Professional Documents
Culture Documents
'Thinking strategies" in this study refers to any method of artistic skill. Participants in this study do not repre-
or technique that a child uses to solve or conceptualize sent outstanding examples of young choreographers or
solutions to problems. Overlaps or similarities between poets, but merely students who have engaged in this
the thinking skills apparent in the children's dance and activity. Most theoretical approaches to curriculum
poetry experiences were explored. design base their rationale on exceptional examples
The setting of the study was an artist in residence of the phenomenon. Howard Gardner, for example,
program. Entitled "Moving to Words," this three-day identifies a specific intelligence within the theory
dance and poetry residency has been part of the fifth of multiple intelligences in part by "the existence of
grade curriculum during National Poetry month at idiots savants, prodigies, and other exceptional indi-
Sol Feinstone Elementary School in Bucks County, viduals."^ Robert and Micbele Root-Bernstein, too,
Pennsylvania. This annual residency brings dance and base their articulation of thinking tools on the reports
poetry together through structured improvisation and of Nohel prize winners and the "century's greatest
group choreography This setting provided an oppor- minds."'" While the ends of the spectrum may serve
tunity to look at the ways in which 10- to 12-year-old to clarify the existence of a phenomenon, there is no
children think when creating dance and poetry. logical or empirical proof that people at either end of
While research in educational psychology has a spectrum are its best representatives. A prodigy's
mainly attempted to look at the effects of the arts on experiences may not accurately represent the mani-
learning from a quantitative viewpoint—attempting festation of that same skill in middle-range learners.
to link increased scholastic test scores with study Educators are designing the majority of curriculum
in the arts, as in Keinamen, Hetland, and Winner's for the middle of the learning spectrum, and research
extensive study^—tbis study was designed from is needed that focuses on these learners.
a qualitative viewpoint that seeks to illuminate
children's experiences of thinking in the arts. This Methodology
design in based on the idea that research should look Part I; Artist in Residence Ciasses
to children's creative experiences, not their testable In part one of the study, a three-day Artist-in-Resi-
products, as a starting point for evaluating the learn- dence program for the fifth grade at Sol Feinstone
ing that is going on. This study is also groimded in the Elementary School was conducted. The program,
belief that children can recall and reflect upon their entitled "Moving to Words," consisted of a series of
experiences with enough clarity to yield insight on a three dance classes. Approximately 25 students at-
particular phenomenon.' In terms of the study, this tended each of the classes, bringing the total number
suggests that children can recall the thinking pro- of participating students to about 100. There was a
cesses they employed during their lived experience of fairly even distribution of boys and girls in each class.
creating and that this recollection is a valid depiction Each 45-niinute class had four sections. While the
of their learning in dance and poetry. actual exercises differed in each of the three sessions,
The study design was also based on the researcher's the format was the same. In section one there was a
close observation of children's creative processes in circle warm-up, which introduced the idea that the
dance over the last 20 years. These observations give body is the expressive medium of the choreographer.
rise to the conviction that children are quite cogni- The warm up included simple rhythmic locomotor
tively active when they create and have the capacity movements aimed at increasing circulation and get-
to articulate these mental experiences if given the ting the students to focus on how various parts of the
opportunity. Children's accounts of their experiences body move. The second section of the class focused on
can inform our conceptualization of the educational stret<;hing. The need forflexibilityin dance was articu-
process. Indeed, including children's experiential self- lated as a way to enhance the movement vocabulary
reports in the research process serves to give agency of the dancer. The third section of the class involved
to the children for whom we are designing curricula. building large locomotor movement combinations
This research continues the tradition of Bond,^ Bond that travel through space. Sometimes referred to by
and Stinson,^ Purcell,'' and Stinson' in focusing on dance teachers as "across thefloorcombinations," the
students' voices in the research. As Green and Stinson students learned sequencing of movements in this
claim, this kind of research can "give a voice to the oth- portion of class. Directions for the movements used in
erwise silent participants in dance and allow those in building these combinations were open-ended so that
decision-making positions to understand more about students could interpret the instructions in a variety
what is happening for their students.. .and thus help of ways. For example, the students were invited to
them make more sensitive decisions.'"* melt for four counts and then roll for four counts in one
It is not only the child's voice that is key to this of the combinations. Since there is no clear expecta-
study; it is the voice of the average child; that is, one tion of how a person "melts," multiple interpretations
who does not exhibit exceptional presence or absence were encouraged and reinforced during the class. It
Journal of Dance Education Volume 6, Number 2 2006 43
was explained to the students that this divergence in language arts curriculum in celebration of National
responses is important in order to allow each of them Poetry Montb (April) concurrent with the Artist-in-
to find his or her own personal voice or style within Residence project. A variety of teaching methods were
the group. This divergence was fostered to reinforce used to elicit this poetry. Each of the four classroom
the concept that learning dance includes creativity in teachers used a slightly different technique. The cre-
addition to imitation. ation of poetry was not done with the researcher, nor
The fourth section of each class session involved were instructional methods or teaching vocabulary
creating group choreography based on a poem. A intentionally coordinated between the Artist-in-Resi-
different poem was used in each class, progressing dence project and the classroom poetry instruction.
from literal to abstract over the three class sessions. The interviews began in a group setting to put the stu-
The specific poems used were selected because they dents at ease. They outnumbered the researcher, cre-
contained images of particular interest to the age ating an atmosphere that focused on their voices and
group of the participants and were not otherwise being experiences. Because 15 students received permission
directly taught as part of the classroom poetry cur- to be interviewed, a larger group than had initially
riculum. Following a brief reading and discussion of been anticipated, two interview groups were formed,
the poem, students were guided through a structured one with seven students and one with eight students.
improvisation to the text. Improvisations became The coordinating teacher of the Artist-in-Residence
less prescribed with each progressive session as well. project randomly assigned students to groups. The
Choreography for session one, for example, was based discussion began with open-ended questions—What
on "We Real Cool" by Gwendolyn Brooks." The stu- is it like when you make up a poem? What are you
dents were asked to communicate the personality of thinking about when you write a poem?
the "cool" people the poem describes with their body While the initial study design was to separate the
postures as they entered. Later in the choreography children for individual interviews following a few
the students made six large sharp shapes with their minutes of group discussion to orient the students
bodies to coordinate with the moment in the poem to the phenomenon, this procedure was not followed.
when a gang fight is described. The movements The students were so comfortable speaking with one
that students were encouraged to create, while not another in a group that it would have been intrusive
prescriptive, were concrete. They had an obvious con- to end the conversation to begin individual interviews.
nection to the actions and intentions communicated In order to honor the researcher's role as listener in
by the poem. Session two involved choreographing the gathering of experiential data, the group format
"The Will of Writing" by James Schevill.'^ Students was allowed to continue. It was impressive to note
began the choreography in this activity with a move- how comfortable the students were in speaking to
ment phrase they created during the "across the one another while maintaining their own opinions.
floor" section of the class. It had no literal or gestural Students disagreed with one another without rancor,
connection to the words of the poem. During the third and seemed to be interested, even stimulated, by their
session, students created movements to "Dreams" by differing and overlapping experiences.
Langston Hughes,'' a poem with no narrative and a The second sot of interviews was based on the
more abstract, multi-layered message. Students were students' experiences in dance in the classes taught
encouraged to see from this process how dance can be during the Artist-in-Residence program. The students
more than simply acting out the literal meaning of the were interviewed to elicit experiential data on their
text, and how each individual dancer can contribute creative process in creating dances using the same
to the creative process. conversational format and interview groups as in the
first set of interviews. The questions for the second
Part II: Interviews interview followed the format of the first. The ques-
In part two of the study, participating students were tions began with:
interviewed twice; once about their experiences creat- What is it like when you make up a dance?
ing poetry and once about their experiences creating What are you thinking about when you choreo-
dances. Any student who participated in Artist-in- graph a dance?
Residence classes could choose to be interviewed. They What are you thinking about when you pick the
needed to get signed permission from their parents, movements you will do in the dance?
in accordance with Institutional Review Board guide-
lines in order to participate. Fifleen students volun- Findings
teered and received permission by the deadline. Part I: Graphic Depictions
The first set of interviews focused on children's The four interview sessions, or conversations, provided
experiences of creating poetry. The children had been a wealth of data. Before analyzing them, the conver-
actively creating poetry as a regular part of their sations were transcribed from audiotapes. Analysis
44 Journal of Dance Education Volume 6, Number 2 2006
began by looking for themes that emerged from the specifically for descriptions that showed how children
children's words. Because so many participants were decided on ways, or strategies, to communicate their
involved at once it was possible to look for patterns of ideas throughout the creative process.
meaning in theflowof the conversation. This is similar Rather than use labels unique to this study to
to the henneneutic phenomenological process of "poet- describe the strategies encountered, designations
izing," a process Max Van Manen characterizes as a previously articulated through educational psychol-
telling of the event that "harkens back to the silence ogy were used whenever possible. It was hoped that
from which the words emanate.''^^ Rather than creat- by using vocabulary from psychology at this point in
ing a verbal reduction of the experience, as Van Manen the analysis the study results could begin to intersect
does through poetizing, a graphic depiction was cre- with the literature read by curriculum specialists in
ated. These graphic depictions of the flow of themes the public education sector In particular, the Root-
and topics in the children's conversations helped to Bernsteins' work was used as a jumping of!' point
clarify when the discussion touched on the research because their theory articulates easily identifiable
topic of cognition. These depictions are referred to as whole brain thinking skills. Robert and Michele Root-
"maps" of the conversations for the purposes of this Bernstein have articulated 13 general-purpose "tools
study. Samples of these maps are provided in Fig- for thinking."'"' These "tools for thinking" are used in
ures 1 and 2. The first two conversations were about creative endeavors in the sciences, arts, humanities,
creating poetry; the second two were about dance and technologies. These 13 general purpose strategies
making. The participants involved in conversations include observing, imaging, abstracting, recognizing
one and three were the same children (group 1); the patterns, forming patterns, analogizing, body think-
participants in conversations two and four were the ing, empathizing, dimensional thinking, modeling,
same children (group 2). The words on the maps were playing, transforming, and synthesizing. It was rea-
taken directly from the children's interviews, with soned that if "tools for thinking" were present in both
the exceptions of words in all capitals. These words dance and language arts activities, then plausible
are topic headings or summarizing terms inserted by links between learning in the two areas could be
the researcher to make the charts succinct and read- surmised.
able. The arrows on the maps show a chronological
perspective for the conversation. The circular areas
represent the moments when the interviews touched Poetry Strategies: Tools for Thinking
on cognition, an intersection with the original research During the poetry interviews the children did, in fact,
question. These sections of the interviews are referred report using strategies that could be identified as
to as "key data." "tools for thinking," particularly empathizing, observ-
ing, recognizing patterns and forming patterns. One
While the major function of these maps became to child reported, "Sometimes I pick an idea, and then
identify which sections of the interview transcripts I like think of what it kind of goes through. I think if
were most relevant to the phenomenon under study, I was that thing, what would happen." This descrip-
these maps also allowed some observations to be made tion of imagining yourself as the object of study (in
about the interviews themselves. By looking at the this example the student was describing herself as
rectangular areas, those not related to the research imagining she were a clock, so that she could write
question, it can be noted that at least one theme in a poem about it) is an example of empathizing, one
each conversation related to catharsis or other issues tool described by the Root-Bemsteins. Another child
of emotional involvement in the creative process. A described this type of empathy as a deliberate day-
consciousness of audience or reader came up in every dreaming: "I daydream like I'm rescuing people from
conversation as well. Feeling and communication, it a burning building or other things like that. That gets
appears, were not sharply separated from thinking me started on stuff, too "
and problem solving for the children in the context
A different strategy is at play in the student who
of these conversations. While more about children,
reported: "Another thing I do is like I look at things
art, and pedagogy could perhaps be deduced from
in my room.. .One time I wrote about the sky because
these conversations, in order to give thoughtful con-
my room was all blue." It is possible to liken this
sideration to a manageable amount of data, further
experience to what the Root-Bemsteins refer to as
analysis was limited to the "key data."
observing as a technique for brainstorming. Students
Part II: Verbal Analysis observe their world and use what they see as topical
material. This was seen again in statements such as:
The second phase of analysis looked more closely at "Sometimes I write about, like, the smallest things
the "key data" for evidence of cognitive processes. As that people don't really notice."
noted earlier, this analysis utilized Gardner's defini- Several students (9 of the 15) also commented on
tion of cognition as thinking and reasoning in looking the need to follow form when writing poetry. These
Journal of Dance Education Volume 6, Number 2 2006 45
KirsI
Durins
cnNsri(>i'SNK,s.Si)f
Sii^iitc ii ptricirni:
^cl^ Viirk
CATHARSIS; tfltast
,.ni;ir,K.Ii.ull,rlinn.s
FRKEDON IN WRIIIM; /
CATHARSIS:
Figure 1 Map of Conversation 1. Poetry discussion with Figure 2 Map of Conversation 4. Dance discussion with
Group 1. Circular areas represent the moments when the Group 2. Circular areas represent the moments when the
conversation touched on cognitive processes, also referred conversation touched on cognitive processes, also referred
to as "key data." Rectan^lar areas represent other topics to as "key data."
of conversation. The arrows represent the chronological
flow of the conversation. Words in all capitals are the accounts of the children's dance experiences. One
researcher's language; all other text is the participating student explained that her ideas for dances come
children's language. from observing:
students found that they: "think about it beforehand, I turn the music on and I listen and I look around.
but I repeat the form... [I] repeat the type of poem," I look outside and I think like how I feel.
or again, "I read it and it had that rhythm...what I look at something.. .and 1 just make a dance out of
we were supposed to do on each line." This shows it. Like something on my shirt [has on a painted
the strategy of recognition of patterns. Students ar- shirt with a dragon and Japanese characters],
ticulated that the form or structure of a poem meant and I make up like a dragon dance.
fitting their ideas into a pattern of words. An empathetic strategy is evident in this student's
Additionally students explained that they altered report uf his or her creative process in dance:
the material to form new patterns with their words:
"I get ideas from people and like I switch it around. I You know those musicals where it's just all rain-
use some of their words, but I'll switch it around and forest and water? It's trickling. It's quiet music. I
use some of my words." usually just think for a while when it's happen-
The Root-Bemsteins identify this tool as forming ing.... So I dance like calm and steady in that
patterns, a correlate but separate strategy from pat- rainforest. I imagine myself in a rainforest.
tern recognition. A couple of children mentioned that As would be expected, there was evidence of body
creating forms and patterns was one of the enjoyable thinking in the children's dance experiences. One
parts of the poetry experience, for example, "The thing child reported: "When you make up a dance you are
I like about poetry is that it has.. .it's in the shape of just having fun and you pay attention to what your
something, or it has a nice form, it's flin to read." body is doing." Another commented that, "I can usu-
Dance Strategies: Tools for Thinking ally just feel if it's right. I can feel if it's wrong." More
than one student commented on the fact that they
A number of these same thinking strategies can listen for patterns of rhythm in the music when they
be seen in the interview data pertaining to dance. are creating dances:
Examples of observing, empathizing, body thinking
and recognition of patterns were discovered in the I think there are certain moves that go with the
46 Journal of Dance Education Volume 6, Number 2 2006
beats, and when Ifindthose beats and rhythms Ohserving, empathizing, recognizing patterns, trans-
in the music, then that's what I'll do |in the formational thinking, and creative reverie were noted
dance]. in both poetry and dance making. What is unclear,
I like to feel the music and go along with it. I go however, is how this is related to pedagogy. Is the
along with the beat. use of common skills made apparent—or even cre-
It seems clear that creating dances for these students, ated—through the teaching process? Would children
particularlyfrommusic, involves recognizing patterns, spontaneously use these strategies in a less struc-
a "tool for thinking." tured, more student-directed learning environment?
Perhaps a next step in this research could be to further
Other Cognitive Strategies and Observations decontextualize, that is, identify more specifically the
conditions under which the use of the same cognitive
One additional strategy came to light in hoth the
strategies in multiple contexts occur. As Perkins and
students' poetry and dance creation experiences.
Salomon state, it is important for educators to "decon-
Students commented that they used other art forms
textualize the transferable aspects [of learning] and
to brainstorm during their creative process. In poetry,
bridge them to other contexts."'"
for example, one student explained;
When I am usually thinking of a poem I draw.. .1 A second topic for further investigation is the way
draw and I draw.. .1 draw to think about what to in which cognitive strategies are applied during the
do next...when I'm doing poetry I draw without creative process. For example, are children learning
thinking. when and how to apply "observing" or "empathiz-
ing" during dance making? Is the creative process
In dance a different student remarked, teaching children how to apply cognitive strategies
I usually listen to the tones of the music and put to solve problems? Learning theorists in dance such
them into colors. Then if they're like hot colors I as Barr and Lewin^" and Matt '^ describe three kinds
would try and do some strong moves, and like cool of knowledge in the problem so]ving process: declara-
colors I would do slow moves. tive, procedural, and metacognitive. "Declarative"
This strategy seems related to the "tools for thinking" refers to the factual material a person knows going
strategy known as transformational thinking. The into a problem-solving situation. "Procedural" refers
Root-Bemsteins define this as "the serial or simulta- to knowing wbat strategies for thinking or problem
neous use of multiple imaginative tools in such a way solving could be applied to the problem. "Metacogni-
that one tool acts upon another.""' It seems however tive" refers to reflecting on the success of the strategies
to be a less advanced version of this strategy. Rather applied and managing and controlling those strate-
than two strategies infiuencing one another, it seems gies for best use. Perhaps the creative process is in
that the thinking described is really more "relational actuality a type of procedural knowledge. The types
brainstorming." Here a student calls on multiple ways of thinking that go on during the creative process
of stimulating thinking by generating artistic product may be closely linked to the types of thinking that
in more than one artistic modality. go on in expert procedural problem solving. One con-
nection between dance and language arts may be the
Another cognitive element that came to light in way in which strategies are applied rather than the
both dance and poetry was the prevalent idea of a strategies themselves. Perhaps the creative process
preconscious state where creative thought occurs. itself is the transferable cognitive strategy that links
Students reported this in two ways. Some conmiented artistic learning to traditional academic learning. For
on the sudden fiash of insight: "You don't even realize dance educators this could mean emphasizing dance
that you're writing and then all of sudden it's done. making and improvisation more in our classes. By
You just do it. You don't really think about it.. .It just making the largest proportion of class time focused
comes to you." Others descrihed this preconscious on technique, we might lose the best opportunity for
state as a semi-dream state, which I call "creative transfer of learning into traditional academic areas.
reverie": "I just close my eyes and whirl and go where This study supports the idea that the creative
the music takes me." process teaches problem-solving strategies. Students'
accoimts of their experiences in creating poetry closely
Discussion match educational psychologist Ellen Winner's de-
In refiectiiig on the findings from this study, two issues scription of tbe creative process.^" In Invented Worlds,
come to light. The first issue relates to the strategic Winner characterizes the creative process as consist-
behaviors themselves, the second to the way these ing of four stages:
strategies are applied during the creative process.
Firstly it seems clear that there are, in these data, 1. Conscious deliberation of the problem,
some common thinking strategies that occur during 2. Subconscious deliberation of the problem while
both the creation of dances and the creation of poetry. attention is turned elsewhere,
Journal of Dance Education Volume 6, Number 2 2006 47