Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.emeraldinsight.com/2044-1266.htm
JCHMSD
9,3 Transit-oriented development
in West Bay, Business District
of Doha, State of Qatar
394 A strategy for enhancing liveability
Received 2 September 2018 and sense of place
Revised 29 January 2019
Accepted 4 March 2019 Mahmoud Al Saeed and Raffaello Furlan
Qatar University, Doha, Qatar
Abstract
Purpose – West Bay, the Business District of Doha, the capital city of the State of Qatar, is facing an urban
regeneration phase due to the construction of the West Bay Central Train Station, a four-storey underground
building hosting the intersection of two metro lines – one long-distance train and one people mover.
The development of the transit village, or transit-oriented development, is raising concerns related to the need
to enhance liveability (as urban quality of life) and sense of place (considering the local cultural identity).
The purpose of this paper is to investigate existing urban elements, such as transit stations, as well as their
impact on the liveability and identity of the place and to define a comprehensive urban regeneration strategy
for the development of the distinctive urban village of West Bay.
Design/methodology/approach – The analysis and data collection were based on the type of data as
tangible aspects which mainly include the physical, and aspects such as diversity, density, connectivity,
transportation systems and public realm. Intangible factors are concluded from close and direct site
observation, semi-structured in-depth interviews, as a face-to-face type of data collection with key persons in
Qatar Rail, the Ministry of the Municipality and public work authorities, where the intangible aspects were
briefed by economic aspects, environmental situation, social pattern and human behaviours. After siting the
base ground of theoretical knowledge and site condition analysis, the authors identified a group of key factors
that respond to the targeted (tangible and intangible) aspects and threats, to propose a design treatment for
the site threats and highlighted issues in addition to a group of recommendations and design strategies
(Charmaz, 2006; Marshall and Rossman, 2010).
Findings – From the data analysis of the site and by revisiting the literature review, a group of
recommendations are formulated. The authors divided the recommendations into two types according to their
method of application. The first is the design approach, where the authors propose integrated design proposals
to tackle and solve the highlighted issues from the findings of site analysis (diversity, density, connectivity in
addition to economic, social and environmental factors). Meanwhile, the second part represents the systematic
recommendations that should be adopted and implemented to enhance the existing situation and form a
guideline for further developments.
Research limitations/implications – This research study could be further expanded to urban planning,
urban design, social development and environmental engineering. Urban design and social development
chiefly focus on the relationship between built and unbuilt forms with an eye to creating healthy, sustainable
communities for current and future generations.
Originality/value – Because issues of social sustainability and urban design have failed to attract suitable
levels of attention from local scholars, gaps have arisen in the research. Accordingly, this research study
investigates the relationship between social sustainability and urban design standards in the State of Qatar
with an eye to translating theoretical knowledge into applicable principles of urban planning. In doing so, it
will help close the gaps in knowledge related to Qatar and GCC countries.
Keywords Urban regeneration, Liveability, Transit-oriented development, West Bay, Sense of place
Paper type Research paper
Literature review
Urban regeneration
The literature reveals that 54 per cent of the world population resides in congested
metropolitan areas or cities (Landry, 2006). This led to the need to avoid further
unsustainable expansion and/or diminishing sprawling and to pursue compactness through
a planning strategy based on the urban regeneration of central areas/districts (Farr, 2011;
Montgomery, 2013).
Figure 1.
West Bay stations
along the red line
JCHMSD The process of urban regeneration is related to local policies and location/nature of the
9,3 regenerated areas (Adair et al., 2009). The unique character, location, use and diversity of
the area make it very difficult to establish a universal definition of urban regeneration
(Adair et al., 2009). However, generally, the process is based on the two main perspectives:
integration and use-enhancement, i.e., a fire station might become an art gallery, and an
expo-district might be converted to a residential neighbourhood (Furlan and Petruccioli,
396 2016; Imrie et al., 2009).
The process of urban regeneration has changed significantly in the past decade, namely,
motivated by the contemporary need to address social sustainability, to enhance liveability
and/or quality of life, to preserve built cultural identity, and to encourage entrepreneurialism
to attract investors (Adair et al., 2009). Therefore, the process is based on the following
pillars (Furlan and Sipe, 2017) (Figure 2):
• Environmental aspects: a successful urban regeneration project needs to address
the local environmental indicators. The term of “think global and act local”
has become the focal point of the most successful urban regeneration projects
(World Bank, 2017).
• Social sustainability: sustainable regeneration projects shall consider the existing
community and its inhabitants’ social needs (Colantonio and Dixon, 2011).
• Location physical and cultural identity: an integrated active policy that promotes
making strong bridges between communities and fostering the city cultural identity
should be adapted in all phases of the sustainable regeneration projects.
• Economic policy and investment forces: economics is the engine of the city
development process and it has the bigger share of interest when the regeneration of
an area seems to consider the place potential to gain back revenues. Actually, it goes
deeper to involve the country economic factors and general plan (Commons, H. o.,
2008), where the economic policy must be aligned with local aspect of investment
force to minimise the side effects of the investment and increase potential benefits
(Dixon and Adams, 2008).
The integration of a transit station within the urban fabric of a city provides an opportunity
to address urban regeneration, where land values encourage businesses and residents to
move to TOD neighbourhoods, which will increase and offer significant opportunities for
Urban Regeneration
Aim
Address social sustainability
Pillars
Tangible pillars Intangible pillars
Plate 1.
Notes: The National Master Plan source; place dynamix, MMUP and Doha, Qatar
Oriental Consultants
JCHMSD The sense of place (place-meanings)
9,3 Urban designers are responsible for creating a positive difference. Urban designers can achieve
such impact only when they release the hidden factors that shape people’s way of living and, in
turn, the place identity people live in (Brown and Dixon, 2014; Rapoport, 1976; Relph, 1976).
Today’s cities are competing to host iconic images such as buildings and spaces representing
their commitment to development as a signature of star architecture (Furlan, 2015). However,
398 the iconic buildings (West Bay skyline as an example of iconic urban components – Plates 2
and 3) might have hidden meanings, but usually they are sculptures implemented in an isolated
context, rather than integrated within the city unique urban fabric, which is a result of an
important historical identity (Carmona and Tiesdell, 2007; Stevenson, 2013). The traditional
process goes back for many years. Moreover, and according to Kasprisin, there are three
components (culture, space and time) that directly contribute to shaping human settlement’s and
built spaces. Kasprisin (2011) argues that the interaction among these components along with
the functionality of built forms will produce the “meaning” of space identity.
Culture in its nature is a complicated term that includes ideas, customs and arts. More
recently scholars included economics, politics and social interaction. This will bring the
discussion of who designs cities; the range of “culture” requires integrated design process
that must be open to the community in a mutually interactive process (Rubin, 1979).
Plate 2.
West Bay skyline
with traditional
Qatari ships
Source: graphicsbuzz.com (2016)
Plate 3.
West Bay
district boundary
Source: Jon Bowles, aliengrove, on Flickr (2014)
The meanings of space in urban design represent the bottom line of life, living and design of Transit-
urban functionality; moreover, space as a living system is the ecological urban design process oriented
where the product does not mean only a “green product” but expands to include the output development
behaviours within the ecological systems of the urban context (Kasprisin, 2011).
Time is a periodic process, the length of time required to take an action forms the concept
of measuring tools, when new actions are taken new periodic measurements are needed, the
time frame concept is important to identify the cultural symbiology and meanings because 399
culture is measured by time and place. The time meanings expand beyond aspects of
history, but it offers a connection to the past. The meanings of time provide designers with
three cardinal tools, which are history, knowledge and probable aspiration and outcomes
(Kasprisin, 2011; Rubin, 1979).
This means that today’s urban designers and planners are no longer required to just give
attention to the implementation and decoration of spaces resulting from built forms such as
town squares, parks and pedestrian networks. Rather, the cardinal role of an urban designer
is to highlight and understand the significant and necessary relationship between built
forms and social-identity meanings of the inhabitants of the space, to shape the settlement
and built forms. This, in turn, will enhance and foster the adaptation and regeneration of
local identity and the sense of belonging of the place.
According to Rykwert, the definition of “urban place meanings and sense of place” is
strongly connected with the cultural comprehension of the “civilisation” through its
“industry”, where the development of cities is motivated by human interventions. Rykwert
identified the city by its industry (technology and machine); the process of city labelling and
heritage identification commences with the agricultural communities, which have been
superseded by the first and second industrial revolutions. The city of London forms a clear
example for describing the cultural heritage by the industry. London has been depicted in
artists, historians and planners’ works through the images of trains, steam engines, steel-made
pavilions and the structure of its bridges. In that sense, the comprehension of place’s meanings
is developing through time along with the conception of the surrounding environment
associated with the city’s economic development (Rikwert, 2000).
Architects and urban planners have always preferred to operate at the macro-scale level
of the built environment (rather than micro-scale housing level), where through the design of
the public realm, city plaza, town halls and railway stations (public buildings), a new style
could be initiated and launched. Therefore, the term “style” refers to the facade of the
building and/or built environment with its embedded meaning. It acts as a semiotic device
that depicts the city image and cultural heritage.
Also, the term “type” refers to the function and/or use of the building/s (i.e. city hall,
church, etc.). Both definitions, style and type are significant in urban planning and
architectural design process: they contribute to shape the city iconic images, cultural
heritage and the perception of place meanings (Rikwert, 2000).
Figure 3.
Nationwide
connections
Source: Qatar Rail (2017)
The motivated transformation in the twentieth century of Doha from a small pearl fishing Transit-
village into an emerging regional urban centre that accommodates more than 1.7m oriented
inhabitants (Salama and Wiedman, 2013) has made of Doha an emerging service hub. The development
growth was from a single core and expanded towards new urban areas developments; for
that purpose the transportation system was majorly redeveloped and expanded to
accommodate the new expansion (Furlan and ElGahani, 2018; Furlan and Faggion, 2015a).
Meanwhile, according to the Qatar National Master plan and Qatar National Vision 401
2030, all megaprojects and construction shall be completed by 2026, where it includes the
infrastructure projects, namely, railway, metros and public transportation facilities in
addition to the development of the major TODs. The ongoing construction of Doha metro
was designed to connect the Hamad International Airport with all major areas (Furlan
and Faggion, 2015a; Furlan and Saeed, 2017a, b). This location is not only significant for
the World Cup 2022 but also to local communities, with a total of 87 stations distributed in
various locations with a total length of 211.9 km (Figure 4). The purpose is to
promote transit villages inside the city fabric. With the metro plan divided into four
different routes (Figure 5):
• Route 1 (the red line) forms the vertical axis, which connects Mesaieed in the south to
Al Khor city in the north crossing Lusail, West Bay and Mesheireb, reaching Hamad
International Airport.
• Route 2 (the green line) connecting Education City with Doha Centre, linking Umm
Slal to the industrial district in the south.
Figure 4.
Stations’ distribution
Source: Qatar Rail (2011)
JCHMSD
9,3
402
Figure 5.
Qatar Rail network
(the four major lines)
Source: Qatar Rail (2011)
• Route 3 (the gold line) makes the link between east and west crossing at the centre of
Mesheireb, Al Waab Street, Al Rayyan and Hamad International Airport.
• Route 4 (blue line) the main role of the blue line is to connect commercial and
residential areas of West Bay with Hamad Airport, in parallel with the C-Ring Road.
The development of these routes is important to resolve major issues of urban planning,
such as traffic congestion, and its externalities on the Qatar economy (Furlan and Faggion,
2015a). Meanwhile, the purpose of the National transit vision is to allocate Qatar as an
international services location with an evolved and attractive urbanism (Salama and
Wiedman, 2013).
403
Figure 6.
Qatar Rail network
(red line)
Source: Qatar Rail (2017)
Urban Design
02 02- Space Culture
Meanings
03- Time Space formation
Literature/Site Analysis
and studies
Ministry of
Literature/Site Analysis
Conclusions Conclusions
Findings/Design Factors
of the selected site and to upcoming planning issues. Moreover, the participants’ selection was
limited to practitioners directly involved into the development of the project ( from initial design
to coordination of construction stages), with extended experience on similar infrastructural
projects, where the intangible factors were shaped by economic, environmental, social and
human-behavioural aspects.
After siting the base ground of theoretical knowledge and site condition analysis, the
authors identified a group of key factors that respond to the targeted (tangible and intangible)
aspects and threats, to propose a design treatment for the site threats and highlighted issues
in addition to a group of recommendations and design strategies (Charmaz, 2006; Marshall
and Rossman, 2010).
Findings
In this section, a list of the findings is presented. The section also reflects upon the
conclusion from the literature and elaborates on the scope of further research in the subject.
JCHMSD Site analysis
9,3 The study area. The vast majority of the West Bay district includes two major municipal
zones (60, 61) (Figure 9), and both extend to include 8 sq. kilometres of land with 70 smaller
subzones, which in turn are divided into more than 130 plots (Figure 10). As the district is
connected directly with water, it has 5 km of coast line and 3 km of direct contact with inner
land. The district includes major establishments, such as the famous old Sheraton Hotel
406 (considered the oldest building in the district: 1982), DECC, City Centre shopping mall and a
group of residential and administration tower buildings (Figure 11).
Context
Site physical analysis (tangible aspects). The physical analysis of the site highlights and
monitors the various physical situations that are related to the research point of interest,
such as diversity, density, connectivity, transportation systems and the public realm.
Diversity. West Bay District has an important geographical location connecting inner
lands with the shoreline. This led the MME to consider the district as a special developments
(SD) zone (Figure 12). The SD classification means for the current time that the allowed
developments include high-rise buildings and governmental services; however, by focussing
on the stations surrounding the area at a length of 450 m radius, we can directly assume that
the main function of the land is for administrative governmental buildings for the station of
WBC, in addition to several specialized services (ministry, research centres and commercial
companies); however, the radius also includes residential functions within its fabric
(Figure 13). Meanwhile, the DECC station radius includes public and community services
Zone 61
Figure 9. Zone 60
West Bay main
municipal zones West Bay Main zones
(60, 61)
Source: Ministry of Municipality and Environment (2018)
Transit-
oriented
development
407
408
Sheraton Hotel
DECC Stations
WCS Stations
Figure 11.
West Bay major
establishments Main Land mark
At the same time, the district itself has no type of connection to surrounding areas and parks
such as Sheraton Park; thus, it is very difficult for a pedestrian to move from the district to
other areas without using vehicle transportation (Figure 16).
Transportation systems. The role of transportation is cardinal not only for the district but
for every location. The district transportation system is divided into four main types, which
cross and circulate inside the district, these types start from solo riders to end with mass
movers, the infrastructure of transportation is connecting the district with surrounding areas,
as well it connects with its section; metro station; two elevated metro stations (WCS, DECC) in
parallel with Majlis al Taawon St and Omar Al Mukhtar St, municipal long-distance buses: the
district has seven main bus stations, distributed along four main lines connecting the upper
section of the district with its lower section crossing the most important location, taxi station;
the district has one dedicated taxi gathering point allocated near the City Centre shopping
mall, and solo rider; since the most common transportation system in Qatar is cars, the district
receives a high level of solo riders daily (Figure 17).
Public realm. The important role of the public realm is usually brought by its necessity
as social gathering places, however, to have functional public realm it should have pleasing
accessibility level to all inhabitants. Moreover, the meaning of public realm extends to
include three main objectives: first, streets: the district of West Bay has sufficient roads to
accommodate vehicle movement; however, road accessibility for pedestrians is poor and
limited in some areas. Meanwhile, the continuity of street is acceptable for cars but again it
is poor for pedestrians. Second, open spaces: the lower section of the district clearly has no
Transit-
oriented
development
409
Figure 12.
West Bay
general zoning
Source: Ministry of Municipality and Environment (2017)
open space to serve the inhabitant in and around the district; meanwhile, the upper section
has very limited access to public open spaces and parks such as Sheraton Park and Corniche
green belt. This limited access is caused by the street cutting the movement between the
district and the parks. Third, green areas: as well as the open space the green areas are poor
and limited to public parks near to Sheraton Hotel, meanwhile, the greenery is limited to the
street buffer zone with no proper distribution (Figure 18).
In-depth interviews and site observation (intangible aspects). The purpose of this section is
to understand and mark the intangible aspects of the site linked to culture, space and time,
which in turn represent the urban design meaning the district analysis (economics,
environment, social patterns, human behaviours, culture and space formation).
JCHMSD
9,3
410
Figure 13.
WCS station, 450 m
land use plan
Economics. According to the latest national master plan published by MME, the West
Bay district is considered the Central Business District: this is directly reflected on the
land use pattern where we clearly notice the dense high-rise office towers allocated along
the district. The cardinal role of the economy has been understood as increasing the
density of supportive infrastructure and buildings such as metro station and the
high-rise office towers.
Environment. The relationship between built form and environment is important as
the land use and economic pattern, the district is suffering from the absence of
environmental aspects such as walkable streets, availability of green areas except for
some minor small green pockets in addition to the central Sheraton Park (Plate 4).
Although some green colour can be noticed, it is limited to a street buffer zone where
it is more focussed aesthetically, leading to the neglect of environmental aspects in
the district.
Social pattern. The purpose of monitoring the social pattern of the inhabitant is to
understand the social aspect among the users; moreover, to link the environment to the
Transit-
oriented
development
411
Figure 14.
DECC station, 450 m
land use plan
social sustainability that is required to develop responsible urban fabric. The social pattern
in the district is almost absent as there is no direct social interaction except the presence of
park visitors from surrounding areas to gather in small groups (Plate 5). This is referred to
as the nature of the district as the business location has a good percentage of employees that
arrive early morning and leave before evening, which in this time the visitors to Sheraton
Park and City Centre Mall start to arrive.
Human behaviours. From the direct and close monitoring for the inhabitants of both
classes (employee and visitor), we can classify the behaviours into two main types
according to the user’s interests: first, driven by direct target, which they formulate the
bigger percentage where the users were driven by a specific reason to visit the district,
such as work or to get some service (governmental). Second, visitors seeking services: the
number of visitors usually increases in evening times when most of the employees leave
the district and the density of vehicular movement decreases, the visitor usually spends
most of the time in three main locations (City Centre shopping mall, Doha Exhibition
Centre and Sheraton Park).
JCHMSD
9,3
412
DECC
WCS
Culture and space formation. Culture is one of the main pillars that form places meaning and
identity. Doha City has transformed in a very short period from a small country to one of the
fastest developing countries in the world, with one of the highest incomes per capita. This
transformation overcame the local themes of identity and meanings; however, by examining
the various fabrics of the district we see the global themes infiltrated in all its buildings,
moreover extended to include the function of the district itself as a global financial district,
since the architectural style is one of the cultural faces, it has been examined at various
locations although the several attempts carried out by the government regulations to
promote the identity and culture through the building architectural style are still hazy and
mixed styles make it hard to unify the general theme that follows the local identity and their
historical cultural meanings (Plate 6).
Urban regeneration
Integrating and adapting a futuristic projects such as Qatar Rail is significant, not only to
foster the economic growth of Qatar but also to enhance the quality of life of the inhabitants,
who will benefit of a sustainable tool of public. However, preserving the city cultural
heritage is also required in order to preserve the values of Qatar heritage and culture. As a
Transit-
oriented
development
413
DECC
WCS
Figure 16.
450 m Station radius Main roads
District Gateway and gateway
result, the development of Doha metro must follow the principles of urban regeneration,
based on the preservation of environmental, social and cultural aspects of the users.
Sense of place
Understanding the meaning of place and inhabitants’ needs require a comprehensive
coordination approach among urban planners, urban designers and architectural designers,
all aiming at enhancing the city iconic image, the meanings that and inhabitants refer to
urban places. Therefore, the approach of simply designing functional spaces is not sufficient
to shape place-meanings. Aesthetic and location aspects are key factors which should be
addressed at the early stages of TOD planning.
414
Figure 17.
Main transportation
systems
Source: Mowasalat (2018)
Recommendations
From the data analysis of the site and by reviewing the literature, a group of recommendations
are formulated. The recommendations were divided into two types according to their method of
application. The first is the design approach, where the authors propose integrated design
proposals to tackle and solve the highlighted issues from the findings of site analysis (diversity,
density, connectivity in addition to economic, social and environmental factors). Meanwhile, the
second part represents the systematic recommendations that should be adopted and
implemented to enhance the existing situation and form a guideline for further developments.
Design proposal
The design proposal was developed in response to the main key factors identified through
site analysis, where each of the threats has a unique type of treatment proposal, according to
the threats’ nature and characteristics. After identifying the key factors and its suitable
treatment based on the literature reviews, a table of conclusions was formulated to highlight
and discuss the conclusions as shown in Table I.
In response to the revealed threats, the authors proposed several layers of treatments,
which include the main key factors under investigation; the proposals include planning
Transit-
oriented
development
415
Sheraton
Sheraton
Hotel
Park
Sheraton parks
WCS
Figure 18.
Green areas and roads
existing situations
JCHMSD
9,3
416
Plate 4.
The lack of greenery
and safe
shaded walkway
Plate 5.
Sheraton park
at night
themes as well as architectural proposals. The first layer is proposing revised land use
layout that encompasses a variable comprehensive mix of uses to satisfy the inhabitants’
needs (Figures 19–21).
Meanwhile, to relieve the dense urban fabric of the district and to increase the green
areas, the authors propose to use the leftover spaces to be merged with urban fabric as
pocket gardens and green areas (Figures 22 and 23).
Transit-
oriented
development
417
Plate 6.
Modern and
globalization in
architectural themes
in West Bay
Diversity The districts land use is The current land Increase the variety of Proposed master
special development use has been land use, by introducing plan
meanings the possibility for
translated to new services that serve
variety in services is high
office towers only inhabitants well-being
Density The current density is Severe shortage Increase the green Proposed master
high, lands are well in green areas cover, pocket gardens plan
occupied and public and public areas
parks, only one
park available
Connectivity Several major roads serve The roads Increase the Design proposal
the district around the connectivity with for pedestrian
district made it surrounding areas bridges
isolated from focussing on pedestrian Shaded areas for
surroundings as well as shared pedestrians
transportation Cycling tracks
Transportation The current transport Traffic Reduce solo riders Proposed master
system models are: congestion Encourage shared plans
Two metro stations Environment transportations Shuttle services
Public buses decline Introduce environment-
Taxis Increase heat friendly method of Table I.
island effect transport such as Threats and treatment
electric buses of the key factors
The lack of safe and consistent pedestrian routes with its components such as connecting bridges,
rest station and shaded walkway, in addition to the absence of cycling routes, has been addressed
by the authors through architectural proposals for the absent elements (Figures 24–26).
The emergent need for enhancing the transportation systems to support the
implementation of metro stations and to decrease the vehicular congestion has been
addressed through the implementation of shuttle buses to connect the districts with their
boundaries and surrounding areas. Meanwhile, the merging of electric charge stations
JCHMSD
9,3
418
Figure 19.
Proposed land use for
West Bay district
Figure 20.
Proposed land
use 450 m around
WCS station
419
Figure 21.
Proposed land
use 450 m around
DECC station
Figure 22.
Proposed green
areas in 450 m around
WCS station
JCHMSD
9,3
420
Figure 23.
Proposed green areas
in 450 m around
DECC station
Figure 24.
Proposed pedestrian,
cycling routes and
pedestrian stations
proposed to allocate more service kiosks around the district where the inhabitants are
dense, which increases the variety of services and supports the local economy (Figure 28
and Plate 7).
421
Figure 25.
Proposed
pedestrian bridges
Figure 26.
Proposed pedestrian
station and
shaded areas
investments in buildings and infrastructure is not sufficient, and causes a loss in identity
and general themes of local culture in favour of globalisation and modernisation. This
creates the necessity to form a set of regulations that consider the three main aspects of
urban design and urban regeneration: environment, economy and local identity, to be
applied as short- and long-term strategies.
From its assigned roles, the main land uses and functions of the West Bay district is as
groups of administrative offices towers, public services quarters and governmental services,
with very limited general public-related areas, and for that purpose the district shall have
more variety and diversity of land uses spaced around the transit stations, the responsible
authorities shall restrict the uses of station surrounding area as mix use including retail,
restaurants, services and public attraction uses, this will make the stations as attractive
JCHMSD
9,3
422
Figure 27.
Proposed shuttle
services routes
Figure 28.
Proposed kiosks
points for visitors and inhabitants of the district, meanwhile the proposed master plan looks
to the district as one unit cannot be separated, and deals with the threats through the
strategies responding to TOD principles (Figure 29).
The district density form represents a high percentage of dense buildings taking the
vertical expansions and by this forming the Doha city edge, causing significant vehicle
presence in the district; the regulation shall relieve the district from this density by
prohibiting any type of construction and focussing on the leftover spaces from cool
spots among the distract fabric; moreover, the enhanced transportation system shall
decrease the density of cars and increase the density of pedestrians, which will lead to
pedestrian-friendly areas.
The existing conventional transportation systems are leading to suffocation and traffic
jams, also increasing the number of cars; however, an enhanced transportation system shall
be implemented working next to the under-construction transportation station, to connect the
stations with each other and to encourage safe movements. This shall be carried out by
Transit-
oriented
development
423
Plate 7.
Proposed kiosks
various new systems, such as shuttle buses, enhanced shaded corridors within the 450 m radii
for pedestrians, provide safe cycling tracks, promote car sharing, expand the regulations of
environment-friendly transportation methods such as electric cars (Figure 30).
To protect and enhance the public realms and its components, in addition to the
environmental aspects a continuous consistent pedestrian service can be called a cool spot
among the district’s urban fabric, distributed at various locations, and it shall form a continuous
line at the range of 450 m walking distance; these cool spots shall have places for short rest and
general services such as pantries, information and accessibility to other types of transporters.
In conclusion, the development of the city master plan, aiming at enhancing the
integration of public transport systems (such as Doha Metro) and land use (TOD projects),
should be based on the adoption a systemic framework, which commences by identifying
the aim and the scale of the project through the analysis of urban regeneration, sense of
place and TOD principles (Figure 31).
Contribution to knowledge
Because issues of social sustainability and urban design have failed to attract suitable
levels of attention from local scholars, gaps have arisen in the research. Accordingly,
this research study investigates the relationship between social sustainability and
urban design standards in the State of Qatar with an eye to translating theoretical
knowledge into applicable principles of urban planning. In doing so, it will help close the
JCHMSD
9,3
424
Land Use
Pedestrian Bridge
Food Kiosk
Services Kiosk
Figure 30.
WCS proposed
treatments methods
gaps in knowledge related to Qatar and GCC countries. Also, this research study is
significant to urban geography and planning because of the visual material presented,
which support the definition and discussion of key-concepts to be adopted for the
enhancement of the selected TOD.
Step 1 Aim to implement TOD
Transit-
oriented
Study and analysis (Pre-planning phase) development
Urban Regeneration Sense of place Transit-oriented
developments
Connectivity
Transportation
Social pattern
Human
Figure 31.
Systems behaviours
TOD integration
Public realm Culture and space formation
framework
References
Adair, A., Berry, J., Haran, M., Hutchison, N. and McGreal, S. (2009), Urban Regeneration: Opportunities
for Property Investment, Investment Property Forum, London.
Bernick, M. and Cervero, R. (1997), Transit Villages for the 21st Century, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY.
Brown, L.J. and Dixon, D. (2014), Urban Design for an Urban Century: Shaping More Livable, Equitable,
and Resilient Cities, 2nd ed., John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY.
Calthorpe, P. (2015), Urbanism in the Age of Climate Change, Routledge, London, pp. 555-568.
Calthorpe, P. and Fulton, W.B. (2001), The Regional City – Planning for the End of Sprawl, Island Press,
Washington, DC.
Carmona, M. and Tiesdell, S. (2007), Urban Design Reader, Routledge, Oxford.
Cervero, R. (2000), “Walk-and-ride: factors influencing pedestrian access to transit”, Journal of Public
Transportation, Vol. 3 No. 4, pp. 1-23.
Charmaz, K. (2006), Constructing Grounded Theory: A Practical Guide Through Qualitative Analysis,
Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA.
Colantonio, A. and Dixon, T. (2011), Urban Regeneration and Social Sustainability: Best Practice from
European Cities, John Wiley & Sons, Oxford.
Commons, H. o. (2008), “Annual report 2008”, The Stationery Office Limited, London.
Commons, H. o. (2009), “Communities and local government’s departmental annual report 2009, and the
performance of the department in 2008–09”, House of Commons, London.
Cooper, D. and Schindler, P. (2011), “Qualitative research”, Business Research Methods, Vol. 4 No. 1,
pp. 160-182.
Creswell, J. (2003), Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed Methods Approaches, 2nd ed..,
Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA.
Curtis, C., Renne, L. and Bertolini, L. (2009), Transit Oriented Development: Making it Happen, MPG
Books, Bodmin.
Denzin, N.K. and Lincoln, Y.S. (2005), Handbook of Qualitative Research, Sage Publications, London.
Dixon, T. and Adams, D. (2008), “Housing supply and brownfield regeneration in a post-Barker
world: is there enough brownfield land in England and Scotland?”, Urban Studies, Vol. 45
No. 1, pp. 115-139.
Dynamix, P. (2011), “The dynamix of facilities, transit oriented development”, White Paper Place Transit-
Dynamix, Place Dynamix, Doha. oriented
Farr, D. (2011), Sustainable Urbanism: Urban Design with Nature, John Wiley & Sons, NJ. development
Furlan, R. (2015), “Liveability and social capital in West Bay, the new business precinct of Doha”,
Arts and Social Sciences Journal, Vol. 6 No. 3, pp. 1-11.
Furlan, R. (2016), “Modern and vernacular settlements in Doha: an urban planning strategy to pursue
modernity and consolidate cultural identity”, Arts and Social Sciences Journal, Vol. 7 No. 2, 427
pp. 171-176.
Furlan, R. and Alattar, D. (2017), “Urban regeneration in Qatar: a comprehensive planning strategy for
the transport oriented development (TOD) of Al-Waab”, Journal of Urban Regeneration and
Renewal, Vol. 11 No. 2, pp. 168-193.
Furlan, R. and Alfaraidy, M. (2017a), “Sense of community in Al-Wakrah city: strategies for the
development of sustainable communities in Qatar”, Saudi Journal of Engineering and
Technology, Vol. 2 No. 10, pp. 390-402.
Furlan, R. and Alfaraidy, M. (2017b), “Urban form and sense of community: exploring the catalyst for
community sustainability for Alwakrah neighbourhood”, Architecture Research, Vol. 7 No. 4,
pp. 123-145.
Furlan, R. and Almohannadi, M. (2016), “Light rail transit and land use: an integrated planning
strategy for Al-Qassar’s TOD in Qatar”, International Journal of Architectural Research –
ArchNet-IJAR’, Vol. 10 No. 3, pp. 170-192.
Furlan, R. and ElGahani, H. (2018), “Post 2022 FIFA World Cup in the state Qatar: urban regeneration
strategies for Doha”, Journal of Urban Regeneration and Renewal, Vol. 11 No. 4, pp. 1-16.
Furlan, R. and Faggion, L. (2015a), “The development of vital precincts in Doha: urban regeneration
and socio-cultural factors”, American Journal of Environmental Engineering, Vol. 5 No. 4,
pp. 120-129.
Furlan, R. and Faggion, L. (2015b), “The Souq Waqif heritage site in Doha: spatial form and livability”,
American Journal of Environmental Engineering, Vol. 5 No. 5, pp. 146-160.
Furlan, R. and Faggion, L. (2017), “Urban regeneration of GCC cities: preserving the urban fabric’s
cultural heritage and social complexity”, Journal of Historical Archaeology & Anthropological
Sciences, Vol. 1 No. 1, pp. 1-16.
Furlan, R. and Petruccioli, A. (2016), “Affordable housing for middle income expats in Qatar: strategies
for implementing livability and urban form”, International Journal of Architectural Research –
ArchNet-IJAR, Vol. 10 No. 3, pp. 138-151.
Furlan, R. and Saeed, M.A. (2017a), “Strategies for the enhancement of users’ social interactions
in Al Mirqab Al Jadeed street in Doha, State of Qatar”, Architecture Research, Vol. 7 No. 3,
pp. 69-83.
Furlan, R. and Saeed, M.A. (2017b), “The urban regeneration of Al Nasser street in Doha (Qatar):
enhancing the spatial form and users’ social interactions”, International Journal of Arts and
Humanities, Vol. 1 No. 7, pp. 567-575.
Furlan, R. and Sipe, N. (2017), “Light rail transit (LRT) and transit villages in Qatar: a planning-
strategy to revitalize the built environment of Doha”, Journal of Urban Regeneration and
Renewal, Vol. 10 No. 4, pp. 1-20.
Furlan, R., Nafi, S. and Alattar, D. (2015), “Urban built form of the Souq Waqif in Doha and user’s social
engagement”, American Journal of Sociological Research, Vol. 5 No. 3, pp. 73-88.
Furlan, R., Zaina, S. and Zaina, S. (2016), “Urban planning in Qatar: strategies and vision for the
development of transit villages in Doha”, Australian Planner, Vol. 53 No. 4, pp. 286-301.
Furlan, R., AlMohannadi, M., Zaina, S. and Zaina, S. (2015), “Integrated approach for the improvement
of human comfort in the public realm: the case of the Corniche, the linear urban link of Doha”,
American Journal of Sociological Research, Vol. 5 No. 4, pp. 89-100.
Gehl, J. (2011), Life between Buildings: Using Public Space, Island Press, New York, NY.
JCHMSD Greenberg, E. (2004), “Regulations shape reality: zoning for transit-oriented development”, in Dittmar,
9,3 H. and Ohland, G. (Eds), The New Transit Town: Best Practices in Transit-oriented Development,
Vol. 1, Island Press, Washington, DC, pp. 19-41.
Imrie, R., Lees, L. and Raco, M. (2009), Regenerating London: Governance, Sustainability and
Community in a Global City, Routledge, New York, NY.
Kasprisin, R. (2011), Urban Design: The Composition of Complexity, Vol. 1, Taylor & Francis, London.
428 Landry, C. (2006), The Art of City-Making, 1st ed., Routledge, London.
Larice, M. and Macdonald, E. (2013), The Urban Design Reader, Routledge, New York, NY.
Marshall, C. and Rossman, G.B. (2014), Designing Qualitative Research, 6th ed., Sage
Publication, MA.
MME (2017), “Paracels lines”, in Doha Master Plan (Ed.), GIS Portal, Ministry of Municipality and
Environment.
Montgomery, C. (2013), Happy City: Transforming Our Lives through Urban Design, Farrar, Straus and
Giroux, New York, NY.
Mowasalat (2017), “West Bay transportation routes”, in Public Transportation Map (Ed.), City
Map, Mowasalat.
Qatar Rail (2011), “Qatar Rail Doha stations”, in Master Plan, Qatar Layout (Ed.), Planning Section,
Qatar Rail.
Qatar Rail (2017), “Qatar Rail strategic master plan”, in Master Plan, Regional Layout (Ed.), GIS Portal,
Qatar Rail.
Rapoport, A. (1976), The Mutual Interaction of People and their Built Environment, Aldine Publishing
Company, Chicago, IL.
Relph, E. (1976), Place and Placelessness, Pion, London.
Rikwert, J. (2000), The Seduction of Place: The History and Future of Cities, University, Oxford.
Rizzo, A. (2014), “Rapid urban development and national master planning in Arab Gulf countries: Qatar
as a case study”, Cities, Vol. 39 No. 1, pp. 50-57.
Roberts, P. (2000), “The evolution, definition and purpose of urban regeneration”, Journal of Urban
Regeneration, pp. 9-36.
Rubin, B. (1979), “Aesthetic ideology and urban design”, Annals of the Association of American
Geographers, Vol. 69 No. 3, pp. 339-361.
Salama, A. and Wiedmann, F. (2013), Demystifying Doha on Architecture and Urbanism in an Emerging
City, Ashgate Publishing, Surrey.
Shaaban, K. and Khalil, R.F. (2012), “Proposed policies to support the new metro system in Qatar”,
Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences, Vol. 48, pp. 2315-2324.
Stevenson, D. (2013), The City, Polity Press, Cambridge.
Walker, J. (2011), Human Transit – How Clearer Thinking about Public Transit can Enrich Our
Communities and Our Lives, Island Press, Washington, DC.
World Bank (2017), “Urban development”, available at: www.worldbank.org/en/topic/
urbandevelopment/overview (accessed 2 August 2018).
For instructions on how to order reprints of this article, please visit our website:
www.emeraldgrouppublishing.com/licensing/reprints.htm
Or contact us for further details: permissions@emeraldinsight.com