Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IDC 201-201
This book overall is very insightful and full of things I did not know. From different
PISA scores around the world and what contributed to them, and how poverty may not have
anything to do with that at all; to teachers and how we see and treat them. All of these things are
discussed in detail in this book like no other that I have read. Schleicher goes on to talk about his
experiences and how he thinks the world needs to change in order to give the future students of
the world a better and proper education. For me, this book was so eye opening. I was able to
understand what he meant and the ideas that he is grasping at and trying to get other people like
educators to understand.
In the beginning of the book, it goes on to talk about the PISA and how it changed the
education system around the world. This test was designed by the OECD in the late 1990s. After
administering the test and looking over the results they were able to conclude that Finland had
the best overall education system. They made education the biggest priority; not sports, or any
other extracurricular activity. Education and school were pretty much all these kids had but they
enjoyed it at the same time and knew the expectations that they were being held to. It was also
found that there was, “no automatic link between social disadvantage and poor performance in
school” (pg. 23). I think that this is so important when we look at education. I think that it does
not matter where you come from or how you got here as long as you are trying to learn and doing
the best that you can. I think Schleicher was right when he said that poverty did not play a role in
the way that children were educated. All that really mattered was the quality of the education that
they were given. If the country provided good, wholesome education to their students then they
did well on their PISA scores. If the country saw education as a back-burner subject then the
scores were awful. I love how Schleicher talks about how it is not about how much money is
spent on education. It only matters on what you do with it and how you use it. He talks more
about how the school systems need to get good quality teachers for their kids and make sure that
those teachers are up to par with education as time goes on. For me, this is one of the most
important things for the students. I also liked the comparison of the education systems in
Singapore, Estonia, Canada, Finland, and Shanghai. All of these countries had awareness of
underperformance and inequities in their education systems. They made innovation a top priority
and made sure to use their resources to the best of their abilities. These countries based their
systems on the fact that every student can succeed when given the right kind of support that is
One thing I really did like was the fact that the president of Brazil knew how bad his
country’s education system was. He knew that it needed improvement and that his students were
not getting all that they needed. He knew that the standards for them were so low and that most
of the people in his country did not think that change was needed. He decided to give out the
PISA test just to prove to everyone where they really were on a global scale. Low and behold the
results were not up to par and Brazil was one of the lowest scoring countries in 1997. I applaud
Carsoso for doing this. People need to have their eyes opened in order to see what is really going
on the world around them. They need to see the things that are hard that way they can know what
they need to change. I think in a lot of the world, especially in this country, we are all scared of
change. We don’t do anything different because we are scared to either hurt someone’s feelings
or do something wrong. I feel like if what we are doing isn’t working then we need to be willing
to change. We need to be willing to see what is wrong and fix it. Children are our future in this
world and it is such a disservice to them if we are not allowing them to be educated properly.
Another point that was made in the book is how a country’s most valuable asset is its children
and its people. In countries like Finland, Japan, and Singapore, they know that education is really
all that they have. They know that is the most important thing for them to make money off of and
to keep their economy alive. They know that their children are the future and if they want to
continue on with the prosperity of their countries, then they take education very seriously. They
hold their children to high expectations and make sure that the have certain life skills that will
make them be able to adapt to things in the world. I think learning new life skills and being able
to adapt to things should be one of the most important things that we teach our kids. Overall, I
think it will make them better students and also better members of society as they get older. The
world is constantly changing and we need to be able to teach them to change with it. There are
still children around the world who are stuck in the old education ways and we can see with the
PISA scores how different their scores really are. When education is made a the top priority you
will see a difference not only in PISA scores but in many other divisions of a country’s
government.
Teachers are another part of the education system that are also undervalued. In many of the
countries in the world, teachers are told what to do and how they need to be teaching their
students. They have no authority over their own classrooms and many of them do not like their
jobs. They are educated once in their lifetimes and not made to keep up with new information or
made to education themselves as time goes on. I think that this is also in a way a disservice to
our children. When the teachers are not where they should be then how can we expect the
students to be there as well? I do not understand how someone who is so important can be treated
the way that they are or made to do things that they may not fully agree with. Teachers in this
country, and I’m sure in other countries of the world as well, have a very hard job. So much is
expected out of them and they are given very littler resources to do so. Teachers are the ones on
the front lines and when we don’t listen to them it directly affects the students. I like how
Schleicher talked about making reforms and how when teachers stand united, more things get
done. This is so true and just goes on to show how we really need to listen to them and make sure
I think all together this book was an eye opener. I was shocked at how different the world really
is all around and how far behind we really are when it comes to educating our students. I think
we really need to take a step back and look at what we are doing. How are we making things
better? Are we changing the things that aren’t working? I think the answers to these questions are
ones that we as future educators need to strive for and we need to be the ones who can help make
a difference.