Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FOSSIL INVERTEBRATES
Contents
Arthropods
Trilobites
Insects
Brachiopods
Bryozoans
Corals and Other Cnidaria
Echinoderms (Other Than Echinoids)
Crinoids
Echinoids
Graptolites
Molluscs Overview
Bivalves
Gastropods
Cephalopods (Other Than Ammonites)
Ammonites
Porifera
in geological time in which preservational failure ecdysis allows segment addition and tagmosis to be
would otherwise obscure our view of evolution of identified from the first instars right up to the adult
the various groups (see Lagerstätten). Furthermore, forms. Unfortunately, for arthropods, moulting of the
there is a gradation of fidelity of preservation even old skin and the time taken to harden the new exo-
in these special examples. To this end, it is entirely skeleton leaves them vulnerable to predator attack or
possible to study the exquisite three-dimensional adverse environmental conditions. For this reason,
outer surfaces of Tertiary flies in amber (Figure 1) or many arthropods (both in aquatic and terrestrial en-
the internalized respiratory systems of Devonian vironments) seek out a ‘moulting refugia’ in which
arachnids. the process of ecdysis and subsequent hardening of
A consequence of the possession of a rigid exoskel- the new exoskeleton can take place in relative safety.
eton composed of cuticle is that, in order for the Where mortality occurs during this post-moult stage,
arthropod to increase in body size over time, the the cuticle of the arthropod fossil formed can display
rigid cuticle has to be shed or moulted and a new wrinkles, creases, or even tears in the structure.
cuticle grown below the surface to replace it. Arthro- The cuticle itself takes the form of hardened scler-
pods differ from many other animal groups in that ites, one per body segment. Dorsal sclerites are termed
they go through the process of ecdysis (literally shed- tergites, ventral sclerites are termed sternites. Where
ding the exoskeleton as a moult) in order to attain the tergites and sternites are fused together, they form
greater body size. Ecdysis is facilitated by the pres- a simple ring structure enclosing the arthropod soft
ence of sutures in the exoskeleton, lines of weakness tissues. Lying between these discrete segments are
which can be broken through so that the arthropod areas of connective and unmineralized cuticle. The
can struggle free of the old skin. The ontogeny of presence of this less robust construction material ex-
plains why, upon death, well-mineralized arthropods,
such as trilobites, can disarticulate to a greater or
lesser degree into their constituent parts (cephalon,
thorax, thoracic segments, pygidium, etc.). The leg
appendages in arthropods are similarly constructed
with cylindrical reinforced cuticular podomeres with
intervening, less well-sclerotized arthrodial mem-
branes connecting them. Muscle attachments re-
quired to move the individual leg podomeres are
attached to small boss-like projections from the inside
of the exoskeleton, called apodemes.
The cuticle of arthropods explains in part their
success in the colonization of such a wide variety
of different environments with widely varying chal-
lenges. The cuticle provides a physical barrier between
the internal organs and the external environment
(which helps to reduce desiccation through water
loss in terrestrial forms) and a chemical barrier in
aquatic conditions (where hypo- or hypersalinity
could upset the osmotic balance, leading to dehydra-
tion of the organism and ultimately death). As well as
a physical barrier, waxes produced by the cuticle layer
help to waterproof this material. Some other more
unusual properties of arthropod cuticle have been
identified recently, including the fluorescence under
ultraviolet (UV) light of ‘hyaline’ cuticle within the
exoskeleton of scorpions. It happens that this ‘hyaline’
layer is actually very resistant to bacterial degrad-
ation and is therefore often the main remaining con-
stituent material of fossil scorpions. For example,
the Early Carboniferous East Kirkton biota of West
Figure 1 A fungus gnat preserved in Baltic amber from
the Upper Oligocene–Lower Eocene of Palanga, Lithuania Lothian, Scotland, contained a number of different
(55). ß The Trustees of the National Museums of Scotland, scorpion taxa which were recovered by hydrofluoric
Edinburgh, UK (NMS G.2002.6.17). acid maceration of the enclosing limestone matrix.
276 FOSSIL INVERTEBRATES/Arthropods
The level of morphological detail made available conventional higher taxon groupings can be identified.
through this technique was as good as studying extant Some examples include:
species.
. Atelocerata (Diplopoda, Chilopoda, Pauropoda,
Symphyla, Hexapoda);
Classification Schemes . Arachnomorpha/Arachnata (Trilobites, Chelicerates,
Trilobitomorpha).
There still remains scope for significant disagreement
in the higher level taxonomy of this group of animals. Arachnomorpha is a clade which basically consists
Historically, the main dichotomy relates to whether of all taxa more closely related to Chelicerates than
the phylum Arthropoda is a monophyletic or poly- crustaceans. Panarthropoda is again a clade, but
phyletic group of organisms. Some variation occurs in this time containing all true arthropods and their
the higher level classification of this group, with some soft-bodied relatives, such as onychophorans and
authors recognizing Arthropoda at phylum level and tardigrades.
the constituent members variously as subphyla or To this end, the term ‘arthropod’ should probably
orders. A monophyletic grouping for the arthropods be used to represent a grade of organization in which
would imply that all of the lower level groupings a soft-bodied ancestor (presumably a segmented
originated from a single common ancestor. This was worm) developed a toughened cuticle. Gene sequen-
the largely historic viewpoint based on the striking cing and molecular markers may provide fascinating
common appearance of the various groups. In order new insights into the interrelationships of the various
to counter what seems to be the logical conclusion high-level arthropod groups.
based on many shared characters in common, the
argument for polyphyly has to promote plausible
What the Fossil Record Says
explanations for the observed similarities between
groups as well as providing proof of separate points Tracing arthropods back through geological time in-
of origin. The fossil record may provide just such dicates that the divisions between the major groups
evidence, allowing the evolution of the various extend almost as far back as the fossil record of
arthropods to be considered with the benefit of deep Metazoa. Convergence of form and channelling by
time hindsight. However, since the work of Sidnie functional morphology of multiple arthropodization
Manton, who suggested that three major groups, the events through forming a rigid cuticle could have led
Crustacea, the Chelicerata, and the Uniramia, would to polyphyly; however, the more complete our record
more comfortably be accommodated as phyla of their of the group becomes, the less likely this seems.
own, the consensus view has swung back to the like-
lihood of the monophyletic status of the group being
the correct conclusion. This has been due in part to
A Brief History
the advent of molecular sequencing techniques. Novel The first arthropods appear in the fossil record of life
(non-morphological) hypotheses linking crustaceans on Earth in the Lower Cambrian some 540 Ma. The
and hexapods were primarily based on the analysis of arthropod faunas of the Chengjiang biota of China
single or a handful of genes. However, as the science demonstrate that, even at this early stage, a diverse
advances and the techniques of extraction improve, range of arthropod body plans had evolved. By
the case for monophyly appears to be more solid. Middle Cambrian times, rapid and explosive radi-
Indeed, one study not only supports the crustacean– ation and evolution of arthropods led to the devel-
hexapod clade, but also recognizes pycnogonids as opment of many different body plans, including
the sister group to other euarthropods. The historical the majority of those still extant. This ‘Cambrian
convention has been to subdivide the Arthropoda into Explosion’ in the number and diversity of arthropo-
the following equal-biased groupings: dan groundplans was one of the first major radiations
of the group and took place in the marine envir-
. Trilobita (containing all trilobites, but excluding
onment. By the Upper Cambrian, trilobites had di-
naroiid arthropods);
versified markedly and this carried through into
. Chelicerata (Arachnida, Scorpionida, Xiphosura,
Ordovician times.
Eurypterida, Chasmataspida);
Mid-Silurian and Lower Devonian rocks yield
. Crustacea;
evidence of the next major step in the evolution of
. Uniramia (including both insects and myriapods).
the arthropods: the colonization of the terrestrial
However, as more and more examples of basal environment, a process termed terrestrialization. Dif-
arthropods and ‘oddball’ taxa are discovered, primar- ferent terrestrial arthropod groups probably took
ily from Fossil Konservat-Lagerstätten, other less different terrestrialization pathways. Although this
FOSSIL INVERTEBRATES/Arthropods 277
is difficult to determine from the fossil forms, extant within the Crustacea continues to the present day,
members of the ancient lineages can lend clues with arthropods still developing new and successive
as to what these pathways might have been. For waves of colonization, particularly in terms of the
example, osmotic concentrations of body fluids in terrestrialization of some decapod crustaceans, such
myriapods suggest that this group terrestrialized as the land crabs.
straight from the sea without an intermediate step in
freshwater.
Respiration
One particular locality which has yielded a dispro-
portionately large amount of data on early terres- From the same basic body plans, different solutions to
trial ecosystems is the Devonian Rhynie Chert the challenges of respiration in aquatic and terrestrial
Lagerstätte in Aberdeenshire, Scotland. Here, the environments have evolved. In the smallest of micro-
silica-mineralizing action of hot spring and geyser arthropods, cutaneous respiration, by which the skin
fluids captured, in three-dimensional detail, early acts as a gas exchange surface, takes place. The ratio
terrestrial arthropods, such as arachnids, insects, of surface area to internal volume limits the max-
and centipedes, as well as aquatic forms, such as imum size of arthropod which can utilise this method.
freshwater crustaceans and euthycarcinoids. The re- In larger aquatic arthropods, respiratory gas ex-
markable morphological stasis in early terrestrial change is through structures termed ‘book gills’.
arthropods, in relation to extant forms, suggests that These thin lamellate cuticular structures are bathed
arthropod-dominated terrestrial ecosystems stabil- in oxygen-containing water, either wholly external to
ized early on in the Earth’s history and that soil and the body, as in the gill branches of trilobites, or in a
litter habitats and inhabitants have changed very little specialized cavity, as in the horseshoe crabs (Figure 2).
ever since. Terrestrial arthropods show adaptation to the par-
One of the novel innovations of arthropods was ticular challenges of living in an environment in
the evolution of muscle-powered flight in the insects which the constant danger of desiccation means that
(see Fossil Invertebrates: Insects). The earliest insects
or apterygotes (insects without wings) first appear in
sediments of Devonian age in the form of collembo-
lans and thysanurans. In earliest Carboniferous times,
the major expansion and evolution of land-based
flora provided new ecological niches available to
this highly adaptable group. The advent of insects
and the development of flight led to the colonization
of an entirely new ecospace. Interestingly, the earliest
non-scorpion arachnids appear to have relied solely
on poisoned fangs to capture and subdue prey items.
Orb web-weaving using spider silk could only have
developed in response to the presence of aerial insects.
By Lower Carboniferous times, the first winged
insects had developed and an explosion in the diver-
sity of insects occurred due to coal swamp forest
ecosystems. Preservation and discovery are aided by
the presence of siderite concretions in the roof shales
to many coal seams which, in turn, are commercially
exploitable. During the Middle Carboniferous, in-
sects became diverse and widespread for the first
time in their fossil record. This trend continued
through the Carboniferous and into the Permian
period, whereupon an explosion in the total diversity
of fossil insects took place. The depositional environ-
ments in which these fossils are found do not differ
significantly, suggesting a real increase in diversity.
During the Jurassic and Cretaceous, favourable shal-
Figure 2 The xiphosuran, Rolfeia sp., from the Lower
low (epieric) sea conditions saw the emergence and Carboniferous of Mumbie Quarry, Glencartholm, Dumfries and
dominance of decapod crustaceans as a major player Galloway, Scotland (1.1). ß The Trustees of the National
in nearshore marine ecosystems. This development Museums of Scotland, Edinburgh, UK (NMS G.1998.35.3).
278 FOSSIL INVERTEBRATES/Arthropods
book gills would cease to function. In terrestrial as the Rhynie Chert opilionids, in which penis and
arthropods, respiration is via book lungs (analogous ovipositor structures are known in separate specimens,
and probably derived in part from book gills) or by a demonstrates morphological conservatism.
tracheal system. The lamellate structure of book Direct morphological evidence of sexual di-
lungs requires additional supporting struts so that morphism, or reproductive structures, has long been
they do not collapse in air. Furthermore, the book identified in the chelicerate arthropod group, the
lungs tend to be positioned internally within the eurypterids. In these arthropods, Type A and Type B
body of the animal as a means of further reducing appendages have been identified on the ventral sur-
water loss through desiccation. The tracheal system faces. A recent study went further and demonstrated
is a passive method of diffusing oxygen into the body that the longer Type A appendage was probably
of the arthropod via a branching system of tubes female, whilst the Type B appendage belonged to the
opening on the surface of the exoskeleton at a tra- male. An elaborate system of flexure along predefined
cheole. The insects show the greatest development of sutures in the cuticle allowed the female to retrieve an
the tracheal system, related no doubt to the oxygen unstalked spermatophore from the substrate prior to
demands of muscle-powered flight. Other unira- storage in the spermathecae.
mians, such as millipedes, also respire in a similar
manner through the presence of a series of paired
spiracles along the length of the body. The earliest
Feeding
example of this form of respiration is recorded in An effective demonstration of how the understanding
the mid-Silurian millipede, Pneumodesmus newmani, of the form and feeding function of extant arthropods
from Stonehaven, Scotland. could be ‘reverse engineered’ to understand those of
The diffusive process involved in tracheal respir- the fossil forms was provided by one particular
ation places an upper limit on the maximum size of example: the Lipostracan crustacean, Lepidocaris,
terrestrial arthropods which utilize this method, known from three-dimensional fossils in the Early
unless a means of secondary ‘pumping’ derived from Devonian Rhynie Chert.
muscle contraction can improve efficiency. Book The most recent synthesis of feeding in trilobites
gills, on the other hand, operate in water and are (see Fossil Invertebrates: Trilobites) suggested that, as
not subject to the same constraints on size which are a group, the various trilobites employed different
faced by a land-based book lung system. In some strategies. Indeed, it was argued that much of the
respects, this may help to explain why the largest variety of form seen in the exoskeletal structure of
arthropod fossils found are those of aquatic organ- trilobites was probably driven in response to specific
isms, such as the extinct eurypterids. Indeed, some feeding modes (Figure 3). In the main, the structures
very active arachnids, such as solfugids (camel spi- most responsive to this driving factor were the cepha-
ders), possess both book lung and tracheal systems, lon (or head region) and the hypostome, a small plate
allowing them to meet the oxygen demands of their lying anterior to the mouth cavity and variously free
highly active and voracious life style. The antiquity or fixed depending on the feeding strategy. The primi-
of the development of tracheal respiratory systems tive mode of feeding in trilobites was identified as
in terrestrial arthropods stretches back as far as predatory or scavenging, with cephalon and accom-
the earliest opilionid (harvestman spider) found in panying hypostome morphology (coupled with over-
the Early Devonian Rhynie Chert, Aberdeenshire, all body shape) used as a guide to indicate possible
Scotland. feeding strategies within different trilobite groups.
However, this may even be a relict from the
arthropods ancestral to the trilobites.
Reproduction On the other hand, detritivorous trilobites pos-
Aquatic and terrestrial environments present differ- sessed a hypostome detached from the doublure of
ent challenges to reproductive strategies in arthro- the cephalon. The glabella (the axially aligned raised
pods. Terrestrial arachnids tackled the problem of area atop the cephalon), where the stomach was
the desiccation of reproductive material by producing thought to reside, would be relatively small in these
a spermatophore, which is either passed from male to forms, reflecting the small quantities of food pro-
female using specially adapted leg appendages or cessed at any one time. Filter-feeding trilobites exhibit
pedipalps (spiders), or left on the ground attached to a different overall morphology again, and often pos-
a stalk (scorpions). sess a highly vaulted cephalon which would have
Internal fertilization is practised by a few groups, allowed the leg appendages to stir into suspension
including the opilionids (harvestman spiders), and the food-bearing sediment particles. The demonstration
preservation of internalized organs in arachnids, such of an elegant scheme such as this in a reasonably
FOSSIL INVERTEBRATES/Arthropods 279
Visual Systems
Two main types of eyes are recognized in the arthro-
pods: compound (multifaceted) and simple ocellar
eyes (Figure 4). Compound eyes probably developed
separately in a number of different arthropod groups,
giving rise to analogous if not homologous structure.
Many arthropods possess both compound and simple
eyes, as demonstrated by the extant chelicerate horse-
shoe crab, Limulus. The ocellar eyes are positioned
on the top of the dorsal surface of the carapace and
are primarily used to detect light levels, indicating
Figure 3 The trilobite, Phacops sp., from the Devonian of Mo-
whether or not the top of the carapace is covered
rocco, North Africa (1.7). ß The Trustees of the National by sand; this information is of particular use to
Museums of Scotland, Edinburgh, UK (NMS G.1987.20.4). burrowing arthropods. The compound eyes of trilo-
bites are further subdivided into holochroal and schi-
zochroal forms, with the schizochroal structure
well-known fossil group should be applied to the developing as a result of paedomorphosis. Holo-
less well-known Palaeozoic arthropods. chroal trilobite eyes consist of many round or polyg-
onal lenses, the edges of which are all in contact and
covered by a single corneal membrane. Schizochroal
Relevance eyes are a unique system restricted to certain trilobite
Arthropod fossils are used by palaeontologists and groups (Phacopina). The lenses are large and separ-
geologists in a number of different ways for different ated from one another. Each separate lens has its own
reasons. In rocks of Palaeozoic age, the trilobites have separate corneal covering. Mounting the eye lens on
long been used as biostratigraphical marker fossils. upstanding and curved turrets may have allowed
They find application in this particular field of study certain trilobite species a full 360 field of vision.
as they are readily fossilized (carbonate-impregnated
exoskeleton), numerically abundant (each individual
moults many times over a lifetime, ‘amplifying’ their
Trace Fossils
number of potential fossils), and show sufficiently The combination of rigid appendages and the ability
rapid speciation events to make them useful as index to be motile in a wide range of ecological habitats has
fossils. In Early Palaeozoic rocks, nektonic species provided a rich and diverse trace fossil record which
are useful in palaeogeographical reconstructions of can be assigned to the activities of arthropods. Trace
former oceans, seas, and, by default, landmasses; the fossils can indicate the presence of arthropods in de-
nektonic life style has led to a widespread occurrence positional environments in which preservation would
of the resultant fossil remains, ideal for broad normally fail, and body fossils are non-existent.
stratigraphical correlations. Another use for the A good example of this is the Permian Coconino
numerically abundant trilobites in a stratigraphical Sandstone Formation of Arizona. Various studies of
framework is the evaluation of evolutionary rates the desert sandstones have revealed the presence of
within well-defined lineages. Such frameworks allow scorpion and tarantula trackways, the body fossils
trilobites to be utilized in studies of evolutionary of which are absent from these environments.
280 FOSSIL INVERTEBRATES/Arthropods
Figure 4 The enigmatic arthropod, Ainiktozoon loganense, from the Silurian Fossil Konservat-Lagerstatten of Lesmahagow, Lanark-
shire, Scotland (1.5). ß The Trustees of the National Museums of Scotland, Edinburgh, UK (NMS G.1996.40.1).
Distinctive trace fossils, such as Kouphichnium, and other plant and animal groups remains import-
can reveal the presence of xiphosuran arthropods ant. Arthropods were an important part of the food
(horseshoe crabs) and, by analogy with their extant chain in the past, just as they are today. Further
relatives, such as Limulus, can be used to imply near- advances in DNA sequencing and other types of mo-
shore or freshwater palaeoenvironments in otherwise lecular data will no doubt increase our knowledge of
sediments devoid of body fossils. Trace fossils, when the inter-relationships of this diverse and fascinating
found in conjunction with body fossil assemblages, group.
may allow behaviour to be interpreted, such as the
speed of movement or different actions (nesting, for-
aging, etc.). Of particular importance in the fossil
See Also
record of insects is the formation of leaf mines and Evolution. Fossil Invertebrates: Trilobites; Insects. La-
bite marks in accompanying floral assemblages, gerstätten. Microfossils: Ostracoda. Palaeoecology.
giving a clear indication of an escalating arms race Trace Fossils.
between plants and arthropods.
Further Reading
Final Remarks
Allen KC and Briggs DEG (1989) Evolution and the Fossil
In conclusion, the Arthropoda can be marked out as Record. London: Belhaven Press, Pinter Publishers.
one of the most important groups of organisms on the Benton MJ (ed.) (1993) The Fossil Record 2. London:
Earth. Their fossil record spans from the earliest Chapman and Hall.
recognizable invertebrate faunas right up until the Braddy SJ and Dunlop JA (1997) The functional
present day. Their numerical abundance, both in the morphology of mating in the Silurian eurypterid,
present and in the past, positions them as the major Baltoeurypterus tetragonophthalmus (Fischer, 1839).
The Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 121:
players in ecological structure: predators and prey in
435–461.
all three major Earth environments (land, sea, and Briggs DEG and Crowther PR (eds.) (1990) Palaeobiology:
air). The group provides excellent opportunities to A Synthesis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
investigate the effects of extinction events, adap- Edgecombe DG, Wilson GDF, Colgan DJ, Gray MR, and
tive radiation, macro- and micro-evolution, and the Cassis G (2000) Arthropod Cladistics: combined analysis
consequences of palaeobiology in extinct groups. of histone H3 and u2 snRNA sequences and morphology.
Understanding the relationships between arthropods Cladistics 16: 155–203.
FOSSIL INVERTEBRATES/Trilobites 281
Fortey RA and Owens RM (1999) Feeding habits in trilo- Rasnitsyn AP and Quicke DLJ (2002) History of Insects.
bites. Palaeontology 43: 429–465. Dordrecht, Boston, London: Kluwer Academic
Fryer G (1985) Structure and habits of living branchiopod Publishers.
crustaceans and their bearing on the interpretation Willmer P (1993) Invertebrate Relationships: Patterns in
of fossil forms. Transactions of the Royal Society of Animal Evolution. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Edinburgh: Earth Sciences 76: 103–113. Press.
Trilobites
A W A Rushton, The Natural History Museum, that more than 5000 genera have now been de-
London, UK scribed and a huge number of species named, perhaps
Copyright 2005, Natural History Museum. All Rights Reserved. approaching 20 000.