Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The thesis titled REDEVELOPMENT OF NEW DELHI RAILWAY STATION has been carried out by the undersigned as part of the Bachelors
Degree Program in the Department of Architecture, School of Planning and Architecture, New Delhi – 110002, India under the
supervision of Shiriesh Malpani ,Prof. Manoj Mathur and Prof. Dr. Jaya Kumar.
I hereby submit 2 hard copies of the report for internal and external evaluation respectively.
The undersigned hereby declares that this is his/her original work and has not been plagiarized in part or full from any source.
Furthermore this work has not been submitted for any degree in this or any other University.
This thesis was carried out during the January – May 2017 semester in the Department of Architecture. Thereafter, based on this
declaration by the candidate, the thesis was placed in front of External Jury held on 24th & 25th of May 2017. For this work, the
candidate was awarded the following marks :
Internal Marks ___________out of 450 Marks
External Marks ___________out of 250 Marks.
On Successful completion of Bachelor of Architecture course by the Candidate, the undersigned hereby accepts the Thesis Report
on behalf of the Department, so that it may be placed in the Architecture Library.
I would like to express my gratitude to my thesis guides Shiriesh Malpani , Prof. Manoj Mathur and Prof. Dr. Jaya Kumar for
guiding me throughout the research and design process . It would not have been possible to carry out this project successfully
without their kind support and inputs at critical stages of design translations .
I am thankful to Prof. Dr. Aruna Ramani Grover and Prof. Dr. Jaya Kumar , Studio Co-ordinators for their guidance and constant
supervision as well as for systematic structuring of the studios so as to make it gradual process of learning and application .
I would like to express my special gratitude and thanks to Mr. Suresh Sharma (Delhi - railway engineer department , DRM Office,
New Delhi Railway Station) Mr. P.R.Mehta (Ex President of CoA, Design Action Group) and Mr. S.K Lohia (CEO, Indian Railways
Station Development Corporation) for their invaluable inputs and contribution and helping me understand the New Delhi Railway
Station . Also , Ar. Sumeet Kumar ( Architect, Indian Railways Station Development Corporation – new proposal for Anand Vihar
Railway Station) for helping me understand the project and giving me insights about the new development policy of Indian
Railways .
My thanks and appreciations also go to my friends who helped me develop the project at every step and others who have willingly
helped me out with their abilities.
I would finally like to thanks my parents. Without their constant support and motivation this project wouldn’t have been possible .
LIST OF CONTENTS
Chapter 1: Introduction
1.1 Introduction and need for identification of the Project
1.2 Proposition
1.3 Architectural Vision
Chapter 2: Research
2.1 Area of Research (General Enquiries)
2.1.1 Primary : Present day Problems
2.1.2 Secondary : Types of Railway Stations, functional layouts.
2.2 Case Studies
2.2.1 Primary Case Study : Anand Vihar Railway Station
2.2.2 Secondary Case Study : Rotterdam Central Station , Netherlands
TaiYuan South Station, China
Chapter 5: Technology
5.1 Structural System
5.2 Universal Accessibility
5.3 Sewage Treatment/ Fire Tank / Water Tank
5.4 Sustainable methods adopted.
Chapter 7: Evolution
7.1 Evolution of Design
Chapter 8: Development
8.1 Design Development
8.2 Design Framework
NEED IDENTIFICATION
PROPOSITION
OBJECTIVES
The railway station as a permanent architecture The objective is to take up revamping under following
manifestation has not just been the centre of urban life. In heads and beyond
most cases, the railway station occupies an unrivalled
prime location in the heart of the city or in another • Large Passenger Concourse Areas with adequate and
convenient central position, connected to other transport high quality facilities for the users.
networks. People on business or tourists almost always • Movement Systems – Pedestrian : There will be
pass through a town’s railway station. seamless movement of incoming as well as outgoing
passengers. It will also take care of integration of
They are large infrastructures that should ideally define passengers coming from Paharganj side towards Ajmeri
the image of the city in which they are placed, but that is Gate, it will continue to integrate with the existing
hardly the case. The stations are generally crippled with Delhi Metro.
low level of maintenance and lack of passenger • Movement Systems – Vehicular : It will be designed in
convenient designs. such a manner, so that, the station does not become a
barrier between both sides of the city. Vehicles will
Whenever the Railway introduces its annual budget, it sets have more than one option to enter and exit. The road
aim to increase more no. of trains and railway tracks. They network will circumscribe the terminal building, so that
hardly identify the underlying issue of the existing stations vehicles can cross either sides, without having to use
which have saturated their potential to handle passengers. the existing congested flyover.
Most terminal and suburban stations are either running on • Amenities : Adequate number of toilets , clean drinking
their peak designed passenger count, or exceeding by a water, security, food courts, restaurants and railway
huge margin. yatra niwas.
ARCHITECTURAL VISION
RESEARCH
Structural Enquiries
What type of structural systems are required?
What kind of materials should be used?
What are the kind of spaces required, that can regulate the structural considerations?
CHAPTER 2
RESEARCH
Condition pertaining to the Site Surroundings The climate of Delhi is an overlap between monsoon-
influenced humid subtropical and semi-arid, with high
Lack of Parking Space. Drop offs are congested. Scarcity in terms of public toilets, variation between summer and winter temperatures and
connectivity between both the sides of the station is very poor. precipitation. Delhi's version of a humid subtropical climate
is markedly different from many other humid subtropical
There is no integrated connection between the Railways and the Metro Stations. Bus Service cities such as Sao Paulo, New Orleans and Brisbane in that
is poor, walkable distance between Ajmeri Gate and Bus Stop is about 500 meters. Lack of the city features dust storms (something more commonly
Food and Beverage stalls, ATMs, Pre Paid Taxi Stalls etc. Signage is often missing, which leads seen in a desert climate), has relatively dry short winters
to confusion and ambiguity. and has a prolonged spell of very hot weather, due to
its semi-arid climate. (The weatherspark)
CHAPTER 2
RESEARCH
Design based Enquiry
What are the constituent functions in a Railway Terminal Station?
Terminal Building, Parking Lot, Platforms, Railway Tracks, Drop offs for Cars,
Buses, TSRs etc. Integrated services such Metro , Trams , Buses (if available).
There are Island platforms and side platforms. Island Platforms, Split level
Platforms and through types.
There are total 7 Island Platforms and 2 Side Platforms currently existing at NDLS.
What are the minimum dimensions for Railway Tracks, Platforms, Staircases
etc.
Staircases
The rise of the stairs shall preferably be limited to 3500 mm. However, specific
site conditions may cause an increase in this dimension.
RESEARCH
Platform Length
Platform length is typically determined by the length of the longest train anticipated for the
station (e.g., a 24-coach train at 22.5m per coach with a 22m engine at each end will require at
least a 584 m platform) plus 4.5 m or as directed by INDIAN RAILWAYS.
Platform Width
Platform width is typically determined by several factors:
a) The width of any VCEs located within the length of the platform.
b) An architecturally preferred minimum 2.640 m clear distance to any obstruction, such as a
VCE, from the platform edge. This distance includes the .609 m wide platform safety edge, a
1.725 m clear passage for customers circulating along the platform length, and a .13 m buffer
zone along the length of the obstruction. Where a platform edge rubbing strip is employed,
the width of the rub strip shall not be included within the preferred minimum clear distance
and the edge of the platform shall be measured from the inside edge of the rubbing. The rub
strip will not be included as part of the .609 m width of the platform safety edge.
c) Station patronage and emergency exiting requirements.
d) Space requirements as determined by Level of Service requirements.
What are the services required in a terminal building? (Lighting, Sounds, MEP etc.)
Terminal Building should be well lit, with maximum day lighting. And providing necessary
points for artificial lighting where ever necessary.
Sound & Acoustic treatment is required in upper class waiting lounges. MEP is applicable
to the type of the terminal building.
As per the bye laws, Parking requirement is 2 ECS per 100 Sqm. (Proposed Built up Area –
50,000 Sqm) Total Parking Required therefore = 1,000 Car Parking.
CHAPTER 2
RESEARCH
Fig. 8 : Minimum dimensions for railway tracks and berth clearance. (Manual for WCS)
CHAPTER 2
RESEARCH
RESEARCH
Structural Enquiries
What type of structural systems are
required?
RESEARCH
PRIIMARY CASE STUDY : ANAND VIHAR (UNDERSTANDING THE CURRENT SITUATION)
CASE STUDY 01
FACT FILE
AREA : 99500 sqm
Phase 2 Development
RESEARCH
Fig. 13 : Anand Vihar Railway Terminal Fig. 14 : Anand Vihar Railway Terminal (View 1)
RESEARCH
Fig. 15 : Panoramic view from the footbridge. Fig. 16 : Collection of Site Images
General Problems
Fig. 12 : Site Plan of Anand Vihar Fig. 16 : Distance between buildings made longer due to lack of integration.
CHAPTER 2
RESEARCH
RESEARCH
Huge number of
passengers
interchange from
local train to either
mode of transport
i.e. bus or metro
because people
towards Delhi
from Ghaziabad to
go to
office/college. Fig. 20 : High Capacity Vehicles Movement At Anand Vihar Junction
RESEARCH
SECONDARY CASE STUDY : ROTTERDAM CENTRAL STATION (Types of Railway Stations, functional layouts.) Number of Platforms – 13
CASE STUDY 02
Platform Type – Island Platforms
RESEARCH
RESEARCH
RESEARCH
RESEARCH
Planning Process – The Terminal has been designed such that there is minimum hindrance to the passenger movement. There is a non ticketed area, which
also functions as departure concourse and offers some amount of retail space.
The tracks have been elevated, which gave a clear passage for passenger movement from both sides of the station. It has two levels, once entered through
the passenger concourse, there is one level that goes down thus connecting to the Metro, whereas the upper level connects to the HST (High Speed
Railway) network.
The routing through the station is logical; travellers are guided by a direct view of the trains and by the daylight that penetrates to the traveller's passage
via the voids that extend
CHAPTER 2
Learning’s From Case Study
RESEARCH
The terminal building has two floors above ground and one underground,
connected by escalators, elevators, and stairs. Inside it, there are many bilingual
direction boards in English and Chinese.
2F: waiting areas, including special areas for business class passengers, group
passengers, mothers and children, and the disabled passengers; servicing areas
including information desks, restaurants, bank, shops, toilets, and hot drink
water; ticket barriers; left luggage office (At the west end of the floor)
1F: Platforms, exits and entrances, security checks, ticket hall, arrival hall, ticket
Fig. 32 : Taiyuan South Railway Station (Arch Daily) office (close to west exit), taxi stands, bus stops, parking lots, toilets, exits.
CHAPTER 2
RESEARCH
Fig. 34 : Taiyuan South Railway Station – First Floor Plan (Arch Daily)
CHAPTER 2
RESEARCH
Fig. 35 : Taiyuan South Railway Station – Platform Level Plan Ground Floor (Arch Daily)
CHAPTER 2
RESEARCH
Fig. 35 : Taiyuan South Railway Station – Sections showing thermal insulation and ventilation (Arch Daily)
Energy-saving space enclosing structure-the external space enclosing structure of Taiyuannan Railway Station employs novel double-layer hollow glass
and stone combined curtain. 6+12+6 tempered LOW-E hollow glass and stone combined curtain, 600mm air space between two layers of curtains and
unique curtain system greatly enhances the thermal inertia of the architectural surface and ensures stable indoor temperature, favourable for reduction
of energy consumption of the station in Taiyuan in cold winter. (Arch Daily)
CHAPTER 2
RESEARCH
KEY PLAN
Fig. 36 : Taiyuan South Railway Station – Section through Shorter Side (Arch Daily)
Fig. 38 : Taiyuan South Railway Station – Section through Longer Side, also showing integration with Metro (Arch Daily)
CHAPTER 2
Learning’s From Case Study
RESEARCH
PROGRAMATIC CONTENT
Sl No. Designated Space Activity Frequency of Use Visual Orientation Floor Level Spatial Character
4. Departure Concourse Departing Passengers Yes, Easily Visible Departure Well Lit up Space with all
24 Hrs the facilities
7. Information Centre Information Hub for Yes, Easily Visible All Levels Compact Unit with
the Passengers 24 Hrs ample space around
Objective: Maximum Passenger Convenience with Fast and Efficient Passenger Flow
Design Approach and Hierarchy: should be done from whole to part:
Primary Order: Describes the creation of Station volumes through large scale engineering. Yard alignment, no. & size of platform, size &
location of concourses etc.
Secondary Order: Building Components, such as detailing of concourse space, facilities of passengers, operational offices, staircases,
escalators, elevators, passageway, entry, exit, roof, ceilings, walls etc.
• Local city developmental bye-laws and master plan shall be followed in designing the capacity of infrastructure facilities, such as
building design.
• Other Codes or specifications in order of priority:
• National Building Code (NBC) & IRC Codes,
• Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS),
• American, British and International Standards,
KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS
(KPI)
Fig. 46 : Overview of Stations of UK and India Fig. 47 : Illustrative Site Plan of NDLS
Presently operational “Platform Berthing Chart” of New Delhi Railway Station as shown below:
21,000
Table 5 : Area Program (Ticketing & Booking) Table 6 : Area Program (Facilities & Amenities)
SUPPORTING FUNCTIONS OUTDOOR FUNCTIONS
Sl No. Space Designation Area Required Sl No. Space Designation Area Required
(Sqm) (Sqm)
1. Railway Police Force (RPF) ( 50 Jawans) - 1. Concourse Area for Passengers (Using 50,000 passengers 75,000
per hour as peak hour rush)
2. General RPF Changing Room ( 100 Jawans) 500 2. For Goods and maintenance 25,000
15. Main Store & Sub Store 200 4. Supporting Functions 6,870
5. Administration 1,450
16. Battery Room 100
2,00,105
6,870
Table 7 : Area Program (Supporting Functions) Table 9 : Area Program (Total Area Requirement)
CHAPTER 4
SITE ANALYSIS
The city has five railway stations with the New Delhi Railway Station being the central one and is the
busiest railway station in the city. Anand Vihar station and Biswan Railway Station are two upcoming
railway stations in the city so as to decentralize the footfall in New Delhi Railway
The New Delhi Interchange becomes one of the most important multimodal nodes as it has the
Railway Station, the Airport Express Metro station and the Yellow line . Another line is proposed to
be built and is currently under construction.
OVERVIEW
NDLS
Fig. 48 : Map of Delhi showing Hazrat Nizamuddin Railway Stn. & NDLS
SITE COMPONENTS
Table 10 : Railway Stations in Delhi (Urban Mobility Conference & Expo 2016) Fig. 75 : : NDLS (from Ajmeri Gate)
PHYSICAL PROFILE
Present Conditions:
Table 11 : Physical Profile of NDLS (Urban Mobility Conference & Expo 2016) Fig. 76 : : Percentage share of train types (Urban Mobility Conference & Expo 2016)
TRAINS MOVEMENT
Table 14 : Peak hour volume (Urban Mobility Conference & Expo 2016)
Table 12 : Platform wise train operation (Urban Mobility Conference & Expo 2016)
Table 13 : Daily Footfall estimations (Urban Mobility Conference & Expo 2016)
Fig. 77 : NDLS Conceptual Block Diagram (Urban Mobility Conference & Expo 2016)
Fig. 79 : Distribution of Passengers by profession (Urban Mobility Fig. 79 : Distribution of Passengers by monthly income (Urban Mobility
Conference & Expo 2016) Conference & Expo 2016)
27 % are Business People & 22 % Govt. Employees 31 % of the station users earn between Rs. 5000
to Rs. 15000
Fig. 78 : Time spent by passengers (Urban Mobility Conference & Expo 2016)
Most of the passengers are spending 20-30 min. at station Fig. 80 : Distribution of Passengers by luggage carrying characteristics
Photographic walk from Ajmeri Gate towards Paharganj
TECHNOLOGY
Fig. 82 : Illustrative photograph of Mumbai CST International Airport, showing the structures.
Fig. 84 : Span/Depth Ratios
Fig. 89 : Super Structural System : Exploded view shows Pre Stressed Members having portal frames on top of it, to support the parametric truss
TECHNOLOGY – Universal Accessibility (Active Systems)
Travellators
Similar to using escalators, people stand, or walk, on the travellator
as its conveyor walkway rolls along. Travellators are typically
installed in pairs to keep opposite flows of people all moving their
designated direction.
Escalators
Escalators are essentially “moving stairs” that transport masses of
people up or down between floors of a building. They are installed
indoors or outdoors and the constant speed can be adjusted to
accommodate increases or decreases in volume of passengers.
Escalator width depends upon the age of the mechanism as well as
the volume of riders. Single-rider widths are between 400 mm and
600mm.
The escalator’s metal grooved steps are linked together and driven
by a motor-driven chain on tracks. In the event the mechanism
breaks down, the escalator can still be used as a staircase access.
Escalators have moving safety handrails. As the escalator ends, the
steps each disappear into an end comb-plate. Escalators are
installed in pairs to keep opposite flows of people all moving their
designated up or down direction.
Factors to be considered
Available renewable energy resource at or near the building site
TYPE OF REASON FOR CHOOSING THE TYPE OF MATERIALS / SYSTEM PROs. CONs. REMARKS
SYSTEM PIRTICULAR SYSTEM COMPONENTS / STANDARDS
Other than the above mentioned systems, this report also looks at Firefighting and Sewage treatment as technologies which will be incorporated into the design.
CHAPTER 6
DESIGN DETERMINANTS
1. Vehicular Movement System
One of the main determinant for this project is driven by the way, traffic movement happens.
The present scheme lets the traffic cross the terminal building from either side of the city,
Fig. 62 : NDLS (Pedestrian Movement Pattern) without causing interference with pedestrian movement.
2. Pedestrian Movement & Way Finding
Pedestrian movement is given the topmost priority. The design decisions were taken in such manner, so that the pedestrian movement can happen without crossing the
vehicular movement at any point at any time.
3. Platforms are kept the way they exist today, Passenger comfort and amenities
CHAPTER 7
DESIGN EVOLUTION
DESIGN DEVELOPMENT
SITE PLAN
DESIGN PORTFOLIO
CONTEXT PLAN (GROUND)
1. Edwards, Brian. Transport Interchange a Challenge for Urban Design . Urban Design. June 2011.
2. Prabhu, Suresh. Railway Budget , Railway Minister . Delhi : Government of India, 2015.
4. Board, Railway. Indian Rail Schedule of Dimensions. Delhi : Government of India, 2004.
5. Railway station Design. 2016, Railway Technical , Railway Systems , Technologies and operation .
6. Railways, Minister of. Indian Railways vision 2020. Delhi : Government of India , 2009.
7. Development of World Class Railway Station Through PPP , Manual for Standard and Specification (volume 1 of 2).
8. Productivity of Railway Stations - Urban Mobility Conference & Expo 2016, Prof. Dr. Sanjay Gupta.