You are on page 1of 10

Available online at www.sciencedirect.

com

Forensic Science International 177 (2008) 1–10


www.elsevier.com/locate/forsciint

Comparison of injuries caused by the pistols Tokarev, Makarov


and Glock 19 at firing distances of 25, 50, 75 and 100 cm
Delia Lepik a,*, Vitaly Vasiliev a, Hardi Reisenbuk b, Ülo Põldsam b
a
Department of Pathological Anatomy and Forensic Medicine, University of Tartu, Ravila 19, 50411 Tartu, Estonia
b
Forensic Service Centre of the Estonian Police, Pärnu mnt 328, 11611 Tallinn, Estonia
Received 5 March 2007; received in revised form 15 August 2007; accepted 23 September 2007
Available online 19 November 2007

Abstract
Firings in the horizontal direction at cloth targets and at human skin from autopsy material were performed using the pistols 7.62 mm Tokarev
(TT), 9 mm Makarov (PM) and 9 mm  19 mm Glock 19 with common ammunition.
On cloth targets, soot was more visible in the case of the TT up to firing distance of 50 cm and there were faint soot flecks on some synthetic
cloths even at a distance of 75 cm. In the case of the PM and the Glock, the soot was seen on some synthetic cloths at a distance of 50 cm. The
gunpowder particles were dispersed over the targets (TT and PM) or concentrated mostly around the bullet entrance hole (Glock 19). Up to a
distance of 75 cm, the Glock 19 left the greatest and the PM the smallest number of gunpowder particles. At a distance of 100 cm, there were only
some gunpowder particles on the cloths.
On skin targets, starting from a distance of 25 cm (Glock 19) and 50 cm (TT and PM), no more soot was macroscopically visible. Histological
examination revealed few dotted deposits of soot (TT and PM) and finer soot particles (PM) on the skin surface up to 50 cm. At a distance of 25 cm,
the gunpowder particles were found in the epidermis and deeper in the dermis (TT and Glock 19), and a distance of 50 cm they were on and in the
stratum corneum. Starting from a distance of 50 cm, in the case of the PM we detected many partially burnt gunpowder grains not connected with
the skin surface. At a distance of 75 cm, the gunpowder particles were on the skin surface, except one or two of them found in the stratum corneum
(TT and PM), and at a distance of 100 cm, the particles were only on the skin surface.
# 2007 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Gunshot wounds; Firing distance; Cloth and skin injuries

1. Introduction a distance of 25 cm with the same make and lot of ammunition


(Test 2). The purpose of the study was to find out the differences
In the case of close-range and medium-range shots, deposits between bullet entrance injuries caused by the pistols Tokarev
of firearm discharge residues can be found on clothes or skin. and Makarov and the Glock 19 at firing distances of 50, 75 and
The intensity and distribution of these deposits is related to the 100 cm and to compare the firings made at a distance of 25 cm
firing distance and other factors influencing the residue with previous results (Test 1). The above-mentioned pistols are
patterns, such as the barrel length, the type of ammunition, the most common pistols in Estonia and for firings we used the
the calibre of the weapon, the angle of the muzzle to target, the most common makes of ammunition in Estonia.
target material, the type of the weapon, and the form of the
rifling [1,2]. 2. Materials and methods
This article is a continuation to our previous study about
injuries caused by the pistols Tokarev and Makarov (four lands For test firings, we used the pistols 7.62 mm Tokarev (TT), 9 mm Makarov
and grooves) and the Glock 19 (hexagonal rifling) at firing (PM) and 9 mm  19 mm Glock 19. The ammunition were following: TT –
7.62 mm  25 mm, bullet mass 5.5 g (manufacturer 21 RPR 63, Romania); PM
distances of 10, 15 and 25 cm [3]. We repeated the test firings at
– 9 mm  18 mm, 6.1 g (9  18 TPZ – Tulskiy patronnyy zavod, Russia); and
Glock – 9 mm  19 mm, 7.45 g/115 grs (9 mm Luger, Fiocchi, Italy). In Fig. 1
are shown the examples of gunpowder grains from the cartridges used for firings
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +372 737 4293; fax: +372 737 4292. on 0.5 cm grids. All bullets were full metal-jacketed. Throughout the firings
E-mail address: delia.lepik@ut.ee (D. Lepik). with the same pistol, we used the same make and lot of ammunition. Before

0379-0738/$ – see front matter # 2007 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.forsciint.2007.09.016
2 D. Lepik et al. / Forensic Science International 177 (2008) 1–10

of fibres 0.4 mm) cloths and three shots at human skin (autopsy material). At a
distance of 25 cm for the Test 2 we made three shots at cloth and two shots at
skin targets. The size of cloth targets were 20 cm  30 cm and skin targets
6 cm  10 cm, 5 cm  15 cm or 6 cm  15 cm. The pieces of skin derived
from the thigh region (regio femoralis) and the stratum corneum was 20–50 mm
thick. For using pieces of human skin, a vote from the Ethics Committee of
Estonia has been obtained. The shots were performed in the horizontal direction
at a right angle to the targets. During the firing, the pieces of cloth and skin were
fixed to a rest. We photographed (Olympus C-2000 digital camera) all targets
with injuries and these photographs were analysed by using the computer
program AnalySIS Pro 3.0. Then we examined the soot, the gunpowder and
other particles and injuries on the cloth under a stereomicroscope Nikon
SMZ800. The skin targets we photographed after 1–2 h or immediately (Test
2) after shooting. The skin samples were fixed in a 4% formaldehyde solution,
and after embedding in paraffin, 3–4 mm sections were made. Then we
examined the haematoxylin and eosin stained slides under a microscope
Olympus BX60. We examined both the cloth and the skin targets by
1 cm  1 cm areas from the right-hand and left-hand side of the bullet entrance
hole (starting from 1 cm from the centre of the entrance hole).

3. Results

3.1. Soot deposit pattern on cloth targets

At a firing distance of 25 cm, in the soot deposit pattern three


zones were distinguishable: central (the most intensive grey),
intermediate (light zone without soot or little soot) and
peripheral (light grey – TT and PM or light brown – Glock) as it
was in Test 1 [3]. The soot deposit was more visible in the case
of the TT: on the cotton and synthetic cloths, the entrance hole
was surrounded by a darker central zone 6.0 cm in diameter and
rings of soot of diminishing intensity. The average diameter of
the soot deposit was 17.0 cm. The PM: the central zone was 5.0
and 5.3 cm in diameter accordingly on the cotton and synthetic
cloths and the bullet wipe was better visible. The zones were
difficult to distinguish. The average diameter of the deposition
was 13.7 and 14.6 cm accordingly on the cotton and synthetic
cloths. The Glock 19: the diameter of the central zone was 5.0
and 5.5 cm and the diameter of the total area of the deposition
was 14.0 and 12.5 cm accordingly on the cotton and on
synthetic cloths. The soot deposit was less intensive and
beginning to fade. The intermediate zone was polygonal and the
peripheral zone resembled concentric arcs (Fig. 2).
At a firing distance of 50 cm, clearly distinguishable zones
of the deposition of soot were no more visible. The TT: the soot
deposited in the round-shaped central zone 6.0 cm in diameter
and peripherally the deposition looked like fragmentary rings or
concentric arcs. The average diameter of the soot deposit on
cotton cloths was 18.3 cm and on synthetic cloths 18.6 cm. The
entrance hole was surrounded by a bullet wipe, which was
better seen on cotton cloths. When we used the PM and the
Glock, the soot was seen on some synthetic cloth targets. For
PM, on four out of five synthetic cloths there was a slight soot
Fig. 1. Examples of gunpowder grains taken from the cartridges used for test deposit around the entrance hole surrounded by fragmentary
firings on 0.5 cm grids. concentric arcs over the target area 18.6 cm on average in
diameter. On one synthetic cloth, a slight soot deposit was only
shooting at targets, we measured muzzle velocities of 10 bullets fired from these
on the peripheral area of the target. The bullet wipe has four
pistols by an Oehler ballistic chronograph Model 35P. Average velocities were
TT – 430 m/s, PM – 301 m/s and Glock – 328 m/s. narrow and four wide sections or was blossom-like on some
At the distances of 50, 75 and 100 cm we made five shots from each pistol at targets. In the case of the Glock, on three out of five synthetic
white cotton (thickness of fibres 0.25 mm) and synthetic (polyester, thickness cloth targets the soot was deposited as fragmentary rings or
D. Lepik et al. / Forensic Science International 177 (2008) 1–10 3

Fig. 2. Macroscopic pattern of soot and gunpowder residue particle distribution on cotton and synthetic cloths at a firing distance of 25 cm.

concentric arcs. The average diameter of the soot deposit was we found finer residue particles in the case of the TT and the
20.3 cm. The bullet wipe was more clearly visible on synthetic PM, especially on synthetic cloths. We counted also the
cloths and on some targets in the shape of a hexagonal or a marks left by these particles after the impact or penetration
polygonal or looked like a petal. through the fibres.
At a firing distance of 75 cm, in the case of the TT there were At a distance of 25 cm, the TT left many gunpowder
faint soot flecks on two out of five synthetic cloths. The bullet particles covered with soot. The maximum diameter of the
wipe was better visible on cotton cloths and it was fragmentary deposited area was 12.5 and 14.5 cm accordingly on the cotton
on synthetic cloths. In the case of the PM and the Glock, the and synthetic cloths. No fibre defects (absence of some part of
soot was not detected. the fibre) were found around the entrance hole as the case had
At a firing distance of 100 cm, only around the entrance hole been with firings from the TT at a distance of 25 cm in Test 1
the bullet wipe remained visible (Figs. 3 and 4). [3]. The PM left only a few gunpowder grains on the targets in
the area of 12.0 and 13.0 cm in diameter. The defect of the
3.2. Deposition of gunpowder residue particles on cloth material at the bullet entrance hole was 0.1 cm in diameter in
targets the cotton cloth in the case of the PM (in two out of three
targets) and 0.1–0.2 cm in a synthetic cloth target in the case of
To determine the distribution and density of the the TT, which was similar to Test 1. The Glock 19: the
gunpowder residue particles, we counted the particles of gunpowder particles and their marks were located in the area of
the size of at least half of the width of the cotton cloth fibre 17.0 and 15.5 cm in diameter, but more densely in the nearest
and at least one third of the synthetic cloth fibre. In addition, area around the entrance hole as it had been in Test 1. Fig. 5
4 D. Lepik et al. / Forensic Science International 177 (2008) 1–10

Fig. 3. Macroscopic pattern of soot and gunpowder residue particle distribution on cotton cloths at firing distances of 50, 75 and 100 cm.

shows the results found on three targets of the same material on target. The maximum diameter of the deposited area was 19.5
the left-hand and right-hand side of the bullet entrance hole. and 17.0 cm accordingly on the cotton and synthetic cloths. In
At a firing distance of 50 cm, in the case of the TT the the case of the PM, only a few particles were detected on the
number of gunpowder particles decreased gradually from target on the area of 9.0 and 13.0 cm in diameter. The Glock 19
the centre of the bullet entrance hole to the peripheral part of the left the greatest number of gunpowder particles and they were
D. Lepik et al. / Forensic Science International 177 (2008) 1–10 5

Fig. 4. Macroscopic pattern of soot and gunpowder residue particle distribution on synthetic cloths at firing distances of 50, 75 and 100 cm.

more densely deposited around the bullet entrance hole as it had deposited areas accordingly on the cotton and synthetic cloth
been in the case of firings at a distance of 25 cm. The maximum were as follows: 6.5 and 14.5 cm (TT), 8.5 and 9.0 cm (PM),
diameter of the deposited area was 17.0 and 17.5 cm. 13.0 and 16.5 cm (Glock). Up to that distance, the Glock 19 left
At a distance of 75 cm, the gunpowder particles were the greatest and the PM the smallest number of gunpowder
dispersed over the targets. The maximum diameters of the particles.
6 D. Lepik et al. / Forensic Science International 177 (2008) 1–10

Fig. 5. Number of gunpowder particles and marks caused by the particles on the cotton (c) and synthetic (s) cloth at a firing distance of 25 cm.

At a distance of 100 cm, there were only some gunpowder pieces of skin were 6 cm  10 cm or 6 cm  15 cm). In the
particles on the targets. Figs. 6–8 present the results found on case of the Glock 19, many gunpowder particles and their
five targets of the same material on the left-hand and right-hand marks were dispersed all over the target (the pieces of skin were
side of the bullet entrance hole. 5 cm  15 cm or 6 cm  15 cm). On one skin target out of
three targets, the gunpowder particles deposited around the
3.3. Macroscopic findings of the skin entrance hole and the powder marks on the peripheral part of
the target.
On the skin targets at a distance of 25 cm, in the case of the At a distance of 75 cm, the TT left some marks and a few
TT the central zone of the soot deposit pattern was seen. Many particles mainly around the entrance hole on one target. The
gunpowder residue particles and marks left by gunpowder PM left fine particles and some bigger ones over the target. In
grains covered the target surface (the pieces of skin were the case of the Glock 19, in comparison with the distance of
6 cm  10 cm). The PM: some gunpowder residue particles of 50 cm, the particles and their marks were less and they were
different size and around the entrance hole faint soot without mainly deposited on the central part of the target.
clear pattern of deposition were seen. The Glock left the At a distance of 100 cm, the TT left only some particles on
greatest number of greenish-yellow gunpowder grains and the targets. After firing from the PM and the Glock, some
more densely around the entrance hole. Starting from a distance particles were seen on two targets out of three. In the case of the
of 25 cm (Glock 19) and 50 cm (TT and PM), no more soot was TT, the particles were bigger and in the case of the PM, they
macroscopically visible. were finer.
At a distance of 50 cm in the case of the TT, in comparison
with the distance of 25 cm, less gunpowder particles were 3.4. Microscopic changes of the skin
found and they were more dispersed all over the targets (the
pieces of skin were 6 cm  10 cm). In the case of the PM, some At a distance of 25 cm, some dotted deposits of the soot were
fine and bigger gunpowder particles were on the target (the on the skin surface and deeper in combination with gunpowder

Fig. 6. Number of gunpowder particles and marks caused by the particles on the cotton (c) and synthetic (s) cloth from the 7.62 mm Tokarev.
D. Lepik et al. / Forensic Science International 177 (2008) 1–10 7

Fig. 7. Number of gunpowder particles and marks caused by the particles on the cotton (c) and synthetic (s) cloth from the 9 mm Makarov.

Fig. 8. Number of gunpowder particles and marks caused by the particles on the cotton (c) and synthetic (s) cloth from the 9 mm  19 mm Glock 19.

particles. The TT: the gunpowder residue particles were present in the stratum corneum. More peripherally, they were only on
on the histological preparations, which originated from 1 to the skin surface (Fig. 9).
4 cm from the centre of the bullet entrance hole, and they had At a distance of 75 cm, in the case of the TT and the PM the
penetrated into the epidermis and deeper into the stratum gunpowder particles were 1–4 cm from the centre of the bullet
papillare and the stratum reticulare of the dermis. The PM: fine entrance hole. In the case of the TT, in comparison with the
soot particles 1–4 cm from the centre of the bullet entrance hole distance of 50 cm, the gunpowder particles were less and mainly
and they were deposited on and in the stratum corneum. The on the skin surface, but one or two of them were found in the
Glock: 1–2 cm from the centre of the bullet entrance hole, the stratum corneum. On one target, the particles were only 1–2 cm
gunpowder particles had penetrated into the epidermis and they from the centre of the bullet entrance hole on the skin surface.
were in the stratum papillare of the dermis. More peripherally After firing from the PM, we detected many partially burnt
they were found only on the skin surface. gunpowder grains not connected with the skin surface. Only on
At a distance of 50 cm, the TT and the PM left a few dotted one skin target, 1–2 cm from the centre of the bullet entrance
deposits of soot on the skin surface and in addition, the PM hole, one gunpowder particle was seen in the stratum corneum.
left some finer soot particles not connected with the skin At a distance of 100 cm, the TT left a few gunpowder
surface. In the case of the Glock, soot was not detected. The particles on the skin surface. These particles were on the
gunpowder residue particles were present on histological histological preparations, which originated from 1 to 3 cm from
preparations, which were taken from 1 to 4 cm from the the centre of the bullet entrance hole. In the case of the PM, 1–
centre of the bullet entrance hole. In the case of the TT, the 4 cm from the centre of the bullet entrance hole, we detected
gunpowder particles were on and in the stratum corneum. For many partially burnt gunpowder grains not connected with the
PM, starting at a distance of 50 cm, many partially burnt skin surface.
gunpowder grains not connected with the skin surface were The Glock 19: at the distances of 75 and 100 cm, a few
found. The PM and the Glock 19: 1–2 cm from the centre of gunpowder particles were deposited and they were in the
the bullet entrance hole, the gunpowder particles were on and nearest area to the bullet entrance hole on the skin surface.
8 D. Lepik et al. / Forensic Science International 177 (2008) 1–10

Fig. 9. Soot and gunpowder residues on the surface of the skin and in its layers at firing distances of 25 and 50 cm: (A), 7.62 mm Tokarev; (B) 9 mm Makarov; (C),
9 mm  19 mm Glock 19.

4. Discussion depth depending on the firing distance. In the case of the TT,
different data about the maximum distance of soot deposit were
Barnes and Helson [1] defined at least five variable published: soot occurs up to 15–30 cm, and by the other
characteristics of gunpowder that influence the residue pattern author’s data up to 45 cm. In the case of using the PM, soot can
imprint: the powder type, grain geometry, chemistry, the charge be found up to 30–40 cm [4].
weight and the burning rate. They found that the character of In our experiments, the soot on the skin began to disappear
the residue pattern could be altered at any given distance by macroscopically at a firing distance of 25 cm and on cloths at a
changing the brand of the ammunition, which may change the distance of 50 cm, but it remained more visible after firing from
powder type or configuration. the TT. In the case of using the PM and the Glock, the soot was
Throughout the firings with the same pistol, we used the only on some synthetic cloths at 50 cm, but the TT left faint
same make and lot of ammunition and chose the most soot flecks even at 75 cm on the synthetic cloth targets. On the
commonly used makes of ammunition in Estonia. histological preparations of skin, in the case of the TT and the
The maximum distance out to which powder soot deposition PM soot was visible at a distance of 50 cm.
occurs for most handguns is 20–30 cm [2]. According to Popov The experiments proved that the shape of individual powder
et al. [4], the soot is seen up to 30–40 cm on white targets. At grain has a significant influence on the maximum range at
those distances, the soot is hardly visible on the skin and not which powder tattooing occurs. Due to a better aerodynamic
visible at all on black targets. The soot not only deposits on the form, ball powder can travel further at a greater velocity,
skin surface, but also is penetrating into the skin in different enabling deposits on the skin at a greater range [5]. To
D. Lepik et al. / Forensic Science International 177 (2008) 1–10 9

determine the firing distance by the size and the density of the gunpowder particles up to 50 cm and a fewer gunpowder particles
gunpowder residue pattern and also the maximum distance at were dispersed over the cloth targets at 75 cm. On the skin, the
which the powder residue pattern is left on the target surface or gunpowder particles were deposited mainly around the entrance
powder tattooing of the skin takes place, it is very important to hole (TT and Glock 19). At a distance of 100 cm, the particles
consider the physical form of the propellant [1,5,6]. were found only on some cloth and skin targets. The PM left only
In our study, but we observed the following: the ammunition a few gunpowder particles at all those distances and the number of
of the TT and the PM produced more soot than the Glock. The the particles diminished with increasing the firing distance.
Glock 19 left the greatest number of gunpowder particles (up to a Examining the depth of penetration of the gunpowder particles
distance of 75 cm) and they were deposited more densely around into the skin revealed that the particles were on and in the stratum
the bullet entrance hole. In the case of the PM, many partially corneum up to a distance of 75 cm (TTand PM) or up to a distance
burnt gunpowder grains were detected on the histological of 50 cm in the nearest area around the bullet entrance hole
preparations. At a distance of 25 cm, differently from Test 1, no (Glock 19). The Glock 19 left the gunpowder particles only on the
tears and recesses were detected in the epidermis as it had been in skin surface in more peripheral parts of the skin target at a distance
the case of the TT and the Glock 19, and gunpowder particles of 50 cm and at distances of 75 and 100 cm.
were not found in the stratum reticulare in the case of the Glock To prove the data about the findings of depositions of
19. These results can be explained with a weaker tearing gunpowder and other gunshot residues at distant ranges, Popov
influence of combustion gases of the propellant and also with and Isakov performed firings at vertically disposed targets
weaker penetration capability due to the loss of velocity of (20 cm  30 cm) from three different Makarov pistols with
gunpowder grains approximately at that distance. In Test 1, we common ammunition at distances of 3–50 m and this revealed
observed gunpowder marks affected by drying of the skin surface deposition of metal-containing microscopic particles, too. But
before examining the skin targets. these particles differ by their smaller size (mostly up to
Barz [7] found that in addition, a variation in the speed of 0.1 mm  0.5 mm) and an uneven pattern of deposition (most
bullets and the material of the targets, the firing direction of the deposition at 2–4 cm from the centre of the bullet
influences the number of particles on the target. For series of entrance hole) in comparison with close-range and medium-
shots in the vertical direction from above downwards, about range shots [4,9,10].
three times more particles were recorded than for respective Analysing the differences between the measurements of the
series in the horizontal direction. powder tattoo pattern on animal bodies and on a blotter paper
Lisitsin et al. [8] supposed that the flying range of Di Maio et al. [5] found that they had measured the main
gunpowder particles depends on the decrease of velocity and powder pattern and ignored the ‘‘flyers,’’ while the criminalists
the burning rate. Interaction of these factors varies depending had measured the entire pattern, including the flyers.
on the type of the gunpowder and the firearm, the target On cloth and skin targets, we compared the areas located on the
material, humidity of the air and other characteristics. right and on the left of the bullet entrance hole. Above and below
Therefore, the test firings from two Makarov pistols with the entrance hole may be slight differences in the number of
different makes of ammunition gave rather different results. gunpowder particles on cloth targets of the size of 20 cm 
Lisitsin et al. found that with increasing the firing distance from 30 cm. Irrespective of the actual size of the skin target, we
50 to 150 cm, the number of gunpowder particles on the compared the areas on histological preparations, which origi-
moistened photographic paper decreased almost similarly both nated from 1 to 4 cm from the centre of the bullet entrance hole.
in the case of vertical and horizontal firing directions due to The findings about gunpowder residues on a cloth and on skin
their burning in the air. The maximum distance at which the are similar but there are some exceptions: starting from a distance
particles were seen was 250–300 cm (one or two particles in the of 25 cm (Glock) and 50 cm (TTand PM), no more soot occurred
case of the horizontal firing direction). Using another Makarov macroscopically on the skin and it was visible only on the
pistol with different ammunition, the number of gunpowder histological preparations. The examination of the histological
particles increased distinctly in the vertical firing direction preparations of the skin after firings from the PM revealed many
(from above downwards), especially at distances of 200– partially burnt gunpowder grains. These particles were perhaps
250 cm. Even in the case of firing at targets from a dry not visible on the cloths due to their microscopic size.
pasteboard, the number of gunpowder particles was large.
According to Popov et al. [4], in the case of the Makarov 5. Conclusion
pistol, many gunpowder and metallic particles are seen up to a
distance of 30–40 cm and only a few particles can be found up Comparing the bullet entrance injuries produced by the
to 100–150 cm on the vertically disposed targets. Around the pistols Tokarev, Makarov and Glock 19 with common
bullet entrance hole mainly gunpowder and metallic particles ammunition at distances of 25, 50, 75 and 100 cm we observed
flying along a linear trajectory are deposited, but the particles the following differences:
can be found beneath the level of the bullet entrance hole or on
the horizontal surface. The flight of particles along a curved (1) in the diameter of the soot deposit pattern and in the
trajectory reaches out to a distance of 2–6 m. maximum distance out to which the soot was visible;
We performed the firings in the horizontal direction at a right (2) in the distribution and the density of the gunpowder residue
angle to the targets. The TT and the Glock 19 left many particles on the cloth targets;
10 D. Lepik et al. / Forensic Science International 177 (2008) 1–10

(3) in the distribution and the depth of penetration of the [3] D. Lepik, V. Vasiliev, Comparison of injuries caused by the pistols
Tokarev, Makarov and Glock 19 at firing distances of 10, 15 and
gunpowder particles on the skin targets.
25 cm, Forensic Sci. Int. 151 (2005) 1–10.
[4] V.L. Popov, V.B. Shigeev, L.E. Kuznetsov, Sudebno-Meditsinskaia Bal-
The results were similar on the cloth and on the skin targets. listika, Gippokrat, Sankt-Peterburg, 2002, pp. 195–200.
[5] V.J.M. Di Maio, C.S. Petty, I.C. Stone, An experimental study of powder
tattooing of the skin, J. Forensic Sci. 21 (2) (1976) 367–372.
Acknowledgement [6] L.C. Haag, Physical forms of contemporary small-arms propellants
and their forensic value, Am. J. Forensic Med. Pathol. 26 (1) (2005)
The authors are grateful to Tõnu Adrik, the former firearm 5–10.
expert of the Forensic Service Centre of the Estonian Police for [7] J. Barz, Die Bestimmung der Schubentfernung aus unverbrannten
helping to perform the test firings. Pulverteilchen, Beitrage zur gerichtlichen Medizin 29 (1972) 327–
334.
[8] A.F. Lisitsin, V.N. Chubuchny, T.T. Sardinov, Gunpowder particles as a
References factor of close shot, Sud. Med. Ekspert. 1 (1990) 10–13.
[9] V.L. Popov, V.D. Isakov, Medicolegal characteristics of deposition of
[1] F.C. Barnes, R.A. Helson, An empirical study of gunpowder residue additional shot factors beyond the limits of close-range shot, Sud. Med.
patterns, J. Forensic Sci. 19 (3) (1974) 448–462. Ekspert. 4 (1986) 6–11.
[2] V.J.M. Di Maio, Gunshot wounds. Practical Aspects of Firearms, Ballis- [10] V.L. Popov, V.D. Isakov, Mechanism of transfer and deposit of metal-
tics, and Forensic Techniques, 2nd ed., CRC Press, Boca Raton/London/ coated particles on the surface of obstacle in case of shot from a long
New York/Washington, DC, 1999, pp. 71–75, 136–144. distance, Sud. Med. Ekspert. 2 (1988) 16–20.

You might also like