Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI: 10.5301/jn.5000188
Pamidronate
Two studies used a similar design to determine the dialyz- Continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD)
ability of clodronate, infusing 300 mg over two hours prior to
four-hour dialysis (7, 8). Calculated clodronate clearances, Because bone metabolism in CAPD has only been studied
86 ± 10 mL/min and 88 ± 16 mL/min, were largely similar to with methylene-bisphosphonate (13), no figures for bisphos-
those for normal renal function. A study of clodronate up- phonate clearance via CAPD can be provided.
take into bone found a clear dependency on PTH levels and
bone metabolism: the higher the PTH, the greater the bone Animal studies
uptake (11).
Initial models of bisphosphonate therapy for hyperparathy-
Ibandronate roid bone disease were explored in animals using ibandro-
nate (14), olpadronate (15), and pamidronate (16).
Clearance of ibandronate 1 mg administered at the start of Ibandronate 1.25 µg/kg or placebo was administered sub-
fourhour hemodialysis was 92 ± 19 mL/min, a value like- cutaneously (sc) weekly for three weeks to 2/3 nephrecto-
wise virtually identical to that for normal renal function (9). mized rats and the results compared with sham-operated
To quantify bone binding in the absence of subsequent di- controls with normal renal function (14). Ibandronate com-
Table I
Target parathormone, calcium and phosphate values according to National Kidney Foundation
Kidney Disease Outcome Quality Initiative (KDOQI) guidelines (5)
Parathyroid hormone 150-300 pg/mL 16.5-33.0 pmol/L Evidence
Calcium 8.4-9.5 mg/dL 2.1-2.37 mmol/L Opinion
Phosphate 3.5-5.5 mg/dL 1.13-1.78 mmol/L Evidence
Calcium × phosphate < 55 mg2/dL2 Evidence
pletely abolished the bone effects of developing hyper- use of the various bisphosphonates in this setting. The first
parathyroidism in nephrectomized rats. Bone resorption trial of clodronate in dialysis patients dates from 1990 (17).
parameters (deoxypyridinoline) and bone volume to total However, this was a very brief study in nine patients with
volume (BV/TV) in the ibandronate group were almost identi- severe hyperparathyroid bone disease who received an
cal to those in the rats with normal renal function. infusion of clodronate 300-600 mg at the end of five con-
A near-identical study design in 5/6 nephrectomized rats secutive dialysis sessions. A significant fall was observed
administered olpadronate 1.6 µg sc weekly for five weeks in bone resorption parameters (hydroxyproline) and calcium
found a similar effect (15). After an initial increase in de- and phosphate levels. Alkaline phosphatase (AP) and PTH
oxypyridinoline in nephrectomized animals, levels in the ac- values, on the other hand, increased. While some of the pa-
tive treatment group subsequently declined to those in the tients were simply followed up, others received clodronate
sham-operated animals versus marked bone resorption in 1.6 g orally daily for a further two weeks. Only these longer-
the placebo controls. Olpadronate significantly reduced the treated patients showed sustained benefit in terms of their
tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) positive osteo- laboratory parameters.
clast count and significantly increased bone volume. In a longer, 12-month, open-label and non-placebo-con-
In the pamidronate study, rats were 5/6 nephrectomized, trolled study, 13 patients with persistent severe hyper-
uninephrectomized, or left intact; 14 weeks later, the uni and parathyroidism (PTH >500 pg/mL [normal 12-65 pg/mL]),
5/6 nephrectomized rats received pamidronate 3 mg/kg/ hypercalcemia (>11 mg/dL), normal phosphate, and osteo-
week sc or placebo for eight weeks; the intact rats received penia (T-score <1 SD), received an infusion of pamidronate
placebo (16). Whereas the uninephrectomized rats devel- 60 mg every two months during dialysis (18). Bone density
oped only mild renal failure with no marked bone metabolic increased significantly in both the lumbar spine and femoral
effects, PTH values increased 5-fold in the 5/6 nephrecto- neck. PTH levels were massively increased at three months,
mized rats. Bone histology revealed renal osteopathy with however, only to reverse subsequently in ten of the 13 pa-
osteitis fibrosa and increased bone turnover. Pamidronate tients: by one year, PTH levels in these 10 patients had fallen
therapy markedly decreased bone metabolism in all animals significantly below baseline, while the calcitriol dose had
and attained values below the normal range, while bone been increased from 1 µg/week to 3 µg/week without caus-
density increased significantly. However, no animal devel- ing the hypercalcemia that had previously made such an
oped osteomalacia. increase impossible. Whether the PTH-lowering effect was
directly because of the pamidronate or the increased dose
Clinical studies (Tab. III) of calcitriol remains an open question.
In another open-label study with no placebo arm, 16 patients
The use of bisphosphonates for hyperparathyroid bone dis- with T-score ≤1.0 SD, PTH ≥2 × normal, and no reduction in
ease in dialysis patients has been the subject of varied edi- other bone metabolism parameters (TRAP5b, bone-specific
torials for years. The available animal studies indicate that AP and CrossLaps) received an injection of ibandronate 2 mg
such an approach is highly promising. All the more astonish- after dialysis every four weeks for 1 year; 11 patients were
ing, therefore, that there should still be virtually no data on the eventually fit for assessment (19). The study revealed a sig-
Table II
Bisphosphonate pharmacokinetics in a four-hour dialysis session
Beigel Ala-Houhala Bergner Buttazzoni
et al (7) et al (8) et al (9) et al (10)
Bisphosphonate Clodronate Clodronate Ibandronate Pamidronate
Dose (mg) 300 300 1 1
Treatment dosage 3 × 300-600 mg/d 2-6 mg 60-90 mg
Dialysis clearance (mL/min) 86 ± 10 88 ± 16 92 ± 19 69 ± 17
% administered dose cleared 35 35 37 32
by dialysis
Table III
Three long-term bisphosphonate studies in dialysis patients
Wetmore et al (20) Torregrosa et al (18) Bergner et al (19)
Type of study Randomized vs. placebo Open-label Open-label
No. (complete data available) 16/15 (31) 13 (13) 16 (12)
Bisphosphonate Alendronate Pamidronate Ibandronate
Dosage 40 mg/week for 60 mg every 2 mg every
6 weeks 8 weeks 4 weeks
Duration (months) 6 12 12
Route Oral Intravenous during Intravenous after
hemodialysis hemodialysis
Inclusion criteria Age >40 y T-score ≤1 T-score ≤1.5
PTH 100-300 pg/mL PTH > 500 pg/mL PTH >130 pg/mL
Calcium × phosphate Calcium >11 mg/dL TRAP 5b & BAP not
<5.65 Phosphate <6 mg/dL below normal range
Endpoint Bone mineral density Not defined Bone mineral density
Bone density Dual energy X-ray Dual energy X-ray Quantitative computed
measurement absorptiometry absorptiometry tomography
Results Reduced bone density Significantly increased Significantly increased
loss vs. placebo bone density in bone density
lumbar spine & hip in lumbar spine
BAP = bone-specific alkaline phosphatase; PTH = parathyroid hormone; TRAP5b = tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase 5b.
Several animal studies have clearly shown that bisphos- PTH elevation alone does not exclude low-turnover oste-
phonate therapy reverses both the histologic changes of opathy (26, 27), every dialysis patient would ideally need a
experimental hyperparathyroidism and the changes in bone bone biopsy before commencing bisphosphonate therapy.
metabolism parameters. Osteomalacia was not induced Other unresolved questions concern the duration of bisphos-
despite the substantial reduction in bone remodeling. Bone phonate therapy in high-turnover osteopathy and the most
density increased markedly, as in the osteoporosis studies. appropriate parameters for monitoring treatment.
Yet despite these pharmacokinetic findings and experimen- Special attention should be given to potential side effects
tal renal osteopathy results, clinical study data are meager: of the bisphosphonates, especially the osteonecrosis of the
just three studies in small numbers of dialysis patients re- jaw. This severe side effect is reported mainly in patients
ceiving bisphosphonates. Doubtless all three studies have with high dose bisphosphonate treatment for malignant
substantial weaknesses here and there and are no substi- bone disease who undergo dental surgery (28). Only few
tute for large randomized placebo-controlled clinical trials, case reports of ONJ in dialysis patients are reported (29).
but they do point to a trend. Another point of interest might be the dosage of calcitriol,
In terms of weaknesses, none of the studies incorporated which increased in two studies (18, 19). Rising PTH levels
the gold standard investigation for diagnosing high turnover after starting bisphosphonate treatment lead to a higher
osteopathy, namely bone biopsy, and all patient numbers dosage of calcitriol with the potential risk of higher calcium
were very low. The studies also relied on bone density and and phosphorus levels. On the other hand, several studies
surrogate markers of bone metabolism (21), not the fracture demonstrated a calcium and phosphorus lowering effect
rates used in the pivotal studies of bisphosphonates in the of bisphosphonate treatment (30-33). Therefore, the risk
treatment of osteoporosis. of high calcium and phosphorus levels leading to a diffuse
In the pamidronate study it is also unclear how much of the tissue or vascular calcification would be low. In addition,
drug administered during dialysis was even taken up in bone, bisphosphonates have also shown a direct beneficial effect
since pamidronate is readily dialyzable. The alendronate on tissue and vascular calcification (34-36).
study can be criticized for the ultralow dose used. Neverthe- A case can be made on the basis of the data presented for
less, some observations remain that are consistent across extending bisphosphonate therapy to dialysis patients with
all three studies. Thus, bisphosphonates increase or stabi- certain forms of renal osteopathy. However, in the complete
lize bone density compared to placebo in dialysis patients absence to date of large randomized placebo-controlled tri-
too. They also increase PTH levels, according to a study of als, such therapy can only be recommended at best as an
this phenomenon by Lu et al (22), because of a transient de- individual management decision. In such cases, prior bone
crease in calcium. However, PTH levels subsequently fall to biopsy to confirm high-turnover osteopathy is mandatory.
below baseline, i.e. the effect is only transient.
Many questions remain open – treatment dose, for a start. Financial support: None.
It could be argued that the higher bone metabolism than in
osteoporosis requires a higher dose of bisphosphonate. On Conflict of interest statement: Dr. Bergner received speakers fee from
the other hand, the absence of renal excretion means that no Abbott, Amgen, Bristol-Myers-Squibb, Lilly and Roche Pharma.
bisphosphonate gets lost, with virtually the entire dose being
available to bone. Dose-finding studies are clearly needed. Address for correspondence:
It is also uncertain whether low bone density alone, as in Raoul Bergner, MD
Medizinische Klinik A
osteoporosis, is a sufficient indication for bisphosphonate
Klinikum der Stadt Ludwigshafen GmbH
therapy in dialysis patients (23-25). The danger in low-turn- Bremserstraße 79
over osteopathy is that the bisphosphonate radically inhibits 67063 Ludwigshafen, Germany
residual bone turnover, resulting in adynamic bone. Since bergnerr@klilu.de
4. Chowdhury MH, Hamada C, Dempster DW. Effects of heparin 21. Gerakis A, Hutchison AJ, Apostolou T, Freemont AJ, Billis A.
on osteoclast activity. J Bone Miner Res. 1992;7(7):771-777. Biochemical markers for non-invasive diagnosis of hyperpara-
5. KDOQI (Kidney Disease Outcomes Quality Initiative). KDOQI thyroid bone disease and adynamic bone in patients on hae-
Clinical Practice Guidelines for Bone Metabolism and Dis- modialysis. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 1996;11(12):2430-2438.
ease in Chronic Kidney Disease. Available at: http://www. 22. Lu KC, Yeung LK, Lin SH, Lin YF, Chu P. Acute effect of pami-
kidney.org/professionals/KDOQI/guidelines_bone/index.htm. dronate on PTH secretion in postmenopausal hemodialysis
Accessed: April 13, 2012. patients with secondary hyperparathyroidism. Am J Kidney
6. Nickolas TL, Leonard MB, Shane E. Chronic kidney disease Dis. 2003;42(6):1221-1227.
and bone fracture: a growing concern. Kidney Int. 2008; 23. Gerakis A, Hadjidakis D, Kokkinakis E, Apostolou T, Raptis
74(6):721-731. S, Billis A. Correlation of bone mineral density with the histo-
7. Beigel AE, Rienhoff E, Olbricht CJ. Removal of clodronate by logical findings of renal osteodystrophy in patients on hemo-
haemodialysis in end-stage renal disease patients. Nephrol dialysis. J Nephrol. 2000;13(6):437-443.
Dial Transplant. 1995;10(12):2266-2268. 24. Fontaine MA, Albert A, Dubois B, Saint-Remy A, Rorive G.
8. Ala-Houhala I, Saha H, Liukko-Sipi S, Ylitalo P, Pasternack A. Fracture and bone mineral density in hemodialysis patients.
Pharmacokinetics of clodronate in haemodialysis patients. Clin Nephrol. 2000;54(3):218-226.
Nephrol Dial Transplant. 1999;14(3):699-705. 25. Ureña P, Bernard-Poenaru O, Ostertag A, et al. Bone mineral
9. Bergner R, Dill K, Boerner D, Uppenkamp M. Elimination of density, biochemical markers and skeletal fractures in haemodi-
intravenously administered ibandronate in patients on hae- alysis patients. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2003;18(11):2325-2331.
modialysis: a monocentre open study. Nephrol Dial Trans- 26. Coen G, Ballanti P, Bonucci E, et al. Renal osteodystrophy
plant. 2002;17(7):1281-1285. in predialysis and hemodialysis patients: comparison of his-
10. Buttazzoni M, Rosa Diez GJ, Jager V, Crucelegui MS, Algrana- tologic patterns and diagnostic predictivity of intact PTH.
ti SL, Plantalech L. Elimination and clearance of pamidronate Nephron. 2002;91(1):103-111.
by haemodialysis. Nephrology (Carlton). 2006;11(3):197-200. 27. Drüeke TB. Is parathyroid hormone measurement useful for the
11. Saha H, Ala-Houhala I, Ylitalo P, Kleimola T, Pasternack A. diagnosis of renal bone disease? Kidney Int. 2008;73(6):674-676.
Skeletal deposition of clodronate is related to parathyroid 28. Pazianas M, Miller P, Blumentals WA, Bernal M, Kothawala P.
function and bone turnover in dialysis patients. Clin Nephrol. A review of the literature on osteonecrosis of the jaw in pa-
2002;58(1):47-53. tients with osteoporosis treated with oral bisphosphonates:
12. Bergner R, Henrich D, Hoffmann M, et al. High bone-binding prevalence, risk factors, and clinical characteristics. Clin
capacity of ibandronate in hemodialysis patients. Int J Clin Ther. 2007;29(8):1548-1558.
Pharmacol Res. 2005;25(3):123-131. 29. Papagni S, Mongelli N, Cozzolino M, Brancaccio D,
13. Joffe P, Henriksen JH. Aspects of osseous, peritoneal and renal Ciccolella F, Favia G. [Avascular jaw osteonecrosis in a
handling of bisphosphonate during peritoneal dialysis: a meth- hemodialysis patient treated with bisphosphonates.]. G Ital
odological study. Scand J Clin Lab Invest. 1996;56(4):327-337. Nefrol. 2007;24(3):230-234.
14. Geng Z, Monier-Faugere MC, Bauss F, Malluche HH. Short-term 30. Davenport A, Goel S, Mackenzie JC. Treatment of hypercal-
administration of the bisphosphonate ibandronate increases caemia with pamidronate in patients with end stage renal
bone volume and prevents hyperparathyroid bone changes in failure. Scand J Urol Nephrol. 1993;27(4):447-451.
mild experimental renal failure. Clin Nephrol. 2000;54(1):45-53. 31. Trimarchi H, Lombi F, Forrester M, et al. Disodium pamidro-
15. Tomat A, Gamba CA, Mandalunis P, et al. Changes in bone nate for treating severe hypercalcemia in a hemodialysis pa-
volume and bone resorption by olpadronate treatment in an tient. Nat Clin Pract Nephrol. 2006;2(8):459-463, quiz 464.
experimental model of uremic bone disease. J Musculoske- 32. Czosnowski LM, Hudson JQ, Canada RB. Hypercalcemia
let Neuronal Interact. 2005;5(2):174-181. associated with tertiary hyperparathyroidism managed con-
16. Jokihaara J, Pörsti IH, Kööbi P, et al. Treatment of experi- servatively with pamidronate in a hemodialysis patient. Am J
mental renal osteodystrophy with pamidronate. Kidney Int. Med Sci. 2009;337(4):300-301.
2008;74(3):319-327. 33. Musso CG, Guelman R, Varela F, et al. Ibandronate improves
17. Hamdy NA, McCloskey EV, Brown CB, Kanis JA. Effects hyperphosphatemia in dialysis patients with hyperparathy-
of clodronate in severe hyperparathyroid bone disease in roidism. Int Urol Nephrol. 2004;36(4):625-627.
chronic renal failure. Nephron. 1990;56(1):6-12. 34. Tamura K, Hashiba H, Kogo H, Aizawa S, Shigematsu T. [Sup-
18. Torregrosa JV, Moreno A, Mas M, Ybarra J, Fuster D. Useful- pressive effects of bisphosphonates on the vascular calcifica-
ness of pamidronate in severe secondary hyperparathyroid- tion in ESRD patients]. Clin Calcium. 2002;12(8):1129-1135.
ism in patients undergoing hemodialysis. Kidney Int Suppl. 35. Obad D, Larsen NA, Pedersen EB. [Regression of severe peri-
2003;85(85):S88-S90. articular calcifications during treatment with bisphosphonate
19. Bergner R, Henrich D, Hoffmann M, Schmidt-Gayk H, Lenz T, in a dialysis patient]. Ugeskr Laeger. 2010;172(9):719-721.
Upperkamp M. Treatment of reduced bone density with iban- 36. Okada Y, Mori H, Tanaka Y, Hashimoto O. [Positioning of
dronate in dialysis patients. J Nephrol. 2008;21(4):510-516. bisphosphonates for vascular calcification]. Clin Calcium.
20. Wetmore JB, Benet LZ, Kleinstuck D, Frassetto L. Effects of 2010;20(11):1711-1717.
short-term alendronate on bone mineral density in haemo-
dialysis patients. Nephrology (Carlton). 2005;10(4):393-399. Accepted: May 08, 2012