You are on page 1of 6

Field Experience On A Novel Pico-Hydel System Using Self Excited Induction

Generator And Electronic Load Controller

S.S.Murthy, Bhim Singh, Ashish Kulkami, R. Sivarajan and Sushma Gupta


Department of Electrical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi
Hauz Khas, New Delhi - I10016, India

Indian Institute of Science (IISc), Bangalore with funding


Abstrocr- The paper presents a unique filed experience of a by Department of Science and Technology (Govt. of
standalone power generating scheme using self excited India) and Indo Norwegian Environment Programme. It
induction generator and electronic load controller by also provides a comprehensive field data on the working
exploiting locally available small hydro potential needing of two electronic load controllers Back to Back Thyristor
minimal civil works. Water is made to flow in a channel and
based ELC. Uncontrolled rectifier chopper based ELC at
stored in a forebay tank whose discharge is regulated to have
a near constant head. A pelton wheel receiving water the project site to demonstrate the viability of such a
through a penstock pipe works as a turbine which drives a system for worldwide use.
self excited induction generator(SE1G). Two types of A Typical Pic0 Hydel plant consists of a Weir which
electronic load controllers(ELC), back to back thyristor is manually made to divert the existing natural flow of the
based ELC and uncontrolled rectifier chopper based ELC water to a forebay which in turn feeds to a penstock. The
were developed and installed in the field tu provide power water impinges on an uncontrolled turbine. The turbine
halance at varying consumer loads. Typical field data are runs the Self Excited Induction Generator (SEIG) which
presented to prove the viability of the scheme and compare is coupled to the turbine by V belts. The ELC helps in
the performance of the load controllers.
maintaining a constant load on the S E E since input
Keywords-Self Excited Induction Generator, power is constant with a fixed head and discharge of the
Electronic Load Controller, Small Hydro turbine. ELC also maintains a constant voltage at the
consumer end. The envisaged task was a great challenge
as regards both technology and project execution.
I. INTRODUCTION Execution involves shifting of machinery to remote
inhospitable locations and installation. Local community
Exploitation of renewable energy sources to augment is not normally techno-savvy and less literate. Technology
power generation as a necessity is an established fact. must he simple, reliable and cost effective. Low head
Among the sources that can be exploited, small hydro, impulse turbines or pelton wheel were chosen with tailor
wind and biomass are proving to be in the forefront for made design for site conditions. I n view of the advantages
power generation. In remote locations where such sources of SEIG on synchronous generator[l,2,1 Ilfor low power
mainly exist establishment of grid has been found to be I-phase application the former was chosen. Off the shelf
uneconomical and not feasible. Feeding such generated induction motor could he employed. ELC[IO,I Ilneed to
power to utility grids has often become unviable. he robust and reliable. While systems may work in the
Therefore a standalone autonomous unit to feed local laboratory environment they often fail in inhospitable
consumers using such renewable energy sources is the tiled conditions. Two types of load controllers were
choice left. India has large number of identified small designed, fabricated to industrial standards and installed
hydro sites where such generation is possible. It is in the field
estimated that there may be more than 10,000 sites with While the published literature [6, IO. 131 mainly deals
possible power varying from I-100kW. These may be with conceptualization and laboratory experience.
classified as pico (I-IOkW) and micro(10-100kW) hydel challenging experience of translating such concept to field
units. Such units must be simple, rugged, economical and conditions and electrifying local consumers for domestic
user-friendly. A sufficient consumer lond should also be loads is rarely reported. This paper narrates this
available in the vicinity. Further in such remote locations, experience.
only domestic loads are prevalent needing single-phase
supply. Since simple uncontrolled turbines without
governors are preferred, the use of Electronic Load
controllers(ELC) comes into picture for providing quality
single-phase power with good voltage regulation for
varying consumer loads. This paper describes the field
experience of installing Pic0 Hydel plants in several
locations in the Indian state of Kamataka by a joint effort
of Indian Institute of Technology (IIT), Delhi,
Technology Informatics Design Endeavor (TIDE) and

842
11. DESCRIPTION OF THE SCHEME The Impulse turbine h:is buckets fixed to the shaft . The

;I
number of valve openings is again decided on the basis of
water availability and the head. The turbine is either
vertically or horizontally mounted according to the site
conditions. There is no control on the incoming water to
=
l Ly-l the turbine. Though stop and start of the power plant is
done with the help of the butterfly valve at the joint
between the penstock and the turbine.
Self Excited Induction Generator (SEIG): Any grid
independent autonomous unit prefers synchronous
Fig I :Typical Pic0 Hydro site
machines. Induction generators can also be used in stand
- alone mode using capacitor excitation. With some
Figure 1 shows the schematic of a P I C 0 - HYDEL site inherent advantages[ I I they are rugged, brushless and
which consists of a weir, channel, forebay, penstock and economical. However for I-phase supply a tailor made I -
power house which has the turbine, SEIG and ELC with phase SEIG[L] or a 3-phase SEIG to supply single phase
dump load. load[3,1 I] may he chosen. The latter was preferred as 'off
Weir: A weir is a small diversion which is made to divert the shelf 3-phase motor could be used with minor design
a part of the stream from its main course. The weir might changes by any manufacturer. To minimize this unbalance
be natural one made by diverting the water with the help the single phase load is connected through a pair of
of the available rocks too. capacitors (normally with a capacitance ratio of 1:l.S). If
Forebay: A forebay is a tank in which the water diverted we connect as stated the output voltage of a star
from the main stream is stored. The forebay is again connected three phase: S E E feeding single phase load
designed according to the water available at the site. will be 415V. Therefore the SEIG was connected in delta
Penstock The penstock is the pipe which starts at the so that the output voltage was 230V as desired for local
forebay and ends at the power house. The penstock feeds loads.
water to the turbine inside the power house. The diameter Electronic Load Controller(ELC) : In conventional
of the penstock also depends upon the availability of hydro power system, ihe governor system is very big in
water and the head. size, complex operalion and difficult to maintain and
Power House: The power house consists of a turbine has a huge investment cost. From efficiency point of
which acts as a prime mover, a SEIG and ELC. The water view, using a governor that steers a flow control valve
from the penstock is directly fed to the turbine through a on the turbine would be much better. But then the
butterfly valve. This water impinges on the blades of the energy is saved by reducing water consumption of the
turbine and the turbine attains its speed. The turbine is turbine so it only makes sense if water can b e stored in
coupled to the SEIG with the help of v-belts. The ratio of a reservoir for future use. Usually micro hydro and
the pulleys is calculated such that the SEIG runs at 1500 pic0 hydro systems do not have such large reservoirs:
rpm. The single-phase supply which is generated from the They are 'run of rivar' systems and any water that is
SEIG is fed to the consumers through ELC which not used right away, gets lost in an overflow.
maintains the generated voltage constant at the consumer Nowadays only mini hydro or full-scale hydro systems
end, ensuring nearly constant output of generator. have governors as these often have large reservoirs so
that water that is saved, can be stored. Governors are
expensive and require careful maintenance, making the
micro hydro system more expensive and less reliable.
Older micro hydro systems often had governors, but
that was because building affordable ELC's only
became possible using modern power electronics.
Therefore the voltage regulation in small hydro
projects is taken care o f by as ELC at the SEIG
terminals . The b a s k principle being consuming the
difference between the constant output power by the
D w p Load generator and the power absorbed by the consumer
load. There are different types of load controllers.
Fig 2 : Power House Derails Some are purely electrical and some which are using
power electronic snitching devices. The different
Fig 2 shows a block diagram of the constituents of the types of ELC's are :
power house. (i)Binary weighted switched resistors.
Turbine: The turbine is the prime mover for the SEIG in (ii)Controlled rectitier feeding dump load.
the power house. In these pic0 hydel sites the turbine (iii)Uncontrolled rectifier with chopper controlled dump
selected was an impulse turbine because it is the most load.
suitable turbine for low head and low power hydro sites. (iv)Phase controlled thyristor based load controller.

843
in which the duty cycle of the pulse if controlled from 0 to
Fig 3 and 4 show two ELC schemes used in the field. 10010, the power is controlled over the entire range. The
Using AC controller and rectifier chopper based ELC's PWM for such chopper can be generated by comparing
respectively. A combination of capacitors C l and C2 the error signal generated by comparing a reference
provide a single phase output for three-phase delta signal with a saw tooth wave is the switching frequency
connected SEIG.. of the chopper. The scheme includes the uncontrolled
rectification of the SEIG terminal followed by a series
chopper. Using IGBT as the switching device due to its
advantages over thyristor or MOSFET can be used as
chopper switch. This removes the complexity of the
power circuit. This scheme generates harmonics but these
harmonics are less compared to thyristor based ELC.
Moreover there is no reactive power burden in this type of
ELC.

111. FIELD DATA

7rlb %I. Fig 5 shows the photograph for the inside of the power
house installed in village Asolli in North Kanara district
Fig 3 Schematic Diagram of Three Phase SEIG wdh Single Phase of Karnataka located between the two towns of Sirsi and
Bach to back Thyristor based ELC
Kumta. Village is about lOkm off the motorable Sirsi -
Kumta road in inhospitable mountain terrain in thick
forest inhabited by wild animals in Western Ghats.
Installation of this unit was a great technological
challenge which has become a great boon to the villagers
who were assured uninterrupted electricity whenever they
need. Selected persons from the village who have studied
up to middle school are trained to operate and maintain
the system. Field data is collected from the above site by
continuous and regular monitoring during evening and
night when the customer load is significant.

Fig 4 : SElG wth Uncontrded Rectifier .GBT basedELC

Back to Back thyristor based ELC : In this scheme. the


principle of phase angle control of back to back thyristor
is made use of. A thyristor is fired at a specific delay
angle relative to the zero voltage crossing of the sine
wave (symmetrical for both halves of the sine wave). The Fig 5 . Photograph of !he power house a1 the site Asolli.
thyristor commutates at next zero crossing. Switching I.Turbine 2. Penstock 3. Dump Load 4. SEIG
occurs a twice the frequency and generates total harmonic 5. IGBT based ELC 6. Thyristor based ELC.
distortion (THD) as high as 35 - 40 lo in current with
added reactive power burden. This scheme can
continuously vary the dump power over nearly the entire
range from zero to full load as the delay angle varies from
I80" to 00.
Uncontrolled Rectifier Chopper based ELC: This load
controller is also known as mark-space ratio controller
indicating the chopper operation of the controller. This
uses the pulse width modulation for the chopper operation

844
The details of the site are as follows The field data collected on both the load controllers is
Gross Head : 23M summaxized in Table1 and Table2 and Table3.
Discharge : 281ps Symbols used are:
Power : 3kW VLy,VYbVbv = 3-Phase line voltages across SEIG
Feeder Pipe : 1600MM dia PVC, 50m length. Ir Iy I b = 3 -Phase cnrrents in SEIG
Forebay : 3*1.2*1.23M VI,,^, Iload = Load voltage and current
Penstock : 160MM diaPVC pipe, 80M length V,ha,Ithd = % THD of load voltage and current
Turbine : Pelton Wheel, without governor. Vdump, Idump = Voltage and current in dump load
SEIG : 3- phase Induction Motor, SSkW, Po,,,Pa = Power of customer load and dump load
230V Delta Connected. 1500rpm

Table 1 : Field Data with Back to Back Thyristor based ELC :

845
Table 2 : Field Data with Uncontrolled Rectifier chopper based ELC

Table 3 : Voltages at the five houses in the village when the power was fed to the distribution cable

Voltage Vo Power Output Voltage Vs Power Output

200
0 0.5
Power Output(kW)
1 1.5
t
m
c
?i
> 210
230
220

200 -
0 1
Power Output(kW)

Fig 6. Voltage Regulation by Thyristor Fig 7. Voltnge Regulation by


Based ELC IGBT bisedELC

846
IV.RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Field data presented on pic0 hydel system with two


types of controllers prove the viability of using such
systems for further installations. Uncontrolled turbine or
pump as turbine may he used. Self excited induction
generators are found to he ideal as they are rugged,
cheap and user friendly. Reliability of the system
centers on the reliability of the electronic load controller
(ELC) which must he rugged and failure proof. The
IGBT based ELC had a better voltage regulation than
the thyristor based ELC

REFERENCES

Munhy. S.S.; Rai, H.C.; Tandon, A.K.: "A novel self-exited


self-regulated single phase induction generator. 11. Experimental
investigation" Energy Conversion. E E E Tmnsactions on ,
Volume: 8 Issue: 3 , Sept. 1993 Page(a): 383 -388.
R. J. Hanington and F. M. M. Bassiauny. "New approach to
determine the critical capacitance far self-excited induction
generaton," IEEE Trans. on Energ." Converrion. Vol. 13, No. 3,
pp. 244-249. Sept. 1998
(31 T. F. chan and L. L. h i , "Capacitance requirements of a three-
phase induction gene~alorself-excited with a single capacitance
and supplying a single-phase load," IEEE Trans. on Energy
Conversion, Vol. 17, No. I , pp. 90-94, March 2002.
141 C. Gmntham, D. Sutanto and B. Mismail. "Steady state and
transient analysis of self-excitrd induction generalor," IEE
Proc., Vol. 136.Pt. B. Na.2,pp. 61-68, March 1989.
151 K. E. Hallmius, P. Vas and J . E. Brown, "Thr analysis of
saturated self-excited asynchronous generator." IEEE Trans. on
Energy Conversion, Vol. 6, No. 2. pp. 336-341, June 199 1.
161 M. H. Salama and P. G. Holmes, "Transient and steady-state
load performance of U stand-alone self-excited induction
generator," IEE Proc. Elecrr. Power Appl. Vol. 143. No. I, pp.
50-58. January 1996.
171 S. K. Jain. I. D. Sharma and S. P. Singh. 'Transient performance
of three-phase self-excited induction generator during balanced
and unbalanced faults." IEE Proc. Gener. Tronsm. Disrrib.. Vol.
149. No. I,pp. 50-57, January 2002.
S. Rajakamna and R. Bonm, "A Technique for the steady-state
analysis of P self-excited induction generator with variable
meed." IEEE Trans. on Enerev ", Conversion. Val. 8. No. 4. DO...
i57-761. December 1993.
[Y] R. Bonen and S. Rajakamna. "Self-excited induction g e n e ~ ~ t o r
with excellent voltage and frequency control," IEE Proc. Gener.
Tronsm. Dim& Vol. 145. No. I, DD. .. 33-39, January 1998.
[ I O ] D. Henderson. "An advanced electronic load governor for
control of micm hydroelectric generation," IEEE Tron~.on
Energv Conversion, Vol. 13. No. 3, pp. 300.304, December
1998.
[ I l l S. S. Murthy, R. Jose and Bhim Singh. "Experience in the
development of microhydel grid independent power generation
scheme using induction generaton for Indian conditions." IEEE
lnrenrnrionol Cor$ on Global Connecriviv in Energ?,
Compder. Commrmicorion and Conrrol, Vol. 2, pp. 461-465,
1998.
1121 E. G. Mama and J . A. Pomilio, "Induction gmerat0r based
system providing regulated voltage with constant frequency. "
Applied Power Electronics Co,ference, Vol. I , pp. 410-415,
1999.
[ 131 S. M Alghuwainem. "Steady-state of an isolated self-excited
induction generator driven by regulated and unregulated
tuhine." IEEE Trow on Energy Conversion. Vol. 14. No. 3,
pp. 718-723, September 1999.
[ 141 E. Suarer and G. Bortalotto, "Voltage-frequency control of self-
excited induction &nerator..( IEEE Trons. on Energy
Conversion. Vol. 14, No. 3, pp. 394401, September 1999

847

You might also like