Professional Documents
Culture Documents
T
Hampshire he ventricular system is routinely accessed their starting location relative to the external
for a variety of emergent and elective auditory canal. Anterior access sites include
Correspondence: neurosurgical procedures.1-4 Depending Kocher’s, Kaufman’s, Paine’s, Menovksy’s, and
Peter J. Morone, MD, upon the indications, different locations within Tubbs’ points; posterior access sites include
Department of Neurological Surgery,
Vanderbilt University Medical Center, the ventricles may need to be accessed. Thus, Keen’s, Frazier’s, Dandy’s, and Sanchez’s points.
1161 21st Avenue South, T4224 MCN, a multitude of ventricular access points have Additionally, we include detailed, multiview
Nashville, TN 37232-2380. been described over the past century.4-14 Each illustrations that provide the reader with a novel
Email: peter.morone@vumc.org
entry point requires an operative technique understanding of the craniometrics associated
Received, February 27, 2019.
with different surface landmarks for burr hole with each point.
Accepted, April 11, 2019. placement, trajectories for catheter passage, and
ending locations within the ventricles.
Copyright
C 2019 by the Although ventricular access is one of the
ANTERIOR ACCESS SITES
Congress of Neurological Surgeons
most common procedures performed, there is Kocher’s Point
a paucity of literature illustrating the operative Kocher’s point is thought to be named
techniques for the most common ventricular after the Swiss neurosurgeon Emil Theodor
access points. Additionally, the operative Kocher (1841-1917).15 However, Cushing16
techniques depicted within the current liter- and Tillmanns6 are credited with describing
ature are poor quality and difficult to interpret. the first ventriculostomy through this point.
Because it is important that all neurosurgeons Kocher’s point is the most common location for
be versed in the craniometrics associated with placement of an external ventricular drain for
these techniques, there is a need for high-quality emergent cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) diversion,
images with clear measurements depicting the but its clinical applicability is diverse. This
details of each access point, which remains location has been used for ventriculoperi-
unmet. toneal shunt catheter insertion,17 endoscopic
In this historical review, we describe the third ventriculostomy,18 endoscopic removal of
indications and operative techniques for 9 colloid cysts,19 and endoscopic removal of intra-
ventricular access points. We separate them into ventricular hemorrhage.20 The starting location
anterior and posterior categories based upon for Kocher’s point is a burr hole that is 11 cm
superior and posterior from the nasion
and 3 cm lateral to midline. This location
ABBREVIATION: CSF, cerebrospinal fluid
generally lies along the midpupillary line and is
1 to 2 cm anterior to the coronal suture. Importantly, this point location for Kaufman’s point is a burr hole that is placed 5 cm
is lateral to the superior sagittal sinus and anterior to the primary superior to the nasion and 3 cm lateral to midline. The catheter
motor cortex, 2 critical areas that should be avoided. For correct should be aimed toward the midline and inferiorly toward a
placement of an external ventricular drain, the catheter should be point that is 3 cm superior to the inion. The catheter should
directed at an angle that is perpendicular to the intersection of be passed approximately 7 cm below the surface of the skin and
lines drawn from the ipsilateral medial canthus and the ipsilateral placed within the frontal horn of the ipsilateral lateral ventricle
external auditory meatus. The catheter should be passed to a (Figure 2). When performing this technique, the skin can be
depth of approximately 6 cm below the skin surface or until the cleaned quickly because the patient’s hair does not need to be
frontal horn of the ipsilateral lateral ventricle is penetrated. For clipped. Although this is an advantage cited by the authors,8 this
maximal drainage of CSF, the tip of the catheter should be placed technique is rarely used in current practice secondary to cosmetic
near the foramen of Monro (Figure 1).2,21,22 In general, it is appearance. The laterality of this approach can be right or left
safest to place the catheter on the patient’s right because this side depending upon the intracranial pathology and has a 90% success
usually corresponds to the nondominant hemisphere. However, rate,8 although, because of its rarity, no large series employing this
depending upon the pathology and surgical goals, a left-sided approach have been completed.
approach may also be used. Despite its popularity, ventricular
cannulation via Kocher’s point remains relatively inaccurate with
miss rates ranging from 4 to 40%.21,23 Paine’s Point
Paine’s point was initially described by Paine et al.9 It allows
Kaufman’s Point for CSF drainage via direct ventricular puncture and was first
Kaufman’s point was first described by Kaufmann and Clark.8 used in patients undergoing a frontotemporal craniotomy for
Via a forehead approach, this point provides rapid access to the aneurysm clipping after aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage.
ventricular system for emergent drainage of CSF. The starting This technique should be employed when there is concern for
severe brain edema after completing a frontotemporal craniotomy. Similar to the indications for placement of a Paine’s point
In this setting, CSF egress lessens the need for brain retraction, ventricular drain, these modifications should be utilized to reduce
which can often be traumatic. After the dura is opened, a point brain edema after completing a frontotemporal craniotomy.
that is 2.5 cm above the floor of the anterior cranial fossa and Hyun et al11 suggested the entry point be extended 2 cm
2.5 cm anterior to the sylvian fissure (marked by the superficial from the anterior limb of Paine’s triangle. The ventricular
sylvian vein) is identified. The intersection of these lines forms catheter should be aimed perpendicular to the convexity of the
the anterior and posterior limbs of Paine’s triangle, respectively. brain and passed to a depth of 5 to 6.5 cm or until reaching
Next, the surface of the pia is cauterized and a ventricular catheter the frontal horn of the ipsilateral lateral ventricle (Figure 3).
is passed at a trajectory that is perpendicular to the convexity of In their study of 10 patients, the authors reported a 100%
the brain surface. The catheter should be advanced 4 to 5 cm or success rate and concluded that their entry site resulted in a
until the frontal horn of the ipsilateral lateral ventricular is reached more accurate trajectory compared with Paine’s point. However,
(Figure 3). Although no clinical series have been reported demon- unlike the technique described by Paine et al,11 they used
strating the efficacy and safety of Paine’s point, several authors neuronavigation.
have concluded that there is theoretical risk of damaging Broca’s Park and Hamm12 suggested the entry point be extended
area, the head of the caudate nucleus, and the thalamus using this 2 cm from the posterior limb of Paine’s triangle. The ventricular
approach.11,12 catheter should be aimed perpendicular to the convexity of the
brain and passed to a depth of 5 to 6 cm or until reaching
the frontal horn of the ipsilateral lateral ventricle (Figure 3).
Modifications to Paine’s Point The authors state that this entry site poses less risk of injury to
Given the risk of damaging Broca’s area, the head of the caudate the head of the caudate nucleus, demonstrating only a 2.5%
nucleus, and the thalamus when passing a ventricular catheter chance of injury compared with a 90% chance of injury when
from Paine’s point, 2 modifications have been proposed.11,12 the catheter was passed from Paine’s point.12 Additionally, in their
clinical series of 32 patients, the ipsilateral frontal horn was cannu- Tubbs’ Point
lated successfully 94% of the time during first pass of the catheter. Tubbs’ point was given definitive landmarks by Tubbs et al,13
but this approach had been previously described in case
reports.24,25 It is used for emergent ventricular decompression
Menovsky’s Point via a transorbital route and is completed with a spinal needle.
Menovsky’s point was described by Menovsky et al10 and can The needle tip is placed under the upper left or right eyelid and
be employed while performing a supraorbital craniotomy through advanced at a trajectory that is 45◦ superior to the orbitomeatal
an eyebrow incision. It is indicated in the setting of brain edema, line and 20◦ toward the midline. If done correctly, the orbital
allowing for CSF drainage and brain relaxation prior to complete roof should be penetrated just medial to the midpupillary line
bone removal. and posterior to the superciliary arch. After advancing the spinal
After completing the initial exposure and drilling the keyhole needle approximately 8 cm, the frontal horn of the ipsilateral
burr hole, the dura should be incised. The ventricular catheter lateral ventricle will be cannulated (Figure 5). Of note, because
should be passed through the burr hole and directed 45◦ toward ventricular access is obtained via a transorbital route, a burr hole
the midline and 20◦ superior to the orbitomeatal line. It should does not need to be drilled, making this procedure more time
be passed to a depth of 5 to 6.5 cm or until the frontal horn of efficient. Although expedient, this technique is seldom performed
the ipsilateral lateral ventricle is reached (Figure 4). In their series because it increases the risk of a globe injury and requires blind
of 10 patients and 5 cadaveric specimens, the authors reported an puncture of the orbital roof. Thus, no clinical series demon-
87% first-pass ventricular cannulation rate.10 strating its efficacy and safety have been performed.
FIGURE 6. Ventricular access via Keen’s point. After a burr hole is placed 2.5 cm superior and
posterior to the pinna of the ear, the catheter should be placed perpendicular to the cortex and aimed
in a slight cephalic direction. The catheter should be advanced 4 to 5 cm or until the trigone of the
ipsilateral lateral ventricle is reached.
C 2016 Elizabeth N. Weissbrod. Used with permission.
Dandy’s Point ventricular cannulation rate, but no studies involving real patients
Dandy’s point was described by Dandy7 as a way to perform have been completed. It is important to note that given the
ventriculography via an occipital approach. Today, the utility of catheter’s trajectory near or through the optic radiations, damage
this approach arises in scenarios in which CSF diversion is needed to the visual fields is a theoretic concern when completing this
for a patient already positioned for an occipital or retromastoid technique.
craniotomy. This can be performed in a planned fashion just
prior to beginning the formal craniotomy, or, more commonly, Sanchez’s Point
on an emergent basis wherein rapid, unplanned CSF diversion Sanchez’s point was described by Sanchez et al.4 This approach
is needed for a patient demonstrating intraoperative signs of is used to catheterize the temporal horn and can be employed to
elevated intracranial pressure that require treatment. The burr divert CSF in the setting of a trapped ventricle or to endoscop-
hole is placed 3 cm above the inion and 2 cm left or right to ically access mesial temporal structures. The burr hole is made
the midline, corresponding to a region of the occipital bone 5.6 cm above the inion and 2.7 cm left or right to the midline.
that is below the lambdoid suture. The catheter tip is directed The catheter is directed 5◦ lateral from a parasagittal plane (which
toward a point 2 cm above the glabella and passed to a distance is parallel to midline) and 30◦ inferior toward the orbitomeatal
of 4 to 5 cm or until CSF is encountered. At this point, the plane. CSF should be encountered at 5 cm, and passage of
tip of the catheter should be positioned within the body of the the catheter an additional 4 to 5 cm (total 9-10 cm) should
ipsilateral lateral ventricle (Figure 8).28,30 Lee et al30 used these place the tip within the temporal horn of the ipsilateral lateral
craniometrics to simulate ventricular trajectories using magnetic ventricle (Figure 9). Using 9 cadaveric specimens, Sanchez et al4
resonance imaging data from 10 patients and achieved a 100% completed 18 approaches and achieved a 100% ventricular
FIGURE 9. Ventricular access via Sanchez’s point. A burr hole is placed 5.6 cm above the inion
and 2.7 cm lateral to midline. The catheter is angled 5◦ lateral to the parasagittal plane and 30◦
inferior toward the orbitomeatal plane. The catheter is then advanced 9 to 10 cm to be positioned
within the temporal horn of the ipsilateral lateral ventricle.
C 2016 Elizabeth N. Weissbrod. Used
with permission.
cannulation success rate. To date, no studies using this approach 12. Park J, Hamm IS. Revision of Paine’s technique for intraoperative ventricular
in real patients have been published. puncture. Surg Neurol. 2008;70(5):503-508; discussion 508.
13. Tubbs RS, Loukas M, Shoja MM, Cohen-Gadol AA. Emergency transor-
bital ventricular puncture: refinement of external landmarks. J Neurosurg.