in effect such as but not limited to:
58
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 5.23
59
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 4.3.1
60
Executive Order No. 26, Sec. 4.3
61
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.3.2
62
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 4.3.3
63
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.3.4,5
64
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 4.3.6
65
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.3.7
66
Executive Order No. 26, Sec. 4.5
Page 9 of 34
a.) Centers of youth activity 67 such as playschools, preparatory schools, elementary
schools, high schools, colleges and universities, youth hostels and recreational facilities
for persons under eighteen (18) years old;
b.) Elevators and stairwells;
c.) Locations in which fire hazards68 are present, including gas stations and storage areas
for flammable liquids, gas, explosives or combustible materials;
d.) Within the buildings and premises of public and private hospitals, medical, dental, and
optical clinics, health centers, nursing homes, dispensaries and laboratories;
e.) Food preparation areas;
f.) Public conveyances
g.) Enclosed, partially enclosed and outdoor areas of transport terminals that are near
entrances and exits or where people pass or congregate;
h.) Within the buildings of all government facilities and premises of all offices of the
Department of Health, Department of Education, Commission on Higher Education,
Department of Social Welfare and Development and the Civil Service Commission
i.) Parks, plazas, playgrounds, sports and recreational facilities,
j.) Other facilities where an absolute smoking ban is imposed under special laws,
ordinances, administrative and executive orders, memorandum circulars and related
policies.69
RULE VI
c) Persons in-charge shall also provide for versions of the signages in vernacular or
in English.71
6.2 Specifications
67
The term “centers for youth activity” may be interpreted, following the statutory construction rule of Ejusdem
generis, wherein the Supreme Court states that where a general word or phrase follows an enumeration of
particular and specific words of the same class or where the latter follow the former, the general word or phrase is
to be construed to include, or to be restricted to, persons, things or cases akin to, resembling, or of the same kind
or class as those specifically mentioned. (Vera v Cuevas, G.R. No. 33693, May 31, 1979)
68
Without prejudice to the definition imposed by competent authorities, the term “fire hazards” may be defined in
this ordinance, with reference to R.A 9514 (Revised Fire Code of 2008), as “Any condition or act which increases or
may cause an increase in the probability of the occurrence of fire, or which may obstruct, delay, hinder or interfere
with fire fighting operations and the safeguarding of life and property.”
69
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 4.3.8
70
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.1
71
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 6.13
Page 10 of 34
a) For public places in general
Standard specifications:72
Dimensions: at least 8 x 16 inches
Design Elements:
- International “No Smoking” and “No Vaping” Symbols occupying not less
than 60% of the print area.
- The following statements occupying 40% or the remainder of the print
area:
Specifications: 73
Dimensions: At least 3.5 square inch on the windshield; and 10 square inch
at the driver’s back seat.
Design Elements:
- International “No Smoking” and “No Vaping” Symbol
- The following statements must appear thereon:
72
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.1
73
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.2
74
This phrase may be changed. The ordinances did not prescribe the specific phrase to use.
Page 11 of 34
- For buses and other heavy transportation: the 3.5 sq. in. sticker shall be
affixed on the back of the windshield, and another 14 sq. in. sticker on the
back of the driver’s seat facing the passengers or in any prominent area of
the conveyance
- For all other public conveyances: the 3.5 sq. in. sticker shall be affixed on the
windshield and the 10 sq. in sticker on the back of the driver’s seat.
Specifications:75
Design Elements:
- The following statement must occupy the print area:
Specifications: 76
Design Elements:
- Graphic health warning on the effects of tobacco use as prescribed by the
City Health Office
- The following statements must occupy the print area:
75
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.5
76
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.8
Page 12 of 34
Specifications: 77
Dimensions: at least 8 in. x 16 inches
Design Elements:
- International “No Smoking” Symbol occupying not less than 70% of the print
area
- The following statements occupying 30% or rest of the print area:
RULE VII
b) Provide ashtrays and any other receptacles for disposing of cigarette or other
tobacco product refuse in the approved Designated Smoking/Vaping Areas. 78
c) Remove from the places where smoking/vaping is prohibited all ashtrays and any
other receptacles for disposing of cigarette refuse. 79
d) Establish internal procedure and measures through which this Ordinance shall be
implemented and enforced within the area of which he or she is in charge. This
includes compliance to the sales, distribution, advertising and promotions
restrictions.80
e) Ensure that all of their employees or subordinates are informed or at least aware
of the Ordinance and these Rules. 81
77
Civil Service Commission MC No. 17-2009
78
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.3
79
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.3
80
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 610
81
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 6.11
82
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 6.12
Page 13 of 34
to report to the Smoke Free Task Force any tobacco product/ENDS selling,
advertising and/or promotion located within 100 meters from its perimeter. 83
RULE VIII
PERSONS LIABLE
The following persons shall be liable under the Ordinance and these Rules:
8.1 Any person or entity who commits any of the prohibited acts.
8.2 Any person-in-charge who knowingly allows, abets or tolerates the commission of any
of the prohibited acts.
8.3 Any person in-charge who fails to fulfill his/her duties and obligations
83
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.6
84
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.9
85
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.4
86
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.4
87
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.7
88
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.14
89
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 6.15
Page 14 of 34
8.4 If the violator is a minor, the enforcer of this Ordinance shall report the incident
to the school principal/dean exercising jurisdiction over the minor-offender where
he shall be required to comply with disciplinary measures under the school where
he/she is enrolled, and/or to the City Social Welfare and Development Office for
appropriate action or intervention, pursuant to Republic Act 9344. Should the
school have no policy for offenses committed by their pupils outside school
premises or if the minor is an out-of-school youth, the enforcer shall present the
minor to the City Social Welfare and Development Office, which may likewise
involve the parents or guardians and/or a Barangay Official where the minor is a
resident.90 91
RULE IX
MATRIX OF PENALTIES
90
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 7.3
91
R.A. 9344 has been amended by R.A. 10360 which provides: “SEC. 57-A. Violations of Local Ordinances. –
Ordinances enacted by local governments concerning juvenile status offenses such as, but not limited to, curfew
violations, truancy, parental disobedience, anti-smoking and anti-drinking laws, as well as light offenses and
misdemeanors against public order or safety such as, but not limited to, disorderly conduct, public scandal,
harassment, drunkenness, public intoxication, criminal nuisance, vandalism, gambling, mendicancy, littering, public
urination, and trespassing, shall be for the protection of children. No penalty shall be imposed on children for said
violations, and they shall instead be brought to their residence or to any barangay official at the barangay hall to
be released to the custody of their parents. Appropriate intervention programs shall be provided for in such
ordinances. The child shall also be recorded as a ‘child at risk’ and not as a ‘child in conflict with the law’. The
ordinance shall also provide for intervention programs, such as counseling, attendance in group activities for
children, and for the parents, attendance in parenting education seminars.”
Page 15 of 34
agencies, hospitals and health facilities, or Second 3,000.00
within 100 meters from any point in the Offense
perimeter of these places.
Page 16 of 34
16) Selling or distributing of sweets, snacks, toys
or any other objects in the form of tobacco
products and/or ENDS which may appeal to
minors or bearing resemblance to their
logo/indicia/packaging.
An offender who has committed any of the prohibited acts defined by Sections 5
(5.1 to 5.9), (5.17 to 5.22) and Section 6 for a third time or oftener shall face criminal
prosecution. The apprehending officer shall execute the enforcement procedure as
provided in Rule XII herein. The said officer shall immediately forward a copy of the same
to the City Legal Office for preparation and filing of the proper complaint.
If found guilty, the violator may be sentenced to suffer imprisonment for a period
not exceeding one (1) year OR be required to pay the fine corresponding to the third and
subsequent offense OR both such imprisonment and fine at the discretion of the court. In
the case of a business entity or establishment, its business license or permit may be
suspended for a minimum duration of one (1) week and a maximum duration of one (1)
month or permanently revoked wherever applicable. 92
9.2 Administrative sanctions for public officials or employees with respect to acts
committed in violation of Rule IV (4.3) hereof.
Any public official or employee who commits any of the acts prohibited under Rule
IV (4.3) hereof shall be considered as a ground for administrative disciplinary action
pursuant to Rule XIV (Discipline) of the Omnibus Rules Implementing Book V of Executive
Order No. 292, without prejudice to the filing of criminal as well as civil actions under
existing laws, rules and regulations.93 94
Any public official or employee who commits any of the malfeasances for public
officials or employees mentioned in Sections 5 (5.10), (5.11), (5.12), (5.13), (5.14), (5.15)
and (5.16) of the Ordinance and these Rules shall be administratively liable and shall be
dealt with appropriate disciplinary action pursuant to the Revised Rules on Administrative
Cases in the Civil Service (RRACCS) and other applicable Civil Service laws, rules and
regulations.
92
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 8.1, 8.2, 8.4
93
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 8.3
94
CSC-DOH Joint Memorandum Circular No. 2010-01
Page 17 of 34
seven (7) working days from its issuance, shall (if basis is Sec. 8.4) or may
(if basis is Sec. 8.1 & 8.2) be suspended for a period not less than one (1)
week but not more than one (1) month, or revoked.95
c) The suspension of the business license or permit shall be lifted only after
compliance with all the requirements stipulated in the Ordinance and these
Rules upon re-inspection or evaluation of the City Health Office, City
Engineer’s/Architect’s Office, Business Permits and Licenses Division, the
Smoke Free Task Force, or any appropriate agency or governing body.
If a violator is unable to pay the fines imposed, he or she may choose to render
community service within the city. For every hour of community service rendered, his/her
outstanding fine shall be reduced by an amount equivalent to triple the hourly minimum
wage of Butuan City. 97
When a Citation Ticket is issued to a violator, the violator shall report to the City
Treasurer’s Office or its duly authorized collecting agent, within five (5) regular business
days after such issuance, where he or she shall either pay the fine imposed or render
community service. 98 If in case the violator is to render community service, the City
Treasurer will endorse him/her to the City ENRO thru the Ecological Solid Waste
Management (ESWM) Division.”
Persons liable who have been apprehended or cited for violation of any of the
prohibited acts of the Ordinance, except for Section 5.10, and who do not wish to contest
the violation, and is willing to pay voluntarily the administrative penalty imposed upon
him/her for the first and second offenses enumerated in Section 8.1 and 8.2. prior to the
filing of formal charges with the proper court shall be allowed to pay the penalty with the
95
The confusion with the suspension or revocation of business permit stems from the fact that under Section 8.1,
the power is discretionary, but in Section 8.4, the suspension is mandatory. Furthermore, from the tenor of the
provisions, it is discretionary with the appropriate authority if they should decide whether to suspend OR revoke
the business permit. Suspension is temporary, while revocation is permanent and requires the application of a new
permit.
96
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 8.4
97
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 8.5
98
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 9.4
99
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 8.6
Page 18 of 34
City Treasurer's Office, within five (5) regular business days from apprehension, to avoid
being criminally prosecuted. Otherwise, the case shall be prosecuted in court.
The “No Contest Provision” can no longer be availed for third and subsequent
offenses.
The proceeds from payment of the herein penalties imposed shall be subject to the
provision on Funding in Section 20 of this Ordinance. 100
Subsidiary Imprisonment may be imposed by the court in the event that the
offender, who is found guilty of violating the provisions of this Ordinance, is unable
to pay the fine which he is sentenced to pay. 101
a. Persons found in violation of this ordinance must present correct and valid
identification. In case any valid and sufficient form of identification is not presented,
he/she shall be brought to the nearest police station for proper identification, then to
the Smoke Free Task Force for the payment of penalty or rendition of community
service.102
RULE X
10.1 Violators of the Ordinance and these Rules shall be informed of the nature of their
respective violation and the penalty associated or corresponding thereto by means of
a Citation Ticket System or issuance of anti-smoking citation tickets.
10.2 The City Treasurer’s Office shall facilitate the printing and issuance of booklets of
Citation Tickets to the enforcers.
a. Name and address of the violator, and, if available, his/her government-issued ID;
100
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 8.7
101
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 8.8
102
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 8.9
103
This is a rule recommended by this Office (in reference to Section 7 of R.A. 9344), to settle doubts as to the age
of a person who is attempting to buy a tobacco/ENDS at the point-of-sale establishments.
Page 19 of 34
b. A checklist of violations under the Ordinance;
d. Option to render community service in case the violator is unable to pay the fine
e. Due date for compliance with the obligations imposed in the ticket 104
10.5 When a Citation Ticket is issued to a violator, the violator shall report to the
City Treasurer’s Office or its duly authorized collecting agent, within five (5) regular
business days after such issuance, where he or she shall either pay the fine imposed
or render community service under Section 8.5 hereof. If in case the violator is to
render community service, the City Treasurer will endorse him/her to the City ENRO
thru the Ecological Solid Waste Management (ESWM) Division.105
10.6 The City Treasurer’s Office shall keep duplicate copies of all Citation Tickets
issued to violators as well as other records of violations of the Ordinance.106
RULE XI
The City Health Officer, with the assistance of the Health Education and
Promotion Officer, or other members of the Smoke Free Task Force, which includes
the CSO representative designated shall develop, promote and implement a
Smoking Cessation Program and encourage the participation therein of public and
private facilities which may be able to provide for its requirements. Smokers who
are willing to quit including those who may be dual users of tobacco or ENDS
products, or ENDS product users who may have developed dependence, and those
found violating this Ordinance may be referred to the Smoking Cessation Program
and its facilities.
RULE XII
ENFORCEMENT
104
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 9 (9.1, 9.2 & 9.3)
105
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 9.4
106
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 9.5
107
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 10
108
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 11
Page 20 of 34
MEMBERS:
- City Administrator
- City Engineer
- City Treasurer
Page 21 of 34
12.2 Disqualifications109
To protect the primary health objectives of the Ordinance from any and all interests
prejudicial to tobacco control policies and to preserve its integrity, the Task Force shall
not include or admit as its member any person or entity who:
109
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 11
110
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 11
111
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12, Par. 1
112
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12, Par. 1
113
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12, Par. 1
114
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12, Par. 1
Page 22 of 34
12.5.1 The City Health Officer shall:
a) Serve as the overall coordinator among all the offices/departments involved
in the implementation of the Ordinance;
c) Monitor, together with the Sanitary Inspector, Enforcers and/or Task Force
members, the compliance of this Ordinance in public places, establishments,
conveyances, point-of-sale, and including the approval/disapproval of permits in
Designated Smoking/Vaping Areas (DSAs/DVAs) as well as permits/licenses for
tobacco/ENDs point-of-sale.115
g) Assist hospitals and other health facilities including any office of the DOH
within Butuan City, together with the Sanitary Inspector, Enforcers and/or Task
Force members, in the monitoring of tobacco/ENDS products’ sales,
advertisements and promotions within 100 meters from the perimeter of schools,
public playgrounds, facilities frequented by minors and health facilities. 116
115
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12.1(c)
116
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12.1(g)
Page 23 of 34
b) Provide technical assistance in terms of trainings, augmentation of logistics
and IEC materials and building networks
a) Conduct, together with the City Health Office or on its own, inspection
activities as provided in the Ordinance;
c) Facilitate the conduct of community service for those offenders who chose
and manifested to undertake the same
117
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12.11 (d)
118
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12.11 (e)
Page 24 of 34
12.5.8 The City Public Information Officer shall:
e) Facilitate the release and allocation of funds derived from the collection of
fines, generated resources and appropriated budget
119
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12.7 (c)
Page 25 of 34
a) Oversee the implementation of smoke free government facilities and
compliance with CSC MC No. 17-2009, this Ordinance and Rules
120
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12.17 (d)
121
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12.17 (e)
Page 26 of 34
a) Conduct periodic monitoring of air, water, soil quality and other studies
pertinent to determining levels of exposure to tobacco smoke, residue, by-
products and litter;
b) Ensure strict compliance of the Memos and Orders on the protection of the
bureaucracy from Tobacco Industry Interference as per FCTC Article 5.3
d) Ensure the posting of “No Smoking” signs and notices on the ban on the sale
of Tobacco Products within 100 meters from the perimeter of schools and
centers of youth activity
b) Coordinate with all Barangay Captains and the PNP in monitoring violations of
the Ordinance within his jurisdiction
122
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 12.13 (but note that this numbering may be a clerical error, and the correct
number should be “12.16”)
Page 27 of 34
b) Monitor compliance of public places, establishments, conveyances, point-of-
sale, DSAs with the Ordinance and Rules, together with other members of the
Task Force
c) Coordinate with enforcers and/or Task Force members regarding the imposition
of fines, suspension or revocation of licenses/permits for violations;
a) Upon a finding by duly authorized enforcers such as members of the PNP and/or
persons duly deputized by the Task Force of a violation of the Ordinance or failure
to comply with the provisions of Section 5 and 6 thereof, the violator shall be
apprehended;
b) The enforcer shall identify the violator and his/her address through any valid
government-issued identification card presented by the latter upon apprehension
such as but not limited to: driver’s license, Professional Identification Card or PRC
license, postal ID, voter’s ID, Unified Multipurpose ID (UMID), Government Service
Insurance System (GSIS) e-card, Social Security System (SSS) card, PhilHealth
card, Senior Citizen’s ID and government office ID.
In case any valid or sufficient form of identification is not presented, he/she shall
be brought to the nearest police station for proper identification.
c) The violator shall then be issued with a citation ticket in accordance with Section 9
of the Ordinance and Rule 10 hereof;
e) Should the violator be a minor as defined in the Ordinance and Rules, he or she
must be brought to the nearest Social Welfare Office for dispensation or
appropriate action subject to Republic Act No. 9344 or the Juvenile Justice and
Welfare Law), and/or to the school authorities at the school where the minor is
enrolled, and/or to the Barangay Office where the minor is a resident, and where
the parents or guardians maybe called.
f) In the conduct of enforcement, monitoring and roving operations, the enforcer may
be accompanied by any barangay official or representative of the barangay, if
available, who shall sign the citation ticket as corroborating witness;
g) The violator shall report to the City Treasurer’s Office or its duly authorized
collecting agent within five (5) regular business days from the time of the issuance
of the citation ticket for the payment of the fine or for him/her to personally manifest
whether or not he/she will undertake community service.
The City Treasurer’s Office shall immediately verify its records to determine the
frequency of commission of the violator concerned. If it has been determined that
123
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 13
Page 28 of 34
the violator has committed any of the prohibited acts for a third time or oftener or
is a habitual delinquent, the said Office shall decline any money tendered by the
former as payment for the fine corresponding to such third or subsequent offense,
and indorse the latter’s citation ticket to the City Legal Office for the filing of
appropriate charges.
If it has been determined that the violator has been apprehended for the first or
second offense, the said Office shall require him/her to pay the fine prescribed for
such first or second offense. Otherwise, if the violator elects and manifests to
undertake community service, the said Office shall refer him/her to the CENRO
through the ESWM Division;
h) The apprehending officers shall forward copies of the citation tickets issued to the
City Treasurer’s Office as frequent as once a week. Immediately thereafter, the
said Office shall:
2) For offenders who have been apprehended for the first and second offense or
instance but have failed to pay or settle the fines corresponding thereto within
the time prescribed, the said Office shall segregate and forward their citation
tickets to the City Legal Office for the preparation and filing of the proper
complaints.
i) The City Legal Office may request in writing the withdrawal of any pending criminal
case filed for violation of the Ordinance subject to the following conditions:
1) The accused has been found to have violated the Ordinance for the first or
second offense but fails to pay or settle the fine corresponding thereto within
the time prescribed and a case is already filed in court.
2) The accused, during the pendency of his case, pays the fine corresponding to
such first or second offense and an additional administrative fine in the
amount of One Thousand Five Hundred Pesos (P 1,500.00) as imposed by SP
Ordinance No. 2417-2002 as amended by SP Ordinance No. 5098-2016.
3) The accused presents to the City Legal Office an Official Receipt duly issued
by the City Treasurer’s Office showing payment of the said fines.
The said Office shall not request the withdrawal of the case of an accused found
to have violated the Ordinance for a third time or oftener inasmuch as the latter is
prohibited from paying the fine and that payment of the fine for the third and
subsequent offense is a penalty which the Court at its discretion can impose with
or without imprisonment for a period not exceeding one (1) year.
Page 29 of 34
a) Members of the PNP and/or persons duly deputized by the Task Force shall
inspect public conveyances plying city streets and thoroughfares during their hours
of operation;
b) Upon a finding of a violation of the Ordinance, the person in-charge thereof shall
be apprehended;
c) The apprehending officer shall identify the violator and his/her address by his/her
driver’s license or by any government-issued identification card presented by the
latter upon apprehension such as but not limited to: Professional Identification
Card or PRC license, postal ID, voter’s ID, Unified Multipurpose ID (UMID),
Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) e-card, Social Security System
(SSS) card, PhilHealth card, Senior Citizen’s ID and government office ID.
In case any valid or sufficient form of identification is not presented, he/she shall
be brought to the nearest police station for proper identification. 124
d) Citation tickets shall then be issued to the person in-charge of the conveyance.
e) In the conduct of enforcement, monitoring and roving operations, the enforcer may
be accompanied by any barangay official or representative of the barangay, if
available, who shall sign the citation ticket as corroborating witness;
f) The violator shall report to the City Treasurer’s Office or its duly authorized
collecting agent within five (5) regular business days from the time of the issuance
of the citation ticket for the payment of the fine or for him/her to personally manifest
whether or not he/she will undertake community service.
The City Treasurer’s Office shall immediately verify its records to determine the
frequency of commission of the violator concerned. If it has been determined that
the violator has committed any of the prohibited acts for a third time or oftener or
is a habitual delinquent, the said Office shall decline any money tendered by the
former as payment for the fine corresponding to such third or subsequent offense,
and indorse the latter’s citation ticket to the City Legal Office for the filing of
appropriate charges.
If it has been determined that the violator has been apprehended for the first or
second offense, the said Office shall require him/her to pay the fine prescribed for
such first or second offense. Otherwise, if the violator elects and manifests to
undertake community service, the said Office shall refer him/her to the CENRO
through the ESWM Division;
124
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 13
Page 30 of 34
citation ticket of the offender concerned to the City Legal Office for the
preparation and filing of the proper complaint.
2) For offenders who have been apprehended for the first and second offense or
instance but have failed to pay or settle the fines corresponding thereto within
the time prescribed, the said Office shall segregate and forward their citation
tickets to the City Legal Office for the preparation and filing of the proper
complaints.
i) The City Legal Office may request in writing the withdrawal of any pending criminal
case filed for violation of the Ordinance subject to the following conditions:
1) The accused has been found to have violated the Ordinance for the first or
second offense but fails to pay or settle the fine corresponding thereto with the
City Treasurer’s Office within the time prescribed and a case is already filed in
court.
2) The accused, during the pendency of his case, pays the City Treasurer’s Office
the fine corresponding to such first or second offense and an additional
administrative fine in the amount of One Thousand Five Hundred Pesos (P
1,500.00) as imposed by SP Ordinance No. 2417-2002 as amended by SP
Ordinance No. 5098-2016.
3) The accused presents to the City Legal Office an Official Receipt duly issued
by the City Treasurer’s Office showing payment of the said fines.
The said Office shall not request the withdrawal of the case of an accused found
to have violated the Ordinance for a third time or oftener inasmuch as the latter is
prohibited from paying the fine and that payment of the fine for the third and
subsequent offense is a penalty which the Court at its discretion can impose with
or without imprisonment for a period not exceeding one (1) year.
a) Representatives from the City Health Office, the City Engineer’s Office and
Business Permits and Licenses Division shall form an inspectorate team to
conduct inspections of establishments and buildings, in enclosed or partially
enclosed public places, workplaces and Designated Smoking Areas to determine
their compliance with the Ordinance and these Rules. In conducting inspections,
the inspectorate team may be joined by any barangay official or representative of
the barangay, if available, who shall sign the citation ticket (or notice of violation)
as corroborating witness;
b) Regular inspection shall be conducted at least once every month by the team either
on its own or simultaneously with other inspections by appropriate offices or
departments, whichever is more frequent, during normal hours of operation of the
establishment;
Page 31 of 34
d) A citation ticket shall be issued for each day the establishment is found to be non-
compliant;
e) Re-inspection of the establishment shall be done any time after the issuance of the
citation ticket but no re-inspection shall be conducted after the lapse of ten (10)
days from the date of issuance of the ticket;
h) In the course of the inspection, the inspectorate team may apprehend individual
violators and request the assistance of the PNP whenever necessary.
a) The City Health Office shall designate one or more civil society organizations
(CSO) not connected/represents interests of the Tobacco Industry to discharge the
duties enumerated in Section 12.8 of the Ordinance subject to the approval of the
City Mayor
b) The Mayor may deputize qualified civilians to serve as enforcers of the Ordinance.
c) Any person can file with the Task Force a report or complaint, or present evidence
for any violation of this Ordinance, or be assigned other duties pursuant to the
attainment of its effective implementation.
RULE XIII
c) Conduct lectures to brief members of the police force on the provisions of the
Ordinance and their responsibilities thereunder with respect to enforcement
125
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 16
126
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 17.1
Page 32 of 34
13.1.2 Provide a copy of the Ordinance and its primer to all establishments with existing
licenses to operate as well as to those applying for new licenses or permits to operate,
and/or permits to sell tobacco/ENDS products, in coordination with the Business Permits
and Licenses Division;127
13.1.3 Provide a copy of the Ordinance and its primer to all public conveyances plying
within and through the city. 128
13.2 The City Engineer’s Office shall put up billboards in all conspicuous places in the
city to inform the public of the restrictions and sanctions imposed by the Ordinance. The
City Public Information Office shall also immediately issue notices regarding the
obligations of persons under the Ordinance at the barangay level for dissemination
therein.129
RULE XIV
APPROPRIATION
14.1 Funding.131
A minimum of ten percent (10%) shall automatically be set aside in the annual budget of
the City for the implementation and enforcement of the Ordinance based on the Butuan
City plans and programs, and to defray expenses such as but not limited to:
14.1.1 Cost of printing copies of the Ordinance, Citation Tickets and information,
education and communication materials pertaining to tobacco control;
14.1.2 Cost of inspection and enforcement by the Smoke Free Task Force including
allowances for meals and transportation, the amounts of which shall be set by the Office
of the Mayor;
14.1.3 Incentives or rewards for private citizens who report violations of the Ordinance;
127
SP Ordinance No. 5598-2018, Sec. 17.2
128
As an observation, this has been omitted in the new ordinance.
129
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 18
130
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 19
131
SP Ordinance No. 4407-2014, Sec. 20
Page 33 of 34
14.1.4 Institutional and operating expenses of the Smoking Cessation Program and
facility;
14.1.5 Other expenses associated with the implementation and enforcement of the
Ordinance.
14.2.1 Twenty-five percent (25%) of the amount of the penalty paid by a violator to the
City Treasurer’s Office shall accrue to the apprehending officer or deputized enforcer as
incentive.
14.2.2 The remainder of seventy-five percent (75%) shall accrue to a Trust Fund
established for the purpose of defraying the costs of operations of the Smoke Free Task
Force. The Task Force shall have the power to determine how the Trust Fund is to be
utilized in furtherance of the Ordinance but subject to the usual government accounting
and auditing rules and regulations.
RULE XV
EFFECTIVITY
These implementing rules and regulations shall take effect fifteen (15) days
following their publication in a newspaper of local or general circulation within the City of
Butuan, and posting in at least two (2) conspicuous places therein.
SO ORDERED.
Done this _____ day of __________ in the year of our Lord, Two Thousand and
Eighteen in Butuan City, Philippines.
Page 34 of 34