CHECK & REVISE RECORD

No.: CBD-17-E05-AR-001

Zhang
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by
Debao
Design
Tower No. E05 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

A-1-GR-001-0 1.The information about trench and pit is not
performed in ST drawings SC-1-FL-001-B
2.The size & depth of trench is not showed in
AR drawings, including in plan A-1-GR-001-0
and in section A-3-00-001-0.
.

3.The location of two ladders is different with

drawing A-1-GR-002-0

Page 1 / 10 22-Apr-20
 Zhang
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by
Debao
Design
Tower No. E05 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

4.There is no information about the decoration

information on walls, ceiling, and floor of the
makeup tank.
5.There is no information about the slope on
the floor of the whole tank.
6.It is necessary to show the details about
pipe penetration on walls and slabs, including
the detail of waterproofing here.

A-1-GR-002-0 1.The size of the opening on the slab is

Page 2 / 10 22-Apr-20
 Zhang
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by
Debao
Design
Tower No. E05 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

different from ST drawing SC-2-FL-001-B

2.Ladders are without protection ,and please

clarify how to support the ladder since there is
no wall beneath the slab in this area. Please
show the detail of installing the ladders.please
clarify the material of the ladder

3.Ladders in the AR drawings are different

from the MEP drawings.（

4.the boundary of the slab of the mezzanine

should be shown in architecture drawing.
Page 3 / 10 22-Apr-20
 Zhang
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by
Debao
Design
Tower No. E05 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

5.Please clarify the function of each opening.

6. There is no handrails on the mezzanine

floor.

A-1-RF-001-0 1.There is no ladder on the north side of the

wall at axis E02 in from level 323.35 to the
roof ,but there is one in the drawingE05-ENV-
GW-3-GN-002

Page 4 / 10 22-Apr-20
 Zhang
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by
Debao
Design
Tower No. E05 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

2. The details indexes about cover & ladder

and railing are essential.
3. If there is any wall above ground ,there is
necessary to show the material of the façade,
including the detail of the the façade, the
specification of the façade material.

A-1-RF-001-0 1. The location of vent pipes for water tanks

A-3-00-001-0 is conflict with parking function showed in
drawing
Page 5 / 10 22-Apr-20
 Zhang
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by
Debao
Design
Tower No. E05 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

2.  The number, position, model and height
of the vent pipe. The reqirements to
protecte them against insects, dust,
collision and rust.
3. The level of the roof is 326.6m ,it conflicts
with the level of the parking area 326.552
in drawing A-3-00-001-0.
4. There are roads and parking area above
the the tank. There is a risk of vibration
caused by the traffic. And it may cause the
dust fall into the water where there is
cover or vent pipe.

Page 6 / 10 22-Apr-20
 Zhang
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by
Debao
Design
Tower No. E05 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

5. It is supposed to show the information and

details of the steel covers,including the
size,the thickness ect.
6. It is supposed to show the level of each
steel cover, since there may be covers
above ground.
7. Size and height of the entrance and exit,
thickness of the cover plate, method of
fixing, weight of the covers, how to move
the cover, whether there is a slit, how to
seal. There are ladders in the pool,
detailed drawings of ladders, depth of
buried parts and requirements for rust
prevention
8. There are no covers on the top of the two
pump pits highlighted in orange line, and
is there any necessity to set two holes on
the roof?

Page 7 / 10 22-Apr-20
 Zhang
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by
Debao
Design
Tower No. E05 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

9. The dimension and location information

about these openings is not performed in
architectural drawings.It is better to show
these kinds of information.

A-3-00-001-0 1. The location of the water stop is different

in AR and ST drawing SC-3-1-001-B. （
Please show the detail at water stop.

2.

Page 8 / 10 22-Apr-20
 Zhang
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by
Debao
Design
Tower No. E05 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

3. Please show the detail of beneath the

bottom slab and above the top slab.（
4. There is waterproof material on the top
slab. Is there any protection for the
waterproofing .Is there requirements of
antiroots for the waterproofing? Please
provide the requirement（

Reviewer Reviewer’s Recheck

Date Date

Page 9 / 10 22-Apr-20
Page 10 / 10 22-Apr-20