Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Summary
Background Sickle cell disease contributes substantially to mortality in children younger than 5 years in sub-Saharan Lancet Glob Health 2016;
Africa. In Uganda, 20 000 babies per year are thought to be born with sickle cell disease, but accurate data are not 4: e195–200
available. We did the cross-sectional Uganda Sickle Surveillance Study to assess the burden of disease. Published Online
January 28, 2016
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
Methods The primary objective of the study was to calculate prevalence of sickle cell trait and disease. We obtained S2214-109X(15)00288-0
punch samples from dried blood spots routinely collected from HIV-exposed infants in ten regions and 112 districts See Comment page e144
across Uganda for the national Early Infant Diagnosis programme. Haemoglobin electrophoresis by isoelectric *Joint senior authors
focusing was done on all samples to identify those from babies with sickle trait or disease. Department of Paediatrics and
Child Health, Makerere
Findings Between February, 2014, and March, 2015, 99 243 dried blood spots were analysed and results were available University College of Health
for 97 631. The overall number of children with sickle cell trait was 12 979 (13·3%) and with disease was 716 (0·7%). Sciences, Kampala, Uganda
(G Ndeezi MBChB PhD,
Sickle cell numbers ranged from 631 (4·6%) for trait and 23 (0·2%) for disease of 13 649 in the South Western region S Kiguli MBChB,
to 1306 (19·8%) for trait and 96 (1·5%) for disease of 6581 in the East Central region. Sickle cell trait was seen in all C M Ndugwa MBChB); Central
districts. The lowest prevalence was less than 3·0% in two districts. Eight districts had prevalence greater than 20·0%, Public Health Laboratories,
with the highest being 23·9%. Sickle cell disease was less common in children older than 12 months or who were Kampala, Uganda (C Kiyaga MSc
MPhil, I Ssewanyana MSc);
HIV positive, which is consistent with comorbidity and early mortality. Division of Hematology,
Cincinnati Children’s Hospital
Interpretation Prevalence of sickle cell trait and disease were high in Uganda, with notable variation between regions Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH,
and districts. The data will help to inform national strategies for sickle cell disease, including neonatal screening. USA (A G Hernandez BA,
T A Howard MS,
R E Ware MD PhD); Mulago
Funding Cincinnati Children’s Research Foundation. Hospital, Kampala, Uganda
(D Munube MBChB); and
Copyright © Ndeezi et al. Open Access article distributed under the terms of CC BY-NC-ND. Ministry of Health for the
Republic of Uganda,
Kampala, Uganda
Introduction progress towards achieving UN Sustainable Development (J Nsungwa MBChB PhD,
Sickle cell disease refers to a group of inherited Goal 3, Good Health and Well-Being, which includes the J R Aceng MBChB MPH)
haemoglobin disorders characterised by a predominance reduction of childhood mortality.7,8 Correspondence to:
of abnormal sickle haemoglobin in erythrocytes.1 Sickle In 2006, WHO issued an important report on sickle Dr Russell E Ware, Division of
Hematology, Cincinnati
cell anaemia, which results from homozygous cell disease in the African region, which described the Children’s Hospital Medical
inheritance of sickle haemoglobin from both parents, is overall prevalence and provided guidelines on care and Center, 3333 Burnet Avenue,
the most common and severe form of sickle cell disease. management strategies.9 WHO also publicised the need Cincinnati, OH 45229, USA
On deoxygenation, sickle haemoglobin undergoes a to improve sickle cell awareness, disease prevention, and russell.ware@cchmc.org
conformational change that promotes intracellular early detection.10 Countries in sub-Saharan Africa have
polymerisation, which leads to distortion of the normal been challenged by WHO to formulate national
biconcave erythrocyte disc into the distinctive and strategies for sickle cell disease that address specific
pathological crescent shape. The resulting haemolytic aims, targets, and objectives. Despite this charge,
anaemia manifests as recurrent vaso-occlusion and ministries of health are hindered from creating
organ damage that together cause substantial morbidity meaningful interventions by many obstacles, including
and early mortality.1 lack of accurate data about the burden and distribution
Worldwide, sickle haemoglobinopathies lead to a sub- of disease within their countries.11
stantial burden of disease that is not adequately Uganda was among the first countries in Africa with a
addressed.2–4 Accurate data are lacking, but the worldwide documented large burden of sickle cell disease. In 1949,
estimate for neonates born with sickle cell disease each substantial differences in the prevalence of sickle cell
year is 400 000, including 300 000 with sickle cell anaemia.5 trait were reported between different tribes, ranging
The greatest burden is seen in sub-Saharan Africa, where from less than 5% for Hamites in the southwest to more
more than 75% of all sickle cell disease occurs, with this than 20% for the northern Nilotices (Lango and Acholi).
proportion projected to increase by 2050.6 In Africa, sickle Some Bantu tribes had even higher rates, including 45%
cell disease contributes substantially to mortality in among Bamba living in the western region.12 A later
children younger than 5 years and, therefore, limits study, however, has suggested lower values.13 Of note,
Research in context
Evidence before this study Africa documents a high burden in Uganda, with wide
Decades have passed since the initial descriptions of sickle cell distribution of sickle cell trait and disease in every region and
trait in different regions of Uganda, but accurate data on district. These national data will inform the Ministry of Health
prevalence are unavailable. We searched PubMed for articles about next steps, including the launch of neonatal screening
published in English up to May, 2015, with the search terms and development of a national sickle cell strategy. We also
“sickle cell”, “screening“, “Uganda”, “Africa”, and “haemoglobin found that frequency of sickle cell disease declined in children
electrophoresis“. We identified four articles published before older than 12 months or with HIV, which was consistent with
1960 that described ethnic origin and distribution of sickle cell comorbidity and early mortality.
trait and disease in Uganda. We found one paper from 2010
Implications of all the available evidence
that described the distribution of sickle cell trait in several
The Ugandan Ministry of Health needed accurate data on
regions of Uganda and seven reports since 2005 that provided
the prevalence and distribution of sickle cell trait and disease
pilot neonatal screening data in other sub-Saharan African
to help the country follow the WHO guidelines for clinical
locations, but could find no comprehensive surveillance data at
management. In view of our results, targeted neonatal
the national level.
screening for sickle cell disease is now warranted in the
Added value of this study districts with the highest burden, along with efforts to
The primary study objective of the Uganda Sickle Surveillance improve education of health-care providers and awareness
Study was to generate critical data on the prevalence of sickle among the public and the government. Similar studies can be
cell trait and disease. Comorbidities that might be associated done in other sub-Saharan countries to help the development
with early mortality in people with sickle cell disease were also of national strategies for the management of sickle cell
explored. This national-level surveillance study in sub-Saharan disease.
though, both studies were based on small samples and within 3 weeks of collection, after which DBS are stored at
were not representative of the whole country. –20° C for about 1 year then discarded. The DBS collected
The Ugandan Ministry of Health recognised the need for between February, 2014, and March, 2015, were shared
accurate, up-to-date data on the burden of sickle cell trait with the newly created sickle cell laboratory in the Central
and disease to inform its efforts to pilot neonatal screening, Public Health Laboratories within 1 week of HIV testing, to
begin early education and preventive measures, and test for normal and abnormal haemoglobins.
eventually create a national strategy. We hypothesised that The study protocol was approved with a waiver for
there is a large burden of sickle cell trait and disease across informed consent by the School of Medicine Research
Uganda, but with substantial geographical variability. A Ethics Committee at Makerere University and the
partnership was established between Cincinnati Children’s Uganda National Council for Science and Technology in
Hospital, Cincinnati, OH, USA, and Makerere University, Kampala. The study was also formally approved by the
Kampala, Uganda, to enable the Ministry of Health to do a Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center
large cross-sectional research study, the Uganda Sickle Institutional Review Board.
Surveillance Study (US3), to generate such data.
Haemoglobin testing
Methods The laboratory methods for haemoglobin testing were
Programme development based on those previously described for a pilot neonatal
The Ugandan Ministry of Health has an active programme haemoglobinopathy screening programme in Angola.15
for prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV that DBS were eluted and analysed by isoelectric focusing for
identifies and treats infected mothers and their exposed the presence of normal and abnormal haemoglobins.
infants. Infected mothers receive antiretroviral drug Isoelectric focusing readily distinguishes between normal
therapy during pregnancy and exposed babies receive and sickle haemoglobin even in the presence of fetal
6 weeks of treatment after birth, followed by testing with haemoglobin. Staff at the Central Public Health
viral PCR for acquired HIV infection, typically before age Laboratories received on-site training by a technical team
6 months. Around 100 000 HIV-exposed infants are tested from Cincinnati Children’s Hospital on the study
each year through the Early Infant Diagnosis programme, protocol, isoelectric focusing procedures, and inter-
which includes a national sample transport system.14 Dried pretation of results. Additional sessions were provided
blood spots (DBS) are collected from exposed infants at remotely for further training, troubleshooting, and overal
health-care facilities across the country, carried by technical laboratory support.
motorcycle to laboratory hubs at the subdistrict level, and The gel bands were independently compared with a
shipped by courier to the Central Public Health Laboratories standard control by two laboratory technicians and
in the capital, Kampala.14 Sample testing is completed reviewed by the laboratory technologist to derive the final
Adult Sickle Fetal Unknown Median Sex (boys/girls/unknown [%]) Normal Sickle Sickle cell Variant
haemoglobin haemoglobin haemoglobin haemoglobin (IQR) age (%) cell trait disease (%)
(months) (%) (%)
Normal Present None Variable None
Trait Present Present Variable None Central 1 2 (2–8) 7127 (48·3%)/7430 (50·4%)/ 12 757 1896 69 34
(n=14 756) 199 (1·3%) (86·5%) (12·8%) (0·5%) (0·2%)
Sickle None Present Variable None
Central 2 2 (2–8) 5364 (48·2%)/5661 (50·8%)/ 9442 1566 94 33
Variant Present None Variable Present (n=11 135) 110 (1·0%) (84·8%) (14·1%) (0·8%) (0·3%)
Table 1: Haemoglobin classifications for isoelectric focusing analysis East Central 3 (2–12) 3275 (49·8%)/3243 (49·3%)/ 5131 1306 96 48
(n=6581) 63 (1·0%) (78·0%) (19·8%) (1·5%) (0·7%)
Kampala 2 (2–8) 6670 (49·5%)/6607 (49·1%)/ 11 499 1835 90 42
(n=13 466) 189 (1·4%) (85·4%) (13·6%) (0·7%) (0·3%)
classification of normal, sickle cell trait, sickle cell
Mid Eastern 3 (2–11) 2342 (48·1%)/2455 (50·5%)/ 4014 752 60 39
disease, or variant (table 1). To verify the accuracy of the (n=4865) 68 (1·4%) (82·5%) (15·5%) (1·2%) (0·8%)
laboratory process, for the first 3 months of the study all Mid Northern 3 (2–12) 6220 (48·7%)/6401 (50·2%)/ 10 028 2445 160 127
samples classified as sickle cell trait or sickle cell disease (n=12 760) 139 (1·1%) (78·6%) (19·2%) (1·3%) (1·0%)
were retested in a second DBS punch. Accuracy was Mid Western 2 (2–10) 6271 (48·4%)/6507 (50·3%)/ 11 418 1431 64 32
higher than 99%. After 3 months, only samples classified (n=12 945) 167 (1·3%) (88·2%) (11·1%) (0·5%) (0·2%)
as sickle cell disease were retested. If the first result was North East 2 (2–10) 2201 (49·4%)/2204 (49·4%)/ 3676 702 46 34
(n=4458) 53 (1·2%) (82·5%) (15.7%) (1·0%) (0·8%)
indeterminate, a second DBS punch was tested in an
South Western 3 (2–11) 6543 (47·9%)/6896 (50·5%)/ 12 979 631 23 16
attempt to obtain a valid result. If the second test was
(n=13 649) 210 (1·5%) (95·1%) (4·6%) (0·2%) (0·1%)
indeterminate, samples were excluded at that point.
West Nile 2 (2–12) 1566 (51·9%)/1406 (46·6%)/ 2534 415 14 53
Results were recorded along with the age of the infant at (n=3016) 44 (1·5%) (84·0%) (13·8%) (0·5%) (1·8%)
the time of DBS collection, location by region and All (n=97 631) 2 (2–9) 47 579 (48·7%)/48 810 83 478 12 979 716 458
district, and HIV status, which are collected in the Early (50·0%)/1242 (1·3%) (85·5%) (13·3%) (0·7%) (0·5%)
Infant Diagnosis programme. Quality control for
Table 2: Haemoglobin results, by region
accuracy of data was periodically assessed by researchers
in Cincinnati and was consistently greater than 97%.
Haemoglobin results were communicated to the
Prevalence
collection sites with the existing HIV notification system. >21·0–24·0%
>18·0–21·0%
>15·0–18·0%
Statistical analysis >12·0–15·0%
The primary study objective was calculation of the >9·0–12·0%
prevalence of sickle cell trait and disease by district and >6·0–9·0%
>3·0–6·0%
region. Secondary objectives were to calculate the effects ≤3·0%
of age and comorbidities on early mortality in children
with sickle cell disease. Frequencies and percentages were
calculated for ten regions and 112 districts. The relations
between sickle cell disease, age, HIV status, and mortality
were investigated by calculation of odds ratios and
95% CIs with the χ² test for binary variables. Reductions
in prevalence of sickle cell disease with increasing age or
positive HIV status were assumed to reflect early mortality.
Correlation between prevalence of sickle cell trait and
malaria (children aged 0–59 months with positive
microscopy16) by region was tested with linear regression.
Results
DBS from 99 243 infants and children were analysed.
98 519 (99·3%) of samples were collected from children
younger than 18 months (median age 2 months, Figure 1: Prevalence of sickle cell trait in 112 districts in Uganda
IQR 2–9), with an equal distribution of boys and girls. Prevalence ranged from 2·5% to 23·9%.
A B
Prevalence Prevalence
19·8% 62·5%
4·6% 4·9%
Figure 2: Prevalence of sickle cell trait and malaria in ten regions in Uganda
(A) Prevalence of sickle cell trait. (B) Prevalence of malaria, based on the Uganda Bureau of Statistics 2009 surveillance project.16
which is higher than predicted when based on the evidence suggests any systematic bias between HIV
prevalence of sickle cell trait. This finding might reflect exposure and the inheritance of sickle cell trait or
assortative (non-random) mating, where individuals have disease. Indeed, prevalence was around 13% in
a preference for specific genotypes and phenotypes. HIV-positive (representing 5% of the total Early Infant
Additional haemoglobin variants with prevalence of 1⋅0% Diagnosis cohort) and HIV-negative infants. Second,
or higher in the Mid Northern and West Nile regions was the cross-sectional study design did not allow collection
unexpected, but we await molecular diagnoses to confirm of longitudinal data, but the Central Public Health
their identities and relevance. Laboratories plan to track these affected infants over
The association between sickle cell trait and malaria time. Finally, optimum clinical care could not be
was suggested many years ago, and was based on the assured for all children identified as having sickle cell
epidemiological overlap of the two disorders in central disease because there are no national treatment
Africa.17,18 Piel and colleagues19 confirmed this association guidelines and knowledge of the disease among health-
at the global level, but our results confirm this association care providers is poor. The Ugandan Ministry of Health,
at the regional level (figure 2). The overlap in Uganda however, is to issue national standards of care to
suggests continuing differential selection pressure for promote appropriate clinical management in all regions
children with sickle cell trait to survive malaria,20 which is and districts.
supported by findings in Gabon,21 and probably also The WHO strategy for sickle cell disease in the
reflects low migration of tribal populations within African Region is bold and comprehensive. The guiding
regions. Since malaria is frequently fatal in children with principles include country ownership of the strategy,
sickle cell disease,22 improved understanding of partnership and team building, evidence-based
prevalence and distribution of sickle cell trait and disease interventions, and cultural sensitivity.10 The Ugandan
might be relevant to national malaria control strategies. Ministry of Health commissioned the US3 study in
Sickle cell disease is frequently associated with early response to the WHO guidelines, specifically to
mortality for infants and young children in sub-Saharan document the burden of sickle cell disease and to
Africa,2,4,6–8 including in two reports by WHO on the African decide how and where to prioritise its limited resources.
Region,9,10 but no definitive data are available due to Pilot neonatal haemoglobinopathy screening efforts in
inadequate studies. Our data, although not longitudinal, sub-Saharan Africa have successfully identified a large
support this association. Age and HIV status also seemed burden of sickle cell disease,15,24–26 and are typically
to be associated with early mortality in children with sickle coupled with immunisations to prevent fatal bacterial
cell disease, as we took reduced prevalence of sickle cell infections.27 Additionally, hydroxyurea has been
disease in children older than 12 months and those who identified as a potentially transformative disease-
were HIV positive to indicate early mortality. The low odds modifying therapy for use in low-resource settings.28
ratio indicates an important potential comorbidity between Accordingly, the proposed next steps for Uganda
HIV and sickle cell disease that should be investigated include targeted neonatal screening in the districts with
prospectively. Further assessment is especially important, the highest burden; training of health-care providers
as the combination is poorly understood, with potential and establishment of regional and district sickle cell
protective effects and synergism for disease complications clinics to provide penicillin and antimalarial
both having been described.23 prophylaxis, family education, and immunisations;
This study had several strengths, including the large research of the safety, dosing, and benefits of
sample size in the Early Infant Diagnosis programme, hydroxyurea; and creation of a national sickle cell
which provided national coverage, high-quality laboratory awareness strategy that will include premarital testing
testing, and the ability to create an accurate geospatial and counselling aimed at lowering the burden of sickle
map at the regional and district levels. The study design cell disease.
was efficient, as repurposing of DBS kept effort, costs, The UN Sustainable Development Goals emphasise
and time low. Other countries within sub-Saharan Africa non-communicable diseases as public health concerns,
that have comprehensive early infant diagnosis and sickle cell disease deserves recognition as a
programmes could obtain similar accurate sickle cell widespread disorder that can lead to serious morbidity,
prevalence data with this strategy. Finally, the study poor quality of life, and early mortality. Despite a plea
established a strong infrastructure, with laboratory staff from key thought leaders to document the natural
being trained to assess sickle cell trait and disease, which history of this disease and the associated mortality in
met the important goal of building local laboratory and Uganda,29 sickle cell disease remains neglected with few
research capacity. This study reflects a highly successful reliable data and little political will to improve the
partnership between government and academia in situation.30 The US3 study provides important data that
Uganda and the USA, which generated data that will will help to rectify these deficits, and supports efforts by
inform policy. government and academia to improve the lives of
The study also had several limitations. All DBS were children and adults with sickle cell disease who are
collected from children exposed to HIV. However, no living in Uganda.