Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Thesis On The Effect of Traffic in The Performance of Employee S in Selected Companies in Metro Manila PDF
Thesis On The Effect of Traffic in The Performance of Employee S in Selected Companies in Metro Manila PDF
________________________________________
An Undergraduate Thesis
Presented to the Faculty of the
College of Business and Entrepreneurial Technology
RIZAL TECHNOLOGICAL UNIVERSITY
Boni Avenue, Mandaluyong City
` ________________________________________
In Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for the Degree
Bachelor of Science in Business Administration
Major in Operations Management
By
Introduction
Traffic is one of the biggest problem that our country is facing nowadays especially
on Metro Manila where the business industry is focused on. “Metro Manila, on an urban level,
was named as having the "worst traffic on Earth," based on a global evaluation conducted by
Waze, a GPS-based navigation app. According to the survey, Manila, on a city level, ranked
number one with the "worst traffic on Earth" with Rio de Janeiro, Sao Paulo, and Jakarta not far
The traffic congestion now plaguing the streets of Metro Manila is wreaking
We can view our traffic from different perspectives: longer commute time,
employee absences, stress, wasted man-hours, and added fuel expenses are just some
of them. But don’t take our word for it. Senator Ralph Recto estimates that the
Philippines suffers around a P2.6 billion (or $55.8 million) economic loss each day
created by traffic congestion. What’s more, this figure rises to P3 billion (or $64.39
million) at the peak of the rainy season. What’s more, the country loses around 0.8% of
its gross domestic product because of this problem, with a productivity loss of P800
We can say without any hesitation that traffic is the most critical problem in the country
right now. And with a chaotic mega-city swarmed by 12 million commuters during the
day, around 367,000 vehicles (more than double its capacity) in EDSA alone, and
extremely congested areas within Taft Avenue, Munoz, Katipunan Avenue, Cubao,
Balintawak, and Baclaran, our traffic problem will continue to get worse if left to rot and
The fact is — traffic is even worse than before. Imagine, one vehicular accident in
Market! Market! In Bonifacio Global City is enough to cause vehicles all the way from
Quezon City and Marikina to be stalled in traffic for more than three hours. For sure,
the public is still waiting for the solutions that could ease their daily suffering.
Traffic is so prevalent in Metro Manila, particularly during weekdays were there are
many commuters especially employees of both public and private sector are affected
but also for businesses as well. According to the study of Hartgen, Fields, Layzell &
San Jose (2014) About 25% of employers and 38% of large employers note that
arrival to work. Employers increasingly provide opportunities for flexible work hours, try
to schedule meetings at less congested times and allow employees to work from home.
Passes or subsidies for transit use are less common. In order to mitigate congestion,
employers suggest demand shifts, capacity improvements, the addition of signs and
signals and transit improvements. In short, local traffic congestion is an increasingly
appropriate solutions.
Conceptual/Theoretical Framework
problems in all great cities resulted from rapid urbanization which always exert negative
externalities upon society. The solution of traffic congestion is highly geocentric and due
to its heterogeneous nature, curbing congestion is one of the hard tasks for transport
which could be absolutely applied for every great cities. Conversely, it is quite feasible
to develop a framework which could be used with or without minor adjustment to deal
with congestion problem. So, the main aim of this paper is to prepare a traffic
congestion mitigation framework which will be useful for urban planners, transport
who are directly or indirectly involved or willing to involve in the task of traffic congestion
management. Literature review is the main source of information of this study. In this
paper, firstly, traffic congestion is defined on the theoretical point of view and then the
causes of traffic congestion are briefly described. After describing the causes, common
management measures, using world- wide, are described and framework for supply
This study aims to know about the effects of traffic to performance of employees
Input
Possible solutions on
how avoid the traffic
that encountered
everyday by the
employees.
3. Traffic causes
tardiness of employees
that result to bad record
of the employees
Figure 1. Research Padigram
Statement of the Problem
The purpose of this study is to determine why the traffic congestion affects the
employee’s performance. One of the problems is more complicated because social and
economic issues involved creating a tangled mess that threatens the development and
progress that the cities are experiencing. It seeks to answer specifically the following
questions:
1. What are the possible solutions on how to avoid the traffic that encountered
3. Why traffic causes tardiness of employees that result to bad record of the
employees?
Hypotheses
The effect of traffic in employee's performance causes a lot of stress that made them
feel exhausted at the start of the day which decreased their productivity at work.
Significance of the study
Commuters
It will benefit the commuters to know what increase their social interaction,
Employees
accident and enhance public image. Also, it help the employees to manage
their time.
Students
It will benefit the students in improving their learning about the traffic that they
can encounter every day. And to gain a better understanding in the effect of
traffic.
Drivers
It will benefit the drivers to improve their driving skills to reduce the risks of
It will benefit the future researchers who will also tackle the same problem in
their research and also will gave them information that they can also use
The study deals with some reasons why traffic affects employee’s performance
and these are the usual situations we see along the road as we commute. The traffic
level by frequency and severity of traffic jams, road quality and infrastructure, driver
safety based on accidents, road hazards and weather, drivers services like access to
gas stations and socio economic (world bank) including access to cars and impact of
gas prices and that’s why traffic affects employees performance because of these
Definition of Terms
To have a better understanding of this study the following key terms are define
Frequency- is the number of occurrences of a repeating event per unit time. [1] It is
webster.com/dictionary/havoc)
(http://www.dictionary.com/browse/mitigate)
(http://www.dictionary.com/browse/plaguing)
(http://www.dictionary.com/browse/prevalent)
as use increases, and is characterized by slower speeds, longer trip times, and
increased vehicular queueing. The most common example is the physical use of roads
by vehicles. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_congestion)
Chapter 2
themselves. The materials presented which includes in this research are the opinions,
principles, and theories of different people are obtained to relate and be used in the
study.
How do we feel about traffic? That’s a no-brainer. We hate it. And we feel the same for
its synonyms which all mean that we’re going to be late for work again, words like
“gridlock” and “congestion”. Anyone who has ever visited, worked in or lived in the
Philippines would know how bad the traffic jams are in the cities, particularly Quezon
City, Manila and Makati. The main avenues of these cities and even the secondary
roads are often congested, and the problems of traffic congestion had become so
serious that the economy is affected in no small way. There is a reason why popular
novelist Dan Brown – author of ‘The Da Vinci Code’ and ‘Angels and Demons’ –
mentioned Metro Manila’s monumental traffic jams in his book ‘Inferno’. He called Metro
Manila the ‘Gates of Hell’. Traffic Problems in the Philippines and Proposed Solutions
(2014)
According to a research titled “Employer Views on Traffic Congestion” (Policy Brief 115
of the Reason Foundation, February 2014), traffic congestion is a problem not just for
individual commuters but for businesses as well. While commuters are greatly
concerned over rush hour traffic, businesses are also concerned with the off-peak hour
(non-rush hour) delivery of goods. It was pointed out in the research that because
businesses are concerned with congestion during both time periods, their views on
traffic congestion differ from those of commuters. Solving rush hour and off-peak
congestion is also more challenging than merely solving rush hour congestion.
The study stated that congestion affects employers in several ways. Primarily, it affects
meetings and other business activities. It also limits worker availability and productivity
workers and employees are a sore issue. Congestion leads to workers arriving late;
commuting hassles for workers, frustration/stress, long work commutes, long travel
In the Philippines, street, traffic or system problems are major issues. These include
causes of traffic such as safety issues, poor road design, traffic signals, and on specific
roads.
In the case of Flat Planet, most of its employees live outside of Ayala, Makati where the
company’s headquarters are located. Many live in the South and North of Makati, and
commute daily to get to work. They have to contend with various ongoing road projects,
the massive volume of private cars and public utility vehicles that occupy the main roads
To avoid getting trapped in the morning rush, Flat Planet employees leave their homes
at least two hours before they shift begins. Without traffic, the commute should take only
an hour or an hour and half give or take. Of course, some employees still arrive late, but
Flat Planet takes a very serious stand against tardiness, as lateness is considered
unprofessional. It has a biometric finger scanner and all staff are required to scan in and
out at the start and end of each day. At the end of each month, those who had many
late days are notified via email. (Hartgen,D,Fields M.G.,Layzell A., San Jose E.2014)
In the Philippines, you can add to the list traffic congestion in Metro Manila as another
sure thing we experience every day. MMDA reported 326,504 vehicles pass through
EDSA every day. 12,000 to 15,000 of them are buses. In 2015, LTO-NCR recorded a
monthly average new registration of 14,783 multi-wheeled vehicles (cars, SUVs, buses
According to the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), traffic congestion cost
the Philippines P2.4 billion every day in 2012. If remain unsolved, our country can lose
P6B daily by 2030. The National Center for Transportation Studies (UP Diliman)
explained that the cost of traffic are based on several factors, among them are: value of
time lost due to delay; fuel costs; vehicle operating costs; Impact on health; and
An average Metro Manila resident, mostly working people travelling to and from their
office, spends 1,000 hours a year in traffic and wastes as much as 28,000 hours of his
economic life. Wasted productivity hours amount to a monetary value that could be used
for other things such as earning extra income or spending more time with the family.
Joey Tibayan-Bayan, a radio reporter laments that going to and from work is such a
chore. She said, “You get all dressed up looking fresh and clean, when you get on the
PUVs, you disembark sweaty tired and dejected. The day has not even started yet!”
John Cueto, VP for Network and Technology, describes the Metro traffic as “tragic”
because it wastes time and effort that results to low productivity. “Mompreneur” Margaux
Hemady Rañosa confessed that her mother and sister were forced to rent a place in
Ortigas because of the exhaustion they get from traffic and waiting for transportation to
go to work. Ron Barbaza, a blogger, would sometimes allot 4 hours of travel time to go
to event venues just to make sure he will not miss his gigs. BPO Manager Shawn
Andrei Summers sums up his frustrations in five words, “Heavy traffic jam stresses me.”
Gretchen Filart Dublin shared that traffic is one of those reasons why she shifted to full-
time freelancing because it takes her 4 hours to travel from Bulacan to her previous
“unbelievable” and getting worse because she now gets late even on weekends. Rizza
Garingo, who leads a field market survey team, would sometimes utter the word
“hellish” when stuck in traffic that only makes him doubly tired at the end of the day.
Cheryl True, a researcher, seems to have given up in finding answers to the traffic
The government has taken some initiatives in response to the worsening traffic situation
and its effect especially to workers like implementing of a four-day work week scheme in
some government offices and the DOLE Advisory No. 4, Series of 2010 that includes
of more than 1,800 corporate and individual members, conducted a survey in one of
their recent monthly meeting attended by more than 200 members. The results showed
that 81% of the respondents are in favor of a 4-day work week scheme. The companies
also shared that they provide benefits to their employees to lessen the effect of traffic
like flexible work schedule, free shuttle, work from home option and gas allowance.
PDI talked to working people from all walks of life and asked them for suggestions on
how to lessen the traffic problems that we are currently facing. The following are their
responses:
Ruth Dela Cruz, IT Consultant. Local companies should start implementing work from
home option especially for positions which don’t require physical reporting in the office.
Kellypad Biasong, Nurse. Improve our train system and implement a “No parking, No
car” policy.
Cristal Maramag, Digital Officer. There should be more means of public transportation
and the government needs to fix our roads especially in flood-prone areas which worsen
the traffic.
Grace Bondad Nicolas, COO of a media and PR firm. Carpooling is another solution we
Raffy Pedrajita, Tech blogger. Every barangay should create a mass parking system for
people who don’t have a garage. Limit car ownership per family or company and fire the
Enzo Luna, Blogger/ Photographer. If only we have a train system that works on time
like in Japan then wasted time going to work or school will be eliminated. Adapting an
John Michael Bueno, Computer Engineer. Use waterways and additional layer of roads
as options for more efficient public transportations. People should see train ads in
Joveth Ong, Entrepreneur. Traffic management should start with LTO, LTFRB and
MMDA. What are those colorum vehicles doing on the streets? For me that’s the basic
be mandated to have vehicles that can pick-up and drop-off employees on designated
points.
Jocelyn Alaraña Magbitang, Travel Agency Owner. Open the gates of private villages
David Ricardo Valencia Ferro, Network Administrator. Old buses should be phased out.
Yenan Glorioso, Project Development Officer. Centralized transport systemis one
solution. Increase the registration of vehicles 500 folds to discouraged car ownership.
Saj Kamid, Research and Extension Specialist. Bus rapid transit should be considered
Agustin John Cabredo, Government employee. I moved near my office and I ride my
bicycle to go to work every day. It’s environment-friendly, cheap and good for the health.
Mark Joshua Pineda, Social Media Officer. Mass transport system, proper jeepney
stops.
Peter Sumile, Publisher. Install walkways and flyovers in intersections, major roads and
national roads.
reprimand all “underperforming” local government officials: mayors, vice mayors and
Gino Romano Santos Decipeda, Process Specialist. Phase out all vehicles 10 years old
and above.
Leo Brisenio, Photographer. We need an effective and efficient transport system which
will be charged per hour for using major roads which are deemed congested. Improve
traffic lights and electronic system and remove incompetent traffic enforcers.
Whether we like it or not, the current traffic situation in Metro Manila will be something
that we will be seeing for the years to come unless a miracle of a solution will pop out
soon. While we are waiting for the antidote that will bring a lasting improvement to our
roads, maybe we can still smile a little in the midst of a traffic jam and spread good
vibes to our fellow motorist instead of pouting or worse, be involved in a road rage.
Or maybe we can consider the clever traffic-buster from working mom Mary Jane
Dionela, who recently migrated from Pasig City to Davao City, who suggested, “Zipline
Metro Manila (CNN Philippines) — Traffic can be deadly. A new study by the World
Health Organization (WHO) reveals about 7 million people die every year due to air
pollution. In Southeast Asia, most of this air pollution comes from traffic in highly
urbanized areas. Air pollution is an "invisible killer," WHO Director Maria Neira said. It
accounts for a third of deaths from lung cancer and stroke, a quarter of deaths from
heart disease, and as much as half of child deaths from pneumonia. On top of that, she
said, air pollution can also give people chronic illnesses, which can be expensive to
treat and can decrease the quality of their lives for years.
Jiao, C. (2016, September 14) (Traffic is main source of deadly air pollution in
According to The Trade Union Congress of the Philippines (TUCP) It mirror's the
situation by saying that the length of time a worker spends on commuting has lessened
three hours for a worker in Metro Manila to travel to work and another three to four
hours to travel back home," TUCP spokesperson Alan Tanjusay said in a separate
interview.
"Since there are no dramatic changes implemented by the government to enhance the
mass transport logistics and scenario in the past 14 years of the Arroyo and Aquino
administrations, we can only imagine the unquantifiable ordeal workers are going
As a result of the poor mass transport service, the TUCP has been calling on
government and employers since 2012 to implement a flexible working time for state
Because of the gridlock, what is usually a 15-minute drive may last up to two hours,
a strenuous commute increases the likeliness of irritability and fatigue which decreases
Cabuenas, J.V. (2015, December 11) Longer Commute, Equals Less Productivity
Roads, vehicles, people, and institutions. These are the top four reasons behind the
"Part of the problem is that people are so impatient and people don't follow rules," said
Ma. Sheilah Napalang, director of the National Center for Transportation Studies.
According to Napalang, the government should prioritize improving the country's mass
public transport system, which includes railway and bus rapid transit. She added that
the premium P2P bus service is a good first step, as it gives another option for
commuters, and encourages private car owners to leave their cars at home.
She added that even with road repairs and improvements, Metro Manila "will burst at
"We can no longer sustain so many private vehicles on the road. We will burst at the
seams, even if we do make third, fourth, fifth level EDSA," Napalang said.
The first thing many people think of when it comes to congested roadways is the
delay. During the morning commute there is additional stress because delays
caused by traffic can make people late for work. And at the end of the day, the
afternoon rush hour is again a frustrating time because the workday is done and
people want to get home to relax, and traffic is preventing it. These delays are
the effects most people feel because they are universal to everyone who has to
A secondary effect of traffic congestion related to delays is the inability to estimate travel
times. Those who regularly travel congested areas know approximately how long it
usually takes to get through a particular area depending on the time of day or the day of
the week. These experienced city drivers have to build in time "just in case" the traffic is
bad. This takes away from leisure time and time to do other tasks throughout the day.
Also, on a day when the traffic is unusually light the built in extra time may be of no use
The stopping and starting in traffic jams burns fuel at a higher rate than the smooth rate
of travel on the open highway. This increase in fuel consumption costs commuters
additional money for fuel and it also contributes to the amount of emissions released by
the vehicles. These emissions create air pollution and are related to global warming.
4. Road Rage
Road rage is a senseless reaction to traffic that is common in congested traffic areas. If
someone is not driving as fast as the person behind him thinks he should, or someone
cuts in front of someone else it can lead to an incident that is dangerous to the offender
and those around him on the road. Road rage often manifests itself as shouting
matches on the road, intentional tailgating, retaliatory traffic maneuvers and mostly a
lack of attention being paid to the traffic around the people involved. It is basically a
be worsening in the Philippines as wealthier Filipinos buy more vehicles and enjoy their
said that the Philippines loses P2.4 billion (Dh204 million) per day in potential income as
Also, for a minute, suppose that 30,000 vehicles pass through each of main roads every
day and each vehicle is able to save one liter of fuel per day due to congestion
reduction. If fuel is priced an average of P45 /L, then this is easily equivalent to savings
of 1,425,000 P per day per road. For 12 roads and assuming to include only travel on
weekdays, the total savings per year can be computed as P4.212 billion.
that relief is underway. It said that the main focus of efforts is to ease traffic flow in
EDSA, Metro Manila’s main thoroughfare. There is also a campaign to remove
unregistered buses from city roads, and to move the terminals of provincial buses away
from EDSA. The government plans to build the north and south terminal so that buses
Based on reports, Metro Manila’s last major road rehabilitation program was
have been implemented since then, but population growth and the commercial and
economic development have also ensured that more business establishments use
Compounding the road situation in Metro Manila the poor drainage system. Whenever
the rains come, commuters are often trapped for long hours in traffic. Spokespersons
from the Department of Public Works and Highways said that it was doing flood
mitigation plans for Metro Manila. The government targets to pave all national roads by
2015-2016.
and serious efforts to improve transportation infrastructure for Metro Manila including
much delayed mass transport systems can translate to genuine benefits. Such benefits
infrastructure to reduce congestion and lower costs associated with traffic jams.
Continued procrastination over road and other infrastructure projects that should have
been implemented long before will only leader to higher productivity losses.
Synthesis
articles, and journals. The concepts and theories that are cited will be useful and vital in
this study for it supports and guides us, as researchers, toward the fulfillment of the
desired output. The cited research will give us a critical and comprehensive analysis,
different information and additional explanation about the assigned research topic.
Based on the different theories of experts, traffic is really a major issue for
individuals especially to those who are working and needed to go to their workplace
Many commuters got sick about the traffic that they encountered every day. It
is inevitable since the road, highways, and such are not quite wide enough to lessen the
traffic since there are lots of different kinds of vehicles especially to those employees
who uses their own vehicle and those employees that commutes to their work every
day. Well, traffic is non-measurable. And that is so hard even if an employee has his or
her own vehicle or none, and also harder to employees that came from far-flung
locations. So they must adjust their time since traffic in Metro Manila is never
adjustable.
Chapter 3
METHODOLOGY
frame and sampling scheme, research instruments, data gathering procedure and
statistical measures that were applied in the investigation for the analysis and
interpretation of data.
Research Design
Companies in Metro Manila for the year of 2016. Being descriptive, it tries to describe
how traffic congestion is perceived by the employees that encounters traffic jams
everyday
answered.
Population Frame and Sampling Scheme
In statistical terms a random sample is a set of items that have been drawn from a
population in such a way that each time an item was selected, every item in the
population had an equal opportunity to appear in the sample. In practical terms, it is not
so easy to draw a random sample. First, the only factor operating when a given item is
The researchers will used random sampling for the results would be unbiased and it has
the characteristic that as the sample size progresses, the sample size approaches true
Research Instrument
The researchers will used the Likert Scale method, according to Study.com
requires them to indicate the extent to which they agree or disagree with a series of
statements. The Likert scale is named after its creator, Rensis Likert, who developed it
in 1932. In survey research, Likert scales are the most commonly used type of scale. In
the example earlier, those who completed Jake's survey had five different options to
choose from to indicate the extent to which they agree with each statement.
Validation of the Instrument
The researchers sought the permission of the persons in the authority before the
questionnaires for making surveys will be given directly to the respondents. The
respondents did their role for answering the questionnaires cooperatively that the
researchers did not find any difficulty or bad instances in securing data from them.
The data that are obtained from the respondents were tabulated systematically in
order understand the correct information related to each element of the target
population.
This study will utilize statistical method to answer the research problems.
X w=
∑ wx
∑w
Where:
X́ W = weighted mean
Directions: Please Read and Encircle the number that indicates to what extent you
Agree or Disagree
1.) Do you think traffic nowadays greatly affect your productivity at work
Strongly Agree Agree Undecided Disagree Strongly Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
2.) Are you always late because of traffic going to your work?
Strongly Agree Agree Undecided Disagree Strongly Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
3.) Don you think there are negative effects of traffic with your health
Strongly Agree Agree Undecided Disagree Strongly Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
4.) Do you think the government is giving enough effort to solve the traffic?
Strongly Agree Agree Undecided Disagree Strongly Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
5.) Do you think there are enough Jeepney’s and busses?
Strongly Agree Agree Undecided Disagree Strongly Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
6.) Do you commute everyday going to your work?
Strongly Agree Agree Undecided Disagree Strongly Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
7.) Are you stressed because of traffic jam you experience every day?
Strongly Agree Agree Undecided Disagree Strongly Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
8.) Do you think pollution affect your health?
Strongly Agree Agree Undecided Disagree Strongly Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
9.) Does better performance of employees help the business to prosper?
Strongly Agree Agree Undecided Disagree Strongly Disagree
1 2 3 4 5
10. Does being stuck at traffic greatly affect you?
Strongly Agree Agree Undecided Disagree Strongly Disagree
1 2 3 4 5