The Disasters Darwinism Brought to

Humanity

By

HARUN YAHYA

X¡lECeh¡c x ¢hnÄ j¡eha¡l A¢in¡f

Ae¤h¡c-
¡c- H He Hj H ®j¡¢je

1 / 88
p§Q£ fœ

i¥¢jL¡ x ¢hwn na−L ¢hfkÑu pª¢øL¡l£z

X¡lECeh¡−cl pw¢rç C¢aq¡pz

X¡lEq~−el hZÑh¡c J Ef¢e−hnh¡c X¡lECeh¡−cl p¡−b gÉ¡¢ph¡−cl iu¡hq ¢jœa¡z

X¡lECeh¡c L¢jE¢eSj hhÑla¡l Evp J ¢i¢šz

fy¤§¢Sh¡c J AbÑe£¢a−a ®k¡NÉa¡j−cl ¢V−L b¡L¡l pwNË¡jz

®~e¢aL Ahru J p¡j¡¢SL j§mÉ−h¡d dÄw−p X¡lX~Ceh¡cz

Efpwq¡l x X¡lECeh¡c£ ¢hoh¡Öf AhnÉC ¢e×L¡ne Ll−a q−hz

f¢l¢nø x ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ¢hï¡¿¹

¢hï¡¿¹/i§m d¡le¡z

2 / 88
 X¡lECeh¡c x ¢hnÄj¡eha¡l A¢in¡f

i§¢jL¡ x ¢hwn na−Ll ¢hfkÑu pª¢øL¡l£

Bjl¡ pÇfТa k¤Ü J pwO¡aju ¢hwn na¡ë£ ®f¢l−u H−p¢R k¡ ¢hnÄ j¡eha¡−L ¢c−u−R c¤xM
®hce¡, NZqaÉ¡, c¡¢lâ Bl p£j¡q£e dÄwp k‘z mr mr ®m¡L ¢eqa J −hf−l¡u¡ qaÉ¡L¡−¾Xl
qaÉ¡L¡−¾Xl
¢nL¡l q−u−Rz AN¢ea ®m¡L r¥d¡u d¤−L d¤−L jªa¤Éj¤−M f¢aa q−u−Rz hý Se−N¡¢ù Nªq, BnËu J
pq¡u pðmq£e q−k−Rz ilZ−f¡oe ®b−L h¢’a q−u p¡¢hÑL ¢el¡fš¡q£ea¡u i¥−N−R mr mr Bcj
p¿¹¡ez mr mr j¡e¤o−L Hje Aj¡e¢hL ¢ekÑ¡a−el ¢nL¡l q−a q−u−R ®k, ®L¡e fö−LJ Hje
dl−el ¢ekÑ¡ae Ll¡ qu e¡z Bl H ph ¢LR¤C Ll¡ q−u−R HL¢V ¢hï¡¢¿¹Ll J ïø ja¡cnÑ
h¡Øah¡u−el E−Ÿ®nÉz l¡S®~e¢aL fË¢a¢qwp¡ Q¢la¡bÑ Ll¡l ®r−œ fË¢a¢V ¢ekÑ¡ae J c¤−iÑ¡−Nl SeÉ
®L¡e e¡ ®L¡e ®~üln¡pL h¡ HLe¡uL h¡ ®üµR¡Q¡l£ n¡pL−cl Ef¢Øq¢a mre£uz ®m¢ee, ø¡¢me,
VÊV¢ú, j¡J−pa¥w, fmfV, ¢qVm¡l, j¤−p¡¢me£, é¡w−L¡, CaÉ¡¢cz H−cl A−e−LC HLC ja¡c−nÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£
¢R−mez Bh¡l ®Lq ®Lq fË¢af−rl jªa¤É e¡ ®cM¡ fkÑ¿¹ a¡−cl ¢h−l¡d£a¡ Ll¡ ®b−L ¢hla q−ae
e¡z H pjØa LjÑL¡®¾Xl j§−m l−u−R flØfl ¢h−l¡d£ ja¡cnÑz H pjØa ®~üln¡pL a¡−cl
pj¡S−L à¾cÄ J pwO¡−al f−b ¢e−u −N−Re Hhw i¡C−L i¡C Hl ¢hl²−Ü ®m¢m−u k¤−Ül SeÉ
fË−l¡¢Qa L−l −cez g−m öl² qu ï¡aªO¡a£ k¤Üz Bl O−V −h¡j¡h¡¢S, A¢NÀ pw−k¡−Nl j¡dÉ−j N¡s£,
k¡eh¡qe, h¡s£Ol, −c¡L¡ef¡V dÄw−pl OVe¡ Hhw Bœ²je¡aÈL J p¢qwp ¢j¢Rm c¡‰¡-
c¡‰¡-q¡‰¡j¡z H
pLm AÙ»d¡l£ p¿»¡p£ ¢eù¥li¡−h -¢e¢ÑhÑQ¡−l ¢nö, ¢L−n¡l, k¤hL j¢qm¡ J hªÜ−L j¡l¢fV L−l Hhw
k¡l¡C H−cl ¢h−l¡d£a¡ L−l a¡−cl−LC qaÉ¡ L−lz a¡l¡ Hje q²cuq£e J f¡o¾X ®k, Hl¡ HLSe
¢el£q ®m¡−Ll j¡b¡u AØœ ®W¢L−u a¡l ®Q¡−Ml ¢c−L a¡¢L−u ¢he¡ ¢àd¡u qaÉ¡ L−lz H ph p¿»¡p£l¡
¢el£q j¡e¤−ol jNS fcc¢ma Ll−a ¢àd¡ L−l e¡z a¡l¡ ¢el£q Sep¡d¡lZ−L h¡s£ ®b−L h¢qØL¡l
L−l a¡ ¢a¢e hªÜ, j¢qm¡, ¢nö −kC ®q¡e e¡ ®Lez H ph ¢ekÑ¡¢aa j¡e¤−ol HLj¡œ Afl¡d ¢Rm
AeÉ ja¡c−nÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£z
¢hwn na¡ë£l c¤ü−fÀl ¢hi£¢oL¡ ®b−L Bjl¡ E®W H−p¢Rz j¡eh S¡¢a−L c¤xpq ®hce¡ J
l−š²l heÉ¡u hC−u
hC−u ®cJu¡ q−u−R öd¤j¡œ ¢hï¡¢¿¹Ll HL¢V ja¡c−nÑ ¢hnÄ¡p J a¡ h¡Øah¡ue Ll¡l
e¡−jz gÉ¡¢p¢Sj J L¢jE¢eSj H c¤¢V ja¡cnÑ−LC j¡eh S¡¢al ¢hfkÑu J c¤xM L−øl L¡−m¡
AdÉ¡u pª¢øl SeÉ n£oÑ jah¡c ¢qp¡−h ¢Q¢q²a Ll¡ k¡uz k¢cJ Bf¡ax cª¢ø−a flØfl ¢h−l¡d£
jah¡c c¤¢V HL¢V Afl¢Vl
Afl¢Vl dÄwp Ll¡l fË−Qø¡u AhÉ¡qa ¢Rmz ¢L¿º fËLa
« paÉ q−m¡ c¤¢V BcnÑC
HL¢V j¡œ Evp −b−L a¡−cl f¤¢ø, n¢š² J pq−k¡N£a¡ fË¡ç q®u−Rz Bl HC Evp ab¡ ja¡cnÑ
j¡e¤−ol cª¢ø BL«ø L−l e¡ hlw phpjuC HL¢V ¢eÖf¡f/¢el£q ašÆ/ja¡cnÑ/d¡le¡/jah¡c ¢qp¡−h

3 / 88
pj¡−S fË¢a¢ùa q−u Bp−Rz HC Evp ab¡ jah¡c q−m¡ x hØa¤h¡c£ cnÑe Hhw X¡lECeh¡c
ab¡ fËL«¢ah¡cz

A−fn¡c¡l S£h ¢h‘¡e£ Q¡mÑp X¡lECe Ee¢hwn na¡ë£−a p¤−jl£u J fË¡Q£e NË£−pl
®f±l¡¢eL NÒf Lb¡ f¤ehÑÉš² Ll¡l j¡dÉ−j X¡lECeh¡c
X¡lECeh¡c fËL¡n J fËQ¡l L−lez Bl Hl ¢i¢š−a
ka…¢m jah¡−cl ¢i¢š i¥¢j l¢Qa q−u−R ph…−m¡ j¡eha¡l SeÉ A¢in¡f ¢qp¡−h f¢lN¢ea
q−u−Rz X¡lEq~eh¡c ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL j¤−M¡n d¡le L−l Hph ï¡¿¹ ja¡cnÑ J H−cl Ae¤p¡l£−cl
aMe ®b−L HL dl−el ¢jbÉ¡ ®~hda¡ c¡e L−l−Rz HC ¢jbÉ¡ ®~hda¡l h−c±m−a ¢hhaÑeh¡c ab¡
X¡lECeh¡c AÒf¢c−el j−dÉ S£h ¢h‘¡e J S£h¡nÈ ¢h‘¡−el A¢d−rœ A¢aœ²j L−l j¡eh pÇfLÑ
®b−L öl² L−l C¢aq¡p, l¡Se£¢a, pj¡S ¢h‘¡e J j¡e¤−ol p¡¢ÑhÑL S£he k¡œ¡l fË¢a¢V ®r−œ Hl
fËi¡h ¢hØa¡l L−lz Ee¢hwn na¡ë£−a ®k ph jah¡c h¡ ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ pj¡S−L fËi¡¢ha L−l¢Rm Hl
L−uL¢V ¢Q¿¹¡l ®pË¡ad¡l¡ X¡lECeh¡−cl a−šÆl j−dÉ a¡−cl ®k±¢š²La¡ h¡ ab¡L¢ba fËj¡e My−¤ S
®fmz g−m X¡lECeh¡−c H pLm ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ h¡ jah¡−cl hÉ¡fL pjbÑe ®f−a prj q−m¡z
A¢Øa−aÄl pwNË¡j "" phmC y−h−Q b¡−L '' AeÉl¡ dÄwpfË¡ç/fl¡¢Sa q−u ""pj¡S ®b−L Acª
AcªnÉ ab¡
¢e¢ÕQq² q−u k¡u fËi«¢a jah¡c j¡eh£u ¢Q¾a¡ ®Qae¡u Ae¤fË−hn L−l Hhw a¡ m¡m−el j¡dÉ−j
j¡eh pj¡−S fË−u¡N Ll−a öl² L−lz X¡lECeh¡c kMe c¡h£ Ll−a b¡−L ®k, "" A¢Ù¹−aÄl SeÉ
pwNË¡j '' J à¾cÄ ""HL¢V fË¡L«¢aL ¢hd¡e Hhw k¡ öd¤j¡œ E¢ác J fË¡e£ SN−a eu hlw a¡
p¡¢hÑLi¡−h j¡eh pj¡−Sl SeÉJ pji¡−h fË−k¡SÉz HC e£¢alC d¡l¡h¡¢qLa¡l B−m¡−L ¢qVm¡l
Hl ¢hL«a ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡u S¡jÑ¡e S¡¢a−L ""fËi¥l S¡¢a'' L¡mÑ j¡LpÑ Hl c¡h£ "" j¡eh S¡¢al C¢aq¡p
®nËe£ pwNË¡−jl C¢aq¡p'' Hhw f¤y¢Sf¢a−cl e£¢a−a de£l¡ Nl£h−cl ""h’e¡ ab¡ ®n¡o−el ''
j¡dÉ−j ""de£ A¢dLal de£ q−h'' Ef¢e−hnh¡c£−cl a«a£u ¢h−nÄl l¡øÊ pj§−ql SeNe−L −n¡oe J
h’e¡l j¡dÉ−j A¢deÙ¹ l¡M¡l p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£ e£¢a fËhaÑ−el à¡l¡ heÑh¡c£ Bœ²je, ¢eNËq, fËh’e¡,
®~hojÉ J Afn¡p−el a¡¢aÄL ®k±¢š²La¡ f¡Ju¡ k¡uz
lh¡VÑ l¡CV (Robert
( Wright)) HLSe ¢hhaÑeh¡c£
eh¡c£ qJu¡ p−aÄJ a¡l hC The Moral
Animal--H j¡eh S¡¢a−L ¢hhaÑeh¡c ¢Li¡−h HL jq¡ ¢hfkÑ−ul pÇj¤M£e L−l−R a¡ ¢e−jÀ¡š²
i¡o¡u heÑe¡ L−l−Re x "" ¢hhaÑeh¡c fËLa
« f−r j¡eh£u LjÑL¡−¾Xl C¢aq¡−p HL¢V c£OÑ J
e£¢a‘¡eq£e jah¡−cl
AfËfË−u¡Nz HC na¡ë£l ®n−ol ¢c−L l¡S−~e¢aL jah¡−cl p¡−b ¢j−m¢j−n HL¢V
A−h¡dÉ l¡S®~e¢aL jah¡c pª¢ø L−l H¢V ""p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡c'' ¢qp¡−h f¢l¢Q¢a m¡i L−l
Hhw aMe −b−LC HC SOeÉ jah¡c, heÑh¡c£, gÉ¡¢ph¡c£ J ph−Q−u q²cuq£e
fy¤¢Sf¢a−cl q¡¢au¡l ¢qp¡−h hÉhq²a q−a b¡−Lz ''
HC f¤Øa−L −k ašÆ, abÉ J fËj¡e¡¢c EfØq¡fe
EfØq¡fe Ll¡ q−u−R a¡l j¡dÉ−j S¡e¡ k¡u ®k,
X¡lECeh¡c öd¤j¡œ S£−hl Evf¢š J ®~h‘¡¢eL ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l j−dÉ Hl hš²hÉ p£¢ja l¡−Me¡ hlw
X¡lECeh¡c HL¢V ®Ny¡s¡ jah¡c k¡ dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡−pl ja Hl Ae¤p¡l£−cl j−dÉ HL dl−el Aå
X¡lECeh¡c
E¾j¡ce¡ pª¢ø L−lz ®~h‘¡¢eL cª¢ø−L¡e ®b−L k¢cJ X¡lECeh¡c pÇf§eÑi¡−h i¥m fËj¡¢ea q−u−|Rz

4 / 88
ah¤J hý ¢h‘¡e£ , l¡Se£¢a¢hc, h¤¢ÜS£¢h J ¢Q¿¹¡¢hc X¡lECeh¡−cl AåL¡l ¢cL Ab¡Ñv Hl ¢hï¡¢¿¹
®S−e h¡ e¡ ®S−eJ HC ®Ny¡s¡ J ¢hï¡¢¿¹Ll jah¡c−L HMe fkÑ¿¹ pjbÑe ¢c−u Bp−Rez k¢c
p¡j¡¢SL
pj¡−Sl Bf¡jl SeNe HC A−~h‘¡¢eL jah¡−cl i¥m œ²¢V J p¡j¡¢ SL r¢a ab¡ p¡¢hÑL ¢hfkÑu
pÇfÑ−L p¢WLi¡−h S¡e−a f¡−le a¡ q−m ®~üln¡pL, ¢ecÑu J Aj¡e¢hL ü¡bÑfl hÉ¢š²−cl H
jah¡c L¡kÑLl£ Ll¡l p¤−k¡N b¡L−he¡z g−m HC ¢hï¡¢¿¹Ll jah¡−cl AffË−u¡N pj¡S ®b−L
¢ejѤm Ll¡ pñh q−hz X¡lECeh¡−cl AffË−u¡N O¢V−u k¡l¡ j¡eh pj¡−S An¡¢¿¹, ¢hnªwMm¡, ®n¡oZ,
h’e¡ J ü¡bÑfl ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ J ja¡cnÑ fËQ¡l, fËp¡l J fË−u¡N L−l h−me ®k, HV¡C ""fË¡L«¢aL
¢hd¡e''z
¢hd¡e''z aMe HV¡ hm¡l Bl ®L¡e p¤−k¡N b¡L−he¡ h¡ pj¡−S a¡ Nªq£a q−he¡z
j¡eha¡ ¢h−l¡d£ pLm ja¡c−nÑl j§m X¡lECeh¡c k¢c pÇf§eÑl²−f pj¡S ®b−L Q¥s¡¿¹i¡−h
Evf¡¢Va
Evf¡¢Va qu ®p ®r−œ HL¢V j¡œ paÉ ¢hcÉj¡e b¡L−hz ®pC jq¡paÉ q−m¡ x ""HC ¢hnÄ ïj¡¾X J
j¡eh S¡¢a−L Bõ¡q pª¢ø L−l−Rez ®k pLm hÉ¢š²hNÑ HC paÉ−L q²cu‰j Ll−a prj q−he
a¡l¡ HJ h¤T−a f¡l−he ®k fËL«a h¡Øah paÉ q−m¡ j¡eh S¡¢al pLm pjpÉ¡ pj¡d¡−el Ef¡u
J f¿Û¡ ‰~nÄl La«ÑL ®fË
®fË¢la In£ NË−¿ÛC ¢e¢qa B−Rz'' hÉ¡fL Se−N¡¢ù k¢c HC d¡le¡ ®f¡oZ L−l
a−h ¢hnÄ pj¡S ®b−L c¤xM, ®hce¡, AeÉ¡u, A¢hQ¡l, c¤−iÑ¡N c¤cÑn¡, NZqaÉ¡ J c¡¢lâ Afp¡¢la
q−h Hhw Hl f¢lh−aÑ fË‘¡, de pÇfc, p¤ü¡ØqÉ, fË¡Q¥kÑ J j¤¢š² j¡eh pj¡−S ¢hl¡S Ll−hz HV¡
aMeC pñh q−h kMe pLm ¢jbÉ¡ J j¡eh S¡¢al SeÉ r¢aL¡lL jah¡c pj¡S −b−L Afpªa
q−h Hhw öd¤ ®pC f¢hœ J In£ jah¡c pj¡−S fË¢a¢ùa Ll¡l j¡dÉ−j fËL«a SeLmÉ¡e p¡de Ll¡
pñh q®hz ""¢Ym j¡l−m f¡V−Lm ®Ry¡s¡'' h¡ ""O¤¢pl hc−m O¤¢p j¡l¡'' Abh¡ Bœ²jeL¡l£−L
A¢dLal hs BO¡a ¢c−u ®L¡e pjpÉ¡l h¡Øah pj¡d¡e Ll¡ pñh euz hlw k¡l¡ H dl−el L¡S
L−l a¡−cl L¡−R ®~dkÑÉ, cu¡ J pq¡e¤i¥¢al p¡−b fËL«a paÉ ¢hØa¡¢lai¡−h heÑe¡l j¡dÉ−j a¡−cl
¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ h¡ dÉ¡e d¡le¡ f¢lhaÑe Ll¡−e¡l j¡dÉ−jC H pjpÉ¡l pj¡d¡e Ll¡ pñhz
HC f¤ØaL ®mM¡l fËL«a E−ŸnÉ q−m¡ k¡l¡ X¡lECeh¡−cl AåL¡lju ¢cL −S−e Abh¡ e¡
®S−e H−a ¢hnÄ¡p J BØq¡ Øq¡fe L−l b¡−Le, a¡−cl−L H j−jÑ Ah¢qa Ll¡ ®k, a¡l¡ fËLªaf−r
®L¡e jah¡c−L pjbÑe Ll−Rez Bl k¡l¡ HC jah¡c−L ¢hnÄ¡p L−le e¡ ¢WLC, a−h a¡l¡
h¡−cl
X¡lECeh¡c−L ¢hnÄ j¡eha¡l SeÉ ýj¢L ül²f h−mJ j−e L−le e¡, a¡−cl X¡lEq~eh¡ −cl AåL¡l
¢cL pÇf−LÑ paÑL Ll¡J H f¤Øa−L ®mM¡l AeÉaj E−ŸnÉz

5 / 88
 fÊbj AdÉ¡u

X¡lEqeh¡−cl pw¢rç C¢aq¡p

¢hnÄj¡ea¡l c¤xM c¤cÑn¡ J ¢hfkÑ

¢hfkÑ−u X¡lECeh¡−cl i¥¢jL¡ pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡l f¤−hÑ Hl
pw¢rç C¢aq¡p B−m¡Qe¡ Ll¡ fË−u¡Sez A−e−Ll d¡le¡ ®k, Q¡mpÑ X¡lECe phÑfËbj ¢hhaÑ
¢hhaÑeh¡−cl
®~h‘¡¢eL fËj¡e, fkÑ−hre J fl£r¡ ¢el£r¡ L−l HC jah¡c fËQ¡l L−lez fËLªaf−r HC jah¡−cl
j§m fËhš²¡ X¡lECe euz a¡C H jah¡−cl Ev−p ®L¡e ®~h‘¡¢eL fËj¡e e¡Cz
fË¡Q£e ®j−p¡−f¡V¡¢ju¡u kMe fË¢aj¡ f¤S¡ ¢i¢šL dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡p Q¡m¤ ¢Rm aMe f|ª¢bh£−a
fË¡−el B¢hiÑ
B¢hiÑ¡h, ¢hnÄ pª¢ø lqpÉ pÇf−LÑ ¢h¢iæ L¥pwØL¡l J −f±l¡¢eL LÒf Lb¡ fËQ¢ma ¢Rmz
H pLm d¡le¡l j−dÉ HL¢V ¢hnÄ¡p h¡ jah¡c ¢Rm ¢hhaÑeh¡cz He¤−j¡-
j¡-C¢mn (ENUMA
( -ELISH )
L¡−hÉ ¢hnÄ pª¢ø pÇf−LÑ hm¡ qu ®k, HL fËmuwLl£ heÉ¡l fl ALpÈ¡v c¤C ®cha¡ m¡qj¡
( LAHMA)) J m¡qj¤
m¡qj¤ (LAHAMU)
( ) Hl B¢hÑi¡h O−Vz
O−Vz HC jah¡−cl j§m d¡le¡ q−µR x ""HL
®ch j§¢aÑ (−cha¡) phÑfËbj ¢e−SC ¢e−S−L pª¢ø L−le Hhw flha£Ñ−a ¢h¢iæ fc¡bÑ Hhw AeÉ¡eÉ
S£h pª¢ø L−l ¢hnÄju R¢s−u f−sz'' AeÉ Lb¡u p¤−jl£u ®f±l¡¢eL LÒfLb¡ Ae¤k¡u£ A®~Sh SmS
BL¡lq£e AhØq¡ q−a qW¡v fª¢bh£−a ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡l j¡dÉ−j fË¡−el Evf¢š J ¢hL¡n quz
HC fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ ®b−L ®cM¡ k¡−µR ®k, p¤−jl£u−cl HC dj£~Ñu ¢hnÄ¡p AbÑ¡v fª¢bh£−a A®~Sh
fc¡bÑ −b−L fË¡−el Evf¢š J ¢hL¡n O−V−R k¡ Q¡mÑp X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl p¡−b AaÉ¿¹
p¡j”pÉf§eÑz H−a fËj¡¢ea qu ®k, ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl
h¡−cl fËbj fËhš²¡ X¡lECe ee hlw a¡ p¤−jl£u fË¢aj¡
f§S¡l£−cl dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡pz flha£Ñ−a Afl HL¢V fË¢aj¡ f§S¡l£ piÉa¡ AbÑ¡v fË¡Q£e NË£−p HC
¢hhaeÑh¡−cl fËp¡l J hÉ¡¢ç O−Vz fË¡Q£e NË£−pl hØa¤h¡c£ c¡nÑ¢eLNe a¡−cl ¢h−nÔoZ fË¢œ²u¡u
SshØa¥ R¡s¡ AeÉ ®L¡e ¢LR¤l A¢ØaaÄ ¢hnÄ
¢hnÄ pª¢ø−a ¢hcÉj¡e a¡ ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−ae e¡z HC pLm NË£L
c¡nÑ¢eL ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ®f±l¡¢eL LÒfL¡¢qe£−L p¤−jl£u piÉa¡l Ešl¡¢dL¡l ¢qp¡−h BaÈØq L−l
¢hnÄpª¢ø a−šÅl Eáh J ¢hL¡n pÇf−LÑ hÉ¡MÉ¡ Ll−a b¡−Lez Hi¡−h hØa¥h¡c£ cnÑe J pª¢øašÆ
pÇf¢LÑa ®f±l¡¢eL L¡¢qe£ fË¡Q£e NË£−p Bjc¡e£
Bjc¡e£ Ll¡ quz fË¡Q£e NË£p ®b−L HC jah¡c flha£Ñ−a
®l¡j¡e pwØL«¢a−a Ae¤fË−hn L−lz Aø¡cn na−L HC Eiu jah¡c f¤el¡u ea¥ei¡−h
BaÈfËL¡n L−l k¡ j§max fË¢aj¡ f§S¡l£ pwØL«¢al ®œ²¡−s fË¢af¡¢maz ¢LR¤ pwMÉL CE−l¡f£u
¢Q¾a¡¢hc, k¡l¡ NË£L cnÑe pÇf−LÑ BNËq£ ¢R−meza¡l¡ Ssh¡c£
Ssh¡c£ ab¡ hØa¥h¡c£ cnÑ−el fË¢a BL«ø
qez HC pLm ¢Q¿¹¡¢hc−cl j−dÉ HL Ni£l ¢jm ¢Rm a¡ q−m¡-
q−m¡- d−jÑl pw−N ¢h−l¡d£a¡ ab¡
e¡¢ØaLa¡ h¡ e¡¢ØaLÉh¡cz
e¡¢ØaLÉh¡cz

6 / 88
 gl¡p£ S£h¢h‘¡e£ S¡ hÉ¡f¢VØV ®mj¡LÑ (Jean
( Baptiste Lamarck)) fËbj hÉ¢š² ¢k¢e
¢hhaeÑh¡c ¢e−u ¢hØa¡¢lai¡−h N−hoe¡ L−lez ®mj¡LÑ
®mj¡LÑ d¡le¡ Ll−ae ®k, pLm fËL¡l fË¡e£
p¡j¡eÉ f¢lh¢aÑal²−f ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡l j¡dÉ−j l²f¡¿¹¢la q−u haÑj¡e l©f d¡le L−l−Rz HC jah¡c
flha£Ñ−a ¢jbÉ¡ ¢qp¡−h fËj¡¢ea quz a¡ p−šÆJ ®mj¡−LÑl HC jah¡c ¢LR¤V¡ f¢lh¢aÑal²−f ®k
hÉ¢š² ¢hnÄh¡p£l ¢eLV EfØq¡fe L−le ¢a¢e q−me hª¢Vn p−Ml S£h ¢h‘¡e£ Q¡mÑp X¡lECez
1859 p¡−m CwmÉ¡−ä Q¡mÑp X¡lECe ay¡l f¤ØaL ¢c Al¢Se Ah ®Øf¢pp (The
( origin of
Species ) Hl j¡dÉ−j HC jah¡c EfØq¡fe L−lez HC f¤Øa−L ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl p¤−jl£u piÉa¡l
−f±l¡¢eL Lb¡ HLV¥ ¢hØa¡¢lai¡−h fËL¡n L−lez ¢a¢e c¡h£ L−le ®k pLm fË¡e£ ®~ch¡v f¡¢e
®b−L Hhw HL f¤hÑ f¤l²o Common Ancestor ®b−L ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡l j¡dÉ−j pª¢ø q−u−Rz AbÑ¡v
HC pLm fË¡e£ üaØg¤aÑi¡−h p¡j¡eÉ f¢lhaÑ−el j¡dÉ−j HL −b−L AeÉ fË¡e£−a l²f¡¿¹¢la q−u®Rz
Q¡mÑp X¡lEC−el HC c¡h£ a¡l pjuL¡l ¢h‘¡e£−cl p¡d¡lZ Ae¤−j¡ce
j¡ce h¡ NËqe−k¡NÉa¡
m¡i Ll−a ApjbÑ quz ¢h−no L−l g¢pm (S£h¡nÈ) ¢h−no‘Ne Ae¤d¡he Ll−a pjbÑ q−u¢R−me
®k, X¡lEC−el c¡h£ HL¢V Lù LÒfe¡ R¡s¡ AeÉ ¢LR¤ euz Hacp−šÆJ pj−ul BhaÑ−e
X¡lEC−el jah¡c pj¡−Sl ¢h¢iæ Nʲ−fl pjbÑe ®f−a b¡−Lz H pjbÑ−el AeÉaj L¡le q−m¡
Ee¢hwn
Ee¢hwn na¡ë£l n¡pL−N¡¢ù X¡lECe J a¡l HC jah¡−c ¢ial a¡−cl A−~hd n¡pe J ®n¡oe
f¡L¡−f¡š² Ll¡l q¡l¡−e¡ p§œ My¤−S −f−u−Rez

ja¡cnÑNa L¡l−e X¡lECeh¡−cl pjbÑe

X¡lEC−el f¤ØaL ¢c Al¢Se Ah ®Øf¢pp(1859)

®Øf¢pp(1859) kMe fËL¡¢na qu aMe ¢h‘¡e AaÉ¿¹
fÕQ¡cfc AhØq¡u ¢Rmz Ec¡qle ül©f
ül©f hm¡ k¡u ®k, ®p−L−m Ae¤h£rZ k−¿»l j¡dÉ−j S£h ®L¡o
(cell)) pð−å ‘¡e AaÉ¿¹ p£¢ja fkÑ¡−ul ¢Rmz AbÑ¡v a¡ HL¢V ¢h¾c¤l (Blot)
( ) ja Hhw Hl
A¢a¢lš² ¢LR¤ S¡e¡ pñh ¢Rme¡z haÑj¡−e Bjl¡ S¡¢e ®k, HC fË¡e ®L¡o HL¢V A¢a S¢Vm
¢eujhÜ fÜ¢a (System)
( ) H L¡l−e ®pC pj−u A−~Sh fc¡bÑ
fc¡bÑ ®b−L ®~ch¡v fË¡−el p¤Qe¡ q−u−R j−jÑ
X¡lEC−el H c¡h£ fËQ¡l Ll−a ®L¡e pjpÉ¡ ®cM¡ k¡u ¢ez Ae¤l©fi¡−h S£h¡nÈ N−hoZ¡J Ae¤æa
fkÑ¡−u b¡L¡u p¡j¡eÉ f¢lhaÑ−el j¡dÉ−j fË¡Z£ SN−al ¢h¢iæ fËS¡¢al pª¢ø q−u−R j−jÑ c¡h£ Ll¡J
pñh q−u¢RmzAbQ haÑj¡−e Hje HL¢VJ S£h¡nÈ ®lLXÑ
®lLXÑ e¡C k¡l p¡q¡−kÉ fËj¡e Ll¡ pñh ®k,
fÊ¡Z£ üaØg§aÑi¡−h HL¢V ®b−L AeÉ¢V−a ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡l j¡dÉ−j ¢hL¡n m¡i L−l−R ab¡ pª¢ø
q−u−Rz Hje¢L ¢LR¤¢ce f¤−hÑJ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£l¡ HC ¢ha−LÑ Aha£Ñe q−u hm−ae "" Bd¡ j¡eh -Bd¡
fË¡e£ i¢hoÉ−a ®L¡e ¢ce −cM¡ k¡−h'' haÑj¡−e a¡l¡
a¡l¡ HV¡ Bl ®L¡e œ²−jC ®N¡fe Ll−a f¡l−R e¡
®k, H c¡h£¢V B−c± paÉ eu z (¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ¢hï¡¢¿¹ AdÉ¡−u ¢hØa¡¢la E−õ¢Ma)
H dl−el fËaÉr fËj¡e b¡L¡ p−šÆJ X¡lECeh¡c£l¡ a¡−cl jah¡c cªti¡−h Ay¡L−s d−l
A¡−Rez X¡lEq~eh¡c£l¡ ¢hNa 150 hvpl k¡hv Ešl¡¢dL¡l p§−œ fË¡ç ‘¡−el
‘¡−el eÉ¡u HC jah¡c
¢hnÄØa¡l p¡−b Ae¤plZ L−l Bp−Rez haÑj¡−e −~h‘¡¢eL N−hoe¡u X¡lEq~
X¡lEq~eh¡c ï¡¿¹ fËj¡¢ea qJu¡

7 / 88
p−šÆJ H jah¡−cl pjbÑ
pjbÑeL¡l£Ne ®S¡l fËQ¡le¡ Q¡¢m−u Bp−Rez X¡lECeh¡−cl A¢ØaaÄ H L¡l−eC
−L¡e e¡ ®L¡e ®N¡¢ùl j−dÉ ¢V−L B−Rz

X¡lECeh¡−cl ph−Q−u N¤l²aÄf¤ZÑ ¢cL q−µR

q−µR H jah¡−c pª¢øLaÑ¡l Aü£L«¢az
az ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl
ašÆ Ae¤k¡u£ fc¡bÑ ®b−L ®~ch¡v S£h−el Eáh q−u−Rz
q−u−Rz X¡lEC−el HC ¢jbÉ¡ c¡h£ Ssh¡c£
®~h‘¡¢eL −b−L öl² L−l pLm e¡¢ØaLÉh¡c£ c¡nÑ¢eL jah¡−cl ¢jbÉ¡ ®~h‘¡¢eL ¢i¢š lQe¡ L−lz
Hl L¡le q−m¡ Ee¢hwn na¡ë£ fkÑ¿¹ A¢dL¡wn ®~h‘¡¢eLC
‘¡¢eLC ¢h‘¡e−L Bõ¡ql pª¢ø pÇf−LÑ
Ae¤på¡e, N−hoZ¡ J a¡l ¢h¢iæ …e¡…e ab¡ ®~h¢nø B¢h×L¡l Ll¡l fÜ¢a ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡
Ll−aez H dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡−pl hÉ¡fLa¡ J ¢hØa«¢al L¡l−e e¡¢ØaL J Ssh¡c£ ®~h‘¡¢eLNe a¡−cl
jah¡c fËQ¡l, fËp¡l J ¢hL¡−nl ®L¡e p¤−k¡N f¡¢µR−me e¡z X¡lECeh¡−c pËø¡l A¢Øa−šÆl Aü£L«¢a
a¡−cl ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ fËj¡−el SeÉ HL dl−el ïj¡aÈL pjbÑe J p¤−k¡N pª¢ø L−lz H L¡l−eC Ssh¡c£
J e¡¢ØaLÉh¡c£ c¡nÑ¢eL, ¢Q¿¹¡¢hc J ¢h‘¡e£ X¡lECeh¡c−L a¡−cl ¢eSü ja¡cnÑ ¢qp¡−h NËqe
L−lez X¡lECeh¡−c pËø¡l Aü£L«¢al p¡−b p¡−b fË¡−el ¢hL¡n J fËL«¢a−a "" S£−hl A¢Øa−aÄl
SeÉ pwNË¡j−L '' HL p§−œ Ny¡b¡ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ quz'' H ""pwNË¡−j ph−Q−u n¢š²n¡m£ ¢hSu£
qu '' Hhw ""c§hÑm fl¡¢Sa J ¢e¢ÕQq² q−u k¡uz'' ®k pLm S£he cnÑe j¡ehS¡¢al SeÉ jq¡
c¤−iÑ¡N J ¢hfkÑu ¢e−u H−p−R a¡−cl p¡−b X¡lECeh¡c£−cl pjbÑe J pq−k¡N£a¡ H L¡l−eC
fËaÉr Ll¡ k¡uz
p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡c x j¡eh£u Q¢l−œ Swm£ BCe fËhaÑe

"" fËL«¢a−a A¢Ùa−aÄl pwNË¡j '' ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl HL¢V AeÉaj ¢cL k¡ H jah¡−cl HL¢V
…l²aÄf§ZÑ a¡¢šÅL ¢i¢šz X¡lEC−el j−a fËL«¢a−a A¢Øa−aÄl SeÉ ¢eù¥l pwNË¡j pwO¢Va q−u
b¡−Lz H pwO¡a
pwO¡a HL¢V ¢Ql¿¹e fË¢œ²u¡z H pwNË¡−j ph pju n¢š²dl c§hÑm−L fl¡¢Sa L−lz HC
fË¢œ²u¡l j¡dÉ−j pj¡−S p¡¢hÑL Eæue p¡¢da q−u b¡−Lz ¢c Al¢Se Ah ®Øf¢pp e¡jL f¤ØaL¢Vl
Ef-
Ef-¢n−l¡e¡−j ¢hou¢V| pw¢rçL¡−l HC i¡o¡u X~fØq¡fe Ll¡ q−u−Rz “ The Origin of Species
by means of Natural Selection or the Preservation of Favoured Race
in the Struggle for Life ” fË¡L«¢aL ¢eh¡QÑe fË¢œ²u¡l j−dÉ fËS¡¢a pj§−ql Evf¢š Abh¡ S£he
pwNË¡−j Be¤L¥mÉ fË¡ç fËS¡¢a pj§−ql pwlrez
hª¢Vn AbÑe£¢a¢hc Vj¡p j¡mb¡p (Thomas
( Malthus)) Hl An Essay on the Principle of
population f¤ØaL¢V ¢Rm X¡lEC−el H jah¡−cl fËd¡e Evp¡q c¡a¡z HC f¤Øa−L j¡eh S¡¢al
SeÉ HL¢V iu¡hq i¢hoÉ−al Cw¢Na ¢Rmz j¡mb¡p ¢qp¡h L−l ®cM¡−me ®k, SepwMÉ¡ AaÉ¿¹
â²aN¢a−a hª¢Ü f¡u Hhw 25 hvp−l a¡ ¢à…e qu ¢L¿º M¡cÉ plhl¡q ®L¡eœ²−jC HC q¡−l hª¢Ü
f¡u e¡z
e¡z g−m j¡ehS¡¢a−L Ae¡q¡−l jªa¤É j¤−M f¢aa qJu¡u T¤¢y Ll pÇj¤M£e q−a q−µRz SepwMÉ¡
¢eu¿»−el ü¡i¡¢hL Ef¡c¡e q−m¡ k¤Ü, c¤¢iÑr J jq¡j¡l£z AbÑ¡v ¢LR¤ ®m¡L−L hy¡¢Q−u l¡M−a q−m
AeÉ−cl jl−a q−hz B¢ØaaÄ h¡ ¢V−L b¡L¡l AbÑC q−µR ¢QlØq¡u£ k¤Üz X¡lXCe ¢e−SC h−m−Re

8 / 88
®k, j¡mb¡−pl f¤Øa−L ""A¢Ù¹−aÄl SeÉ pwNË¡j'' pÇfÑL£u jah¡c a¡−L ¢hhaÑeh¡c pÇf−LÑ ¢Q¿¹¡
Ll−a ¢nM¡uz ¢a¢e ¢m−M−Re, ""1838 p¡−ml A−ƒ¡hl j¡−p AbÑ¡v Bj¡l fÜ¢aNa Ae¤på¡e
fË¢œ²u¡l 15 j¡p fl qW¡v B¢j SepwMÉ¡l Efl ®mM¡ j¡mb¡−pl hC¢V f−s S¡e−a f¡¢l ®k,
c£OÑ¢c−el d¡l¡h¡¢qL
d¡l¡h¡¢qL fkÑ−hr−el j¡dÉ−j ®cM¡ ®N−R ®k, fË¡e£ J E¢ác SN−a pwNË¡−jl j¡dÉ−j
¢e−S−cl A¢Ù¹aÄ ¢V−L b¡L¡l jah¡c ¢edÑ¡le Ll¡ B−Rz HlC p¤œ d−l qW¡v Bj¡l ®h¡−d¡cu qu
®k, H dl−el f¢l¢Øq¢a−a (A¢Øa−aÄl pwNË¡j) Be¤L¥mÉ fË¡ç fÊS¡¢a ¢hSu£ qu AbÑ¡v ¢V−L
b¡−L, fË¢aL¥m f¢l−h−n pwNË
pwNË¡jla fËS¡¢a fl¡¢Sa q−u dÄwpfË¡ç quz HlC gmn˲¢a−a ea¥e
fËS¡¢al pª¢ø quz Ah−n−o HC f¤Øa−LC B¢j HL¢V ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ ašÆ ab¡ L¡kÑLl£ jah¡−cl
på¡e f¡Cz''
Ee¢hwn na¡ë£−a j¡mb¡−pl H ašÆ k−bø pj¡cªa quz q~E−l¡−fl A¢iS¡a h¤¢ÜS£¢hNe
¢h−noi¡−h H jah¡−cl pjbÑe ®k¡N¡ez
®k¡N¡ez Ee¢hwn na−L CE−l¡f£u ¢Q¿¹¡¢hcNe j¡mb¡−pl SepwMÉ¡
pjpÉ¡ pwœ²¡¿¹ jah¡−cl ®k …l²aÄ fËc¡e L−le a¡ The Scientific Background of the Nazi
‘‘ Race Purification ” e¡S£−cl fËS¡¢a f¢löÜLle LjÑpQ¤ £l ®~h‘¡¢eL ®fËr¡fV ¢eh−å E−õM
Ll¡ quz Ee¢hwn na−Ll fËbj¡−dÑ
bj¡−dÑ pjNË CE−l¡−f n¡pL ®nËe£l hÉ¡¢š²hNÑ pcÉ Eá¡¢ha j¡mb¡−pl
"" SepwMÉ¡ pjpÉ¡ '' pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ L−lez Aaxfl n¡pL ®nÊe£ j¡mb¡−pl jah¡c h¡Øah¡ue
Ll¡l LjÑp§Q£ NËqe L−lez Hl BJa¡u c¢l−âl jªa¥Él q¡l hª¢Ü, c¢lâ Se−N¡¢ùl f¢lµRæa¡ AbÑ¡v
ü¡ØqÉ p−Qaea¡ hª¢Ül f¢lh−aÑ
f¢lh−aÑ Bjl¡ hlw ¢hfl£a f¿Û¡C NËqe Ll−h¡z Bj¡−cl nql…¢m−a
AfËnØaLl l¡Øa¡ ¢ejÑ¡e, ®R¡V ®R¡V h¡pNª−q hý ®m¡L b¡L¡l hÉhØq¡ Llhz g−m Hje Aü¡ØqÉLl
f¢l−hn pª¢ÖY~ Ll¡ q−h k¡−a ®fÔ−Nl Bœ²je ¢e¢ÕQa Ll¡ pñh quz Bj¡−cl fõ£ Hm¡L¡…−m¡
f¡¢ehÜ Hm¡L¡u ¢ejÑ¡e Ll−h¡ Hhw pyÉ¡apyÉ¡−a
É¡−a J r¢aLl f¢l−h−n Sehp¢a Øq¡f−e Evp¡q
fËc¡e Ll−h¡ CaÉ¡¢c g−m c¡¢lâ qW¡−e¡l ®Q−u c¢lâ−cl jªaɨ l j¡dÉ−j SepwMÉ¡ ¢eu¿»e L¡kÑœ²j
aÄl¡¢eÄa quz HC ¢eù¥l e£¢a Ae¤pl−el j¡dÉ−j AbÑ¡v A¢Øa−aÄl pwNË¡−j n¢š²dl ¢hSu£ J c§hÑm
fl¡Øa J ¢e¢ÕQq² q−u k¡−hz HC fË¢œ²u¡u â²a J hdÑen£m SepwMÉ¡l pja¡ hS¡u l¡M¡ pñh
q−hz
Ee¢hwn na¡ë£−a CwmÉ¡−¾X HC ¢eù¥l ""Nl£h ¢ede '' LjÑpQ§ £ fËL«af−rC h¡Øah¡ue Ll¡
quz Hl BJa¡u HL¢V ¢nÒf¡ue fÜ¢a fË¢a¢ùa qu ®kM¡−e 8/9 hR−ll ¢nö nË¢jL−cl 16 O¾V¡
Lum¡l M¢el Aj¡e¢hL f¢l−h−n L¡S Ll−a h¡dÉ Ll¡ q−a¡ Hhw H fË¢œ²u¡u q¡S¡l q¡S¡l ¢nö
¢ede Ll¡ quz ""A¢Øa−aÄl pwNË¡−jl'' a¡¢šÆL ¢i¢š k¡ j¡mb¡p ¢c−u¢R−me HlC d¡l¡h¡¢qLa¡u
CwmÉ¡−ä mr mr Nl£h Se−N¡¢ù j¡e−hal S£he k¡fe Ll−a h¡dÉ q−u−Rez
a−a
X¡lECe, j¡mb¡−pl ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ à¡l¡ fËi¡¢ha q−u d¡le¡ Ll−me ®k, pjNË fËL«¢a−a HC
d¡l¡C ¢hl¡Sj¡ez L¡−SC j¡eh pj¡−SJ H d¡l¡ fË−u¡N Ll¡ E¢Qaz HV¡ q−m¡-
q−m¡- ""n¢š²n¡m£
®k¡NÉa−ll ¢hSu J c§hÑ−ml fl¡Su J dÄwp '' ¢a¢e ¢h−noi¡−h Hl Efl …l²aÄ¡−l¡f L−lez HV¡
AmwOe£u J ¢QlØq¡u£ fË¡L«¢aL ¢hd¡e ¢qp¡−h ¢a¢e pª¢øLaÑ¡l A¢Ø¹aÄ Aü£L«¢al j¡dÉ−j ¢a¢e
Sep¡d¡l−el
Sep¡d¡l−el dj£Ñu j§mÉ−h¡d, e£¢a J BcnÑ−L ¢hpSÑe ¢c−a Evp¡¢qa L−le L¡le H…−m¡ q−m¡

9 / 88
a¡l ""A¢Ø¹−aÄl pwNË¡j'' jah¡−cl ¢eù¥l fË−u¡N fÜ¢al f¢lf¢¿Ûz H L¡l−eC X¡lEC−el jah¡c
aMe ®b−LC n¡pL ®nËe£l f§eÑ pjbÑe m¡i L−lz phÑfËbj k¡ CwmÉ¡−¾X J flha£Ñ−a pjNË f¢ÕQj¡
¢h−nÄ a¡ R¢s−k f−sz
p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£, fy¤¢Sf¢a J AeÉ¡eÉ hØa¥h¡c£ h¤¢ÜS£¢hNe HC jah¡c−L ü¡Na S¡e¡ez L¡le
C−a¡j−dÉ a¡l¡ ®k i¡lp¡jÉ J e£¢aq£e ®n¡oe ¢i¢šL l¡S®~e¢aL fÜ¢a fËhaÑe L−l¢R−mez H
jah¡−cl j−dÉC a¡l ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL ®k±¢š²La¡ ®cM−a −f−u¢R−mez HC L¡l−e a¡l¡ H
ja¡cnÑ
ja¡cnÑ Ae¢a¢hm−ð NËqe L−l Hl h¡Øah¡u−el SeÉ ph ¡aÈL ®Qø¡ AhÉ¡qa l¡−Mez
phÑÑ¡aÈL
¢hhaÑeh¡c A¢Q−lC pj¡®Sl pLm Øa−l Ae¤fÊ−hn L−lz pj¡Saš, C¢aq¡p, j−e¡¢h‘¡e,
l¡øÊ¢h‘¡e CaÉ¡¢c AbÑ¡v pj¡−S Hje ®L¡e ¢hou lCm e¡ k¡ Hl fËi¡−h fËi¡h¡¢eÄa qu¢ez fË¢a¢V
®r−œ j§m fË¢af¡cÉ ¢hou h¡ −nÔ¡N¡e q−m¡ "" A¢Ø¹−aÄl SeÉ pwNË¡j '' J ""®k¡NÉa−jl ¢V−L
b¡L¡z''
b¡L¡z'' l¡S®~e¢aL cm, S¡¢a, ®cn, fËn¡pe, h¡¢e¢SÉL fË¢aù¡e AbÑ¡v pj¡−Sl fË¡u fË¢a¢V hÉ¢š²
HC Bc−nÑ Ae¤fË¡¢ea qu L¡le C¢aj−dÉ pj¡®S fËd¡e ¢eu¿»eL¡l£ ja¡cnÑ ¢qp¡−h X¡lECeh¡c
fË¢aù¡ m¡i L−l−R h¡ AeÉ Lb¡u,
Lb¡u, pj¡−Sl pLm ¢Q¾a¡, ®Qae¡, i¡hd¡l¡u X¡lECeh¡c
A¢h−µRcÉi¡−h k¤š² q−u k¡uz Hje¢L ¢QœLm¡, l¡Se£¢a, C¢aq¡p H pLm ®rœJ X¡lECe£
ja¡c−nÑl BJa¡ h¢qiѤa b¡Lm e¡z
X¡lECeh¡−cl p¡−b fË¢a¢V ¢ho®ul pÇfLÑ Øq¡fe Ll¡l
Ll¡l phÑ¡aÈL fË−Qø¡ AhÉ¡qa b¡−Lz
X¡lECeh¡c£ cª¢ø−L¡e ®b−L −k −L¡e ¢hou hÉ¡MÉ¡, ¢h−nÔoZ J fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ Ll¡l l£¢a/fÜ¢a Q¡m¤ Ll¡
quz HlC gmn˲¢a−a Hje¢L X¡lECeh¡−cl e¡j e¡ S¡e¡ p−šÆJ X¡lECe£ ja¡c−nÑl ¢i¢š−a ®k
dl−el pj¡S hÉhØq¡ N−s EW¡l Lb¡ a¡C pj¡−S N−s E−Wz
X¡lECe ¢e−SC p¤f¡¢ln L−l¢R−me ®k, a¡l jah¡c (¢hhaÑeh¡c) ®ke p¡j¡¢SL ¢h‘¡−e
fË−u¡−Nl ®r−œ p¡j¡¢SL j§mÉ−h¡−dl ¢hou¢V ¢h−hQe¡ L−l fË−u¡N Ll¡ quz 1869 p¡−m HCQ ¢bm
(H. Thiel)) Hl ¢eLV ¢m¢Ma HL f−œ ¢a¢e E−õM L−le ®k x
""fË
""fËS¡¢apj§−ql ¢hhaÑ®el ®r−œ B¢j ®k ja¡ja fËL¡n L−l¢R a¡ pj¡¢SL j§mÉ−h¡d J
p¡j¡¢SL ¢h‘¡−el ®r−œ ®ke pji¡−h hÉhq¡l e¡ Ll¡ quz Bf¢e a¡ cªti¡−h ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−a
f¡−lez ¢a¢e B−l¡ h−me ®k, C−a¡f§−hÑ B¢j ®L¡eœ²−jC j−e L¢l e¡C ®k, Bj¡l ja¡ja ¢h¢iæ
…l²aÄf§eÑ ¢ho−u (®~e¢aL j§mÉ−h¡d−L h¡c ¢c−u)
¢c−u) Ha hÉ¡fLi¡−h hÉhq¡l Ll¡ q−hz ""fËL«¢al HC
pwNË¡j '' j¡eh£u Q¢lœ J LjÑL¡−¾X
L¡−¾X B−l¡f Ll¡ quz g−m hZÑh¡c, gÉ¡p£h¡c, L¢jE¢eSj,
p¡jË¡SÉh¡c fËi«¢a e¡−j H pwNË¡j BaÈfËL¡n L−l Hhw Hl j¡dÉ−j n¢š²dl hÉ¢š², S¡¢a, ®N¡¢ù,
a¡−cl ¢h−hQe¡u k¡l¡ c§hÑm a¡−cl dÄwp Ll¡l ea¥e q¡¢au¡l −f−m¡z HC dÄwp k−‘l ab¡L¢ba
¢h‘¡e pÇja ašÅ f¡Ju¡ ®Nmz H L¡l−e
L¡l−e haÑj¡−e k¡l¡ SoeÉ NeqaÉ¡ J j¡e¤−ol p¡−b föl eÉ¡u
BQlZ L−lz j¡e¤o−L j¡e¤−ol ¢hl²−Ü −m¢m−u ®cu Hhw j¡e¤−ol N¡œh−ZÑl L¡l−e q£e ¢h−hQe¡
L−lz fË¢a−k¡N£a¡l e¡−j ®R¡V hÉhp¡ fË¢aù¡e hå L−l ®cu, de£ q−uJ c¢lâ−cl fË¢a pq−k¡N£a¡l
q¡a h¡¢s−u ®cu e¡, a¡−cl L¡kÑLm¡f−L
m¡f−L ¢e¾c¡ Ll¡ h¡ h¡d¡ ®cJu¡ Apñh q−u cy¡¢s−u−Rz L¡lZ

10 / 88
a¡−cl j−a a¡l¡ HL¢V ab¡L¢ba fË¡L«¢aL J ®~h‘¡¢eL BC−el BJa¡u H ph ¢e¢hÑQ¡−l Ll−Rz
H pLm LjÑL¡ä−L HL Lb¡u p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡c ¢qp¡−h BMÉ¡¢ua Ll¡ q−QRz

fËMÉ¡a ¢hhaÑeh¡c£, B−j¢lL¡e S£h¡nÈ ¢h‘¡e£ STEPHEN JAY GOULD H paÉ

ü£L¡l L−l E−õM L−l−Re x 1859 p¡−m The Origin of Species fËL¡¢na qJu¡l fl c¡p fËb¡,
p¡jÊ¡SÉh¡c, heÑh¡c, ®nËe£ pwNË¡j, ¢mwN ®~hojÉ fËi«¢a p¡j¡¢SL J l¡S®~e¢aL Ae¡Q¡l "" ¢h‘¡−el
e¡−j fË¢aù¡ m¡i L−l−Rz'' j¡eh piÉa¡l C¢aq¡−p k¤Ü, ¢eù¥la¡, S¡aÉ¡¢ij¡e,
S¡aÉ¡¢ij¡e, pwO¡a,
hhÑ−l¡¢Qa LjÑL¡ä pwO¢Va q−u−Rz ¢L¿º ph pju j¡eh S¡¢a−L ¢nr¡ ®cJu¡ q−u−R a¡−cl H
pLm LjÑL¡ä AeÉ¡u, i¤m, Hhw a¡ ®b−L ¢hla ®b−L j¡eh S¡¢a−L n¡¢¿¹ J eÉ¡u¢hQ¡l fË¢aù¡
Ll¡l SeÉ Bqh¡e S¡e¡−e¡ q−u−Rz j¡eh S¡¢a In£ d−jÑl j¡dÉ−j A¿¹a f−r HV¥L¥ h¤T−a J
S¡e−a ®f−l¢Rm ®k, a¡−cl H pLm Evf£sej§mL LjÑL¡−ä ¢mç qJu¡ i¥m h¡ AeÉ¡u k¡
®~e¢aLa¡¢h−l¡d£z Ee¢hwn na¡ë£−a X¡lEq~eh¡−cl fËQ¡l J fËp¡−ll fl Sej−e H d¡le¡ pª¢ø
q−m¡ m¡i, S¤m¤j J A¢hQ¡−ll SeÉ à¾cÄ pwNË¡j Ll¡l HL¢V ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL ®k±¢š²La¡ l−u−Rz
hm¡ q−m¡ HV¡ j¡eh Q¢l−œl ®~h¢nøÉz H dl−el Bœ²je¡aÈL J hhÑ−l¡¢Qa BQlZ ®p a¡l f§hÑ
f¤l²o−cl(f¡n¢hL Q¢lœ) L¡R ®b−L Ešl¡¢dL¡l p§−œ ®f−u−|R a¡C SwN−m ®ki¡−h ph−Q−u hmn¡m£
J Bœ²je¡aÈL fË¡Z£, pwNË¡−jl j¡dÉ−j ¢e−Sl A¢Ù¹a−Ä L ¢V¢L−u l¡−M, ®pC HLC BCe j¡eh
pj¡−SJ pji¡−h fË−k¡SÉz
k¡SÉz H ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l fËi¡−h fª¢bh£l ¢h¢iæ Øq¡−e k¤Ü, ¢hfkÑu, NZqa¡É
hÉ¡fLi¡−h fËp¡l m¡i L−lz X¡lEq~eh¡c H pLm LjÑL¡−ä pjbÑe J Evp¡q ®k¡N¡uz AbÑ¡v H
jah¡c pLm fËL¡l lš²f¡a, pwO¡a, ¢ekÑ¡ae J c¤xM-
M-Lø-
Lø-®L ®k±¢š²L pjbÑe ¢c−u b¡−Lz H
L¡l−eC ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL k¤¢š² J fª
fªù−f¡oLa¡u pLm j¡ehdÄwp£ jah¡c pj§q ®~e¢aLi¡−h
n¢š²n¡m£ q−a b¡−Lz gmn˲¢a−a ¢hwn na¡ë£−a "" HL c¤−iÑ¡−Nl naL '' ¢qp¡−h BMÉ¡¢ka| Ll¡
quz
C¢aq¡−pl AdÉ¡fL Jacques Barzun ay¡l hC DARWIN, MARX, WAGNER haÑj¡e
¢h−nÄl ®~e¢aLa¡l Adxfa−el L¡le Ae¤på¡e J j§mÉ¡u−el ®fËr¡f−V ®~h‘¡¢eL, pj¡Sa¡¢šÆL J
pwØL«¢aL ¢hou¡¢c fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ L−l−Rez H f¤Øa−L pj¡−S X¡lEq~eh¡−cl fËi¡h heÑe¡ fËpw−N ¢a¢e
E−õM L−le ®k x
1870 p¡m ®b−L 1914 p¡−ml j−dÉ CE−l¡−fl fË−aÉL¢V ®c−nl k¤Üh¡S l¡S®~e¢aL cm
Q¡¢µRm AÙ», hÉ¢š² ü¡a¿»h¡c£ cm Q¡¢µRm ¢eù¥l fË¢a−k¡N£a¡,
¢a−k¡N£a¡, l¡Sa¿»h¡c£ c−ml c¡h£ ¢Rm AeNËpl
Se−N¡¢ùl Efl fË¡d¡eÉ ¢hØa¡l, pj¡Sa¡¢¿»L c−ml ¢Rm c¡h£-
c¡h£-rja¡ cMm, hZÑh¡c£ c−ml c¡h£
¢h−l¡d£−cl BiÉ¿¹l£e h¢q×L¡l/Bhp¡uez H pLm ja¡cnÑ£C ®L¡e e¡ ®L¡ei¡−h a¡−cl ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l
üf−r X¡lECeh¡c−L hÉhq¡l L−lez X¡lECe J ®Øfep¡l
®Øfep¡l ¢hou¢V f§−hÑC EfØq¡fe L−l¢R−me,
H−a hm¡ q−m¡ −k−qa¥ ®L¡e h−eÑl ®nËùaÄ HL¢V S£h ¢h‘¡−el ¢hou −k−qa¥ a¡ j¡eh pj¡S
pÇfL£Ña a¡C HV¡ pj¡S ¢h‘¡−el ¢hou hØa¥, HV¡C X¡lEqeh¡cz

11 / 88
 Ee¢hwn na¡ë£−a X¡lECe kMe a¡l ¢hhaÑeh¡c a−šÆl j¡dÉ−j c¡h£ Ll−me ®k, pª¢øLaÑ¡
La«ÑL −L¡e
−L¡e ¢LR¤ pª¢ø Ll¡ qu e¡C, hlw "" ®~ch¡v üaØg¤aÑi¡−h '' H…¢m ¢hL¡n m¡i L−l−Rz
j¡eh S¡¢a J fn¤L¥m HL A¢iæ f§hÑ f¤l²o ®b−L B¢hi¨Ña q−u Hhw flha£Ñ−a HL A¢a Eæa
fËS¡¢a/fË¡e£ ¢qp¡−h BaÈfËL¡n L−l−Rz A¢dL¡wn ®m¡LC aMe HC c¡h£l fËL«a L¥gm pÇf−LÑ
d¡le¡ Ll−a hÉbÑ q−u−Rz
q−u−Rz ¢hwn na¡ë£®a HC L¥g−ml iu¡hqa¡ pjNË fª¢bh£−a R¡¢s−u f−s−Rz
k¡l¡ j¡eh S¡¢a−L ""Eæa fö'' ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ L−l−R, a¡l¡ c§hÑm, Ap¤Øq J a¡−cl ¢h−hQe¡u
""e£Q '' h−m j−e L−l−R a¡−cl ""q£e fË¡e£ '' ¢qp¡−h NeÉ L−l Oªe¡i−h fcc¢ma L−l−Rz Hhw
HC a¡−cl ®b−L ""e£Q¥ fËS¡¢a−L'' ¢eù¥li¡−h qaÉ¡ Ll−a ¢àd¡ L−l e¡Cz L¡le a¡−cl a−šÆ
HL¢V j¤−M¡n hÉhq¡l Ll¡ q−µR a¡q−m¡ "" fË¡L«¢aL BCez'' Hi¡−hC X¡lEeh¡c ¢h−nÄ
jq¡¢hfkÑu ¢e−u H−p−R Hhw â²aN¢a−a a¡ pjNË ¢h−nÄ R¢s−u f−X−Rz hØa¥h¡c£ J e¡¢ØaLÉh¡c£
c¡nÑ¢eLN−el ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ X¡lECeh¡−cl
X¡lECeh¡−cl ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL i¡hd¡l¡u Eá¡¢ha qJu¡l f§hÑ fkÑ¿¹
fª¢bh£l A¢dL¡wn j¡e¤oC ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−a¡ ®k HLSe pª¢øLaÑ¡ B−Rez ¢a¢e j¡e¤opq pjNË fË¡e£ J
E¢ác pª¢ø L−l−Rez a¡R¡s¡ AeÉ¡eÉ fË¡e£ ®b−L j¡e¤oÉ fËS¡¢al HL¢V ®j±¢mL f¡bÑLÉ l−u−R L¡le
j¡e¤−ol l−u−R BaÈ¡ k¡ pª¢øLaÑ
øLaÑ¡l HL AeeÉ pª¢øz j¡e¤o ®p ®k h−eÑl h¡ S¡¢al h¡ ®N¡−œlC ®q¡L
e¡ ®Le, j¡e¤o Bõ¡ql pª¢ø J a¡l h¡¾c¡ h¡ c¡pz djÑq£ea¡ ab¡ e¡¢ØaLÉh¡−cl n¢š²−a h¢mu¡e
q−u X¡lEeh¡c ¢h¢iæ p¡j¡¢SL ®nËe£ pª¢ø L−lz Hl¡ j¡e¤o HL¢V Eæa fËS¡¢al fö ¢qp¡−h NeÉ
Ll−a b¡−L Hhw HL¢V ¢eù¥
¢eù¥l J fË¢a−k¡N£a¡j§mL ¢eù¥l ¢hnÄ cª¢øi¢‰ NËqe L−l pLm LjÑL¡−ä
j¡eha¡h¡c£ c¡u--c¡¢u−aÄl Aü£L«¢al j¡dÉ−j a¡l¡
e£¢a J BcnÑ hSÑe L−lz pª¢øLaÑ¡l fË¢a ®L¡e c¡u
Hje HL¢V pwØL«¢a pª¢ø L−l −kM¡−e pLm fËL¡l ü¡bÑfla¡ J ¢eù¥la¡ ®k±¢š²L ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡
Ll¡ quz HC pwØL«¢a ®b−L ""h¡c
®b−L ¢h¢iæ ja, fb J Bc−nÑl S¾j qu Hhw H−cl fË−aÉL¢V "" h¡c h¡
ja¡cnÑ '' j¡ehS¡¢a ab¡ fª¢bh£l SeÉ HL HL¢V jq¡ ¢hfkÑu ¢qp¡−h BaÈfËL¡n L−lz
X¡lEq~eh¡c ®k pjØa ""jah¡c−L'' pjbÑe c¡e L−l−R Hhw H dl−el a¡¢šÅL pjbÑe J
pq−k¡N£a¡ ¢Li¡−h ¢hnÄj¡eha¡−L r¢aNËØa L−l−R a¡l ¢hØa¡¢la ¢hhle flha£Ñ−a fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ Ll¡
q−hz

12 / 88
 ¢àa£u AdÉ¡u

X¡lXC−el x S¡¢aNa ¢h−ào-

¢h−ào-hZÑh¡c J Efe¢e−hnh¡c

X¡lEC−el O¢eù hå¥ fË−gpl ADAM SEDGWICK ¢R−me a¡−clC HLSe k¡l¡
¢hhaÑeh¡−cl iu¡hq L¥gm pÇf−LÑ f§−hÑq~ Ae¤d¡he Ll−a ®f−l¢R−mez HC f¤ØaL¢V f¡W L−l
L−l Hl
¢houhØa¥ Ae¤d¡he Ll¡l fl ¢a¢e j¿¹hÉ L−l¢R−mez "" HC ja¡cnÑ phÑSeN¡qÉ q−m j¡eh S¡¢al
SeÉ Hje hhÑla¡ J ¢eù¥la¡ ¢e−u Bp−h k¡ Aa£−a j¡e¤o LMeJ fËaÉr L−l e¡Cz'' C¢aq¡p
fËj¡e L−l−R ®k ADAM SEDGWICK Hl d¡le¡ Aj§mL ¢Rme¡ hlw X¡lECeh¡−cl k¤¢š² J
ab¡L¢ba fË¡L«¢aL BC−el BJa¡u k¡ L−l−Re a¡ C¢aq¡−p HL L¡−m¡ AdÉ¡u ¢qp¡−h ¢Q¢q²a
q−u B−Rz öd¤j¡œ S¡¢aNa J S¾j ab¡ hZÑNa L¡l−e mr mr j¡e¤o−L ¢e¢hÑQ¡−l qaÉ¡ L−lz
g−m Ee¢hwn na¡ë£ q−u−R AåL¡l k¤Nz
X¡lEC−el f§−hÑ k¢cJ S¡¢aNa ®~hojÉ J NZqaÉ¡ pwO¢Va q−u−R, ¢L¿º X¡lECeh¡c H
dl−el −~hojÉ−L HL¢V ¢jbÉ¡ ®~h‘¡¢eL ®nËùaÄ J Am£L ®k±¢š²La¡ c¡e L−l−R k¡ ¢h−nÄl C¢aq¡−p
LMeJ ®~e¢aL pjbÑe m¡i Ll−a prj qu e¡Cz

A¡e¤L¨mÉ fË¡ç fËS¡¢a pj§q pwlrZ

haÑj¡−e A¢dL¡wn X¡lECeh¡c£ c¡h£ L−l b¡−Le ®k, X¡lECe LMeJ hZÑh¡c£ ¢R−me e¡
hlw hZÑh¡c£l¡
h¡c£l¡ a¡−cl
a¡−cl jah¡c−L Se¢fËu Ll¡l
Ll¡l m−rÉ X¡lEC−el jah¡c®L hÉhq¡l L−l¢R−mez ay¡l¡
B−l¡ c¡h£ L−le, X¡lEC−el f¤Øa−L The Origin of Species Ef-
Ef-¢n−l¡e¡j By the
preservation of Favoured Races öd¤j¡œ fË¡Z£ SN−al ®r−œ hÉhq¡l Ll¡ q−u−Rz H ph c¡h£l
fËhš²¡l¡ fËL«af−r H f¤Øa−L X¡lECe
X¡lECe j¡eh fËS¡¢a pÇf−LÑ ¢L ja¡ja EfØq¡fe L−l−Re a¡
Aü£L¡l Ll−Re h¡ a¡ ¢h−hQe¡ L−le¢ez
X¡lXCe a¡l f¤Øa−L E−õM L−l−Re ®k, j¡eh S¡¢a ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡u ¢h¢iæ fkÑ¡u
A¢aœ²j L−l H−p−Rz ®L¡e −L¡e j¡eh fËS¡¢a AeÉ−cl a¥me¡u A¢dLal ¢hL¢na J ANËpl
q−u−Rz ®L¡e ®L¡e fËS¡¢a h¡ a¡−cl f§hÑ f¤l²o j¡eh−cl a¥me¡u ¢LR¤V¡ Eæa h¡ ANËpl h¡
A¢dLal ¢hL¢naz H fËS¡¢al ®L¡e −L¡e¢V Bh¡l h¡e−ll fkÑ¡u −b−L HLV¥ p¡j¡eÉ ®hn£ Eæaz
''X¡lECe
''X¡lECe B−l¡ c¡h£ L−le ®k, (¢h¢iæ j¡e¤o) fËS¡¢al j−dÉ "" A¢Øa−aÄl SeÉ pwNË¡j ''
fn¤−cl eÉ¡u pji¡−h fË−k¡SÉz "" Ae§Lm
¥ f¢l−hn fË¡ç fËS¡¢a '' H pwNË¡−j ¢hSu£ q−u b¡−Lz
X¡lEC−el j−a H pLm " p¤¢hd¡fÊ¡ç ' fËS¡¢a q−m¡ CE−l¡f£u ®nÄaL¡u S¡¢a pj§qz H¢nu¡ J
B¢éL¡u je¤oÉ fËS¡¢a "" A¢Ù¹−aÄl H pwNË¡−j ¢f¢R−u l−u−R h¡ a¡l¡ q−m¡ ¢f¢R−u fs¡ Se−N¡¢ùz

13 / 88
¢a¢e B−l¡ c¡h£ L−le ®k, H fËS¡¢a
S¡¢a pj§q ¢hnÄhÉ¡f£ "" A¢Ø¹−aÄl pwNË¡−j pÇf§eÑl©−f fl¡¢Sa
q−u ¢e¢ÕQq² q−u k¡−h ''z
""na¡ë£l Nee¡u Ac§l i¢hoÉ−a piÉ fËS¡¢al j¡e¤o AhnÉC ApiÉ J hhÑl fËS¡¢al
Se−N¡ù£−L fª¢bh£ ®b−L ¢ej§m Ll−h Hhw a¡−cl Øq¡e A¢dL¡l Ll−hz j¡e¤o a¡l ¢eLVaj fËS¡¢a
Hl p¡−b pÇf−LÑ
pÇf−LÑl ®r−œ A¢dLal E¾j¤š² J p¤n£m q−hz AbÑ¡v haÑj¡−e (1859 p¡−m) A¡¢éL¡l
¢e−NË¡ h¡ A−øÊ¢mu¡e (B¢ch¡p£ ) Hhw N¢lm¡−cl p¡−b ®k, dl−el BQlZ Ll¡ qu a¡ L−Ln£u -
CE−l¡f£u Hhw AeÉ ®hh¤e fËi«¢a ¢ejÀ fËS¡¢al ®b−L Eæa ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ k¡uz''
The Origin of Species Hl AeÉœ ¢a¢e c¡¢h L−l−Re ®k, Ae¤æa fËS¡¢al Se−N¡ù£ dÄwp
q−u k¡Ju¡ E¢Qaz Eæa fËS¡¢al j¡e¤o−cl a¡−cl S£¢ha J lr¡ Ll¡l ®L¡e fË−u¡Se£ua¡ e¡Cz
¢a¢e fn¤ fËSee J fË¢af¡m−el fÜ¢al p¡−b ¢hou¢V a¥me¡ L−l E−õM L−le ®k x
"" Ae¤æa Se−N¡ù£l p¡−b p¡−b k¡l¡
k¡l¡ n¡¢l¢lL J j¡e¢pLi¡−h c¤hÑm a¡−cl A¢Q−lC ¢ej§Ñm
Ll¡ q−h Hhw k¡l¡ p¡d¡leax p¤ü¡−ØqÉl A¢dL¡l£ a¡l¡C ¢V−L b¡L−hz Bjl¡ piÉ j¡e¤ol¡ HC
¢ej§Ñm fË¢œ²u¡u h¡d¡ ¢c−u b¡¢L, Bjl¡ f¡Nm J c§hÑm−cl, j¡e¢pL −l¡NNËØa−cl SeÉ q¡pf¡a¡m J
ü¡ØqÉ ¢eh¡p ¢ejÑ¡e L¢l, c¢lâ Se−N¡¢ùl SeÉ N¢lh£ BCe fËeue L¢lz Bj¡−cl ¢Q¢LvpLl¡ ®no
j¤ýaÑ fkÑ¿¹ H ph ®m¡−Ll S£he hy¡Q¡−e¡l SeÉ phÑ¡aÈL fË−Qø¡ AhÉ¡qa l¡−Mez HV¡ ¢hnÄ¡p Ll¡l
k¤¢š² pwNa L¡le l−u−R ®k, ¢VL¡ q¡S¡l q¡S¡l j¡e¤o−L ¢e¢ÕQa jªa¥Él q¡a ®b−L lr¡
L−l−Rz Aa£−a k¡l¡ n¡¢ll£Li¡−h c§hÑm ¢Rm
¢Rm a¡l¡ …¢V hp−¿¹ jªa¥É j§−M f¢aa q−a¡z p¤n£m
pj¡−Sl c§hÑm hÉ¢š²hNÑ, H pLm LjÑL¡ä−L a¡−cl cu¡ ¢qp¡−h fËQ¡le¡ Q¡m¡ez k¡l¡ fö fËSee
fË¢œ²u¡ fkÑ−hre L−l−Re a¡l¡ AhnÉC p−¾cq Ll−he ®k, H dl−el LjÑL¡ä j¡eh fËS¡¢al
ü¡i¡¢hL ¢hL¡−nl SeÉ AaÉ¿¹ r¢aL¡lLz''
Bjl¡ mrÉ L−l¢R ®k, X¡lECe a¡l f¤Øa−L A−øÊ¢mu¡l (B¢cj fËS¡¢a) J A¡¢éL¡l
¢e−NË¡ −N¢lm¡−cl HL pja¡−m ¢e−u H−p c¡h£ L−l−Re ®k, H pLm Se−N¡ù£ ¢ejÑm
§ q−u
(Ll¡)k¡Ju¡ E¢Qaz a¡l ¢h−hQe¡u AeÉ¡eÉ "" q£e '' fËS¡¢al Se−N¡ù£l SepwMÉ¡ h¡s−a ®cJu¡
E¢Qa eu k¡−a H…¢m cʲa ¢e¢ÕQq²
¢e¢ÕQq² q−u k¡uz AaHh −cM¡ k¡−µR ®k hZÑh¡c£ a−šÆ X¡lECe
E−õ¢Mai¡−h a¡ pjbÑe J Ae¤−j¡ce ¢c−u−Rez
X¡lEC−el hZÑh¡c£ ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ Ae¤k¡u£ p¤piÉ j¡e¤−ol fËd¡e c¡¢uaÄ J LaÑhÉ q−m¡
¢hhaÑeh¡−cl fË¢œ²u¡ (AbÑ¡v q£e Se−N¡ù£l ¢e¢ÕQq² Ll¡l L¡S) aÄl¡¢eÄa Ll¡z H f¢l¢Øq¢a−a ""
®~h‘¡¢eL '' cª¢øi¢‰l ¢cL ¢c−u ¢hQ¡l Ll−a ®N−m haÑj¡−e H ph ¢ejÀ fËS¡¢al ®L¡e Bf¢š
b¡L¡l Lb¡ euz L¡le H q£e Se−N¡ù£−L ®L¡e e¡ ®L¡ei¡−h ¢ej§Ñm q−aC q−hz
X¡lEC−el hZÑh¡c£ cª¢øi¢‰ a¡l ¢h¢iæ −mM¡u f¢lm¢ra quz Ec¡qlZ ül©f hm¡ k¡u ®k,
Tierra Del Fuego Se−N¡¢ù
Se−N¡¢ù pÇf−LÑ a¡l heÑh¡c£ cª¢øiwN£ fÊL¡n f¡u H hÉ¡f¡−l Hm¡L¡l Øq¡e£u
A¢dh¡p£ pÇf−LÑ a¡l heÑe¡uz ¢a¢e ¢m−M−Re "" Hl¡ pÇf§eÑ eNÀ b¡−L, lw ®j−M b¡−L, föl ja
k¡−µR a¡C Bq¡l L−l, pÇf§eÑ ¢eu¿»eq£e, a¡−cl ®N¡−œl h¡C−ll ®m¡−Ll fË¢a ¢eù¥l, a¡l¡ a¡−cl
nœ²−L ¢ef£se L−l Be¾c
Be¾c f¡u, Øœ£−cl p¡−b c¤hÑÉhq¡l L−l, −cha¡−cl E−Ÿ−nÉ fË¡e£−L h¢m ®cu,

14 / 88
¢nö−cl qaÉ¡, L−l pÇfѧe L¥pwØL¡l¡µRæ HL¢V Se−N¡ù£ '' AbQ X¡lEC−el f§−hÑ N−hoL WP
Snow HLC Hm¡L¡u ïje L−l pÇf§eÑ ¢iæ ¢Qœ E−õM L−l−Rez ¢a¢e h−me, Hl¡ M¤h n¢š²n¡m£
®k¡Ü¡z a¡l¡ a¡−cl ¢nn§−cl
cl fË¢a AaÉ¿¹ −pÀqn£m, a¡−cl A−eL ¢nÒfLm¡ A¢a pjªÜ, a¡l¡
pÇf−cl Efl A¢dL¡−ll ü£L«¢a ®cu, a¡l¡ a¡−cl hªÜ¡ j¢qm¡−cl La«ÑaÄ ®j−e Q−mz ''
H pLm Ec¡qle ®b−L ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, X¡lX~Ce HLSe
HLSe f¤−l¡f¤¢l hZÑh¡c£ ®m¡L ¢R−mez
fËLªaf−r X¡lEq~e a¡l f¤ØaL Decent of Man H p¤piÉ
iÉ j¡e¤oÉ fËS¡¢al p¡−b AeNËpl
fËS¡¢al a¥me¡ fËpw−N hý dl−el j¿¹hÉ L−l¢Rm k¡ Benjamin Farrington a¡l hC What
Darwin Really Said hC H ¢hØa¡¢la ¢m¢fhÜ L−l−Rez
""a¡R¡s¡, X¡lEq~−el jah¡−c pª¢øLaÑ¡l Aü£L«¢al L¡l−Z ph j¡e¤o−L Bõ¡q pj¡ei¡−h
pª¢ø L−l−Re H h¡Øah paÉ
paÉ a¡ SeNe h¤T−aC f¡l−m¡e¡z
f¡l−m¡e¡z hZÑh¡−cl E›¡e J a¡l ¢hnÄhÉ¡f£
NËqe−k¡NÉa¡l AeÉaj L¡lZ q−m¡ HC X¡lECeh¡cz''
B−j¢lL¡e ®~h‘¡¢eL James Ferguson pª¢øLaÑ¡l Aü£L«¢al p¡−b hZÑh¡−cl E›¡−el Ni£l
pÇf−LÑl ¢hou Hi¡−h heÑe¡ L−l−Re x
ea¥e eªašÆ AÒf¢c−el j−dÉC j¡eh pª¢øl Evp pÇf−LÑ c¤C ¢hh¡cj¡e a−šÆl ®fËr¡fV
¢qp¡−h L¡S Ll−m¡z j¡eh pj¡−S fËQ¢ma ¢hcÉj¡e d¡le¡/jah¡c ¢Rm ®k j¡e¤−ol N¡−ul lw h¡
Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢n−øÉC k¡C ®q¡L e¡ ®Le pLm j¡e¤o Bcj (Bx) ®b−L BNa Hhw Bõ¡q Bcj
pª¢ø L−l−Rez ph¡C HL hwnS¡a (MONOGENISM)
( HL hwnS¡az k¡ HL¢V dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡p k¡
N£SÑ¡ La«ÑL fËcš ¢nr¡z HV¡ Aø¡cn na¡ë£ fkÑ¿¹ ¢hnÄhÉ¡f£ NËqe−k¡NÉ ¢Rmz ¢L¿º kMe HC
dj£ÑuLa«Ñ−aÄl ¢h−l¡d£a¡ L−l ea¥e jah¡c AbÑ¡v j¡e¤−ol (POLYGENISM)
( ) HL¡¢dL hwnm¢aL¡
l−u−Rz AbÑ¡v ®L¡e HLL hÉ¢š² j¡e¤−ol B¢c ¢fa¡ euz AbÑ¡v ¢h¢iæ S¡¢apš Æ¡l ¢fa¡J
¢fa¡J ¢h¢iæz
g−m dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡−pl j¡dÉ−j ¢h¢iæ S¡¢al j−dÉ ®k ï¡¢a−aÄl håe ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rm a¡ ¢Ræ q−u ®Nmz
AbÑ¡v ¢hnÄ ï¡a«−aÄl j§−m L¤W¡l¡O¡a Ll¡ q−m¡z
i¡la£u eªašÆ¢hc LALITA VIDYARTHI X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl j¡dÉ−j hZÑh¡c
¢Li¡−h pj¡S ¢h‘¡−e Nªq£a qu a¡l ¢hhlZ X~−õM L−l ¢m−M−Re x
"" X¡lEC−el ®k¡NÉaj ¢V−L b¡®L jah¡c pj¡S ¢h‘¡e£Ne ü¡Na S¡e¡−mez a¡l¡ ¢hnÄ¡p
Ll−me j¡eh fËS¡¢a ¢h¢iæ ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡ A¢aœ²j L−l a¡l Q¨s¡¿¹ AhØq¡ (AbÑ¡v) ®nÄaL¡u−cl
piÉa¡u Eæ£a q−u−Rz Ee¢hwn na¡ë£l ¢àa£u¡−dÑ f¡ÕQ¡®aÉl A¢dL¡wn ¢h‘¡e£ hZÑh¡c−L h¡Øah
paÉ ¢qp¡−h ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−a öl² Ll−me h¡ ®j−e ¢e−mez''
X¡lECe flha£Ñ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£l¡ a¡l hZÑh¡c£ ja¡cnÑ b¡L¡l ¢hou¢V ®S¡−l−n¡−l fËQ¡l-
¡l-fËL¡n
Ll−a b¡L−mez H L¡S Ll−a a¡l¡ pLm e£¢a BcnÑ hSÑe L−l A−eL ®~h‘¡¢eL ApwN¢a J
¢jbÉ¡l BnËu NËqe L−lez Hl¡ i¡h−a b¡−Le, H ašÆ fËj¡−el j¡dÉ−j a¡l¡ a¡−cl ®~nÊùaÄ
®~h‘¡¢eLi¡−h fËj¡e L−l ¢iæ fËS¡¢al j¡eh p¿¹¡e−L ¢ekÑ¡ae, n¡pe, −n¡oe J fË−u¡Se−h¡−d
¢e¢ÕQq² Ll¡l ""fËL«¢a fËcš A¢dL¡l '' ASÑe L−l−Rez

15 / 88
 Stephen Jay Gould a¡l f¤ØaL The Mismeasure of Man Hl a«a£u AdÉ¡−u E−õM
L−l−Re ®k, ¢LR¤ pwMÉL eªašÆ¢hc, ®nÄa¡wN®cl ab¡L¢ba ®nËùaÄ fËj¡e Ll¡l SeÉ ¢jbÉ¡ ašÆ J
Ef¡š hÉhq¡l L−l−Rez Gould Hl j−a H fË¢œ²u¡u a¡−cl ®cM¡/f¡Ju¡ S£h¡nÈ, j¡b¡l M¤¢m J
j¢Øa−Ll BL¡l pÇf−LÑ ¢jbÉ¡Q¡l L−l−Rez a¡−cl d¡le¡ ¢Rm j¡eh h¤¢Ühª¢šl p¡−b j¢Øa−Ll
BL¡−ll HL¢V pÇfLÑ B−Rz A−eL eªašÆ¢hc L−Ln£u−cl M¤¢ml BL¡l CµR¡L«ai¡−h hs ®c¢M−u
i¡la£u J L¡−m¡ Se−N¡¢ùl h¤¢Ü Lj ¢qp¡−h EfØq¡fe L−l−Rez k¡ ¢Rm ®~h‘¡¢eL N−hoe¡l e¡−j
L−l ®Q±kÑhª¢š/®S¡µQ¤¡l£ h¡ S¡¢mu¡¢az
Gould a¡l f¤ØaL Ever Since Darwin H E−õM L−l−Re ®k, ¢LR¤ ¢hL«a a−bÉl
j¡dÉ−j a¡−cl ¢jbÉ¡ c¡h£ AbÑ¡v ¢LR¤ ¢LR¤ j¡e¤o fËS¡¢a "" q£e '' fËj¡e Ll−a hÜf¢lLl ¢R−me x
Hacekel J a¡l pwN£l¡J Eš−ll ®nÄa¡wN Se−N¡¢ùl ®nËùaÄ fËj¡−el SeÉ ®S¡l c¡h£ E›¡fe
L−lez j¡eh nl£l J ®b−L
a¡l hÉhq¡l pÇfL£Ña ¢h¢iæ S£h¡nÈ J AeÉ¡eÉ fËj¡e¡¢c (j¢ØaL ®b −L
®h¡a¡j fkÑ¿¹) Oo¡-
Oo¡-j¡S¡ L−l a¡−cl c¡h£l pjbÑ−e ¢h¢iæ abÉ/ašÅ EfØq¡fe Ll−a b¡−Lez
Herbert Spencer ¢m−M®Re x ""ApiÉ−cl h¤¢Ühª¢šJ a¡−cl p¿¹¡e−cl j−dÉ f¤el¡hª¢š O−Vz''
1864 p¡−m Carl Vogt M¤h ®S¡−l-
®S¡−l-®n¡−l hm−a öl² L−le ®k, "" HLSe f§eÑ huØL ¢e−NË¡l
h¤¢Ühª¢šl j¡œ¡ HL¢V ¢nöl eÉ¡u Bjl¡ AaÉ¿¹ fËaÉ−ul p¡−b hm−a f¡¢l ®k k¢cJ ®L¡e ®L¡e
®N¡œ l¡øÊ fË¢aù¡ L−l−Rz Aá¤a pwO, fË¢aù¡e pª¢ø L−l−R, ¢L¿º Ah¢nøl¡ h¡ pjNË (L«o·¡wN)
fËS¡¢a p¡j¢NËLi¡−h e¡ Aa£−a e¡ haÑj¡−e j¡eh S¡¢al Eæu−e Hje ®L¡e i§¢jL¡ l¡−M e¡C
®k L¡l−e a¡−cl
a¡−cl hy¡¢Q−u l¡M¡ k¡uz''
gl¡p£ He¡V¢jø ETIENNESERRES L«o·¡‰ f¤l²ol¡ B¢cj (AeNËpl h¡ Ae¤æa
fËS¡¢a) L¡le a¡−cl Belly Button HLV¥ e£−Ql ¢c−L Ah¢Øqaz
""X¡lEq−el pjp¡j¢uL ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ Havelock Ellis ®nËù J ""q£e'' fËS¡¢al f¡bÑ−LÉl
ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL hÉ¡MÉ¡ fËc¡e L−l E−õM L−le ®k, A¢dL¡wn B¢éL¡e fËS¡¢al ¢nö, Lc¡¢Qa
®L¡e CE−l¡f£u ¢nö ®b−L Lj h¤¢Üj¡e q−u b¡−Lz ¢L¿º B¢éL¡e ¢nö hup hª¢Ül p¡−b ¢e−hÑ¡d J
ÙÛ¤m h¤¢Ü pÇfæ q−u k¡u Hhw a¡l pjNË S£he HL¢V pwL£Ñe/®Ny¡s¡ l£¢a-
l£¢a-e£¢al hå−e BhÜ q−u
f−sz fr¡¿¹−l HLSe CE−l¡f£u a¡l
a¡l ¢nö p¤mi Evg¥õa¡ hS¡u l¡−Mz''
gl¡p£ eªašÆ¢hc Vacher de Lapouge c¡h£ L−le ®k, ""A−nÄa¡‰ ®nËe£i¥š² j¡eh p¿¹¡eNe
ApiÉ j¡eh fËS¡¢al hwndl Abh¡ ¢jnËl−š²l Adx f¢aa Se−N¡¢ùl fË¢a¢e¢dz ¢a¢e é¡−¾pl
¢h¢iæ ®N¡lØq¡e −b−L fÉ¡¢l®pl A¢iS¡a J e£Q¥ ®nËe£l j¡e¤−ol M¤¢m N−hoe¡ L−lez a¡l
N−hoe¡l ®k gm¡gm fËL¡n L−le a¡ q−m¡ x HL¢V ¢e¢cÑø BL«¢al M¤¢ml A¢dL¡l£ hÉ¢š² üi¡haC
de£, BaÈ¢hnÄ¡p£, j¤š², ü¡d£e, lrZn£m, A−Òf a¥ø, HLSe BcÑn ®phL/c¡p qJu¡l −k¡NÉz
fËL«af−r p¡j¡¢SL ¢ehÑ¡Q−el j¡dÉ−jC ®nËe£ ¢heÉ¡p q−u b¡−Lz ®nËù je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al
S¡¢al pcpÉl¡C
EµQal ®nËe£i¥š² q−u b¡−Lz j¡e¤−ol M¤¢ml BL¡®l p¡−b Be¤f¡¢aL q¡−l j¡e¤o de InÄ−kÑÉl
A¢dL¡l£ q−u b¡−Lz Lapouge B−l¡ h−me, L−uL hR−ll j−dÉC j¡e¤o BL«¢a ®N¡m Abh¡ ®Q¡M¡

16 / 88
qJu¡l SeÉ qaÉ¡ Ll−hz a¡l H i¢hoà¡e£ paÉ q−u¢Rmz ¢hwn na¡ë£−a hÉ¡fL Se−N¡¢ù−L
Se−N¡¢ù−L
eªnwpi¡−h öd¤j¡œ hZÑh¡−cl L¡l−Z qaÉ¡ Ll¡ quz
öd¤j¡œ eª¢h‘¡e£ eu hlw Entomologist (L£V ašÆ¢hc) J X¡lEC−el ¢hL«a ¢hhaÑeh¡−c
Ni£l ¢hnÄ¡p£ q−u hZÑh¡−cl ja¡c−nÑl Ae¤p¡l£ q−u−Rez Ec¡qle ül©f hm¡ k¡u ®k,1861 p¡−m
HLSe hª¢Vn L£VašÆ¢hc fª¢bh£l ¢h¢iæ ®c−nl j¡e¤
j¡e¤−ol ®c−q hph¡pL¡l£ EL¥−el Efl N−hoe¡
L−l H ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ Efe£a qe ®k, HL ¢e¢cÑø fËS¡¢al EL¥e ¢iæ je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al ®c−q h¡p Ll−a
f¡−le¡z haÑj¡e ®~h‘¡¢eL cª¢øi¢‰ ¢c−u ¢hou¢V ¢h−nÔoZ Ll−m HV¡ q¡pÉfc R¡s¡ AeÉ ¢LR¤
¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ k¡u e¡z kMe ®cM¡ k¡u ®k Hje¢L ®~h‘¡¢eL hÉ¢š²aÄ fkÑ¿¹ H dl−el Lb¡ ®O¡oe¡
L−le, aMe h¤T−a q−h, ¢LR¤ pwMÉL ®Ny¡s¡ hZÑh¡c£ H dl−el A−k±¢š²L Ah¡ÑQ£e J pÇf§eÑ AbÑq£e
®nÔ¡N¡e hÉhq¡l Ll−a f¡−l Hje ¢L HJ hm¡ ®k−a f¡−l ¢e−NË¡ EL¥e …−m¡ ¢e−NË¡z''
X¡lECe a−šÆl hZÑh¡c£ ¢cL Ee¢hwn na−Ll ¢àa£u¡−dÑ CE−l¡f£u ®nÄa¡wN−cl j−dÉ
hÉ¡fLi¡−h Se¢fÊua¡ m¡i L−lz L¡le I pju HLSe −nÄa¡wN a¡−cl Aj¡e¢hL J ¢eù¥l
LjÑL¡−äl a¡¢šÅL ®k±¢š²La¡ M¤yS¢R−mez

hª¢Vn Ef¢e−hnh¡c J X¡lECeh¡c

X¡lEC−el hZÑh¡c e£¢a h¡Øah¡u−el j¡dÉ−j ®k ®cn¢V ph−Q−u ®hn£ m¡ih¡e qu a¡q−m¡
a¡l j¡a«i¨¢j hª−Vez X¡lECe kMe H jah¡c EfØq¡fe L−le aMe ®NËV hª−Ve fª¢bh£l
Ef¢e−hnh¡c£ p¡jË¡SÉ ¢qp¡−h n£−oÑ AhØq¡e Ll−Rz i¡la ®b−L mÉ¡¢Ve B−j¢lL¡ fkÑ¿¹ pjع
fË¡L«¢aL pÇfc hª¢Vn p¡jË¡−SÉl LlamNaz ®nÄa¡wN j¡e¤o a¡−cl ü¡−bÑ fª¢bh£ m¤ãe Ll−Rz a−h
C¢aq¡p a¡−cl m¤−Vl¡ ¢qp¡−h ¢Q¢q²a
¢Q¢q²a Ll²L a¡ ®L¡e l¡øÊ fR¾c Ll¢Rm e¡z H L¡l−e a¡l¡ a¡−cl
n¡pe J −n¡oe ®k p¢WL a¡l HL¢V ®k±¢š²L hÉ¡MÉ¡ Ae¤på¡e Ll¢Rmz ®k pjØa ®cn Ef¢e−hn
¢qp¡−h a¡−cl Ad£e ¢Rm ®p pjØa ®c−nl SeNe "" B¢ch¡p£ '' "" fö p¤mi S£h¿¹ fË¡e£''
¢qp¡−h ¢Q¢q²a Ll¡z ®k pLm Se−N¡¢ù−L hÉ¡fLi¡−h
hÉ¡fLi¡−h qaÉ¡ Ll¡, h¡ k¡−cl p¡−b Aj¡e¢hL BQlZ
Ll¡ q−µR a¡l¡ fËLªa f−r ü¡i¡¢hL j¡eh p¿¹¡e eu hlw a¡l¡ "" AdÑ j¡eh -AdÑ föz '' a¡C
a¡−cl p¡−b ®k ¢eù¥l BQlZ Ll¡ q−µR a¡ Afl¡d eu HV¡ fËj¡e Ll¡l SeÉ f’cn J ®o¡sn
na¡ë£−a Ef¢e−hnh¡c fª¢bh£−a fËhaÑ−el pju ®b−L H dl−e a¡¢šÆL Ae¤på¡e AhÉ¡qa ¢Rmz
Chirstopher Columbus a¡l B−j¢lL¡ k¡œ¡l pju c¡h£ L−le ®k, −L¡e ®L¡e Se−N¡¢ù AdÑ-
föl Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢nø pÇfæz HC c¡h£ Ae¤k¡u£ B−j¢lL¡l B¢ch¡p£Ne je¤oÉ p¿¹¡e eu hlw a¡l¡
HL dl−el Eæa fö fËS¡¢alz H L¡l−e a¡−cl−L Øq¡e£u Ef¢e−hnh¡c£−cl
Ef¢e−hnh¡c£−cl ®ph¡u ¢e−u¡¢Sa
Ll¡ k¡uz
B−j¢lL¡ B¢h×L¡l pwœ²¡¿¹ ¢p−ej¡…¢m−a Chirstopher Columbus −L kaC Øq¡e£u
Sep¡d¡l−el fË¢a cu¡m¤, q²cuh¡e J ejË ¢qp¡−h ¢Q¢q²a Ll¡ ®q¡L e¡ ®Le fËLa
« f−r ¢a¢e
"®e¢Vi' B−j¢lL¡e−cl je¤oÉfc h¡QÉ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll−ae e¡z

17 / 88
 Chirstopher Columbus fËb−jC −pM¡−e hÉ¡fL NeqaÉ¡ pwO¢Va L−lez ¢a¢e ®k
pjØa ®cn B¢h×L¡l L−l−Re, ®p N¤¢m Ef¢e−h−n f¢lea L−le Hhw ""®e¢Vi−cl'' œ²£ac¡p
¢qp¡−h hÉhq¡l L−lez c¡p hÉhp¡ öl² Ll¡l ""L«¢aaÄ '' a¡−LC ®cJu¡ k¡uz ®Øfe£u
Ef¢e−hnh¡c£ a¡−cl ""¢ekÑ¡ae J ®n¡oe e£¢a '' h¡Øah¡ue L−l Hhw a¡ hq¡m l¡−M J NZqaÉ¡
pj§q hÉ¡fL BL¡l d¡le L−lz Ec¡qlZ ül©f E−õM Ll¡ k¡u, ®L¡e à£−f Columbus fËbj
BNje L−le aMe Hl SepwMÉ¡ ¢Rm 200000z ¢hn hRl fl H pwMÉ¡ cy¡s¡u 50,000 Hhw
1540 p¡−m H pwMÉ¡ cy¡s¡u j¡œ HL q¡S¡−lz 1519 p¡−ml ®éh˲u¡l£−a kMe ¢hMÉ¡a ®Øfe£u
¢hSu£ Cortes ®j¢„−L¡u BNje L−le aMe HM¡eL¡l SepwMÉ¡ ¢Rm 25 ¢j¢muez 1605 p¡−m
a¡ L−j cy¡s¡u 1 ¢j¢mu−ez 1492 p¡−m Hispaniola à£−f SepwMÉ¡ ¢Rm 7-
7-8 ¢j¢mue k¡, 1496
p¡−m L−j 4 ¢j¢mue c¡s¡u Hhw1570 p¡−m H−cl j−dÉ j¡œ 125 Se S£¢ha b¡−Lz
I¢aq¡¢pLN−el
I¢aq¡¢pLN−el ¢qp¡h Ae¤k¡u£ Columbus H jq¡−c−n fcÑ¡fe Ll¡l fl 100 hR−ll Lj pj−ul
j−dÉ 95 ¢j¢mue ®m¡L−L Ef¢e−hnh¡c£l¡ qaÉ¡ L−lz kMe Columbus B−j¢lL¡ B¢h×L¡l L−le
(1492 p¡m) aMe Ef¢e−h−nl SepwMÉ¡ ¢Rm 30 ¢j¢muez aMe −b−L AcÉ¡h¢d NZ qaÉ¡l
®fË¢r−a haÑj¡−e H¢V HL¢V fË
fË¡u q¡l¡−e¡ fËS¡¢a ¢qp¡−h ¢V−L B−R k¡−cl pwMÉ¡ 2 ¢j¢mu−elJ
L−j c¡¢s−u−Rz H pLm hÉ¡fL J ¢eù¥l NZqaÉ¡l fËd¡e L¡le q−µR H ph "®e¢Vi' Sep¡d¡le−L
Bcj p¿¹¡e ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ e¡ L−l hlw a¡−cl−L fö ¢qp¡−h NeÉ Ll¡ q−u−Rz
p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£−cl H c¡h£ h¡ k¤¢š² A¢dL¡wn ®m¡LC
®m¡LC NËqe L−l¢ez L¡le CE−l¡−f aMe pLm
j¡e¤o HL Bc−jl hwndl Hhw Bõ¡q pLm−L pj¡ei¡−h pª¢ø L−l−Re H dj£Ñu c¡h£/ja¡ja ph¡C
cªti¡−h ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−a¡z Øq¡e£u j¡e¤−ol p¡−b Aj¡e¢hL BQl−el a¡l¡ a£hË fË¢ah¡c L−l Hhw
¢hl²−Ü AhØq¡e NËqe L−lz H hÉ¡f¡−l Barthlome de las Casas (Columbus Hl B−j¢lL¡
A¢ik¡œ¡l pqN¡j£) Hl ¢eLV Chipas Hl Bishop Hl fœ¢V HL¢V Ešj Ec¡qlZ ¢qp¡−h E−õM
Ll¡ k¡uz ¢hnf a¡l f−œ E−õM L−le ""fË¢a¢V −e¢Vi HLSe fËL«a Bcj p¿¹¡e '' ®f¡f fm
®e¢Vi−cl p¡−b Aj¡e¢hL BQlZ Ll¡l SeÉ 1537 p¡−m H g−a¡u¡u Ef¢e−hnh¡c£−cl A¢in¡f
®ce Hhw ®O¡oe¡ L−le ®k, ®e¢Vil¡ p¢aÉL¡l j¡eh p¿¹¡e Hhw a¡l¡ djÑ NËq−el j¡dÉ−j ‰~j¡ec¡l
q−a f¡−lez
¢L¿º Ee¢hwn na¡ë£−a f¢l¢Øq¢al Bj§m f¢lhaÑe p¡¢da quz SeN−el j−dÉ hØa¥h¡c£
cnÑ−el hÉ¡fL fËQ¡l, fËi¡h Hhw dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡p ¢n¢bm qJu¡l L¡l−e j¡e¤o ®k Bõ¡ql
Bõ¡ql pª¢ø a¡
Aü£L¡l Ll¡l fËhea¡ pª¢ø qkz g−m H pju ®b−L ""hZÑh¡c '' Hl E›¡e O−Vz Ee¢hwn na−Ll
X¡lEC−el hØah¡c£ cnÑe H−a HL ea¥e j¡œ¡ ®k¡N qu Hhw CE−l¡−fl p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£−cl fËd¡e
q¡¢au¡−l f¢lZa quz
James Joll c£OÑ ¢ce k¡ha AdÉ¡fL ¢qp¡−h A„−g¡XÑ, ø¡e−g¡XÑ J qÉ¡iÑ
qÉ¡iÑ¡X ¢hnÄ¢hcÉ¡m−ul
C¢aq¡−pl AdÉ¡fL ¢qp¡−h L¡S L−lez ¢a¢e a¡l EUROPE SINCE 1870 NË¿Û k¡ HMe

18 / 88
¢hnÄ¢hcÉ¡m−ul pj§−ql f¡WÉf¤ØaL ¢qp¡−h f¡WÉp§Q£−a A¿¹Ñiš
¥ ² B−Rz H f¤Øa−L ¢a¢e X¡lECeh¡c,
hZÑh¡c, p¡jË¡SÉh¡−cl f¡lØf¢lL pÇf−LÑ heÑe¡ L−l−Re x
""p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£−cl fËd¡e Evp¡qhÉ”L jah¡c q−m¡ p¡d¡lei¡−h k¡−L p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡c
¢qp¡−h ®nËe£ ¢heÉ¡p Ll¡ k¡uz H jah¡−c l¡øÊpj§q A¢Øa−aÄl Se¡ HL ¢QlØq¡u£ pwNË¡−j ¢mç ®L¡e
®L¡e je¤oÉ fËS¡¢a−L AeÉ−cl ®Q−u ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fË¢œ²u¡u ®nÊù ¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qa Hhw H pwNË¡−j
ph−Q−u n¢š²n¡m£ fËS¡¢a hm fË−u¡−Nl j¡dÉ−j phpju a¡−cl ®nËùaÄ hS¡u l¡−Mz Charles
Darwin hª¢Vn fËL«¢a¢hc kb¡œ²−j 1859 p¡−m The Origin of species Hhw 1871 p¡−m The
Descent of Man f¤ØaL¢V fËL¡n L−lez HC f¤ØaL c¤¢V−a fËL¡¢na i¡hd¡l¡ CE−l¡f£u ¢Q¿¹¡
SN−a ¢h¢iæ n¡M¡u hÉ¡fL ¢haÑ−Ll Ts ®a¡−mz
®a¡−mz X¡lECe Hhw a¡l pjp¡j¢uL ¢Q¿¹¡¢hc k¡−cl
j−dÉ ¢h¢iæ c¡nÑ¢eLJ ¢R−me Herbert Spencer ¢R−me a¡−cl j−dÉ AeÉaj, H−cl ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ A¢a
â²aN¢a−a Hje Hje ¢hou h¡ fË−nÀl Ešl ®My¡S¡l ®Qø¡ Ll¡ qu, k¡l p¡−b ¢h‘¡−el c§laj
pÇfLÑ e¡Cz X¡lEC−el jah¡−cl HL¢V ¢cL q−µR a¡
a¡ Hje HL¢V fË−u¡¢NL, ¢hnÄ¡p pª¢ø L−l a¡
q−m¡ pj¡S Eæu−e œ²jhdÑj¡e SepwMÉ¡ J p£¢ja pÇf−cl L¡l−e SeN−el j−dÉ A¢Øa−aÄl SeÉ
HL¢V p¡hÑr¢eL à¾cÄ pwNË¡j ¢hl¡S L−lz H k¤−Ü ph−Q−u "" n¢š²n¡m£ ab¡ ®k¡NÉaj '' ¢hSu
m¡i L−l ¢V−L b¡−L AeÉl¡ dÄwpfË¡ç quz pj¡−S HC jah¡c Q¡m¤ qJu¡l ®fË¢r−a "" ¢V−L ''
b¡L¡ fËS¡¢al à¾cÄ pwNË¡−j L«a AfLjÑ−L HL¢V ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL J ®~e¢aL pjbÑe fËc¡e Ll¡
pqSp¡dÉ quz AbÑ¡v ®L¡e ¢h−no j¡e¤o fËS¡¢al ®nËùaÄz
"" fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Q−el '' jah¡c AeÉ HL¢V ja¡c−nÑl p¡−b pq−SC S¢sa q−u k¡u a¡
q−m¡ ®L¡e ¢h−no je¤o fËS¡¢al ®nËùaÄz gl¡p£ ®mML Count Joseph Arthur Gobineau 1853
p¡−m An Essay on the Inequaility of Human Races e¡jL f¤ØaL fËL¡n L−lez ¢a¢e a¡l
f¤Øa−L ®S¡l c¡h£ L−le ®k, j¡eh pj¡−S ®pC je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al ""®nËùaÄ '' ®hn£ hS¡u b¡−L, −k
fËS¡¢a A¢dL S¡¢aNa
S¡¢aNa ¢höÜa¡ lr¡ Ll−a pjbÑ quz HlC d¡l¡h¡¢qLa¡u Gobineau Hl j−a
BkÑS¡¢a ph−Q−u pgm S¡¢a ¢qp¡−h ¢V−L B−Rz Houston Stewart Chambrelain H jah¡c
B−l¡ HL d¡f H¢N−u ¢e−u k¡ez S¡jÑ¡e S¡a£u e¡S£ ®ea¡ HXmg ¢qVm¡l Chambrelain −L
M¤h fR¾c Ll−ae H L¡l−e 1927 p¡−m HC −mM−Ll jªan
¥ kÉ¡u ¢qVm¡l hÉ¢š²Nai¡−h Ef¢Øqa
q−u¢R−mez
Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡ ®b−L fËj¡¢ea qu ®k, p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£, hZÑh¡c£ J X¡lECeh¡c£ ¢hnÄ¡p£−cl
ja¡c−nÑl j−dÉ Aá¤a pw−k¡N B−Rz Hje¢L ¢qVm¡l hÉ¢š²Nai¡−h H d¡l¡u A¿¹Ñiš
¥ ² l−u−Rez
Ee¢hwn na−Ll p¡jÊ¡SÉh¡c£ J e¡S£h¡c£ H c¤C ja¡c−nÑl ¢i¢š i§¢j ¢qp¡−h X¡lECeh¡c i¥¢jL¡
−l−M−Rz fËL«af−r H na−L H ja¡cnÑ ¢hnÄ−L lš²pÀ¡−el j¡dÉ−j Lmw¢La L−l−Rz ¢hwn
na¡ë£−a a¡l¡ H d¡l¡ AhÉ¡qa −l−M−−Rz
¢i−ƒ¡¢lu¡ k¤−Nl ®NËVhª−Ve X¡lEqeh¡c−L HL¢V ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL ja¡cnÑ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡
L−l−Rz Ef¢e−hnh¡c
Ef¢e−hnh¡c ®b−L ph−Q−u ®hn£ m¡ih¡e q−u−R ®NÊV hª−Vez a¡C phÑ¡aÈL Ef¢e−hnh¡c£

19 / 88
n¢š² ¢qp¡−h hª−Ve a¡l M--Lø
¢eS ü¡−bÑ ®n¡oe fË¢œ²u¡l j¡dÉ−j Øq¡e£u A¢dh¡p£−cl ¢hfkÑu, c¤xM
¢nL¡l
pª¢ø e¡ Ll¡l ®L¡e L¡le p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£ hª−Ve ®c−M¢ez hª¢Vn p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£−cl −e¡wl¡ l¡Se£¢al ¢nL ¡l
q−m¡ Q£−el ¢hl©−Ü ""B¢gj k¤Üz''®NË
z''®NËV hª−Ve i¡l−a fËØa¥aL«a B¢gj Ee¢hwn na−Ll fËbj¡−dÑ
®Q¡l¡Q¡m¡e£−cl j¡dÉ−j Q£−e ¢hœ²k Ll−a¡z pj−ul Bh−aÑ HC B¢gj ®Q¡lQ¡m¡e£®cl L¡kÑœ²−j
A¢dL N¢a p’¡¢la quz L¡le hª−Ve H −b−L a¡l ¢h−cn h¡¢e−SÉl O¡V¢a f¤¢o−u ¢eaz Q£e−c−n
B¢g−jl
B¢g−jl HC Ae¤fË−hn ®cn¢Vl l¡øÊ£u p¡hÑ−i±j La«Ñ−aÄl Efl ®e¢ah¡QL fËi¡h f−sz g−m Q£e¡
pj¡−S a¡ hÉ¡fLi¡−h ¢hfkÑ−ul pª¢ø L−lz H ®fË¢r−a Q£e plL¡l A¡¢gj Bjc¡e£ ¢e¢oÜ ®O¡oe¡
Ll−a h¡dÉ quz g−m öl² qu fËbj B¢gj k¤Ü (1838-
(1838-1842) öl² quz H−a ®L¡e p−¾cq e¡C
®k, H k¤−Ül g−m ®cn¢V ®cE¢mu¡ q−u k¡uz p¡j¢lL n¢š²l AfËa¥ma¡ J ¢h−cn£ n¢š²l q¡−a
a¡−cl fl¡S−ul L¡l−e Q£e a¡l j¡b¡ ea Ll−a h¡dÉ quz1842 p¡m ®b−L f¡ÕQ¡aÉ l¡øÊpj§q
B−Øa B−Øa Q£−el l¡øÊ£u p£j¡l j−dÉ ¢h¢iæ Sehp¢a(Concessions)
Sehp¢a ®L¾cÐ N−s ®a¡−mza¡l¡ Q£e¡
plL¡−ll L¡R −b−L ¢hØa£eÑ
¢hØa£eÑ Hm¡L¡l (Portquarter
( Concession) i¥¢j CS¡l¡ ®eu Hhw
®cn¢V®L Hi¡−h ¢h−cn£−cl L¡−R E¾j¤š² L−l k¡−a L−l a¡ ph−Q−u ®hn£ EfL«a q−u f−sz Hl
g−m l¡øÊn¢š² c§hÑm Hhw ®cn¢V c¡¢l−âl Ll¡m NË¡−p f¢aa qu Hhw œ²j¡Na l¡øÊ£u i¨-M−¾Xl
pw−L¡Q®e ®cn¢V k¤Ü ¢hNË−ql ¢nL¡−l
¢nL¡−l f¢lea quz
hª¢Vn p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£ e£¢a Q£e¡ A¢i‘¡a¡l j−dÉ p£j¡hÜ ¢Rme¡ hlw, Ee¢hwn na¡ë£−a hª¢Vn
p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£
¡SÉh¡c£ e£¢al ¢ekÑ¡ae J c¤xM Lø,
Lø, ¢hfkÑu c¢rZ B¢éL¡, i¡lahoÑ J A−øÊ¢mu¡l SeNeJ
fËaÉr L−lz
hª−V−el Hq~ ¢ef£sej§mL L¡kÑLm¡−fl ®k±¢š²L ¢i¢š Hhw a¡−cl e£¢al p¢WLa¡
p¢WLa¡ fËj¡e
Ll¡l c¡¢uaÄ hª¢Vn pj¡S ¢h‘¡e£ J ®~h‘¡¢eL−cl Efl haÑ¡u z H−r−œ Q¡mÑp X¡lEC−el jah¡c
ph−Q−u …l²aÄf§eÑ J L¡kÑLl ¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qa qu z L¡le X¡lEq~e c¡h£ L−le ®k ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl
¢h¢iæ Øa−l HL¢V "" ®nËù j¡ehS¡¢al A¢ØaaÄ hS¡u B−R Hhw H pLm ""Eæa fËS¡¢a q−m¡
®nÄa¡wN fËS¡¢a'' Hhw k¤¢š² fËcnÑe L−le ®k, AeÉ¡eÉ je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al Efl ®nÄa¡wN−cl HC
AaÉ¡Q¡l J A¢hQ¡l J ¢eù¥l BQle HL¢V ""fË¡L«¢aL BCe z''
hZÑh¡c£ J X~f¢e−hnh¡c£−cl f−r X¡lECe ®k k¤¢š² fËcnÑe L−le, Hl ®fË¢r−a Swiss
Federal Insititute of Technology Hl fËMÉ¡a
MÉ¡a Q£e¡ ¢h‘¡e£ Kenneth J. Hsu h−me ®k, ""
X¡lECe ¢i−ƒ¡¢lu¡ k¤−Nl HLSe ®~h‘¡¢eL Hhw pj¡−Sl fË¢a¢ùa pcpÉ ¢qp¡−h hmf§hÑL Q£−e
N¡e−h¡Y~ f¡¢W−u Q£−e A¡¢gj Bjc¡e£ Ll¡ quz Bl H pLm LjÑL¡¾XC Ll¡ q−u−R fË¢a−k¡N£a¡
abÉ j¤š² h¡¢eSÉ Hhw ®k¡NÉaj−cl ¢V−L b¡L¡l e£¢a h¡Øah¡u−el
h¡Øah¡u−el e¡−jz''

X¡lEC−el a¥L£Ñcl ¢hl©−Ü ®~h¢la¡

Ee¢hwn na¡ë£l ®n−ol ¢c−L Jpj¡e£ p¡jË¡SÉ (OTTOMAN EMPIRE) hª¢Vn

Ef¢e−hnh¡c£−cl ¢eLV fËd¡e mrÉ hØa¥−a f¢lea quz H pj−u Jpj¡e£ p¡jË¡−SÉl p£j¡ C−u−je

20 / 88
 pj−u
−b−L öl² L−l hpe£u q¡l−S−N¡¢he¡ fkÑ¿¹ ¢hØa«a ¢Rmz Eš² pj −u Hq~ ¢hØaªe Hm¡L¡ ¢eu¿»e Ll¡
plL¡−ll f−r L¢We q−u f−s¢Rmz k¢cJ C−a¡f§−hÑ Jpj¡e£ p¡jË¡−SÉl n¡¢¿¹ nªwMm¡ J ¢el¡fš¡
hS¡u b¡Laz H f¢l¢Øq¢a−a Mªø¡e pwMÉ¡mO¤l¡ ü¡d£ea¡l c¡h£ E›¡fe Ll¢Rm Hhw l¡¢nu¡l j−a¡
hªqv p¡j¢lL n¢š² Jpj¡e£ p¡jË¡−SÉl A¢Øa−aÄl fË¢a ýj¢L q−u BaÈfËL¡n Ll¢Rmz Ee¢hwn
na¡ë£l ®n−ol ¢c−L hª−Ve J 顾p Jpj¡e£ p¡jÊ¡−SÉl ¢hl²Ü n¢š²l p¡−b q¡a ¢j¢m−u¢Rmz ¢h−no
L−l hª−Ve, Jpj¡e£ p¡jË¡−SÉl c¢rZ A’®ml fË−c−nl ¢c−L a¡l ®m¡m¤f cª¢ø ¢e−rf Ll¢Rmz
1878 p¡−m h¡¢mÑe Q¥¢š²l j¡dÉ−j CE−l¡f£u p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£ n¢š² pj§−ql Jpj¡e£ p¡jË¡SÉ−L
i¡N¡i¡¢N L−l ®eJu¡l f¢lLÒfe¡ fËL¡¢na quz hª−Ve 1882 Mªø¡−ë ¢jnl cMm L−l k¡ Jpj¡e£
p¡jË¡−SÉl A¿¹Ñi¥š² ¢Rmz hª¢Y~n Ef¢e−hnh¡c£Ne flha£Ñ−a Jpj¡e£ p¡jË¡−SÉl A¿¹ÑNa jdÉfË¡QÉ cMm
Ll¡l f¢lLÒfe¡ L−lz
hª−Ve phpju Ef¢e−hnh¡c£ e£¢al üf−r hZÑh¡c®L
¡c®L fËd¡e q¡¢au¡l ¢qp¡−h hÉhq¡l Llaz
hª¢Vn plL¡l E−ŸnÉj§mLi¡−h a¤¢LÑ S¡¢a−L HL¢V "" Ae¤æa'' Se−N¡¢ù ¢qp¡−h ¢Q¢q²a Llaz
hª¢Vn fËd¡ej¿»£ Willam Ewart Gladstone fËL¡−nÉ ®O¡oe¡ Ll−ae ®k, ""a¥¢LÑ Se−N¡¢ù
piÉa¡l
je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al pcpÉC eu h¡ je¤oÉ fch¡QÉ eu Hhw j¡eh piÉa¡ l ü¡−bÑ a¡−cl−L H¢nu¡l
Steppes A’®m ¢ha¡¢sa Hhw He®a¡¢mu¡ ®b−L ¢e¢ÕQq² Ll¡ E¢Qaz'' hª¢Vn plL¡−ll HC
A¢ija J h¡LÉh¡Z Jpj¡e£ p¡jË¡−SÉl ¢hl²−Ü L−uL cnL d−l AhÉ¡qa ¢Rmz hª−Ve a¥¢LÑ S¡¢a−L
HL¢V Ae¤æa Se−N¡¢ù ¢qp¡−h ¢Q¢œa Lla k¡−a HC S¡¢a ""AeNËpl CE−l¡f£u ®nÄa¡wN−cl
a¡wN−cl L¡−R
a¡−cl j¡b¡ ea Ll−a h¡dÉ quz H pLm fËQ¡le¡u ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL ¢i¢š q−µR Q¡mÑp
X¡lECez
a¥L£Ñ S¡¢a pÇf¢LÑa X¡lEC−el A¢ija1888 p¡−m The Life and Letterts of Charles
Darwin e¡jL f¤Øa−L ®cM¡ k¡uz X¡lECe ja¡ja fËL¡n L−le ®k, ""ab¡L¢ba Ae¤æa fËS¡¢a
fË¡L«
¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Qe fË¢œ²u¡l j¡dÉ−j ¢e¢ÕQq² q−u j¡eh piÉa¡ Eæu−e E−õM−k¡NÉ i§¢jL¡ l¡M−a prj
q−hz''
flha£Ñ−a a¤L£Ñ S¡¢a pÇf−LÑ a¡l j¿¹hÉ q−m¡ x "" B¢j k¢c Bfe¡−L piÉa¡l Eæue
fË¢œ²u¡u fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Q−el pwNË¡j J Hhw Hl d¡l¡h¡¢qLa¡l i¥¢jL¡ E−õM L¢l a¡ ¢hnÄ¡p Ll¡C
Bfe¡l SeÉ L¢We q−hz pÈlZ Ll²e L−uL naL f§−hÑ a¥L£Ñ−cl à¡l¡ ¢hfkÑØa qJu¡l Baw−Ll
Ty¤¢Ll j−dÉ CE−l¡f£ pju L¡¢V−u−Rz Bl haÑj¡−e k¡ HL¢V q¡pÉØfc hÉ¡f¡lz
H A¢Øa−aÄl pwNË¡−j A¢dLal p¤piÉ L−Ln£u (CE−l¡f£u) fËS¡¢a öeÉ NiÑ a¥L£Ñ−cl
fl¡¢Sa L−l−Rz Ac¤l i¢hoÉ−a
i¢hoÉ−a pjNË fª¢bh£−a La ¢ejÀal (B¢cj) fËS¡¢a ®k Eæa J p¤piÉ
fËS¡¢al q¡−a ¢e¢ÕQq² q−u k¡−h a¡l Cuš¡ e¡Cz''
X¡lEC−el H pjØa ApwN¢af§eÑ J ApwmNÀ Lb¡h¡aÑ¡ Jpj¡e£u
pj¡−Sl ¢hl²−Ü hª¢Vn p¡jË¡SÉh¡−cl L¥e£¢a h¡Øah¡u−e ¢m¢Ma fËQ¡le¡ c¢mm ¢qp¡−h hÉhq¡l Ll¡
quz fËL«af−r H ®fË¡f¡N¡ä¡ q¡¢au¡l AaÉ¿¹ L¡kÑLl ¢qp¡−h fËj¡¢ea quz X¡lEC−el i¢hà¡e£
a¥L£Ñ S¡¢a A¢Q−lC ¢e¢ÕQq² q−u k¡−h "" Hhw ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl A−j¡O BCe Ae¤k¡u£ a¡ OV−h '' H

21 / 88
dl−el ja¡ja a¥L£Ñ−cl ¢hl²−Ü nœ²a¡ pª¢øl fËQ¡le¡l ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL ¢i¢š fÊØal Øq¡fe
L−lz X¡lE−el jah¡c h¡Øah¡u−e hª−V−el CµR¡l h¡Øah fË¢agme O−V fËbj ¢hnÄk−¤ Ül j¡dÉ−jz H
jq¡k¤Ü 1914 p¡−m öl² qu HL¢c−L S¡jÑ¡e£ J A−ø-
A−ø-q¡−‰l£u pjË¡SÉ J Aflf−r hª−Ve J
a¡l ¢jœ 顾p J l¡¢nu¡l f¡lØf¢lL ü¡−bÑl ¢h−l¡d£a¡l j¡dÉ−j H k¤−Ül n¤l² quz Jpj¡e£ p¡jË¡SÉ
dÄwp J i¡N¡i¡¢Nl ¢hou¢V
¢hou¢V H k¤−Ül HL¢V A¢m¢Ma AbQ p¤¢Q¢¿¹a E−ŸnÉ ¢qp¡−h ¢edÑ¡¢la quz
hª−Ve Jpj¡e£u p¡jË¡−SÉl ¢hl²−Ü c¤C ¢cL ®b−L Bœ²je f¢lLÒfe¡ L−lz H k¤−Ül fËbj é¾V
¢Rm LÉ¡e¡m, fÉ¡−mø¡Ce J Cl¡L ®b−Lz E−ŸnÉ ¢Rm H pLm A’®m Ah¢Øqa Jpj¡e£u p¡jË¡−SÉl
A¿¹ÑNa jdÉfË¡−QÉl i¥¢j NË¡p Ll¡z ¢àa£u é¾V ¢Rm NÉ¡¢m−f¡¢m, fËbj jq¡k¤−Ül ph−Q−u
lš²ru£ k¤Ü HM¡−eC pwO¢Va quz h£−l¡¢Qa k¤−Ü a¥L£Ñ ®pe¡h¡¢qe£l 250,000 ®m¡L ¢eqa quz
hª¢Vnl¡ H k¤−Ü a¥L£Ñ−cl ¢hl¦−Ü hª¢Vn L−m¡e£l B¢dh¡p£ i¡la£u, A−øÊ¢mu¡ J ¢eE¢SmÉ¡ä Hl
®~peÉ hÉhq¡l L−lz L¡lZ a¤L£Ñl¡ q−m¡ ""Ae¤æa fËS¡¢a '' H dl−el fËS¡¢al p¡−b p¤piÉ
hª¢Vn−cl k¤−Ü Aha£Ñe qJu¡ a¡−cl ¢h−hQe¡u ""pÇj¡eSeL '' euz
X¡lEC−el a¥L£Ñ−cl ¢hl²−Ü ®~hl£a¡ fËbj jq¡k¤−Ül flJ AhÉ¡qa ¢Rmz Hje ¢L haÑj¡−eJ
CE−l¡f£u ¢eE-
¢eE-e¡S£l¡ kMe q~E−l¡−f a¥L£−cl fËa¡le¡j§mLi¡−h Bœ²je L−l, aMe
Bœ²jeL¡l£Ne a¥L£Ñ S¡¢al ¢hl²−Ü X¡lEC−el "" ApwmNÀ J g¡ma¥ '' A¢ija a¡−cl−L
Evp¡¢qa h¡ E‹£¢ha L−lz X¡lEC−el Hph ja¡ja h¡ A¢ija haÑj¡−e (HL ¢hwn) ¢hl²Üh¡c£
hZÑh¡c£Ne La«ÑL fËQ¡¢la a¥L£Ñ−cl nœ²−cl C¾V¡l−e−Vl fªù¡u ®cM−a f¡Ju¡ k¡uz

22 / 88
 a«a£u AdÉ¡u

B−j¢lL¡l hZÑh¡c J p¡j¡¢SL X¡lEqeh¡c

p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡c®L öd¤j¡œ hª−VeC eu hlw pLm hZÑh¡c£ J p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£−cl pjbÑe

®k¡N¡uz H ja¡c−nÑl pjbÑeL¡l£−cl ®ea¡−cl n£−oÑ ¢R−me B−j¢lL¡l ®fË¢p−X¾V Theodore
Roosevelt ¢a¢e H ja¡c−nÑl fÊd¡e fËhš²¡ J h¡Øah¡ueL¡l£z ®fË¢p−X¾V Roosevelt H LjÑp§Q£l
AbÑ¡v S¡¢apšÆ¡l ¢h−m¡f (Ethnic
( Cleansing)) B−j¢lL¡l Øq¡e£u A¢dh¡p£−cl (Red Indian)
pwl¢ra Hm¡L¡u h¡dÉa¡j§mL Bh¡pe fË¢œ²u¡l e¡−j ¢ede The Winning of the West f§Øa−L
NZqaÉ¡ J S¡¢aNa pwNË¡−jl j¡dÉ−j ¢ede HL¢V Af¢lq¡kÑ L¡kÑœ²j J ja¡cnÑ ¢qp¡−h fË¢a¢ùa
qu X¡lECeh¡cz L¡lZ H ja¡c−nÑ Øq¡e£u A¢dh¡p£−cl ""Ae¤æa '' fËS¡¢al Se−N¡¢ù ¢qp¡−h
pw‘¡¢ua Ll¡ q−u−Rz
Roosevelt f§−hÑC Ae¤d¡he L−l¢R−me ®k, −e¢Vi B−j¢lL¡e−cl p¡−b pÇj¡¢ea ®L¡e Q¥¢š²
h¡Øah¡ue Ll¡l fË−u¡Se£ua¡ e¡C k¡ "" Ae¤æa fËS¡¢a '' ašÆ Ae¤k¡u£ pjbÑe−k¡NÉz 1871
p¡−m B−j¢lL¡l Lw−NËp ®e¢Vi B−j¢lL¡e−cl p¡−b pÇf¡¢ca pLm Q¥¢š² ANË¡qÉ L−l a¡−cl−L
jl² Hm¡L¡u hph¡p Ll−a h¡dÉ L−l, k¡−a jl²i¥¢j−a a¡l¡ jªa¥Él SeÉ A−fr¡ Ll−hz k¢c Q¥¢š²l
Afl fr−L ""j¡e¤o ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡C e¡ Ll¡ qu '' a¡q−m a¡−cl pÇf¡¢ca Q¥¢š² h¡Øah¡ue Ll¡
h¡ j¡eÉ Ll¡l ®L¡e fË−u¡Se£ua¡ b¡−L ¢L ?
Roosevelt fÊØa¡¢ha f§−hÑ¡¢õ¢Ma hZÑh¡c£ k¤−Ül pgm h¡Øah¡u−el j¡dÉ−j Cw−lS£
i¡o¡i¡o£−cl (Anglo
( Saxons) fª¢bh£l phÑœ fË¢a¢ùa Ll¡ pñh j−jÑ ¢h−hQe¡ Ll−aez Josiah
Strong B−j¢lL¡e ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ Protestant ¢hnf J Anglo Saxon hZÑh¡c a−šÆl HLSe ¢h−no
fËhš²¡ ¢R−mez ¢a¢eJ hZÑh¡c ašÆ pjbÑ−e HLC k¤¢š² fË−u¡N Ll−aez ¢a¢e ¢m−M−Re, "" aMe ¢hnÄ
C¢aq¡−pl HL ea¥e AdÉ¡−u fË−hn Ll−hz ®pC Q¨s¡¿¹ fË¢a−k¡N£a¡ ®k hÉ¡f¡−l Anglo Saxons--®cl
fË¢n¢ra
n¢ra Ll¡ q−u−Rz ¢hou¢V B¢j k¢c kb¡kbi¡−h h¤T−a i¤m e¡ L¢lz a¡q−m HC n¢š²n¡m£
fËS¡¢a ®j¢„−L¡, jdÉ J c¢rZ B−j¢lL¡, pj¤−âl à£f pj§−q J B¢éL¡ A¢aœ²j L−l a¡−cl
®nËùaÄ hS¡u l¡M−h Hhw H hÉ¡f¡−l L¡−l¡ ®L¡e lLj p−¾cq Ll¡l AhL¡n e¡C ®k HC
fË¢a−k¡N£a¡l gm q−h ""®k¡NÉaj−cl
""®k¡NÉaj−cl ¢V−L b¡L¡l pwNË¡jz'' L¡−m¡ j¡e¤−ol nœ²−cl ®ea«Øq¡e£u−cl
ph¡C p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡−cl −O¡lal pjbÑL ¢R−mez a¡−cl hZÑh¡c£ ašÆ j¡ehS¡¢a−L ¢h¢iæ
Øa−l ¢heÉ¡p J pw‘¡¢ua L−l Hhw −nÄa¡wN−cl ph−Q−u Eæa fËS¡¢a ¢qp¡−h ®O¡oe¡ L−lz
fr¡¿¹−l L¡−m¡ fËS¡¢a−L ph−Q−u Ae¤æa B¢ch¡p£ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ L−l a¡C pwNa L¡l−eC a¡l¡
X¡lECeh¡−cl hZÑh¡c£ BcÑn−L BL−s d−lez

23 / 88
 ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ®O¡l hZÑh¡c£ a¡¢šÆL, Henry Fairfield Osborn a¡l The Evoluation of
Human Races n£oÑL fËh−å E−õM L−le, "" HLSe huØL ¢e−NË¡ j¡e¤−ol Nsfsa¡ h¤¢Ü hª¢š
p¡d¡le Se−N¡¢ùl (Homo
( Sapiens)) HN¡l hvpl huú j¡eh ¢nöl pj¡e''
H k¤¢š²−a L¡−m¡l¡ jeoÉC euz AeÉ HLSe ¢hMÉ¡a hZÑh¡−cl pjbÑeL¡l£ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£
Carleton Coon, 1962 p¡−m a¡l fËL¡¢na f¤ØaL The Origins of Race H ja hÉš² L−le ®k,
p¡c¡ J L¡−m¡ c¤¢V Bm¡c¡ fËS¡¢az Homo Erectus k¤−N H ¢hi¡Se pÇfæ q−u−Rz HC
¢hi¡S−el fl ®nÄaL¡u fËS¡¢a ¢hhaÑ−el j¡dÉ−j A¢dLal Eæa q®u−Rz L¡−m¡ j¡e¤o−cl HC heÑ
®~ho−jÉl ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l d¡lL-
d¡lL-h¡qLl¡ HC ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL hÉ¡MÉ¡ c£OÑ ¢ce k¡ha a¡−cl ja¡c−nÑ
hÉhq¡l L−l Bp−Rez
B−j¢lL¡e pj¡−S hZÑh¡−cl −O¡l pjbÑ
pjbÑeL¡l£ HL¢V ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL jah¡−cl
¢hcÉj¡ea¡l L¡l−e a¡ â²a N¢a−a R¢s−u f−sz hZÑh¡−cl ¢h−l¡d£ ¢qp¡−h MÉ¡a W E Dubois
E−õM L−le ®k "" ¢hwn na−Ll ph−Q−u hs pjpÉ¡ q−m¡ hZÑh¡cz hZÑh¡−cl pjpÉ¡ Hje HL¢V
ph−Q−u
l¡−øÊ hÉ¡fLi¡−h BaÈfËL¡n L−l−R −k ®cn¢V Bh¡l fª¢bh£l p h−Q−u hs Nea¡¢¿»L l¡øÊ q−a
BNËq£z ®L¡e ®L¡e ®r−œ a¡ h¡Øah¡¢ua q−u−RJz H¢V HL¢V Bf¡a ¢h−l¡d£ paÉ k¡l ®L¡e
…l²aÄC fËc¡e Ll¡ qu e¡z E−õMÉ c¡pfËb¡l Ahp¡e L¡−m¡ J p¡c¡ Se−N¡¢ùl j−dÉ ï¡aªaÄ−h¡d
Beu−el SeÉ k−bø i¨¢jL¡ l¡M−a hÉbÑ q−u−Rz ¢a¢e j−e L−le BCe£ ®~hojÉ k¡ AÒf pj−ul
j−dÉC pª¢ø q−u−R Hhw haÑj¡−e HV¡C h¡Øa−h Bq~e pwNa ¢qp¡−h f¢lN¢ea q−u−R Hhw H
f¢l¢Øq¢a ®b−L f¢lœ¡e m¡−il Ef¡u J f¿Û¡ Ae¤på¡e Ll¡ q−µRz''

H pj−uC fËbj hZÑ−~hojÉj§mL BCe fËhaÑe Ll¡ qu k¡ L¥MÉ¡a Jim Crow Laws ¢qp¡−h
f¢l¢Qaz (−nÄa¡wN−cl ¢fËu L¡−m¡
L¡−m¡ j¡e¤o−cl L¡−R ¢e¢¾ca e¡j q−m¡ Jim Crow)) L¡−m¡ ®m¡L−cl
LMeC ""j¡e¤o'' ¢qp¡−h NeÉ Ll¡ q−a¡ e¡z phÑ−r−œ a¡−cl ApÇj¡e J Ah‘¡l ®Q¡−M ®cM¡
q−a¡z A¢dL¿º HV¡ öd¤j¡œ L−uLSe hZÑh¡c£ hÉ¢š²l j−e¡i¡h ¢Rme¡ hlw HV¡ B−j¢lL¡e plL¡l
La«ÑL fËe£a BC−el j¡dÉ−j ¢edÑ¡le Ll¡ q−u¢Rmz 1875 p¡−m ®V−ep£ (Tennesse)
( ) l¡−SÉ
phÑfËbj p¡c¡ J L¡−m¡−cl SeÉ fªbL ®VÊe J VÊ¡j hÉhq¡−ll SeÉ BCe Ae¤−j¡¢ca quz
a¡vr¢eLi¡−h c¢r−el pLm l¡−øÊ ®VÊ−el Ae¤l©f BCe Q¡m¤ quz g−m ""n¤d¤j¡œ p¡c¡−cl SeÉ,'',
""L¡−m¡ '' CaÉ¡¢c p¡Ce ®h¡XÑ phÑœ ®T¡m¡−e¡ quz fËLa
« f−r H ph ¢LRC¤ C−a¡j−dÉ ¢hcÉj¡e
f¢l¢Øq¢a−a BCe¡e¤N jkÑ¡c¡l j¡dÉ−jC ¢e¢ÕQa Ll¡ quz p¡c¡ J L¡−m¡−cl j−dÉ ¢hh¡q ¢e¢oÜ Ll¡
quz HC fªbL£Lle BC−el BJa¡u p¡c¡ J L¡−m¡−cl SeÉ Bm¡c¡ q¡pf¡a¡m, ®SmM¡e¡,
®N¡lØq¡e ¢ejÑ¡e J hÉhq¡l h¡dÉa¡j§mL ¢qp¡−h fËhaÑe Ll¡ quz h¡Øah ®r−œ ®q¡−Vm, e¡VÉn¡m¡,
NÊ¿Û¡N¡l, ¢mgV J N£SÑ¡uJ a¡ Q¡m¤ Ll¡ quz HC ¢h¢µRæLle ph−Q−u Ni£li¡−h ØL¥m pj§−q
f¢lm¢ra qu k¡ HC L¡−m¡−cl ph−Q−u ®hn£ r¢aNËØa L−l Hhw a¡−cl S¡¢aNa p¡wØL«¢aL
Eæue fË¢œ²u¡u ph−Q−u hs h¡d¡ ¢qp¡−h BaÁfËL¡n L−lz

24 / 88
 p¡c¡-
p¡c¡-L¡−m¡l HC S¡¢aNa
S¡¢aNa ®~hojÉ J fªbL£Ll−el p¡−b p¡−b p¢qwpa¡ hÉ¡fLi¡−h hª¢Ü
f¡uz L¡−m¡ ®m¡L−cl ¢he¡ ¢hQ¡−l qaÉ¡l pwMÉ¡ â²a hª¢Ü f¡uz 1890 −b−L 1901 p¡−ml j−dÉ
1300 L¡−m¡ j¡e¤o−L ¢he¡ ¢hQ¡−l (Lynching)
( ) eªnwpi¡−h qaÉ¡ Ll¡ quz H pj−u ¢h¢iæ L¡l−e
¢h¢iæ l¡−øÊ L¡−m¡ ®m¡L−cl ¢h−â¡q
¢h−â¡q ®cM¡ ®cuz B−m¡QÉ pj−u hZÑh¡c pÇf−LÑ ¢h¢iæ ja J
¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ BaÈfËL¡n L−lz H ¢ho−u B−j¢lL¡l S£h¢hcÉ¡ ¢houL hZÑh¡c£ cª¢øi‰£ pð¢ma R.B
Bean Hl j¡b¡l M¤¢ml f¢lj¡f ¢houL N−hoe¡l gm¡g−ml j¡dÉ−j fËL¡¢na quz a¡R¡s¡
B−j¢lL¡e SeNe−L ¢eu¿»eq£e A¢ii¡oe −b−L pwlre Ll¡l
Ll¡l AS¤q¡−a HL¢V ¢e¢cÑø dl−el
hZÑh¡−cl E›¡e O−Vz Passing of the Great Race (1916) e¡jL f¤Øa−Ll ®mML Madison Grants
¢m−M−Re "" c¤C fËS¡¢al (p¡c¡ J L¡−m¡) B¿¹ ¢hh¡−ql p¿¹¡e Ae¤æa fËS¡¢al ®Q−uJ ¢eL«ø
fËS¡¢al pª¢ø Ll−hz'' ""H L¡l−e ¢a¢e HC c¤C ¢iæ fËS¡¢al ¢hh¡q
¢hh¡q ¢e¢oÜ Ll−el c¡h£ S¡e¡ez ''
¢h−nÄl AeÉ¡eÉ ®c−nl eÉ¡u B−j¢lL¡−aJ hZÑh¡c ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rmz ¢L¿º Bjl¡ mrÉ L−l¢R Ee¢hwn
na¡ë£l ¢àa£u¡−dÑ X¡lECeh¡−cl hZÑh¡c£ cª¢øi¢‰ H e£¢a−L −O¡l pjbÑe L−lz Ec¡qle ül©f
hm¡ k¡u hZÑh¡c£l¡ a¡−cl ja¡cnÑ EfØq¡f−el ®r−œ ph pju X¡lECeh¡c−L
X¡lECeh¡c−L a¡−cl ®nÔ¡N¡e
¢qp¡−h hÉhq¡l Ll−a¡z HC jah¡c fËQ¡−ll f§−hÑ H dl−el ¢Q¿¹¡ J L¡kÑœ²j−L ¢eù¥l ¢qp¡−h
¢h−h¢Qa q−a¡, ¢L¿º X¡lECeh¡−cl a¡¢šÆL pjbÑ−el ®fË¢r−a H phq~ ""fË¡L«¢aL BCe'' ¢qp¡−h
NeÉ Ll¡ quz

X¡lEC−el hZÑh¡c£ J Aj¡e¢hL e£¢a

A−ø¢mu¡u B¢ch¡p£−cl
B¢ch¡p£−cl ¢ede x

A−øÊ¢mu¡l B¢ch¡p£−cl Aborigines hm¡ quz H pLm B¢ch¡p£ H Efjq¡−c−n q¡S¡l

q¡S¡l hRl d−l hph¡p L−l Bp¢Rmz ¢L¿º CE−l¡f£u Ef¢e−hnh¡c£−cl H jq¡−c−n Ae¤fË−h−nl
®fË¢r−a B¢ch¡p£l¡ C¢aq¡−pl ph−Q−u hs ¢ede k−‘l ¢nL¡l quz ®k ja¡c−nÑl ¢i¢š−a H ¢ede
L¡kÑ
L¡kÑœ²j f¢lQ¡me¡ Ll¡ qu a¡l e¡j q−m¡ X¡lECeh¡cz X¡lECeh¡−cl Bc¢nÑL cª¢øi¢‰ HC
Se−N¡¢ùl hhÑ−l¡¢Qa J Aj¡e¢hL ¢ekÑ¡a−el L¡le OY~¡uz 1870 p¡−m ¢hhÑaeh¡c£ eªašÆ¢hc Max
Muller, Anthropological Review of London f¢œL¡l HL ¢eh−å j¡eh pÇfc¡u−L 7¢V
fËS¡¢a−a ®nËe£ ¢heÉ¡p
¢heÉ¡p L−lez HC ®nËe£ ¢heÉ¡−p phÑ−nËù fËS¡¢a ¢qp¡−h CE−l¡f£u −nÄa¡wN−L
¢edÑ¡le Ll¡ qu Hhw phÑ¢ejÀ fËS¡¢a ¢qp¡−h A−øÊ¢mu¡e B¢ch¡p£®cl−L ¢Q¢q²a Ll¡ quz
1876 p¡−m ¢hMÉ¡a pjp¡j¢uL X¡lECeh¡c£ H. K Rusden, Aborigins pÇf−LÑ ¢e−jÀ¡š²
ja¡ja EfØq¡fe L−le x ""®k¡NÉa
""®k¡NÉaj−cl
®k¡NÉaj−cl ¢V−L b¡L¡l AbÑ q−µR ®S¡l k¡l j¤õ¤L a¡l ''
a¡C Bjl¡ fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Q−el HC AmwOe£u BCe h¡Øah¡u−el j¡dÉ−j ¢e¢hÑL¡l ¢Q−š e£Q¥
e£Q¥
fËS¡¢al A−øÊ¢mu¡l B¢ch¡p£ J j¡®~l (¢eE¢SmÉ¡ä Hl B¢ch¡p£) fËS¡¢a−L dl¡ −b−L ¢e¢ÕQq² Ll¡l

25 / 88
hÉhØq¡ NËq−el SeÉ Bqh¡e S¡e¡Cz Bjl¡ a¡−cl
a¡−cl (B¢ch¡p£−cl) ®~f¢œL p§−œ fË¡ç c¤−iÑ¡N
n¡¿¹i¡−h fËaÉr Ll−h¡z''
1890 p¡−m l−um −p¡p¡C¢V Ah a¡pj¡¢eu¡l (Royal
( Society of Tasmania ) i¡Cp
®fË¢p−X¾V James Barnard ¢m−M−Re, ""(B¢ch¡p£−cl) ¢ede fË¢œ²u¡ ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ®k¡NÉaj−cl
¢V−L b¡L¡l ¢hou¢VJ HL AmwOe£u fË
fË¡L«¢aL ¢hd¡ez a¡C H A−øÊ¢mu¡e B¢ch¡p£−cl qaÉ¡ J
a¡−cl Nªq R¡s¡ Ll¡l hÉ¡f¡−l ®L¡e lLj ¢e¾ce£u Ah−qm¡ Ll¡ q−µR h−m j−e Ll¡l ®L¡e
k¤¢š²pwNa L¡le e¡Cz'' X¡lEeh¡−cl H dl−el hZÑh¡c£ ¢eù¥l e£¢al L¡l−e B¢ch¡p£−cl
eªnwpi¡−h qaÉ¡l HL jq¡k‘ öl² q−u k¡uz B¢ch¡p£−cl
B¢ch¡p£−cl L¢aÑa jØaL ®øn−el clS¡u clS¡u
V¡w¢N−u l¡M¡ q−a¡z ¢ho ¢j¢nËa l²¢V M¡C−u B¢ch¡p£ f¢lh¡−ll pcpÉ−cl qaÉ¡ Ll¡ quz A−øÊ¢mu¡l
¢h¢iæ Hm¡L¡l B¢ch¡p£−cl hp¢a 50 hvp−ll j−dÉ AaÉ¿¹ ¢eù¥la¡l p¡−b ¢e¢ÕQq² Ll¡ quz
®no
B¢ch¡p£−cl qaÉ¡l j¡dÉ−jC H e£¢al h¡Øah¡ue L¡kÑœ²j ®n o q−u k¡u e¡C hlw H
fËS¡¢al A−eL pcpÉ−L N−hoe¡l fö ¢qp¡−h hÉhq¡l Ll¡ quz Ju¡¢nwVe ¢X¢pØq Smithsonian
Institute ¢h¢iæ fËS¡¢al 15000 hÉ¢š²−L pwlre L−lz 10000 A−øÊ¢mu B¢ch¡p£−L
S¡q¡S−k¡−N hª¢Vn ¢jE¢Su¡−j ®fËlZ Ll¡ qu k¡−a L−l fË¡e£ ®b−L j¡e−h E−š¡le fË¢œ²u¡l
Missing Link M¤y−S f¡Ju¡ k¡uz
k¡c¤Ol La«Ñfr öd¤j¡œ q¡s ¢e−u p¿ºø b¡−Le¢e hlw Hph B¢ch¡p£−cl jNS pwlre L−l
a¡ EµQj§−m ¢hœ²u L−lez a¡ R¡s¡ H−cl−L qaÉ¡ L−l N−hoe¡N¡−l ¢N¢e¢fN ¢qp¡−h hÉhq¡l Ll¡l
hý fËj¡e l−u−Rz H dl−el ¢eù¥l LjÑL¡−äl ¢LR¤ abÉ fËj¡e ¢e−jÀ E−õM Ll¡ q−m¡ x
Korah Wills, ¢k¢e 1866 p¡−m Bowen, Queensland Hl ®jul ¢R−mez a¡l jªa¥É nkÉ¡u
pȪ¢a heÑe¡L¡−m ¢a¢e ¢Li¡−h1865 p¡−m ®~h‘¡¢eL ej¤e¡ pwNË−ql SeÉ HLSe Øq¡e£u ®N¡œf¢a−L
qaÉ¡ L−l a¡l jªa ®cq M¾X-
M¾X-¢hMä L−le a¡l ¢hØa¡¢la heÑe¡ fËc¡e L−lez
¢pXe£l A−øÊ¢mu¡e
mu¡e k¡c¤O®ll Australian Museum Hl ¢LE−lVl Edward Ramsay,
¢k¢e 1874 p¡m ®b−L 20 hvpl k¡ha H f−c A¢d¢ùa ¢R−mez ¢a¢e H dl−el L¡−S ¢pÜqØa
h¡ f¡lcn£Ñ ¢R−mez ¢a¢e ¢jE¢Su¡−jl f¤¢ØaL¡ h¡ h¤L−mV fËL¡n L−lez HC f¤¢ØaL¡u
B¢ch¡p£−cl abÉ pð¢ma A−øÊ¢mu¡e fË¡e£ AdÉ¡−u
AdÉ¡−u (Chapter) H Australian Amimal
¢n−l¡e¡−j HL¢V AdÉ¡u A¿¹i¥Ñš² ¢Rmz HC f¤¢Øa¡L¡u Lhl ®b−L jªa−cq pwNËq J ¢Li¡−h
jªa−c−ql nl£l −b−L h¤−m−Vl ¢Qq² Afp¡le L−l ej¤e¡ pwNËq Ll¡l fÜ¢a heÑe¡ Ll¡ quz
Amale Dietrich (L¡−m¡ jªa¥É c§a ¢qp¡−h L¤MÉ¡a) S¡jÑ¡e ¢hhaÑeh¡c£,
h¡c£, A−øÊ¢mu¡ BNje
L−lez ¢a¢e Øq¡e£u föf¡meL¡l£ ¢h¢iæ fË¢aù¡e−L ¢LR¤ B¢ch¡p£−L …¢m L−l qaÉ¡ L−l ej§e¡
¢qp¡−h ¢h−no L−l H−cl jªa−cq ø¡g (Stuff)
( ) L−l k¡c¤O−l fËcnÑ−el hÉhØq¡ Ll¡l fËØa¡h ®cez
HL S¡uN¡ ®b−L h¢qØL«a q−mJ ¢a¢e H ej§e¡pq S¡jÑ¡e£−a ®gla k¡ez

26 / 88
 New South Walles Hl k¡SL HL
HL iu¡hq qaÉ¡ k−‘¡l ü¡r£ ¢R−mez L−uL XSe f¤l²o,
e¡l£ J ¢nö B¢ch¡p£−cl
B¢ch¡p£−cl A−øÊ¢mu f¤¢mn hhÑ−l¡¢Qai¡−h qaÉ¡ L−lz 45 ¢V L¡V¡ jØaL ¢pÜ L−l
Hhw Hl j−dÉ i¡−m¡ 10¢V j¡b¡l M¤¢m ¢h−c−n S¡q¡S¡a/lç¡e£ Ll¡l SeÉ h¡„h¾c£ Ll¡ quz
¢hwn na¡ë£−a B¢ch¡p£−cl
B¢ch¡p£−cl ¢ede fË¢œ²u¡ AhÉ¡qa
AhÉ¡qa ¢Rmz H ®r−œ ¢h¢iæ fÜ¢al j−dÉ
B¢ch¡p£ ¢nö−cl hm fË−u¡−Nl j¡dÉ−j a¡−cl f¢lh¡l −b−L ¢h¢µRæ l¡M¡ −hn L¡kÑLl ¢qp¡−h
¢h−h¢Qa ¢Rmz
1997 p¡−ml 28 H¢fËm Philadelpha Daily News f¢œL¡u Alan Thornhil
B¢ch¡p£−cl f¤ex Nee¡ fÜ¢a pÇf−LÑ HL¢V pwh¡c
pwh¡c fË¢a−hce fËL¡n L−le k¡ ¢Rm ¢ejÀl©f x

"" A−øÊm£u
£u B¢ch¡p£−cl f¤ex Nee¡l j¡dÉ−j f¡Ls¡J Ll¡ ''

H−p¡¢p−u−VX −fËp x A−øÊ¢mu¡l Ešl f¢ÕQ−jl pji§¢j Hm¡L¡u hph¡pla B¢ch¡p£l¡ a¡−cl
¢nö−cl fÊ¡u Lum¡l L¡¢m ¢c−u −mfe Lla, k¡−a l¡øÊ£u pj¡S LmÉ¡e Lj£Ñ a¡−cl−L e¡ ¢e−u
®k−a f¡−lz LmÉ¡e Lj£Ñl¡ H ph ¢nö−L ®f−mC a¡−cl
a¡−cl d−l ¢e−u ®kaz A−eL hRl fl (H dl−el
®Q¡l¡C ¢nö) h−me "" Bj¡−cl m¤L¡−e¡l E−Ÿ−nÉ Nm¡u Lum¡l ®R¡f ®mfe Ll¡ q−a¡ ''
fö M¡j¡−ll HLSe Lj£Ñ k¡−L ¢nöL¡−m Q¥¢l Ll¡ q−u¢Rm h−me, "" Bj¡−cl hup kMe 5/6
hRl aMe Bj¡−cl−L
Bj¡−cl−L Moola Bulla Q¥¢l L−l ¢e−u k¡Ju¡ quz Australian Human Rights
and Equal Opportunity Commission Hl "" hwnd¡l¡ Q¥¢ll Ae¤på¡e fË¢a−hc−e H dl−el
q²cu ¢hc¡lL q¡S¡l q¡S¡l L¡¢qe£ l−u−Rz 1910 p¡m ®b−L 1970 p¡m fkÑ¿¹ 1mr B¢ch¡p£
¢nö p¿¹¡e a¡−cl ¢fa¡j¡a¡ ®b−L ¢h¢µRæ Ll¡ quz H dl−el p¡c¡ Q¡js¡l ¢nö−cl f¡Ls¡J L−l
®nÄa¡wN f¢lh¡−ll fË¢af¡m−el SeÉ ®cJu¡ quz L¡−m¡ Q¡js¡l ¢nö−cl H¢ajM¡e¡u ®fËlZ Ll¡
q−a¡z''
Hje¢L haÑj¡−eJ H ®hce¡ Ha Ni£l ®k H pjØa OVe¡ L¢jn−el Q¤s¡¿¹ fË¢a−hc−e
®he¡−j fËL¡n Ll¡ quz "" a¡−cl−L h¡s£−a ¢e−u B−p¡'' HV¡C ph¡l c¡h£z L¢jne ja fËL¡n
L−l ®k, S¡¢apw−Ol pw‘¡ Ae¤k¡u£ ac¡e£¿¹e plL¡l£ La«Ñf−rl LjÑL¡ä NZqaÉ¡ ¢qp¡−h
¢h−h¢Qaz ac¿¹ L¢jn−el p¤f¡¢ln Ae¤k¡u£ Q¥¢h/f¡Q¡lL«a ¢nö−cl SeÉ r¢af¤le fËc¡−el ¢hou¢V
fË¢af¡me Ll−a plL¡l Aü£Lª¢a S¡¢e−u−Rz
Bjl¡ fËaÉr
aÉr L−l¢R ®k, H dl−el J S¡¢aNa ¢ede phC X¡lECeh¡−cl a−šÆl ¢i¢š−a
pwO¢Va q−u−Rz Bl a¡ q−m¡ ""fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Qe'' ab¡ ""®k¡NÉaj−cl ¢V−L b¡L¡'' A−øÊm£u
B¢ch¡p£−cl fË¢a ®k eªnwp BQlZ Ll¡ q−u−R a¡ X¡lEq~eh¡−cl ¢hnÄhÉ¡f£ dÄwpk−‘l HL¢V Mä
¢Qœ j¡œz

27 / 88
 JV¡ ®h‰¡

The Origin of Species f¤Øa−L h¢eÑa X¡lE−el c¡h£ j¡e¤oÉ fËS¡¢a J h¡el HLC ®N¡œ
®b−L Eá¤az flha£Ñ−a H c¡h£l pjbÑ−e S£h¡nÈ Ae¤på¡−el ¢q¢sL f−s k¡uz ¢L¿º ¢LR¤ pwMÉL
¢hhaÑe¡h¡c£ ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−ae "" AdÑ h¡el-
h¡el-AdÑj¡eh '' fËS¡¢al öd¤ S£h¡nÈC eu hlw H dl−el
""S£h '' fª¢bh£l ®L¡e A’−m S£¢ha AhØq¡u ¢hcÉj¡ez ¢hwn na¡ë£l fËbj ¢c−L HC Missing
Link Ae¤å¡−el L¡l−e hý hhÑ−l¡¢Qa LjÑL¡ä O−Vz H ph OVe¡l j−dÉ HL¢V q−m¡ ¢fNj£ Ota
Benga z 1904 p¡−m ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ N−hoL Samuel Verner, L−‰¡ ®b−L Ota Benga ®L h¾c£
L−lez j¡a«i¡o¡u HC e¡−jl
e¡−jl AbÑ q−m¡ ""hå¥z'' Ota Benga ¢R−me ¢hh¡¢qa J a¡l c¤CSe p¿¹¡e
¢Rmz AbQ a¡−L föl ja ¢nLm fs¡−e¡ qu J My¡Q¡l j−dÉ h¾c£ L−l B−j¢lL¡u f¡W¡−e¡ quz
B−j¢lL¡u St Louies World Fair H ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ ¢h‘¡e£l¡ a¡−L ¢h¢iæ fËS¡¢al
h¡el−cl p¡−b M¡yQ¡u h¾c£ L−l je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al ""ph−Q−u ¢eLVaj fË¡e£ '' ¢qp¡−h fËcnÑe L−lez
c¤C hRl fl a¡l¡ Ota Benga ®L ¢eECu−LlÑ Bronx ¢Q¢su¡M¡e¡u −fËle Ll¡ qu ®kM¡−e a¡−L
My¡Q¡u h¾c£ L−l Dinah e¡−jl HL¢V N¢lm¡, Dohung e¡−jl HL¢V Jl¡w JV¡e J ¢LR¤
¢nÇf¡S£l p¡−b j¡e¤−ol ph−Q−u fË¡Q£eaj f§hÑ p¤l£ ¢qp¡−h fËcnÑe Ll¡ quz
¢Q¢su¡M¡e¡l ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ f¢lQ¡mL Dr. Willam T Horniday, je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al Missing
Link pwNËq Ll¡l ¢hlm L«¢aaÄ heÑe¡ L−l cnÑe¡b£Ñl E−Ÿ−nÉ c£OÑ hšªa¡ ®cez cnÑe¡b£Ñne My¡Q¡u
h¾c£ Ota Benga Hl p¡−b föl eÉ¡u BQle L−lez New York Times –H
H f¢œL¡u cnÑe¡b£Ñ−cl
j−e¡i¡h ¢e−jÀ¡š² i¡o¡u fËL¡n Ll¡ qu x
"" ¢Q¢su¡M¡e¡u 40,000 cnÑe¡b£Ñ Ef¢Øqa quz fË¡u fË−aÉL¢V f¤l²o j¢qm¡ J ¢nö fËd¡e
BLoÑe ¢qp¡−h B¢éL¡l HC heÉ j¡e¤o−L fËaÉr L−lz cnÑe¡b£ÑNe Ota Benga ®L pjØa ¢ce
j¡−W a¡s¡ L−l, ¢QvL¡l L−l, ¢hâ²f L−l, a£hË ¢QvL¡l J q–
q–−N¡m Ll−a b¡−Lz ®Lq ®Lq a¡l
fy¡S−l Ny¤a¡ j¡−l, ®Lq ®Lq e¡Q−a b¡−L , ph¡C a¡−L E−ŸnÉ L−l q¡pÉ f¢lq¡p Ll−a b¡−Lz''
1906 p¡−ml 17 −p−ÃY~ðl New York Journal f¢œL¡u a£hË fË¢ah¡c L−l E−õM L−l,
k¢cJ H pLm LjÑL¡−äl ¢hhaÑeh¡cC fËj¡−el E−Ÿ−nÉ Ll¡ q−µR, ah¤J HV¡ j¡eha¡l fË¢a
A¢hQ¡l J ¢eù¥la¡z I f¢œL¡l i¡o¡u "" H pLm ®m¡L (k¡c¤Ol La«Ñfr) −L¡e lLj ¢Q¿¹¡-i¡he¡
h¡ fË‘¡ ¢h−hQe¡ e¡ L−l B¢éL¡l HLSe h¡je j¡eh−L h¡e−ll My¡Q¡u f¤−l fËcÑne Ll−Rz
pñha a¡l¡ d¡le¡ Ll−R Hl j¡dÉ−j a¡l¡ Sep¡d¡le−L ¢hhaÑeh¡c pÇf−LÑ
pÇf−LÑ h¡Øah ‘¡e c¡e
Ll−Rz ""fËLªaf−r Hl h¡Øah ¢cL q−µR −k A¡¢éL¡e fËS¡¢al HLSe pcpÉ−L h¾c£ L−l H
S¡¢al fË¢a Ah‘¡/f¢lq¡p Ll¡z k¢cJ H−c−nl p¡c¡−cl a¡−cl fË¢a pq¡e¤i¨¢a ®cM¡−e¡ E¢Qaz
¢h−no L−l ®p kMe ¢ekÑ¡ae J ¢eù¥la¡l ¢nL¡l q−u−Rz HV¡ HLV¡ m‹¡, Oªe¡ J c§iÑ¡NÉSeL
NÉSeL
OVe¡z L¡le fËL«af−r ®k jq¡n¢š² Bj¡−cl pLm−L HLC BaÈ¡ J Ae¤i¨¢a ¢c−u fª¢bh£−a

28 / 88
®fËle L−l−Re, ®pC HLC j¡e¤−ol n¡l£¢lL c§hÑma¡ S¢ea L¡l−e a¡−L My¡Q¡u f¤−l Sepj−r ®qu
fË¢afæ Ll¡ q−µRz''
The New York Daily Tribune H ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl h¡Øah fËj¡e ®cM¡−e¡l E−Ÿ−nÉ Ota
Benga Hl fËcnÑe£ pÇf−LÑ ¢hØa¡¢la fË¢a−hce fËL¡n L−l−Rz ¢Q¢su¡M¡e¡l X¡lECeh¡c£
f¢lQ¡m−Ll BaÈfr pjbÑe L−l, ®k hš²hÉ EfØq¡fe L−l−Re a¡ e£¢a ¢hh¢SÑaz Na pç¡−q
New York Zoological park H HLSe B¢éL¡e ¢fNj£−L Jl¡w, JV¡e Hl p¡−b My¡Q¡u fËcnÑe
Ll¡l OVe¡¢V hÉ¡fLi¡−h
hÉ¡fLi¡−h pj¡−m¡¢Qa quz ®Lq ®Lq −O¡oe¡ L−le ®k, Hl j¡dÉ−j ¢Q¢su¡M¡e¡l
f¢lQ¡mL Hornday ¢e−NË¡−cl p¡−b h¡el fËS¡¢al Ni£l ¢jm l−u−R a¡ ®cM¡−e¡l hÉhØq¡
L−l−Rez Dr. Hornday a¡ Aü£L¡l L−l h−m−Re ""HC h¡je¢V My¡Q¡u l¡M¡ q−u−R −pV¡C a¡l
SeÉ ph−Q−u Bl¡jc¡uL S¡uN¡z a¡ R¡s¡ Bjl¡ h¤T−aJ f¡l¢Re¡ ®k a¡−L Bjl¡ Bl ®L¡b¡uC
h¡ l¡M−a f¡¢lz ®p ®L¡eœ²−jC h¾c£ euz a−h HV¡ ®LE hm−he¡ ®k a¡−L ®L¡e eSlc¡l£ hÉa£a
j¤š²i¡−h O¤−l ®hs¡−e¡l p¤−k¡N ®cJu¡ E¢Qaz''
Ota Benga ®L N¢lm¡−cl p¡−b fö−cl ja My¡Q¡u h¾c£ L−l fËcnÑe Ll¡−e¡l ¢hou¢V
¢h¢iæ
¢h¢iæ jq−m hÉ¡fLi¡−h pj¡−m¡¢Qa quz ¢h¢iæ j¡eha¡h¡c£ pwNWe H L¡kÑœ²j h¾d Ll¡l Ae¤−l¡d
S¡e¡ez a¡l¡ E−õM L−le ®k Ota Benga HLSe j¡eh p¿¹¡e a¡l p¡−b H dl−el ¢eù¥l BQle
Ll¡ ®L¡eœ²−jC pwNa euz H dl−el HL¢V B−hcefœ 12 ®p−ÃVðl 1906 p¡−ml New York
Globe H fËL¡¢na qu B−hce fœ¢V ¢Rm ¢ejÀl©f x
pÇf¡cL j−q¡cu,
B¢j c¢r−Z (B−j¢lL¡l c¢rZ l¡SÉ
l¡SÉ pj§q) hý hvpl hph¡p L−l¢Rz H L¡l−e ®k B¢j
¢e−NË¡−cl ®hn£ fR¾c L¢l a¡ eu hlw B¢j ¢e−NË¡−cl−L j¡e¤o ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ L¢lz HC jq¡eN−l
La«Ñfr ¢Li¡−h Bronx ¢Q¢sk¡M¡e¡u HL¢V ¢e−NË¡ h¡mL−L h¡e−ll
h¡e−ll My¡Q¡u h¾c£ L−l fËcnÑe Ll¡l
ja m‹¡SeL L¡S Ll¡l Ae¤j¢a fËc¡e Ll−a f¡−lz ¢fNj£ ¢houL pLm LjÑL¡−äl Ae¤på¡e
qJu¡ fË−u¡Sez
AER, New York, Sept 12.
Ota Benga Hl p¡−b j¡e¢hL BQlZ Ll¡l SeÉ HL¢V B−hc−el i¡o¡ ¢Rm ¢ejÀl©fx
j¡eh J h¡el fËcnÑe£ djÑk¡S−Ll Aee¤
Aee¤−j¡cez
j¡cez ®hi¡−lä Dr. Mac Arthur j−e L−le ®k,
H dl−el fËcnÑe£ j¡eha¡l SeÉ Afj¡eSeLz H dl−el fËcnÑe£l SeÉ ®k c¡u£ ®p B¢éL¡e−cl
p¡−b p¡−b ¢e−S−LJ Afj¡e L−l−Rz ¢a¢e B−l¡ h−me, H r¥â j¡eh p¿¹¡e−L föl ja j−e e¡
L−l a¡−L hlw a¡−L Bõ¡q fËcš rja¡ ¢hL¡−nl SeÉ ØL¥−m i¢aÑ L−l ®cu¡ E¢Qaz AeÉ
HLSe djÑk¡SL Dr. Gilbert h−me, HC fËcnÑe£¢V iu¡hq hÉ¡f¡l Hhw ¢a¢e (Dr.
( Gilbert)) J
AeÉ¡eÉ k¡SLNe Dr. Mac Arthur p¡−b p¡−b HLC OVe¡ ®cM−a Q¡e a¡ q−m¡ x HC h¤njÉ¡e−L
h¡e−ll My¡Q¡ ®b−L j¤š² L−l AeÉ ®L¡b¡u f¡W¡−e qu ''

29 / 88
 H ph ¢LR¤l ®no qu Ota Benga Hl BaÈqaÉ¡l j¡dÉ−jz ¢L¿º HM¡−eJ HLSe p¡d¡le
j¡e¤−ol j§a¥Él ®Q−u a¡ A¢dLal pjpÉ¡l pª¢ø L−lz X¡lECeh¡c£ hZÑh¡−cl hÉhq¡¢lL ¢cL La
¢eù¥l J hhÑ−l¡¢Qa q−a f¡−l H OVe¡ a¡l HL¢V h¡Øah ej¤e¡z

j¡dÉ−j
j¡e−hl ®nËùaÄ Q¢l−œl j¡dÉ−j ¢edÑ¡¢la qu, l−š²l h¡ h−ZÑl j¡ dÉ−j eu

X¡lEq~eh¡c£−cl c¡h£ Ae¤k¡u£ j¡e¤o f¤n−cl HL¢V Eæa pwØLle Hhw ¢LR¤ fËS¡¢al
Eæ¢al h¡ ¢hL¡−nl fkÑ¡u pÇfѧe e¡ qJu¡u H pjØa fËS¡¢al ®m¡L fË¡u fö fkÑ¡−ul b¡L¡l
L¡l−e H dl−el fËS¡¢a j¡eh piÉa¡l SeÉ dÄwp¡aÈL J iu¡hqz ®k pLm hÉ¢š² X¡lEC−el H
c¡h£ h¡ jah¡c
jah¡c pjbÑe L−l b¡−Lez a¡l¡ AeÉ¡eÉ fËS¡¢al j¡e¤−ol p¡−b ¢eù¥l J ¢ekÑ¡aej§mL
BQle L−l b¡−Le a¡−cl−L L¡¢We f¢l¢Øq¢a−a hph¡p Ll−a h¡dÉ L−le Hhw Hje¢L −rœ
¢h−n−o ¢ej§ÑmJ L−lez
Bryan Appleyard a¡l Brave New Worlds e¡jL f¤Øa−L −mML hZÑh¡c£−cl ®~ül¡Q¡l£
j−e¡i¡h ¢e−jÀ
¢e−jÀ¡š² i¡o¡u hÉ¡M¡ L−l−Rez "" k¢c ®Lq ®L¡eœ²−j Bfe¡−L e£Qal fËS¡¢a ¢qp¡−h NeÉ
h¡ ¢h−hQe¡ L−l a¡ ®~h‘¡¢eL Abh¡ L¥pwØL¡lj§mL k¡C ®q¡L e¡ ®Le ®p−r−œ ®L¡e p£j¡−lM¡ e¡
®l−MC Bfe¡l Efl −k ¢eù¥l BQle Ll¡ q−µR a¡ pÇf§eÑ eÉ¡u pwNai¡−hC ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ q−hz
L¡E−L "" e£Q¥
e£Q¥ '' fËS¡¢a ¢qp¡−h ¢hnÄ¡p Ll¡ q−µR j−jÑ ®L¡e hÉ¢š²−L M¡l¡f, iuwLl, Hhw
EµQal fËS¡¢al SeÉ ýj¢L ¢qp¡−h ¢Q¢q²a Ll¡l fËbj fc−rfz ®Lq ®Lq Bh¡l H d¡le¡−L
A¡−l¡ HL d¡f H¢N−u ¢e−u p¡d¡lei¡−h ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−a f¡−le ®k pLm ""e£Q¥'' fËS¡¢al pLm pcpÉ
iuwLl L¡le a¡l¡ j¡e¤−ol S£he J ü¡−ØqÉl SeÉ ýj¢L ül©fz H ®fË¢r−a a¡l¡ H−cl S¾j
¢eu¿»e, (håÉ¡Lle) ¢hh¡−q ¢e−od¡‘¡ Abh¡ ®rœ ¢h−n−o H pjØa ""e£Q¥'' fËS¡¢al Bœ²je −b−L
je¤oÉL¥m−L lr¡ Ll¡l SeÉ a¡−cl−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l p¤f¡¢ln Ll−a f¡−lez
pLm j¡e¤o HLC fË¢œ²u¡u J Ef¡c¡−e pª¢øz pLm−LC jq¡e Bõ¡qa¡m¡ pª¢ø L−l−Rez
f¢hœ ®L¡l¡−e j¡eh pª¢ø pÇf−LÑ Hi¡−h heÑe¡ Ll¡ q−u−R x "" ¢k¢e ay¡q¡l fË−aÉL¢V pª¢ø−L pªSe
L¢lu¡−Re p−hÑ¡šjl©−f Hhw LcÑj q−a j¡e¤o pª¢øl p§Qe¡ L¢lu¡−Rez Aaxfl ¢a¢e a¡q¡l hwn
Evfæ L−le a¥µR alm fc¡−bÑl ¢ekÑ¡p qC−az f−l Eq¡−L L¢lu¡−Re p¤W¡j Hhw a¡q¡−a g¥y¢Lu¡
¢cu¡−Re a¡q¡l l²q qC−a Hhw −a¡j¡¢cN−L ¢cu¡−Re LeÑ, Qr¨ J A¿¹xLle ®a¡j¡l¡ A¢a p¡j¡eÉC
L«a‘a¡ fËL¡n Llz (p¤l¡ ®pSc¡ 7-
7-9)z''
Ef−l¡š² Bu¡a pj§q ®b−L S¡e¡ k¡u ®k, je¤oÉ fËS¡¢a A¡õ¡q La«ÑL g¥−L ®cu¡ BaÈ¡
a¡l ¢eS ®c−q d¡le L−lz −L¡e lLj S¡¢aNa ®~hojÉ hÉ¢a−l−L pLm j¡e¤o ¢Q¿¹¡ L−l, Ae¤ih
L−l i¡mh¡−p, hÉ¡b¡ f¡u, E−š¢Sa h¡ B−hN a¡¢sa qu, Bh¡l ®p ®fË¢jL, q©cuh¡e, cu¡m¤
Bh¡l pLm j¡e¤o AaÉ¡Q¡l/¢ef£sej§mL BQle Ll−a f¡−lz H L¡l−e ®k pjØa j¡e¤o AeÉ
fËS¡¢al Se−N¡¢ù−L "" AdÑ J Ae¤æa fË¡e£ '' ¢qp¡−h
¢qp¡−h NeÉ L−l a¡−cl p¡−b Aj¡e¢hL BQle
L−l a¡−cl−L ¢ekÑ¡ae L−l a¡−cl−L ®n¡oe L−l Hhw k¡l¡ H dl−el LjÑL¡¾X−L pjbÑe L−l

30 / 88
Hhw Hl üf−r ¢jbÉ¡ fËj¡e J ašÆ EfØq¡fe L−lz a¡l¡ A‘a¡hnax Lh£l¡ …e¡−q (jq¡ f¡f/
Afl¡d) ¢mç quz
Bj¡−cl p¡j−e A−eL pj¡S l−u−R, a¡−cl p¡wØL«¢aL
aL Eæ¢al fkÑ¡u Bj¡−cl a¥me¡u
¢LR¤V¡ e£Q¥ Øa−llz ¢L¿º a¡−cl j−dÉJ ph dl−el j¡e¢hL …e¡hm£ ¢hcÉj¡ez a−h a¡−cl ®r−œ
¢hnÄ ®ea«−aÄl SeÉ ®k dl−el fË−L±nmNa S·¡e J ®k¡NÉa¡ clL¡l a¡l O¡V¢a l−u−Rz a¡R¡s¡
p¡wúª¢aL ¢cL ®b−LJ a¡−cl ¢LR¤V¡ O¡V¢a l−u−Rz Bh¡l Bhq¡Ju¡S¢ea L¡l−e ¢LR¤ Se−|N¡¢ù
¢iæ dl−el fË¡L«¢aL f¢l−h−n hph¡p L−l Hhw ¢h¢µRæ S£he k¡fe L−l b¡−Lz H L¡l−e ¢hnÄ
piÉa¡ ®b−L Bm¡c¡ p¡wØLª¢aL f¢l−h−n a¡l¡ hph¡p L−lz ¢L¿¹ fË¢a¢V ®r−œ fËb¡, I¢aqÉ,
AiÉ¡p J l£¢ae£¢a−a a¡l¡ p¡d¡le j¡e¤−ol eÉ¡u BQ¡l-
BQ¡l-BQle L−l b¡−Lz ¢L¿º k¡l¡
k¡l¡ heÑh¡−cl
p¤¢hd¡−i¡N£, a¡l¡ Evp¡q EŸ£fe¡l p¡−b X¡lEeh¡c£ ašÆ¡e¤k¡u£ H pjØa j¡e¤o−L "Ae¤æafËS¡¢al'
¡¢al'
j¡e¤o ¢qp¡−h p¡hÉØa L−l, k¢cJ a¡l¡ ®L¡e hÉ¡f¡−l p¡d¡le j¡e¤o −b−L Bm¡c¡ eu, AbQ
a¡−cl−L "" ¢ejÀal fËS¡¢a '' ¢qp¡−h NeÉ L−l Hje¢L a¡−cl−L fö fkÑ¡−ul h−mJ j−e L−l
b¡−Lz HC d¡le¡l L¡l−e Bj¡−cl pjuL¡−mJ Hje ®m¡LJ l−u−Re a¡l¡ Hph ¢f¢R−u fs¡
Se−|N¡¢ùl ®m¡L−L Oªe¡ J ®qu fË¢afæ L−l, öd¤j¡œ H L¡l−e ®k, a¡l¡ fkÑ¡ç f¢lj¡−e ""Eæa''
euz Bõ¡qa¡m¡ hZÑh¡c−L pÇf§eÑl©−f ¢e¢oÜ h¡ q¡l¡j ®O¡oe¡ L−l−Rez Bõ¡qa¡m¡ j¡e¤o−L ¢h¢iæ
h−ZÑ Hhw ¢h¢iæ i¡o¡-
i¡o¡-i¡o£ ¢qp¡−h pª¢ø L−l−Rez Hl j−dÉ pª¢ø ®~h¢Qœ J Bõ¡ql ¢ef¤Z ¢nÒfLm¡
fËL¡¢na J ¢hL¢na q−u−R −L¡l−el i¡o¡u a¡ ¢ejÀl©f x
"" a¡l (Bõ¡ql) ¢e−cÑne¡hm£l j−dÉ l−u−R BL¡n J fª¢bh£l pª¢ø Hhw −a¡j¡−cl i¡o¡ J
hZÑ®~h¢Q−œz Cq¡−a ‘¡e£−cl SeÉ AhnÉC hý ¢ecnÑ
¢ecnÑe l¢qu¡−R''( p¤l¡ l©j-
l©j-22)z'' Bõ¡ql ¢eLV
j¡e¤−ol HLj¡œ ®nËùaÄ a¡l Q¢l−œz a¡l pLm fËL¡l N¤e¡q J f¡f L¡S −b−L j¤š² b¡L¡l j−dÉ
Hhw X~æa Q¢l−œl A¢dL¡l£ qJu¡ k¡ ®M¡c¡i£¢a ®b−L Eá¤a quz a¡R¡s¡ j¡e¤−ol ®nËùaÄ öd¤j¡œ
®M¡c¡i£¢al Efl ¢eiÑln£m k¡ ®cq hZÑ h¡ −Qq¡l¡l
−Qq¡l¡l ®p±¾c−kÑl j¡dÉ−j ¢el©¢fa que¡z H ¢hou¢V
−L¡l¡−el i¡o¡u ¢ejÀl©f x
"" ®q j¡e¤o, B¢j ®a¡j¡¢cN−L pª¢ø L¢lu¡¢R HL f¤l²o J HL e¡l£ qC−a, f−l
®a¡j¡¢cN−L ¢hiš² L¢lu¡¢R ¢h¢iæ S¡¢a J ®N¡−œ, k¡q¡−a ®a¡jl¡ H−L Af−ll p¡−b f¢l¢Qa
qC−a f¡−l¡z ®a¡j¡−cl j−dÉ Bõ¡ql ¢eLV −|pC hÉ¡¢š²C A¢dL jkÑ¡c¡pÇfæ ®k −a¡j¡−cl j−dÉ
A¢dL j¤š¡L£ h¡ ®M¡c¡i£l²z ¢eÕQuC Bõ¡q pLm ¢LR¤ S¡−ee J pjØa Mhl l¡−Me (p¤l¡ Bm
q¤Sl¡a-
l¡a-13)z''

31 / 88
 a«a£u AdÉ¡u

X¡lECeh¡c J gÉ¡p£h¡−cl p¡−b Ni£l osk¿»j§mL Bya¡a

X¡lECeh¡−cl p¡−b ¢qVm¡−ll Aöi H~LÉ

fËËbj jq¡k¤
jq¡k¤−Ül fl¡¢Sa n¢š² S¡jÑ¡e£−a k¤−Ü¡šl ¢hnªwMm¡ q−a e¡S£h¡−cl pª¢ø quz HC
f¡¢VÑl ®ea¡ ¢R−me, hcl¡N£, HLN¤y−u J Bœ²je¡aÈL Q¢l−œl hÉ¢š² k¡l e¡j ¢qVm¡lz ¢qVm¡−ll
¢hnÄcª¢ø iwN£l ¢i¢š ¢Rm hZÑh¡cz ¢qVm¡l ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−ae, BkÑ S¡¢a k¡ S¡jÑ¡e£l j§m ¢i¢šz HC
S¡¢a fª¢bh£l AeÉ¡eÉ S¡¢a q−a ""®nËù '' a¡C a¡l¡C ¢h−nÄl AeÉ¡eÉ S¡¢a−L n¡pe Ll−hz ¢a¢e
üfÀ ®cM−ae, BkÑ S¡¢a HL¢V ¢hnÄ p¡jË¡SÉ N−s a¥m−h k¡ 1000 hRl Øq¡u£ q−hz ¢qVm¡l a¡l
HC hZÑh¡c£ a−šÆl ®~h‘¡¢eL pjbÑe X¡lEC−el ¢hhÑaeh¡c£ a−šÆl j−dÉ My−¤ S f¡ez a¡l ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡
hZÑh¡c£ S¡jÑ
S¡jÑ¡e I¢aq¡¢pL Heinrich von Treitschke à¡l¡ c¡l²ei¡−h fËi¡¢haz Heinrich
X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl HLSe HL¢eù pjbÑL ¢R−mez ¢a¢e a¡l hZÑh¡c£ jah¡−cl ¢i¢š ¢qp¡−h
X¡lECeh¡c−L NËqe L−lez ¢a¢e c¡h£ Ll−ae, ®L¡e S¡¢a ®Lhmj¡œ X¡lEC−el "" ®k¡NÉaj−cl
¢V−L b¡L¡l '' jah¡c Ae¤k¡u£ fËQä fË¢a−k¡N£a¡l j¡dÉ−jC Eæ¢a Ll−a f¡−l Hhw a¡l AbÑ q−µR
x AhnÉñ¡h£ J c£OÑØq¡u£ k¤Üz a¡l d¡le¡ ¢Rm alh¡l£ à¡l¡ ¢hSuC q−µR hhÑla¡ ®b−L piÉa¡ J
A‘¡ea¡ −b−L S·¡e¡−m¡L ¢e−u Bp¡l HL¢V fÜ¢az ¢a¢e j−e Ll−ae, f£ah−ZÑl
S¡¢apj§−ql j−dÉ ®L¡e ®~n¢ÒfL ‘¡e h¡ l¡S−~e¢aL ü¡d£ea¡l ‘¡e h¡ d¡le¡ e¡Cz L¡−m¡ j¡e¤o−cl
H¢V HL¢V A−j¡O ¢h¢d¢m¢f ®k a¡l¡ pÇf§eÑ ®üµR¡u ®nÄaL¡u S¡¢al ®ph¡u ¢QlØq¡u£i¡−h ¢e−u¡¢Sa
b¡L−hz''
H¢c−L Hitler,, Treitschke Hl j−a¡C X¡lECeh¡−cl ¢h−no L−l ""¢V−L b¡L¡l SeÉ
pwNË¡j '' ašÆ −b−L a¡l ¢eSü ja¡cnÑ
ja¡cnÑ ¢hL¢na L−l¢R−mez a¡l L¥MÉ¡a f¤ØaL Mein Kampf
A¢Øa−aÄl SeÉ pwNË¡j jah¡c'' à¡l¡ fËi¡¢haz X¡lEC−el eÉ¡u ¢qVm¡lJ
(My Struggle) “A¢Øa−aÄ
ACE−l¡f£u Se−N¡¢ù−L h¡el fËS¡¢al A¢a¢lš² ¢LR¤ j−e Ll−ae e¡z ¢a¢e hm−ae "" el¢iL
S¡jÑ¡e S¡¢a−L h¡c ¢c−m hy¡¾c−ll e¡Q R¡s¡ ¢LR¤C b¡L−h e¡z '' 1933 p¡−m Nuremburg H
e¡¢S f¡¢VÑl −n¡i¡k¡œ¡u ¢a¢e ®O¡oe¡ L−le "" HL¢V EµQ h¡ ®nËù(BkÑ)fËS¡¢a Ae¤æa h¡ e£Q
fËS¡¢al SeNe−L n¡pe Ll−h, HV¡ HL¢V A¢dL¡l k¡ Bjl¡ fËL¢« a−a ®cM−a f¡C Hhw HV¡C
HLj¡œ ®h¡dNjÉ J k¤¢š² pwNa ¢i¢šl
A¢dL¡l L¡le HV¡ ®~h‘¡¢eL ¢i¢š l Efl fË¢a¢ùaz'' Hitler
¢k¢e BkÑ S¡¢al ®nËù−aÄ ¢hnÄ¡p£ ¢R−me, L¡lZ ¢a¢e H ®nËùaÄ ¢a¢e HL¢V fËL«¢a fËcš A¢dL¡l
¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll−aez
Dr. Hentry M Morris i¨af§hÑ President of the Institute for Creation Research,
¢qVm¡−ll Mein Kampf hC −b−L Eઢa ¢c−u E−õM L−l h−me, "" Cý¢c S¡¢a HL¢V j¡e−hal

32 / 88
fËS¡¢al Se−N¡¢ù k¡ f§hÑ ¢edÑ¡¢la S¾jNa Ešl¡¢dL¡l ¢qp¡−h M¡l¡f, ®kje e¡¢L el¢iL S¡jÑ¡e
S¡¢a−L jqv L¡−Sl SeÉC pª¢ø Ll¡ q−u−Rz C¢aq¡p Hje HL¢V q¡S¡l hR−ll jq¡e p¡jË¡SÉ pª¢ø
Ll−hz k¡l ¢i¢š q−h ¢h¢iæ fËS¡¢al jkÑ¡c¡ ¢i¢šL n¡pe
n¡pe hÉhØq¡ k¡ fËL«¢a La«ÑL ¢edÑ¡¢laz''
¢qVm¡l j−e Ll−ae ®k, j¡e¤o HL¢V A¢a Eæa fËS¡¢al fö, a¡C ¢a¢e j¡eh fËS¡¢al A¢dL
Eæ¢al SeÉ hÜf¢lLl ¢R−me Hhw H dl−el ab¡L¢ba Eæ¢al ¢hou¢V e¡S£ A¡−¾c¡m−el Qy¤s¡¿¹
E−ŸnÉ ¢Rmz ¢h−hQe¡u
H E−ŸnÉ h¡Øah¡u−el fËbj fc−rf ¢Rm a¡−cl ¢h−hQ e¡u "" Eæa '' Se−N¡¢ù
®b−L ""Ae¤æa'' fËS¡¢al ¢h¢µRæ J Bm¡c¡ Ll¡z H ®r−œ e¡¢Sh¡c£l¡ X¡lECeh¡c h¡Øah¡u−el
fc−rf NËqe L−lez H L¡−S a¡l¡ Eugenic h¡ ""Eæa j¡eh fËS¡¢a Evfæ Ll¡l jah¡c'' NÊqe
L−lz Eæa j¡eh fËS¡¢a fËSe−el jah¡c X¡lECeh¡−cl j−dÉC ¢e¢qaz
¢e¢qaz
¢hwn na¡ë£l
na¡ë£l fËbj¡−dÑ HC jah¡c BaÈfËL¡n L−lz Hl h¡Øah¡ue fË¢œ²u¡ q−m¡-
q−m¡- Ap¤Øq
J fË¢ahå£ ®m¡LSe−L ¢ejѧm Ll¡ J ü¡ØqÉh¡e ®m¡−Ll pwMÉ¡ hª¢Ül j¡dÉ−j Eæa fËS¡¢al j¡e¤o
pª¢ø Ll¡z HC ¢hL«a ašÆ¡e¤k¡u£ föl ®r−œ ®kje ü¡ØqÉh¡e föl p¡−b ¢jm−el j¡dÉ−j
j¡dÉ−j Eæa fö
S¾j ®eu Ae¤l©fi¡−h j¡eh
j¡eh S¡¢a−L Eæa
Eæa Ll¡ pñh Hhw a¡ Ll¡ E¢QaJ h−Vz X¡lECeh¡c£
¢Q¿¹¡¢hcNeC hwnNa L¡l−e HC LjÑp§Q£l d¡lL J h¡qLz CwmÉ¡−ä H LjÑpQ§ £l fËd¡e ¢R−me Q¡mpÑ
X¡lEq~−el Q¡Q¡a i¡C Francies Galton Hhw a¡l f¤œ Leonard Darwin
HV¡ AaÉ¿¹ f¢l×L¡l ®k, "" Eæa je¤oÉ fËSee fÜ¢a '' (Eugenic)) X¡lECeh¡c ®b−L
Eá¤az fËL«af−r aMe HC jah¡c ¢houL fËQ¡le¡ ¢h−no …l²aÄpq fËL¡n Ll¡ quz HC fË¢œ²u¡
h¡Øah¡u−el AbÑ q−µR je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡l j¡dÉ−j Eæa S¡−al j¡e¤o ab¡ ü£u
j¡e¤¤o La«ÑL ¢e−S NËqe
fËS¡¢al ¢hL¡−nl ®rÌ−œ pª¢øLaÑ¡−L L¡kÑa Aü£L¡l Ll¡z AbÑ¡v HC c¡¢uaÄ j¡e
Ll¡z
Ju¡¢nwY~e CE¢eiÑ¡¢p¢Vl ¢Q¢Lvp¡ ¢houL I¢aq¡¢pL(Medical
I¢aq¡¢pL( Historian)) Kenneth
Ludmerer E−õM L−le ®k, HC ašÆ Plato Hl Republic Hl pjuL¡m ®b−LC Q¡m¤ ¢Rmz
a−h ¢a¢e B−l¡ E−õM L−le ®k, X¡lEeh¡−cl L¡l−e H a−šÆ HL ea¥e j¡œ¡ ®k¡N quz ¢a¢e
E−õM L−le, "" Eæa j¡eh S¡¢al fËSe−el d¡le¡ Ee¢hwn na−Ll ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡z H pj−u H
i¡hd¡l¡ ¢hL¡−nl HL¡¢dL L¡le h¡ Evp l−u−Rz Hl j−dÉ ph−Q−u hs L¡le q−m¡ X¡lEC|eh¡cz
Eugenic H në¢Vl pËøÊ¡ Francis Galton, a¡l H ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ pl¡p¢l X¡lEeh¡−cl k¤¢š²pwNa J
h¢dÑa pwØLle,
pwØLle, k¡ a¡l Q¡Q¡a i¡C Charles Darwin E›¡fe L−l¢R−mez
S¡jÑ¡e£l fËMÉ¡a ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ S£h¢h‘¡e£ Ernst Haeckel S¡jÑ
S¡jÑ¡e£−a H ja¡cnÑ phÑfËbj
fËQ¡l L−lez ¢a¢e X¡lEC−el HLSe O¢eù hå¥ J pq−k¡N£ ¢R−mez ¢hhaÑ−el pjbÑ−e ¢a¢e
Recaptulation e¡jL HL¢V A¢ieh ašÆ fËc¡e L−le
L−le a¡q−m¡ ¢h¢iæ fËS¡¢al S£¢ha fË¡e£l
Embyro ®cM−a HLC lLjz flha£Ñ−a fËj¡¢ea qu ®k, Haekel ¢jbÉ¡ Data plhl¡q L−l a¡l
ašÆ EfØq¡fe L−l¢R−mez Haekel HL¢c−L ®kje ®~h‘¡¢eL fËa¡le¡l BnËu ¢e−u¢R−mez AeÉ¢c−L
¢a¢e Eugenic jah¡−cl ®S¡l fËa¡le¡ Q¡¢m−u k¡¢µR−mez ¢a¢e fl¡jnÑ ®ce ®k, fË¢ahå£ ¢nö−L

33 / 88
S¾j NÊq−el p¡−b p¡−b qaÉ¡ Ll¡ E¢Qaz H fË¢œ²u¡u pj¡−S ¢hhaÑ®el d¡l¡ aÄl¡¢eÄa q−hz ¢a¢e
B−l¡ c¡¢h L−le, L¥ù−l¡N£, LÉ¡¾p¡l¡œ²¡¿¹ J j¡e¢pL ®l¡N£−cl−L ®hce¡q£e jªa¥Él j¡dÉ−j qaÉ¡ Ll¡
E¢Qa, a¡ e¡ q−m a¡l¡ pj¡−Sl SeÉ ®h¡T¡ ül©f q−u cy¡s¡−hz g−m ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fË¢œ²u¡ nÔb
N¢a pÇfæ q−u fs−hz B−j¢lL¡e N−hoL George Stein S¡jÑ¡e ¢h‘¡e£ Hackel ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl
fË¢a a¡l Aå Be¤N−aÉl ¢hou¢V American Scientist e¡jL jÉ¡N¡¢S−e fËL¡n L−lez H−a ¢a¢e
E−õM L−le ®k, Hackel c¡h£ L−l−Re X¡lECeh¡c p¢WLz j¡ehS¡¢a
j¡ehS¡¢a AhÉnC fË¡e£ SNa −b−L
¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡l j¡dÉ−j pª¢ø q−u−Rz "" H i¡−hC S¡jÑ¡e£−a X¡lEqeh¡−cl c§iÑ¡NÉSeL fcQ¡le¡
öl² q−u−Rz j¡eh S¡¢al p¡j¡¢SL J l¡S®~e¢aL A¢ØaaÄ X¡lEq~−el j−a ¢hhÑaeh¡−cl ab¡
fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Q−el BC®el à¡l¡ ¢eu¢¿»az H hÉ¡f¡−l AeÉ ®L¡e k¤¢š² h¡ ja fËL¡n Ll¡C q−µR
L¥pwØL¡l ab¡ h¡¢am−k¡NÉ ''
Hackel 1919 p¡−m jªa¥Éj¤−M f¢aa qez ¢L¿º a¡l ja¡cnÑ e¡S£l¡ Ešl¡¢dL¡l ül©f NËqe
L−lz Hl AÒf¢ce f−lC ¢qVm¡l rja¡u B−l¡qe L−le Hhw l¡øÊ£ui¡−h HC Eæa ""j¡eh fËSee
LjÑp§Q£'' q¡−a ®eu¡ quz A. E. Wilder Smith ay¡l ¢hMÉ¡a Man’s Origin Man’s Destiny e¡jL
f¤ØaL ¢qVm¡−ll hÉhq²a ¢eSü i¡o¡u HC LjÑp§Q£ Hi¡−h heÑe¡ L−le x
"" SeLmÉ¡ej§mL l¡®øÊ SeN−el nl£l J je pÇf−LÑ ¢nr¡ HL …l²aÄf§eÑ i¥̈¢jL¡ f¡me
L−lz ¢L¿º j¡e¤o h¡ hÉ¢š² ¢ehÑ¡QeJ k−bø …l²aÄfe
§ Ñz Ae¤l©fi¡−h je¤oÉ fËSee ®r−œ
®r−œ
®L¡e hÉ¢š² n¡l£¢lL h¡ j¡e¢pLi¡−h Ap¤Øq a¡ ¢ehÑ¡Qe Ll¡l c¡¢uaÄ l¡−øÊl l−u−|Rz H L¡l−e l¡øÊ
AhnÉC H c¡¢uaÄ AaÉ¿¹ ¢eù¥la¡l p¡−b ¢eù¥li¡−h AeÉ ¢LR¤ ¢h−hQe¡ e¡ L−l n¡l£¢lLi¡−h c§hÑm h¡
fË¢ahå£ ®m¡L S¾j e¡ qJu¡l hÉhØq¡ NÊqe Ll−hz j¡eh fËS¡¢al p¡¢hÑLÑ Eæu−el SeÉ j¡œ 600
hRl k¡ha H LjÑp§Q£ Q¡m¤ Ll¡ q−hz H−a L−l pj¡−S hph¡pL¡l£ j¡eh pÇfÐc¡−ul ü¡ØqÉNa
Eæ¢a J ¢hL¡−nl j¡dÉ−j piÉa¡l ®k Eæ¢a p¡¢da q−h haÑj¡−e a¡ d¡le¡ Ll¡J pñh eu ''
""k¢c fËS¡¢al ph−Q−u ü¡ØqÉh¡e J EhÑl pcpÉ−cl ¢Q¢q²a Ll¡ k¡u a¡q−m HL¢V ""A¢ieh Eæa
Se−N¡¢ù
Se−N¡¢ù '' ®~al£ Ll¡ pñh q−h AeÉb¡u H dl−el n¡¢ll£L J BdÉ¡aÈ Eæa dl−el h£S Bjl¡
q¡¢l−u −gm−h¡z'' ¢qVm¡−ll HC e£¢a h¡Øah¡u−el ü¡−bÑ j¡e¢pLi¡−h Ap§Øq, S¾j¡å, f‰¤ Hhw
S¾jNai¡−h c§hÑm a¡−cl−L HL¢V ¢h−no håÉ¡LlZ −L−¾cÐ h¾c£ L−l l¡M¡ q−a¡z Hdl−el ®m¡L
S¡jÑ¡e ¢höÜ S¡¢aNa pšÆ¡ J fËS¡¢al ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡l j¡dÉ−j Eæ¢al SeÉ fË¢ahåL h¡
r¢aL¡lL h£S¡e¤ ¢qp¡−h NeÉ Ll¡ quz ¢qVm¡−ll ®N¡fe ¢e−cÑ−n Hph ®m¡L−cl qaÉ¡ Ll¡ quz
H dl−el qaÉ¡L¡¾X AaÉ¿¹ k¤¢š² pwNa ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ quz L¡le H dl−el
S¾jNa c§hÑma¡ pÇfeÀ ®m¡L−cl pj¡−S ®h¡T¡ J pj¡−Sl SeÉ ""Am¡iSeL '' ¢qp¡−h NeÉ
Ll¡ q−a¡ Hhw fËS¡¢aNa Eæu−e h¡d¡ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ q−a¡z La«Ñf−rl ¢h−hQe¡u "" e£Q ''
h¡ ""Ae¤æa'' N˲f−L HC LjÑp§Q£−a fkÑ¡uœ²−j A¿¹iÑ¥š² Ll¡ quz flha£Ñ−a Ap§Øq, ®h¡h¡, L¡m¡,
huØL ®m¡L, S¢äp J …l²al j¡e¢pL ®l¡N£−cl
®l¡N£−cl HC "" −N¡fe qaÉ¡L¡ä '' LjÑp§Q£−a A¿¹Ñi¥š²
Ll¡ quz

34 / 88
 1936 p¡−m h¡¢mÑe A¢m¢Çf−L L¡−m¡ HÉ¡b−mV Jesse Owens Q¡l¢V ®p¡e¡l ®j−Xm m¡i
L−lez ¢CVm¡l AeÉ¡eÉ fË¢a−k¡N£−cl A¢ie¾ce S¡e¡−mJ Jesse -®L A¢ie¾ce S¡e¡−a Aü£Lª¢a
S¡e¡e Hhw â²a ®ø¢Xu¡j aÉ¡N L−l Q−m k¡ez j¢qm¡−cl−L
j¢qm¡−cl−L ®L¡e ®L¡e ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ f¤l²o−cl ®Q−u
"" e£Q¥ '' fËS¡¢a ¢qp¡−h NeÉ L−lez Dr. Robert Wartenberg flha£Ñ−a California Hl ¢hMÉ¡a
Neurologist, e¡l£−cl ""e£Q'' fËj¡e Ll¡l ®Qø¡ L−l E−õM L−le ®k, j¢qm¡−cl k¢c pwlrZ e¡
Ll¡ qu a¡l¡ S£¢ha b¡L−a f¡−le¡z H L¡l−e ¢a¢e ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ Efe£a qe ®k k¢c HC c§hÑm
j¢qm¡−cl â²aa¡l p¡−b Afp¡¢la e¡ Ll¡ (¢ej§Ñm) qu a¡q−m ""fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Qe'' j¢qm¡−cl
®r−œ f¤l²o−cl a¥me¡u Lj fË−k¡SÉ q−hz '' HC ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ Ae¤k¡u£ e¡¢S S¡jÑ¡e£−a e¡l£−cl SeÉ
¢LR¤ ¢LR¤ ®fn¡u ¢e−u¡¢Sa qJu¡l −r−œ fËL¡nÉ ¢h¢d¢e−od
¢h¢d¢e−od B−l¡f Ll¡ quz
X¡lECeh¡c J Eugenic jah¡−cl fË¡−u¡¢NL Eæu−el fl S¡jÑ¡e£l hZÑh¡c£ ¢h‘¡e£l¡
fËL¡−nÉ pj¡−Sl Ae¢i−fËa pcpÉ−cl qaÉ¡ Ll¡l p¤f¡¢ln L−lez H ph ¢h‘¡e£−cl HLSe
Adolf Jost pl¡p¢li¡−h ¢Q¢LvpL−cl H dl−el ®m¡L−cl qaÉ¡ Ll¡l fl¡jnÑ ¢c−u HL¢V f¤
f¤ØaL
¢m−Mez 1895 p¡−m Das Recht auf den Tod ( The Right to Death) e¡jL f¤Øa−L Jost k¤¢š²
fËcnÑe L−le ®k ""p¡j¡¢SL p¤ü¡ØqÉ hS¡u l¡M¡l ü¡−bÑ l¡øÊ®L AhnÉC Hph ®m¡L−cl qaÉ¡ Ll¡l
c¡¢uaÄ ¢e−a q−hz'' Adolf Jost ¢qVm¡−ll HLSe fl¡jnÑc¡a¡ ¢R−mez a¡−L 30 hR−ll f−lJ
f−lJ
l¡S®~e¢aL j−’ ®cM¡ ¢Nu¡−Rz ¢qVm¡l h−me, l¡øÊ AhnÉC ®cM−h ®k öd¤j¡œ p¤ü¡−ØqÉl A¢dL¡l£−cl
p¿¹¡e q−hz AhnÉC a¡−cl−L A−k¡NÉ ®O¡oe¡ Ll¡ q−h k¡l¡ cªnÉa Ap¤Øq h¡ S¾jNai¡−h ®L¡e
®l¡N hqe Ll−R, a¡l¡ ®ke AeÉ −m¡L−cl ®l¡N¡œ²¡¿¹ e¡ Ll−a f¡−l a¡−cl−L pj¡S −b−L
Afp¡le
Afp¡le (qaÉ¡) Ll¡ q−hz 1933 p¡−m fËe£a HL BC−el BJa¡u 350,000 Se j¡e¢pL−l¡N£,
30,000 ¢Sfp£, na na L¡−m¡ ¢nö−L ¢h¢iæ fÜ¢a ab¡ ®M¡S¡Lle, l”el¢nÈ, Ce−SLne,
−k±e¡w−N C−mL¢VÊL nL ¢c−u håÉ¡Lle LjÑp§Q£ h¡Øah¡ue Ll¡ quz HLSe e¡S£ LjÑLaÑ¡ h−me,
""e¡S£h¡c q−m¡ fË¡−u¡¢NL S£h ¢h‘¡e '' a¡R¡s¡ S¡jÑ¡e S¡¢al Eæue fË¢œ²u¡ aÄl¡¢eÄa Ll¡l m−rÉ
¢eù¥l fÜ¢a−a ¢el£q ®m¡L−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡ quz Hl j¡dÉ−j ¢qVm¡l Eugenic a−šÆl B−l¡ HL¢V
naÑ f§le L−lez a¡ q−m¡ üZÑ−Ln£ e£m eued¡l£ f¤l²o J j¢qm¡−cl S¡jÑ¡e fËS¡¢al fË¢a¢e¢d
¢qp¡−h ¢edÑ¡le Ll¡ qu Hhw
Hhw a¡−cl ¢jm−el j¡dÉ−j p¿¹¡e Evf¡c−el SeÉ Evp¡¢qa Ll¡ quz
1935 p¡−m H L¡−Sl SeÉ ¢h−no dl−el M¡j¡l (ab¡ NZ−hnÉ¡mu) fË¢aù¡ Ll¡ quz H pLm
M¡j¡−l hZÑh¡c£−cl naÑf§leL¡l£ j¢qm¡−cl p¡−b Hp Hp LjÑLaÑ¡−cl ((S S Officers)) (S¡jÑ¡e ¢h−no
rja¡fË¡ç LjÑLaÑ¡) ¢jme OV¡−e¡l hÉhØq¡ Ll¡ quz l¡øÊ£ui¡−h H dl−el A−~hd p¿¹¡e−cl
fË¢af¡m−el J hÉhØq¡ Ll¡ quz k¡−a ¢qVm¡−ll ü−fÀl 1000 hR−ll S¡jÑ¡e p¡jÊ¡−SÉl SeÉ
Efk¤š² ®~p¢eL plhl¡q Ll¡ pñh quz

35 / 88
 e¡S£®cl BkÑ hZÑh¡c£ ¢hï¡¢¿¹

e¡S£h¡c£l¡ X¡lECeh¡−cl ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡u Eá¤Ü q−u ""BkÑl¡ phÑ−nËù S¡¢a '' H ašÆ
ašÆ fËj¡e
Ll¡l ®Qø¡u Aha£Ñe quz X¡lECe fËj¡e L−le ®k, j¡e¤o ka ®hn£ Eæa q−h a¡l j¡b¡l M¤¢m
aa hs q−a b¡L−hz e¡S£h¡c£l¡ H jah¡c−L AaÉ¿¹ …l²aÄ pqL¡−l NÊqe L−l Hhw j¡e¤−ol
AeÉ¡eÉ
j¡b¡l M¤¢ml j¡f ¢e−u fËcnÑe Ll−a b¡−L ®k S¡jÑ¡e S¡¢a ®nËùz S¡jÑ¡e£−a BNa AeÉ¡ eÉ fËS¡¢al
®m¡−Ll/Se−N¡¢ùl j¡b¡l M¤¢ml ®Q−u S¡jÑ¡e£−cl j¡b¡l M¤¢m hs ®pV¡ a¥me¡ Ll¡l hÉhØq¡ q¡−a
®eJu¡ quz j¡e¤−ol cy¡a, ®Q¡M, Q¥m J AeÉ¡eÉ Ahuh A‰ fËaÉwN ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl cª¢ø−L¡e ®b−L
j§mÉ¡ue Ll¡ quz a¡−cl−L
®k pjØa ®m¡L H ¢h−hQe¡u h¡ j¡ec−ä Efk¤š² ¢h−h¢Qa e¡ q−m a ¡−cl−L
j¡e¤o fËSee LjÑp§Q£l BJa¡u ¢ede Ll¡ q−a¡z Hdl−el "f¡Nm¡j£' J ¢eù¥l LjÑL¡¾X
X¡lEq~eh¡c£ e£¢al p¡j¡¢SL h¡Øah¡u−el e¡−j Ll¡ quz
B−j¢lL¡e I¢aq¡¢pL Michael Grodin ay¡l f¤ØaL The Nazi Doctors and the
Nuremberg Code H h¡Øaha¡ ¢e−jÀ¡š² i¡o¡u E−õM L−le x
"" B¢j j−e L¢l ¢hwn na¡ë£l ®no ¢c−L k¡ Ll¡ q−u−R a¡ e¡S£ Bc−nÑl p¡−b p¡j¡¢SL
X¡lECeh¡−cl HL Af§hÑ ¢jm J pjeÄu l−u−R Hhw fËS¡¢aNa ü¡ØqÉ ¢h‘¡e (Racial Hygienc)
a¡l¡ H pju Q¡m¤ L−l (a¡ Hl p¡−b p¡j”pÉf§eÑ) Q¨s¡¿¹ ¢h−nÔo−e k¡ l−u−R a¡ q−m¡ x
George Stein ¢hou¢Y~ Hi¡−h hÉ¡MÉ¡ L−le, ""e¡S£h¡c Bl k¡C ®q¡L e¡ ®Le HV¡C
fËbjh¡−l j−a¡ HL¢V p¤pwqa fË−Qø¡ k¡l j¡dÉ−j Hje HL¢V l¡S®~e¢aL pÇfÐc¡u pª¢ø Ll¡, k¡
HL¢V f§eÑ¡‰ ®~She£¢al Efl fË¢a¢ùaz HC ""®~She£¢a'' X¡lECeh¡c£ ¢hfÔ−hl −~h‘¡¢eL p−aÉl
p¡−b pÇf§eÑ pwN¢af¤eÑz''
fËËMÉ¡a
É¡a ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ Sir Arthur Keith ¢qVm¡l pÇf−LÑ ay¡l j¿¹−hÉ E−õM L−le, "" S¡jÑ¡e
g¥−uh¡l (®ea¡) HLSe ¢hhaÑeh¡c£z ¢a¢e f¢lL¢Òfai¡−h S¡jÑ¡e£−a ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ e£¢a J BcÑn
h¡Øah¡u−el ®Qø¡ L−l−Rez'' Darwin Before and After f¤Øa−Ll ®mML Robert Clarke
h−me, ¢qVm¡l pñha
pñha h¡mÉL¡m −b−LC ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl à¡l¡ fËi¡¢ha q−u H d¡le¡ ®f¡oe L®le,
EµQal fËS¡¢a ""¢V−L b¡L¡l pwNË¡®j'' e£Q fËS¡¢a−L fl¡Øa L−l Ad£e L−l l¡−Mz ""e¡S£
S¡jÑ¡e£l l¡S®~e¢aL cnÑe ¢qVm¡−ll HC ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ Ae¤k¡u£ fË¢a¢ùa quz'' Race and the Reich
e¡jL f¤Øa−Ll ®mML Joseph Tenenbaum E−õM L−le ""S¡jÑ¡e£l l¡S®~e¢aL cnÑe H ¢hnÄ¡p
®b−L ¢e¢jÑa qu ®k, ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ i¡hd¡l¡ Eæ¢al j§mj¿», pwNË¡j, ¢ehÑ¡Qe (fË¡L«¢aL) Hhw
""®k¡NÉaj ¢V−L b¡L¡l a−šÆl ¢i¢š−a Hph ¢LR¤C X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl j§mj¿» ¢qp¡−h
¢h−h¢Qaz'' S¡jÑ¡e£l pj¡S a¡¢šÆL cnÑ−e k¡ f§hÑ −b−L AwL¥¢la ¢Rmz Hi¡−hC S¡jÑ¡e S¡¢a hm

36 / 88
fË−u¡−Nl j¡dÉ−j ¢hnÄ n¡pe Ll¡l S¾jNa A¢dL¡−ll jah¡c pª¢ø quz a¡C S¡jÑ¡e p¡jË¡SÉJ c§hÑm
S¡¢a pšÆ¡l p¡−b q¡a¥s£ J ®f−lL pÇfLÑ pª¢ø quz''
e¡S£ ®ea¡−cl j−dÉ ¢qVm¡l HL¡C öd¤ H ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ja¡c−nÑl pjbÑL ¢R−me e¡z
Henrich Himmler, S¡jÑ¡e …ç f¤¢mn (®Nø¡−f¡) h¡¢qe£l fËd¡e h−me, fË¡L«¢aL BCe Ae¤k¡u£
""®k¡NÉaj ¢V−L b¡L¡l pwNË¡j'' Hl ¢eSü N¢a−a Qm−hz fËL«af−r pLm e¡S£ ®ea«hª¾cl¡C
¢hhaÑeh¡c J S¡jÑ¡e hZÑh¡−cl ®O¡l pjbÑL J a¡ h¡Øah¡u−el SeÉ fË¢an˲¢ahÜ ¢R−mez
Ae¤
Ae¤l©fi¡−h S¡jÑ¡e ¢h‘¡e£ J ¢nÒff¢aNeJ S¡jÑ¡e£l L¡−m¡ hvpl …¢m−a H jah¡−cl Aå
Ae¤p¡l£ ¢R−mez
¢qVm¡−ll d−jÑl fË¢a fË|Qä Oªe¡

¢hhaÑeh¡c£ ašÆ pjbÑe Ll¡l ¢fR−e ¢qVm¡−ll AeÉ HL¢V …l²aÄf§eÑ L¡le ¢Rm, a¡ q−m¡
AØœz
dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡−pl ¢hl©−Ü HV¡ ¢Rm HL¢V j¡l¡aÈL q¡¢au¡l h¡ A Øœz In£ pLm djÑ¢hnÄ¡−pl fË¢a
¢qVm¡−ll fËQä Oªe¡ ¢Rmz ®~e¢aL …e¡hm£ ®kje cu¡, ejËa¡, j¡eha¡ k¡ pLm In£ djÑ ¢hnÄ¡−pl
fËd¡e ¢e−cÑn, HC ¢e−cÑn¡hm£ X¡lECeh¡−cl ¢eù¥l J k¤Üh¡−S ¢hnÄ¡p£−cl BkÑ hw®nl ®nËùaÄ ab¡
S¡j¡Ñe S¡¢al SeÉ a¡−cl d¡le¡ Ae¤k¡u£ Eæ¢al SeÉ HL¢V fËhm ¢h−l¡d£ n¢š² ¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qa
q−a¡z H L¡l−eC 1933 p¡−m e¡¢Sl¡ kMe rja¡ cMm L−l S¡jÑ¡e pj¡S hÉhØq¡u a¡l¡ aMe
f§−hÑl eÉ¡u HL dl−el j§¢aÑ f§S¡l (Pagan)
( fË¢a BL«ø quz ü¢ØaL¡ (SWASTIKA) k¡ fË¡Q£e
j§¢aÑ f¤S¡l fËa£L a¡l¡ l¡øÊ£u BQ¡l Ae¤ù¡−e hÉhq¡l Ll−a öl² L−lz ¢hhaÑeh¡c, fÉ¡N¡e
pwØL«¢al Ešl¡¢dL¡l ¢qp¡−h e¡S£ l¡S®~e¢aL cnÑ−el j−dÉ ¢jm My−¤ S f¡uz MªødjÑ pÇf−LÑ ja¡ja
l¡M−a ¢N−u ¢qVm¡l HL Øfø i¡o¡u j¿¹hÉ L−le ®k x
""p¤pwN¢Wa ¢jbÉ¡Q¡l (Mªø djÑ) AhnÉC dÄwp Ll−a q−hz l¡øÊ−L AhnÉC Q¨s¡¿¹ rja¡l
A¢dL¡l£ b¡L−a q−hz B¢j ®~nnhL¡−mC j−e Lla¡j ®k, ¢Xe¡j¡CV ¢c−u djÑ−L dÄwp Ll¡ E¢Qaz
aMe −b−LC B¢j h¤T−a ¢n¢M H hÉ¡f¡−l M¤h LjC ®N¡fe£ua¡l p¤−k¡N B−Rz phÑ−no
f¢l¢Øq¢a St Peter Hl ®Qu¡l k¡ HL¢V c§hÑm hª−Ül fËa£L ¢qp¡−h HMeJ ¢V−L B−R ¢LR¤ pwMÉL
Ai¡N£ hªÜ¡ k¡l p¡j−e cy¡¢s−u/eaS¡e¤
¢s−u/eaS¡e¤ q−k b¡−Lz k¡ −q¡L, ü¡ØqÉh¡e k¤hL −nËe£ Bj¡−cl f−r
B−Rz f§−hÑJ Bj¡−cl SeNe ®L¡e dl−el dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡p R¡s¡C k−bø i¡mi¡−hC S£he k¡fe
L−l−Rz Bj¡l Ru ¢X¢ine Hp Hp(S.
Hp( S. Army)) ®~peÉ l−u−R a¡l¡ d−jÑl hÉ¡f¡−l pÇf§eÑ
Ec¡p£ez'' ¢qVm¡−ll d−jÑl fË¢a HC h£anË
h£anËÜ¡ pÇf−LÑ Daniel Gasman a¡l f¤ØaL The
Scientific Origins of National Socialism H ¢m−M−Re, ¢qVm¡l fËb¡Na d−jÑl ¢hl©−Ü
HLLi¡−h ®~S¢hL ¢hhaÑeh¡c−L ph−Q−u …l²aÄf§eÑ q¡¢au¡l ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll−aez ¢a¢e hýh¡l
Mªø djÑ−L ®qu fË¢afæ L−le H L¡l−e ®k, dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ
¢hnÄ¡p X¡lEq~eh¡c£ ¢nr¡l f¢lf¢¿Ûz ¢qVm¡−ll
L¡−R Bd§¢eL ¢h‘¡e J p¡wØL«¢aL ¢höÜa¡l fËa£L q−m¡ ¢Rm X¡lECeh¡cz

37 / 88
 ¢hwn na¡ë£−a AN¢ea dÄwp k−‘l fËd¡e L¡le q−m¡ ¢qVm¡l J e¡S£−cl Q¡¢l¢œL
®~h¢n−øÉl A¢dL¡l£ hÉ¢š² k¡l¡ fËL«af−r ®L¡e d−jÑC ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−ae e¡z H ph hÉ¢š²hNÑ
hÉ¢š²hNÑ Bõ¡ql
A¢ØaaÄ Aü£L¡l Ll−ae Hhw ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−ae ®k, j¡eh S¡¢a ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡u ""Eæa fË¡e£ ''
¢qp¡−h pªø q−u−Rz a¡l¡ ¢e−S−cl−L c¤cÑje£u, L¡E−L −L¡e lLj Sh¡¢c¢qa¡ h¡ c¡uhÜa¡l E−ÜÑ
¢h−hQe¡ Ll−aez a¡−cl ®L¡e dl−el ®M¡c¡ i£¢a a¡−cl
¢Rme¡, ¢Rme¡ ®L¡e flL¡−ml iu, a¡ −cl
e£¢aq£ea¡ J ®üµR¡Q¡¢la¡l ®L¡e p£j¡−lM¡ ¢Rme¡z H L¡l−eC a¡l¡ ¢eù¤li¡−h ¢e¢hÑQ¡−l mr mr
®m¡L−L qaÉ¡ Ll−a prj qez HLV¡ pj¡S hÉhØq¡ ®k j¡eh S¡¢al SeÉ La dl−el ¢ekÑ¡ae J
c¤xM-
M-Lø J ¢hfkÑ−ul pÇj¤M£e q−a f¡−l a¡l SÆm¿¹ Ec¡qle q−m¡ ¢qVm¡−ll Bjmz öd¤j¡œ
¢qVm¡lC eu hlw Bjl¡ flha£Ñ−a ®cMh Stalin, Mao, Polpot, Franco, Mussolini J AeÉ¡eÉ
k¡l¡ ¢hn na−Ll ¢hnÄ−L lš²pÀ¡a L−l−Re a¡l¡ fË−aÉ−Lq~ pÇf§eÑi¡−h djÑq£e hÉ¢š² ¢R−mez
djÑq£ea¡ fª¢bh£−a ¢L ¢hfkÑ−ul pª¢ø Ll−a f¡−l H−cl L¡kÑLm¡f −b−L ¢nr¡ NÊqe Ll¡ ®k−a
f¡−lz fr¡¿¹−l
−l k¡l¡ Bõ¡ql Efl ¢hnÄ¡p Øq¡fe L−l Hhw ®L¡l¡¢eL ®~e¢aL ¢e−cÑne¡ J Ae¤−j¡ce
Ae¤ple L−l Q−me, a¡l¡ pj¡−Sl SeÉ n¡¢¿¹, ¢el¡fš¡ fË¡Q¥kÑ J HL¢V B−m¡¢La pj¡S ¢ejÑ¡e L−l
b¡−Lez k¡l¡ A¡õ¡ql d−jÑl ¢hnÄ¡p£ a¡l¡ LMeJ fª¢bh£l ®L¡b¡J L¡−l¡ n¡¢¿¹ ¢h¢OÀa L−le¡ hlw a¡l¡
ph pju cu¡, hå¤aÄ, ¢hnÄØaa¡, pq−k¡N£a¡l hÉ¡f¡−l pj¡S−L Evp¡q fËc¡e L−l b¡−Lz

X¡lECeh¡c£ gÉ¡¢pø j¤−p¡¢me£ La«ÑL pªø c¤−iÑ¡N J ¢hfkÑu

¢qVm¡l ®kje X¡lECeh¡−cl Efl ¢i¢š L−l S¡jÑ¡e£−a l¡øÊ f¢lQ¡me¡l e£¢a ¢edÑ¡le
L−l¢R−mez HLCi¡−h a¡l pjp¡j¢uL J ¢jœ Benito Mussolini X¡lECeh¡c£®cl c¡h£ J
ja¡c−nÑl ¢i¢š−a Ca¡m£−L p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£ J gÉ¡¢ph¡c£ i¡hd¡l¡u f¢lQ¡¢ma L−lez j¤−p¡¢me£
HLSe X¡lECeh¡c£ ¢R−mez ¢a¢e ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−ae ®k, p¢qwpa¡ ¢hnÄ C¢aq¡−pl fËd¡e Q¡¢mL¡ n¢š²
Hhw k¤−Ül j¡dÉ−jC ¢hfÔh pwO¢Va quz a¡l j−a CwmÉ¡−äl k¤−Ül fË¢a Ae£q¡ hª¢Vn p¡jÊ¡−SÉl
Adxfa−el fËd¡e fËj¡ez
j¤−p¡¢me£ gl¡p£−cl B¢bÑL pq¡ua¡u HL¢V f¢œL¡ fËL¡n L−l¢R−me a¡l e¡j ¢Rm (II
Popolu DIitalla The people of Italy) H f¢œL¡l ¢n−l¡e¡−j ¢a¢e −k fËhQe hÉhq¡l L−le
a¡ q−m¡ x “ He who has iron will also have bread ” AbÑ¡v SeNe−L H h¡aÑ¡ ®cJu¡ q−m¡,
l²¢V pwNË−ql SeÉ fË−u¡Se pjl n¢š²lz j¤−p¡¢me£ a¡l gÉ¡¢pø f¡¢Vl fËa£L ¢qp¡−h L¥W¡l ¢edÑ¡le
L−lez L¡le L¥W¡l q−m¡ k¤Ü, pwO¡a J jªaÉ¥ l fËa£Lz j¤−p¡¢me£l Q¢l−œl ®~h¢nø fË−aÉL gÉ¡¢p−øl
j−a¡ Bœ²je¡aÈL J BCe i‰L¡l£ fËhea¡z
hea¡z a¡l Q¢lœ pÇf−LÑ Denis Mack Smith HL¢V
f¤ØaL lQe¡ L−lez ¢a¢e X~−õM L−le ®k, j¤−p¡¢me£ Af¢lhaÑe£u ¢hnÄ¡−pl A¢dL¡l£ ¢R®mez
Ae¤l©fi¡−h Bœ²je¡aÈL j−e¡i¡h, J BCe mwOe Ll¡l fËhea¡ a¡l j−dÉ mrÉe£uz AeÉ¡eÉ

38 / 88
X¡lEq~eh¡c£ gÉ¡¢pø−cl j−a¡ j¤−p¡¢me£l k¤Üw−cq£,
w−cq£, Bœ²je¡aÈL J ¢ef£sej§mL e£¢a pj§q hÉ¡fL
qaÉ¡L¡¾X OV¡uz g−m hý f¢lh¡lJ Nªqq£e qu Hhw A−eL ®cn dÄwp Øa¥−f f¢lZa quz hÔÉL n¡VÑ
(Black Shirt)) e¡jL ¢h−no h¡¢qe£l j¡dÉ−j qaÉ¡ J ¢ekÑ¡ae Q¡m¡−e¡ quz H dl−el LjÑL¡ä öd¤
a¡l ¢e−Sl ®c−nC p£j¡hÜ ¢Rm e¡, hlw AeÉ ®c−nJ a¡ ¢hØa«a J pÇfÐp¡¢la Ll¡ quz 1935
p¡−m ¢a¢e C¢bJ¢fu¡ cMm L−le Hhw 1941 p¡−m 15,000 −m¡L ¢ede Ll¡ quz ¢a¢e
Ae¢a¢hm−ð C¢bJ¢fu¡ cM−ml X¡lECeh¡c£ a¡¢šÆL ®k±¢š²La¡ fËcnÑe L−lez j¤−p¡¢me£ h−me,
®k−qa¥ C¢bJ¢fu¡l SeNe L¡−m¡ a¡C e£Q¥ fËS¡¢alz a¡C Ca¡m£u−cl j−a¡ ®nÄa Se−N¡¢ù n¡pL
qJu¡l SeÉ a¡−cl NhÑ Ll¡ E¢Qaz Ca¡m£, 1911 p¡−ml A−ƒ¡hl j¡−p j¤p¢mj ®cn ¢m¢hu¡ cMm
L−lz j¤−p¡¢me£l pj−u j¤p¢mj−cl Efl qaÉ¡, ¢ekÑ¡ae J p¢qwpa¡l hÉ¡fLa¡ hª¢Ü f¡uz 10
cMmc¡¢l−aÄ
®éh˲u¡l£,1947 p¡−m j¤−p¡¢me£l jªa¥Él fl HL¢V Q¥¢š²l j¡dÉ−j Ca¡m£l HC cMmc ¡¢l−aÄl ®no
quz H pj−u (1911-
(1911-1947) 1.5 ¢j¢mue j¤pmj¡e−L nq£c Ll¡ qu Hhw q¡S¡l q¡S¡l Bqa
J f‰¤ Ll¡ quz
j¤−p¡¢me£ a¡l ¢eù¥l, ¢ekÑ¡aej§mL BQl−el SeÉ C¢aq¡−p L¥MÉ¡a q−u B−Rez ¢a¢e
gÉ¡¢ph¡c
gÉ¡¢ph¡c pjbÑe J h¡Øah¡ue Ll−aez H pÇf−LÑ ¢a¢e HL hšª²a¡u h−me x gÉ¡¢ph¡c ®L¡e
®L¡e
Ec¡la¡h¡c eu hlw HLe¡uLa¿», S¡a£u ¢el¡fš¡ pwlrZ L−le¡ hlw HV¡ hÉ¢š²Na pÇf¢šl
ü£L«¢a fËc¡e L−lz
¢qVm¡l J j¤−p¡¢me£l Ec¡ql−e A¡jl¡ fËaÉr L−l¢R ®k, gÉ¡¢ph¡c ®kM¡−e n¢š²dl J ¢eù¥l
a¡C p¢WL ®k±¢š²L J ®nËù ¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qa ja¡c−nÑ pgma¡ J Eæu−el fËd¡e fÜ¢a q−m¡
q−m¡
¢eù¥la¡, hhÑla¡, Bœ²je¡aÈL cª¢øi¢‰, à¾cÄ k¤Ü J pwO¡az H phC q−m¡ X¡lECeh¡−cl h¡Øah
fË−u¡N J c¡h£l pgm h¡Øah¡ue a¡ q−m¡-
q−m¡- ""n¢š²n¡m£ hy¡Q−h h¡ ¢V−L b¡L−h Bl c§hÑm ¢e¢ÕQq²
q−u k¡−hz'' H fË¢œ²u¡C mr mr ®m¡−Ll c§−iÑ¡N h−u ¢e−u H−p−Rz

®Øf−e gÉ¡¢pø −ea¡ é¡w−L¡l

é¡w−L¡l AaÉ¡Q¡l

®Øf−el ®Se¡−l−m¡¢p−j¡ gÊ¡w−L¡ ¢R−me HLSe AeÉaj gÉ¡¢pø ®ea¡z ¢a¢e ¢hwn na¡ë£−a
−Øf−e j¡e¤−ol lš² N‰¡ hC−u ®cez é¡w−L¡, ¢qVm¡l J j¤−p¡¢me£l fËaÉr pq¡ua¡u ®Øf−e
FALANGIE gÉ¡p£h¡c B−¾c¡m−el e¡−j Nªqk¤Ü öl² L−lez ¢a¢e ®Øf−el SeN−el SeÉ Qlj
c¤−iÑ¡N J ¢ekÑ¡a−el L¡le OV¡ez g−m ®Øf−e Nªqk¤−Ül j¡dÉ−j i¡C J i¡C, ¢fa¡l ¢hl©−Ü f¤−œl
j−dÉ k¤Ü pwO¢Va quz Nªqk¤−Ül pju fË¢a¢ce N−s l¡Sd¡e£ j¡¢â−c 250 Se, h¡−pÑ¡−m¡e£u 150
Hhw ®p¢i−m 80 Se ¢eqa q−a¡z L¡E−L L¡E−L j¡b¡l j−dÉ ®f−lL W¤−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡ q−a¡z pjNËË
−c−n Aj¡e¢hL J hÉ¡fL NeqaÉ¡ pwO¢Va quz Ec¡qleül©f E−õM Ll¡ k¡u ®k, j¡¢â−cl Eš®l
r¥â f¡q¡s −Ol¡ NË¡−j 31 Se NË¡jh¡p£−L é¡w−L¡−L ®i¡V e¡ ®cJu¡l Afl¡−d ®NËç¡l Ll¡

39 / 88
quz H−cl j−dÉ 13 Se ®L VÊ¡−L ¢e−u k¡Ju¡ qu Hhw NË¡−jl h¡C−l ¢e−u H−p l¡Øa¡l f¡−n …¢m
L−l qaÉ¡ Ll¡
Ll¡ quz gÉ¡¢ph¡c£l¡ −p¢i−ml (Seville) L¡−R HL¢Y nq−l fË−hn L−lz 300 Se−L
qaÉ¡ L−lz ®Øfe£u Nªqk¤−Ü 800,000 ®m¡L ¢eqa qu, 200,000 Se−L ®Se¡−lm é¡w−L¡l
¢e−cÑ−n qaÉ¡ Ll¡ quz mr mr ®m¡L Bqa Abh¡ f‰¤ quz

¢qVm¡l−L a¡l AØœ fl£r¡l SeÉ ®Se¡−lm é¡w−L¡ −N¡−ul¢eL¡ nq−ll

nq−ll
SeNe−L (qaÉ¡l SeÉ) Efq¡l ®ce

gÉ¡¢pø é¡w−L¡l HC Nªqk¤−Ü ¢qVm¡l J j¤−p¡¢me£ ¢R−me ph−Q−u hs pjbÑeL¡l£z é¡w−L¡

a¡l ¢jœ−cl f¤lØL«a Ll−a ¢fRf¡ qe¢ez ¢a¢e j¡eh C¢aq¡−p ph−Q−u ¢eù¥l Aj¡e¢hL Q¥¢š²
ü¡rl L−lez é¡w−L¡ GUERNICA e¡jL ®R¡V HL¢V nql e¡S£−cl j¡le¡Øœ fl£r¡ Ll¡l SeÉ
¢qVm¡l−L Efq¡l ®ce (HC nq−ll dÄwpk‘C f¡h−m¡ ¢fL¡−p¡l ¢hnÄ¢hMÉ¡a ¢QœLjÑ ®N¡−ul¢eL¡)z
1937 p¡−ml 5 ®j e¡S£−cl ea¥e −h¡j¡ …−ul¢eL¡u ®gm¡ quz nqlh¡p£l¡ O¤j −b−LC
EW−a EW−aC ®h¡j¡h¡S£l ¢nL¡l q−u jªaɤ j¤−M f¢aa quz nql¢V e¡S£−cl ®h¡j¡l² ¢hj¡−el mrÉ
hØa¥ Ll¡l SeÉ é¡w−L¡ ¢qVm¡l−L Efq¡l ¢c−u¢R−mez
HC OVe¡ fÊL«af−r ®pC ¢hL«a cnÑ−el pª¢ø, k¡ j¡e¤o−L N−hoe¡N¡−l fö ¢qp¡−h NeÉ L−lz
HC cnÑe k¡l SeÉ q¡S¡l q¡S¡l ®m¡L jªa¥Éhle L−l öd¤j¡œ j¡le¡−Øœl rja¡ fl£r¡ Ll¡l SeÉz
Hl g−m q¡S¡l q¡S¡l ®m¡L ¢ekÑ¡¢aa, Bqa, f‰¤ J jªa¥Éj¤−M f¢aa quz HMeJ q¡S¡l q¡S¡l
®m¡L c§−iÑ¡Npq ®hy−Q B−Rez H cnÑe j¡ehS¡¢a−L fö R¡s¡ AeÉ ¢LR¤ ¢h−hQe¡ L−le¡ Hhw k¤Ü−L
j¡eh S¡¢al Eæu−el ph−Q−u L¡kÑLl£ f¿Û¡ ¢qp¡−h ¢edÑ¡le L−lz a¡C H cnÑe h¡ H dl−el ®k
®L¡e ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ h¡ ja¡cnÑ ka¢ce ¢hcÉj¡e b¡L−h, NeqaÉ¡, ¢ekÑ¡ae, Evf£se J c§−iÑ¡N j¡eh
S¡¢al SeÉ Ahd¡¢la fË¢œ²u¡ ¢qp¡−h ¢hl¡Sj¡e b¡L−hz

fËËbj J ¢àa£u ¢hnÄ k¤−Ü X¡lEqeh¡−cl fËØa¥¢aj§mL i¥¢jL¡

fËMÉ¡a hª¢Vn I¢aq¡¢pL fË−gpl James Joll a¡l f¤ØaL EURORE Since 1870 H
fËbj jq¡k¤−Ül L¡le hÉ¡MÉ¡ fËpw−N ¢m−M−Re
¢m−M−Re ®k, ac¡e£¿¹e CE−l¡f£u ®ea«hª−¾cl X¡lECeh¡c£
¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l gpm q−m¡ H k¤Ü, a¡l i¡o¡u x
Bjl¡ fËaÉr L−l¢R ®k, ¢Li¡−h X¡lECeh¡c£ ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡/ja¡cnÑ Ee¢hwn na¡ë£l ®noi¡−N
p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£ i¡hd¡l¡−L fËi¡¢ha L−l−Rz ¢L¿º HV¡ AaÉ¿¹ …l²aÄf§eÑ ®k, fËbj ¢hnÄ k¤−Ül f§hÑha£
hRl pj§−q A¢dL¡wn CE−l¡f£u ®ea«hª¾c Br¢lL A−bÑq~ "" A¢Øa−aÄl SeÉ pwNË¡j '' J ""
®k¡NÉaj−cl ¢V−L b¡L¡l '' jah¡c h¡Øa−h fË−u¡N L−l−Rez Ec¡qleül©f hm¡ k¡u ®k, Austo-

40 / 88
Hungarian pj¡−SÉl Chief of Staff, Franz Baron Conrad Von Hoetzendorff fËbj ¢hnÄk−¤ Ül
fl a¡l pȪ¢a Lb¡u ¢m−M−Re x
j¡eha¡h¡c£ djÑpj§q ®~e¢aL ¢nr¡ J c¡nÑ¢eL jah¡c/ašÆ AhnÉ j¡e¤−ol ""A¢Øa−aÄl
pwNË¡j '' h¡Øah¡ue fË¢œ²u¡−L AaÉ¿¹ Øý¤m Ef¡−u h¡d¡NËØa L−lz ¢L¿º H…¢m LMeJ fª¢bh£l
fËd¡e Q¡¢mL¡n¢š² ¢qp¡−h f¢lN¢ea qu e¡z H ¢hnÄk−¤ Ül dÄwp k¡ HL¢V jq¡e p’¡me
p’¡me n¢š² ¢qp¡−h
l¡øÊ J Se S£h−e BNje L−l−Rz HV¡ q−m¡ HL dl−el hSÊf¡a h¡ T’¡ k¡ fË¡L«¢aL ¢hd¡e
Ae¤k¡u£ a¡l c¡¢uaÄ AhnÉC pÇf¡ce Ll−hz'' HC dl−el ja¡c−nÑl d¡lL J h¡qL ¢qp¡−h
Contard Hl A¢øu¡e l¡Shwn lr¡l SeÉ fË¢a−l¡dj§mL k¤−Ül ®k±¢š²La¡ fË¢ed¡e−k¡NÉz
Bjl¡ fËaÉr L−l¢R ®k, H dl−el ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ öd¤j¡œ pjle¡uL−cl j−dÉ p£j¡hÜ ¢Rme¡,
hlw pj¡S ¢h‘¡e£ Max Weber, ¢k¢e B¿¹SÑ¡¢aL f¢lj¾X−m ""A¢Øa−aÄ
""A¢Øa−aÄl pwNË¡j'' jah¡−cl
h¡Øah¡u−el hÉ¡f¡−l Ni£l BNËq£ ¢R−mez a¡ R¡s¡ Kurt Reizler S¡jÑ¡e Chancellor
Theobald Von Bethmann Hollweg Hl HL¡¿¹ p¢Qh, 1914 p¡−m ¢m−M−Re, ""j¡e¤−ol j−dÉ
¢QlØq¡u£ JQ§s¡¿¹ nœ²a¡ HL¢V S¾jNa hÉ¡f¡lz f¡lØf¢lL ¢h−l¡d k¡ Bjl¡ pj¡−Sl phÑœ fËaÉr
L¢l, HV¡ j¡eh Q¢l−œl ®L¡e ¢hL«a ¢cL eu hlw HY~¡C fª¢bh£l j§mp§œ Hhw S£−hl ¢eSü
A¢Øa−aÄl p¡−b S¢sa HL¢V hÉ¡f¡lz''
Friedrich Von Bernhardi, fËbj ¢h−nÄl HLSe S¡jÑ¡e pjle¡uL J S¡jÑ¡e p¡j¡¢SL
X¡lX~Ceh¡c£ J k¤−Ül HLSe ®eaªØq¡e£u hÉ¢š² ¢a¢e h−me ""k¤Ü j¡eh S¡¢al SeÉ HL¢V S£h
®~h‘¡¢eL fË−u¡Se£ua¡z HY~¡ Hje HLV¡ fË−u¡Se k¡ ""fË¡L«¢aL pwNË¡−jl '' ¢h¢iæ ¢cL J ¢hi¡−Nl
j−dÉ ¢hl¡¢Saz S£h ¢h‘¡−el ¢cL ®b−L a¡ kb¡kb ¢pÜ¡¿¹, a−h H ph ¢pÜ¡¿¹ fË¡L«¢aL ¢h¢iæ
Ef¡c¡−el Efl pÇf§eÑ ¢eiÑln£mz''
fËËbj jq¡k¤−Ül L¡le ¢qp¡h Bjl¡ fÊaÉr L−l¢R, q~E−l¡f£u ¢Q¿¹¡¢hc, pjl¢hc J
l¡S®~e¢aL ®ea«hª−¾cl d¡le¡ ¢Rm k¤Ü, lš²f¡a, c§−iÑ¡N HL¢V A−j¡O fË¡L«¢aL ¢hd¡ez ®k ja¡cnÑ
HL¢V fËS¾j−L dÄw−pl j¤−M ¢e−u ®N−R a¡ ®k ¢jbÉ¡ ašÆ J a−bÉl Efl fË¢a¢ùaz X¡lEC−el
jah¡c-
jah¡c- ""S£h−el SeÉ pwNË¡j '' J ""®nËù p¤¢hd¡−i¡N£ fËS¡¢a''z
¡¢a''z Bernarde c¤C hRl fl h−me
x fËbj jq¡k¤−Ül j¡dÉ−j HL¢V "" ®~Sh ®~h‘¡¢eL Eæue '' ((Biological Development)) p¡de
p¡de
Ll¡l Lb¡ ¢Rm a¡ öl² q−u−Rz Hl g−m 8 ¢j¢mue jªa, na na nql dÄwpØa¥−f f¢lea q−u−R,
mr mr ®m¡L Bqa q−u−R J f‰¤ q−u−Rz ®m¡L Nªqq£e J ®hL¡l q−u−Rz B−l¡ mr mr e¡S£
k¤−Ül Evp X¡lECeh¡c£−cl j−dÉ ¢e¢qaz 21 hvpl fl öl² qu (¢àa£u jq¡k¤Ü) g−m 50
¢j¢mue ®m¡L jªa¥É hlZ
hlZ L−lz ¢qVm¡l fË¡uC a¡l k¤Ü J NeqaÉ¡l e£¢al p¡−b X¡lECeh¡c−L
pÇfªš L−l−Rez ¢a¢e ¢h−hQe¡ Ll−ae k¤−Ül j¡dÉ−j öd¤j¡œ c§hÑm fËS¡¢al Se−N¡¢ù−L ¢ede Ll¡
eu hlw fËi¥ fËS¡¢al c§hÑm hÉ¢š²hNÑ−L ¢e¢ÕQq² Ll¡ pñhz e¡S£ S¡jÑ¡e£ k¤Ü−L ph pju fËnwp¡l

41 / 88
p¡−b ¢h−hQe¡ Ll−aez
Ll−aez a¡−cl ¢hL«a ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡u ""fËS¡¢al Eæu−el'' SeÉ k¤Ü HL¢V Af¢lq¡kÑ
fÊ¢œ²u¡ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll−a¡z
X¡lECeh¡c£ A.E Wiggam hÉ¡MÉ¡ L−le ®k, k¤Ü j¡e¤o−L Eæa L−lz ¢qVm¡l La«ÑL a¡l
pjle£¢a H ja¡j−al ¢i¢š−aC fËeue Ll¡ q−u−Rz 1922 p¡−m HL f¤Øa−L E−õM Ll¡ qu x
®L¡e
®L¡e HL pj−u j¡e¤−ol j¢ØaL a¡l "" Q¡Q¡a i¡C '' h¡el −b−L p¡j¡eÉ ®hn£ ¢Rmz ¢L¿º
m¡¢b, L¡js, k¤Ü J nœ²−L h¤¢Ül j¡dÉ−j fl¡¢Sa L−l Hhw H pÇf−LÑ k¡−cl ®L¡e d¡le¡/−Qae¡
Hhw fË−u¡Se£u h¤¢Ühª¢š J n¢š² ¢Rme¡ a¡l¡ jªa¨Éhle L−lz H fË¢œ²u¡u j¡e¤−ol j¢ØaL k−bø
Eæa q−u−Rz
¢qVm¡l Wiggam Hl eÉ¡u ¢hhaÑeh¡c£−cl pjbÑe ®f−a b¡−Lez H−cl j−a k¡l¡ S£¢ha
b¡L−a Q¡e a¡−cl SeÉ k¤Ü HL¢V Af¢lq¡kÑ fÊ¢œ²u¡z ¢qVm¡l a¡l f¤ØaL Mein Kamipf -H
¢m−M−Re x pjNË ¢hnÄ fËL«¢a−a ph−ml p¡−b c§hÑ−ml j−dÉ pwNË¡j HL¢V Øq¡u£ ¢hd¡ez H fË¢œ²u¡u
ph−ml ¢hSu J c§hÑ−ml fl¡Su AhnÉñ¡h£ hÉ¡f¡lz HV¡ e¡ q−m fËL«¢al dÄwp/ru Ahd¡¢la ®k
hy¡Q−a Q¡C−h a¡−LC k¤Ü Ll−a q−hz HC ¢h−nÄ ®kM¡−e pwNË¡j HL¢V ¢QlØq¡u£ fË¡L«¢aL ¢hd¡ez
®k k¤Ü Ll−a BNËq£ ee ay¡l H fª¢bh£−a −hy−Q b¡L¡l ®L¡e A¢dL¡l e¡Cz H R¡s¡ AeÉ ®L¡e
lLj ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ fË
fËLª¢al p¡−b f¢lq¡p Ll¡ R¡s¡ Bl ¢LR¤ euz gmn˲¢a−a c¤xM, c¤cÑn¡, hÉ¡¢d j¡eh
S¡¢a−L NË¡p Ll−hz
X¡lECeh¡c£−cl c¡h£ Ae¤u¡u£ ¢V−L b¡L¡l pwNË¡−j öd¤j¡œ n¢š²dlC ¢V−L b¡−L Hhw HC
fËS¡¢a p¢aL¡l ¢hL¡n m¡i L−lz Hl AbÑ q−µR HC Eæa fËS¡¢a pj¡−S fË¢aù¡ f¡uz j¡eh
S¡¢al
S¡¢al Eæu−el SeÉ k¤Ü−L HL¢V A¢a fË−u¡Se£u Ef¡c¡e ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ quz Ec¡qleül©f
hm¡ k¡u ®k, ¢qVm¡−ll d¡le¡ Ae¤k¡u£ S¡j¡Ñe S¡¢al ®nÔÊùaÄ q−m¡ k¤−Ül j¡dÉ−j a¡l ®Q−u c§hÑm
fËS¡¢a−L ¢e¢ÕQq² Ll¡z k¢cJ S¡jÑ¡e S¡¢al SeÉ k¤Ü ®L¡e ea¥e ¢hou ¢Rm e¡ ah¤J HC
ab¡L¢ba
ab¡L¢ba −~h‘¡¢eL ®k±¢š²La¡ a¡−cl k¤Üh¡S e£¢al Ae¤pl−el HL¢V ®fËle¡c¡u£ n¢š² ¢qp¡−h
L¡S L−lz ¢qVm¡l AeÉœ c¡h£ L−l−Re ®k, Bjl¡ ®k j¡eh piÉa¡−L S¡¢e p¡hÑr¢eL k¤Ü R¡s¡ a¡
¢V−L b¡L−a f¡l−a¡ e¡z
HAECKEL Hl k¤Ü pð−å d¡le¡ ¢Rm ®k, fË¡Q£e NË£−pl HL¢V eNl l¡ø SPARTA
hhÑ−l¡¢Qa k¤Üe£¢a h¡Øah¡ue Ll¡ E¢Qaz ¢a¢e ¢m−M−Re ®k, SPARTA A¢dh¡p£−cl e£¢a
Ae¤k¡u£ p¤ü¡−Øql A¢dL¡l£ J phm ¢nö hÉa£a AeÉ pLm−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l e£¢al j¡dÉ−j a¡l¡
HL¢V ®n±kÑ h£kÑn¡m£ S¡¢a ¢qp¡−h f¢lN¢ea q−u¢Rmz n§d§j¡œ S¡jÑ¡e£ eu hlw pjNË CE−l¡−f
SepwMÉ¡l fËd¡e
¡e ¢eu¡jL ¢qp¡−h k¤Ü ®Lq~ ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ q−a¡z S¡jÑ¡e pj¡Sh¡c£ X¡lECeh¡c£
Friedrich Vonrenhanbi ¢m−M−Re ®k, k¤Ü e¡ q−m pj¡−S c§hÑm Hhw ¢hL«a fËS¡¢al ®m¡−Ll¡
a¡−cl BkÑ Hhw pwMÉ¡l n¢š²−a Eæa fËS¡¢al Se−N¡¢ù−L ®L¡eW¡p¡ L−l −gm−h a¡C k¤−Ül

42 / 88
fËL«a fË−u¡Se£ua¡
u¡Se£ua¡ q−µR Hl j¡dÉ−j ®k¡NÉaj−cl ¢V−L b¡L¡l hÉhØq¡ ¢e¢ÕQaLlez H L¡l−eC k¤Ü
HL¢V Af¢lq¡kÑ ®~S¢hL fË¢œ²u¡z
E−õ¢Ma ¢hhle£ −b−L Bjl¡ ®cM−a f¡C ®k, ¢qVm¡l Hhw a¡l e¡S£ ja¡c−nÑl pjbÑLNe
X¡lECeh¡−cl à¡l¡ fËi¡¢ha q−u pj¡S Eæu−el ®r−œ k¤Ü−L j¡eh S¡¢al jq¡¢hfkÑ−ul SeÉ ®k
pjØa hÉ¢š²hNÑ c¡u£ Q¡mp X¡lECe a¡−cl j−dÉ AeÉajz
fË−gpl JERRY VERGMAN ¢àa£u jq¡k¤−Ü X¡lEq~eh¡−cl fËi¡h pÇf−LÑ h−me ®k,
fË¡ç fËj¡e¡¢c −b−L HV¡ AaÉ¿¹ f¢l×L¡l ®k, S¡jÑ¡e S¡¢al ¢Q¿¹¡ J L¡kÑLm¡−fl j−dÉ
X¡lECeh¡−cl fËi¡h fËQäi¡−h mrÉe£uz fËL«a f−r ¢àa£u jq¡k¤
jq¡k¤−Ül L¡le ¢qp¡−h X¡lECeh¡c−L
c¡u£ Ll¡ k¡uz H k¤−Ü 40 mr j¡e¤−ol jªaɨ J 6 ¢YÊ~¢mue Xm¡l r¢a p¡¢da pwO¢Va quz
¢hhaÑeh¡−cl paÉa¡ pÇf−LÑ ¢qVm¡l ¢Øql ¢e¢ÕQa ¢R−me, a¡C ¢a¢e j¡eh S¡¢al œ¡eLaÑ¡ ¢qp¡−h
¢h−hQe¡ Ll−aez HL¢V ea¥e Eæa ab¡ ®nËù j¡eh S¡¢a pª¢ø Ll¡l j¡dÉ−j ¢a¢e j¡eh piÉa¡−L
¢hhaÑeh¡−cl p−hÑ¡µQ ¢hL¢na fkÑ¡u ¢e−u k¡−he HV¡C ¢Rm a¡l fËaÉ¡n¡z
HV¡ paÉ ®k, X¡lECe a¡l HC jah¡c fËQ¡l Ll¡l f§−hÑ fª¢bh£−a AN¢ea k¤Ü pwO¢Va
q−u−Rz ¢L¿º HC jah¡−cl fËi¡−h ¢h−nÄ phÑfËbj k¤−Ül HL¢V ¢jbÉ¡ ®~h‘¡¢eL pjbÑe fËc¡e Ll¡
q−u−Rz
q−u−Rz k¤Ü pwOV−e X¡lECeh¡−cl ®e¢ah¡QL i¥¢jL¡ pÇf−LÑ MAX NORDAU “The
Philosophy and Morals of War” k¡ B−j¢lL¡u k−bø B−m¡se pª¢ø L−l¢Rmz ¢a¢e HC fËh−¾d
E−õM L−le −k, fª¢bh£−a k¤−Ül ph−Q−u hs pjbÑeL¡l£ La«Ñfr q−µR Q¡mÑp X¡lECe HC jah¡c
fËhaÑ−el p¡−b a¡−cl Q¢l−œl
Q¢l−œl hhÑ−l¡¢Qa, lš²ru£ Hhw ¢qwpË ¢Q¿¹¡-®Qae¡ k¡ X¡lECeh¡c ab¡
¢h‘¡−el Bhl−e ®Y−L ¢c−u−Rz
Ee¢hwn na¡ë£l fl ¢hwn na¡ë£−a ®k lš²ru£ k¤Ü pwO¢Va qu, ¢hnÄ Aa£−a LMeJ
fËaÉr L−l e¡Cz HV¡ ®L¡e L¡La¡m£u OVe¡ ¢Rme¡ hlw hØa¥h¡c£ ¢Q¿¹¡¢hc X¡lECe, L¡mÑ j¡LÑp
J é−u−Xl ¢Q¿¹
¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ HC f¢l¢Øq¢a pª¢øl SeÉ c¡u£z X¡lX~Ceh¡c£ a−šÆl ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL k¤¢š²
HC k¤−Ül ®rœ fËØa¥a L−l¢Rmz ®~üla¡¢¿»L ®ea«hª¾c k¤Ü−L j¡eh piÉa¡l SeÉ ®k HL¢V
Af¢lq¡kÑ fÊ¢œ²u¡ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll−aez a¡l¡ HC Ei
Eiuuk¤−Ü 60 ¢j¢mue ®m¡L−L qaÉ¡ L−l−Rz

ehÉ e¡S£N®el AfLjÑ

¢qVm¡l J j¤−p¡¢me£ k¢cJ gÉ¢ph¡c£ n¡pL−cl p¡−b L¥MÉ¡a S S GESTAPO Abh¡ “Black
shirt ”--®cl L¡kÑLm¡f Aa£−al C¢aq¡p j−e q−mJ ehÉ e¡S£ pw|NWe pjªq a¡−cl ja¡cnÑ
Ae¤k¡u£ HMe p¢œ²ui¡−h L¡S L−l k¡−µRz
pÇfТaLL¡−m hZÑh¡c£ J gÉ¡¢ph¡c£ B−¾c¡me f¤el¡u j¡b¡Q¡s¡
j¡b¡Q¡s¡ ¢c−u E−W−Rz H−cl j−dÉ
S¡j¡Ñ¡e£l ehÉ gÉ¡¢ph¡cl¡C ANËN¡j£z HC ehÉ e¡S£l¡ fÊLa
« f−r ®hL¡l, N¤ä¡, j¡cL¡pš², lš²
¢ff¡p¤ hÉ¢š²h−NÑl pjeÄ−u N¢Wa HL¢V ®N¡¢ùz H−cl j−dÉ gÉ¢ph¡c£ Q¢l−œl pLm ®~h¢nøÉC ¢hcÉj¡ez

43 / 88
ehÉ e¡S£−cl pÇf−LÑ Mh−ll L¡N−S fËL¡¢na HL¢V fËh¾d ®b−L a¡−cl lš² ¢ff¡p¤ Hhw
Bœ²je¡aÈL Q¢l−œl f¢lQu f¡Ju¡ k¡uz lš² ¢ff¡p¤, NhÑ Hhw ®Ny¡s¡j£ Facist Olympia Group
Hl pcpÉ−cl Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢nøÉz HC ¢ae¢V n−ël j−dÉC kb¡kbi¡−h fËL¡n Ll¡ k¡uz haÑj¡−e HC
pwØq¡u 35 q¡S¡l pcpÉ l−u−|R Hhw fË−aÉL pc−pÉl ®Q¡−M rja¡ B−l¡q−el
B−l¡q−el HL c¤cÑje£u CµR¡l
fË¢agme ®cM−a f¡Ju¡ k¡uz HC ehÉ e¡S£l¡ "jq¡e' ¢qVm¡l J AeÉ¡eÉ ®ea¡−cl ja¡cnÑ AbÑ¡v
p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡−cl Ae¤p¡l£z a¡l¡ a¡−cl e¡S£ J hZÑh¡c£ ja¡cnÑ fËQ¡−ll SeÉ ®k C¾V¡l−eV
fË¢aù¡ L−l−R −pM¡−e X¡lECe J a¡l ja¡c®nlÑ fËnwp¡ pq−SC fËaÉr Ll¡ k¡uz L¡le
X¡lECeh¡c a¡−cl pLm AfLjÑ J B−¾c¡m−el a¡¢šÆL pjbÑe fËc¡e L−l b¡−Lz HC ph
C¾V¡−e−Vl f¡a¡u f¡a¡u a¡l¡ X¡lECeh¡c−L Hjei¡−h EfØq¡fe L−l k¡−a L−l j−e q−a f¡−l
®k, H¢V Hje HL¢V jah¡c k¡ ¢hnÄ¡p−k¡NÉ J AhnÉ f¡me£uz k¢cJ Bjl¡ S¡¢e X¡lEq~eh¡−cl
®L¡e ®~h‘¡¢eL
‘¡¢eL ¢i¢š ®eCz
H pjØa M¤e J Bœ²je ehÉ e¡S£l¡ AaÉ¿¹ ¢eù¥li¡−h pÇfæ L−l b¡−Lz ehÉ e¡S£l¡
j¡e¤o f¤¢s−u qaÉ¡ Ll−a M¤h Be¾c m¡i L−l, a¡l¡ iu ®cM¡u, ®R¡V
®R¡V ¢nöl Efl AaÉ¡Q¡l L−lz
¢h−no L−l a¥L£Ñl¡ a¡−cl Bœ²j−el AeÉaj ¢nL¡lz ehÉ e¡S£Ne C¾V¡l−et~ p¡C−Vl fË¢a¢V ¢cL
®b−LC
®b−LC a¥L£~−cl fË¢a a¡−cl nœ²a¡ fËL¡n L−l Hhw h¡Øa−h a¡ L¡−kÑ f¢lZa L−lz ehÉ e¡S£−cl
C¾V¡l−eV p¡C−Vl a¡−cl Hje HL¢V Eઢa ¢e−jÀ E−õM Ll¡ q−m¡ x
""k¢c
""k¢c HMe Bj¡l q¡−a rja¡ b¡La a¡q−m A¢dL¡wn a¥L£Ñ−cl−LC
cl−LC NÉ¡p ®Qð¡−l
Y¥L¡Ca¡jz'' ehÉ e¡S£−cl a¥L£Ñ−cl fË¢a HC nœ²a¡l
nœ²a¡l ¢i¢š X¡lECeh¡−cl j−dÉC ¢e¢qa B−Rz ehÉ
e¡S£h¡c£−cl hš²−hÉl pjbÑ−e a¥L£Ñ−cl fË¢a nœ²a¡ h¡ Oªe¡ pÇfL£Ña X¡lEC−el ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL
k¤¢š² EfØq¡fe L−lz HC AdÉ¡−ul ®no fªù¡u ehÉ e¡S£−cl fË¢a¢ùa ¢LR¤ C¾V¡l−eV p¡C−V a¥L£Ñ
S¡¢al fË¢a a¡−cl j−e¡i¡h fËL¡n Ll¡ q−u−Rz pÇfТa ehÉ e¡S£−cl a¥L£Ñ Hhw AeÉ¡eÉ Se−N¡¢ùl
fË¢a Evf£se J ¢ef£se p¡wO¡¢aLi¡−h hª¢Ü ®f−u−Rz 2000 p¡−ml 12 BNø a¥L£Ñ ®~c¢eL
Sabah H ehÉ e¡S£−cl à¡l¡ pwO¢Va ¢h¢iæ Bœ²j−el HL¢V a¡¢mL¡ fËL¡n L−lz
THURINGEN l¡−SÉ GERA nq−l ELRAHMAN jp¢S−cl S¡e¡m¡ S¤e j¡−p i¡‰¡
i¡‰¡ quz
Baden Wurttemberg l¡−SÉl EPPingen nq−ll HL¢V a¥L£Ñ jp¢S−cl c¤C¢V Molotov
LL−Vm ¢e−rf Ll¡ quz
Pinneberg Hl Utersen Bh¡¢pL Hm¡L¡u Ah¢Øqa Green MosqueH
H j−m¡Vi LL−Vm
¢e−rf Ll¡ quz Meningen Hl HL¢V a¥L£Ñ−cl Ad§É¢oa hpah¡s£−a A¢NÀ pw−k¡N Ll¡ quz
Bocholt Hl Ah¢Øqa HL¢V a¥L£Ñ L¢g q¡Ep Hhw ®mh¡e−el A¢dh¡p£ Ad§É¢oa hpa h¡s£−a A¢NÀ
pw−k¡N Ll¡ quz 14 Se ®m¡L Bqa qu Hl j−dÉ 01 Se …l²al Bqa quz f§hÑ S¡jÑ¡e nql

44 / 88
 H HL Cl¡L£ f¢lh¡−ll 7j¡p hu−pl ¢nn¤−L j¡¢V−a R¤−s ®gm¡ qu Hhw ¢nö¢V
CHEMNITZ -H
N¤l²ali¡−h Bqa quz
quz
H dl−el eÉ¡LL¡lSeL OVe¡ pÇfТaLL¡−m B−l¡ pwO¢Va q−u−Rz a¥L£Ñ−cl pÇf−LÑ
X¡lEC−el f¤−hÑ¡−õ¢Ma nœ²a¡l ¢hou¢V ehÉ e¡S£−cl ¢cL ¢e−cÑne¡ ¢qp¡−h L¡S L−lz 1992 p¡−ml
e−ið−l MOLN nq−l a¥L£Ñ−cl fË¢a Bœ²je, flha£Ñ−a 1993 p¡−m Solingen nq−l 05 Se
a¥L£Ñ−L ehÉ e¡S£l¡
e¡S£l¡ f¤¢s−u qaÉ¡ L−lz S¡j¡Ñe ¢j¢Xu¡ HC OVe¡−L ¢qVm¡l k¤−Nl flha£Ñ pj−ul
SOeÉaj hZÑh¡c£ qaÉ¡L¡ä ¢qp¡−h BMÉ¡¢ua L−lz flha£Ñ hRl…−m¡−a H dl−el A−eL OVe¡l
Mhl f¡Ju¡ k¡uz a¥L£Ñ−cl h¡s£−a A¢NÀpw−k¡N Ll¡ qu Hhw A−eL a¥L£Ñ−L ¢f¢V−u Bqa Ll¡
quz H R¡s¡ NË£p, qmÉ¡−ä
qmÉ¡−ä H dl−el A¡œ²j−el OVe¡ O−Vz HL¢V OVe¡u a¥L£Ñ j¢qm¡−L 05
p¿¹¡epq qaÉ¡ Ll¡ quz HC OVe¡l SeÉ pwO¢Va ®n¡L ¢j¢R−m Ef¢Øqa hÉ¢š²h−NÑl ¢eLV
ü¢ØaL¡) pq jªa¨Él ýj¢Lpq fœ ®fËlZ Ll¡ quz
“SWASTIKA” (ü¢ØaL¡)

a¥L£Ñ−cl ¢hl²−Ü H dl−el hZÑh¡c£ Bœ²j®el ApwMÉ OVe¡l j−dÉ L−uL¢V j¡œ E−õM Ll¡
q−m¡z X¡lECe Hhw gÉ¡¢ph¡c£ ¢qVm¡−ll Ešl¡¢dL¡l£−cl à¡l¡C H dl−el qaÉ¡ Hhw Bœ²j−el
OVe¡ OV¡−e¡ q−µRz H dl−el Aj¡e¢hL L¡kÑœ²j hå Ll¡l SeÉ BCeNa hÉhØq¡ NÊqe k−bø euz
fËL«a f−r H ph LjÑL¡¾X h¾d Ll¡l SeÉ BCe£ fË¢œ²u¡l f¡n¡f¡¢n HL¢V Bc¢nÑL k¤Ü
Af¢lq¡kÑ
Af¢lq¡kÑz H pjØa Bœ²je¡aÈL LjÑL¡−äl ®q¡a¡l¡ "hZÑh¡c' ®L fË¡L«¢aL BCe ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡
L−le Hhw X¡lECeh¡c ka¢ce fkÑ¿¹ A−~h‘¡¢eL Hhw ¢i¢šq£e ¢qp¡−h a¡−cl L¡−R fËa£uj¡e q−h
aa¢ce Hph LjÑL¡ä Qm−aC b¡L−hz

45 / 88
 4bÑ AdÉ¡u

X¡lECeh¡c x L¢jE¢eø h−hÑ¡−l¡¢Qa BQl−el

BQl−el Evp

¢hwn na¡ë£−a ®k ja¡cnÑ j¡eh S¡¢al SeÉ ph−Q−u hhÑ−l¡¢Qa J r¢aL¡lL ¢qp¡−h
fËj¡¢ea q−u−Rz −kC ja¡c−nÑl e¡j pj¡Sa¿»z Ee¢hwn na¡ë£−a pj¡Sa¿» ®k c¤Se S¡jÑ¡e
c¡nÑ¢eL−cl j¡dÉ−j Hl p−hÑ¡µQ ¢nM−l B−l¡qe L−l, a¡l¡ q−µRe L¡mÑ j¡LÑp J ®éX¡¢lL
H−”mpz HC ja¡cnÑ
ja¡cnÑ fª¢bh£−a Ha lš²f¡a OY~¡u ®k e¡S£ Hhw p¡jÊ¡SÉh¡c£ n¢š²−cl
AaÉ¡Q¡l−LJ a¡ jÔ¡e L−l−Rz HC ja¡cnÑ AN¢ea ¢el£q ®m¡L−L qaÉ¡ L−l−R Hhw Hl j¡dÉ−j
¢hnÄhÉ¡f£ pwO¡a, iu, qa¡n¡ fËQ¡l J fËp¡−ll j¡dÉ−j pjNË j¡ehS¡¢a−L NË¡p L−l−Rz Hje¢L
HMeJ k¢c ®Lq ""®m±q kh¢eL¡''
kh¢eL¡'' J l¡¢nu¡l Lb¡ E−õM L−l aMe Sej−e Hje HL œ¡−pl
pj¡−Sl Lb¡ j−e qu, ®pM¡−e AåL¡l, L¥u¡n¡ Hhw qa¡n¡ SefË¡eq£e l¡Øa¡O¡V, c¤xM-
M-LÖV J HL
iu¡hq f¢l¢Øq¢al Lb¡ j−e L¢l−u ®cuz k¢cJ 1991 p−m l¡¢nu¡−a pj¡Sa−¿»l fae q−u−R
ah¤J Hl dÄwp¡h−no HMeJ ¢hcÉj¡ez Ae¤−j¡ceq£e pj¡Sh¡c£
pj¡Sh¡c£-
j¡Sh¡c£-j¡LÑph¡c£−cl ¢LR¤ hÉ¢š² kaC j¤š²
h¤¢Ü pÇfæ Ssh¡c£ cnÑe Hhw pj¡Sh¡−cl AåL¡l ¢cL HMeJ fkÑ¿¹ SeNe−L fËi¡¢ha Ll−Rz
fËL«af−r HC ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ J ja¡cnÑ j¡eh pj¡S−L djÑq£e Hhw e£¢aq£e ¢qp¡−h fË¢af¡me L−l
Q−m−Rz
HC ja¡cnÑ k¡ fª¢bh£l pLm ®i±N¢mL Hm¡L¡u p¿»¡p J pwO¡−al fËQ¡l J fËp¡l
O¢V−u−R, a¡ fÊL«af−r B¢cL¡−ml HL¢V jah¡−cl fÊ¢a¢e¢daÄL¡l£ ja¡cnÑ à¡¢¾cÄL hØa¤h¡cz H¢V
Hje HL¢V ¢hnÄ¡p k¡ ¢h−hQe¡ L−l ®k, fª¢bh£−a pLm dl−el Eæ¢a h¡ ¢hL¡n q−m¡ à¾cÄ J
pwNË¡−jl gpmz HC ja¡c−nÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£ q−u j¡LÑp Hhw H−”mp fª¢bh£l pLm LjÑL¡ä fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ J
¢h−nÔoe L−lez j¡LÑp c¡h£ L−le, j¡eh S¡¢al C¢aq¡p q−m¡ à¾cÅ pwO¡a J pwNË¡−jl C¢aq¡pz
j¡eh S¡¢al haÑj¡e pjpÉ¡ q−µR nË¢jL−cl p¡−b f¤y¢Sf¢a−cl pwNË¡j h¡ k¤Üz nË¢jL pÇfÐc¡u
A¢Q−lC ¢hfÔ−hl j¡dÉ−j HL¢V p¡jÉh¡c£ pj¡S NWe Ll−hz
AeÉ¡eÉ Ssh¡c£
Ssh¡c£ c¡nÑ¢eL−cl eÉ¡u pj¡Sa−¿»l HC c¤C fË¢aù¡a¡, djÑ pÇf−LÑ HL¢V p¤Ni£l
Oªe¡ ®f¡oe Ll−aez j¡LÑp Hhw H−”mp c¤S−e e¡¢ØaLÉh¡−cl Ae¤p¡l£ ¢R−me Hhw pj¡Sa¿»
fËQ¡−ll SeÉ dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡p Hhw Ae¤n¡pe−L pj¡S −b−L ¢ha¡¢sa Ll¡ HL¢V Af¢lq¡kÑ L¡kÑœ²j
¢qp¡−h a¡l¡ ¢h−hQe¡ Ll−aez
Ll−aez ¢L¿º j¡LÑp J H−”mp Hl H jah¡c fËQ¡−ll ®r−œ HL¢V
…l²aÄf§eÑ O¡V¢a ¢Rm a¡ q−m¡ x ""hÉ¡fL Se−N¡¢ù−L BL«ø Ll¡l SeÉ a¡−cl ja¡cnÑ−L HL¢V
®~h‘¡¢eL l©f ®cJk¡ Hhw ®k iuw|Ll a¡¢šÆL pMÉa¡ J ¢jœa¡ j¡eh S¡¢al SeÉ c¤xM, ®hce¡,
qa¡n¡, c¤cÑn¡, NeqaÉ¡ Hhw ï¡a«O¡¢a k¤−Ül
Ül L¡le OY~¡u Hhw HC jah¡cC ¢hwn na¡ë£l p¡−b
AeÉ pLm pjuL¡−ml f¡bÑLÉ pª¢ø L−lz X¡lECe a¡l Origin of Species hC−a ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ®k
ašÆ EfØq¡fe L−le, j¡LÑp J Hw−Nmp fËLa
« f−r a¡−cl ja¡ja fËL¡−nl SeÉ H dl−el

46 / 88
a−šÆl Ae¤på¡−e ¢R−mez Q¡mÑp X¡lECe c¡h£ L−le ®k, fË−aÉL¢V
−aÉL¢V fË¡e£ ¢V−L b¡L¡l pwNË¡j Abh¡
à¡¢¾cÄL pwNË¡−jl j¡dÉ−j ¢V−L b¡−Lz Efl¿º ¢a¢e (X¡lECe) pª¢ø LaÑ¡l A¢ØaaÄ J pLm fËL¡l
dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡p−L Aü£L¡l L−lez j¡LÑp Hhw H−”mp HC i¡hd¡l¡ ab¡ ja¡cnÑ−L m¤−g ®eez

j¡LpÑ J H−”mp Hl X¡lXCe fË£¢a

pj¡Sa−¿»l fËQ¡l J fËp¡−ll

¡−ll SeÉ X¡lECeh¡−cl Af¢lq¡kÑa¡ S¡e¡ k¡u H hÉ¡f¡−l a¡−cl
j¡LÑp J H−”m−pl fœ¡m¡f −b−Lz X¡lEC−el f§ØaL fËL¡¢na (1859) qJu¡l L−uL j¡−pl
j−dÉC H−‘mp j¡LÑ−pl L¡−R HL f−œ ¢m−Me
""X¡lECe k¡l f¤ØaL (The
( Origin of Species)) B¢j HMe fs¢R a¡ HL Lb¡u Af§hÑ
J QjvL¡lz'' Hl Eš−l j¡LÑp 19 ¢X−pðl 1860 p¡−m H−‘mp−L ¢mM−me; ""HC hC−a
Bj¡−cl ja¡c−nÑl fË¡L«¢aL C¢aq¡−pl j§m p§œ heÑe¡ Ll¡ q−u−Rz''
1861 p¡−ml 16 S¡e¤u¡l£ j¡LÑp a¡l pj¡S¡h¡c£ hå¥ LASSALLE ®L ¢m−Me
"" X¡lEC−el f¤ØaL¢V Bj¡l SeÉ Aa£h …l²aÄfe
§ Ñ L¡le j¡eh C¢aq¡−pl
C¢aq¡−pl ®nËe£ pwNË¡−jl ¢i¢š
ašÅ pð¢ma fË¡L«¢aL ¢h‘¡−el ašÆ H hC−a heÑe¡ Ll¡ q−u−Rz '' H −b−L pj¡Sh¡c£−cl ¢eLV
¢hhaeÑh¡−cl N¤l²aÄ Ae¤d¡he Ll¡ k¡uz
j¡LÑp a¡l ph−Q−u …l²aÄf§eÑ f¤ØaL DAS CAPITAL X¡lEC−el e¡−j EvpNÑ L−l a¡l
fË¢a nËÜ¡ ‘¡fe L−lez HC f¤Øa−Ll fËbj pwØLl−e
pwØLl−e j¡LÑp ¢e−S−L hª¢Vn fËL¢« a¢hc X¡lEC−el
HLSe ""HL¡¿¹ iš²'' (Sincere admirer)) ¢qp¡−h E−õM L−lez
Ae¤l©fi¡−h H−”mp J X¡lEC−el fË¢a a¡l nËÜ¡ hÉš² L−l E−õM L−le ®k, fËL«¢a q−m¡
à¡¢¾cÄL hØa¥h¡−cl L¡kÑ−rœ; a¡C HV¡ AhnÉC p¢WL ®k, ®no fkÑ¿¹ fÊLª¢a à¡¢¾cÄLi¡−hC L¡S L−l
b¡−L −L¡e B¢d−i¡¢~aL pš¡l j¡dÉ−j euz H hÉ¡f¡−l X¡lX~C−el e¡jC AeÉ ph¡l B−NC
E−õM−k¡NÉz
H−‘mp, X¡lECe J j¡LÑp®L pj¡ei¡−h fËnwp¡ L−l h−m−Re ®k, X¡lECe ®kje
S£h¢h‘¡−el ®r−œ ¢hhaÑe¡h¡−cl p§œ B¢h×L¡l L−l−Re, j¡LÑpJ Ae¤l©fi¡−h j¡eh piÉa¡l
C¢aq¡−p ¢hhaÑeh¡c B¢h×L¡l L−l−Rez H−‘mp Hl AeÉ HL¢V ®mM¡u ¢a¢e X¡lEC−el djÑ ¢h−l¡d£
HC jah¡−cl …l²aÄ heÑe¡ L−l E−õM L−le ®k, "" ¢a¢e (X¡lECe) fËL¢« aL ¢hL¡−n BdÉ¡aÈh¡c
ab¡ i¡hh¡c£ jah¡−cl j§−m L¥W¡l¡O¡a L−l−Rez L¡le ¢a¢e fËj¡e L−l−Re, S£h ¢h‘¡−el j¡dÉ−j
N¡R-
N¡R-f¡m¡, fË¡e£ SN−a
SN−a Hhw phÑ−n−o j¡eh S¡¢a fkÑ¿¹ mr mr hR−ll ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fË¢œ²u¡u ¢hL¡n
m¡i L−l−Rz a¡R¡s¡ H−‘mp X¡lEq~−el jah¡c ü£L¡l J pjbÑe L−l “The Part Played by
Labour in the Transition form APE to Man”--n£oÑL fËhå ¢m−Mez
B−j¢lL¡e N−hoL Cornway Zirckle pj¡Sa−¿»l fË¢aù¡a¡−cl
aù¡a¡−cl a¡vr¢eLi¡−h
¢hhaÑeh¡c−L NËqe Ll¡l L¡le E−õM L−l ¢m−M−Re x

47 / 88
 ""j¡LÑp J H−‘mp X¡lEC−el The Origin of Species f¤ØaL¢V fËL¡¢na qh¡l p¡−b
p¡−b ¢hhaÑeh¡c−L pjbÑe Ll−a b¡−Lez pj¡Sa−¿»l fË¢aù¡a¡l¡ Hje HL¢V jah¡−cl Ae¤på¡−e
¢R−me k¡ j¡ehS¡¢al pª¢ø−a ®L¡e A−m±¢LL
A−m±¢LL n¢š²l A¢ØaaÄ Aü£L¡l L−lz ¢hhaÑeh¡c a¡−cl SeÉ
HY~¡C plhl¡q L−l, k¡ a¡−cl hØa¤h¡c£ cnÑ−el ¢i¢šl ¢p¢s hÉ¡MÉ¡l ¢qp¡−h hÉhq¡l Ll¡ k¡uz
a¡R¡s¡ X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl hÉ¡MÉ¡ AbÑ¡v ¢hhaÑe ""fË
""fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Q−el'' j¡dÉ−j pwO¢Va q−u−R,
k¡ pj¡Sh¡c£−cl HL¢V ¢hLÒf fËf’ h¡ jah¡c k¡ ¢hcÉj¡e pLm fËL¡l S£h−el ¢hL¡−nl E−ŸnÉ
kb¡kbi¡−h hÉ¡MÉ¡ L−lz
Harper’s Magazine Hl Tom Bethell j¡LÑph¡−cl p¡−b X¡lECeh¡−cl ®j¡~¢mL pw−k¡N
¢e−jÀ¡š² i¡o¡u fËL¡n L−l−Re "" j¡LÑp ®L¡e AbÑ®e
~ ¢aL L¡l−e X¡lEC−el f¤Øa−Ll Ae¤l¡N£ h¡
iš² ¢R−me e¡ hlw Hl j§m L¡le q−µR X¡lX~Ce ®k ¢hnÄ cª¢øi‰£ fËL¡n L−le a¡ pÇf§eÑl©−f
hØa¤h¡c£ Hhw H hÉ¡MÉ¡l j−dÉ ®L¡e AcªnÉ A−~Sh h¡ BdÉ¡¢aÈL pšÆ¡l h¡C−l ®L¡e ¢LR¤lA¢Øa−aÄl
ü£L«¢a e¡Cz H …l²aÄf§ZÑ ¢cL ¢h−hQe¡ L−l X¡lECe J j¡LÑp AhnÉC flØf−ll hå¥ J pq−k¡N£z
haÑj¡−e X¡lECeh¡c
X¡lECeh¡c J j¡LÑph¡−cl jdÉL¡l ¢j−ml ¢hou¢V HL¢V phÑSe¢h¢ca paÉ ¢qp¡−h
¢h−h¢Qaz L¡mÑ j¡LÑ−pl S£he£ NÊ−¿Û H ¢jm pÇf−LÑ k¡ hm¡ q−u−R, a¡ Ec¡qle ¢qp¡−h E−õM Ll¡
®k−a f¡−l, ""X¡lECeh¡c fËL«af−r Hje HL¢V p§œ NË¢¿Û, k¡l SeÉ j¡LÑph¡−cl pjbÑ−e pLm
fËL¡l abÉ J fËj¡e¡¢c ¢e¢qa
¢e¢qa B−Rz X¡lEC−el ¢hhÑaeh¡−cl hÉ¡fL fËQ¡l J fËp¡l j¡LÑph¡c£
cnÑ−el SeÉ HL¢V
HL¢V EhÑl ®rœ ¢qp¡−h L¡S L−l Hhw nË¢jL ®nËe£l hÉ¡fL pjbÑe ®f−a p¡q¡kÉ
L−lz j¡LÑp H−‘mp J ®m¢ee, X¡lEC−el jah¡c−L pj¢dL …l²aÄ fËc¡e L−le Hhw Hl ¢h¢iæ
®~h‘¡¢eL …l²aÄ a¥−m d−lez Hi¡−h Eiu jah¡c
jah¡c fËQ¡l fË¢œ²u¡ aÄl¡¢eÄa Ll−a flØfl flØfl−L
pq¡ua¡ L−lz
Bjl¡ S¡¢e j¡LÑp J H−‘mp X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ k¡ HL¢V e¡¢ØaLÉh¡c£ ¢hnÄ cª¢ø
i‰£l ®~h‘¡¢eL pjbÑec¡eL¡l£ jah¡c ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ L−l M¤hC Be¾c ®f−aez ¢L¿º H dl−el
Be¾c ¢Rm Apj−u¡¢Qaz L¡le H jah¡c Ee¢hwn na−L fËQ¡l m¡i L−l kMe ¢h‘¡e Hje HL
B¢cj fkÑ¡−u ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rmz ¢h¢iæ i¤mï¡¢¿¹ J ®~h‘¡¢eL fËj¡e¡¢cl k−bø Ai¡h f¢lm¢ra q−a¡z
¢hwn na¡ë£l ¢àa£u¡−dÑ ¢h¢iæ ®~h‘¡¢eL N−hoe¡l Eæ¢a p¡¢da qu Hhw −~h‘¡¢eL fÜ¢a−a
X¡lX~Ceh¡−cl i¥mï¡¢¿¹J AL¡kÑLl fËj¡¢Za quz AbÑ¡v L¢jE¢eø
L¢jE¢eø J hØa¥h¡c£ ja¡c−nÑl fa−el
p¡−b p¡−b X¡lEq~eh¡−cl fae O−Vz p¢WL S¡e¡l SeÉ fs¤e (The
( Evolution Deceit By
Harun Yahya)zz ®k−qa¥ hØa¤h¡c£ J Ssh¡c£ c¡nÑ¢eL J ¢Q¿¹¡¢hcl¡ S¡e−ae ®k, X¡lECeh¡−cl
a¡−cl
fae, dÄwp h¡ AL¡kÑLl h¡ A®~h‘¡¢eL ¢qp¡−h fËj¡¢ea qJu¡l p¡−b p¡−b a ¡−cl jah¡c j¡eh
S¡¢al L¡−R hÉbÑ ¢qp¡−h fkÑh¢pa q−h H ¢h−hQe¡u a¡l¡ Bd§¢eL ¢h‘¡e N−hoe¡l gm¡gm kac¤l
pñh ®N¡fe Ll¡l ®Qø¡ L−lez

48 / 88
 j¡LÑp, H−”mp Hl Ae¤p¡l£−cl X¡lECe fË£¢a

j¡LÑp J H−‘mp Hl Ae¤p¡l£Ne k¡l¡ mr mr ®m¡L−L qaÉ¡ L−l−R BlJ mr ®L¡¢V

j¡e¤−ol SeÉ pwO¡a
pwO¡a iu J ®hce¡l L¡le ¢qp¡−h O¢V−u−Re,
O¢V−u−Re, a¡l¡ AaÉ¿¹ Be¾c J BNË−ql
p¡−b X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡c pjbÑe J pj¡−S L¡kÑLl L−l−Rez −p¡¢i−ua l¡¢nu¡l −ea«h¾c j¡LÑp J
H−‘m−pl e£¢a h¡Øah¡¢ua L−l¢R−me a¡−cl p¡−b ¢hhaÑeh¡c£−cl pw−k¡N h¡ BcnÑNa ¢j−ml
¢ho−u John More ¢m−M−Re "" ®p¡¢i−ua l¡¢nu¡l ®ea«hª−¾cl ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l p¡−b ¢hhaÑeh¡c£−cl
ja¡c−nÑl Ni£l ¢jm mrÉ Ll¡ k¡uz
j¡LÑ−pl pj¡Sa−¿»l fËLÒf ®m¢eeC l¡¢nu¡u h¡Øah¡ue L−lez L¢jE¢eø hm−n¢iL
B−¾c¡m−el ®ea¡ ®m¢ee pnØœ ¢hfÔ−hl j¡dÉ−j l¡¢nu¡ S¡la−¿»l Ahp¡e OV¡ez fËbj jq¡k¤−Ül
X¡j¡−X¡−ml fl
fl hm−n¢iLl¡ ®k dl−el p¤−k¡N My¤S¢Rm a¡ ®f−u k¡uz 1917 p¡−ml A−ƒ¡h−l
®m¢e−el ®ea«®aÄ L¢jE¢eS−jl Ae¤p¡l£l¡ l¡¢nu¡u rja¡ cMm L−lz ¢hfÔ−hl fl l¡¢nu¡k 03
hvpl hÉ¡f£ L¢jE¢eø J S¡lf¿Û£−cl j−dÉ HL lš²¡š² Nªq k¤−Ül p§Qe¡ quz
AeÉ¡eÉ L¢jE¢eø ®ea¡−cl eÉ¡u ®m¢eeJ hØa¤
hØa¤h¡c£ cnÑ−e X¡lEC−el jah¡c−L ¢i¢š i¥¢j
¢qp¡−h AaÉ¿¹ …l²−aÄl p¡−b E−õM L−lez X¡lEC~eh¡−cl fË¢a ®m¢e−el cª¢ø i‰£ a¡l HL
hš²−hÉ fËL¡n f¡u k¡ ¢ejÀl©f, ""X¡lECe HC ¢hnÄ¡−pl Ahp¡e O¢V−u−Re ®k fË¡e£ J E¢áa
SN−al j−dÉ ®L¡e pÇfLÑ e¡Cz öd¤j¡œ a¡ "" ®~ch¡v'' pª¢ø q−u−R
q−u−R Hhw a¡ ‰~nÄl La«ÑL pª¢ø Ll¡
q−u−R Hhw k¡ Af¢lhaÑe£u AbÑ¡v ®L¡e Ahc¡e h¡ A¢ØaaÄ X¡lECe Aü£L¡l L−l−Rez ®m¢e−el
f−l hm−n¢iL ®ea¡−cl j−dÉ ph−Q−u ¢k¢e ANËNeÉ ¢R−me a¡l e¡j ¢Rm VÊV¢ú ¢a¢eJ
X¡lECeh¡c−L AaÉ¿¹ …l²aÄ ¢c−aez ¢a¢e X¡lECeh¡−cl fË¢a a¡l Ae¤l¡N ¢e−jÀ
¢e−jÀ¡š² i¡o¡u fËL¡n
L−l−Re,
¢hSuz''1924
"" ®~Sh fc¡−bÑl j−dÉ à¡¢¾àL hØa¥h¡−cl B¢h×L¡l q−µR X¡lEC−el phÑ−nËù ¢hSuz''1924
p¡−m ®m¢e−el jªa¤Él fl L¢jE¢eø f¡¢Y~l ®ea«aÄ fª¢bh£l C¢aq¡−pl L¥MÉ¡a lš² ®m¡m¤f
−~üla¡¢¿»L−cl HLSe Stalin Hl q¡−a eÉØa quz a¡l 30 hRl rja¡ b¡L¡L¡m£e pj−u ¢ecÑu
L¢jE¢eø ja¡cnÑ h¡Øah¡ueL¡l£ ®ea«−aÄl k¡ qJu¡ E¢Qa, ®p¢VC fËj¡−el SeÉ phÑ¡aÈL fË−Qø¡
Q¡m¡−e¡ quz øÉ¡¢m−el fÊbj N¤l²aÄf§eÑ L¡S ¢Rm l¡¢nu¡l 80 % L«¢oS£¢h−cl S¢j l¡øÊ£uLlez
hÉ¢š²Na j¡¢mL¡e¡l Aü£L«¢al e£¢a Q¡m¤Ll−el e¡−j pjØa gpm l¡øÊ£u ¢eu¿»−e ¢e−u
¢e−u Bp¡ qu
Hhw a¡ l¡øÊ£u pnØœ LjÑLaÑ¡−cl j¡dÉ−j f¢lQ¡me¡ J ¢eu¢¿»a quz g−m HL iu¡hq c§¢iÑr
®cM¡ ®cuz mr mr −m¡L, j¢qm¡, ¢nö J hªÜl¡ HC c¤¢iÑ−r e¡ ®M−u jªaÉ¥ j¤−M f¢aa quz
öd¤j¡œ L−Ln¡p A’®mC jª−al pwMÉ¡ ¢Rm cn mrz
øÉ¡¢m−el e£¢a h¡Øah¡u−e h¡d¡ c¡eL¡l£ q¡S¡l
q¡S¡l q¡S¡l ®m¡L−L øÉ¡¢me p¡C−h¢lu¡u iu¡hq
nËj ¢n¢h−l ®fËle L−lez H pjØa nËj ¢n¢hl ¢Rm fËL«af−r ®SmM¡e¡z HM¡−e L¡S Ll−a Ll−a
A¢dL¡wn ®m¡LC j¡l¡ ®kaz g−m H ¢n¢hl…−m¡ h¾c£−cl ®N¡lØq¡e ¢qp¡−h f¢lN¢Za qaz AeÉ¢c−L
øÉ¡¢m−el N¤ç f¤¢m−nl q¡−a mr mr ®m¡L ¢eù¥li¡−h ¢eqa
¢eqa quz

49 / 88
 ¢œ²¢ju¡h¡p£ J a¥L£Ñpq mr mr hÉ¢š²−L l¡¢nu¡l c§laj Hm¡L¡u ®cn¡¿¹−l h¡dÉ Ll¡ quz
øÉ¡¢m−el H dl−el lš²¡š² L¡kÑœ²j h¡Øah¡ue fË¢œ²u¡u 20 ¢j¢mue −m¡L−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡ quz
I¢aq¡¢pLNe E−õM L−l−Re ®k H dl−el ¢eù¥l LjÑL¡−ä ¢a¢e fÊQ¥l Be¾c ®f−aez hm¡ q−u
b¡−L øÉ¡¢me
øÉ¡¢me a¡l ®œ²j¢m−el l¡SfË¡p¡−c h−p Le−p−¾VÊne LÉ¡−Çfl jªa hÉ¢š² h¡ ¢eqa hÉ¢š²−cl
a¡¢mL¡ ®c−M M¤h M¤¢n q−aez a¡l H dl−el ¢hL«a j¡e¢pLa¡ R¡s¡J Ssh¡c£ cnÑ−el Efl
¢hnÄ¡−pl fËi¡hC a¡−L ¢ejÑj M¤e£−a f¢lea L−l¢Rmz øÉ¡¢m−el ¢e−Sl i¡o¡u H cnÑ−el
(L¢jE¢eSj ja¡cnÑ ) j§m ¢i¢š q−m¡ - X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡cz X¡lECeh¡−cl …l²aÄ pÇf−LÑ
¢a¢e ¢m−M−Re x ""®L¡e lLj ¢hï¡¢¿¹ h¡ ¢àd¡ à¾cÄ R¡s¡C Bjl¡ ¢ei¤Ñmi¡−h ¢hcÉ¡m−ul R¡œ−cl
¢ae¢V ¢hou ¢nr¡ ¢c−a Q¡C a¡ q−m¡-
q−m¡- fª¢bh£l hup, i¨a¡¢šÆL pª¢ø ašÆ J X¡lEC−el ja¡cnÑ
ab¡ ¢hhaÑeh¡c ''
øÉ¡¢m−el
øÉ¡¢m−el S£¢ha b¡L¡L¡m£e pj−u a¡l HL h¡mÉh¾d¤ G Glurdhdze a¡l e¡¢ØaL qJu¡l
OVe¡ heÑe¡ L−l HL¢V f¤ØaL lQe¡ L−le Land Marks in the Life of Stalin –H
H f¤Øa−L ¢a¢e
¢m−M−Re,
®~nn−h ¢a¢e (øÉ¡¢me) kMe N£SÑ¡l ØL¥−m fs¡öe¡ Ll−aez ¢a¢e ¢hâ²f¡aÈL ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ J
¢h−nÔoedj£Ñ
edj£Ñ ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l A¢dL¡l£ ¢R−mez flha£Ñ−a ¢a¢e Q¡mÑp X¡lEC−el f¤ØaL fs¡ öl² Ll−me
Hhw HLSe e¡¢ØaL q−u ®N−mez'' HC f¤Øa−L ®mML X~−õM L−l−Re ®k, "" øÉ¡¢m−el ‰~nÄ−l
A¢hnÄ¡−pl L¡le ¢a¢e ¢e−SC ®mML−L h−m−Re, a¡ q−m¡ X¡lX~C−el f¤ØaLz øÉ¡¢me HC
−mML−L X¡lEC−el HL¢V f¤ØaL Efq¡l ®ce Hhw a¡ fs¡l SeÉ h¡mÉhå¥−L Q¡fJ fË−k¡N
L−lez''
øÉ¡¢m−el X¡lECe¡−cl fË¢a Aå ¢hnÄ¡−pl HL¢V …l²aÄf§eÑ ¢ecnÑe q−m¡ ¢a¢e rja¡u
B−l¡q−el fl l¡¢nu¡l ¢nr¡ hÉhØq¡ ab¡ f¡W p§Q£ −b−L Mendel S¡¢aNa a−šÆl l¡øÊ£u
Aü£L«¢a ab¡ h¢q×L¡lz E−õMÉ H jah¡c ¢hwn
¢hwn na¡ë£−a ¢h‘¡e SN−a phÑSe ü£L«a jah¡c
¢qp¡−h Nªq£a quz HC ®~h‘¡¢eL jah¡−c Lamark Hl jah¡c ®L¡e fË¡e£l A¢SÑa Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢nøÉ
pj§q flha£Ñ fËS¾j Ešl¡¢dL¡l p§−œ A¡aÈfËL¡n h¡ ¢hL¡n m¡i L−lz E−õMÉ, ¢hwn na−Ll fËbj
¢cL −b−L ¢h−nÄl ¢h‘¡e SNa Lamark Hl jah¡c h¡¢am ¢qp¡−h ®O¡oe¡ L−l MendeL Hl
jah¡c NÊqe L−l−Rz l¡¢nu¡e ®~h‘¡¢eL Lysenko fkÑ−hre L−le ®k, Mendel Hl jah¡c
X¡lECeh¡−cl Efl HL¢V ¢hl¡V BO¡a AbÑ¡v X¡lECeh¡−cl HL¢V ¢hl¡V c§hÑma¡ a¥−m d−lz
¢hou¢V ¢a¢e øÉ¡¢me−L Ah¢qa L−lez øÉ¡¢me l¡¢nu¡e I ®~h‘¡¢e−Ll i¡hd¡l¡u
i¡hd¡l¡u AaÉ¿¹ QjL«a qe
Hhw a¡−L l¡¢nu¡l ¢h‘¡e f¢lo−cl fËd¡e ¢qp¡−h ¢e−u¡N fËc¡e L−lez a¡C Mendel Hl
fËS¡¢aNa ašÆ øÉ¡¢m−el jªa¥ÉfkÑ¿¹ l¡¢nu¡l ®L¡e ®~h‘¡¢eL N−hoe¡ h¡ ØL¥m L−m−S NÊqe Ll¡
qu¢ez øÉ¡¢m−el n¡pe¡j−m l¡¢nu¡ HL¢V œ¡−pl l¡S−aÄ f¢lZa quz mr mr ®®m¡L
m¡L Baw−Ll
j−dÉ hph¡p Ll−a b¡−Lz ¢elfl¡d£ qJu¡ p−šÆJ ®k ®L¡e hÉ¢š² ®k ®L¡e pj−u −cn¡¿¹l h¡

50 / 88
ALÒfe£u n¡¢Øal ¢nL¡l qJu¡l i−u, i£a −b−L ¢ce k¡fe Ll−a b¡−Lz öd¤j¡œ L¢jE¢eø eu,
gÉ¡¢ph¡−cl C¢aq¡−pJ HLC dl−el ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ J a¡l h¡Øah¡ue ®cM−a f¡Ju¡ k¡uz
HV¡ HL¢V ¢Øql ¢e¢ÕQa paÉ ®k, ®m¢ee, øÉ¡¢me, j¡J−p¤a¥w, ¢qVm¡l J j¤−p¡¢me£l eÉ¡u lš²
®m¡m¤f ®ea«hª¾c J a¡−cl ja¡cnÑ HL¢V j¡œ Evp −b−L Evp¡¢laz k¢cJ a¡−cl ¢fR−e AeÉ
HL¢V ®c¡o£ frJ l−u−Rz k¡ ®q¡L H ®ea¡−cl H dl−el i¡lp¡jÉq£e J Aj¡e¢hL BQlZ Hhw ®k
L¡l−e Hl¡ j¡eha¡l ¢hl©−Ü
¢hl©−Ü Afl¡d pwNW−el SeÉ c¡u£ ®pV¡ HL¢V Bf¡ax ®~h‘¡¢eL k¤¢š² J
pjbÑe a¡−cl k¤¢N−u−R a¡ q−m¡ Ss h¡ hØa¥h¡c£ cnÑe J X¡lECeh¡cz

j¡J−pa¥w x X¡lECe J L¡mÑ j¡LÑp Hl Q£e¡ c§a

l¡¢nu¡u øÉ¡¢me kMe ®~üln¡pL ¢qp¡−h l¡ÖYÊ~k¿» f¢lQ¡me¡ Ll¢R−me aMe Q£−e
X¡lECeh¡−cl ja¡c−nÑ
ja¡c−nÑ AeÉ HL¢V L¢jE¢eø l¡øÊ fË¢a¢ùa quz c£OÑ Nªq k¤−Ül fl 1949 p¡−m
j¡J−pa¥w Hl ®ea«−aÄ Q£e¡ L¢jE¢eøl¡ rja¡ cMm L−lz j¡J−pa¥w l¡¢nu¡l Bc−m HLC dl−el
¢ef£sej§mL HL¢V l¡øÊk¿» N−s ®a¡−mez j¡J®pa¥w Hl LjÑL¡−ä øÉ¡¢me hÉ¡fL pjbÑe fËc¡e
L−lez Q£e ApwMÉ qaÉ¡k−‘l HL¢V
HL¢V hdÉi¨¢j ¢qp¡−h BaÈfËL¡n L−lz flha£Ñ hRl pj§−q
j¡J−pa¥w Hl k¤hL pqLj£Ñl¡ k¡l¡ Red Guard ¢qp¡−h f¢l¢Q¢a m¡i L−l, a¡l¡
a¡l¡ Q£e−L HL¢V
œ¡−pl l¡S−aÄ f¢lea L−lz j¡J, Q£−e ®k l¡S®~e¢aL cnÑ−el j¡dÉ−j l¡øÊk¿» NWe L−le ®p pÇf−LÑ
fËL¡nÉ ®O¡oe¡u h−me,
""Q£e¡ pj¡Sa¿»
pj¡Sa¿» X¡lX~CeJ a¡l ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl Ef−l fË¢a¢ùaz j¡J hÉ¢š²Nai¡−h j¡LÑph¡c£,
e¡¢ØaL J ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl fË¢a Ni£l fËaÉu£ ¢R−mez Great Leap Forward B−¾c¡m−el fËbj
¢c−L j¡J−pa¥w , X¡lECeh¡c Hhw Hl pjbÑ−e ¢m¢Ma f¤ØaL, fËhå J fËL¡ne¡ Q£e¡ ¢nr¡
hÉhØq¡u h¡dÉa¡j§mL ¢qp¡−h ®O¡oe¡
®O¡oe¡ L−lez
Q£e¡ L¢jE¢eøl¡ rja¡u B−l¡q−el fl ¢hhaÑeh¡c−L a¡−cl ja¡c−nÑl ¢i¢š ¢qp¡−h NÊqe
L−lz k¢cJ fËL«af−r Hl hýf§hÑ −b−LC Q£e¡ h¤¢ÜS£¢hNe H ja¡cnÑ NÐqe L−l¢R−mez Ee¢hwn
na−L Q£e pÇf−LÑ f¡ÕQ¡−aÉ d¡le¡ ¢Rm H¢V q−m¡ HL¢V ""O¤j¿¹ ®~caÉ, ¢h¢µRæ J fË¡Q£e p¡wØL«¢aL
¢aL
L¥pwØL¡−l ¢hnÄ¡p£ HL¢V S¡¢az'' H pj®u M¤h Lj pwMÉL CE−l¡f£u d¡le¡ Ll−a prj
q−u¢R−me, ®k Q£e¡ h¤¢ÜS£¢hNe A¢a hÉNËi¡−h X¡lX~Ceh¡c£ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ a−šÆl fË¢a BNËq£ q−u a¡
HL¢V Bn¡hÉ”L fËN¢an£m J f¢lhaÑ−el fËd¡e Q¡¢mL¡ n¢š² ¢qp¡−h hÉhq¡l Ll−a prj q−a
f¡−lz Q£e¡
Q£e¡ ®mML Hu Shith (Living Philosopies,1931) ¢m−M−Re ®k, 1898 p¡−m kMe
Thomas Huxley Hl f§ØaL Evolution And Ethics fËL¡¢na q−m¡, HV¡ a¡vr¢eLi¡−h Q£e¡
h¤¢ÜS£¢hN−el fËnwp¡ J NÊqe−k¡NÉa¡ m¡i Llmz de£ hÉ¢š²l¡ Hq~ hC−ul p¤mi pwØLle ®hl
Ll−m¡ k¡−a p¡d¡lZ ®m¡−Ll L¡−R a¡ a¡s¡a¡¢s ®f±R¡−e¡ pñh quz
HC Q£e¡ h¤¢ÜS£¢hl¡C pj¡Sa−¿»l fË¢a BL«ø qe J ¢hfÔ−h ®ea«aÄ fËc¡e L−lez Hl¡
X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ a−šÅl pjbÑL ¢R−mez Q£e ®c−nl HL¢V phÑ−nÄlh¡c£ cnÑe J C¢aq¡p b¡L¡

51 / 88
 a¡−cl
p−šÆJ a¡−cl f−r X¡lECeh¡c£ J pj¡Sa−¿»l fË¢a BL«ø qJu¡u a¡ a¡ −cl SeÉ ®L¡e dl−el
fË¢ahåL ¢qp¡−h ®cM¡ ®cu ¢ez New Scientist f¢œL¡u HL¢V fËh−å HLSe L¡e¡X£u X¡lECeh¡c£
c¡nÑ¢eL Michael Ruse, ¢hwn na−Ll fËbj ¢cLL¡l Q£e¡ f¢l¢Øq¢a pÇf−LÑ ¢m−M−Re,
"" H pLm i¡hd¡l¡ Q£e−c−n a¡vr¢eLi¡−h a¡l ¢nLs Ns−a prj q−m¡z f¡ÕQ¡−aÉ
¢hhaÑ
¢hhaÑeh¡−cl fË¢a ®k p¡j¡¢SL ¢h¢d¢e−od ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rmz Q£−el ¢Q¿¹¡ J djÑ ¢hnÄ¡−pl −r−œ H
dl−el ®L¡e fË¢ahåLa¡ ¢Rm e¡z ¢LR¤ ¢LR¤ ®r−œ X¡lECeh¡c−L Q£e¡ ¢qp¡−hC A¢i¢qa Ll¡ k¡uz
a¡J h¡c£(Taoists)
h¡c£ J ehÉ Le¢gE¢pu¡e djÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£ ""j¡e¤o−L'' HL dl−el fc¡bÑ (Thingness)
¢qp¡−hC heÑe¡ Ll¡ q−u−Rz a¡C Bj¡−cl (X¡lECeh¡c£−cl) j¡e¤o−L ""Eæa fË¡e£ '' qJu¡l
ja¡cnÑ¢V Q£e¡−cl SeÉ ®L¡e hs dl−el ""nL'' ¢qp¡−h ®cM¡ ®cu¢ez''
haÑj¡−e Q£−el l¡øÊ£u l¡S®~e¢aL e£¢a ¢qp¡−h HL dl−el j¡LÑph¡c J ®m¢eeh¡c ¢qp¡−h
®O¡oe¡ Ll¡ q−u−Rz ¢L¿º X¡lECeh¡−cl
X¡lECeh¡−cl hØa¥h¡c£ djÑ ¢el−fr ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ ( p¡d¡lZ p¡j¡¢SL cnÑe)
k¡ j¡J−pa¥w J a¡l ¢hfÔh£ Ae¤p¡l£l¡ ASÑe L−l¢R−me HlC gpm haÑj¡−e f¡Ju¡ k¡−µRz
Michael Ruse Hl Ef−l¡š² j¿¹hÉ Ae¤k¡u£ X¡lECeh¡−cl Ni£l ¢nL−sl Ef¢Øq¢al L¡l−e
Q£−e pq−SC pj¡Sa¿» L¡−uj Ll¡ pñh q−u−Rz Q£e¡
Q£e¡ SeNe X¡lECeh¡−cl à¡l¡ fËa¡¢la q−u
j¡J−pa¥w Hl fr¡mðe L−l a¡l e¡lL£u qaÉ¡k−‘l p¡r£ q−u−Rez
pj¡Sa¿» fª¢bh£l ¢h¢iæ ®c−n ®N¢lm¡ k¤Ü, lš²¡š² p¿»¡ph¡c, Nªqk¤Ü J pwO¡−al L¡le
¢qp¡−h BaÈfËL¡n L−l−Rz a¥lúJ a¡l j−dÉ HL¢Vz1960 Hhw 1970 Hl cn−L ¢h¢iæ N˲f
pnØœ pwNË
pwNË¡−jl j¡dÉ−j a¥l−ØL pj¡Sa−¿»l AåL¡l ¢h¢io£L¡ju AdÉ¡u pª¢ø Ll−a fËu¡p£
q−u¢Rmz 1980 p¡−ml fl L¢jE¢eø p¿»¡p£l¡ haÑj¡e ¢h¢µRea¡h¡c£−cl p¡−b q¡a ¢j¢m−u q¡S¡l
q¡S¡l ®m¡−Ll qaÉ¡l L¡le OY~¡uz H−a hý LaÑhÉla f¤¢mn J ®pe¡h¡¢qe£l pcpÉJ jªa¨ÉhlZ
L−lez
L¢jE¢eø ja¡cnÑ
ja¡cnÑ J X¡lX~Ceh¡c HLC pja¡−m 150 hRl d−l fª¢bh£−a lš²f¡a
O¢V−u−Rz Hje¢L haÑj¡−eJ L¢jE¢eSj, X¡lECeh¡−cl ph−Q−u hs pjbÑLz fª¢bh£l ®k ®L¡e ®c−n
k¡l¡C ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl pjbÑL a¡−cl fËbj p¡¢l−a ph pju pj¡Sh¡c£−clC ®cM−a f¡Ju¡ k¡uz L¡le
L¡mÑ j¡LÑp h−m−Re L¢jE¢eø ja¡c−nÑ
ja¡c−nÑl ¢i¢š i¨¢j−a l−u−R ¢hhaÑeh¡cz HV¡ fË¡Lª¢aL ¢h‘¡e J
e¡¢ØaLÉh¡−cl pjbÑ−e HL dl−el ¢jbÉ¡ ®~h‘¡¢eL pjbÑe ®k¡N¡uz

X¡lECeh¡c J pj¡Sa−¿»l ¢jœa¡l ¢i¢š x d−jÑl fË¢a Ni£l Oªe¡

Ssh¡c£ J L¢jE¢eø−cl, X¡lEq~eh¡−cl fË¢a ByL−s d−l b¡L¡l fËd¡e L¡le q−µR
e¡¢ØaLÉh¡−cl fË¢a pjbÑez Ssh¡c£ cnÑ−el C¢aq¡−pl pLm k¤−NC ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rmz Ee¢hwn naL
fkÑ¿¹ c¡nÑ¢eL−cl H ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ f¤Øa−Ll j−dÉC p£j¡hÜ ¢Rmz L¡le aMe fkÑ¿¹ A¢dL¡wn ®~h‘¡¢eLC
d−jÑ BØq¡n£m J pËø¡l A¢Øa−aÄ ¢hnÄ¡p£ ¢R−mez ¢Lǹ Ee¢hwn na−L fË¡L«¢aL ¢h‘¡e Ssh¡c£
cnÑe J ¢hhaÑeh¡c£
h¡c£ jah¡c je¤oÉ pj¡−S h¡Øah¡¢ua Ll¡ q−m¡z X~e¢hwn na−L X¡lECeh¡c,

52 / 88
djÑq£e Ssh¡c£ p¡wØL«¢aL ¢i¢š a¡l i¨¢jL¡ l¡M−a öl² L−l k¡l L¥gm ¢hwn na¡ë£−a f§eÑi¡−h
BaÈfËL¡n Ll−a b¡−Lz
HC Ss cnÑ−el gpm ¢qp¡−h ®k hØa¥h¡c£ pwØL«¢a N−s E−W HY~¡C fÊL«af−r c¤C¢V
jq¡k¤−Ül B…e fË‹Æ¢ma L−l, Hhw AN¢ea Nªq k¤Ü, p¿»¡ph¡c, NZqaÉ¡, NZ¢e¢ÕQq²Lle J q¡S¡l
q¡S¡l hhÑ−l¡¢Qa LjÑL¡−äl pËø¡ ¢qp¡−h L¡S L−lz HC dÄwp k−‘ ®L¡¢V ®L¡¢V −m¡L−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡
quz mr mr −m¡L−L ¢emÑ‹ÆSeLi¡−h ¢ekÑ¡ae, ¢eNÊq J SOeÉ BQl−el ¢nL¡l q−a quz ""
p¿»¡p£l¡ X¡lECeh¡−cl Ssh¡c£ cnÑ−el fËi¡−h q−u fËi¡¢ha ¢e−S−cl−L fn¤l AdxØae f¤l²o
¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ L−l f¡q¡s fhÑ−a j¡e−hal S£he k¡f−e Evp¡q£ q−u E−Wz ®L¡e lLj ¢àa£u
¢Q¿¹¡ e¡ L−l j¤ý−aÑl j−dÉ ¢elfl¡d ¢nö, j¢qm¡ J hªÜ−L M¤e Ll−a ¢àd¡ L−le¡z a¡l¡ e¡
¢e−S−cl pÇf−LÑ, e¡ AeÉ ®L¡e ®m¡L−L
®m¡L−L pª¢øLaÑ¡l phÑ−nËù pª¢ø-
ø- j¡e¤o−L je, BaÈ¡, ¢h−hL,
h¤¢Ühª¢š pÇfæ fË¡e£ h−m NeÉ L−l e¡ hlw HL¢V ¢qwpË fË¡e£, AeÉ fË¡e£l p¡−b ®kl©f BQle
L−l a¡l¡J Ae¤l©f BQle Ll−a b¡−Lz øÉ¡¢m−el ¢e¢hÑQ¡−l XSe XSe Q¡QÑ J jp¢Sc d¤¢mp¡v
Ll¡l OVe¡l j¡dÉ−j L¢jE¢eø−cl d−jÑl fË
fË¢a Ae£q¡l HL¢V Ec¡qle ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ k¡uz
The Long War Against God Hl ®mML Henry Morris ®M¡c¡−â¡q£a¡l p¡−b
X¡lECeh¡−cl ¢jm ab¡ pw−k¡N pÇf−LÑ h−me ®k, X¡lECeh¡−cl ¢LR¤ ®~h‘¡¢eL O¡V¢a J c¤hÑma¡
b¡L¡ p−šÆJ HC jah¡®c L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢n−øÉl L¡l−e
L¡l−e HV¡ ph dl−el djÑ−cÊ¡q£ fÜ¢a
J pwØL¡l−L Evp¡¢qa Ll¡l pjbÑe ®k¡N¡uz Hl j−dÉ pj¡Sa¡¢¿»L jah¡c ph−Q−u E−õM−k¡NÉ
p¡gmÉ ASÑe L−lz
¢hnÄ
¢hnÄhÉ¡f£ L¢jE¢eøl¡ fËa¡¢la q−u ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−a b¡−Le ®k, HY~¡ AhnÉC paÉz L¡le
L¢jE¢eø jah¡c ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl Efl fË¢a¢ùaz ""pj¡Sa¡¢¿»L jah¡c J Ssh¡c£ cnÑ−el p¡−b d−jÑl
¢h−l¡d hm−n¢iL ¢hfÔ−hl pju Qlj BL¡l d¡le L−lz N£SÑ¡ J jp¢Sc dÄwpØa¥−f f¢lea Ll¡
quz'' ea¥e pj¡Sa¡¢¿»L pj¡ShÉhØq¡ ®b−L k¡−cl h¡C−l l¡M¡ qu dj£Ñu hÉ¢š²aÄ a¡−cl j−dÉ
a¡−cl−L
AeÉajz k¢cJ pLm pj¡−SC djÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£ ®m¡−Ll A¢ØaaÄ b¡−Lz a¡− cl−L dj£Ñu L¡−S h¡d¡ fËc¡e
Ll¡ quz R¤¢Vl ¢ce ¢qp¡−h l¢hh¡l−L h¡¢am Ll¡ quz L¡le l¢hh¡l Mªø¡e−cl Ef¡pe¡l SeÉ
¢edÑ¡¢laz p¡d¡lZ R¤¢Vl d¡le¡ h¡c ®cJu¡ quz ph¡q~−L pç¡−q fy¡Q ¢ce L¡S Ll¡ h¡dÉa¡j§mL Ll¡
Q¡m¤
qu Hhw ®k ®L¡e ¢ce−L R¤¢Vl ¢ce ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡l ¢hd¡e Q¡ m¤ Ll¡ quz HV¡ L¢jE¢eøl¡
dj£Ñu BQ¡l Ae¤ù¡e h¡¢am Ll¡l pwNË¡−jl Awn ¢qp¡−h Q¡m¤ L−lz 1928 J 1930 p¡−m d−jÑ
¢hnÄ¡p£−cl Ll cn…e hª¢Ü Ll¡ quz a¡−cl M¡cÉâ−hÉl ®lne J ü¡ØqÉ ®ph¡ −b−L h¢’a Ll¡ quz
AbÑ¡v a¡l¡ pLm fËL¡l e¡N¢lL p¤¢hd¡ −i¡−Nl A¢dL¡l q¡l¡uz a¡−cl−L fË¡uC ®NÊga¡−ll ¢nL¡l
q−a quz Q¡L¥l£ −b−L hlM¡Øa Ll¡ qu Hhw ®cn¡¿¹−l ®fËlZ Ll¡ quz 1936 p¡−ml j−dÉ fË¡u
65 % jp¢Sc J 70 % N£SÑ¡ dÄwp Ll¡ quz
L¢jE¢eø ®cn A¡m−h¢eu¡ d−jÑl ¢hl²−Ü ph−Q−u L−W¡l AhØq¡e ®euz H ®c−nl e¡¢ØaL
®ea¡ ¢R−me Envr Hodjazz ¢a¢e 1967 ¢a¢e p¡−m Bm−h¢eu¡−L fËbj ""djÑq£e'' l¡øÊ ¢qp¡−h
®O¡oe¡ ®cez d−jÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£®cl−L ®L¡e L¡le R¡s¡C ®S−m L−uc L−l l¡M¡ quz H−cl A−eL−LC

53 / 88
L¡l¡N¡−lC jªa¥Éj¤−M f¢aa qez 1968 p¡−m c¤C Se ¢hnf J 5000 djÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£−L …¢m L−l
qaÉ¡ Ll¡ quz Ae¤l©fi¡−h j¤p¢mj−cl qaÉ¡ Ll¡ quz j¡¢pL f¢œL¡ Nendori −a ®O¡oe¡ Ll¡ qu
®k, 2169 ¢V jp¢Sc J N£SÑ¡ hå Ll¡ quz Hl j−dÉ LÉ¡b¢mL Ef¡p¡e¡mu ¢Rm 327 ¢Vz
L¢jE¢eø−cl H pjØa LjÑL¡ä p−¾cq¡a£ai¡−h fËj¡e L−le ®k, a¡l¡ Hje HL¢V pj¡S ¢ejÑ¡e
Ll−a Q¡u, k¡ Aåi¡−h Bõ¡ql A¢ØaaÄ Aü£L¡l Ll−h Hhw d−jÑl ®L¡e lLj e¡j ¢en¡e¡ b¡L−h
e¡z H pj¡−S öd¤j¡œ hØa¥h¡−c ¢hnÄ¡p£ Hhw hع¤−L p−hÑ¡µQ ANÊ¡¢dL¡l fËc¡e Ll−hz
L¢jE¢eø ®ea«hª¾cl¡ S¡e−ae ®k, a¡−cl CµR¡ja SeNe−L f¢lQ¡¢ma Ll−a q−m Hje
HL Se−N¡¢ù ®~al£ Ll¡ fË−u¡Se ®kM¡−e j¡e¤o L¡S Ll−h L¡ä‘¡eq£e, Ae¤i¨¢aq£e ®j¢n−el jaz
p−h¡Ñ
p−h¡Ñf¢l H−cl q−a q−h Bõ¡qa¡m¡l A¢Øa−aÄ A¢hnÄ¡p£ Se−N¡¢ùz öd¤j¡œ a¡q−mC a¡−cl
Q¡¢qc¡e¤k¡u£ H−cl−L ¢c−u ph dl−el ¢ef£sej§mL J qaÉ¡L¡ä OV¡−e¡ pñh q−hz e¡¢ØaLÉh¡c£
X¡lEq~eh¡c ph lL−jl ¢ekÑ¡ae, ¢ef£se, à¾cÅ, pwNË¡j, ¢eù¥la¡ J qaÉ¡ pjbÑe L−l k¢cJ djÑ
Hph L¡S−L ¢e¢oÜ
¢e¢oÜ ®O¡oe¡ L−l−Rz ®k pjØa ja¡c−nÑ j¡e¤−ol S£h−el ®L¡e j§mÉ B−R h−m
¢h−hQe¡ L−l e¡, a¡l¡C ¢hwn na−L jq¡e−¾c l−š²l heÉ¡ hC−u−Rz ¢hwn na−L ¢el¢h¢µRæ k¤Ü,
NZqaÉ¡, ¢h−â¡q, pwNÊ¡j J pwO¡−al fËd¡e L¡le HY~¡Cz

X¡lECeh¡c£ L¢jE¢eø−cl ¢hnÄhÉ¡f£ AaÉ¡Q¡l J p£j¡q£e ¢ekÑ

¢ekÑ¡ae

®~el¡SÉh¡c J p¿»¡ph¡c H c¤−V¡ q−m¡ j¡„ÑL¡c J pj¡Sa¿»h¡−cl AaÉ¡hnÉL q¡¢au¡lz L¡mÑ

j¡LÑp S£¢ha b¡L¡L¡m£e pj−u Paris Commune (1848) ¢h−â¡−q j¡LÑph¡−cl fl£r¡L¡m£e
pj−u p¿»¡p J pwO¡−al fË¢a a¡−cl cª¢ø iwN£ mre£uz p¿»¡ph¡c, L¢jE¢eø jah¡−cl HL
Af¢lq¡kÑ Awn ¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qaz ¢h−no L−l j¡LÑph¡−cl h¡Øah¡ue fË¢œ²u¡u ®m¢ee a¡ ¢h−noi¡−h
hÉhq¡l L−lez AbÑ¡v ®m¢ee −b−L HC d¡l¡ öl² qu Hhw k¡ AcÉ¡h¢d AhÉ¡qa B−Rz fª¢bh£l
ph S¡uN¡−aC L¢jE¢eSj mr mr ®m¡−Ll lš² T¢l−u−Rz p¿»¡ph¡c£ pwNW−el j¡dÉ−j SeN−el
c¤xM-
M-c¤cÑn¡, i£¢a, p¿»¡p J pwNË¡−jl j−dÉ hph¡p Ll−a h¡dÉ L−l−Rz haÑj¡−e pLm L¢jE¢eø
®ea¡l¡C a¡−cl à¡l¡ pwO¢Va AaÉ¡Q¡l, ¢ef£se, ¢ekÑ¡ae J qaÉ¡L¡−äl SeÉ pÈle£uz Hacp−šÆJ
®L¡e ®L¡e jqm H dl−el ¢eù¥l, W¡ä¡ j¡b¡l qaÉ¡L¡l£, ¢hL«aje¡, f£seL¡l£l g−V¡ ®cJu¡−m
V¡w¢N−u a¡−cl−L ®ea¡ ¢qp¡−h ü£L«¢a ¢c−u b¡−Le k¡ p¢aÉC c¤xMSeLz
L¢jE¢eøl¡ k¢cJ c¡h£ L−l b¡−Le, p¿»¡p J pwO¡−al p¡−b L¢jE¢eS−jl ®L¡e pÇfLÑ
e¡Cz hlw HV¡ ®L¡e ®L¡e hÉ¢š² ¢h−n−ol ¢h¢µRæ L¡kÑœ²jz L¢jE¢eøl¡ kaC a¡−cl ®c¡o Aü£L¡l
Ll¡l ®Qø¡ Ll²L e¡, ®Le HV¡ HL¢V Aeü£L¡kÑ paÉ ®k, L¢jE¢eS−jl fËhš²l¡ p¿»¡ph¡−cl üf−r
ja¡ja J k¤¢š² fËcnÑe L−l¢Rm Hhw a¡ a¡−cl BcÑ−nl HL¢V AaÉ¡hnÉL£u ¢cL h¡ Awn
¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ L−l−Rez H ¢ho−u B−j¢lL¡e l¡øÊ¢h‘¡e£ Samuel Francis X~−õM L−le x

54 / 88
 j¡LÑp J H−‘mp ph pjuC pwO¡af§§eÑ
h−m H−p−Re, ®k ¢hfÔh ph pju pwO¡af J fËQä q−a
q−hz ¢hfÔh£−cl−L n¡pL ®nËe£l ¢hl²−Ü A¢a BhnÉC hm fË−u¡N Ll−a q−hz ®L¡e ®L¡e ®r−œ
a¡l¡ p¿»¡ph¡c−L pjbÑeJ L−l−Rez
L¡mÑ j¡LÑp h−me "" ¢hfÔh k¤−Ül eÉ¡u Eæaj¡−el Lm¡ ®L±nm ''Hhw ¢a¢e ¢hfÔh£
l¡Se£¢al HLSe fË¡e f¤l²o Danton gl¡p£ ¢hfÔ−hl Hl HL¢V ¢hMÉ¡a ®nÔ¡N¡e-
N¡e- ""Bœ²je,
Bœ²je J f¤el¡u Bœ²je'' hÉhq¡l L−lez
®m¢eeJ p¿»¡ph¡−cl f¢lL¢Òfa fË−u¡−Nl fË−u¡Se£ua¡ pÇf−LÑ ¢h¢iæ pju hš²hÉ J ¢hhª¢a
fËc¡e Ll−Re k¡l L−uL¢V ¢e−jÀ Eܪ¢a Ll¡ q−m¡ x
""fË
""fËL«af−r l¡øÊ Hje HL¢V k¿» k¡l j¡dÉ−j HL ®nËe£l Efl AeÉ ®nËe£ ¢ekÑ¡ae
¡ae Q¡m¡uz
®~üla¿» Hje HL¢V l¡øÊ hÉhØq¡ k¡ fËaÉri¡−h ®L¡e BCeNa ¢h¢d¢e−od R¡s¡ pÇf§eÑl©−f n¢š² h¡
hmfË−u¡−Nl à¡l¡ f¢lQ¡¢ma J ¢eu¢¿»az nË¢jL ®nËe£l HLe¡uLa¿» q−m¡ Hje HL¢V l¡øÊ hÉhØq¡
plL¡l
k¡ d¢eL ®nËe£l Efl nË¢jL ®nËe£l pnØœ pwNË¡−jl j¡dÉ−j A¢SÑa J pwl¢ra plL ¡l hÉhØq¡fe¡,
k¡, ®k ®L¡e dl−el BCe£ ¢h¢d¢e−od −b−L pÇf§eÑ ü¡d£ez Bjl¡ ®L¡e j−aC l¡S®~e¢aL
qaÉ¡L¡−äl ¢h−l¡d£ eCz'' a−h a¡ pl¡p¢l Ne B−¾c¡m−el p¡−b S¢sa h¡ hÉ¢š²Na p¿»¡p£
LjÑL¡ä H hÉ¡f¡−l HV¡C ¢hQ¡kÑ ¢houz rja¡ ASÑ−el SeÉ ®nËe£ p−Qae nË¢jLl¡ A¢dL¡wn
®m¡−Ll
®m¡−Ll pjbÑe Bc¡u Ll−h karZ fkÑ¿¹ SeN−el fË¢a ®L¡e ¢ekÑ¡ae e¡ Ll¡ qu Hhw rja¡u
k¡Ju¡l AeÉ ®L¡e Ef¡u e¡ b¡−Lz ®L¡e HL Lj£Ñ pj¡−h−n a¡−cl B−¾c¡m−e p¿»¡ph¡−cl pjbÑe
pÇf−LÑ ®m¢ee ®k iu¡hq hšªa¡ ®ce a¡ q−m¡ x
""k¢c
""k¢c p¡d¡le Sea¡ üaxØg¤aÑi¡−h e¡ −S−N E−W a¡ q−m ®L¡e ¢LR¤C qJu¡l pñ¡he¡ e¡C
qC-- (a¡
ka¢ce fkÑ¿¹ e¡ Bjl¡ Bn¡h¡c£−cl p¡−b ®k dl−el BQlZ Ll¡ E¢Qa a¡ Ll−a hÉbÑ qC
q−m¡) a¡−cl j¡b¡u HL¢V h¤−mV Y¥¢L−u e¡ ®cC a¡q−m Bjl¡ ®L¡e ¢ceC Bj¡−cl N¿¹hÉØq−m
®f±R−a prj q−h¡ e¡z
l¡¢nu¡l A−ƒ¡hl ¢hfÔ−hl AeÉaj HLSe ®ea¡ VÊV¢„, ®m¢e−el
®m¢e−el hšªa¡l hÉ¡M¡ L−l h−me
®k, ¢hfÔ−hl p¡−b ¢hfÔh£ ®nËe£ a¡−cl L¡−R ka dl−el Ef¡u J f¿Û¡ l−u−R ph…¢ml pàhÉhq¡l
Ll−h-
Ll−h- fË−u¡Se−h¡−d pnØœ ¢hfÔ−hl J p¿»¡p£ LjÑL¡−äl j¡dÉ−jz'' VÊV¢ØL hšªa¡u HL d¡f ®hn£
H¢N−u h−me x ""haÑj¡−e Bj¡−cl HLj¡œ fR¾c q−m¡ Nªqk¤Üz H Nªqk¤Ü l²¢Vl SeÉ k¤Üz Nªqk¤Ü
c£OÑS£¢h ®q¡L z'' l¡¢nu¡l hm−n¢iL ¢hfÔ−h ®m¢ee J Y~VÊ ¢„ Hl ja a¡¢šÆL−cl e£¢a J ja¡cnÑ
L¡−kÑ f¢lea Ll¡ quz1917 p¡−ml nlvL¡m£e ¢hfÔ−h hÉ¡fL qaÉ¡k−‘ m¤Vf¡V J iu¡hq ¢hfkÑ−ul
p§Qe¡ quz H pju k¡l¡ H ¢hfÔ−hl ¢h−l¡d£ ¢Rm h¡ k¡−cl−L ¢hfÔh ¢h−l¡d£
¢h−l¡d£ ¢qp¡−h j−e Ll¡ q−a¡z
a¡−cl−L ®L¡e p¤¢e¢cÑø A¢i−k¡N R¡s¡C ®NËç¡l L−l …¢m L−l qaÉ¡ Ll¡ q−a¡z a¡−cl Nª−q
m¤Val¡S L−l dÄwp L−l ®gm¡ q−a¡z p¿»¡ph¡c, ®m¢ee J VÊV¢ØLl Bj−m öl² q−mJ øÉ¡¢m−el

55 / 88
n¡pe¡j−m HV¡ ph−Q−u SoeÉi¡−h BaÈfËL¡n L−lz ®p¡¢i−ua L¡l¡N¡lN¤¢m pÇf−LÑ heÑe¡ L−l
The New York Times Hl H Harison E Salisbury ¢m−M−Re ®k x pjNË jq¡−c−n p¿»¡−pl
l¡SaÄ L¡−uj quz H ¢hfÔ−hl ®q¡a¡l¡ q¡S¡l q¡S¡l qaÉ¡L¡ä mr mr ®m¡−Ll jªaɤ OY~¡u, HC
−p¡¢i−ua pj¡S hÉhØq¡ fËL«af−r HL¢V "" œ¡p hÉhØq¡ ” Soviet Terror System ¢qp¡−hC
¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ k¡u Hl a¥me¡u S¡la¿» A−eL pqe£u J j¡e¢hL ¢qp¡−h BMÉ¡¢ua Ll¡ k¡uz
Bjl¡ ¢hQ¢ma q−u k¡C, kMe ®cM¡ k¡u HL¢V p¤ù¥ f¢lLÒfe¡l j¡dÉ−j ®~ce¢¾ce ¢eu¢ja
AfLjÑ ab¡ ¢eù¥l BQl−el j¡dÉ−j fË¢a hRl 3 −b−L 4 ¢j¢mue ®m¡L−L L¡¢uL nË−j h¡dÉ Ll¡
J ¢QlØq¡u£ ®cn¡¿¹−l ®fËle Ll¡ quz Hdl−el L¡kÑœ²j−L Hje ü¡i¡¢hL fkÑ¡−u ¢e−u Bp¡ qu ®k,
h¾c£l¡ S¡e−aJ f¡lae¡ a¡−cl Afl¡dC ¢L Hhw a¡−cl ¢hl©−Ü ¢L l¡uC h¡ ®cJu¡ q−u−Rz
¢œ²¢ju¡l a¥L£Ñ, jdÉ H¢nu¡l a¥L£Ñ J L¡S¡L Se−N¡¢ù ¢h−ni¡−h HC ®p¡¢i−ua fÜ¢al
ph−Q−u hs p¿»¡−pl ¢ejÑj ¢nL¡l
¢nL¡l q®a quz Troiki e¡−jl ¢h−no Bc¡m−al j¡dÉ−j l¡¢nu¡e
pj¡S−L L¡S¡L Se−N¡¢ù ®b−L ¢höÜ l¡M¡l hÉhØq¡ Ll¡ quz1920 p¡−m öd¤j¡œ A−ƒ¡h−lC
Troiki 6000 Se−L j§a¨É cä¡−l¡f L−l k¡ A¢hm−ð L¡kÑLl£ Ll¡ quz H plL¡−ll k¡l¡ ¢h−l¡d£a¡
L−l¢Rm a¡−cl f¢lh¡l−L ®NÊga¡l Ll¡ qu,
qu, Hje¢L a¡−cl fË¢a−hn£−cl f¢lL¢Òfai¡−h ¢SÇj£
Ll¡ qu Hhw Le−p®¾VÊne (Concentration
( Camp)) LÉ¡−Çf f¡W¡−e¡ quz Ukraine - Ah¢Øqa H
dl−el HL¢V LÉ¡−Çfl fËd¡e Martrin Latis a¡l HL¢V fË¢a−hc®e ü£L¡l L−le, fËLa
« f−r
H…¢m ¢Rm jªa¥É LÉ¡Çfz fË¢a−hc−e E−õM Ll¡ qu ®k x Maikop Hl ¢eL−V Ah¢Øqa HL¢V
LÉ¡−Çf j¢qm¡, ¢nö J hªÜ−cl−L j¡e−hal S£he k¡f−e h¡dÉ Ll¡ q−a¡z A−ƒ¡h−l fËQä n£a J
L¡c¡u a¡l¡ j¡¢Rl ja j¡l¡ k¡uz H ph j¢qm¡ hy¡Q¡l SeÉ ph¢LR¤ Ll−a fËØa¥az ®k ph ®~p¢eL
H−cl f¡q¡l¡l L¡−S ¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢Rm a¡l¡ H f¢l¢Øq¢al f§eÑ p¤−k¡N NÊqe L−l j¢qm¡ h¾c£−cl p¡−b
®hnÉ¡l eÉ¡u hÉhq¡l Ll−a¡z
X¡lECeh¡−cl fËi¡−h L¢jE¢eø ¢hfÓh£l¡ Sep¡d¡le−L f¡N−ml j−a¡ qaÉ¡ Ll−a¡z
pjp¡j¢uL c¡¢m¢mL fËj¡−el j¡dÉ−j S¡e¡ k¡u, H−cl HLj¡œ E−ŸnÉ ¢Rm pÇf§eÑ ¢edez a¡−cl
d¡le¡ ¢Rm ka −hn£ pwMÉL ®m¡L−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡ q−h a¡−cl pgma¡l q¡l aa ®hn£ q−hz a¡−cl
¢h−hQe¡u ¢hfÔ−hl ¢h−l¡d£ fË−aÉL¢V ®m¡L−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l ¢pÜ¡¿¹ NÊqe Ll¡ q−u¢Rm x Pyatigorsk
Cheka (Extraordinary Committee for war Against the Counter Revolution) fË¢a¢ce 300
−m¡L−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l ¢pÜ¡¿¹ NÊqe L−lz a¡l¡ nql…¢m−a ¢h¢iæ jqõ¡u i¡N L−l Hhw fË¢a¢V jqõ¡
−b−L ¢edÑ¡¢la pwMÉL ®m¡L−L qaÉ¡l a¡¢mL¡ fËØa¥a Ll−a¡z Kislouodsk nq−l ®L¡e p¤¾cl
¢hLÒf fËØa¡h e¡ b¡L¡u q¡pf¡a¡−m i¢aÑ ®l¡N£−cl qaÉ¡ Ll¡l ¢pÜ¡¿¹ Nªq£a J L¡−kÑ f¢lea Ll¡
quz Krasnyi Mech ( The Red Sword) e¡jL L¢jE¢eø−cl f¢œL¡l
f¢œL¡l fËd¡e ¢eh−¾d (Lead
Article) hm¡ qu ®k, L¢jE¢eÖY~l¡ k¡ M¤n£ a¡C Ll¡l rja¡ l¡−M Hhw ¢hnÄ¡p L−l −k, m¡m lš²

56 / 88
e¡ Tl¡−m m¡m B−¾c¡me pgm q−h e¡z Bj¡−cl L¡−R ph ¢LR¤C NÐqe−k¡NÉ L¡le A¡jl¡C ¢h−nÄ
fËbj AaÉ¡Q¡l eu c¡paÄ eu hlw j¡eh S¡¢a−L j¤š² J ü¡d£e Ll¡l SeÉ AØœ
AØœ d¡le L−l¢Rz
a¡C lš² f¡¢el ja fËh¡¢qa q−a q−hz h¤S§Ñu¡−cl L¡−m¡ fa¡L¡ (Smcp¤É ¢qp¡−h BMÉ¡¢ua)
l−š² l¢”a qu Bl A¡j¡−cl m¡m fa¡L¡ ¢Ql¢ce m¡m b¡−Lz f¤l¡−e¡ fª¢bh£l jªaѧÉl j¡dÉ−jC
Bjl¡ Bj¡−cl j¤š² h¡ ü¡d£e L−l¢R k¡−a nªN¡ml¡ (f¤l¡−e¡ n¡pLl¡) Bl ¢g−l Bp−a e¡ f¡−lz
øÉ¡¢me H dl−el ¢ekÑ¡ae R¡s¡J “Requisiting detachment” e¡−j HL ¢h−no CE¢eV
N−s ®a¡−mez ®kM¡−e L«oL−cl hm fË−u¡−Nl j¡dÉ−j npÉ gm¡−e¡ q−a¡z H dl−el q~E¢e®Vl
LjÑLaÑ¡Ne pLm fËL¡l ¢ekÑ¡ae Ll¡l SeÉ rja¡fË¡ç ¢Rmz
1922 p¡−ml 14 ®éh˲u¡l£ H dl−el CE¢e−Vl HLSe
HLSe f¢lcnÑL ¢m−Me ®k x HC ¢h−no
CE¢e−Vl rja¡ AfhÉhq¡−ll j¡œ¡ p¢aÉL¡li¡−h A¢hnÄ¡pÉ fkÑ¡−u ®fy±−R−R, ®NËç¡lL«a L«oL−cl
−N¡m¡h¡¢sl W¡ä¡u l¡M¡ quz flha£Ñ−a a¡−cl jªaɨ l iu ®c¢M−u fËQ¾Xi¡−h QhL¡−e¡ quz ®k
pjØa L«oL ¢edÑ¡¢la f¢lj¡e npÉ Evf¡ce Ll−a hÉbÑ qu, a¡−cl ®S¡lf§hÑL EmwN L−l NË¡−jl
fËd¡e ps−L −O¡l¡−e¡ qu Hhw AeÉ HL¢V W¡ä¡ qÉwN¡−l h¾c£ L−l l¡M¡ quz hý pwMÉL j¢qm¡−L
−hýn e¡ qJu¡ fkÑ¿¹ fËQäi¡−h fËq¡l Ll¡ qu Hhw f−l Emw|N L−l hl−gl j−dÉ N−aÑl j−dÉ
¢e−rf L−l qaÉ¡ Ll¡ quz
øÉ¡¢me ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−ae ®k, −Øfe l¡¢nu¡e−cl SeÉ ®L¡e ¢h−no p¤−k¡N h−u ¢e−u Bp−h, ®k
L¡l−e ¢a¢e ®Øf−el AiÉ¿¹l£e hÉ¡f¡−l qØa−rf L−le Hhw ®Øfe£u Nªqk¤−Ü L¢jE¢eø−cl pjbÑe
®cez l¡¢nu¡l H p¿»¡p£ LjÑL¡ä ®Øf−eJ Bjc¡e£ Ll¡ quz
¢ekÑ¡ae J ¢eù¥la¡l HL¢Y~ Ec¡qle q−m¡-
q−m¡- HL¢V Le−pe−VÊne LÉ¡−Çf ®kM¡−e 200 øÉ¡¢me
¢h−l¡d£−L
¢h−l¡d£−L 1938 p¡−m h¾c£ Ll¡ quz øÉ¡¢m−el pjbÑLl¡ kMe CHEKA fË¢aù¡ Ll−m¡ a¡−cl
¢ekÑ¡a−el S®~eL i¥š² heÑe¡ L−le ®k x L¡R¡L¡¢R Ah¢Øqa HL¢V LhlØq¡e f¢l×L¡l-
f¢l×L¡l-f¢lµRæ Ll¡
q−m¡z Chekists--®cl HL¢V e¡lL£u/®~fn¡¢QL f¢lLÒfe¡ ¢Rm-
¢Rm- a¡l¡ LhlØq¡−el pj¡¢d fËØal M¤−m
jª−al
al LwL¡m, q¡s−N¡s J fyQ¡Nm¡ nl£l f¤−l¡f¤¢l fËaÉr Ll−h Hhw HM¡−eC ph−Q−u L−W¡l
fËL«¢al ®m¡L−cl h¾c£ L−l l¡M−hz a¡−cl ¢ekÑ¡a−el ¢h¢iæ dl−el ¢eù¥l fÜ¢a ¢Rmz ¢LR¤ ¢LR¤
h¾c£−L j¡b¡ ¢e−Ql ¢c−L ®l−M pjØa ¢ce ®l−M ¢caz AeÉ−cl−L L¡hÑ¡−Xl j−dÉ h¾c£ L−l l¡Maz
a¡−a öd¤
öd¤ ¢enÄ¡p −eJu¡l SeÉ HL¢V ¢Râ L−l l¡Maz ph−Q−u SOeÉ fÜ¢a ¢Rm ""XÊu¡l ''
fÜ¢a h¾c£−cl HL¢V ®R¡V ®Q±L¡−Wl j¡−T Bpe ¢fy¢s fÜ¢a−a h¡dÉ L−l z A−eL¢ce fkÑ¿¹ H
AhØq¡u h¾c£ L−l l¡M¡ L¡E−L L¡E−L Bh¡l 8/10 ¢ce k¡hv ®L¡e lLj e¡s¡Q¡s¡ Ll¡l p¤−k¡N
®b−L h¢’a AhØq¡u h¾c£ L−l −l−M ®cu¡ quz
¢hnÄhÉ¡f£ pj¡Sa¿»£−cl ¢ekÑ¡ae, AaÉ¡Q¡l J hhÑla¡ pÇf−LÑ 1931 p¡−m Pope Pious
X~−õM
Encyclical Quadraesimo Anno -X~−õM L−le x pj¡Sa¿» c¤C¢V ¢S¢ep fËQ¡l L−l J ®f−a Q¡u-
Q¡u-
hÉ¡f¡−l
a¡ q−m¡ ¢elh¢µRæ ®nËe£ pwNË¡j Hhw hÉ¢š²Na pÇf¢šl pÇf§eÑ ¢h−m¡f p¡dez H hÉ¡f¡−l a¡−cl
®L¡e ®N¡fe£ua¡ e¡C h¡ ®L¡e ®N¡fe fÜ¢al Lb¡ hm¡J qu e¡ hlw a¡ Ll¡ qu Sepj−r,

57 / 88
, −M¡m¡−M¡¢mi¡−h Hhw pñ¡hÉ ®k ®L¡e f¿Û¡u a¡ ®p ka SOeÉ h¡ hhÑ−l¡¢Qa ®q¡L e¡ ®Lez H
E−ŸnÉ h¡Øah¡u−el SeÉ ®L¡e iu-
iu-i£¢a nËÜ¡ h¡ i¡mh¡p¡ fR¾c AfR−¾cl ®L¡e Øq¡e e¡Cz
rja¡u
rja¡u B−l¡q−el fl H ja¡cnÑ h¡Øah¡u−el SeÉ −k ®L¡e ¢eù¥l J Aj¡e¢hL BQlZ Ll−a
®L¡e ¢àd¡-
¢àd¡-à¾cÄ l¡−Me¡z AbÑ¡v ¢eù¥li¡−h a¡ h¡Øah¡ue L−lz f§hÑ CE−l¡f J H¢nu¡u ®k iu¡hq
NZqaÉ¡ J dÄwpk‘ H−cl à¡l¡ p¡¢da q−u−R a¡ HlC fËj¡e hqe L−lz E¢õ¢Ma heÑe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u
®k, pj¡Sa¿» fËd¡e
d¡e c¤¢V e£¢a h¡Øah¡ue Ll−a Q¡u-
Q¡u-¢eù¥l ®nËe£ pwNË¡j J hÉ¢š²Na j¡¢mL¡e¡l
pÇf§eÑ ¢h−m¡f p¡dez AeÉ Lb¡u ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl h¡Øah¡ue AbÑ¡v X¡lECe ®k fÜ¢a S£h¢h‘¡−el
®r−œ fË−u¡N L−l¢R−me ®pC HLC jah¡c j¡eh pj¡−S fË−u¡N Ll¡z AbÑ¡v Swm£ fË¡e£l¡
A¢Øa−aÄl SeÉ −k k¤Ü L−l Hhw
Hhw ¢V−L b¡−Lz j¡e¤oÉ pj¡−Sl ®m¡−Ll¡ HLCi¡−h f¡lØf¢lL k¤−Ü
¢mç b¡L−h a¡C L¡−l¡ ®L¡e ¢eSü pÇf¢š b¡L¡lJ fË−u¡Se e¡Cz L¡le ""®S¡l k¡l j¤õ¤L a¡l''z
HM¡−e hÉ¢š²Na pÇfc b¡L¡l AhL¡n h¡ p¤−k¡N L¡l h¡ ®L¡b¡uz pj¡Sa¿» ®k ¢hfkÑ−ul L¡le
O¢V−u−R a¡ l¡¢nu¡u ®no q−u k¡u¢ez
k¡u¢ez ®k pjØa ®cn Hl fËi¡−h r¢aNËÅØa q−u−R Q£e a¡l j−dÉ
AeÉajz
X¡lX~Ceh¡c£ j¡J−pa¥w J a¡l dÄwpk‘

Q£e¡ L¢jE¢eø ®ea¡ j¡J−pa¥w Hl c¤C fËd¡e …l² ¢R−me Q¡mÑp X¡lECe J ®S¡−pg
MSeL
øÉ¡¢mez c¤¢V iu¡hq e¡j k¡ j¡J Hl hÉ¢š²−aÄ ¢j−n ¢N−u¢Rm, k¡ Q£e¡ C¢aq¡−p HL Ni£l c¤xMSe L
J L¡−m¡ AdÉ¡−ul p§Qe¡ L−lz fË¡u 6-
6-10 ¢j¢mue ®m¡L−L j¡J−pa¥w Hl pl¡p¢l ¢e−cÑ−n qaÉ¡
Ll¡ quz ®L¡¢V ®L¡¢V ®m¡L−L fË¢a¢hfÔh£ ¢qp¡−h S£h−el A¢dL¡wn pju ®S−m L¡V¡−a q−k−|Rz
HM¡−e fË¡u 20 ¢j¢mue ®m¡L j¡l¡ k¡uz 1959-
1959-60 p¡−m 20 ®b−L 40 ¢j¢mue ®m¡L Ae¡q¡−l
jªa¥Éhle
hle L−lz The Great Leap Forward e¡jL Qlj ®Ny¡s¡ e£¢al L¡l−e1989 p¡−ml S¤®e
Tienanmen Square NZqaÉ¡u fË¡u 1000 q¡S¡l ®m¡L j¡l¡ k¡uz p¡ÇfТaL C¢aq¡−p H dl−el
OVe¡C Q£e¡ e£¢a h¢qx fËL¡−nl HL¢V Awnz
f§hÑ a¥L£ÑØa¡−e j¤p¢mj−cl qaÉ¡ J hÉ¡fL dÄwpk‘ HMeJ Qm−Rz Q£e¡ ¢hfÔ−hl pju iu¡hq
hhÑ−l¡¢Qa J Aj¡e¢hL OVe¡ OV−a b¡−Lz Q£e¡ SeNe aMe HL dl−el NZp−Çj¡q−el ¢nL¡l
quz pLm fËL¡l SOeÉ LjÑL¡ä J qaÉ¡ Ah−m¡Le L−l a¡l¡ ¢QvL¡l L−l Hl pjbÑe ®cuz
Le Livre Noir Du Communism (Black Book of Communism) e¡jL f¤ØaL¢V k¡ HLcm
¢nrL J I¢aq¡¢pL La«ÑL ¢m¢Maz pj¡Sh¡c£−cl ¢eù¥l J hhÑ−l¡¢Qa LjÑL¡¾X pÇf−LÑ ¢m−M−Re,
pjØa SeNe−L fË¢a ¢hfÄh£−cl Ne ¢hQ¡l ®cM¡l SeÉ Bj¿»e S¡e¡−e¡ quz H−cl
n¡¢Øa jªa¥c¾Xz fÊ−aÉ−LC H qaÉ¡L¡−ä p¡¢jm qu Hhw ¢QvL¡l L−l hm−a b¡−L - ""qaÉ¡ Ll,
qaÉ¡ Llz'' flha£Ñ−a jªa−cq−L Red Guard Hl ¢eLV qØa¡¿¹l Ll¡z a¡−cl c¡¢uaÄ q−m¡ a¡
M¾X ¢hMä Ll¡z LMeJ LMeJ Mä ®cq| l¡æ¡ L−l M¡Ju¡ q−a¡z Abh¡ jª−al f¢lh¡−ll pcpÉ−cl
®S¡l L−l a¡ Bq¡l Ll¡−e¡ q−a¡ ph¡C−L HL ®i¡−S c¡Ju¡a ®cJu¡ q−a¡ ®kM¡−e i¨af§hÑ
i¨ü¡j£l q©c¢fä J L¢mS¡ i¡N L−l ®cJu¡ q−a¡z pcÉ L¢aÑa jØaL…−m¡ p¡¢lhÜi¡−h ®m¡q¡l

58 / 88
c−ä ¢hÜ L−l pi¡u hš²ªa¡l j−’ l¡M¡ q−a¡z H dl−el fË¢a¢qwp¡ fl¡ue elj¡wp ir−el ®j¡q
flha£Ñ−a L−ð¡¢Xu¡l fmfV fËn¡p−e hÉ¡fLi¡−h Q¡m¤ Ll¡ quz fË¡Q£e f§hÑ H¢nu¡l AfpwØL«¢a
HL¢V ¢cL (el j¡wn irZ) k¡ Q£e¡ I¢aq¡¢pL jq¡ ¢hfkÑ
¢hfkÑ−ul j−dÉ p¡cªnÉ ®cM¡ k¡uz

L¢jE¢eø hhÑla¡l ¢aš² j¡p¤m

L¢jE¢eøl¡ ®kM¡−eC rja¡ B−l¡qe Ll−a prj q−u−R ®p ph ®c−nC H dl−el ¢eù¥l J
hhÑ−l¡¢Qa OVe¡ OV¡−e¡ q−u−Rz L−ð¡¢Xu¡, Ešl ®L¡¢lu¡, m¡Jp, ¢i−uae¡j, f§hÑ CE−l¡f£u J
B¢éL¡l ®cn pj§−ql SeNe Ae¤l©f OVe¡l fËaÉr L−l−R h¡ ¢nL¡l q−u−Rz HC lš²ru£
OVe¡hm£l ab¡ L¢jE¢eø−cl l¡øÊ£u rja¡ cM−ml j¡n¤−ml ¢hØa¡¢la ¢hhle The Black Book of
Communisim e¡jL f¤Øa−L ¢m¢fhÜ B−R k¡l ¢LR¤ Awn ¢ejÀl©f x ®cn, plL¡l h¡ n¡pe
fÜ¢a Ae¤k¡u£ ¢h¢iæa¡ b¡L¡ p−šÆJ Afl¡d…−m¡l fÉ¡V¡eÑ pÇf−LÑ Afl¡d…¢ml HL¢V pe¡š²Lle
h¡ ¢Q¢q²aLl−el ja HL¢V Ry¡Q h¡ ej§e¡ ®cM−a f¡Ju¡ k¡uz H ph ej¤e¡l j−dÉ l−u−R ¢h¢iæ
fÜ¢a−a-
fÜ¢a−a-…¢m L−l qaÉ¡, f¤ex f¤ex gy¡¢pl L¡−ù T¤¢m−u qaÉ¡, f¡¢e−a s¤¢h−u qaÉ¡, ¢f¢V−u qaÉ¡,
®L¡e ®L¡e ®r−œ NÉ¡p h¡ ¢ho fË−u¡−N qaÉ¡, Abh¡ N¡s£ c¤OÑVe¡u jªa¥É OV¡−e¡, hÉ¡fL pwMÉL
SeNe−L e¡ M¡C−u ®j−l ®gm¡, j¡eh pªø c§¢iÑ−rl j¡dÉ−j jªaÉ¥ l f¢l−hn pª¢ø h¡ r¥d¡u jªaÉ¥ , M¡cÉ
e¡ ¢c−u d¤−L d¤−L jªa¥Él ¢c−L ®W−m ®cJu¡ Abh¡ c¤CCz ®cn¡¿¹¢laLle, H fË¢œ²u¡u k¡a¡u¡−al
L−ø hý pwMÉL ®m¡L j¡l¡ k¡u Abh¡ hÜ k¡uN¡u h¾c£ q−u b¡L¡l L−ø ®m¡L j¡l¡ k¡u,
h¡dÉa¡j§mL nËj ab¡ p£j¡q£e LÓ¡¢¿¹, Ap¤Øqa¡, r¥d¡ J W¡ä¡u jªa¥Éz LMeJ LMeJ H−L Nªqk¤Ü
¢qp¡−h BMÉ¡¢ua Ll¡ quz a−h ¢hou¢V B−l¡ S¢Vmz n¡pL ®nËe£l p¡−b ¢h−â¡q£−cl p¡−b à¾cÄ
pwNË¡−j jªa¥É J p¡d¡le SeNe−L hÉ¡fL q¡−l qaÉ¡ Ll¡l ¢hou¢V Bm¡c¡i¡−h
Bm¡c¡i¡−h ¢Q¢q²a Ll¡ M¤hC
Løp¡dÉz k¡−q¡L, Bj¡−cl ®L¡b¡J e¡ ®L¡b¡u ®b−L öl² −a¡ Ll−a q−hz H ph Afl¡dj¤mL
L¡kÑœ²−jl HL¢V (−hplL¡l£) ¢qp¡−hl a¡¢mL¡ ®b−L Afl¡d pj§−ql iu¡hqa¡ ¢LR¤ h¤T−a f¡l¡
k¡−h x
œ²x ew −c−nl e¡j jªa¥Él pwMÉ¡/f¢lj¡e
Lz ®p¡¢i−ua CE¢eue 20 ¢j¢mue
¢j¢mue jªa¥É
Mz Q£e 65 ¢j¢mue jªa¥É
Nz ¢i−uae¡j 1¢j¢mue jªaÉ¥
Oz Ešl ®L¡¢lu¡ 2¢j¢mue jªaÉ¥
Pz f§hÑ CE−l¡f 1¢j¢mue jªaÉ¥
Qz L−ð¡¢Xu¡ 2¢j¢mue jªaÉ¥
Rz mÉ¡¢Ve B−j¢lL¡ 1,50,000 jªa¥É
Sz B¢éL¡ 1.7 ¢j¢mue jªa¥É
Tz BgN¡¢eØq¡e 1.5 ¢j¢mue jªa¥É
Uz B¿¹SÑ¡¢aL
¢aL L¢jE¢eø B−¾c¡m−e Hhw L¢jE¢e¢ø f¡¢VÑ 10,000
rja¡u A¢d¢ùa e¡ b¡L¡L¡m£e f¢l¢Øq¢a−a
phÑp¡L¥−mÉ 100 ¢j¢mue −m¡L jªa¥Éhle L−lz

59 / 88
 L¢jE¢eø plL¡l J pwNWe pj§q HLC ja¡c−nÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£ ¢Rm x pLm j¡eh£u Ae¤i¨¢a kb¡
cu¡, j¡u¡, eÉ¡u ¢hQ¡l ¢h−hL−L ®L¡eœ²−jC
®L¡eœ²−jC ®L¡e fËL¡l …l²aÄ ®cJu¡ q−h e¡ h¡ k¡−h e¡z qW¡v
L−l j¡eh pj¡S HL¢V k¤Ü−rœ J NZqaÉ¡l j¡dÉj ¢qp¡−h f¢lN¢ea q−a öl² Ll−m¡z ®kje e¡¢L
h−e ¢qwpË fÊ¡e£l¡ M¡cÉ J i¥¢jl SeÉ pwNË¡−j ¢mç qu, ®p lLji¡−hC j¡e¤o j¡e¤−ol p¡−b HLC
L¡l−e k¤−Ü Aha£eÑ q−a öl² Ll−m¡z a¡C
a¡C a¡l¡ "" föl '' eÉ¡u BQle Ll−a öl² L−lz L¡le
X¡lECe a¡−cl−L ¢n¢M−u−Re ®k, j§max j¡e¤o HL dl−el föz fö ®kje ¢V−L b¡L¡l SeÉ
pwNË¡−j ¢mç qu, a¡C a¡−cl−LJ Ae¤l©f hÉhq¡l h¡ BQle Ll¡ E¢Qa h¡ Ll−a q−hz
dl−el
HC Aj¡e¢hL B−¾c¡me pj§−ql ®ea¡l¡ j−e Ll−a b¡−Le ®k, HL dl− el ¢jbÉ¡ ®~h‘¡¢eL
k¤¢š²l j¤−M¡n NËq−el j¡dÉ−j a¡l¡ SeN−el nËÜ¡ J BØq¡ ASÑe Ll−a prj q−u−Rz hm−n¢iL
−ea«hª¾c ®S¡l Nm¡u a¡−cl Bœ²je, p¿»¡p J NZqaÉ¡ pÇf−LÑ Lb¡ hm−a prj q−u−Re öd¤j¡œ
H L¡l−e ®k X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡c H dl−el LjÑL¡ä−L pjbÑe fËc¡e L−lz P. J. Hl Darlington
a¡l Evolution for Naturalists e¡jL f¤Øa−L E−õM L−l−Re ®k, hhÑla¡ ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl HL¢V
Af¢lq¡kÑ ü¡i¡¢hL fËhea¡ J gpmz a¡C H dl−el BQle M¤hC k¤¢š² pwNaz phÑfËb−j k¡
fË¢Zd¡e−k¡NÉ a¡ q−m¡ ü¡bÑfla¡ J pwO¡a j¡eh Q¢l−œ S¾jNai¡−h a¡l fn¤f§hÑf¤l²o −b−L
Ešl¡¢dL¡l
Ešl¡¢dL¡l ¢qp¡−h m¡i L−l−Rz a¡C à¾cÄ pwO¡a J pwNË¡j j¡e¤−ol SeÉ AaÉ¿¹ ü¡i¡¢hL k¡
¢hhaÑ−elC pª¢øz''
¢hhaÑeh¡c£−cl H dl−el ü£L¡−l¡¢š² Ae¤k¡u£ HV¡ AaÉ¿¹ f¢l×L¡l ®k, X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡c
q−m¡ L¢jE¢eø ja¡c®nÑl fb ¢e−cÑnLz H L¡l−eC a¡l¡, j¡e¤o−L fö ¢qp¡−h j−e L−l Hhw
Hhw föl
p¡−b ®kje BQle Ll¡ E¢Qa a¡C L−l b¡−Lz L¡le k¡l¡ L¢jE¢eSj-
L¢jE¢eSj-X¡lECeh¡c−L a¡−cl
ja¡cnÑ ¢qp¡−h NÊqe L−l, a¡l¡ pª¢øLaÑ¡ H fª¢bh£−a a¡l Bp¡l L¡le J flL¡−m a¡l
LjÑL¡−äl SeÉ Bõ¡ql L¡−R Sh¡h¢c¢q Ll¡l ¢hou¢V ¢hpȪa qu h¡ ¢h−hQe¡C L−l e¡z g−m
Bõ¡q−a A¢hnÄ¡p£ pLm
pLm ®m¡−Ll ja, ®p HLSe AaÉ¿¹ ü¡bÑfl, ¢eù¥l-¢ecÑu, ®~üla¿»£ Hje¢L
¢qwpË, M¤¢e ¢qp¡−h BaÈ fËL¡n L−lz Bõ¡qa¡m¡ f¢hœ ®L¡l¡−e H dl−el ®m¡−Ll f¢le¢a pÇf−LÑ
H i¡−h E−õM L−l−Re x
""®Lhm a¡q¡−cl ¢hl²−Ü hÉhØq¡ Ahmðe Ll¡ qC−a k¡q¡l¡ j¡e¤−ol Efl AaÉ¡Q¡l L−l
Hhw fª¢bh£−a
bh£−a AeÉ¡ui¡−h ¢h−â¡q¡Qle L¢lu¡ ®hs¡u Eq¡−cl SeÉ l−u−R jjÑØa¥c n¡¢Øaz ''( p¤l¡¡--
p§l¡-
¡-42)z

60 / 88
 Efpwq¡l

d−jÑl Ae¤f¢Øq¢al L¡l−e HV¡ pj¡Sa¡¢¿»L B−¾c¡m®e HL¢V fËL¡nÉ p¿»¡p ¢qp¡−h
A¡aÈfËL¡n L−l−Rz L¢jE¢eø, e¡S£h¡c£ J p¡jË¡SÉh¡c£−cl j¡eh S¡¢al Efl H dl−el NZqaÉ¡,
M¤e, ¢ec¡l²e c¤xM c¤cÑn¡l OVe¡hm£ fËaÉr L−l A−e−L i¡h®ae ®k, H ja¡cnÑ pj§−ql Ae¤p¡l£l¡
¢Li¡−h p¡d¡le j¡eh£u Ae¤i¨¢a ®b−L ¢hQ¥Éa q−u H dl−el SOeÉ L¡kÑLm¡−f ¢mç q−a f¡−lz
fËL«a f−r H dl−el hhÑ−l¡¢Qa J ¢ef£sej§mL OVe¡ pwOV−el HLj¡œ L¡le q−m¡ - H pjØa
ja¡c−nÑ
ja¡c−nÑl ®ea«hª¾c ®L¡e d−jÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£ ¢R−me e¡, a¡−cl ®M¡c¡l L¡−R Sh¡h¢c¢qa¡ h¡ ®M¡c¡i£¢al
®L¡e d¡le¡J ¢Rme¡z ®L¡e hÉ¢š² k¢c ®M¡c¡i£l² qu, a¡ q−m ®p ®L¡e œ²−jC f¤−hÑ¡−õ¢Ma ®L¡e
AeÉ¡u, A¢hQ¡l, AaÉ¡Q¡l h¡ M¤e Ll−a prj q−h e¡z Efl¿º ¢k¢e Bõ¡q J flL¡−m ¢hnÄ¡p
L−le, ¢a¢e
¢a¢e LMeJ H dl−el ¢hï¡¢¿¹jm
§ L ®M¡c¡−â¡q£ ja¡c−nÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£J q−a f¡−le e¡z
fr¡¿¹−l ®k ®m¡L, ®L¡e d−jÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£ eu h¡ k¡l A¿¹−l ®M¡c¡i£¢a b¡−L e¡, a¡l L¡−Sl
®L¡e p£j¡®lM¡ b¡−L e¡z ®p ¢hnÄ¡p L−l ®k, ®p Hhw a¡l f§hÑ f¤l²o fö ¢Rm Hhw ¢hhaÑeh¡c£
fË¢œ²u¡u j¡e−h l©f¡¿¹
l©f¡¿¹¢la q−u−Rz ®p HJ ¢hnÄ¡p L−l, Ss fc¡bÑ R¡s¡ fª¢bh£−a Bl ¢LR¤C e¡C,
ph ¢LR¤C Ss fc¡bÑ ®b−L ®~ch¡v pª¢ø q−u−Rz H dl−el ®m¡LC p¤−k¡N ®f−m H dl−el ¢eù¥l
A¡Qle Ll−a prj quz fËbj ¢c−L k¢cJ j−e q−a f¡−l ®k, a¡l¡ L¡−l¡ ®L¡e r¢a Ll−a prj
q−he e¡z ¢L¿º Efk¤š² f¢l−hn
f¢l−hn ®f−m ®cM¡ k¡−h ®k, ®p HLSe SOeÉ M¤e£ ¢qp¡−h BaÈfËL¡n L−l
Hhw NZqaÉ¡, …çqaÉ¡, j¡e¤o−L ¢ekÑ¡ae, e¡ M¡C−u qaÉ¡ CaÉ¡¢c L¡kÑœ²j Ll−a ¢àd¡ L−l e¡, öd¤
H L¡l−eq~ ®k a¡l fË¢afr H ja¡c−nÑ ¢hnÄ¡p£ euz
1970 p¡−m p¡¢q−aÉ ®e¡−hm ¢hSu£ l¡¢nu¡e ®mML Alexander I Solzhenitsyn 1983
p¡−m m¾X−e HL hšªa¡u l¡¢nu¡l SeN−el c¤xM c¤cn
Ñ ¡l L¡le heÑe¡ fËpw−N h−me,
""BS ®b−L AdÑ na¡ë£ f§−hÑ kMe B¢j ¢nö ¢Rm¡j, aMe −hn ¢LR¤ hªÜ ®m¡L l¡¢nu¡l
SeN−el c§−iÑ¡−Nl L¡le hÉ¡MÉ¡ fËpw−N hm−a ö−e−Re, j¡e¤o Bõ¡q−L i¥−m ®N−R ®p L¡l−eC H
ph ¢LR¤ q−u−Rz aMe ®b−L BS fkÑ¿¹ 50 hvpl d−l B¢j Bj¡−cl ¢hfÔ−hl C¢aq¡p ¢e−u
N−hoe¡ L−l¢Rz H fË¢œ²u¡u na na hC f¡W L−l¢Rz hÉ¢š²Nai¡−h na na fËj¡e J p¡rÉ pwNËq
L−l¢Rz H ¢h−â¡−ql BhSÑe¡ f¢l×L¡l Ll¡l m−rÉ ¢e−SJ 8 i¢mEj f¤ØaL ¢m−M¢Rz ¢L¿¹ BSJ
Bj¡−L k¢c ®LqBj¡−cl jq¡ dÄdÄwpk‘ k¡−a 60 mr ®m¡L®L h¢m q−a q−u−R a¡l fËd¡e L¡le
pw¢rçaji¡−h hm−a hm¡ qu, a¡q−m B¢j ®pC Lb¡lC f¤el¡hª¢š Ll¡ R¡s¡ p¢WLi¡−h AeÉ
¢LR¤C hm−a f¡l−h¡e¡, Bl a¡ q−m¡-
q−m¡-j¡e¤o DnÄl−L i¨−m ®N−R, a¡C H ph OVe¡l Aha¡le¡
q−u−Rz''
Solzhenitsyn Hl fkÑ−hre p¢WLz fËL«af−r
f−r ®M¡c¡i£¢al Ae¤f¢Øq¢a h¡ Bõ¡q−L i¥−m
k¡Ju¡l L¡l−eC pj¡−S H dl−el p¿»¡p; pwO¡a J AaÉ¡Q¡l OV−a f¡−l Hhw ph¡C H hÉ¡f¡−l
p¡r£−N¡f¡−ml i¨¢jL¡u Aha£Ñe q−hz fr¡¿¹−l Bõ¡qa¡m¡ LMeJ ®L¡e ¢LR¤ i¥−me e¡ ®L¡e i¥§m

61 / 88
L−le e¡z q©cuq£e L¢jE¢eø ®ea«hª¾c a¡l¡ ¢e−S−cl−L fËQä rja¡dl ¢h−hQe¡ L−l pj¡S
f¢lQ¡me¡l SeÉ ¢h¢iæ l£¢a fÜ¢a Ae¤på¡e h¡ B¢h×L¡l Ll−a¡z ¢e−S−cl j−dÉ ®N¡fe pi¡u
SeN−el SeÉ ¢eaÉ ea¥e ¢ekÑ¡a−el g¢¾c ¢g¢Ll Ll−a¡z a¡l¡ kMe H…−m¡ Ll−a¡ Bõ¡qa¡m¡
Hl ph ¢LR¤C S¡e−aez a¡l¡ k¡ L−l−R a¡l n¡¢Øa Bõ¡qa¡m¡ AhnÉC ¢c−hez f¢hœ ®L¡l¡−e
¢a¢e ®O¡oe¡ L−l−Re, ""®pC ¢ce, ®k¢ce Eq¡−cl pLm−L HL−œ E¢›a Ll¡ qC−h Hhw Eq¡¢cN−L
S¡e¡Cu¡ ®cJu¡ qC−h k¡q¡ Eq¡l¡ L¢la, Bõ¡q a¡q¡l ¢qp¡h l¡¢Mu¡−Rez Bõ¡q phÑ ¢ho−u pjÉL
â|ø¡z a§¢j ¢L mrÉ Ll e¡, BL¡n jäm£ J fª¢bh£−a k¡q¡ ¢LR¤ B−R Bõ¡q a¡q¡ S¡−ee, ¢ae
¢ae
hÉ¢š²l j−dÉ Hje ®L¡e ®N¡fe fl¡jnÑ qu e¡, k¡q¡−a Qa¥bÑ Se ¢qp¡−h ¢a¢e Ef¢Øqa e¡ b¡−Le
Hhw fy¡Q hÉ¢š²l j−dÉJ qu e¡, k¡q¡−a ¢a¢e où Se ¢qp¡−h Ef¢Øqa e¡ b¡®Lez Eq¡l¡
Hac−fr¡ Lj qEL h¡ ®hn£ ®q¡L ¢a¢e ®a¡ a¡q¡−cl pL−ml pw−NC B−Re Eq¡l¡ ®kM¡−eC
b¡L¥e e¡ ®Lez Aaxfl Eq¡l¡ k¡q¡ L−l ¢a¢e Eq¡¢cN−L ¢Lu¡j−al ¢ce a¡q¡ S¡e¡Cu¡ ¢c−hez
¢eÕQuC Bõ¡q phÑ ¢ho−u pjÉL AhNa (p¤l¡ j¤S¡c¡m¡-
¡c¡m¡-6-7)z''
H−cl j−dÉ ®L¡e −L¡e jqm h¡ ®N¡¢ù ph ¢eù¥l ®ea¡−cl−L Ae¤ple Ll−a¡z a¡−cl ¢fR−e
q¡j¡…¢E ¢c−u Qm−a¡z a¡−cl f¢le¢a pÇf−LÑ f¢hœ ®L¡l¡−e −O¡oe¡ Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, ""¢eÕQuC
Bõ¡q j¡e¤−ol fË¢a S¤m¤j L−le e¡, hlw j¡e¤oC ¢e−S−cl fË¢a S¤m¤j L−lz(p¤l¡¡--CEe¤p-44)z
AbÑ¡v Hl¡ ¢e−Sl¡C Bõ¡ql djÑ i¤−m ¢N−u ¢e−S−cl Efl S¤m¤j L−l−Rz
""H fª¢bh£−a k¡l¡ AeÉ¡u AfLjÑ L−l a¡−cl HC fª¢bh£−a ¢L AhØq¡ qu H pÇf−LÑ
f¢hœ
f¢hœ ®L¡l¡−e hm¡ q−u−R x j¡e¤−ol L«aL−jÑl cl²e Øq−m J pj¤−â ¢hfkÑu Rs¡Cu¡ f−s, k¡q¡l
g−m Bõ¡q Eq¡−cl ®L¡e ®L¡e L−jÑl n¡¢Øa ¢a¢e Bü¡ce Ll¡e k¡q¡−a a¡q¡l¡ ¢g¢lu¡ B−p(p¤l¡
l¡c-
l¡c-41)z
j¡eh S¡¢al SeÉ Bõ¡q La«ÑL ¢hfkÑu öd¤j¡œ Bõ¡q flL¡m J ay¡l L¡−R Sh¡h¢c¢q
Ll¡l Efl
Efl Ni£l ¢hnÄ¡p L−l pv LjÑ L−l k¡Ju¡z AbÑ¡v Bõ¡l ®cJu¡ ®L¡l¡−el ¢e−cÑn Ae¤k¡u£
Eæa ®~e¢aL Q¢lœ AbÑ¡v j¡e¤−ol fË¢a i¡mh¡p¡ cu¡, ¢hnÄ¡p fËi¢ª a pc…e ¢hL¢na Ll¡l j¡dÉ−j
S£he f¢lQ¡me¡ Ll¡z HC ¢hou¢V f¢hœ ®L¡l¡−e Hi¡−h E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R,
""j¤¢je qCu¡ f¤l²o J e¡l£l j−dÉ ®k ®Lq pv LjÑ L¢l−h a¡q¡−L B¢j ¢eÕQuC f¢hœ
S£he c¡e L¢lh Hhw a¡q¡¢cN−L a¡q¡−cl L−jÑl ®nËù f¤lØL¡l c¡e Llh ''(p¤l¡¡--e¡qm-
e¡qm-97)z

f¤y¢Sh¡c x AbÑe£¢a−a −hy−Q b¡L¡l pwNË¡j

f¤y¢Sh¡c AbÑ q−µR f§y¢Sl p¡hÑ−i±jaÄ, k¡ HL¢V E¾j¤š² J Ah¡d AbÑ®e

~ ¢aL hÉhØq¡ k¡l
¢i¢š öd§j¡œ m¡i h¡ j¤e¡g¡z HC AbÑ hÉhØq¡u pj¡S fË¢a−k¡N£a¡−L ®L¾cÐ L−lC f¢lQ¡¢ma q−u
b¡−Lz fy¤¢Sh¡−c ¢ae¢V A¢a …l²aÄf§eÑ Ef¡c¡e l−u−R-
l−u−R-hÉ¢š² ü¡a¿»h¡c, fË¢a−k¡N£a¡ J j¤e¡g¡ h¡
¢qp¡−h
m¡i f¤y¢Sh¡−c hÉ¢š² ü¡a¿» A¢a …l²aÄf§ZÑz L¡le H AbÑ hÉhØq¡u hÉ¢š²−L pj¡−Sl Awn ¢qp¡ −h
¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ qu e¡z hlw a¡−L HLSe hÉ¢š² ¢qp¡−h HL¡L£ ü£u fË−Qø¡u pj¡−S fË¢a¢ùa q−a

62 / 88
quz f¤y¢Sh¡c£ pj¡S Hje HL¢V l‰j’ ®kM¡−e fË¢a¢V hÉ¢š²®L A−eÉl p¡−b L−W¡l J ¢eù¥l
fË¢a−k¡N£a¡j§mL f¢l¢Øq¢al ®j¡L¡¢hm¡ Ll−a quz HV¡ Hje HL¢V Øq¡e ®kje e¡¢L X¡lECe
heÑe¡ L−l−Re,
L−l−Re,
®kM¡−e hmn¡m£ pj¡−S ¢V−L b¡L−h c§hÑm J rja¡q£e dÄwp J ¢e¢ÕQq²
¢e¢ÕQq² q−u k¡−hz ah¤J
®kM¡−e ¢eù¥l fË¢a−k¡N£a¡ fËd¡e Q¡¢mL¡ n¢š² ¢qp¡−h L¡S L−l b¡−Lz
fy¤¢Sh¡c£ jah¡−cl k¤¢š² Ae¤k¡u£ fË¢a¢V hÉ¢š² - k¡ HLSe ®m¡L, ®L¡Çf¡e£ Abh¡ S¡¢a
k¡C ®q¡L e¡ ®Le öd¤j¡œ ¢e−Sl p¤
p¤¢hd¡ J Eæ¢al SeÉ S£he pwNË¡−j Aha£eÑ q−hz HC k¤−Ü
ph−Q−u hs Ef¡c¡e q−m¡ Evf¡cez ph−Q−u i¡m Evf¡ceL¡l£ ¢V−L b¡L−h c§hÑm J A−k¡NÉl¡ dÄwp
q−u pj¡S −b−L ¢hm£e q−u k¡−hz f¤y¢Sh¡−cl h¡Øah Ahuh h¡ L¡W¡−j¡ H lLjz H AbÑ hÉhØq¡u
k¡l¡ H L−W¡l S£he pwNË¡−j fl¡¢Sa J ¢e¢ÕQq² q−u c¢l−âl L¡a¡−l a¡−cl Øq¡e L−l ¢e−µR
a¡l¡J ®k j¡e¤o −p Lb¡ ¢h−hQe¡uC Be¡ q−µR e¡z H ®r−œ −k ¢hou¢V ¢h−noi¡−h fË¢Zd¡e−k¡NÉ a¡
q−m¡-
q−m¡- p¡¢hÑLi¡−h j¡e¤−ol hlw S£he k¡œ¡l j¡e Eæue eu AbÑ®e
~ ¢aL Eæue Hhw H Eæu−el
g−m fË¡ç j¡m¡j¡m h¡ ®ph¡l j¡ez H L¡l−eC
L¡l−eC HLSe f¤y¢Sf¢a k¡−L ¢a¢e AbÑ®~e¢aL pwNË¡−j
fcc¢ma L−l pj¡S −b−L ¢e¢ÕQq² L®l fË¢aù¡m¡i Ll−me ¢a¢e LMeJ ®pC qa c¢lâ hÉ¢š²l
SeÉ ®L¡e ®~e¢aLa¡ h¡ pq¡e¤i¨¢a h¡ ¢h−h−Ll cwne Ae¤ih L−le e¡, Hhw a¡−LJ (S£he
pwNË¡−j fl¡¢Sa hÉ¢š² ) ®k HL Ni£l pwL−V L¡m L¡V¡−a h¡dÉ q−a qu, a¡ ¢h−hQe¡uC Be¡
qu e¡ z HY~¡C pj¡−S AbÑ®~e¢aL X¡lECeh¡−cl h¡Øah fË−u¡Nz
pj¡−Sl pLm ®r−œ fË¢a−k¡N£a¡j§mL Evp¡q fËc¡e Ll¡ fË−u¡Sez a¡C H jah¡−cl
fËØa¡he¡z HC AbÑ hÉhØq¡fe¡u c§hÑm J fl¡¢Sa hÉ¢š²−L ®L¡e lLj p¡q¡kÉ pq−k¡N£a¡ fËc¡−el
®L¡e fË−u¡Se e¡Cz p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡−cl a¡¢šÅLl¡ fy¢¤ Sh¡−cl p¡g−mÉl SeÉ H dl−el
S£he¡c−nÑlC ®~e¢aL ab¡ ""a¡¢šÆL pjbÑe J ab¡L¢ba ""®~h‘¡¢eL k¤¢š² '' fËc¡e L−l−Rez
Ec¡qleül©f hm¡ k¡u, f¤§¢Sh¡c£ X¡lECeh¡−cl fËd¡e pjbÑL−cl HLSe Tille E−õM L−l−Re,
""pj¡−S
""pj¡−S ¢h−â¡q−L fÊ¢aqa Ll¡l SeÉ
SeÉ AbÑ®~e¢aL S£he pwNË¡−j fl¡¢Sa ®nËe£−L p¡q¡kÉ
Ll¡ q−h HL¢V jØahs i¤̈mz L¡le Hl AbÑ q−m¡ ""fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Qe'' fË¢œ²u¡u h¡d¡ h¡
fË¢ahåLa¡ pª¢ø Ll¡ Bl HV¡C q−m¡ p¡j¡¢SL ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ¢i¢šz''
p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡−cl AeÉaj fËhš²¡ Herbert Spencer ¢k¢e SeS£h−e p¡j¡¢SL
p¡j¡¢SL
X¡lECeh¡−cl e£¢a fË−u¡−Nl fËb¡ Q¡m¤ L−lez ¢a¢e h−me, k¢c ®Lq Nl£h q®u b¡−L HV¡ a¡lC
®c¡oz a¡C a¡−L de£ Ll¡l hÉ¡f¡−l AhnÉC ®Lq ®L¡e lLj p¡q¡kÉ pq−k¡N£a¡ Ll−h e¡z ka
A®~e¢aL fÜ¢a−aC ®q¡L e¡ ®Le HV¡C (de£ qJu¡V¡C) a¡l ®k¡NÉa¡z H L¡l−eC de£ hÉ¢š² ¢V−L
b¡L−hz
b¡L−hz fr¡¿¹−l Nl£h j¡e¤o pj¡S ®b−L ¢e¢ÕQq² q−u k¡−hz haÑj¡e pj¡S hÉhØq¡u ¢hcÉj¡e
X¡lECeh¡c£-
X¡lECeh¡c£-f¤§y¢Sh¡c£ ®~e¢aLa¡l HV¡C p¡l¡wnz 1850 p¡−m Spencer a¡l HC cª¢øi‰£ pjbÑe
L−l Social Statistics e¡jL f§ØaL fËeue L−l−Rez ¢a¢e pLm fËL¡l pj¡S LmÉ¡ej§mL L¡−S
l¡øÊÊ£u pq¡ua¡l
pq¡ua¡l ¢h−l¡¢da¡ L−lez Hje¢L ü¡ØqÉ ®ph¡, ØL¥−m plL¡l£ pq¡ua¡, h¡dÉa¡j¤mL ¢VL¡

63 / 88
fÊc¡e L¡kÑœ²j fkÑ¿¹ ay¡l fËØa¡¢ha LjÑp§Q£−a ®k ®L¡e LmÉ¡ej§mL L¡−S plL¡l£ pq¡ua¡ e¡
®cJu¡ A¿¹iѧš² Ll¡ quz L¡le p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡−cl j−a p¡j¡¢SL ®nËe£¢heÉ¡p n¢š²dl−cl ¢V−L
b¡L¡l e£¢al
e£¢al ¢i¢š−a fËe£az c§hÑm J Nl£−cl pjbÑe J ®L¡e lLj pq¡ua¡ HC e£¢al f¢lf¢¿Ûz
de£l¡ H L¡l−eC de£ ®k, a¡l¡ A¢dLal−k¡NÉ h¡ Efk¤š²z ®L¡e ®L¡e S¡¢a AeÉ−cl n¡pe J
®n¡oe L−l L¡le a¡l¡ a¡−cl ®Q−u ®nËùz ®L¡e ®L¡e S¡¢a/fËS¡¢a L¡−l¡ Ad£e q−u k¡u L¡le
a¡l¡ Ad£eØq−cl ®Q−u A¢dL h¤¢Üj¡e ab¡ ®k¡NÉz Spencer H jah¡c pj¡−S AaÉ¿¹ L−W¡li¡−h
fË−u¡−Nl frf¡¢a ¢R−mez ¢a¢e h−me x a¡l¡ k¢c üuwpÇf§eÑi¡−h ®hy−Q b¡L−a f¡−l, a¡q−mC a¡l¡
hy¡Q−h Hhw a¡−cl ®hy−Q b¡L¡ E¢Qaz fr¡¿¹−l a¡l¡ k¢c pÇf§eÑl©−f ®hy−Q b¡L−a e¡ f¡−l, a¡l¡
j¡l¡ k¡−h Hhw
Hhw a¡−cl jªa¥É OV¡C pj¡−Sl SeÉ j‰mSeLz

B−j¢lL¡l Yale University Hl l¡Se£¢a J pj¡S ¢h‘¡−el AdÉ¡fL Graham

Sumner ¢k¢e B−j¢lL¡u p¡j¡¢SL X¡lEeh¡−cl j§Mf¡œz a¡l HL¢V fËh−å a¡l¡ ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡
pw¢rç¡L¡−l ¢ejÀ¢m¢Ma Ef−l
i¡o¡u fËL¡n L−le, "" Bjl¡ k¢c ®L¡e ®m¡L−L pj¡−S E f−l EW−a
p¡q¡kÉ L¢l, a¡l AbÑ q−m¡ a¡−L d¡LL¡ ®cJu¡z AbÑ¡v HV¡ HL¢V fË¢a¢œ²u¡z pj¡−S H fË¢œ²u¡
NÊqe Ll¡l AbÑ q−m¡-
q−m¡- L¡E−L Ef−l EW¡−e¡ q−m AeÉ HLSe−L d¡LL¡ ¢c−u e£−Q e¡j¡−e¡z''
New York Hl American Museum Hl Natural History Magazine Hl ¢p¢eul
pÇf¡cL Richard Milner ¢m−M−Re ®k, "" p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡−cl HLSe j§MÉ fËhš²¡,
Princeton Hl William Graham Sumner Hl j−a, pj¡−Sl ®L¡¢Vf¢al¡C q−µR ph−Q−u
®k¡NÉhÉ¢š² Hhw pLm fËL¡l p¤¢hd¡ f¡Ju¡l SeÉ Efk¤š²z a¡l¡ L−W¡l fË¢a−k¡N£a¡j§mL
f¢l¢Øq¢a−a fË¡L«¢aLi¡−h ¢ehÑ¡¢Qa hÉ¢š²hNÑ
hÉ¢š²hNÑz
Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡ ®b−L fËa£uj¡e qu ®k p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡c£l¡ f¤y¢Sh¡c£ pj¡S hÉhØq¡u
X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡c−L "" ®~h‘¡¢eL '' hÉ¡MÉ¡ fËc¡e L−l H¢V−L pjbÑe ¢c−u b¡−Lez g−m j¡e¤−ol
j−e dj£Ñu j§mÉ−h¡d, p¡q¡kÉ, pq−k¡N£a¡, j¡eha¡h¡c CaÉ¡¢c ¢Q¿¹¡ -®Qae¡ pÇf§eÑl©−f Afpª
Afpªa qu
Hhw Hl hc−m ü¡bÑfla¡, Qa¥la¡, p¤¢hd¡h¡c£ c§¢øi‰£ CaÉ¡¢c LjÑL¡ä pj¡−S fËnwpe£u ¢qp¡−h
¢h−h¢Qa quz
p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡−cl HLSe …l²aÄf§eÑ a¡¢šÆL B−j¢lL¡l AdÉ¡fL E.A Ross h−me,
"" Mªø¡e dj£Ñu j§mÉ−h¡d c¡e c¢re¡ k¡l AbÑ q−m¡ cu¡, j¡eha¡, ®ph¡, jja¡ CaÉ¡¢c
CaÉ¡¢c - k¡ j§MÑ J
Af¢lea h¤¢Ü pÇfæ hÉ¢š²−cl c¡phv ®hy−Q b¡L¡l BnËu Øqmz Ross Hl j−a "" H fË¢œ²u¡u
cu¡ c¡¢rZÉ CaÉ¡¢cl j¡dÉ−j l¡øÊk¿» a¡l BnË−u h¢dl J ®h¡h¡-
®h¡h¡-L¡m¡−L ¢e−u B−p AbÑ¡v H¢V
HL¢V ®h¡h¡ L¡m¡ fËS¡¢a pª¢øl fË¢œ²u¡ j¡œz'' H ph ¢LR¤ fËaÉ¡M¡e L−l ¢a¢e h−me,
h−me, H pLm
LjÑL¡ä ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ü¡i¡¢hL ANËN¢a−L hÉ¡qa L−lz H fËpw−N Ross a¡l Q§s¡¿¹ l¡u ®O¡oe¡
L−l h−me "" H ¢hnÄ−L ®h−qØa h¡e¡−e¡l ph−Q−u pw¢rç fb q−m¡, ""k¡l¡ H hÉ¡f¡−l ®hn£
BNËq£, a¡l¡ ®ke

64 / 88
¢eS E−cÉ¡−N S¡q¡æ¡−jl
S¡q¡æ¡−jl ¢c−L ANËpl quz'' AbÑ¡v pLm Aj¡e¢hL L¡−S ®m¡L A¢dL BNËq£ quz
A¡jl¡ fËaÉr L−l¢R, X¡lECeh¡c f¤y¢Sh¡c£ AbÑ hÉhØq¡l a¡¢šÆL ¢i¢š ¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qaz Bh¡l
l¡S®~e¢aL fÜ¢a−aJ HC ja¡h¡c −b−L a¡l BL¡l BL«¢a ab¡ L¡W¡−j¡ NÊqe L−l b¡−Lz
H L¡l−eC ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, f¤y¢Sf¢al¡C q−µR p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡−cl ph−Q−u hs pjbÑLz
n¢š²h¡c£−cl
n¢š²h¡c£−cl E›¡e Nl£h−cl fcc¢ma Ll¡ Hhw Hje HL¢V AbÑ®e
~ ¢aL cnÑe h¡ cª¢øi‰£ pª¢ø Ll¡
®kM¡−e cu¡, p¡q¡kÉ, pq−k¡N£a¡ j¡eha¡h¡−cl ®L¡e Øq¡e h¡ Ef¢Øq¢a e¡C Hhw HC dl−el
c¡nÑ¢eL ¢Q¿¹¡ h¡ ja¡cnÑ−L ¢e¾c¡ h¡ ApjbÑe−k¡NÉ ¢h−hQe¡ e¡ L−l hlw H¢V−L ""®~h‘¡¢eL
hÉ¡MÉ¡'' h¡ ""fË
""fË¡L«¢aL BCe'' ¢qp¡−h p¡e−¾c NÊqe Ll¡ quz
Social Darwinism in American Thought f¤Øa−Ll Richard Hofstadter E−õM
L−l−Re ®k, Ee¢hwn na−Ll Rail Magnaete (−lmfb
−lmfb ¢ejÑ¡a¡ hÉhp¡u£)
hÉhp¡u£) Chauncery Depew
®S¡l ¢c−u h−me, ¢eECuLÑ nq−l k¡l¡ kn, ®p±i¡NÉ J rja¡ ASÑe L−l−Re
L−l−Re a¡l¡ fËLa
« f−r ""
®k¡NÉaj−cl ¢V−L b¡L¡ '' a−šÆl BcnÑ fË¢a¢e¢daÄL¡l£ hÉ¢š²aÄz L¡le Hl¡ ®nËù ®k¡NÉa¡,
c¤lc¢nÑa¡, M¡f M¡Ju¡−e¡l Ap¡d¡le ®k¡NÉa¡h−m H p¡gmÉ ASÑe L−l−Rez AeÉ HLSe Railway
Baron, James J. Hill c¡h£ L−le, ®lm ®L¡Çf¡e£…−m¡l ®p±i¡NÉ J pgma¡ ""®k¡NÉaj−cl
""®k¡NÉaj−cl ¢V−L
b¡L¡l BC−el'' j¡dÉ−jC ¢edÑ¡¢laz B−j¢lL¡l fËMÉ¡a fy¢¤ Sf¢a Andrew Carneige a¡l
¢hhaÑeh¡−cl Efl ¢hnÄ¡p, H i¡o¡u hÉš² L−le, ""B¢j ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl paÉa¡ My¤−S f−u¢Rz''
AeÉœ ¢a¢e ¢m−M−Re x HC fË¢a−k¡N£a¡j§mL BCe HM¡−e B−Rz A¡jl¡ HV¡ f¡n L¡¢V−u ®k−a
f¡lh
f¡lh e¡, Bl Hl ®L¡e ¢hLÒfJ e¡Cz k¢cJ BCe LMeJ LMeJ hÉ¢š² ¢h−n−ol SeÉ L−W¡l
¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qa quz a−h j¡eh S¡¢al SeÉ HV¡ HL phÑ−nÊù fÜ¢a) L¡le Hl j¡dÉ−j fË¢a¢V
¢hi¡−N ®k¡NÉaj−cl ¢V−L b¡L¡l ¢hou¢V ¢e¢ÕQa quz''
B−j¢lL¡l ph−Q−u hs fy¤¢Sf¢a−cl X¡lECeh¡−cl fË¢a j−e¡i¡h
j−e¡i¡h pÇf−LÑ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£
®~h‘¡¢eL Kennett J. HSU a¡l ¢ehå Darwin’s Three Mistakes H E−õM L−l−Re,
X¡lECeh¡c−L hÉ¢š² fË¢a−k¡N£a¡l üf−r hÉhq¡l Ll¡ qu Hhw Hl ü¡i¡¢hL Ae¤¢pÜ¡¿¹ ¢qp¡−h a¡
j¤š² h¡S¡l AbÑe£¢a ab¡ f¤y¢Sh¡−cJ HC e£¢a CwmÉ¡ä J B−j¢lL¡u Q¡m¤ Ll¡ quz Andrew
Carneige ¢m−M−Re ®k, ""fË¢a−k¡N£a¡j¤mL BCe fR¾c AfR¾c k¡C ®q¡L e¡ ®Le HV¡l A¢ØaaÄ
B−R Hhw a¡ Bjl¡ h¡c ¢c−a f¡¢le¡z''
¢hnÄ¢hMÉ¡a de£ f¤y¢Sf¢a Rockefeller HL d¡f H¢N−u ¢e−u c¡h£ L−le x ""hªqv
hÉhp¡l ¢hL¡n q−m¡ ®k¡NÉaj−cl ¢V−L b¡L¡l h¡Øah fË¢agmez HV¡ fË¡L«¢aL BC−el p¡j¡¢SL
h¡Øah¡uez''
HV¡ p¢aÉC M¤h ®L±a¥qmSeL ®k, B−j¢lL¡l fy¤¢Sf¢a−cl ¢h¢iæ fË¢aù¡a¡ ®kje lL−gm¡l
g¡E−¾Xne, L¡l−eN£ Ce¢ø¢VEVne fËi¢« a ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl N−hoe¡ L¡kÑœ²−j B¢bÑL pq¡ua¡ fËc¡e L−l
b¡−Lz

65 / 88
 Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡u Bjl¡ ®cM−a f¡C ®k, fy¤¢Sh¡c
Sh¡c Sep¡d¡le−L öd¤j¡œ V¡L¡ J H−b−L
fË¡ç rja¡−L f§S¡ Ll−a h¡dÉ L−l h¡ ®V−e B−ez fª¢bh£l pLm dj£Ñu J ®~e¢aL j§mÉ−h¡d−L
…l²aÄq£e h¡ h¡−S ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ L−lz ®k pLm pj¡S hÉhØq¡ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ ja¡cnÑ Ae¤k¡u£
cu¡,, j¡u¡, BaÈaÉ¡N fËi¢¨ a j¡eh£u
f¢lQ¡¢ma qu, a¡l¡ öd¤ hØa¥h¡c£ n¢š²lC N¤l²aÄ ¢c−u b¡−Lz cu¡
…e¡hm£l ¢c−L a¡ ®L¡e lLj c§laj pÇfLÑJ l¡−M e¡z
haÑj¡−e fª¢bh£l fË¡u pLm pj¡S hÉhØq¡uC fy¤¢Sh¡c£ ®~e¢aLa¡l fËi¡h¡d£ez H L¡l−e
Nl£h, Apq¡u J fw…−cl ®L¡e fËL¡l cu¡ c¡¢rZ¡ h¡ p¡q¡kÉ pq−k¡N£a¡ ®cJu¡ qu e¡z Hje ¢L
k¢c a¡l¡ ®L¡e L¡l−e ®l¡−N Bœ²¡¿¹ qu, a¡−cl f¡−n H−p cy¡s¡−h Hje j¡e¤oC ®cM−a f¡Ju¡ k¡u
®R−m--®j−u−cl p¡−b ¢eù¥l J
e¡ Hhw Hi¡−hC ®p dy¤−L dy¤−L j¡l¡ k¡uz ®L¡e ®L¡e ®c−n ®R¡V ®R¡V ®R−m
Aj¡e¢hL L¡S Ll−a h¡dÉ Ll¡ quz haÑj¡−e c§¢iÑr f£¢sa C¢bJ¢fu¡l Hl SeN−el Ae¡q¡−l
jªa¥Él L¡le HC fy¤¢Sh¡c£ ®~e¢aLa¡z AbÑ¡v Hl¡ f¤y¢Sh¡c£ ®~e¢aLa¡l ¢nL¡lz k¢cJ ¢h¢iæ ®cn
®b−L fkÑ¡ç p¡q¡kÉ-
p¡q¡kÉ-pq−k¡N£a¡ HC r¥d¡aÑ j¡e¤o …−m¡−L EÜ¡l Ll¡ ®kaz ¢L¿º a¡l¡ Ae¡q¡−l J
c¡¢l−cÊl L¥W¡l¡O¡−a j¡e−hal S£he k¡fe Ll−a h¡dÉ q−µRz
fy¤¢Sh¡c£ pj¡−Sl Bl HL¢V ®~h¢nøÉ q−m¡ HV¡ pj¡−S Apja¡ h¡ Ap¡−jÉl pª¢ø L−lz H
dl−el pj¡−S de£ J c¢l−âl hÉhd¡e œ²j¡Na h¡s−a b¡−Lz Nl£hl¡ ka Nl£h q−a b¡−L de£l¡
aa de£ q−a b¡−Lz mr mr Nªqq£e ®m¡−Ll A¢ØaaÄ J a¡−cl−L Aj¡e¢hL f¢l¢Øq¢a−a
hph¡p Ll−a q−µR a¡ fy¤¢Sh¡c£ pj¡−Sl A¢h−µRcÉ Awnz Hje¢L B−j¢lL¡l ja de£ J Eæa
®c−n fy¤¢Sh¡c£ je-
je-j¡e¢pLa¡l L¡l−e H dl−el f¢l¢Øq¢a ¢hcÉj¡ez k¢cJ B−j¢lL¡l pj¡S Ha
pÇfcn¡m£, ®k CµR¡ Ll−m a¡l¡ H ph c¢lâ f£¢sa Se−N¡¢ù−L lr¡ Ll−a f¡−l, a¡−cl Q¡L¥l£
¢c−a f¡−lz ¢L¿º haÑj¡e je-
je-j¡e¢pLa¡ q−m¡ Nl£h−cl p¡q¡kÉ eu hlw a¡−cl−L fcc¢ma L−l
hs ab¡ de£ qJu¡z H L¡l−e H pjpÉ¡l ®L¡e pj¡d¡e qu e¡z fËLa
« f−r HV¡ q−m¡ p¡j¡¢SL
¢hhaÑeh¡−cl h¡Øah fË−u¡−Nl gpmz H−cl j−a hs q−a q−m L¡E−L e¡ L¡E−L fcc¢ma
Ll−aC q−hz''
H fËpw−N HL¢V …²l²aÄf§ZÑ ¢ho−ul fË¢a cª¢ø BloÑe Ll¡ q−µR, a¡ q−m¡ j¡eh piÉa¡l
C¢aq¡−p
C¢aq¡−p ph pju Nl£h J ¢exü hÉ¢š²l A¢ØaaÄ ®cM¡ ¢N−u−Rz Hph pj¡−Sl ü¡bÑ ¢Q¿¹¡ k¡ hØa¥h¡c£
¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡−LJ …l²aÄf§eÑ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ q−a¡z pj¡−S ü¡bÑfla¡, nWa¡, hÉ¢š² ü¡bÑC de£ qJu¡l
HLj¡œ Ef¡u ¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qa q−a¡z Aa£−aJ pj¡−S H dl−el ®m¡−Ll A¢ØaaÄ ¢Rm, k¡l¡ fËQä
hØa¥h¡c£ J ®~e¢aLa¡l ¢hQ¡−l ®L¡e BcÑn Øq¡e£u hÉ¢š² ¢Rm e¡z ¢L¿º Ee¢hwn na−Ll ¢àa£u¡−dÑ
H dl−el je-
je-j¡e¢pLa¡ pÇfæ hÉ¢š² HL ea¥e ja¡c−nÑl pÇj¤M£e quz ¢hNa 150 hvpl fl
Hdl−el ¢eù¥l ü¡bÑ¡å hÉ¢š² pj¡−S pj¡−m¡¢Qa J ¢e¢¾ca qJu¡l f¢lh−aÑ fËnw¢pa J e¢¾ca q−a
n¤l² L−lz L¡le pj¡−S H dl−el Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢nø fÊ¡L«¢aL ¢hd¡e ab¡ ü¡i¡¢hL j¡eh£u Q¢lœ
¢qp¡−h BMÉ¡¢ua Ll¡ quz H ®fË¢r−a X¡lECeh¡c pj¡−S HL¢V ¢jbÉ¡ djÑja ¢qp¡−h fË¢a¢ùa
qu, k¡ pLm fËL¡l e£¢aq£ea¡ J q²cuq£e j−e¡hª¢š J ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡−L AeÉ¡u pjbÑe fËc¡e L−l

66 / 88
b¡−Lz H ¢hou¢V
¢hou¢V Robert E D Clark Hi¡−h hÉ¡MÉ¡ L−l−Re, ""pw−r−f
""pw−r−f ¢hhaÑeh¡c HLSe
Afl¡d£−L a¡l ¢h−h−Ll håe −b−L AhL¡n c¡e L−l, HLSe fË¢a−k¡N£l fË¢a ph−Q−u
e£¢a‘¡e öeÉ BQleJ A−k±¢š²L ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ q−h e¡, j¾c−L i¡−m¡ hm−a q−hz''
""Evolution
"" or Creation e¡jL f¤Øa−L H Enoch ¢m−M−Re, "" Prof. J. Holmes
h−me, X¡lECeh¡c pj¡−S p¢WLi¡−h fË−u¡N Ll¡ q−m i¡m−L ¢V−L b¡L¡l j¡ec−ä ¢hQ¡l Ll−a
q−hz HV¡ fËL«af−r S‰−ml BCe ®kM¡−e ""®S¡l k¡l j¤õ¤L a¡l '' Hhw ®k¡NÉajC ¢V−L
b¡−Lz Qa¥la¡ h¡ ¢eù¥la¡ h¡ L¡f¤l²oa¡ h¡ fËa¡le¡ k¡C ®q¡L e¡
e¡ ®Le, a¡C hÉ¢š²l pj¡−S ¢V−L
b¡L¡l SeÉ i¡m J p¢WLz''
A¡jl¡ ®c−M¢R ®k, djÑq£ea¡ J X¡lECeh¡c ¢hNa 150 hR−l pLm ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ j§mÉ−h¡d J
ja¡cnÑ−L ¢fR−e ®g−m ¢hnÄ j¡eha¡l SeÉ c¤xM, ®hce¡, Lø, c¤−iÑ¡N c¤¢ÕQ¿¹¡ J qa¡n¡ h−u ¢e−u
H−p−Rz djÑq£ea¡ J X¡lECeh¡c−L k¡l¡ ¢e−S−cl
¢e−S−cl ü¡bÑ p¤lr¡l q¡¢au¡l j−e L−l−Rz a¡l¡ ¢e−S−cl
SeÉ HC cnÑe Ae¤ple L−l−R a¡q−m¡-
a¡q−m¡- c§hÑm ¢e¢ÕQq² q−h J phm ¢V−L b¡L−hz a¡l¡ h¤T−a
f¡−l¢e ®k, H fË¢œ²u¡u a¡l¡ pjNË j¡eh S¡¢al SeÉ HL¢V ¢hl¡V gy¡c ®~al£ Ll−Rz fËLa«f−r
flha£Ñ−a a¡l¡ ¢e−Sl¡C Hl ¢nL¡l q−u−Rz L¡le
L¡le a¡l¡ ®hy−Q h¡ ¢V−L b¡L¡l SeÉ ka pwNË¡j
Bl ¢h¢iæ jah¡c h¡ a−šÆl h¾d−e BhÜ qJu¡l ka fË−Qø¡C Q¡m¡L e¡ ®Le, h¡Øa−h ¢hnÄ
hËj¡ä f¢lQ¡me¡l ®r−œ HL Se fËi¨, HLSe ¢hQ¡lL J HLSe j¡œ j¡¢mL l−k−Rez ¢a¢e ®L¡e
reØq¡u£ rja¡dl euz fËL«af−r Bõ¡q fËcš p¤−k¡−Nl pàÉhq¡l
pàÉhq¡l L−lC H ja¡c−nÑl Ae¤pl−e
¢eù¥l, ¢ekÑ¡ae, à¾cÄ, pwNË¡−jl j¡−T rja¡ n¢š² J pÇfc ASÑe L−l a¡ Bõ¡lC c¡ez kaC ®p
¢hnÄ¡p Ll²L e¡ ®Le, ®p Hje HL¢V f¢l¢Øq¢a−a/h¡ pj¡−S hph¡p Ll−R ®pM¡−e hm ab¡
rja¡n¡m£l¡ ¢hSu£ qu b¡−Lzz ¢L¿º fËLa
Hhw c§hÑml¡ pj¡S ®b−L ¢hm£e h¡ ¢e¢ÕQq² q−u b¡−L ª paÉ
HC ®k, fª¢bh£−a j¡ehS¡¢a HL¢V L¢We fl£r¡l pÇj¤M£ez H ¢hou¢V f¢hœ −L¡l¡−e Hi¡−h ®O¡oe¡
Ll¡ q−u−R, ""fª¢bh£l h¤−L k¡q¡ ¢LR¤ B−R B¢j ®pC…−m¡−L Eq¡l ®n¡i¡ L¢lu¡¢R, j¡e¤o−L fl£r¡
L¢lh¡l SeÉ Eq¡−cl j−dÉ ®L L−jÑ "®nËù' (p¤l¡ L¡q¡g-
L¡q¡g-7)z
k¡l¡ j−e L−l a¡−cl ¢hš-
¢hš-®~hih, rja¡ J n¢š² a¡l¡ ab¡ L¢ba A¢Øa−aÄl pwNË¡−jl
j¡dÉ−j ASÑe L−l−Rz a¡l¡ ®k ¢L q©cu ¢hc¡lL ®hce¡ J r¢al pÇj¤M£e q−h, −k ®L¡e r¢a
f§l−el ®L¡e hÉhØq¡ e¡Cz f¤el²›¡e ¢ch−p kMe a¡l¡ fËLa
« h¡Øaha¡ Ae¤d¡he Ll−a prj q−h,
aMe a¡l¡ h¤T−a f¡l−h ¢L dl−el
dl−el A¿¹p¡löeÉ, gy¡f¡ J ¢jbÉ¡ S£he cnÑe a¡l¡ m¡me L−l®Rz
f¢hœ −L¡l¡−e ¢hou¢V Hi¡−h E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R, "" S¡æ¡ah¡p£Ne, A¢NÀh¡p£¢cN−L p−ð¡de L¢lu¡
h¢m−h Bj¡−cl fË¢af¡mL Bj¡¢cN−L ®k fË¢an˲¢a ¢cu¡¢R−me, Bjl¡ ®a¡ a¡q¡ paÉ
f¡Cu¡¢R−a¡j¡−cl fË¢af¡mL ®a¡j¡¢cN−L ®k fË¢anË
an˲¢a ¢cu¡¢R−me −a¡jl¡
−a¡jl¡ a¡q¡ paÉ f¡Cu¡−Re ¢L?
¢L?
Eq¡l¡ h¢m−h qyÉ¡z Aaxfl S®~eL ®O¡oe¡L¡l£ a¡q¡−cl j−dÉ ®O¡oe¡ L¢l−h, Bõ¡ql m¡ea
S¡¢mj−cl Efl k¡q¡l¡ fË¢ahåLa¡ pª¢ø L¢la Hhw Eq¡−a hœ²a¡ Ae¤på¡e L¢lax Eq¡l¡C
B−Ml¡a pj−å A¢hnÄ¡p£ z (p¤l¡ Bl¡g-
Bl¡g-40-
40-45)

67 / 88
 Bl¡gh¡p£Ne, ®k
®k ®m¡L¢cN−L ¢Qq² à¡l¡ ¢Q¢e−h Hhw a¡q¡¢cN−L p−ð¡de L¢lu¡ h¢m−h,
Bl¡g--48)
−a¡j¡−cl cm J ®a¡j¡−cl AqwL¡l ®L¡e L¡−S B¢pm e¡z (p¤l¡ Bl¡g
X¡lEq|~eh¡c£ fy¤¢Sh¡c£ dÉ¡e d¡le¡ h¡ ja¡c−nÑl à¡l¡ k¡l¡ fËi¡¢ha qu ¢e Hhw k¡l¡ H
fª¢bh£−a a¡−cl BNj−el L¡le i¨®m k¡u e¡C Hhw H pj−å p−Qae Hhw Bõ¡qa¡m¡l A¢Øa−aÄ
BØq¡n£mz a¡l¡ AeÉ¡eÉ j¡e¤o−L Bõ¡ql pª¢ø S£h ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ L−l Hhw Bõ¡ql ¢e−cÑn
Ae¤k¡u£ k¡−cl p¡−b jd¤l, cu¡ J ®pÀqn£m BQle L−l Hhw a¡−cl c¤xM Lø Ap¤¢hd¡ c§l Ll¡l
SeÉ pñ¡hÉ ph ¢LR¤ L−lz Hl¡ a¡−cl p¡−b ¢j¢ø Lb¡ h−m, H¢aj−cl ®cM¡öe¡ L−l, Ap¤Øq J
fw…−cl ®cMi¡m L−lz H dl−el ®m¡L f¡f L¡S ®b−L ¢hla b¡−L Hhw −L¡l¡−e h¢eÑa Bõ¡ql
B−cn Ae¤k¡u£ a¡−cl LaÑ−hÉ A¢hQm b¡−Lz Hl¡C pÇfc, S¡¢a, hZÑ, ®nËe£, BcnÑ ab¡ cnÑ−el
®L¡e f−l¡u¡ L−l e¡z a¡l¡ H pLm c§hÑma¡ ®b−L pÇf§Ñe j¤š²z f¢hœ ®L¡l¡e Ae¤k¡u£ Bõ¡ql
cª¢ø−a Hl¡C phÑ−nÊùz

®~e¢aLa¡ ¢hdÄwp£ X¡lECeh¡c

¢hnÄj¡eha¡ ab¡ j¡eh S¡¢al SeÉ X¡lX~Ceh¡c ph−Q−u hs ®k r¢a p¡de L−l−R a¡ q−m¡
SeN−el djÑ ¢hnÄ¡p ®b−L ¢hQ¨Éa Ll¡z dj£Ñu pLm fËL¡l e£¢a J j§mÉ−h¡d Afpªa q−m¡z g−m
®~e¢aL Hhw BdÉ¡¢aÈL Ahru pj¡S−L NË¡p L−l −gm−m¡z
H fkÑ¡−u A−e−L hm−a f¡−le ®k, fª¢bh£−a hý djÑq£e ®m¡L h¡p L−l Bp−Re k¡l¡
X¡lECe h¡ X¡lECeh¡c pÇf−LÑ ®L¡e d¡le¡C l¡M−ae e¡z a¡C H hÉ¡f¡−l X¡lECe−L ®c¡o¡−l¡f
Ll¡ pwNa euz haÑj¡−e M¤h Lj pwMÉL ‘¡e£ hÉ¢š² X¡lECeh¡−cl üf−r hš²hÉ EfØq¡fe L−l
b¡−Lez
b¡−Lez ¢L¿º fËL«af−r p£¢ja hÉ¢š²hNÑC pj¡−Sl A¢dL¡wn ®r−œC j¡e¤−ol ¢Q¿¹¡-®Qae¡−L fËi¡¢ha
L−l b¡−Lez pj¡−Sl AN¢ea ®m¡L a¡−cl à¡l¡ fËi¡¢ha q−u b¡−Lz a¡l¡ a¡−cl ¢hnÄ cª¢øi¢‰
hÉ¡fLi¡−h pj¡−S R¢X−u| ¢c−a prjz Ec¡qleül©f hm¡ k¡u, ¢hnÄ¢hcÉ¡m−ul ¢hMÉ¡a AdÉ¡fL,
¢p−ej¡ f¢lQ¡mL, ¢hnÄ¢hMÉ¡a fËL¡ne¡ fË¢aù¡−el pÇf¡cL, Mh−l L¡NS ab¡ f¢œL¡l p¡−b S¢sa
A¢dL¡wn hÉ¢š²hNÑC ¢hhaÑeh¡−c ¢hnÄ
¢hnÄ¡p£ Hhw pwNa L¡l−eC e¡¢ØaLz H L¡l−eC pj¡−Sl ®k ®r−œ
Hl¡ ¢hQle L−le, ®p ph ®r−œ a¡−cl ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ J e¡¢ØaLÉh¡c£ ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ fËi¡¢ha L−l b¡−Lez
g−m HC
HC ¢hL«a ja¡cnÑ pj¡−S hÉ¡fLi¡−h NÊqe−k¡NÉa¡ J Se¢fËua¡ ®f−u b¡−Lz
q¡iÑ¡X ¢hnÄ¢hcÉ¡m−ul ¢hnÄ¢hMÉ¡a X¡lEqeh¡c£ S£h-
S£h-¢h‘¡e£ Ernst Mayr pj¡−S ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl
AhØq¡e h¡ i¥¢jL¡ pÇf−LÑ ¢m−M−Re x
""X¡lEC−el pjuL¡m −b−L fË−aÉL hÉ¢š² ü£L¡l L−l Bp−Re ®k, j¡e¤o J h¡el HLC
hwnd¡l¡ ®b−L Eá¤az ¢hhaÑeh¡c j¡e¤−ol ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l pLm ®rœ Ab¡Ñv cnÑe, A¢d¢hcÉ¡, e£¢an¡Øœ,
l¡Se£¢a, AbÑe£¢a ph¢LR¤−LC fËi¡¢ha L−l−Rz''
X¡lX~Ceh¡−cl ja¡c−nÑl B¢dfaÉ pj¡S S£h−e HL¢V A¢a n¢š²n¡m£ p−Çj¡qe£ ¢qp¡−h
L¡S L−l−Rz k¤h pÇfÐc¡−ul HL ¢hn¡m Awn k¡−cl S£he pÇf−LÑ
pÇf−LÑ A¢i‘a¡ Lj Hhw ¢hnÄ

68 / 88
cª¢øiwN£ pÇf−LÑ ®L¡e üµR d¡le¡ e¡Cz a¡l¡C ¢h−no L−l pq−SC X¡lECeh¡−cl ¢nr¡l fË¢a
A¡L«ø q−u b¡−Lz A¢a pq−SC H pLm ®m¡L−L HL¢V ¢edÑ¡¢la ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡u ¢e−u Bp¡ k¡uz L¡le
Mh−ll L¡NS, p¡j¢uL£−a a¡l¡ k¡ f¡W L−l, a¡l¡ −k ¢p−ej¡ h¡ e¡VL ®c®M,
®c®M, ®k N¡e ö−e Hhw
ph−Q−u …l²aÄf§eÑ q−m¡ a¡l¡ ¢hcÉ¡m−u −k dl−el ¢nr¡ NÊqe L−l b¡−Lz HlC fËi¡−hl g−mC Na
150 hRl k¡hv X¡lECeh¡c−L paÉ ¢qp¡−h ®m¡−L ¢hnÄ¡p L−l Bp−R k¢cJ a¡ fËa¡le¡j§mL J
A−~h‘¡¢eL ¢qp¡−h fËj¡¢Zaz
mr Ll−m ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, fËL¡−nÉ djÑ¢h−l¡d£ fËQ¡le¡
¡le¡ k¢cJ Lc¡¢Qv Ll¡ qu Hhw fËL¡−nÉ
®LqC djÑq£ea¡ pÇf−LÑ hš²h¡ l¡−M e¡z HC L¡l−e ¢h¢iæ −N¡fe J p¤rÈ fË¢œ²u¡u Hq~ L¡kÑœ²j
f¢lQ¡me¡ Ll¡ quz djÑ ¢e−u q¡¢p-
q¡¢p-W¡–
W¡–¡, dj£Ñu ¢hou Hhw djÑ¢hnÄ¡p£ hÉ¢š²hNÑ Hhw fËQ¡le¡ L¡kÑœ²®j
Hje Hje në EµQ¡le Ll¡ qu, k¡l j¡dÉ−j Bõ¡ql A¢ØaaÄ, i¡NÉ−L Aü£L¡l Ll¡ quz p‰£a,
EfeÉ¡p, ¢p−ej¡, Mh−ll L¡N−Sl ¢n−l¡e¡j, q¡pÉ−L±a¥L CaÉ¡¢c dj£Ñu AffËQ¡−ll ®N¡fe j¡dÉj
¢qp¡−h hÉhq²a quz
AeÉ¢c−L X¡lECeh¡−cl ¢hou¡¢c djÑ¢h−l¡d£ fËQ¡le¡l ph−Q−u p¡d¡lZ q¡¢au¡lz ®L¡e lLj
f¡lØf¢lL pÇfLÑ h¡ p§œ R¡s¡C h¡el,
h¡el, j¡eh S¡¢al f§hÑ f¤l²o ¢Rm HC pÇf§eÑ ¢jbÉ¡ Lb¡¢V fËQ¡l
Ll¡ quz j−e¡¢h‘¡e N−hoe¡uJ X¡lECeh¡c−L p¤rÈi¡−h ¢e−u Bp¡ quz g−m Hje HL¢Y~ pj¡S
c¡u--c¡¢uaÄ A¢a a¥µRi¡−h NÊqe
N¢Wa qu, ®k pj¡−Sl pcpÉl¡ djÑ, f¤el²›¡e h¡ flL¡m J ®~e¢aL c¡u
L−lz H pj¡S Bm¡Óq pÇf−LÑ ¢Q¿¹¡J L−l
L−l e¡, iuJ L−l e¡, ¢hnÄ¡pJ L−l e¡, g−m a¡l¡ a¡−cl
LjÑL¡−ä ®L¡e eÉ¡ue£¢a, dj,Ñ BcnÑ ¢LRC¤ ¢h−hQe¡ L−l e¡ hlw a¡−cl d¡le¡ Ae¤k¡u£ a¡−cl f§hÑ
f¤l²o AbÑ¡v föl eÉ¡u BQle L−lz Ec¡qle ül©f hm¡ k¡u ®k, djÑ ¢hnÄ¡p pÇf−LÑ Aje−k¡N£ J
®M¡c¡i£l² eu Hje j¢qm¡l L¡−R paÄ£aÄ h¡ pv Q¢lœ h¡ Q¢lœha£ qJu¡l fËaÉ¡n¡ Ll¡ k¡u e¡z
L¡le a¡l¡ a¡−cl L¡−Sl p£j¡−lM¡ pÇf−LÑ Ah¢qa eu hlw a¡l¡ ®k ®L¡e dl−el e£¢aq£ea¡ J
Apv L¡S Ll¡l SeÉ BNËq£ q−hz haÑj¡−e Bj¡−cl pj¡−S HC d¡le¡C fËQ¡l Ll¡ q−u−R ®k,
®~e¢aL Q¢l−œl N¤l²aÄ h¡ dj£Ñu Ae¤n¡pe h¡ ¢h¢d ¢hd¡−el ®L¡e …l²aÄ e¡Cz djÑ pÇf−LÑ j¡e¤−ol
HC dl−el ¢hQ§É¢a h¡ A¢hnÄ¡p X¡lECe¡−cl hÉ¡fL fËQ¡−lC gmz g−m j¡e¤o j−e L−l ®k, a¡l
LjÑL¡−äl ®L¡e c¡k-
c¡k-c¡¢uaÄ e¡C Hhw a¡l L¡−l¡ L¡−R Sh¡h¢c¢qJ Ll−a q−h e¡z HC d¡le¡ a¡−L
¢c−el fl ¢ce A¢dL M¡l¡f L¡S Ll¡l ¢c−L d¡¢ha
d¡¢ha L−lz
®me--®ce,
Ni£l Ae¤på¡−e ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, fÊ−aÉL qaÉ¡, f¢aa¡hª¢š, fËa¡le¡, S¤u¡Q¥¢l, O¤o ®me
œ²u-
œ²u-¢hœ²−u, ®m¡L WL¡−e¡pq pLm A®~e¢aL L¡kÑœ²−j djÑq£ea¡C fËd¡e L¡le ¢qp¡−h cªnÉj¡e quz
djÑq£ea¡ fËQ¡le¡l fËd¡e ¢hou q−µR X¡lECeh¡−cl ¢jbÉ¡ ašÆ AbÑ¡v j¡e¤o ®~ch¡v pª¢ø q−u−R a¡C
a¡l ®L¡e pËø¡ h¡ pª¢øLaÑ¡ e¡Cz
The Lie: Evolution Hl ®mML Ken Ham X¡lECeh¡−cl djÑq£ea¡ pÇf−LÑ ¢m−M−Re ®k,
"" k¢c Bf¢e Bõ¡q−L Aü£L¡l L−le Hhw Bõ¡ql S¡uN¡u AeÉ ®L¡e ¢hnÄ¡p-
p-k¡ qW¡v
h¡ H−m¡f¡b¡¢s ®L¡e fË¢œ²u¡u ¢hnÄ¡p Øq¡fe L−le, ®p ®r−œ eÉ¡u J AeÉ¡−ul ®L¡e ¢i¢š b¡−L e¡z

69 / 88
BCe hm−a a¡C h¤T¡u, k¡ Bf¢e ®~al£ Ll−a Q¡ez HM¡−e ®L¡e e£¢a, paÉ h¡ Ae¤n¡p−el h¡m¡C
®eCz SeNe ¢e−Sl¡C ¢e−S−cl BCe fËeue Ll−hz''
¢hMÉ¡a X¡lECeh¡c£ Theodious Dobzhansky ü£L¡l L−le ®k, "" fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Qe k¡
X¡lECeh¡−cl ¢i¢š, Hl j¡dÉ−j
j¡dÉ−j HL¢V ®~e¢aLa¡q£e J Adf¢aa pj¡S pª¢ø L−lz fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Qe
Aq¢jL¡h¡c, p¡q¢pLa¡l f¢lh−aÑ L¡f¤l²oa¡, fËa¡le¡ J ®n¡oe fËi¢« a L¡kÑœ²j−L m¡me L−l
b¡−Lz pj¡−Sl ¢h¢iæ jqm j¡e¤−ol HCph ü¡i¡¢hL ®~h¢nø pj§q ¢hL¡−n h¡d¡ ®cu Hhw ¢e−od L−l
hlw, fr¡¿¹−l, H…−m¡l f¢lh−aÑ
f¢lh−aÑ cu¡, jq¡e¤iha¡ f−l¡fL¡l£a¡, ®N¡œ, S¡¢al ab¡ j¡eha¡l SeÉ
BaÈaÉ¡−Nl ja Q¡¢l¢œL …e¡hm£−LC fª¢bh£l pLm pj¡S hÉhØq¡uC f¢l−f¡oe L−l b¡−Lz
Bjl¡ Bj¡−cl Q¡lf¡−n a¡L¡−mC ®~e¢aLa¡l Ni£l J Q§s¡¿¹ Ahr−ul ¢Qq² ®cM−a f¡−h¡, k¡
X¡lECeh¡c hým fË−Qø¡l j¡dÉ−j Beue Ll−a
Ll−a prj q−u−Rz fËN¢a J piÉa¡l Eæu−e
f¡lØf¢lL pq−k¡N£a¡ HL¡NÊa¡, nÊÜ¡ J ®pÀqn£ma¡®L h¡c ®cJu¡l g−m ®k fËN¢a J piÉa¡l
Eæue p¡de Ll¡ q−u−R j−jÑ d¡le¡ q−u b¡−L Hhw H pÇf−LÑ fË¡uC hm¡ b¡−L ®k, hªqšl
Evf¡ce J Eæue L¡kÑœ²−jl SeÉ H dl−el f¢l¢Øq¢a pª¢ø Ll¡ Sl²¢lz fËL«af−r, j¡e¤o−L H
föl fkÑ¡−u e¡¢j−u Be¡l j¡dÉ−jC H dl−el ab¡L¢ba Eæue p¡de LjÑL¡−äl j¡dÉ−j Ll¡ pñh
q−u−Rz a¡C HC dl−el LjÑL¡ä−L Eæue h¡ piÉa¡ ¢qp¡−h BMÉ¡¢ua Ll¡ p¢WL euz fËLa
ª
paÉ HC ®k, j¡e¤o ®L¡e fö eu Hhw −L¡e fö q−a −p BNjeJ L−l¢ez Bõ¡qa¡m¡ j¡e¤o−L
k¤¢š², h¤¢Ü, ¢h−hL J BaÈ¡ ¢c−u pª¢ø L−l−Rez HC pjØa …e¡hm£l L¡l−eC j¡e¤o−L pÇf§eÑ
Bm¡c¡ fËS¡¢a ¢h−hQe¡ Ll®a q−hz ¢L¿º X¡lECeh¡c£ hÙºh¡c£−cl fËi¡−h j¡e¤o a¡l ®~e¢aL
Q¢l−œl H pjØa …e¡hm£ i¨−m ®N−R Hhw Adx f¢aa q−u pwL£eÑa¡, Q¢lœq£ea¡, ¢h−hLq£ea¡l
Hje fkÑ¡−k
−k ®f±−R−R, Hje¢L fö−cl j−dÉJ H dl−el Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢nøÉ ®cM−a f¡Ju¡ k¡u e¡z
a¡l¡ h−me, ""k¡C ®q¡L e¡ ®Le Bjl¡ fö−cl AdxØae f¤l²o Hhw H…−m¡ Bj¡−cl hwn£u
Ešl¡¢dL¡l Hhw H hÉ¡f¡−l HL¢V ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL k¤¢š²aLÑ EfØq¡fe L−le, k¡ a¡−cl
¢h−hLq£ea¡ J CµR¡ n¢š²l Ai¡−hl
Ai¡−hl fË¢agmez
A−eL X¡lEqeh¡c£ ®~h‘¡¢eL HC k¤¢š² ¢c−u öl² L−le ®k, j¡e¤−ol j−dÉ ®k Afl¡d
fËhea¡ ®cM¡ k¡u, a¡ a¡−cl fö f§hÑf¤l²o−cl Ešl¡¢dL¡lz fËMÉ¡a ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ Stephen Jay
Gould c¡h£ L−le, k¢cJ fËb−j Ca¡¢mu¡e fc¡bÑ¢hc Lombroso a¡l hC Ever Since Darwin
H E−õM L−le, Afl¡d fËhea¡l ®~h‘¡¢eL ašÅ Lc¡¢Qa ea¥ez ¢L¿º Lombroso ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ašÆ
¢houL HL ¢hL«a k¤¢š² EfØÚq¡fe L−lez ¢a¢e h−me, ""S¾jNa Afl¡d£ qJu¡l L¡le öd¤j¡œ
h¤¢Üïwna¡ h¡ Ap¤Øqa¡ euz HV¡ Br¢lL A−bÑ f¤hÑf¤l²−ol ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡l HL¢V fkÑ¡uz Bj¡−cl
B¢cj h¡el f§hÑf¤l²o−cl Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢nøÉ pj§q Bj¡−cl hwnd¡l¡u f¤el¡hª¢š OY~¡uz ¢LR¤ ¢LR¤
®m¡−Ll j−dÉ f§hÑf¤l²o−cl, A¢dL¡wn Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢nÖY~É pj§q ¢hcÉj¡e b¡−Lz H−cl H ph Q¡¢l¢œL
®~h¢nøÉpj§q Aa£a ApiÉ pj¡−Sl SeÉ kb¡kb b¡L−mJ haÑj¡e pj¡−S H ph ®~h¢nøÉ NÊqe−k¡NÉ
eu ¢hd¡u Bjl¡ a¡−cl−L Afl¡d£ ¢qp¡−h BMÉ¡¢ua L¢lz Bjl¡ a¡−cl−L Ll²e¡ Ll−a f¡¢l,
L¡le a¡l¡ a¡−cl−L (S¾jNai¡−h) p¡q¡kÉ Ll−a prj eu z''

70 / 88
 X¡lECeh¡c£−cl c¡¢h Ae¤k¡u£, ®L¡e j¡e¤o j¡e¤o−L qaÉ¡ L−l, a¡−L ®hce¡ ®cu, Q¥¢l L−l,
j¡l¢fV L−l, H ph LjÑL¡ä k¡l¡ OV¡u a¡l¡ a¡−cl L¢ba f§hÑfl
¤ ²o−cl Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢n−øÉl
Ešl¡¢dL¡l£z H L¡l−e k¡l¡ H ph Afl¡dj§mL L¡S L−l H−a a¡−cl ®L¡e ®c¡o e¡C Hhw a¡l¡
rj¡l −k¡NÉz '' HC ¢hL«a ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l fËi¡−h pj¡−S Afl¡−dl c−äl ¢hd¡e ¢p¢bmi¡−h L¡kÑLl Ll¡
qu Hhw pj¡−S Afl¡−dl pwMÉ¡ ¢ce ¢ce hª¢Ü f¡uz
H pjØa hš²hÉ/ja¡j−al −fË¢r−a ®cM¡ k¡−µR, X¡lECeh¡c£l¡ j¡e¤−ol ¢h−hL, CµR¡n¢š²,
k¤¢š², ¢hQ¡lh¤¢Ü−h¡d CaÉ¡¢c a¥µR ¢hou Hhw a¡l¡ j¡e¤o−L h¤¢Üq£e J öd¤j¡œ fö fËhª¢šl à¡l¡
f¢lQ¡¢ma fË¡e£ ¢qp¡−h j−e L−lez HC ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡e¤k¡u£ HL¢V ¢qwpË ¢pwq ®kje a¡l Bœ²je¡aÈL
j−e¡i¡h h¡c ¢c−u ¢el£q BQle ®kje -®~dkÑ, j¡SÑe¡ fËi«¢a pc…e¡hm£ ASÑe Ll−a prj qu
e¡z HLSe j¡e¤−ol j−dÉJ Ae¤l©f jej¡e¢pLa¡ h¡ ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l ¢hcÉj¡ea¡l AbÑ q−µR, pj¡−S
An¡¢¿¹, ¢el¡fš¡q£ea¡, à¾cÄ-pwO¡a, pwNË¡j J k¤Ü Qm−aC b¡L−h Bl X¡lECeh¡c H dl−el
pj¡S hÉhØq¡C
hÉhØq¡C fËaÉ¡n¡ L−lz H d¡le¡ pj¡−S ¢hcÉj¡e b¡L−m pj¡−S HL dl−el L¡ä‘¡eq£e
Se−N¡¢ù pª¢ø qu, k¡l¡ ¢e−S−cl−L pÇf§eÑl©−f ü¡d£e J ®hf−l¡u¡ h−m j−e Ll−a b¡−Lz

X¡lEC−el fËØa¡¢ha cnÑe x j¡eha¡l SeÉ ¢eù¥l J qa¡n¡hÉ”L

®L¡e hÉ¢š²l S£h−el k¢c ®L¡e E−ŸnÉ e¡ b¡−L, a¡ q−m a¡l Q¢l−œ¡æu−el ®L¡e lLj
fË−Qø¡C b¡−L e¡z ®p S£he−L c¡u-
c¡u-c¡¢uaÄq£e, a¡j¡n¡l hÙº j−e L−l, Ae¤i¨¢aq£e J ph ¢LR¤C a¡l
L¡−R …l²aÄq£e h−m j−e qu, a¡l L¡kÑœ²−j ¢h−h−Ll ®L¡e i§¢jL¡ b¡−L e¡z ®p ¢e−S−L ®k ®L¡e
BCe L¡e¤−el E−dÑ h−m j−e L−lz a¡l ®L¡e pc…e¡hm£ J Eæa QQ¡¢l¢œL
¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢nøÉ b¡−L e¡ h¡ a¡
ASÑ−el ®L¡e fË−Qø¡C a¡l j−dÉ f¢lm¢ra qu e¡z a¡l H ¢hL«a cª
c¢øi‰£
ª¢øi‰£ Ae¤k¡u£ ®HL¢V Eæa
dl−el föz AbÑ¡v ®p öd¤ AeÉ¡eÉ fË¡e£l j−a¡ p¤M¡cÉ J fËSee J ph dl−el ¢h−e¡ce J Be¾c
b¡−Lz
a¡l S£h−el HLj¡œ E−ŸnÉ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ L−l Hhw jªaÉ¥ l A−fr¡u b¡ −Lz Hi¡−h X¡lECe h¡
X¡lECeh¡−cl ¢LR¤C e¡ S¡e¡ p−šÆJ HLSe p¡d¡le j¡e¤o, X¡lEC−el BcÑ®nl Ae¤p¡l£ j¡eh
p¿¹¡e ¢qp¡−h pj¡−S BaÈfËL¡n L−lz Hl¡ ®k−qa¥ HL¢V ¢eù¥l S£he k¡fe L−l b¡−Lz g−m a¡l¡
Hhww ¢LR¤C a¡−cl
®~el¡nÉSeL J qa¡n¡hÉ”L q−u b¡−Lz jªa¤Él j¡dÉ−j ph ¢LR¤lC pj¡¢ç OV−h Hh
Ap¤M£ L−l e¡z g−m a¡l¡ ¢e−S−cl j−dÉ HL dl−el h¾c£ ¢qp¡−h ¢ce L¡V¡uz BaÈqaÉ¡, j¡e¢pL
pjpÉ¡, qa¡n¡, j¡e¢pL Ahp¡c fËi«¢a ®e¢ah¡QL fËi¡h j¡eh pj¡−S X¡lECeh¡−cl fËaÉr gmz
¢hhaÑeh¡−cl HLSe ®S¡l pjbÑL Richard Dawkens Hl j−a j¡e¤o HL¢V fËSee k¿»
j¡œz
j¡œz j¡e¤−ol S£h−el fËd¡e E−ŸnÉ q−m¡ j¡e¤o e¡jL fË¡e£l h£S flha£Ñ fËS−¾jl ¢eLV ®fy±−R
®cJu¡ Dawkins Hl ¢hL«a ¢Q¿¹d¡l¡u H R¡s¡ j¡eh fËS¡¢a−a HC fª¢bh£ ®hy−Q b¡L¡l Afl
®L¡e E−ŸnÉ e¡Cz H ¢hnÄ J j¡eh S¡¢a ®~ch¡v pwO¢Va HL ¢hnªwMm¡l j¡−T pª¢ø q−u−Rz k¡l¡ H
dl−el
dl−el ¢hï¡¢¿¹Ll ¢Q¿¹¡-®Qae¡ à¡l¡ BµRæ b¡−L, a¡l¡ pq−SC qa¡n¡ J ¢el¡n¡l ¢nL¡l q−u k¡ez

71 / 88
®k ¢hnÄ¡p L−l S£h−el fËd¡e E−ŸnÉ q−m¡ öd¤ fËSee J ph ¢LR¤C jªa¥Él p¡−b p¡−b ®no q−u
k¡uz a¡l L¡−R -®fËj, i¡mh¡p¡, hå¥aÄ, ®p±¾ckÑ, paÉ, paa¡ ph ¢LR¤C a¥µRz S£he ¢eù¥l J
AfË−u¡Se£u Hhw ph ¢LR¤C ¢el¡e¾c J AbÑq£ez
Unweaving The Rainbow f¤Øa−L j¤Mh−å Hawkins j¡eh S£h−e X¡lECeh¡−cl
®e¢ah¡QL J qa¡n¡hÉ”L fËi¡−hl Lb¡ ü£L¡l L−l ¢m−M−Re x
Bj¡l f¤Øa−Ll HLSe ¢h−cn£ fËL¡nL a¡l hC f−s h−m−Re "" j¡eh S£h−el n£am,
AåL¡l J ¢eù¥l ¢cL k¡ HC hC−a
hC−a ¢mM¡ q−u−R a¡ a¡−L Hi¡−h ¢hQ¢ma L−l−R, −k ¢a¢e l¡−œ
O¤j¡−a prj qe¢ez'' AeÉl¡ a¡−L (−mML−L) fËnÀ L−l−Re, ¢a¢e O¤j −b−L ®Lje L−l S¡NÐa
q−a f¡−lez ¢iæ ®c−nl HLSe ¢nrL a¡−L ¢e¾c¡ L−l ¢m−M−Re ®k, HLSe R¡œ£ a¡l hC f−s
S£h−el E−ŸnÉq£ea¡ Am£LaÄ J gy¡f¡ ¢cL pÇf−LÑ
pÇf−LÑ f−s ®p Ly¡c−a b¡−Lz ®pC ¢nrL a¡l
R¡œ£−L hC¢V AeÉ L¡E−L e¡ ®cM¡−e¡l SeÉ fl¡jnÑ ¢c−u−Re, L¡le H dl−el ®~el¡SÉh¡c£ J
qa¡n¡hÉ”L dÉ¡e d¡le¡u ®ke Bl ®LE fËi¡¢ha e¡ quz pLm fËL¡l ¢h‘¡e ¢houL fs¡öe¡ j¡eh
S£he pÇf−LÑ Hje HL dl−el ¢el¡e¾c, e£lp, L¡ù pcªn c§xM,
xM, ®hce¡c¡uL J qa¡n¡hÉ”L d¡le¡
®cu Hhw ®p j¡eh S£he HL¢V Ae¤hÑl ®rœ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ L−l Hhw S£h−el fË¢a Apñh
h£anËÜ q−u f−s k¡ HV¡ ¢h‘¡e pÇf−LÑ HL¢V A¢a p¡d¡le A¢i−k¡N ¢qp¡−h ®cM¡ k¡uz k¢cJ
¢h‘¡e£l¡ HV¡ ¢e−u ®Mm−a M¤h Be¾c −f−u b¡−Lez Bj¡l pqLj£Ñ Peter Akins Hdl−el
¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ ®b−LC a¡l hC The Second Law (1984) ¢mM¡l L¡S öl² L−lez ¢a¢e ¢m−M−Re x
""Bjl¡ ¢hnªwMm¡ h¡ ®N¡mj¡−ml p¿¹¡e Ni£l L¡W¡−j¡Na f¢lhaÑe q−m¡ dÄwpz ph
¢LR¤l Ni£−l l−u−R c§e£Ñ¢a, AfË¢a−l¡dÉ ¢hnªwMm¡l ®YE, phÑn¡¿¹ qJu¡C E−ŸnÉz
®L¡e lLj ¢cL ¢e−cÑ
¢e−cÑne¡q£e S£he k¡œ¡z HC AåL¡l¡µRæa¡ Bj¡−cl ü£L¡l Ll−a q−hz Bjl¡
k¢c Ni£li¡−h på¡e L¢l a¡q−m ¢hnÄhËj¡−ä HL dl−el Al¡SLa¡C ®cM−a f¡C''
fËMÉ¡a S¡jÑ¡e X¡lECeh¡c£ J hZÑh¡c£ c¡nÑ¢eL Nietzschei a¡l hZÑh¡c£ ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡u
¢qVm¡−ll ""BkÑ S¡¢al ®nËùaÄ'' jah¡−cl a¡¢šÅL pjbÑe fËc¡e L−lez ¢a¢e h−m−Re, S£he−L
""qa¡n¡h”L'' h−m j−e Ll−a q−hz Nietzschei Hl a¥µRh¡c j§max H ja¡c−nÑl pjbÑe L−l
b¡−Lz j¡e¤o ¢eÕQuC ®L¡e e¡ ®L¡e jq¡e E−Ÿ−nÉl SeÉ ®hy−Q b¡−Lz Nietzschei ¢k¢e Bõ¡ql
A¢ØaaÄ−L Aü£L¡l L−lez ay¡l d¡le¡ Ae¤k¡u£ j¡e¤−ol S−¾jl
S−¾jl E−Ÿ−nÉl p¡−b pª¢øLaÑ¡l ®L¡e
pÇfLÑ e¡Cz H L¡l−e a¡l j−a j¡e¤o ph pju a¡l S£h−el E−ŸnÉ Ae¤p¾d¡−el SeÉ hÉØa
b¡−Lz ¢L¿º a¡ e¡ ®f−u −p qa¡n¡ J ®~el¡nÉSeL i¡hd¡l¡u f¢aa quz j¡e¤−ol E¢Qa a¡l
S£h−el fËL«a E−ŸnÉ My¤−S ®hl Ll¡z ¢L¿º Nietzschei Hl ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ Ae¤k¡u£ k¢c ®Lq a¡l S−¾jl
j§m E−ŸnÉ Aü£L¡l L−l a¡q−m AhnÉC ®p a¡ My¤−S f¡−h e¡z H ®r−œ Nietzschei HL
dl−el f¡Nm¡−V j−e¡i¡−hl f¢lQu ¢c−u−Rez
jq¡e Bõ¡qa¡m¡ j¡e¤o−L pª¢ø L−l−Re ®k pj¡ShÉhØq¡ H jq¡paÉ−L i§¢m−u ®cuz ®pC
pj¡S A¢a AhnÉC HL¢V BdÉ¡¢aÈL J ®~e¢aL dÄw−pl ¢nL¡l q−u b¡−Lz depÇfc, SeLmÉ¡e J

72 / 88
AbÑ®~e¢aL ANËN¢a k¡C ®q¡L e¡ ®Le, ®p pj¡S LMeJ n¡¢¿¹ J ¢el¡fš¡ ¢c−a prj qu e¡z g−m
Sep¡d¡le p¡d¡le ¢h−h−Ll c¡h£ Ae¤k¡u£ a¡−cl Q¢lœ−L f¢lQ¡me¡ Ll−a hÉbÑ quz a¡C ay¡l¡
¢e−S−cl−L hmN¡q£e J E−ŸnÉq£e fË¡e£ ¢qp¡−h ¢e−S−cl−L ¢h−hQe¡ L−l ®k ®L¡e dl−el A®~hd
J A®~e¢aL L¡S Ll−a ¢fRf¡ qu e¡z H L¡l−e a¡l¡ qa¡n¡, Ap¤M£ J qa¡n¡NËØa fË¡e£ ¢qp¡−h
L¡m L¡V¡uz HY~¡C a¡−cl ph−Q−u hs c¤xM ®k, a¡l¡ j−e L−l a¡−cl jªa¥Él p¡−b p¡−b ph ¢LR¤
®no q−u k¡−hz a¡l¡ öd¤ jªa¨¡l flC S£h−el fËL«a a¡vfkÑ Ae¤d¡he Ll−a prj q−hz fr¡¿¹−l
®k hÉ¢š² Bõ¡q J flL¡−m ¢hnÄ¡p L−l −p a¡l S£h−el jq¡e E−ŸnÉ pÇf−LÑ p−Qae, ®p Bõ¡ql
cu¡, Ae¤LÇf¡ m¡−il J ®h−qn−al Bn¡u S£hef¡a L−l b¡−Lz a¡l S£h−e k¡C OV¥L e¡ ®Le
®p Bõ¡q ®L deÉh¡c J L«a‘a¡ ‘¡fe L−lz H L¡l−e ®p LMeJ qa¡n¡ h¡ Ahp¡cNË
Ahp¡cNËØaa¡ h¡
¢el¡fš¡q£ea¡l ¢nL¡l qu e¡z

X¡lECeh¡−cl ¢hoh¡Öf ¢e×L¡ne Ll¡ Af¢lq¡kÑz

j¡eh C¢aq¡−pl pLm k¤−NC k¤Ü, pwO¡a, AaÉ¡Q¡l J M¤e ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rmz ¢L¿º X¡lECeh¡c
¢jbÉ¡ J ab¡L¢ba ®~h‘¡¢eL j¤−M¡−nl Bhle hÉhq¡l L−l−Rz ¢hwn na−L a¡l g−m ®k pLm
à¾cÄ-pwO¡a AaÉ¡Q¡l
AaÉ¡Q¡l J k¤−Ül OVe¡ pwO¢Va q−u−R Hl hÉ¡¢ç J ¢hØa¡l fª¢bh£l C¢aq¡−pl pLm
®lLXÑ i‰ L−l−Rz S£h−el pª¢ø J ¢hL¡n pð−å X¡lEq~eh¡−cl pÇf§eÑ ¢hï¡¢¿¹Ll c¡h£ J d¡le¡ H
ph ja¡cnÑ ab¡ cnÑe …çO¡aL, ®~üln¡pL, ¢hL«a j¡e¢pLa¡ pÇfæ f£seL¡l£ pL−ml
LjÑL¡ä−LC HL dl−el ®~e¢aL pjbÑ
pjbÑe c¡e L−l h−m−R - HV¡ q−m¡ "" fË¡L«¢aL BCe '' k¡ fË¡e£
J E¢ác SN−al ja je¤oÉ pj¡−S pji¡−h fË−k¡SÉz
Bj¡−cl pj−u ¢hhaÑeh¡c−L c¡nÑ¢eL J Bc¢nÑL L¡l−e ®k±¢š²L ¢qp¡−h pjbÑe fËc¡e Ll¡
quz ¢hwn na−L Ef¢e−hnh¡−c a¡l p−hÑ¡µQ ¢nM−l ®f±−R¢Rmz S¡jÑ¡e£−a e¡S£h¡c, ®|®|p¡¢i−ua
p¡¢i−ua
CE¢eu−e pj¡Sa¿» Aa£−al OVe¡ ¢qp¡−h f¢lN¢eaz ¢L¿º X¡lEq~eh¡c£ hØa¥h¡c£ cnÑe k¡ H
pjØa ja¡c−nÑl ¢i¢š ¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qa a¡ haÑj¡−eJ AaÉ¿¹ ®S¡−l−n¡−l ®L¡e ®L¡e jqm La«ÑL
pjbÑe J p¤lr¡ Ll¡ quz a¡C H cnÑ−el e£lh Ef¢Øq¢a ab¡ fËi¡h fª¢bh£l pLm dÄwp¡aÈL
LjÑL¡−ä
¡−ä Ae¤ih Ll¡ k¡uz j¡eh pj¡−S ¢hfkÑ−u X¡lECeh¡−cl i¥¢jL¡ pÇf−LÑ Kenneth J. Hsu
hÉ¢š²Nai¡−h HLSe X¡lEq~eh¡c£ qJu¡ p−šÆJ ¢m−M−Re ®k x
"" Bjl¡ HL¢V ¢eù¥l p¡j¡¢SL
p¡j¡¢SL ja¡c−nÑl Apq¡u ¢nL¡l, k¡ Hje ¢nr¡C ®cu ®k, hÉ¢š²,
®nËe£ J S¡¢a pj§q HL L¢We fË¢a−k¡N£a¡u Aha£eÑ
Aha£eÑ, Bl HV¡C S£h−el ü¡i¡¢hL
AhØq¡z HV¡J AaÉ¿¹ ü¡i¡¢hL ®k, pj¡−S fË¢a¢ùa h¡ ®nËù hÉ¢š²hNÑ üi¡haC a¡−cl ®b−L
r¥â h¡ e£Q¥−cl A¢dL¡l ®b−L h¢’a Ll−hz B¢j AaÉ¿¹ cªta¡l p¡−b hm−a f¡¢l ®k fË¡L«¢aL
jah¡cz''
¢ehÑ¡Q−el BCe ®L¡e ¢h‘¡e eu hlw HV¡ HL¢V nua¡e£ h¡ ïø p¡j¡¢SL jah¡cz ''
HL¡l−eC ¢hQ¡¢lL h¡ h¡¢qÉL paÑLaÑ¡ j§mL hÉhØq¡ AhnÉC |NÊqe Ll−a q−hz H
paÑLaÑ¡j§mL hÉhØq¡ fËL«af−r HC p¡j¡¢SL X¡lECeh¡−cl c¤øra−L Bhle ®cJu¡l fË−Qø¡ j¡œz

73 / 88
Hl Øq¡u£ pj¡d¡e l−u−R ®~h‘¡¢eL J p¡wØL«¢aL ¢Q¢Lvp¡uz AbÑ¡v pj¡−Sl ®~h‘¡¢eL J p¡wØL«¢aL
cªnÉfV −b−L X¡lECeh¡−cl Afp¡le h¡ dÄw−pl p¡−b p¡−bC ®k pjØa ja¡cnÑ Hl −b−L n¢š² h¡
lp Bqle Lla a¡ AcªnÉ h¡ ®no q−u k¡−hz Bl Hl AbÑ q−m¡ Bõ¡ql CµR¡u pj¡S ab¡
fª¢bh£l pLm AaÉ¡Q¡l J ¢ef£s−el ¢QlØq¡u£ Ahp¡ez
H L¡l−e Dj¡ec¡l, ¢h−hLh¡e J BdÉ¡¢aÈL j§mÉ−h¡d pÇfæ −m¡L−cl Efl HL¢V …l²
c¡¢uaÄ l−u−Rz X¡lEq~eh¡c ¢hNa na−Ll fª¢bh£−a ®k ¢hfkÑu pª¢ø J Se c¤−iÑ¡−Nl L¡le ¢Rm a¡
i¥−m k¡Ju¡ h¡ H−L Ahj§mÉ¡ue Ll¡ HL¢V hs dl−el
dl−el i¥m q−hz ¢k¢e H ¢hou¢Vl fË−u¡Se£ua¡
kb¡kbi¡−h Ae¤d¡he L−l−Re, ¢a¢e HC ja¡h¡−cl ¢hl²−Ü hÉ¡fL J phÑ¡aÈL p¡wúª¢aL Bœ²je
ab¡ B−¾c¡me h¡ fË¢a−l¡d N−s a¥m−he, k¡−a L−l ¢hNa 150 hvp−ll HC jq¡ fËh’e¡ pj¡S
®b−L pÇf§eÑ ¢ej§Ñm q−u k¡uz HC fËh’e¡j§mL ja¡cnÑ pj¡S −b−L Afp¡le Ll¡l HL¢V j¡œ
fÜ¢a l−u−Rz a¡ q−m¡, j¡eh S¡¢al pÇj¤−M ka fËnÀ h¡ pjpÉ¡ l−u−R a¡l kb¡kb pj¡d¡ez f¢hœ
®L¡l¡−el
®L¡l¡−el ®~e¢aL Q¢l−œl p¡¢hÑL fË−u¡N J h¡Øah¡u−el j¡dÉ−jC HV¡ qJu¡ pñhz H pjØa ¢hfkÑu,
c¤xM-
M-c¤cÑn¡l aMeC Ahp¡e q−h, kMe SeNe d−jÑ fËL«a ¢hnÄ¡p£ q−hz f¢hœ ®L¡l¡e Ae¤k¡u£ kMe
®L¡l¡−el
p¤¾cl, ®pÀq, jja¡, ®fËj, cu¡, p¤¢hQ¡l, pq−k¡N£a¡ J ®~dkÑ pj¡−S ¢hl¡S Ll−hz f¢hœ ®L¡l¡− el
HL¢V Bu¡−a E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R - "" paÉ Bp−h ¢jbÉ¡ c§l q−u k¡−h '' hm¤e paÉ B¢pu¡−R
Hhw ¢jbÉ¡ ¢hm¤ç qCu¡−R ¢jbÉ¡ ®a¡ ¢hm¤ç qCh¡lC(p¤l¡-
¡- Cnl¡ h¡¢eCpl¡Cm-
h¡¢eCpl¡Cm-81)z

----------------------

74 / 88
 f¢l¢nø

X¡lECeh¡c Abh¡ ¢hhaÑeh¡c ašÅ fËLa

« f−r HL¢V ïj¡aÈL J A®~h‘¡¢eL jah¡c, k¡
pËø¡l A¢Ù¹aÄ−L Aü£L¡l Ll¡l E−Ÿ−nÉ fËQ¡l J fËL¡n Ll¡ q−u¢Rm ¢L¿º ®p E−Ÿ−nÉ p¡d−e HV¡
hÉbÑ q−u−R z H jah¡c Ae¤k¡u£ fª¢bh£−a S£h−el p§Qe¡ q−u−R A®~Sh fc¡bÑ ®b−L fkÑ¡uœ²¢jL
®~ch¡v pwO¢Va OVe¡hm£l pw¢jnË−ez HC jah¡c e¡e¡i¡−h ¢e¢¾ca qu kMe ®~h‘¡¢eLi¡−h fËj¡¢Za
qu ®k, HC ¢hnÄ hË¡rÈ¡ä fËL«af−r Bõ¡qÚa¡m¡ pª¢ø L−l−Re z jq¡e Bõ¡qa¡m¡ ¢k¢e H ¢hnÄ
AaÉ¿¹ p¤nª´Mmi¡−h pª¢ø L−l−Re Hhw Hl r¥â¡¢ar¥â ¢hou¡¢cJ H nª´Mm¡l BJa¡i¥š² L−l−Re z
fr¡¿¹−l H jah¡−cl c¡h£ Ae¤k¡u£ fª¢bh£l fË¡Z£L¨m Bõ¡qÚ pª¢ø L−le e¡C hlw
hlw ®~ch¡v ®p…−m¡ pª¢ø
q−u−R HV¡ paÉ h−m ®j−e ®eu¡l ®L¡e p¤−k¡N e¡C z
Bjl¡ X¡lECeh¡c fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ L−l p¢aÉC ®cM−a f¡C ®k, ®~h‘¡¢eL N−hoe¡u H a−šÅl ®L¡e ¢i¢š
e¡C z A®~Sh fc¡−bÑl a¥me¡u ®~Sh fË¡−Zl pª¢ø L¡W¡−j¡ A−eL ®hn£ S¢Vm J A¢ieh z Ec¡qle
ül©f hm¡ k¡u ®k, A®~Sh fc¡−bÑl Ae¤…−m¡ ¢Li¡−h i¡lp¡jÉf§ZÑ J p¤nª´Mmi¡−h pª¢ø Ll¡ q−u−Rz
Efl¿º H AZ¤…−m¡ Bh¡l ¢Li¡−h S¢Vm L¡W¡−j¡l BJa¡u fË¡Z£ SN−a p¤¢heÉÙ¹i¡−h pª¢ø Ll¡
q−u−R z Bjl¡ fl£r¡ L−l ®cM−a f¡C ¢L Ap¡d¡lZ ®L±nm J fË¢œ²u¡u H…−m¡−L ¢heÉ¡p Ll¡
q−u−R ®kje, ®fË¡¢Ve, −œ²¡jSj
−œ²¡jSj J HeS¡Cj fËi¢« a z
S£h SN−al H Ap¡d¡lZ LjÑL¡ä fkÑ−hr−el fl ¢hwn na−L ¢hhaÑeh¡c h¡¢am h¡ ¢jbÉ¡ ¢qp¡−h
fËj¡¢Za q−u−Rz
Bjl¡ H ¢hou¢V f¤wM¡e¤´M Bj¡−cl AeÉ fËL¡ne¡ pj§−q fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ L−l¢R Hhw haÑj¡−eJ
H d¡l¡ AhÉ¡qa l−u−R z ¢L¿º ¢hou¢Vl …l¦aÄ Ae¤d¡he L−l a¡ HM¡−eJ f¤ehÑÉš² Ll¡ q−m¡ z

X¡lECeh¡−cl fa−el L¡lZ

Fe¢hwn na−Ll jdÉi¡−N ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl p−hÑ¡µQ ¢hL¡n O−V, H jah¡−cl C¢aq¡p Ae¤på¡e
Ll−m fË¡Q£e NË£p ®c−n Hl Evp f¡Ju¡ k¡u z 1859 p¡−m Q¡mÑp X¡lEC−el The Origin of
Species fËL¡¢na qJul fl H jah¡c ¢h−nÄl ¢h‘¡e SN−a HL …l¦aÄf§ZÑ B−m¡Qe¡l ¢houhÙº
¢q−p−h A¿¹iѤš² quz fª¢bh£l fË¢a¢V fËS¡¢a Bm¡c¡i¡−h ®k Bõ¡q pª¢ø L−l−Re, H f¤Ù¹−L
X¡lECe H d¡le¡l ¢hl¦−Ü AhÙÛ¡e NËqe L−le z X¡lECe c¡h£ L−le pLm fËS¡¢a HL¢V p¡d¡lZ
f§hÑ f¤l¦o (Common
( Ancestor) ®b−L pj−ul ¢hhaÑ−e p¡j¡eÉ f¢lhaÑ
f¢lhaÑ−el j¡dÉ−j haÑj¡e l©f
d¡lZ L−l−R z
X¡lECe ¢e−SC h−m−Re ®k, a¡l H jah¡c ®L¡e jSh¤a ®~h‘¡¢eL p−aÉl Efl fË¢a¢ùa eu hlw
H ašÅ ü¡i¡¢hL k¤¢š²l œ²jhª¢Ül HL¢V fkÑ¡uœ²j hÉ¡MÉ¡ j¡œ z

75 / 88
 fËL«af−r X¡lECe a¡l f¤Ù¹−Ll HL¢V AdÉ¡−u The Difficulties on Theory ¢n−l¡e¡−j
¢n−l¡e¡−j
¢e−SC ¢LR¤ …l¦aÄf§ZÑ fËnÀ E›¡fe L−l¢R−me k¡l ®L¡e Ešl a¡l ¢e−SlC S¡e¡ ¢Rm e¡ z
X¡lECe d¡le¡ L−l¢R−me flha£Ñ−a ¢h‘¡−el ANËN¢al p¡−b p¡−b ¢eaÉ ea¥e B¢h×L¡−ll j¡dÉ−j
a¡l AS¡e¡ fËnÀ pj§−ql Ešl My¤−S f¡Ju¡ k¡−h g−m a¡l jah¡c−L pjbÑe fËc¡e Ll−a pq¡ua¡
Ll−h z ¢L¿º
¢L¿º c¤x−Ml ¢hou X¡lEC−el H fËaÉ¡n¡l pÇf§ZÑ ¢hfl£a OVe¡ O−V−R z AbÑ¡v ¢h‘¡−el
ANËN¢al p¡d−el j¡dÉ−j X¡lECeh¡−cl j§m c¡h£…−m¡C H−Ll fl HL A®~h‘¡¢eL J ¢i¢šq£e
¢qp¡−h fËj¡¢Za q−u−R z

a¡¡ q−m¡ x
®~h‘¡¢eL cª¢øi‰£−a X¡lECeh¡c ¢ae¢V ¢n−l¡e¡−j ¢hiš² L−l fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ Ll¡ k¡u a

(1) fª¢bh£−a phÑfËbj S£h−el E−jÈo ¢Li¡−h pwO¢Va q−m¡ a¡l ®L¡e hÉ¡MÉ¡ fËc¡e L−l e¡z
(2) H ašÅ Ae¤k¡u£ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fË¢œ²u¡u pwO¢Va OVe¡ pj§−ql h¡Ù¹h J ®~h‘¡¢eL fËj¡Z M¤−S e¡
f¡Ju¡z
(3) fË¡ç S£h¡nÈ fËj¡e¡¢c H a−šÅl ¢WL ¢hfl£a p¡rÉ fËc¡e L−l z

Bjl¡
Bjl¡ H AdÉ¡−u h¢ZÑa ¢n−l¡e¡j ¢hou…¢m fkÑ¡uœ²−j B−m¡Qe¡ Ll−h¡ z

fËbj AmwOe£u h¡d¡ x fË¡−Zl Evp

X¡lEC−el c¡h£ Ae¤k¡u£ fª¢bh£−a fË¡®~N¢qa¡¢pL k¤−Nl fË¡u 3.8 ¢h¢mue hRl f§−hÑ HL¢V
j¡œ ®L¡o ®b−L pLm fËS¡¢al pª¢øl E−jÈo quz ®Lje L−l HL¢V j¡œ ®L¡o ®b−L mr mr
S¢Vm fËS¡¢a pj§q pª¢ø q−a f¡−l, Bl k¢c q−uC b¡−L a¡l ®L¡e S£h¡nÈ fËj¡Z ®~h‘¡¢eL
abÉ¡e¤på¡−e e¡ f¡Ju¡l L¡lZC h¡ ¢L Hl pc¤šl H jah¡−cl ¢ial f¡Ju¡ k¡u e¡ z ¢L¿º H
pjÙ¹ B−m¡Qe¡l f§−hÑ Bjl¡ fËb−jC ¢hhaÑ−el B−m¡QÉ pjuL¡mV¡ LMe Hhw ¢Li¡−h HC fËbj
®L¡−ol B¢hiÑ¡h O−V a¡l
a¡l Ešl ®My¡S¡l ®Qø¡ Ll−h¡ z ¢hhaÑeh¡c ®k−qa¥ pª¢ø fË¢œ²u¡u ®L¡e
B¢d−i±¢aL pšÅ¡l h¡ n¢š²l A¢Ù¹aÄ Aü£L¡l L−l, a¡C H jah¡c c¡h£ L−l ®k, fËbj ®L¡o¢V ®L¡e
fËL¡l f¢lLÒfe¡ h¡ nªwMm¡l j¡dÉ−j pª¢ø qu e¡C hlw a¡ qW¡v L−l fË¡L«¢aL BCe Ae¤k¡u£
üaxØg¥aÑi¡−h HV¡ A¢Ù¹−aÄ H−p k¡u z AeÉ Lb¡u H jah¡−cl c¡h£ Ae¤k¡u£ A®~Sh fc¡bÑ ®b−L H
fË¡Z£ ®L¡o AhnÉC üaxØg§aÑi¡−h pª¢ø q−u−R z H d¡le¡ S£h ¢h‘¡−el ®j±¢mL BC−el pÇf§ZÑ
f¢lf¿Û£ ¢hd¡u a¡ pÇf§ZÑ ANËqZ−k¡NÉ z

76 / 88
 S£he ®b−L S£he B−p

X¡lECe a¡l f¤Ù¹−L S£h−el Evp pÇf−LÑ ®L¡e A¡−m¡Lf¡a L−le¢e z ac¡e£¿¹e
®~h‘¡¢eL Eæ¢a AaÉ¿¹ fË¡b¢jL fkÑ¡−u b¡L¡l L¡l−Z ¢a¢e d¡le¡ L−l¢R−me fË¡b£ SNa A¢a plm
L¡W¡−j¡l pª¢øz jdÉk¤N£u ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ Ae¤k¡u£ fËS¡¢a pj§−ql üaxØg§aÑ S¾j ašÅ jah¡c Ae¤k¡u£
X¡lEqeJ ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−ae A®~Sh fc¡bÑ ®b−L ®~ch¡v üuw¢œ²ui¡−h S£h−el ¢hL¡n
¢hL¡n O−V b¡−L Hhw
¢a¢e H d¡le¡ a¡l ¢hhaÑeh¡c a−šÅJ hÉhq¡l L−le z ®pC pjuL¡l p¡d¡lZ ¢hnÄ¡p ¢Rm M¡cÉ â−hÉl
E¢µRø ®b−L ¢h¢iæ L£−Vl S¾j q−u b¡−L h¡ Nj ®b−L ®f¡L¡ pª¢ø quz H d¡le¡ fËj¡Z Ll¡l SeÉ
¢h¢iæ dl−el fl£r¡ ¢el£r¡ Q¡m¡−e¡ quz hÙ¹¡l Efl N−jl ¢LR¤ Awn ®l−M ®cJu¡ q−a¡ d¡le¡
Ll¡ q−a¡ ¢LR¤re fl HM¡−e EL¥e h¡ ®f¡L¡ pª¢ø q−h z j¡w−pl Efl ®f¡L¡l ¢X−jl A¢Ù¹aÄ−L
A®~Sh fc¡bÑ ®b−L fË¡−Zl p’¡−ll fËj¡Z ¢qp¡−h EfÙÛ¡fe Ll¡ q−a¡ z k¢cJ flha£Ñ−a fËj¡¢Za
qu ®k, fËL«af−r j¡w−pl Efl ®f¡L¡l ¢Xj üaxØg§aÑi¡−h ®~al£ qu e¡ hlw f¢lh¡¢qa
f¢lh¡¢qa m¡iÑ¡ k¡
M¡¢m ®Q¡−M ®cM¡ k¡u e¡, a¡ ®b−L ¢X−jl pª¢ø q−u b¡−L z
X¡lECe kMe a¡l H f¤Ù¹L The Origin of Species (1859) ¢m−Me aMe fª¢bh£−a ®~h‘¡¢eL−cl
p¡d¡lZ d¡le¡ ¢Rm −k, A®~Sh fc¡bÑ ®b−L S£h¡e¤ üaxØg§aÑi¡−h pª¢ø q−u b¡−L z X¡lEq−el H
f¤Ù¹L j¤â−el j¡œ 5 hvp−ll j−dÉ gl¡p£ S£h ¢h‘¡e£ LOUIS PASTEUR ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl j§m
¢i¢š i¥m fËj¡Z L−le z c£OÑ N−hoe¡ J fl£r¡ ¢el£r¡l fl LOUIS PASTEUR h−me, A®~Sh
fc¡bÑ ®b−L fË¡−Zl p’¡l qu H d¡le¡ ¢Ql¢c−el SeÉ Lh−l ®fË¡¢ba Ll¡ q−m¡ z X¡lECeh¡c£l¡
f¡Ùº−ll H jah¡c fËQ¡−l c£OÑ¢ce k¡ha
k¡ha h¡d¡ ¢c−u Bp¢R−me z ¢L¿º HV¡ ¢h‘¡e ¢qp¡−h fË¢a¢ùa
qu Hhw S£h SN−al −L¡−ol S¢Vm L¡W¡−j¡ Ahd¡¢lai¡−h fËj¡¢Za qu Hhw üaxØg§aÑi¡−h fË¡−Zl
E−jÈo O−V H ašÅ a¡ h¡¢am ¢qp¡−h NZÉ qu z

¢hwn na−L A−fn¡c¡l£ pwNË¡j

¢hwn na−L l¡¢nu¡l ¢hM¡a S£h ¢h‘¡e£ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ Alexandar Oparin phÑfËbj S£h−el
Evp pÇf−LÑ N−hoe¡ öl¦ L−le z 1930 cn−L −hn ¢LR¤ jah¡−c Oparin S£h−el p§Qe¡ ®~ch¡v
qu j−jÑ c¡h£ Ll−a b¡−Le z a−h a¡l H fË−Qø¡ hÉbÑa¡u fkÑh¢pa qu, AhnÉ ¢a¢e ¢e−SC a¡
ü£L¡l L−lez ¢a¢e h−me, c¤iÑ¡NÉhna, f¤−l¡ ¢hhaÑe a−šÅl j−dÉ ®L¡−ol
®L¡−ol Ev−pl ¢hou¢V ph−Q−u
AåL¡l (c¤hÑmaj) ¢cL h¡ Awn z

77 / 88
 ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ ®~h‘¡¢eLl¡ S£h−el Evp pÇf−LÑ pj¡d¡e f¡Ju¡l m−r Oparin Hl ašÅ
Ae¤k¡u£ N−hoe¡ Q¡¢m−u k¡e z H−cl j−dÉ ph−Q−u ¢hMÉ¡a q−me B−j¢lL¡l l¡p¡ue¢hc Stanley
Miller,, ¢a¢e 1953 ¢h‘¡e¡N¡−l/N−hoe¡N¡−l NÉ¡p, n¢š², fª¢bh£ pª¢øl B¢cj AhÙÛ¡e J ¢LR¤ ®~Sh
AZ¤ (H¢j−e¡ H¢pX) ¢j¢nËa L−l ®fË¡¢Ve pª¢øl ®Qø¡ L−le z HC N−hoe¡l hÉbÑa¡ ®pC pju
¢hhaÑeh¡−cl pÇf−LÑ HL¢V …l¦aÄf§ZÑ OVe¡ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qa z ®k Bhq¡Ju¡u H N−hoe¡ f¢lQ¡me¡
Ll¡ qu fª¢bh£l h¡Ù¹h f¢l¢ÙÛ¢a pÇf§ZÑ ¢iæ ¢Rm j−jÑ flha£Ñ−a S¡e¡ k¡u z c£OÑ e£lha¡l fl
Miller ü£L¡l L−le, ®k f¢l¢ÙÛ¢a J Bhq¡Ju¡u H N−hoe¡ f¢lQ¡me¡ Ll¡ q−u¢Rm a¡ fËLa
«
AhÙÛ¡l p¡−b pwN¢af§ZÑ ¢Rme¡ z
S£h−el Evp pÇf−LÑ hÉ¡MÉ¡ ®cJu¡l H fË−Qø¡ f¤−l¡ ¢hwn naL d−l Qm−a b¡−L Hhw k¡
hÉbÑa¡u fkÑh¢pa quz 1998 p¡−m ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ p¡j¢uL£ EARTH H SCIPPS Institute, SAN
Diego, Hl Geo Chemist, Geffery Ada a¡l HL fËh−å H paÉ fËL¡n L−l ¢a¢e ¢m−M−Re x
Bjl¡ haÑj¡−e ¢hwn na−L hph¡p Ll¢R z Bjl¡ HMeJ ph−Q−u L¢We fË−nÀl pÇj¤M£e
q¢µR a¡q−m¡ fª¢bh£−a
bh£−a S£h−el E−jÈo ¢Li¡−h pñh q−m¡?
q−m¡?

®S
~ h L¡W¡−j¡l S¢Vma¡

¢hhaÑeh¡c£−cl fË¡−Zl Ev−pl Ae¤på¡e fË¢œ²u¡u ph−Q−u L¢We fËnÀ H L¡l−ZC E›¡¢fa qu
®k, p¡d¡lZi¡−h ph−Q−u plm fËL«¢al fË¡Z£ ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ qu, −p ph fË¡Z£l ®~Sh L¡W¡−j¡
L−l−R
A¢hnÄ¡pÉi¡−h S¢Vmz j¡eh S¡¢a ka ®~h‘¡¢eL J k¿»f¡¢a B¢h×L¡l L−l−R a¡l ®Q−u HL¢V S£h¿¹
®L¡o A−eL ®hn£ S¢Vm z a¡R¡s¡ fª¢bh£l phÑ¡d¤¢eL ®~h‘¡¢eL N−hoe¡N¡−lJ HL¢V S£h¿¹ ®L¡o
®~al£ Ll¡ pñh eu z
HL¢V ®L¡o pª¢øl SeÉ ®kph f¢l¢ÙÛ¢a J naÑ fË−u¡Se a¡ ®L¡eœ²−jC ®~ch¡v ¢qp¡−h
BMÉ¡¢ua Ll¡ k¡ue¡z ®fË¡¢Ve pª¢ø J ®L¡o ¢ejÑ¡−el ¢h¢iæ Awn HLC p¡−b ®~ch¡v HL£i¨a qJu¡l
pñ¡he¡ 500 H¢j−e¡ H¢pX pªø qJu¡l 950 h¡−l HLh¡l j¡œ z AwL n¡−Ù»l ¢qp¡h Ae¤k¡u£
1050 Hl j−dÉ 1 q−m a¡ h¡Ù¹−h pwO¢Va qJu¡ Apñh z Ec¡qleül©f hm¡ k¡u ®k, DNA AZ¤
k¡ ¢eE¢LÓu¡p Hl j−dÉ AhÙÛ¡e L−l z HC DNA Hl j−dÉ j¡e¤−ol S¾j ¢houL
¢houL ¢h¢iæ abÉ
p¢æ−h¢na b¡−L z j¡e¤−ol genetic code k¢c L¡N−Sl Efl ¢mM¡ qu a¡q−m 500 fªù¡l 900 hC
q−h z DNA pÇf−LÑ HL¢V A¢a¢lš² abÉ q−m¡ HV¡l fË¢al©f ¢qp¡−h L¡S Ll−a q−m HL¢V
¢h−no dl−el ®fË¡¢Ve h¡ HeS¡C−jl fË−u¡Se quz H…−m¡ öd¤ aMeC DNA Hl −L¡X Hl j¡dÉ−jC
L¡kÑ
L¡kÑLl qu z HV¡ flØf−ll Efl ¢eiÑln£m z a¡C H−cl fË¢al©f qJu¡l SeÉ HLC p¡−b
Ef¢ÙÛ¢a fË−u¡Se qu z H L¡l−ZC fª¢bh£−L fË¡−Zl Evp pÇf¢LÑa Ae¤på¡e fË¢œ²u¡u HL¢V
AQm¡hÙÛ¡l pª¢ø qu z

78 / 88
 1994 p¡−ml A−ƒ¡hl, Scientific American p¡j¢uL£−a p¡e ¢Xu¡−N¡ LÉ¡¢mÑ−g¡¢eu¡
CE¢ei¡¢pÑ
CE¢ei¡¢pÑ¢Vl fË−gpl Leslie orge ¢m−M−Re x
®fË¡¢Ve J ¢eE¢LÓL H¢pX Ei−ulC L¡W¡−j¡Na fËL¢« a AaÉ¿¹ S¢Vm fËL«¢al a¡C H c¤¢V
HLC pja¡−m ¢h¢œ²u¡ L−l ea¥e pª¢øl ¢hou¢V L¡kÑa Apñh z a¡R¡s¡ H c¤¢Vl HL¢V R¡s¡
AeÉ¢Vl A¢Ù¹aÄJ Apñh z g−m Bf¡ax cª¢ø−a L¡E−L H dl−el ¢pÜ¡−¿¹C Efe£a
Efe£a q−a q−hC
®k, fËL«af−r fª¢bh£−a fË¡Z ®L¡e l¡p¡u¢eL ¢h¢œ²u¡l j¡dÉ−j pª¢ø h¡ Eá¤a qu e¡C z

¢hhaÑeh¡−cl L¢Òfa L¡W¡−j¡

X¡lECe a−šÅl ¢àa£u c¤hÑm ¢cL k¡l j¡dÉ−j ašÅ¢V h¡¢am fËj¡¢Za qu a¡q−m¡,
X¡lECeh¡c fËj¡−Zl SeÉ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fÜ¢a ¢qp¡−h ®k c¤¢V jah¡c E›¡¢fa
E›¡¢fa qu h¡Ù¹¢hLf−r a¡l
j−dÉ ®L¡e ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fË¢œ²u¡C e¡C z
X¡lECe a¡l ¢hhaÑeh¡c a−šÅl p¡−b fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Qe−L pÇf§ZÑi¡−h HL£i¨a L−l
EfÙÛ¡fe L−l−Re z HC fË¢œ²u¡−L ¢a¢e HaC …l¦aÄ fËc¡e L−l−Re k¡ a¡l f¤Ù¹−Ll e¡j Ll−el
j¡dÉ−jC ®h¡T¡ k¡u, - The Origin of Species, By means of Natural Selection.
HV¡ HC d¡le¡l Efl fË¢a¢ùa ®k fËL«¢a−a fËS¡¢a pj§−ql A¢Ù¹aÄ ¢V¢L−u l¡M¡l SeÉ ®k
pwNË¡j q−u b¡−L a¡−a n¢š²n¡m£ k¡l¡ a¡l¡ fËL«¢al ¢h¢iæ fË¢aL¨m f¢l−h−nl pw−N M¡f M¡Ju¡−a
ül©f
prj qu Hhw ¢V−L b¡−L h¡ H pwNË¡−j Su£ qu z Ec¡qle ül©f hm¡ qu ®k, kMe ®L¡e q¢l−Zl
cm ¢qwp fË¡Z£ LaѪL Bœ²¡¿¹ qu, aMe ®k q¢lZ¢V ph−Q−u â¦a ®c±s¡−a prj qu ®pC ®hy−Q b¡−L
z Hi¡−h H q¢l−Zl cm¢V â¦a ¢hQle n¢š²n¡m£ q¢lZ−cl pjeÄ−u N¢Wa q−h z ¢L¿º a¡C h−m HC
fË¢œ²u¡u q¢lZ…−m¡ ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡u ®O¡s¡u f¢lZa qu e¡ z H L¡l−ZC ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl H LjÑ
fÜ¢al j−dÉ ®L¡e ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ n¢š² ¢e¢qa e¡C z X¡lECe a¡l a−šÅl H c¤hÑm ¢cL pÇf−LÑ pjÉL
Ah¢qa ¢R−me, ¢a¢e ¢e−SC ü£L¡l L−l a¡l The Origin of Species f¤Ù−¹ L hm−a h¡dÉ q−u−R
Ae¤L¨m J hÉ¢aœ²jdj£Ñ f¢lh¢aÑa f¢l¢ÙÛ¢al pª¢ø e¡ q−m fË¡L«¢al ¢ehÑ
¢ehÑ¡Qe ®L¡e i¨¢jL¡C l¡M−a
prj qu e¡ z

mÉj¡−LÑl fËi¡h

a¡q−m ¢Li¡−h HC hÉ¢aœ²jdj£Ñ f¢lh¢aÑa f¢l¢ÙÛ¢a pª¢ø qJu¡ pñh z ac¡e£¿¹e ®p−L−m
p£¢ja ¢h‘¡¢e mÉ¡j¡LÑ, gl¡p£ S£h¢h‘¡e£ ‘¡e ¢c−u X¡lECe, mÉj¡LÑ Hl a−šÅl j¡dÉ−j H fË−nÀl
Ešl ¢c−a p−Qø qez ¢a¢e X¡lEC−el f§−hÑ
hÑ HL jah¡c fËQ¡l L−le z ¢a¢e c¡h£ L−le, fË¡Z£
S£¢ha AhÙÛ¡u ®k pjÙ¹ n¡l£¢lL f¢lhaÑ−el A¢i‘a¡ ASÑe L−l a¡l Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢nø pj§q
flha£Ñ fËS−¾j ea¥e fËS¡¢a pª¢ø L−l Hhw H d¡l¡ hwn flØfl¡u AhÉ¡qa b¡−L z mÉj¡LÑ Hl
d¡le¡ Ae¤k¡u£ ¢Sl¡g Hje HL¢V fË¡Z£, k¡ q¢lZ ®b−L ¢hhaÑe fË¢œ²u¡u a¡l Nm¡ hwn flØfl¡u

79 / 88
pwNË¡−jl j¡dÉ−j hª¢Ü ®f−u−R Hhw ®p haÑj¡−e a¡l mð¡ Nm¡ ¢c−u mð¡ N¡−Rl f¡a¡ ®M−a prj
q−µR z
X¡lECe a¡l - The Origin of Species f¤Ù−¹ L H dl−el B−l¡ Ec¡qle ®fn L−l−Rez
®kje ¢a¢e E−õM L−l−Re ¢LR¤ pwMÉL i¡m¤L M¡−cÉl på¡−e
på¡−e f¡¢e−a fË−hn L−l Hhw flha£Ñ−a
¢a¢j−a l©f¡¿¹¢la quz ¢L¿º ¢hwn na−L MENDEL fË¡Z£ SN−a Ešl¡¢dL¡l pðå£u hwn ¢h‘¡e
¢houL jah¡c fËQ¡l J fËj¡Z L−le a¡l j¡dÉ−j H pLm ab¡L¢ba A¢SÑa Q¡¢l¢œL ®~h¢nø flha£Ñ
fËS−¾j ÙÛ¡e¡¿¹l pÇfL£Ñu LÒfL¡¢qe£ h¡¢am J A®~h‘¡¢eL ¢qp¡−h
¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qa qu z H L¡l−Z
fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Q−el LjÑ fÜ¢a pÇf§ZÑl©−f h¡¢am q−u k¡u z

ehÉ X¡lECeh¡c J Hl pw−n¡de

X¡lECeh¡c£l¡ H AhÙÛ¡ ®b−L E−š¡l−el m−r HL¢V Bd¤¢eL ¢pe−b¢VL jah¡c h¡ ehÉ
X¡lECeh¡c fËQ¡l öl¦ L−l, k¡ 1930 cn−Ll −noi¡−N ®hn Se¢fËua¡ ASÑe L−l z Hh¡l
Hh¡l a¡l¡
fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Q−el p¡−b “hÉ¢aœ²jdj£Ñ
hÉ¢aœ²jdj£Ñ Ae¤L¨m f¢l¢ÙÛ¢al”
al h¡ f¢lhaÑen£ma¡l L¡lZ Abh¡ fË¡Z£l
“h£S” O¢Va œ¦¢V h¡ ®c¡o k¡ ®l¢X−une h¡ X¥¢fÔ−Lne i¥−ml SeÉ pwO¢Va q−u b¡−L j−jÑ c¡h£
L−le z haÑj¡−e X¡lECeh¡c£ HC ea¥e j−Xm Ae¤k¡u£ ehÉ X¡lECeh¡c L¡kÑLl ¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡
L−l Hl pjbÑe L−l b¡−Le z H ašÅ Ae¤k¡u£ mr mr fËS¡¢a S¾jNa œ¦¢V h¡ f¢lhaÑ−el j¡dÉ−j
pª¢ø q−µR z pj−ul ¢hhaÑ−e S¢Vm fË¢œ²u¡u Hph fË¡Z£−a L¡e, ®Q¡M, g¥pg¥p, X¡e¡ pª¢ø q−µR z ¢L¿º
fËL«a ®~h‘¡¢eL paÉ k¡ H jah¡c−L pÇf§ZÑ e¡LQ L−l −cu a¡q−m¡ x f¢lhaÑen£ma¡
n£ma¡ fË¡Z£
SN−al ¢hL¡n OV¡u e¡ hlw a¡ r¢aNËÙ¹ h¡ dÄwp L−l-
L−l- Hl pqS L¡lZ q−µR DNA A¢a S¢Vm
L¡W¡−j¡, H−a p¡j¡eÉ f¢lhaÑe J AZ¤l NWe fË¢œ²u¡u a¡ r¢ap¡de L−l j¡œ z B−j¢lL¡e
Scientist B G Ranganthan a¡ Hi¡−h hZÑe¡ L−l−Re x f¢lhaÑepj§q, r¥â, H−m¡f¡b¡¢s J
r¢aL¡lL k¡l pñ¡he¡ AaÉ¿¹ ¢hlm Hhw a¡ A¢dL¡wn ®r−œC AL¡kÑLl z f¢lhaÑe d¡l¡l HC
Q¡l¢V ®~h¢nø HV¡C fËj¡Z L−l ®k, a¡ ®L¡e ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ Eæue h¡ ¢hL¡n fË¢œ²u¡u ®L¡e L¡kÑLl£
i¨¢jL¡ l¡M−a prj eu z ®L¡e ¢h−no dl−el fËS¡¢al ®r−œ HV¡ AL¡kÑLl Abh¡ r¢aL¡lL
¢qp¡−h ¢h−h¢Qa z HL¢V O¢sl H−m¡f¡b¡¢s h¡ Af¢lL¢Òfa f¢lhaÑe LMeJ O¢s¢Vl …eNa
f¢lhaÑe p¡de L−le¡ hlw ®pV¡ r¢aNËÙÛ L−l h¡ AL¡kÑLl qu z HL¢V i¨¢jLÇf LMeC eNl
Eæu−e ®L¡e i¨¢jL¡ l¡−Me¡ hlw a¡l dÄwp p¡de L−l j¡œ z
fËL«af−r ®L¡e L¡kÑLl h¡ fË−u¡Se£u f¢lhaÑe, hwn ¢h‘¡−e N−hoe¡u fkÑ−hre Ll¡ k¡u¢e
hlw N−hoe¡u HV¡C −cM¡ ®N−R pLm fËL¡l f¢lhaÑeC r¢aL¡lL z HV¡C fËaÉr Ll¡ ®N−R ®k,
¢hhaÑeh¡c£ ašÅ Ae¤k¡u£ f¢lhaÑe pj§q hwnNa ¢h‘¡−el HL¢V …l¦aÄf§ZÑ OVe¡ k¡ öd¤ fË¡Z£−L f‰¤
h¡ dÄwpC L−l b¡−L z j¡e¤−ol ®r−œ ph−Q−u p¡d¡lZ ®L¡o£u f¢lhaÑe q−m¡ LÉ¡¾p¡l z a¡C ®L¡e
dÄwp¡aÈL fË¢œ²u¡ ®L¡eœ²−jC ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fÜ¢a h¡ ®L±nm q−a f¡−le¡ z fË¡L«¢aL ¢ehÑ¡Qe, k¡
X¡lECe ü£L¡l L−l¢R−me, a¡ ¢eSüi¡−h ¢LR¤C Ll−a prj eu z Bjl¡ fËaÉr L−l¢R ®k,

80 / 88
fËL«a paÉ HV¡C ®k, fËL«¢a−a ®L¡e ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ −L±nm h¡ fÜ¢a h−m ¢LR¤ e¡C z ®k−qa¥
fËL«¢a−a ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ ®L±nm e¡C, a¡C ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ab¡ L¢ba pju¢V HL¢V L¢Òfa d¡le¡j¡œ k¡
LMeJ ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rme¡ z

S£h¡nÈ fËj¡Z x ®L¡e A¿¹ha£ÑL¡m£e BL«¢al A¢Ù¹−aÄl fËj¡Z/¢ecnÑe z

X¡lEC−el ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl OVe¡ ®k, LMeJ O−V¢e a¡l ph−Q−u h¡Ù¹h fËj¡Z q−m¡ S£h¡−nÈl
B¢Ù¹−aÄl Ae¤f¢ÙÛ¢a z
¢hhaÑeh¡c£ ašÅ Ae¤k¡u£ pLm S£¢ha fË¡Z£ f¡lØf¢lL f¢lhaÑ−el j¡dÉ−j haÑj¡e
BL¡l/BL«¢a d¡le L−l−R z HL¢V f§hÑha£Ñ fË¡Z£Ñ pj−ul ¢hhaÑ−e AeÉ fË¡Z£−a l©f¡¿¹¢la qu z
pLm fË¡Z£C Hi¡−hC ¢hL¡n m¡i L−l−R z HC jah¡c Ae¤p¡−l H fË¢œ²u¡u mr mr hRl
pjuL¡−ml j−dÉ fkÑ
fkÑ¡uœ²−j haÑj¡e fkÑ¡−u Eæa q−u−R z H L¡l−Z AN¢ea jdÉha£Ñ fËS¡¢a H
pjuL¡−m ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rm k¡−cl fci¡−l fª¢bh£ fËL¢Çfa q−a¡ z

Ec¡qlZ ül©f hm¡ k¡u ®k, k¢c jvpÉ k¡ haÑj¡e BL¡l BL«¢a−a ¢hcÉj¡e z a¡l¡
¢hhaÑ−el ®L¡e HL fkÑ¡−u pl£pªf BL¡l d¡le L−l¢Rm, A¡d¡j¡R-
A¡d¡j¡R-A¡d¡pl£pª
A¡d¡pl£pªf BL¡−lJ a¡l¡
AhnÉC ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rmz Abh¡ pl£pª−fl BL¡l hq¡m b¡L¡L¡m£e pj−uC a¡l¡ fr£L¥−ml ¢LR¤ ®~h¢nø
d¡le L−l¢Rm, ®p−r−œ pl£pªf-fr£ AhnÉC ¢hl¡S Lla z ®k−qa¥ a¡l¡ ¢hhaÑ−el ¢h¢iæ fkÑ¡u
A¢aœ²j Ll¢Rm, a¡C a¡l¡ AhnÉC c¤hÑm, Ap¤ÙÛ, ApÇf§ZÑ, Af§ZÑ¡‰ J œ¦¢Vf§ZÑ fË¡Z£ ¢qp¡−h
fª¢bh£−a Qm¡−gl¡ Lla z ¢hhaÑeh¡c£−cl c¡h£ Ae¤k¡u£ H dl−el A¿¹ha£Ñ BL¡l/BL«¢a pÇfæ
fË¡Z£ AhnÉC Aa£aL¡−m ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rm z
p¢aÉC k¢c H dl−el fË¡Z£l A¢Ù¹aÄ ®b−LC b¡−L a−h H pLm fËS¡¢al ¢h¢iæ dl−el
BL¡l J BL«¢a b¡L¡ Hhw H−cl pwMÉ¡ mr mr qJu¡ AaÉ¿¹ ü¡i¡¢hL z a¡C H dl−el Aá¤a
BL«¢al ¢h¢iæ fËS¡¢al A¢Ù¹−aÄl −L¡e e¡ ®L¡e ¢Qq² h¡ fËj¡Z h¡ ¢ecnÑe AbÑ¡v k¡l S£h¡nÈ fËj¡Z
b¡L¡ E¢Qa z

X¡lECe a¡l f¤Ù¹L The Origin of Species Hi¡−h EfÙÛ¡fe L−l−Re z Bj¡l ¢hhaÑeh¡c
jah¡c k¢c p¢aÉ qu a¡q−m ApwMÉ A¿¹ha£ÑL¡m£e fËS¡¢al k¡l p¡−b HLC dl−el fËS¡¢al Ni£l
¢jm pÇfæ fËS¡¢al A¢Ù¹aÄ AhnÉC b¡L−a q−h z g−m H dl−el f§−hÑL¡l fËS¡¢al A¢Ù¹aÄ pð¢ma
S£h¡−nÈl fËj¡Z AhnÉC b¡L−a q−h z

X¡lEC−el Bn¡iwN

81 / 88
 Fe¢hwn naL ®b−L öl¦ L−l BS fkÑ¿¹ fª¢bh£l fË¡u pLm Be¡−Q L¡e¡−Q S£h¡nÈ
N−hoe¡ f¢lQ¡me¡
f¢lQ¡me¡ Ll¡ p−šÅJ H dl−el ®L¡e A¿¹ha£Ñ BL¡l h¡ fËL¡−ll ®L¡e fË¡Z£l S£h¡nÈ
f¡Ju¡ k¡u¢e z H pLm Mee L¡−Sl j¡dÉ−j ®k pjÙ¹ S£h¡nÈ f¡Ju¡ ®N−R a¡l p¡−b ¢hhaÑeh¡c£−cl
fËaÉ¡n¡ Ae¤k¡u£ ¢LR¤C f¡Ju¡ k¡u e¡C, hlw S£h¡nÈ fkÑ−hr−e ®cM¡ ®N−R, fËS¡¢a pj§q f§ZÑ¡‰ J
pÇf¤ZÑl©−f qW¡v L−l fª¢bh£−a B¢hi¨Ña q−u−R z ®L¡e A¿¹ha£Ñ fË¡Z£l A¢Ù¹aÄ f¡Ju¡ k¡u¢e z
HLSe ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ S£h¡nÈ ¢hn¡lc qJu¡ p−šÅJ DEREK W AGER ¢hou¢V ü£L¡l L−l
E−õM L−l−Re ®k, Bjl¡ k¢c S£h¡nÈ fËj¡e¡¢c f§hÑ¡fl fkÑ−hre L¢l fËS¡¢a Ae¤k¡u£ h¡ Hl
¢hL¡−nl fkÑ¡u Ae¤k¡u£-
¡u£-a¡q−m ®L¡e fkÑ¡uœ²¢jL ¢hL¡n ®cM¡ k¡u e¡ hlw qW¡v L−l HL¢V
fËS¡¢al B¢hiÑ¡h h¡ AeÉ HL¢V fËS¡¢al ¢a−l¡d¡eC ®cM−a f¡Ju¡ k¡u z AeÉ Lb¡u S£h¡nÈ
pj§−ql fkÑ−hr−e ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, pLm fËS¡¢a pj§q qW¡v L−l f§ZÑ¡‰l©−f h¡ BL¡l BL«¢a−a
¢hcÉj¡e, ®L¡e A¿¹ha£ÑL¡m£e BL¡l/BL«¢a−a
a−a a¡−cl ®cM−a f¡Ju¡ k¡u¢e z AbÑ¡v X¡lECe k¡
f§hÑ¡e¤j¡e h¡ i¢hoÉh¡e£ L−l¢R−me ¢hou¢V fËaÉri¡−h Hl ¢hfl£a z Efl¿º fËS¡¢a pj§q ®k
f¢lL¢Òfai¡−h pª¢ø Ll¡ q−u−R HV¡ a¡lC h¡Ù¹h fËj¡Z z fËS¡¢a pj§q ®L¡el©f f§hÑ f¤l¦o hÉa£a,
œ¦¢Vq£e Hhw qW¡v L−l B¢hiѧa qJu¡l ¢hou¢V
¢hou¢V fËj¡Z L−l ®k, fËS¡¢a pj§q pª¢ø Ll¡ q−u−R z
fËMÉ¡a ¢hË¢Vn ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ S£h ¢h‘¡e£ DOUG LAS FUTUYMA HC paÉ−L ü£L¡l L−l h−m−Re
x
fËS¡¢apj§−ql pª¢ø h¡ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fË¢œ²u¡u N¢Wa HC c¤−ul j¡−T fË¡Z£ pj§−ql p§Qe¡l pñ¡hÉ
h¡MÉ¡ l−u−Rz fËS¡¢a pj§q qu f§ZÑ¡‰ Ahu−h ¢hL¢na
¢hL¢na q−u fª¢bh£−a B¢hi¨Ña q−u−R Abh¡ pª¢øC
qu e¡C z ®k−qa¥ f§−hÑl ®L¡e fË¡Z£ ®b−L f¢lhaÑe h¡ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fË¢œ²u¡u pªø ®L¡e fË¡Z£l A¢Ù¹aÄ
f¡Ju¡ k¡u¢e z hlw fËS¡¢a pj§q f§ZÑ¡‰ Ahu−h pÇf§ZÑ ¢hL¢na fkÑ¡−u fª¢bh£−a B¢hi¨Ña q−u−R z
a¡C HV¡ AhnÉC ü£L¡kÑ ®k, fËS¡¢a
¡¢a pj§q−L ¢h‘¡eju HL jq¡ pšÅ¡ pª¢ø L−l−Re z
S£h¡nÈ HV¡C fËj¡Z L−l ®k, fËS¡¢apj§q f§ZÑ¡‰ J p¤Q¡l©l©−f N¢Wa z AeÉ Lb¡u
X¡lEC−el ¢Q¿¹¡l ¢hfl£a fË¢œ²u¡u AbÑ¡v fËS¡¢a pj§q ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fË¢œ²u¡u eu hlw pª¢ø fË¢œ²u¡u
dl¡d¡−j Efe£a q−u−R z
¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fË¢œ²u¡u j¡eh pª¢øl LÒfL¡¢qe£

¢hhaÑeh¡−cl fËhš²¡l¡ ph−Q−u ®hn£ −k ¢hou¢V B−m¡Qe¡u ¢e−u B−pe, a¡q−m¡ j¡e¤o pª¢øl
Evp h¡ j¡eh pª¢øl lqpÉ z X¡lECeh¡c£l¡ H ¢ho−u c¡h£ L−l b¡−Le ®k, Bd¤¢eL j¡e¤o ¢LR¤
c¡h££ Ae¤k¡u£ fË¡u 4
pwMÉL h¡el fËS¡¢al f§hÑ f¤l¦o ®b−L ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fË¢œ²u¡u Eá¤a q−u−R z H c¡h
®b−L 5 ¢j¢mue hRl pjuL¡m ®b−L öl¦ q−u−R Hhw fª¢bh£−a Bd¤¢eL j¡e¤o J a¡l f§hÑ
f¤l¦o−cl A¿¹Ñha£Ñ BL«¢a J fÊL«¢a ¢h¢nø fËS¡¢a hph¡p Ll−a¡z H L¢Òfa d¡le¡ Ae¤k¡u£ j¡e¤o
j§ma 4 fkÑ¡−u ¢hL¡n m¡i L−l−R, a¡q−m¡ x
1. AUSTRALOPITHECUS
2. HOMO HABILIES

82 / 88
 3. HOMO ERECTUS
4. HOMO SAPIENS
¢hhaÑeh¡c£l¡ je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al ab¡L¢ba phÑfËbj f§hÑfl
¤ o−cl e¡jLle L−l−Re Australo Pithectus
k¡l AbÑ c¢r−el h¡el z fËL«af−r HC Australo Pithectus q−m¡ HL ¢hm¤ç fËS¡¢al h¡el z
B−j¢lL¡ k¤š²l¡ø J hª−V−el c¤C ¢hnÄ¢hMÉ¡a Anatomist, Austrolopethicist pÇf−LÑ hÉ¡fL
N−hoe¡l j¡dÉ−j S¡e−a ®f−l−Re ®k, HV¡ HL¢V m¤ç fËS¡¢al h¡e−ll hwn k¡l p¡−b j¡e¤o
fËS¡¢al n¡l£¢lL L¡W¡−j¡l −L¡e ¢jmC e¡C z
¢hhaÑeh¡c£l¡ je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al flha£Ñ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ fË¢œ²u¡−L Homo h¡ j¡eh ®nËe£ ¢q−p−h
¢hi¡Se L−l−Re z H c¡h£ Ae¤k¡u£ Homo
Homo ®nËe£i¥š² fËS¡¢a Australopithecus −nËe£ −b−L
A¢dLal Eæa h¡ ¢hL¡¢na z ¢hhaÑeh¡c£l¡ H pLm S£h¡−nÈl fkÑ¡uœ²¢jL ®nËe£ ¢heÉ¡p Ae¤k¡u£
je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al HL¢V L¢Òfa ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ f¢lLÒfe¡ fËÙºa L−le z je¤oÉ pª¢øl H œ²j¢hL¡−nl
f¢lLÒfe¡ fËL«af−r HL¢V LÒfL¡¢qe£ R¡s¡ ¢LR¤
¢LR¤C eu z L¡lZ ¢h¢iæ ¢h¢iæ fËS¡¢al j−dÉ −L¡e
¢hhaÑeh¡c£ ¢jm f¢lm¢ra qJu¡l ®L¡e fËj¡Z e¡ f¡Ju¡u ¢hou¢V AfËj¡¢Za z ¢hwn na−Ll
HLSe ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl L–
L–l pjbÑL Ernst Mayr H Lb¡ ü£L¡l L−l E−õM L−l−Re ®k, fËL«af−r
H hwn a¡¢mL¡u
a¡¢mL¡u Homo Sapiens fkÑ¿¹ −L¡e p§œ (Chain)
( ) f¡Ju¡ k¡u¢e h¡ H p§œ q¡¢l−u ®N−R z
je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al pª¢ø f¢lLÒfe¡ hZÑe¡ fËp−‰ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£l¡ Australopithe-cus>Homo
Habilis>Homo erectus>Homo Sapiens HC hwn¡e¤œ²j Ae¤ple Ll¡ q−u−R j−jÑ c¡h£ L−le z
fr¡¿¹−l S£h¡nÈ ¢h‘¡e£l¡ B¢h×L¡l L−l−Re ®k, Australopithecus, Homo habilis J Homo
erectus HLC pj−u fª¢bh£l ¢h¢iæ Hm¡L¡u hph¡p Ll−a¡ z a¡R¡s¡ Homo erectus ®nËe£i¥š²
fË¡Z£ A¢a pÇfТaL¡m fkÑ¿¹ fª¢bh£−a ¢hcÉj¡e ¢Rmz N−hoe¡u ®cM¡ ®N−R ®k x
“Homo sapiens (Bd¤¢eL j¡e¤o) neandertalensis J Homo erectus HLC pjuL¡−m
f¡n¡f¡¢n
f¡n¡f¡¢n fª¢bh£−a
bh£−a hph¡p Ll−a b¡−L z
H ®b−LC fËj¡¢Za qu ®k, je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al f§hÑ f¤l¦o pÇf¢LÑa ašÅ H−Lh¡−lC ¢i¢šq£e ab¡
L¢Òfaz
Harvard University Hl ¢hMÉ¡a S£h¡nÈ ¢h‘¡e£, Stephen Jay Gould ¢k¢e ¢e−S HLSe
¢hhaÑeh¡c£ qJu¡ p−šÅJ X¡lECeh¡¡−cl H Eiu pwLV Hi¡−h hZÑe¡ L−l−Re x
Bj¡−cl
Bj¡−cl (hwn m¢aL¡l) ¢py¢sl ¢ae fËS¡¢a-
¡¢a-Africanus, Australopithecines J Homo habilies
Hl −L¡e fËS¡¢aC L¡−l¡ ®b−L Eá§a qu¢e z a¡R¡s¡ HC ¢ae ®nËe£l ®L¡e ®nËe£l j−dÉ fª¢bh£−a
a¡−cl A¢Ù¹aÄ b¡L¡ AhÙÛ¡u ®L¡e dl−el ¢hhaÑ−el mre fkÑ−hre Ll¡ k¡u¢e z
AbÑ¡v ú¥m L−m−Sl f¡WÉ
f¡WÉ f¤Ù¹−L h¡ ¢p−ej¡u je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al ¢hhaÑ−el (AdÑ j¡eh-
j¡eh-AdÑ
h¡e−ll) ®k ¢Qœ h¡ R¢h ®cM¡ k¡u a¡ h¡−e¡u¡V J L¢Òfa, ®~h‘¡¢eL N−hoe¡u Hl −L¡e ¢i¢š M¤−y S
f¡Ju¡ k¡u¢e z H…−m¡ öd¤j¡œ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£−cl fËQ¡le¡ ¢qp¡−h H ašÅ ¢SC−u l¡M¡l H¢V HL¢V
Af−L±nm j¡œ z

83 / 88
 ¢hË−V−el HLSe pÇj¡¢ea J ¢hMÉ¡a ¢hhaÑeh¡c£ Lord Sobly Zuckerman 15 hvpl
k¡ha Australophitecus S£h¡nÈ ¢e−u N−hoe¡ L−l H ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ Efe£a qe ®k, “je¤oÉ fËS¡¢al
hwn m¢aL¡u h¡el fËS¡¢al f§hÑ f¤l¦−ol ®L¡e pÇfLÑ e¡C z
Zuckerman ¢h‘¡e pðå£u HL¢V p¤¾cl hZÑ¡m£ ¢h−nÔoe L−l−Re z ¢a¢e ‘¡−el ¢h¢iæ
n¡M¡/fËn¡M¡l j−dÉ ®nËe£ ¢heÉ¡p L−l ®~h‘¡¢eL Abh¡ A®~h‘¡¢eL ¢qp¡−h A¢i¢qa L−l−Re, ¢h‘¡−el
®L¡e n¡M¡ k¡ h¡Ù¹h ¢i¢šL gm¡g−m Efl fË¢a¢ùa Abh¡ k¡l¡ ¢h‘¡e ¢qp¡−h ü£L¡l L−le e¡
a¡−cl L¡−R HC hZÑ¡m£ ®~h‘¡¢eL ¢h−nÔoe EfÙÛ¡fe L−le, Zuckerman Hl a¡¢mL¡u
a¡¢mL¡u ph−Q−u
p¢WL h¡ h¡Ù¹h ¢h‘¡e ¢qp¡−h fc¡bÑ¢hcÉ¡ Hhw lp¡ue¢hcÉ¡ z Hl fl B−p S£h ¢h‘¡−el ÙÛ¡e Hhw
Hl f−l p¡j¡¢SL ¢h‘¡e pj§q z H hZÑ¡m£ ¢h−nÔo−el ®no fË¡−¿¹ l−u−R k¡−L fË¡uC A®~h‘¡¢eL
¢qp¡−h ¢h−hQe¡ Ll¡ q−u b¡−L a¡q−m¡-
a¡q−m¡-®V¢mfÉ¡¢b, o−ø¢¾cÐu Hhw phÑ−n−o l−u−R j¡e¤−ol ¢hhaÑ−el
jah¡c z p¡¢hÑL ¢hou¢V ¢a¢e Hi¡−h hZÑe¡ L−l−Re x
Bjl¡ k¢c a¡vr¢eLi¡−h h¡Ù¹h paÉ ¢houL ¢h‘¡e h¡ ab¡L¢ba S£h ¢h‘¡e h¡ j¡e¤−ol
A¢a¢¾cÐu ‘¡e h¡ j¡e¤−ol S£h¡−nÈl C¢aq¡p, ®p−r−œ HLSe ¢hnÄÙ¹ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£l −r−œ ph ¢LR¤C
pñh z ®p−r−œ HLSe ¢hhaÑeh¡−c Ni£l ¢hnÄ¡p£, flØfl ¢h−l¡d£ A−eL ¢LR¤ HLC p¡−b ¢hnÄ¡p
Ll−a f¡−le z
a¡C j¡eh C¢aq¡−pl ¢hhaÑe L−uLSe HL−f−n j¿¹hÉ J X¡lECeh¡−c ¢LR¤ pwMÉL Aå
¢hnÄ¡p£−cl L−uL¢V S£h¡nÈ fkÑ−hr−el gpm R¡s¡ Bl ¢LR¤ euz

j¡e¤−ol −Q¡M J L¡−el LjÑfÜ¢a

j¡e¤−ol −Q¡M J L¡e ®k Ap¡d¡le

Ap¡d¡le fÜ¢a−a L¡S L−l, ®p pÇf−LÑ ¢hhaÑeh¡c£l¡ HC
®L±n−ml ®L¡e pc¤šl ¢c−a prj qe e¡z Bjl¡ ¢L S¡¢e Bj¡−cl ®Q¡M ¢Li¡−h L¡S L−l ? H
fË−nÀl Ešl S¡e¡l f§−hÑ Bjl¡ ¢Li¡−h ®c¢M H fË−nÀl Sh¡h ®My¡S¡l ®Qø¡ L¢l z B−m¡L l¢nÈ
®L¡e hÙº ®b−L fË¢ag¢ma q−u ®Q¡−Ml ®l¢Ve¡l ¢hfl£a ¢cL q−a f¢aa quz HM¡−e HC B−m¡L
l¢nÈ pj§q ®~hc¤É¢aL ¢pNe¡−m f¢lZa q−u j¡eh j¢Ù¹−×Ll ®L−¾cÐl ¢fR−e Ah¢ÙÛa HL¢V r¥â Spot
h¡ ¢h¾c¤−a ®fy±R¡u z HC ®~hc¤É¢aL ¢pNe¡m pj§q ¢h¢iæ fË¢œ²u¡u R¢h−a f¢lZa qu Hhw Bjl¡
®cM−a f¡C z HC ®VL¢eLÉ¡m −fËr¡f−V Bjl¡ ¢hou¢V ¢Q¿¹¡ Ll−a f¡¢l z
j¡eh j¢Ù¹−ú ®L¡e B−m¡ e¡C z Hl AbÑ q−m¡ j¢Ù¹−×Ll AiÉ¿¹li¡−N Ni£l AåL¡l
¢hl¡Sj¡ez Hhw j¢Ù¹−×Ll Hm¡L¡u ®L¡e B−m¡ −fy±R¡u e¡ z j¢Ù¹−×Ll ®k S¡uN¡u cnÑ−el ®L¾cÐ
Ah¢ÙÛa Eš² ÙÛ¡e¢V−a LMeJ ®L¡e B−m¡ ®fy¡~R¡−a f¡−he¡ z j¡e¤−ol S¡e¡ j−a Hl ®Q−u ®L¡e
AåL¡l
AåL¡l S¡uN¡ ®L¡b¡J e¡C z AbQ Bjl¡ B−m¡¢La, ESÆm fª¢bh£ cnÑe L−l b¡¢L z
j¡eh Qr¥−a Hje p¤r¡¢ap¤r J Øfø fË¢a¢hð pª¢ø Ll−a prj ®k, ¢hwn na−Ll
phÑ¡d¤¢eL ®~h‘¡¢eL fËk¤¢š²J a¡ ®~al£ Ll−a prj qu e¡C z Ec¡qle ül©f hm¡ k¡u ®k, Bf¢e

84 / 88
®k hC¢V f¡W Ll−Re, Bfe¡l ®k q¡a ¢c−u
¢c−u a¡ d−l l¡M−Re Hhw j¡b¡ EQ¥ L−l Q¡¢l¢c−L a¡L¡e,
Bf¢e ¢L LMeJ HC dl−el p¤rÈ J Øfø fË¢a¢hð AeÉ ®L¡b¡J ®c−M−Re ¢L? fª¢bh£l phÑ−nËù
®V¢m¢ine fËÙºaL¡lL ®L¡Çf¡e£J H dl−el ®V¢m¢ine (Screen)) fcÑ¡ Bfe¡l SeÉ H lLj Eæa
dl−el ®V¢m¢ine ®~al£ Ll−a prj q−he¡ zj¡
zj¡eh
j¡eh Qr¥l HC fË¢a¢h𠢜j¤M£, l‰£eJ
l‰£eJ A¢a p§rÈ z
na¡¢dL hRl d−l q¡S¡l q¡S¡l cr fË−L±nm£ H dl−el p¤rÈ fË¢a¢hð pª¢ø Ll−a hÉbÑ q−u−Re z
H m−r ¢hl¡V ¢hl¡V L¡lM¡e¡, f¢lLÒfe¡, ¢h¢iæ dl−el ¢XS¡Ce ¢e−u fËQ¥l N−hoe¡ Ll¡ q−u−R
¢L¿º H L¡−S a¡l¡ pgm qe¢e z Bh¡l Bf¢e ®V¢m¢in−el fcÑ
fcÑ¡l ¢c−L a¡L¡e Hhw Bfe¡l
q¡−a dl¡ hC¢Vl ¢c−L cª¢ø ¢ce z Bf¢e A¢a AhnÉC f¡bÑLÉV¡ mr Ll−Re z ¢V¢i fcÑ¡ ¢àj¡¢œL
R¢h ®cM¡u fr¡¿¹−l Bfe¡l Qr¥ Ni£la¡pq ¢œj¡¢œL R¢h fËcnÑe L−l b¡−L z
k¢cJ hR−ll fl hRl q¡S¡l q¡S¡l C¢”¢eu¡l hÉ¡fL N−hoe¡l fl ¢œj¡¢œL ®V¢m¢ine
®~al£ Ll−a prj q−u−R ¢WL, ¢L¿º Qnj¡ R¡s¡ a¡ ®cM¡ pñh euz a¡R¡s¡ HV¡ H dl−el L«¢œj
¢œj¡¢œL cnÑe fÜ¢a−a R¢hl fÕQ¡ci¨¢j T¡fp¡ J pÇj¤Mi¡N L¡NS m¡N¡−e¡l ja ®cM¡ k¡u ¢L¿º
a¡ LMeJ j¡eh Qr¥l ja Ha Øfø J p§rÈ eu z LÉ¡−jl¡ J −V¢m¢ine Eiu ®r−œC fË¢a¢h−ðl
j¡e r¥æ qu z
¢hhaÑ
¢hhaÑeh¡c£l¡ c¡h£ L−le ®k, j¡eh Qr¥l HC p§rÈa¡J Øføa¡l Lm¡ −L±nm ®~ch¡v pª¢ø
q−u−Rz AbQ ®L¡e ®m¡L k¢c h−m Bfe¡l O−ll ®V¢m¢ine ®pV¢V üaØg¤aÑi¡−h ¢e¢jÑa q−uR,
AbÑ¡v ®V¢m¢in−el pjÙ¹ S¢Vm k¿»¡wn pj§q HL¢œa q−u H dl−el HL¢V AaÉ¡d¤¢eL p¤¾cl k¿»
¢qp¡−h Bfe¡l O−l q¡¢Sl
q¡¢Sl q−u−R k¡l j¡dÉ−j Hje p¤¾cl R¢h ®cM¡ k¡u, a¡q−m¡ a¡ ¢L HL¢V
NËqe−k¡NÉ fËÙ¹¡he¡ q−a f¡−l ?
®k−qa¥ j¡eh Qr¥l ®Q−u ¢ejÀj¡−el fË¢a¢hð pª¢øL¡l£ k¿» qW¡v L−l pª¢ø Ll¡ pñh eu z
a¡C j¡eh Qr¥l ja Eæa fË¢a¢hð pª¢øL¡l£ k¿» −L¡eœ²−jC ®~ch¡v pª¢ø qu e¡C z j¡e¤−ol L¡−el
−r−œ HLC Lb¡ pji¡−h fË−k¡SÉ z L¡−el h¡C−ll Awn ph dl−el fË¡ç në h¢qxLZÑ NËqZ L−l
a¡ jdÉ L−ZÑl ¢c−L d¡¢ha quz jdÉ LZÑ H në al‰ a£hË L−l, A¿¹xL−ZÑ a¡ ®fËle L−l, A¿¹xLZÑ
¢hou¢V
a¡ ®~hc¤É¢aL pw−La ¢qp¡−h f¢lZa L−l a¡ j¢Ù¹−×L ®fËle L−l Hhw ®Q¡−Ml jaC nËh−el ¢hou¢V
j¢Ù¹−×Ll ®L−¾cÐ Q¨s¡¿¹ Ll¡ quz
Qr¥ J L−ZÑl Ev−pl ¢hou¢V pji¡−h L¡kÑLl q−u b¡−L z AbÑ¡v j¢Ù¹×L B−m¡l jaC në
®b−L ¢h¢µRæ b¡−L z H−a ®L¡e dl−el në fË−hn Ll−a ®cJu¡ qu e¡ z a¡C h¡C−l ka dl−el
nëC ®q¡L e¡ −Le, j¢Ù¹×L ¢L¿º pÇf§ZÑl©−f ¢exnë z ah¤J a£rÈ nëJ j¢Ù¹
j¢Ù¹×L h¤T−a f¡−l z
Bfe¡l j¢Ù¹×L k¢cJ në ®b−L ¢h¢µRæ ah¤J Bf¢e ¢WLC A−œ²øÊ¡l h¡Se¡ öe−a ®f−u b¡−Le z
Bh¡l ¢i−sl j−dÉ ph dl−el ®N¡mj¡−ml BJu¡S nËhe L−l b¡−Le z k¢c H pju Bfe¡l
j¢Ù¹−×L ®L¡e p§rÈ k¿» ¢c−u f¢lj¡f Ll¡ q−a¡ ®cM¡ ®k−a¡ a¡ pÇf§ZÑi¡−h nëq£e h¡ ¢exnë z
fË¢a¢hð h¡ R¢h N−hoe¡l jaC j§m në al‰ k¡ pªSe J f¤ex pªSe ¢L pñh a¡ ¢e−u
hR−ll fl hRl N−hoe¡ Ll¡ q−u−R z HlC gmn˦¢a−a ®~al£ Ll¡ q−u−R në lrL/NËqe k¿»
(Sound Recorder)) k¡−a j§m në al‰ ¢hnÄÙa
¹ ¡l p¡−b ®lLXÑ Ll¡ k¡u z Hph Lm¡−L±nm J

85 / 88
q¡S¡l q¡S¡l C¢”¢eu¡l
C¢”¢eu¡l J ¢h−no‘−cl N−hoe¡ J fË−Qø¡ p−šÅJ j¡eh nËhe k¿» ab¡ L−ZÑ¢¾cÐ−ul
eÉ¡u Øfø, a£rÈ në NËqe k¿» j¡e¤o BS fkÑ¿¹ ®~al£ Ll−a prj qu¢ez fª¢bh£l phÑ−nËù
®L¡Çf¡e£l p−hÑ¡vL«ø H1-
H1-F1 në NËqe k−¿»l Lb¡C ¢Q¿¹¡ Ll¦e, Hje¢L Hph k¿»f¡¢a ¢c−u në
®lLXÑ Ll¡ q−mJ ¢LR¤ në al‰ q¡¢l−u k¡u, a¡R¡s¡ k¿»¢V Q¡m¤ Ll−m ®L¡e N¡e öl¦l f§−hÑ HL
dl−el Hiss Hiss në qu z AbQ j¡eh ®c−ql Lm¡ ®L±n−ml j¡dÉ−j k¡ pª¢ø h¡ NËqe Ll¡
qu a¡ AaÉ¿¹ p§rÈ J Øfø z j¡eh£u LZÑ LMeJ Hiss Hiss BJu¡S pð¢ma ®L¡e në al‰
NËqe L−l e¡ −kje e¡¢L HI-FI në NËqe fË¢œ²u¡u q−u b¡−L z j¡eh S¡¢al pª¢ø ®b−L AcÉ¡h¢d
HV¡C q−u Bp−R z
BS fkÑ¿¹ je¤oÉ LaѪL ®L¡e cnÑe k¿» h¡ në NËqe k¿» j¡e¤−ol ®Q¡M J L−ZÑl ja cr,
f§ZÑ¡‰ J pgm k¿» ®~al£ Ll−a prj qu e¡C z

j¢Ù¹−×Ll AiÉ¿¹l ®b−L ®c−M J ö−e x ®L¡eÚ ®p Se

®p ®L¡e Se ¢k¢e j¡eh j¢Ù¹

j¢Ù¹−×Ll j−dÉ AhÙÛ¡e L−l j¤‡ q−u N¡e J f¡¢Ml Lm-
Lm-L¡L¢m
®n¡−ee J ®N¡m¡−fl Nå ®ee z j¡e¤−ol ®Q¡−Ml, L¡−el J e¡−Ll EŸ£fe¡pj§q ®~hc¤É¢aL-
¢aL-
l¡p¡u¢eL (Electro-chemical)
( ) pÀ¡u¤ al‰ ¢qp¡−h j¢Ù¹−×L fË−hn L−l z S£h ¢h‘¡e, fË¡Z lp¡ue J
nl£lhªš ¢houL f¤Ù¹−L j¡eh j¢Ù¹−×L ¢Li¡−h
¢Li¡−h fË¢a¢hð pª¢ø qu a¡l ¢hÙ¹¡¢la ¢hhlZ ®f−a f¡−le z
¢L¿º Bf¢e H−r−œ ph−Q−u …l¦aÄf§ZÑ −k ¢hou¢Vl ®L¡e E−õMC f¡−he e¡, a¡q−m¡ ®L¡e ®p Se
¢k¢e j¡eh j¢Ù¹−×L LMeJ fË¢a¢hð h¡ R¢h, në, Nå pð¢ma Electro-chemical al‰ ¢qp¡−h
Efm¢Ü L−le h¡ C¢¾cÐu à¡l¡ ‘¡e m¡i L−le z ®pM¡−eC l−u−R ®pC “jq¡ ®Qae¡” k¡ Qr¥, LZÑ
J e¡−Ll ®L¡e fË−u¡Se£ua¡ R¡s¡C ph ¢LR¤ ¢ei¥Ñmi¡−h Efm¢Ü h¡ h¤T−a prj z HC jq¡ ®Qae¡l
j¡¢mL ®L ? H hÉ¡f¡−l ®L¡e p−¾cq e¡C ®k, HV¡ C¢¾cÐ−ul ®L¡e hÉ¡f¡l euz Q¢hÑl f¤l¦ Ù¹l J
¢eEl−el pj¢ø ¢c−u N¢Wa j¢Ù¹×L z H L¡l−ZC h¡Ù¹
h¡Ù¹hh¡c£ X¡lECeh¡c£ k¡l¡ ¢hnÄ¡p L−l ph¢LR¤C
hÙºl à¡l¡ N¢Wa, a¡l¡ H fË−nÀl pc¤šl fËc¡e Ll−a pÇf§ZÑ Arjz
HC jq¡ ®Qae¡ q−µR Bõ¡qa¡m¡ LaѪL pªø BaÈ¡ z HC BaÈ¡l ®cM¡, öe¡ J Nå Ae¤ih
Ll¡l SeÉ ®Q¡M, L¡e h¡ e¡−Ll ®L¡e fË−u¡Se que¡ z Efl¿º ¢Q¿¹¡ Ll¡l SeÉ HC BaÈ¡l ®L¡e
j¢Ù¹−×LlJ clL¡l qu e¡z
¢k¢eC HC p¤Øfø ®~h‘¡¢eL abÉ fËj¡Z pÇf−LÑ f¡W Ll−he, a¡l¡ jq¡e Bõ¡q l¡¢îm
Bm B¢je pÇf−LÑ ¢Q¿¹¡ J N−hoe¡ Ll−he ay¡−L iu Ll−he z ay¡l L¡−R BnËu fË¡bÑe¡ Ll−he,
ay¡l L¡−R BnËu fË¡bÑe¡ Ll−he, p−hÑ¡f¢l öd¤ a¡−LC i¡mh¡p−he z ¢k¢e HC pjNË ¢hnÄhËr¡ä−L
N¡t AåL¡l, L−uL ®p¢¾V¢jV¡l r¥â, ¢œj¡¢œL, l¢‰e R¡u¡Oe, B−m¡L‹Æm L¡W¡−j¡l j−dÉ h¾c£ h¡
pwL¥¢Qa L−l pª¢ø L−l−Rez

86 / 88
 HLSe hÙh
º ¡c£l ¢hn¡Ä p

Efk¤Ñš² B−m¡Qe¡, fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡l j¡dÉ−j Bjl¡ fkÑ−hre Llm¡j ®k, ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl ašÅ
®M¡m¡M¤¢mi¡−h
mi¡−h ®~h‘¡¢eL abÉ J Ef¡−šl p¡−b pwOoÑn£m ab¡ i¥m h¡ ¢i¢šq£e z fª¢bh£−a fË¡−Zl
Evp pÇf−LÑ H jah¡−cl c¡h£ ¢h‘¡−el ¢hQ¡−l ¢i¢šq£e z fË¡Z pª¢ø fË¢œ²u¡u ®k ¢hhaÑeh¡c£
fÜ¢al c¡h£ H jah¡−c Ll¡ q−u−R a¡ h¡Ù¹h pÇja eu z S£h¡nÈ ®lLXÑ Ae¤k¡u£ ®L¡e
A¿¹ha£ÑL¡m£e fË¡Z£l på¡e
på¡e f¡Ju¡ k¡u e¡C z H L¡l−Z ¢hhaÑeh¡c A®~h‘¡¢eL ¢qp¡−h cnÑe SNa
®b−L ®T−s ®gm¡ E¢Qa z fËL«af−r fª¢bh£l C¢aq¡−pl ¢h¢iæ fkÑ¡−u A−eL ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ h¡ jah¡c
¢h‘¡−el SNa ®b−L Afp¡le Ll¡ q−u−R ¢hhaÑeh¡c j−XmJ Hl j−dÉ A¿¹iÑš
§ ² z
¢hhaÑeh¡c−L c¤iÑ¡NÉhna hmf§hÑL ¢h‘¡e pÇja ¢qp¡−h Q¡m¡−e¡l fË−Qø¡ AhÉ¡qa l−u−R,
Hje¢L ¢LR¤ pwMÉL ¢hhaÑeh¡−cl pj¡−m¡Qe¡−L ¢h‘¡−el Efl Bœ²je ¢qp¡−hJ A¢i¢qa L−l
b¡−Le z ¢L¿º ®Le? Hl L¡lZ q−µR ¢LR¤ pwMÉL ®m¡−Ll L¡−R ¢hhaÑeh¡c HL¢V Af¢lq¡kÑ ®Ny¡s¡¢j
k¡ fË¡u dj£Ñu ¢hnÄ¡−pl ja L¡kÑLl z Hph jqm AaÉ¿¹ ®S¡−l−n¡−l hÙºh¡−c ¢hnÄ¡p£ q−u
X¡lECeh¡c à¡l¡ fËi¡¢ha Hhw pª¢ø lq−pÉl hÙºh¡c£ hÉ¡MÉ¡ HLj¡œ X¡lECeh¡−cl j¡dÉ−jC L−l
b¡−Le a¡l¡ fËL¡−nÉC a¡ ®O¡oe¡ L−le z
q¡i¡XÑ CE¢ei¡¢pÑ¢Vl ¢hMÉ¡a Geneticist Richard Lewontin ¢k¢e HLSe ¢hhaÑeh¡c£,
¢a¢e ¢e−S−L fËb−j HLSe
HLSe hÙºh¡c£ ¢Q¿¹¡¢hc Hhw f−l HLSe ¢h‘¡e£ ¢qp¡−h f¢lQu ¢c−a fR¾c
L−le, ¢a¢e E−õM L−l−Re x
HC C¢¾cÐuNË¡qÉ ¢hnÄ pÇf−LÑ hÙºh¡c£ hÉ¡MÉ¡l ®~h‘¡¢eL fËb¡ h¡ f¿Û¡ k¡C ®q¡L e¡ ®Le,
Bjl¡ A¢a AhnÉC Bj¡−cl hÙºh¡c£ ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l fË¢a Be¤N−aÉl ANË¡¡¢dL¡l b¡L¡l L¡l−Z Bj¡−cl
¢eSü Ae¤på¡e fÜ¢a J ¢LR¤ hÙº ab¡ Ssh¡c£ jah¡c pª¢ø Ll¡ fË−u¡Se k¡ (¢hnÄ pª¢øl lqpÉ
pÇf−LÑ) öd¤ hÙºh¡c£ hÉ¡MÉ¡C fËc¡e Ll−h, a¡ ®p ka c¤−‘Ñu, üaxØg§aÑ ‘¡e ¢h−l¡d£ h¡ p§œ ¢hq£e
®L¡e
®q¡L e¡ ®Le z a¡R¡s¡ ®pC hÙºh¡c£ ¢Q¿¹¡ ®Qae¡ h¡ i¡hd¡l¡C Q¨s¡¿¹, a¡C Bjl¡ H−r−œ ®L¡ e
In£ h¡Z£ h¡ jah¡c−L ®L¡eœ²−jC NËqZ Ll−a f¡¢le¡ z
H ®b−L fËj¡¢Za qu ®k X¡lECeh¡c k¡ AaÉ¿¹ ®Ny¡s¡ HL¢V jah¡c hÙºh¡c£ cnÑe−L S£¢ha
h¡ hy¡¢Q−u l¡M¡l SeÉ HC jah¡c−L ¢V¢L−u l¡M¡ q−µR z HC Aå cnÑe h¡ jah¡c hÙº R¡s¡ AeÉ
¢LR¤l A¢Ù¹aÄ ü£L¡l L−le¡ z H L¡l−ZC HV¡ ¢hnÄ¡p Ll¡ qu ®k, fË¡Z, ®Qae¡ J üš¡¢hq£e hÙº
fª¢bh£−a fË¡Z pª¢ø L−l−R z H jah¡c d¡le¡ L−l ®k, fª¢bh£−a hph¡pla mr mr fËS¡¢a-
¡¢a-fr£,
j¡R, ¢Sl¡g, h¡O, ®f¡L¡-
®f¡L¡-j¡Ls, hªr, g¥m, ¢a¢j Hhw j¡e¤o ph ¢LR¤C hÙº ®b−L pª¢ø q−u−R-
q−u−R-AbÑ¡v
¢hc¤Év J hª¢øf¡a ®b−L pª¢ø z H dl−el
dl−el ¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡ h¡ d¡le¡ fËL«af−r p¡d¡lZ h¤¢Ü J ®~h‘¡¢eL
¢Q¿¹¡d¡l¡l ¢hfl£a z AbQ X¡lECeh¡c£l¡ H jah¡c−L HMeJ A−ål ja ByL−s ®l−M−Re L¡lZ
a¡l¡ ¢Q¿¹¡l ®r−œ fË−hn Ll−a ®L¡e In£ h¡ B¢d−i±¢aL ®L¡e hÉ¡MÉ¡ NËqZ Ll−a BNËq£ eu z

87 / 88
 k¢c ®Lq hÙºh¡c£ HL ®f−n cª¢øi‰£ f¢laÉ¡N L−l fª¢bh£l fË¡Z SN−al ¢c−L ®M¡m¡ j−e
mr L−le, ¢a¢e A¢a AhnÉC fËL«a paÉ Ae¤d¡he Ll−a prj q−he ®k, SN−al pjÙ¹ fË¡Z£
®pC jq¡ n¢š²n¡m£, jq¡‘¡e£ J flj fË‘¡j−ul pª¢ø z ¢a¢eC ®pC pËø¡ ¢k¢e n§eÉ ®b−L HC ¢hn¡m
¢hnÄ hËrÈ¡ä pª¢ø L−l−Re, ¢k¢e fË−aÉL fË¡Z£l eLn¡,
eLn¡, BL¡l, BL«¢a, fËL«¢a phÑ¡‰ p¤¾cli¡−h pª¢ø
L−l−Re z

--------------

88 / 88