Project Name: Central Business District East Phase-1

Client: M/s Minstry of Housing, Utilities & Urban Development

Consultant Name: M/s Dar Al Handasah
Contractor Name: M/s China State Construction Engineering Corp Ltd

Sl. SCG Manufacturer/ Supplier Contractor Reply Rem

No Comments: Reply arks
Drawings and general provisions of the Contract, including General and
Supplementary Conditions and Division 01 Specification Sections, apply to Noted By Contractor. However, Kelvion will coordinate
1 Noted & Comply
this Section (as per clause 1.1-A) and the contractor requested to provide with the contractor for cooling tower related
the related documents for the supplier inputs.
Exposed moving parts, parts that produce high operating temperature,
parts which may be electrically energized, and parts that may be a hazard to
operating personnel shall be insulated, fully enclosed, guarded, or fitted
2 Not applicable Noted By contractor, If any.
with other types of safety devices. Safety devices shall be installed so that
proper operation of equipment is not impaired. Welding and cutting safety
requirements shall be in accordance with AWS Z49.1. (as per clause
1.4-E) and it is common responsibility for both supplier and contractor

Design, construction, commissioning, operation, maintenance, repair,

replacement, and expansion shall comply with ASHRAE 188-201, Noted，water management will
By water treatment specialist and operation &
3 Legionellosis’; Risk Management Building Water Systems. Submit water submit separately by water
maintenance team.
management program documents in compliance with listed standard (as per treatment submittal
clause 1.4-F) and it is common responsibility for both supplier and contractor

Structural Performance: Engineer cooling tower structure and foundation

as required by the Control Documents. Prepare calculations, shop drawings
and other structural data necessary for the verification of the design of
cooling tower structure and foundations, signed and sealed by a qualified
Point load details and layout will be submitted after
professional engineer responsible for their preparation. (as per clause 1.5- Noted，will coordinate with
4 Comply as remarks detailed engineering by Kelvion Engineer, which is
B) and it is common responsibility for both supplier and contractor Submit manufacture post order activity.
each item in this Article according to the Conditions of the Contract and
Front-End Documents Specification Sections. (as per clause 1.6-A General)
and the contractor requested to provide the related documents for the
supplier

The tower manufacturer shall submit detailed structural design

Design calculation will be submitted upon the
calculations, factors of safety and the method used to obtain them, as
5 Comply as remarks completion of detail engineering, which is post
well as test data to confirm the material structural strength
order activity . 'Test data'. Not Applicable
characteristics. (as per clause 1.6-B)
where test data is required.
Warranty period shall start from the date of the substantial completion of Noted
6 Comply as remarks Please refer section 8 for sample warranty letter.
the project (as per clause 1.10-3)
The proposed field erected cooling towers are field
Factory acceptance test required while employee/engineer witness factory The proposed field erected cooling test at site for thermal performance as per CTI ATC
7 Not applicable towers are field erected ,not
test for similar factory assembled products as per clause 3.8 & 2.6-E 105 by CTI Certified third party testing agency
applicable for factory test within 1 year of installation.

Fan Blades made of FRP, propeller with maximum tip speed of 50 meter per
8 second while the supplier proposed speed may accepted subject to submit Noted with thanks
matching standard

Refer to Division 16 "Common Electrical Requirements for HVAC Equipment" The proposed are field erected
9 Not applicable cooling towers.And Division 16 is not The proposed are field erected cooling towers.
for general requirements for factory installed motors as per clause 2.3-A
in SPEC of CUC
Supplier reply about ST. ST. crane and gantry required for motor and gear
removal as per clause 2.3-H may accepted subject to supplier guarantee
1 Comply
the painting material withstand humid site conditions coming from TSE
0
water and giving more details
Not accepted for supplier reply about seismic & vibration control direct
isolation (not applicable) since the supplier/contractor requested to submit
1 Noted Noted Post order activity for structural structural analysis.
seismic/vibration control calculations for approval as per specs clauses 1.5-
1
A, 2.4 & 3.2

Contractor/supplier have to coordinate about filtration system, sweeper

Kelvion will coordinate the contractor for cooling
1 for basin cleaning, variable speed drive and other accessories supply (refer Comply
tower related works.
2 to the latest IFC)
Please refer enclosed our water quality guidelines
Clarify your reference about permissible values allowed in circulating
1 Comply for the proposed NET fills which is suitable for the
3 cooling water mentioned in your submittal and if your material suitable for
given
TSE water
water quality.

Submit coordination drawing between the submitted cooling towers Kelvion will coordinate with the contractor for
1 Comply as remarks
including all accessories and piping with sufficient service area and design cooling tower related inputs.
4
available area
Noted. NFPA 70 refers to the installation of
installations for electrical components to be listed and labeled by NFPA 70 electrical conductors and control panels, which
1 as per clause 1.7-B (NFPA 70 related to bench work of safe electrical design, By contractor is by contractor. However, Kelvion will
5 installation and test to protect people & property from electrical hazard) coordinate with the contractor for cooling tower
related motor.
Provide safety plan comply to OSHA to be applied during delivery, storing, Noted will submit method statement
1 By contractor
handling, assembly and erection separately for approval
6
The proposed cooling towers are sized with 5%
Recheck for the fan power consumption where the motor power to be reserve capacity. Moreover, at 100% capacity the
1 Comply as remarks
25% more than the break fan power difference in actual design fan shaft power to the
7
installed capacity is approximately 20%.

6/28/2020 Reply to Shaker Comments 06June2020 1/1