Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GH ES
HI E A
R
C
H
FO
June 2008 Issue…
R
1 Torsional Vibration of Turbine
TH
Generator by Variable Speed Drives
E REAL WOR
4 Fast Front Grid Substation
Insulation Coordination Studies
7 Inter-connected Offshore
Power System Energization Studies
10 Comparison of PSCAD®/EMTDC™ and
June 2008 RTDS-based Simulations of Pitch Controlled
Wind Power Generation System
LD
13 Magnetic Radiation of
Low Frequency Installations
15 Research – A Business Necessity
16 PSCAD® 2008 Training Sessions
For studies investigating torsional vibration The six phase WFSM was implemented in PSCAD®
of turbine generators, a time-domain PSCAD®/ with two three-phase voltage sources and two two-
EMTDC™ analysis provides important informa- winding transformers. Each fictitious three-phase
tion on the magnitude and damping of oscil- synchronous motor of the actual six-phase synchro-
lations, as well as the existence of torsional nous motor was represented by its Thevenin equiva-
resonance at frequencies traditionally calcu- lent circuit, using sub-transient impedances. Two
lated using a frequency domain or eigenvalue identical three-phase, zero-impedance, two-winding
analysis. Mott MacDonald has used PSCAD®/ transformers were used to achieve the desired 30°
EMTDC™ to perform a number of such studies. The phase shift between the two winding groups.
work presented here discusses the potential of the
inter-harmonic currents produced by variable speed (ii) A twelve pulse LCI drive comprising four, six-
Load Commutated Inverter (LCI) drives to excite pulse thyristor bridges, was implemented using the
a torsional resonance mode of the gas and steam PSCAD® six pulse bridge model. The control inputs
turbine generators in a combined cycle power plant to both the rectifier and inverter are their firing
typically used in remote gas compression facilities. delay angles relative to their respective transformer
HV AC busbars. By varying these firing angles, the
Building the Model Inter-harmonic torsional power factor at the rectifier and inverter and DC
studies require modelling various elements of the power transfer can be adjusted. Different DC link
system. For the studies described here, the major inter-harmonic options can be investigated.
modelling efforts were devoted to the variable
speed LCI drives, and the gas and steam turbine (iii) A four winding input transformer, represented
generators and their torsional characteristics. using a standard built-in PSCAD® model. The fourth
Other components, such as interconnecting cables winding was connected to a harmonic filter unit com-
and transformers were modelled using standard prising a number of high-pass and single tuned filters.
components available in the PSCAD® master library.
To allow the PSCAD®/EMTDC™ study to be performed,
Variable Speed LCI Drives The purpose-built it is necessary to determine the steady-state operat-
model of the LCI drives implemented in PSCAD® ing conditions of the drive and program these into
consists of the following components: the model. The key parameter to be varied is the
power transferred across the DC link. In the model,
(i) A six-phase wound field synchronous motor the magnitude and frequency of the voltage source
(WFSM) which is used to provide the same harmonic representing the Thevenin equivalent circuit of the
performance as that of a twelve pulse inverter driven machine was varied so that a constant
driven motor.
V/f ratio was achieved. The firing angle of the inverter the other provides a lumped representation of the
was assumed to remain constant with changes in the turbine sections. It was observed that the mutual
drive output frequency and voltage, but the rectifier damping between the two masses is a key factor
firing angle was varied to adjust the DC-link power. which has to be determined accurately. The damping
data provided by manufacturer was provided in
Combined Cycle Power Plant The electrical charac- a form that was not suitable as direct input to the
teristics of the gas and steam synchronous generators spring-mass model in the PSCAD®. The data was
were represented using built-in synchronous machine therefore converted into mutual damping values
models. A dedicated model was developed in PSCAD® prior to use.
for a typical heavy-duty single-shaft gas turbine. The
governor maintains the generator speed after the Results The individual gas and steam turbine and
machine was released in the model and the torsional the LCI drive models were combined into a single
dynamics were enabled. Instability would have been integrated model. This was used to investigate
experienced if no generator controller was modelled. operating conditions at which there is a potential
No governor was assumed for the steam turbine as the of an LCI drive to excite a torsional resonance on
gas turbine provides the primary frequency control a gas or a steam turbine generator. As an example,
in the system. For the purposes of the steady-state two PSCAD® case studies comprising a single gas tur-
inter-harmonic studies, the excitation system of the bine-generator connected to a single LCI drive via the
gas and steam turbine generators were omitted. generator and drive transformers are discussed here
and the results are shown in Figure 2 and Figure 3.
Torsional characteristics of the turbogenerators were
represented using a built-in PSCAD® multi-mass model. The critical drive output frequencies associated with
The original higher order torsional models provided by the inter-harmonic components that can develop
manufacturers were simplified into a two mass model. an air gap electromagnetic torque at first (most
One is associated with the synchronous generator and dominant) mechanical torsional resonance frequency
3 Phas e 3 Phas e
RMS R MS V9_pu
+ +
Idc1
Ldc R _dc
Com . Com .
Bus Bus
AM AM
P = 32.16 P = 31.87 P = 31 .87
Harm onicFil ter GM GM 90 [MVA]
Q = 27.66 Q = -16.38 Q = -1 7.21
7.5 [k V] / 7.5 [kV]
GAMMA_I +
1.0E6 [ohm]
A Vdc3 A #2 #1 A
ALPHA_RR ALPHA_II Vs rc1 3 Phas e
V Vd c1 V V L_S2
AO AO RMS
1.0E6 [ohm]
Vs rc1_p u
0.00179 [ohm]
Ph
POC KB KB
6 Pul s e 6 Puls e Ph_s 2
1.0E 6 [ohm ] Bridge Bridge
#4 ENAB_R ENAB_I
F
1.0E6 [ohm ]
Itr_HV f_s 2_op
#3 #1
V
#2 Idc2 V_s 21
Com . Com .
Bus Bus
1.0E6 [ohm ]P = 32.48 AM AM
P = 31.67 P = 31 .68
Q = 26.71 GM GM Q = -16.22 90 [MVA] Q = -1 7.05
7.5 [k V] / 7.5 [kV]
+
A A #2 #1 A
ALPHA_RR ALPHA_II 3 Phas e
V Vd c2 Vdc4 V V L_S2
AO AO RMS
1.0E6 [ohm]
KB KB
6 Pul s e 6 Puls e Ph_s 2
Bridge Bri dge
ENAB_R ENAB_I
F
f_s 2_op
V
V_s 21
PMR_A : Controls
Pdc(MW) REC_DPF INV_DPF Vdc1_M Vdc3_M INV_GAMMA V132_pu
Figure 1 PSCAD® circuit diagram for the drive system (the LCI drive, four winding transformer,
harmonic filter and six-phase motor) used for the inter-harmonic torsional study.
of a GTG were determined using frequency domain The magnitude of the electromagnetic torque at
techniques. In the simulation Case01, the drive the torsional frequency is significantly higher than
output speed was set to 86% of rated speed which that tolerable by the GTG.
corresponds to a critical operating condition.
The studies were repeated with the drive output
speed being reduced by 0.5 Hz (Case02). In this
case, the DC-link power and the turbine mechanical
power were maintained practically the same as
Case01. Both the shaft torque and DFT analysis of
the electromagnetic torque signal indicate that the
torsional activities reduces dramatically compared
to Case01 and no torsional excitation occurs in this
case. Comparing Figure 2 and Figure 3, it is clear
that a small change in the drive output frequency is
very effective in significantly reducing the level of
torsional twisting torque experienced on the shaft.
Figure 3 Shaft torque between the gas turbine and generator - Case02. PSCAD®/EMTDC™ has been proved to be a very
effective tool in assessing the critical drive output
Once the multi-mass model is enabled at t=3 sec, the speeds and determining amplitude of torsional
excitation of the GTG first torsional mode starts to oscillations at the design stage of such projects.
build up. This is shown in Figure 2 which illustrates
the shaft torque between the turbine and generator. Babak.Badrzadeh@mottmac.com
Kenneth.Smith@mottmac.com
The magnitude of the electromagnetic torque induced Roddy.Wilson@mottmac.com
by inter-harmonics at torsional resonance frequency
was then determined using a Discrete Fourier
Transform (DFT) of the time domain torque signal.
JUNE 2008 3
Fast Front Grid Substation
Insulation Coordination Studies
Dr. Colin Foote, Dr. Kenneth Smith, and Mr. Roddy Wilson
Mott MacDonald – Transmission & Distribution Division
For fast front studies, such as predicting the The lines between each tower are represented as
transient performance of transmission lines separate travelling wave models using the PSCAD®
under lightning impulse conditions, a time frequency dependent (phase) travelling wave model.
domain calculation using an electromagnetic The overhead earth/shielding wire is included in the
transient analysis program is required. model and retained as a conductor.
PSCAD®/EMTDC™ provides all the tools necessary
to develop and complete a detailed fast front insula- Substation Bus Work Air insulated substation bus
tion coordination study. Mott MacDonald has used work is represented by a Bergeron line model for
the software to perform a number of such studies, each section between junctions and terminations.
including assessing the need for surge arresters on Shunt capacitances, including those associated with
a 400/132 kV autotransformer and its associated instrument transformers, circuit breakers and discon-
132 kV cable as described here. nectors, are neglected to give a more conservative
assessment of surge current and voltage.
Building the Model Undertaking fast front insula-
tion coordination studies requires modelling various
elements of the system. For the studies described
here, the model included the 400 kV overhead line,
air-insulated bus work in the substation, the 400/132 kV
transformer and its cable, and surge arrestors.
JUNE 2008 5
With a lower lightning current, it takes longer for Conclusions PSCAD®/EMTDC™ has been used by
breakdown to occur. The BIL of the transformer HV Mott MacDonald to assess transient overvoltages
terminals is 1425 kVp. The studies show that lightning due to lightning strikes. The ability of the surge
currents with a peak magnitude above 140 kA may arrestors to absorb energy from the lightning
result in transient overvoltages that exceed this limit. impulses was also assessed.
The studies found that the voltages at 132 kV remain The studies found that surge arrestors are not
well within the BIL of the transformer LV terminals required at 132 kV, resulting in cost savings and design
(550 kVp) and the 132 kV cable (650 kVp). Figure 3 simplification. However, the results reveal possible
shows the three phase voltages at the open end transient overvoltages at the 400 kV terminals that
of the 132 kV cable for a 150 kAp lightning strike exceed the BIL of the autotransformer HV terminals.
to the earth wire. The energy absorbed by the surge The studies are based on worst-case conditions that
arrestor varies considerably for lightning strikes of provide a conservative assessment but have a low
different magnitude, as shown in the plot in Figure 4. probability of occurring. Furthermore, the lightning
The energy levels are well within the capability of strike must have a peak magnitude above 140 kA
the 400 kV surge arrestor (3696.6 kJ). to cause voltages in excess of the transformer BIL and
lightning data suggests that only a very small fraction
of lightning strikes are of this magnitude.
Colin.Foote@mottmac.com
Kenneth.Smith@mottmac.com
Roddy.Wilson@mottmac.com
JUNE 2008 7
Harmonic Analysis of Transformer Inrush Current Figure 3 shows the initial 11 kV system voltage
Due to the non-symmetrical waveshape, the trans- waveshape after switching in the 4.5 MVA transformer
former inrush current contains all harmonic compo- at the offshore platform for least favourable point
nents, i.e. fundamental, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, etc., as on wave switching against one GTG. The system is un-
well as a DC (zero frequency) component. As an exam- loaded and the transformer initially had 80% residual
ple, using the transformer modelling methodology flux linkage. High levels of distortion are present on
described above, the peak inrush current waveform the 11 kV voltage waveshape. The harmonic voltage
experienced when energizing a 4.5 MVA, 6/0.72 kV, components present in the 11 kV voltage waveform
Z=7.0%, 50 Hz, Dy11 transformer against an ideal were calculated using a travelling sample window
zero impedance source was obtained using PSCAD®. DFT. During the inrush transient, the largest voltage
The harmonic content of the phase A transient inrush components are at the 5th and 6th harmonics of the
current was calculated using a Discrete Fourier Trans- supply frequency.
form (DFT) with a moving window and is presented
in Figure 2. In this case, the 2nd harmonic is by far
the dominant one. The harmonic components decay
as the inrush transient decays towards the normal
steady state operating conditions.
Figure 4 produced using the PSCAD®/EMTDC™ Conclusions PSCAD®/EMTDC™ has been used
impedance/frequency scanning tool shows that as by Mott MacDonald to assess harmonic overvoltages
more generators come online, the system resonant due to transformer energization in an offshore inter-
frequency is increased. Therefore, increased genera- connected system. Studies of this type can be used
tion can be beneficial in reducing the sustained to recommend the generation and load line-up
overvoltages when one of the harmonic current required to ensure that both the voltage dip and
components in the inrush current coincides with harmonic overvoltages are within acceptable limits.
the system resonant frequency. As the system load
increases, the magnitude of the impedance peaks PSCAD®/EMTDC™ provides the tools necessary to
will tend to decrease. Therefore, additional load is perform this type of analysis and helps to identify
also beneficial in reducing harmonic overvoltages. possible problems and investigate practical
engineering solutions.
Ryan.Turner@mottmac.com
Kenneth.Smith@mottmac.com
Roddy.Wilson@mottmac.com
JUNE 2008 9
Comparison of PSCAD®/EMTDC™ & RTDS-based
Simulations of a Pitch Controlled Wind Power
Generation System
Dae-Jin Park, Young-Ju Kim, Hyo-Ryong Seo, Minwon Park, In-Keun Yu, Changwon National University, Korea
Mohd Hasan Ali, Ryerson University, Canada
10 P U L S E T H E M A N I T O B A H V D C R E S E A R C H C E N T R E J O U R N A L
Wind Turbine Pitch Control System Figure 4(a) RTDS EMTDC™
shows the measured real wind velocity data obtained
Simulation Time Step 54 ÜS 50 ÜS
from an anemometer. Figure 4(b) depicts the variation
of the pitch angle corresponding to various real wind Squirrel Cage Induction
Type
velocities. The pitch control system is operated for Generator (3 MW)
Generator
keeping the constant generator output power when
Rated RMS
the wind velocity exceeded the rated value. 0.3983 kV
Phase Voltage
Grid
squirrel cage induction generator speed kept constant 22.9 kV / 0.33 kV
even under changing wind velocity.
Line Impedance 0.02 + j0.1p.u
JUNE 2008 11
Comparison of results between RTDS
and EMTDC™ Figure 6 shows the simulation
results of WPGS using RTDS and EMTDC™. The Case5
of real wind speed patterns is used for this simulation.
As shown in the figures, the results are very similar
for both cases.
Figure 6 Simulation results of WPGS (a) RTDS results (b) EMTDC™ results.
This article is a summary of presentations ([1] Exposure limit values for the frequency
ranges of selected installations:
and [2]) of Daho Taghezout (Applied Magnetics,
Switzerland), Nadia Nibbio and Philippe Chollet Installation Exposure limit value
(Romande Energie, Switzerland). For complete Railways 16 2/3 Hz 300 µT; 10 000 V/m
presentations, email: software@cedrat.com High-voltage power lines 50 Hz 100 µT; 5 000 V/m
Radio broadcasting
FLUX is a finite element software application used transmitters 10-400 MHz 28 V/m
for electromagnetic and thermal simulation, both in Mobile telephone 900 MHz 41 V/m
2D and 3D. It can handle the design and analysis of Base stations 1800 MHz 58 V/m
any electromagnetic device. Based on 30 years of UMTS base stations 2100 MHz 61 V/m
experience, FLUX is reliable and accurate, featuring
a large number of functionalities: multi-parametric Installation limit values within the frequency
ranges of selected installations:
analysis, extended import capabilities (STEP, IGES...),
Installation Installation limit value
and mixed meshed generation [3]. FLUX is developed
Railways 1 µT (24 hr mean)
by CEDRAT Group in France. The Manitoba HVDC
Research Centre has been in partnership with CEDRAT High-voltage power lines 1 µT
JUNE 2008 13
The distribution of the field on the ground level can Improvements and new measurements
then be evaluated as in Figure 3. A MV-LV distribution From these simulations, improvements have been
station is essentially made of three radiating parts: proposed, such as reducing the current per cable
transformers, cables and a switchboard. All parts have (parallel power transmission), increasing the space
been modelled and their influence has been evaluated between source and influence zone, reducing space
in the field generation. We can see in Figure 4 that between phases and phase-neutral line, avoiding long
the 1 µT limit is at 12 m above the station ground level. cable connections, magnetic shielding of distribution
Figure 5 also shows the magnetic field on walls of boards, etc. Some have been carried out to follow
the station: it is indeed higher than 1 µT. the Swiss regulations as can be seen in Figure 6.
References
[1] “Magnetic radiation of lf installations”, Daho Taghezout, Nadia
Nibbio; presentation at FLUX Users Conference 2004, Grenoble, France
Figure 5 Magnetic field on walls of station. [2] “Magnetic field radiated by low voltage electrical equipments”,
Philippe Chollet, Nadia Nibbio; presentation at FLUX Users Conference
2007, Lyon, France
[3] More information about FLUX at http://www.cedrat-groupe.com/
or software@cedrat.com
14 PULSE THE MANITOBA HVDC RESEARCH CENTRE JOURNAL JUNE 2008 14
PUBLICATION AGREEMENT # 41197007
RETURN UNDELIVERABLE CANADIAN ADDRESSES TO
MANITOBA HVDC RESEARCH CENTRE INC.
244 CREE CRESCENT
WINNIPEG MB R3J 3W1 CANADA
The Manitoba HVDC Research Centre has been The U of M has a strong postgraduate program
active in research since its founding in 1981. in the Faculty of Engineering and this has had a
Many notable developments have occurred positive impact on the undergraduate program.
including the creation of the world’s first real Growing interest in power systems has resulted in
time digital simulator and the popular PSCAD®/ one third of students now taking a Power Systems
EMTDC™ Power System Simulation Software. elective, and 25% of final year projects are in the
The organization has been devoted to excellence power area [1].
in simulation and now these tools help to facilitate
continued innovation in power systems and simulation. Power systems are inherently complex; utilizing
Our close partnership with the University of Manitoba, many technologies for their operations. The science
Power Systems group remains a key strategic advantage of modelling various devices in a simulation program is
for us. equally complex requiring fundamental understanding
of the physics of each device, advanced mathematics
Our relationship with the U of M is a definite and computer science skills. You also require the
win-win with benefits on several fronts: knowledge of how to model large and complex
• Students work on projects of value to industry systems, as well as, the knowledge and experience
and at the same time obtain their degrees, of how electrical utility business operates in the
• Researchers perform work that is relevant to energy market.
industry and challenging in the academic world,
• Researchers become an extension of our own The market for simulation tools is relatively small
research team providing new ideas and exceptional when compared to the gaming or communications
skilled labour which complements and expands industry, thus the investment in these tools is low.
knowledge base, This market reality forces us to find novel ways to
• Funding from government is leveraged with maintain competencies in the required areas. Jointly
contributions from industry, undertaking these complex problems challenges
• Results are published and peer reviewed, our staff and provides a rich environment to grow
providing a mechanism to ensure excellence, professionally. The relationship with the University
and foster technology and brand recognition of Manitoba is one based on trust and has become
through media that is widely read and respected. a business necessity for our organization. Without
this relationship, PSCAD®/EMTDC™ would not be the
The need for new advanced research in Power System program it is today.
Simulation was identified as a priority by the various
stakeholders in Manitoba. To achieve this vision, References:
the sponsors applied for an Industrial Research [1] Innovative Strategies to Address Human Resource Demands for
Chair from the Canadian National Sciences and Graduate Engineers in the 21st Century Canadian Power Sector,
Engineering Research Council (NSERC). Industrial CIGRE Canada, 2007, Calgary.
Research Chairs are highly prestigious appointments
on a major research endeavour of interest to industry.
Collaboration between the Chairs' sponsors develops
new technologies that are fed back into commercial
offerings. In addition to new products, students and
researchers gain the knowledge and experience.
JUNE 2008 15
Lightning Coordination & Fast Front Studies
Substation modelling for a fast front study,
representing station equipment, stray capacitances,
relevant standards, transmission tower model for
flash-over studies, surge arrester representation
and data. Duration: 2 Days
Modelling and Application of FACTS Devices
Fundamentals of solid-state FACTS systems.
System modelling, control system modelling,
converter modelling, and system impact studies.
Duration: 2–3 Days
Expanding Knowledge
The following courses are available, as well
Connect with Us!
as custom training courses – please contact July 20–24, 2008
sales@pscad.com for more information. IEEE PES General Meeting
Pittsburgh, USA
Introduction to PSCAD® and Applications
Includes discussion of AC transients, fault and August 25 –29, 2008
protection, transformer saturation, wind energy, 42nd CIGRE 2008
FACTS, distributed generation, and power quality Technical Session and Exhibition
with practical examples. Duration: 3 Days Paris, France
please send us an email to info@hvdc.ca Articles and submissions addressing the use of PSCAD® in the real world are always welcome.
periodically, so please see www.pscad.com for
AC Switching Study Applications in PSCAD® more information about course availability.
Pulse is distributed free of charge and is posted electronically at www.hvdc.ca If you would like to receive a copy of Pulse,
Fundamentals of switching transients,
September 2008
modelling issues of power system equipment,
Introduction to PSCAD® and Applications
stray capacitances/inductances, surge arrester
energy requirements, batch mode processing October 2008
and relevant standards, direct conversion of Introduction to PSCAD® and Applications
PSS/E files to PSCAD®. Duration: 2–3 Days
November 2008
Distributed Generation & Power Quality HVDC Training Course
Includes wind energy system modelling, integration
All training courses mentioned above are held
to the grid, power quality issues, and other DG
at the Manitoba HVDC Research Centre Inc.
methods such as solar PV, small diesel plants,
Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
fuel cells. Duration: 3 Days
sales@pscad.com www.pscad.com ©2008 Manitoba HVDC Research Centre Inc. Printed in Canada